budget and legislative analyst · city planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69%...

116
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO BOARD OF SUPERVISORS BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST 1390 Market Street, Suite 1150, San Francisco, CA 94102 (415) 5529292 FAX (415) 2520461 Budget and Legislative Analyst 1 Policy Analysis Report To: Supervisor Kim From: Budget and Legislative Analyst’s Office Re: Study of Municipal Fines Date: February 9, 2016 Summary of Requested Action Your office requested that the Budget and Legislative Analyst conduct a study on municipal fines. Specifically, you requested that we establish a comprehensive list of all the municipal fines that the City has the power to levy on residents and visitors including: (1) what fines exist; (2) the frequency of the fines; (3) the amount of monies that each fine elicits for the City on an annual basis; and, (4) the options for repayment for each fine as well as the consequences if the fine is not paid. You also requested that we calculate the revenues brought in from municipal fines as a percentage of the citywide budget. For further information about this report, contact Severin Campbell at the Budget and Legislative Analyst’s Office. Executive Summary As seen in the comprehensive list of municipal fines attached to this report, we have identified approximately 430 violations of City ordinance or contracts over the last three fiscal years that are subject to a fine. Further, we found that 1,866,614 municipal citations were issued in Fiscal Year (FY) 201415 and $88,639,237 1 in revenue was collected in FY 201415 from municipal fines. This represents about 1.03 percent of the FY 201415 budget as proposed by the Mayor in June 2014. 2 As seen in Exhibit 1 below, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (MTA) issued a majority of citywide citations over the last three years. MTA citations have primarily been issued for parking on a street during street sweeping days and hours, failure to pay a parking meter, parking in excess of the hours permitted in a residential or carpool zone, and improper parking on grades. 1 This amount includes revenues collected on Port property that in some cases is due to the enforcement of State code. The comprehensive list attached to this report does not include this revenue and sums to $85,891,987. 2 The Mayor’s proposed Budget and Appropriation Ordinance as of June 2, 2014 included $8,566,996,836 in projected total sources of funds.

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jun-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

CITY  AND  COUNTY  OF  SAN  FRANCISCO  BOARD  OF  SUPERVISORS  BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST 

1390 Market Street, Suite 1150, San Francisco, CA 94102  (415) 552‐9292  FAX (415) 252‐0461

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

Policy Analysis Report 

To:   Supervisor Kim       

From:   Budget and Legislative Analyst’s Office 

Re:   Study of Municipal Fines 

Date:   February 9, 2016 

 

Summary of Requested Action 

Your office  requested  that  the Budget  and  Legislative Analyst  conduct  a  study on municipal 

fines.  Specifically,  you  requested  that we establish  a  comprehensive  list of  all  the municipal 

fines that the City has the power to levy on residents and visitors including: (1) what fines exist; 

(2) the frequency of the fines; (3) the amount of monies that each fine elicits for the City on an 

annual basis; and,  (4) the options  for repayment  for each  fine as well as the consequences  if 

the  fine  is  not  paid.    You  also  requested  that  we  calculate  the  revenues  brought  in  from 

municipal fines as a percentage of the citywide budget. 

For  further  information about  this  report,  contact  Severin Campbell at  the Budget and  Legislative 

Analyst’s Office.  

 

Executive Summary 

As  seen  in  the comprehensive  list of municipal  fines attached  to  this  report, we have 

identified approximately 430 violations of City ordinance or contracts over the last three 

fiscal  years  that  are  subject  to  a  fine.  Further,  we  found  that  1,866,614 municipal 

citations  were  issued  in  Fiscal  Year  (FY)  2014‐15  and  $88,639,2371  in  revenue  was 

collected in FY 2014‐15 from municipal fines. This represents about 1.03 percent of the 

FY 2014‐15 budget as proposed by the Mayor in June 2014.2 

As  seen  in Exhibit 1 below,  the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency  (MTA) 

issued  a majority  of  citywide  citations  over  the  last  three  years. MTA  citations  have 

primarily been  issued  for parking on a  street during  street  sweeping days and hours, 

failure to pay a parking meter, parking in excess of the hours permitted in a residential 

or carpool zone, and improper parking on grades. 

                                                                 

1 This amount includes revenues collected on Port property that in some cases is due to the enforcement of State code. The comprehensive list attached to this report does not include this revenue and sums to $85,891,987. 

2  The Mayor’s  proposed  Budget  and  Appropriation  Ordinance  as  of  June  2,  2014  included  $8,566,996,836  in projected total sources of funds. 

Page 2: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

As seen in Exhibit 2 below, the MTA also collected the highest amount of revenue from 

the  issuance  of municipal  fines.  In  total, MTA  collected  $82,438,866  in  FY  2014‐15, 

primarily from the same violations with the highest number of citations issued (parking 

on  a  street  during  street  sweeping  days  and  hours,  failure  to  pay  a  parking meter, 

parking in excess of the hours permitted in a residential or carpool zone, and improper 

parking on grades). 

   

Page 3: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

Exhibit 1: Total Number of Citations Issued 

FY 2012‐13 through FY 2014‐15 

 Department 

 

Total Number of Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Citations Percent of 

Total  Citations Percent of 

Total  Citations Percent of 

Total 

Airport*  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  868  0.05% 

Building Inspection  773  0.04%  602  0.03%  670  0.04% 

City Administrator  215  0.01%  151  0.01%  106  0.01% 

City Planning  82  0.00%  83  0.00%  86  0.00% 

Controller3  2  0.00%  5  0.00%  12  0.00% 

Courts  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

District Attorney  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

Economic and Workforce Development 

0  0.00%  1  0.00%  4  0.00% 

Ethics Commission  7  0.00%  6  0.00%  16  0.00% 

Fire  0  0.00%  3  0.00%  8  0.00% 

Library  615,692  30.63%  591,200  31.45%  584,788  31.33% 

Municipal Transportation Agency 

1,353,389  67.34%  1,243,287  66.15%  1,228,978  65.84% 

Police  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

Port  37,608  1.87%  41,739  2.22%  44,909  2.41% 

Public Health**  58  0.00%  71  0.00%  85  0.00% 

Public Utilities Commission  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  8  0.00% 

Public Works  1,393  0.07%  2,004  0.11%  3,245  0.17% 

Recreation and Parks***  649  0.03%  417  0.02%  2,831  0.15% 

Sheriff  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

Treasurer/Tax Collector  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

Total  2,009,868  100.00%  1,879,569  100.00%  1,866,614  100.00% 

* Does not count the number of traffic citations 

**Does not count the number of garbage and refuse citations 

***Recreation and Park Department is missing data for September 2013 – December 2013  

 

   

                                                                 

3  The  Controller’s  Office  is  not  the  charging  department  for  these  citations.  Rather,  the  Controller’s  Office manages  the 

administrative appeals process under Chapter 100 of the Administrative Code. These numbers reflect citation appeals enforced by the Controller’s Office, but charged by another department. 

Page 4: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

Exhibit 2: Total Citation Revenue Collected 

FY 2012‐13 through FY 2014‐15 

 Department 

 

Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Citation Revenue Percent of 

Total Citation Revenue 

Percent of Total 

Citation Revenue 

Percent of Total 

Airport  $157,199  0.16%  $167,162  0.18%  $438,643  0.49% 

Building Inspection  $742,839  0.75%  $563,415  0.61%  $560,158  0.63% 

City Administrator  $438,835  0.44%  $520,550  0.56%  $545,264  0.62% 

City Planning  $127,396  0.13%  $780,066  0.84%  $610,921  0.69% 

Controller4  $400  0.00%  $2,100  0.00%  $3,000  0.00% 

Courts  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

District Attorney  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

Economic and Workforce Development 

$0  0.00%  $1,356  0.00%  $4,987  0.01% 

Ethics Commission  $10,380  0.01%  $24,500  0.03%  $35,950  0.04% 

Fire  $0  0.00%  $3,000  0.00%  $8,000  0.01% 

Library  $599,552  0.61%  $509,762  0.55%  $458,464  0.52% 

Municipal Transportation Agency 

$92,825,846  93.81%  $87,272,410  93.75%  $82,438,866  93.00% 

Police  $110,456  0.11%  $81,702  0.09%  $77,279  0.09% 

Port*  $3,495,068  3.53%  $2,875,719  3.09%  $2,747,250  3.10% 

Public Health**  $311,260  0.31%  $160,956  0.17%  $364,505  0.41% 

Public Utilities Commission  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  $135,814  0.15% 

Public Works  $129,024  0.13%  $123,254  0.13%  $210,136  0.24% 

Recreation and Park***  $0  0.00%  $0  0.00%  $0  0.00% 

Sheriff  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

Treasurer/Tax Collector  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐  N/A  ‐ 

Total  $98,948,256  100.00%  $93,085,952  100.00%  $88,639,237  100.00% 

*Revenue includes state violation citation revenue earned 

**Does not count garbage and refuse citations 

***Recreation and Park Department is missing data for September 2013 – December 2013.  

 

 

                                                                 

4  The  Controller’s  Office  is  not  the  charging  department  for  these  citations.  Rather,  the  Controller’s  Office manages  the 

administrative appeals process under Chapter 100 of  the Administrative Code. These numbers  reflect  revenue  from citation appeals enforced by the Controller’s Office, but charged by another department. 

Page 5: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

California  Government  Code  Section  53069.4  and  Chapter  100  of  the  City’s 

Administrative  Code  establish  standard  procedures  for  the  imposition,  enforcement, 

collection,  and  administrative  review  of  “administrative  fines.”  These  code  sections 

govern many of the municipal fines cited  in San Francisco. However, very few citations 

undergo the administrative appeals process staffed by the Controller’s Office—only 12 

total violations underwent  the appeals process  in FY 2014‐15.  If  fine amounts are not 

explicitly  stated  in  the  respective  code  provision,  charging  officials may  consider  ten 

factors when  determining  the  amount  of  the  fine. Municipal  fines  not  governed  by 

Chapter 100 of the Administrative Code are generally governed by the code section that 

they reside or, in some cases, by agreement with a vendor. 

 

The  City  lacks  a  uniform  citation‐tracking  protocol  across  departments. Although  the 

Controller’s Office tracks revenue from fines, fees, and forfeitures, this data comingles 

revenue  from  fees  for  services  and does not  include  all  fine  revenue  across  the City. 

Further, some City departments issue one citation for multiple violations or do not track 

the  revenue  that  is  received  from  citations, making  it difficult  to  tie  the number  and 

dollar  amounts  of  citations  to  violations.  An  additional  complication  is  that  many 

citations are State codes, which are enforced locally with revenue either shared with or 

provided completely to the State.  

 

The  City’s  codes,  including  the  Health  Code,  include  many  citations  that  are  not 

enforced and appear to be obsolete. For example, Article 12 of the Health Code includes 

a  section  regulating  the  manufacture  of  shoddy,  a  recycled  wool  textile  that  was 

common  in  the  19th  century.  Additionally,  the  City  has  a  Port  Code  that  is  rarely 

enforced, and is a holdover from when the City had separate Port fire and police forces. 

Further, we note in this report several instances where it appears that departments are 

not  enforcing  various  codes  as  demonstrated  by  the  lack  of  citations  issued  for 

violations over the past three fiscal years.  

  

Project staff: Jennifer Millman, Jadie Wasilco, and Dan Goncher    

   

Page 6: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

 

The City’s Administrative Fines 

 Municipal Administrative Fines 

City officers or employees with authority to enforce certain ordinances (“charging 

officials”) may  issue  a  citation when  an  individual  or  party  has  violated  one  or 

more provisions of certain City ordinances. A fine is defined by the Administrative 

Code5 to mean the dollar amount of the administrative fine that the person cited 

is required to pay for violation of an ordinance as set forth by the charging official. 

 

California  Government  Code  Section  53069.46  and  Chapter  1007  of  the  City’s 

Administrative  Code  provide  the  governance  framework  for  the  imposition, 

enforcement, collection, and administrative review of municipal “administrative” 

citations  and  fines  in  San  Francisco.  Although  many  municipal  fines  in  San 

Francisco are considered administrative citations and therefore governed by these 

two  code  sections, other municipal  fines are governed by  the ordinances under 

which they were established as described in more detail below in the department‐

specific  sections and  in  the comprehensive  list, which  is attached  to  this  report. 

Chapter 100 of  the Administrative Code only  governs municipal  fines when  the 

ordinances under which they were established identify them to be “administrative 

fines.”   

 

The Administrative Code also  stipulates  that  the  charging official may provide a 

notice of the citation to the owner of real property when there is a nexus between 

the violation and  the  real property  located  in  the City. The charging official may 

also impose a lien on the property when cited consistent with Administrative Code 

requirements.  

 

Administrative Fine Amounts and Payment Requirements 

 

The  Administrative  Code  stipulates  maximum  administrative  fine  amounts, 

consistent with State Code, and states that the  imposition of administrative fines 

is “not  intended to be punitive  in nature, but  is  instead  intended to compensate 

the  public  for  the  injury  and  damage  caused  by  the  prohibited  conduct.” 

                                                                 

5 Section 100.2 6 California Government Code Section 53069.4 was established in 1951 and amended in January 2008. 7 Chapter 100 of the City’s Administrative Code was added by Ordinance 73‐08 in April 2008. 

Page 7: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

Specifically,  the  code  states  that  the  amount  of  the  fine  for  violation  of  an 

ordinance shall be: 

Up to $100 for a first violation of the ordinance; 

Up to $200 for a second violation of the same ordinance within one year 

of the date of the first violation; and, 

Up to $500 for each additional violation of the same ordinance within one 

year of the date of a second or subsequent violation. 

 

Further, the Administrative Code allows the charging official to take one or more 

of 10 factors  into consideration when determining the amount of the fine. These 

factors include: 

 

1. The duration of the violation; 

2. The frequency, recurrence, and number of violations by the same violator; 

3. The seriousness of the violation; 

4. The good faith efforts of the violator to correct the violation; 

5. The economic impact of the fine on the violator; 

6. The injury or damage, if any, suffered by any member of the public; 

7. The impact of the violation on the community; 

8. The  amount  of  City  staff  time,  which  was  expended  investigating  or 

addressing the violation; 

9. The amount of fines imposed by the charging official in similar situations; 

and, 

10. Such other factors as justice may require. 

 

Persons who are cited with administrative fines must be provided with at least 30 

days for payment from the date the citation is served. Further, the Administrative 

Code stipulates that fines that remain unpaid 30 days after the due date shall be 

subject  to a  late payment penalty of 10 percent plus  interest at  the  rate of one 

percent  per month  on  the  outstanding  balance, which  is  added  to  the  penalty 

amount  from  the date  that payment  is due.  In addition, where  there  is a nexus 

between the violation and real property against which the City may impose a lien 

for non‐payment of the citation. 

 

The amount of unpaid fines and any applicable late payment charges constitute a 

debt  to the City under  the Administrative Code. As such, the City may  file a civil 

action or pursue other legal remedy, such as placing a lien on real property when 

applicable, to collect such money.  

 

    

Page 8: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

Appeals and Hearing Procedures  

The  Controller’s  Office  staffs  the  administrative  appeals  process,  pursuant  to 

Administrative Code Chapter 100  related  to Administrative Fines. This  is  further 

discussed in the Controller’s Office section below.  

 

Municipal Fine Information by Department 

Airport  

The San Francisco International Airport issues administrative fines for violations of 

the Airport’s Rules and Regulations as provided under Rule 14  (“General Fines”). 

Violations of Rule 14 and respective administrative fines may be cumulative (one 

citation  may  contain  multiple  fines)  and  may  be  in  addition  to  other  civil  or 

criminal federal, state, or local penalties. Violations fall under four categories: (1) 

General Conduct; (2) Parking; (3) Commercial Ground Transportation Operations; 

and, (4) Airfield Safety and Security.  

General Conduct addresses violations by the public of rules pertaining to littering, 

smoking, traffic rules, and interfering with wildlife. Most of these violations carry a 

fine of $100 for the first offense, $150 for the second offense within 12 months of 

the first offense, and $250 for the third offense within 12 months of the first. The 

Airport only receives a portion of the traffic fine revenue for on‐airport violations 

by the public from the Superior Court of San Mateo County, which processes such 

fines. Traffic fines issued to permittee operators (e.g., airport shuttles, taxis, etc.) 

are not shared with San Mateo County. No other Airport fines are shared with San 

Mateo County. 

Violation of parking  rules  carries a  fine of $50  for  the  first offense, $75  for  the 

second offense, and $100 for the third offense. 

Commercial  Ground  Transportation Operations  rules  address  general  operating 

requirements  (such  as  operating  permits  and  vehicle  markings),  conduct  on 

airport  roadways  (such  as  bypassing  the  taxicab  holding  area,  or  loading  and 

unloading passengers at  inappropriate  locations),  limousines operating without a 

permit  and  pre‐arrangement,  and  transportation  network  companies  violating 

permit requirements. Depending on the rule section, fines are either: (1) $100 for 

the first offense, $150 for the second offense, and $250 for the third offense; or 

(2) $250 for the first offense, $500 for the second offense, and $750 for the third 

offense. 

Page 9: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

 

 

Airfield  Safety  and  Security  rules  address  issues  including  unsafe  aircraft 

operation, failure to report accidents or extended delays, and security violations. 

Most  Airfield  Safety  and  Security  violations  carry  a  fine  of  $750  for  the  first 

offense, $1,000 for the second offense, and $1,250 for the third offense. During FY 

2014‐15,  the Airport began  levying  fines  for  rule violations by airfield operators; 

prior  to  FY  2014‐15,  airfield  operators  were  only  issued  admonishments.  The 

Airport also levies penalties on tenants for violating permit and/or lease terms. 

Department Total Number of Citations*  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Airport Commission  N/A  N/A 868 $157,199  $167,162   $438,643 

* Note: Does not  include number of  traffic  citations  as  they are processed by  San Mateo County,  and  the City 

receives a pro‐rata  lump  sum  share of  the  revenues. The number of  citations  shown  for  FY 2014‐15  is only  for 

Airfield Safety and Security violations.  

Building Inspection 

The Department  of  Building  Inspection  (DBI)  issues  administrative  penalties  for 

work  without  a  permit  in  violation  of  the  San  Francisco  Building,  Electrical, 

Plumbing,  or Mechanical  Codes  of  2013,  respectively.  Code  violations  for work 

without  a  permit  are  charged  at  nine  times  the  Permit  Issuance  Fee  plus  the 

original permit fee. Plumbing, Mechanical, and Electrical Permit Issuance Fees and 

original  permit  fees  vary  based  on  DBI  fee  schedules  that  are  tied  to  various 

factors such as size of the project. Building Permit Issuance Fees are based on the 

valuation  of  the  project.  According  to  DBI  staff,  although  San  Francisco  has 

separate Mechanical and Plumbing Codes, mechanical and plumbing violations are 

tracked  together,  so  separate  amounts  of mechanical  and  plumbing  violations 

could not be identified. 

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Building Inspection  773  602  670  $742,839   $563,415   $560,158   

City Administrator 

The City Administrator  is able  to assess and cite penalties  related  to ordinances 

regarding minimum wage, paid  sick  leave, prevailing wage, health  care  security, 

health  care  accountability,  fair  chance,  family  friendly workplaces,  and  formula 

retail  employee  rights,  which  fall  under  the  Office  of  Labor  Standards  and 

Enforcement (OLSE), as well as violations of entertainment regulations, which are 

housed within the Entertainment Commission.  

Page 10: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

10 

 

 

Investigations into violations of the City’s employment‐related ordinances, such as 

the  Health  Care  Accountability  Ordinance  and  Minimum  Compensation 

Ordinance,  can be  lengthy,  and  take multiple  years  to  complete.  Therefore  the 

number  of  citations  issued  by  OLSE  in  one  year  may  differ  greatly  from  the 

amount of citation revenue brought in that same year.   

For violations enforced by OLSE, violators can pay  the penalty  in  its entirety, or 

can  request a payment plan. Many penalties are assessed  through a  settlement 

process  between  OLSE  and  the  violator.  OLSE  can  take  the  case  to  a  hearing 

presided by an administrative law judge.  

For the Entertainment Commission, late payments can accrue penalties as defined 

by  Administrative  Code  Chapter  100.  The  Entertainment  Commission  can  also 

proceed with other forms of corrective action including suspension of permits.  

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

City Administrator  215  151  106  $438,835  $520,550   $545,264 

 

City Planning 

The Planning Department assesses penalties under both the Administrative Code 

and  the  Planning  Code  related  to  short  term  rentals,  general  advertising  signs, 

non‐specialized  enforcement  actions,  building  permit  applications,  and  code 

violation abatement.  

Payment  of  citations  is  requested  in  full  within  30  days  of  the  date  the 

Department's  notice  of  penalties  is  mailed.  The  Department  may  negotiate  a 

payment plan  in some cases. Delinquent payments are referred to the Bureau of 

Delinquent Revenue, which can place liens on properties and perform other legal 

actions,  as  well  as  charge  collection  fees  (typically  25  percent)  on  top  of  the 

outstanding balance.  

Citations are  issued most  frequently  for general enforcement and building  code 

permit violation abatements. As a  result,  these categories generally bring  in  the 

most  citation  revenue, with  the  exception  of  settlement  fees  allocated  to  the 

Planning Department from general advertising sign lawsuits.   

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

City Planning  82  83  86  $127,396   $780,066   $610,921  

 

Page 11: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

11 

 

 

Controller 

The  Controller’s  Office  staffs  the  administrative  appeals  process,  pursuant  to 

Administrative  Code  Chapter  100  related  to  Administrative  Fines.  When  the 

Controller’s Office receives an appeal, staff notifies the issuing department of the 

appeal,  holds  the  fine  amount,  and  schedules  a  hearing where  the  Controller, 

Deputy Controller or contractor serves as  the Hearing Officer. Upon  the Hearing 

Officer’s determination,  the Controller’s Office either allocates  the  full or partial 

fine amount to the issuing department or reimburses the appellant.  

Under  Chapter  100  of  the  Administrative  Code,  the  Controller’s  Office  has 

produced  administrative  forms  and  templates  to  carry  out  their  Chapter  100 

duties,  including  a  hardship  deposit  waiver  application,  template  for  waiver 

determination, and templates for all notifications related to the appeals process.  

The Controller’s Office considers the total penalty amount of the citation in order 

to  validate  the  appeal  request which may  consist  of multiple  violations. When 

reporting  on  the  number  of  violations  and  associated  revenue,  the  Controller’s 

Office groups code violations, rather than reporting on violations by type.  

The  Controller’s  Office  staffs  the  administrative  appeals  process  for  code 

violations  issued  by  the  Fire  Department,  Department  of  the  Environment, 

Entertainment Commission, and the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement.  

