case:17-03283-lts doc#:1806 filed:11/15/17 entered:11/15 ...€¦ · chapter 11 cases effective as...

Hearing Date: December 20, 2017 at 9:30 a.m. (prevailing Atlantic Standard Time) Objection Deadline: December 6, 2017

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF PUERTO RICO

In re: THE FINANCIAL OVERSIGHT AND MANAGEMENT BOARD FOR PUERTO RICO, as representative of THE COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO, et al.

Debtors.1

PROMESA Title III No. 17 BK 3283-LTS

(Jointly Administered)

SUMMARY COVER TO THE FIRST INTERIM APPLICATION OF

BENNAZAR, GARCÍA & MILIÁN, C.S.P. FOR ALLOWANCE OF COMPENSATION FOR SERVICES RENDERED AND REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES

INCURRED AS ATTORNEYS THE OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO

FROM JUNE 16, 2017 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 2017

Name of Applicant: Bennazar, García & Milián, C.S.P.

Authorized to Provide Services To: The Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico

Period for which compensation is sought: June 16, 2017 through September 30, 2017

1 The Debtors in these jointly-administered PROMESA title III cases, along with each Debtor’s respective

title III case number listed as a bankruptcy case number due to software limitations and the last four (4) digits of each Debtor’s federal tax identification number, as applicable, are: (i) Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3481); (ii) Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3284) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 8474); (iii) Puerto Rico Highways and Transportation Authority (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3567-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3808); (iv) Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3566-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 9686); and (v) Puerto Rico Electric and Power Authority (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 4780) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3747).

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1806 Filed:11/15/17 Entered:11/15/17 21:06:01 Desc: Main Document of 23

2

Monthly Fee Statements subject to the request: June-July 2017 August 2017 September 2017

Total compensation sought this period: $280,175.002

Total expenses sought this period: $7,952.24

Petition Date: May 3, 2017

Retention Date: June 16, 2017

Date of Order Approving Employment: August 10, 2017

Total compensation approved by interim order to date: None

Total expenses approved by interim order to date: None

Total compensation paid to date: None

Total expenses paid to date: None

Total compensation subject to objection: None

Total expenses subject to objection: None

Blended rate in this application for all attorneys: $322.58

Blended rate in this application for all timekeepers: $322.58

Number of Professionals Included in this Application: 5

Difference Between Fees Budgeted and Compensation Sought:

N/A

Number of Professionals Billing Fewer than 15 Hours to this Case:

1

Rates Higher than Those Disclosed at Retention: None

Objection Deadline: December 13, 2017

2 The compensation requested on Bennazar’s monthly fee statements totals $281,675.00. As detailed in the

Application, Bennazar has voluntarily reduced its request by $1,500.00 to reflect two time entries in which timekeepers recorded non-working travel time at their full hourly rate.


3

Time Billed By Professonial

Name of Professional Title

Year Admitted

Hourly Billing Rate

Total Billed Hours

Total Compensation

A.J. Bennazar Zequeira Partner 1974 $375.00 276.5 $103,687.50

Hector Mayol Kauffmann Partner 2010 $375.00 287.5 $105,187.50

Francisco Del Castillo Associate 2001 $250.00 264.2 $66,050.00

Eunice Candelaria Associate 2014 $150.00 41.5 $6,225.00

Carlos R. Ramírez Isern Associate 2016 $150.00 3.5 $525.00

Totals:

873.2

$ 281,675.00

3

Blended Rate: $322.58

3 This total does not reflect Bennazar’s voluntary reduction of $1,500.00 for non-working travel time.


Hearing Date: December 20, 2017 at 9:30 a.m. (prevailing Atlantic Standard Time) Objection Deadline: December 6, 2017



Debtors.4



FIRST INTERIM APPLICATION OF BENNAZAR, GARCÍA &

MILIÁN FOR ALLOWANCE OF COMPENSATION AND REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES INCURRED AS ATTORNEYS THE OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO

FROM JUNE 16, 2017 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 2017

To the Honorable United States District Court Judge Laura Taylor Swain:

Bennazar, García & Milián, C.S.P. ( “Bennazar”), attorneys for The Official Committee

of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (the “Retiree Committee”) in the

above-captioned Title III cases (“Title III Cases”), hereby submits this first application

(“Application”) for an award of interim compensation for professional services rendered in the

4 The Debtors in these jointly-administered PROMESA title III cases, along with each Debtor’s respective title III case number listed as a bankruptcy case number due to software limitations and the last four (4) digits of each Debtor’s federal tax identification number, as applicable, are: (i) Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3481); (ii) Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3284) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 8474); (iii) Puerto Rico Highways and Transportation Authority (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3567-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3808); (iv) Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3566-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 9686); and (v) Puerto Rico Electric and Power Authority (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 4780) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3747).


5

amount of $280,175.00, and reimbursement for actual and necessary expenses incurred in

connection with such services in the amount of $7,957.24, for the period from June 16, 2017

through September 30, 2017 (the “Interim Period”). Bennazar submits this Application pursuant

to sections 316 and 317 of the Puerto Rico Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act

(“PROMESA”),5 48 U.S.C. §§ 2176, 2177; sections 105(a) and 503(b) of the Bankruptcy Code,6

11 U.S.C. § 503(b); Rule 2016(a) of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure (the “Bankruptcy

Rules”)7; Rule 2016-1 of the Bankruptcy Rules for the United States Bankruptcy Court for the

District of Puerto Rico (the “Local Rules”)8; the Court’s Order Authorizing the Employment of

Bennazar, García & Milián, C.S.P. as Attorneys for the Committee of Retired Employees

(“Retention Order”) [Dkt. No. 1003]; the First Amended Order Setting Procedures for Interim

Compensation and Reimbursement of Expenses of Professionals (“Interim Compensation

Order”) [Dkt. No. 1715]; the United States Trustee’s Guidelines for Reviewing Applications for

Compensation and Reimbursement of Expenses Filed Under 11 U.S.C. § 330 by Attorneys in Large

Chapter 11 Cases Effective as of November 1, 2013 (the “UST Guidelines”),9 and the Fee Review-

Timeline and Process Memorandum prepared by the Fee Examiner. In support of the Application,

5 PROMESA is codified at 48 U.S.C. §§ 2101–2241.

6 The Bankruptcy Code is codified at 11 U.S.C. §§ 101–1532. Unless otherwise noted, all Bankruptcy Code

sections cited in the Application are made applicable to these Title III Cases pursuant to section 301(a) of PROMESA. 7 All Bankruptcy Rules referenced in this Application are made applicable to these Title III Cases pursuant to section 310 of PROMESA. 8 The Local Rules are made applicable here by the Court’s Order (A) Imposing and Rendering Applicable

Local Bankruptcy Rules to These Title III Cases, (B) Authorizing Establishment of Certain Notice, Case Management, and Administrative Procedures, and (C) Granting Related Relief [Dkt. No. 249]. 9 Pursuant to the Interim Compensation Order and Local Rule 2016-1, the Retiree Committee is required to

comply with the UST Guidelines.


6

Bennazar submits the Certification of A.J. Bennazar Zequeira (the “Bennazar Certification”),

attached hereto as Exhibit A, and respectfully represents as follows:

Preliminary Statement

1. Bennazar has served as counsel to the Retiree Committee since June 16, 2017. The

Retiree Committee represents approximately 160,000 retired employees of the Commonwealth

and various governmental bodies and their surviving beneficiaries, including Puerto Rico’s retired

teachers, police officers, firefighters, judges, municipal clerks, engineers, and other government

workers of all categories (the “Retirees”). The Retirees’ pensions are underfunded by at least $49

billion. They are the largest group of creditors in these Title III Cases.

2. During the Interim Period, Bennazar performed a variety legal services that were

necessary and appropriate for the efficient and economical resolution of the Retiree Committee’s

interests in the Title III Cases, including, among other things: meeting and conferring with the

Retiree Committee; providing local counsel expertise; advising the Retiree Committee of its

powers and duties; advising the Retiree Committee regarding proposed modifications of their

pension, healthcare, and other accrued retirement benefits of Puerto Rico’s public-employment

retirees; representing the Retiree Committee at court hearings and mediation sessions involving

matters pertaining to the benefits of the Retirees; preparing on behalf of the Retiree Committee

motions, applications, orders, and other legal papers; advising the Retiree Committee with respect

to bankruptcy, labor, employee benefits, and litigation issues concerning the Retirees’ benefits.

3. Bennazar’s work during the Interim Period was necessary for, and beneficial to, the

Retirees and served to ensure that the interests of the Retirees were properly represented and

safeguarded in these Title III Cases. Bennazar respectfully requests that the Court award the fees

and expenses requested in this Application.


7

Jurisdiction

4. The United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico (the “Court”) has

subject matter jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to PROMESA section 306(a).

5. Venue is proper pursuant to PROMESA section 307(a).

6. Bennazar makes this Application pursuant to PROMESA sections 316 and 317,

Bankruptcy Code sections 105(a) and 503(b), Bankruptcy Rule 2016, Local Rule 2016-1, the

Retention Order, the Interim Compensation Order, and the UST Guidelines.10

Background

7. On May 3, 2017, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (the “Commonwealth”), by

and through the Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico (the “Oversight

Board”), as the Commonwealth’s representative pursuant to section 315(b) of PROMESA, filed

a petition with the Court under title III of PROMESA.

8. On May 5, 2017, the Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (“COFINA”),

by and through the Oversight Board, as COFINA’s representative pursuant to PROMESA section

315(b), filed a petition with the Court under title III of PROMESA.

9. On May 21, 2017, the Puerto Rico Highways and Transportation Authority

(“HTA”), by and through the Oversight Board, as HTA’s representative pursuant to PROMESA

section 315(b), filed a petition with the Court under title III of PROMESA.

10

Bennazar has reviewed the Memorandum submitted by the Fee Examiner and is endeavoring to comply with all requirements of the Interim Order and the UST Guidelines. Bennazar’s offices were completely destroyed by Hurricane Maria. It has worked diligently to compile the information contained in this Application. To the extent certain information directed by the Interim Order or Guidelines or requested by the Fee Examiner in his Memorandum is not included, Bennazar requests from this Court an exception under the circumstances.


8

10. On May 21, 2017, the Employees Retirement System for the Commonwealth of

Puerto Rico (“ERS”), by and through the Oversight Board, as ERS’s representative pursuant to

PROMESA section 315(b), filed a petition with the Court under title III of PROMESA.

11. On July 3, 2017, the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (“PREPA”), by and

through the Oversight Board, as HTA’s representative pursuant to PROMESA section 315(b), filed

a petition with the Court under title III of PROMESA.

12. Through Orders of this Court, the Commonwealth, COFINA, HTA, ERS, and

PREPA Title III Cases are jointly administered for procedural purposes only, pursuant to

PROMESA section 304(g) and Bankruptcy Rule 1015. [See Dkt. Nos. 242, 537, 1417.]

13. On May 5, 2017, the Ad Hoc Committee for the Protection of Accrued Retirement

Benefits of Puerto Rico’s Public Employees and Retirees (the “Ad Hoc Retiree Committee”)

filed a motion seeking the appointment of an official committee of retired employees. [Dkt. No.

8.] On May 19, 2017, Guy G. Gebhardt, Acting United States Trustee for Region 21 (the “U.S.

Trustee”) filed a response in opposition to the Ad Hoc Retiree Committee’s motion. [Dkt. No.

192.]

14. On June 15, 2017, U.S. Trustee, pursuant to section 1102(a)(1) of the Bankruptcy

Code, appointed the Retiree Committee, consisting of the following nine individuals: Blanca

Paniagua, Carmen Nunez, José Marin, Juan Ortiz, Lydia Pellot, Marcos A. Lopez, Miguel Fabre,

Milagros Acevedo, and Rosario Pacheco. [Dkt. No. 340.]

Bennazar’s Retention and Fee Request

15. On June 16, 2017, the Retiree Committee elected to employ Bennazar to represent

the Retiree Committee.


9

16. On July 19, 2017, the Retiree Committee filed its Application for an Order

Approving the Employment of Bennazar, García & Milián, C.S.P. [Dkt. No. 683] (“Retention

Application”) pursuant to section 105(a) and 1103 of the Bankruptcy Code.11

17. On August 10, 2017, the Court entered the Retention Order approving Bennazar’s

retention as counsel to the Retiree Committee, effective June 16, 2017, on the terms and conditions

identified in the Retention Application. A copy of the Retention Order is attached hereto as

Exhibit B. Pursuant to the Retention Order, Bennazar is entitled to compensation for reasonable,

actual, and necessary professional services rendered and reimbursement of expenses incurred in

connection with the Title III Cases.

18. Bennazar’s fees are based upon hours charged, recorded in tenth of an hour

increments, at Bennazar’s ordinary and customary hourly rates in effect as of January 1 of the

calendar year in which the services are rendered, plus reimbursement of actual, necessary out-of-

pocket expenses and other charges incurred by Bennazar on behalf of the Retiree Committee.

Bennazar adjusts its rates annually at the start of each calendar year. The rates set forth herein are

Bennazar’s 2017 rates, and are consistent with the rates charged to other clients, including outside

of bankruptcy.

19. The cover sheet to this Application contains a schedule setting forth all Bennazar

professionals and paraprofessionals who have performed services in the Title III Cases during the

Interim Period, the capacity in which each individual is employed by Bennazar, the hourly billing

rate charged for services performed by such individual, the aggregate number of hours expended

11

In a chapter 11 case, a committee appointed under section 1102 of the Bankruptcy Code ordinarily would seek authority to employ counsel pursuant to section 328. Because PROMESA does not incorporate section 328 of the Bankruptcy Code, the Retiree Committee moved for approval of its Retention Application pursuant to sections 105(a) and 1103(a). See PROMESA § 301(a) (omitting Bankruptcy Code sections 327 and 328 from incorporation into PROMESA).


10

in this case and fees billed therefore, and the year in which each professional was first licensed to

practice law.

20. By this Application, Bennazar seeks (i) allowance of compensation in the amount

of $280,175.00; and (ii) reimbursement of expenses in the amount of $7,957.24. Bennazar has not

received any payment for services performed or reimbursement for expenses incurred during the

Interim Period.

21. This is Bennazar’s first request for interim compensation in these Title III Cases.

As set forth in the Bennazar Certification, all of the services for which interim compensation is

sought herein were rendered for and on behalf of the Retiree Committee in connection with these

chapter 11 cases. To the best of the Bennazar’s knowledge and as disclosed in the Declaration Of

A.J. Bennazar In Support Of Application of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the

Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for Order Approving the Employment of Bennazar and Block LLP

[Dkt. No. 683, Ex. A] (the “Bennazar Declaration”), Bennazar is a “disinterested person” as

defined in section 101(14) of the Bankruptcy Code, and except as otherwise specified in the

Bennazar Declaration, Bennazar’s partners, associates, and special attorneys do not hold or

represent any interest adverse to the Retiree Committee.

22. Bennazar might have in the past represented, might currently represent, and likely

in the future will represent parties in interest in this case in connection with matters unrelated to

the Retiree Committee or the Title III Cases. In the Bennazar Declaration, Bennazar disclosed its

connections to parties in interest in the Title III Cases that it has been able to ascertain using its

reasonable efforts. Bennazar will update such disclosures, as appropriate, if Bennazar becomes

aware of relevant and material new information.


11

23. Bennazar performed the services for which it is seeking compensation on behalf of

the Retiree Committee and not on behalf of any other committee, creditor, or other entity.

24. Bennazar has not received payment or promise of payment from any source other

than the Retiree Committee for services provided or to be provided in any capacity whatsoever in

connection with the Title III Cases.

25. Bennazar does not share fees with any attorneys except to the extent permitted by

section 504 of the Bankruptcy Code.

Fees and Expenses Incurred During Interim Period

A. Customary Billing Disclosures

26. Bennazar’s hourly rates are set at a level designed to compensate Bennazar fairly

for the work of its attorneys and paraprofessionals and to cover fixed and routine expenses. The

hourly rates and corresponding rate structure utilized by Bennazar in this cases are equivalent to

the hourly rates and corresponding rate structure used by Bennazar for similar complex corporate,

securities, litigation, and restructuring matters, whether in court or otherwise, regardless of

whether a fee application is required. The rates and rate structure reflect that such complex matters

typically are national in scope and typically involve great complexity, high stakes, and intense

time pressures.

27. Exhibit C to this Application reflects the time entries of the five timekeepers who

billed to this matter during the Interim Compensation period and for which Bennazar is seeking

compensation. Exhibit C contains the detailed time entries, redacted where necessary to preserve

privilege, work product, or confidentiality. The blended rate for all Bennazar attorneys (no non-

attorneys billed during the Interim Compensation Period) is $322.58.


12

B. Fees Incurred During Interim Period

28. In the ordinary course of Bennazar’s practice, Bennazar maintains records of the

time spent on the professional services provided to the Retiree Committee. Below is a summary

of fees incurred and hours worked during the Interim Period for which compensation is sought on

an hourly basis in this Application:

Time Billed By Professional

Name of Professional Title

Year Admitted

Hourly Billing Rate

Total Billed Hours

Total Compensation

A.J. Bennazar Zequeira Partner 1974 $375.00 276.5 $103,687.50

Hector Mayol Kauffmann Partner 2010 $375.00 287.5 $105,187.50

Francisco Del Castillo Associate 2001 $250.00 264.2 $66,050.00

Eunice Candelaria Associate 2014 $150.00 41.5 $6,225.00

Carlos R. Ramírez Isern Associate 2016 $150.00 3.5 $525.00

Totals:

873.2

$ 281,675.00

12

C. Expenses Incurred During Interim Period

29. In the ordinary course of Bennazar’s practice, Bennazar maintains a record of

expenses incurred in rendering professional services to the Retiree Committee and for which

reimbursement is sought. Exhibit D to this Application is a summary for the Interim Period of the

total amount of expenses for which Bennazar seeks reimbursement with respect to each category

of expenses. The out-of-pocket disbursement sum is broken down into categories of charges.

12

This total does not reflect Bennazar’s voluntary reduction of $1,500.00 for non-working travel time.


13

Summary of Legal Services Provided During the Interim Period

30. During the Interim Period, Bennazar provided important professional services to

the Retiree Committee in connection with the Title III Cases. Detailed descriptions of the specific

services provided and the time expended performing such services are attached as Exhibit C, and

a summary of the services Bennazar provided to the Retiree Committee during the Interim Period

is set forth below.

31. Bennazar has established subject matters categories (each, a “Matter Category”)

for keeping time records of the work performed for the Retiree Committee.13 The following is a

summary, by Matter Category, of the professional services provided by Bennazar during the

Interim Period. This summary is organized in accordance with Bennazar’s internal system of

matter numbers.

Court Hearings

32. Bennazar’s recorded time entries in this category reflect attendance and

representation of the Retiree Committee at court hearings; preparation for court hearings; and

review of pleadings and other submissions considered at or relevant to court hearings.

Mediation

33. Bennazar’s recorded time entries in this category reflect representation of the

Retiree Committee in all aspects of the confidential mediation process. Due to the confidential

nature of the mediation the time entries have been redacted.

13

Bennazar’s time entries for June-August are not separated by matter. As a result of Hurricane Maria and the destruction it caused Bennazar’s offices, Bennazar did not have the ability to revise its June-Augst invoices by matter. To the extent requested by the Court or the Fee Examiner, Bennazar will supplement its time entries with matter designations.


14

Committee Governance and Attendance at Meetings

34. Bennazar’s recorded time entries in this category reflect assistance of the Retiree

Committee in the proper performance of its duties; attending all of the meetings of the Retiree

Committee; and assisting the Retiree Committee in preparing agendas and minutes for those

meetings.

Case Administration/Miscellaneous

35. Bennazar’s recorded time entries in this category reflect (a) communication with

Retiree Committee members about the status of the case; (b) preparation of pleadings and court

submissions not attributable to another Matter Category; (c) negotiation with other parties in

interest; (d) time spent conferring with counsel to other parties in interest and other constituents

regarding the status of the case; (e) reviewing case developments and litigation activity; (f) internal

meetings and communication not attributable to another Matter Category; (g) case and project

management.

Employment of Professionals/Fee Applications

36. Bennazar’s recorded time entries in this category reflect (a) preparation of

Bennazar’s Retention Application and monthly fee statements; (b) review of potential conflicts of

interest; (c) communication with the United States Trustee’s office concerning appropriate

compensation and retention procedures; and (d) assisting the Retiree Committee’s advisors and

actuaries with the preparation of their monthly statements.

Pension Analysis

37. Bennazar’s recorded time entries in this category reflect (a) review and analysis of

retiree pension plans and proposed modifications to the Retiree Committee’s constituents’ accrued

benefits; (b) communication with other parties in interest, including the Oversight Board and

Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority; (c) review and analysis of pension


15

analysis prepared by the Retiree Committee’s financial advisors and actuaries and third parties;

and (d) communication Retiree Committee’s financial advisors and actuaries regarding pension

treatment.

Healthcare and Other Postemployment Benefit Analysis


healthcare and other postemployment benefits (“OPEB”) and proposed modifications to same;

(b) review and analysis of OPEB analysis; and (c) communication Retiree Committee’s financial

advisors and actuaries regarding OPEB treatment.

Contested Matters - GO/COFINA


COFINA and general obligation (“GO”) bonds; (b) review and analysis of competing bondholder

claims and court submissions; (c) review and analysis of Court orders re same; and

(d) communication with the Retiree Committee and the Retirees Committee’s advisors and

actuaries regarding bondholders’ claims.

ERS Bond Issues


litigation challenging the legality and constitutionality of the Commonwealth’s actions with

respect to ERS; (b) review and analysis of the priority and secured status of ERS bond debt;

(c) preparation of research memoranda regarding ERS bondholder claims; and (d) preparation of

intervention motion and motion to dismiss in ERS bondholder adversary proceedings, Altair v.

Commonwealth, Adv. Proc. Nos. 17-219 and 17-220.

Communications with Retirees

41. Bennazar’s recorded time entries in this category reflect time spent engaging with

Retirees and Bennazar’s coordination with the Retiree Committee’s Information Agent to develop


16

a Retiree Committee website; preparation of notices to retirees regarding protection of retirees’

claims and interests; and responding to questions raised by retirees.

Travel Time

42. This time entry reflects non-productive travel time, including travel for court

appearances, committee meetings, and mediation sessions. Pursuant to Local Rule 2016-1(a),

Bennazar is seeking compensation at one-half of its normal rate for time spent traveling in

connection with its representation of the Retiree Committee.

43. Bennazar has voluntarily reduced its requested compensation by $1,500.00 to

reflect two entries where timekeepers recorded travel time at their full hourly rate. July 8, 2017

($937.50) and September 1, 2017 ($562.50).

44. For two additional entries, timekeepers reduced their hours recorded by 50% rather

than the hourly rate: August 15, 2017 (2.5 hours travel from San Juan to New York City) and

August 28, 2017 (4.0 hours for round-trip travel from San Juan to New York). This reduction

results in a 50% reduction in compensable fees.

45. As summarized in Exhibit D and as set forth in detail in Exhibit E, Bennazar has

incurred a total of $7,952.24 in expenses on behalf of the Retiree Committee during the Interim

Period. These charges are intended to reimburse Bennazar’s direct costs that are not included in

Bennazar’s hourly billing rates. Only clients who actually use services of the types set forth in

Exhibit E of this Fee Application are separately charged for such services.

COMPENSATION REQUESTED

46. The services for which Bennazar seeks compensation in this Application were, at

the time provided, necessary for and beneficial to the Retiree Committee and his administration of

the Retiree Committee. Bennazar performed these services economically, effectively, and


17

efficiently, and they benefited the Retiree Committee. Bennazar submits that the compensation

requested is reasonable in light of the nature, extent, and value of such services to the Retiree

Committee. Accordingly, Bennazar submits the compensation sought in this Application is

warranted and should be approved.

A. Compensation Under Sections 316 and 317 of PROMESA.

47. Section 317 of PROMESA authorizes interim compensation of professionals and

incorporates the substantive standards of section 316 of PROMESA to govern the Court’s award

of interim compensation. Section 316 of PROMESA provides that a court may award a

professional employed under section 1103 of the Bankruptcy Code “reasonable compensation for

actual, necessary services rendered,” and “reimbursement for actual, necessary expenses.” 48

U.S.C. § 2176(a)(1), (2). Section 316(c) sets forth the criteria for such an award:

In determining the amount of reasonable compensation to be awarded to a professional person, the court shall consider the nature, the extent, and the value of such services, taking into account all relevant factors, including—

(1) the time spent on such services;

(2) the rates charged for such services;

(3) whether the services were necessary to the administration of, or beneficial at the time at which the service was rendered toward the completion of, a case under this chapter;

(4) whether the services were performed within a reasonable amount of time commensurate with the complexity, importance, and nature of the problem, issue, or task addressed;

(5) with respect to a professional person, whether the person is board certified or otherwise has demonstrated skill and experience in the restructuring field; and

(6) whether the compensation is reasonable based on the customary compensation charged by comparably skilled practitioners in cases other than cases under this subchapter or Title 11.


18

48 U.S.C. § 2176(c).

48. As analyzed below, Bennazar submits the elements governing awards of

compensation under PROMESA justify the allowance requested.

1. The Time and Labor Required

49. During the Interim Period, Bennazar’s partners and associates spent 873.2 hours

providing professional services to the Retiree Committee for which Bennazar seeks compensation

on an hourly basis. Bennazar coordinated its efforts with co-counsel to prevent duplication of

efforts and thereby not spend more time than required. Bennazar required this amount of time to

conduct its investigation, research and analyze numerous, complex, novel issues arising from the

Title III Cases, advise the Retiree Committee with respect to these issues, participate in resolution

of these issues, and the other tasks described herein.

2. The Rates Charged for Such Services

50. During the Interim Period, Bennazar’s hourly billing rates ranged from $150.00 to

$250.00 for associates and were $375.00 for partners. Based on the recorded hours expended by

Bennazar’s attorneys and paraprofessionals, the average hourly billing rate for Bennazar’s services

$322.58.

51. Bennazar’s hourly rates are set at a level designed to compensate Bennazar fairly

for the work of its attorneys and paraprofessionals and to cover certain fixed and routine overhead

expenses. Hourly rates vary with the experience and seniority of the individuals assigned. These

hourly rates are subject to periodic adjustments to reflect economic and other conditions and are

consistent with the rates charged elsewhere.

52. The hourly rates and corresponding rate structure that Bennazar charges in these

cases are equivalent to or less than the hourly rates and corresponding rate structure that Bennazar


19

charges for similar complex corporate, securities, litigation, and restructuring matters, whether in

court or otherwise, regardless of whether a fee application is required.

3. The Necessity of the Services and the Benefit to the Estate

53. As described herein, the services rendered by Bennazar were necessary for the

efficient and economical resolution of the Retiree Committee’s interests in the Title III Cases. All

of those services directly benefitted the Retiree Committee.

4. The Reasonableness of the Time Spent, Based on the Complexity, Importance, Nature of the Issues

54. Bennazar’s work involved the representation of the Title III Cases’ largest creditor

constituency—Puerto Rico’s 160,000 retired teachers, police officers, firefighters, judges,

municipal clerks, engineers, and other government workers of all categories—and Bennazar’s

professional services during the Interim Period were necessary to ensure that the interests of the

Retirees were re properly represented and safeguarded and that all matters relevant to the Retiree

Committee were handled in an appropriate manner. The compensation requested is reasonable in

light of those services.

5. The Experience, Reputation, and Ability of the Attorneys Providing Services

55. Bennazar attorneys have achieved a high degree of expertise and positive

reputations in their respective fields. Bennazar’s attorneys have extensive experience, knowledge

and resources in the areas of civil, commercial and administrative law, including, specifically,

those related to Puerto Rico’s Retirement Systems enabling acts, civil litigation, as well as

arbitration and mediation procedures.

6. Customary Compensation

56. The work for which Bennazar seeks compensation in this Application is of the type

and nature for which Bennazar customarily would seek compensation at the rates identified in this


20

Application. In addition, the compensation Bennazar seeks in this Application is comparable to

the compensation it would have sought for comparable work outside of a chapter 11 case.

57. Bennazar submits that the compensation requested is reasonable under all the

factors considered under sections 316 and 317 of PROMESA and that the factors justify the

allowance in full of Bennazar’s compensation and reimbursement request.

58. In view of the foregoing, Bennazar respectfully requests that it be allowed interim

compensation in the amount of $280,175.00 for services rendered during the Interim Period.

B. Reasonable and Necessary Expenses Incurred in Providing Services to the Retiree Committee.

59. For the Interim Period, Bennazar requests reimbursement of $7,952.24 for

reasonable and necessary costs and expenses incurred on behalf of the Retiree Committee.

60. Bennazar’s normal billing rates do not take these costs and expenses into

consideration. Rather, Bennazar bills each cost and expense to the applicable client. Because of

the disparity between the different clients’ requirements for expenses such as travel, computer-

assisted research, teleconference services, postage, courier and messenger services, and

photocopying, it is difficult to charge costs and expenses fairly and equitably by including them in

Bennazar’s ordinary billing rates. Accordingly, Bennazar generally charges each client for such

costs and expenses separately, in each case, at Bennazar’s costs.

61. Bennazar does not include the amortization of the cost of any investment,

equipment, or capital outlay in its charges for these services.

62. Any services billed by a third-party vendor, with the exception of certain computer-

assisted research charges, are charged to the Retiree Committee in the amount billed to and paid

by Bennazar. Like many large law firms, Bennazar has negotiated a special arrangement with

computerized research companies under which Bennazar pays a flat rate monthly fee for


21

computerized research services. Consistent with its general policy of billing out-of-pocket

expenses only to clients for which the use of such services is required, Bennazar separately charges

each client for computer-assisted research. To account for such charges while passing through

Bennazar’s cost savings resulting from its special arrangements, Bennazar charges those clients

for which such services are required at a reduced rate that is less than the rate charged by the

computerized research companies to the general public for such services. These charges are

intended to cover Bennazar’s direct costs for computerized research.

63. Pursuant to Local Rule 2016-1(b)(7), Bennazar seeks reimbursement for air travel

limited to the amount spent on coach fare.

64. Bennazar has made reasonable efforts to minimize its costs and expenses in

connection with its representation of the Retiree Committee. Each of the costs and expenses

Bennazar has incurred in providing professional services to the Retiree Committee was necessary,

reasonable, and justified under the circumstances to serve the needs of the Retiree Committee.

STATEMENT BY BENNAZAR UNDER ¶ C(5) OF THE UST GUIDELINES

65. This engagement does not involve variations from Bennazar’s standard and

customary billing rates.

66. None of the professionals included in this Application varied their hourly rate based

on the geographic location of the Title III Cases.

67. The Application does not include time or fees related to reviewing or revising time

records or preparing, reviewing, or revising invoices.

68. The Application does not include time or fees for reviewing time records to redact

any privileged or other confidential information.


22

69. The hourly rates specified in the Retention Application were effective January 1,

2017, and have not increased since that time. Bennazar’s engagement letter with the Retiree

Committee provides that Bennazar’s scheduled hourly rates are periodically adjusted, generally at

the beginning of a calendar year.

RESERVATION OF RIGHTS AND NOTICE

70. It is possible that some professional time expended or expenses incurred during the

Interim Period are not reflected in the Application. Bennazar reserves the right to include such

amounts in future fee applications.

71. Pursuant to the Interim Compensation Order, the Retiree Committee has provided

notice of this Application to: (a) the U.S. Trustee; (b) counsel to the Oversight Board; (c) counsel

to the Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority; (d) counsel to the Official

Committee of Unsecured Creditors; (e) the Fee Examiner; and (f) all parties that have filed a notice

of appearance with the Clerk of this Court, pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2002 and applicable

provisions of the Local Rules, and requested such notice.

NO PRIOR REQUEST

72. No prior application for the relief requested by this Application has been made to

this or any other court.

