characterization of tooth movement in corticotomy ... · title: characterization of tooth movement...

1
Results Results Bone Volume Bone Volume Oneway Oneway ANOVA with ANOVA with Scheffe Scheffe post hoc testing showed a significant difference post hoc testing showed a significant difference in the bone volume in the VOI at post in the bone volume in the VOI at post - - op day 14 op day 14 (10.1) (10.1) compared to control days compared to control days 21 and 42 21 and 42 (16.3 and 17.0, p<.05). (16.3 and 17.0, p<.05). Bone Volume Fraction Bone Volume Fraction Bone volume fraction (BV/TV) after decortication at post Bone volume fraction (BV/TV) after decortication at post - - op days 7, 14, 21, and op days 7, 14, 21, and 42 was significantly lower 42 was significantly lower (p<.05), (p<.05), than all controls and 3 than all controls and 3 - - day post decortication; day post decortication; lowest BV/TV was 14 days after decortication lowest BV/TV was 14 days after decortication (37.2%) (37.2%) compared to 3 compared to 3 - - day post day post decortication decortication (49.5%) (49.5%) and all controls and all controls (50.5% to 57.8%). (50.5% to 57.8%). Average Mineral Density Average Mineral Density (All Voxels) (All Voxels) In all post decortication groups In all post decortication groups (except 3 (except 3 - - day post day post decortication), decortication), average mineral density of HA for all voxels average mineral density of HA for all voxels was significantly lower than all controls was significantly lower than all controls (except 3 (except 3 - - day day control); control); lowest was 42 lowest was 42 - - day post decortication day post decortication (458.2 mg (458.2 mg HA/ HA/ ccm ccm ) ) and significantly lower than all controls and significantly lower than all controls (568.7 to (568.7 to 598.1 mg HA/ 598.1 mg HA/ ccm ccm ) ) except day 3 except day 3 (530.0 mg HA/ (530.0 mg HA/ ccm ccm ). ). Conclusion Conclusion Using Micro Using Micro - - CT analysis, alveolar bone was studied in 3 CT analysis, alveolar bone was studied in 3 - - D as an organ and a D as an organ and a subtle modeling tissue subsequent to decortication and tooth mov subtle modeling tissue subsequent to decortication and tooth mov ement. ement. Decreases in bone fraction & density were evident as early as 7 Decreases in bone fraction & density were evident as early as 7 days post days post decortication and tooth movement appeared to prolong the osteope decortication and tooth movement appeared to prolong the osteope nic effect nic effect initiated by selective decortication. initiated by selective decortication. Osteopenia is a state of relative demineralization commensurate Osteopenia is a state of relative demineralization commensurate with bone with bone modeling and may explain the rapid tooth movement. modeling and may explain the rapid tooth movement. Micro Micro - - computed computed tomography (Micro tomography (Micro - - CT) is an emerging technology that allows CT) is an emerging technology that allows nondestructive assessment and analysis of the three dimensional nondestructive assessment and analysis of the three dimensional structure structure of bone. of bone. Objectives Objectives Using Micro Using Micro - - CT technology, to evaluate the osteopenic condition of alveolar CT technology, to evaluate the osteopenic condition of alveolar bone (density and volume) after selective decortication and the bone (density and volume) after selective decortication and the effect of effect of tooth movement on medullary bone re tooth movement on medullary bone re - - mineralization over a six week period. mineralization over a six week period. Methods & Materials Methods & Materials Procedure: Procedure: 28 CRL 28 CRL - - CD male rats underwent selective CD male rats underwent selective buccal & palatal alveolar decortication buccal & palatal alveolar decortication adjacent to the left maxillary first molar in a adjacent to the left maxillary first molar in a split mouth design. split mouth design. Mesial tooth movement using a 25 gram Sentalloy spring Mesial tooth movement using a 25 gram Sentalloy spring secured to a micro secured to a micro - - screw lingual to the upper incisors. screw lingual to the upper incisors. At least 5 animals sacrificed at post At least 5 animals sacrificed at post - - op days 3, 7, 14, 21, and 42. op days 3, 7, 14, 21, and 42. Total maxillas prepared for Micro Total maxillas prepared for Micro - - CT volumetric imaging CT volumetric imaging (SCANCO Medical uCT (SCANCO Medical uCT - - 40, a desktop cone beam scanner) 40, a desktop cone beam scanner) and scanned at 70 and scanned at 70 kVP kVP & 114 & 114 microA microA , with 200 , with 200 msec msec . integration time per angle, at medium . integration time per angle, at medium resolution resolution (1024x1024 pixel slice), (1024x1024 pixel slice), and 36 micron voxel size and 36 micron voxel size (slice thickness). (slice thickness). All samples All samples binarized binarized using the same parameters for filter and threshold. using the same parameters for filter and threshold. Data of Interest: Data of Interest: The volume of interest (VOI) surrounding the left maxillary firs The volume of interest (VOI) surrounding the left maxillary firs t molar was t molar was defined as: mesial defined as: mesial - - most of 1 most of 1 st st molar; mesial molar; mesial - - most of 2 most of 2 nd nd molar; lateral molar; lateral - - most most of buccal & palatal alveolar cortical plates; apical of buccal & palatal alveolar cortical plates; apical - - most of 1 most of 1 st st molar root tip; molar root tip; and coronal and coronal - - most of 1 most of 1 st st molar root furcation. The following variables were molar root furcation. The following variables were calculated for control and treated sides: bone volume, bone volu calculated for control and treated sides: bone volume, bone volu me/total me/total volume (BV/TV), and average mineral density of hydroxyappatite ( volume (BV/TV), and average mineral density of hydroxyappatite ( HA) taken HA) taken over all voxels in the volume. over all voxels in the volume. Micro Micro - - CT Analysis of Osteopenia CT Analysis of Osteopenia Following Following Selective Alveolar Decortication & Tooth Movement Selective Alveolar Decortication & Tooth Movement Boston University Boston University K.B. Pham K.B. Pham - - Nguyen* Nguyen* , , D.J. Ferguson, R.S. Carvalho, A. Kantarci, T.E. Van Dyke D.J. Ferguson, R.S. Carvalho, A. Kantarci, T.E. Van Dyke Introduction Introduction Decortication Decortication - - facilitated orthodontics is a relatively new technique facilitated orthodontics is a relatively new technique combining braces and alveolar corticotomy plus grafting (PAOO combining braces and alveolar corticotomy plus grafting (PAOO tm tm ). ). (Wilcko, WM, et al. (Wilcko, WM, et al. Internat Internat J Perio J Perio Restor Restor Dent 21:9 Dent 21:9 - - 19, 2001) 19, 2001) Malocclusions Malocclusions are resolved and dental arches are resolved and dental arches decrowded decrowded 3X to 4X more rapidly 3X to 4X more rapidly than without PAOO than without PAOO tm tm . . ( ( Wilcko WM, et al. World J Ortho 4:197 Wilcko WM, et al. World J Ortho 4:197 - - 205, 2003) 205, 2003) Decortication is an incision made into cortical bone after the Decortication is an incision made into cortical bone after the orthodontic appliances have been placed. orthodontic appliances have been placed. Surgical scarring of Surgical scarring of alveolar bone induces a localized increase in hard and soft tiss alveolar bone induces a localized increase in hard and soft tiss ue ue turnover, a process collectively known as Regional Acceleratory turnover, a process collectively known as Regional Acceleratory Phenomena or RAP. Phenomena or RAP. (Frost HA, (Frost HA, Orthop Orthop Clin Clin of N of N Amer Amer 12:725, 1981) 12:725, 1981) Sebaoun Sebaoun ( ( MS Thesis, BU, 2005) MS Thesis, BU, 2005) demonstrated an increase demonstrated an increase in apposition and resorption in apposition and resorption of rat alveolar spongiosa of rat alveolar spongiosa adjacent to corticotomy adjacent to corticotomy incisions with 3X bone incisions with 3X bone turnover and diminished turnover and diminished bone density. bone density. Verna showed a significant increase in tooth Verna showed a significant increase in tooth movement when increased bone turnover was movement when increased bone turnover was induced in rats. induced in rats. ( ( EurJO EurJO 22:343, 2000) 22:343, 2000) BV/TV BV/TV Group Group Surgery Surgery Control Control 50.5% 50.5% 55.1% 55.1% 57.8% 57.8% 21 Day 21 Day 44.8%* 44.8%* 56.3% 56.3% 42 Day 42 Day 40.0%* 40.0%* 55.9% 55.9% 3 Day 3 Day 49.5% 49.5% 7 Day 7 Day 14 Day 14 Day 37.2%* 37.2%* 45.5%* 45.5%* 3X spongiosa turnover Decortication incisions (from: Sebaoun J-D, Masters Thesis, BU, 2006) (after: Wilcko WM, et al: World J Ortho 4:197-205, 2003) (after: Wilcko WM, et al: Internat J Perio Restor Dent 4:9-19, 2001) Pre-Tx 6 months Post Tx Pre-Tx 6 months Post Tx Corticotomy incisions Bone grafting material Post Corticotomy @ 3 wks Post Corticotomy @ 3 wks Control @ 3 wks Control @ 3 wks 2.5X 2.5X Orthodontics & Periodontology * = p<.05 * = p<.05 Average Average Mineral Mineral Density Density Surgery Surgery Control Control 530.0 530.0 568.7 568.7 598.1 598.1 21 Day 21 Day 500.1* 500.1* 583.6 583.6 42 Day 42 Day 458.2* 458.2* 584.9 584.9 3 Day 3 Day 542.8 542.8 7 Day 7 Day 14 Day 14 Day 468.4* 468.4* 526.4* 526.4* * = p<.05 * = p<.05

