challenges of the panama canal expansion dredging...

29
Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan Challenges Challenges of of the the Panama Panama Canal Canal Expansion Expansion Dredging Dredging Plan Plan Will Quinby, P.E., Program Management Advisor Dredging/Dry Excavation 20 May 2008 Will Quinby, P.E., Program Management Advisor Dredging/Dry Excavation 20 May 2008

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Challengesof the

Panama Canal ExpansionDredging Plan

ChallengesChallengesofof thethe

PanamaPanama Canal Canal ExpansionExpansionDredgingDredging PlanPlan

Will Quinby, P.E., Program Management Advisor

Dredging/Dry Excavation

20 May 2008

Will Quinby, P.E., Program Management Advisor

Dredging/Dry Excavation

20 May 2008

Page 2: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

A Unique ProgramA Unique ProgramCutting a new channel through hills to a new

set of LocksDredging through the Continental Divide

Cutting a new channel through hills to a new set of Locks

Dredging through the Continental Divide

Page 3: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Expansion Program Dredging ScopeEntrance Channels

PacificAtlantic

Freshwater DredgingGatun LakePacific Access Channel/Dry ExcavationGaillard/Culebra Cut

Lessons

Expansion Program Dredging ScopeEntrance Channels

PacificAtlantic

Freshwater DredgingGatun LakePacific Access Channel/Dry ExcavationGaillard/Culebra Cut

Lessons

Page 4: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

PACIFIC ENTRANCE CHANNELPACIFIC ENTRANCE CHANNEL

Total dredging volume = 9.1 M m3

Pacific southern approach channel = 2.5 M m3

Pacific entrance deepening andwidening = 6.6 M m3

Page 5: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

PACIFIC ENTRANCE CHANNEL DESCRIPTION

PACIFIC ENTRANCE CHANNEL DESCRIPTION

Widening from 192 m to a minimum 225 mDeepening from -14.2 m to -15.5 m MLWSTotal est. volume: 9.1 M m3 Length 14.4 KmAward: 31 March 2008Estimated Start: July 2008Duration: 4 years

Page 6: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

PACIFIC SOUTH APPROACH CHANNEL

Page 7: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

PACIFIC ENTRANCE DREDGINGNORTHEN SECTOR

Page 8: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

PACIFIC ENTRANCE DREDGINGSOUTHERN SECTOR

PACIFIC ENTRANCE DREDGINGSOUTHERN SECTOR

Page 9: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

PACIFIC ENTRANCE CHANNELDREDGED MATERIAL DISPOSALPACIFIC ENTRANCE CHANNEL

DREDGED MATERIAL DISPOSAL

8,652,588TORTOLITA SOUTH(Open Water)

7,313,678TORTOLITA (Open Water)

1,492,811PALO SECO(Open Water)

3,657,280FARFAN(Upland)

2,294,000VELASQUEZ(Upland)

CapacityArea/Type

Page 10: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

ATLANTIC ENTRANCE CHANNEL

Total estimated Atlantic Dredgingvolume 26.6 to 30.7 M m3

Atlantic NorthernAnchoragedeepening

12.6 to 16.7 M m3

Atlantic Northernaccess channel =

7 M m3

Atlantic Entrancedeepening and

widening = 7 M m3

Page 11: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Atlantic Entrance1 Contract

• Widening from 192 m to a minimum 225 m• Deepen: -14.2 m MLW. to -15.5 m MLW.• Dredging = 14 M m3• Dry excavation = 1 M m3• Total:15 Mm3 (Million cubic meters)• Material: mud, silt, clay and sand

•Approach Channel: Hardness <15 Mpa.

Atlantic Entrance1 Contract

• Widening from 192 m to a minimum 225 m• Deepen: -14.2 m MLW. to -15.5 m MLW.• Dredging = 14 M m3• Dry excavation = 1 M m3• Total:15 Mm3 (Million cubic meters)• Material: mud, silt, clay and sand

•Approach Channel: Hardness <15 Mpa.

