byzantium between east and west: competing hellenisms in the alexiad of anna komnene and her...
DESCRIPTION
in East Meets West in the Middle Agesand the Early Modern Period, vol. 12 of series: Fundamentals of Medieval andEarly Modern Culture, ed. by Albrecht Classen and Marilyn Sandidge (Berlin and New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2013), 263-87.TRANSCRIPT
-
Byzantium between East and West: Competing Hellenisms in the Alexiad of Anna Komnene and her Contemporaries, in East Meets West in the Middle Ages and the Early Modern Period, vol. 12 of series: Fundamentals of Medieval and Early Modern Culture, ed. by Albrecht Classen and Marilyn Sandidge (Berlin and New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2013), 263-87.
-
Chapter3GlenM.Cooper
(BrighamYoungUniversity,Provo,Utah)
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest:CompetingHellenismsintheAlexiadofAnnaKomneneandherContemporaries
Introduction
Inrecentyears,theAlexiadofAnnaKomnene(1083ca.1153)hasundergoneamuchneededreassessment. Long held to be either Annas merely edited version of her deceasedhusbandsresearchnotesanddrafts,or thedistortedproductionofanhysterical,bitterwoman,undermorecarefulscrutinytheworkhasbeenshowntobeavaluablehistoricalresource,authoredbyahighlyeducatedandintelligentwoman.Theworkrequirescarefulandnuancedinterpretation,however,consideringboththecontextofthetimewhenitwascomposed(midtolate1140s),aswellasitsrhetoricalfeatures.Thepicturethathasemergedinrecentscholarshipisofacarefullycraftedworkwithathreefoldpurpose(atleast):arehabilitationofherfatherAlexiosIs(r.10811118)memoryontheonehand,acriticismofhernephewManuelIs(r.114380)policiesontheother,andanoveralldepictionofwhattheidealByzantineruleroughttobe.Inaddition,heraccountoftheWesterncrusadersprovidesvaluableinsightintoEastWestperceptions.Oneaspectofthiscriticismhasnotreceivedmuchattention,however.Itiswellknown
thatemperorManuelcultivatedmedicineandastrologyathiscourt,andthatheactuallypracticedmedical treatment successfully. It is alsowell known thatAnna included amedicallyinformedanddetailedaccountofherfathersdeathintheAlexiad.Whatseemstohaveescapednoticeisthatsheactuallystructuresmuchofhernarrativearoundacomplexmedicalanalogythat,togetherwiththedeathaccount,supportthetwofoldpurposeofthetext.Furthermore, therewas a contest overwhich form ofHellenism, i.e., revivedGreek
culture,wouldnotonlydominatetheByzantinecourt,butthewholeofChristendomaswell:apurelyGreekHellenismontheonehand,orsomemixtureofGreek,Arabic,andLatin
-
GlenM.Cooper264
Hellenism thatwas being imported from theWest on the other. For the sake of thisdiscussion, the former will be called Eastern Hellenism, and the latter, WesternHellenism.IshalldemonstratehowtheAlexiadwasastrategicmoveinthiscontest.AttheByzantinecourt,thiscontestwaspartofanideologicalstruggleoverwhichbranchoftheKomnenos familywasmost suited to rule.Tiedup in thiswereAnnas andManuelsfundamentallydifferent attitudes toward thewesternLatins.Manuel isknown forhisopennesstotheLatinsandtheirways,whilestillassertinghimselfastheirintellectualandideological superior, onewhom they ought to recognize as the rightful leader of theChristian world. Greek learning, and especially expertise in medical and astrologicalknowledge,werehighlyvisibleelementsofthatpersona.Anna,ontheotherhand,presentsherfatherashandlingtheLatins,whoareunquestionablydangerousbarbarians,withamorecannydistrust,holdingthemandtheircultureatarmslength.Asshemakesclearonnearly every page, via herAtticizing language and frequent classical allusions,GreeklearningrightfullybelongsonlytothesophisticatedByzantineculture.Iargueherethat:1)inthefaceofEmperorManuelsflamboyantandpublicdisplaysof
medical knowledge, Anna asserts in the Alexiad her own medical competence andknowledgeofnaturalphilosophytoshowthatshe,too,isfittorule,perhaps,asakindofphilosopherking.Implicitinheraccountistheassumptionthattheidealruleroughttohavemedicallearning.And2)eventhoughAlexiosisnotknowntohavehadanymedicalknowledgeperse,AnnaarguesthathefunctionedassomethingfarmoreimportantforthehealthoftheEmpire:hewasaphysicianfortheillsofstate.Myargumentshallproceedasfollows:afterreviewingthehistoricalcontextfortwelfth
centuryByzantineintellectuallife,includingdiscussingtheflavorsofHellenism,Annasbiographywillbediscussedbriefly,withthemostattentiondevotedtoherabortiveattempttoseizepowerafterherfathersdeath.Hersubsequentcareeristhendescribed,includingthecompositionoftheAlexiadaswellastheintellectualcircleshefostered.ThecareerofManuel isreviewed,with focusonhis interests inmedicineandastrology. In themainsectionofthisarticle,theAlexiaditselfisconsidered,intermsofthemedicalconceptsthatstructureit,aswellasthemedicalknowledgeexhibitedinAnnasdescriptionofherfathersfinalillnessanddeath.
HellenisminTwelfthCenturyByzantineSocietyTheKomnenianperiodwasoneofrevivalofByzantineculture,continuing,inlargemeasure,therevivalbegununderthepreviousMacedoniandynasty(8671056),duringwhichperiodthe careerofMichaelPsellos (1018ca.1078), the restorerofphilosophy,was especiallyimportant.The intellectualactivityof theKomnenianperiod,moreover,wassignificant
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 265
enoughtobelabeledtheThirdSophisticinarecentstudyoftheperiod.1Centraltothatrevivalwasarenaissanceofinterestintheintellectuallegacyofclassicalantiquity,namely,Hellenism,anemulation,toonedegreeoranother,ofancientGreekwritersandthinkers.Thisrevivalwas,however,temperedwithareligiousdimensionaswell,apurgingofthesinsofcourt,suchasastrologyandimmorality,inanefforttocourtthefavorsofheaveninordertoensurethesurvivaloftheEmpire,whichhadbeenendangeredbysuch,asitwasthought.Theheresy trials thatoccurred throughout,however,aswellas theassociatedcondemnationsofspecificGreekphilosophicaldoctrines,indicatethatnoteveryaspectofHellenismwastolerated.Nevertheless,astrologycontinuedtobepracticed,even,asIshallshow,byanemperor(Manuel),moreover,animperialprincess,AnnaKomnene,studiedunapprovedclassicalliterature,againstherparentswishes.Thus,therewerecompetingversionsofHellenisminByzantium,whichdifferedintheirdegreeofcompatibilitywiththeOrthodoxChristianestablishment.
GrecoArabicTranslationsandtheRevivalofHellenismAnArabicformofHellenismdeveloped intheeighthtoninthcenturies intheAbbasidCaliphate,asaproductofthetranslationmovementthatwasthenoccurringinBaghdad.Ineffect, Arabic thinkers had translated much Greek philosophical literature, studied itcarefully,andtransformeditintoamoreusefulform.WhileitispresentlyunclearpreciselyhowthismovementaffectedByzantium,itdoesseemtohavebeenacontributingfactorspurringontheMacedonianRenaissance,bothonanideologicallevel:Howcanweallowtheinfideltooutdouswithourownlegacy?,aswellasonapracticallevel,byprovidingamarketforGreekmanuscripts,somecopyingeffortofwhichseemstohavebeendirectedtowardpatronsintheCaliphate.2D.GutashasobservedacorrelationbetweentheearliestextantGreekminusculemanuscriptsand theearliestGreek texts translated intoArabic,whichisprobablynotmerecoincidence.AnimportantquestionishowmuchdidIslamicintellectualactivitiesaffectByzantium,
andbywhatmeans?WhiletherewereArabsinByzantium,astradersanddiplomats,theevidencefortheirinvolvementasintermediariesisslimandunderexplored,unlikethatofthe later Palaiologan period.3 Other more promising leads are found in the imperialembassiesthathaddirectexchangesbetweenConstantinopleandBaghdad.4Anotherfeature
1 AnthonyKaldellis,HellenisminByzantium:TheTransformationofGreekIdentityandtheReceptionoftheClassicalTradition(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2007),Chapter5,i.e.,225316.
2 DimitriGutas,GreekThought,ArabicCulture:TheGraecoArabicTranslationMovement inBaghdadandEarlyAbbasidSociety(2nd4th/8th10thcenturies)(LondonandNewYork:Routledge,1998),17586.
3 MariaMavroudi,ExchangeswithArabicWritersduringtheLateByzantinePeriod,Byzantium,FaithandPower(12611557):PerspectivesonLateByzantineArtandCulture,ed.S.T.Brooks(NewYork:TheMetropolitanMuseumofArt;NewHaven,NJ:YaleUniversityPress,2006),6275.
4 Someoftheseexchangesarediscussedin:PaulMagdalino,TheRoadtoBaghdadintheThoughtWorldof
-
GlenM.Cooper266
oftherivalrybetweenBaghdadandConstantinopleisthatembellishedaccountsofsuchexchangesexaggerate the intellectual levelof theByzantines,suggesting that theywereagitatedby thesituation,sinceBaghdadandwhat itrepresentedasacreativecenterofintellectuallifeseemstohaveexcitedtheirenvy.Weareonfirmergroundwithwelldocumentedcasesof influenceandexchange.For
example,SymeonSeth(fl.2ndhalfoftheeleventhcentury)wasaconduitforsomeideasfromtheEast,includingastrologicalideas.5SethwasfromAntioch,andhadacareerasatranslatorfromArabictoGreek,translatingtheKalilawaDimnastory,6andalsoauthoringamanualofdietforEmperorMichaelDoukas(r.107178),whichincludesmaterialderivedfromArabic.7HeissaidtohavetraveledtoEgypttoobserveaneclipse(1058).Howeverthatmayhavebeen,bythetwelfthcentury,HellenismwasaliveissueforByzantineintellectuals.ThereisasmatteringofevidencesuggestingthatastronomicalideasfromtheIslamicworldhadenteredtheByzantineintellectualworldevenbeforethecareerofMichaelPsellos.8ThepeculiarlyArabicHellenism thatdeveloped inBaghdadwasmore thansimplya
translationofGreektreatisesintoArabic.Rather,itwasanoriginalcreationoutofexistingmaterials. The Arab thinker alKind (d. ca. 873) has been credited with discoveringphilosophy and founding an original,Arabic, school out of the texts thatwere beingdiscovered and translated. He could not have been part of an ancient philosophicaltraditionPeripatetic,Epicurean,Stoic,orAcademic,sincetheseschoolshadalldiedoutinlateantiquity.Instead,modelinghisapproachafterthattakenbyEuclidinhispresentationofgeometricalconcepts,heassembledwhateverpiecesoftheGreektraditionsuitedhisresearchneeds.9Apolymathwithuniversalinterests,however,alKindsthoughtwentintodecline within a century of his death, when Aristotles texts appeared in Baghdad.Nevertheless,thegroundworkthathelaidmadeArabicAristotelianismaswellasthewholeArabicscientificandphilosophicalenterprisepossible.
