carlo scodanibbio presents: achieving quick change-overcarlo scodanibbio presents: ... total...
TRANSCRIPT
1
achieving quick achieving quick
changechange--overover
Carlo Carlo ScodanibbioScodanibbio presents:presents:
a training event organised by:a training event organised by:
the the ““secretsecret”” of Flow Production andof Flow Production and
the key that opens the door to Lean Manufacturingthe key that opens the door to Lean Manufacturing
clients are monstersclients are monsters……..
2
manufacturingmanufacturingyesterdayyesterday today/tomorrowtoday/tomorrow
Approach:Approach:
Make good products Make good products
cheaply and quicklycheaply and quickly
The present market cake is not
growing much larger, but varietyvariety is,
due to diversity of customers’ needs.
Besides, customers request and
expect shorter delivery schedulesshorter delivery schedules,
higher qualityhigher quality, and high reliabilityhigh reliability.
This dictates a “higher varietyhigher variety--small small
lotslots” style of production, featuring
high quality, speedy delivery and
assured safety/reliability.
PQCDS approachPQCDS approach(diversified PRODUCTS, of high (diversified PRODUCTS, of high
QUALITY, at low COST, with QUALITY, at low COST, with
speedy DELIVERY and assured speedy DELIVERY and assured
SAFETY/RELIABILITY)SAFETY/RELIABILITY)
QCD approachQCD approach(Quality (Quality -- Cost Cost -- Delivery)Delivery)
SellerSeller’’s Markets Market BuyerBuyer’’s Markets Market
Costs associated Costs associated
with with WasteWaste could could
be built into be built into
ProductProduct’’s prices price
Clients are no Clients are no
longer prepared to longer prepared to
subsidise subsidise
manufacturersmanufacturers’’
costs associated costs associated
with with WasteWaste
manufacturingmanufacturingyesterdayyesterday today/tomorrowtoday/tomorrow
3
Factory Management Factory Management
determines Production determines Production
CapacityCapacity
Costs + Profit = Selling PriceCosts + Profit = Selling Price
(Product(Product--Out approach)Out approach)
Customers determine Customers determine
Production Capacity Production Capacity
Selling Price Selling Price -- Profit = CostsProfit = Costs
(Market(Market--In approach)In approach)
(Estimate(Estimate--based Levelling)based Levelling) (Reality(Reality--based Levelling)based Levelling)
manufacturingmanufacturingyesterdayyesterday today/tomorrowtoday/tomorrow
Profit is something that Profit is something that
comes naturally out of comes naturally out of
the manufacturing and the manufacturing and
marketing processmarketing process
Profit is something Profit is something
that must be created that must be created
and earned through and earned through
hard workhard work
Manufacturing Cycle Manufacturing Cycle
TimeTime
>> Selling Cycle Time>> Selling Cycle Time
Manufacturing Cycle Manufacturing Cycle
Time Time
--> = Selling Cycle Time> = Selling Cycle Time
manufacturingmanufacturingyesterdayyesterday today/tomorrowtoday/tomorrow
4
ManufacturingManufacturing
is the businessis the business
of makingof making
productsproducts
ManufacturingManufacturing
is a is a
SERVICESERVICE
INDUSTRYINDUSTRY
manufacturingmanufacturingyesterdayyesterday today/tomorrowtoday/tomorrow
5
VAMVAM
VALUE ADDING VALUE ADDING
MANAGEMENTMANAGEMENT
6
the VAM approach to the productive processthe VAM approach to the productive process
process process
time time
analysisanalysis
homework ?homework ?
..oh, yes !!!..oh, yes !!!
7
SEWSEWSYSTEMATIC SYSTEMATIC
ELIMINATION OF WASTEELIMINATION OF WASTE
VALUE!VALUE!