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Controller  2  5  12  $400  $2,100  $3,000  

Superior Court 

The Superior Court  functions as a collection agency  for the City of San Francisco 

and  books  the  revenue  on  behalf  of  the  City.  The  Court  does  not  have  the 

authority  to  issue citations.  If  individuals do not pay court‐ordered citations,  the 

Court’s collection programs are authorized to use tools such as additional fines or 

wage garnishments to motivate  individuals to pay their debt. While counties are 

statutorily responsible for the collection of such debt, collection duties are often 

delegated to the courts.  

Penalties can be paid in full or through an installment plan. Nonpayment results in 

little consequence, as  the Court  treats  them as a collections case, which can be 

reported  to  the  credit  bureaus  if  not  paid  in  full.  If  the  violation  goes  to  the 

Franchise Tax Board, a tax intercept can take place if a tax refund is available. For 

traffic fines, a driver’s license hold may be put in place for non‐payment.  

Page 12: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

12 

 

 

District Attorney 

The District Attorney does not  assess any municipal  fines. The District Attorney 

can bring  civil  actions  under  State Business &  Professions Code  Sections  17200 

and  17500,  related  to  unfair  competition  and  false  advertising,  respectively. 

According  to  the  District  Attorney,  cases  are  intermittent  and  unpredictable; 

therefore the number of cases and revenue brought in varies greatly from year to 

year.  

Defendants  generally  pay  the  entire  civil  penalty  at  the  time  of  judgment  or 

shortly  thereafter.  On  occasion,  payments  may  be  made  over  time,  with 

stipulations  set  forth  in  the  judgment.  Failure  to  pay  the  penalty  would  be  a 

violation of the judgment and enforceable by the judge. 

Most  criminal  fines  and  fees  assessed  for  a  criminal  case  are  collected  by  the 

Superior Court via accounts set up through a collection agency.  

Economic and Workforce Development 

The Office of Economic and Workforce Development  (OEWD) enforces  the Local 

Hiring  Policy  for  Construction.  The  Policy  covers  City  public  works  and 

improvement contracts in excess of $400,000 advertised for bids in or after March 

2011.  In 2015, the Policy was amended to cover contracts  in excess of $600,000 

advertised  in or after August 2015. The mandatory  local hiring participation  level 

increases  annually  over  the  first  seven  years  of  implementation,  up  to  a 

mandatory  participation  level  within  each  trade  of  50  percent  of  work  hours 

performed by  local residents, with no  less than 25 percent of project performed 

by disadvantaged workers. As of March 2015, the mandatory participation level is 

held  at  30  percent  for  an  additional  24  months  or  until  further  Board  of 

Supervisors  action.  Contractors  or  subcontractors  who  fail  to  satisfy  the  local 

hiring requirements must forfeit to the City an amount equal to the  journeyman 

or apprentice prevailing wage rate for their trade for each hour that they fell short 

of the local hiring requirement. 

According to OEWD, two of the five Local Hiring Policy‐related penalties imposed 

in FY 2013‐14 and FY 2014‐15 have not yet been paid. Eight additional penalties 

have been  imposed  to date  in FY 2015‐16, of which  five penalties have not yet 

been paid. 

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Economic and Workforce Development  0  1  4  $0   $1,356   $4,987  

Page 13: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

13 

 

 

 

Ethics Commission 

The  Ethics  Commission  is  authorized  to  impose  administrative  fines  of  up  to 

$5,000, or three times the amount which the person failed to report or unlawfully 

contributed,  for  violations  of  the  Campaign  and  Governmental  Conduct  Code 

related  to  campaign  finance,  lobbying,  conflicts  of  interest,  and  governmental 

ethics  in accordance with City Charter Section C3.699‐13. The Commission  is also 

authorized  to  impose  late  filing  fees  for  failure  to  timely  file  various  reports, 

including  campaign  reports,  campaign  consultant  reports,  lobbying  reports,  and 

annual  statements  of  economic  interests.  Late  fees  are  not  included  in  the 

administrative fine amounts included in this report. 

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Ethics Commission  7  6  16  $10,380   $24,500   $35,950  

 Fire 

The San Francisco Fire Code was replaced with the 2013 Fire Code  in November 

2013, which became operative on January 1, 2014. Under the code, a Fire official 

may  issue a written notice of violation when they find: (1) a code violation or (2) 

activity being performed without a required permit or in violation of a permit.   

Under Chapter 1, Section 105 of the Fire Code, operational permits are required 

for hot work, storage and use of liquid propane gas, use of open flame and torches 

in wildfire risk areas, and stationary storage of battery systems with liquid capacity 

greater  than  50  gallons.  In  addition,  construction  permits  are  required  for 

installation of car stacking parking systems in buildings.  

A Fire official may issue a stop work order for work without a permit. If correction 

of  the  code  violation  is  required,  the  Fire  Code  official  may  charge  an 

administrative fee of $1,000 for re‐inspection to certify compliance. Violating the 

code or refusing to comply with a notice of violation is subject to a civil penalty up 

to $1,000 per day that the violation  is committed or permitted to continue, plus 

attorney’s fees. Civil penalties are recovered in civil actions brought by the City in 

court. Failing  to comply with an order or removing a posted notice or order  is a 

misdemeanor. 

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Fire  0  3  8  $0   $3,000   $8,000  

Page 14: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

14 

 

 

Library 

The Library has the authority to assess  fines under Administrative Code Sections 

8.21  and  8.22,  related  to  library  fines  and  fees.  Fines  are  generally  cited  for 

overdue  books,  lost  books,  visitor’s  library  cards,  lost  library  cards,  damaged 

materials, and inter‐library loan services.  

If  fines are not paid, patrons may make  full or partial payment on  fines.  If  their 

fines are over $10, patrons are no longer permitted to check out library materials. 

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Library  615,692  591,200  584,788  $599,552   $509,762   $458,464  

 

Municipal Transportation Agency 

The  San  Francisco  Municipal  Transportation  Agency  (MTA)  assesses  municipal 

penalties under  the  Transportation Code, Park Code, Golden Gate Bridge Code, 

Harbor Code and the Municipal Police Code. MTA code violations are related to a 

variety of non‐moving  transportation  violations  including  traffic  control, parking 

enforcement,  and  transit  violations,  among  others.  MTA  may  cite  violations 

throughout  the  City,  including  on  Park  and  Port  property.  Moving  vehicle 

violations  are  enforced by  the  Police Department, not MTA.  The MTA  enforces 

non‐moving transportation violations of state vehicle code, which are not included 

in this analysis.  

The most common MTA citation issued is for vehicles parked on the street on the 

days  and  hours  where  parking  is  prohibited  for  street  sweeping.  Revenue 

collected  from  street  sweeping  citations  is  the  largest  share  of  MTA  citation 

revenue. Other  common MTA  citations  include  failure  to  pay  a  parking meter, 

parking  in  excess  of  the  hours  permitted  in  a  residential  or  carpool  zone,  and 

improper  parking  on  grades.  In  addition,  over  the  past  two  fiscal  years,  the 

number of  fare evasion  citations has greatly  increased, and become one of  the 

most commonly issued MTA citations. 

The price of some citations varies depending upon whether the citation  is  issued 

within or outside of  the MTA designated Downtown Core, where  violations  are 

more expensive. 

Late payment penalties for violations of the Transportation Code are as follows: 

Page 15: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

15 

 

 

Failure to pay a citation penalty by the first due date affixed to the notice of 

violation shall be $30; 

Failure to pay a citation penalty by the second due date affixed to the notice of 

violation shall be $40; 

Fee to reimburse the City for collection costs incurred as a result of a citation 

that  is neither contested or paid by the first due date affixed to the notice of 

violation shall be $46; and 

Fee  to  reimburse  the  City  for  the  costs  of  removing  boots  from  vehicles  is 

$316. 

The SFMTA offers community service in lieu of payment and payment plan options 

for customers with eligible citations. These options are not available  if a vehicle 

has  been  booted  or  towed,  or  if  the  citations  have  been  assigned  to  special 

collections.  

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

MTA  1,353,389   1,243,287   1,228,978   $92,825,846  $87,272,410  $82,438,866 

Police 

The  Police  Code  is  comprised  of  numerous  violations, which  have  either  been 

codified by state or local statute. According to the General Counsel (City Attorney 

designee) for the Police Department, it is impossible to know which codes resulted 

from  state  or  local  legislation,  and  therefore  the  impact  of  citation  revenue 

earned  from each  violation of  local  code, without manually going  through each 

violation in the Police Code. As of the writing of this report, that information is not 

available. 

However,  the  Police Department  assesses municipal  fines  related  to  the  Police 

Emergency  Alarm  Ordinance, which  imposes  fines  related  to  false  alarms.  The 

Police Department  tracks the revenue brought  in  from the citations, but not  the 

number  of  citations  issued  per  fiscal  year.  In  addition,  the  Police  Department 

assesses a fine of $0.50 per every $10 traffic citation  issued, which  is put toward 

the  Department’s  Automated  Fingerprint  Fund.  Although  this  fine  is  state 

legislated, it provides revenue to the Police Department.  

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Police  *  *  *  $110,456  $81,702   $77,279 * Note: The Police Department does not track the number of citations issued under the Police Emergency Alarm 

Ordinance. 

Page 16: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

16 

 

 

Port 

There are numerous violations  that can be cited under  the Port code  related  to 

disorderly conduct, animals,  traffic  regulations, and  required permits  to conduct 

activities on Port property. As  the Port Code  is generally not enforced, penalties 

for late and non‐payment are unknown. 

Most  violations  that occur on Port property  are  cited under  the Transportation 

Code, Park Code, and Harbor Code by  the MTA or  the Police code by  the Police 

Department. Therefore, no citations have been issued for a majority of Port Code 

violations over the past three fiscal years.   

Citation  information below only reflects violations cited by MTA.  Information for 

citations issued by the Police Department is not available.  

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Port  37,608  41,739  44,909  $3,495,068   $2,875,719   $2,747,250  Note: The revenue earned from citations  includes revenue earned from citations of both municipal 

code  and  State  code.  However,  only  violations  of  local municipal  code  are  counted  in  the  total 

number  of  citations  per  fiscal  year.  The  Port  is  not  able  to  separate  out  revenue  earned  from 

violations of municipal code and State code. The Port’s citation revenues are also net of numerous 

deductions such as state surcharges, and shares for other entities such as the Golden Gate Bridge, 

among others.  

Public Health 

The Department of Public Health (DPH) has authority to  issue fines for violations 

of a wide variety of San Francisco Health Code provisions. However, according to 

Mr. Richard Lee, Acting Director of Environmental Health, DPH primarily exercises 

their authority  to enforce  violations  related  to garbage and  refuse,  food  facility 

permits, hazardous materials, hazardous waste generation, underground storage 

tanks, and licensing of massage practitioners and businesses. 

DPH’s Health Officer holds monthly hearings on behalf of  the Director of Health 

and may impose fines for Health Code violations. Individuals may appeal at these 

hearings  any  fines  or  penalties  that  were  assessed  for  not  complying  with 

inspections related to Health Code provisions.  

Administrative  fines,  such as  late‐payment penalties, do not have  the  right  to a 

hearing.  Such  fines  related  to  hazardous  materials  and  underground  storage 

tanks, under Health Code Article 21,  include  fines  for  late application submittals 

(for temporary and full time storage facilities) and for failure to obtain approval or 

schedule  site  inspections  prior  to  closure,  removal,  or  modification  of 

Page 17: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

17 

 

 

underground storage tanks. The amounts associated with the administrative fines 

related to Health Code Article 21 are not included in this report because DPH staff 

stated that they did not have the resources to compile citation records in a timely 

manner.  

Failure  to pay administrative  fines may result  in  formal enforcement action. The 

Tax  Collector  collects  the  administrative  fines  for  failure  to maintain  adequate 

refuse  collection  service  at  residential  and  commercial  properties  through 

property tax bills. The Tax Collector allocates the portion of the property tax bill 

associated with  the  refuse  fines  to DPH.  If  a  complaint  is  issued,  the  City may 

assess civil penalties up to $2,000 per violation per day. For willful violations of the 

Health Code, the City may assess civil penalties up to $5,000 per day. 

Department Total Number of Citations*  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Public Health  58  71  85  $311,260   $160,956   $364,505  * Note: Does not  include number of garbage and refuse citations, fines for  late application submittals for storage 

tank  facilities,  or  fines  related  to  closure,  removal,  or modification  of  underground  storage  tanks  as DPH  staff 

stated they did not have the resources to compile citation information in a timely manner.  

Public Utilities Commission 

The  San  Francisco  Public Utilities  Commission  (PUC)  issues  a  charge  for  excess 

water  usage  among  commercial  (non‐residential)  irrigation  customers.  In May 

2015, the PUC adopted a Drought Program to achieve a 10 percent system‐wide 

reduction in water use and a mandatory reduction of 25 percent among irrigation 

customers. The excess use charge is 200 percent (two times) the applicable water 

rate. The PUC also charges a  late payment penalty for bills that are 30 days past 

due,  but  late  payments  are  not  included  in  the  administrative  fine  amounts 

included in this report.  

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Public Utilities Commission  N/A  N/A  8  N/A  N/A  $135,814  

Public Works 

The  Department  of  Public Works  (DPW)  has  the  authority  to  assess  penalties 

under the Administrative Code, Public Works Code, Health Code, and Police Code. 

The most  common DPW  citations  have  been  issued  for  portions  of  the Health 

Code  related  to  illegal  dumping, maintenance  of  refuse  collection  services  and 

public health nuisances, as well as portions of  the Police Code  related  to public 

Page 18: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

18 

 

 

littering,  littering on public property, public  litter receptacles, and obstruction of 

streets and sidewalks.  

Citation  recipients are given 90 days  from  issuance or decision of appeal  to pay 

the amount due. In some rare cases payment plans are permitted. In the case of 

non‐payment of administrative citations, the value of the citation is transferred to 

the property owner's  tax bill along with an additional 12 percent administrative 

fee. 

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Public Works  1,393   2,004   3,245   $129,024   $123,254   $210,136  

 

Recreation and Park Department 

The Recreation and Park Department (RPD) assesses penalties from the Park Code, 

Health  Code,  Transportation  Code,  and  Police  Code  that  occur  on  City  park 

property. Fines are paid to the Superior Court or can be worked off by community 

service. If fines are not paid, late penalties are incurred and an arrest warrant can 

be issued. The offender might be required to appear in criminal court.  

The Park Patrol Division of RPD administers and tracks citations. According to RPD, 

all citation  revenue  is collected by  the Superior Court and RPD does not  receive 

the revenue, nor do they know much revenue  is actually collected from citations 

or who the funds are provided to.  

Department Total Number of Citations  Total Revenues from Citations 

FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14*  FY 2014‐15  FY 2012‐13  FY 2013‐14  FY 2014‐15 

Recreation and Parks  649  417  2,831  $**   $**   $**  *RPD is missing data from September 2013‐December 2013 therefore FY 13‐14 is not entirely complete.  

**  Note:  The  Recreation  and  Parks  Department  does  not  collect  or  receive  the  revenue  that  results  from  the 

Department’s citations and does not track such revenue.  

 Sheriff’s Department 

The  Sheriff’s  Department  does  not  impose  municipal  fines  or  collect  citation 

revenue  from  municipal  fines.  However,  the  Department  does  receive 

reimbursement  funding  from  violations  of  the  State  Penal  Code which  are  set, 

collected,  and  distributed  by  the  State  Superior  Courts.  For  every  $10  in  court 

fines  or  fees,  $1  goes  to  the  DNA  Fund,  legislated  by  Penal  Code  296,  and 

managed  by  the  Sheriff’s Department’s DNA Unit.  The DNA  Fund  supports  the 

Page 19: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

19 

 

 

DNA Unit, which oversees the DNA collection from anyone arrested or convicted 

for a felony offense. The DNA Fund monies may only be used for costs associated 

with  DNA  collections  including  the  DNA  Unit’s  salaries  and  benefits,  supplies, 

shipping  costs,  and  equipment.  The  Sheriff’s  Department  currently  receives  75 

percent  of  the  fund, while  the  state  receives  25  percent.  Funding may  only  be 

used for costs of the Sheriff’s Department DNA Unit.  

The Sheriff’s Department has received approximately $1,080,000 from these fines 

since 2005. The balance in the fund is currently $377,219.8  

Treasurer/Tax Collector 

The Treasurer/Tax Collector assesses municipal fines under the Business and Tax 

Regulations  Code  related  to  violations  by  businesses  to  produce  certain 

registration and financial  information, maintain and produce records as required, 

and others.9  

Penalties increase cumulatively by 50 percent for each subsequent violation of the 

same  provision  by  the  same  person within  a  three  year  period.  The maximum 

penalty that may be imposed by administrative citation in a calendar year for each 

type of violation is $25,000. The Tax Collector may also assess enforcement costs, 

including attorney's fees, which do not count toward the $25,000 maximum. 

In FY 2012‐13 and FY 2013‐14, the Treasurer/Tax Collector’s Bureau of Delinquent 

Revenue  collected  residual  delinquent  collections  for  the  Superior  Court,  the 

terms of which were  governed by  a Memorandum of Understanding. However, 

the  Department  does  not  have  specific  information  about  the  citations  or 

revenues collected, only an aggregate amount collected by fiscal year.  

 

Conclusions 

We  have  identified  approximately  430  violations  of  City  ordinance  or  contracts 

over the  last three  fiscal years that are subject  to a  fine. Further, we  found that 

1,866,614 municipal citations were issued in FY 2014‐15, resulting in $88,639,237. 

This represents about 1.03 percent of the City’s budgeted revenues in FY 2014‐15.  

                                                                 

8 The DNA fund is currently missing a state reimbursement from 2008 which could potentially result in an additional $190,000 ‐ $200,000 for the fund. 9 The Treasurer/Tax Collector was not able to provide the number of citations and citation revenue earned by the writing of this report.  

Page 20: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Report to Supervisor Kim February 9, 2016     

                                                        Budget and Legislative Analyst 

20 

 

 

Of  the  $88,639,237  in  fine  revenues  in  FY  2014‐15,  $82,438,866  or  93  percent 

were  due  to  citations  issued  by  the  San  Francisco  Municipal  Transportation 

Agency  (MTA). MTA citations have primarily been  issued for: parking on a street 

during street sweeping days and hours, failure to pay a parking meter, parking in 

excess  of  the  hours  permitted  in  a  residential  or  carpool  zone,  and  improper 

parking on grades. 

The City  lacks a uniform citation‐tracking protocol across departments. Although 

the Controller’s Office  tracks  revenue  from  fines,  fees, and  forfeitures,  this data 

comingles  revenue  from  fees  for  services and does not  include  all  fine  revenue 

across  the  City.  Further,  some  City  departments  issue  one  citation  for multiple 

violations or do not  track  the  revenue  that  is  received  from  citations, making  it 

difficult  to  tie  the  number  and  dollar  amounts  of  citations  to  violations.  An 

additional complication is that many citations are State codes, which are enforced 

locally with revenue either shared with or provided completely to the State.   

The City’s  codes,  including  the Health Code  include many  citations  that are not enforced and appear to be obsolete. For example, Article 12 of the Health Code includes a section regulating  the manufacture of shoddy, a recycled wool  textile that was common in the 19th century. Additionally, the City has a Port Code that is rarely enforced, and  is a holdover from the days that the City had separate Port fire and police  forces. Further, we note  in  this  report several  instances where  it appears that departments are not enforcing various codes as demonstrated by the lack of citations issued for violations over the past three fiscal years.  

 

Recommendation  

The Board of Supervisors should request the Controller to work with City departments, as 

part  of  the  annual  budget  process,  to  evaluate  and  report  to  the  Board  on  which 

administrative or penalties require better enforcement and which should be deleted from 

the Administrative Code.  

Page 21: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 1

City Administrator

ADM General Description

The Office of the City Administrator can assess penalties for violations of the Minimum Wage Ordinance, Paid Sick Leave Ordinance, Prevailing Wage requirements, Health Care Security Ordinance, Health Care Accountability Ordinance, Minimum Compensation Ordinance, Fair Chance Ordinance, Family Friendly Workplace Ordinance, and Formula Retail Employee Rights Ordinances. For the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE), violators can pay the penalty in its entirety, or can request a payment plan that accommodates their income. Many penalties are assessed through a settlement process between OLSE and the violator. OLSE can take the case to a hearing presided by an administrative law judge. For the Entertainment Commission, late payments can accrue penalties as defined by Admin Code Ch. 100, The Entertainment Commission can also proceed with other forms of corrective action including suspension of permits.

Minimum Wage Ordinance (Admin Code Sec 12R)

Violations related to paying employees less than minimum wage.

Administrative Penalty: An administrative penalty in the amount of $50 to each Employee or person whose rights under this Chapter were violated for each day that the violation occurred or continued. Civil Penalty: City Atty may bring a civil action. City shall be entitled to attorney's fees and costs where the City is prevailing party

Yes Yes

Paid Sick Leave Ordinance (Admin Code Ch. 12W)

Violations related to failing to provide employees with required paid sick leave.

The Agency may also order the violating employer or person to pay to the City a sum of not more than $50.00 for each day or portion thereof and for each employee or person as to whom the violation occurred or continued. Such funds shall be allocated to the agency and used to offset the costs of implementing and enforcing this Chapter.

Yes

Page 22: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 2

City Administrator

Prevailing Wage Ordinance (Admin Code 6.22(e))

Violation for contractors or subcontractors performing a public work or improvement for the City to pay less than the prevailing wage as provided in the Code.

Contractor must pay the City back wages due plus penalties in the amount no less than $50 per day for each laborer.

Yes

Health Care Security Ordinance (Admin Code Ch. 14)

Violation for employers to fail to make required health care expenditures on behalf of covered employee.

Not to exceed $100 per worker per quarter Yes

Health Care Accountability Ordinance (Admin Code Ch. 12Q)

Violation for City Contractors who fail to provide health plan benefits to their covered employees or make payments to the City for use by the Department of Public Health.

Contracting party must pay the City liquidated damages of up to $100 for each one-week pay period for each employee.

Yes

Minimum Compensation Ordinance (Admin Code Sec 12P)

Violation for City Contractor's failure to provide the required Minimum Compensation (hourly wage and time off)

Contractor must pay liquidated damages of up to one hundred dollars ($100) for each one-week pay period for each employee not provided the required compensation.

Yes

Fair Chance Ordinance (Police Code, Article 49; Admin Code Section 12T)

Violation for covered employers to ask about arrest or conviction records on job applications, or to take adverse action against an applicant or employee for exercising their rights under the ordinance or cooperating with OLSE. New as of 8/13/14.

1st offense- warning and notice to correct 2nd offense- $50 per employee 3rd & more offense- no more than $100 per employee

Yes

Family Friendly Workplace Ordinance (Admin Code Chapter 12Z)

Violation for employee of a company with 20 or more employees, who has been employed for six months or more and works at least eight hours per week on a regular basis to request a flexible or predictable working arrangement to assist with caregiving responsibilities for family members. New as of 1/1/2014.

1st offense- warning and notice to correct 2nd offense- $50 which the Employer must pay the employee City may also order the employer to pay the City no more than $50 for each day for investigating and remedying the violation.