NinthCenturyByzantium,Byzantium in theNinthCentury:Dead orAlive?, ed.L.Brubaker (Aldershot:Ashgate,1998),195213.
5 AccordingtoAlexiad,6.7:AnnaComnena,AnnaeComnenaeAlexias,ed.A.KambylisandD.R.Reinsch,vol.XL.1,CorpusFontiumHistoriaeByzantinae.SeriesBerolinensis,(BerlinandNewYork:WalterdeGruyter,2001),18182.Englishtranslation:AnnaKomnene,TheAlexiad,trans.E.R.A.Sewter;rev.PeterFrankopan,reviseded.PenguinClassics(London:Penguin,2009),16465.
6 SimeonSeth,StephanitesundIchnelates:berlieferungsgeschichteundText,trans.LarsOlofSjberg(Uppsala:Almqvist&Wiksell,1962).
7 MarcmileProsperLouisBrunet,SimonSeth,mdecindelempereurMichelDoucas;savie,sonoeuvre.PremiretraductionenfranaisdutraitRecueildespropritsdesalimentsparordrealphabtique(Bordeaux:Delmas,1939).
8 NigelG.Wilson,ScholarsofByzantium,Reviseded.(LondonandCambridge,MA:DuckworthandMedievalAcademyofAmerica,1996),165.
9 DimitriGutas,GeometryandtheRebirthofPhilosophyinArabicwithalKindi,Words,TextsandConceptsCruisingtheMediterraneanSea:StudiesontheSources,ContentsandInfluencesofIslamicCivilizationandArabicPhilosophyandScience,ed.R.ArnzenandJ.Thielmann(Leuven:Peeters,2004),195209;here195.Seealso:Gutas,OriginsinBaghdad,TheCambridgeHistoryofMedievalPhilosophy,ed.RobertPasnau(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2010),1125.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 267
The careerofalKind findsa curiousparallel in the figureof theByzantineMichaelPsellos.AproductoftheMacedonianRenaissance,Psellostowersoverhiscontemporariesinthebreadthofhisphilosophicalunderstanding,andinhisvastcorpusofworksonvariedsubjects.InhisownassessmentofhisachievementofrevivingthepursuitofphilosophyinByzantium,hesaysthatIfoundphilosophyonlyafterithadbreatheditslast,andthatIalonereviveditwithmyownpowers,havingfoundnoworthwhileteachers.10(Thisselfassesssmentwasnoidleboast,butissupportedbytheextentandcharacterofhissurvivingwritings). So, even though there may have been a linguistic continuity between theByzantinesandtheancientGreekphilosophicalschools,thesetraditionshadalsodiedoutthere as well. Psellos, in reinventing philosophy could not have avoided creatingsomethingnew,whichsuitedhisowninterestsandtheneedsofthetime.Thewholenotionofwhatisinvolvedinrevivinganintellectualtraditionfromscratchhasbeenunderexploredasyet.This issue ishighly significant inAnnas career,as I shall show later, since shefosteredtherebirthofAristotelianstudiesinByzantium,andpossiblyalso,throughcontactwithJamesofVenice,ofWesternEurope.The complexity of conflicting Hellenisms became even more complicated with the
increasedpresenceoftheLatins intheEmpire,andespeciallywithManuelIspersonalinterestandinvolvementwiththem.TheWesthadbeenundergoingaclassicalrevivalofitsownalready fora fewcenturies,andwas in themidstofanother, theTwelfthCenturyRenaissance.AnextensionofthepoliticalrivalrybetweenRomeandConstantinople,therewasdevelopinganintellectualrivalrybetweenEastandWest,mostapparentbetweenthemultiethniccourtoftheNormanSicilyofRogerII(r.11301154),andtheByzantiumofManuelI.ThefactthattheLatinrevivalwasbeingmostrecentlyfueledbyArabicinfluencesfromSpainandSicilymeantthattheirHellenismwasdevelopinginadifferentdirectionfromthatofByzantium,namely,perpetuatingtheradicalchangesthatIslamicthinkershadintroduced.Thisseemstobemostapparentinthedisciplineofastrology,whichhadbeencompletelyreshapedunderArabic influenceduringtheninthcentury.11Asaresult,theLatinswieldedyetanotherformofHellenism,onethat,initsoriginalArabicform,claimedpriorityover theByzantine form,due to thevolatilepoliticalcircumstancesandrivalrybetweenByzantiumandtheCaliphateduringtheeighthninthcenturies.12ThecontestoverHellenism,itsproperform,andwhohastherighttoitextendsbackat
least to theperiod of theGrecoArabic translations.The caliphs and their intellectualsrecognizedmuchofgreatvalueintheHellenisticlegacy,andcametoconsideritsfruitastheproperpossessionoftheworldofIslam.Afterall,theByzantineswhohadlongneglected
10 Psellos,Chronographia6.7,quotedin:Kaldellis,Hellenism(seenote1),193.11 Paul Magdalino, The Porphyrogenita and the Astrologers: A Commentary on Alexiad VI.7.17,
Porphyrogenita: Essays on the History and Literature of Byzantium and the Latin East in Honor of JulianChrysostomides, ed.CharalambosDendrinos, JonathanHarris, JudithHerrin,andEireneHarvaliaCrook(Aldershot:Ashgate,2003),3031.
12 DimitriGutas,GreekThought(seenote2),8395.
-
GlenM.Cooper268
thislegacy,wereadefeatedpeople,havinglosttwothirdsoftheirterritorytothearmiesofIslam, and it was only a matter of time before some Muslim prince would captureConstantinople, putting an end to the Christian Empire, and fulfilling the ProphetMuhammadsprophecyandpromise.13ThingsnaturallylookeddifferentfromtheByzantinepointofview.ThelegacyofHellenismhadalwaysbeentheirs,andhowwasitthattheupstart,infidelArabshavebeensosuccessfulwithit?TherewasafeltneedtofindoutwhattheMuslimswereupto,butdiscreetly.Moreover,theLatinspresentedyetanotheropponentinthiscontest.Anewandvigorous
rivalfromtheWest,thiswesternLatinHellenismhadbeenformativelyshapedbytheArabenlightenment.Whileourknowledgeof therelationshipbetweenArabicandByzantinethoughtisstillmurky,thereisnodoubtthattheinfluxandstudyofArabicversionsofGreektextsrevolutionizedwesternLatinthought,makingitapowerfultoolinthehandsofLatinthinkers,moredynamicandfreshinsomewaysthantheHellenismofByzantium.
TheChallengingEleventhCenturyIn spiteof the contributionsofMichaelPsellosandothers to theByzantine intellectualrevival,thepoliticalandmilitaryreversesoftheeleventhcenturythreatenedtobringtheEmpiretoanearlyend.Furthermore,theantagonisticresponseoftheChurch(aswellasofthe Komnenos regime) to Pselloss Neoplatonizing, as typified by the 1082 trial andcondemnation of John Italos (ca. 1025after 1082), one of his students, seems to haveencouraged intellectuals topursue themore earthcenteredAristotelianism.This latterschoolofphilosophy,beingfundamentallyempiricalinorientation,hadmoreincommonwithancientGreekmedicine,andmayhavebeenanencouragingfactorintherecultivationof medical science as well as for the dramatic shift in Byzantine attitudes towardphysicians.14 At the beginning of the period, physicians are routinely lampooned inliterature,and theirgreedand incompetenceareemphasized.However,by the timeofManuelsreignandAnnascompositionoftheAlexiad,theoccupationofaphysicianhasbecomearespectedprofession.Itmustberemembered,however,thatAristotelianism,too,containedelementsthatwerecontrarytoChurchdogma,thatwouldeventuallyneedtobedealtwith.Infact,asdiscussedbelow,suchaprojectofreconcilingAristotlewithChristian
13 Discussedatlengthin:NadiaMariaElChaikh,ByzantiumasViewedbytheArabs(Cambridge,MA:HarvardUniversityPress,2004);see,e.g.,4345.
14 AlexanderP.KazhdanandAnnWhartonEpstein,Change inByzantineCulture in theEleventhandTwelfthCenturies(1985;Berkeley,LosAngeles,andLondon:UniversityofCaliforniaPress,1990),15456;seealsoAlexanderKazhdan,The Imageof theMedicalDoctor inByzantineLiteratureof theTenth toTwelfthCenturies,SymposiumonByzantineMedicine,ed.JohnScarborough.DumbartonOaksPapers(Washington,DC:1984),5051.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 269
theologywas undertaken by Byzantine intellectuals underAnnas sponsorship,whichanticipatedtheprojectofThomasAquinasbyacentury.
TheNewModelofGovernmentWiththeusurpationofAlexiosKomnenosin1081,however,therecameanewmodelofimperialgovernment,towhichcanbeattributedmuchofhissuccess inrevitalizingtheEmpire,butwhichcanalsobeunderstoodassowingtheseedsofthelaterunravelingofthose gainsduring the late twelfth century.15Alexios came to rely onmembers ofhisextendedfamilytoassistinruling,fromhismother,tohiswife,andallhisvariedmalerelations. Ineffect,hecreateda family franchise inwhichvirtuallyanymemberof theimperialfamilymightfeelthathe(orshe)hadasmuchrighttothethroneasanyother.WhilethisseemedtoworkunderAlexios,underhissuccessors,however,itspawnedrivalsandrebellions,themostdevastatingofwhichwastheseizureofthethroneandmurderofManuelsyoungson,AlexiosIIin1183byamemberofacollateralbranchoftheKomnenosfamily,AndronikosI(r.11831185).Annasownattempttoseizethethroneafterherfathersdeathisanimportantpartofmypresentstory.