8
9
SUMMARY OF THE MAIN TYPES OF WASTESUMMARY OF THE MAIN TYPES OF WASTE
��OverproductionOverproduction
��TransportationTransportation
��Waiting/idlingWaiting/idling
��DefectsDefects
��ControlControl
��MotionMotion
��UnUn--needed processing stepsneeded processing steps
��StockStock
WASTE WASTE –– THE TABLE OF EXCUSES THE TABLE OF EXCUSES -- OLDOLD1) That's the way we have always done it1) That's the way we have always done it
12) I wasn't hired to do that12) I wasn't hired to do that
11) I thought I told you11) I thought I told you
10) I'm so busy I just can't get around to it10) I'm so busy I just can't get around to it
9) I didn't think it was very important9) I didn't think it was very important
8) I forgot8) I forgot
7) Wait till the boss comes back & ask him7) Wait till the boss comes back & ask him
6) That's his job 6) That's his job -- not minenot mine
5) I am waiting for an OK5) I am waiting for an OK
4) No one told me to go ahead4) No one told me to go ahead
3) That's not in my department3) That's not in my department
2) I didn't know you were in a hurry for it2) I didn't know you were in a hurry for it
10
WASTE WASTE –– THE TABLE OF EXCUSES THE TABLE OF EXCUSES -- NEWNEW1) That's the way we have always done it1) That's the way we have always done it
12) All machines eventually give problems12) All machines eventually give problems
11) We must control quality or clients will complain11) We must control quality or clients will complain
10) Set10) Set--up time cannot be reduced furtherup time cannot be reduced further……..
9) We need stock: it9) We need stock: it’’s a good investments a good investment
8) Impossible8) Impossible
7) You mean we are stupid the way we do it???7) You mean we are stupid the way we do it???
6) Managers and consultants6) Managers and consultants……. Only able to mess us up. Only able to mess us up
5) We have tried in the past, and it didn5) We have tried in the past, and it didn’’t workt work……
4) Why change? We are already so busy4) Why change? We are already so busy……..
3) This way we know it works3) This way we know it works……..
2) There is no better way, believe me2) There is no better way, believe me……..
spot the waste!spot the waste!Manufacturing IndustryManufacturing Industry
11
PUSH and PULL PRODUCTION METHODSPUSH and PULL PRODUCTION METHODS
the productive process in manufacturingthe productive process in manufacturingsome definitionssome definitions
12
the productive process in manufacturingthe productive process in manufacturingsome definitionssome definitions
PUSH and PULL PRODUCTION METHODSPUSH and PULL PRODUCTION METHODS
the productive process in manufacturingthe productive process in manufacturingsome definitionssome definitions
PUSH and PULL PRODUCTION METHODSPUSH and PULL PRODUCTION METHODS
13
BATCH (PUSH) PRODUCTION vs. BATCH (PUSH) PRODUCTION vs.
CONTINUOUS FLOW (PULL) PRODUCTIONCONTINUOUS FLOW (PULL) PRODUCTION
the productive process in manufacturingthe productive process in manufacturing
ONON--TIME DELIVERY RATE (OTDR)TIME DELIVERY RATE (OTDR)Degree of reliabilityreliability of any upstream operation to release in due time its output
to a downstream operation.
A Flow System may compound problems and reduce considerably the overall
process’ OTDR unless the entire process is improved/streamlined:
the productive process in manufacturingthe productive process in manufacturingsome definitionssome definitions
14
““batch productionbatch production”” vs. vs.
““oneone--piece flowpiece flow””
LEAN MANUFACTURING LEAN MANUFACTURING
and FLOW PRODUCTIONand FLOW PRODUCTION
the target:the target:
p i p e l i n e f l o wp i p e l i n e f l o w
c o n t i n u o u s f l o wc o n t i n u o u s f l o w
15
Lean Manufacturing uses less of everything Lean Manufacturing uses less of everything
compared with mass production:compared with mass production:
half the human effort in the factory, half the half the human effort in the factory, half the
manufacturing floor space, half the investment manufacturing floor space, half the investment
in tools, half the engineering hours to develop in tools, half the engineering hours to develop
a new product in half the time. a new product in half the time.
