champ observations of multiple field-aligned currents

CHAMP Observations of CHAMP Observations of Multiple Field-Aligned Currents Multiple Field-Aligned Currents

Dimitar Danov 1, Petko Nenovski 2

1 Solar-Terrestrial Influences LaboratorySolar-Terrestrial Influences Laboratory, , Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, BulgariaBulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria

2 Geophysical InstituteGeophysical Institute, , Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, BulgariaBulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia, Bulgaria

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201

0CHAMP Observations of Multiple Field-Aligned Currents (FAC)

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


IntroductionIntroduction We analyze FAC measurements on board the CHAMP satellite, conducted on days 30.06-02.07.2008, under quiet geomagnetic conditions. In general, there are 91 crossings over polar regions (46 in the Northern and 45 – in the Southern hemisphere). A typical picture of measurements is shown on Fig.1.

Figure 1

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


What in the data is unusual?A) too many FAC sheets B) too intense FAC in the polar cap The procedure of determination of FAC density and distribution by single satellite measurement is accompanied with the some uncertainties

Principal objective of our work is identification of ‘false’ FAC sheets

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Possible sources of false FAC sheets. Possible sources of false FAC sheets.

1.Associated with calculations.

The formula used is:

We see that at small angles of attack ( big α ), the calculation error becomes unacceptably large.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Possible sources of false FAC sheets. Possible sources of false FAC sheets. 2.Errors independent of the instrument

They are related to departure from the basic assumption for unlimited in azimuthal direction layers (false sheets) - Illustrated in Fig.2 and 2b.

Figure 2.a Two cases of satellite crossing square to finite current sheet

On both figures current density is 1 (to us) , the finite dimensions of the sheet are 20x2 and it is centered on (0,0). (in conventional units). The measured tangential B-field component is parallel to the X-axis, the normal component - to Y-axis.

With blue squares are shown the

areas of false currents.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201



2.Errors independent of the instrument

Figure 2.b Three cases of satellite crossing to finite current sheet, at angles of attack different from 900.

With blue squares are shown the

areas of false currents.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201



2.Errors independent of the instrument Summary: In cases shown on figures 2a and 2b, a “three sheet” structure appears – one true (in the middle) and two “false” on both sides.

Errors in FAC estimation…. Errors in FAC estimation…. (summary)(summary)

In case of finite (azimuthally) FAC sheets, the measurements are highly

dependent on the way in which the satellite encounters them.False layers appear and / or Actual FAC values are greater than measuredAt small angles of attack ( big α ), the calculation error becomes unacceptably large.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


ProcessingProcessing of CHAMP’s Dataof CHAMP’s Data We define single current sheet, as measurements spacing between two zero crossings of the curve shown in Figure 1. 1084 sheets are numbered around the north pole and 1176 - around the south pole;We believe that an averaged FAC would presents layers better than the maximum value of the FAC in layers In order to reduce the number of false FACs, we impose the following conditions:1/ the average density must be «significantly» different from zero (Student criterion) (56 sheets were removed in North, 76 – in SUD)2/ all FAC obtained at attack angles (the angle between the satellite trajectory and polar oval) less than 650 were discarded (136 - in North, 720 – in SUD) (thus whole séances were omitted)Knowing the coordinates (LAT, MLT) of the points where the satellite encounters the boundaries of the layers, we can determine "thickness" δLAT and “width” δLong=15*δMLT of the layers and angle of attack3/ impose the condition that α must be larger than 650 (311 sheets were removed in North, 155 – in SUD)These conditions are sufficient to exclude all layers in the DAWN-DUSK sectors. All satellite passes are in Noon-Night direction.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


ResultsResults

Most part of the measured FAC are weak. They are positioned equatorward or poleward from the main area of observation. Strong FACs (>0.5μA/m-2) were noted in the following intervals: [770;830]NORD/NOON, [670;740]NORD/NIGHT and [680;730]SUD/NIGHT

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Results Results continuationcontinuation

1. Most part of the measured FAC are weak. They are positioned equatorward or poleward from the main area of observation. Strong FACs (>0.5μA/m-2) were noted in the following intervals: [770;830]NORD/NOON, [670;740]NORD/NIGHT and [680;730]SUD/NIGHT

2. The stronger ones are associated with open field lines on dayside, and prolonged (L > 7) on night side. ( Tsyganenko GEOPAC2005 )

3. The number of simultaneously measured FAC sheets is time dependent. It have a peak in the intervals (UT) 01:28÷06:25 and 16:48÷21:34 on 30 June, 00:28÷05:12 and 17:07÷21:51 on 01 July ...

4. In other time intervals we measure 1÷3 sheets per sector. It exists passes with zero sheets in one sector and 2÷3 sheets in other.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Results Results continuationcontinuation

Figure 3 An example of good agreement of measurements with the model, perhaps because the satellite crosses the layers perpendicular and away from their edges.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


ConclusionsConclusions

There are no regions where the sign of current remains unchanged, therefore, it is not possible to discriminate regions similar to R1/R2

We were unable to find a relationship between SW-parameters and observed FAC structures.

Possible reasons include: 1. Within the time resolution of SW-parameters data (1 min sampling rate

in OMNI-WEB data base) the FAC changes its sign several times.2. Effects caused by the FAC structure crossings (especially after the

manner of that crossing) distort the measurements in such a way, that the relationship of FAC with the solar wind parameters is lost.

Acknowledgments:Acknowledgments:

The authors thank Dr Patricia RitterDr Patricia Ritter and Dr Hermann LuehrDr Hermann Luehr

(from Helmholtz Centre Potsdam, GFZ German Research Centre for Geosciences, Germany)

for providing CHAMP data, consulting and their recent publications on FAC.

Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Sec

on

d W

ork

sh

op

"S

ola

r in

flu

en

ces

on

th

e io

no

sp

he

re

a

nd

mag

ne

tos

ph

ere

",

So

zop

ol,

Bu

lgar

ia, 7

-11

Ju

ne

,201


Thank you for your attention Thank you for your attention

champ observations of multiple field-aligned currents

Documents