AnnaKomnene:BirthandEducationAsherhistoryshows,AnnawasacarefulstudentoftheancientGreekhistorians,especiallyThucydides,aswellofHomer,asliberalquotesfromtheIliadandtheOdysseythroughoutshow.Herfirststatementabouthereducationoccursinthefirstparagraphofthebook,where she identifies herself as a (purpleborn), andmentions herthoroughknowledgeofGreek,rhetoric,Aristotle,Plato,andthetraditionalQuadriviumofthehighersciences(arithmetic,harmonictheory,geometry,andastronomy).16SeveralfactsaboutAnnaslifecontributedtoherrivalrywithherbrotherandnephew.She
wasbornonDecember2,1083,notlongafterherfatherhadusurpedtheImperialthrone.Shewasthusa,atitleassumedbyimperialchildrenborninthepurplestonedchamberofthepalace.Thisdesignationwassometimesusedasanadditionaltokenoflegitimacytorule,orasaclaimonthethrone.Beingbornafteronesfatherwasfirmlyonthe throne suggestedboth stabilityandhope that thedynastywould continue. Itevenprovidedasenseofhavingbeenpreordained.Annadescribesthechamberinconnection
15 SeePaulMagdalino,TheEmpireoftheKomnenoi(11181204),TheCambridgeHistoryoftheByzantineEmpirec.5001492,ed.JonathanShepard(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2008),65763.
16 Alexiad,15.7(seenote3),trans.455;ed.48485.
-
GlenM.Cooper270
withrelatingthestoryofherownbirth.17Alexios,asausurperwithquestionablelegitimacy,washimselfkeentouseeveryavailabletokenoflegitimacy.18Annasfuneraloration,deliveredbyGeorgeTornikes,atwelfthcenturyintellectualand
Metropolitan of Ephesus, only recently brought to light, relates that Annas parentsencouragedherinterestsinGreeklearningtoapoint.Shewasforbiddentostudygrammarandrhetoric,subjectsthoughttocorrupttheyouth,becausetheyweretaughtviapassagesdrawnfrompaganGreekliterature,muchofwhoseethos(e.g.,theimmoralbehavioroftheOlympiandeities)wasnotwhataChristiangirloughttobeexposedto.19Nevertheless,Annamanagedtostudytheseforbiddensubjectswithpalaceeunuchsonthesly,andacquiredmorethanamerelysuperficialunderstandingofmedicaltheory.Choniatesdescribesherasardentlydevotedtophilosophy,thequeenofallsciences,andeducatedineveryfield.20Inthecontextoflamentingthedeclineofclassicalstudies,whichforherweregrammar,poetics,andhistoryallmendonowisplaydraughtsandgambleshedescribedhowshehadstudiedrhetoric,history,poetryandphilosophy.21Shescornedthelearningoftheseskillsthroughthethenpopularmethodofschedography,orthestudyandimitationofshortexcerptsdrawnfromtheclassicalcorpus.Thiswasaquick(butsuperficial)waytoacquiretheessentialelementsofaclassicaleducation,andtoappeareducated,andsecureajobintheimperialadministration.Annainsisted,rather,thatworksbereadintheirentirety.
BetrothalsandMarriageAnimperialfemale,Annawasapoliticaltoolofherfathersashesoughttostrengthenhisownlegitimacyandtoextendhisfamilysinfluenceinthestate.So,asayounggirl,shewasbetrothed toConstantineDoukas (ca.1074ca.1095),a representativeofoneof themostpowerfulfamiliesintheEmpire,andshewassenttohishometoberaisedbyhismother,MariaofAlania(ca.1050after1103),aformerempress.Constantine,himselfa,sonofthepreviousemperor,MichaelVIIDoukas(r.10711078),wasalsoapoliticaltool,representingalegitimizinglinktothepreviousdynasty,andhadbeenbetrothedto
17 Alexiad,6.8(seenote3),trans.167;ed.18384.SeealsoBook2,Ch.21ofConstantineVIIPorphrygenitos,DeCeremoniisAulaeByzantinae,ed.JohannJacobReiske,CorpusScriptorumHistoriaeByzantinae(Bonn:Weber,1829),61519,foradescriptionoftheceremoniesaccompanyingthebirthofaporphyrogennetoschild.
18 JudithHerrin,Byzantium:TheSurprisingLifeofaMedievalEmpire(Princeton,NJ:PrincetonUniversityPress,2008),23234.
19 RobertBrowning,AnUnpublishedFuneralOrationonAnnaComnena,AristotleTransformed:TheAncientCommentatorsandtheirInfluence,ed.RichardSorabji(Ithaca,NY:CornellUniversityPress,1990),40405.
20 NiketasChoniates,NicetaeChoniataehistoria,parsprior,vol.11.1,CorpusFontiumHistoriaeByzantinae.SeriesBerolinensis,ed.J.vanDieten(BerlinandNewYork:WalterdeGruyter,1975),10.Englishtranslation:NiketasChoniates,OCityofByzantium,AnnalsofNiketasChoniates,trans.HarryJ.Magoulias(Detroit,MI:WayneStateUniversityPress,1984),8.
21 Alexiad,15.7(seenote3),trans.455;ed.48485.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 271
otherpoliticallydesirablewomenbeforeAnna.SinceAlexioshadnomaleheirsatthattime,ConstantinewascrownedasCaesartheheirdesignate.Thus,atleasttheregimecouldcontinue via a smooth transition, in the event ofAlexioss premature death. In 1087,however, a son, John,was born, and so the need forConstantine evaporated, and hevanishedfromtherecordperhapshediedyoung,beforeanyactualmarriagehadbeenformalizedbetweenhimandAnna.Tenyearslater(1097),Annawasactuallymarriedtoanothereligibleyoungman,NikephorosBryennios,adescendantofhisnamesake, theformerdouxofDyrrachion,whohadrevoltedagainstMichaelVIIagenerationearlier,andhadbeendefeatedandblindedbyAlexioshimself.22ThismarriageappearstohavebeenanothermeasurebyAlexiostoneutralizeapotentialthreat.
TheSuccessionfromAlexiosThehistorian,NiketasChoniates(ca.11551215/16),reportsthatAlexioshadnointentionthatanyoneotherthanhisson,John,shouldsucceedhim,inspiteofEmpressEirenesovertfavorforAnnashusband,Bryennios.23Whatkingdomallowsthethronetopasstoanelderdaughter,whentheresaperfectlycapableson?SuchapracticehadneverbeenfollowedintheRomanEmpiresinceitsbeginning.Furthermore,AlexioswroteapoetichandbookofstatecraftforJohn,butweknowofnothingsimilarpreparedforAnna.24Evidently,Alexioshad given the successionmuch thought, and it didnt includeAnna or her husband,althoughthelatterheldthetitleCaesar,normallyreservedforanemperorintraining.
TheAttemptedCoupAnnahadtremendousselfconfidence.Apparently,shefeltthatherwholelifeshehadbeenpreparedtosucceedhermotherasempress,aswifetoastrongleader,whohadbeenchosenbyherfather.Shewas,afterall,Alexiossoldestchild,andofallhischildren,sheresembledhimmostclosely.25Shecamefromafamilyofpowerfulwomen,andhadbeennamedafterherpaternalgrandmother,AnnaDalassene,whosepoliticalmaneuveringshadbroughtherfamilytopowerinthefirstplace.26Shewasa.Shealsohadafirstrate
22 Alexiad1.6(seenote3),trans.2324;ed.27.23 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.5;ed.5.24 P.Maas,DieMusendesKaisersAlexiusI,ByzantinischeZeitschrift22(1913):34859.Seethediscussionin:
PaulMagdalino,TheEmpireofManuelKomnenos11431180(1993;Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2002).,2730.
25 Asshesays:Alexiad,6.8(seenote3),trans.167;ed.184.26 Alexiad2.2(seenote3),trans.5253;ed.5758;and2.5,trans.5960;ed.6566.SeealsoBarbaraHill,Actions
SpeakLouderThanWords:AnnaKomnenesAttemptedUsurpation,AnnaKomneneandHerTimes,ed.ThaliaGoumaPeterson(NewYorkandLondon:GarlandPublishing,Inc.,2000),50.