Also it requires keeping far less than half the Also it requires keeping far less than half the
needed inventory and results in fewer needed inventory and results in fewer
defectsdefects……....
the the ““SOCOSOCO”” (5S) approach(5S) approach
16
a a socosoco storystory
a a socosoco factoryfactory
17
HEAVY MECHANISATION / HEAVY MECHANISATION /
AUTOMATIONAUTOMATION
LEAN MANUFACTURING LEAN MANUFACTURING
and TPMand TPM
TOTAL PRODUCTIVE MAINTENANCETOTAL PRODUCTIVE MAINTENANCE
THE 6 BIG LOSSESTHE 6 BIG LOSSES
18
THE 6 BIG LOSSESTHE 6 BIG LOSSES
THE 6 BIG LOSSESTHE 6 BIG LOSSES
19
ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGEACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
changechange--over timeover time
= interval of time elapsed between = interval of time elapsed between
production of production of last defectlast defect--free itemfree item
(product, by(product, by--product, workproduct, work--piece....) piece....)
of of previous lotprevious lot, and , and first defectfirst defect--free free
itemitem of of next lotnext lot
definitionsdefinitions
20
1. Changing1. Changing--over efficiently over efficiently
and effectively requires a and effectively requires a
high level of knowledge high level of knowledge
and ability, which areand ability, which are
the result of long the result of long
training and experiencetraining and experience
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
2. Producing in large lots2. Producing in large lots
mitigates the effects andmitigates the effects and
counterbalances the costscounterbalances the costs
of long c/o timesof long c/o times
21
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
3. Producing with the 3. Producing with the
criterion of "economic lot criterion of "economic lot
size" does also size" does also
counterbalance the cost counterbalance the cost
of (large) inventory, of (large) inventory,
consequent to largeconsequent to large--lotlot
productionproduction
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
E.L.S. (ECONOMIC LOT SIZE) = E.O.Q. (ECONOMIC ORDER QUANTITY)E.L.S. (ECONOMIC LOT SIZE) = E.O.Q. (ECONOMIC ORDER QUANTITY)
22
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
23
large lot result: mitigation of negative effects large lot result: mitigation of negative effects
of (long) setof (long) set--up times and associated costsup times and associated costs
EXAMPLE 1
SETUP
TIME
LOT
SIZE
PRINCIPAL
OPERATION
TIME (PER ITEM)
OVERALL OPERATION TIME
(PER ITEM)
%
IMPR
%
%
IMPR
%
3 hrs 100 1 min 1 min + (3 x 60)/100 = 2,8 min 100 /
3 hrs 1.000 1 min 1 min + (3 x 60)/1.000 = 1,18 min 42 58 100 /
3 hrs 10.000 1 min 1 min + (3 x 60)/10.000 = 1,018 min 36 64 86 14
EXAMPLE 2
SETUP TIME
LOT SIZE
PRINCIPAL
OPERATION TIME (PER ITEM)
OVERALL OPERATION TIME (PER ITEM)
%
IMPR %
%
IMPR %
6 hrs 100 1 min 1 min + (6 x 60)/100 = 4,6 min 100 /
6 hrs 1.000 1 min 1 min + (6 x 60)/1.000 = 1,36 min 30 70 100 /
6 hrs 10.000 1 min 1 min + (6 x 60)/10.000 = 1,036 min 23 77 76 24
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
considerationsconsiderations
�increasing the size of a small lot brings a
substantial improvement to the (unit) overall
operation time - but with further lot size increases,
the rate of improvement decreases
��increasing the size of a small lot brings a increasing the size of a small lot brings a
substantial improvement to the (unit) overall substantial improvement to the (unit) overall
operation time operation time -- but but with further lot size increaseswith further lot size increases, ,
the rate of improvement decreasesthe rate of improvement decreases
�the longer the set-up time, the more effective the
benefits of increasing lot size
��the the longer the setlonger the set--up timeup time, the , the more effective the more effective the
benefitsbenefits of increasing lot sizeof increasing lot size
�in any case, with traditional approach to set-up
activities, large-lot production apparently is the
best method to reduce and even minimise the
negative effects of set-up
��in any case, in any case, with traditional approach to setwith traditional approach to set--upup
activities, largeactivities, large--lot production apparently is the lot production apparently is the
best method to reduce and even minimise the best method to reduce and even minimise the
negative effects of setnegative effects of set--upup
24
common assumption: changecommon assumption: change--over time cannot be over time cannot be
drastically reduceddrastically reduced
BUT IT CAN !!BUT IT CAN !!
OBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/OOBSOLETE, TRADITIONAL ASSUMPTIONS ON C/O
if a 3 hrs setif a 3 hrs set--up time can be reduced to 3 minutes, up time can be reduced to 3 minutes,
producing in large lots would be meaninglessproducing in large lots would be meaningless
�and days of limited product variety
and large-scale mass production are
gone forever ....!!
��and days of limited product variety and days of limited product variety
and largeand large--scale mass production are scale mass production are
gone forever ....!!gone forever ....!!
MAIN TYPES OF CHANGEMAIN TYPES OF CHANGE--OVER OPERATIONSOVER OPERATIONS
1. EXCHANGING DIES & BLADES1. EXCHANGING DIES & BLADES: dies, moulds, drill bits, : dies, moulds, drill bits, sawbladessawblades
and other tools, silkand other tools, silk--screening plates, etc. screening plates, etc. -- also: cleaning and replacing also: cleaning and replacing
filters (ex. in plastic extruders) and similar operations which filters (ex. in plastic extruders) and similar operations which cause a cause a
temporary halt to production.temporary halt to production.
2. CHANGING STANDARD PARAMETERS2. CHANGING STANDARD PARAMETERS: in NC machines, dairy : in NC machines, dairy
processes, chemical processes.....processes, chemical processes.....
3. "SWITCHOVER" or "RE3. "SWITCHOVER" or "RE--TOOLING"TOOLING": :
in assembly lines in assembly lines -- includes exchanging supplies of components and includes exchanging supplies of components and
materials, assembly jigs and equipment, etc.materials, assembly jigs and equipment, etc.
in certain machines in certain machines –– includes new material feed to machine (includes new material feed to machine (f.if.i. new . new
rolls of paper in winders, or new rolls of paper/material/plastirolls of paper in winders, or new rolls of paper/material/plastic films in c films in
printers, etc.printers, etc.
4. GENERAL SET4. GENERAL SET--UPUP prior to manufacturing: arranging the equipment, prior to manufacturing: arranging the equipment,
assigning tasks, checking drawings & work schedules, etc.assigning tasks, checking drawings & work schedules, etc.
25
1. PREPARATION, CHECKING OF PARTS, TOOLS & 1. PREPARATION, CHECKING OF PARTS, TOOLS &
MATERIALS, AND AFTERMATERIALS, AND AFTER--PROCESS ACTIVITIESPROCESS ACTIVITIES
4. TRIAL RUNS AND ADJUSTEMENTS4. TRIAL RUNS AND ADJUSTEMENTS
3. MEASUREMENTS, SETTINGS AND CALIBRATIONS3. MEASUREMENTS, SETTINGS AND CALIBRATIONS
2. REMOVING AND MOUNTING PARTS, DIES, TOOLS, 2. REMOVING AND MOUNTING PARTS, DIES, TOOLS,
MATERIALS......MATERIALS......
4 BASIC STEPS IN THE CHANGE4 BASIC STEPS IN THE CHANGE--OVER PROCESSOVER PROCESS
every setevery set--up operation generally includes:up operation generally includes:
effects of long seteffects of long set--upsups
26
ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGEACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
��INTERNAL CHANGEINTERNAL CHANGE--OVER OPERATIONSOVER OPERATIONS
Those that cannot be implemented unless the Those that cannot be implemented unless the
process is stoppedprocess is stopped
��WASTEWASTE
Inessential operations (not necessary, or Inessential operations (not necessary, or
operations that could be avoided or eliminated) and operations that could be avoided or eliminated) and
wasteful operations inherent in the two classes wasteful operations inherent in the two classes
above. Examples: waiting for a forkabove. Examples: waiting for a fork--lift, searching lift, searching
for jigs and tools, unfor jigs and tools, un--necessary adjustments.......necessary adjustments.......