Yes

Formula Retail Employee Rights Ordinances (Police Code Art. 33F and 33G)

Fines of up to $500 per employee for violations related to hours, retention, treatment of part-time workers or scheduling.

Up to $500 per employee Yes

Page 23: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 3

City Administrator

Entertainment Commission Citations (Police Code Sections 1060.26(b) and 1070.24(b)

Violations for noise abatement, signs, private club violations, security plan violations or good neighbor violations.

Administrative Penalties Admin Code Ch. 100: 1st Violation: Not more than $100 2nd Violation: Not more than $200 3rd or More: Not more than $500 (2nd or more violations have to be within 1 year of the first)

Yes

Airport

AIR General Description

The Airport Commission authorizes law enforcement personnel and Airport official to issue fines for violations of Rule 14 of the Commissions' Rules & Regulations. The Airport receives a portion of the traffic fine revenue for on-airport violations by the public from the Superior Court of San Mateo County, which processes such fines. Traffic fines issued to permittee operators (e.g., airport shuttles, taxis, etc.) are not shared with San Mateo County. No other Airport fines are shared with San Mateo County.

Violation of Traffic Rules (Rule 14, Section 4.1(A))

Airport Commission employees or law enforcement officers may cite infractions of the Airport Commissions' Rules and Regulations. Payment is due within 30 days of the date of citation.

First offense: $100; Second offense: $150; Third offense: $250

Yes

Miscellaneous Tenant/Operator Violations (Rule 14, Various Sections)

Violations of airfield rules or permit/lease terms $50 - $1000 Yes

Controller

CON General Description

(Solely Citation Appeals)

The Controller's Office manages the administrative appeals process pursuant to Admin Code Ch. 100. Since October 2014, the Controller's Office has staffed appeals from the code violations issued by the Fire Department, Department of the Environment, Entertainment Commission and the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement. While the Controller's Office could hear an appeal of any administrative penalty, only violations for which an administrative appeals process has been initiated since October 2014 are listed below.

Page 24: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 4

Controller

Minimum Wage (Admin Code Sec 12R.5 (b))

Failure to post notice of minimum wage rate.

Administrative Penalty:$500Increase by 50% for each subsequent violation of the same provision within a 3 year period. Maximum penalty in a calendar year for each violation shall be $5,000, or $10,000 if a citation for retaliation is issued. City can also impose liens on property for non-payment. Civil Penalty:City Atty may bring a civil action. City shall be entitled to attorney's fees and costs where the City is prevailing party.

Yes Yes

Minimum Wage (Admin Code Sec 12R.5 (c) )

Failure to maintain payroll records or to retain payroll records for four years; failure to allow the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement to inspect payroll records.

Administrative Penalty: $500 Increase by 50% for each subsequent violation of the same provision within a 3 year period. Maximum penalty in a calendar year for each violation shall be $5,000, or $10,000 if a citation for retaliation is issued. City can also impose liens on property for non-payment. Civil Penalty: City Atty may bring a civil action. City shall be entitled to attorney's fees and costs where the City is prevailing party.

Yes Yes

Commuter Benefits Program (Environment Code Section 427)

Failure to offer at least one transportation benefit program to Covered Employees.

Infraction: 1st Violation - $100 2nd Violation - $200 3rd Violation- $500 Administrative: Admin Code Ch. 100: 1st Violation: Not more than $100 2nd Violation: Not more than $200 3rd or More: Not more than $500 (2nd or more violations have to be within 1 year of the first)

Yes Infraction

Controller

Page 25: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 5

Fire Code Section 3504.2 - Fire Watch

Fire watches shall be provided during hot work activities and continue for a minimum of 30 minutes after the conclusion of the work. The fire code official, or the responsible manager under a hot work program is authorized to extend the fire watch based on the hazards of work being performed.

$1,000 Yes

Fire Code Section 901.8- Removal of Equipment

It shall be unlawful for any person to remove, tamper with or otherwise disturb any fire hydrant, fire detection and alarm system, fire suppression system or other fire appliance required by this code except for the purpose of extinguishing fire, training purposes, recharging or making necessary repairs, or when approved by the fire code official.

$1,000 Yes

Entertainment Regulations for Extended-Hours Premises (Police Code Section 1070) & Noise Abatement (Police Code Section 1060.12) Combined

Violations can be issued for: noise abatement violations, sign violations, private club violations, security plan violations, minors and good neighbor violations. Fines that remain unpaid 30 days after the due date shall be subject to a late payment penalty of 10% plus interest at the rate of 1% per month on the outstanding balance, which shall be added to the penalty amount from the date payment is due. The City may also file a civil action or pursue another legal remedy to collect such monty. If there is a nexus with real property, the City can initiate a lien on the property in the amount of the payment due and additional costs,

Criminal Penalty (Infraction): 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 OR a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not to exceed $1,000, OR by imprisonment in the County Jail for a period not to exceed 6 months, or by fine and imprisonment. 3rd offense- up to $500, or a misdemeanor with a fine of $1,000 OR by imprisonment in the County Jail for a period not to exceed 6 months, or by fine and imprisonment. Administrative Penalty Admin Code Ch. 100: 1st Violation: Not more than $100 2nd Violation: Not more than $200 3rd or More: Not more than $500 (2nd or more violations have to be within 1 year of the first) If violated more than once in a 12-month period, shall be an infraction OR a misdemeanor.

Yes Infraction Yes-jail time is

possible

Planning

Page 26: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 6

CPC General Description

The Planning Department assess fines related to: short-term rentals, general advertising signs, general non-specialized enforcement actions, building permit applications and code violation abatements. Payment is requested in full within 30 days of the date the Department's notice of penalties is mailed. Sometimes, a payment plan may be negotiated. Delinquent payments are referred to the Bureau of Delinquent Revenue which can place liens on properties and perform other legal actions, as well as charging collection fees (typically 25%) on top of the outstanding balance.

Residential Unit Conversion and Demolition (Admin Code Ch 41a)

Violation if a permanent resident offers their primary residence as a short-term residential rental without registering with the Short-term Residential Rental Registry, paying fees and following reporting requirements.

Administrative Penalty: 1st violation - $484 per day per violation 2nd violation- $968 per day per violation 3rd violation- $1,452 per day per violation

Yes

Violation of General Advertising Sign Requirements (Planning Code Sec 610(b)(2)(b)

Violation if a general advertisting sign is deemed to be a public nuisance.

Administrative Penalty : (i) 100 square feet or less - $100 per day per violation; (ii) 101 - 300 square feet - $1,000 per day per violation; (iii) 301 - 500 square feet - $1,750 per day per violation; (iv) Over 500 square feet - $2,500 per day per violation.

Yes

Enforcement Against Violations (Planning Code Section 176)

Violation of general, non-specialized enforcement actions.

Administrative Penalty: $250 each day the violation is unabated Civil Penalties: Up to $200 per day, in addition to City's costs of enforcement, and attorney's fees and costs. Criminal Penalties: Misdemeanor - Up to $200 per day, and imprisonment for up to six months, or both fined and imprisoned

Yes Yes Yes

Permit Applications (Planning Code Section 355(a)(1))

Inspection fee to monitor code violation abatements. $1,271 inspection fee (collected by DBI for Planning at permit issuance)

Page 27: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 7

Building Inspection

DBI General Description

DBI issues penalties for conducting work without a permit. Payment is collected with other permit fees.

Electrical Code Penalties for working without a permit 9 times the Permit Issuance Fee plus the original permit fee (varies by project size)

Yes

Plumbing/Mechanical Code

Penalties for working without a permit 9 times the Permit Issuance Fee plus the original permit fee (varies by project size)

Yes

Building Code Penalties for working without a permit 9 times the Permit Issuance Fee plus the original permit fee (varies by project size)

Yes

Public Health

DPH General Description

DPH has the ability to issue fines in order to help enforce 15 separate articles of the City's Health Code. However, DPH staff have indicated that there are only three articles of the Health Code, which are commonly enforced with fines. The Department also has the ability to issue fines under the California Retail Food Code and the California Health and Safety Code.

Health Code Article 5 (General Public Health)

Violations carrying fines include illegally establishing/managing day care facilities without a permit; eligible businesses that fail to post smokeless tobacco warnings; and, eligible businesses that fail to post alcohol consumption warnings.

Yes

Health Code Article 6 (Garbage & Refuse), Section 290

Violations carrying fines include illegal dumping; improper removal of waste from a fish market; improper removal of construction/demolition debris; failure to initiate/maintain adequate refuse collection or to provide sufficient refuse containers; and, unauthorized removal of recyclable materials.

$87 for residential, $127 for commercial liens or 10% of bill

Yes

Health Code Article 7 (Laundries)

Violations carrying fines include spraying of clothes with water emitted from the mouth of a laundry owner or employee and soliciting laundry services outside of the laundry premises.

Yes

Page 28: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 8

Public Health

Health Code Article 8 (Food and Food Products)

Violations carrying fines include manufacture, etc. of dangerous substances intended to be used in the preservation of any food or drink; not providing a sample of food preservatives to the Department on its demand; using unsanitary water for irrigating vegetables used for human consumption or for not obtaining a license before producing or selling vegetables for human consumption; manufacture, etc. of adulterated, mislabled, or misbranded food or liquor; the failure of a food establishment to provide toilet and handwashing facilities for use by employees; failure to adhere to permitting and regulations for food preparation and food service establishments; and, providing an incentive item at a restaurant if the meal doesn't meet certain nutritional standards.

Yes

Health Code Article 11 (Nuisances)

Violations carrying fines include illegal discharge of soot or smoke within an residential or commercial district; having any public health nuisance as defined by Section 581; failure to obtain a certificate of sanitation for a hotel; resisting an order to vacate a hotel; and, neglecting or refusing to remove and destroy poison ivy or poison oak.

Yes

Health Code Article 11A (Bed Bugs)

Any property owner or property manager who fails to follow the provisions of Article 11A relating to the prevention, treatment, disclosure, and recording may be subject to fines.

Yes

Health Code Article 12 (General Sanitation)

Violations carrying fines include improper manufacture of cigars; improper manufacture of shoddy; improper delivery of drugs, cosmetics, etc. on door steps; improper making or remaking of mattresses; allowing the return of certain merchandise; and, the use of the common cigar cutter any place where cigars are sold.

Yes

Health Code Article 19 (Smoking)

Violation of the requirement of employers to prohibit smoking in the workplace carries a potential civil penalty of up to $500.

Yes

Health Code Article 19F (Smoking in Enclosed Areas)

Violation of City rules for the prohibition of smoking in buildings, certain vehicles, certain unenclosed areas, and enclosed structures containing certain uses and certain areas of sports stadiums carry fines.

Yes

Page 29: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 9

Public Health

Health Code Article 19H (Permits for Sales of Tobacco)

Violations carrying fines include selling tobacco without a permit and related infractions.

Yes

Health Code Article 19I (Smoking in City Parks and Recreation Areas)

Any person who violates the prohibition against smoking in city park and recreational areas or at farmers markets may be fined.

Yes

Health Code Article 19J (Prohibition of Pharmacies Selling Tobacco Products)

Violation of the prohibition against selling tobacco products at pharmacies may result in a fine.

Yes

Health Code Article 19K (Prohibition of Selling Tobacco on City Property)

Violation of the prohibition against selling tobacco on property owned or under the control of the City can result in a fine.

Yes

Health Code Article 19O (Use of Smokeless Tobacco at Athletic Venues)

Violations of the prohibition against the use of tobacco products at athletic venues (sports playing fields or sports arenas) are subject to fines.

Yes

Health Code Article 21 (Hazardous Materials)

Failure to properly operate and care for underground storage tanks to preven the release of hazardous materials may result in fines.

Yes Yes

Health Code Article 24 (CFC Recovery & Recycling)

Violations against the sale of CFC containers or release of CFC without a permit are subject to fines.

Yes

Health Code Article 25 (Medical Waste)

Unauthorized treatment or disposal of medical waste can incur fines and/or liens.

Yes

Page 30: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 10

Public Health

Health Code Article 26 (Lead Poisoning)

Failure to adhere with an order from the Director or fails to abate lead hazards as ordered by the Director may result in penalties.

Yes

Health Code Section 29.10 (Massage)

Operating without a massage business permit $500 for operating without a permit; $1000 for operating without establishment permit (1st violation)

Yes

Health Code Section 29.12 (Massage)

Using massage facilities for residential sleeping purposes; improperly attired massage service providers; substandard sanitation; doors locked during business hours; engaging in lewd conduct or performing sex acts on massage business premises

Improper Attire 1st Offense: $0 - $250 for improper attire; 2nd Offense: $500. Prostitution $2500 for operating a house of prostitution; $500 and 60 day suspension of practitioner permit for engaging in prostitution

Yes

Yes (CA Penal Code

Section 11225 - building used for prosti-tution)

Health Code Section 29.15 (Massage)

Knowingly employing an indvidual without massage practitoner or CAMTC certification

$750 for employing non-permitted practitioner(s); $1000 for employing unlicensed practitioner (1st violation in 24-month period)

Yes

Health Code Section 29.18 (Massage)

Operating between the hours of 10pm and 7am $750 for operating after 10pm (1st violation); $1000 for operating massage establishment after 10pm

Yes

Health Code Section 29.19 (Massage)

Restricting reasonable inspection of massage establishment

1st Offense: $1000; 2nd Offense: $2,500; 3rd Offense: $5000

Yes

Health Code Section 29.2 (Massage)

Practicing massage for compensation without a massage practictioner permit or CAMTC certification

$250 for conducting massage without practitioner permit; $150 for expired practitioner certificate

Yes

Health Code Section 29.21 (Massage)

Revocation of massage establishment permit for practitioners not certified by the CAMTC

$1000 - $5250 Yes

Health Code Section 29.25 (Massage)

Administrative action for violating regulations $250 - $1000 Yes

Health Code Section 29.9 (Massage)

Registration of massage establishments that employ only CAMTC certified practitioners

$1,000 Yes

Page 31: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 11

Public Health

Health Code Article 30 (Diesel Back-up Generators)

Violations carrying fines include failure to maintain a valid certificate; operating a diesel generator beyond the allowable hours; failure to submit records for operation of a diesel generator; providing false information or records to the Department; and, failing to comply with a Director's order.

Yes

Health Code Article 33 (Medical Marijuana)

Any dispensary, dispensary operator, or dispensary manager who violates any provision of Article 33 may be subject to administrative penalties.

Yes

Health Code Article 40 (Body Art)

Performing body art without being registered, owning or operating a body art facility without a health permit, or operating a temporary body art booth in violation of Article 40 may be subject to a fine.

Yes

Public Works

DPW General Description

The Department of Public Works has the authority to issue fines under the Administrative Code (Community Preservation and Blight Reduction Act), the Public Works Code (PWC), the Health Code, and the Police Code. Citation recipients are given 90 days from issuance/decision of appeal to pay the amount due. Rarely, payment plans are allowed. In the case of non-payment of administrative citations, the value of the citation is transferred to the property owner's tax bill with an additional 12% administrative fee.

Page 32: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 12

Public Works

Community Preservation and Blight Reduction Act (Administrative Code 80.3(b) & 80.4(b))

Owners of blighted property that fail to abate a blighted property violation may be subject to administrative, civil and criminal penalties.

Sec. 80.3(d) Administrative Penalties: Staff can issue notices of violation and/or take other enforcement actions including those in Section 80.4, administrative penalties pursuant to Admin Code Chapter 100 or Police Code Article 1, Section 39-1 Admin Code Ch. 100: 1st Violation: Not more than $100 2nd Violation (within year): Not more than $200 3rd or More (within year): Not more than $500 Police Code Article 1, Section 39-1 Penalties that remain unpaid after 30 days are subject to a late payment penalty of ten percent (10%) plus interest at the rate of one percent (1%) per month on the outstanding balance, which shall be added to the penalty amounts from the date that payment is due. Persons and entities against whom administrative penalties are imposed shall also be liable for the costs and attorney's fees incurred by the City and County in bringing any civil action to enforce the provisions of this section Sec 80.5- General Provisions The minimum charge for City abatement (if property owner does not abate): (1) $400, or (2) the actual cost (including overhead, administrative costs, attorney fees), and the City's costs for Section 80.5 hearings (including enforcement fees) Sec. 80.7 (c) Civil Penalties: Up to $100 per day for each day (15-90 days after Notice) From $100 - $500 per day (91 -120 days after Notice) From $500 - $1,000 per day (121 days on) 80.8 (d) Failure to Pay: Director can initiate lien proceedings under Article XX, Section 10.230 of the Administrative Code

Yes

The City Attorney may apply to any court having juris-diction for any relief as will abate or remove such nuis-ance

(80.7)(b) This Chapter may be enforced by an injunction issued by any court having juris-diction upon any suit by the City or owner or neighbor of a proper-ty affected by a viola-tion

Page 33: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 13

Public Works

DPW Enforced Provisions of the Health Code

DPW may (along with DPH- Environmental Health) enforce portions of Article 6 (Sections 280, 283, 291) of the Health Code pertaining to illegal dumping of refuse; proper maintenance of refuse collection service to dwellings and commercial properties; Article 1 (Section 40) pertaining to dogs defecating on public property; and, Article 11 (Section 581) pertaining to public health nuisances.

Section 280: First offense - Between $80-$100 Second offense- $150-$200 Each additional offense - $250-$500 OR If charged as misdemeanor, punished by imprisonment or a fine not to exceed $1,000 Section 283: First offense - Between $80-$100 Second offense- $150-$200 Each additional offense - $250-$500 OR Administrative penalty not to exceed $1,000 per violation Section 291: Fines defined by Admin Code Chapter 100 DPW could also elect to assess administrative penalties under Section 39-1 of the Police Code

Yes Optional - Misdemea

nor

DPW Enforced Provisions of the Police Code

DPW may (along with the Police Department) enforce portions of Article 1 of the Police Code including Section 33 pertaining to public littering; Section 34 pertaining to a property owner allowing litter to reamin or accumulate upon the sidewalk in front or abutting his/her building; Section 35a pertaining to the use of public litter receptacles for sidewalk cleaning or household garbage; and, Section 63 pertaining to the obstruction of streets and sidewalks.

Sections 33, 34, 35aFirst offense - $80-$100Second offense - $150-$200Each additional offense - $300-$500Section 63Administrative penalty not to exceed $300 per violation

Yes

Page 34: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 14

Public Works

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Litter Receptacles (PWC 170(a))

Violations carrying fines include not removing garbage receptacles from the sidewalk, street, or any public right-of-way (for businesses: immediately after the contents have been collected or immediately upon opening of a business premises; for resdents: within 24 hours after placing the receptacles out for collection and after the receptacle has been collected).

Infraction: 1st Offense: $80 - $100 2nd Offense: $150- $200 3rd or More: $250- $500 OR Administrative Penalty not to exceed $250 for each violation.

Yes Infraction

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Litter Receptacles Permits (PWC 170(b))

Violations of securely locking cans, containers and receptacles placed for collection.

Infraction: 1st Offense: $80 - $100 2nd Offense: $150- $200 3rd or More: $250- $500 OR Administrative Penalty not to exceed $250 for each violation.

Yes Infraction

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Liter Receptacles (PWC 173(b))

Violations carrying fines include: (1) operators of grocery stores, liquor stores, or an establishment selling food or beverages failing to place and maintain a litter receptacle outside each exit or maintaining a set of three containers for recyclables, compostables, and trash and (2) operator of a place of employment failing to provide and maintain ashtrays and other receptacles for the disposal of cigarettes, cigars, and other similar combustible products and that comply with the design, capacity, location, and number as prescribed by the Director of Public Works

Infraction: 1st Offense: $80 - $100 2nd Offense: $150- $200 3rd or More: $250- $500 OR Administrative Penalty not to exceed $250 for each violation.

Yes Infraction No

Page 35: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 15

Public Works

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Liter Receptacles (PWC 173 (e))

Failure of person, firm, or corporation operating a grocery store, liquor store, or an establishment selling food or beverages for consumption to empty such receptacle when full and at the close of business each day.

Infraction: 1st Offense: $80 - $100 2nd Offense: $150- $200 3rd or More: $250- $500 OR Administrative Penalty not to exceed $250 for each violation.

Yes Infraction No

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Liter Receptacles (PWC 174)

Failure by any person, firm, or corporation to abate any nuisance detrimental to health or any accumulation of filth, garbage, etc. on the public sidewalk, public stairway or other right-of-way for public pedestrian travel that abuts property owned or occupied.

Sec. 80.3(d) Administrative Penalties: Staff can issue notices of violation and/or take other enforcement actions including those in Section 80.4, administrative penalties pursuant to Admin Code Chapter 100 or Police Code Article 1, Section 39-1 Admin Code Ch. 100: 1st Violation: Not more than $100 2nd Violation (in one year): Not more than $200 3rd or More (in one year): Not more than $500 Police Code Article 1, Section 39-1 Unpaid penalties after 30 days are subject to a 10% late payment fee plus interest at the rate of 1%/month on the outstanding balance. Persons and entities against whom administrative penalties are imposed shall also be liable for the City’s enforcement costs and attorney’s fees Sec 80.5- General Provisions The minimum charge : (1) $400, or (2) the actual cost to the City (including overhead and administrative costs, as well as attorneys’ fees where the Director has elected to seek recovery of attorneys’ fees), and the City's cost of preparation for and appearance at the hearing required by Section 80.5 and all prior and subsequent attendant costs (including enforcement fees and costs incurred and penalties assessed in ascertaining violations) Sec. 80.7 (c) Civil Penalities: Up to $100 per day for each day (15-90 days after issuance of Notice) From $100 - $500 per day (91 -120 days after issuance of Notice) From $500 - $1,000 per day (121 days on) 80.8 (d) Failure to Pay: Director can initiate lien proceedings under Article XX, Section 10.230 of the Administrative Code

Yes

The City Attorney may apply to any court having jurisdic-tion for any relief as will abate or remove such nuisance

(80.7)(b) This Chapter may be enforced by an injunction issued by any court having jurisdic-tion upon any suit by the City or owner or neighbor of a property affected by a violation

Page 36: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 16

Public Works

PWC Article 5.2: Tables and Chairs in Public Sidewalk or Roadway Areas (PWC 176)

Violations carrying fines include: (1) the owner or operator of a business establishement occupying any portion of a public sidewalk, court, alley or street with tables and chairs without first obtaining a permit and (2) the owner or operator of a business establishment not maintain an insurance policy in full force and effect within the guidelines established in Section 176.5 of the Public Works Code.

$100; if violations continue or fine is not paid, the Director of Public Works may prohibit placement of tables and chairs until such penalty has been paid or the condition corrected

Infraction

PWC Article 5.3: Display of Fruits and Vegetables or Non-food Merchandise on Public Sidewalks (PWC 183)

Violations carrying fines include occupying any portion of a public sidewalk with stands for the display of fruits and vegetable or nonfood merchandise without a permit or not within the permit area per the Director's approval.

