cityrise and cityquake: network dynamics of city growth, trade networks, and conflict five...

56
Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in Eurasia in the Last Millennium: Definitive Evidence of Macro Civilizational Dynamics Doug White In collaboration with Laurent Tambayong, MBS, UCI Nataša Keyžar, U. Ljubljana Ben Lind, Sociology, UCI 4-UC Human Sciences and Complexity June 22, 2006 videoseminar

Upload: samson-watson

Post on 14-Jan-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade

Networks, and Conflict

Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in Eurasia in the Last Millennium: Definitive Evidence of Macro Civilizational Dynamics

Doug WhiteIn collaboration with

Laurent Tambayong, MBS, UCINataša Keyžar, U. Ljubljana

Ben Lind, Sociology, UCI

4-UC Human Sciences and Complexity June 22, 2006 videoseminar

Page 2: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

2

Outline: Cityrise and Cityquake

1) What are cityquakes & how they are measured? Cityquake/rise city size scaling definitions q-exponential measure of cityrise&fall (cityquakes)Tsallis non-extensive statistical mechanics & theory – network

trajectories and long-range correlations

2) Introduction to the Historical SlidesNetwork definitions for trade routesChronological network slides of Eurasian cities How q for cities changes over time

3) Summary of dynamics Interesting things (many!) to do with these data

Page 3: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

3

• Imagine a sandpile experiment, pouring sand on the top of the pile, until the pyramid of sand undergoes little quakes until it finally collapses into a flatter heap.

• In a cityquake, when a city size distribution collapses, it isn’t quite so dramatic, but goes from

this (low-q) to this(with a Zipf-like tail) (high-q)

… and then builds back up again (cityrise)

(1) What is a cityquake?

Page 4: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

4

• The sand pile model has a complex dynamic with power law scaling of the size and recurrent timing of rises and quakes.

• Cityquakes and cityrises, & their rises and falls over centuries, were only discovered in 2005 by White and Kejžar, using methods of Tsallis.

• They have a more complex dynamic: of growth, innovation, and exchange, affecting capacity for sustainability, and conflict over resources.

• Coming to understand this dynamic may be essential for our species’ sustainability on earth.

a complex dynamic(1) cityquakes

Page 5: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

5

The discovery of cityquakes builds on Chandler’s 1987 study of the sizes of the largest 75 world cities in 28 historical periods, and -- instead of measuring the tendency of the very largest cities of size s to form a power law distribution in which freq(s) ~ 1/sα, or the rank-size method of Zipf -- used a new scaling method, the q-exponential. It converges to a power law in the tail and is both theoretically motivated and ideal for measuring distribution curves like these:

measurement(1) cityquakes

Page 6: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

6

To see differences in city size distributions clearly over centuries, and for the whole spectrum of sizes rather than just the extreme tails, we bin the log(s=sizes) of cities as the x=log(s) axis, and put the cumulative number of people in cities of size s or greater on the y axis. We then get varying distributions over time like these.

Constructing the size distributions(1) cityquakes

Page 7: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

7

q entropy scaling function: y = y(0)(1 + (1

– q) s/κ)-1/(q-1) y(0)=intercept parameter κ=scale parameter q=q-exponential parameter

the usual entropy S=K ln W =S1 as defined by Sq=K(1-∑ipi

q)/(q-1)pi is the probability for size logbin s low q distributions converge toward

exponential, thin power-law tails (sometimes exaggerated in actuality)

high q distributions have thicker power-law tails and more differentiated body

Cumulative log-log city size distributions

The q function, y=f(s|q,κ), optimizes the entropy Sq

(low q) more equal populations in body compared to tails

Page 8: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

8

What does fitting this q-function mean?

One way to fit a null hypothesis for completely random behavior is to fit the data to a maximum entropy function S=K ln W= ( | q = 1)

Optimizing q to get best fits to a q-entropy function means finding the best description of departure from randomness (q = 1) in which there is nonlinear, multiplicative, or proportionality effects for which only the tail of the distribution conforms asymptotically to a power law (e.g., rich get richer, but less so for the poor).

Sq=K(1-∑ipiq)/(q-1)

(1) cityquakes

Page 9: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

9

scaling definitions related to q

Pareto (Power-law) for city sizes – usually applied to larger tails of size distributions only – linear in log-log.