Width: 225m (740´) ▶Width: 225m (740´) ▶

THE ATLANTIC ENTRANCE AND NORTH APPROACH CHANNEL

Page 12: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

ATLANTIC ENTRANCEATLANTIC ENTRANCE

15.52184NORTH APPROACHCHANNEL

15.5225 / 2609.80ATLANTICENTRANCE

DESIGN DEPTH (m)

CHANNELWIDTH

(m)

LENGTH (km)SECTION

Page 13: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Freshwater DredgingFreshwater Dredging

Gatun Lake

Pacific Access Channel Dredging

Gaillard/Culebra Cut

Gatun Lake

Pacific Access Channel Dredging

Gaillard/Culebra Cut

Page 14: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

FRESHWATER DREDGING VOLUMES

13 MSubtotal0.4Intermediate Plug (Pacific Locks)0.5North Plug (Pacific Locks)3.2Pacific Access Channel (FFP contract)3.8Charter Option (Equipment Rental)5.1Gatún Lake North (FFP contract)

CONTRACTS14 MSubtotal3.3Gaillard Cut10.7Gatún LakeM m3ACP RESOURCES

Grand Total Freshwater Dredging 27 M m3

Page 15: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Gatún Lake

Page 16: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Fixed Price Contract:

• 5 M m3, from Gatún to Buena Vista Reach.

• Option: 2.5M m3 Mechanical Dredging in other reaches• Includes island removal, drilling & blasting, dry excavation

Estimated Award : February 2009Estimated Start: June 2009Estimated Completion: October 2013

Gatún Gatún LakeLake

Page 17: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

PacificPacific Access Access ChannelChannel

Page 18: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Dry ExcavationDry Excavation

Page 19: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Pacific Access ChannelSequence of Excavation

PAC. No.5

PAC. No.2

PAC. No.4

PAC. No.3

PAC. No.1

Page 20: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

FixedFixed PricePrice Contract: Contract: •• 3.2 M m3.2 M m33, , northnorth endend ofof thethe Access Access ChannelChannel toto thethe PacificPacific LocksLocks

•• EstimatedEstimated AwardAward : Feb 2009: Feb 2009•• EstEst. . StartStart: : JuneJune 20092009•• EstEst CompletionCompletion: May 2011: May 2011

Pacific Access Channel Dredging

Page 21: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

The Gaillard/Culebra CutThe Gaillard/Culebra Cut

Page 22: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Dredging in the CutDredging in the CutSignificant operating restrictionsLimited disposal areas for hydraulic dredging: ACP’s New Cutter

Suction Dredge maximum operating rangeDisposal Elevation above water level ranges from 10 to 130 m. ANAM (Environmental Requirements)Cycle times for mechanical dredging range from 2 to 6 hours

UXO Cucaracha

Bas ObispoN

Page 23: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

SlidesSlides

Page 24: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

SlidesSlides

Page 25: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

SlidesSlides

Page 26: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Dredging Lessons Dredging Lessons Programs must be viewed as Programs – Not a collection of independent Projects

- Master Program Schedule

Dredged Material Disposal Areas are not the sexiest part of an Authority’s portfolio

Nevertheless, a competent party must be assigned the responsibility to survey, permit, maintain, and manage these resources

Programs must be viewed as Programs – Not a collection of independent Projects

- Master Program Schedule

Dredged Material Disposal Areas are not the sexiest part of an Authority’s portfolio

Nevertheless, a competent party must be assigned the responsibility to survey, permit, maintain, and manage these resources

Page 27: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

Dredging Lessons Dredging Lessons Marshalling the resources to execute a major program takes time. Start early acquiring:

Geophysical investigations/SurveysDredging EquipmentSupport Equipment and Personnel (Pilots, tug captains)

Contract Scopes of Work, Bidding Time, MobilizationPartnering with Pilots, Port Interests, Environmental Agencies, Contractors can have significant beneficial impacts to a dredging program. Interference = RiskImpacts of Fuel Prices, Foreign Exchange, and the world dredging market can pose significant risks

Marshalling the resources to execute a major program takes time. Start early acquiring:

Geophysical investigations/SurveysDredging EquipmentSupport Equipment and Personnel (Pilots, tug captains)

Contract Scopes of Work, Bidding Time, MobilizationPartnering with Pilots, Port Interests, Environmental Agencies, Contractors can have significant beneficial impacts to a dredging program. Interference = RiskImpacts of Fuel Prices, Foreign Exchange, and the world dredging market can pose significant risks

Page 28: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

CONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Page 29: Challenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Planaapa.files.cms-plus.com/PDFs/08HARBORS_Quinby_Will.pdfChallenges of the Panama Canal Expansion Dredging Plan of the Panama Canal

QUESTIONS?QUESTIONS?