1st Offense: Not to exceed $100; 2nd Offense: Not to exceed $200; 3rd Offense: Not to exceed $500 (2nd & 3rd offense have to be within one year of the 1st)

Infraction

PWC Article 5.4: Regulation of Newsracks (PWC 184.8)

Noncompliance with Section 184 of the Public Works Code, which regulates newsracks on sidewalks and public right-of-ways, including placing newsracks in a prohibited area or not properly maintaining and displaying newsracks.

Administrative Penalties: 1st Offense: $50 2nd Offense: $100 3rd or More: $250

Yes

PWC Article 5.6: Posting of Signs on City-Owned Lamp Posts or Utility Poles (PWC 184.57-184.63)

Violations carrying fines include posting signs on public property such as lamp posts, utility poles, benches, etc. or posting any signs on certain historic and decorative lamp posts.

Criminal Penalty:Infraction- between $100-$500Or by community service in lieu of fineCivil Penalties (failing to pay amount billed):(1) The costs incurred by the City occasioned by the failure to remove signs and by damaged property occasioned by their posting or removal, and (2) the costs to the City incurred in obtaining imposition of such civil penalties through litigation, including the cost of paying City employees or other persons to engage in the litigation, and (3) an additional amount equal to 50 percent of the total of (1) and (2).Administrative Penalties:1st Offense: $502nd Offense: $1003rd or More: $250

Yes Yes Yes

Page 37: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 17

Public Works

PWC Article 5.7 Handbill Distribution (PWC Section 184.70 (b) and (c))

Violations related to distribution of handbills Sec 184.72- Criminal Penalties Not to exceed $250

Yes

PWC Article 5.8: Permit Regulations for Mobile Food Facilities Concerning Products for Human Consumption (PWC 184.98)

If the Director determines that the permittee has exceeded the scope of their mobile food facility permit (including not complying with color curb controls or operating in an otherwise restricted area) or operate without a permit, the permitee or person may be subject to criminal, civil, or administrative penalties.

Criminal Penalty: 1st Violation: Not more than $100 2nd Violation: Not more than $200 3rd or More: Not more than $500 (2nd or more violations have to be within 1 year of the first) Civil Penalties: Not to exceed $500/day for each day that such violation is committed or permitted to continue as well as attorney’s fees and costs incurred in bringing a civil action. OR Administrative Penalty: Not to exceed $1,000 per day for each violation (in accordance with Section 39-1 of the Police Code)

Yes Yes Yes

PWC Article 15: Miscellaneous (PWC 708.1)

Constructing, repairing, or replacing any sidewalk within the City and County of San Francisco, without first obtaining a permit from DPW unless DPW decides that no permit is needed or the work is covered by Section 707 of the PWC.

$1,000 Yes

Page 38: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 18

Public Works

Temporary occupancy of street (PWC Section 724)

Violation of temporary street occupancy permits. A permit will be required for occupying any part of the street or sidewalk for building construction operations or for any other purpose, and shall be granted only to the owner or lessee of the premises fronting thereon or his or her authorized agent.

Sec 724.5 - Penalty Fee and Criminal Penalty (a) Up to $1,000 per day for each day of violation. Failure to pay any fee assessed under these provisions shall constitute good cause for the project property shall be subject to a lien in the same amount (b) Criminal Penalty: Not to exceed $100 for the first violation within one year Not to exceed $200 for a second violation within one year from the date of the first violation Not to exceed $500 for the third and each additional violation within one year from the date of the first violation (c) Administrative Penalty: Shall not exceed $300 for each violation

Yes Yes

Debris Boxes (PWC Section 725)

Debris box violations including: uses, registration and permit, placement, reflectors and striping, identification of owner and debris box covers

Infraction - $100 fine Misdemeanor - up to $500 or by imprisonment in the County Jail for a period of not more than 5 days, or by both such fine and imprisonment

Infraction Misdemea

nor

Mobile storage containers (PWC Section 726)

DPW is authorized to order the immediate removal of a mobile storage container when the storage container constitutes a safety hazard or public nuisance, or when the presence of an emergency requires removal. If the owner does not move the mobile storage container immediately, the permittee shall pay to the City the costs of removal.

Cost to the City of removal of the mobile storage container

Yes

Page 39: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 19

Public Works

PWC Article 15: Miscellaneous (PWC 735)

Any property owner who maintains a blighted vacant lot is subject to fines under Chapter 80 of the Administrative Code

Sec. 80.3(d) Administrative Penalties:Staff can issue notices of violation and/or take other enforcement actions including those in Section 80.4, administrative penalties pursuant to Admin Code Chapter 100 or Police Code Article 1, Section 39-1Admin Code Ch. 100:1st Violation: Not more than $1002nd Violation: Not more than $2003rd or More: Not more than $500(2nd or more violations have to be within 1 year of the first)Police Code Article 1, Section 39-1Penalties that remain unpaid 30 days after the due date shall be subject to a late payment penalty of ten percent (10%) plus interest at the rate of one percent (1%) per month on the outstanding balance, which shall be added to the penalty amounts from the date that payment is due. Persons and entities against whom administrative penalties are imposed shall also be liable for the costs and attorney's fees incurred by the City and County in bringing any civil action to enforce the provisions of this section,Sec 80.5- General ProvisionsThe minimum charge of abatement for City abatement (if property owner does not abate): (1) $400, or (2) the actual cost to the City (including overhead and administrative costs, as well as attorneys’ fees where the Director has elected to seek recovery of attorneys’ fees), and the City's cost of preparation for and appearance at the hearing required by Section 80.5 and all prior and subsequent attendant costs (including enforcement fees and costs incurred and penalties assessed in ascertaining violations)Sec. 80.7 (c) Civil Penalties:Up to $100 per day for each day (15-90 days after issuance of Notice)From $100 - $500 per day (91 -120 days after issuance of Notice)From $500 - $1,000 per day (121 days on)80.8 (d) Failure to Pay: Director can initiate lien proceedings under Article XX, Section 10.230 of the Administrative Code

Yes Yes Yes

Page 40: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 20

Public Works

PWC Article 16: Urban Forestry Ordinance (PWC 808)

If any individual intentionally, maliciously, or by gross negligence injures or destroys a street tree, any tree on City property, a significant tree, landmark tree, landscape material in any street median, center strip, or other landscaped portion of a public right-of-way or engages in any construction work without first taking steps to protect such trees, such individual may be subject to fines.

Criminal Penalties: 1st Offense: $200 2nd or More w/in 1 Year: $400 Every violation determined to be a misdemeanor is punishable by a fine not exceeding $1,000. Civil Penalties: Not-to-exceed $500 per day as well as recovery of the attorney's fees and costs incurred in bringing the civil action Administrative Penalties: A sum of money equal to the tree or landscape replacement value or the diminishment of the tree or landscape's value. The administrative penalty can not be any less than $500 per violation. If a party performs major maintenance on a street tree without a permit or injures/destroys/removes such a tree, they may be subject to a penalty of up to $10,000 per violation in addition to other penalties specified.

Yes Yes Yes

Debris Box Companies Operating in CCSF (DPW Order 175,512)

Violations include: placement of debris box in restricted traffic street zones, placement of debris box on sidewalk area without special permits, no permits on debrix box, absent or missing registration number, missing or damaged reflectors, failure to notify DPW prior to placement of debris box in the right-of-way

$100 per day and/or cost of removal Unregistered and/or unbonded debris boxes are subject to $1000 fine per day

Yes

Page 41: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 21

Public Works

Tables and Chairs in Public Sidewalk or Roadway Areas (DPW Order 162,240)

Provides implementation guidelines for regulating tables and chairs in public sidewalk or roadway areas.

$100; if violations continue or fine is not paid, the Director of Public Works may prohibit placement of tables and chairs until such penalty has been paid or the condition corrected.

Yes

Excavation in the Public Right of Way (PWC Section 2.4)

Violations of excavating in the public right-of-way without a permit Criminal Fines: (d) Among other violations, citations may be issued for the following specific violations: (i) Excavation without a valid permit; (ii) Excavation without proof of the permit issuance on site; (iii) Excavation without proper notice to the Underground Service Alert; (iv) Excavation without proper public notice; (v) Excavation that violates the Traffic Code; (vi) Excavation that violates the regulations concerning excavation sites (Section 2.4.53), which include, but are not limited to, protection of the excavation, housekeeping and removal of excavated material, and hazardous material; (vii) Excavation that does not meet the requirements for restoration concerning backfill, replacement of pavement base, and finished pavement (Section 2.4.55(b)); or (viii) Excavation that exceeds the scope of the permit, including, but not limited to, obstructing the path of automobile or pedestrian travel in excess of the permitted area.

Sec 2.4.81 Administrative Penalties & Costs Administrative penalties shall not exceed $1,000 per day, per violation. Notwithstanding the penalty limit above, person excavating without a valid permit may be assessed a penalty not to exceed $10,000 per day, per violation. Enforcement costs can also be assessed Sec. 2.4.82 Civil Penalties and Fees Civil penalty not to exceed $500 for each day such a violation is committed Sec 2.4.83 Criminal Fines Every violation determined to be an infraction is punishable by (1) a fine not exceeding $100 for the first violation within one year; (2) a fine not exceeding $200 for a second violation within one year from the date of the first violation; (3) a fine not exceeding $500 for the third and each additional violation within one year from the date of the first violation.

Yes Yes Yes

Page 42: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 22

Public Works

Sidewalk Display Merchandise (DPW Order 166,458)

Provides a schedule of penalties to be paid by business establishments that are in violation of PWC Article 5.3 regarding regulations for displays on public sidewalk areas.

Unmaintained/unclean display/sidewalk/gutter area- $100 Permit not visibly posted- $100 Display stands exceeding permitted areas- $100 Sidewalk area altered without permit- $100 Obstruction of required minimum path of travel - $200 Display items different from inside establishment - $200 Merchandise exceeding or beyond permitted areas- $200 Display stands in place outside prescribed times as set forth in permit - $200 Non compliance with local state and federal laws governing accessibility- $200 Operation without valid permitee - $200 Willful operation without valid permit - $500

Yes

Ethics

ETHICS General Description

The Ethics Commission is authorized to impose administrative fines for violations related to campaign finance, lobbying, conflicts of interest, and governmental ethics. Unpaid settlements are referred to the TTX Bureau of Delinquent Revenues.

SF Campaign & Governmental Conduct Code

Failure to disclose lobbying contacts, improper use of campaign fund, facilure to maintain required committee records, disclosure statements in too small of font, failure to file campaign statements, financial conflict of interest, failure to disclose contacts with officers of the City, failure to report contributions. Penalty payments are due to the Ethics Commission within 10 days of stipulation. If violator fails to pay within 10 days, the Commission can reopen the matter and prosecute the violator. Penalties not paid within 60 days are supposed to be referred to the Tax Collector's Bureau of Delinquent Revenues.

Settlements range from $500 - $9,000 Yes

Fire

FIR General Description

A Fire official may issue a stop work order for work without a permit. If correction of the code violation is required, the Fire Code official may charge an administrative fee for re-inspection to certify compliance.

Fire Code 2013, Section 109

Re-inspection fee charged when a fire code official issues a notice of violation and sets a date for compliance and re-inspection.

$1,000 Yes

Page 43: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 23

Library

LIB General Description

The Library can assess fines related to late fees, books paid, processing fes, visitor's cards, lost cards, miscellaneous and inter-library loans. Patrons may make full or partial payment on fines and fees.If their fines/fees are over $10, patrons can no longer check out library materials.

Library

Library Fines (Admin Code Sec 8.21-2(a, c))

Violations for overdue fines by material and by patron, library card replacement, replacement of lost materials, lost/damaged fees, document delivery and special services, fees for lost and damaged materials owned by other libraries

Overdue Fines: Daily Fines - $.05 - $0.25 daily, $2 - $10 maximum Library Card Replacement: $0.50-$1 Replacement of Lost Materials: $5 - $35 per item; $10-$40 maximum Lost/Damaged Fees: $0.25 - $1 Document Delivery & Special Services: $0.25 - $100 Fines for Lost and Damaged Materials Owned by Other Libraries: $0 - $200 per item

Yes

Page 44: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 24

Municipal Transportation

Agency

MTA General Description

MTA fines help enforce parking regulations, general traffic and transportation regulations (such as riding a bicycle in a restricted area or driving in a transit-only area), unauthorized use of commercial vehicles, and transit violations (fare evasions, misconduct). MTA enforces State vehicle codes with fines. SFMTA does not enforce any violations related to moving vehicles, only parked vehicles. SFPD issues citations for moving vehicles. Late Payment Penalties: a) Failure to pay a citation penalty by the first due take affixed to the notice of violation shall be $30 b) Failure to pay a citation penalty by the second due date affixed to the notice of violation shall be $40 c) Fee to reimburse the City for collection costs incurred as a result of a citation that is neither contested or paid by the first due date affixed to the notice of violation shall be $46 d) Fee to reimburse the City for the costs of removing boots from vehicles shall be $316.

Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.H.2

Violation to park in a prohibited or restricted parking area.

$50 Yes

Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.H.3

Violation to park at a meter beyond the maximum time permitted outside the Downtown Core.

$50 Yes

Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.H.4.J

Violation to park in a handicap space without a disabled placard.

$50 Yes

No Permit or Expired Parking (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6A)

Violation to have an expired or no permit in permit parking area.

$61 Yes

Page 45: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 25

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Prohibited/Restricted Parking (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6B)

Violation to park in a prohibited or restricted parking area.

$82 Yes

Parked in Excess of 24 Hours (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6C)

Violation to park in excess of 24 hours. $55 Yes

Parked in Handicapped Parking Area or Blocking Handicapped Access (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6D)

Violation to park in a handicap parking area, or block handicapped access.

$335 Yes

Abandoned Vehicle (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6E)

Violation to abandon a vehicle. $229 Yes

Blocking or Parked in Intersection (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6F)

Violation to block or park in an intersection. $97 Yes

Parked in Safety/Red Zone (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6G)

Violation to park in a safety/red zone. $97 Yes

Page 46: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 26

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Parked in a Yellow Zone (Golden Gate Bridge Code Go1.I.6H)

Violation to park in a yellow zone. $82 Yes

Parked in White Zone (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6I)

Violation to park in a white zone. $97 Yes

Parked in Crosswalk (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6J)

Violation to park in a crosswalk. $97 Yes

Blocking Public/Private Driveway (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6K)

Violation to block a public or private driveway. $97 Yes

Parked on or Blocking Sidewalk (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6L)

Violation to park on a block a sidewalk. $107 Yes

Obstructing Traffic (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6M)

Violation to obstruct traffic. $107 Yes

Double Parked (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6N)

Violation to double park. $107 Yes

Parked in a Bus Stop (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6O)

Violation to park in a bus stop. $271 Yes

Page 47: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 27

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Parked in Posted No Parking Area (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6P)

Violation to park in a posted no parking area. $55 Yes

Parked in Posted Preferential Parking Area (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6Q)

Violation to park in a posted preferential parking area. $55 Yes

Motor Vehicle Alarm System (Municipal Police Code Sec 3703)

Violation to have an alarm system within a motor vehicle that does not automatically shut off after five minutes.

Criminal Penalty: Infraction 1st violation - $100 2nd violation - $200 $300 for each subsequent violation Administrative Penalties as per Admin Code Ch. 100 Civil Penalties up to $500 per violation per day

Yes Yes Yes

Limitations on Audible Alarm Systems (Municipal Police Code Sec 3704)

Violation to have an alarm system that emits sounds similar to those of sirens or emergency vehicles.

Criminal Penalty: Infraction 1st violation - $100 2nd violation - $200 $300 for each subsequent violation Administrative Penalties as per Admin Code Ch. 100 Civil Penalties up to $500 per violation per day

Yes

Parking Limited Areas including Sunday (Harbor Code 20.1)

Violation to park at metered spaces from 7:00am to 7:00pm for a longer period of time than designated on any day including Sunday and Holidays

$23 Mis-

demeanor

Page 48: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 28

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Parking Prohibited (Harbor Code 22)

Violation to park for a longer period of time than necessary for the actual loading or unloading and delivering of passengers or freight or packages upon the following areas: wharfs, bulkhead wharfs, quays, storage areas, designated loading zones.

$23

Mis-

demeanor

Specific Parking Regulations (Harbor Code 24B)

Violation to disobet an official sign pertaining to parking regulations as determined by curb markings. Red and white strip indicates no parking without a license or permit from the Port.

$23

Mis-

demeanor

Reserved Parking Spaces: Parking Prohibited in Zones Marked for Restricted Parking (Harbor Code 25)

Violation to park in reserved parking spaces in the Port area without a parking permit issued by the Port Property Department.

$23

Mis-

demeanor

Stopping Prohibited on The Embarcadero (Harbor Code 34)

Violation to stop on a portion of The Embarcadero bounded by the intersections with Bay Street and Powell Street.

$23

Mis-

demeanor

No Violation Incorrect violation code cited on ticket. Various depending on the fine.

Mis-

demeanor

Signs to be Obeyed (PK3.02)

Violation to willfully disobey notices, prohibitions or directions on any sign posted by the Recreation and Park Commission or Recreation and Park Department.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 49: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 29

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01A)

Violation to drive or propel any vehicle within any park except upon paved roads, driveways, and highways provided or unpaved roads designated by sign or signal for use by such vehicular traffic.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01C)

Violation to drive or propel any vehicle on any planted area or on any access road or unpaved service road or firetrail in any park.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01D)

Violation to park any vehicle on any lawn, or planted area, or unimproved area or on any pedestrian or equestrian lane, or access road, unpaved service road, or firetrail in any manner that blocks access to or exit from any service road where Rec and Park Commission prohibits vehicular parking.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 50: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 30

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01E)

Violation to wash, grease, or repair any vehicle in any park except when repairs are nevessary for immediate removal of any damaged or disabled vehicle from the park.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01F)

Violation to park on any road in any park except on the extreme right side of said road immediately adjacent to any curb or planted portion of the park unless otherwise permitted.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01G)

Violation to park an automobile or any other vehicle, including a house trailer attended or unattended in any park other than the Marina Green, between the hours of 10:00pm and 6am, except when attending an event or function authorized by RPD, when such parking is necessary because of an emergency,or when a sign is posted which states otherwise.

Infraction1st offense- up to $1002nd offense- up to $2003rd offense- up to $500MisdemeanorUp to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01H)

Violation to park an automobile or any other vehicle, including a house trailer attended or unattended in any park other than the Marina Green, between the hours of 10:00pm and 6am, unless person has a watercraft moored at Yacht Harbor and has a displayed permit, or such parking is necessary because of an emergency.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 51: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 31

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01I)

Violation to park an in a parking lot which is open for public use and for which a fee is charged for parking, including but limited to Kezar Parking Lot, for a period of more than 24 hours after the expiration of the period for which a fee is charged, unless otherwise allowed by permit.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Parking of Customer's Vehicles in Golden Gate Park (PK6.03)

Violation for a person who operates or is employed by a business which has custody of vehicles belonging to a peron other than those who own or are employed by the business to park any such vehicle in Golden Gate Park.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Certain Business Vehicles Prohibited from Golden Gate Park (PK6.04)

Violation for a person who operates or is employed by a business which is located within one mile of Golden Gate park to park in Golden Gate Park within one mile of such business location a vehicle that advertises or has the name of such business.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Commercial Vehicles Prohibited (PK6.05)

Violation to bring into any park any vehicle designed, used or maintained primarily for the transportation of goods, wares, merchandise, soil, building material except designated roads in Section 6.05

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 52: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 32

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Parking of Sightseeing Buses (PK6.06)

Violation to park a sightseeing bus in Golden Gate Park unless such person has a permit from RPD, or park in an are designated as a parking area for sightseeing buses.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Park Code 6.06.2 Not in code Fine amount unknown

Permits Required (PK7.03U)

Violation without a permit to park any vehicle in any park in an area not normally used for parking vehicles or in an area normally used for parking vehicles when the vehicle is used in conjunction with an activity for which a permit is obtained

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction Mis-

demeanor

Parking Restrictions on SFMTA Property (TRC Sec 1009)

Violation for any person to park in a non-SFMTA owned vehicle, whether attended or unattended in any the locations listed in the code.

$68 Infraction

Pedestrian Crossings (TRC7.2.10)

Penalty for a pedestrian to cross a roadway at any place other than by a route at right angles to the curb or by the shortest route to the opposite curb, or within the Downtown Core, to cross a roadway other than in a marked or unmarked crosswalk

$62 Infraction

Bicycle Riding Restricted (TRC7.2.12)

Penalty if riding a bicycle upon any sidewalk in violation of any restriction on riding bicycles on sidewalks except as authorized in Section 1007 of Division II.

$100 Infraction

Non-motorized user-propelled vehicles (NUV) (TRC7.2.13)

Violations include: riding a NUV on sidewalk, in the roadway, and prohibitions while operating a NUV, including: with an object that obstructs or impair's the rider's vision, wearing headphones, headsets or earplugs, operating in a reckless manner that endangers the safety of people or property

$62 Infraction

Page 53: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 33

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Residential/ Carpool Parking (TRC7.2.20)

Violation to Park for a period exceeding the posted time limit in a Residential Permit Parking Area or a Carpool Permit Parking Area without a permit. (315(a), 412(a)

$78 Infraction

Street Cleaning Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.22)

Violation to park any vehicle on any street on the days, and between the hours posted within the signs giving notice of the days and hours that parking is prohibited for street sweeping.

$68 Infraction

Payment of Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23A)

Violation to park a vehicle within the Downtown Core in any parking space controlled by a parking meter without immediately making payment.

$78 Infraction

Payment of Parking Meter - Outside of Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23B)

Violation to park a vehicle outside the Downtown Core in any parking space controlled by a parking meter without immediately making payment.

$68 Infraction

Curb Parking - Red Zones (TRC7.2.25)

Violation to park a vehicle in a red zone indicated by red paint on the curb at any time, except vehicles expressly authorized to stop at that Stand

$106 Infraction

Curb Parking - Yellow Zones (TRC7.2.26)

Violation to Park in a yellow zone indicated by yellow paint on the curb or signage, except for the purpose of loading or unloading passengers or freight, during any time in which Parking is restricted or prohibited at that yellow zone. Commercial vehicles shall not park in a yellow zone in excess of three minutes.

$91 Infraction

Curb Parking - White Zones (TRC7.2.27)

Violation to park a vehicle, except to load or unload passengers, in a white zone indicated by white paint on the curb or signage for more than five minutes during any time in which Parking is restricted or prohibited at that white zone. Violation to stop at any time when parking is restricted or prohibited, unless vehicle operator is in attendance.

$106 Infraction

Curb Parking - Green Zones (TRC7.2.28)

Violation to park a vehicle in a green zone beyond the specified time limits.

$78 Infraction

Page 54: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 34

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Parking Prohibited for more than 72 Hours (TRC7.2.29)

Violation to park on a public street for more than 72 consecutive hours.