-
GlenM.Cooper272
classicaleducation,andshecouldhardlyhavefailedtolearnfromPlatosRepublicaboutthephilosopherking.Annaseemstohavefanciedherselfasthephilosopherandherhusbandasthetalentedorator,andapopulargeneralaformidablerulingpair.Shewasfarmorelearnedthanherbrother.However,asAlexiosknew,itrequiresmorethanbooklearningtoruleanempire,anditwasJohn,whoactuallysucceededinsecuringthethrone.WhileAlexioslaydying,thequestionofwhowouldsucceedhimseemstohaveremained
unsettled.TheviewofChoniateswasthatAlexioshadintendedJohntobehisheirallalong,and thatAnnaandhermotherwere rebellingagainsthiswishes.Choniates states thatAlexioshadgivenJohnthetokensofsuccession,theredbuskins,andhadpermittedhimtobeacclaimedascoemperor.EmpressEireneDoukaina,however,supportedherdaughterandher soninlaw, theCaesar, and systematically attempted toundermine JohnwithAlexioswho, according to Choniates, feigned to listen, but deliberately ignored heradvice.27Thisreport,however,seemsdifficulttotakeatfacevalue,sinceAlexiosisknowntohavereliedheavilyonhersupportandcounselthroughouthisreign.Indeed,whenhishealthbegan to failsomeyearsbeforehisdeath (ca.1112),Eireneassumedsomeof theresponsibilityofruling.TheempresscontrastedthesuperiorqualitiesofBryennioswiththeirson John.Choniatesclaims thatwhenAlexioshadenoughof this,hechidedher,citingearlierRomanprecedent:WhendidanyRomanemperorsetasideaperfectlygoodsonforasoninlaw?28ChoniatescalledAlexiosadissembler:nooneeverknewhistrueintentions,andthecircumstancesaroundthesuccessionbearthisup.WhileAlexioslaydying(August,1118),Johnbegantogatherthesupportofhisextended
relatives,ashisfatherhaddoneingainingandmaintainingpower.ChoniatesdescribeshowJohn,whilevisitinghisstrickenfatheronhisdeathbedandpretendingtoembracehim,secretlyslipped thesignetring fromhis fathershand.29 John thenhurried to theGreatPalace,thecenterofimperialgovernment,tosecurehisposition,whereheremainedbarredinforseveraldays.Hetherebymissedthefuneralofhisfather,inspiteofhismothersorderforhimtobepresent.30DuringthefirstyearofJohnsreign,anumberofhisrelatives,organizedbyhissister
Anna,revoltedinfavoroftheCaesarBryennios.TheyplannedtomurderJohnwhilehewasencamped outside the city walls. Bryennios, however, stalled, and the zeal of theconspirators withered, and so the revolt died. The rebels were not maimed norflagellatedtheusualpunishmentforinsurrectionbuttheirpropertywasseized,thoughmosthaditrestoredbeforelong.Asawoman,Annacouldnotleadtherebellionoutsideofthewomens quarters, andwithoutBryennios as agent,hermastermindedplot failed.AccordingtoChoniates,Annawassoangrywithherhusbandfornotleadingtherevoltthat
27 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.5;ed.5.28 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.5;ed.56.29 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.6;ed.6.30 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.67;ed.8.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 273
shepubliclycalledhimanobscenewordforthefemalegenitalsimplyingthatheactedlikeawoman,andshewonderedwhyshehadntbeenbornwiththemaleorganinsteadofhim.31AsforAnna,Johnhadcollectedallofherwealthandclothes,andwasabouttogiveit
awaytohisfriend,theTurkishbornGrandDomesticJohnAxouch.JohnisreportedtohaveobservedthatNaturehadreversedthings,sothathenowhadtheupperhandoverhisknowitallschemingsister.ButAxouchrefusedtoacceptthegift,andpersuadedhimtoforgiveAnna,andrestoretheproperty.32Bryenniosremainedfaithfultotheemperoruntilhisdeath(1137).Anna,however,nodoubtperceivedasdangerousforherlearningandunwomanlycharacter,was confined,alongwithhermother,underhousearrest in theKecharitomeneMonasteryontheedgeofthecity,whichhadbeenfoundedbyhermother.Eirenehadbuiltapartmentstherefortheuseofimperialwomen.Thismusthavebeenaterriblepunishmentforawomanaccustomedtotheintellectualandpoliticalexcitementsofcourtlife.HeraccesstovisitorswaslimitedshecomplainsintheAlexiadhowmeanherbrotherandnephewweretoher.SheblamesJohnforwearingoutherhusbandonmilitarycampaignsthatledtohisfinallethalillness,probablycancer.33ThehistorianChoniatessassessmentisthatwomensimplydonothavewhatisneeded
torule,whichheillustratedinhisaccount:themanwhousesallofhisconnections(mostlyoutsideofthepalace:thearmy,thecrowd,extendedfamily)tosecurepowerhere,Johnisnaturallymorefittorule.Incontrast,women,cloisteredinpalacesandhomesbynature,cannotsecurethenecessarysupportoutsidepalacewalls,andsomustrelyonmen.
AnnasLaterCareer:AristotleasanIdeologicalWeaponAsfarasweknow,Annaremainedinconfinementfortherestofherlife.Althoughshecomplainsofhersituation in theAlexiad,shewaspermitted tohavevisitors.Moreover,accordingtotheevidenceinhereulogy,shecultivatedacircleofintellectualswhorevivedAristotelian studies.34 The eulogist reports that she continuedherown studies,whichBrowningsuggestsinvolvedspecialiststoguideherreadingandpossiblyalsotoprovidelectures,andthatsheorganizedandprobablypatronizedotherscholars,suchasMichaelofEphesus,whopreparedcommentariesonAristotlestreatises,withemphasisonthetreatisesforwhichtherewerenosurvivingancientcommentaries.BrowningnotesthatthetraditionofcommentingonAristotleceasedwithStephanusof
Alexandriainthesixthcentury,nottoberesumeduntiltheeleventh/twelfthcentury,withtheeffortsofscholarssuchasEustratios,MetropolitanofNicaea(whohadbeenapupilof
31 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.8;10.Notemycorrectedtranslation.Noconditionofpeniscaptivusisreferredtointhispassage.
32 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.8;ed.11.33 Alexiad,Prologue(seenote5),trans.57;ed.810.34 Browning,UnpublishedFuneralOration(seenote19),399400;seealsoWilson,Scholars(seenote8),18184.
-
GlenM.Cooper274
Psellosspupil,JohnItalos),andMichaelofEphesus(bothfl.earlytwelfthcentury).MostofthelateantiquecommentariesweredevotedtothelogicalworksoftheOrganon.So,thefocusofAnnascirclewasontheRhetoric,thePolitics,andthezoologicalandanthropologicaltreatises,whichhadnocommentaries,afactsuggestingthattheyhadbeenneglectedinLateAntiquityandearlyByzantium.IntheprefacetoEustratiosscommentarytotheNicomacheanEthics,hecreditsapowerful
imperial femalepatron, thoughunnamed.Browning speculates thatAnnawasmeant.Eustratioshadbeendisgraced in1117,andso two fellowexiles fromByzantinesocietyworkedtogetheronaprojecttoadvancenaturalphilosophy.35Annawasevidentlyatoughtaskmaster:theeulogistreportsthatMichaelofEphesuscomplainedthathelosthiseyesightbecauseshekepthimupallnightwritingbycandlelight.36Browningalsosupposes,quiteplausibly,thatJamesofVenice(fl.ca.11361150)hadcontactwithAnnascircleinthe1130s,wherehelearnedofthePhysicsandtheDesophisticiselenchis,whichhelatertranslatedintoLatin.37
ThisJameswasanextremelyimportantconduitofAristotelianlogicaltreatises,thelogicanova(newlogic)thatcompletedtheOrganon.38OfthetextsthatheacquiredandtranslatedfromGreek,thePosteriorAnalyticswasthemostinfluential,andhelpedtoshapetheradicaldevelopmentsinEuropeanlogicandscienceafterthetwelfthcentury.So,ineffect,AnnascirclehelpedspuronthedevelopmentofAristotlestudiesinWesternEurope.Inrecentyears,JamesofVenicewasatthecenterofanattempttoshowthatmedieval
EuropeowednothingtotheAraboIslamiccivilizationforitsknowledgeofAristotleandGreeklearningingeneral.39AccordingtoS.Gouguenheiminacontroversialbook,onthebasisofnoevidence,JameswastheheadtranslatorofavastGrecoLatintranslationeffort,centeredatMontSaintMichelinnorthernFrance.HefurtherassertsthattheintellectualdevelopmentofWesternEuropewouldhaveoccurred inessentially thesamewayhadEurope been completely cut off from Islamic civilization. This thesis, against whichnumerouscounterexamplescouldbegiven,iscompletelyfalse,andfliesinthefaceofmuchrecentscholarshipthatprovestheopposite.PannedbyhisFrenchcolleagues,whoexposedGouguenheimsmotivationsasbeingdeterminedbypresentFrenchpoliticalissues,thebookalsogarnerednegativescholarlyreviews.40Thepassionsthatthisbookhassparked,bothforandagainstitsfantasticthesis,showhowquestionsofinfluenceacrossEastandWestcangeneratemorethanacloisteredscholarlyinterest.
35 Browning,UnpublishedFuneralOration(seenote19),400.36 Browning,UnpublishedFuneralOration(seenote19),406.37 Browning,UnpublishedFuneralOration(seenote19),401.38 LorenzoMinioPaluello,JacobusVeneticusGrecus:CanonistandTranslatorofAristotle,Traditio8(1952):
265304.39 SylvainGouguenheim,AristoteauMontSaintMichel:Les racinesgrecquesde lEuropechrtienne,LUnivers
Historique(Paris:ditionsduSeuil,2008).40 SeeStevenJ.Livesey,Reviewof:SylvainGouguenheim.AristoteauMontSaintMichel:Lesracinesgrecquesde
lEuropechrtienne.LUniversHistorique(Paris:ditionsduSeuil,2008),Isis100.3(2009):64850,forinstance.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 275
Even thoughhequestions the value of the eulogists account ofAnnasphilosophy,Browningsummarizesherbasicphilosophicalposition.41Hercirclesoughttoadaptancientphilosophy (sc.PlatoandAristotle) tomake it compatiblewithChristiandoctrine.ShefavoredAristotle,butdidnotaccepthisdoctrineoftheuncreatedcosmos.SheborrowedsomeideasfromPlato,suchasthetripartitesoul,butrejected,ofcourse,thetransmigrationofsouls.Ineffect,AnnaandhercirclewereattemptingaThomistprojectacenturyearlierthanAquinas.Morerelevanttothepresentstudy,however,isthatAnnawrotetheAlexiad,amasterpiece
withacomplexpurpose,asnotedearlier.Thedetailswillbediscussedinthefinalsectionofthisarticle.
ManuelKomnenos(r.11431280)ManuelwasbornonNovember28,1118,severalmonthsafterthedeathofhisgrandfather,Alexios.AstheyoungestsonofJohnII(r.11181143),hisascensiontothepurplewasnotaforegoneconclusion.NotlongbeforeJohnsdeath,however,histwooldestsonssuddenlydiedinquicksuccession.ManuelwasproclaimedemperorinCiliciawhilehiselderbrotherIsaacwasstillalive,andsohehadtorushtoConstantinopletosecurehissuccession.JohnsupposedlysaidonhisdeathbedthatManuelwouldmakeabetteremperor,moreover,thatithadbeenforetoldthathewouldrule.42ManueldevelopedareputationasaLatinophile.HewasthesonofaHungarianmother,
andbetrothed,andlatermarriedaGermanimperialprincess,whichmusthavecontributedtothisinterestinpeoplestotheWest.Heemployedforeignersinhisarmies,and,morethananypreviousEmperor,useddynasticmarriageallianceswithnonByzantinerulingfamiliesaspolicy.HeevenemployedmanyTurksinhisarmyandadministration,andnegotiatedwiththeTurkishSultanofRum,KilijArslanII(r.11561192).Anaptcharacterizationofhisattitudeisthis:hedealtwithWesternerswithaconfidenceinByzantinesuperiority,andfailedtorealizehowpowerfulanddangeroustheyreallywere.43Nevertheless,hehadabroadintellect,andwascapableinphilosophyandtheology,andenjoyedparticipatingindebatesinthesesubjects.44Manuelsreignhasbeencharacterizedasdecadentandasanexpressionofanempirein
decline,basedmainlyontheperspectivepresentedbyNiketasChoniates,whofoundbothhis fascination with astrology and his sensualitynot to mention his inappropriate
41 Browning,UnpublishedFuneralOration(seenote19),40102.42 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.26;ed.4546.43 WarrenTreadgold,AHistoryoftheByzantineStateandSociety(Stanford,CA:StanfordUniversityPress,1997),
638.44 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.30;ed.5051;andtrans.12023;ed.21219.
