case study vaillant: multi-project management with ms project and sap integration
DESCRIPTION
At the Vaillant Group, the R&D department forms the heart of the business – and it has highly qualified teams around the globe to ensure that the company upholds its track record in innovation. Today, the Vaillant Group has a centralized, enterprise-wide project management system for R&D that is shared by all its offices and integrated with core business systems like SAP. The solution delivers a deep level of insight that has significantly increased project management efficiency throughout the company. It also provides a wide range of customizable reports at the click of a button, so anyone can check how a project is progressing with just the right level of information for their needs. Everyone in R&D agrees that the Microsoft PPM system delivers the information they need to avoid bottlenecks and ensure smooth and accurate resource allocation as a result.TRANSCRIPT
Case Study
www.theprojectgroup.comTel:+49 (89) 61 55 93 - 30
TPG is a registered trademark in the European Union and in the United States of America.
Copyright TPG The Project GroupAll rights reserved 12/2012 (v1.0)
Enterprise Project Management for Research & Development
Industry
Heating
Ventilation
Air-conditioning
Solution Components
- Microsoft PPM 2010
- Microsoft SharePoint 2010
- TPG PSLink
- TPG ProjectLink
- TPG ResourceLink
- TPG MTA Server
of an astonishing range of inventions in the years
and decades that followed, and the pioneering
spirit and commitment to customer satisfaction
is still very much alive in the company today. With
some € 2.3 bn in sales and more than 12,000 em-
ployees, the Vaillant Group maintains production
and R&D facilities in many European countries
and in China.
No man is an island
The Vaillant Group has been using SAP as its cen-
tral business system for many years and – like
many other companies – thought that the logical
solution to the need for a project management
system would be to go down the SAP route as
well. However, Vaillant Group staff soon found that
there was only limited scope for operational project
planning and monitoring in the systems and de-
cided to look at standalone systems instead.
The company did have a mixture of isolated instanc-
es of Microsoft Project 2003, other standalone proj-
ect management tools as well as Excel in use within
certain teams, but the information in these systems
was limited to the workgroups involved and was not
shared with the rest of the R&D department. As a
result, the resource planning process for a new proj-
ect meant contacting or visiting each R&D team in
each country, then consolidating all the information
into a resource allocation plan. In addition, the Vaillant
When Johann Vaillant – an ambitious, 23-year-old
tailor’s son from Remscheid in Germany – started
his company in 1874, he was determined to bring
the convenience of on-tap hot water to millions
of ordinary families. With his “closed-system”
gas boiler, he launched a groundbreaking new
technology that kept the combustion gases sepa-
rate from the water they were heating, making
the whole system much safer. Later on, one of
his company’s most successful inventions was
central heating. Until then, each room had to be
equipped with its own oven or fireplace – but en-
gineers at the Vaillant Group thought it would be
far more efficient to have a boiler in one central
location and pump hot water into simple radiators
in the rest of the house. These were just the start
At the Vaillant Group, the R&D department forms the heart of the business – and it has highly quali-
fied teams around the globe to ensure that the company upholds its track record in innovation.
With a range of different brands in Europe and beyond, the company found it a challenge to manage
planning for new products, prioritize the projects, and assign multi-location development teams to
each one. Today, the Vaillant Group has a centralized, enterprise-wide project management system
for R&D that is shared by all its offices and integrated with core business systems like SAP. The
solution delivers a deep level of insight that has significantly increased project management ef-
ficiency throughout the company. It also provides a wide range of customizable reports at the click
of a button, so anyone can check how a project is progressing with just the right level of information
for their needs. Everyone in R&D agrees that the Microsoft PPM system delivers the information they
need to avoid bottlenecks and ensure smooth and accurate resource allocation as a result.
“We sat down with the project managers and asked them what their requirements for a proj-ect management system would be. One of their first comments was that they wanted the look and feel of the system to closely re-semble Microsoft Project.”
had a number of other add-on products that would
extend the functionality of the Microsoft Project
system and improve productivity at the Vaillant
Group. These included TPG ProjectLink, which en-
ables project managers to share information about
schedules between different projects. The Vaillant
Group tested the two products simultaneously.