$106 Infraction

Overtime Parking- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30A)

Violation to park longer than posted time restrictions within the Downtown Core.

$78 Infraction

Overtime Parking - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30B)

Violation to park longer than posted time restrictions outside the Downtown Core.

$68 Infraction

Overtime Meter Parking- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30C)

Violation to park at a meter beyond the maximum time permitted within the Downtown Core.

$78 Infraction

Overtime Meter Parking - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30D)

Violation to park at a meter beyond the maximum time permitted outside the Downtown Core.

$68 Infraction

Perpendicular or Angled Parking (TRC7.2.32)

Violation to park in a manner other than indicated by signs, or park in a metered space without the front of the vehicle closest to the parking meter.

$62 Infraction

Blocking Residential Door (TRC7.2.33)

Violation to park a vehicle blocking an entrance to a residence.

$48 Infraction

Parking Adjacent to or on Median Dividers or Traffic Islands (TRC7.2.34)

Violation to park on or nnext to a traffic island, lines or structures in the public right of way with the purpose of separating traffic.

$78 Infraction

Parking on Grades (TRC7.2.35)

Violation to park on a 3% or more grade or slope without setting the brakes and turning the wheels against the curb.

$62 Infraction

Page 55: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 35

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Parking Oversized vehicles within 100 feet of an Intersection (TRC7.2.36)

Violation to park a vehicle six feet or taller within 100 feet of an intersection as designated by signs.

$110 Infraction

Motorcycle Parking (TRC7.2.37)

Violation to park a vehicle other than a motorcycle in a parking space designated for motorcycles only.

$106 Infraction

Parking in Stands (TRC7.2.38)

Violation to park in a stand, except the vehicle belonging to the class of vehicles authorized to use that stand; to park or stop a vehicle in a Tour Bus standing area; to park or stop a Tour Bus for longer than the designated time restrictions, or other loading restrictions.

$106 Infraction

Parking Within Transit-Only Lanes (TRC7.2.39)

Violation to park within a transit-only designated lane. $110 Infraction

Parking Prohibition- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.40)

Violation to park in any portion a street in the Downtown Core where parking is prohibited.

$101 Infraction

Parking Prohibition - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.41)

Violation to park in any portion a street outside of the Downtown Core where parking is prohibited.

$91 Infraction

Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.42)

Violation to park in any portion of a street that is subject to a parking restriction.

$91 Infraction

Parking on Public Property (TRC7.2.43)

Violation to park on any public property (with numerous exceptions)

$68 Infraction

Page 56: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 36

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44A)

Violation to display a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that has been reported as lost, stolen, revoked or expired for a period longer than 60 days.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44B)

Violation to display a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that is not used to transport or in reasonable proximity to the person who the placard of license plate was issued.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44C)

Violation to display a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that is counterfeit, fored, altered or mutilated.

$875 Infraction

Diverting of Traffic and Temporary Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.45)

Violation to park a vehicle in violation of a temporary parking prohibition or restruction on any street or area, or to disbey the order of a police officer or parking control officer to remove a vehicle from a street or area.

$68 Infraction

Temporary Parking and Traffic Restrictions (TRC7.2.46)

Violation to park in any temporary parking or traffic restriction authorized by the SFMTA for construction work , or that is posted.

$68 Infraction

Removal of Chalk Marks (TRC7.2.47)

Violation to remove chalk marks from the tires of a vehicles placed by a Parking Control Officer for the purpose of enforcing parking regulations.

$110 Infraction

Construction or Repairing of Vehicles (TRC7.2.48)

Violation to construct or repair a vehicle on a public street except when repairs are necessary in case of an accident or breakdown to enable the removal of the vehicle from the street.

$83 Infraction

Displaying Permit on Other Vehicles (TRC7.2.49)

Violation to use or display a parking permit on a vehicle other than the vehicle for which it is issued.

$110 Infraction

Page 57: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 37

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Displaying Fraudulent Parking Permit or Submitting False, Misleading or Fraudulent Information on a Residential Parking Permit Application (TRC7.2.50)

Violation to use or display a fraudulent parking permit; or to knowingly make a false, misleading or fraudulent statement or representation on an application or renewal of a residential parking permit.

$110 Infraction

Parking within Parking Space (TRC7.2.51)

Violation to park a vehicle other than in a designated parking space, or across boundaries of a parking space, in any manner than the vehicle is not entirely within the parking space.

$62 Infraction

Car Share Vehicle Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.52)

Violation to park a vehicle in a parking space designated as exclusive use for car share vehicles.

$110 Infraction

Large Vehicle Parkings Restrictions (TRC7.2.54)

Violation to park a vehicle over 22 feet in length, or seven feet in height, camp trailers, fifth wheel travel trailers, house cars, trailer coaches, mobile homes, recreational vehicles, or semi trailers between the hours of 12am and 6am when MTA signs are posted giving notice.

$110 Infraction

Payment of Parking Facility Charges; Proof of Payment (TRC7.2.60)

Violation for failure or neglect to pay parking changes while parked in a municipal parking facility; or failure to display a parking ticket or receipt where parking facility requires the display of a parking ticket or receipt as proof of payment.

$62 Infraction

Use of Entrance and Exit of Municipal Parking Facility (TRC7.2.61)

Violation to enter a municipal parking facility by any means of ingress that is not marked with the word "entrance" or otherwise indicated by arrows, signs, or words of entry; or to exit a municipal parking facility by any means of egress not marked with the word "exit" or otherwise indicated by arrows, signs, or words.

$100 Infraction

Page 58: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 38

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Blocking Parking Spaces (TRC7.2.62)

Violation to park in a manner which wholly or partially obstructs or interferes with access to any parking space, or that obstructs with movement of vehicles in an ingress or egress from a municipal parking facility.

$62 Infraction

Blocking an Electric Charging Bay (TRC7.2.64)

Violation to park a non-electric vehicle in a parking space equipped with an electric vehicle charging bay, or in a manner that locks or occupies the electric vehicle charging bay.

$110 Infraction

Overtime Parking (TRC7.2.65)

Violation to park in a municipal parking garage for longer than posted time restrictions; to remain at a parking meter beyond the maximum time permitted.

$68 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66A)

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that has been reported lost, stolen, surrendered, canceled, revoked or expired, or issued to a person who has been deceased for a period exceeding 60 days.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66B)

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that is not being used to transport and is not in reasonable proximity of the person whom the license plate or placard was issued to a person who is authorized to be transported in the vehicle displaying the placard or license plate.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions TRC7.2.66C

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privilege that is counterfeit, forged, altered or mutilated.

$875 Infraction

Obstructing Traffic - Vehicle (TRC7.2.70)

Violation to park a vehicle in a manner to obstruct the flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic.

$110 Infraction

Page 59: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 39

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Obstructing Traffic-without Permit; Violation of Terms of Permit; Violation of Division II, Section 903 (TRC7.2.71)

Violation to obstruct traffic without a Special Traffic Permit, obstruct traffic in violation of the terms of a Special Traffic Permit, or violate regulations set forth in Division II, Sec 903

$563 Infraction

Driving in a Transit-Only Area (TRC7.2.72)

Violation to operate a vehicle or any portion of a vehicle within a transit-only designated area, except public transit vehicles, taxicabs, vehicles preparing to make a turn, or vehicles entering into or exiting from a stopped position at the curb.

$73 Infraction

Driving Through Parades (TRC7.2.73)

Violation to drive between vehicles of an authorized parade.

$100 Infraction

Streetcar Right-of-Way- Vehicles Prohibited (TRC7.2.74)

Violation to drive a vehicle over, upon or across any streetcar right of way which has been raised 3 inches or more above the adjacent roadway, except to enter or exit a garage or driveway, or to pass a disabled vehicle.

$100 Infraction

Passing Safety Zones (TRC7.2.75)

Violation to drive any vehicle other than a public transit vehicle to the left of any safety zone established at a regular streetcar stop between the hours and locations specified in Division II.

$100 Infraction

TRC7.2.76 "Reserved" $100 Infraction

Weight Restricted Streets (TRC7.2.77)

Violation to operate on any portio of a street a vehicle with a gross weight in excess of the authorized weight limit established for that street.

$100 Infraction

Parking or Driving of Vehicles in Port Area (TRC7.2.78)

Violation to park a vehicle or leave an animal parked upon any property under control and jurisdiction of the Port Commission, or on property in violation of Port regulations.

Violation amount unknown Infraction

Page 60: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 40

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Vehicles for Hire and Taxis; Parking Prohibited in Certain Use Districts (TRC7.2.80)

Violation for the operator of any vehicle for hire parked at a location designated for the exclusive use of Tour Buses to leave any such vehicle unattended in any street in a RH-1(D), RH-1, RH-2, RH-3, RH-4, RM-1, RM-2, RM-3, RM-4 or P Use District, or for any Taxi to remain parked in such districts for a period in excess of 4 hours.

$110 Infraction

Parking of Vehicles for Commercial Advertising Purposes (TRC7.2.81)

Violation to park a vehicles displaying commercial advertising on any public street or in any public or private parking lot in the City for the primary purpose of displaying a commercial advertising sign. Does not apply to passenger vehicles with a maximum occupancy of 6 passengers, or to vehicles perked while loading or unloading, engaged in delivery of services, parking within 600 feet of the registered owner of the vehicle.

$110 Infraction

Selling from a Vehicle Restricted (TRC7.2.82)

Violation for any person to park a vehicle on a street in a business district and offer merchandise, services, food or beverages from that vehicle except for Mobile Food Facilities; and for any person to park a mobile food facility in any street in any residential area without a valid and displayed permit from DPW.

$110 Infraction

Truck Loading Zone (TRC7.2.83)

Violation to park a vehicle in a Truck Loading Zone other than a truck, except as expressly authorized by applicable signage.

$91 Infraction

Commercial Vehicle Parking in Certain Districts (TRC7.2.84)

Violation to park a motor truck, truck tractor, road tractor, van, trailer, delivery wagon or any vehicle for commercial purposes in excess of limitations on manufacturer's gross vehicle weight rating, for a period in excess of 1 hour between the hours of 2am and 6am on any street with weight limits, except while delivering goods or when used by a recreational equipment vendor.

$110 Infraction

Idling Engine While Parked (TRC7.2.86)

Violation for a commercial vehicle, private bus, or motor vehicle for hire to idle while parked upon the public right of way for more than five minutes, unless the vehicle is temporarily stopped for the sole purpose of loading or unloading passengers.

$100 Infraction

Page 61: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 41

Municipal Transportation

Agency

On Street Sales Restrictions (TRC7.2.88)

Violation to park a vehicle on an on-street parking place for the purpose of displaying the sale of the vehicle unless it is parked within 600 feet of the residents of the registered owner of the vehicle.

$62 Infraction

Tour Narration by Bus Drivers (TRC7.2.89)

Violation for the driver of any City Tour Bus to engage in tour narration while such vehicle is in motion on any public street.

Violation amount unknown Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC 7.2.101)

Violation to evade transit fare, generally. $112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101A)

Violation for any passenger in a public transit station or public transit vehicle to evade fare collection system or proof of payment.

$112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101B)

Violation to board or ride a light rail vehicle, streetcar, cable car, motor coach, or trolley coach without prior or concurrent payment of fare.

$112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101C)

Failure to display a valid fare receipt or transit pass in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101D)

Violation to misuse any transfer, pass, ticket or token with the intent to evade the payment of any fare.

$112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101E)

Violation to knowingly use or attempt to use any illegally printed, duplicated, or otherwise reproduced token, card, transfer or other item for entry onto a transit vehicle or into any transit station with the intent of evading payment of fare.

$112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101F)

Violation for an unauthorized person to use a discount ticket or fail to present acceptable proff of eligibility to use a discount ticket.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102)

Infraction

Page 62: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 42

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102A)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to play sound equipment on or in a system facility or vehicle.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102B)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to smoke, eat or drink in or on a system facility where those areas are prohibited.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102C)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to expectorate upon or within a system facility or vehicle.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102D)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to willfully disturb others on or in a system facility or vehicle by engaging in boisterous or unruly behavior.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102E)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to carry an explosive or acid, flammable liquid, or toxic or hazardous material in a system facility or vehicle.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102F)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to urinate or defecate in a system facility or vehicle except in a lavatory, with the exception of those that cannot comply as a result of a disability, age, or medical condition.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102G)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to willfully block the free movement of another person in a system facility or vehicle.

$112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102H)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to skateboard, roller skate, bicycle ride or roller blade in a system facility, vehicle, or parking structure.

$112 Infraction

Page 63: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 43

Municipal Transportation

Agency

Conversing with Operating Personnel Prohibited (TRC7.2.103)

Violation for any person to engage any operater of a street car, cable car, bus or trolley coach in conversation, except for the purpose of procuring necessary information.

$57 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC 2.104)

Violation of Clipper Card regulations, generally. $112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104A)

Violation to fail to display a valid Clipper Card at the request of an authorized representative of the transit system or peace officer while on a transit vehicle or in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104B)

Violation to misuse any Clipper card with the intent to evade the payment of any fare, or to fail to taga Clipper card transponder or card reader while on a transit vehicle or in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104C)

Violation to knowingly use or attempt to use any illegally printed, duplicated, or otherwise reproduced Clipper card for entry onto a transit vehicle orinto any transit station with the intent of evading payment of a fare.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104D)

Violation for any unauthorized person to use a discount Clipper card or fail to present, upon request from a system fare inspector, acceptable proof of eligibility to use the discount Clipper card.

$112 Infraction

Obstructing Traffic (TRC7.3.3)

Violation to obstruct traffic four or more times within one year without a Special Traffic Permit, or violate the terms of a Special Traffic Permit or the regulations set forth in Division II, Sec 903.

Fine - at least $1,000 OR Imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding six months OR Both

Infraction Misdemea

nor

Page 64: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 44

Economic & Workforce

Development

OEWD General Description

The Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) enforces the Local Hiring Policy for Construction. The Policy covers City public works and improvement contracts in excess of $400,000 advertised for bids on or after March 2011. In 2015, the Policy was amended to cover contracts in excess of $600,000 advertised on or after August 2015.

Local Hiring Policy for Construction (Admin Code Chapter 6.22(g))

Penalties for violation of mandatory local worker participation level for City project work hours.

Equal to the prevailing wage rate for each hour that the contractor fell short of the local hiring requirement

Police

POL General Description

The Police do not collect any municipal fines, but do receive some fine revenue legislated by the State. These include .50 on every $10 of traffic fines for Cal-ID fingerprinting, monies from a crime lab fee/fine administered by the Courts and deposited by the Controller into a Police account, and false alarm fees which are collected by Treasurer/ Tax Collector

Page 65: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 45

Police

Police Emergency Alarm Ordinance (Police Code Section 3714)

Penalties related to false alarms of alarm systems.

1st false alarm- no penalty 2nd false alarm- $100 3rd false alarm- $150 per alarm 4th false alarm- $200 per alarm 5th false alarm- $250 per alarm Use of non-licensed alarm system - $100, plus $250 for each false alarm. Tax Collector can waive the first $100 penalty if alarm user submits an application for a license within 10 days of the violation. $250 penalty for alarm installation company if determined alarm was the result of an in-site employee of the alarm installation company. $250 penalty for failure to verify alarm system signals by the monitoring company. $500 if Tax Collector determines alarm installation or monitoring company knowingly made a false statement relating to its duties and obligations Penalties are subject to collection and enforcement provision of Sect 3710.5 and 3718 including late payment penalties and accrual of interest.

Yes

Page 66: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 46

Port

PORT General Description

There are numerous violations that can be cited under the Port code ranging related to: disorderly conduct, animals, traffic regulations and required permits to conduct activities on all lands, and waters, including any street, wharf, bulkhead wharf, pier, quay, storage area, waterway or navigable waters within the control and jurisdiction of the Port Commission. Violations under the Port Code are rarely cited since the City no longer has a separate Port Police.

Parking Prohibited (Harbor Code 22)

Violation to park for a longer period of time than necessary for the actual loading or unloading and delivering of passengers or freight or packages upon the following areas: wharfs, bulkhead wharfs, quays, storage areas, designated loading zones.

$23 Mis-

demeanor

Specific Parking Regulations (Harbor Code 24B)

Violation to disobey an official sign pertaining to parking regulations as determined by curb markings. Red and white strip indicates no parking without a license or permit from the Port.

$23

Mis-

demeanor

Reserved Parking Spaces: Parking Prohibited in Zones Marked for Restricted Parking (Harbor Code 25)

Violation to park in reserved parking spaces in the Port area without a parking permit issued by the Port Property Department.

$23

Mis-

demeanor

Signs to be Obeyed (PK3.02)

Violation to willfully disobey notices, prohibitions or directions on any sign posted by the Recreation and Park Commission or Recreation and Park Department.

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 67: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 47

Port

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01D)

Violation to park any vehicle on any lawn, or planted area, or unimproved area or on any pedestrian or equestrian lane, or access road, unpaved service road, or firetrail in any manner that blocks access to or exit from any service road where Rec and Park Commission prohibits vehicular parking.

Infraction 1st offense- Not to exceed $50 Second offense- Not to exceed $100 Third and each additional offense - $250 (Violated within a one year period)

Infraction

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01G)

Violation to park an automobile or any other vehicle, including a house trailer attended or unattended in any park other than the Marina Green, between the hours of 10:00pm and 6am, except when attending an event or function authorized by RPD, when such parking is necessary because of an emergency, or when a sign is posted which states otherwise.

Infraction 1st offense- Not to exceed $50 Second offense- Not to exceed $100 Third and each additional offense - $250 (Violated within a one year period)

Infraction

Permits Required (PK7.03U)

Violation without a permit to park any vehicle in any park in an area not normally used for parking vehicles or in an area normally used for parking vehicles when the vehicle is used in conjunction with an activity for which a permit is obtained

Infraction 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500 Misdemeanor Up to $1,000 fine and up to six months in jail OR fine and imprisonment

Payment of Parking Meter (TRC7.2.23)

Violation to park without paying the meter (Downtown Core or Outside Downtown Core not specified)

Infraction

Payment of Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23A)

Violation to park a vehicle within the Downtown Core in any parking space controlled by a parking meter without immediately making payment.

$78 Infraction

Motorcycle Parking (TRC7.2.37)

Violation to park a vehicle other than a motorcycle in a parking space designated for motorcycles only.

$106 Infraction

Motorcycle Parking (TRC7.2.37)

Violation to park a vehicle other than a motorcycle in a parking space designated for motorcycles only.

$106 Infraction

Page 68: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 48

Port

Residential/ Carpool Parking (TRC7.2.20)

Violation to Park for a period exceeding the posted time limit in a Residential Permit Parking Area or a Carpool Permit Parking Area without a permit. (315(a), 412(a)

$78 Infraction

Perpendicular or Angled Parking (TRC7.2.32)

Violation to park in a manner other than indicated by signs, or park in a metered space without the front of the vehicle closest to the parking meter.

$62 Infraction

Payment of Parking Facility Charges; Proof of Payment (TRC7.2.60)

Violation for failure or neglect to pay parking changes while parked in a municipal parking facility; or failure to display a parking ticket or receipt where parking facility requires the display of a parking ticket or receipt as proof of payment.

$62 Infraction

Parking within Parking Space (TRC7.2.51)

Violation to park a vehicle other than in a designated parking space, or across boundaries of a parking space, in any manner than the vehicle is not entirely within the parking space.

$62 Infraction

Parking Prohibition- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.40)

Violation to park in any portion a street in the Downtown Core where parking is prohibited.

$101 Infraction

Parking Prohibition - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.41)

Violation to park in any portion a street outside of the Downtown Core where parking is prohibited.

$91 Infraction

Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.42)

Violation to park in any portion of a street that is subject to a parking restriction.

$91 Infraction

Overtime Parking- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30A)

Violation to park longer than posted time restrictions within the Downtown Core.

$78 Infraction

Overtime Parking - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30B)

Violation to park longer than posted time restrictions outside the Downtown Core.

$68 Infraction

Page 69: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 49

Port

Overtime Parking at a Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30C)

Violation to park at a parking meter beyond the maximum time permitted within the Downtown Core

$78 Infraction

Overtime Parking at a Parking Meter - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30D)

Violation to park at a parking meter beyond the maximum time permitted outside the Downtown Core

$68 Infraction

Temporary Parking and Traffic Restrictions (TRC7.2.46)

Violation to park in any temporary parking or traffic restriction authorized by the SFMTA for construction work , or that is posted.

$68 Infraction

Truck Loading Zone (TRC7.2.83)

Violation to park a vehicle in a Truck Loading Zone other than a truck, except as expressly authorized by applicable signage.

$91 Infraction

Diverting of Traffic and Temporary Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.45)

Violation to park a vehicle in violation of a temporary parking prohibition or restruction on any street or area, or to disbey the order of a police officer or parking control officer to remove a vehicle from a street or area.

$68 Infraction

Parking Prohibited for more than 72 Hours (TRC7.2.29)

Violation to park on a public street for more than 72 consecutive hours.

$106 Infraction

Street Cleaning Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.22)

Violation to park any vehicle on any street on the days, and between the hours posted within the signs giving notice of the days and hours that parking is prohibited for street sweeping.

$68 Infraction

Curb Parking - Red Zones (TRC7.2.25)

Violation to park a vehicle in a red zone indicated by red paint on the curb at any time, except vehicles expressly authorized to stop at that Stand

$106 Infraction

Page 70: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 50

Port

Curb Parking - Yellow Zones (TRC7.2.26)

Violation to Park in a yellow zone indicated by yellow paint on the curb or signage, except for the purpose of loading or unloading passengers or freight, during any time in which Parking is restricted or prohibited at that yellow zone. Commercial vehicles shall not park in a yellow zone in excess of three minutes.

$91 Infraction

Curb Parking - Yellow Zones (TRC7.2.26)

Violation to Park in a yellow zone indicated by yellow paint on the curb or signage, except for the purpose of loading or unloading passengers or freight, during any time in which Parking is restricted or prohibited at that yellow zone. Commercial vehicles shall not park in a yellow zone in excess of three minutes.

$91 Infraction

Curb Parking - White Zones (TRC7.2.27)

Violation to park a vehicle, except to load or unload passengers, in a white zone indicated by white paint on the curb or signage for more than five minutes during any time in which Parking is restricted or prohibited at that white zone. Violation to stop at any time when parking is restricted or prohibited, unless vehicle operator is in attendance.

$106 Infraction

Curb Parking - Green Zones (TRC7.2.28)

Violation to park a vehicle in a green zone indicated by the green pain on the curb beyond the specific time limits.

$78 Infraction

Parking in Stands (TRC7.2.38)

Violation to park in a stand, except the vehicle belonging to the class of vehicles authorized to use that stand; to park or stop a vehicle in a Tour Bus standing area; to park or stop a Tour Bus for longer than the designated time restrictions, or other loading restrictions.