WHEREFORE, Bennazar respectfully requests that the Court enter an order: (a) awarding

Bennazar compensation for professional and paraprofessional services provided during the Interim

Period in the amount of $280,175.00; (b) reimbursement of actual, reasonable and necessary

expenses incurred in the Interim Period in the amount of $7,952.24; (c) granting such other relief

as is appropriate under the circumstances.


23

Respectfully submitted, BENNAZAR, GARCÍA & MILIÁN, C.S.P. By: /s/ A.J. Bennazar-Zequeira A.J. Bennazar-Zequeira Edificio Union Plaza PH-A piso 18 Avenida Ponce de León #416 Hato Rey, San Juan Puerto Rico 00918 [email protected] 787-754-9191 (telephone) 787-764-3101 (facsimile) Counsel for The Official Committee of Retired Employees of Puerto Rico

Dated: November 15, 2017


EXHIBIT A

CERTIFICATION OF A.J. BENNAZAR-ZEQUEIRA

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1806-1 Filed:11/15/17 Entered:11/15/17 21:06:01 Desc: Exhibit A - Certification of A.J. Bennazar-Zequeira Page 1 of 4



Debtors.1



VERIFIED CERTIFICATION OF A.J. BENNAZAR-ZEQUEIRA

IN SUPPORT OF THE FIRST APPLICATION OF BENNAZAR, GARCÍA & MILIÁN, C.S.P. FOR ALLOWANCE OF COMPENSATION FOR SERVICES RENDERED AND REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES

INCURRED AS ATTORNEYS TO THE OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO

RICO FROM JUNE 16, 2017 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 2017

I, A.J. Bennazar-Zequeira, have the responsibility for ensuring that the First Application

of Bennazar, García & Milián, C.S.P. for Allowance of Compensation for Services Rendered and

Reimbursement of Expenses Incurred As Attorneys to The Official Committee of Retired

Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico From June 16, 2017 through September 30, 2017

1 The Debtors in these jointly-administered PROMESA title III cases, along with each Debtor’s respective

title III case number listed as a bankruptcy case number due to software limitations and the last four (4) digits of each Debtor’s federal tax identification number, as applicable, are: (i) Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3481); (ii) Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3284) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 8474); (iii) Puerto Rico Highways and Transportation Authority (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3567-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3808); (iv) Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3566-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 9686); and (v) Puerto Rico Electric and Power Authority (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 4780) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3747).


2

(the “Application”) complies with applicable provisions of PROMESA, the Bankruptcy Rules,

the Local Rules, the Retention Order, the Interim Compensation Order, and the UST Guidelines.2

I hereby certify the following:

1. I am a partner in the firm of Bennazar, García & Milián, C.S.P. (“Bennazar”),

and have been duly admitted to practice law in the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

2. I am the lead attorney from Bennazar representing the Retiree Committee

in connection with the above-captioned Title III Cases. I am authorized to submit this

certification in support of the Application. Except as otherwise noted, I have personal

knowledge of the matters set forth herein.

3. I have read the Application. The statements contained in the Application

are true and correct according to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.

4. To the best of my knowledge, information, and belief, formed after

reasonable inquiry, the fees and disbursements sought in the Application are permissible

under PROMESA, the Bankruptcy Rules, the Local Rules, orders of this Court, and the

UST Guidelines.3

5. The fees and disbursements sought in the Application are billed at rates

Bennazar employs and other Bennazar clients accept in matters of this nature.

2 All capitalized terms have the meaning provided in the Application unless otherwise defined herein.

3 Bennazar has reviewed the Memorandum submitted by the Fee Examiner and is endeavoring to comply

with all requirements of the Interim Order and the UST Guidelines. Bennazar’s offices were completely destroyed by Hurricane Maria. It has worked diligently to compile the information contained in this Application. To the extent certain information directed by the Interim Order or Guidelines or requested by the Fee Examiner in his Memorandum is not included, Bennazar requests from this Court an exception under the circumstances.


3

6. None of the professionals seeking compensation varied their hourly rate

based on their geographic location.

7. Bennazar is not seeking compensation for this Interim Period for time spent

reviewing or revising time records or preparing, reviewing, or revising invoices.

8. Bennazar does not make a profit on costs or expenses for which it seeks

reimbursement, whether the service is performed by Bennazar in-house or through a

third party.

9. In accordance with Rule 2016(a) of the Bankruptcy Rules and 11 U.S.C.

§ 504, no agreement or understanding exists between Bennazar and any other person for

the sharing of compensation to be received in connection with the above cases except as

authorized by PROMESA, the Bankruptcy Rules, and the Local Rules.

10. All services for which Bennazar seeks compensation were professional

services rendered to the Retiree Committee and not on behalf of any other person.

I certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of my

knowledge, information, and belief formed after reasonable inquiry.

Executed on November 15, 2017

/s/ A.J. Bennazar-Zequeira A.J. Bennazar-Zequeira


EXHIBIT B

RETENTION ORDER

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1806-2 Filed:11/15/17 Entered:11/15/17 21:06:01 Desc: Exhibit B - Retention Order Page 1 of 4

081017 BENNAZAR RETENTION ORDER VERSION AUGUST 10, 2017 1

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF PUERTO RICO

ORDER AUTHORIZING THE

EMPLOYMENT OF BENNAZAR, GARCIA & MILIAN, CSP AS ATTORNEYS FOR THE COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES

Upon the Application filed by the Committee of Retired Employees of Puerto Rico (the

“Retiree Committee”) in these Title III Cases for entry of an order to employ the law firm of

Bennazar, García & Milián, CSP (“BGM, CSP”) as attorneys for the Retiree Committee effective

as of June 16, 2017, pursuant to sections 105(a) and 1103(a) of Title 11 of the United States Code

(the “Bankruptcy Code”), made applicable to these cases pursuant to Section 301(a) of the Puerto

Rico Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act (“PROMESA”), 48 U.S.C. § 2161(a);2

1 The Debtors in these PROMESA title III cases, along with each Debtor’s respective title III case number listed as a bankruptcy case number due to software limitations and the last four (4) digits of each Debtor’s federal tax identification number, as applicable, are the (i) Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3481); (ii) Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3284) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 8474); (iii) Puerto Rico Highways and Transportation Authority (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3567-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 3808); and (iv) Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (Bankruptcy Case No. 17 BK 3566-LTS) (Last Four Digits of Federal Tax ID: 9686). 2 PROMESA is codified at 48 U.S.C. §§ 2101–2241. Unless otherwise noted, all Bankruptcy Code sections cited in this Application are made applicable to these Title III Cases by Section 301(a) of PROMESA.


Debtors.1



Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1003 Filed:08/10/17 Entered:08/10/17 17:14:59 Desc: Main Document Page 1 of 3



and upon the Declaration of A. J. Bennazar Zequeira in Support of the Application (the “Bennazar

Declaration”); and the Court finding that (a) the Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this

matter pursuant to PROMESA section 306(a); (b) BGM, CSP does not hold or represent any

interest materially adverse to the Retiree Committee with respect to matters for which BGM, CSP

is to be retained; and (c) the Retiree Committee’s retention of BGM, CSP is in the best interest of

the Retiree Committee; and the Court finding that notice of the Application given by the Retiree

Committee was sufficient under the circumstances and that no other or further notice is necessary;

and the Court being fully advised in the premises and having determined that the legal and factual

bases set forth in the Application, the Bennazar Declaration establish just cause for the relief herein

granted; it is hereby:

ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT:

1. The Application is GRANTED, as set forth herein.

2. The Retiree Committee is authorized, pursuant to section 1103(a) of the Bankruptcy

Code to employ BGM, CSP as its counsel in these Title III Cases in accordance with the terms

and conditions set forth in the Application effective as of June 16, 2017.

3. BGM, CSP shall be entitled to allowance and payment of compensation for

professional services rendered and reimbursement of expenses incurred in connection with these

Title III Cases as an administrative priority expense under section 503(b) of the Bankruptcy Code

pursuant to any procedures established and required by PROMESA, this Court, and the United

States Trustee.

4. The Retiree Committee is authorized and empowered to take all actions necessary

to implement the relief granted in this Order.

5. The terms and conditions of this Order shall be immediately effective and




enforceable upon its entry.

6. This Court retains exclusive jurisdiction with respect to all matters arising from or

related to the implementation, interpretation, and enforcement of this order.

7. This order resolves docket entry no. 683.

SO ORDERED.

Dated: August 10, 2017 /s/ Laura Taylor Swain LAURA TAYLOR SWAIN United States District Judge



EXHIBIT C

DETAILED TIME RECORDS FOR BENNAZAR, GARCIA & MILlAN, C.S.P.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1806-3 Filed:11/15/17 Entered:11/15/17 21:06:01 Desc: Exhibit C- Detailed Time Records Page 1 of 112

BEN NAZAR, GARCIA & MILIAN, C.S.P.APARTADO POSTAL 194000 NUM. 212 SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO 00919-4000

Tetefono: (787) 754-9191 Fax: (787) 764-3101

[email protected] [email protected]

Num. S.S. 66-0535704

August 15, 2017 Invoice #170702

OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES P/C JOSE MARIN, CHAIRPERSON

RE: COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO CASE NUMBER 17-BK-03283 (D.P.R.)

FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED THROUGH JULY 31,2017

HOURS AMOUNT

COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO T5-3357I

6/15/2017 AJB Several conferences with HMK and exchange of notes with R.Gordon on orders issued in the case on appointment of a mediation Committee by Judge Swain and the appointment of the Official Retiree Committee by the US Trustee. Follow up on organizing first meeting of the Committee for tomorrow.

6/16/2017 AJB Exchange of correspondence and T/C with attorney R. Gordon of Jenner & Block, H. Mayol and official Retiree Committee members re: meeting today. Attended meeting of the official Retiree Committee.

6.40 2,400.00

5.60 2,100.00

5.00 1,875.00HMK Attended meeting of the Official Retiree Committee; Reviewed and revised engagement documents.

6/19/2017 AJB Further correspondence and exchange of notes with attorneys C.Steege and M. Root of Jenner & Block on draft by-laws for the official Retiree Committee; discussed same with H. Mayol and E. Candelaria. Preparation for meeting tomorrow. Received and examined several motions and court orders entered in the case today.

6/20/2017 ECD Compilation of documents to be discussed at meeting of theOfficial Committee of Retired employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (The Committee). Review draft of proposed rules of debate and bylaws of the committee. Attendance at meeting of the committee.

4.40 1,650.00

7.00 1,050.00

6.00 2,250.00HMK Meeting with retired Judge Fabre; attended meeting of theCommittee. Approval of minutes, by laws and engagement letters.


OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES

HOURS AMOUNT

6/20/2017 AJB Meeting with Retiree Judge Miguel Fabre, president of the PR Retired Judges Association and member of the Official Retiree Committee. In the afternoon, attended meeting of the Official Retiree Committee.

6.00 2,250.00

6/21/2017 AJB Exchange of correspondence with members of the Official Retiree Committee, H. Mayol, M. Root, C. Steege and Eunice Candelaria on engagement follow up; review minutes of yesterday's meeting and follow up to set up next meeting of the Official Retiree Committee.

4.70 1,762.50

6/22/2017 ECD Preparation of the minutes of the meeting held on 6-20-17.Update bylaws with the amendments approved during the meeting. Inclusion of amendments in a final document. Reviewed final text.

4.00 600.00

AJB Correspondence with C. Steege, M. Root, R. Gordon, H. Mayol and Sgt. Jose Marin, president of the Official Committee of Retirees; received and examined proposed minutes of last meeting and proposed agenda for next. Filing of pro-hac-vice requests for M. Root, C. Steege and R. Levine of Jenner & Block. Worked on informative motion re: R. Gordon's representation of Official Retiree Committee.

6.20 2,325.00

6/23/2017 ECD Translation into English of the following: minutes of the meetingheld on 6-20-17; bylaws with the amendments; letter to be sent to the members of the committee and agenda of the meeting scheduled for 6-27-17. Conference call with C. Steege and M. Root re: various issues related to the meeting scheduled for 6-27-17. T/C with M. Acevedo (secretary of the committee) re: the agenda and documents to be distributed for the meeting scheduled for 6-27-17.

5.60 840.00

6.50 2,437.50AJB Worked on draft informative motion regarding R. Gordon's severance of professional relation with MPP and his representation of the Official Retiree Committee. Exchange of correspondence with M. Root and R. Gordon. Preparation for meeting of the Official Retiree Committee next Tuesday, June 27. Docket follow up and review of all court notices.

6/24/2017 AJB Continued preparation for meeting of the Official RetireeCommittee that will be held next Tuesday and the appearances of counsel at the court hearing scheduled for next Wednesday, June

3.80 1,425.00

28.

6/26/2017 ECD Work on Spanish translation of the following document: official committee of retired employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico talking points; memorandum to C. Steege re: translated document.

1.30 195.00

3.90 1,462.50AJB Received and examined motions prior to the hearing set forWednesday June 28. Exchange of memoranda and T/C with R. Gordon, M. Root, C. Steege, H. Mayol and E. Candelaria in preparation for meeting with official Retiree Committee (ORC) set for tomorrow. Follow up on filing of PHV motions.

6/27/2017 ECD Attendance at meeting of the committee. Update the bylaws with the amendments approved during the meeting in a final document.

4.80 720.00



HOURS AMOUNT

6/27/2017 HMK Meeting with co-counsel team to prepare plan of work for the Committee meeting and various presentations.

HMK Attended meeting of ORC to select Actuary and Financial Advisor

FDC Meeting with R. Gordon, C. Steege, R. Levin and M. Root from Jenner & Block re: preparation for meeting with the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

3.00 1,125.00

1,800.004.80

0.50 125.00

FDC Review of presentation by FTI Capital Advisors to the OfficialCommittee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.50 125.00

FDC Review of proposed internal rules of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

FDC Review of presentation by Phoenix Management to the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.70 175.00

0.40 100.00

FDC Review of presentation by Zolfo Cooper to the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

FDC Review of presentation by Segal (actuarial firm) to the OfficialCommittee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.40 100.00

0.50 125.00

6.50 2,437.506/28/2017 HMK Attending 2nd Omnibus Hearing at the Puerto Rico Federal District Court.

2.50 625.00 1FDC Research of motions filed and ruling in the case of VOYAINSTITUTIONAL TRUST COMPANY vs. UPR, Civil No. 16-2519 (FAB).

6/29/2017 ECD Conference call with Jenner & Block LLP attorneys team and H.Mayol re: discussion of case strategy. Later, another conference call with Jenner & Block LLP attorneys team and H. Mayol re: continuation of further discussion of case strategy.

HMK Conference call with Jenner & Block team. Later, another conference call re: case strategy.

FDC Review of Presentation titled: In re: The Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico as representative of The Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

6/30/2017 ECD Translation into English of the following: bylaw with amendments, cover letter of the email to be sent to the members of the committee and the agenda of the meeting to be held scheduled for 7-6-17. Several electronic communications with C. Steege and M. Root re: various issues related to the meeting of 7-6-17. T/C with M. Acevedo (secretary of the committee) re: logistics of the preparations of the agenda and minutes of the meetings.

HMK Attending Fiscal Board meeting in San Juan. Conference with FA and Actuary.

3.00 450.00

750.002.00

75.000.30i

3.30 495.00

3.00 1,125.00



HOURS AMOUNT

6/30/2017, FDC Legal research of Clawback provisions taken by theCommonwealth of Puerto Rico during the last and current administration.

625.002.50

FDC Read memorandum from M. Root regarding the next meeting of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.10 25.00

FDC Review of proposed agenda for the July 6, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.10 25.00

7/3/2017 FDC Review and legal research of multiple acts and executive orders regarding the clawback of funds for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. Draft of memorandum regarding clawback provisions.

AJB Received and examined notices of filings and orders issued in the case, following last Wednesday's court hearing. Note to HMK.

4.50 1,125.00

675.001.80

7/5/2017 FDC Read note from M. Root to schedule a conference call with representatives of Segal and Jenner & Block.

0.10 25.00

FDC Conference Call with S. Wohl, M. Root, K. Nicholl and C. Steege regarding the Employee Retirement System of Puerto Rico.

FDC Received note from C. Steege, re: Additional Follow-up question about cases of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico regarding pension benefits.

FDC Research on the most recent financial reports available from the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

125.000.50

0.10 25.00

1.40 350.00

1.00 375.00HMK Review of documents in preparation of Official Committee meeting on 7-6-17, Including Cofina GO'controversy and Clawback questions re: our intervention in the case.

AJB Received and examined exchange of correspondence with Jenner & Block (Gordon, Root, Steege) on upcoming meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Conference with H. Mayol and E. Candelaria . Received, reviewed and examined memorandum by attorney F. Del Castillo on the "Clawback" provisions of P.R. Law and ensuing exchange of memoranda with R. Gordon, M. Root and H. Mayol.

7/6/2017 ECD Spanish translation of the following document: Cofina protocol stipulation and electronic communication to M. Root re: same; conference call with J. Marin, discussion of the agenda and documents to be presented during the meeting. Preparation for meeting, compilation and organization of documents to be discussed at the meeting scheduled for today and revision of the minutes of the meeting held on 6-27-17. Attendance at meeting of the committee.

750.002.00

9.50 1,425.00

25.000.10FDC Memo to S. Wohl, M. Root, K. Nicholl and C. Steege with a copy of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Financial Information and Operating Data Report for December 18, 2016.



HOURS AMOUNT

7/6/2017 FDC Legal Research about the most recent retirement cases decided by the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico. Correspondence to C. Steege and M. Root about the most recent retirement cases decided by the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico.

FDC Meeting with H. Mayol in preparation for meeting with the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

875.003.50

250.001.00

FDC Attended meeting of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

4.50 1,125.00

FDC Review of "Perfil del Pensionado del Gobierno de Puerto Rico, segtin estudios realizados por la Comision Especial Permanente sobre los Sistemas de Retiro (2003-2009)", re: Profile of retirees.

HMK Conference call with Committee Chair J. Marin and Co-counsel team to review Chair's agenda for the meeting.

HMK Meeting with FDC re: aspects of the PR Treasury Circular letter to be discussed at the Committee meeting. Meeting with ECD to review meeting handouts and documents. Attended meeting of the Committee and directed the discussion including translation of discussion topics. Travel San Juan to New York to attend Proskauer meeting.

AJB Received and examined correspondence from Jenner & Block (M. Root) with draft retention application and R. Gordon declaration. Discussed with H. Mayol. Received and examined PR Government Retiree profile issued by the PR Permanent Commission on retirement systems (CEPSR by its Spanish Acronym) Received and examined executed by-laws of the Official Retiree Committee. Conference with F. del Castillo. Attended meeting of the Official Retiree Committee here at our offices. Post meeting, conference with F. Del Castillo and E. Candelaria

0.20 50.00

2.00 750.00

8.30 3,112.50

7.00 2,625.00* .

3.80 1,425.007/7/2017 HMK In NYC, met with Proskauer, Jenner and FTI. Interview with candidate for Public Relations consultant to the Committee.

AJB Exchange of correspondence with Chair and Secretary of official Retiree Committee over the minutes of yesterday's meeting, the by laws and the agenda for the next meeting. Conference with F. Del Castillo on services to be provided to Official Retiree Committee. Exchange of notes with M. Root and R. Gordon.

825.002.20

5.00 1,875.007/8/2017 HMK Travel New York to San Juan.

125.000.507/10/2017 FDC Review of Motion Requesting Appointment of AdditionalCommittee of Government Employees and Active Pension Plan Participants Or, in the Alternative, for the Reconstitution of the Retiree Committee filled by the University of Puerto Rico Retirement Trust, July 10, 2017.

FDC Received and examined memo from H. Mayol to R. Levin regarding the Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR Trust.

25.000.10



HOURS AMOUNT

7/10/2017 FDC Received note from R. Levin to H. Mayol regarding a MotionRequesting Appointment of Additional Committee filed by UPR T rust.

0.10 25.00

AJB Further exchange of correspondence regarding minutes of last meeting and agenda for next meeting of the official Retiree Committee. Received and examined summary of ECF Activity in the Title III cases. Further conference with F. Del Castillo. Received and examined motion filed by the UPR Retirement System Trust seeking to re-configure official Retiree Committee. Discussed with F. Del Castillo. Exchange of notes with Jenner& Block.

2.90 1,087.50

7/11/2017 FDC Note to R. Levin, HMK, B. Gordon, C. Steege and M. Root regarding Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR.

0.20 50.00

HMK Conference call on response to UPR objections to Committee composition.

0.60 225.00

2.60 975.00AJB Received and examined motion filed by official Committee of unsecured creditors; received and examined correspondence from R. Gordon, R. Levin and M. Root (Jenner & Block) on retention of actuaries and financial advisors. Conference with H. Mayol re: same. Follow up on agenda for next meeting of Retiree Committee.

7/12/2017 FDC Read e-mail from C. Steege regarding Motion RequestingAppointment of Additional Committee by UPR. Read e-mail from HMK regarding Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR. Read e-mail from C. Steege regarding Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR. Read e-mail from B. Gordon regarding Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR. Read e-mail from R. Levin to HMK regarding the Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR. Read e-mail from B. Gordon regarding Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR. Read e-mail from B. Gordon regarding Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee by UPR.

AJB Received and examined notices issued by the Clerk of the USDC via the ECF System. Exchange of memoranda with R. Gordon, M. Root (Jenner & Block) and H. Mayol on agenda for next meeting of the official Retiree Committee.

0.70 175.00

1.70 637.50

0.10 25.007/13/2017 FDC Read e-mail from R. Levin regarding the attendance at July 12 meeting.

HMK Attend meeting with Movimiento Pro Pensionados. Conference call with R. Gordon to interview public relations firms.

AJB Reviewed and follow up on motions filed and orders issued as per notice produced by the Clerk of the Court through the ECF System. Exchange of correspondence with R. Levin, R. Gordon,C. Steege and H. Mayol on motion filed by UPR Retirement SystemTrust.

7/14/2017 ECD T/C with J. Marin (Chairman of the Retiree Committee) re:discussion of the agenda of the 7-18-17 meeting. T/C with M.Root re: discussion of additional topics to be included in the

4.00 1,500.00

525.001.40

3.00 . 450.00



HOURS AMOUNT

agenda of the meeting. Prepare final draft agenda for the meeting. Electronic communication with M. Root, J. Marin and H. Mayol re: copy of the final draft prepared agenda.

7/14/2017 FDC Read e-mail from K. Nicholl (Segal) regarding the attendance at July 12 meeting.

HMK Review agenda and minutes in preparation of July 18 Committee meeting with Jose Marin and E. Candelaria. Internal status conference AJB, H. Mayol and Jenner & Block team.

AJB Exchange of correspondence with Sgt. J. Marin and later with C. Steege, E. Candelaria and M. Root on agenda for the next meeting of the Retiree Committee. Reviewed motions filed and orders issued as notified through the ECF System. Follow up E. Candelaria on minutes of prior meeting.

7/16/2017 HMK Reviewed and commented on GO-COFINA Stipulation.

7/17/2017 FDC Read e-mail from R. Levin regarding the Attendance at July 12 meeting.

HMK Conference call with Jenner & Block team and follow up with AJB on agenda items for Committee Meeting. T/C with R Gordon on Agenda for Committee meeting. Conference call with Chair Marin on agenda items re: Mediation topics.

AJB In the afternoon, participated in conference among counsel with R. Levin, C. Steege, R. Gordon, M. Root, H. Mayol, F. Del Castillo in anticipation and preparation for tomorrow's meeting of the Official Retiree Committee. Also exchange of correspondence with R. Levin, M. Root on talking points for the Committee.

AJB Exchange of correspondence with R. Levin and H. Mayol on draft Exchange of correspondence

with C. Steege and R. Gordon on the COFINA proposed stipulation. Discussed with H. Mayol. Reviewed and revised draft minutes of prior meeting and proposed agenda for tomorrow's meeting of the Official Retiree Committee. Exchange of memoranda with Sgt. J. Marin, president of the Official Retiree Committee.

0.10 25.00

1.20 450.00

1.80 675.00

0.70 262.50

0.10 25.00

3.30 1,237.50

600.001.60

5.60 2,100.00

0.50 125.007/18/2017 FDC Review of documents to be included and presented to the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

4.50 1,125.00FDC Meeting with the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

7.40 2,775.00HMK Translate R. Gordon's memorandum to the Committee.Preparation for Committee meeting, including preparation of talking points, minutes and member data packages. Attended scheduled meeting of the Committee.

AJB Exchange of final texts of proposed talking points, minutes of last meeting and agenda for Today's meeting. Final preparation for, and attendance at meeting of the Official Retiree Committee. Post meeting conference with H. Mayol and F. Del Castillo.

6.20 2,325.00



HOURS AMOUNT

7/19/2017 FDC Review of document (draft) re: stipulation and agreed orderapproving procedure to resolve Commonwealth-Cofina Dispute, Case No. 17 BK3283-LTS.

0.50 125.00

FDC Called Carlos Ramos from Employees Retirement Systemrequesting to include a message from the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico in the payment slip that is sent by the System to retirees every 3 months.

FDC Conference Call with B. Gordon, R. Levin, C. Steege and M. Root from Jenner & Block and H. Mayol, A. J. Bennazar re:

follow Up of Committee, Intervention in several proceedings, Mediation and other issues.

FDC Research of laws pertaining to the retirement systems of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.20 50.00

1.50 375.00

1.70 425.00

FDC Review of 2015 Audited Financial Statements of the Retirement System of the University of Puerto Rico.

HMK Review of pending items from Committee meeting. Prepared talking points and obtained final contracts from financial advisor and actuary. Retiree Committee Professionals Conference call with Jenner, FTI and AJB re: mediation strategies.

7/20/2017 FDC Research of laws pertaining to the retirement systems of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.70 175.00

3.00 1,125.00

1.00 250.00

0.50 187.50HMK Adding language to motion regarding

AJB Exchange of correspondence with M. Root on retentiondocuments; worked on our draft motion in compliance with court order regarding prior representation of Ad Hoc Committee; Conference with H. Mayol on Official Retiree Committee's request to interview other prospective PR services.

AJB Worked on retention documents. Post meeting clean-up;Reviewed motions filed and orders issued as notified by the clerk of the court via the ECF system. Reviewed translation into Spanish of the Official Committee's talking points prepared by Jenner & Block as modified during yesterday's conference. Exchange of correspondence with M. Root on draft motion to comply with court order.

7/21/2017 HMK Conference call with Marchand, ICS, R. Gordon and E.Candelaria. Discuss conflict issues and fee structure. Conference call with J. Marin and R. Gordon regarding professional contracts.

AJB Completed motion in compliance with court order and filed same (682); correspondence with M. Root on retention papers; conference with H. Mayol re: same. Approved final text of notice of hearing, application, exhibits and proposed order (683) and filed same. Follow up with E. Candelaria on minutes of last meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Reviewed motions filed and orders issued.

4.70 1,762.50

4.50 1,687.50

1.10 412.50

4.80 1,800.00

375.001.007/22/2017 HMK Review and draft amendments to



HOURS AMOUNT

7/23/2017 HMK Discuss with Chair J. Marin to consider his concerns.

150.000.40

7/24/2017 FDC Draft of memorandum Review of

Read e-mail from B. Gordon and document

with comments to

Read 2nd e-mail from B. Gordon

Read 3rd e-mail from B. Gordon

FDC Read e-mail from B. Gordon

Read 5th e-mail from B. Gordon

Read e-mail from R.

Levin

Read e-mail from C. Steege

Draft of e-mail to answer



. Draft of e-mail to answer C. Steege

6.90 1,725.00

0.80 200.00

1.50 562.50HMK Conference call with C. Steege, M. Root and Chair Marin. Consider comments

AJB Reviewed motions filed and orders entered as reported by the clerk of the court through the ECF System on Saturday 22 and today; In the afternoon, participated in conference with H Mayol,F. Del Castillo, M. Root, C. Steege, R. Gordon and R. Levin.

7/25/2017 FDC Call with R. Gordon and HMK re: several issues about the Official Committee were discussed.

FDC Review of memorandum . Review and

corrections of minutes of the July 18, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Meeting with H. Mayol regarding several

2.20 825.00

!

! 0.30 75.00

7.60 1,900.00



HOURS AMOUNT

issues about the case; PayGo System Circular Letter, Dr. Marcos Lbpez (member of the Committee) legal claim against the University of Puerto Rico. Review and translation from Spanish to English of the minutes of the July 18, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Translation from English to Spanish of the memorandum regarding retirement laws and cases.

Preparation of minutes from last Committee meeting of July 18, 2017.

7/25/2017 HMK 3.50 1,312.50

AJB Received and examined memorandum

. Correspondence with Mathew Hindman on signature logistics.

7/26/2017 FDC Meeting with HMK regarding administrative issues for the next meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Continued translation from English to Spanish of the memorandum regarding retirement laws and cases. Conference call with B. Gordon, C. Steege, M. Root, R. Levin, M. Bluming, HMK and S. Levine. Revision and modification of translation from English to Spanish of

HMK Prepare and send latest version of minutes to CommitteeSecretary include comments and new language suggested by M. Root, Review records and notes of meeting agenda and minutes. Discussion with AFSCME on strategy for the ERS-POB litigation. JennerTeam, S Levine, M. Blummin.

AJB Received and examined several motions and proposed orders filed by debtors (705, 716, 717, 718, 719, 720); follow up on motions filed and orders issued as per notices of the clerk via the ECF system. Meeting with H. Mayoi and F. Del Castillo re; upcoming meeting of official Committee Retirees, items for agenda, pending matters. Conference with A. Rodriguez on taking of minutes for next meeting.

7/27/2017 FDC Read e-mail and attachments from R. Levin regarding -Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions.

HMK Review with FDC motion to object UPR Trust and Meditation Statement.

2.20 825.00

8.80 2,200.00

600.001.60

3.00 1,125.00

0.30 75.00

187.500.50

675.00Met with H. Mayoi and F. Del Castillo in anticipation of meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees scheduled for next week. Reviewed notices of motions filed and orders issued as per the ECF system. Follow up on filing of signature page of

Read e-mail and attachments from R. Levin regarding Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Read e-mail from HMK regarding R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Read 2nd e-mail from HMK regarding R, Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Read 3rd e-mail from HMK regarding R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB

1.80AJB

150.000.607/28/2017 FDC



HOURS AMOUNT

restructuring in special sessions. Draft of e-mail to R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Read 2nd e-mail R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Read e-mail from B. Gordon regarding R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions.

7/28/2017 FDC Review of Press Conference of Ramon Rosario (representative of the Governor of Puerto Rico) regarding the pending legislation to implement the PayGo System. Review of presentation accompanied by Ramdn Rosario during the Press Conference regarding the pending legislation to implement the PayGo System. Draft of e-mail regarding R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Evaluation of minutes, agenda and documents to be presented during the August 1st, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Draft of e-mail to the members of the Official Committee of Retirees with the minutes, agenda and documents to be presented during the August 1st, 2017 meeting. Review of Official Committee of Retired Employees Objection to Motion Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004. Read e-mail and comments from B. Gordon to Official Committee of Retired Employees Objection to Motion Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004.

FDC Read e-mail from M. Root regarding the changes proposed by B. Gordon to Official Committee of Retired Employees Objection to Motion Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004. Read 2nd e-mail from B. Gordon regarding R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Read e-mail from R. Levin regarding the changes proposed by B. Gordon to Official Committee of Retired Employees Objection to Motion Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004.Read e-mail from J. Marin about a correction to the agenda of the August 1st, 2017 meeting.

HMK Analyze pension reform bill to be considered by the PR legislature. Discuss possible positions of the Committee. Conference call with FDC. Review of US Trustees motion and Committee motion to object discovery procedures by the UCC. Memos by FDC and Jenner group.

AJB Conference with F. Del Castillo re: meeting of the Official Retiree Committee scheduled for next week. Follow up on minutes of last meeting. Reviewed notice of motions filed and orders issued produced by the clerk of the court via the ECF system. Met with M. Quevedo to review and discuss debtors' proposed order on compensation of professionals retained by Official Committees.

7/30/2017 HMK Review of latest case motions and documents to be presented to Committee meeting on 8-1. Emails with Jenner group.