Proof-of-Concept followed by go-live
“Together with specialists from TPG, we imple-
mented the proof-of-concept system with TPG
PSLink and TPG ProjectLink during summer 2010,”
comments Fritsche. “We wanted to verify that proj-
ect managers and other project-related staff would
be able to work with the system with no problem
and ensure that acceptance levels would be as
high as possible.” Each project worker entered his
or her hours into the timesheet and this informa-
tion was exported to SAP. Since the Vaillant Group
runs projects with mixed teams across various
R&D sites, the hours needed to be posted to the
appropriate country-code. The correct distribution
of actual work from the EPM into SAP company
codes was handled by TPG PSLink automatically,
in accordance with country specific accounting
rules. The Vaillant Group then validated what had
become a much more streamlined process. It also
added two further TPG products to the system –
TPG ResourceLink, which imports resource data
from SAP and other sources and populates the
Microsoft Project Server enterprise resource pool,
and TPG MTA Server, a milestone trend analysis
solution that lets project managers see how mile-
stones are progressing over time.
Centralized solution reaching out to all offices
Following training courses in all locations in De-
cember 2010 the grand day arrived on 1.1.2011
with the whole system going into production –
Microsoft Project, TPG PSLink, TPG ResourceLink,
TPG ProjectLink, TPG MTA Server and a number
of tailored reports. The Microsoft PPM solution
went live in all of Vaillant’s R&D sites simultane-
ously. These include the Remscheid headquarters
as well as France, Spain, Slovakia and Turkey, fol-
lowed by China in spring 2011.
Group’s existing systems could not keep pace with
the increasing complexity of development require-
ments, particularly with regard to components to be
used in multiple product lines.
SAP integration a must-have
“It was at that point in 2009 – that we sat down
with the project managers and asked them what
their requirements for a project management
system would be,” says Jörn Fritsche, Project
Manager in Vaillant Group R&D Support. “One of
their first comments was that they wanted the
look and feel of the system to closely resemble
Microsoft Project.”
A further requirement was that the system should
be integrated with SAP to automate data shar-
ing and minimize the need for project staff to
work with SAP themselves. Fritsche and a cross-
functional validation team took a close look at Mi-
crosoft Project and confirmed that it would meet
most of the requirements – but not all. As it does
not offer integration with SAP as standard, Fritsche
talked to TPG and one other company as both pro-
vide a proven integration solution.
Putting the systems through their paces
“We installed and ran the two solutions for a week
each,” notes Jörn Fritsche. “We wanted to put the
systems through their paces in a real-life environ-
ment and be sure that the two companies really
understood our requirements.” A multi-disciplinary
group comprising staff from R&D project manage-
ment, IT and R&D Controlling recorded the results
of their tests in a detailed evaluation matrix. Aside
from TPG PSLink, the interface between SAP and
Microsoft Project, Jörn Fritsche had noted that TPG
Jörn Fritsche, Project
Manager in Vaillant Group
R&D Support
“We wanted to verify that project managers and other project-related staff would be able to work with the system with no problem and ensure that acceptance levels would be as high as possible.”
“The system gives us a very deep level of insight that improves project management efficiency throughout the company.”
“We can see at a glance which people or teams are becoming overloaded.”
sues arise. This was the case after go-live at the
Vaillant Group due to some undetected glitches
in Microsoft PPM. One of these had a critical
impact on the entire system, as it failed to log
any actual-hours data. TPG’s specialists reacted
immediately and supported the Vaillant Group’s
IT staff throughout the entire escalation process
with Microsoft to resolve the bug. The exemplary
teamwork between Microsoft technical support,
TPG’s specialists and the customer’s IT staff
made it possible to apply a workaround quickly,
followed by the implementation of permanent
bug-fix from Microsoft as soon as it became
available.
Results: “The deep level of insight improves
our project management efficiency”
The Vaillant Group now finds that its whole R&D
project planning process is more efficient. “We
can see at a glance which people or teams are
becoming overloaded,” comments Dr. Rainer
Lang, Group R&D Manager Heat Pumps”.
“Aside from the resource aspects, we can see
how projects are progressing in terms of their
delivery deadlines – and the reports are customiz-
In summer 2011, the PPM system was extend-
ed to the Industrial Manufacturing department
throughout the group. At the Vaillant Group,
there is a close link between R&D and Industrial
Manufacturing. This area needs to be able to plan
production lines and test benches in advance,
requiring a seamless hand-over of developed
products from R&D. The Vaillant Group uses TPG
ProjectLink in this area to provide crucial trans-
parency between projects and departments.
Glitches resolved with great teamwork
One of the hallmarks of a successful business
partnership is that the supplier is on hand with
tangible help and advice when unforeseen is-
agement system that would streamline resource
planning and management throughout the group
and deliver insight about project status and risks
at any time.
