brian kane, musicophobia

Upload: kanebri

Post on 18-Oct-2015

26 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

A critique of some recent theories of sound art.

TRANSCRIPT

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    1/20

    ! " # $ % & ' ( & ) $ * + & - # & " . /! " # $ % & ' ( & ) $ * + & - # & " . /* - 0 * . / 0 ( 1 / 1 ! * . / # & 2 * - 0* - 0 * . / 0 ( 1 / 1 ! * . / # & 2 * - 0

    0 ( 1 & - 30 ( 1 & - 3) - $ * . 4 * . 1) - $ * . 4 * . 1

    !"#$ %&'($ )"*+*,-' ./$ 0"# 1232 4&5$#5 )5*'#6 *0 .(- 0"# 7*5-0 0*8# *$ 0"# (.(59:- "*-0/5;

    0"(0 *0 .#$0 0/ ( -/&$9 (50*-0< 4"# 8#5# 7(=0 /7 )"*+*,':- >*=0/5; /70#$ />#5-"(9/.#9 =5*0*=(+(--#--8#$0 /7!"#$%&'()"#5 .*$$*$? ,*#=#< @0 .(- (- *7 "#5 >*=0/5; .#5# $/0 -*8,+; "#5 /.$6

    A&0 ( >*=0/5; 7/5 -/&$9 (50 (+0/?#0"#5< B5*0(*$:- C"($$#+ D C&+0&5# E9*0/56 F(00"#. C(*$6

    .5/0#6 G4"# "*?"H,5/7*+# .*$ 7/5 %&-($ )"*+*,-' 8*?"0 I&-0 A&*+9 0"*- &, 0/ 0"# 0*,,*$? ,/*$0

    $##9#9 7/5 -/&$9 (50 0/ 5#(++; 0(J# /77#$ 0"/-# =5*0*=(+ /7 )"*+*,-':- ./5J6 $/0#9 0"#

    -"*70 /7 (00#$0*/$ 75/8 "#5 ./5J 0/ "#5 7*#+9< G@7 .# .($0#9 0/ A# -+*?"0+; 7(=#0*/&-6K .5/0#

    =5*0*= F*="(#+ L+/>#56 G.# =/&+9 =(++ *0 "*-0/5; *$ 0"# 8(J*$?< %/&$9 (50*-0- (5# /$ 0"# 8(5="M

    N#>#5 A#7/5# *$ 0"# 1OH;#(5 "*-0/5; /7 0"# 4&5$#5 )5*'# "(- *0 A##$ ./$ A; ($ (50*-0 ."/ "(9

    $/0"*$? 0/ -"/. 7/5 "#5 P1Q6222 ,5*'# 8/$#; A&0 -/&$9- 7(A5*=(0#9 A; "#5 /.$ >/*=#*$9*=(0*/$ 7/5 -/&$9 (50 (+0/?#0"#5R G4"5## ="##5- 7/5 -/&$9 (50*-0-< B&0 $/0 0"*- /$##5