7/31/2017 FDC Draft of e-mail to the members of the Official Committee ofRetirees and B. Gordon, R. Levin, M. Root and C. Steege with the minutes, agenda and documents to be presented during the August 1st, 2017 meeting. Read e-mail from C. Steege regarding including in the mailings the attorneys from AFSCME. Review of

4.20 1,050.00

0.40 , 100.00

487.501.30

3.40 1,275.00

0.50 187.50

500.002.00


;

Page 12 '*OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES

HOURS AMOUNT

House Bill 1163, or the Law to Guarantee the Payment of Our Pensioners and Establish a New Plan of Defined Contributions for Public Servants. Read 3rd e-mail R. Levin e-mail about Legislature to consider measures to include pension, GDB restructuring in special sessions. Read e-mail and attachment from C. Steege about obtaining the Pension Reform bill in English.

7/31/2017 FDC Read e-mail from HMK answering C. Steege about obtaining the Pension Reform bill in English.Read e-mail and attachments from R. Levin about obtaining the Pension Reform bill in English. Read e-mail from R. Levin regarding Read e-maii from B. Gordon regarding Review of the Official Committee of Retired Employees objection to Motion requesting Appointment of Additional Committee of Government Employees and Active Pension Plan Participants or, in the alternative, for reconstitution of the Retiree Committee and the translation to Spanish for the August 1, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retired Employees.

FDC Review of Reservation of Rights of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico with respect to the ERS Joint Stipulation and the translation to Spanish for the August 1, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retired Employees. Conference call with B. Gordon, C. Steege,M. Root, R. Levin, HMK and representatives from FTI Consulting and Segal. Review of agenda for the August 1, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Draft of e-mail to HMK with the agenda for the August 1, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Read e-mail from HMK regarding the agenda for the August 1, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees. Read e-mail from M. Root regarding PROMESA Oversight Board's first annual report. Read of PROMESA Oversight Board's first Annual Report an Annex. Read e-mail from M. Root regarding notice of ERS creditor matrix.

HMK Preparing and translating court motions to be presented to the Committee meeting August 1, 2017. Interview with Tere SOarez, public relations firm for presenting to the Committee.Professionals Conference Call.

1.00 250.00

2.00 500.00

4.10 1,537.50

4.80 1,800.00AJB Reviewed and revised drafts of several documents for meeting tomorrow of official Retiree Committee (ORC). Translations into Spanish of ORC objection to UPR Trust’s motion; ORC objection to UCC discovery motion; proposed agenda. Reservation of rights in ERS case; Reviewed Dkts 7855-810; Discussed with F. Del Castillo. Participated in T/C with R. Levin, C. Steege, R. Gordon, M. Root, H. Mayol and F. Del Castillo.

[ 315.60 100,037.50]SUBTOTAL:

315.60 $100,037.50FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICE RENDERED


BENNAZAR, GARCIA & MILIAN, CSPAPART ADO POSTAL 194000 NUM. 212 SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO 00919-4000

Phone: 787-754-9191 Fax: 787-764-3101

[email protected] TAX ID: 66-0535704

October 4,2017 Invoice #170801

Official Committee of Retired Employees P/C Mr. Jos6 Marin, Chairperson

Re: Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Case Number: 17-BK-03283 (D.P.R.)

For services rendered through August 31,2017

Commonwealth of Puerto Rico [5-3357]

Date Attorney/ Activity Hours Amount

8/1/2017 FDC0.50 125.00

Read Opposition of Defendant Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., to Motion of COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition for (I) Modification of the Order Granting Interpleader, or (II) In the Alternative, Clarification of the Interpleader Memorandum Option and Intervention Denial Order, filed July 28,2017.

8/1/2017 HMKStudy Fiscal Board’s proposed restructuring of pension benefits.

HMKConference with F, del Castillo to discuss FOMB proposal.

HMKResponse to R. Levin e-mail.

1.00 375.00

8/1/20170.20 75.00

8/1/20170.10 37.50

Page 1 of 56


1

AmountHoursAttorney / Activity HMK

Draft e-mail to the Jenner & Bennazar team on initial reaction to FOMB proposal.

HMKMeeting with FDC to analyze Pension Reform Bill and implications to Retirees. Call with Chairman Marin on communications to Retirees through pension check mailing at ERS.

HMKRead e-mail and attachment from C. Steege about pension reform memo.

FDCRead Joinder of Assured Guaranty Corp., and Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., to the Motion of The Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to Reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. s. 105(A) and 1102(A)(4), filed July 28, 2017.

HMKAttending Official Committee meeting.

FDCAttendance at Meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees.

FDC

Draft of 3 rd e-mail regarding notice of ERS creditor matrix and alternatives to communicate with retirees.

FDCDraft of 2nd e-mail regarding notice of ERS creditor matrix and alternatives to communicate with retirees.

FDC

Read Joinder of the Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority to the response of Financial Oversight and Management Board to COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition’s Motion for Modification of Order Granting Interpleader and reservation of Rights, filed July 31,2017.

Date8/1/2017

112.500.30

8/1/20171.00 375.00

8/1/20170.50 187.50

8/1/20170.10 25.00

8/1/20171,125.003.00

8/1/2017800.003.20

8/1/2017

8/1/201725.000.10

8/1/201775.000.30

Page 2 of 56


Attorney / ActivityFDC

Read Ambac Assurance Corporation’s Reservation Rights Regarding the Revised Motion of Debtors for Order Approving Stipulation Providing Procedure to Resolve Commonwealth- Cofina Dispute, Filed July 28, 2017.

FDCDraft of e-mail regarding notice of ERS creditor matrix and alternatives to communicate with retirees.

FDCRead e-mail from R. Levin regarding notice of ERS creditor matrix; read reply from C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail from R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail from C. Steege; read 3rd e-mail from C. Steege; read reply e-mail from H. Mayol; read and reply e- mail from K. Nicholl; read 4th e-mail from C. Steege; read 5th e-mail from C. Steege; read e- mail reply from B. Gordon; read 2nd e-mail from H. Mayol; read 6th e-mail from C. Steege; and 3rd e-mail from R. Levin.

FDC

Read objection of debtors to motion requesting appointment of additional committee of government employees and active pension plan participants or, in the alternative, for the reconstitution of the Retiree Committee, filed July 28,2017.

Date Hours Amount8/1/2017

0.10 25.00

8/1/20170.20 50.00

8/1/20171.30 325.00

8/1/20170.10 25.00

8/1/2017 FDCMeeting with H. Mayol to study and analyze pension reform bill. (P. del S. 603 y el P. de la C. 1163).

HMK

0.50 125.00

8/1/20170.20 75.00Read response of Financial Oversight and

Management Board to COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition’s motion for modification of order granting interpleader, by COFINA, filed July 31,2017.

Page 3 of 56


Hours AmountDate Attorney / ActivityHMK8/1/2017

0.60 225.00Read objection of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders’ motion to reconstitute Committee under Bankruptcy Code Sections 105(A) and 1102(A)(4), filed July 31,2017.

8/1/2017 HMK0.10 37.50

Read notice of consensual extension of objection deadline regarding motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105(A) and 1102 (A)(4) from the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders, filed July 28,2017.

8/1/2017 HMK37.500.10Read notice of consensual extensions of objection

deadline regarding motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004 from Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, Filed July 28, 2017.

HMKRead and review Employee Retirement System Bondholders adversary complaint filed July 27, 2017.

HMKRead and review order regarding the applicability of F.R.B.P. 2017 to the Title III Cases and further proposed amendment to the case management order from July 26, 2017 by Judge Swain.

HMKRead Mutual Fund Group’s and Puerto Rico Funds’ response to COFINA Senior Bondholders’ motion to modify or clarify court orders, filed July 28,2017.

8/1/20170.80 300.00

8/1/20170.20 75.00

8/1/20170.30 112.50

Page 4 of S6


Date8/1/2017

Attorney / ActivityHMK

Read National’s response to motion of COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition for (I) Modification of the Order Granting Interpleader, or (II) in the Alternative, Clarification of the Interpleader Memorandum Opinion and Intervention Denial Order, filed July 28,2017.

HMKE-mail to professional team on procedure to send notices to retirees via their pay receipt quarterly mailing.

HMKRead objection of debtors to motion requesting appointment of additional Committee of Government Employees and active pension plan participants.

HMK

Read e-mail from R. Levin regarding notice of ERS creditor matrix; read reply from C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail from R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail from C. Steege; read 3rd e-mail from C. Steege; read reply e-mail from K. Nicholl; read 4th e-mail from C. Steege; read 5th e-mail from C. Steege; read e-mail reply from B. Gordon; read 6th e-mail from C. Steege; and 3rd e-mail from R. Levin.

HMKRead Ambac Assurance Corporation’s reservation of rights regarding the revised motion of debtors for order approving stipulation providing procedure to resolve Commonwealth- Cofina dispute, filed July 28, 2017.

HMKRead Joinder of the Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority to the response of Financial Oversight and Management Board to COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition’s Motion for Modification of Older Granting Interpleader and reservation of Rights, filed July 31,2017.

Hours Amount

0.10 37.50

8/1/20170.20 75.00

8/1/20170.10 37.50

8/1/20171.00 375.00

8/1/20170.10 37.50

8/1/20170.20 75.00

Page 5 of 56


Date Attorney / Activity Hours Amount8/1/2017 HMK

0.50 187.50Read opposition of defendant Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., to motion of COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition.

HMKRead Joinder of Assured Guaranty Corp., and Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., to the Motion of The Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to Reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105(A) and 1102(A)(4), filed July 28, 2017.

HMKAnalyzed pension reform bill and implications to retirees.

HMK

Call with Chairman Marin on Communications to Retirees through pension check mailing at ERS.

HMKRead e-mail from C. Steege regarding obtaining the actuarial data from the systems.

FDCRead objection of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders’ Motion to Reconstitute Committee Under Bankruptcy Code Sections 105(A) and 1102(A)(4), filed July 31, 2017.

8/1/20170.10 37.50

8/1/20170.50 187.50

8/1/2017187.500.50

8/1/20170.10 37.50

8/1/20170.60 150.00

8/1/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Read notice of consensual extensions of objection

deadline regarding motion of official Committee of unsecured creditors for order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004- from Official Committee of unsecured Creditors of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, filed July 28, 2017.

Page 6 of 56


1

Date Attorney / Activity Hours Amount8/1/2017 AJB

4.80 1,800.00Reviewed final text corrected drafts of materials for today’s meeting of the Official Retiree Committee: Agenda, minutes of last meeting; objection to UPR Trust motion; objection to UCC discovery request reservation of rights in ERS case, translations into Spanish of the 3 motions and

. Various conferences with H. Mayol

and F. del Castillo. Attended the ORC meeting.FDC

Read and review employee retirement system bondholders adversary complaint filed July 27, 2017.

FDCRead order of reference to a Magistrate Judge the Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004 - July 26,2017 by Judge Swain.

FDCRead and review Order Regarding the Applicability of F.R.B.P. 2019 to the Title III Cases and Further Proposed Amendment to the Case Management Order - July 26,2017 by Judge Swain.

8/1/20170.80 200.00

8/1/20170.10 25.00

8/1/20170.20 50.00

8/1/2017 FDCRead notice of Consensual Extension of Objection Deadline Regarding Motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to Reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors Pursuant to U.S.C. §§ 105(A) and 1102 (A)(4) from the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders, filed July 28, 2017.

FDCDraft of e-mail to answer question from R. Levin regarding the announcement of new legislation regarding the PayGo system and the benefits of active participants.

0.10 25.00

8/1/20170.10 25.00

Page 7 of 56


HoursAttorney / ActivityFDC

Read Response of Financial Oversight and Management Board to COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition’s Motion for Modification of Order Granting Interpleader, by COFINA filed July 31, 2017.

FDCRead e-mail from C. Steege regarding obtaining the actuarial data from the retirement systems.

FDCRead Informative Motion of The Bank of New York Mellon, as Trustee, Regarding Acceleration of COFINA Bonds, filed July 31,2017.

FDCRead e-mail and attachment from C. Steege about Pension Reform Memo,

FDCRead e-mail from M, Root about conference call about Pension Reform Memo; read reply e-mail from R. Levin.

FDCRead Mutual Fund Group’s and Puerto Rico Funds’ Response to COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Motion to Modify or Clarify Court Orders, filed July 28, 2017.

FDCRead e-mail from Milagros Acevedo (Secretary) about corrections to the minute of July 6, 2017 of the Official Committee of Retirees.

.AmountDate8/1/2017

0.20 50,00

8/1/20170.10 25.00

8/1/20170.20 50.00

8/1/2017125.000.50

8/1/20170.20 50.00

8/1/20170.30 75.00

8/1/20170.10 25.00

8/1/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Read National's Response to Motion of COFINA

Senior Bondholders' Coalition for (I) Modification of the Order Granting Interpleader, or (II) in the Alternative, Clarification of the Interpleader Memorandum Opinion and Intervention Denial Order, filed July 28,2017.

Page 8 of 56


'I


3.80 1,425.00Received and examined memorandum from

issued via ECF system. Exchange of memoranda with R. Levin, C. Steege, H. Mayol and R. Gordon on proposed press release. Exchange of notes with M. Root on draft proposed motion for August 8 hearing.

HMKRead response of United States Trustee to motion requesting appointment of additional Committee of Government Employees and Active Pension Plan Participants or, in the Alternative, for the reconstitution of the Retiree Committee, July 28, 2017.

HMKRead e-mail and attachment from B. Gordon regarding the Financial Oversight and Management Board's memorandum to modify pension benefits.

HMKRead objection of AAFAF to the motion of the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, filed July 31,2017.

HMKRead objection of debtors to motion of Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute statuatory Committee of Unsecured Claimholders, filed July 28,2017.

8/2/20170.20 75.00

8/2/20170.50 187.50

8/2/20170.40 150.00

8/2/20170.20 75.00

Page 9 of 56


Pate Attorney / Activity HMK

Read Omnibus objection of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to motions of University of Puerto Rico Retirement System Trust and Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee requesting appointment of additional Official Creditors' Committees.

HMKRead United States Trustee's response to the Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committees request for an order directing the appointment of an Official Committee of Puerto Rico Municipalities, filed July 28, 2017-

HMKParticipated in a meeting with FOMB lawyers and Committee professionals.

HMK

Read statement of Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority in opposition to various motions requesting appointment of additional statutory Committees and/or the reconstitution of statuatory Committees, filed July 28,2017.

HMKReceived e-mail from C. Steege, reviewed motion for intervention.

Hours Amount8/2/2017

0.20 75.00

8/2/20170.10 37.50

8/2/20172.50 937.50

8/2/20170.10 37.50

8/2/20170.50 187.50

Page 10 of 56


Attorney / ActivityDate Hours Amount8/2/2017 HMK

0.80 300.00Reviewed various edits to original memo on FOMB pension restructuring proposal.

HMKReview of statement for the Committee on the FOMB pension restructuring proposal. Edits by Segal FTI and R. Levin. Response to Professionals on scope of the statement.

HMKRead informative motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors regarding applicability of Backruptcy Rule 2019 to Title III Cases and further proposed amendment to case management order, filed August 2, 2017.

HMKRead limited objection of Ambac Assurance Corporation to Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee's request for an order pursuant to 48 U.S.C. s. 2161 and 11 U.S.C. s. 1102 directing the appointment of an Official Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee, July 28,2017.

HMKRead United States Trustee's response to the motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105 (A) and 1105(A)(4), filed July 28, 2017.

HMKRead Ambac Assurance Corporation's objection to motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditorts, filed July 28, 2017.

HMKRead Financial Guaranty Insurance Company's response in support of motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute The Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105 (A) and 1102(A)(4), filed July 28, 2017.

8/2/20170.80 300.00

8/2/20170.10 37.50

8/2/20170.10 37.50

8/2/20170.10 37.50

8/2/20170.10 37.50

8/2/20170.10 37.50

Page 11 of 56



Read memorandum order granting urgent motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to expedite consideration of motion leave to intervene and denying motion for leave to intervene under bankruptcy Rule 7024, August 1,2017 by Judge T. Swain.

HMK


0.20 75.00

8/2/20172.90 1,087.50

Read e-mail and attachments (draft of press release in English and Spanish from the Official Retiree Committee) from M. Root; read e-mail reply and attachments from K. Nichols; read e-mail and attachment from R. Levin; read e-mail reply from S. Simms; read 2nd e-mail from S. Simms; read 2nd e-mail from K. Nichols; read reply from S. Wohl; read 2nd e-mail by S. Wohl; read e-mail reply L. Park; read e-mail reply from by K. Steege; read 2nd e-mail from K. Steege; read 3rd e-mail from Steege; read 3rd e-mail from S. Simms; read 2nd e-mail from R. Levin; read 3rd e-mail from R. Levin; read e-mail from B. Gordon; read 2nd e- mail from B. Gordon; read 4th e-mail from R. Levin; read 3rd e-mail B, Gordon; and 3rd e-mail from S. Wohl. AJB informed.

FDCRead Response of United States Trustee to Motion Requesting Appointment of Additional Committee of Government Employees and Active Pension Plan Participants or, in the Alternative, for the Recostitution of the Retiree Committee, July 28, 2017,

FDCRead Ambac Assurance Corporation's objection to motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders' to reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, filed July 28,2017.

8/2/20170.20 50.00

8/2/20170.10 25.00

Page 12 of 56


Date Attorney / ActivityFDC

Read United States Trustee's response to the Motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105(A) and 1102(A)(4), filed July 28, 2017.

FDC

Read limited objection of Ambac Assurance Corporation to Ad Hod Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee's request for an order pursuant to 48 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C § 1102 directing the appointment of an official Puerto Rico Municipal Committee, July 28, 2017.

FDCConference call with attorneys from the Financial Oversight and Management Board regarding the announcement of pension reform to the retirees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and discussion of the memorandum (left beforeconference call was over).

FDCRead informative motion of official committee of unsecured creditors regarding applicability of Bankruptcy Rule 2019 to Title Illcases and further proposed amendment to case management order, filed August 2, 2017.

FDCRead memorandum order granting urgent motion of official committee of unsecured creditors to expedite consideration of motion for leave to intervebe and denying motion for leave to intervene under Bankruptcy Rule 7024, August 1, 2017 by Judge T. Swain.


0.10 25.00

8/2/20170.10 25.00

8/2/20171.40 350.00

8/2/20170.10 25.00

8/2/20170.20 50.00

Page 13 of 56


Attorney / Activity 8/2/2017 FDC

Hours AmountDate

2.90 725.00

Read e-mail and attachments (draft of press release in English and Spanish from the Official Retiree Committee) from M. Root; read e-mail reply and attachments from K. Nichols; read e-mail and attachment from R. Levin; read e-mail reply from H. Mayol; read e-mail reply from S. Simms; read 2nd e-mail from H. Mayol; read 2nd e-mail from S. Simms; read 2nd e-mail from K. Nichols; read reply from S. Wohl; read e-mail reply from L.Park; read 2nd e-mail from K Nichols; read e-mail reply from K. Steege ; read 3rd e-mail from H. Mayol; read 4th e-mail from H. Mayol; read 3rd e- mail from Steege; read 3rd e-mail from S. Simms; read 2nd e-mail from R. Levin; read 3rd e-mail from S. Simms; read 5th e-mail from H. Mayol; read 3rd e-mail from R. Levin; read e-mail from B. Gordon; read 2nd e-mail from B. Gordon; read 4th e-mail from R. Levin; read 3rd e-mail from B. Gordon; read 3rd e-mail from S. Wohl.

FDCRead financial guaranty insurance company's response in support of motion of the Ad Hoc Group Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute the official committee of unsecured creditors pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 105 (A) and 1102(A)(4), filed.FDC

8/2/20170.10 25.00

8/2/20170.10 25.00

Read Statement of Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority in Opposition to Various Motions Requesting Appointment of Additional Statutory Committees and/or the Reconstitution of Statutory Committees.

8/2/2017 FDC75.00Read e-mail and attachment from 0.30

read e-mail reply fromiayo

Page 14 of 56


Date8/2/2017

Attorney / ActivityFDC

Read United States Trustee's Response to the Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee's Request for an Order Directing the Appointment of an Official Committee's of Puerto Rico Municipalities, filed July 28,2017.

FDCRead Omnibus objection of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to motions of University of Puerto Rico Retirement System Trust and Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee requesting appointment of additional Official Creditors' Committees, filed July 28,2017.

FDCRead objection of debtors to motion of Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute statuatory Committee of Unsecured Claimholders, filed July 28,2017.

FDCRead objection of AAFAF to the motion of the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, filed July 31,2017.

FDCregarding the Financial Oversight and Management Board's memorandum to modify pension benefits.

FDC

Hours Amount

0.10 25.00

8/2/20170.20 50.00

8/2/20170.20 50.00

8/2/20170.40 100.00

8/2/20170.80 200.00

8/3/20170.10 25.00

Read objection of debtors to motion of the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, filed August 3, 2017.

FDCRead e-mail and attachment from M. Root about the agenda for the August 8,2017 meeting of the Official Commettee of Retirees.

8/3/20170.20 50.00

Page 15 of 56


Attorney/ ActivityFDC

Read 3rd e-mail about press release from the Official Retiree Committee by K. Nichols; draft of e-mail about press release from the Official Retiree Committee; read e-mail from AJB; read 2nd e-mail from M. Root; read 3rd e-mail from M. Root; read 4th e-mail from M. Root; read 2nd e-mail from AJB; read 5th e-mail from M. Root.

AJBReceived and examined memorandum issued by the FOMB on proposed pension cuts (reductions) to Puerto Rico Retirees. Discussed with H. Mayol and F. del Castillo. Two conferences meetings with R. Levin, C. Steege, R. Gordon, M, Root and other advisors. Reviewed and proposed changes to ORC pronouncement to be issued publicly. Examined PR House Bill 1163 en pension plan payments. Reviewed court docket.

FDCRead e-mail from M. Root regarding the Official Retiree Committee materials for the 3:00PM conference call with the group.

FDCRead e-mail from B. Gordon regarding demographic data from the Employees Retirement System and Judiciary Terirement System.

HMKRead 3rd e-mail about press release from the Official Retiree Committee by K. Nichols; draft of e-mail about press release from the Official Retiree Committee; read e-mail from AJB; read 2nd e-mail from M. Root; read 3rd e-mail from M. Root; read 4th e-mail from M. Root; read 2nd e-mail from AJB; read 5th e-mail from M. Root.

HMKRead e-mail and attachment from M. Root about the agenda for the August 8,2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees.

Hours AmountDate8/3/2017

0.90 225.00

8/3/20175.50 2,062.50

8/3/20170.20 50.00

8/3/20170.10 25.00

8/3/20170.90 337.50

8/3/201775.000.20

Page 16 of 56


Date Attorney / Activity 8/3/2017 HMK

Hours Amount

0.10 37.50Read objection of debtors to motion of the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, filed August 3,2017.

8/3/2017 HMK0.10 37.50Read e-mail from B. Gordon regarding

demographic data from the Employees Retirement System and Judiciary Terirement System.

8/3/2017 HMKRead e-mail from M. Root regarding the Official Retiree Committee Materials for the conference call with the group.

8/3/2017 HMK

0.20 75.00

Conference call with professional in preparation for Commettee meeting and proposed press release on pension restructuring proposal by the FOMB.

0.80 300.00

8/3/2017 HMK300.00

8/3/2017 HMKCommittee conference call with professionals to approve press release in reaction to FOMB proposal.

1.00 375.00

8/4/2017 HMKRead motion of Official Committee of Retired employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for leave to intervene under Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed August 4,2017.

8/4/2017 HMK

0.10 37.50

Read e-mail from B. Gordon about explanatory memorandum on pension reform.

0.10 37.50

Page 17 of 56


Attorney / Activity HMK

Read e-mail from A.J. Bennazar about the agenda for the August 8,2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; draft e-mail about additional items to include in the agenda for the August 8, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee Retirees; read 2nd e-mail and attachment from M. Root; read 3rd e-mail from M. Root; read 4th e- mail from M. Root; and draft of 2nd e-mail and changes to attachment about additional items to include in the agenda for the August 8, 2017 meeting of the Official Commettee of Retirees.

HMKRead notice of hearing on motion of Official Committees of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for leave to intervene under Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed August 4,2017.

HMKPreparation of Committee Meeting Agenda for August 8 meeting.

HMKPROMESA public meeting and press conference in Puerto- Rico. Agenda included Pension Plan Reform.

HMKRead e-mail from B. Gordon regarding press release of PROMESA Board pursuing pension benefit reductions over government objections.

HMKRead e-mail and attachment from Jos6 Marin, President of the Official Commettee of Retirees, about the agenda of the next meeting.

HMKReview, analysis and comments of Oversight Board Memorandum of August 4, 2017, titled Explanatory Memorandum on Pension Reform.

HMKRead e-mail from B. Gordon about explanatory memorandum on pension reform; and read e-mail reply from C. Steege.

Hours AmountDate8/4/2017

0.90 337.50

8/4/20170.10 37.50

8/4/20171.00 375,00

8/4/20174.00 1,500.00

8/4/20170.20 75.00

8/4/20170.10 37.50

8/4/20171.00 375.00

8/4/20170.20 75.00

Page 18 of 56


Date Attorney / Activity 8/4/2017 HMK

Read e-mail and attachment (Oversight Board Memorandum of August 4, 2017) from B. Gordon about right-sizing measures in Commonwealth Fiscal Plan.

Hours Amount

0.30 112.50

8/4/2017 HMKRead reply to various objections and responses to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors' motion for leave to intervene under Bankruptcy Rule 7024 in Peaje Adversary Proceeding, filed August 4, 2017.

8/4/2017 HMK

0.40 150.00

Read urgent motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for entry of order adjourning hearing on motion of Committee.

0.10 37.50

8/4/2017 HMK0.20 75.00Read response of the COFINA Senior

Bondholders' coalition to the informative motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors regarding applicability of Bankruptcy Rule 2019 to the Title III Cases and further proposed amendment to case management order, filed August 4,2017.

8/4/2017 FDCBondholders' coalition to the informative motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors regarding applicability of Bankruptcy Rule 2019 to the Title III Cases and further proposed

0.20 50.00

8/4/2017 FDCDraft of memorandum requested by the Official Committee of Retirees about the proposed bill to guarantee the payment of pension benefits and establish a new defined contributions plan for public servants.

5.20 1,300.00

8/4/2017 FDCRead e-mail and attachment from Jose Marfn, President of the Official Commettee of Retirees, about the agenda of the next meeting.

0.10 25.00

Page 19 of 56


Date Attorney / Activity FDC

Read urgent motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for entry of order adjourning hearing on motion of Committee for order under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, and adjouring reply deadline, filed August 4, 2017.

FDCRead reply to various objections and responses to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors' motion for leave to intervene under Bankruptcy Rule 7024 in Peaje Adversary Proceeding, filed August 4,2017.

FDCAugust 8,2017, meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; draft e-mail about additional items to include in the agenda for the August 8,2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; read 2nd e-mail and attachment from M. Root; read e-mail reply from H. Mayol; read 3rd e-mail from M. Root; read 4th e-mail from M. Root; and draft of 2nd e-mail and changes to attachment about additional items to include in the agenda for

AJBReceived and examined 4 motions filed by the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors; several motions filed by B NY - Mellon and by assured guarantyMunicipal Corp.; Received and examined official Retiree Committee's motion to intervene in adversary proceeding filed by GO bondholders; Follow up on filing of ORC motion on attendance at August 9-10 hearing and retention of PTI Consulting. Conference with H. Mayol. Reviewed proposed agenda for August 8 meeting and minutes of prior meeting.

FDCRead e-mail from B, Gordon about explanatory memorandum on pension reform.


0.10 25.00

8/4/20170.40 100.00

8/4/20170.90 225.00

8/4/20175.90 2,212.50

8/4/20170.10 25.00

Page 20 of 56



Read notice of hearing on motion of Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commowealth of Puerto Rico for leave to intervene under Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed August 4, 2017.

FDCRead motion of Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for leave to intervene under Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed August 4, 2017.

FDCRead e-mail and attachment (Oversight Board Memorandum of August 4, 2017) from B. Gordon about right- sizing measures in Commonwealth Fiscal Plan.

FDCRead e-mail from B. Gordon about explanatory memorandum on pension reform; read e-mail refly from C. Steege.

FDCReview and analysis of oversight board memorandum of August 4,2017, titled explanatory memorandum on pension reform.

FDCCall with Jose Marin, president of the Official Committee of Retirees, about the agenda of the next meeting.

FDCRead e-mail from B. Gordon, regarding press release of the PROMESA Board pursuing pension benefit reductions over government objections.

HMKRead informative motion of Official Committee pf Unsecured Creditors requesting to be heard at August 9-10,2017 hearing with respect to motion COFINA Senior Bondholders' Coalition.

HMKRead e-mail from B. Gordon about the agenda for the August 8,2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees and documents to be included for the consideration of the members.


0.10 25.00

8/4/20170.50 125.00

8/4/20170.30 75.00

8/4/20170.20 50.00

8/4/20171.20 300.00

8/4/20170.20 50.00

8/4/20170.20 50.00

8/5/20170.20 75.00

8/5/20170,10 37.50

Page 21 of 56


Hours AmountDate Attorney / ActivityHMK

Read reply in support of motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105(A) and 1102(A)(4), filed August 4,2017.

HMKRead omnibus reply of Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee to objections to request for an order pursuant to 48 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 1102 directing the appointment of an Official Puerto Rico.

HMKRead and replied to C. Steege request from S.Word and Segal. Wrote e-mail explaining basic healthcare questions.

HMKReview minuted and Agenda sent by F. del Castillo

FDCTranlation into Englich of memorandum requested by the Official Committee of Retirees about the bill to guarantee the payment of pension benefits and establish a new defined contributions plan for public servants. HMK informed.

HMKRead omnibus reply to objections to motion requesting appointment of additional Committee of Government Employees and Active pension plan or, in the alternative, for the reconstitution of the Retiree Committee, by the University of Puerto Rico Retirement System Trust, filed August 4, 2017.

FDCRead omnibus reply to objections to motion requesting appointment of additional Committee of Government Employees and Active pension plan or, in the alternative, for the reconstitution of the Retiree Committee, by the University of Puerto Rico Retirement System Trust, filed August 4, 2017.

8/5/20170.30 112.50

75.000.208/5/2017

8/5/2017112.500.30

8/5/2017300.000.80

8/5/20173.30 825.00

8/5/201775.000.20

8/5/201750.000.20

Page 22 of 56



Read reply in support of motion of the Ad Hoc Group of general obligation bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of unsecured creditors pursuant to 11 U.S.C. §§ 105(A) and 1102(A)(4), filed August 4, 2017.

FDCRead e-mail from B. Gordon about the agenda for the August 8,2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees and documents to be included for the consideration of the members.

FDCRead informative motion of Official Committee of unsecured creditors requesting to be heard at August 9-10,2017 hearing with respect to motion COFINA senior bondholders' coalition for modification of interpleader order and related pleadings, filed August 4, 2017.

FDCRead onmibus reply of Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee to objections to request for an order pursuant to 48 U.S.C. §2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 1102 directing the appointment of an Official Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee, filed August 4, 2017.

HMKReceive e-mail from M. Root with Spanish translations review and correct motion to intervene and motion to dismiss.

HMKWrote e-mail about the agenda for the August 8, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees and documents to be included for the consideration of the members; read e-mail reply from C. Steege, read 2nd e-mail from B. Gordon; and read 3rd e-mail from B. Gordon.


0.30 75.00

8/5/20170.10 25.00

8/5/20170.20 50.00

8/5/20170.20 50.00

8/6/2017300.000.80

8/6/20170.40 150.00

Page 23 of 56


I1

Hours AmountAttorney / Activity FDC

Read 2nd e-mail from H. Mayol about the agenda for the August 8, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees and documents to be included for the consideration of the members; read e-mail reply from C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail from B. Gordon; and read 3rd e-mail from B. Gordon.

