case studies and other classroom reality shows session iii: preparing case studies john casey school...
TRANSCRIPT
Case Studies and Other Classroom Reality Shows
Session III: Preparing Case Studies
John CaseySchool of Public Affairs
The Dam A new industrial/manufacturing area is to be built, which will be available to operate at full capacity in 5 years.To supply the needed water and power to the industrial area, it has been decided to build a dam on a nearby river. A dam of this scale will take 5 years to build.
Initial surveys have indicated that there are two possible locations for the dam, but without further survey work – which will take one year to complete – there is a risk that the construction will collapse in one of the two locations. If the dam is started in the wrong place, it is predicted that it will need to be abandoned after one year of construction.
If the dam is not built on time (i.e. in the 5 years), there will significant “delay costs”, based on the lost economic opportunities, delay in provision of employment, penalty to be paid to industrial site developer, etc. The costs associated with building the dam are:
- Survey: 0.1 billion- Construction: 100 billion / year (x 5 years)- Delay costs: 500 billion / year
The Dam
How/where do we build the dam – A or B?
A B
Industrial
Survey: 0.1 billion
Construction: 100 b/ year (x 5)
Delay costs: 500 b/ year
[email protected] (Adapted from a case used by Yehezkel Dror in his workshops in statecraft professionalism)
Definition of a case
Content– 5 lines to 50 pages – Print, online, multimedia– Account of real circumstances– Presents context and development
but not outcome
Process– Student-centered– Active learning– Instructor as facilitator
Toxic Bosses
Academic approachhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YdcMsNokiIk
Consultant approachhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSi5R8txxmI&feature=related
Funny approachhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--nTCbAZpAw&feature=related
Real approach – Kevin Johnson “The results guy”http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=96890384
Robert Sterling Clark
3 Cases on nonprofit advocacy- Solid waste management- Foster care- Education funding
“Traditional” cases + multimedia support
Confidentiality issues