city of madison historic preservation project · • 1931 first preservation ordinance in us •...

38
CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT

Upload: others

Post on 11-Jul-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT

Page 2: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

PURPOSE OF THE PROJECT

Creating Madison’s first plan to identify, celebrate, and preserve the places that represent our collective history.

Page 3: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

WHY IS HISTORIC PRESERVATION IMPORTANT?

Page 4: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

WHAT IS A PLAN?

Page 5: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

PLAN PROCESS

Where are we? (Discovery/Values)

Where do we want to go? (Goals + Objectives)

What options do we have to get there? (Alternatives)

What are our priorities? (Actions)

Page 6: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

TWO PROJECT PARTS

1 Historic Preservation Ordinance Revisions

• Revise Historic District Sections

2 The Plan

• Discovery of Historic Resources Data

• Development of the Historic Preservation Plan

Page 7: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

CONSULTANT TEAM

JENNIFER L. LEHRKEAIA, LEED AP, NCARB, OWNER

ROWAN DAVIDSONASSOCIATE AIA

BOB SHORTASSOCIATE AIA____________

TIMOTHY HEGGLANDCONSULTANT

CAROLYN ESSWEINAICP, CNU-A, OWNER

JASON TISHOWNER

Page 8: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

HISTORIC PRESERVATION ORDINANCE

Page 9: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

• 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US

• 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin

• 1970 First Preservation Ordinance in Madison

• 2015 Major Ordinance Revisions (LORC)

HISTORIC PRESERVATIONORDINANCE REVISIONS

Page 10: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

HISTORIC RESOURCES

Landmarks

• 182 individual sites

Historic Districts

• Mansion Hill (designated 1970)• Third Lake Ridge (designated 1978)• University Heights (designated 1985)• Marquette Bungalows (designated 1994)• First Settlement (designated 2001)

Page 11: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

MANSION HILL

Page 12: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

MANSION HILL

Page 13: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

THIRD LAKE RIDGE

Page 14: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

THIRD LAKE RIDGE

Page 15: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

UNIVERSITY HEIGHTS

Page 16: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

UNIVERSITY HEIGHTS

Page 17: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

MARQUETTE BUNGALOWS

Page 18: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

MARQUETTE BUNGALOWS

Page 19: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

FIRST SETTLEMENT

Page 20: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

FIRST SETTLEMENT

Page 21: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

Standards are a series of concepts about maintaining, repairing, and replacing historic materials, as well as designing new additions or making alterations in order to retain the historic character of the resource.

WHAT ARE STANDARDS FOR REVIEW?

Page 22: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

• Building Height and Scale• Proportion of front façade and openings• Rhythm of solids to voids in front facades• Rhythm of spacing and buildings on streets• Rhythm of entrance porch and other projections• Relationship of materials, texture, and color• Roof shape• Landscaping

WHAT ARE STANDARDS FOR REVIEW?

Page 23: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

• Create equal standards across all districts

• Incorporate current industry practices

• Make ordinance easier to understand

WHY REVISE STANDARDS FOR REVIEW?

Page 24: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

ORDINANCE REVISION PROCESS

Page 25: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

Public Meetings15 meetings (3 meetings in each district)

• Gather input from district property owners, commission members, and City residents

• Identify ordinance successes and challenges

• Inform revisions to be made to the ordinance.

ORDINANCE REVISION PROCESS NEXT STEPS

Page 26: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

HISTORIC PRESERVATIONPLAN

Page 27: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

PURPOSE OF THE PLAN

Creating Madison’s first ever plan to identify, celebrate, and preserve the places that represent our collective history.

Page 28: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

DISCOVERY OFHISTORIC RESOURCES DATA

Information is vital to make informed decisions - Accurate and up-to-date- Include all neighborhoods of the city- Include all members of the community

So we can answer the questions:- Which properties are historic?- Which historic resources are important?- Which historic resources are worth preserving?

Page 29: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

Historical data with a focus on underrepresented communities including:

• African American• First Nation• Hmong• Latino / Hispanic• LGBT+• Women• others

DISCOVERY OF HISTORIC RESOURCES DATA

Page 30: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

• Conduct research at local institutions

• Engage community organizations

• Discover information provided by community members

• Identify properties associated with the history of each community

• Evaluate properties (survey)

DISCOVERY OF HISTORIC RESOURCES DATA

Page 31: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

DISCOVERY OF HISTORIC RESOURCES DATA

AgricultureArchitectureArt and literatureCommerceEducationEntertainment & RecreationGovernmentIndustryPlanning & Landscape ArchitectureReligionSettlementSocial & Political MovementsTransportation

Possible Historical Themes:

Page 32: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLAN

• Historic Resource Data Discovery

• Community Values

• Goals & Objectives

• Implementation Strategy

• Citywide Future Survey Strategy

Page 33: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLAN

Data Discovery &Community Values (Where are we?)

• Public Input meetings Fall / Winter 2017

• Discuss importance of historic preservation

Page 34: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

HISTORIC PRESERVATION PLAN

SAVE THE DATEPlease join us to discuss:Community ValuesNovember 2, 2017Location to be determined

Page 35: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT PRINCIPLES

• Connect on a personal level – make it relevant• Actively engage underrepresented communities• Strengthen existing groups and networks• Provide options to participate a little or a lot• Explain how input will be used• Be responsive and flexible • Keep it simple – not academic• Ask people what they need and how they want to

participate

Page 36: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT

We need your help –

How do we effectively engage underrepresented communities?

How do we make historic preservation matter more to you?

Page 37: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

BREAKOUT CONVERSATIONS

Page 38: CITY OF MADISON HISTORIC PRESERVATION PROJECT · • 1931 First Preservation Ordinance in US • 1967 First Preservation Ordinance in Wisconsin • 1970 First Preservation Ordinance

THANK YOU FOR PARTICIPATINGAmy Scanlon, Preservation [email protected](608) 266-6552 or (608) 267-8649 (se habla español)