FDCRead adversary complaint from "Union de Trabajadores de la Industria Electrica y Riego", against defendants the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority and the Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico, filed August 6, 2017.

FDC

Read order for evidentiary on the motion of plaintiff Peaje Investments, LLC, for August 8, 2017 and August 7, 2017 by Judge Swain.

FDCConference with R. Gordon and H. Mayol regarding pension reform legislation (P. del S. 603 yP.de la C. 1163).

FDCRead objection and motion of Aurelius to dismiss Title III Petition, filed August 7,2017.

FDCDiscussed new versions of Minutes of the August 1,2017 meeting and agenda of the August 8, meeting with H. Mayol.

AJBReviewed and revised drafts of documents to be distributed to the members of the official Retiree Committee (ORC) at tomorrow's meeting; minute of last meeting, agenda, motion filed last Friday, translation into Spanish, talking points. Conference with H. Mayol re: same.

Date8/6/2017

0.40 100.00

8/6/20170.30 75.00

8/7/20170.10 25.00

8/7/20170.50 125.00

8/7/2017125.000.50

8/7/2017125.000.50

8/7/20171.90 712.50

Page 24 of 56


I

Date Attorney / ActivityHMK

Read order for evidentiary hearing on the motion of plaintiff Peaje Investment, LLC., for August 8, 2017, August 7, 2017 by Judge Swain,

HMKRead objection and motion of Aurelius to dismiss Title III Petition, filed August 7, 2017.

HMKDiscussed new versions of minutes of the August 1 meeting and agenda of the August 8 meeting with F. del Castillo.

HMKTelemundo TV Interview to explain Committee's position on pension reductions proposed by the FOMB.

HMKDiscussed with R. Gordon and F. del Castillo aspects of pension reform proposal by FOMB and the pension reform Law approved by PR legislature.

FDCRead order granting urgent motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to adjourn hearing on motion of committee order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004 authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, and to adjourn reply deadline. August 8, 2017 by Magistrate Judith Gail Dein.

AJBAttended meeting of the ORC at the Sheraton Convention Center Hotel. Post- meeting debriefing with attorney R. Gordon, C. Steege, M. Root, H. Mayol and F. del Castillo.

HMK

Read order granting urgent motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to adjourn hearing on motion of committee order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004 authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, and to adjourn reply deadline. August 8,2017 by Magistrate Judith Gail Dein.


0,10 37.50

8/7/20170.10 37.50

8/7/20170.50 187.50

8/7/20170.80 300.00

8/7/20170.80 300.00

8/8/20170.10 25.00

8/8/20176.30 2,362.50

8/8/20170.10 37.50

Page 25 of 56


It

HoursAttorney / Activity HMK

Administrative preparation for the meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees at the Sheraton Hotel.

HMKMeeting with R. Gordon, C. Steege, M. Root and F. del Castillo to coordinate agenda for Official Retiree meeting.

FDCAdministrative preparation for the meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees at the Sheraton Hotel; meeting with R. Gordon, C. Steege, M.Root and H. Mayol to coordinate the meeting.

FDCRead opposition of financial oversight and management board for Puerto Rico, as Commonwealth representative, to motion for relief from automatic stay, filed August 8,2017.

AmountDate8/8/2017

187.500.50

8/8/20172.10 787.50

8/8/2017525.002.10

8/8/2017100.000.40

8/8/2017 FDCReview of notice of agenda of matters scheduled for the hearing on August 9,2017 at 9:30 AM and notice of amended agenda.

FDCMeeting of the Official Committee of Retirees at the Sheraton Hotel.

HMKRead opposition of financial oversight and management Board for Puerto Rico, as Commonwealth Representative, to motion for relief from automatic stay, filed August 8,2017.

HMKReview of notice of agenda of matters scheduled for the hearing on August 9,2017 at 9:30 and notice of amended agenda.

HMKRead answer and counterclaims from Pension Obligation Bondholders (Altair Global Credit Opportunities Fund and others), filed August 8, 2017.

125.000.50

8/8/20171,500.006.00

8/8/20170.10 37.50

8/8/2017675.001.80

8/8/2017150.000.40

Page 26 of 56


r


Attending Official Committee meeting with Jenner & Block, FTI, A. J. Bennazar, presentations by Marchard ICS and publicity Tere Suarez.

AJBReceived and examined notice of filing of second revised order setting procedures for interim compensation and reimbursements of expenses of professionals. Discussed with H. Mayol.

FDCDraft e-mail to Milagros Acevedo (secretary) and Jose Marin (President) about pending corrections to the minutes of July 6,2017 of the Official Committee of Retirees.

FDCCorrections approved by the Official Committee of Retirees to the minutes of August 1, 2017.

FDCRead answer and counterclaims from pension obligation bondholders (Altair Global Credit opportunities Fund and others), filed August 8,

FDCDraft e-mail to Milagros Acevedo (Secretary) and Jose Marin (President) about the corrections approved by the Official Committee of Retirees to the other minutes of August 1, 2017.

HMKAttended court hearing in San Juan.

AJBReceived and examined ECF notices of motions' filed and orders issued in the Title III cases. Conference with F. del Castillo on preparation on minutes of last Tuesday's ORC meeting. Follow up on rescheduling of next ORC meeting, originally set for August 15, now rescheduled for August 23. Conference with H. Mayol on mediation meeting in NYC next week.

AJBAttended Omnibus hearing before the Hon. Laura Taylor Swain at the USDC-PR.


6.20 2,325.00

8/9/20170.60 225.00

8/9/20170.10 25.00

8/9/20170.20 50.00

8/9/20170.70 175.00

8/9/20170.10 25.00

8/9/20174.00 1,500.00

8/9/20171.80 675.00

8/9/20174.00 1,500.00

Page 27 of 56


IT

Attorney / Aetivit Hours AmountDate8/10/2017 FDC

Read e-mail from B. Gordon regarding judge Swain denying the UPR Trust's request to reconstitute the Official Retiree Committee.

0.10 25.00

8/10/2017 FDCRead memorandum opinion and order denying motion to intervene, August 10, 2017 by Judge Swain.

0.10 25.00

8/10/2017 HMK 0.50 125.00187.54Read e-mail from B. Gordon regarding Judge

Swain the UPR Trust's. Request to reconstitute the Official Retiree Committee.

0.50

8/10/2017 HMKRead memorandum opinion and order denying motion to intervene, August 10, 2017 by Judge Swain.

262.500.70

8/10/2017 AJB3.20 1,200.00

Post-hearing cleanup; conference with F. Del Castillo re: minutes of ORC meeting of last Tuesday; exhange of notes with M. Root, Sgt. J. Marin and H. Mayol on re-scheduling of next ORC meeting in light of mediation conference in NYC next week; reviewed notices of motions and orders issued by ECF system. Received and examined Judge Swaine's order denying UPR Trust's motion to reconstitute ORC; exchange of memoranda with R. Gordon. S, Simms, C. Steege and Sgt. J. Marin.

8/11/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Read memorandum opinion and order denying

motion requesting appointment of additional Committee of Government Employees and active pension plan participants or, in the alternative, for the reconstitution of the Retiree Committee, Agusut 11,2017 by Judge Swain.

Page 28 of 56


)

Date Attorney/ Activity Hours Amount8/11/2017 AJB

2.80 1,050.00Received and examined court orders 1000 to 1002, on the retention of professionals; follow up on filing amended proposed order regarding application of the Official Committee of Retired Employees for the employment of Segal Consulting (990); order approving procedure to resolve Commonwealth Cofina dispute. Reviewed orders issued and motions filed. Exhange of corresponden with R. Gordon.

8/11/2017 HMKRead memorandum opinion and order denying the motion of the Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee, August 11,2017 by Judge Swain.

0.10 37.50

8/11/2017 HMKRead e-mail from B. Gordon regarding Retiree Committee documents (demographic data); answered e-mail to B. Gordon.

0.10 37.50

8/11/2017 FDCRead notice of expedited appeal under Promesa of denial of committee motion to intervene, by Official Committee of Unsecdured Creditors, (filed August 11,2017.

0.10 25.00

8/11/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Read memorandum opinion and order denying the

motion of the Ad Hoc Puerto Rico Municipalities Committee, August 11, 2017 by Judge Swain.

8/11/2017 FDCRead memorandum opinion and order denying the motion of the Ad Hoc Group of general obligation bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of unsecured creditors.

0.10 25.00

8/11/2017 FDCRead e-mail from B. Gordon regarding Retiree Committee documents (demographic data); answered e-mail to B. Gordon; read e-mail reply from H. Mayol.

0.30 75.00

8/11/2017 HMKRead notice of expedited appeal under Promesa of denial of Committee motion to intervene, by Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors filed August 11,2017.

0.10 37.50

Page 29 of 56


1


Read memorandum opinion and order denying motion requesting appointment.

0.10 37.50

8/11/2017 HMK0.10 37.50Read memorandum opinion and order denying the

motion of the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders to reconstitute the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditos.

8/13/2017 FDCRead application of oversight board for entry of order authorizing employment and payment of Phoenix Management Services, LLC as financial advisor for mediation team, filed Augst 13,2017.

0.20 50.00

8/14/2017 HMKRead and review of Assured Guaranty Corp., Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., and plaintiff National Public Finance Guarantee Corp. Memorandum in opposition to defendants'motion to dismiss the complaint pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) and (B)(6), file August 14, 2017.

0.10 37.50

8/14/2017 FDCRead defendants' closing statement in opposition to plaintiff Peaje Investments LLC's PI motion, filed August 14,2017.

0.20 50.00

8/14/2017 FDCDraft letter to Armando Rivera, executive director to arrange meeting with Segal for the 21 or 22 of August.

0.30 75.00

8/14/2017 FDCRead and review of Assured Guaranty Corp. Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. and Plaintiff National Public Finance Guarantee Corp. memorandum in opposition to defendat's motion to dismiss the complaint pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) and (B)(6) filed August 14,2017

1.50 375.00

8/14/2017 HMKRead defendants'closing statement in opposition to plaintiff Peaje Investments LLC's PI motion, filed August 14,2017.

562.501.50

Page 30 of 56


Date Attorney / Activity 8/14/2017 FDC

Hours Amount

Conference call with R. Gordon, H. Mayol, C. Steege, M. Root, S. Gumbs, S. Wohl, S. Simms, R. Levin and K. Nichols. Several issues were

0.60 150.00

discussed (release of demographic data, mediation, case litigation, etc.)

8/14/2017 FDCRead closing statement of plaintiff Peaje Investments LLC regarding Peaje's motion (i) for preliminary injunction and (ii) for relief from stay or altemativevely adequate protection, filed August 14, 2017.

0.20 50.00

8/14/2017 HMKT/C with professionals Jenner, BennaZar and Segal FTI.

0.80 300.00

8/14/2017 HMKMeeting with R. Gordon, M. Root and Jorge Marchand to specify roles and contest of information agent contract.

1.30 487.50

8/14/2017 HMKRead statement of plaintiff Peaje Investments LLC regarding Peaje's motion.

0.20 75.00

8/14/2017 AJBReviewed and read motions filed and orders 3.20 1,200.00issued. Participated in T/conference with Jenner team, FTI and Segal, H. Mayol and F. Del Castillo on preparations for mediation sessions. Several conferences throughout day with H. Mayol, F. Del Castillo and Sgt. Marin.

8/15/2017 FDCRead memorandum from

Barbara J. Houser.

0.20 50.00

8/15/2017 FDCRead order directing supplemental briefing, August 15,2017 by Judge Swain.

8/15/147 HMK

0.10 25.00

0.10 37.50

Page 31 of 56


1

Attorney / Activity HoursDate Amount8/15/2017 HMK

Read order directing supplemental briefing, August 15, 2017 by Judge Swain.

0.10 37.50

8/15/2017 HMKDiscussion and analysis with A. J. Bennazar, 0.50 187.50

8/15/2017 HMKTravel to New York City to attend mediation hearing.

2.50 937.50

8/15/2017 HMKStudied GO Bondholders cases and claims against COFINA and COFINA responses in preparation for mediation process.

1.50 562.50

8/15/2017 AJBFollow up on issuance of order authorizing employment of BGM by the ORC (Dkt 1003); exchange of correspondence with M. Root on methodology to be used pursuant to the proposed interim compensation order T/C with A. Quilinchini of Publicidad Tere Sudrez re: choice made by ORC. Follow up on motions filed and orders issued as per ECF system. Meeting with H. Mayol prior to mediation in NYC this week.

1.80 675.00

8/16/2017 HMKMeeting with R. Gordon and R. Levin 2.00 750.00

8/16/2017 HMK1.50 562.50

Page 32 of 56



4.20 1,575.00Received T/C from H. Mayol on need conduct research under PR Constitution on the taxing powers of the Commonwealth Government in the contexct of the COFINA claims. Received and

■. ■ : i : E-

follow up on motions filed and orders issued as per the ECF system. Began review of Lex Claims,LLC (3:16-cv-02374 (FAB) on COFINA dispute.

8/16/2017 CRIResearch on PR constitutional issues and taxing power of PR legislature. Conf A. J. Bennazar.

3.50 525.00

8/16/2017 FDC0.20 50.00

Read notice of presentment of third revised order setting procedures for interim compensation and reimbursement of expenses of professionals, filed August 17,2017 by the Commonwealth.

8/16/2017 FDCRead defendants's motion and memorandum to compel production of documents, filed August 16, 2017 by ERS bondholders.

0.30 75.00

8/16/2017 FDCRead stipulated protective order, filed August 16, 2017.

0.30 75.00

8/16/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Committee of Regired Employees of the

Commonwealth of Puerto Rico regarding participation in the August 22,2017 Hearing, filed August 16,2017.

8/16/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Read order scheduling and regarding procedures

for attendance, participation and observation of August 23, 2017, oral argument, by Judge Swain.

8/16/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Read order scheduling and regarding procedures

for attendance, participation and observation of August 23, 2017, oral argument by Judge Swain.

Page 33 of 56


AmountHoursAttorney / ActivityDate8/16/2017 FDC

0.10Read verified statement of the Official Committee of Regired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2019, filed August 16,2017.

25.00

8/17/2017 HMKReturn New York to San Juan. 4.00 1,500.00

8/17/2017 HMK0.10 37.50Read motion from oversight and management

board to dismiss plaintiffs (UPR - RUM Professors) complaint pursuant to fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(1) and (B)(6), filed August 16,2017.

8/17/2017 HMKRead reference to Magistrate Judge Judith Dein form general pre-trial management August 17, 2017 by Judge Swain.

0.10 37.50

8/17/2017 HMKRead order scheduling briefing and hearing in connection with the Aurelius Motions, August 17, 2017 by Judge Swain.

37.500.10

8/17/2017 HMK0.10 37.50Read order certifying matters to the attorney

general of the United State, August 17,2017 by Judge Swain.

8/17/2017 HMKRead order certifying matters to the attorney general of the United States, August 17, 2017.

37.500.10

8/17/2017 HMKRead memorandum titled! 0.20 75.00

8/17/2017 FDC0.20 50.00Read notice of presentement of fourth revised

order setting procedures for interim compensation and reimbursement of expenses of professionals, filed August 17,2017 by the Commonwealth.

Page 34 of 56


Date Attorney / Activity Hours Amount8/17/2017 FDC

Draft of e-mail to Jose Marin, president of the Official Committee of Retirees and draft of e-mail to group of professionals from Jenner and Blcok Segal and FTI Consulting regarding the subjects to be covered during the next meeting of the Committee (August 23,2017); read e-mail reply from M. Root; and draft of e-mail to Jose Marin confirming the hour of the meeting.

0.40 100.00

8/17/2017 FDCReceived telephone calls from attorney Ataveira Mela, retiree Wilfredo Fontanez and Wanda Real regarding notifications mailed to creditors of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and if they are represented by the Official Committee of Retirees under Title III of PROMESA.

0.80 200.00

8/17/2017 FDCDraft of minutes and review of documents for the August 8, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees.

2.30 575.00

8/17/2017 FDCRead memorandum titled 0.10 25.00

8/17/2017 FDCRead order certifying matters to the attorney general of the United States, August 17, 2017.

0.10 25.00

8/17/2017 FDCRad order scheduling briefing and hearing in connection with the Aurelius Motions, August 17, 2017 by Judge Swain.

25.000.10

8/17/2017 FDC0.10 25.00

Read reference to Magistrate Judge Judith Dein for general pre-trial management, August 17, 2017.

Page 35 of 56


Hours AmountDate Attorney / Activity8/17/2017 AJB

4.60 1,725.00Follow up with F. Del Castillo on agenda for next meeting of the ORC; Review of motions filed and orders issued via the ECF sysem. Follow up on filing of informative motion on behalf of ORC re: August 23 hearing; continued review of pleadings in the Lex calims-Cofina litigation. Research on Commonwealth constitutional issues in light of Cofina dispute. Examined Marchand proposal.

8/17/2017 FDCRead motion from oversight and management board to dismill plaintiffs (UPR-RUM Pipfessors) complaint pursuant to Fed R. Civ. P 12(b)(1) and (B)(6), filed August 16, 2017.

0.40 100.00

8/17/2017 FDCRead order amending case management procedures, August 17,2017 by Judge Swain.

0.20 50.00

8/18/2017 FDCReview of ffaft of Consulting Services Proposal by Marchand ICS Gorup (Public Relations Firm selected by the Official committee).

8/18/2017 AJB1.90 712.50Received and examined second amended notice,

case management administrative procedures; order certifying matters to the attorney General of the US re challenge to consitutionality of appointment of PROMESA Board (913-914); order scheduling briefing and hearing on consitutional challenge; reviewed motions filed and orders entered via the EDF system; motion from UCC to Magistrate J. Gaid Dein on August 22 hearing; motion of the National Public Finance Corp.; related motions.

Page 36 of 56



1.80 675.00Received and examined UCC's Omnibus reply to objections and responses to UCC's motion for order under Bankrupcty Rule 2004 re discovery. Conference with F. Del Castillo on minutes of last meeting of ORC and agenda for next Wednesday's meeting; conference with H. Mayol to review and discuss calendar of mediation events. Conference with C. Ramirez re resesarch

.8/18/2017 AJB

Received and examined notice of the FOMB re 1.20 450.00Centro de Periodismo Investigativo; informative motion of GO Group; UCC notice re hearing. Received and examined correspondence from R. Gordon on public statements made by the Rosello administration payments to GO bondholders, suppliers and pensions.

8/18/2017 FDCRead omnibus reply of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to various objections and responses to committee motion for order, under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, authorizing discovery program with respect to certain causes of Puerto Rico financial crisis, filed August 18,2017.

0.40 100.00

8/18/2017 FDCConference call with Jorge Marchand of Marchand ICS Group, Robert Gordon, Catherine Steege and Melissa Root from Jenner & Block LLP and

1.00 250.00

Hector Mayol, about the Consulting Services Proposal.

8/18/2017 HMKT/c with R. Gordon, M. Root, F. del Castillo with Jorge Marchand to discuss service contract terms and conditions.

1.00 375.00

Page 37 of 56


Hours AmountAttorney / Activity FDC

Continued draft of minutes, review of documents and translation to English of minutes for the August 8, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; T/c with Milagros Acevedo, Secretary of the Official Committee, about the minutes of August 8,2017.

FDCRead e-mail and attachment from M. Root with draft of agenda for the August 23,2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; draft of e-mail to Jose Marin about draft of agenda; draft of e-mail reply to M. Root with changes to the agenda; read 2nd e-mail from M. Root with additional changes to the agenda; draft and translation of agenda; draft of e-mail to the members of the Official Committe attaching the agenda and minutes of the August 8, 2017 meeting.

HMK

Read e-mail and attachment from M. Root with draft of agenda for the August 23,2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; read 2nd e- mail from M. Root with additional changes to the Agenda; draft of e-mail to the members of the Official Committee attaching the agenda and minutes of the August 8,2017.

HMKReview of documents and meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; T/c with Milagros Acevedo, Secretary of the Official Committee, about the minutes of August 8, 2017.FDCRead reply in further suppport of Confina Senior Parties' urgent motion regarding discovery disputes and for a pretrial hearing pursuant to Fed. R.Bankr. P 7016, filed August 18,2017.

FDCRead order for reference to Magistrate Judge, August 18,2017 by Judge Swain.

Date8/18/2017

1,675.006.70

8/18/2017200.000.80

8/18/20170.40 150.00

8/18/20171.20 450.00

8/19/201750.000.20

8/19/20170.14 25.00

Page 38 of 56



Draft e-mail and attachment of several documents 0.60 150.00to the members of the Official Committee of Retirees and CC to teams of professionals.

8/19/2017 HMK1.00 375.00Read review and comment on agenda for 8/23

committee meeting and minutes of prior meeting.8/19/2017 HMK

Read order for reference to Magistraste Judge, August 18,2017 by Judge Swain.

0.60 225.00

8/19/2017 HMKRead reply in further support of Cofina Senior Parties'urgent motion regarding discovery disputes and for a pretrial hearing pursuant to Fed. R. Bankruptcy P. 7016, filed August 18,2017.

0.40 150.00

8/21/2017 FDCMeeting with Luis Benabe from The Marketing Center and Jorge Marchand from Marchand ICS Group to discuss the preparation of a socioeconomic study of retirees.

1.20 300,00

8/21/2017 FDCDraft e-mail to Luis Benabe from The Marketing Center and the attachment of several documents

0.30 75.00

(actuarial reports from the 3 retirement systems and 2 studies regarding retirees in Puerto Rico) in order for him to make a proposal of services.

8/21/2017 HMKRead FDC e-mail to Luis Benabe from the 0.10 37.50marketing center with attachment in order for him to make a proposal of services.

8/21/2017 HMKT/c with Professionals (Jenner & Block Team/Segal Team/FTI Consulting and Bennaar, Garcia & Milian Team) of the Official Retiree of Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

2.00 750.00

8/21/2017 HMKMeeting with Stuart Wohl of Segal Co. at Mi Salud to learn about eligibility and benefits of medicaid equivalent plan. Luz Cruz, director and Walter Dobek Deputy Director.

1.20 450.00

Page 39 of 56


I

Attorney / Activity HoursDate Amount8/21/2017 HMK

Meeting at Triple-S with S. Wohl (Segal), Dorelisse Juarbe, Nanette Vargas and Gustavo Perez of Triple-S to leam about health plans available to Retirees - Law 95 and Medicaid.

1.40 525.00

8/21/2017 HMK2.30 862.50Meeting with S. Wohl-Segal to discuss Puerto Rico

pension laws benefits health benefits and composition and mission of Retirees Committee.

8/21/2017 HMKMeeting with Stuart Wohl and MMM with Dr. Raul Montalvo, president of MMM MSO to leam about their benefits to Retirees with and without Medicare.

1.00 375.00

8/21/2017 FDC2,00Conference call with professionals (Jenner &

Block team/Segal team/FTI Consulting team and Bennazar, Garcia & Milidn team) of the Official Retiree of Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

500.00

8/21/2017 FDCMotion to dismiss plaintiffs'complaint pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) and 12(B)(6) by the Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico, filed August 21, 2017.

1.20 300.00

8/21/2017 FDCRead adversary complaint by the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees on behalf of SPU, filed August 22, 2017.

0.10 25.00

8/21/2017 AJBParticipated in teleconference with the ORC professional team: Jenner, Segal, FTI and BGMCSP.

2.00 750.00

8/22/2017 FDC0.10 25.00Read e-mail from M. Root regarding the

memorandum to the Official Committee of Cases under Title III PROMESA; draft e-mail response.

Page 40 of 56


1


Read e-mail from M. Root regarding the memorandum to the Official Committee of Cases under Title III of PROMESA; draft e-mail

0.20 50.00

response.8/22/2017 FDC

Review and translation to Spanish of memorandum to the Official Committee of Cases under Title III of PROMESA prepared by Jenner & Block and for distritubion to retirees.

1.20 300.00

8/22/2017 HMKRead adversary complaint by the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees on behalf of SPU, filed August 22, 2017.

0.30 112.50

8/22/2017 HMK1.00 375.00Review memorandum to the Official Committee of

Cases under Title El of PROMESA prepared by Jenner & Block and for distribution to retirees.

8/22/2017 HMKRead Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico's answer to defendants' counterclaims, filed August 22, 2017.

1.00 375.00

8/22/2017 HMKMeeting with Stuart Wohl at ASES Puerto Rico Health Insurance Benefits Administration: Manuel Tristani Benefits Director; Carlos Guzman - Law 95 Benefits Administrator. Discussed and understand benefits to Government active and retirees.

1.00 375.00

8/22/2017 HMK 2.80 1,050.00Discussion with S. Wohl-Segal about PR Health System benefit plans retirement systems PROMESA Official Committee requirements and strategy.

8/22/2017 HMKMeeting Stuart Wohl-Segal with MCS, Roberto Pando, president of MCS Salud and Carlos de Jesus VP. Discussed MCS Advantage and Medicaid offerings to retirees and health care funding prospects.

1.70 637.50

Page 41 of 56


Attorney l_ Activity AJB

Reviewed documents for tomorrow's meeting of the ORC. Several conferences throughout day with F. Del Castillo and H. Mayol. Reviewed pleadings filed and orders issued.

FDCDraft e-mail and attachment of document to J. Marchand regarding study titled "Perfil del Pensionado del Gobiemo de Puerto Rico 2003- 2009".

FDCRead Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commounwealth of Puerto Rico's answer to defendants' counterclaims, filed August 22, 2017,

FDCDraft e-mail to M. Root regarding memoranduym of status of PROMESA cases.

HMKT/C with Committee Chair Jos6 Marin and F. del Castillo to review agenda items for Committee meeting.

HMKT/c with Jos6 Marin, president of ORC and F. Del Castillo regarding adversary complaint filed by the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees on behalf of SPU filed August 22, 2017.

HMKT/c with Jose Marin, president of ORC, Jorge Marchand of Marchand ICS Group and F. Del Castillo regarding the next steps to be taken regarding the communication strategy of the Committee.

HMKAttend Committee Meeting (All professionals and members).

HMKT/c with Jenner professionals and F. del Castillo. Discussed AFSCME motion and possible options to present to the Committee.


4.50 1,687.50

8/22/20170.20 50.00

8/22/20170.30 75.00

8/23/20170.10 25.00

8/23/20171.00 375.00

8/23/20170.50 187.50

8/23/20170.60 225.00

8/23/20174.00 1,500.00

8/23/20170.50 187.50

Page 42 of 56


1


T/c with F. del Castillo, Jose Marin and Jorge Marchand to discuss web page possible retirees

0.50 187.50

survey,8/23/2017 AJB

Attended ORC meeting. 3.00 1,125.008/23/2017 FDC

Read objection to defendants'urgent motion for an order extending their time to respond to plaintiffs adversary complaint by ERS Secured Creditors, filed August 23,2017.

0.20 50.00

8/23/2017 FDCRead e-mail from B. Gordon regarding the Retiree Committee website.

0.10 25.00

8/23/2017 HMK0.30 112.50T/C with B. Gordon, R. Levin, C. Steege, M. Root

and F, del Castillo about adversary complaint filed by the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees on behalf of SPU, filed August 22,2017, and the discussion of the complaint with the Retiree Committee.

8/23/2017 AJBWorked on memorandum to R. Levin on PR Constitutional law issues re Cofina.

8/23/2017 FDCRead e-mail from J. Marchand about the domains for the Retiree Committee website.

5.20 1,950.00

0.10 25.00

8/23/2017 FDCT/c with B. Gordon, R. Levin, C. Steege, M. Root and H. Mayol about adversary complaint filed by the American Federation of State, county and Municipal Employees on behalf of SPU, filed August 22,2017, and the discussion of the complaint with the Retiree Committee.

0.60 150.00

8/23/2017 FDCT/c with Jose Marin, president of Retirement committee, and H. Mayol regarding the agenda and issues to discuss during the meeting.

1.00 250.00

8/23/2017 FDCPreparation for the August 23,2017 meeting of Official Retiree Committee (coordination with secretaries, documents and materials).

0.90 225.00

Page 43 of 56



T/c with Jose Marin, President of Retirement committee, Jorge Marchand of Marchand ICS Group and H. Mayol regarding the next steps to be taken regarding the communication strategy of the Committee.

0.50 125.00

8/23/2017 FDCAttended meeting of the Official Committee or Retirees.

3.00 750.00

8/23/2017 FDCRead e-mail from R. Gordon regarding the presence of the lawyers of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees during the next Official Committee meeting.

0.10 25.00

8/23/2017 FDCRead order setting procedures for interim compensation and reimbursement of expenses of professionals, August 23,2017, Judge Swain.

0.20 50.00

8/23/2017 FDCmemorandum of laws and cases regarding pension benefits.

0.10 25.00

8/24/2017 HMK1.00 375.00T/c with Jenner & Block team, FDC, A. J.

Bennazar to review agenda for mediation sessions in NY, topics for mediation statement.

8/24/2017 AJBParticipated in teleconference with Jenner team, F. Del Castillo and H. Mayol on mediation memoranda on behalf of ORC.

1.00 375.00

8/24/2017 AJB1Continued providing support to R. Levin on ORC

memorandum on the GO-COFINA dispute. Researched additional P.R case law.

3.80 1,425.00

8/24/2017 HMKWrote e-mail to S. Wohl-Segal on Triple-S meeting on 8/21.

0.20 75.00

8/24/2017 HMK0.30 112.50Read A. J. Bennazar memo on constitutional issues

related to GO and COFINA bondholder claims.

Page 44 of 56



Hours Amount

Read interim order in respect of Rule 2004 Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, August 24,2017 by Magistrate Judge Judith Gail Dein.

0.10 25.00

8/24/2017 FDCRead e-mail by B. Gordon regarding R. Benabe service proposal.

0.10 25.00

8/24/2017 FDC0.40 100.00Read ERS, AAFAF, the Commonwealth of Puerto

Rico and the FOMB's responses and objectios to defendants' motion to compel production of documents, filed August 24, 2017.

8/25/2017 FDCRead and reviewed Act 106-2017 "Ley para Garantizar el Pago a Nuestros Pensionados y Establecer un Nuevo Plan de Aportaciones Definidas para los Servicores Publicos", act that establishes de Pay Go System.

1.30 325.00

8/25/2017 HMKRead recent docket entries and motions. 0.50 187.50

8/25/2017 HMKT/c with Luis Benabe and F. Del Castillo to discuss scope and contents of Retiree Survey to be conducted, discussed availability and sources of information.

0.50 187.50

8/25/2017 FDCRead e-mail from R. Levin regarding memorandum PR Constitution; read 2nd e-mail from R. Levin regarding same subject.

0.60 150.00

8/25/2017 FDC0.60 150.00Read e-mail from L. Benabe regarding the study of

social and financial condition of retirees; draft of e- mail reply to Mr. Benabe; read e-mail reply from L. Benabe; conference call with L. Benabe and H. Mayol regarding the study, sample of ertirees and how to obtain the information.

8/25/2017 FDCRead motion of National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation for entry of an order pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2004 authorizing discovery, filed August 25,2017.

0.40 100.00

Page 45 of 56



Read transcription of hearing before Judith Gail Dein, United States Magistrate Judge. United States District Court 1 Courtroom 18, Boston, Massachusetts 02210, August 22,2017.FDCRead amended notice of appointment of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, August 25, 2017 by Guy G. Gebhardt, acting United States Trustee.

0.10 25.00

8/25/20170.10 25.00

8/25/2017 FDC0.40 100.00Read e-mail and attachments from A. J. Bennazar

regarding Official PR Supreme Court texts of the cited cases, memorandum PR Constitution.

8/25/2017 FDC0.50 125.00T/c with L. Benabe and H. Mayol regarding the

retiree survey to be prepared and how to obtain the data.

8/25/2017 FDC0.60 150.00Read e-mail from C. Steege and read and reviewed

draft statement; read e-mail reply and attachment by R. Lellvin; read e-mail reply from H. Mayol; read e-mail reply from C. Steege.