Pareto slope coefficient – larger for thin tail, smaller for thick tail. Zipf law specifies α+1 = 1/(q – 1) = 2

q parameter scaling – inverse to Pareto coef. β for tails: q = 1 + 1/ β. Zipfian q is 1.5

q = 1 is exponential; maximum q=2.q values differ in long historical periods

(1) cityquakes

Page 10: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

10

(2) Introduction to historical slides

• Network of cities within 800 miles of each other

• Cityquake index q – to be explained – drawn on lower left showing how q for cities changes over time relative to spatial networks (& trade)– Black line for China; lighter Grey line for the World

• Largest 5 cities will be shown in red ; next largest 5 cities shown in cyan.

• These slides start with a cityquake in 1300

• Dashed lines as placeholders for silk routes

Page 11: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

11

Cityquakes: world city size q-population distributions & conflict events: (two sorts: resolved and unresolved w.wars)25-100 year intervals – led by China (heavy line)

(2) historical

Page 12: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

12

What are q-cityquakes historically?

They represent a decades-long slumping of the urban size hierarchy, especially as measured by weighting the points in the logged distribution for cities of size s proportionally to the numbers of people in cities at that size or larger.

They tend to occur at the scale of world cities, continent-wide distributions, or large integrated and bounded macroregions.

There is a long duration of slumps (hi-q continuity) at these scales, as long as 200 years.

(2) historical

Page 13: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

13

What is a q-rise historically?

They represent a decades-long rise in the urban size hierarchy, especially as measured by weighting the points in the logged distribution for cities of size s proportionally to the numbers of people in cities at that size or larger.

They tend to occur at the scale of world cities, continent-wide distributions, or large integrated and bounded macroregions.

There is a long duration of rises (low-q continuity) at these scales, as long as 200 years.

(2) historical

Page 14: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

14

Network definitionsPotential trade connections – cities within a trading

radius of two cities (e.g., 800 miles)

Biconnected pairs of nodes: 2 or more independent routes

Bicomponent – a largest subnetwork in which all pairs of nodes (cities) are biconnected

N = the effective number of separate or intersecting bicomponents, e.g., N=3

a b

(2) historical

Page 15: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

15

Focusing on Eurasia, slides will show 23 historical periods, starting in 900 CE, each with a network of major trade route potentials among the biggest 70 world cities (data from Chandler 1987). Trading zone radius for these illustrations is 800 miles, e.g., 1 month travel in medieval period.

We make multiple networks at different radii for purposes of finding boundaries of replication.

Where and How many (N) are the bicomponents?

Co-variations in q on lower left, sequentially

N leads q ?

Explanatory correlates of q?

Predictors of growth contributing to q?

(2) historical

Page 16: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

16

The statistical question for describing cityrise&fall: what are the correlates of q that we can expect to see in the slides?

• Ratio of average distances (DD/AA) large/large over small/small: divided by World Average distances between cities (rationorm)

• Laurent has a result (which I haven’t checked as yet as he is in Indonesia)

• in a 1400 mile radius (2200km)R2 = .43 (R=-.665)

• (hi dist ~ low q): a result we were searching for to describe q, holds to 19251400 mile radius (2200km)

• in a 600 mile radius (1000 km) Rationorm R2 = .286 (-.252 adj)

of R2 = .64 using differences in q and differences in radius pop measures for successive periods

(2) historical

Page 17: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

17

q varies inversely to large/large city distances within and 1000 km divided by the average intercity distance

R2=.4234

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500

rationorm

d/a//ratio

q87

y axis=d/a-ratio/rationormx axis=q *1000

y = -1.12x + 6094

R2 = 0.4225

900

1100

1300

1500

1700

1900

2100

2300

3200 3400 3600 3800 4000 4200 4400

Page 18: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

18

Other results still under investigation: here q varies inversely to populations within distances 800 and 1000 km

Page 19: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

19

How to “describe” changes in q?In a cityquake period, trade shrinks spatially to smaller regions as a result of conflicts at the boundaries of large regions. The net result of “safer cities” that shrink the average distances between them and those of large cities.

I.e., The location of multiple largest-hubs also shrinks to within regions. These regions eventually become our megacity regions of today.

In cityrise periods trade expands to broader interregional networks with a net result of increasing average distances between them and those of large cities.

I.e., Also true for the largest hubs – these become the global cities, farther apart.