$106 Infraction

Parking Adjacent to or on Median Dividers or Traffic Islands (TRC7.2.34)

Violation to park on or nnext to a traffic island, lines or structures in the public right of way with the purpose of separating traffic.

$78 Infraction

Parking on Grades (TRC7.2.35)

Violation to park on a 3% or more grade or slope without setting the brakes and turning the wheels against the curb.

$62 Infraction

Page 71: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 51

Port

Parking within Parking Space (TRC7.2.51)

Violation to park a vehicle other than in a designated parking space, or across boundaries of a parking space, in any manner than the vehicle is not entirely within the parking space.

$62 Infraction

Idling Engine While Parked (TRC7.2.86)

Violation for a commercial vehicle, private bus, or motor vehicle for hire to idle while parked upon the public right of way for more than five minutes, unless the vehicle is temporarily stopped for the sole purpose of loading or unloading passengers.

$100 Infraction

Parking Oversized vehicles within 100 feet of an Intersection (TRC7.2.36)

Violation to park a vehicle six feet or taller within 100 feet of an intersection as designated by signs.

$110 Infraction

Obstructing Traffic - Vehicle (TRC7.2.70)

Violation to park a vehicle in a manner to obstruct the flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic.

$110 Infraction

Perpendicular or Angled Parking (TRC7.2.32)

Violation to park in a manner other than indicated by signs, or park in a metered space without the front of the vehicle closest to the parking meter.

$62 Infraction

Parking in Stands (TRC7.2.38)

Violation to park in a stand, except the vehicle belonging to the class of vehicles authorized to use that stand; to park or stop a vehicle in a Tour Bus standing area; to park or stop a Tour Bus for longer than the designated time restrictions, or other loading restrictions.

$106 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC 7.2.101)

Violation to evade transit fare, generally. $112 Infraction

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102B)

Violation for any passenger in or about a public transit station or public transit vehicle to smoke, eat or drink in or on a system facility where those areas are prohibited.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104A)

Violation to fail to display a valid Clipper Card at the request of an authorized representative of the transit system or peace officer while on a transit vehicle or in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Page 72: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 52

Port

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104B)

Violation to misuse any Clipper card with the intent to evade the payment of any fare, or to fail to taga Clipper card transponder or card reader while on a transit vehicle or in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104D)

Violation for any unauthorized person to use a discount Clipper card or fail to present, upon request from a system fare inspector, acceptable proof of eligibility to use the discount Clipper card.

$112 Infraction

Parking Restrictions on SFMTA Property (TRC Sec 1009)

Violation for any person to park in a non-SFMTA owned vehicle, whether attended or unattended in any the locations listed in the code.

$68 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC 2.104)

Violation of Clipper Card regulations, generally. $112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC 7.2.101)

Violation to evade transit fare, generally. $112 Infraction

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101C)

Failure to display a valid fare receipt or transit pass in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104A)

Violation to fail to display a valid Clipper Card at the request of an authorized representative of the transit system or peace officer while on a transit vehicle or in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104B)

Violation to misuse any Clipper card with the intent to evade the payment of any fare, or to fail to taga Clipper card transponder or card reader while on a transit vehicle or in a Proof of Payment Zone.

$112 Infraction

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104D)

Violation for any unauthorized person to use a discount Clipper card or fail to present, upon request from a system fare inspector, acceptable proof of eligibility to use the discount Clipper card.

$112 Infraction

Page 73: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 53

Port

Payment of Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23A)

Violation to park a vehicle inside the Downtown Core in any parking space controlled by a parking meter without immediately making payment.

$68 Infraction

Payment of Parking Meter - Outside of Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23B)

Violation to park a vehicle outside the Downtown Core in any parking space controlled by a parking meter without immediately making payment.

$68 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44A)

Violation to display a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that has been reported as lost, stolen, revoked or expired for a period longer than 60 days.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44B)

Violation to display a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that is not used to transport or in reasonable proximity to the person who the placard of license plate was issued.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44C)

Violation to display a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that is counterfeit, fored, altered or mutilated.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66A)

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that has been reported lost, stolen, surrendered, canceled, revoked or expired, or issued to a person who has been deceased for a period exceeding 60 days.

$875 Infraction

Page 74: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 54

Port

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66B)

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that is not being used to transport and is not in reasonable proximity of the person whom the license plate or placard was issued to a person who is authorized to be transported in the vehicle displaying the placard or license plate.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions TRC7.2.66C

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privilege that is counterfeit, forged, altered or mutilated.

$875 Infraction

Overtime Parking (TRC7.2.65)

Violation to park in a municipal parking garage for longer than posted time restrictions; to remain at a parking meter beyond the maximum time permitted.

$68 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66A)

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that has been reported lost, stolen, surrendered, canceled, revoked or expired, or issued to a person who has been deceased for a period exceeding 60 days.

$875 Infraction

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66B)

Violation to park in any municipal or privately owned parking facility with a disabled parking placard or special license plate in order to obtain special parking privileges that is not being used to transport and is not in reasonable proximity of the person whom the license plate or placard was issued to a person who is authorized to be transported in the vehicle displaying the placard or license plate.

$875 Infraction

Page 75: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 55

Port

Parking of Vehicles for Commercial Advertising Purposes (TRC7.2.81)

Violation to park a vehicles displaying commercial advertising on any public street or in any public or private parking lot in the City for the primary purpose of displaying a commercial advertising sign. Does not apply to passenger vehicles with a maximum occupancy of 6 passengers, or to vehicles perked while loading or unloading, engaged in delivery of services, parking within 600 feet of the registered owner of the vehicle.

$110 Infraction

Obstructing Traffic (TRC7.3.3)

Violation to obstruct traffic four or more times within one year without a Special Traffic Permit, or violate the terms of a Special Traffic Permit or the regulations set forth in Division II, Sec 903.

Fine - at least $1,000 OR Imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding six months OR Both

Infraction Misdemea

nor

Failure to Display Receipt TRC 7.2.1

Unable to locate in Code.

Parking Meter (Downtown) TRC 7.2.2

Unable to locate in Code.

Parking Meter (Outside of Downtown)TRC 7.2.3

Unable to locate in Code.

Parking Prohibited (Outside of Downtown) TRC 7.2.4

Unable to locate in Code.

Parked Not within Space TRC 7.2.5

Unable to locate in Code.

TRC 7.2.6 Unable to locate in Code.

Obstructing Traffic TRC 7.2.7

Unable to locate in Code.

Stopped in a Truck Loading Zone TRC 7.2.8

Unable to locate in Code.

Municpal Police Code 710.2

Unable to locate in Code.

T38D Unable to locate in Code.

Page 76: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 56

Port

T32.12 Unable to locate in Code.

Signs to by Obeyed (Port Code Sec 2.2)

Violation to willfully disobey notices, prohibitions, or directions on any sign posted by the Commission.

Misdemeanor OR Infraction, decision shall be made by the District Attorney Infraction: 1st offense- $10-$50 2nd and additional offenses- $20-$100 Misdemeanor: Up to $500 or by imprisonment in County Jail for a period of not more than six months, or by both fine and imprisonment.

Infraction Mis-

demeanor

Athletic Activities Prohibited in Certain Areas (Port Code Sec 2.4)

Violation to participate in athletic activities where prohibited as noted by a sign.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Restrictions on Posting of Signs (Port Code Sec 2.5)

Violation to post signs, notice, handbills, circulates and pamphlets to trees, shrubs, plants, fences, buildings, monuments, walls, posts, vehicles or other physical objects.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Personal Services (Port Code Sec 2.6)

Violation to provide personal instructional services for compensation without having first obtained a permit, concession, license or lease from the Executive Director.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Airplanes, Helicopters, Hot Air Balloons, Prohibited (Port Code Sec 2.7)

Violation to launch or land an airplane, parachute, hang glider, hot air balloon or any other machine or apparatus of aviation in any park without written permission from the Executive Director.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Peddling and Vending Merchandise or Printed Material (Port Code Sec 2.8)

Violation to sell or exchange food, beverages, good, wares or merchandise in any park without a permit, concession, license or lease from the Executive Director.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Camping Prohibited (Port Code Sec 2.9)

Violation to camp except with written permission from the Executive Director.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 77: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 57

Port

Sleeping Prohibited During Certain Hours (Sec 2.10)

Violation to sleep in the park between the hours of 10:00pm and 6:00 am except with special permission by the Executive Director.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Performance of Labor (Port Code Sec 2.11)

Violation to perform labor on the park without permission of the Executive Director.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Building Materials (Port Code Sec 2.12)

Violation to place, pile, deposit or leave any building material in any park without necessary permits.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Ground Restored to Condition (Port Code Sec 2.13)

Violation to not restore ground to condition after work has been done in any part of the park.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Warning Signals at Dangerous Points (Port Code Sec 2.14)

Violation not to provide warnings of dangers if performing work in the park that makes it dangerous.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Disorderly Conduct (Port Code Sec 3.1)

Violation to: throw dangerous objects, fire or carry firearms or weapons; carry or use a model airplane powered by liquid fuel; make or maintain a fire, climb or lie upon a tree, shrub, monument, wall, fence, shelter, fountain, statue, building, construction or structure; emit excreta of the human body except in proper receptacles;

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Swimming Restrictions (Port Code Sec 3.2)

Violation to enter the waters of any lake, pond, pool, tank, fountain or reservoir in any park except with written permission by the Executive Director.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Polluting Waters Prohibited (Port Code Sec 3.3)

Violation to throw garbage or other polluting matter into any pool, pond, tank, or fountain in any park, or into the water of the San Francisco Bay.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 78: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 58

Port

Removal of Trees, Wood, Etc (Port Code Sec 3.6)

Violation to remove or take away any tree, wood, bush, turf, shrub, flower, plany, grass, soil, rock or anything of like kind from any park without permission from the Executive Director.

Per Port Code Sec 3.7: 1st offense- $50-$100 2nd offense- $100-$500 3rd offense- $150-$500 Court shall also impose a civil penalty or an amount necessary to reimburse the Commission for the value of removed material and labor expended to replace ot restore this area.

Yes Yes

Interference with Port Commission and Park Employees (Park Code 3.8)

Violation to interfere with an employee of the Commission or an authorized contractor while the person is constructing, repairing, or caring for any portion of the park.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction Mis-

demeanor

Alcoholic Beverages (Port Code Sec 3.9)

Violation to consume alcoholic bevereages in any of the parks unless there is permission from the Executive Director or Port Commission.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Refusal to Obey Lawful Order (Port Code Sec 3.12)

Violation to refuse to obey the lawful order of a police officer.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Minors, Parents and Guardians of (Port Code Sec 3.15)

Violation for a parent to allow a minor to do any act or thing prohibited by the provisions of this Code.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Dogs, Cats Only Allowed (Port Code Sec 4.1)

Violation to bring into the park any animal except for dogs and domestic cats.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Animals Prohibited from Certain Areas (Port Code Sec 4.2)

Violation to allow any animal to enter into a building, playground, sandbox or other area reserved for childern, or to enter or drink the water of any drinking fountain, lake or pond except as designated and maintained for such purposes.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Cats on Leash or in Transport Box (Port Code Sec 4.3)

Violation to bring into the park a domestic cat unless it is on a leash or in an animal transport box.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 79: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 59

Port

Vicious Animals Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.4)

Violation to keep or premit to remain in a park a noisy, vicious or dangerous animal.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Abandonment of Animals Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.5)

Violation to abandon any animals in any park. See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Feeding Animals Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.6)

Violation to feed or offer to any animal in any park any substance which would be likely to be harmful to it.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Disturbing Animals, Birds, Fish Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.7)

Violation to hunt, injur or disturb any animal in any park except nuisances as identified by Executive Director. Exceptions in Article 7, Chapter VIII of the Police Code.

See Port Code Sec 2.2 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Public Utilities Commission

PUC General Description

The Public Utilities Commission charges excess water use charges to irrigation customers and late payment penalty charges when customers do not pay their bills within 30 days.

Excess Water Use Charges (Irrigation Customers)

This is a new penalty charge for irrigation customers that do not conserve water under the Commission approved water regulation process. The penalty charge went into effect starting in FY 2014-15.

Late Payment Penalty

PUC charges a late payment penalty when customers do not pay their bills within 30 days. Any charge or fee not paid within 30 days shall be subject to a late penalty equal to one-half of one percent (1/2%) for each 30 days or fraction thereof on the amount owed. This late payment penalty also applies to wholesale customers.

Page 80: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 60

Recreation and Park

REC General Description

The Recreation and Parks Department assesses fines for violations of a variety of activities in the City's parks. Payments for fines are made to the Superior Court, or worked off by community service. If fines are not paid, an arrest warrant can be put out for the offender, and they might need to appear in criminal court. The complaint charging the violation shall specify whether the violation is a misdemeanor or infraction. If a person is conviceted of a crime involving vandalism, defacement or destruction of park property, that person shall be liable for any and all costs associated with restoring the affected area. Note: RPD is missing data from September 2013-December 2013, so FY 2013-14 data is not entirely complete.

Signs to be Obeyed (Park Code 3.02)

Violation to willfully disobey notices, prohibitions or directions on any sign posted by Rec and Park Commission or RPD.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Athletic Activities Prohibited in Certain Areas (Park Code 3.05)

Violation to participate in athletic activities in the Japanese Tea Garden, Arboretum and Conservatory Valley.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Launching Boats Prohibited (Park Code 3.06)

Violation to launch a boat or watercraft in any lake in any park, with various exceptions.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Restrictions on Posting Signs (Parks Code 3.07)

Violation to post signs, notices, handbills, circulars and pamphlets on physical objects in the park, with exceptions.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Personal Services (Park Code 3.08)

Violation to use facilities or areas of the park for athletic instruction for compensation without a permit, concession, license or lease from the Recreation and Park Commission.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 81: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 61

Recreation and Park

Airplanes, Helicopters, Hot Air Balloons etc Prohibited (Park Code 3.09)

Violation to launch or land any airplane, helicopter, parachute, hang glider, hot air balloon; violation to bring into the park any balloon with a diameter of more than 6 feet or gas capacity of more than 115 cubic feet.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Peddling Vending Merchandise Prohibited/Require Permit (Park Code 3.10)

Violation to bring goods, wares or merchandise for sale or barter, exchange without a permit, concession, license or lease from the RPD or Commission.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Camping Prohibited (Park Code 3.12)

Violation to construct, maintain or inhabit a structure used for housing accommodations in the park except with permission from RPD or Commission.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Sleeping in Park Ground Prohibited 8pm-8am (Park Code 3.13)

Violation to sleep in the park between the hours of 8pm and 8am, except with special permission from RPD.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Performance of Labor Prohibited (Park Code 3.14)

Violation to perform any labor on or upon any park without permission of RPD.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Building Materials (Park Code 3.15)

Violation to place, pile, deposit or leave building material in the park without a permit from RPD.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Hours of Operation (Park Code 3.21)

Violation to enter and use any park from 5am to midnight daily, with exceptions including traveling through the park on roads or bike paths or permission from RPD.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Throwing Objects in a Dangerous Nature (Park Code 4.01(a))

Violation to throw or propel objects of a potentially dangerous nature.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Weapons (Park Code 4.01(b))

Violation to fire or carry firearms or instruments adopted for use primarily as a weapon.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 82: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 62

Recreation and Park

Firecracker or Fireworks Prohibited (Park Code 4.01(c))

Violation to fire or carry a firecracker, rocket, torpedo or other fireworks.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Make, Kindle, Maintaining a Fire Prohibited in the Park (Park Code 4.01(e))

Violation to carry or use a model airplane powered by liquid fuel or designed to be used with such fuel.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Climbing or Lying on Trees, Shrubs, Walls, Structures, etc (Park Code 4.01(f))

Violation to climb or lie upon any tree, shrub, monument, wall, fence, shelter, fountain, statue, building, construction or structure.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Emission, Ejection or Excretion of Human Waste (Park Code 4.01(g))

Violation to emit, eject, or cause to be deposited any excreta of the human body except in proper receptacles.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No exposure of genitals, pubic hair, buttocks, perineum (Park Code 4.01(h))

Violation to expose genitals, pubic hair, buttocks, perineum, anal region or pubic hair region or any portion of the female breast at or below the areola, except for children under 5 years old.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Entering Opposite Sex Restroom Prohibited (Park Code 4.01(i))

Violation to enter a restroom or toilet set apart for use of the opposite sex, except children under the age of 5 years accompanied by a parent or guardian or authorized maintenance personnel.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Gain or Attempt Entry to Facility of Park Without Paying (Park Code 4.01(j))

Violation to attempt admittance to facilities in a park where a charge is made without paying that charge.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 83: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 63

Recreation and Park

Play Percussion Instrument (Park Code 4.01(k))

Violation to play a percussion instrument at a time or location prohibited by RPD.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Entering into an Animal Enclosure at the SF Zoo (Park Code 4.01(l))

Violation to enter into an animal enclosure or habitat at the SF Zoo without authorization.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Rules of SF Zoo (Park Code 4.01(m))

Failure to follow rules of the SF Zoo or Zoo Staff. $192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Graffiti (Park Code 4.01(n))

Violation to possess, carry, use or keep graffiti, etching tools or slap tags.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Swimming Restrictions (Park Code 4.02)

No swimming in any lake, pond, pool, tank, fountain or reservoir in any park without permission.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Polluting Waters Prohibited (Park Code 4.03)

Violation to throw trash or other garbage objects into any pool, pond, tank or any fountain in any park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Littering and Dumping of Waste Matter Prohibited (Park Code 4.04)

State law prohibits littering or dumping of waste matter in any public park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Malicious Destruction of Property (Park Code 4.05)

State law probations malicious defacement, damage, or destruction of real or personal property.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Removal of Trees, Wood, Plants, Soil Prohibited (Park Code 4.06)

Violation to remove trees, wood, bush, turf, shrub, flower, plant, grass, soil, rock from any park without RPD permission.

$192

In addition to civil penalty in an amount necessary to reimburse RPD for the value of material removed and

labor to restore the material removed.

Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 84: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 64

Recreation and Park

Interference with Recreation and Park Department Employee Prohibited (Park Code 4.08)

Violation to interfere with an employee of the RPD, DPW or other authorized contractor while that person is engaged in construction, repair or caring for any portion of the park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Certain Acts Prohibited at Candlestick, Kezar (Park Code 4.09)

Violation to bring in vanned or bottled beverages to Candlestick Park Stadium, Kezar Stadium or Kezar Pavilion; violation to kick or throw objects into the three venues where an event is being held.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Alcoholic Beverage Consumption Prohibited (Park Code 4.10)

Violation to consume alcoholic beverages in parks across the City.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Disobey Regulations (Park Code 4.12D)

SFPD or RPD employees can order a person to stay out of or leave any park if that person is: consuming alcoholic beverages, usings drugs, doing an injurious act to any park or building, while disobeying rules of an athletic facility, heaving noise, boisterous, or rowdy, in violation of Sec 4.10 of the Park Code.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Refusal to Obey Lawful Order (Park Code Sec 4.13)

Violation to be unlawful for any person to refuse to obey the lawful order of a police officer or an employee of the RPD.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Fighting, Disturbing Peace, Offensive Words (Park Code 4.14)

State law prohibits unlawful fighting in public places, willful disturbance of others by loud and unreasonable noise, use of offensive words in a public place.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Intoxication by Alcohol or Drugs (Park Code 4.15)

State law prohibits any person in a public place who is under the influence of drugs, alcohol or other substances and endangers himself or others and interferes with the free use of a public way.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Minors, Parents and Guardians (Park Code 4.16)

Violation of a parent or guardian or a minor to allow such a minor to do any act or think in any park prohibited by the Code.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 85: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 65

Recreation and Park

Skateboard Safety Requirements (Park Code 4.17)

Violation to ride a skateboard in any facility owned or operated by the City and County without a helmet, elbow pads and knee pads.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Dogs, Cats, Horses Only Allowed (Park Code 5.01)

Violation to bring any animal other than horses, dogs and domestic cats in any park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Animals Prohibited in Certain Areas (Park Code 5.02)

No animals other than Police horses shall enter any building, the Zoo, the Arboretum, Japanese Tea Garden and Conservatory Valley, playground, sandbox, any body of water with the exception of guide dogs.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Cats Must be on Leash or in Transport Box (Park Code 5.03)

Violation to bring a domestic cat into a park unless it is on a leash or in a transport box.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Horses (Park Code 5.04)

Violation to lead, ride or let loose a horse in any park. $192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Vicious Animal Prohibited (Park Code 5.05)

Violation to keep or permit a noisy, vicious or dangerous animal in a park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Abandonment of Animals Prohibited (Park Code 5.06)

Violation to abandon any animal in any park. $192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Feeding Animals Prohibited (Park Code 5.07)

Violation to feed animals harmful substances; feed wild animals in the park; feed animals in the SF Zoo.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Disturbing Animals, Birds, Fish Prohibited (Park Code 5.08)

Violation to hunt, chase, shoot, trap, discharge or throw missiles at, harass, disturb, taunt, endanger, capture, injure, or destroy any animal in any park, including the bison paddock, and the San Francisco Zoological Gardens, or to permit any animal in such person's custody or control to do so

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 86: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 66

Recreation and Park

Keeping of Elephants (Park Code 5.09)

Violation to keep an elephant at the SF Zoo without permission from the City.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Vehicle Driving Stay on Paved Roadway (Park Code 6.01(a))

Violation to drive a vehicle in the park on anything except paved roads, driveways, highways, or unpaved roads with signs for use by vehicular traffic.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Driving Safely (Park Code 6.01(b))

Violation to operate a vehicle that is not in a careful manner or at a lawful rate of speed.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Vehicle Driving in Planted Area Access Road or Service Road (Park Code 6.01(c))

Violation to drive a vehicle on a planted area or on an access road or unpaved service road or firetrail in a park

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Parking on Grass/Dirt/Pedestrian Path (Park Code 6.01(d))

Violation to park a vehicle on a lawn, planted area, unimproved area, pedestrian, equestrian lane, access road, unpaved service road or fire trail to block access or exit from any right of way

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Automotive Repair or Washing in the Park (Park Code 6.01(e))

Violation to wash, grease, or repair any vehicle in any park except as repairs are necessary for the immediate removal of a damaged or disabled vehicle from the park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Parking in Wrong Direction (Park Code 6.01(f))

Violation to be parked anywhere in a park anywhere except on the extreme right side of raid and immediately adjacent to any curb or any planted portion of the park. Exceptions can be made by Rec and Park Commission.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Parking in Park 10pm - 6am (Park Code 6.01(g))

Violation to park a vehicle in any park, other than the Marina Green, between the hours of 10pm to 6am, with some exceptions.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 87: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 67

Recreation and Park

No Parking in Marina 10pm-6am OR No Permit Displayed (Park Code 6.01(h))

Violation to park a vehicle in the Marina Green between the hours of 10pm and 6am, with some exceptions.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Parking in Paid Lot for More Than 24 Hours (Park Code 6.01(i))

Violation in a park to remain parked in a parking lot which is open for public use and a fee is charged for a period of more than 24 hours after the expiration of the period for which a fee is charged.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

No Parking of Oversized Vehicles in Kezar Parking Lot (Park Code 6.01(j))

Violation to park an oversized vehicle in Kezar Parking Lot, unless allowed otherwise by permit.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Leaving a Disabled Vehicle in a Fee-Based Parking Lot (Park Code 6.01(k))

Violation to leave a disabled vehicle parked in a fee-based parking lot.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Parking of Customer's Vehicles in Golden Gate Park (Park Code 6.03)

Violation to operate a vehicle for a business operating in Golden Gate Park by anyone other than those who own or are employed by the business to park in Golden Gate Park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Certain Business Vehicles Prohibited from Golden Gate Park (Park Code 6.04)

Violation for any person who operates or is employed by a business which is located within one mile of Golden Gate Park within one mile of such business to park in Golden Gate Park with advertising matter on the vehicle.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Commercial Vehicles Prohibited (Park Code 6.05)

Violation to transport commercial goods except by the transverse road across Golden Gate Park, or upon Stanyan Street.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Page 88: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 68

Recreation and Park

Parking of Sightseeing Buses (Park Code 6.06)

Violation to park a sightseeing bus in Golden Gate Park without a permit from RPD, or in a designated parking area for sightseeing buses.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Funeral Procession Routes (Park Code 6.07)

No funeral process shall enter Golden Gate Park except by the transverse road across Golden Gate Park, upon Stanyan Street, or upon Main Drive from Stanyan Street entrance to the park to Kezar Drive.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Transportation of Residential or Commercial Garbage (Park Code 6.08)

Violation to transport residential or commercial garbage in any vehicle within the confines of any park.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Soliciting Passengers for Vehicles Prohibited (Park Code 6.09)

Violation to solicit passengers in any park without a permit from RPD.