8/25/2017 FDC0.70 175.00

Read joint motion by the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders, Assured Guaranty Corp. Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. and The Mutual Fund Group for Order Authorizing Rule 2004 Examination, filed August 25, 2017.

8/25/2017 FDC0.80 200.00Read e-mail from R. Gordon regarding mediation

hearings ; read e- mail reply by S. Simms; read 2nd e-mail reply from R. Gordon; read e-mail reply by H. Mayol; read e-mail reply C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail reply by S. Simms; read 3rd e-mail reply by B. Gordon; read 3rd e-mail reply by S. Simms.

Page 46 of 56



Continued legal research on PR Constitutional case 6.80 2,550.00

Reviewed opinions of the PR Secretary of Justice and records of the PR Constitutional Assembly. Forwarded cases to R.

> Levin,8/25/2017 FDC

Read e-mail from J. Marchand regarding the domain of the web page for the Official Committee of Retirees.

0.10 25.00

8/25/2017 FDCRead and review memorandum on Puerto Rico Constitution, Article VI Sec. 2, by A, J. Bennazar and supporting cases.

0.30 75.00

8/25/2017 FDCRead notice of hearing on motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for leave to be

0.50 125.00

heard and/or to intervene under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed August 25, 2017.

8/25/2017 FDCRead reply in support of defendants' motion to compel production of documents, by ERS Bondholders,filed August 25, 2017.

0.10 25.00

8/26/2017 HMKRead docket entries and motions, orders issued on 8/25.

0.50 187.50

8/26/2017 HMK1.00 375.00Read, reviewed and commented on

8/26/2017 HMKRead e-mails from R. Gordon, C. Steege and R.Levin on

0.30 112.50

Page 47 of 56


Attorney / Activity FDC

Read e-mail from A. J. Bennaar regarding PR Constitution Article VI - PROMESA; read 2nd e- mail from A. J. Bennazar; read reply e-mail by R. Levin.

FDC ________Read e-mail from R. Levin regarding^

HoursDate Amount8/26/2017

0,30 75.00

8/26/20170.10 25.00

8/26/2017 AJBContinued to provide support to R. Levin on the 1,800,004.80

8/26/2017 FDC0.40 100.00Read e-mail from R. Levin regarding

8/27/2017 AJBReceived and examined R. Gordon's draft of 1,200.003.20

|Received and examined comments and edits proposed by L. Park of FTI Consulting; Received and examined comments and edits proposed by R. Levin, C. Steege, M. Root and R.

8/27/2017 FDCRead e-mail from Liz Parks, FTI Consulting regarding H

0.50 125.00

(READ E-MAIL REPLY FROM R. Levin; read e-mail reply C. Steege; read 2nd reply from C. Steege and read and reviewed draft of changes to the documents.

Page 48 of 56


Date Attorney/Activity 8/27/2017 HMK

Hours Amount

Read various e-mails by R. Levin, R. Gordon, M.Root with comments to C. Stooge dralt.H

0.50 187.50

8/27/2017 HMK1.00 375.00

8/27/2017 FDCRead e-mail and attached documents by R. Gordon regardingreply by R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail reply by R. Gordon; read e-mail reply by C. Steege and attachment; read 2nd e-mail reply to C. Steege; read 3rd e-mail reply by R. Levin; read 4th e-mail reply by R. Levin; read 3rd e-mail reply by B. Gordon.

1.10 275.00read e-mail

8/28/2017 HMKMeeting with Robert Gordon (Jenner) in preparation for mediation sessions; discussed intervention in FOMB v. Rossello case.

1.00 375.00

8/28/2017 HMKRead summary of proposed revised fiscal plan by PRASA and FOMB letter to Rossello on ability to dismiss Boards of Directors.

0.30 112.50

8/28/2017 HMKRead daily docket and 0.50 187.50

8/28/2017 HMK0.50 187.50Discussion with R. Gordon on intervention by

OCR in FOMB lawsuit against governor Rossello.8/28/2017 HMK

Read motion of Ad Hoc Group of GO Bondholders for discovery under Section 2004. Discussion with Roberto Gordon on possible position by OCR.

0.50 187.50

Page 49 of 56


HoursDate Attorney / Activity Amount8/28/2017 HMK

Non working travel time San Juan to New York to attend mediation sessions

4.00 1,500.00

8/28/2017 HMKReviewed FDC and AJB work schedule and topics covered through 8/27/2017.

375.001.00

8/28/2017 FDCFlight to New York City for mediation sessions. 7.50 1,875.00

8/28/2017 AJBReceived and examined from L. Park 1.80 675.00

8/28/2017 AJB450.00Received and examined complaint in adversary

proceeding 17-00250 (LTS) FOMB vs Rossello (Governor) for declaratory judgment and injunctions relief. Exchange of comments and observations with R. Gordon, R. Levin, C. Steege on basis for the ORC to file an interpleader to oppose the Fiscal Plan's proposed cuts to pensionns.

1.20

8/28/2017 AJB0.80 300.00Received and examined 12 subpoenas served upon

serveral Commonwealth officers and agencies and upon Rothschild & Co. in adversary Proceeding 17- 00133 (LTS) by Kramer Levin in the COFINA- BNYM inteq?leader.[

8/28/2017 FDCRead non-debtor defendants'supplemental reply in support of joint motion to dismiss plaintiffs complaint pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) and (B)(6), filed August 28,2017 by AAFAF.

0.20 50.00

Page 50 of 56


!


0.70 175.00Read adversary complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief by FOMB, filed August 28,2017.

8/28/2017 FDCRead reply memorandum in support of motion to dismiss plaintiffs'complaint pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) and j(B)(6), file August 28,2017, by FOMB.

0.50 125,00

8/28/2017 FDCRead e-mail from B. Gordon regarding communication stragegy; read reply from J. Marchand.

0.20 50.00

8/29/2017 HMK9.50 3,562.50

8/29/2017 AJBFurther review and discussion of Adversary Proceedings complaint by FOBM vs Governor R. Rosselld and basis for interpleader on behalf of ORC; exchange of notes with R. Gordon and R. Levin. Received and examined note from M.

2.80 1,050.00

Bienstock (Proskauer) rejecting proposed conference among counsel. Reviewed motions filed and orders entered as per the EFC System. Received and examined UCC request to intervene in BNYM interpleader.

8/29/2017 FDC9.50 2,375.00

8/29/2017 FDCRead joint stipulation and scheduling order for Commonwealth COFINA Dispute, filed August 29,2017.

0.10 25.00

8/29/2017 FDCRead urgent motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, in its capacity as agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, for leave to intervene under 11 U.S.C. §1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed August 29, 2017.

0.20 50.00

Page 51 of 56


Hours AmountAttorney / ActivityDate8/29/2017 FDC

75.000.30Read notice of hearing on motion of American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees to Stay Proceeding or, in the alternative, (i) consolidated proceedings or (ii) for leave to intervene under federal rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7024. Read motion of American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees to Stay Proceedings or, in the alternative (i) consolidate proceedings or (ii) for leave to intervene under federal rule of Banjruptcy Procedure 7024, filed August 29, 2017.

8/29/2017 FDC0,10 25.00

Read amended notice of hearing on motion of American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees to Stay Proceeding or, in the alternative, (i) consolidate proceedings or (ii) for leave to intervene under Federal Rule or Bankruptcy Procedure 7024, file August 29, 2017.

8/30/2017 FDCRead order scheduling expedited hearing on urgent motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, in its capacity as agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, for leave to intervene under 11 U.S.C. §1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024, Augut 30, Magistrate Judge Dein.

0.10 25.00

8/30/2017 FDCRead notice of filing of creditor list for Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (COFINA) global notes and statement of limitations, methods, and disclaimers regarding the creditor list for the PR Sales Tax Financing Corporation, filed August 30,2017.

50.000.20

8/30/2017 HMK8.00 3,000.00

Page 52 of 56


Date Attorney / ActivityAJB

Received and examined stipulation and scheduling order for Commonwealth COFINA dispute;Further exchange of memoranda regarding complaint FOMB vs Governor; ORC will intervene. Exchange of correspondence with K. Nicoll (Segal), C. Steege, S. Gumbs (FTC, H, Mayol, R. Gordon, R. Levin on undertakings to obtain data from Milliman. Reviewed motion filed and orders issued as per the EFC System.

FDC


1.70 637.50

8/30/20170.20 50.00Read supplemental brief of financial oversight and

management board for Puerto Rico in opposition to motion of Ad Hoc Group of PREP A Bondholders, National Public Finance Guaranty Municipal Corp. Assured Guaranty Corp.Assured Guaranty Municiapl Corp. and Syncora Guarantee Inc. fr relief from automatic stay, filed August 29, 2017.

FDCRead notice of filing of creditor list for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico / global notes and statement of limitations, methods, and diclaimers regarding the creditor list for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico filed August 30,2017.

8/30/20170.30 75.00

8/30/20172,125.00

8/31/2017 FDC6.50 1,625.00

8/31/2017 FDCRead second amended notice of appointment of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, August 31, 2017 by Guy G. Gebhardt, Acting United States Trustee.

0.10 25.00

8/31/2017 FDCRead order regarding joint stipulation and scheduling order for Commonwealth- COFINA dispute, August 31, 2017 by Judge Swain.

0.10 25.00

Page 53 of 56


Attorney/ ActivityDate Hours Amount8/31/2017 FDC

0.20 50.00Draft e-mail to M. Root regarding the September 5,2017 Official Retiree Committee meeting; read e-mail reply from M. Root.

8/31/2017 HMK8.50 3,187.50

8/31/2017 AJBReviewed motion to inform filing of Commonwealth list of creditors; examined motion to inform filing of the Cofina creditor list. Review of the motions filed and orders issued as per the ECF system. T/C with HMK in NYC at the mediation sessions. Exchange of notes with Sgt. J. Marin and other members of the ORC on

1.50 562.50

Committee meeting scheduled for next Tuesday. Follow up on agenda and minutes of prior meeting.

8/31/2017 FDC1.00 250.00Draft of e-mail to J. Marin, President, regarding

agenda of the September 5,2017 Official Retiree Committee Meeting; read e-mail reply from J. Marin; draft of reply to e-mail to J. Marin and modification of the agenda; read reply from J. Marin; draft of reply to e-mail to J. Marin; read reply e-mail from J. Marin and draft of e-mail reply and final modification to agenda.

8/31/2017 AJBReviewed memorandum from F. del Catillo on 1.20 450.002014 financial report on ERS of the P.R. Electric Power Authority; exchange of correspondence re: same with R. Levin, F. del Castillo, K. Nicholl (Segal) and C. Steege.

8/31/2017 FDCRead e-mail fromR, Levin about the agenda to be sent by Judge Houser for the next mediation meetings.

0.10 25.00

8/31/2017 FDCRead e-mail from R. Levin about

and the role of the Official Retirement Committee.

0.10 25.00

Page 54 of 56



Hours Amount

0.30 75.00Read e-mail from C. Steege regarding progress on Milliman disclosures; read e-mail reply by R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail and reply by C. Steege.

8/31/2017 FDCFlight from New York to Puerto Rico after mediation sessions.

2.00 500.00

SUBTOTAL: $124,850.04377.94

Page 55 of 56


of 44

BENNAZAR, GARCÍA & MILIÁN, C.S.P. APARTADO POSTAL 194000 NÚM.212 SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO 00919-4000

Teléfono: (787) 754-9191 Fax: (787) 764-3101

[email protected] [email protected] Núm. S.S. 66-0535704

October 30, 2017 Invoice #170901

OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES P/C MR. JOSE MARIN, CHAIRPERSON

RE: COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO

CASE NUMBER 17-BK-03283 (D.P.R.)

FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 2017

DATE ATTORNEY/ACTIVITY HOURS RATE AMOUNT

CASE ADMINISTRATION/MISCELLANOUS (MATTER NUMBER 10008) 09/06/17

09/08/17

AJB

AJB

Follow up with R. Gordon on ORC professionals fee invoices; Received and examined exchange of correspondence between R. Gordon (ORC) and Suzzanne Uhland (AAFAF); Received and examined letter of R. Gordon to AAFAF director Gerardo Portela. Received and examined motion to submit Master Service list by attorney G. Olivera Dubón and noticed BGM, CSP is not included. Note to H. Mayol and F. del Castillo. Exchange of notes with H. Mayol and C. Steege on distribution of

0.90

0.60

375.00 375.00

337.50

225.00 chores for next week, including ORC next meeting and attendance

at

09/10/17

AJB

Wrote memorandum to Gabriel Oliveras Dubón (O & B) to follow up on the updated Title III cases service list; received automatic response. Note to H. Mayol and R. Gordon. Exchange of notes with C. Steege and F. del Castillo on

0.80

375.00 300.00

09/11/17 HMK Meeting with AJB to review staffing and topic assignment to legal staff.

0.20 375.00 75.00


of 44


09/16/17 HMK Read memorandum

. 0.10 375.00 37.50

SUB TOTAL 2.60 975.00

EMPLOYMENT OF PROFESSIONALS AND FEE APPLICATIONS (MATTER NUMBER 10016)

09/30/17 HMK Preparing September Fee Application for H Mayol. 1.00 375.00 375.00

SUB TOTAL 1.00 375.00

COMMITTEE GOVERNANCE AND ATTENDANCE AT MEETINGS (MATTER NUMBER 10024)

09/01/17 FDC Draft of minutes in Spanish and English of the August 23, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees.

3.50 250.00 875.00

09/01/17

AJB

Several telephone conferences and exchange of notes with Sgt. Marín and F. del Castillo on setting up ORC meeting for next Tuesday. Reviewed draft of minutes of August 23 meeting prepared by F. del Castillo. Reviewed and revised proposed agenda for next Tuesday's meeting.

2.40

375.00 900.00

09/01/17

FDC

Draft of e-mail (.1) to M. Root regarding the minutes of the August 23, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; read e-mail reply (.1) and attachment with comments (.1) to the minutes.

0.30

250.00 75.00

09/01/17

FDC

Read e-mail by Jose Marin, President, giving final ok to the draft of agenda for the September 5 meeting.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/01/17

FDC

Draft of e-mail to all members of the Official Committee of Retirees and all professional teams, including the agenda for the September 5, meeting and the draft of minutes from the August 23 meeting.

0.30

250.00 75.00


of 44


09/04/17 AJB Further preparation for tomorrow's ORC meeting. Reviewed final

drafts of prior meeting minutes and agenda; exchange of correspondence and notes with F. del Castillo, Sgt. Marín, R. Gordon on need to reschedule meeting, now tentatively set for October 18.

1.40 375.00 525.00

09/04/17

FDC

Read e-mail (.1) from R. Gordon regarding the Retiree Committee/ PREPA composition; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read 2nd e-

0.30

250.00 75.00

mail (.1) from R. Gordon.

09/04/17

FDC

Received message (.1) from Jose Marin, President, regarding the

0.40

250.00 100.00

cancelation of the September 5, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee of Retirees; read e-mail (.1) from A Bennazar regarding the cancelation; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

09/05/17

AJB

Exchange of correspondence and notes, T/C with Sgt. Marín, F. del

0.60

375.00 225.00

Castillo, R. Gordon re: re-scheduling of next ORC meeting and modification of agenda.

09/10/17

AJB

Exchange of notes with F. del Castillo and R. Gordon on next ORC

0.60

375.00 225.00 meeting logistics and agenda.

09/10/17

FDC

Read e-mail from R. Gordon regarding the schedule of the next

0.10

250.00 25.00

Official Committee meeting.

09/10/17

HMK

Read e-mail from R. Gordon regarding the schedule of the next Official Committee meeting.

0.10

375.00 37.50

09/11/17

HMK

Read various emails and responded on survey of Committee

0.30

375.00

112.50

members available to .

09/12/17

FDC

Draft of e-mail to Jenner & Block legal team regarding the

0.10

250.00

25.00

responses of the members of the Official Committee of Retirees to attend to .


of 44


09/13/17 AJB Further exchange of notes with F. del Castillo on responses by

individual ORC members to availability survey. 0.40 375.00 150.00

09/14/17 FDC Preparation of Agenda (.2) for the September 19, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee and draft of e-mail (.1) to legal team with new agenda and attachments;

0.30 250.00 75.00

09/14/17 AJB Received and exmained revised agenfa for September 19 ORC

meeting conference with F. del Castillo, to discuss results of survey of individual committee members on availability to participate in

. Exchange of

1.30 375.00 487.50

09/14/17 FDC Draft of e-mail (.1) and preparation of attachments (.2) regarding 1.20 250.00 300.00 the responses of members of the Official Committee to participate ; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read e-mail

reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; draft of e-mail reply (.1); read 3rd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; telephone call

with J. Marin (.1) regarding sending e-mail to Committee Members; draft of e-mail (.1) to J. Marin attaching contact list; draft of e-mail (.2) to all Committee Members regarding their prior professional experience.

09/14/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from H. Mayol regarding the Order Establishing 0.30 250.00 75.00 Deadlines and Procedures for Filing Proofs of Claim; draft of e-mail (.1) reply to H. Mayol and legal team; read e-mail reply (.1) from C. Steege.

09/14/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from H. Mayol regarding motion of International 0.20 250.00 50.00 Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW) Service Employees International Union and American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO to Intervene Under Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7024 filed in adversary proceeding 17-250 (Docket No. 10); draft of e-mail (.1) reply to H. Mayol and legal team.

09/14/17 FDC Draft of e-mail (.1) to committee members regarding their prior occupations; read e-mail reply (.1) from J. Ortiz; read e-mail reply (.1) by M. Lopez.

0.30 250.00 75.00


of 44


09/15/17 AJB Received from F. del Castillo memorandum with final drafts of 1.60 375.00 600.00 english and spanish texts of agenda for September 19 ORC meeting and final drafts in spanish and english of August 23 minutes. Exchange of notes throughout day with F. del Castillo, H. Mayol, R. Gordon and Sgt. Marín on logistics for the next ORC meeting. Exchange of correspondence regarding same with Jenner team. Received and examined correspondence from Marchand ISC Group on ORC public realtions and communications in general to all Commonwealth of P.R. pensioners. Received and examined further correspondence from individual ORC members on . Received and examined Marchand cost quote and response of SGT. Marín.

09/15/17 FDC Read e-mail from F. Díaz from Marchand ICS Group regarding several issues related to public relations of the Official Committee.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/15/17 FDC Conference Call with Jenner & Block, FTI Consultants & Segal regarding

.

1.00 250.00 250.00

09/15/17

FDC

Read e-mail (.1) from M. Root regarding the new draft of the agenda; draft of e-mail and amendment (.2) to the agenda of the September 19, 2017 meeting of the Official Committee; draft of e- mail to J. Marin (.1) for approval of Agenda; draft of e-mail (.2) to Committee Members and all professionals with the agenda and attachments.

0.60

250.00 150.00

09/15/17

FDC

Read e-mail reply (.1) from M. Acevedo to committee members regarding their prior occupations; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Núñez; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Pacheco; read e-mail reply (.1) by J. Ortiz.

0.40

250.00 100.00

09/15/17

FDC

Read e-mail and review of attachment from M. Rivera of Marchand ICS team regarding the website for the Official Committee of Retirees.

0.30

250.00 75.00


of 44


09/17/17 FDC Draft of e-mail (.1) to members of the Official Committee regarding 0.60 250.00 150.00

their prior professions; Prepared (.5) amended contact list of members of the Official Committee with their prior occupations.

09/18/17 AJB Exchange of correspondence with ORC members and F. del Castillo on re-scheduting ORC meeting originally set for tomorrow; Examined correspondence from F. del Castillo to R. Levin on ORC individual members' information on background and availability. Received memorandum from R. Gordon on Marchand's proposed web page for ORC.

0.80 375.00 300.00

SUB TOTAL 19.90 6,162.50

COMMUNICATIONS WITH RETIREES (MATTER NUMBER 10032)

09/11/17 HMK Read emails from R Levin and C Steege on Retirees question on

proposed Bar Dates; redacted language of notice to Retirees. 0.20 375.00 75.00

09/13/17 HMK Redact and edit proposed notice to all Retirees with information on actions needed to protect their claims and interests.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/13/17 HMK Read memo from F del Castillo with result of survey of Committee members on availability to travel and participate in

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/14/17 HMK Read email from R Levin requesting further information from

Committee members. 0.10 375.00 37.50

SUB TOTAL 0.60 225.00

HEALTHCARE/OPEB ANALYSIS (MATTER NUMBER 10040)

09/13/17 HMK Met with Stuart Wohl and staff from Segal to receive briefing on healthcare alternatives to PR Retirees. Jenner Team

2.00 375.00 750.00


of 44


SUB TOTAL 2.00 750.00

PENSION ANALYSIS (MATTER NUMBER 10059)

09/05/17 FDC Read and review the

1.90 250.00 475.00

09/10/17 FDC Read e-mail from R. Gordon regarding the Assets transferred from

ERS. 0.10 250.00 25.00

09/10/17 HMK Read e-mail from R. Gordon regarding the Assets transferred from ERS.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/11/17 AJB Received and examined exchange of correspondence between R. 1.40 375.00 525.00 Gordon, H. Mayol, F. del Castillo on issue regarding assets transferred from ERS to Commonwealth of P.R. Also exchange of correspondence on claims bar dates and on actuarial data provided by Milliman.

09/11/17 FDC Draft of e-mail (.3) to R. Gordon and legal team regarding the Assets

transferred from ERS; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read e- 1.10 250.00 275.00

mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; draft of 2nd e-mail (.2) to R. Gordon and legal team; read 3rd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read

e-mail reply (.1) by H. Mayol.

09/11/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding Claims Bar Date Motion; 0.40 250.00 100.00 read e-mail reply (.1) from R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail (.1) from C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail (.1) from R. Levin.

09/11/17

FDC

Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding PRGERS file posted; read e mail reply (.1) from R. Gordon.

0.10

250.00 25.00


of 44


09/11/17 HMK Draft of e-mail (.3) to R. Gordon and legal team regarding the Assets 1.00 375.00 375.00

transferred from ERS; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read e- mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; draft of 2nd e-mail (.2) to R. Gordon and legal team; read 3rd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege.

09/11/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding Claims Bar Date Motion; read e-mail reply (.1) from R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail (.1) from C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail (.1) from R. Levin.

0.40 375.00 150.00

09/11/17 HMK Answer emails from R Gordon & C Steege on availabilty of ERS

actuarial data provided by Milliman. 0.20 375.00 75.00

09/14/17 HMK Research Law 3-2013 and related documents on pension reforms,

including actuarial assumptions. Forward documents to F del Castillo for further research.

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/18/17 FDC Draft of comments to

0.50 250.00 125.00

09/25/17 FDC Read e-mail and attachment by L. Park regarding PR - follow up on

Pension in Fiscal Plan.

09/25/17 HMK Read e-mail and attachment by L. Park regarding PR - follow up on Pension in Fiscal Plan.

0.40 250.00 100.00 0.40 375.00 150.00

SUB TOTAL 8.30 2,550.00

CONTESTED MATTERS, GO/COFINA (MATTER NUMBER 10075)

09/02/17 AJB Exchange of notes with F. del Castillo; received and examined joint informative motion of B. Whyte (agent for Cofina) and UCC re: amended joint stipulation and rescheduling order; motion of National Public Finance Guarantee Corp. UCC several motions for leave to be heard; amended joint stipulation and sheduling order; stipulation for exchange of conferences info and materials.

1.70 375.00 637.50


of 44


09/02/17 FDC Read Joint Informative Motion of Bettina Whyte, in her Capacity as 0.10 250.00 25.00 Agent for Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (COFINA), and Committee of Unsecured Creditors in its Capacity as Agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Regarding Amended Joint Stipulation and Scheduling Order for Commonwealth-COFINA Dispute, filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

09/02/17 FDC Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of National Public Finance 0.10 250.00 25.00 Guarantee Corporation for entry of an Order Pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2004 Authorizing Discovery, filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

09/02/17 FDC Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of Official Committee of 0.30 250.00 75.00 Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 / Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17-BK-3283 (LTS); Adv. Proc. No. 17-155 (LTS) in 17-BK-3283 (LTS).

09/02/17 FDC Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of Official Committee of 0.30 250.00 75.00 Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 / Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 filed 9/1/17. Case:17- 09/02/17

FDC

00228-LTS Doc#:24 Filed:09/01/17Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of Official Committee of

0.30

250.00 75.00

Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 / Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00232-LTS Doc#:18 Filed:09/01/17.


of 44


09/02/17 FDC Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of Official Committee of 0.30 250.00 75.00 Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 / Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00159-LTS Doc#:69 Filed:09/01/17.

09/02/17 FDC Read Amended Joint Stipulation and Scheduling Order for Commonwealth-COFINA Dispute, filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283- LTS

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/02/17 FDC Read Stipulation and Order for the Production and Exchange of 0.20 250.00 50.00 Confidential Information / Agreement to Respect Confidential Material, filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17 CV 1685-LTS; No. 17 BK 3566- LTS; No. 17 AP 213-LTS.

09/02/17 HMK Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of National Public Finance

Guarantee Corporation for entry of an Order Pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2004 Authorizing Discovery, filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/02/17 HMK Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 / Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17-BK-3283 (LTS); Adv. Proc. No. 17-155 (LTS) in 17-BK-3283 (LTS).

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/02/17 HMK Read Stipulation and Order for the Production and Exchange of Confidential Information / Agreement to Respect Confidential Material, filed 9/1/17. Case No. 17 CV 1685-LTS; No. 17 BK 3566- LTS; No. 17 AP 213-LTS.

0.20 375.00 75.00


of 44


09/04/17 AJB Exchange of notes and T/C with H. Mayol, F. del Castillo, Jenner

team re: proposed adjournment of the October 4 omnibus hearing. 0.60 350.00 225.00

09/05/17 AJB Received and examined final text of ORC motion on proposed adjournment of October 4 omnibus hearing; exchange of notes with C. Steege; note to F. del Castillo; Received motion by National Public Finance Guarantee Corp re: discovery; Received and examined fee statement of Paul Hastings and discussed with F. del Castillo; received and examined AAFAF's motion on reservation of rights.

0.80 375.00 300.00

09/05/17

FDC

Read Informative Motion of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Regarding the Proposed Adjournment of the October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1364 Filed:09/26/17.

0.10

250.00

25.00

09/05/17

FDC

Read Notice Regarding Hearing on Motion of National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation for Entry of an Order Pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2004 Authorizing Discovery, by Judge Swain – 9/5/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/05/17

FDC

Read the Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority’s Objection and Reservation of Rights with Respect to Paul Hastings LLP’s Monthly Fee Statement, filed 9/5/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/06/17

FDC

Read Order Clarifying Briefing Schedule in Connection with the Aurelius Motions and UTIER Adversary Proceeding, by Judge Swain, 9/6/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/06/17

FDC

Read Order Setting Briefing Schedule by Judge Swain, entered 9/6/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; Adv. Proc. No. 17-228-LTS.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/06/17

AJB

Received and examined Judge Swain's order on briefing of adversary proceedings; order setting schedules; Urgent motion on reservation of rights by AAFAF regarding upcoming deadlines.

0.30

375.00 112.50


of 44


09/06/17 FDC Read Urgent Informative Motion Regarding Hurricane Irma and

Reservation of Rights with Respect to Upcoming Deadlines, by AAFAF filed 9/6/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 4780-LTS.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/08/17 FDC Objection of Bettina M. Whyte, in Her Capacity as Agent for the 0.20 250.00 50.00 Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (COFINA), to the Motions of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, in its Capacity as Agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, (1) For Leave to Intervene Under 11 U.S.C. 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024 and (2) For Clarification of May 30, 2017 Interpleader Order. Case:17-00133-LTS Doc#:375 Filed:09/08/17.

09/08/17 FDC Read Objection of The Bank of New York Mellon, as Trustee, to the 0.30 250.00 75.00 Urgent Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, in its Capacity as Agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, for Leave to Intervene Under 11 U.S.C. § 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00133-LTS Doc#:376 Filed:09/08/17

09/08/17 FDC Read Objection of the COFINA Senior Bondholders’ Coalition and National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation (The “COFINA Senior Parties”) to the Urgent Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, in its Capacity as Agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, for Leave to Intervene Under 11 U.S.C. § 1109(B) and Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00133-LTS Doc#:377 Filed:09/08/17.

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/08/17

FDC

Read Opinion and Order Denying Motion for Preliminary Injunction and Motion for Relief from the Automatic Stay. Case:17-03567-LTS Doc#:260 Filed:09/08/17.

0.30

250.00 75.00

09/08/17

FDC

Read AMBAC Assurance Corporation’s Objection to Urgent Motion of the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to Intervene. Case:17-00133-LTS Doc#:378 Filed:09/08/17

0.20

250.00 50.00

09/08/17

FDC

Read and review of Complaint filed by Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors vs. COFINA agent. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1254 Filed:09/08/17

0.50

250.00

125.00


of 44


09/11/17 AJB Exchange of correspondence with R. Levin, C. Steege and R. Gordon 1.20 375.00 450.00 on P.R. perfection of liens issue in relation to applicable provisions of PR law. Conference with H. Mayol, F. del Castillo and C. Ramírez re: same. Further inquiry with C. Ramírez on P.R. versions of certain uniform commercial code provisions.

09/11/17 AJB Received and examined UTIERS's opposition to UCC request to 0.50 375.00 187.50 intervene. Exchange of correspondence with Jenner team on ORC's motion for leave to intervene in cases 3283,3566-LTS. Received and examined Cofina's statement in support of application of 48 USC 2125 and related matters.

09/11/17 AJB Received and examined Cofina objection to UCC motions for leave

to intervene and clasification of interpleader order; BNY-Mellon objection to UCC intervention; also the objections of Senior Cofina bondholders and AMBAC's

0.70 375.00 262.50

09/11/17 FDC Read (.1) Notice of Hearing on Application of COFINA Agent for Entry of Order Authorizing Retention of Centerview Partners LLC as Financial Advisors and Expert / Read (.2) Application of COFINA Agent for Entry of Order Authorizing Retention of Centerview Partners LLC as Financial Advisors and Expert, filed 9/11/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

0.30 250.00 75.00

09/11/17 FDC Read Opposition of Unión de Trabajadores de la Industria Eléctrica y 0.20 250.00 50.00 Riego (UTIER) to “Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024”. Case:17-00228-LTS Doc#:33 Filed:09/11/17.

09/11/17 FDC Read and review Motion of Official Committee of Retired 1.10 250.00 275.00 Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for Leave to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 3566-LTS; Adv. Proc. No. 17-219 in 17 BK 3283-LTS. Doc#:14 Filed:09/11/17.

09/11/17 FDC Read Debtor’s Opposition to Motion of Interamericas Turnkey, Inc.,

to Review and Stay, filed 9/11/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 3567-LTS

0.30 250.00 75.00


of 44


09/11/17 FDC Read Statement in Support of COFINA Agent’s Motion Pursuant to

48 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 105(A) For Order: (I) Confirming that 48 U.S.C. § 2125 Applies to COFINA Agent; (II) Confirming Retention of Local Counsel; and (III) Clarifying Payment of Fees and Expenses of COFINA Agent and Her Professionals, filed 9/11/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

09/11/17 HMK Conference with AJB, FDC and C Ramirez on perfection of COFINA liens under Puerto Rico UCC.

0.10 250.00 25.00 0.50 375.00 187.50

09/11/17 HMK Discussion with Governor Acevedo Vila on the initial structure of COFINA and bond lien strucutre.

0.50 375.00 187.50

09/11/17 HMK Read (.1) Notice of Hearing on Application of COFINA Agent for

Entry of Order Authorizing Retention of Centerview Partners LLC as Financial Advisors and Expert / Read (.2) Application of COFINA Agent for Entry of Order Authorizing Retention of Centerview Partners LLC as Financial Advisors and Expert, filed 9/11/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/11/17 HMK Read and review Motion of Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for Leave to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 3566-LTS; Adv. Proc. No. 17-219 in 17 BK 3283-LTS. Doc#:14 Filed:09/11/17.