-
GlenM.Cooper276
familiaritywithwesternbarbarianstohavebeenagreatliabilities.45AsP.Magdalinohasargued,however,thisviewisinaccurate,andbiasedbythefactthattheEmpiredidinfactdecline and fall to theLatins in thegeneration afterManuelsdeath.On the contrary,Manuels reign was one of great brilliance, and represented an apogee of Byzantinecivilizationinmanyways,inparticular,ofintellectualactivity.46SincethefocusofthisarticleisonAnnaandtheAlexiad,IcoveronlythemainpointsofManuelsreign.InManuelscareer,Hellenismwasusedasatoolofdiplomacy.Inheritingarelatively
stableandwealthystatefromhisfatherandgrandfather,Manuelcultivatedtheancientsciences,especiallyastrologyandmedicine,andemployedthemaspartofthepersonahepresentedtoforeignrulers,especiallytheLatinrulersoftheWest.Thiswaspartofacontestofculturaloneupmanship,especiallywiththeNormanKingdomofSicily.Inparticular,RogerII(r.11301154)cultivatedtheancientsciencesathiscourt,and,moreover,wasaidedbyArabscholars.47Manuelexportedbookstoandsoughtknowledgefromotherprinces,inP. Magdalinos expression, to blind his adversaries by science.48 For example, adiplomaticgiftofPtolemysAlmagestwassentfromManueltothecourtatPalermo(ca.1160).Thesewerecalculatedhegemonicmeasurestoshowhissuperioritytothem.TotheNormans of Sicily the message was: dabble in Arab science, but know that the bestastronomyandmedicineistobefoundinConstantinople.Furthermore,whywouldtheemperorofByzantiumbeinterestedinaskingHenryIIofEngland(r.11541189)aboutsuchanoutof thewayplaceasWales,except toexhibithimselfas themost inquisitive (sc.scientific)rulerinChristendom?49ManuelsembassiestotheWesthavebeencharacterizedasmutualexchangesofknowledge,evenasattemptstoremovetheobstaclesbetweenEastandWest.50IpreferP.Magdalinosreading,however,namely,thattheseembassieswereviewedby theByzantinesasasymmetricalexchanges,sinceIdontbelieve thatManuelthoughthemightfindmuchusefulknowledgeintheWest.Inmedicine,Manuelpossessedconsiderableexpertiseanddelightedtopracticehealing
foreignrulersanddignitaries,among themBaldwin IIIof Jerusalem (r.11431163)andConradIIIofGermany(r.11381152).ThefactthatnolessapersonthantheEmperorcouldpracticemedicineshowsthattheimageofthephysicianinByzantineculturehadalreadyshiftedfrombunglingorunscrupulousquackstothatofahighlyrespectedprofession.51The fact that EmperorManuel practicedmedicine and exhibited a profoundmedical
45 Choniates,Historia(seenote20),trans.32;ed.54.46 Abrilliantreassessmentofhisreign:Magdalino,TheEmpireofManuelKomnenos(seenote24)..47 HubertHouben,RogerIIofSicily:ARulerbetweenEastandWest,trans.GrahamA.LoudandDianeMilburn,
CambridgeMedievalTextbooks(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2002),98113.48 Magdalino,TheEmpireofManuelKomnenos(seenote24),379;andMagdalino,Porphyrogenita(seenote11),
2831.49 Magdalino,EmpireofManuelKomnenos(seenote24),379.50 CharlesHomerHaskins,StudiesintheHistoryofMediaevalScience(Cambridge,MA:HarvardUniversityPress,
1924),19495.51 KazhdanandEpstein,ChangeinByzantineCulture(seenote14),155.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 277
knowledgeshowsthatmedicinewasnolongerthedomainoftherudemechanicals.52Thiscanalsobeobserved in theAlexiad,where in the finaldeathscene,Annadescribes theprofessionalclassofphysiciansattendingherfather,eventhoughshedisagreeswiththeirdiagnosesandprescriptions.ManuelsetBaldwinsbrokenarmafterafallfromahorsein1159.Hepersonallyadministered toConrad,who fell illon theSecondCrusade,afterinviting him to convalesce in Constantinople. Manuel was even observed to applybloodlettingandtoprescribedmedicationswhentheprofessionalphysicianswereabsent.Tobeabletodothisrequiredadeepunderstandingofmedicalprinciples,forexample,toknowwhatsimples,orbasicelements,tocombineintoadrugforspecificailments,aswellaswhentoletblood(usuallydeterminedbyrecoursetoastrology)andhowmuch.AstrologywasalsoakeeninterestofManuels.Hewroteadefenseofastrology,toprove
thatitwascompatiblewithChristiandoctrine,53inresponsetoaletterfromananonymousmonkwhohadaccusedManuelofheresyforhisinterestinastrology.Hisdefensesetsforthsomeof thestandardarguments insupportof theArt.54Hewasawareof theparallelsbetweenthetwoancientdisciplinesofastrologyandmedicine,andappealedtotheirsharedconjecturalcharacterinhisdefense.TheEmperorspositionwasattackedbyMichaelGlykas,a theologianwho seems tohavepreviously sufferedpunishmentatManuelshand forsedition.Theemperorsdefensebeginsbydifferentiatingbetweentwokindsofastrology:1)akind
thattakesthestarsasintelligentandlivingbeings,whocanbeentreatedthroughprayersandamulets.Thiskind,Manuelaffirms,isrightlytobecondemnedasaformofidolatry.And,2)akindthattakesthestarstohavebeencreatedbyGod,andtoserveasmessengersandsignsofhiswillandmysteries.This,accordingtoManuel,wasgivenbyGodtomankindforourbenefit,andoughttobecultivated.55Manuel also argues that, becausemedicine and astrology are related, and both are
conjecturalartsi.e.,theyrelyonacertainamountofguessing,56thenneitherartshouldbefaulted if it occasionally leads to undesirable or incorrect results. Glykas mocks thisreasoning:arguingthatwhilemedicineisarational,empiricalscience,astrologyisirrationalandunscientific,citingHippocratesandGaleninsupport.57
52 SeeMagdalino,EmpireofManuelKomnenos(seenote24),361.53 Manuelsdefense:ImperatorisManuelComnenietMichaelGlycaedisputatio,inFranzCumont,andFranzBoll,
eds.CatalogusCodicumAstrologorumGraecorum.Vol.V.1(Brussels:HenriLamertin,1904),10825.Glykassresponseisonpages12540.
54 DemetraGeorge,ManuelIKomnenosandMichaelGlycas:ATwelfthCenturyDefenceandRefutationofAstrology,CultureandCosmos5.1(2001):348;here25.
55 DemetraGeorge.ManuelIKomnenosandMichaelGlykas:ATwelfthCenturyDefenseandRefutationofAstrology,M.A.Thesis,UniversityofOregon,2000,Chap.2,24.
56 Astandardcomparisonsinceantiquity.SeeGeorge,ManuelIKomnenos(seenote57),Chap.2,13.57 George,ManuelIKomnenos(seenote57),24.GlykasappearsnothavebeenfamiliarwithGalensDediebus
decretoriis,whichadvancesastrologicalargumentsinconnectionwithsoundlyscientificmedicalprognosis.SeeGalen,Dediebusdecretoriis,fromGreekintoArabic:ACriticalEdition,withTranslationandCommentary,andHistoricalIntroductionofH. unaynibnIsh. q,Kitb(ayymalbuh. rn,MedicineintheMedievalMediterranean,ed.
-
GlenM.Cooper278
ItisinthearenaofmedicinethattherivalrybetweenAnnaandherbrothersfamilywasfurtherdeveloped.Manuelattemptedtopresenthimselfineverypossiblewaythemodelprince, the proper heir of his grandfather Alexioss legacy. Possessing knowledge ofmedicineandtheexpertisetopracticehealingwasonlyoneofthevisiblemanifestationsofthis.Thekingashealerisamotifwithancientorigins,eventakingonareligiousdimensionintheintellectuallylesssophisticatedWestoftheearlyMiddleAges.58TohavepersonallytreatedWesternrulersduringtheSecondCrusadewasahighlyvisiblestatementofthesuperiorityofByzantinecivilizationandofitsenlightenedemperor.
TheAlexiad:OpeningNowthatIhavedescribedthecontextofthemidtwelfthcenturycontestofHellenismsbetweenbranchesoftheKomnenosfamily,Imovetopresenttheheartofmyarticle,namely,thedetailsofAnnasargumentsassetforthinherepicbiographyofherfather.TheopeningoftheworksetsforthAnnasreasonsforwritingthislengthybiographyof
herfather.Inaclassicizingsentiment,shenotesthat,wereitnotforthescienceofhistorythestreamof timewouldbearall thingsoff tooblivion.59Shenotes, inparticular,howimportantitisthatthegreatdeedsofherfathernotbeforgotten.Yet,ithasrecentlybeenarguedthatAlexiossmemorywasnotlikelytofade:hissuccessorskeptitalivetobolstertheirownlegitimacy.60ThefactthatAlexiossmemorywascontestedterritoryinthe1140sfurthersupportstheargumentthattheAlexiad,whichwascompletedatthattime,wasamoveinthatcontest.Annaproceedsbydescribingthegenesisofherproject.Herhusbandhadbeenrequested
byEmpressEirenetowriteahistoryoftheKomnenianperiod.TheresultwashisMaterialsforaHistory,coveringtherisetopoweroftheKomnenosfamily,10571081,whichwasunfinishedatthetimeofhisdeath.61AnnaconceivedofherprojectaspickingupwhereBryennioshadleftoff.TherelationshipbetweenhisprojectandtheAlexiadhasbeenthe
andtrans.GlenM.Cooper(London:Ashgate,2011).Galenstreatisewasthesubjectofacenturieslongdebateover the validity of astrology,which began in the twelfth century and extended into theRenaissance.SeeConcettaPennuto,TheDebateonCriticalDays inRenaissance Italy,AstroMedicine:AstrologyandMedicine,EastandWest,ed.AnnaAkasoy,CharlesBurnett,andRonitYoeliTlalim(Florence:SismelEdizionedelGalluzzo,2008),7598.