    $/$="(+($0+; .5/0#6 G%/&$9 (50 *- $/0"*$? $#.6 /7 =/&5-#6K /77#5*$? ( ,/00#9 "*-0/5;R

    .&.#$015&-6 7 *-0$%81 7 $##"1 9:; 0(1 !"#$% $##"1

    !"#$%&'(&)$*+ &- #&"./ *-0 *./ 0(1 /1!*./# &2 *-0 0(1&-3

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    2/20

    4"#/ >($ U/#-A&5? .(- ( ,*/$##5< V&50 %=".*00#5- 8(9# 8(5>#+/&- -/&$9 (50 *$

    0"# 3W12- ($9 3WX2-Y "*- >/*=# -=&+,0- ($9 -.//,- 0"5/&?" 0"# (*5 +*J# ( A*,+($#

    /&0 /7 =/$05/+< Z0 /$# 8/8#$0 *0 -/&$9- +*J# ( A*596 ($9 0"#$6 8/8#$0- +(0#56 +*J#

    0"# 5*-*$? $/0#- /7 ( 5#>>*$? =(5< E9*0" %*0.#++ .(- (0 *0 0// .*0" "#5 7+&0; >/*=#< Z-

    .(- Z++#$ L*$-A#5? ($9 B/A C/AA*$?< 1

    !"#0"#5 -/&$9 (50 *- ($ #8#5?*$? 9*-=*,+*$# /5 /+9 "(06 0"#5# *- $/ 9/&A0 0"(0 0"#*+,"-. "/

    ("0&' %-**- =&55#$0+; ( =/00(?# *$9&-05;< [/& =($ 0#-0 0"# >#5(=*0; 0"# =+(*8 A; ,#5&-*$? (0

    0"# -,(0# /7 A//J- 0"(0 "(># A##$ ,&A+*-"#9 /$ 0"# 0/,*=< 4/ ?#0 ( 5#,5#-#$0(0*># -(8,+*$?6

    @ 5#=/88#$9 ( S&*=J ?+($=# (0 0"# =(0(+/? /7 A//J- /$ -/&$9 ,&A+*-"#9 A; C/$0*$&&8#$:0 .# "(9 ($

    (50 /7 -/&$9- 7/5 ( >#5; +/$? 0*8#6 ($9 "(-$:0 *0 ?/$# A; 0"# $(8# /7 8&-*=e N/0 $#=#--(5*+;6

    (0 +#(-06 (==/59*$? 0/ 0./ /7 0"#-# 0#\0- c%#0" V*8 C/"#$:->& *+, 4$2&6 "/ %& ?%-($9 %(+/8a

    b/#?#+*$:-!2(*,&2&7 *" 8"2(, %&' A2$,&5,d< B/0" (&0"/5- #\,+*=*0+; 0"#/5*'# -/&$9 (50 (- ( ,5(=0*=#0"(0 *- 9*-0*$=0 75/8 8&-*=f9*-0*$=0 $/0 A; *0- &-# /7 -/&$96 A&0 A; 0"# ,#5=#,0&(+6 =/$=#,0&(+

    ($9 *$-0*0&0*/$(+ *--- 5(*-#9 A; -/&$9./5J-< B/0" (&0"/5- (00#8,0 0/ 9*77#5#$0*(0# -/&$9 (50

    75/8 8&-*= *$ S&*0# 9*-0*$=06 ($9 S&*0# *$=/8,(0*A+#6 .(;-#+/,

    (,,5/,5*(0# ($9 -(+*#$0 0#58- 7/5 =/$-*9#5*$? 0"# 5#+(0*/$-"*, /7 -/&$9 (50 0/ 8&-*=# &-#9d6 ($9 0"(0 ($;0"*$? 0"(0 #\=##9- 0"#-# 7/58- *- =/$-*9#5#9

    ,#5*,"#5(+ 0/ 0"# ./5J *0-#+7< @0 *- ,5#=*-#+; 0"*- #\=#-- 0"(0 A#=/8#- =#$05(+ *$ -/&$9 (50f/5

    ."(0 V*8HC/"#$ (+-/ 9#-*?$(0#- (- G#\,($9#9 -/$*= ,5(=0*=#*0;6 ( ,#5-,#=0*># -"(,#9 A; -/=*(+6 ,/+*0*=(+6

    ?#$9#56 =+(-- ($9 5(=*(+ #\,#5*#$=#< @0 ./&+9 $#=#--(5*+; *$=+&9# =/$-*9#5(0*/$ /7

    0"# 5#+(0*/$-"*,- 0/ ($9 A#0.##$ ,5/=#-- ($9 ,5/9&=06 0"# -,(=# /7 ,5/9&=0*/$

    >#5-&- 0"# -,(=# /7 5#=#,0*/$6 0"# 0*8# /7 8(J*$? 5#+(0*># 0/ 0"# 0*8# /7 A#"/+9*$?#$0*/$- /7 0"# -*0# /7 #$=/&$0#56

    0"# =/$0#\0 /7 ,#57/58($=# ($9 (&9*0*/$6 0"# 8/9# /7 ,5#-#$0(0*/$6 (8,+*7*=(0*/$6