1.10 375.00 412.50

09/11/17 HMK Read Opposition of Unión de Trabajadores de la Industria Eléctrica y Riego (UTIER) to “Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024”. Case:17-00228-LTS Doc#:33 Filed:09/11/17.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/11/17 HMK Read Statement in Support of COFINA Agent’s Motion Pursuant to 48 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 105(A) For Order: (I) Confirming that 48 U.S.C. § 2125 Applies to COFINA Agent; (II) Confirming Retention of Local Counsel; and (III) Clarifying Payment of Fees and Expenses of COFINA Agent and Her Professionals, filed 9/11/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS.

0.10 375.00 37.50


of 44


09/12/17 AJB Received and examined AMBAC's motion re: Notice of hearing and 0.80 375.00 300.00 procedural order; Motion for order establishing deadlines… etc.; UCC motion in compliance with notice; UCC motion to intervene in adversary proceedings (17-00133-LTS); Motions to intervene of UAW and AFL-CIO; UCC motion to reply to various obejctions; Commonwealth response to Cofina's motion in 17-BK-3283.

09/12/17 FDC Read Informative Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured 0.10 250.00 25.00 Creditors in Compliance with Notice Regarding Order Scheduling September 15, 2017 Expedited Hearing to Address Urgent Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors, in its Capacity as Agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, for Leave to Intervene Under 11 U.S.C. § 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed 9/12/17. Case No. 17-BK-3283 (LTS); Adv. Proc. No. 17-00133 (LTS).

09/12/17 FDC Read Motion for Order (A) Establishing Deadlines and Procedures 0.40 250.00 100.00 for Filing Proofs of Claim and (B) Approving Form and Manner of Notice Thereof / proposed Order, filed 9/12/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; Case No. 17 BK 4780-LTS. Doc. 1,286.

09/12/17 FDC Read Notice of Hearing on Motion of International Union, United 0.40 250.00 100.00 Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW), Service Employees International Union and American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO to Intervene Under Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7024 / proposed Order, filed 9/12/17. Case No. 17-BK-03283 (LTS); Adv. No. 17-250-LTS. Doc. 10

09/12/17 FDC Read Notice of Hearing, by the Commonwealth filed 9/12/17. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; Case No. 17 BK 4780-LTS. Doc. 1,287

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/12/17 FDC Read Reply to Various Objections to Urgent Motion of Official 0.30 250.00 75.00 Committee of Unsecured Creditors, in its Capacity as Agent for Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, for Leave to Intervene Under 11 U.S.C. § 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024, filed 9/12/17. Case No. 17-BK-3283 (LTS); Case No. 17-BK-3284 (LTS); Adv. Proc. No. 17- 133 (LTS) in 17-BK-3284 (LTS). Doc. 388


of 44


09/12/17 FDC Read Response of Commonwealth Agent to Motion of COFINA

Agent for Order Confirming that 48 U.S.C. § 2125 Applies to COFINA Agent / draft of Order, filed 9/12/17. Case No. 17-BK-3283 (LTS).

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/13/17 AJB Further exchange of notes with Jenner team on P.R. constitutional 2.40 375.00 900.00 issues. Received and examined motion to intervene by UAW and AFL-CIO in adversary proceedings 17-250; Notice of hearing and proposed order by the Commonwealth of P.R. (O & B) and status report of FOMB regarding UCC motion for order (Dkt. 1289); AMBAC's motion on discovery; Debtors entities' motion to amend case management order.. etc.; AMBAC's opposition to motion to dismiss, in cases 17BK3283 abd 3567; Urgent motion for extension of deadlines; Motion of US Trustee to appoint fee examiner; Order (LTS) granting motion to stripe (HTA bonds issue). Reviewed memorandum from F. del Castillo on Cofina bonds issue.

09/13/17 FDC Read AMBAC Assurance Corporation’s Motion or Entry of Order Authorizing Discovery Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004. Doc#: 1,283 Filed:09/12/17.

0.40 250.00 100.00

09/13/17 FDC Read Ambac Assurance Corporation’s Opposition to Defendants’ Request for Judicial Notice. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 3567-LTS; Adv. Proc. No. 17-00159-LTS. Doc#:75 Filed:09/12/17.

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/13/17 FDC Read Debtors Entities’ Motion to Amend Second Amended Notice, 0.20 250.00 50.00 Case Management and Administrative Procedures to Further Revise Protocol for Stay Relief Motions. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 4780-LTS Doc#:268 Filed:09/13/17.

09/13/17 FDC Read Plaintiff Ambac Assurance Corporation’s Opposition to Motion 1.10 250.00 275.00 to Dismiss Plaintiff’s Complaint Pursuant To Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) And (B)(6). Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 3567-LTS. Doc#:74 Filed:09/12/17.


of 44


09/13/17 FDC Read Informative Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors and Status Report Regarding Discovery Discussions, Renewed Request for Authorization of Discovery Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, and Agreed Notice to Conduct Hearing on Motion at October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1284 Filed:09/12/17.

0.40 250.00 100.00

09/13/17

FDC

Read Urgent Motion for Extension of Deadlines in Connection with the Second Amended Notice, Case Management and Administrative Procedures. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 4780-LTS Doc#:267 Filed:09/13/17

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/13/17

FDC

Read Urgent Motion of the United States Trustee Pursuant to PROMESA Sections 316 And 317 and Bankruptcy Code Section 105(A) for Entry of Order Appointing a Fee Examiner and Related Relief. Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 4780-LTS Doc#:1296 Filed:09/13/17.

0.20

250.00 50.00

09/13/17

HMK

Analyse F del Castillo memo on legal framework for initial COFINA Bond issuance

0.20

375.00 75.00

09/13/17

HMK

Meeting with Jenner and FTI on

1.00

375.00

375.00

09/13/17

HMK

Read order from Judge Swain granting Motion to Strike - HTA bonds are not secured by consensual lien under Article 9 of the UCC.

0.30

375.00

112.50

09/13/17 FDC Read Plaintiffs’ (Assured Guaranty Corp.) Memorandum in 0.70 250.00 175.00 Opposition to Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss the Amended Complaint Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) And (B)(6). Case No. 17 BK 3283-LTS; No. 17 BK 3567-LTS; Adv. Proc. No. 17-155-LTS in 17 BK 3283 Adv. Proc. No. 17-156-LTS in 17 BK 3567. Doc#:70 Filed:09/12/17.

09/13/17 FDC Read Status Report of Financial Oversight and Management Board 0.30 250.00 75.00 for Puerto Rico Regarding Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Entry of Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, Authorizing Discovery Program. Case 17-03283-LTS Doc#:1289 Filed:09/12/17.


of 44


09/13/17 HMK Read various emails from R Gordon, R Levin, C Klein with further

discussions on the issue of automatic perfection of the COFINA lien on sales tax.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/14/17 AJB Received and examined memorandum from Olivia Hoffman (Jenner)

with draft of the proposed notice of intervention by the ORC in adversary proceeding 17-00257 initiated by the UCC. Received and examined UCC's informative motion, reply to various objections and response to motion of Cofina agent in adversary proceedings 3283 and 3284. Also received and examined Urgent motion for extension of deadlines and Debtors entities' motion on case management procedures in adversary proceeding 17-03283. Received and examined opinion and order (LTS) denying motion of PREPA bondholders for relief of automatic stay; conference with F. del Castillo re: same. Received and examined exchange of correspondence between R. Levin, C. Klein, F. del Castillo on further review and discussion of the "automatic perfection" issue. Received order (LTS) granting Trustee's request to appoint a fee examiner and order granting extension of deadline. Received memorandum from C. Steege on deadlines to file p-o-c's. Received and examined notice of filing of supplemental declaration by UCC (Paul Hastings).

1.80 375.00 675.00

09/14/17

FDC

Read Opinion and Order Denying Motion of Ad Hoc Group of PREPA Bondholders, Et Al., for Relief from the Automatic Stay (Docket Entry No. 74). Case:17-04780-LTS Doc#:299 Filed:09/14/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/14/17 FDC Read Order Granting the Scheduling Aspect of the Urgent Motion of 0.10 250.00 25.00 the United States Trustee Pursuant to PROMESA Sections 316 and 317 and Bankruptcy Code Section 105(A) for Entry of an Order Appointing a Fee Examiner and Related Relief to be Heard at the October 4, 2017 Hearing.

09/14/17 FDC Read Order Granting Urgent Motion for Extension of Deadlines in 0.10 250.00 25.00 Connection with the Second Amended Notice, Case Management and Administrative Procedures. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1307 Filed:09/14/17.


of 44


09/14/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) regarding the Order Establishing Deadlines and

Procedures for Filing Proofs of Claim; draft of e-mail (.1) reply to legal team; read e-mail reply (.1) from C. Steege.

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/14/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) motion of International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW) Service Employees International Union and American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO to Intervene Under Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7024 filed in adversary proceeding 17-250 (Docket No. 10); draft of e-mail (.1) reply to legal team.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/14/17 HMK Reviewed draft of Motion to Intervene in the Commonwealth/COFINA adversary proceeding.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/15/17 AJB Reviewed all motions filed and orders issued as per the ECF system; 3.80 375.00 1,425.00 Received and examined answer of Cofina agent in adversary proceedings 0257; Creditor list of the ERS and notices realted thereto. Discussed with F. del Castillo draft of the ORC motion to intervene in UCC adversary proceeding 0257; Continued review of opinion and order (LTS) in adversary proceedings 3567 and 3283 denying Peaje's request for TRO and other unjunctive relief abd uderlying documents (complaint, reply, motions) as ruling may impact Cofina controversy; exchange of memoranda with C. Klein, H. Mayol, C. Steege, R. Levin, R. Gordon, C. Wedoff. Received and examined memorandum and order (LTS) granting FOMB's motion to strike in adversary proceedings 3567 and 3283. Conference with F. del Castillo to set set up a conference next Monday with Jenner team to discuss the "automatic perfection" issue. Received and examined standing orders issued today by judge LTS.

09/15/17 FDC Read Notice of Filing of Creditor List for the Employees Retirement 0.20 250.00 50.00 System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico / Global Notes and Statement of Limitations, Methods, and Disclaimers Regarding the Creditor List for the Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1316-1 Filed:09/15/17.



Page 20 of 44

09/15/17 FDC Read Answer, Defenses, and Counterclaims of the Appointed Agent

of the Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corporation (COFINA). Case:17-00257-LTS Doc#:27 Filed:09/15/17.

0.60 250.00 150.00

09/16/17 HMK Read UAW et al Motion for Joinder - Docket 1326 0.10 375.00 37.50

09/17/17 FDC Read draft of Notice of Intervention by the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/18/17 AJB Read memorandum of C. Ramírez to C. Klein on "automatic 1.80 375.00 675.00 perfection" issue; read F. del Castillo memorandum on the "ERS resolution as a statute" issue; Participated in conference with H. Mayol, F. del Castillo and Jenner team on result of Jenner's and BGM's respective researches. Received and examined court order from the USDC-PR on closing of court until September 21.

09/18/17 FDC Read Joinder of International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace 0.10 250.00 25.00 and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW), Service Employees International Union, and American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO to AFSCME’s Reply to Opposition to Motion of Interamericas Turnkey, Inc. to Review and Stay [Dkt. Entry No. 1326]. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1330 Filed:09/18/17.

09/18/17 FDC Read AFSCME’s Reply to Opposition to Motion of Interamericas Turnkey, Inc. to Review and Stay.

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/18/17 FDC Read Opposition of Financial Oversight and Management Board to 0.20 250.00 50.00 Nonparties International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW), Service Employees International Union and American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO Motion to Intervene Under Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7024. Case:17-00250-LTS Doc#:14 Filed:09/18/17.

09/18/17 FDC Read Order Confirming Adjournment of Hearing and Regarding 0.10 250.00 25.00 Procedures for Attendance, Participation and Observation of September 27, 2017 Hearing. By Judge Swain. Case:17-00125-LTS Doc#:78 Filed:09/18/17.



Page 21 of 44

09/18/17 FDC Read Order Granting Motion for Enlargement of Time to Respond

to Financial Oversight Board Reply to Motion to Review and Stay Debtor’s Representative to Deprive the Commonwealth of Internal Revenue (Refiled as Permitted). Case:17-03567-LTS Doc#:287 Filed:09/18/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/18/17

FDC

Read Order Regarding Notice from The Clerk No. 17-11. Case:17- 03283-LTS Doc#:1325 Filed:09/18/17

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/18/17

FDC

Read the Puerto Rico Fiscal Agency and Financial Advisory Authority’s Reply in Response to the Oversight Board’s Opposition to Motion of Interamericas Turnkey, Inc. to Review and Stay. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1327 Filed:09/18/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/18/17

FDC

Read Urgent Motion to Extend Deadlines in Joint Stipulation. Case:17-00213-LTS Doc#:62 Filed:09/18/17.

0.30

250.00 75.00

09/18/17

HMK

Read Opposition of Financial Oversight and Management Board to Nonparties International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW), Service Employees International Union and American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO Motion to Intervene Under Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7024. Case:17-00250-LTS Doc#:14 Filed:09/18/17.

0.20

375.00 75.00

09/18/17

HMK

Conference call - AJB, FDC, HM with Jenner Team on Liens and

1.00

375.00 375.00

Preferences in GO/ COFINA controversy.



Page 22 of 44

09/19/17 AJB Received from C. Steege draft of the ORC objection to UCC's motion 3.80 375.00 1,425.00 for order authorizing discovery. Note to F. del Castillo. Received and examined FOMB's informative motion, FGIC motion to join Ad hoc group of GO's request for discovery, objection of BNY-Mellon to Cofina's motions in 17-3283, objection of debtors to Cofina's agent's motion in 17-3283, Cofina's objection to Cofina agent's motion, opposition of Assured Guaranty, et als to UCC motion to intervene in 0232,opposition of National Public Finance/Guaranty Corp. et als to UCC's motion in 0156, FOMB's opposition to our request to intervene in 0219. Received and examined draft of ORC's objection to UCC's motion for order authorizing discovery. Received and examined debtors' Omnibus objection to motions regarding discovery, order (LTS) regarding October 4 Omnibus hearing, plaintiff's memorandum in opposition to ORC motion to intervene in 0189, Plaintiff's memorandum in opposition to UCC's motion to intervene in 0189, ERS "secured" creditors joinder to discovery motions, Plaintiff's objection to ORC motion to intervene in 0219. Received and examined urgent informative motion regarding Hurricaine María and request for adjournment, etc.

09/19/17 FDC Read Informative Motion of the Financial Oversight and Management Board Regarding September 27, 2017 Hearing. Case:17-00125-LTS Doc#:80 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/19/17

FDC

Read Joinder of Financial Guaranty Insurance Company to Joint Motion by the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders, Assured Guaranty Corp., Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., and the Mutual Fund Group for Order Authorizing Rule 2004 Examination. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1335 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/19/17 FDC Read Joint Stipulation and [Proposed] Order Addressing Motion of 0.10 250.00 25.00 Scotiabank de Puerto Rico, as Administrative Agent, and Funds Advised by Solus Alternative Asset Management LP for Leave to Intervene. Case:17-00232-LTS Doc#:34 Filed:09/19/17.



Page 23 of 44

09/19/17 FDC Read Limited Objection of The Bank of New York Mellon, as Trustee, 0.20 250.00 50.00 to the COFINA Agent’s Motion Pursuant to 48 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 105(A) for Order: (I) Confirming That 48 U.S.C. § 2125 Applies to COFINA Agent; (II) Confirming Retention of Local Counsel; and (III) Clarifying Payment of Fees and Expenses of COFINA Agent and Her Professionals. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1336 Filed:09/19/17.

09/19/17 FDC Read Limited Response of Official Committee of Unsecured 0.10 250.00 25.00 Creditors to Motion of Scotiabank de Puerto Rico, as Administrative Agent, and Fund Advised by Solus Alternative Asset Management LP for Leave to Intervene. Case:17-00232-LTS Doc#:33 Filed:09/19/17.

09/19/17 FDC Objection of Debtors to COFINA Agent’s Motion Pursuant to 48 0.10 250.00 25.00 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 105(A) for Order: (I) Confirming That 48 U.S.C. § 2125 Applies to COFINA Agent; (II) Confirming Retention of Local Counsel; and (III) Clarifying Payment of Fees and Expenses of COFINA Agent and Her Professionals. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1348 Filed:09/19/17.

09/19/17 FDC Read Objection of COFINA to Application of COFINA Agent for Entry 0.10 250.00 25.00 of Order Authorizing Retention of Centerview Partners LLC as Financial Advisor and Expert. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1347 Filed:09/19/17.

09/19/17 FDC Read Opposition of Assured Guaranty Corp., Assured Guaranty 0.30 250.00 75.00 Municipal Corp., the Ad Hoc Group of PREPA Bondholders, National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation, and Syncora Guarantee Inc. to the Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to Intervene. Case:17-00232-LTS Doc#:36 Filed:09/19/17

09/19/17 FDC Read Opposition of National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation, 0.30 250.00 75.00 Financial Guaranty Insurance Company, Assured Guaranty Corp., and Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. to the Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene. Case:17-00156-LTS Doc#:71 Filed:09/19/17.



Page 24 of 44

09/19/17 FDC Read Opposition of the Oversight Board as Representative of the 0.20 250.00 50.00 Commonwealth and the Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico to Motion of Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for Leave to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00219-LTS Doc#:17 Filed:09/19/17.

09/19/17 FDC Read Ambac Assurance Corporation’s Objection to Motion of the 0.30 250.00 75.00 Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard Under Bankruptcy Code 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00159-LTS Doc#:76 Filed:09/19/17.

09/19/17 FDC Read Debtors’ Omnibus Objection to Motions for Orders 0.70 250.00 175.00 Authorizing Rule 2004 Discovery / Declaration of Timothy W. Mungovan in Support of Debtors’ Omnibus Objection to Motions for Orders Authorizing Rule 2004 Discovery. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1345 Filed:09/19/17.

09/19/17 FDC Read draft of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the 0.20 250.00 50.00 Commonwealth of Puerto Rico’s Objection to Informative Motion and Statement Regarding Status Reports Filed in Connection with the Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, Authorizing Discovery Program with Respect to Certain Causes of the Puerto Rico Financial Crisis.

09/19/17 FDC Read Order Withdrawing this Court’s Prior Order (Docket Entry No. 0.10 250.00 25.00 1325) and Requiring the Oversight Board to Confer with the Other Parties in Interest and Propose a Revised Schedule in Connection with October Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1341 Filed:09/19/17

09/19/17 FDC Read Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Official 0.20 250.00 50.00 Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for Leave to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17- 00189-LTS Doc#:48 Filed:09/19/17



Page 25 of 44

09/19/17 FDC Read Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Official 0.20 250.00 50.00 Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00189-LTS Doc#:49 Filed:09/19/17

09/19/17 FDC Read Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00189-LTS Doc#:49 Filed:09/19/17.

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/19/17

FDC

Read ERS Secured Creditors Joinder to Rule 2004 Motions. Case:17- 03283-LTS Doc#:1340 Filed:09/19/17

0.10

250.00

25.00

09/19/17

FDC

Read Plaintiffs’ Objection to Retiree Committee’s Motion to Intervene. Case:17-00219-LTS Doc#:16 Filed:09/19/17

0.40

250.00 100.00

09/19/17

FDC

Read Response of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to (I) Motion of National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation for Entry of Order Pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2004 Authorizing Discovery; (II) Joint Motion by Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders, Assured Guaranty Corp. Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., and Mutual Fund Group for Order Authorizing Rule 2004 Examination; and (III) Ambac Assurance Corporation’s Motion for Entry of Order Authorizing Discovery Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1344 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/19/17

FDC

Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to Be Heard and/or Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00155- LTS Doc#:70 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10

250.00

25.00

09/19/17

FDC

Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to be Heard and/or Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00159- LTS Doc#:77 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00



Page 26 of 44

09/19/17 FDC Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’

Motion for Leave to be Heard and/or Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00189- LTS Doc#:50 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/19/17 FDC Read Urgent Informative Motion Regarding Hurricane Maria and

Request for Adjournment of Certain Upcoming Deadlines. Case:17- 03283-LTS Doc#:1332 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/19/17 HMK Guaranty Municipal Corp., and Mutual Fund Group for Order

Authorizing Rule 2004 Examination; and (III) Ambac Assurance Corporation’s Motion for Entry of Order Authorizing Discovery Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1344 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Objection of Debtors to COFINA Agent’s Motion Pursuant to 48 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 105(A) for Order: (I) Confirming That 48 U.S.C. § 2125 Applies to COFINA Agent; (II) Confirming Retention of Local Counsel; and (III) Clarifying Payment of Fees and Expenses of COFINA Agent and Her Professionals. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1348 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Ambac Assurance Corporation’s Objection to Motion of the

Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard Under Bankruptcy Code 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00159-LTS Doc#:76 Filed:09/19/17.

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Debtors’ Omnibus Objection to Motions for Orders

Authorizing Rule 2004 Discovery / Declaration of Timothy W. Mungovan in Support of Debtors’ Omnibus Objection to Motions for Orders Authorizing Rule 2004 Discovery. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1345 Filed:09/19/17.

0.50 375.00 187.50

09/19/17 HMK Read draft of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico’s Objection to Informative Motion and Statement Regarding Status Reports Filed in Connection with the Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Order, Under Bankruptcy Rule 2004, Authorizing Discovery Program with Respect to Certain causes of PR Financial crisis.

0.20 375.00 75.00



Page 27 of 44

09/19/17 HMK Read ERS Secured Creditors Joinder to Rule 2004 Motions. Case:17-

03283-LTS Doc#:1340 Filed:09/19/17. 0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Informative Motion of the Financial Oversight and Management Board Regarding September 27, 2017 Hearing. Case:17-00125-LTS Doc#:80 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Joinder of Financial Guaranty Insurance Company to Joint

Motion by the Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders, Assured Guaranty Corp., Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., and the Mutual Fund Group for Order Authorizing Rule 2004 Examination. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1335 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Limited Objection of The Bank of New York Mellon, as Trustee, to the COFINA Agent’s Motion Pursuant to 48 U.S.C. § 2161 and 11 U.S.C. § 105(A) for Order: (I) Confirming That 48 U.S.C. § 2125 Applies to COFINA Agent; (II) Confirming Retention of Local Counsel; and (III) Clarifying Payment of Fees and Expenses of COFINA Agent and Her Professionals. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1336 Filed:09/19/17.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/19/17 HMK Read Limited Response of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to Motion of Scotiabank de Puerto Rico, as Administrative Agent, and Fund Advised by Solus Alternative.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Objection of COFINA to Application of COFINA Agent for Entry of Order Authorizing Retention of Centerview Partners LLC as Financial Advisor and Expert. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1347 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Opposition of Assured Guaranty Corp., Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp., the Ad Hoc Group of PREPA Bondholders, National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation, and Syncora Guarantee Inc. to the Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to Intervene. Case:17-00232-LTS Doc#:36 Filed:09/19/17.

0.30 375.00 112.50



Page 28 of 44

09/19/17 HMK Read Opposition of National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation,

Financial Guaranty Insurance Company, Assured Guaranty Corp., and Assured Guaranty Municipal Corp. to the Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene. Case:17-00156-LTS Doc#:71 Filed:09/19/17.

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Opposition of the Oversight Board as Representative of the Commonwealth and the Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico to Motion of Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for Leave to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00219-LTS Doc#:17 Filed:09/19/17.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/19/17 HMK Read Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico for Leave to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17- 00189-LTS Doc#:48 Filed:09/19/17.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/19/17 HMK Read Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00189-LTS Doc#:49 Filed:09/19/17.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/19/17 HMK Read Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors for Leave to be Heard and/or to Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00189-LTS Doc#:49 Filed:09/19/17.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/19/17 HMK Read Plaintiffs’ Objection to Retiree Committee’s Motion to Intervene. Case:17-00219-LTS Doc#:16 Filed:09/19/17.

0.40 375.00 150.00



Page 29 of 44

09/19/17 HMK Read Response of Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors to (I)

Motion of National Public Finance Guarantee Corporation for Entry of Order Pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 2004 Authorizing Discovery; (II) Joint Motion by Ad Hoc Group of General Obligation Bondholders, Assured Guaranty Corp. Assured.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to Be Heard and/or Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00155- LTS Doc#:70 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to be Heard and/or Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00156- LTS Doc#:72 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’


0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’ Motion for Leave to be Heard and/or Intervene Under Bankruptcy Code Section 1109(B) and/or Bankruptcy Rule 7024. Case:17-00189- LTS Doc#:50 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/19/17 HMK Read Urgent Informative Motion Regarding Hurricane Maria and Request for Adjournment of Certain Upcoming Deadlines. Case:17- 03283-LTS Doc#:1332 Filed:09/19/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/22/17 AJB Received and examined memorandum from R. Gordon on need to re-schedule case calendar in light of devastation caused by Hurricaine María. Also received memoranda from M. Root on judge Houser's proposal for a 60 day adjournment, W. Stuart (Segal), S. Gumbs (FTI Consulting).

0.60 375.00 225.00



Page 30 of 44

09/22/17 FDC Read Joint Informative Motion of All Parties Regarding Objection 0.10 250.00 25.00 Deadline for Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss Complaint Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(B)(1) And 12(B)(6). Case:17-00189-LTS Doc#:52 Filed:09/22/17.

09/22/17 FDC Read Order Requiring the Oversight Board to Confer with Plaintiffs

Regarding September 27, 2017 Hearing. Case:17-00125-LTS Doc#:83 Filed:09/22/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/22/17 FDC Read e-mail from R. Gordon regarding Puerto Rico Proceedings. 0.10 250.00 25.00

09/22/17 FDC Read First Supplemental Declaration of Luc A. Despins Regarding Retention of Paul Hastings LLP as Counsel to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1357 Filed:09/22/17.

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/22/17 FDC Read Sentence of the First Circuit of Appeals Case: 17-1831, Date Filed: 09/22/2017.

0.30 250.00 75.00

09/22/17 HMK Read C Steege draft response to Rule 2004 discovery motion and redact comments.

0.40 375.00 150.00

09/22/17 HMK Read Docket 1344 - Assured et al motion for Discovery under rule 2004.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/22/17 HMK Read Docket 1345 - Debtor's objection to Assured et al motion for discovery.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/22/17 HMK Read FOMB, Debtors'opposition to Committee motion to intervene in litigation. - Case 17-00219 Docket 17.

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/24/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding the October 4, Omnibus hearing; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read 3rd e- mail reply (.1) C. Steege; read 3rd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin.

0.80 250.00 200.00



Page 31 of 44

09/25/17 AJB Received and examined order (LTS) instructing FOMB to confer with

plaintiffs on September 27 hearing, Joint informative motion on deadlines, Urgent motion on Hurricane María, Supplemental declaration of Luc A. Despins on retention of Paul Hastings. Exchange of correspondence with Jenner team on need to re- structure case calendar. Received FOMB's informative motion regarding upcoming hearings. Received and examined draft of ORC's motion regarding the adjournment of October 4 hearing.

0.80 375.00 300.00

09/25/17

FDC

Read Notice Regarding Impending Hearings in the Above-Captioned

0.10

250.00 25.00

Cases and Related Adversary Proceedings. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1361 Filed:09/25/17.

09/25/17

FDC

Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding AAFAF’s urgent motion; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read 2nd email (.1) by C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail (.1) by R. Levin.

0.40

250.00 100.00

09/25/17

FDC

Read Order Directing the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors

0.10

250.00 25.00

to File a Supplemental Brief. Case:17-00125-LTS Doc#:86 Filed:09/25/17.

09/25/17

FDC

Informative Motion of Financial Oversight and Management Board

0.30

250.00 75.00

Regarding (A) October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing and (B) September 27, 2017 Hearing on Motion to Dismiss. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1362 Filed:09/26/17.

09/25/17

FDC

Read Response to Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors’

0.10

250.00 25.00


09/25/17

FDC

Read Urgent Informative Motion Regarding the Impact of Hurricane

0.10

250.00 25.00 Maria and Proceeding within these Title III Cases. Case:17-03283- LTS Doc#:1360 Filed:09/25/17

09/25/17

HMK

Informative Motion of Financial Oversight and Management Board

0.30

375.00 112.50

Regarding (A) October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing and (B) September 27, 2017 Hearing on Motion to Dismiss. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1362 Filed:09/26/17.



Page 32 of 44

09/25/17 HMK Read Informative Motion of the Official Committee of Retired

Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Regarding the Proposed Adjournment of The October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1364 Filed:09/26/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/26/17 FDC Read Informative Motion of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Regarding the Proposed Adjournment of The October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1364 Filed:09/26/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/26/17

AJB

Received and examined USCA 1st opinion and order reversing LTS on UCC's requests to intervene in all adversary proceedings, order (LTS) on upcoming hearings.

0.50

375.00 187.50

09/26/17

FDC

Read Order Regarding September 27, 2017 Oral Argument and October Omnibus Hearing. Judge Swain. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1365 Filed:09/26/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/26/17

FDC

Read Informative Motion of Financial Oversight and Management Board Regarding (A) October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing and (B) September 27, 2017 Hearing on Motion to Dismiss. Case:17-03283- LTS Doc#:1362 Filed:09/26/17.

0.30

250.00 75.00

09/26/17

HMK

Read Informative Motion of Financial Oversight and Management

0.30

375.00 112.50

Board Regarding (A) October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing and (B) September 27, 2017 Hearing on Motion to Dismiss. Case:17-03283- LTS Doc#:1362 Filed:09/26/17.

09/26/17 HMK Read Informative Motion of the Official Committee of Retired Employees of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Regarding the Proposed Adjournment of the October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1364 Filed:09/26/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/26/17 HMK Read Opinion and Judgement of First District, Federal Appeals Court reversing Judge Swain on rights of UCC to intervene in all aspects of Adversary Proceedings under Title III.

0.40 375.00 150.00

09/26/17 HMK Read Order Regarding September 27, 2017 Oral Argument and October Omnibus Hearing. Judge Swain. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1365 Filed:09/26/17.

0.10 375.00 37.50



Page 33 of 44

09/27/17 AJB Received and examined opinion and order (LTS) denying UCC's

request to intervene in 0133, order directing supplemental briefing (Judge Dein) informative motion of FOMB.

0.40 375.00 150.00

09/27/17 FDC Read Informative Motion of the Financial Oversight and Management Board Regarding September 27, 2017 Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1368 Filed:09/27/17

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/27/17 FDC Read Opinion and Order Denying Motion of the Committee of Unsecured Creditors, as Agent for the Commonwealth, to Intervene. Case:17-00133-LTS Doc#:416 Filed:09/27/17.

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/27/17 FDC Read Order Directing Supplemental Briefing. Judge Dein. Case:17- 00155-LTS Doc#:72 Filed:09/27/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/27/17 FDC Read Order Directing Supplemental Briefing. Judge Dein. Case:17- 00156-LTS Doc#:74 Filed:09/27/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/27/17 FDC Read Order Directing Supplemental Briefing. Judge Dein. Case:17-

00189-LTS Doc#:54 Filed:09/27/17. 0.10 250.00 25.00

09/28/17

FDC

Read Informative Motion of the ERS Secured Bondholders with Respect to the Court’s Order Regarding September 27, 2017 Oral Argument and October Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1378 Filed:09/28/17

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/28/17 FDC Read Informative Motion Regarding Intent to Appear at October 4, 2017 Hearing. Case:17-00125-LTS Doc#:92 Filed:09/28/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/28/17

FDC

Read (3) Informative Motion of American Federation of State, County & Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO Regarding the Proposed Adjournment of the October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17- 00250-LTS Doc#:22 Filed:09/28/17/ Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1374 Filed:09/28/17/ Case:17-00242-LTS Doc#:29 Filed:09/28/17.

0.30

250.00 75.00

09/28/17

FDC

Read ERS’s Opposition to Defendants’ Urgent Motion to Extend Deadlines in Joint Stipulation. Case:17-00213-LTS Doc#:65 Filed:09/28/17.

