cervical spine injuries in sport - dr jonathon ball
TRANSCRIPT
RNSH
Cervical Spine
Injuries in Sport
“Its All in the Game”
Dr Jonathon R. BallFRACS BMed BMedSc(Hons)
GradDipBiomedE
Neurosurgeon and Spinal Surgeon
Royal North Shore Hospital
North Shore Private Hospital
Sydney, Australia
Head of Department, Neurosurgery
Royal North Shore Hospital
Sydney, Australia
RNSH
RNSH
Cervical Fractures @ RNSHn = 389
RNSHsource :http://www.abc.net.au/7.30/
RNSHsource : www. trove.nla.gov.au
RNSH
Outline
• Acute spinal cord injury
• Cervical cord neurapraxia
• Burners/Stingers
• Cervical disc protrusions & fractures
RNSH
SCI in Australia (2007-2008)
• 285 traumatic SCIs
• 25 (9%) “struck by, or collision with another
person or object”
• 10 participating in sporting or leisure activities
(excludes water actives)
source : AIHW: Norton L 2010. Spinal cord injury, Australia 2007–08. Injury research and statistics series no. 52. Cat. no. INJCAT 128. Canberra: AIHW.
RNSHsource : http://irbplayerwelfare.com/pdfs/CI_Risk_Assessment_EN.pdf
RNSHsource : http://irbplayerwelfare.com/pdfs/CI_Risk_Assessment_EN.pdf
RNSH
Outline
• Acute spinal cord injury
• Cervical cord neurapraxia
• Burners/Stingers
• Cervical disc protrusions & fractures
RNSH
RNSH
Classification of CCN
• type (neurologic
deficit)
• plegia
• paresis
• parasthesia
• grade (duration)
• 1 : < 15 mins
• 2 : 15 mins - 24 hrs
• 3 : > 24 hrs
• pattern
• quad : all 4 limbs
• upper : both upper
limbs
• lower : both lower
limbs
• hemi : ipsilateral
upper/lower limbs
RNSH
‘Pincer Mechanism’after Penning (1962)
source : Torg JS et al. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 84(1):112-122 (2002).
RNSH
Pathophysiology
source : Torg JS et al. Clin Orthop Relat Res. (321):259-69 (1995).
RNSH
Pathophysiology
source : Torg JS et al. Clin Orthop Relat Res. (321):259-69 (1995).
RNSH
Torg/Pavlov Ratio
source : Chao S et al. Sports Med. 40(1):59-75 (2010).
RNSHsource : Torg JS et al. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 78(9):1308-14 (1996).
RNSH
RNSH
source : Meredith DS et al. Am J Sports Med. 78(9):1308-14 (2013).
RNSH
Outline
• Acute spinal cord injury
• Cervical spinal cord neurapraxia
• Burners/Stingers
• Cervical disc protrusions & fractures
RNSH
‘Burners/Stingers’
• temporary episode of unilateral upper extremity
dysaesthesia +/- motor weakness
source : Chang D & Bosco J. Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis. 64(3-4): 119-129
(2006).
RNSH
Outline
• Acute spinal cord injury
• Cervical spinal cord neurapraxia
• Burners/Stingers
• Cervical disc protrusions & fractures
RNSH
To Operate or Not ?
• acute patent safety
• need for acute neurologic decompression
• need for acute stabilisation
• future RTP considerations
• higher functional demand - prevent further
injuries
• potential for ‘timely’ healing op vs non-op
based on : C. Prusmack, NASS
2013.
RNSH
Neurologic Decompression
• Clinical
• neuro exam : normal, improving, worsening,
fixed
• radicular vs cord vs plexus
• Radiographic
• SC compression : disc, fracture, haematoma
• Functional Reserve : ?? how much
• Stenosis : focal, diffuse, congenital,
degenerative
• Foraminal stenosis
• Contusionbased on : C. Prusmack, NASS
2013.
RNSH
Future RTP Considerations
• safety issues
• prevent further SCI
• prevent further neurologic symptoms
• consequence of surgical intervention
• professional issues
• level of player
• sport & position
• livelihood
• timing
based on : C. Prusmack, NASS
2013.
RNSH
• 99 x NFL players
• 53 x operative
• 32 x ACDF, 3 x foraminotomy, 16 not known
• RTP 72 % (29.3 games, 2.8 years)
• ASD 5.3%
• 46 x non-operative
• RTP 46 % (14.7 games, 1.5 years)
RNSH
• 16 x NFL players
• 9 x radicular Sx, 3 x CCN
• initial non-operative Mx
• 3 x ACDF - 1 x RTP
• 13 non-operative - 8 x RTP
RNSHsource : Burnett MG JS & Sonntag V Neurosurg Focus. 15;21(4):E5
(2006).
RNSH
• 15 subjects (7 x NFL, 8 x WWE)
• RTP 13/15
• adjacent disc herniation - 1 subject after 2 years
RNSH
• 19 professional rugby players (1998-2003)
• 17 x single level ACDF, 2 x double level
• 13 x RTP same level, 1 x RTP lower level
• 5 did not RTP
• 2 x recurrent neck/radicular symptoms
RNSH
Return to Play Criteria
• Clinical
• no neck pain, normal cervical range of motion,
normal neurologic exam
• no prohibitive history
• Radiographic
• flex-ext XR - no instability
• CT : no significant fracture
• MR : no cord compression (? functional reserve,
contusion, foraminal stenosis)
based on : C. Prusmack, NASS
2013.
RNSH
Outline
• Acute spinal cord injury
• Cervical cord neurapraxia
• Burners/Stingers
• Cervical disc protrusions & fractures
RNSH
RNSH