58 MarcBloch,TheRoyalTouch,trans.J.E.Anderson(NewYork:DorsetPress,1989).59 Alexiad,Prologue(seenote5),trans.3;ed.5.60 PaulMagdalino,ThePenoftheAunt:EchoesoftheMidTwelfthCenturyintheAlexiad,AnnaKomneneand
herTimes,ed.ThaliaGoumaPeterson(NewYorkandLondon:GarlandPublishing,2000),1543,17;alsoPaulStephenson,AnnaComnenasAlexiadasaSourcefortheSecondCrusade?,JournalofMedievalHistory29(2003):4154;here45.
61 NicephorusBryennius,NicphoreBryennios histoire: introduction, texte, traduction etnotes, ed.PaulGautier(Brussels:Byzantion,1975).
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 279
subjectofdebateinrecentyears.DidAnnaplagiarizehisnotesandsketchesforthehistoryofherfathersreign?Or(morelikely,inmyview)didshemerelyrelyonsomeofhisnotesforeventsthatshecouldnothavewitnessed,suchasbattles,butthefurtherresearch,viainterviewsofparticipants,and,aboveall,thewritingishers?62Throughouthernarrative,shetellsreadershowshefeelsaboutspecificpersons,events,
orpolicies.As such, shepioneered anewkindofwriting:prosewith anunconcealedsubjectivity. Edward Gibbon, not one for less than the masculine, objective history,denigratedherworkastherantingsofanemotionalwoman.63
TheEpicDimensionTheAlexiadselfconsciouslyevokestheepicsofHomer:HowcouldthestoryofthesalvationoftheRomanEmpirefrombarbarianhordesduringherfathersreignnotbeepic?AnnafrequentlyquotesHomer,andhertitlerecallstheIliad.CharacterdevelopmentissimilartoHomers,andherbattledescriptionsremindusofthesame.AlexiosisheroiclikeAchilles,thoughfarlessdestructive.HisdeedsarelargerthanlifehislifesmissionandhislaborsweretosaveGodschosenpeople,theOrthodoxGreekRomanChristianEmpirefromitsenemies.InsteadofthefallofthecityTroy,asintheHomericstories,theAlexiaddepictsthesalvationofacity(Constantinople),althoughexpressingfearthatcurrentimperialpolicieswouldleadtomoretrials.Andso,inadditiontoextollingherfathersdeeds,theworkisacritiqueoftheimperialpoliciesofhernephew,Manuel,atthetimeitwaswritten,neartheendofherlifeinthelate1140s.64
TheAlexiadasaCritiqueofAlexiossSuccessorsHistorianshavequestionedthehistoricalvalueoftheAlexiadforseveralreasons,includingthat itwaswrittenbya less thanobjectivewoman,and iscoloredbyemotion,butalsobecauseherchronologyisincorrectinsomeplacesandherdescriptionsofsomekeyevents,suchasheroftquoteddescriptionofthearrivalofthecrusadersduringtheFirstCrusade,
62 Foradiscussionoftheauthorshipquestion,see:JamesHowardJohnston,AnnaKomneneandtheAlexiad,AlexiosIKomnenos,ed.MargaretMullettandDionSmythe(Holywood,NorthernIreland:PrioryPress,1996),260302.
63 EdwardGibbon,TheHistoryoftheDeclineandFalloftheRomanEmpire,ed.J.B.BurywithanIntroductionbyW.E.H.Lecky,12vols.(1776;NewYork:FreddeFauandCo.,1906),vol.8(Chapter48):287Yet,insteadofthesimplicityofstyleandnarrativewhichwinsourbelief,anelaborateaffectationofrhetoricandsciencebetraysineverypagethevanityofafemaleauthor.Seealso:EllenQuandahl,andSusanC.Jarratt,ToRecallHimWillbeaSubjectofLamentation:AnnaComnenaasRhetoricalHistoriographer,Rhetorica:AJournaloftheHistoryofRhetoric26.3(2008):30135;here308.
64 Magdalino,PenoftheAunt(seenote62),1516.
-
GlenM.Cooper280
are inaccurate.However, it has recently been shown thatAnnas treatment of severalsubjects,includingthearrivalofthecrusaders,reflectstheconcernsofthetimewhenshewas writing her book, in the 1140s rather than the 1090s.65 Her description fits thecircumstancesof theSecondCrusade,whichhadpassed throughConstantinople in the1140s,ratherthantheFirst.HerdescriptionofthoseeventswasanimplicitcriticismofhowManuel had handled the later crusaders.66 Moreover, she emphasizes her fatherscondemnationofastrology,hiskeendistrustofthewesternKelts(i.e.theFrenchandGermancrusaders),andhisChristianvirtuesasavehicletocriticizethereignofhernephew,Manuel.ManuelwasnotorioustomanyByzantinesforhisfavortowardwesternbarbarians,foreignbrides,andgivingawaytoomanyprincessesinpoliticalmarriagestowesterners,hisobsessionwith astrology, and hismanymistresses. Some of these vicesthe love forastrology,condemnedbytheChurch,andtheWestlovinginparticularwerelaterblamed,byChoniates and others, for provoking the divine judgment that fell on the Empire,resultinginitstragiccaptureandsackbytheVenetianledcrusadersduringtheillfatedFourthCrusadein1204.Inanextendedpassage,Annaprovidesanoverviewofthehistoryofastrology,apractice
ofwhichshedisapproves.Theoccasionwastorelatehowanastrologer,namedSeth,hadforetoldthedeathoftheEmpiresarchenemy,theNormanRobertGuiscard(d.1085).Shemakesadigression,whereshestatesthattheartofdivinationbyastrologywasarecentinvention,nothavingexistedintheancientworld.Sheclaimsthattherulesandconceptsofthisformofastrologywerearecentinvention.Thisis,ofcourse,mistaken,sincewenowknowthathoroscopicastrologywasdevelopedinHellenisticEgyptfromelementsthatweremuch older.67 P. Magdalino interprets Annas divination as oracular astrology,connectedwithforecastingthedeathsofrulersandthefuturesofdynasties.Thisformofastrology was associated with Sassanian Persia, and had been mingled with Greekastrological ideasduring thecreativeperiodof theGrecoArabic translations,especiallythoughthewritingsofAbMashar,towhomInextturn.68Rather thandismissAnnasaccountcompletely, there issome truth in it: thekindof
astrology that was being studied and practiced in her day had been thoroughlyrevolutionizedbytheArabicwritingsofAbMashar,theninthcenturyastrologer(Latin:Albumasar;Byzantine:Apomasar).Thedifferenceissignificantenoughtobenoticedwhenone compares the most scientific treatise of astrology from antiquity, namely, theTetrabiblosofPtolemy,withthesystemdevelopedbyAbMasharinhisGreatIntroduction
65 PaulStephenson,AnnaComnenasAlexiadasaSourcefortheSecondCrusade?,JournalofMedievalHistory29(2003):4154;here4244.
66 Stephenson,AnnaComnenasAlexiad(seenote67),44;53.67 GlenM.Cooper,Astrology:TheScienceofSignsintheHeavens,TheOxfordHandbooktoScienceandMedicine
in the Classical World, ed. Paul T. Keyser and John Scarborough (Oxford: Oxford University Press,Forthcoming).
68 Magdalino,Porphyrogenita(seenote11),1719.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 281
toJudicialAstrology.69AbMasharhadintegratedalloftheancientsciencesintohissystem,andtreatedastrologyasanAristotelianMasterScience.70AMasterScienceembracesallother disciplines in a special way: 1) all other sciences are but preparatory for it(propaedeutic),e.g.astronomyprovidestheplanetarypositions,butisincapable,withinitsownterms,toexplainwhattheconfigurationsmeanintermsofnaturalphilosophyforwhichastrologyisbothnecessaryandsuperiortoastronomy;and2)itoffersproofsofthebasicprinciplesthataremerelyassumedinthelowersciences.Aristotlesawaprogressionhere:weacceptsomeoftheprinciplesassumedinthelowersciencestentatively,untilwemovetothemasterscience,fromwhichvantagepointwecansurveythemallandseehowthewholesystemfitstogether.MetaphysicswasforAristotletheMasterScience,whichincludesbothmaterialandnonmaterialsubstancesandtheirchanges.ForAbMashar,medicineandastrologyaremostcloselyrelated:heevenstatesthatastrologyistheprinciple(awwal,awwaliyya)ofmedicine,suggestingthatmedicineisaformofappliedastrology.Annaclaimstohavelearnedtherudimentsofastrologyaspartofhereducation,butonly
inordertorefuteit.Shenotesthatastrologywasverypopularintheperiodbeforethereignofherfather,whoexertedmuchefforttoeradicateit,andtopromotetherealsciences.ShementionsSethperhaps thesamepersonasSymeonSethdiscussedearlieranda fewothersbyname, somewith connections to theArabworld.Faith in the stars she callssimpleminded.ItiseasytoseeinthispassageacriticismofManuel,who,accordingtoChoniates,wasasdevotedtotheartofastrologyasanyrulercouldbe.
TheControllingMedicalAnalogyoftheAlexiadAnnashowsherknowledgeofGreekhumoralmedicineviaagrandmedicalanalogythatstructureslargeportionsofhernarrativeintheAlexiad.AsfarasIknow,thisfeaturehasnotbeennoticedbefore.Sheinvokestheancientanalogyofthebodypolitic,andconsidersthefactorsthatmakeitill,orkeepithealthy,aswellasthesymptomsofitsinternalillnesses.ThisnotonlyshowsherownknowledgeofancientGreekmedicine,butalsoimpliesthatsheexpectedasophisticatedgraspofancientmedicalandpoliticalconceptsfromherreaders.Theanalogyisasfollows:theEmpireislikenedtoabody,withsocialandpoliticalfactors
takentobecausesofhealthorillness.Adisruptioninthestateisdescribedintermsofaphysicalillness.Restoringsocialorpoliticalorderisdescribedintermsofmedicaltherapy.Thisancientbodilypoliticalanalogywasexpressedmosteloquently inPlatosRepublic,
69 I.e.,KitbalMadkhalalkabr)al)ilmah. kmalnujm.AbMasharalBalkh[Albumasar],Liberintroductoriimaiorisadscientiamjudicorumastrorum,ed.R.Lemay(Naples:IstitutoUniversitarioOrientale,19951996).Ptolemy,Tetrabiblos,trans.F.E.Robbins,vol.435.LoebClassicalLibrary.Rpt.(1940;Cambridge,MA:HarvardUniversityPress,1980).