��EXTERNAL CHANGEEXTERNAL CHANGE--OVER OPERATIONSOVER OPERATIONS
Those that can be implemented independently of Those that can be implemented independently of
the processthe process
today's classification of changetoday's classification of change--over operationsover operations
INTERNAL CHANGEINTERNAL CHANGE--OVER TIMEOVER TIME
throughout this time throughout this time no no
value is added to productsvalue is added to products
Interval of time during which Interval of time during which the productive the productive
process stopsprocess stops: this : this should beshould be the real and proper the real and proper
changechange--over timeover time, that begins when the current , that begins when the current
lot process finishes, and ends when the next lot lot process finishes, and ends when the next lot
process produces the 1st defectprocess produces the 1st defect--free item.free item.
definitionsdefinitions
27
EXTERNAL CHANGEEXTERNAL CHANGE--OVER TIMEOVER TIME
part of this time may elapse before Internal part of this time may elapse before Internal
ChangeChange--Over Time, and part afterOver Time, and part after
Interval of time during processing (of previous Interval of time during processing (of previous
and next lot), during which and next lot), during which changechange--over related over related
activitiesactivities (like transport, preparation, etc.) may (like transport, preparation, etc.) may
and and should beshould be implemented by various implemented by various
personnel (fitters, workers, operators....).personnel (fitters, workers, operators....).
definitionsdefinitions
OVERALL CHANGEOVERALL CHANGE--OVER TIME OVER TIME = = Internal ChangeInternal Change--Over Time + Over Time +
External ChangeExternal Change--Over Time.Over Time.
definitionsdefinitions
28
ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGEACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
objectivesobjectives
streamlinestreamline (essential) (essential) external c/o activitiesexternal c/o activities
eliminateeliminate/minimise /minimise adjustmentsadjustments
minimise timeminimise time required for (essential) required for (essential) internal c/o activitiesinternal c/o activities
make make easyeasy all c/o operations, so that they can be implemented all c/o operations, so that they can be implemented
by medium/lowby medium/low--skilled workersskilled workers
eliminate eliminate wastewaste
ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGEACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
objectivesobjectives
streamlinestreamline (essential) (essential) external c/o activitiesexternal c/o activities
eliminateeliminate/minimise /minimise adjustmentsadjustments
minimise timeminimise time required for (essential) required for (essential) internal c/o activitiesinternal c/o activities
make make easyeasy all c/o operations, so that they can be implemented all c/o operations, so that they can be implemented
by medium/lowby medium/low--skilled workersskilled workers
eliminate eliminate wastewaste
29
flow production and quick changeflow production and quick change--overover
the missing link...the missing link...Charlie Rev. 0 Charlie Rev. 0
22 minutes22 minutes
traditional improvement traditional improvement
vs. AQCO improvementvs. AQCO improvement
30
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 1.STEP 1. FORM a QCO IMPROVEMENT TEAMFORM a QCO IMPROVEMENT TEAM
STEP 6.STEP 6. STREAMLINE EXTERNAL C/OSTREAMLINE EXTERNAL C/O
STEP 5.STEP 5. STREAMLINE REMAINING INTERNAL STREAMLINE REMAINING INTERNAL
C/OC/O
STEP 4.STEP 4. TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO
EXTERNAL C/OEXTERNAL C/O
STEP 3.STEP 3. GET RID OF WASTEFUL OPERATIONS GET RID OF WASTEFUL OPERATIONS
(eliminate most of them with the SOCO method)(eliminate most of them with the SOCO method)
STEP 2.STEP 2. ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS
(and categorise them: internal (and categorise them: internal -- external external -- waste)waste)
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 1.STEP 1. FORM a QCO IMPROVEMENT TEAMFORM a QCO IMPROVEMENT TEAM
STEP 6.STEP 6. STREAMLINE EXTERNAL C/OSTREAMLINE EXTERNAL C/O
STEP 5.STEP 5. STREAMLINE REMAINING INTERNAL STREAMLINE REMAINING INTERNAL
C/OC/O
STEP 4.STEP 4. TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO
EXTERNAL C/OEXTERNAL C/O
STEP 3.STEP 3. GET RID OF WASTEFUL OPERATIONS GET RID OF WASTEFUL OPERATIONS
(eliminate most of them with the SOCO method)(eliminate most of them with the SOCO method)
STEP 2.STEP 2. ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS
(and categorise them: internal (and categorise them: internal -- external external -- waste)waste)
handle handle aqcoaqco as as
a project!a project!