$158 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Commercial Photography Prohibited (Park Code 7.12)

Violation to engage in commercial photography, filming or recording in any park without a permit.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Failure to Obtain Permits (Park Code 7.17)

Violation to not obtain permits for certain activities on park property.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Smoking and Using Tobacco Prohibited (Health Code 19(I)

Violation to smoke in a City park and recreational area.

Infraction: 1st offense- up to $100 2nd offense- up to $200 3rd offense- up to $500

(must be committed within a one-year period of first offense)

Infraction

Leash Law/Supervise in DPA (Health Code 41.12(a))

Violation to allow an animal other than a domestic cat to run at large within the City and County except in areas designated as animal exercise areas.

Late charge of $25 shall be assessed for failure to obtain a dog license, or renew an expired license. Late charges

shall be changed in addition to license fee. Yes

Yes

Page 89: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 69

Recreation and Park

Permits Required (Park Code 7.03)

Violation to perform following activities without a permit: (a) conduct or sponsor a parade; (b) conduct or sponsor an event where 50 or more people engage in petitioning; (c) solicit in the Music Concourse Area of Golden Gate Park; (d) sell books, newspapers, periodicals; (e) conduct a performance that has been publicized four hours or more in advance; (f) perform or produce a show or movie that has been publicized four hours or more in advance; (g) make a speech that has been publicized four hours or more in advance; (h) conduct or sponsor a religious event with 50 or more people; (i) conduct or sponsor a musical performance that has been publicized four hours or more, uses sound amplification equipment, involves a band or orchestra; (j) participate in a picnic, dance or other social gathering involving 20 or more people; (k) sell or provide food to people; (l) conduct or sponsor a marathon or race which with 25 or more people or interferes with normal flow of vehicular or pedestrian traffic; (m) conduct or sponsor an event that utilizes sound amplification equipment; (n) conduct or sponsor an exhibition; (o) conduct or sponsor an animal show; (p) conduct a wedding ceremony; (q) conduct or sponsor an art show; (r) operate an amusement park device; (s) sponsor an organized kite flying event; (t) station or erect a structure; (u) park in an area not normally used for parking vehicles in conjunction for an activity for which a permit is obtained.

$192 Infraction

Mis-

demeanor

Failure to Pick Up Animal Defecation (Health Code 40(a))

Violation to allow a dog to defecate on public property, or the private property of another unless the person immediately removes and properly disposes of the feces.

Infraction: 1st offense- up to $50 2nd offense- up to $100 3rd offense- up to $1,000 OR imprisonment in County Jail for a period of no more than 1 year, OR by fine and imprisonment.

Infraction

Dog License (Health Code 41.15)

Violation to own or keep a dog over the age of four months within the City without a current license.

Infraction:1st offense- $252nd offense- Misdemeanor, fine between $25-$2503rd offense- Misdemeanor, fine $50-$500 OR by imprisonment for a period not more than six months, OR both a fine and imprisonment.

Yes

Page 90: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 70

Recreation and Park

Dog Bite (Health Code 41.5.1(a)(1))

Violation for a dog to bite a person or an animal.

Sec 3912- Enforcement and Penalties Infraction: 1st offense - up to $100 2nd offense - up to $200 3rd offense - Misdemeanor, and up to $1,000 fine OR Administrative Fines: 1st offense- up to $50 2nd offense- up to $100 3rd offense- up to $500

Yes Yes

Dog Walking License Required (Health Code Article 39, Sec 3902)

Violation to walk four or more dogs at one time for consideration on Park Property without a permit.

$470 Yes Yes

Garbage Receptacles (Public Works Code Sec 170(a))

Violations carrying fines include not removing garbage receptacles from the sidewalk, street, or any public right-of-way (for businesses: immediately after the contents have been collected or immediately upon opening of a business premises; for residents: within 24 hours after placing the receptacles out for collection and after the receptacle has been collected).

$470 Yes Yes

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Litter Receptacles Permits (PWC 170(b))

Violations of securely locking cans, containers and receptacles placed for collection.

$470 Yes Yes

PWC Article 5.1: Placement and Maintenance of Litter Receptacles (PWC 173(c))

Violation to anyone operating a place of employment to maintain adjacent to the place of employment sufficient ashtrays or other receptacles for the disposal of cigarettes, cigars, and other combustible products used by employees and patrons who smoke.

$97 Yes Yes

Red Zone (Transportation Code 7.2.25)

Violation to park a vehicle in a red zone indicated by red paint on the curb at any time, except that vehicle may stop at a Stand with red curb if that class of vehicle is expressly authorized to stop at that Stand.

$55 Infraction

Page 91: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 71

Recreation and Park

Parking on Grades (Transportation Code 7.2.35)

Violation to park on a 3% or more grade or slope without setting the brakes and turning the wheels against the curb.

$82 Infraction

Towaway Outside Downtown (Transportation Code 7.2.41)

Violation to park on any street, alley or portion of a street or alley this is subject to a posted parking prohibition.

$82 Infraction

Prohibited Parking Restrictions (Transportation Code 7.2.42)

Violation to park on any street, alley or portion of a street or alley that is subject to a parking restriction described in Article 800 of Division II (32.6-32.6.37; 32.1.10)

$105 Infraction

Urination and Defecation (Municipal Police Code Sec 153)

Violation to deposit human urine or feces in a public or private property other than property designated or set aside for that purpose.

Between $50-$500 Infraction

Possession of Gambling Implements (Municipal Police Code Sec 293)

Violation to have in possession implements for playing any banking game.

Between $100 and $500 or imprisonment in County Jail

or by both fine and imprisonment

Mis-demeanor

Feeding Birds (Municipal Police Code 486)

Violation to feed any bird or wild animal in or on any sidewalk, street or highway in the City. It is unlawful to feed a red masked parakeet in any park in the City.

$105 Infraction

Page 92: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 72

Treasurer Tax Collector

TTX General Description

The Treasurer Tax Collector assesses fines under the Business and Tax Regulations Code related to violations by businesses to produce certain registration and financial information, maintain and produce records, as required, among others. Penalties increase cumulatively by 50% for each subsequent violation of the same provision by the same person within a three year period. The maximum penalty that may be imposed by administrative citation in a calendar year for each type of violation is $25,000. The Tax Collector may also assess enforcement costs, including attorney's fees. These costs do not count toward the $25,000 maximum.

Page 93: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

Penalty Type

Violation/ Code Section

Description Citation Amounts Admin Civil Criminal

Attachment: Municipal Fines Descriptions Page 73

Treasurer Tax Collector

Failure to:

Business and Tax Regulations Code

6.19-3

-obtain or post a Certificate of Authority to Collect 3rd-Party Taxes

$500 Yes

-obtain or post an Annual Business Registration Certificate

$100 Yes

-show proof of current Business Registration Certificate $100 Yes

-post a bond $500 Yes

-produce information requested by the Tax Collector within 30 days of mailing of such request

$100 Yes

-produce financial records requested by the Tax Collector $500 Yes

-retain financial records $500 Yes

-allow the Tax Collector to inspect financial records $500 Yes

-file a return, including filing a blank or incomplete return $500 Yes

-provide a Receipt to an Occupant as required $100 Yes

-cooperate with any City agency as required $500 Yes

-maintain RCE Records as required by Article 22 $500 Yes

-accurately report the dates and times that the Parking Station did not utilize RCE in monthly or quarterly Parking Tax statements as required by this Article and Article 22

$500 Yes

-use good faith efforts to repair non-functioning RCE $100 Yes

-certify conformance with the provisions of Article 22 concurrent with payment or remittance of Parking Taxes

$500 Yes

Operating a Parking Station without utilizing RCE or business practices and procedures as required

$500 Yes

Intentionally tampering with RCE, including but not limited to altering or deleting data gathered or maintained by RCE

$500 Yes

Substituting a Parking Ticket with a Discount Parking Ticket for the purposes of falsely reporting or falsely recording the amount of Rent collected from an Occupant

$500 Yes

Refusing to produce RCE Records timely when requested by the Tax Collector or other authorized agency as required under Sections 2223,2230 and 2236 of Article 22 or when requested under Section 6.4-1 and 6.5-1 of this Article

$500 Yes

Page 94: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 1

City Administrator

Minimum Wage Ordinance (AC Sec 12R) and Paid Sick Leave Ordinance (Admin Code Ch. 12W)

35 $106,903 42 $107,921 47 $70,037

The number of citations and dollar amount of citations in each fiscal year includes combined penalties for Minimum Wage s and Paid Sick Leave Ordinances

Prevailing Wage (AC 6.22(e)) 51 $129,025 69 $260,418 63 $208,746

Health Care Security Ordinance (Admin Code Ch. 14) 5 $147,932 26 $140,574 21 $141,953

Investigations of violations of the Health Care Security Ordinance and Health Care Access Ordinance can take multiple years to complete. Therefore cases initiated in one fiscal year, may not lead to assessed penalties in that year.

Health Care Accountability Ordinance (Admin Code Ch. 12Q) 0 $159,154 6 $10,687 8 $6,849

The number of citations and dollar amount of citations in each fiscal year includes combined penalties for violations of the Health Care Accountability Ordinance and the Minimum Compensation Ordinance (see description on the line below. Investigations of violations of the Health Care Security Ordinance and Health Care Access Ordinance can take multiple years to complete. Therefore cases iniitiated in one fiscal year, may not lead to assessed penalties for one or more fiscal years.

Minimum Comp (AC Sec 12P)

Fair Chance Ordinance (Police Code, Article 49; Admin Code Section 12T) 0 $0 N/A N/A N/A N/A

No actual penalties for violations of these ordinances have been assessed as of 1/1/2016. The Fair Chance Ordinance became operative on 8/13/2014. OLSE has received complaints of violations, and investigations are ongoing.

Family Friendly Workplace Ordinance (Admin Code Chapter 12Z)

0 $0 N/A N/A N/A N/A

No actual penalties for violations of these ordinances have been assessed as of 1/1/2016. The Family Friendly Workplace Ordinance became operative on 1/1/2014, and there was a one-year grace period before fees could be assessed for violation.

Formula Retail Employee Rights Ordinances (Police Code Art. 33F and 33G)

0 $0 N/A N/A N/A N/A No actual penalties for violations of these ordinances have been assessed as of 1/1/2016.

Entertainment Comm (Police Code Sections 1060.26(b) 1070.24(b) 15 $2,250 8 $950 76 $11,250

Page 95: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 2

Airport Violation of Traffic Rules (Rule 14, Section 4.1(A)) $143,643 $167,162 $157,199 Number of citations not known

Miscellaneous Tenant/Operator Violations (Rule 14, Various Sections)

868 $295,000 Airfield operators were not fined prior to FY 2014-15, only issued admonishments

Controller Minimum Wage (Admin Code Sec 12R.5 (b)) 1 $500 1 $500

Minimum Wage (Admin Code Sec 12R.5 (c) ) 1 $500 1 $500

Commuter Benefits Program (Environment Code Section 427) 8

No citation revenue collected in FY 14-15 because revenue was returned to appellants, as they were found not to be in violation.

Fire Code Section 3504.2 - Fire Watch 1 $1,000

Fire Code Section 901.8- Removal of Equipment 2 $2,000

Entertainment Regulations for Extended-Hours Premises (Police Code Section 1070) & Noise Abatement (Police Code Section 1060.12) Combined

2 $100 2 $400 These two violations are combined because that is how they are listed on the actual citation administered.

Planning Residential Unit Conversion and Demolition (Admin Code Ch 41a) 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0

Violation of General Advertising Sign Requirements (Planning Code Sec 610(b)(2)(b)

2 $245,067 1 $656,147 12 $17,500

Enforcement Against Violations (Planning Code Section 176) 84 $365,854 82 $123,919 70 $109,896 FAMIS Index Code 290034; Sub Object 61165

Permit Applications (Planning Code Section 355(a)(1))

It is considered as Code Violation monitoring; fee collected included in Code Enforcement (index code 290034-61165)

Building Inspection Electrical Code 81 $135,337 75 $136,488 163 $200,036 Plumbing/Mechanical Code 196 $81,458 191 $100,090 230 $136,158 Building Code 393 $343,363 336 $326,837 380 $406,645

Page 96: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 3

Public Health Health Code Article 5 (General Public Health) Article 6 Sec 290 (Garbage/Refuse) $156,133 $83,891 $78,793 Not known how many citations were issued Article 7 (Laundries) Article 8 (Food and Food Products) Article 11 (Nuisances) Article 11A (Bed Bugs) Article 12 (General Sanitation) Article 19 (Smoking) Article 19F (Enclosed Area Smoking) Article 19H (Tobacco Sales Permits) Article 19I (Smoking in City Parks) Article 19J (No Pharmacies Selling Tobacco Products)

Article 19K (No Tobacco Sales on City Property)

Article 19O (Smokeless Tobacco at Athletic Venues)

Article 21 (Hazardous Materials) 60 $177,272 38 $40,965 32 $208,567 Article 24 (CFC Recovery/ Recycling) Article 25 (Medical Waste) Article 26 (Lead Poisoning) Section 29.10 (Massage) 5 $5,250 7 $7,000 7 $6,000 Section 29.12 (Massage) 2 $1,000 3 $2,100 7 $9,250 Section 29.15 (Massage) 7 $6,500 5 $5,000 5 $3,250 Section 29.18 (Massage) 0 $0 12 $17,250 5 $5,000 Section 29.19 (Massage) 2 $3,500 0 $0 0 $0 Section 29.2 (Massage) 4 $1,600 5 $4,000 2 $400 Section 29.21 (Massage) 3 $11,250 0 $0 0 $0 Section 29.25 (Massage) 0 $0 1 $750 0 $0 Section 29.9 (Massage) 2 $2,000 0 $0 0 $0 Article 30 (Diesel Back-up Generators)

Article 33 (Medical Marijuana) Article 40 (Body Art)

Page 97: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 4

Public Works Community Preservation and Blight Reduction Act (Administrative Code 80.3(b) & 80.4(b))

1,113 $65,234 483 $96,637 546 $102,599

DPW Enforced Provisions of the Health Code

1,202 $92,369 805 $12,763 311 $10,227 Citation amount includes sum of MHC 280, 283, 291.1, 291.2, 581

DPW Enforced Provisions of the Police Code

257 $24,559 274 $8,425 125 $7,568 Citation amount includes sum of MPC: MPC 33, MPC 34, MPC 35A, MPC 63A

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Litter Receptacles (PWC 170(a))

315 $21,422 49 $2,538 77 $5,655

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Litter Receptacles Permits (PWC 170(b))

3

1 $50 3 $250

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Liter Receptacles (PWC 173(b))

4 $600

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Liter Receptacles (PWC 173 (e))

1 $100

PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Liter Receptacles (PWC 174)

51 $6,032 74 $2,491 25 $1,975

PWC Article 5.2: Tables and Chairs in Public Sidewalk or Roadway Areas (PWC 176)

3 - 2 - 4 -

PWC Article 5.3: Display of Fruits and Vegetables or Non-food Merchandise on Public Sidewalks (PWC 183)

14 - 23 - 16 -

PWC Article 5.4: Regulation of Newsracks (PWC 184.8)

- 2 $150

-

PWC Article 5.6: Posting of Signs on City-Owned Lamp Posts or Utility Poles (PWC 184.57-184.63)

11 $420 1 $100 2 $150

PWC Article 5.7 Handbill Distribution (PWC Section 184.70 (b) and (c))

- 1 -

-

PWC Article 5.8: Permit Regulations for Mobile Food Facilities Concerning Products for Human Consumption (PWC 184.98)

- 4 -

- Citations for 184.98 (c) and 184.98 (e)

PWC Article 15: Miscellaneous (PWC 708.1)

-

-

- No issued/paid

Obstruction of Street (PWC Section 723)

- 1 -

-

Page 98: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 5

Public Works Temporary occupancy of street (PWC Section 724)

148 120 95 Citations for 724(a)(1),(2),(3),' 724.3(a),(b),(c); 724.4(a); 724.5; 724.6; 724.7(e)

Debris Boxes (PWC Section 725) 19 5

Citations for 725.3, 725.6 Mobile storage containers (PWC Section 726)

2 2 Citations for 726.1(b), 726.2(a), 726.6(a), 726.6(d)

PWC Article 15: Miscellaneous (PWC 735)

PWC Article 16: Urban Forestry Ordinance (PWC 808)

1 $100

Excavation in the Public Right of Way (PWC Section 2.4)

48 50 61

Debris Box Companies Operating in CCSF (DPW Order 175,512)

5 4 20

Tables and Chairs in Public Sidewalk or Roadway Areas (DPW Order 162,240)

12 20 75 Citations for #162,240 II.C.2, II.C.4, III.A, III.B, III.C, III.D, III.G, III.H10, III.H12, III.H3, III.H4, III.H7, IVA

Sidewalk Display Merchandise (DPW Order 166,458)

43 82 27 Citations for #166,458 II.D, III.C, III.D, III.E, IV.A, IV.B, IV.D, IV.H,V.B

Ethics SF Campaign & Governmental Conduct Code

16 $35,950 6 $24,500 7 $10,380

Fire Fire Code 2013, Section 109 8 $8,000 3 $3,000

Library Library Fines (Admin Code Sec 8.21-2(a, c))

584,788 $458,464 591,200 $509,762 615,692 $599,552

MTA

Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.H.2 148 $6,853 148 $7,018

The Golden Gate Bridge Code separates penalties for violations that occur on SF properties and Marin properties. The citation amounts are for SF violations only.

Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.H.3 177 $5,310 248 $7,816

Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.H.4.J 4 $947

No Permit or Expired Parking (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6A)

136 $7,105 104 $4,807

Prohibited/Restricted Parking (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6B)

136 $8,990 31 $2,085

Page 99: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 6

MTA Parked in Excess of 24 Hours (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6C)

Parked in Handicapped Parking Area or Blocking Handicapped Access (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6D)

4 $670 5 $1786

Abandoned Vehicle (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6E)

Blocking or Parked in Intersection (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6F)

1

Parked in Safety/Red Zone (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6G)

13 $960 5 $454

Parked in a Yellow Zone (Golden Gate Bridge Code Go1.I.6H)

Parked in White Zone (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6I)

5 $388 2 $194

Parked in Crosswalk (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6J)

1 $208

Blocking Public/Private Driveway (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6K)

Parked on or Blocking Sidewalk (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6L)

Obstructing Traffic (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6M)

1 $107

Double Parked (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6N)

3 $214

Parked in a Bus Stop (Golden Gate Bridge Code GO1.I.6O)

26 $4548 17 $2842

Parked in Posted No Parking Area (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6P)

Parked in Posted Preferential Parking Area (Golden Gate Bridge Code G01.I.6Q)

Motor Vehicle Alarm System (Municipal Police Code Sec 3703)

19 $1004 27 $1506 26 $1390

Page 100: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 7

MTA Limitations on Audible Alarm Systems (Municipal Police Code Sec 3704)

9 $535 13 $874 17 $1,157

Parking Limited Areas including Sunday (Harbor Code 20.1)

1 $0

The SFMTA has issued citations under the Harbor Traffic Code. However this spreadsheet does not include all Harbor Code Traffic violations.

Parking Prohibited (Harbor Code 22)

11 $190 8 $138

Specific Parking Regulations (Harbor Code 24B)

5 $115 1 $23 1 $0

Reserved Parking Spaces: Parking Prohibited in Zones Marked for Restricted Parking (Harbor Code 25)

9 $229 17 $373 35 $928

Stopping Prohibited on The Embarcadero (Harbor Code 34)

1 $0

No Violation 658 $2,258 1,050 $5,680 1,021 $7,453 Signs to be Obeyed (PK3.02) 112 $3,384 67 $4,716 53 $1,471 Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01A)

3 $127

2 $46

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01C)

11 $307 6 $115 2 $23

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01D)

307 $7,717 418 $11,623 297 $9,441

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01E)

3 $180

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01F)

5 $92 9 $166

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01G)

1,162 $31,821 1,102 $33,776 1,122 $34,266

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01H)

1,222 $31,405 918 $26,723 141 $4,476

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01I)

1 $23 2 $46 1 $23

Parking of Customer's Vehicles in Golden Gate Park (PK6.03)

Certain Business Vehicles Not in Golden Gate Park (PK6.04)

Commercial Vehicles Prohibited (PK6.05)

14 $313 3 $110

Page 101: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 8

MTA Parking of Sightseeing Buses (PK6.06)

12 $298 20 $508 23 $626

Park Code 6.06.2 3 $48 This code number does not exist in the Park Code. May have been issued in error.