(2) historical

Page 20: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

20

1300 AD

CITYQUAKE FOR EURASIA (following one for China) AND FOR THE WORLD

Broken network links characterize high q (here: tenuous interregional connectors)

4-Khanate conflicts lessen Mongol trade

Mongols conquer Southern Song 1279: Kublai Khan becomes Yuan emperor

Mongol use and spread paper money after 1264

=cutnode

Page 21: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

21

1350 AD

Broken network links characterize high q (tenuous interregional connectors)

Mongols refocus on Yuan administration of China. Silk routes now less important

Black Death spread in China, then to Mongols, then the West

Page 22: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

22

1400 AD

Renewed network links characterize low q (power law tail)

1368 Ming retake China

Silk routes cut by Ming, Turkmeni marching lords to the West

Page 23: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

23

1450 AD

high q again led by China, 100 years, although Europe will sail to the New World

Silk routes unimportant

3rd Ming reign explores spice routes to Africa: 1421 Ming move capital to Peking; edict to end treasure voyages; China turns inward

1421: All land and sea routes for Europeans to the East are closed.

Page 24: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

24

1500 AD

Renewed network links characterize low q (power law tail) – but China high q leads change

World population growth turns super-exponential (with resources from the new world?)

Page 25: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

25

1550 AD

Broken network links characterize high q

Page 26: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

26

1600 AD

Renewed network links will lead change to low q (here: tenuous interregional connectors)

Page 27: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

27

1650 AD

Renewed network links characterize low q (power law tail) – China synchronized

Page 28: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

28

1700 AD

Broken network links return to high q – esp. for China leading

Page 29: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

29

1750 AD

Broken network links typify high q – China leading – bifurcated world

Page 30: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

30

1800 AD

Broken network links typify high q – bifurcated world

Circum-European cities start to overtake China in number

Page 31: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

31

1825 AD

Broken network links typify high q – trifurcated world – best example of high local navigability

European cities overtake China in number and size

Industrial revolution

Page 32: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

32

1850 AD

Broken network links typify high q – trifurcated world – but China developing power-law tail

(here: tenuous interregional connectors)

Page 33: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

33

1875 AD

Broken network links typify high q – bifurcated - China power-law tail thinning toward low-q

(here: tenuous interregional connectors)

Page 34: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

34

1900 AD

Broken network links typify high q – trifurcated Eurodominant - China leads shift to low-q 50 yrs

Page 35: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

35

1914 AD

Page 36: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

36

1925 AD

Broken network links typify high q – trifurcated - rise of Japan - China returns to high q

Page 37: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

37

1950 AD

Start of a low q Zipfian tail for world city distribution – trifurcated – but linked by airlines

Page 38: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

38

1970

Page 39: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

39

A statistical question: what causes city growth generally?

• 50 years time lag:

• No time lag:

• Control for: 120 mile radius

• Control for: 250 mile or greater radii

• (R2 ≥ .50 for each)

• Back Population in 600 mile radius– R2 = .29.25 (adj)

• Population in 120 mile radius – R2 = .64.35 (adj) (total)

• Back pop partial R2 = .36

• Back pop partial R2 => .0

• Fractal property of same backpop correlation for 400-1200 miles

(2) historical

Page 40: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

40

comment

• Population change is a generational variable, changing in say 25 year intervals

• Our data are coded in 50

• If we interpolated our data into 25 intervals, would we get a better test?

(2) historical

Sequel: early transition from 900-1000 (high q quake); 1100-1250 lo-q cityrise

Page 41: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

41

Tracing a cityrise in Eurasia from the year 900

• Three regions:• Some separations:• Silk road connections:• Islamic isolate in Spain:

• Baghdad a huge capital:• After the rebellion of An

Lushan, 755, the Tang (618-907) were in decline. Arab ships loot Canton in 758.

• Near East, India, China• >800 miles btwn large cities.• Some small cities, peter out.• Arab conquests very wide.• Arab fleets in Mediterranean• Changan (Xi’an) in China a

declining center of the Tang dynasty, who had lost the northwest to the Arabs in 751 and shifted to xenophobia.

(2) historical

Page 42: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

42

0900 AD

low q with thin power law tails of global hubs CORRELATES with global network links

first stirrings of globalization

(Europe: no large cities) Central Asia

Medit.