31
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 1.STEP 1. FORM a QCO IMPROVEMENT TEAMFORM a QCO IMPROVEMENT TEAM
key pointskey points
Primary Team + subPrimary Team + sub--TeamsTeams
CoCo--ordination!ordination!
Pilot Project?Pilot Project?
AQCO Project Manager + subAQCO Project Manager + sub--Project ManagersProject Managers
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 2.STEP 2. ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS
(and categorise them: internal (and categorise them: internal -- external external -- waste)waste)
key pointskey points
PRELIMINARY ANALYSISPRELIMINARY ANALYSIS
••list all current c/o operationslist all current c/o operations
••establish most critical ones and assign priorities to the establish most critical ones and assign priorities to the qcoqco team team
by using aby using a
changechange--over summary tableover summary table
32
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 2.STEP 2. ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS
(and categorise them: internal (and categorise them: internal -- external external -- waste)waste)
key pointskey points
PRELIMINARY ANALYSISPRELIMINARY ANALYSIS
••if necessary, or in case of large discrepancies between if necessary, or in case of large discrepancies between
c/o durations (for the same c/o code), analyse further c/o durations (for the same c/o code), analyse further
certain c/o operations using acertain c/o operations using a
changechange--over timetable & comparison chartover timetable & comparison chart
33
34
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 2.STEP 2. ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS
(and categorise them: internal (and categorise them: internal -- external external -- waste)waste)
key pointskey points
ININ--DEPTH ANALYSIS OF C/O OPERATIONSDEPTH ANALYSIS OF C/O OPERATIONS
••using VCR extensively, analyse in detail c/o operation using VCR extensively, analyse in detail c/o operation
with awith a
changechange--over operations analysis chartover operations analysis chart
35
36
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 2.STEP 2. ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS ANALYSE CURRENT C/O OPERATIONS
(and categorise them: internal (and categorise them: internal -- external external -- waste)waste)
key pointskey points
ININ--DEPTH ANALYSIS OF C/O OPERATIONSDEPTH ANALYSIS OF C/O OPERATIONS
••Brainstorming: team members to fill an appropriateBrainstorming: team members to fill an appropriate
changechange--over improvement listover improvement list
37
38
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 4.STEP 4. TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO
EXTERNAL C/OEXTERNAL C/O
STEP 3.STEP 3. GET RID OF WASTEFUL OPERATIONS GET RID OF WASTEFUL OPERATIONS
(eliminate most of them with the SOCO method)(eliminate most of them with the SOCO method)
key pointskey points
••Kill Kill ““Preparation WastePreparation Waste”” & & ““Cleanup WasteCleanup Waste”” using theusing the
SOCO methodSOCO method
STEP 6.STEP 6. STREAMLINE EXTERNAL C/OSTREAMLINE EXTERNAL C/O
39
CHANGECHANGE--OVER CHECKOVER CHECK--TABLETABLE
C/O SOCO CHECKC/O SOCO CHECK--TABLESTABLES
dedicated diededicated die--change cartchange cart
40
C/O SOCO CHECKC/O SOCO CHECK--TABLESTABLES
external drillexternal drill--bits changebits change--overover
back to Charlieback to Charlie……
rev. 1rev. 1Charlie Rev. 1 Charlie Rev. 1
4 minutes4 minutes
41
42
6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE6 PRACTICAL STEPS FOR ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE--OVEROVER
STEP 5.STEP 5. STREAMLINE REMAINING INTERNAL STREAMLINE REMAINING INTERNAL
C/OC/Okey pointskey points
••kill waste in internal c/o operations kill waste in internal c/o operations
ADJUSTMENT ADJUSTMENT
WASTEWASTE
REPLACEMENT REPLACEMENT
WASTEWASTE
bolts fighting!bolts fighting! pokapoka--yoke!yoke!
boltsbolts--fighting checkfighting check--listlistA) AVOID THE NEED (= ELIMINATE)A) AVOID THE NEED (= ELIMINATE)
••Can we go for any other type of fastener?Can we go for any other type of fastener?