0.20

250.00 50.00



Page 34 of 44

09/28/17 FDC Read Informative Motion of Cofina Agent Regarding Matters

Scheduled to be Heard at October Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283- LTS Doc#:1372 Filed:09/28/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/28/17 09/29/17

FDC

FDC

Read Informative Motion of International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW), Service Employees International Union and American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO Regarding the Adjournment of the October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17- 03283-LTS Doc#:1371 Filed:09/28/17. Read Motion on Consent to Adjourn Pietrantoni Mendez & Alvarez

0.10

0.10

250.00

250.00

25.00

25.00 LLC’s Motion to Quash Subpoena [Docket No. 28]. Case:17-00257-

LTS Doc#:51 Filed:09/29/17.

09/29/17

FDC

Read Official Committee’s Supplemental Briefing in Support of Limited Participation. Case:17-00125-LTS Doc#:93 Filed:09/29/17.

0.20

250.00 50.00

09/29/17

FDC

Read Debtors’ Objection to the ERS Bondholders’ Motion for Proposed Joinder to Rule 2004 Motions. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1380 Filed:09/29/17.

0.20

250.00 50.00

09/29/17

FDC

Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding 17-03283-LTS (Generic) Order; read e-mail reply (.1) by A. J. Bennazar.

0.20

250.00 50.00

09/29/17 FDC Read Order Regarding Matters Originally Noticed for October 4, 2017 Omnibus Hearing. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1381 Filed:09/29/17.

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/29/17

FDC

Read Order Regarding the Urgent Informative Motion of Defendant Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico Regarding Deadlines Related to the Adversary Complaint. Case:17- 03283-LTS Doc#:1383 Filed:09/29/17.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/29/17

HMK

Read AFSCME motion on Case 17-13283 and 17-242, Adversary

0.20

375.00 75.00Proceeding on employee furloughs and pension cuts.

SUB TOTAL 59.90 19,500.00

ERS BOND ISSUES (MATTER NUMBER 10091)



Page 35 of 44

09/11/17 AJB Exchange of memoranda and correspondence with C. Steege. R.

Levin, C. Klein (Jenner) on perfection of liens questions regarding Pension obligation bonds (POB's) pursuant to P.R. law. Follow up with C. Ramírez in local law research. Further discussion of threshold findings with H. Mayol, F. del Castillo and C. Ramírez.

2.10 375.00 787.50

09/11/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege and attached memorandum from C. Klein (.2) regarding automatic perfection issue of POBs; rear e-mail reply (.1) from H. Mayol; legal research (2) and draft of e-mail (.5) regarding automatic perfection of POB’s; read 2nd email (.1) from C. Steege; read 3rd e-mail (.1) from C. Steege; read e-mail reply (.2) from C. Klein with additional questions; read e-mail reply (.1) and attachment (.3) from R. Gordon.

3.70 250.00 925.00

09/11/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege and attached memorandum from C. Klein (.2) regarding automatic perfection issue of POBs; read 2nd email (.1) from C. Steege; read 3rd e-mail (.1) from C. Steege; read e- mail reply (.2) from C. Klein with additional questions; read e-mail reply (.1) and attachment (.3) from R. Gordon.

1.10 375.00 412.50

09/11/17 HMK Discussed with AJB and FDC an answer to R Levin's question on ERS bondholders'claims to pension fund assets transferred to PR Treasury Department.

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/11/17 HMK Read email from R Levin requesting research on Puerto Rico Enforcement of Judgements laws and cases, forwarded to F del Castillo and A Bennazar.

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/12/17 AJB Continued exchange of memoranda and notes with C. Steege. R. Levin, R. Gordon, H. Mayol and F. del Castillo on issue of direct payment of pensions by the Commonwealth government vis-à-vis employer contributions that have been eliminated. Further researchon lien perfection issues.

2.40 375.00 900.00



Page 36 of 44

09/12/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from C. Klein regarding Automatic Perfection; read

e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by C. Klein; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Wedoff and several attachments (.7); read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) and attachment (.3) by R. Levin.

1.60 250.00 400.00

09/12/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) from C. Klein regarding Automatic Perfection; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by C. Klein; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Wedoff and several attachments (.7); read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) and attachment (.3) by R. Levin.

1.60 375.00 600.00

09/13/17 AJB Continued research and discussion of "automatic perfection" issues. Meeting with F. del Castillo and C. Ramírez to discuss same. Exchange of memoranda with C. Steege and C. Klein re: same.

3.00 375.00 1,125.00

09/13/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) by Y. Bennazar regarding perfection issues of ERS 2.10 250.00 525.00 Bondholders; meeting (.5) with Y. Bennazar and C. Ramírez regarding perfection issues of ERS Bondholders; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; additional legal research (1.2) and draft of e-mail (.2) reply to C. Klein regarding automatic perfection issue of POBs.

09/13/17 FDC Telephone call (.2) to the Office of Legislative Services of Puerto 0.80 250.00 200.00 Rico to obtain an official translation to English of Act 447 of 1951; draft of e-mail (.2) to J. Ortega of the Office of Legislative Services; read e-mail reply (.1) and attachments (.3) from J. Ortega of the Office of Legislative Services.

09/14/17 AJB Further exchange of correspondence and memoranda with C. Klein

and H. Mayol on the "automatic perfection" issue. 0.50 375.00 187.50

09/14/17 FDC Draft of e-mail to C. Klein and legal team with attachment of official translation to English of 3 LPRA sec. 799.

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/14/17 HMK Read and review C Klein memo on perfection fo lien by ERS

Bondholders lien. 0.20 375.00 75.00



Page 37 of 44

09/15/17 AJB Reviewed and discussed with F. del Castillo the memorandum of C. 2.40 375.00 900.00 Klein on the ERS bond controversy with POB bondholders; discussed with C. Ramírez; Meeting with F. del Castillo and C. Ramírez on further research under P.R. law needed. Further exchange of notes and memoranda with Jenner team.

09/15/17 FDC Read e-mail and attachments (.4) from C. Klein regarding automatic 1.30 250.00 325.00 perfection issue; meeting with C. Ramírez and A. J. Bennazar (.2) regarding the legal analysis requested by C. Klein; read e-mail reply

(.1) from C. Ramirez; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) from C. Klein; read e- mail (.1) from R. Levin; read 3rd e-mail and attachments (.3) from C.

Klein; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

09/15/17 FDC Read e-mail and attachment by M. Root regarding UCC filing issues. 0.30 250.00 75.00

09/15/17 FDC Legal research regarding the effect of bond resolutions of POBs. 0.90 250.00 225.00

09/15/17 HMK Read Notice of Filing of Creditor List for the Employees Retirement 0.20 375.00 75.00 System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico / Global Notes and Statement of Limitations, Methods, and Disclaimers Regarding the Creditor List for the Employees Retirement System of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1316-1 Filed:09/15/17.

09/16/17 HMK Review memo from C Klein: Analysis of Sufficiency of UCC financing statement filed by ERS Bondholders.

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/16/17 HMK Discussed memo from F del Castillo on ERS Bond Resolution as a

Statute. 0.30 375.00 112.50

09/18/17 AJB Conference with H. Mayol, F. del Castillo and C. Ramírez on the

"automatic perfection" issue. 0.60 375.00 225.00

09/18/17 FDC Cont. Legal research regarding the effect of bond resolutions of

POBs. 2.50 250.00 625.00



Page 38 of 44

09/18/17 FDC Conference call with C. Klein, R. Gordon, M. Root, C. Steege, R.

Levin, H. Mayol, C. Ramirez and Y. Bennazar regarding ERS bonds perfection issues. Left before conference call ended.

0.70 250.00 175.00

09/18/17

FDC

Draft of e-mail - memorandum (.8) to C. Klein regarding the

1.00

250.00 250.00 automatic perfection issue and Act 447 / local regulations and jurisprudence; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Klein; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin.

09/18/17

FDC

Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding ERS Schedule; read e-mail (.1) by R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail (.1) by C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail (.1)

0.30

250.00 75.00

by R. Levin. 09/18/17

HMK

Meeting with AJB, FDC reviewing ERS Pension Obligation Bonds

1.00

375.00 375.00

documents to research clawback and constitutional provisions issues.

SUB TOTAL 31.40 9,850.00

NON WORKING TRAVEL TIME (MATTER NUMBER 10105)

09/01/17 FDC Flight to from New York to Puerto Rico after .

Fight from midnight, arriving 3:36 am; at 4:30 am in residence (billed half).

4.50 250.00 1,125.00

09/01/17 HMK Travel from NYC to San Juan, returning from NYC 50% of Rate

6.00 375.00 1,125.00

09/11/17

HMK Travel from San Juan to DC to attend 4.00

375.00 750.00

09/15/17

HMK Return from DC to San Juan 4.00

375.00 750.00

SUB TOTAL 18.50 3,750.00 COURT HEARINGS (MATTER NUMBER 10121)

09/25/17 HMK Read email from P Possinger on rescheduling of Omnibus Hearing and deadlines for motions.

0.10 375.00 37.50



Page 39 of 44

SUB TOTAL 0.10 37.50

MEDIATION (MATTER NUMBER 10148)

09/01/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) by S. Wohl ; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail (.1) by S. Wohl; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

0.40 250.00 100.00

09/01/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) by S. Wohl ;

read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read 2nd e-mail (.1) by s. Wohl; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

0.40 375.00 150.00

09/04/17 AJB Received and examined memoranda from 0.50 375.00 187.50

09/04/17 FDC Read e-mail and attached

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/04/17

FDC

Read e-mail and attached

.

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/04/17 FDC Read e-mail from R. Gordon regarding

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/05/17

AJB

Exchange of correspondence with R. Gordon to coordinate

1.20

375.00 450.00

09/06/17

AJB

Further undetarkings to attend and participate

0.70

375.00 262.50



Page 40 of 44

09/06/17 FDC Read e-mail and attached

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/11/17 AJB Exchange of correspondence with the Jenner team, F. del Castillo 2.20 375.00 825.00 and H. Mayol, and then with Sgt. J. Marín and other members of the ORC on

09/11/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) 0.50 250.00 125.00 ; read e-mail reply (.1)

from M. Root; rear 2nd e-mail (.1) from R. Levin; telephone call (.2)

with J. Marin, President of Official Retirement Committee to obtain information from members.

09/11/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from J. Marin to Committee Members regarding ; read 2nd e-mail (.1)

0.70 250.00 175.00

from J. Marin; read e-mail reply (.1) by M. Fabre, Member; read e- mail reply (.1) M. Acevedo, Member; read e-mail (.1) reply R. Pacheco, Member; read WhatsApp reply (.1) from C. Núñez, Member; read WhatsApp reply (.1) from B. Paniagua, Member.

09/11/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) from J. Marin to Committee Members regarding ; read 2nd e-mail (.1)

from J. Marin; read e-mail reply (.1) by M. Fabre, Member; read e- mail reply (.1) M. Acevedo, Member; read e-mail (.1) reply R. Pacheco, Member; read WhatsApp reply (.1) from C. Núñez, Member; read WhatsApp reply (.1) from B. Paniagua, Member.

0.70 375.00 262.50



Page 41 of 44

09/12/17 AJB Received and . 1.20 375.00 450.00 Continued exchange of correspondence with Jenner team on attendance by BGM team members to

09/12/17 FDC Telephone call (.2) with J. Marin, President of Official Retirement 0.60 250.00 150.00 Committee, regarding (.2) to legal team regarding the answers of the members of the Committee; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

09/12/17 FDC Read e-mail from

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/12/17 HMK Read e-mail from

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/12/17 HMK Participate

8.00 375.00 3,000.00

09/13/17 AJB Received and examined

. 0.40 375.00 150.00

09/13/17 FDC Conference call with H. Mayol and B. Gordon regarding the

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/13/17

FDC

Read e-mail from

0.30

250.00 75.00

09/13/17

HMK

Participate .

5.50

375.00 2,062.50



Page 42 of 44

09/13/17 HMK Conference call with F. del Castillo and B. Gordon regarding the

0.20 375.00 75.00

09/13/17 HMK Read e-mail from

0.30 375.00 112.50

09/14/17 AJB Received note from R. Levin 2.20 375.00 825.00

09/14/17 FDC Conference call with H. Mayol y A. J. Bennazar regarding

.

0.40 250.00 100.00

09/14/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from R. Levin regarding ; draft of e-mail reply (.1) to R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail (.1) from R. Levin .

0.30 250.00 75.00

09/14/17 FDC Read email and review of .

0.30 250.00 75.00

09/14/17 HMK Participate 1.50 375.00 562.50

09/14/17 HMK Conference call with F. del Castillo y Y. Bennazar regarding

.

0.40 375.00 150.00

09/14/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) from R. Levin regarding ; draft of e-mail reply (.1) to R. Levin; read 2nd e-mail (.1) from R. Levin .

0.30 375.00 112.50



Page 43 of 44

09/14/17 HMK Read email and review of attachment

. 0.30 375.00 112.50

09/15/17 AJB Received and examined

0.40 375.00 150.00

09/15/17 FDC Read e-mail

0.20 250.00 50.00

09/15/17 HMK Conference Call with Jenner & Block, FTI Consultants & Segal

regarding

1.00 375.00 375.00

09/18/17 AJB Received and examined 0.30 375.00 112.50

09/18/17 FDC Read and review

0.10 250.00 25.00

09/19/17 FDC Read and review 0.10 250.00 25.00

09/19/17

HMK

Read and review

0.10

375.00 37.50

09/22/17

FDC

Read .

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/22/17

FDC

Read e-mail (.1) from R. Levin to J. Houser regarding

0.60

250.00 150.00

; read e-mail reply (.1) by S. Wohl;read e-mail reply (.1) by M. Root; read 2nd e-mail (.1) by R. Levin;

read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon; read e-mail reply (.1) by K. Nicholl.

09/22/17

FDC

Read e-mail from M. Root

0.10

250.00 25.00 .

09/23/17

FDC

Read .

0.10

250.00 25.00



Page 44 of 44

09/24/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) from R. Levin regarding '

(.1) by R. Gordon; read e-mail reply (.1) 0.50 250.00 125.00

by S. Simms; read e-mail reply (.1) by K. Nicholl; read 2nd e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

09/25/17

AJB

Received

0.50

375.00 187.50

09/25/17 FDC Read . 0.10 250.00 25.00

09/25/17 HMK Read 0.20 375.00 75.00

09/25/17 HMK Read

0.10 375.00 37.50

09/29/17 AJB Received and examined 0.30 375.00 112.50

09/29/17

FDC

Read .

0.10

250.00 25.00

09/29/17 FDC Read e-mail (.1) 0.40 250.00 100.00

by R. Levin; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

09/29/17 HMK Read e-mail (.1) from C. Steege regarding

; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Levin; read e-mail reply (.1) by C. Steege; read e-mail reply (.1) by R. Gordon.

0.40 375.00 150.00

SUB TOTAL 36.00 12,675.00

FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED 180.3 $56,850.00

[Any expenses during the period covered in this invoice, if any, shall be included in our next statement.]


EXHIBIT D

SUMMARY OF BENNAZAR, GARCIA & MILIAN, C.S.P. EXPENSES

Expense Description AmountTravel

Airfare $1,681.65Hotel $2,361.41Meals $24.34Ground Transportation $662.09Combined Flight and Hotel Charge $1,503.68

Meals for Committee Meetings $122.27Office Supplies $43.89U.C.C. Search $104.00Photocopy Expense $1,448.91

TOTAL $7,952.24

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1806-4 Filed:11/15/17 Entered:11/15/17 21:06:01 Desc: Exhibit D - Summary of Expenses Page 1 of 1

EXHIBIT E

DETAILED EXPENSES OF BENNAZAR, GARCIA & MILIAN, C.S.P.

Case:17-03283-LTS Doc#:1806-5 Filed:11/15/17 Entered:11/15/17 21:06:01 Desc: Exhibit E - Detailed Expenses Page 1 of 34


AMOUNT

COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO 15-33571

6/20/2017 DOCUMENT REPRODUCTION (EXTERNAL SERVICES) 203.31

500.707/6/2017 TRAVEL EXPENSES: PLANE TICKETS

7/6/2017 TRAVEL EXPENSES: GROUND TRANSPORT 57.09

OTHER BILLABLE EXPENSES: SNACKS (FOR ORC MEETING) 27.37

7/7/2017 TRAVEL EXPENSES: GROUND TRANSPORT 27.25

64.807/8/2017 TRAVEL EXPENSES: GROUND TRANSPORT

49.75TRAVEL EXPENSES: AIRPORT PARKING FEE

665.90TRAVEL EXPENSES: HOTEL ACCOMMODATION

43.897/31/2017 OTHER BILLABLE EXPENSES: OFFICE SUPPLIES

OTHER BILLABLE EXPENSES: GROCERIES AND SNACKS (FOR ORC MEETING) 42.21

1,206.40DOCUMENT REPRODUCTION

[ 2,888.67 ]SUBTOTAL:

$2,888.67TOTAL COST

$102,926.17TOTAL AMOUNT THIS BILL


InvoiceNo. 50876Vazquez & Velazquez Enterprises, Inc.

41 6 Ponce de Leon Ave., Union Plaza Bldg Suite 3, Hato Rey, P.R. 00918 Tel. 751-1555 Fax 751-1572 Date 6/20/17SOLD TO

Maureen Quevedo Bennazar, Garcia & Milian, C.S.P. Penthouse A, Edit. Union Plaza Ave. Ponce De Leon #41 6,Hato Rey PR 00918

P.O. #

AMOUNT■ . . i • ■____________________________________ •• •'____________________ ' •

; DESCRIPTION :'QUANTITY :» ••**.Clr Copy "SEGAL'S PROPOSAL TO THE OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIREES", 8.5 x 11 White Bond

182.349

1/4" Comb Binding

182.3450% deposit required for jobs without approved credit.A $20.00 charge will be added for returned checks.No returns will be accepted after five days of receipt of merchandise

SUBTOTALStatu

SHIPPIN^UnlCiP£l

TOTAL

AMOUNT DUE

18.23TAX2.74

203.31203.31

Please pay from this invoice

Thank you for allowing us to serve you.

q Pick Up q Cash

q Delivery q Charge Amount Receivedq Check #

I/DateReceived by


7/5/2017 Your trip - View reservations on aa.com - American Airlines !Plan Travel I ravel information AAdvantage .. AAmerican Airlines

Your tripIssued: Monday, July 3,2017

Status: Ticketed

Record locator: XWGIXG

Trip name: SJU/JFK

%aSo E3

Same-day flight changeChange tripCheck in Chancre seats

Depart San Juan, to New York, NYThursday, July 6, 2017

Traveltime

Aircraft ClassFlight Arrive SeatsDepart

4h 738 Economy1357 American

Airlines ^

9:315:20 2BF

11mPM PMJFKSJU

On time Estimated Estimated

5:20 9:31PM PM

Terminal: 8 Gate: 37 Baggage: -

Terminal: C Gate: C3

f mate notification

Return New York, NY to San Juan,Saturday, July 8, 2017

https://www.aa. com/reservation/emailcheckin.do?firstName=HECTOR&lastName=MAYOL%20KAUFFMANN&recordLQcator=XWGIXO&cd=130815&g... 1/3


7/5/2017 Your trip-View reservations on aa.com - American Airlines

Traveitime

Arrive Aircraft ClassFlight SeatsDepart

12:25 4:23 3hv 1357 American

Airlines

738 Economy ^

PMPM 58mSJUJFK

Cost summary$411.00 Bag and optional fees tPPassenger x 1

Your total $56.20 Reservation and tickets FAQs P

Taxes

$0.00....... Price and Tax information

$467.20 P

Carrier-imposed fees

$50070 ... . ».

Subtotal

Includes all taxes and carrier- imposed fees $33.50Preferred Seats

AAdvantage® benefits

Priority $0.00

$0.00Same-day Standby

$500.70nofaS (all passengers)

Passengers

Hector Mayol Kauffmann 5295466 (AAdvantage)

Check in online

Add / edit osssenoer information

hUps://www.aa.com/reservation/emailcheckin.do?firstName=HECTOR&lastName=WIAYOL%2QKAUFFMANNl&recorclLocator=XWGIXO&cd-130815&g... 2/3


Do not expose to excessive heat or direct sunlightI STAPLE

I fit'o■0 : HEREfBR rey.zmi CPNitUHtPRINTED IN USA. BY MAGNETIC TICKET AND LABEL CORP., DALLAS. TX Jc *

.#3* i i *- *| IfSf Ilf

^ c- *1

| > |1"D o

>o n 5QJ TTD 13; ** X* 31 S

* * ** * ** * **■’ X* X-

%73 CD8Sc X- X- X X =I m 3.8”Tl7s■n =jm T:n )*■ 2z> X■ z -iH'"1-.

\ < wzr: c_ T3 2V. .V »Z3 Tl 70 >

ts OIom

nl\JH

^ ei •3-(Tl

>

Cc>0 LXoo73

® S8PS£ §^1! s

>5f*~ g-si

lx

1 *00rv

o-40)g<—i—i «-ic? i go

lh

tm , fm m -

SSW'q

o r-uiroN3 oSno

2U1■

Ca>1*1 m&x§%

•$••:* 2. ••!?* -..

' OVS rvj 5C 3

ui ’/i

05

73 o>ooTJ **4; /p ”0

CJI05

11/1 0301

m/ o

°3 2co3i/v3 Z3 2 S

>s i"5*5|_ tn

>OCJ

i ?c C W ■< r mR •r 73 nj,>c O> 73-a 537s SUJ M

n o g7s >UT 2 >-<c-S ^ z d> ccnS _fcs ■*vi 7s Tl

m tiZ 2Z >m za z

73 >> 7s Z.-

NJ>unw

M73 L- "0: r -n 73,S1

oM Tv-<ZIT3 mw Smt/3

z o;O T3

I


Print7/10/2017

Subject: Your Thursday evening trip with Uber

From: Uber Receipts ([email protected])

[email protected];

•M •

■ .

To:

Thursday, July 6, 2017 10:15 PMDate:. « i. r. +5 ** -■-> >•

e>Yu ' ®. M T W ' © Ma/-* ' 5Sfap -ur @ • fe, fk ■ » .* | \

1 lb ■ I Ipillli | fpt i •New York y ® ■,

- _ I muBay0""- . / ■ f f ■ rM v*tSl,eam ; g

■Mpp ® Hfe -

$57.09Thanks for choosing Uber, Hector

July 6, 2017 [ uberX

§/ 09:38pm ( Central Terminal Area, Jamaica, NY

<§: 10:14pm | 550 ParkAve, New York, NY

You rode with Mohammed00:36:19 uberX

I16.44

i1/3about:blank

(


:7/10/2017 PrintI

miles Trip time Car :! •

Iff r?'iff

ADD A TIP

Your Fare

57.09Trip fare

$57.09Subtotal

51.26Before taxes

4.55Sales Tax (8.875%)

1.28Black Car Fund (2.5%)

CHARGED

HI Personal $57.097002

Affiliated with WE ITER LLC (B02617)Dispatched by Weiter (B02617)License Plate: T648194CFHV License Number: 5555172Driver's TLC License Number: 5488388To submit a complaint to the NYC TLC, please call 311..

■

:';

*r2/3ahnt if-‘hlanW


7/10/2017 Print

i

Invite your friends and family. Get a free ride worth up to $20 when you refer a friend to try Uber.

Share code: hectorm371 1.ti;

■

Need help?

Tap Help In your app to contact us with questions about your trip.

Leave something behind? Track it down.

Attachments

« Inap_483f4dal-2c0a-4fc9-8d3c-e2332clb5e5f.map__483f4dal-2c0a-4fc9-8d3c-e2332clb5e5f (431.89KB)

.

3/3about:blank


*

.

ns^miag/.

REG 07-06-2017 13:00000074

CT 1 07-06-2017 13:03REG000077

CT 11 DEPT006 T12 $1.251 DEPT006 T12....Jf•) #25

DEPT006,, ,-T17,.- .41:'25 1 DEPT0(ji6; . T12 $1.251 DEPT006 T12 $1.251 DEPT006 T12 $1.251 DEPT006 T12 $0.601 DEPT006 T12 ,$0:i6O

1 0£PT$36 T12 $0.851 DEPT006 T12 $0.851 DEPT006 T12 $0.851 DEPT006 T12 40*1851 DEPT006.,., 1#&&§f85

•TAT ':-f $14. 15Jfjfl*' $0.14

$14.15 $1.49

1 5 *■, 7 8 CASH VGG^: 7 $5.00

1 1 DEPT006 T12 $1.301 DEPT006 T12 . ,4^301 DEPT006. ; $4301 ’OE;t?TO06. i '!' T127 $1.301 BESPT0O6 T12 $1.301 0EPT006 T12 $1,301 DEPT 006 T12 $1.301 DEPT 006 T12 .,.$4 7.30

T X1 , '■ * $0.10TA%'-;' $10.40

$1.09 $ T1.5 9

.~u v3f?°

$0. 60TA1

:TX2: TL:CASH

41CGTA2 'TX2

iTL

•»

H

Snacks

;*.

r


nvn RECEIPTNTA -NYC TRANSIT N063-42 ST-PORT AUTH NEW YORK CITY NYnvn #: 16S9(N063 0703)Fri 07 July'17 14:23Trans: Sale OK Payment Node; Credit Amount: $ 26.25Bonus: $ 1.31Card Value: $ 27.56New Card Fee: $ 1.00Total Paid: $ 27.25t^

AMERICAN EXPRESS Card #:***********8 000

Auth#: 521521 Ref 049568299809Serial #:2831497438T^LL

Transport

000FARE

Call (212?SMETR0CARD

AEROSTAR AIRPORT HOLDINGS LUC PO Box 3B0B5

00987 San Juan PR;

CREDIT RECEIPTi

05170296HACK #MEDALLION 07/08717 03:02-09:30 TRIP It :RATE It :JFK - MANHATTAN Miles R2 :FARE R2 :STATE SRCHGS IMP.SRCHC-i. :

T17/704/03207/8/2017 16:24 Caja: 704 Num Red bo: 17/704/204838

■7T11

24247i 2 Estancia** TICKET MULTIPISOS **

02030356856 Tar i fa■' 2017 TARIFA R0TA0I0

Entrada Pago

Dur. Estancia Imports

16.61Num. producto$52.00

$0.50$0.30

$12.00 / $64.80 ^

7/6/2017.16:03 7/8/2017 ’l 6:24

2d OOh 22rn $ 49. 75

TIPSGRAND TOTAL CARDNUMBER AUTHOR.

4644005822

***********352 $ 44. 62 $ 0.45 5; 4. 68

MID: Base Imp. : MUNICIPAL(IX): ESTATALdO. 5%)

ENTRY METHOD: CONTACT CHIPA0000000041Q10RID:APPL. NAME: MASTERCARD $ 49. 75TOTAL:

OODBATC: . ** PAGO CON TARJETA **Tar jeta:

Autorizacion:

AC: . ************0467 960116B73DADC6A19F8227

REC/INU#: 24247 ***********462TID: Gracias por su visits

Fscha amision: 7/B/2D17 16:25Contact TLC DIAL 3-1 1

Transport Parking Fee


N EW YORK

*■

Room Number:Arrival Date: Departure Date: Confirmation Number: Page No:

0605Mr. Hector MayolA35 Calle 1 Parques de San Ignacio San Juan 00921 Puerto Rico

07-06-1707-08-17183462141 of 1

Guest Name:

INFORMATION INVOICE A/R No:Folio No: 07-08-17

Credits jDescription ChargesDateL__________

07-06-17 Room# 0605 : CHECK# 19821 Torn Ranch Cashews 3 Room# 0605 : CHECK# 19822 San Pellegrino Limon

14.62MiniBar

13.29MiniBar07-06-17

Room Accommodation State Sales Tax - 8.875 PCT Occ Tax State -5.875 PCT Occ Tax Local Varies Javits Center Tax 1.50USD Regency Bar Room Accommodation State Sales Tax - 8.875 PCT Occ Tax State - 5.875 PCT Occ Tax Local Varies Javits Center Tax 1.50USD

259.0022.9915.22

07-06-1707-06-1707-06-1707-06-1707-06-1707-07-1707-07-1707-07-1707-07-1707-07-1707-07-17

2.001.50

CHECK# 1164 36.57259.00

22.9915.222.001.50

0.00665.90Total

665.90Balance

♦

540 Park Avenue New York, NY 10065T 212.759.4100 F 212.826.5674 loewshotels.com

LOEWSR EG E NCY NOTE L


Pueblo®Office .jbeobot

OfifieeM&srOfficeMax Store 6667 526 Juan Calaf Street

Ha,to Hey, PR 00918 C787 > 29*1-0300

LAG AMERICAS Gerente Jaime Huertas

Tel. 787 763 4030

SERVICIO DE REPRRBCION DE CELULfiRES EL HISH0 DIR (ver asociado para detalles)

06/2*1/2017 17,3,.2STR 6667 REE 2 TRW 1:532 EHP 790282

GROCERYDARNEL VAG0S CAFE FOAM S/TAP

1 K 2/ $6.00

1 B 2/ 556.00

$0,69 T122:.0.6 PH

COCA COLA REG

SPRITE REG TABLE WATER TABLE WATER TABLE WATER

DASANI TO OZGENERAL MERCHANDISE

MEVERA GRNDE/S/G

Items Subtotal Subtotal GOV [117.15]HUN [$22.65]

TOTALDebit card

H JMWIisMitnMuM! 1840 Balance

$3.00 T12Ft

SALE$3.00 T2F $3.49 T12f $3.49 T12F $3.49 T12F$2.50 T2F XT

DescriptionProduct ID 345660 -PRFLGOPY, 11“,Y 433649 PSRT'FL / 2-PKT .10

Total.1 '0

'-*J20/973 @ 6 :99

1 $ 2/ $5.00You Pay 20.S7SS

Subtotal: •33.-96$2.99 TT2uPR City Tax

PR State Tax0.343.5610.6V. ; $22.65

$22,65~ lotei-V

Debit

1 TDS Swiped ■(•-'vufi'iSA-• *»** ***** *******-**.***** s*-**-***-*** *********

CONTROL: "

.3-7.86 37.86

$1.80 .$0.23

SUPPLIES $24.68$24.68

' DSYK-Y—XfIRSJOD:

MRUREEN ..QUEVEDO .2900.4960.1 Please create -your online rewards account at offlcedepot.com/rewards.You must complete your account to

,v, * r*. tv ■ v . ^c I aim .your -.rewards and v i ev-J. syourstatus..

:$0.00!

Item count 8!

*.r.rrgroceriesShop online at www.offi'cedepot .corn

a eMaese^wtHe^wwwt***********************■UE HRNT TO HERR FROM -YOU !

Participate -in our online customer survey andxeceive -a :couponU'or •'STD-off -your next suaFI'fyins

purchase df "SBO; or none .on off.los -.supplies, furniture -iand mare,

(Excludes Technology. Limit ,1 '.coupon per household/business,7

Visit www,offIcedepot, com/'feedback and enter the survey code below:

14W6 FVJ0 R6X2***** *.** ********•**-***•**********■ ***** * *****


i(K)W< MMOK II OOPS If A!

I Hato Rev Luries a sabado 6:30am a 10:00pm

Domingo 8:00am a 7:00pm Tel&fono (787) 756-7474

Sr. Jose Rivera Cartagena-Gerenter

Provisiones Borden UHT 2% 32 02 Borden UHT 2% 32 02 Bounty servilletas 1 Cameo cream sandwich Econo vasos plastico 10 4 P0R

SE AH0RRA:

1.95 mf 1.95 mf 1.79 m 5.99 mf

5.00 1.25 m! 0.14 *Total Sin Impuesto:

Tipo Impuesto Tributable 9.03

12.93

12.93Cantida Imp

Estatal Municipal TOTAL IMP.

0.950.131.08

SNACKS and

GROCERIES

5 BAL PEND. Efectivo

14.01'20.01

CAMBIOUSTED AH0RRA HOY!

