NAME OF FIRM(S)

1 Metric Engineering Inc.

1A - Proposer's Experience and Qualifications (Max. 35 points) 28 30 32 902A - Proposer's Team Experience (Max. 35 points) 28 29 30 873A - Experience of Senior Project Administrator/Engineer (Max. 10 points) 6 8 9 234A - CEI Philosophy, Methodology and Process (Max. 10 points) 8 8 9 255A - Technical Approach (Max. 10 points) 7 8 8 23

Qualitative Scores 77 83 88 248 3

Ale

jand

ro B

arrio

s (M

iam

i-Dad

e C

ount

y)

Gira

ldo

"Ger

ry"

Mar

quez

(OC

I/CO

M)

FIN

AL

RA

NK

SUB

-TO

TAL

QU

ALI

TATI

VE S

CO

RES

TOTA

L SC

OR

ES

Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager

REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034

Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI

EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING

John

De

Pazo

s (O

CI/C

OM

)CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP

PROJECT B-30624

Thursday, May 3, 2018 EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEMBERS

TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034

DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENT

Page 1 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson

Ale

jand

ro B

arrio

s (M

iam

i-Dad

e C

ount

y)

Gira

ldo

"Ger

ry"

Mar

quez

(OC

I/CO

M)

FIN

AL

RA

NK

SUB

-TO

TAL

QU

ALI

TATI

VE S

CO

RES

TOTA

L SC

OR

ES

Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager

REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034

Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI

EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING

John

De

Pazo

s (O

CI/C

OM

)CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP

PROJECT B-30624

Thursday, May 3, 2018 EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEMBERS

TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034

DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENT

2 R.J. Behar & Company, Inc.

1A - Proposer's Experience and Qualifications (Max. 35 points) 27 29 34 902A - Proposer's Team Experience (Max. 35 points) 27 31 34 923A - Experience of Senior Project Administrator/Engineer (Max. 10 points) 9 9 9 274A - CEI Philosophy, Methodology and Process (Max. 10 points) 9 8 9 265A - Technical Approach (Max. 10 points) 9 9 10 28

Qualitative Scores 81 86 96 263 2Page 2 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson

Ale

jand

ro B

arrio

s (M

iam

i-Dad

e C

ount

y)

Gira

ldo

"Ger

ry"

Mar

quez

(OC

I/CO

M)

FIN

AL

RA

NK

SUB

-TO

TAL

QU

ALI

TATI

VE S

CO

RES

TOTA

L SC

OR

ES

Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager

REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034

Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI

EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING

John

De

Pazo

s (O

CI/C

OM

)CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP

PROJECT B-30624

Thursday, May 3, 2018 EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEMBERS

TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034

DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENT

3 Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc.

1A - Proposer's Experience and Qualifications (Max. 35 points) 30 31 32 932A - Proposer's Team Experience (Max. 35 points) 30 31 32 933A - Experience of Senior Project Administrator/Engineer (Max. 10 points) 9 9 8 264A - CEI Philosophy, Methodology and Process (Max. 10 points) 9 8 9 265A - Technical Approach (Max. 10 points) 9 9 9 27

Qualitative Scores 87 88 90 265 1Page 3 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson

Name Score JP Score GM Score AB TQP1 Criteria 1 Criteria 2 Criteria 22 Criteria 3 Criteria 4 TQP2 TQP3 Percentage FinalCalvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc. 87 88 90 265 93 93 26 26 27 265 265 88.3% 1R.J. Behar & Company, Inc. 81 86 96 263 90 92 27 26 28 263 263 87.7% 2Metric Engineering Inc. 77 83 88 248 90 87 23 25 23 248 248 82.7% 3

Tota

l Poi

nts P

erce

ntag

e

EVALUATION SCORES

BY COMMITTEE

Prop

oser

's Qu

alific

atio

ns an

d Ex

perie

nce

Tota

l Poi

nts

EVALUTION SCORES BY CRITERIA

Emilio T. González, Ph. D., City Manager

SUMMARY TABULATION SHEET RFQ NO. 16-17-034

Gira

ldo

"Ger

ry" M

arqu

ez (O

CI/C

OM)

Aleja

ndro

Bar

rios (

Miam

i-Dad

e Cou

nty)

CEI P

hilo

soph

y, Me

thod

olog

y and

Pro

cess

Tota

l Qua

litat

ive P

oint

s

(A

ll Com

mitt

ee M

embe

rs)

Prop

oser

's Te

am E

xper

ience

John

De P

azos

(OCI

/COM

)

FINA

L RA

NKIN

G

Tech

nica

l App

roac

h

Annie Perez, CPPO, Director of Procurement Steven C. Williamson, Director, OCI

Expe

rienc

e of S

enio

r Pro

ject

Adm

inist

rato

r/Eng

inee

r

EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETINGThursday, May 3, 2018

Tota

l Qua

litat

ive P

oint

s

(A

ll Eva

luat

ion

Crite

ria)

DEPARTMENT OF PROCUREMENTREQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS (RFQ) 16-17-034

CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING AND INSPECTION SERVICES FOR OVERTOWN GREENWAY AT NW 11TH TERRRACE - FDOT LAP

PROJECT B-30624

Page 4 of 4 Sade Chaney, Chairperson