70 PeterAdamson,AbMa)shar,alKindandthePhilosophicalDefenseofAstrology,RecherchesdeThologieetPhilosophieMdivales69.2(2001):24570;here24749.
-
GlenM.Cooper282
whereitservestherhetoricalandanalyticalfunctionofallowingtheelementsofhisidealstatetobeexaminedmoreclosely.71Annawouldalsohavenotedthefrequentdiscussionofmedicineandphysiciansinthecontextofthepoliticalphilosophybeingdevelopedthere,aswellasthenotionoftheGuardianorphilosopherking,inwhosecarethestateistobeplaced.InAnnascase,theEmpireisafflictedfromwithinandwithoutbydangerousenemies,
bothmilitaryaswellasideological.Alexios,withhissuperiorunderstandingoftheartofimperialstatecraftontheonehand,andDestinyontheother,wasthephysician,underwhosecarethestatecouldbecured,i.e.restoredtoorderandsetonceagainonafirmfoundation.LargelysuccessfulindefeatingimperialenemieswithinandoutsidetheEmpire,thefinaltragedyisthatAlexios,whohasspenthiswholelifeintheserviceofhispeople,isfinally brought down by an actual illness, exacerbated by the misguided efforts ofincompetent physicians. By including a description of his final illness, Anna, whosebiographytothatpointhasassumedheroicdimensions,addsthetragicelement:theGreatManisbroughtlow.Shesensestheincongruityherself,whenshestatesthatbysodoing,shetransgresses the laws of history.72Nevertheless, the tragic is appropriate in a classicalcontext,sinceclassicaltragedyconcernedlargerthanlifefigures,suchastheAlexiosoftheAlexiad.Thispoliticamedicalanalogyispresentedimmediatelybeforeweareintroducedtothe
NormanRobertGuiscard(d.1085)whoalongwithhissonBohemondofTaranto(d.1111),arelongtermthreatstothehealthoftheEmpireAnnaclassifiesRobertasanincurabledisease.73InaccordwithGreekmedicaltheory,Annaobservesthatdiseasescanhavetwobroadclassesofcauses:externalandinternal.Whilethelatteraremoredangerous,becausethey threaten the internalorgans, thedangersof the former are impossible to control,preciselybecause they are external (and, she adds, arebrought onbyFatea strangecomment foronewhobelievesastrology is foolish).Guiscardandhis sonare externalafflictions,whereasBasiltheBogomil(andotherrebelswithintheEmpire,suchasRoussel,Basilakios,andallpretenderstothethronefromwithintheEmpire)areinternalafflictions.TheproperformoftreatmentfortheseafflictionsinthelongtraditionofGreekmedicine
is:fortheformer,onemusttrytoremovetheexternalfactor.ThisAlexiosdoesthroughwarfareagainsttheNormans,andotherbarbarians.Forthelatter,thephysicianmustinducethepatientsbodytopurgetheafflictionasquicklyaspossible,inordertominimizeinternaldamage.Alexios seeks toneutralize these threats eitherviamilitary actionor throughnegotiations,showingclemencytomostrebels,ifrepentant.Nosuchmercy,however,is
71 Plato,Republic, 368e369b;434d in:Plato,PlatosRepublic,trans.G.M.A.Grube(1974;Indianapolis,IN:HackettPublishingCompany,1987),3839;99.Platostripartitedivisionofthesoulintoarational,spirited,andappetitivepart,correspondsinthebodytothehead,chest,andabdomenandsexorgans,respectively,andinthestatetotheguardians(philosopherkings),thesoldiers,andthefarmersandlaborers,respectively.
72 Alexiad15.11(seenote5),trans.46364;ed.494.73 Alexiad1.10(seenote5),trans.2930;ed.3435.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 283
extendedtoBasiltheheretic,who,inspiteofAlexiosspersonalefforts(Annaemphasizes)refusestorecanthisheresy,andso isconsignedtotheflames.74Themedicalanalogy isapplicable at this level also: since fiery fevers prepare the body to expel the diseasedsubstance,purgationofheresyfromthestatebyburningtheunrepentanthereticwouldseemtobethemostappropriateprocedure.Ifthiswerenotso,andthedeathofthehereticwas theprimaryobjective, thenwhynotsimplydecapitateorexecutehim insome lessritualisticmannerthanbyburning?Alexioswasnotcompletelywithoutinvolvementinmedicalmatters,asshownbythe
attentionhegavetorestoringandrefoundingofthenotedOrphanage(orphanotropheion),whichhadfacilitiestocarefortheelderlyandinfirm.75Hisson,JohnII,continuedthefamilytraditionofmedicalcharity.InthePantokratorMonastery,whichhefounded,heincludedhospital facilities, which are described in its foundation charter. His facility was asophisticatedhealinginstitution,thelargestintheEmpire.76
TheDeathofAlexios:AnnasCritiqueofthePhysiciansInowturntoAnnasaccountofherfathersfinalillnessanddeath,whichisoneofthemostdetailedmedicaldescriptionsinmedievalliterature.Inthisaccount,Annasimultaneouslyexhibitsherownmedicalknowledge,anddemonstratestheincompetenceofthephysiciansentrustedwithherfatherscare.Sheprovidesasystematicaccountoftheprogressoftheillness,sometimesnotingthedaycountedfromthebeginningonwhichchangesoccur,inamannersimilartotheHippocraticEpidemics,thetreatisewhichbegantheGreektraditionof tracking the daytoday progress of illnesses.Only one of the physicians,NicholasKallikles(fl.midtwelfthcentury),wastrulycompetentinherview.77HecorrectlysurmisedAlexiossconditionaswellasthepropertreatment,buthisviewswerevoteddown.Alexiossfinaldeclinebeganaboutayearandahalfafterhehadreturnedfromhisfinal
militarycampaigns(aroundFebruary,1118).AviolentwindblastedConstantinople,whichcaused a shift inAlexioss humors, causing them to settle in his shoulder and neck.78AccordingtoGreekmedicaltheory,dramaticmeteorologicalchangestendedtoaffecttheinternalstatesofpatients.AlthoughAnnadoesntmentionastrology,astrologicalinfluenceswerethoughttobeofthesameorderastheweatherininfluencingpatients.Asalready
74 Alexiad15.9(seenote5),trans.45963;ed.48993.75 Alexiad,15.7(seenote5),trans.45456;ed.48185.76 KazhdanandEpstein,ChangeinByzantineCulture(seenote14),15657;TimothyS.Miller,TheBirthofthe
HospitalintheByzantineEmpire(BaltimoreandLondon:TheJohnsHopkinsUniversityPress,1997),9,14.77 Kallikleswas also an important poet, and some scholars think he authored the Timarion, the famous
anonymous satiricalwork.KazhdanandEpstein,Change inByzantineCulture (seenote14),139.For theTimarion,seeKaldellis,Hellenism(seenote1),27783.
78 Alexiad15.11(seenote5),trans.464;ed.494.
-
GlenM.Cooper284
noted,Annasattitudetowardastrologywasdismissive,andformsoneofthepointsofcriticismofhernephew,Manuel.ThedangerinAlexiosssituationwasthoughttoarisefromthehumorsbeingconcentrated
inanunnaturalmanner,inonepartofhisbody.Thehumorswereelementalfluidsblood,phlegm,yellowbile,andblackbilethemixtureandflowofwhichwereusedtoexplainillnessandhealth,andtoindicatestrategiesoftherapy.Thenaturalconditionofahumanbodyisforhumorstoflowthroughandoutofthebodywithoutobstruction.Concentrationofhumorsindicatedanobstructionofsomekind,andthepossibilitythatthehumorswouldputrefyandbegintodestroyvitaltissuethattheycontact.Therefore,thepropertherapywasto evacuate thehumors beforedamage could occur, and this could bedone either bydraining,orbyencouragingthebodytoconcoct(cook)thebadhumorsandexpelthemassediment in theurine,or in theexcrement,orperspiration,orviasomeotherbodilysecretion.Thisprocesscouldbeencouraged,whenurgent,throughemeticorcatharticdrugs,whichexpelleddangeroushumorsthroughvomiting.Thisexpulsiveeventwascalledacrisis.79
Annawasnotedforhermedicalknowledge,therudimentsofwhichsheobtainedaspartofherclassicaleducation.80Forthisreason,hermother,EmpressEirene,appointedherasamedical liaisonbetween thedoctorscounciland the imperial family, to interpret thedoctorsdiagnosesanddeliberations.81Althoughshewasnotallowedtoparticipateinthedecisionmaking,nor todiagnosenorprescribeanything,shewaspermitted topreparemealsfor,andfeedherfather.82KallikleswastheonlyoneofthedoctorswhonoticedthedangerAlexioswasinfromthe
concentrationofhumors.Eitherhehadhimselfobserveda swellingonAlexios,or theEmperorhadcomplainedofpainthere.Kalliklesknewthatthehumorsmustbeevacuatedimmediately.Asnotedearlier,drugswereusedtohastentheexpulsionoftheaccumulatedhumors. The proper order of treatment, according to the Hippocratic school andrecommendedalsobyGalen,wasdietfirst,thendrugs,andonlyafterthesemethodsfail,toresorttosurgery,suchasbleeding,and ifthatfails,cautery.83Sometimesregulating thepatientsnourishmentwassufficienttoinduceabeneficialcrisis.Inthepresentsituation,however,Kallikles surmised thatmoreurgentmeasuresmust be taken.However, theimperialpatienthadnevertakendrugs.Purgativescouldbetraumaticonthepatient,so,
79 Fordetaileddiscussion of themedical concept of crisis, see:Galen,De diebus decretoriis, ed.Cooper,Commentary(seenote59),39094.
80 GeorgeTornikes,14.logedAnneComnne:DiscourssurlamortdelaPorphyrognte,KyraAnnelaKaisarissa,GeorgesetDmtriosTorniks.LettresetDiscours.Introduction,Texte,Analyses,TraductionetNotesparJeanDarrouzs.LeMondeByzantin(Paris:ditionsduCentreNationaldelaRechercheScientifique,1970),220323;here307.Seealso:Browning,UnpublishedFuneralOration(seenote19),396.