    5#=/59*$?6 5#,5/9&=0*/$< N/0"*$? *- /&0 /7 A/&$9-< 4/ ,(5(,"5(-# U#55*9(6 0"#5#

    *- $/ #\05(H8&-*=< c32`d

    h*77*$? /$ U#55*9(:- =+(*8 0"(0 0"#5# *- $/0"*$? /&0-*9# 0"# 0#\0 c/5 +*0#5(++; G0"#5# *- $/

    /&0-*9#H0#\0Kd6 V*8HC/"#$ (5?- (?(*$-0 0"# +#?*0*8(=; /7 0"# =(0#?/5; /7 0"# #\05(H8&-*=(+#50*$? 0"# 8&-*=(+ ./5J6 A;

    0"-62&7*06 A; 0&5$*$? 0"#:%-,-7"&*$0/ 0"#,-7"&< U#>#+/,*$? 0"# (5?&8#$0 *$0/ ( 9#7*$*0*/$6

    k%/&$9 (50l *- 8#5#+; 0"# 5#8(*$9#5 =5#(0#9 A; 8&-*= =+/-*$? /77 *0- A/59#5- 0/ 0"#

    #\05(H8&-*=(+6 0/ ($; *$-0($=# /7:%-"$,0"(0 =/&+9 $/0 A# =/87/50(A+; #\,5#--#9

    *$ 0"#$%&70,/7 0"# !#-0#5$ $/0(0*/$(+ -;-0#8< @$-0($=#- /7 $/$H!#-0#5$ 8&-*=./&+9 $/0 A# -/&$9 (50< Z+0"/&?" 0"#; 8(; #8,+/; -,#=*7*= 7#(0&5#-6 -&=" (-

    8*=5/0/$(+*0*#- $/0 5#,5#-#$0#9 *$ 0"# .#-0#5$ /=0(># k-*=l6 0"#-# 7#(0&5#- =($ -0*++

    A# &$9#5-0//9 ($96 0/ -/8# #\0#$06 5#,5#-#$0#9 *$ ( .(; 0"(0 *- +#?*A+# 0/ !#-0#5$

    8&-*=(+ 8#0"/9-< %/&$9 (50 *- (50 0"(0 ,/-*0- 8#($*$? /5 >(+ *$ 5#?*-0#5- $/0

    (==/&$0#9 7/5 A; !#-0#5$ 8&-*=(+ -;-0#8-< m$+*J# -=&+,0&5#6 ($9 0/ ( +#--#5 #\0#$06

    =*$#8(6 8&-*= 7(*+#9 0/ 5#=/?$*'# *0-#+7 *$ *0- #\,($9#9 -*0&(0*/$< c32`d

    4"# 8/-0 ,5/>/=(0*># =+(*8 *- 0"(0 G$/$H!#-0#5$ 8&-*=K ./&+9$:0 A# -/&$9 (50< n/5 V*8H

    C/"#$6 0"# /$0/+/?; /7 -/&$9 (50 *- $#=#--(5*+; *$ /,,/-*0*/$ 0/ !#-0#5$ F&-*= -*$=# *0/==&,*#- 0"# G#\05(8&-*=(+6K 0"# -&,,+#8#$0 ,5/-=5*A#9 A; F&-*=< %/&$9 (50 *- =/$-05&=0#9

    /&0 /7 0"#'2(E,5*% F,FG-%/7 !#-0#5$ 8&-*=< %/&$9 (50 *- F&-*=:-H*+,-(+ *- 9#5*>#96 $/0 75/8 0"# >*-&(+

    /5 8(0#5*(+ S&(+*0*#- /7 0"# $/8*$(0#9 /AI#=0 (- *0 5#+(0#- 0/ 0"# 05(9*0*/$ /7 (50

    /AI#=0-6 A&0 75/8 0"# (50*-0*= (=0 (- *0 5#+(0#- 0/ 0"# 05(9*0*/$ /7 (50*-0*= (=0-< c33Xd