6.00

TOTAL DESCUENTOS 1 0.14 </TOTAL AH0RRAD0 C/F 0.14

#

CONTROL: QMZEM-2DCEHi ST1i

j,

Cajero(a): Estefania Escobar LI Tienda.-OOOOl Terminal :006 #Cajero:0015 #Trans. 7489

Gracias por su patrocinioDevoluciones con recibo:

Por ra2ones de seguridad alimentaria Productos no perecederos 72 horas

Productos perecederos 24 horas Fotocopie, pierde legibill dad

C0MPRALE AL DE A0UI IPrimero lo nuestro!

www.compra1ea1deaqui.com

16Jul2017 11:06:29

’

;

\i


%

#11847 400 AVE MUNOZ RIVERA SAN JUAN, PR 00918 787-298-8460

: 207 3288 0021 07/17/2017 7:38 AM,1 I

'BLK .340204155420932 REGULAR PRICE 6.29 REWARDS SAVINGS 1.89 RETURN VALUE 4.40

NICE* PURIFIED WATR (PR) 16.9Z24S .04902292153 'REGULAR PRICE 3.9S'REWARDS SAVINGS 0.50 RETURN VALUE 3.49

. .. : ' .‘AD - - « SALE: ■

:&! L

3.49 .SALE:

i-HV-SUBTOTAL STATE TAX A=10,;5J5 MUN FOOD TAX 8=1.0%MUN GENERAL TAX D=1.0%TOTALDEBIT CARD "'-'CHANGE

! Tf

0.03:

- 1.5V.Bottled water

-!•8.42 S .42: .00

BALANCE REWARDS SAVINGS; THANK YOU FOR SHOPPING AT WALGREENS, GET MORE WITH BALANCE REWARDS, REDEEM POINTS FOR SOMETHING EXTRA ; IN A FUTURE PURCHASE, RESTRICTIONS

APPLY. FOR TERMS AND CONDITIONS,' VISIT WALGREENS.. COM/.BALANCE.

2,.39I

\

$ rqjsLuL#*\Q

is


X

Office depot

OfficeMax' jpSAN JUAN - (787.) 294-0300

07/29/2017 1:06PM

. 2PVT53YPX4SXXEUIRUI1

1 SALE. 211033 BDR,INP,DR,r,

Subtotal:PR State Tax10,5V -

PR City Taxi %Total:

Debit Card 1840:

6667-3-3862-298899-17.6.1 18,“19 SS 18.491,910,18

- .£0.61 20.61

!Supplies

i■ -TDS Swiped

' •■■F.6RNU-M7JHJ .

:T.y''-MAUREEN QLEVED0'"290019601;',-' .,Please’create your online rewards account at•of ficedep.pt.con/rewands. ■•You must complete you" account to claim ycur rewards and view your- .J. i-. ■ .. "... ....status..,, . .

CONTROL; :■

r.*OD s

i

. ■ ■ at

,vShop-online '-at: www,officedepot . com

S*****************************************WE WANT TO HERR FROM YOU!

Participate in our .online .customer ■'■r'sUrvey"arid 'receive a' coup'orv-'for

$10-off’ your'next qualifyIns purchase of ,$5'0’ or mare an

office supplies, furniture and more. (Excludes Technology. Limit 1 coupon per

household/business.)

Visit www.offIcedepot.com/feedback and enter the survey rcode below:

S1UG YTC1 1869********** ****** O************************


Tuesday, August 15, 2017 at 9:51:11AM

Generated(£eq u itracConsolidated Account Detail

CIient='5-3357' and (From: '2017-6-15' To: '2017-7-31')

Starting Date: 7/18/2017 Ending Date: Number of Days: 147/31/2017

UserDate Type CountTime AmountLocation: BGM:Bennazar, Garcia & Milian, C.S.P.

Client: 5-3357:OFFICIAL COMMITTEE OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES [5-3357] Matter: 1: [5-3357] OFFICIAL COMMITTEE

2:10:04PM 2:27:42PM10:28:43AM Rivera Perez, Maria del R.9:22:12AM Rivera Perez, Maria del R.12:41:59PM Rivera Perez, Maria del R.12:42:46PM Rivera Perez, Maria del R.1:41:43PM Rivera Perez, Maria del R.

Totals for Matter: 1

Disb:E-MANUAL COPIES Disb:E-MANUAL COPIES Disb:E-MANUAL COPIES Disb:E-MANUAL COPIES Disb:E-MANUAL COPIES CopyD isb:E-MAN UAL COPIES

$782.40$72.00

$8.80$24.40

$5.20$11.20

$302.40

Rivera Perez, Maria del R. Rivera Perez, Maria del R.

1,9567/18/20177/18/20177/19/20177/20/20177/20/20177/20/20177/31/2017

18022611328

756

$1,206,40

$1,206.40Totals for Client: 5-3357;;

$1,206.40Totals for Location: BGM

i

*

*

:Copyright© 2017, Equitrac Page 1


EXPENSES1,503.68Travel and hotel accomodations for Atty. Francisco

Del Castillo (from August 28 to September l,8/28/2017 2017).

39.20Ground transportation from airport to hotel 8/2 8/2017 (roundtrip) for Atty. Francisco Del Castillo 8/28/2017 Bags for Atty. Francisco Del Castillo

Taxi from Hotel (Grand Hyatt) to Proskauer Rose 8/28/2017 LLP (mediation) (Atty. Francisco Del Castillo)

Taxi from San Juan airport to residence (Atty. Del

50.0017.10

40.458/28/2017 Castillo)

45 pages for Fiscal Plan; 5 pages for printout of Prime Clerk main page; 48 pages Act 106-2017

8/28/2017 (Pension Reform Act) (Total: 98)

39.20

BGMCSP: Groceries for ORC meeting of August 28.158/31/2017 23,2017.

Crosstown Searches & Filing, Inc.: UCC Search 8/31/2017 (Inv. 2017-770) .

104.00

Travel to NY (from August 15 tol7,2017) for Atty. 8/15/2017 H6ctor Mayol)8/15/2017 Hotel accomodation for Atty. Hector Mayol 8/15/2017 Ground transportation for Atty. Hdctor Mayol 8/17/2017 Ground transportation for Atty. Hector Mayol

Travel to NY (from August 28 to September 1, 8/28/2017 2017) for Atty. Hector Mayol 8/28/2017 Hotel accomodation for Atty. Hdctor Mayol 8/28/2017 Ground transportation for Atty. Hector Mayol 8/28/2017 Meals for Atty. H6ctor Mayol 8/28/2017 Snacks for ORC meeting

496.75

577.1565.5662.80

684.20

1,118.3666.5629.3415.01

Page 55 of 56


Attorney / Activity Hours AmountDate8/29/2017 Snacks for ORC meeting 8/30/2017 Ground transportation for Atty. H6ctor Mayol 8/31/2017 Ground transportation for Atty. Hector Mayol 9/1 /2017 Ground transportation for Atty. Hector Mayol 9/1/2017 Ground transportation for Atty. Hector Mayol

9.539.50

11.7670.2730.00

Total expenses $5,068.57

TOTAL AMOUNT OF THIS BILL $129,918.61

Page 56 of 56


Copies: |4S pages for Fiscal Plan; 5 pages for printout of Prime Clerk main page; 48 pages Act 106-2017 (Pension Reform Acl).;

Travel: Fight and hotel from August 28 to September 1, 2017 - $1,503.68; Ground transportation from airport to hotel (roundtrip) - $39.20; Bags: $50; Taxi from Hotel (Grand Hyatt) to Proskauer Rose LLP (mediation): $8.80 & $8:30; Taxi from San Juan airport to residence: $40.45; TOTAL: $1.650.43

Commented [FdCf):Eitu Aienin cepiiipira el cuoque I debar leelutr en la fkctuie glebe).

En consideraci6n al acuerdo de honorarios por hora de $200, tenemos un total de $25,860 por servicios prestados en el mes de agosto de 2017,

Cordialmente,

Lcdo. Francisco del Castillo Orozco

25

i


BENNAZAR, GARCIA & Ml LI AN, CSP

11 de septiembre de 2017

Asunto: Relacidn de gastos relaclonados al litiglo del Comit£ de PensionadosPROMESA Titulo III Num. 17-BK-3283(D.P.R.)Segunda factura: hasta el 31 de agosto de 2017

GASTOS DEL BUFETE

Fecha Descripcion Cantidad8/23/2017 Provisiones para reunidn de pensionados

del 23 de agosto de 2017 (Groceries for ORC meeting of August 23, 2017)

$28.15

$28.15TOTAL

Maureen Quevedo

C;\Users\Admin\Documents\Maui,een\COMITt DE PENSIONADOS - USBC\FACTURA AGOSTO 2017\2017-09-ll • GASTOS SEGUNDA FACTURA,kIsk


tAdOi

ecOmoiEHf rwia#iu

Hato ReyLunes a sAbado 6:30am a 10:00pm

Domingo B:00am a 7:00pm Teldfono (787) 756-7474

Sr. Josd Rivera Cartagena-Gerente

«mi.iLaUftS Borden L81T 2% 32 oz

1.95Dart vaso cafe foam Du Ice Cana NOCal 100 Du Ice Cana azucar 21 Econo vasos plastico

5.00

7.804 I mf1.29 m2.19 mf 1.68 mf

1.254 POR SE AH0RRA:

Selva cuchillo 25pk Selva tensaor 25pk Veryfine apple 10 oz Veryfine apple 10 oz Veryflne apple 10 oz Veryfine fruit punch Veryfine fruit punch Veryfine fruit punch Veryfine orange 10 o Veryfine orange 10 o Veryfine orange 10 o Veryfine orange 10 o Veryfine orange 10 o Veryfine orange 10 o

m0.14

0.69 m0.69 m0.99 mf0.99 mf0.99 mf0.99 mf0.99 mf0.99 mf

mf0.990.99 mf0.99 mf

mf0.990.99 mf0.99 mf

Total Sin Impuesta;T1 po Impuesto Tribirtable Estatal Municipal TOTAL IMP.

27.47CantI da Imp

3.92 0.4127.47 0.27

0.68

22 BAL PEND. ATH Manual

2B.1528.15

0.00CAMBIOUSTED AH0RRA HOY!

TOTAL DESCUENT0S f 0.14TOTAL AHORRADO C/F 0.14

H ^3 fa faCONTROL: 7EV9S-KSBXLST O

Ca.iero(a): Hi Ida Boni I la Tienda,00001 Terminal :006 l/Cajero:009Q

KTrans. 9617Gracias por su patroclnio

Devoluoiones con recibo:Por razones de seguridad alimentaria Productos no perecederos 72 horas

Productos perecederos 24 horas Fotocopie, plerde lsgibilidad

C0MPRALE AL DE A0UI iPrimero lo nuestro!

www.compralealdeaqui.com

23Ago2017 9:04:18


*

InvoiceCROSSTOWN SEARCHES & FILINGS, INC.

URB. SIERRA BAYAMON 27 #8 CALLE 26 BAYAMON PR 00961-4334

Date Invoice #9/15/2017 2017-770

Bill To Ship To

BENNAZAR, GARCIA & MILIAN CSP LIC CARLOS R. RAMIREZ ISERN APARTADO POSTAL 194000 #212 SAN JUAN PR 00919-4000

P.O. Number Terms Rep Ship Via F.O.B. Project

9/J5/2017

Quantity Item Code 1 UCCSEARCH

Description

SISTEMA DE RETIRO DE LOS EMPLEADOS DEL GOBIERNO DEL ESTADO LIBRE ASOCIADO DE PUERTO RICOImpuesto sabre Ventss y Uso (IVU)

Price Each Amount

100.00 100.00

IVU 4% 4.00% 400

Se requiere el pngo tie esta factura, cierre o no el cast).Total $104.00


8/11/2017 Print trip and receipt - Your trip detaile - American Airlines

AmericanAirUnes*

CM your boarding piM foitorT Scon tMa barood* at any American Alrttno* BalSServIca Machlfm,

AA RECORD LOCATOR; XWSNPP

San Juan to New York1 Adult

Tuesday August 15, 2017 - Thursday August 17, 2017

Total Paid:$496.75 USD

AA Record Locator Reservation NameXWSNPP SJU/JFKYui,r r«:r.fjrti -i! Jtor i’:i‘yt^i.jri■ v*Fval:m cyrfi'ti Mice rwmuf-r will tiDEdod la rctreua ot 'it* -rancts /our Slatus: Ticketed Aug 10, 2017

n fVfli'ilJl.

I

Flight Depart Arrive Fare Amount

Adult1 * $370-00 USD

American Airlines San Juan (SJU) AugusMS, 2017 06:20 PM Travel Time : 4 h 11 m Class: Economy Seat: 16C

New York (JFK)August 15, 2D17 09:31 PM Booking Coda: S Plane Type : 730

I $370,00 USD1357Trip Options

|Prafarrad Seale $70.55 USD

Taxes & Carrier-Imposed FeesFlight Depart Arrive

466.20 USDTaxesAmerican Airlines New York (JFK)

August 17, 2017 12:25 PM Travel Time : 3 h 58 m Class: Economy Seal: 12C

San Juan(SJU)

August 17. 2017 04:23 PM Booking Code : N Plgne Typa: 730

1357 Carrler-lmpoaed Faas $0.00 USD

Flight Subtotal

$496.75 USD

ReceiptPASSENGER TICKET NUMBER FREQUENT FLYER NUMBER Tax/FeWCtuiKpFARE TICKET TOTAL

MAYOL.HECTOft M OO10W630B7O0

Paymart Typa: MASTER CARD ’*'**'**4644 Total

PAS9ENQER SEAT NUMBER(3) PRICE TudFeWCharga SEAT TOTAL

MAYOL, HECTOR M 16C.12C 70.55 USD 70.56 USO

Total 70.55 USD ;

Endorsements/RestrictionsNONREF/CHG FEE APPLIES/NO VALU

Terms and conditions:ir you've already begun travel, this receipt rriBy only show portions of your trip not Down.

If your ticket Involves travel outside the U.S., Canada, U.S. Virgin Islands or Puerto Rico and has been reissued, your ticket total may not Include all taxes. Please contact Reservations for the correct total.

A summary of all the terms and conditions that apply to your travel are available an ae.com/candltlonsofcarTtBge.

litl|)s7/www.iia.com/resorvaUon/pnnllllrierary.(io?rorwar(1aitiniiraryRnceipt8>isReceipt^lriio&anchorLocaUona%2Fresotvallon%2FnridRnservalianSi]bml . 1/1


8/10/2017 Itinerary: New York

• We understand that sometime* plana change. We do not charge a cancel or change fee. When the airline charges such fees in accordance with Its own policies, the cost will be passed on to you.

• Tickets are nonrefundable, nontransferable and name changes are not allowed.

• Please read the complete penalty rules for changes and cancellationsOpens in a new window, applicable to this fare.

• Please read important information regarding airline liability limitations Opens In a new window..

BOOKEDLoews Regency New York HotelAug 1S, 2017-Aug 17, 2017

Your reservation is booked. No need to call us to reconfirm this reservation. Additional Hotel Services

54D Park Avenue, New York, NY, 10065 United States of America

The below fees and deposits only apply If they are not Included In your selected room rate.

Tel: 1 (212) 759-4100, Fax: 1 (212) 6B8-2S9B

The following fees and deposits are charged by the property at time of service, check-ln, or check-out.

Check-in• Breakfast fee: between USD 22 and

USD 34 per parson (approximately)

• Valet parking fee: USD 90 per night

• Pet fee: USD 50 per accommodation, par stay

• A late check-out fee will be charged

• Rollaway bed fee: USD 50.0 per

• Check-In time starts at 4 PM

• Minimum check-in age is 21

• Your room/unit will be guaranteed for late arrival.

Important Hotel Information

Although Travelocity does not charge a fee to change or cancel your booking, Loews Regency New York Hotel may still charge a fee in accordance with Its own rules & regulations.

day• Cancellations or changes made after 4:00pm (Eastern Daylight Time

(US & Canada)) on Aug 12, 2017 or no-shows are subject to a property fee equal to the first nights rate plus taxes and fees.

• Prices and hotel availability are not guaranteed until full payment is recelved.lf you would Ilka to book multiple rooms, you must use a different name for each room. Otherwise, the duplicate reservation will be canceled by the hotel.

Noise-free rooms not guaranteed

• View your online Itinerary for additional rules and restrictions.

The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not Include tax and are subject to chango.

Luxury Room, 1 King BadRoom

Reserved tor HECTOR M MAYOL 1 adult

1 king bed, non-smoking roomRequests

https://www.trav9locily.com/ilinerB ry-print7tr1pid=691cc07a-2102-48l>4-b92a-07d47198bOedSltlneraryNvmb9r=7287192582762 2/3


1*

8/10/2017 (317 unread) - Yahoo - Yahoo Mall

A.. i

Q. All Hector Mayol, search your mailbox

TravelocityH email®e.traveloclty.com □ (417) 520-5312

Search emails

Travelocity travel confirmation - Aug 15 - it. rra-'r.l Yd’icc

El

Your reservation Is boohed and con firm ad. There te no need to coll ue to reconfirm this reservation.

Traveler Information

HECTOR M MAYOL Adult

No frequent flyer details provided

Ticket # 0018645369703

* Seat assignments, special meals, frequent flyer point awards and special assistance requests should be confirmed directly with the airline.

Aug 15, 2017 - Departure Nonstop Total travel time: 4 h 11 m

>4 h 11 m 1,621 ml

Sun Juan New York

SJU 5;20pm JFK 9:31pm

Terminal BAmerican Alrtlnee 1157Economy / Coach {9) | Confirm seats with the airline4

Aug 17, 2017 - Return Nonstop

Terminal 8

Total travel time: 3 li 88 m >e>3 h 58 m

1,621 mlSsn JuanNow York

\ JFK 12:25pmTerminal 0American Airlines 1357Economy / Coach (N) | Confirm seats with the airline''

SJU 4:23pm Tarminal B

Airline Rules & Regulations

• We understand that Bomollmas plans charge. We da not charge a cancel or change fee. When the alrllna charges such fees in accordance with Its own pollclaa, the coat will be pissed on to you.

• Tickets aro nonrefundable, ncnlransferable and name changes are not allowed.

• Please read the complete penalty rules for changes and cancellations Opens In a new window, applicable to (his fare.

• Pleaea read Important Information regarding airline liability limitation! Opens In a new window..

i

CC

Wo have confirmed your hotel reservation with the property.

VI ow hotel details

540 Park Avenue, New York, NY, 10065 United States ofAmerica

Tat: 1 1212} 759-4100, Fax: 1 (212! 0B8-2B96

ht1ps://mg.mail.yahoo.com/nao/launch7.ra nd=cu52034tbkbt4#555610994 1/1


Itinerary: New York8/10/201T

#

travelocity*

New YorkAug 15, 2017 - Aug 17, 2017 | Itinerary # 7287192582762

Price SummaryImportant Information

• All passengers traveling to the US must provide valid travel documents and details of their full US destination address for US Immigration.

• Proof of citizenship Is required for International travel. Be sure to bring all necessary documentation (e.g. passport, visa, transit permit). To leam more, visit our Visa and Passport page .

Flight + Hotel $1,073.90

Total Price $1,073,90

AH prices Include taxes & fees and are quoted In US

dollars.

TICKETING IN PROGRESSSan Juan (SJU) - New York (JFK)Aug 15, 2017 - Aug 17, 2017,1 round trip ticket

Additional Flight ServicesYour ticket Is not yet confirmed. Wa are confirming It with the airline and will update your online Itinerary within 24 hours.

• The airline may charge additional fees Opens in a new window, for checked baggage or other optional services.

Traveler Information

HECTOR M MAYOL Adult

Ticketing In progressNo frequent flyer details provided

* Seat assignments, special meals, frequent flyer point awards and special assistance requests should be confirmed directly with the airline.

Total travel time: 4 h 11 mAug 15,2017 - Departure Nonstop

4 h 11 mSan Juan New York JFK 9:31pm\ SJU 5:20pm

American Airlines 1357Economy / Coach (S) | Confirm seats with the airline'

Total travel time: 3 h 58 mAug 17,2017 - Return Nonstop

3h 58 mNew York San Juan SJU 4:23pm\ JFK 12:25pm

American Airlines 1357Economy / Coach (N) | Confirm seats with the airline*

Airline Rules ft Regulations

• Fares are not guaranteed until ticketed.

https://wviiw.travelDclty.com/Hin0rary-print?tripid=601ccO7a-21O2-48b4-b92B-O7d47198b0ed4ltln9ra[yNu(iiber=7287192582782 1/3


§ g 2 =S 5 -a * JS55-.:° - vJ § 3 3§ P S ■»«»«■"-»» S2N= P

£ g '£ ? P <=• ® «- S3 ?. F Si ̂S 5“J ggggggg ^ SI S 5X X

II

I!

:!

I

*m ms:z-tC3D?o-3H^ oi»--n3)?ccjm3 cn DM-ic>-(7ciTJiia>a.r?3r-^HM\oo o - xoxv/>« -h : rm<t- rn x z> 7*x »—m -< ox*x vom—*v» i/i : tnr* o*-< x x> ci x c x ar x'-s x"o <r 3 - 2-* owj n> x 3 — — rr.-< =c m OPO XX- W3 -ox x»-**•■■—<. m —i on^ ~ x *—O X* XX - X<.n X -

c.* .— r>* x —*a fa *« a* •• —J •• >* * - a* *a i»-H 00

’=

LO

illiill -JG">3 3XoC a* •• rp?0

O-’mSt-

*%■

■f m

S S 3cn r_2

VI:-

*V- i*• ' ^ iA> ^gs r»«

I-*-10sI*K-*

on


1

Booking Confirmation9/212017

Total Extras; 10.00 USD

You're all set to jet!

5od4 ?U ivConfinnatKin code: SCMVOVl:

Tra elers

i.

U ,X

f It .

Your flights

Flight 1404New York-Kennedy. MY (JFK) \ior fijtj 5117, 1:50 PM

“?irq" Hi,m Pm:>San Juan. PR (5 Jin Via'. Ali-j 2011 1U:00 AM NC'Stcu

Faro: Bliyo Plus tyf'tt iiW’

Flight 0003

JelBlue

S*n Juan PRfSJUiNew York-Kennedy NY{uFKj f-ri fioti 1 iOt ' ! 1,2 TAM K. 3no ' 2D 17 3 20 PM

AJ2C

Tsxm &tw

USU' i /

Total faro: $684.20 USD

Extras

1/2Mtp*7/bookJ«tbti».oom/B6/Connrm«ttonFofwart.»lo


*

Transactions9/2/2017

Posted transactions

08/29/17 50.00 so

OB/28/17 66.56 67

08/28/17 1.10 I

08/27/17 40.00 40

06/27/17 22.30 22

08/26/17 25.00 25

08/25/17 46.88 47

08/25/17 24.99 25

08/24/17 32.20 32

08/24/17 10.42 10

OB/24/17 99.00 99

08/23/17 40.95 41

08/22/17 622.20 622

08/22/17 684.20 684

4644

08/22/17

OB/24/17

684.20JETBLUE 27921823532441 08005382583 UT 1ET0LUE AIRWAYS

Questions about this purchase? Visit our

*The merchant location may not match the physical address where you made your purchase, ft Is common far merchants to use the address of a central branch, headquarters ':l

08/19/17 25.95 26

08/19/17 -3,429.78

08/18/17 58.10 58

08/17/17 21.76 22

08/17/17 62.80 63

08/16/17 90.00 90

08/15/17 -27.80 -56

08/13/17 160.00 320

08/11/17 70.55 142

08/11/17 35.29 35

08/10/17 426.20 852

08/10/17 647.70 648

08/08/17 40.00 40

08/07/17 50.18 50

TOTAL (Since last statement) 3,454.33 -3,457.58 4,055

hflps://www. bardaycardus.com/serv1dng/actlvlty 1/2


jetBlue jetbiue TSAPre/BOARDING PASSName: Name:

MAYOL/HECTOIcM MAYOL/HECTOR MFrom : Depart r Date; i PM- Fram/To:

New Yjark nFK)

San JujirfC PR (S2U)11:27 AM 01 Sep E6 3 3FK/SJU

Tc; Arrive: Depart: Date:

3:20 PM 11:27 AM 01 Sep 17Flight;

B6 3Confirmation Boarding Time: Seat:IT I TV Seat:

SCMVOU 10:52 AM 04 22B$eq

22BTrueBlue Number; Ticket Number: Class:nB6 2076344244 2792182353244 0, zBoarding gate closes 15 minutes pr4

IBAGte deportur

FLIGHTGATEBOARDING PASS

CONFIRMATION: SCMVOU 140-A5 B6TICKET NUMBER;

TVLPre/TRUE BLUE; 2076344244

BOARDING DOORS CLOSE/ 9:25 AM 9:45 m

DEPARTURE10:00 AM

ARRIVAL1:53 PMII«jjI.

IVji1R KTjr. Ur i ririitflm SEAT •--< S■ , ,• -

f—' PA0 II 9B11 i

■■ 'U- 'i t VJ*. t V -

JFKAugust 28, 2017Welcome abQard.MAYOL, HECTOR M

New YorkSan Juan, PRhI C ■ I

Your fare includes @n)

IBAG

r-rw


44

Grand Hyatt New York 109 East 42nd Street New York, NY 10017 Tel: 212-883-1234 Fax:212-697-3772 www.grandnewyork.hyatt.com/

G R AN D | HYATT'

INVOICE

Payee Hector MayolA35 Calle 1 Parques De San Ign San Juan Puerto Rico

Room No. Arrival

282808-28-17

Departure 09-01-17Page No. 1 of 2Folio Window 1Confirmation No. 5042437501

Group Name Booking No,

Folio No. 16861161647486308

DescriptionDate Charges Credits

08-28-17OB-28-1708-28-1708-28-1708-28-1708-29-1708-29-1708-29-1708-29-1708-29-1708-30-1708-30-1708-30-1708-30-1708-30-1708-31-1708-31-1708-31-1708-31-1708-31-1709-01-17

Accommodation NY/NYC Sales Tax 8.875% NYC Occupancy Tax 5.B75% NYC Unit Occupancy Tax NYC Javits Occupancy Tax Accommodation NY/NYC Sales Tax 8.875% NYC Occupancy Tax 5.B75% NYC Unit Occupancy Tax NYC Javits Occupancy Tax Accommodation NY/NYC Sales Tax 8.875% NYC Occupancy Tax 5.875% NYC Unit Occupancy Tax NYC Javits Occupancy Tax Accommodation NY/NYC Sales Tax 8.875% NYC Occupancy Tax 5.875% NYC Unit Occupancy Tax NYC Javits Occupancy Tax American Express

243.1021.5814.282.001.50

243.1021.5814.282.001.50

243.1021.5814.282.001.50

233.1020.6913.692.001.50

XXXXXXXXXXXX8000 xx/xx 1,118.36

Total 1,118.36 1,118.36

Guest Signature Balance 0,00

I agree that my liability for this bill Is not waived end I agree to be held personally liable In tho event that the Indicated parson, company or association fails to pay for any part or the full amount of IhesB charges.

WE HOPE YOU ENJOYED YOUR STAY WITH USI

How was your stay at the Grand Hyatt New York?Our goal Is to provide every guest with an excellent stay. We are interested to hear any comments regarding your visit. Please contact our Consumer Affairs Department via E-Mail at: [email protected]

World of Hyatt Summary No Membership to be credited

Join World of Hyatt today and starl earning points for stays, dining and more. Visit www worldoihvall.com

Lost and Found Inquiries: [email protected]

For Inquiries concerning your bill, please call 886-586-6308

Please remit payment to:


4

metropolitan areaarea METROPOLITAN U-X7-

CREDIT RECEIPT*.00-104993

ftfigOHACK t»MEDALLION :09X01X1? 09:04-00:39TRIP tt RATE #JFK - MANHATTAN Miles R2 FARE R2 TOLLS «Mid-Tun:$5.76 STATE SRCHC:IMP.SRCHG. :

:

I^TURiSTICO 6486:2:

16.35 $52.00

:FROMjS^rVLTO

:

*Tg;^ JSlCtDFARE $0.50 $0.30

$11.71 $?0.27

**$8000 856753

n u »1 U***34€

LUGGAGE $ TOTAL

TIPS :GRAND TOTAL:$ AMEXAUTHOR.SIGNATURE

THANK YOU FOR YOUR VISIT TO PUERTO RICO*:

MID*.ENTRY METHOD: CONTACT CHIP

A00000002501AID:APPL. NAME: AMERICAN EXPRESSCREDIT RECEIPT

0012ATC!HACK ft MEDALLION :TRIP®#17 14:28~15,15 RATE #JFK - MANHATTAN Miles R2 FARE R2 TOLLS !Mid-Tuns$5.76 STATE SRCHG:IMP.SRCHG. :

: 05295248 CREDIT RECEIPT ACi2U86 5C70FDl88532«DbJ

RECXINU#:HACK tt MEDALLION 08X31X17 08:50-09:02 TRIP # :RATE H :STAND. CITY RATE Miles R1 :FARE R1 :STATE SRCHG:IMP.SRCHG. :

05003435 6486 44. f l 441 44*4569: 5428 7C27 TID:: 2

27044 DESCRIPTION:: 17.53$52.00

1:0.84

$9.00 $0.50 $0.30 $1.96

$11.76 ***4644

062652 ***********807

Signature!$0.50 $0.30 $8.00

$66.56 ***4644 065822

entry netSo"?*""'*533CONTACT CHIP

TIPS TIPSGRAND TOTAL: MASTER C AUTHOR.

GRAND TOTAL MASTER C AUTHOR. ::

MID! MID: MAYOLXHECTORENTRY METHOD: CONTACT CHIPAID: A0000000041010AID! A0000000041010 CARDHOLDER ACKNOUtEDGES

RECEIPT OF FUNDS IN THE RMOUNT OF THE 101111. INDICATED AND AGREES U) PERFORM rut- Cl: I GAT 101 IS . NOTED IN CARDHOLDER'S AGREEMENT 111 fH ISSUER

APPL. NAME: .MASTERCARD

APPL. NAME: MASTERCARD ATC!ATC! 00F500F4 AC:AC: 99449638E7CFC4D3

RECXINU#:A05C3BCBC3BF90CERECXINU#: 27044 ***********5685428***********444 TID!TID:

I

Contact TLC DIAL 3-1-1 Contact TLC DIAL 3-1-1

- s -<p -t-i


•L

GRAND HYATT NEW YORK

O'Brien's Ir1sh Pub 134 Herat 46th Street

New York, NY 212-391-1516

rn«rkETCheek 1 72 08/2B/17-A 7 : 14pmGuests 1 HICHELLE

■34 LUIS DELGADOTable D—10

;HK 2569 AUG29 1 17 7:52AM1.. BUD1.. TODAY'S CATCH

5.0021.951 BISCUIT

1 COFFEE FOOD SALES * TAXTOTAL PAID $ CASH $ CHANGE DUE

5.003.75

Items 26.95B .75Tax 2.390.78

TOTAL 29.349.53 20.00 10.47

---- 734 CLOSED AUG29 7:53AM —Listed Below is the Suggested Gratuity

15X Suggested Gratuity: 4.40 18X Suggested Gratuity: 5.30 20X Suggested Gratuity: 5.B5

World of Hyatttoday and start earning points for stays, dining and more. Visit worldofhyatt.com.*Not point earning eligible. #Not point redemption eligible. JOIN US ON TWITTER 8 FACEBDOK

fMARKETHYATTNYC

THAW YOUFOR YOUR PATRONAGE

GO RAIBH MILE HAITH AGAT Go n’eiri an bothar leaf.

SEE YOU AGAIN SOON.

r; v■ t

? : i f ’i i .. 1 ■?: -:T 4IHI 5 ■' % ” k

i> . i -4T «-- 11o l* III r: 7

‘“If Jf

1 ?

.-i0Ii r. fji !? .?-! 2*r : 10

yr.k* ~ « a«■

” j 1

• i ■

■h■v- (A

i u ' • i0 o< s; ?L< r■ **o