81 Alexiad,15.11(seenote5),trans.46465;ed.494.82 Alexiad,15.11(seenote5),trans.468;ed.49798.83 Hippocrates,Aphorisms,7.87,HippocratesVolumeIV:LoebClassicalLibrary,ed.W.H.S.Jones(1931;Cambridge,
MA:HarvardUniversityPress,1992),21617.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 285
withoutknowingwhateffecttheymighthaveonAlexios,thecouncilofdoctorsdecideditbesttoavoidthem.Kalliklesswarningthatifthehumorswerenotimmediatelyevacuatedbydrugs,thediseasedmaterialmightflowintooneofthevitalorgans,suchastheheart,andbegintodestroyit,wasignored.Tothegreatreliefofeveryone,theillnessapparentlyvanishedafteranexpectednumber
ofdays.Annaalludestotheancientmedicalschemeofthecriticaldays,accordingtowhichspecifickindsofillnesseshaveexpectedlifespans,andtheircharacter,whetheracuteorchronic,aswellaswhethertheywillendinrecoveryordeath,canbeinferredfromhowtheillnesschangesonspecificdays,measuredfromitsbeginning.Thisschemeisagainreferredtoneartheendoftheaccount,whenAnnanotesthatAlexiosdiedtheeleventhdayoftheillness.84However,thiswasafalserecovery,andKalliklessdiagnosiswasvindicated,sincesixmonthslatertheillnessreturnedinadeadlyform(August,1118).Thefirstsymptomsofthefinalillnessappearedinthechest:thedangeroushumorshadmovedfromtheshouldersto thechestcavity,asKallikleshadpredicted.Alexios feltaheaviness inhischest,anddifficultybreathing.Alexioswas no ordinaryprivilegedpatient, forwhosediseases one could blame an
unhealthy lifestyle, such as toomuchof thewrong sortsof food, and lackofphysicalexercise.Toomuchofthewrongkindsoffoodscouldproduceaplethoraofbadhumors,andlackofactivitycouldhinderthefreeflowofthehumors,soimportantformaintaininggoodhealth.Helivedthesimple,almostascetic,lifestyleofasoldier.Theancientdoctorscounseledtheirpatientstomaintainaregimenthatwouldtendtoproduceanidealbalancedbodyinabalancedlifestyle.Annaobservesthatstressandworrycanalsodamageapatientshealth,andAlexioshasspenthislifeinperpetualstressovertheaffairsofstate.85Indeed,AnnaattributesanearlierseriousillnessofAlexiostothestresscausedbytheinnumerableKeltswhowereinvadingtheEmpire.86Alexioscertainlyhadthefinancialmeanstofollowahealthyregimen,supervisedbyanynumberofthebestdoctorsintheEmpire.Buthedidnot,whichwashissacrificeforhispeople,forthatwouldhavemeant,inhismind,neglectingthedireemergenciesofstatewithwhichhewasconstantlyfaced.Astheillnessprogressed,Alexiossbreathingbecameextremelydifficult.Moreover,he
couldnotreclineonhissideonaccountofpainthere,andsohadtoremainupright.Noremedy,includingbleeding,wastoanyavail.Bloodlettingwasacommonformofsurgerytoaffectthedispositionofthehumors.Sincebloodwasthemostaccessiblehumortodrain,physiciansthoughtthatbyalteringthehumoralbalance,theotherhumorswouldrespond,causingthedangerousplethoratodissipate.87
84 Fordayeleven,seeGalen,Dediebusdecretoriis,ed.Cooper,K793(seenote59),13839;andCommentary,413;423.
85 SeeGalen,Dediebusdecretoriis,ed.Cooper,K826(seenote59),19899;andCommentary,434.86 Alexiad,14.4(seenote5),trans.41011;ed.43840.87 SeePeterBrainsusefulstudy:GalenonBloodletting:AStudyoftheOrigins,DevelopmentandValidityofHis
Opinions,withaTranslationoftheThreeWorks(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,1986).
-
GlenM.Cooper286
Whenbleedingfailed,thephysiciansresortedtopepperasakindofpurgative.88Pepperwasthoughttoprovokeasmallartificialcrisis,viasweating,whichmightexpelthediseasedhumors.The resultwashopeful, as some of the symptoms temporarily lessened.Thisimproved condition lasted only three to fourdays, afterwhich the painful symptomsreturned.Annaexplainedthatthepepperactuallymadehisconditionworse,bynotonlyfailing toexpel thecorrupthumors,butdispersing them into thespaces inhisarteries,where,lurking,theyremainedadangertohim.Thenext symptoms to appearwere swellingof the abdomen and lower extremities,
accompaniedbyfever.Thedoctorsattackedtheswellingfirst,throughcautery,buttonoavail.Toattempttodissipateaconcentrationofhumorswithhotironssuggestsdesperatemeasures.89Furthermore,thismeasuremusthavehorrifiedAnna,sincethehotironwasoftenusedtoputouttheeyesofpretenderstothethrone,torenderthemunfittorule,asakindermeasurethanexecution.ShedescribesseveralepisodesofblindingintheAlexiad.90Soontheswellingspreadtohismouthandthroat,sothatthepatientcouldnotswallowwithoutdifficulty.Annawasentrustedwithfeedinghim,oneof theonlymedical tasksavailabletoawoman,evenoneofAnnaslearning.Afterelevendays,thepatientdied.Theeleventhdaywasacriticaldayonwhichonemightexpecttoseechangesintheillnessthatwouldleadeithertorecoveryortodeath.AlthoughAlexiossuffereddiarrhea,atypicalcriticalsymptom,whichoftenindicatedthatabeneficialcrisiswasoccurring,hedied.Thepatientwassoweakenedbytheillnessthathecouldnotsurviveacrisis,evenifhehadexperiencedone.
Conclusion
IncontrasttoManuelsverypublicdisplaysofhismedicalknowledge,Annaexpressedhermedicalknowledge,bothinthefabricofherhistory,aswellasintheextendeddescriptionandanalysisofher fathers final illness.Manuelsdisplayswerenotwithoutapoliticalmessagetoforeignrulers,namely,thatthebestmedicineistobefoundinConstantinople.NeitherisAnnasaccountwithoutapoliticaldimension.Inhercase,sheisculminatingthepersonathatshehasbeendevelopingofherselfforfifteenbooksasoneeducatedinancientGreekcultureandconversantinphilosophy.Shedoesthis,Ibelieve,asawaytostrengthen
88 Galen,OnthePropertiesofFoodstuffs(Dealimentorumfacultatibus),trans.OwenPowell(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2003),38;Galen,Dealimentorumfacultatibus,OperaOmnia,vol.6,ed.C.G.Khn(Leipzig:CarlCnobloch,1823),453748;here477.
89 JoelleJouannaBouchet,LaCautrisationdanslaMdecineAntique:tudesurleVocabulaire,lesInstrumentsetlesTechniquesdanslaLittratureLatine,Galenos1(2007):87111.
90 Alexiad1.3(seenote5),trans.1415;ed.1617;9.9,trans.257;ed.279.See:JohnLascaratos,andS.Marketos,ThePenaltyofBlindingDuringByzantineTimes.MedicalRemarks,DocumentaOphthalmologica81.1(1992):13344.
-
ByzantiumbetweenEastandWest 287
herclaimtothethrone,eventhoughitwasthwartedbyherbrotherJohn,thirtyyearsearlier,andbythispointshecouldhavehadnohopeofeverachievingimperialpower.Implicitinheraccount,however, isherbelief thata rulereducated inphilosophy (andhistory) issuperior to onewho isnot, even if that ruler is awoman.TheEasternHellenism shevalidateslooksprimarilytotheclassicalGreekpast,unadulteratedbyforeign(sc.barbarian)influences.HerattitudetowardimportationsfromArabicisgenerallydismissive.Manuel,ontheotherhand,findsuse inelementsofaWesternHellenism,namely,theLatinizedGrecoArabictradition.He,too,useshisknowledgeofthistradition,especiallyinmedicineandastrology,topresenthimselfasanidealRomanemperor,onetowhomallbarbarianrulersoweobeisance.AnnacreatesthepersonaofherfatherintheAlexiadwithasimilarpurpose,showing thather idealrulermaintainsaproperdistance from thebarbarians.UnfortunatelyforAnna,thecontestwenttothefactionwithpoliticalsavvy,connections,andgenderonitsside,which,ironically,isjustwhatAlexioswouldhavewanted.UnfortunatelyforManueland theEmpire,hisexcessive familiaritywith theLatinscontributed to thedownfallofhisdynastyandByzantiumitself,orsoitwouldseem.Thisarticlehas examined contrastingByzantineHellenismsprimarily in themedical
context.Nodoubt,throughfurtheranddeeperexaminationoftheAlexiadandbycomparingitwithotheraspectsofManuelscareer,aswellaswithothercontemporaryByzantineintellectuals,itmightbepossibletorefineandextendthethesisformulatedhere.However,forthemomentitseemsquiteclearthatAnnasdisplayofmedicalknowledgerepresentsbothherconceptoftheidealruler,aswellasherclaimtobethelegitimateheirofherfather.ThefateofAnnasEasternHellenism,ontheotherhand,wasnotwhatshemighthave
wished.WesternHellenismwasamorevigorousandversatiletool,andeventuallyproveditselftobethemoreprogressiveandenduring.WhatboththeArabicHellenismofBaghdad,and theAraboLatin (Western)Hellenism ofToledo andPalermodemonstrate are theadvantages of allowing the best of foreign influences to mingle freely in intellectualdiscourse.ThisisjustwhatAnnawantedtoavoid:cantherebeanythinggoodthatcouldcomefromthebarbariansofeitherWestorEast?AndthegrowinghostilitybetweenEastandWestmerelyintensifiedtheintellectualxenophobiaofByzantineculture.IntheWest,thetremendousintellectualachievementsofThomasAquinas,reconcilingreasonandfaithforhisage,weremadepossiblebytheamalgamationofallstrandsofthoughtthatmayhaveeitheroriginatedintheancientGreektradition,orwereinspiredbyit,suchasthecreativeoutpouringofArabicthoughtthathereliedupon.EventuallytheSummaofThomaswastranslatedintoGreek,inthefourteenthcenturybyDemetriusKydones(13241398),butbythatpointByzantiumwaslosingtherace.
-
Blank Page