    4"&-6 ( ,*#=# /7F0(2I0, 5"&5-J*, +*J# ^&= n#55(5*:- K-,(I0, P2,&6 ."*=" "(- /70#$ A##$

    &$9#5-0//9 (- ( -/$*= 5#(9;8(9#6 ,(--#- 0"# 0#-0f."*+# %="(#77#5:- =/8,/-*0*/$- 7(*+#6 ($9 9*77#5#$0*(+< Z G$/$H=/="+#(5K -/&$9 (50 *- ($ (50 /7 c($9

    (A/&0d 5#(9*$? -/&$9-# ( "#(5*$? 0"(0 *- 0"# 8(0#5*(+ "#(596 $/.6 =/$0*$?#$0+; ($9 *$9*>*9&(++;< cXd

    Z 7#. =+(*8- -0($9 /&0R 7*5-06 -"# =+(*8- 0"(0 0"# /AI#=0p,"#$/8#$/$ c."*=" *- (+5#(9; (,5/A+#8(0*= =/$I&$=0*/$ *$ ,"#$/8#$/+/?*=(+ 0#58-d *-G,2&7 Q:-"'05,'K A; 0"# -#$-# 8/9(+*0;

    #8,+/;#9< c!# 8*?"0 .($0 0/ =(++ 0"*- 0"# G+*-0#$#5 (- ,5/9&=#5K 8/0*7#5:-

    A/9; ,#5-,*=&/&-< cF/5# /$ 0"(0 +(0#5*-*/$< b*-*/$ />#55*9#-

    "#(5*$?6 -*$=#6 (==/59*$? 0/ b/#?#+*$6 .# (5# *$?5(*$#9 *$0/ G-&A-&8k*$?l -/&$9 *$0/ 0"#

    >*-&(+#5; $(0&5# (--&8#- ( 9*-0($=# 75/8 0"# /AI#=0o%##*$? (+.(;-

    "(,,#$- *$ ( 8#0(H,/-*0*/$6 (.(; 75/8 0"# -##$< Z$9 0"*- 9*-0($=# #$(A+#- ( 9#0(="8#$0

    ($9 /AI#=0*>*0; 0"(0 ,5#-#$0- *0-#+7 (- 05&0"#+

    0/ &-6 ."#$ .# +//J &, *0 9/#- $/0 (,,#(5 ."#5# .# 0"*$J *0 8*?"0< )#5"(,- 0"*- =/$05(9*=0-

    b/#?#+*$:- =+(*8 0"(0 .# (5# (+.(;- -*8&+0($#/&- .*0" 0"# "#(59< _/.#>#56 *0 9#,#$9- /$."(0 G0"# "#(59K *-< n/5 b/#?#+*$6 0"# "#(59 *- -*8,+; 0"# -/&$9 *0-#+76 $/0 0"# 0"*$? 0/ ."*="

    0"# -/&$9 5#7#5-< 4"(0 *- ."; -"# 9*77#5#$0*(0#- 0"# G-/&5=#K 75/8 0"# G-/&$9 *0-#+7(0*/$ 0"(0

    -/&$9- =($ A# #8*00#9 75/8 /AI#=0- *$ .(;- 0"(0 0"#*5 +//J6 /5 >*-&(+ (005*A&0#-6 =($$/0< !"#$

    !"#$%&'(&)$*+ &- #&"./ *-0 *./ 0(1 /1!*./# &2 *-0 0(1&-3 B

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    8/20

    @ ./55; (A/&0 0"# 7(=0 0"(0 0"# ,+($# 9/#-$:0 (,,#(5 *$ 0"# -J; ."#5# @ "#(5 *0 0/ A#6 b/#?#+*$

    8*?"0 0"*$J 0"*- ( =(-# /7 -&A-&8*$? -/&$9 0/ 0"# >*-&(+#H;/&6 *- (+-/ ($ (=0 /7 -&-,#$9*$?