••Can we use a (mechanical, hydraulic) clamp?Can we use a (mechanical, hydraulic) clamp?
••Can we rather use a vice?Can we rather use a vice?
••What else can be used instead of bolts (& nuts, screws...)?What else can be used instead of bolts (& nuts, screws...)?
••Can we eliminate bolts altogether?Can we eliminate bolts altogether?
••Can we rather use a wedge, a taper pin, a knockCan we rather use a wedge, a taper pin, a knock--pin, spring and pin, spring and
checkcheck--pin, spring and cam.......pin, spring and cam.......
••Can we possibly use a magnet? And vacuum suction?Can we possibly use a magnet? And vacuum suction?
••How can we create an interlock?How can we create an interlock?
••May be with a groove and checkMay be with a groove and check--spring?spring?
••What about going for a "snapWhat about going for a "snap--in" cassette style method?in" cassette style method?
43
boltsbolts--fighting checkfighting check--listlistB) IMPROVEB) IMPROVE
••Do we really need all these bolts, or can we reduce their numberDo we really need all these bolts, or can we reduce their number??
••Can we reduce the time spent to tighten and fasten bolts?Can we reduce the time spent to tighten and fasten bolts?
••Can we do without tools?Can we do without tools?
••Can we build a tool into the bolt (nut, screw......)Can we build a tool into the bolt (nut, screw......)
••Can we reduce the number of turns of this bolt?Can we reduce the number of turns of this bolt?
••Can we make bolts shorter?Can we make bolts shorter?
••Can we do it with only three turns? And one only? And 1/3 only?Can we do it with only three turns? And one only? And 1/3 only?
••Can we avoid to remove nuts and washers?Can we avoid to remove nuts and washers?
boltsbolts--fighting checkfighting check--listlistB) IMPROVEB) IMPROVE
••Can we use a "slipCan we use a "slip--off" bolt (the "Uoff" bolt (the "U--slot" method)?slot" method)?
••Can we avoid to remove bolts? Can they stay there?Can we avoid to remove bolts? Can they stay there?
••Can we go for a "pearCan we go for a "pear--shaped" hole method?shaped" hole method?
••Can we use the "C" (or "U") washer method?Can we use the "C" (or "U") washer method?
••Can we use sliding bolts with sideCan we use sliding bolts with side--slots/groves slots/groves
(The Split(The Split--Thread Method)?Thread Method)?
44
pokapoka--yokeyoke
45
MISTAKEMISTAKE--PROOFING IN EVERYDAYPROOFING IN EVERYDAY’’S LIFES LIFE
MISTAKEMISTAKE--PROOFING IN EVERYDAYPROOFING IN EVERYDAY’’S LIFES LIFE
46
MISTAKEMISTAKE--PROOFING IN EVERYDAYPROOFING IN EVERYDAY’’S LIFES LIFE
POKAPOKA--YOKE APPLICATIONSYOKE APPLICATIONS
47
POKAPOKA--YOKE APPLICATIONSYOKE APPLICATIONS
back to Charlieback to Charlie……
rev. 2rev. 2Charlie Rev. 2 Charlie Rev. 2
2 minutes2 minutes
48
49
back to Charlieback to Charlie……
rev. 3rev. 3Charlie Rev. 3 Charlie Rev. 3
1,4 minutes1,4 minutes
50
back to Charlieback to Charlie……
rev. 4rev. 4Charlie Rev. 4 Charlie Rev. 4
10 seconds10 seconds
51
52
from SMED to OTEDfrom SMED to OTED
Charlie Rev. 5 Charlie Rev. 5
1 second1 second
is it possible?is it possible?
