central exclusive production of heavy ... - durham...

52
1 V.A. Khoze (IPPP, Durham) Central exclusive production of heavy quarkonia and charmonium-like states (selected topics) X

Upload: others

Post on 16-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

1

V.A. Khoze (IPPP, Durham)

Central exclusive production of heavy quarkoniaand charmonium-like states

(selected topics)

X

Page 2: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

2

Introduction (why we are interested in CEP processes?)

Standard Candle CEP reactions.

CEP as a way to study old and new heavy resonances

Towards the Full Acceptance Detector at the LHC (bj-1992).

Summary and Outlook.

(for new physics)

Page 3: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

3

Page 4: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

4

(a lot of attention)

(KMR-2000)

Page 5: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

5

CDF results (dijets, γγ, χc), D0

not so long ago: between Scylla and Charibdis:Many orders of magnitude differences in the theoretical predictions are now an ancient

history

σH(CEP) ~ 10 σH (incl)-4

(1997-2013)

The Durham technology

(new LHCb & CMS results)

Page 6: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

6

(KMR-2000)

Page 7: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

7

Could

Page 8: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

8

Page 9: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

9

Page 10: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

10

All 3 measurements are all in good agreement (factor “few”) with the Durham group predictions.

*

*

*Prpospects !

FSC@LHC

(more coming soon )

Tevatron observations: CDF and D0 each have exclusive JJ events > 100 GeV

80

First CEP measurements

Page 11: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

11

Too good to be true ?!

Phys.Rev.Lett.102:242001,2009

80

(LHCb-first inclusive mid-July 2013)

Page 12: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

12

(A. Alekseev-1958-positronium)KMR-01

The effects of non-zero (especially for 2+ ). …and especially without proton detectors!

Page 13: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

13

2

First ‘exclusive’ events now being seen at LHCb.Results suggestive of a sizeable contribution.

1 : 0.6 : 0.22

Page 14: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

14(in a good agreement with the Durham expectations)

Page 15: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

15

Page 16: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

16Spin-parity Analyzer

Page 17: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

17

Page 18: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

18

(0 ) /d dσ φ− ≈

Very topical for STAR@RHIC forthcoming measurements with tagged forward protons.

KKMR-03

Hopefully, LHCb one day if/when RPs are installed.

SPIN-PARITY ANALYSER

Page 19: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

19

Page 20: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

20

Page 21: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

21

Page 22: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

22

and light

(CMS, Totem+CMS- soon to come)

Page 23: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

23

Page 24: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

2424

(Currently no complete theoretical description of onium properties.)

(BABAR (2008))

(spins- still unconfirmed)

The heaviest and most compact quark-antiquark bound state in nature

P-wave Bottomonia

Page 25: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

25

Page 26: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

26

Zoo of charmonium –like XYZ states

Page 27: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

27

Page 28: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

28“Charmonium production & decay”, 6-8 March 2013, LAL, Orsay

Page 29: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

29

Page 30: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

30

Page 31: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

31Good Luck to LHCb

Page 32: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

32

Towards Full Acceptance Detector (bj- 1992)

IS THERE A WAY OUT ?

Yes, an addition of Forward Shower Counters around beam pipes- low PU runs

first results of combined CMS+ TOTEM measurements with the

FSCs on (see showers from particles with | | = 7-9)

( Alice is installing such counters, ongoing studies for LHCb)

Page 33: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

33

Published in JINST-2009

(Installed in 2011 at the CMS)

Page 34: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

34

Page 35: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

35

Page 36: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

36

Page 37: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

37

Page 38: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

38Dipion CEP- coming soon

Page 39: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

39

Page 40: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

40

LHCbExcellent particle ID (pion/Kaonseparation), vertex and proper

time resolutionexotic states….

Potentially rich program of CDP studies with the LHCb

JINST 4:P11019,2009.

Page 41: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

41

Page 42: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

42

An installation of the FSCs and RPs at the LHCb could strongly enhance physics potential for the CEP measurements.

Currently active studies are in progress, both on the experimental and theory sides.

Page 43: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

43

We are looking forward to new exciting adventures in

Exclusiveland

Page 44: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

44

Page 45: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

45

Page 46: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

46

Page 47: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

47

Page 48: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

48

Page 49: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

49

Page 50: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

50

Page 51: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

51

Page 52: Central exclusive production of heavy ... - Durham Universityvalery/my-talks/khoze-Flavour13F.pdf · The Durham technology (new LHCb & CMS results) 6 (KMR-2000) 7 Could. 8. 9. 10

52

UNCERTAINTIES UNCERTAINTIES

Known Unknowns

Unknown Unknowns

N(N)LO- radiative effects (K-factors etc..)‘…possible inadequancy of PT theory in αs …’ R.Barbieri et al-1980

‘ ‘Right’ choice of gluon densities, in particular at so low scales as in the case( potentiality of a factor of ~3 rise for the H-case ) .

Complete model for calculation of enhanced absorption.

c

Gluons at so low scales, surprises are not excluded at all.

χ

Non- pQCD effects in the meson characteristics.Currently no complete description of heavy quarkonium characteristics.

‘Two gluon width does not tell the whole story.’

Could be Could be Factor of 5 up or down Factor of 5 up or down