chair: paul baker, ga independent schools special interest group panel: robert morris, igcse ning...
TRANSCRIPT
Chair: Paul Baker, GA Independent Schools Special Interest Group
Panel: Robert Morris, IGCSE Ning Leader and Geography Teacher,
Shrewsbury School; Peter Price, Head of Geography, Charterhouse School and
IGCSE ExaminerLianne Aherne, Geography Teacher, Wycombe Abbey School.
My personal views; I’m not speaking for my school or any exam board
Thanks to Edexcel for use of slides Pre-16 and post-16 almost entirely linear Ethos aiming to maximise learning time and
minimise examination disruption Geography Department traditionally offered
OCR GCE and OCR C GCSE Pre-16: majority of subjects offer IGCSE Post-16: majority offer Pre-U (only 3 offer A
Level) From 2011, Charterhouse will also offer IB
Key features First teaching in Sept 2009 for exam
in June 2011 IGCSEs are recognized as equivalent,
grade for grade, to UK GCSEs Edexcel Certificate plans?
Familiar content Uncomplicated, un-tiered
qualification Option to localise content
www.edexcel.com/igcse2009 Electronic copies of Specs, SAMs, TSMs Resources – tied text published (Pearson);
we use New Wider World 3 (Nelson Thornes) Training, including online Inset Ask the Expert & Ask Edexcel UK networking (new for Edexcel?) Ning (administered by Rob Morris,
Shrewsbury)
Offers more choice of topics for study and less content coverage (teaching time in international centres?)
Integrated assessment of practical skills, including actual and virtual fieldwork
NO CONTROLLED ASSESSMENT Streamlines assessment into a
single, common external examination paper with no fieldwork report option
Nine topics with three in each of three Sections – A, B and C
Basically physical geography (The Natural Environment and People):
1. River Environments 2. Coastal Environments 3. Hazardous Environments Expectation that teachers will choose
TWO not all three to study
Basically human geography (People and their Environments):
1. Economic Activity and Energy 2. Ecosystems and Rural
Environments 3. Urban Environments Again, expectation that teachers will
choose only TWO to study
Addresses contemporary global issues:
1. Fragile Environments, including soil erosion, desertification, TRF de-forestation and global warming
2. Globalisation and Migration 3. Development and Human Welfare Candidates expected to study only
ONE of the three topics
Amounts to a FIVE topic programme – approximately one topic every ten weeks
Each topic has a standard format built around THREE key ideas and specifies practical skills (Sections A and B) and examples (all three Sections) needing to be covered
Candidates required to study EIGHT fieldwork opportunities (TWO in each of their FOUR Section A and B topics) as part of practical skill development
Sustainable development and future worlds overarch all nine topics/units
Candidates required to study EIGHT fieldwork opportunities (TWO in each of their FOUR Section A and B topics), e.g.
Measuring river channel features/water quality Beach measurements Surveying peoples’ views on the management of
coastlines/a hazard event/renewable energy Collecting and recording weather data Small-scale ecosystem investigation Farm production study Urban Environmental Quality Survey and land use transects Delivery?
Charterhouse Year 10s cover these fieldwork requirements in a week-long trip to the south of France in June
Shrewsbury do a number of days to cover the requirements in Shropshire and Wales
Assessment through one common untiered written examination paper
June 2011 first paper (only one paper per year) 2 hour 45 minute exam in Q & A booklet format E-marked Candidates answer five of nine structured questions,
each carrying 30 marks Answer two from each of Sections A and B, and one from
C Variety of question types within each full question.
Incline of difficulty from opening short-response to nine mark extended prose finale (stretch and challenge)
Section A and B questions contain practical skills/fieldwork parts
Past papers from “old” Spec cover most topics
Specification designed for 2-year programme delivery over 5 terms
1 topic/unit per term Teaching time guide = 1.5 hours +
1hr homework per week Teachers free to choose own case
studies and contexts for learning
IGCSEs are recognized as equivalent, grade for grade, to UK GCSEs - part of Cambridge ICE
Only one tier for assessment Two or three papers (dependent on
whether fieldwork report is done) Papers available in June or November
Teacher Support website Electronic copies of Specs, SAMs,
TSMs Resources – Course specific
textbooks Training, including online and face to
face INSET Online Community
Offers choice of topics for study and less content coverage
Fieldwork Report (2000 words) or Fieldwork paper
NO CONTROLLED ASSESSMENT Skills paper
Divided into three themes which have been designed to develop an understanding of both the natural and the human environment:
Population and settlement The natural environment Economic development and the use
of resources
Basically Human geography: Population Dynamics• Density, distribution, growth, migration
and structure Settlement • Development, functions, spheres of
influence, land use and problems
Basically physical geography (The natural environment):
Plate Tectonics Landforms and Landscape Processes
(rivers and coasts) Weather, Climate and Natural
Vegetation Inter-relationships between the natural
environment and human activities
Economic development and the use of resources
Agricultural systems Industrial systems Leisure activities and tourism Energy and water resources Environmental risks and benefits: resource
conservation and management
Candidates have to study all topics though only 1 question has to be answered on each them
The skills paper may ask questions across a variety of themes
Centres may offer either the Coursework report (paper 3 ) or the Alternative to Coursework Paper (paper 4) for assessment.
The Coursework has to be 2000 words in length and the title approved by CIE
Titles are suggested
Paper 1 – 1 hour 45 minutes – 45% of marks Tests Themes 1-3 Candidates answer any three questions out of six. There are two structured and resource based
questions set on each of three themes. Paper 2 - 1 hour 30 minutes – 27.5 % of
marks Candidates answer all the questions. The paper is based on testing the interpretation and
analysis of geographical information and on the application of graphical and other techniques.
One question is based on a 1:25 000 or 1:50 000 topographical map of a tropical area such as Zimbabwe, the Caribbean or Mauritius.
and either Paper 3 Coursework (Centre-based assessment) Teachers set one school-based assignment of up to
2000 words. Or Paper 4 1 hour 30 minutes Alternative to Coursework Candidates answer all the questions, completing a series of
written tasks based on the three themes The questions involve an appreciation of a range of
techniques used in fieldwork studies
27.5% of marks
Terminal assessment in both courses Do endless modules make a good education? Broad content with some challenging contemporary
twists Broad fieldwork in Edexcel but ‘back to the future’ in
CIE Growing support community (“Ask an Expert” gives
excellent access to Chief Examiner in Edexcel) NO CONTROLLED ASSESSMENT IN EITHERBUT Linearity in a modular curriculum Lacks resourcing of a domestic Spec International board on a steep learning curve about
servicing increased centres in their home country