Upload: others

Post on 13-Oct-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Characterization of Tooth Movement in Corticotomy ... · Title: Characterization of Tooth Movement in Corticotomy-Facilitated Orthodontics Michael Kacewicz BUSDM Author: user Created

ResultsResultsBone VolumeBone VolumeOnewayOneway ANOVA with ANOVA with ScheffeScheffe post hoc testing showed a significant difference post hoc testing showed a significant difference in the bone volume in the VOI at postin the bone volume in the VOI at post--op day 14 op day 14 (10.1)(10.1) compared to control days compared to control days 21 and 42 21 and 42 (16.3 and 17.0, p<.05).(16.3 and 17.0, p<.05).

Bone Volume FractionBone Volume FractionBone volume fraction (BV/TV) after decortication at postBone volume fraction (BV/TV) after decortication at post--op days 7, 14, 21, and op days 7, 14, 21, and 42 was significantly lower 42 was significantly lower (p<.05),(p<.05), than all controls and 3than all controls and 3--day post decortication; day post decortication; lowest BV/TV was 14 days after decortication lowest BV/TV was 14 days after decortication (37.2%)(37.2%) compared to 3compared to 3--day post day post decortication decortication (49.5%)(49.5%) and all controls and all controls (50.5% to 57.8%).(50.5% to 57.8%).

Average Mineral Density Average Mineral Density (All Voxels)(All Voxels)In all post decortication groups In all post decortication groups (except 3(except 3--day post day post decortication),decortication), average mineral density of HA for all voxels average mineral density of HA for all voxels was significantly lower than all controls was significantly lower than all controls (except 3(except 3--day day control);control); lowest was 42lowest was 42--day post decortication day post decortication (458.2 mg (458.2 mg HA/HA/ccmccm)) and significantly lower than all controls and significantly lower than all controls (568.7 to (568.7 to 598.1 mg HA/598.1 mg HA/ccmccm)) except day 3 except day 3 (530.0 mg HA/(530.0 mg HA/ccmccm).).