7 RULES FOR AQCO7 RULES FOR AQCORULE 1.RULE 1. C/O BEGINS AND ENDS WITH THE C/O BEGINS AND ENDS WITH THE SOCO METHODSOCO METHOD
RULE 2.RULE 2. TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO EXTERNAL C/O, TRANSFORM INTERNAL C/O INTO EXTERNAL C/O,
AND AND ONLY THENONLY THEN IMPROVE REMAINING INTERNAL C/OIMPROVE REMAINING INTERNAL C/O
RULE 3.RULE 3. BOLTS ARE OUR ENEMYBOLTS ARE OUR ENEMY
RULE 4.RULE 4. IF YOU HAVE TO USE YOUR HANDS, MAKE SURE IF YOU HAVE TO USE YOUR HANDS, MAKE SURE
YOUR FEET STAY PUTYOUR FEET STAY PUT
RULE 5.RULE 5. ELIMINATE THE NEED FOR SPECIAL FINEELIMINATE THE NEED FOR SPECIAL FINE--TUNING TUNING
SKILLSSKILLS
RULE 6.RULE 6. STANDARDS ARE STANDARDSSTANDARDS ARE STANDARDS, MEANT TO BE , MEANT TO BE
KEPT AND RESPECTEDKEPT AND RESPECTED
RULE 7.RULE 7. STANDARDISE C/O OPERATIONS IN SUCH A WAY STANDARDISE C/O OPERATIONS IN SUCH A WAY
THAT THAT ANYBODYANYBODY CAN IMPLEMENT THEMCAN IMPLEMENT THEM
53
2 BEST RULES FOR AQCO2 BEST RULES FOR AQCO
do not spend money on do not spend money on
aqcoaqco, use your brain!, use your brain!
do it right now!do it right now!
a QCO casea QCO casepositioning jig for automated positioning jig for automated
robotrobot--welding of silencerswelding of silencers
54
QCOQCOdream or reality?dream or reality?
AQCO and PEOPLEAQCO and PEOPLE
and: the importance of Top Management commitment and: the importance of Top Management commitment
in implementing an AQCO programin implementing an AQCO program
55
a practical model for TEIa practical model for TEI
56
achieving quick changeachieving quick change--overoverA course presented by Carlo A course presented by Carlo ScodanibbioScodanibbio
Organised by:Organised by:
CREDITSCREDITS
The documentary material of this course is based on papers and wThe documentary material of this course is based on papers and works of:orks of:
and on personal experience and development by Carlo and on personal experience and development by Carlo ScodanibbioScodanibbio
MUSIC BYMUSIC BY
Bach Bach –– Barry Barry -- Beethoven Beethoven –– Grieg Grieg –– HaydinHaydin -- Mozart Mozart –– MuffatMuffat –– Paganini Paganini -- Ponchielli Ponchielli ––
RimskyRimsky--Korsakov Korsakov -- Rossini Rossini –– R. Strauss R. Strauss -- Verdi Verdi -- Vivaldi Vivaldi –– Wagner & othersWagner & others
Copyright Copyright ©© Carlo Carlo ScodanibbioScodanibbio 20092009
57
achieving quick achieving quick
changechange--overover
““““““““a cultural revolutiona cultural revolutiona cultural revolutiona cultural revolutiona cultural revolutiona cultural revolutiona cultural revolutiona cultural revolution””””””””
ACHIEVING QUICK CHANGE-OVERPower Point Presentation by Carlo Scodanibbio
Copyright: © Carlo Scodanibbio 2008/09 – All rights reserved
A simple copyright statement: you are authorised to install this presentation in one computer station only.
You are authorised to print this entire presentation and copy it for exclusive use by employees of your Organisation.
You are not authorised to distribute this presentation - by electronic or other means and supports - outside your Organisation.
http://www.scodanibbio.com
More Power Point presentations at:
http://www.scodanibbio.com/site/present.html
Articles by Carlo Scodanibbio at:
http://www.scodanibbio.com/site/articles.html
E-courses and e-books by Carlo Scodanibbio at:
http://www.scodanibbio.com/site/e_courses.html