Permits Required (PK7.03U) 193 $6,485 161 $5,416 102 $3,535 Parking Restrictions on SFMTA Property (TRC Sec 1009)

22 $1,264 614 $43,958 389 $27,157

Pedestrian Crossings (TRC7.2.10) 4 $169 3 $202 Bicycle Riding Restricted (TRC7.2.12)

2 $0

Non-motorized user-propelled vehicles (NUV) (TRC7.2.13)

1 $0

Residential/Carpool Parking (TRC7.2.20)

164,003 $12,137,968 141,984 $11,121,271 155,640 $11,959,155

Street Cleaning Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.22)

520,655 $33,138,323 504,927 $34,110,552 509,885 $33,785,146

Payment of Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23A)

91,688 $6,600,797 106,364 $8,083,875 125,863 $9,341,742

Payment of Parking Meter - Outside of Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23B)

174,306 $11,307,023 215,856 $14,782,359 248,737 $16,597,502

Curb Parking - Red Zones (TRC7.2.25)

12,997 $1,238,029 12,294 $1,227,238 13,160 $1,276,866

Curb Parking - Yellow Zones (TRC7.2.26)

27,901 $2,230,489 20,725 $1,768,091 30,953 $2,582,510

Curb Parking - White Zones (TRC7.2.27)

8,128 $746,364 7,605 $738,257 8,660 $819,292

Curb Parking - Green Zones (TRC7.2.28)

929 $66,707 846 $64,972 936 $70,689

Parking Prohibited for more than 72 Hours (TRC7.2.29)

1,718 $120,771 1,157 $87,493 1,217 $92,233

Overtime Parking- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30A)

5,538 $382,818 4,983 $387,751 6,024 $451,570

Overtime Parking - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30B)

17,363 $1,123,009 17,505 $1,214,366 18,916 $1,285,567

Overtime Meter Parking- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30C)

757 $55,001

Overtime Meter Parking - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30D)

1,020 $64,400

Perpendicular Parking (TRC7.2.32) 1,640 $96,166 1,442 $90,842 1,409 $89,979

Page 102: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 9

MTA Blocking Residential Door (TRC7.2.33)

$1 $46

Parking Adjacent to or on Median Dividers or Traffic Islands (TRC7.2.34)

$1,932 $142,651 $1,372 $104,869 $1,897 $142,177

Parking on Grades (TRC7.2.35) $44,857 $2,600,851 $45,467 $2,778,061 $62,987 $3,822,381 Parking Oversized vehicles within 100 feet of an Intersection (TRC7.2.36)

$19 $1,876 $15 $1,606 $21 $956

Motorcycle Parking (TRC7.2.37) $535 $49,534 $421 $42,579 $571 $54,100 Parking in Stands (TRC7.2.38) $2,767 $249,561 $1,555 $151,122 $1,562 $150,350 Parking Within Transit-Only Lanes (TRC7.2.39)

$75 $7,130 $19 $1,920

Parking Prohibition- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.40)

$32,643 $2,921,603 $29,352 $2,761,388 $27,075 $2,505,286

Parking Prohibition - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.41)

$22,167 $1,770,631 $22,166 $1,872,314 $17,124 $1,424,864

Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.42) $2,479 $169,548 $1,803 $141,962 $14,697 $1,175,173 Parking on Public Property (TRC7.2.43)

$2,076 $124,470 $2,379 $164,833 $1,892 $123,174

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44A)

$573 $307,598 $389 $219,654 $1 $0

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44B)

$893 $577,864 $715 $527,453

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44C)

$32 $23,915 $18 $12,386

Diverting of Traffic and Temporary Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.45)

$3,285 $198,556 $3,220 $208,465 $3,990 $252,424

Page 103: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 10

MTA Temporary Parking and Traffic Restrictions (TRC7.2.46)

3,634 $228,911 3,014 $202,732 2,812 $184,728

Removal of Chalk Marks (TRC7.2.47) 19 $1,666 13 $1,453 25 $2,523 Construction or Repairing of Vehicles (TRC7.2.48)

1 $0 1 $183

Displaying Permit on Other Vehicles (TRC7.2.49)

148 $13,010 214 $19,315 292 $28,357

Displaying Fraudulent Parking Permit or Submitting False, Misleading or Fraudulent Information on a Residential Parking Permit Application (TRC7.2.50)

33 $3,238 11 $1,134

Parking within Parking Space (TRC7.2.51)

3,012 $174,353 3,396 $211,860 4,027 $244,730

Car Share Vehicle Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.52)

102 $10,109 60 $6,395 1 $110

Large Vehicle Parkings Restrictions (TRC7.2.54)

89 $5,930 296 $19,930

Payment of Parking Facility Charges; Proof of Payment (TRC7.2.60)

3,399 $204,579 5,222 $333,731 6,270 $393,390

Use of Entrance and Exit of Municipal Parking Facility (TRC7.2.61)

1 $0

Blocking Parking Spaces (TRC7.2.62) 56 $3,159 44 $2,170 19 $1,107 Blocking an Electric Charging Bay (TRC7.2.64)

13 $1,265

Overtime Parking (TRC7.2.65) 69 $3,948 12 $696 103 $5,559 Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66A)

25 $17,687 29 $20,219

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66B)

107 $73,922 112 $78,601

Page 104: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 11

MTA Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions TRC7.2.66C

4 $1,760 4 $1,760

Obstructing Traffic - Vehicle (TRC7.2.70)

2,350 $215,358 1,246 $120,837 430 $45,119

Obstructing Traffic-without Permit; Violation of Terms of Permit; Violation of Division II, Section 903 (TRC7.2.71)

1 $0

Driving in a Transit-Only Area (TRC7.2.72)

5 $404 2 $198

Driving Through Parades (TRC7.2.73)

Streetcar Right-of-Way- Vehicles Prohibited (TRC7.2.74)

1 $100

Passing Safety Zones (TRC7.2.75) 1 $128

TRC7.2.76 1 $100 According to MTA, "Reserved" means they are working on a new code. The ticket issued under this code was most likely a mistake.

Weight Restricted Streets (TRC7.2.77)

1 $166

Parking or Driving of Vehicles in Port Area (TRC7.2.78)

MTA is not aware of violation amount. No citations have been issued under this code in the past three fiscal years.

Vehicles for Hire and Taxis; Parking Prohibited in Certain Use Districts (TRC7.2.80)

59 $5,321 281 $28,245 333 $35,667

Parking of Vehicles for Commercial Advertising Purposes (TRC7.2.81)

58 $6,697 18 $1,430 10 $934

Selling from a Vehicle Restricted (TRC7.2.82)

3 $0

Truck Loading Zone (TRC7.2.83) 12,647 $1,033,851 8,274 $705,880 12,183 $1,014,307 Commercial Vehicle Parking in Certain Districts (TRC7.2.84)

128 $11,870 120 $11,884 128 $11,885

Idling Engine While Parked (TRC7.2.86)

41 $4,162 10 $1,028 7 $764

Page 105: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 12

MTA On Street Sales Restrictions (TRC7.2.88)

99 $3,437 145 $4,080 244 $7,517

Tour Narration by Bus Drivers (TRC7.2.89)

MTA is not aware of violation amount, although one citation has been issued under this code in the past three fiscal years.

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC 7.2.101)

28 $1,187 434 $12,900 42,307 $1,273,332

According to SFMTA, citations used to be issued under this general code provision, and then officers were later trained to cite more specifically, i.e. adding a-f to the Section and proceeding to issue tickets under the more specific code violations.

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101A)

69 $3,224 2,756 $87,073 3,692 $125,118

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101B)

37 $1,305 1,388 $54,737 337 $7,512

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101C)

42,694 $1,041,570 47,840 $1,285,486 3,635 $104,443

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101D)

49 $2,310 1,570 $84,634 57 $2,931

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101E)

12 $545 32 $2,124 20 $1,057

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101F)

11 $218 43 $1,664 21 $412

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102)

13 $0 56 $1,352 368 $9,801

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102A)

18 $356 12 $668 12 $588

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102B)

25 $327 50 $2,110 18 $758

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102C)

1 $109 4 $0 1 $0

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102D)

104 $1,919 161 $4,609 85 $2,298

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102E)

2 $0 3 $0 3 $0

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102F)

4 $0 3 $172

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102G)

1 $0 4 $103

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102H)

1 $0 3 $0 2 $103

Page 106: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 13

MTA Conversing with Operating

Personnel Prohibited (TRC7.2.103) 1 $0

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC 2.104) 13 $760 394 $24,926 15,203 $968,218

According to SFMTA, citations used to be issued under this general code provision, and then officers

were later trained to cite more specifically, i.e. adding a-d to the Section and proceeding to issue

tickets under the more specific code violations. Clipper Card Regulations

(TRC7.2.104A) 1,109 $58,855 2,665 $170,731 1,693 $113,229 Clipper Card Regulations

(TRC7.2.104B) 10,014 $652,581 12,619 $877,846 1,673 $110,147 Clipper Card Regulations

(TRC7.2.104C) 8 $494 177 $11,606 89 $4,914 Clipper Card Regulations

(TRC7.2.104D) 1,576 $76,267 1,026 $48,247 433 $13,796 Obstructing Traffic (TRC7.3.3) 11 $8,143

Economic & Workforce Development

Local Hiring Policy for Construction (Admin Code Chapter 6.22(g)) 4 $4,987 1 $1,356

Police Police Emergency Alarm Ordinance (Police Code Section 3714) $77,279 $81,702 $110,456

Port

The Port tracks the number of citations issued by code violation, but not the actual citation revenue collected by code violation. They only have this information in aggregate listed below. FY 2012-13 - $2,747,250 FY 2013-14- $2,875,719 FY 2014-15- $3,495,068

Parking Prohibited (Harbor Code 22) 1

Specific Parking Regulations (Harbor Code 24B) 3

Reserved Parking Spaces: Parking Prohibited in Zones Marked for Restricted Parking (Harbor Code 25)

16 26

Signs to be Obeyed (PK3.02) 6

Page 107: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 14

Port Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01D) 1 2

Operation and Parking of Vehicles (PK6.01G) 2 9

Permits Required (PK7.03U) 1 1 21 Payment of Parking Meter (TRC7.2.23) 13,629

Payment of Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23A) 4,092 11,967

Motorcycle Parking (TRC7.2.37) 38 2 7 Motorcycle Parking (TRC7.2.37) 90 Residential/Carpool Parking (TRC7.2.20) 284 134 420

Perpendicular or Angled Parking (TRC7.2.32) 1

Payment of Parking Facility Charges; Proof of Payment (TRC7.2.60) 4 19 36

Parking within Parking Space (TRC7.2.51) 1

Parking Prohibition- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.40) 1,109 1 872

Parking Prohibition - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.41) 1,383 1 378

Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.42) 9 866 Overtime Parking- Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30A) 721 261 677

Overtime Parking - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30B) 1,318 437 1,990

Overtime Parking at a Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30C)

24

Overtime Parking at a Parking Meter - Outside Downtown Core (TRC7.2.30D)

28

Temporary Parking and Traffic Restrictions (TRC7.2.46) 23 9 14

Page 108: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 15

Port Truck Loading Zone (TRC7.2.83) 335 59 88 Diverting of Traffic and Temporary Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.45) 63 16 70

Parking Prohibited for more than 72 Hours (TRC7.2.29) 8 2

Street Cleaning Parking Restrictions (TRC7.2.22) 3,474 736 3,625

Curb Parking - Red Zones (TRC7.2.25) 321 113 290

Curb Parking - Yellow Zones (TRC7.2.26) 45 112

Curb Parking - Yellow Zones (TRC7.2.26) 270 234

Curb Parking - White Zones (TRC7.2.27) 218 46 195

Curb Parking - Green Zones (TRC7.2.28) 1

Parking in Stands (TRC7.2.38) 143 38 22 Parking Adjacent to or on Median Dividers or Traffic Islands (TRC7.2.34)

1 4

Parking on Grades (TRC7.2.35) 6 5 31 Parking within Parking Space (TRC7.2.51) 469 110 1,190

Idling Engine While Parked (TRC7.2.86) 4 1 2

Parking Oversized vehicles within 100 feet of an Intersection (TRC7.2.36)

2 2

Obstructing Traffic - Vehicle (TRC7.2.70) 79 7 36

Perpendicular or Angled Parking (TRC7.2.32) 680 157 663

Parking in Stands (TRC7.2.38) 22 Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC 7.2.101) 63

Passenger Conduct Regulations (TRC7.2.102B) 1

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104A) 1

Page 109: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 16

Port Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104B) 21

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104D) 2

Parking Restrictions on SFMTA Property (TRC Sec 1009) 1 3

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC 2.104) 62 8

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC 7.2.101) 1

Fare Evasion Regulations (TRC7.2.101C) 28

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104A) 9

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104B) 25

Clipper Card Regulations (TRC7.2.104D) 3

Payment of Parking Meter - Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23A) 16,753

Payment of Parking Meter - Outside of Downtown Core (TRC7.2.23B) 16,976 3,772

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44A)

31 12

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44B)

12 8

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Plate Restrictions (TRC7.2.44C)

1

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66A)

1

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66B)

2

Disabled Parking Placard TRC7.2.66C 1

Page 110: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 17

Port Overtime Parking (TRC7.2.65) 2 Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66A)

2

Disabled Parking Placard and Special License Restrictions (TRC7.2.66B)

10

Parking of Vehicles for Commercial Advertising Purposes (TRC7.2.81) 5

Obstructing Traffic (TRC7.3.3) 2 Failure to Display Receipt TRC 7.2.1 Parking Meter (Downtown) TRC 7.2.2 26,141

Parking Meter (Outside of Downtown)TRC 7.2.3 2,226

Parking Prohibited (Outside of Downtown) TRC 7.2.4 2,170

Parked Not within Space TRC 7.2.5 713 TRC 7.2.6 22 Obstructing Traffic TRC 7.2.7 49 Stopped in a Truck Loading Zone TRC 7.2.8 184

Municpal Police Code 710.2 1 T38D 1 T32.12 2 Signs to by Obeyed (Port Code Sec 2.2)

Athletic Activities Prohibited in Certain Areas (Port Code Sec 2.4)

Restrictions on Posting of Signs (Port Code Sec 2.5)

Personal Services (Port Code Sec 2.6)

Airplanes, Helicopters, Hot Air Balloons, Prohibited (Port Code Sec 2.7)

Peddling and Vending Merchandise (Port Code Sec 2.8)

Page 111: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 18

Port Camping Prohibited (PC Sec 2.9) Sleeping Prohibited During Certain Hours (Sec 2.10)

Performance of Labor (PC Sec 2.11) Building Materials (Port Code Sec 2.12)

Ground Restored to Condition (Port Code Sec 2.13)

Warning Signals at Dangerous Points (Port Code Sec 2.14)

Disorderly Conduct (PC Sec 3.1) Swimming Restrictions (Port Code Sec 3.2)

Polluting Waters Prohibited (Port Code Sec 3.3)

Removal of Trees, Wood, Etc (Port Code Sec 3.6)

Interference with Port Commission and Park Employees (Park Code 3.8)

Alcoholic Beverages (Port Code Sec 3.9)

Refusal to Obey Lawful Order (Port Code Sec 3.12)

Minors, Parents and Guardians of (Port Code Sec 3.15)

Dogs, Cats Only Allowed (Port Code Sec 4.1)

Animals Prohibited from Certain Areas (Port Code Sec 4.2)

Cats on Leash or in Transport Box (Port Code Sec 4.3)

Vicious Animals Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.4)

Abandonment of Animals Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.5)

Feeding Animals Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.6)

Disturbing Animals, Birds, Fish Prohibited (Port Code Sec 4.7)

Page 112: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 19

PUC Excess Water Use Charges (Irrigation Customers) 8 $135,814 N/A N/A N/A N/A

Late Payment Penalty

Recreation and Park

RPD only reported the fines assessed due to code violations, but not the actual amount of citation revenue collected. Note: RPD is missing data from September 2013-December 2013, so FY 2013-14 data is not entirely accurate.

Signs to be Obeyed (PC 3.02) 60 $11,520 3 $576 29 Athletic Activities Prohibited in Certain Areas (Park Code 3.05)

Launching Boats Prohibited (PC 3.06)

Restrictions on Posting Signs (PC 3.07) 3 $576 1 $192

Personal Services (PC 3.08) Airplanes, Helicopters, Hot Air Balloons etc Prohibited (PC 3.09) 0 0

Peddling Vending Merchandise Prohibited/Require Permit (PC 3.10) 26 $4,992 1 $192 23

Camping Prohibited (PC 3.12) 1,332 $255,168 225 $42,714 182 Sleeping in Park Ground Prohibited 8pm-8am (PC 3.13) 495 $98,848 124 $23,403 304

Performance of Labor Prohibited (PC 3.14) 6 $1,152 0

Building Materials (PC 3.15) Hours of Operation (PC 3.21) 167 $32,064 9 $1,728 Throwing Objects in a Dangerous Nature (Park Code 4.01(a)) 2 $384 0

Weapons (Park Code 4.01(b)) Firecracker or Fireworks Prohibited (Park Code 4.01(c)) 4 $768 0 8

Make, Kindle, Maintaining a Fire Prohibited in the Park (Park Code 4.01(e))

30 $5,760 1 $192 5

No Climbing or Lying on Trees, Shrubs, Walls, Structures, etc (Park Code 4.01(f))

19 $3,648 1 $384 1

Page 113: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 20

Recreation and Park No Emission, Ejection or Excretion of Human Waste (Park Code 4.01(g))

54 $10,368 10 $1,920 5

No exposure of genitals, pubic hair, buttocks, perineum (Park Code 4.01(h))

5 $960 1 $192

Entering Opposite Sex Restroom Prohibited (Park Code 4.01(i)) 1 $192 1 $192

Gain or Attempt Entry to Facility of Park Without Paying (Park Code 4.01(j))

9 $1,728 0

Play Percussion Instrument (Park Code 4.01(k))

Entering into an Animal Enclosure at the SF Zoo (Park Code 4.01(l))

Rules of SF Zoo (Park Code 4.01(m)) Graffiti (Park Code 4.01(n)) Swimming Restrictions (Park Code 4.02) 1 $192 0 1

Polluting Waters Prohibited (Park Code 4.03)

Littering and Dumping of Waste Matter Prohibited (Park Code 4.04) 3 $576 1 $192 3

Malicious Destruction of Property (Park Code 4.05) 24 $4,608 1 $192 2

Removal of Trees, Wood, Plants, Soil Prohibited (Park Code 4.06) 4 $768 0 2

Interference with Recreation and Park Department Employee Prohibited (Park Code 4.08)

13 $2,496 2 $384 1

Certain Acts Prohibited at Candlestick, Kezar (Park Code 4.09)

Alcoholic Beverage Consumption Prohibited (Park Code 4.10) 121 $23,232 8 $1,536 22

Disobey Regulations (Park Code 4.12D)

Refusal to Obey Lawful Order (Park Code Sec 4.13) 6 $1,152 1 $192 1

Page 114: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 21

Recreation and Park Fighting, Disturbing Peace, Offensive Words (Park Code 4.14) 2 $576 0

Intoxication by Alcohol or Drugs (Park Code 4.15) 9 $1,536 2 $384 2

Minors, Parents and Guardians (Park Code 4.16)

Skateboard Safety Requirements (Park Code 4.17)

Dogs, Cats, Horses Only Allowed (Park Code 5.01)

Animals Prohibited in Certain Areas (Park Code 5.02) 5 $960 0

Cats Must be on Leash or in Transport Box (Park Code 5.03)

Horses (Park Code 5.04) Vicious Animal Prohibited (Park Code 5.05)

Abandonment of Animals Prohibited (Park Code 5.06)

Feeding Animals Prohibited (Park Code 5.07) 1 $192 0

Disturbing Animals, Birds, Fish Prohibited (Park Code 5.08) 4 0

Keeping of Elephants (Park Code 5.09)

Vehicle Driving Stay on Paved Roadway (Park Code 6.01(a)) 5 $960 0

Driving Safely (Park Code 6.01(b)) No Vehicle Driving in Planted Area Access Road or Service Road (Park Code 6.01(c))

4 $768 3 $576

No Parking on Grass/Dirt/Pedestrian Path (Park Code 6.01(d))

5 $115 0

No Automotive Repair or Washing in the Park (Park Code 6.01(e)) 0 1 $23 1

Parking in Wrong Direction (Park Code 6.01(f)) 0 0

No Parking in Park 10pm - 6am (Park Code 6.01(g)) 11 $259 0

Page 115: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 22

Recreation and Park No Parking in Marina 10pm-6am OR No Permit Displayed (Park Code 6.01(h))

52 $1,221 0

No Parking in Paid Lot for More Than 24 Hours (Park Code 6.01(i))

No Parking of Oversized Vehicles in Kezar Parking Lot (Park Code 6.01(j))

Leaving a Disabled Vehicle in a Fee-Based Parking Lot (Park Code 6.01(k))

Parking of Customer's Vehicles in Golden Gate Park (Park Code 6.03)

Certain Business Vehicles Prohibited from Golden Gate Park (Park Code 6.04)

Commercial Vehicles Prohibited (Park Code 6.05)

Parking of Sightseeing Buses (Park Code 6.06)

Funeral Procession Routes (Park Code 6.07)

Transportation of Residential or Commercial Garbage (Park Code 6.08)

Soliciting Passengers for Vehicles Prohibited (Park Code 6.09)

Permits Required (Park Code 7.03) 44 $8,448 6 $957 12 Combined individual 7.03 violations (a-u) Commercial Photography Prohibited (Park Code 7.12) 1 $192 0 1

Failure to Obtain Permits (Park Code 7.17) 13 $2,496 4 $765 1

Smoking and Using Tobacco Prohibited (Health Code 19(I) 135 $25,728 7 $1,344 25

Failure to Pick Up Animal Defecation (Health Code 40(a)) 3 $1,410 0 2

Leash Law/Supervise in DPA (Health Code 41.12(a)) 125 $15,048 3 $357 14

Dog License (Health Code 41.15) 2 $238 0 Dog Bite (Health Code 41.5.1(a)(1)) 0 0 1

Page 116: BUDGET AND LEGISLATIVE ANALYST · City Planning $127,396 0.13% $780,066 0.84% $610,921 0.69% Controller4 $400 0.00%$2,100 $3,000 Courts N/A ‐ N/A ‐ N/A ‐ District Attorney N/A

FY 2014-15 Citations FY 2013-14 Citations FY 2012-13 Citations Department and Violation Number Amount Number Amount Number Amount Notes

Attachment: Municipal Fines Citations Page 23

Recreation and Park Dog Walking License Required (Health Code Article 39, Sec 3902) 11 $2,112 0 Garbage Receptacles (Public Works Code Sec 170(a)) PWC Article 5.1: Anti-Litter Receptacles Permits (PWC 170(b))

PWC Article 5.1: Placement and Maintenance of Litter Receptacles (PWC 173(c))

Red Zone (Transportation Code 7.2.25) 11 $1,100 0

Parking on Grades (Transportation Code 7.2.35) $58 1

Towaway Outside Downtown (Transportation Code 7.2.41) 2 $170 0

Prohibited Parking Restrictions (Transportation Code 7.2.42) 0 0

Urination and Defecation (Municipal Police Code Sec 153) 1

Possession of Gambling Implements Prohibited (Municipal Police Code Sec 293)

Feeding Birds (Municipal Police Code 486) 1 $105 0

TTX General Description Business and Tax Regulations Code

6.19-3 No citation or revenue information available