ConclusionConclusionUsing MicroUsing Micro--CT analysis, alveolar bone was studied in 3CT analysis, alveolar bone was studied in 3--D as an organ and a D as an organ and a subtle modeling tissue subsequent to decortication and tooth movsubtle modeling tissue subsequent to decortication and tooth movement. ement. Decreases in bone fraction & density were evident as early as 7 Decreases in bone fraction & density were evident as early as 7 days post days post decortication and tooth movement appeared to prolong the osteopedecortication and tooth movement appeared to prolong the osteopenic effect nic effect initiated by selective decortication.initiated by selective decortication.

Osteopenia is a state of relative demineralization commensurate Osteopenia is a state of relative demineralization commensurate with bone with bone modeling and may explain the rapid tooth movement.modeling and may explain the rapid tooth movement. MicroMicro--computed computed tomography (Microtomography (Micro--CT) is an emerging technology that allows CT) is an emerging technology that allows nondestructive assessment and analysis of the three dimensional nondestructive assessment and analysis of the three dimensional structure structure of bone.of bone.

ObjectivesObjectivesUsing MicroUsing Micro--CT technology, to evaluate the osteopenic condition of alveolar CT technology, to evaluate the osteopenic condition of alveolar bone (density and volume) after selective decortication and the bone (density and volume) after selective decortication and the effect of effect of tooth movement on medullary bone retooth movement on medullary bone re--mineralization over a six week period.mineralization over a six week period.

Methods & Materials Methods & Materials Procedure:Procedure:

▪▪ 28 CRL28 CRL--CD male rats underwent selective CD male rats underwent selective buccal & palatal alveolar decortication buccal & palatal alveolar decortication adjacent to the left maxillary first molar in a adjacent to the left maxillary first molar in a split mouth design. split mouth design.

▪▪ Mesial tooth movement using a 25 gram Sentalloy spring Mesial tooth movement using a 25 gram Sentalloy spring secured to a microsecured to a micro--screw lingual to the upper incisors. screw lingual to the upper incisors.

▪▪ At least 5 animals sacrificed at postAt least 5 animals sacrificed at post--op days 3, 7, 14, 21, and 42. op days 3, 7, 14, 21, and 42. ▪▪ Total maxillas prepared for MicroTotal maxillas prepared for Micro--CT volumetric imaging CT volumetric imaging

(SCANCO Medical uCT(SCANCO Medical uCT--40, a desktop cone beam scanner)40, a desktop cone beam scanner) and scanned at 70and scanned at 70kVPkVP & 114 & 114 microAmicroA, with 200 , with 200 msecmsec. integration time per angle, at medium. integration time per angle, at mediumresolution resolution (1024x1024 pixel slice),(1024x1024 pixel slice), and 36 micron voxel size and 36 micron voxel size (slice thickness).(slice thickness).

▪▪ All samples All samples binarizedbinarized using the same parameters for filter and threshold.using the same parameters for filter and threshold.

Data of Interest:Data of Interest:The volume of interest (VOI) surrounding the left maxillary firsThe volume of interest (VOI) surrounding the left maxillary first molar was t molar was defined as: mesialdefined as: mesial--most of 1most of 1stst molar; mesialmolar; mesial--most of 2most of 2ndnd molar; lateralmolar; lateral--most most of buccal & palatal alveolar cortical plates; apicalof buccal & palatal alveolar cortical plates; apical--most of 1most of 1stst molar root tip; molar root tip; and coronaland coronal--most of 1most of 1stst molar root furcation. The following variables were molar root furcation. The following variables were calculated for control and treated sides: bone volume, bone volucalculated for control and treated sides: bone volume, bone volume/total me/total volume (BV/TV), and average mineral density of hydroxyappatite (volume (BV/TV), and average mineral density of hydroxyappatite (HA) taken HA) taken over all voxels in the volume.over all voxels in the volume.