The Solution: The enterprise management solu-
tion is based on Microsoft Project Server with the
addition of several TPG products to extend the func-
tionality of the system. Notably, the Vaillant Group
is using TPG PSLink for integrating SAP with Mi-
crosoft Project; TPG ResourceLink to populate the
enterprise resource pool with data from any source,
including SAP; TPG ProjectLink for sharing informa-
tion about schedules, across projects; and TPG MTA
Server for on-demand milestone trend analysis.
The Benefits: Significant increase in insight into
resource availability and workloads, ensuring that
projects are completed on time and on budget.
Flexible reporting with different levels of detail de-
pending on the recipient. Increased transparency
across multiple projects and R&D locations.
The Company: The Vaillant Group is an interna-
tional heating, ventilation and air-conditioning tech-
nology concern based in Remscheid, Germany. As
one of the world’s market and technology leaders,
it develops and produces tailor-made products, sys-
tems and services for domestic comfort. The prod-
uct portfolio ranges from efficient heating appliances
based on customary fuels to system solutions for
using regenerative energy sources. In financial year
2011 the company, which has been family-owned
since its founding in 1874, achieved with about
12,000 employees sales totaling €2.3 billion.
The Challenge: The Vaillant Group is an innova-
tion-driven company and its R&D department
forms the core of the business. With R&D facili-
ties in many European countries and in China, the
company was using isolated project management
systems that were not interconnected. The com-
pany initially worked with SAP project manage-
ment, which proved a challenge for R&D staff. The
Vaillant Group required a centralized project man-
Image source: Lonza Ltd., Basel
www.theprojectgroup.comTel:+49 (89) 61 55 93 - 30
TPG is a registered trademark in the European Union and in the United States of America.
Copyright TPG The Project GroupAll rights reserved 12/2012 (v1.0)
Jörn Fritsche is also keeping a keen eye on ways
to extend the system to leverage its full potential.
“For example, we’re currently testing the func-
tionality of the Portfolio Server to support the
strategic selection process,” he says.
More departments and functionality
He is also testing a new TPG product – the TPG Port-
folioPlanner. This lets project managers aggregate
the data from new and current projects and show
each one as a task in Microsoft Project, producing
a clear and comprehensive overview of all projects
in a single chart. Managers can then simply drag
and drop the graphic within the portfolio, helping
them to decide when to start a new project. They
can optimize the plan depending on what resources
are available when, enabling them to pinpoint an ac-
curate start date without overloading their teams.
In addition, the success – and almost 100% user
acceptance level – of the R&D department’s PPM
system has been making waves within the Vaillant
Group. Other departments have expressed an in-
terest in trying it out to improve the management
of their own projects. That’s what makes it like an
efficient central heating system – a centralized so-
lution whose beneficial effects are felt throughout
the organization.
able!” Senior management, for example, may only
want a one-page report on a couple of strategic
projects or KPIs, while project managers and oth-
ers need much more detail.
“It’s the detail that makes the difference,” adds
Fritsche. “The system gives us a very deep level
of insight that improves project management ef-
ficiency throughout the company. It supports our
modular product development approach, where
the product is a master project that is comprised
of a number of sub-projects. This multi-project
management solution, which is based on TPG
ProjectLink, gives us the required transparency,
pinpoints the dependencies between projects
and illustrates the impact that a delay in one mod-
ule will have on the master project.”
“Our PPM system enables us to synchronize
projects that are running in parallel,” comments
Markus Hiegemann, Project Manager for Heat
Pumps at the Vaillant Group. “We can foresee if
there is likely to be a delay or a potential bottle-
neck and act quickly to prevent it. This helps us to
ensure that even very complex international R&D
projects are completed on time and on budget.”
Overall, the system has significantly improved
resource availability and management.
“We can foresee if there is likely to be a delay or a potential bottleneck and act quickly to prevent it. This helps us to ensure that even very complex international R&D projects are completed on time and on budget.“
Reference Customer
Vaillant GmbH
Berghauser Str. 40
42859 Remscheid, Germany
Jörn Fritsche
Project Manager Vaillant Group R&D Support
Tel: +49 2191 18 4825
www.vaillant-group.com
Solution implemented by
TPG The Project Group GmbH
Destouchesstr. 68
80796 Munich, Germany
Stavros Georgantzis
Managing Director and co-owner
Tel: +49 89 615 593 30
www.theprojectgroup.com