China

Near East (rise) (decline)

India

In these slides we connect the city network & city size distributions and power-law tails connected to q-exponential scaling of city sizesq

(sca

ling

size

s)

Changan

Bagdad & Changan (Xi’an)

cutnodes

Silk Routes

Page 43: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

43

1000 AD (cityquakes)

• Two regions:• One cut-node city:• Silk road connections:• Islamic isolate in Spain:

• Baghdad taken by Shi’ite Buyids, pop shrinks 85%

• Probable cityquake collapse (high q)

• Venetian trade begins

• Near East vs. India&China• Ghazna-Afghanistan, expands• More small cities, peter out.• Arab polities in conflict.• Arab fleets fall into neglect• 5 Dynasties in north, 10

Kingdoms to the south to 960, Kaifeng becomes the capital of the No. Song, civil service based on talent, but tribute paid to the northern tribes.

(2) historical

Page 44: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

44

1000 AD

960: Song capital startup at Kaifeng.

City sizes in collapse - Seems to be high q (cityquake), population flattening. But global network fosters small-scale trade that will build more global centers over time.

N~2

Silk Routes

Page 45: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

45

The time is 1100 (cityrise)

• One connected world:• One cut-node: Bougie• Silk road connections:• High point of trade• Islamic Spain tied in• Large cities spread out• Cityrise (low q)• Venetian trade connects to

Milano, radiates to Europe

• Kyoto to Marrakesh• Mediterranean trade rising• More small cities, peter out.• Byzantium struggles with

Normans in Palermo ….• Venetian fleets expand• High point of Song innovation

and trade, capital at Kaifeng. Invention of national markets, credit mechanisms, and paper money diffuse

(2) historical

Page 46: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

46

1100 AD

CITYRISE

Global network links characterize low q (more exponential body with power law tail for city sizes)

Silk Routes

Page 47: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

47

1150 AD

Global network links characterize low q (more exponential body with power law tail for city sizes)

1127: Northern Song capital of Kaifeng conquered, Song to south at Hangzhou

Silk Routes diminish

Page 48: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

48

1200 AD

Song capital at Hangzhou

Golden Horde silk routes

Global network links characterize low q

Silk Routes prosper

Pax Mongolia: Control of C+W Asia ; Chin in No. China use and spread paper money from 1154

Page 49: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

49

1250 AD

QITYQUAKE FOR CHINA

Broken network links for China lead change to high q – lead the west by 50 years

1215: Jin lose Beijing to Mongols

1234: Mongols conquer Jin

Song capital stays at Hangzhou in South but silk route trade disrupted by conflict

Silk Routes decline

Page 50: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

50

1300 AD

CITYQUAKE FOR EURASIA (following one for China) AND FOR THE WORLD

Broken network links characterize high q (here: tenuous interregional connectors)

4-Khanate conflicts lessen Mongol trade

Mongols conquer Southern Song 1279: Kublai Khan becomes Yuan emperor

Mongol use and spread paper money after 1264

=cutnode

Page 51: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

51

Some findings, reiterated and extended:

• Zipfian for city sizes not invariant

• Actual city size distributions are q-governed and reflect spread or self-enclosure that is greatly affected by war and trade

• Trade zone N biconnectedness (as affected by conflict) interacts with city size q distributions (p<.003) varying by a fitted q-exponential parameter (time-lag effect higher, p <.001)

• (We give the rest of the dynamics in other papers), especially those dealing with the medieval period in Europe but the interesting things to do are these

(2) historical

Page 52: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

52

Does N (effective bicomponents) lead q?

Can we find dynamics such as: external war breaking links → city quakes in q → population cycle → internal war diminishing external boundaries → allowing links to reconfigure at a global level

(3) Things to do

Page 53: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

53

N leads q more clearly when dichotomized

Regional fragments

(3) Things to do

Page 54: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

54

(3) Interesting things to do with the data• Looking at the correlative dynamics for Turchin’s

dataset on secular cycles. Secular rise/fall to q-rise/fall two-to-one timing. Involves breaking out regions: China, England, Continental Europe, USA, Japan; and scaling q for each.

• Relating the q-quake timings to world and regional population growth in general.

• Finding the relations of all this to upsweeps of global empires (the Chase-Dunn project at UCR) and networks of royals and nobles (Ben Jester) …

• And more: possibly a joint NSF HSD grant …?

Page 55: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

55

low lowhigh[q3- high

q-periods have a close fit, at different time scales doublings, with: 2:1 Secular Population cycles

(not shown) ~4:1 Modelski world leadership cycles, circa 8:1 Kondratiev cycles

(3) Things to do

Page 56: Cityrise and Cityquake: Network Dynamics of City Growth, Trade Networks, and Conflict Five Alternations Between Global Economy and Regional Economies in

56

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

5.0

900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000

Year

NN converges for different distances: MEGACITIES and GAPS

(3) Things to do