MicroMicro--CT Analysis of Osteopenia CT Analysis of Osteopenia Following Following Selective Alveolar Decortication & Tooth Movement Selective Alveolar Decortication & Tooth Movement

Boston UniversityBoston UniversityK.B. PhamK.B. Pham--Nguyen*Nguyen*,, D.J. Ferguson, R.S. Carvalho, A. Kantarci, T.E. Van DykeD.J. Ferguson, R.S. Carvalho, A. Kantarci, T.E. Van Dyke

IntroductionIntroductionDecorticationDecortication--facilitated orthodontics is a relatively new technique facilitated orthodontics is a relatively new technique combining braces and alveolar corticotomy plus grafting (PAOOcombining braces and alveolar corticotomy plus grafting (PAOOtmtm). ). (Wilcko, WM, et al. (Wilcko, WM, et al. InternatInternat J Perio J Perio RestorRestor Dent 21:9Dent 21:9--19, 2001)19, 2001) Malocclusions Malocclusions are resolved and dental arches are resolved and dental arches decrowdeddecrowded 3X to 4X more rapidly 3X to 4X more rapidly than without PAOOthan without PAOOtmtm. . ((Wilcko WM, et al. World J Ortho 4:197Wilcko WM, et al. World J Ortho 4:197--205, 2003)205, 2003)

Decortication is an incision made into cortical bone after the Decortication is an incision made into cortical bone after the orthodontic appliances have been placed. orthodontic appliances have been placed. Surgical scarring of Surgical scarring of alveolar bone induces a localized increase in hard and soft tissalveolar bone induces a localized increase in hard and soft tissue ue turnover, a process collectively known as Regional Acceleratory turnover, a process collectively known as Regional Acceleratory Phenomena or RAP. Phenomena or RAP. (Frost HA, (Frost HA, OrthopOrthop ClinClin of N of N AmerAmer 12:725, 1981)12:725, 1981)

Sebaoun Sebaoun ((MS Thesis, BU, 2005)MS Thesis, BU, 2005)

demonstrated an increase demonstrated an increase in apposition and resorption in apposition and resorption of rat alveolar spongiosa of rat alveolar spongiosa adjacent to corticotomy adjacent to corticotomy incisions with 3X bone incisions with 3X bone turnover and diminished turnover and diminished bone density.bone density.

Verna showed a significant increase in tooth Verna showed a significant increase in tooth movement when increased bone turnover wasmovement when increased bone turnover wasinduced in rats. induced in rats. ((EurJOEurJO 22:343, 2000)22:343, 2000)

BV/TV BV/TV GroupGroup SurgerySurgery ControlControl

50.5%50.5%

55.1%55.1%

57.8%57.8%

21 Day21 Day 44.8%*44.8%* 56.3%56.3%

42 Day42 Day 40.0%*40.0%* 55.9%55.9%

3 Day3 Day 49.5%49.5%

7 Day7 Day14 Day14 Day 37.2%*37.2%*

45.5%*45.5%*

3X spongiosa turnoverDecortication incisions

(from: Sebaoun J-D, Masters Thesis, BU, 2006)

(after: Wilcko WM, et al: World J Ortho 4:197-205, 2003)

(after: Wilcko WM, et al: Internat J Perio Restor Dent 4:9-19, 2001)Pre-Tx 6 months Post Tx Pre-Tx 6 months Post Tx

Corticotomyincisions

Bone graftingmaterial

Post Corticotomy @ 3 wksPost Corticotomy @ 3 wksControl @ 3 wksControl @ 3 wks

2.5X2.5X

Orthodontics &Periodontology

* = p<.05* = p<.05

AverageAverageMineral Mineral DensityDensity

SurgerySurgery ControlControl

530.0530.0568.7568.7598.1598.1

21 Day21 Day 500.1*500.1* 583.6583.642 Day42 Day 458.2*458.2* 584.9584.9

3 Day3 Day 542.8542.87 Day7 Day14 Day14 Day 468.4*468.4*

526.4*526.4*

* = p<.05* = p<.05