business incubation case studybusiness incubation …one more economic development strategy at our...

54
Business Incubation Case Study

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jun-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


6 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation Case Study

Page 2: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Preview

1. Intro to Business Incubation A. General

B. Northwest Regional Planning Commission

2. Virtual Incubation

3. Physical Business Incubation

4. Building Your Own Incubator

Page 3: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation: Introduction

Page 4: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Definition

Business Incubation is…

the process of accelerating the growth and success of start-up and early stage companies through an array of business support resources and services that could include:

- Physical space

- Capital

- Coaching

- Common services &

- Networking connections.

Page 5: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal.

STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business Recruitment STRATEGY 3 Downtown Redevelopment STRATEGY 4 Business Incubation

Another Tool in the Toolbox…

Page 6: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Why Businesses Fail

1. Lack of Know-How

- Little understanding of business fundamentals

- Little prior business experience

- Poor preparation, initiation and planning

2. Lack of Capital

- Many start up with too little capital

Page 7: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

About 48% of businesses are still alive by Year 5.

(52% are DEAD!)

In an incubation environment the 5-year

survival rate is 87%

Incubation significantly boosts new business survival rates.

Incubation effect

87% survival rate for

incubated companies

Survival Rates Improve

Page 8: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Average 2.5 years company starts

to take off

3-6 years company graduates

from incubator 7-10 years

things get exciting

YEARS

It’s a long term strategy

Company enters Incubator

Page 9: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

FAIL FAIL

Moderate

Struggle

Success

Home Run

Struggle

Moderate

Success

Moderate

75+ emp.

50 - 75 emp.

10 - 50 emp.

< 10 emp.

Success Varies

Page 10: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Results to date 40 Companies 373 jobs $53 Million in Annual Sales $16.8 Million Annual Payroll $42.2 Million Private Investment

Company Age Emp.

A 4 years 47

B 5 years 34

C 5 years 18

D 5 years 17

E 7 years 14

But It Really Works!

Page 11: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 12: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

20,000 sf Incubator 2 tenants

12,000 sf Incubator 3 tenants

Incubator graduates

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

20,000 sf & 12,000 sf

Grantsburg, WI

Pop. 1,200

Page 13: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Siren Enterprise Center 16,000 sf

Siren, WI

Pop. 806

Page 14: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Spooner Enterprise Center

(four facilities) 60,000 sf

Spooner, WI

Pop. 677

Page 15: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

“Virtual” Business Incubation

(Start here)

Page 16: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Too many vacancies downtown! Business Plan Contest

Round 1 – 1 page describing idea Round 2 – Business Plan Round 3 – Presentation / Q&A Prizes

$10,000 start-up capital $2,000 sign & awning grant Website Newspaper & Radio advertising Chamber membership Coaching / mentoring (SBDC & SWIF)

Partners

Page 17: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Building Renovation

Page 18: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Elena’s Bakery “The Sweet Spot”

Page 19: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy
Page 20: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

https://youtu.be/k9RX5WAxtbA

Stamp-N-Storage

Business Plan Contest

Prizes

$5,000 working capital Coaching / mentoring

Page 21: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Physical Business Incubation

Page 22: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Goals

1. Populate industrial park

2. Diversify local economy

3. Spark entrepreneurial activity

4. Build tax base

5. Additional customers for power utility

6. Create jobs

Page 23: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Location

Industrial Park

Page 24: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Building Layout

80’ wide bays Bathrooms 2 Docks 2 Docks roughed in 3 drive-in doors Utilities separately metered

Page 25: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Manufacturing

Must “Export”

Physical growth required

Admission Criteria

Page 26: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Company Requirements

Coach / mentor (SBDC and / or Initiative Foundation)

Monthly check in w/ Incubator Staff

“Drop money to bottom line”

If successful – establishing their own facility.

Page 27: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Won’t compete with private leasing.

We’re not “renting space” – we’re incubating companies.

No “lifestyle” businesses

No service businesses

Selective admission criteria

Dealing with Private Sector

Page 28: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Features

Low rents ($3.84 psf)

Education

Resources

Page 29: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 30: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 31: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Interior

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 32: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Interior

Page 33: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

20,000 sf 5 bays (each 4,000 sf) 2,000 sf offices Conference Room Work Room Break Room Guest Offices (2)

Key card entry system

SB2030 energy standard

Page 34: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 35: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 36: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 37: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 38: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 39: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 40: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 41: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Laser marking, laser etching and laser engraving Many of the products are class III implantable

devices. Obtaining ISO 9001 Certification 8,000 sf Current employment 3 Ft / 2 PT 2-Year projection 10 FT 3-year projection 15 FT

Page 42: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 43: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Manufacturer of precision cut foam, polystyrene and Styrofoam.

“If you can dream it, we can built it with foam!”

5,000 sf 3 FT employees

Page 44: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 45: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 46: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 47: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Construction Budget

Line Item Cost

Architectural & Engineering $55,000

Construction Monitoring $38,030

Site work / Parking lots / Footings & Foundations $705,140

Building / Interior SOG / etc. $1,332,860

Alternates $182,200

Miscellaneous (Key Card Entry / I-T items) $17,752

Contingency $128,681

TOTAL $2,459,663

Base bid was $2,038,000

Page 48: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Alternates Included

Alternate Cost

Offices $138,800

Concrete truck lot $11,300

Windows / Drywall $25,000

8’ Metal Liner $7,100

TOTAL $182,200

Page 49: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Funding Your Incubator

Page 50: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Funding Your Incubator

I. Tax Increment Financing A. Existing Tax Increment

B. Economic Development TIF District

II. MIF Dollars A. De-federalized

B. Federalized

III. City A. Excess Bond Fund

B. General Fund Balance

IV. Federal EDA

Page 51: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Action Steps

Join InBIA.

Attend InBIA Annual Conference.

Visit Hutchinson.

Do a “virtual” incubation project.

Page 52: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Review

1. Intro to Business Incubation A. General

B. Northwest Regional Planning Commission

2. Virtual Incubation

3. Physical Business Incubation

4. Building Your Own Incubator

Page 53: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Questions?

Page 54: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation Case Study