    >*-*/$< C(-0 *$ #\,+*=*0+; _&--#5+*($ 0#58-6 G( -/$*= #,/="ao*- ( -05*,,*$? (.(; 75/8 0"# -/$*=

    ($;0"*$? 0"(0 0*#- *0 0/ >*-&(+*0;ok4"# (*8 *-l $/0 0/ 5#9&=# 0"# "#(59 A&0 0/ ?#0 0/ 0"# .#(+0"

    /7 0"# "#(59 0"5/&?" A5(=J#0#9 +*-0#$*$?*-&(+6 /5 9#,#$9- /$ 0"# -/&5=# /7 0"# -/&$96 0"# ,#57/58#56 /5 0"# $/0(0#9

    -=/5# 8/5# 0"($ 0"# -/&$9- 0"#8-#+>#-6 8&-*= A#=/8#- >*-&(+*-&(+ *- -/ *$?5(*$#9 (- 0/ A+*?"0 8&-*==5*0*=*-8 ($9 0"# 9*-=/&5-# /7 -/&$9 (506 ."/-# 7/=&- *- *$>(5*(A+; /$ 0"# -=/5#

    /5 0"# (55($?#8#$06 /$ 0"# /5="#-05( /5 0"# ,#57/58#56 0"# -/&$9 -/&5=#6 0"#

    *$-0(++(0*/$ >*#. /5 0"# 9/=&8#$0(0*/$ /7 0"# -/$*= #>#$06 *$ -"/50 0"# >*-&(+

    8($*7#-0(0*/$ 5(0"#5 0"($ 0"# -/&$9- "#(59< c\*d

    Z$9 ( 7#. ,(?#- +(0#56 G4"# 0#\0 (- .5*0*$? *- 0"# 8&-*=(+ ./5J6 75(8#9 A; =/$>#$0*/$Y

    *0 (++/.- #$05; 0/ -=5&0*$*'*$? #;#- 0"(0 *$0#5,5#0 *06 ."*+# ?5($0*$? *0 0"# -,(=# 7/5 0"(0

    *$0#5,5#0(0*/$*-&(+< Z$96 (+0"/&?" b/#?#+*$ *$-*-0- 0"(06 G0"# *-- "#5# *- $/0 ( 9*-0*$=0*/$

    A#0.##$ 8&-*= ($9 -/&$9 (506 A&0 "/. A/0" /7 0"#8 (5# +*-0#$#9 0/o6K c]d @ (8 =/$>*$=#9

    0"(0 0"(0 *- 0"# =(-#< _#5# *- "#5 -05/$?#-0 =(-# 7/5 8&-*= (- ,5*8(5*+; >*-&(+f(- 5#S&*5*$? (

    9*77#5#$0 8/9# /7 +*-0#$*$? 0"($ 0"# 8/9# ,5/,#5 0/ -/&$9 (50R

    !"#$ 05(*$*$? (- ( =+(--*=(+ 8&-*=*($ ;/& (5# (-J#9 0/ *9#$0*7; 8*$/5 0"*59-6 ,#57#=0

    7*70"-6 8(I/5 -#>#$0"- ($9 -/ /$R -/&$9- (5# ?*>#$ $(8#- ($9 (5# /5?($*'#9 *$

    5#+(0*/$ 0/ #(=" /0"#56 ($9 *0 A#=/8#- ( 8(00#5 /7 5#=/?$*'*$? ."(0 *- A#*$? ,+(;#9

    ($9 (005*A&0*$? 0"# 5*?"0 0#58 0/ 0"# =/55#-,/$9*$? 0/$(+ 5#+(0*/$-"*,< [/& =($$/0,/--*A+; ?*># 0"# 5*?"0 ($-.#5 &$+#-- ;/& J$/. ."(0 ;/& (5# +*-0#$*$? 7/56 ($9

    0"# j+*-0#$*$? 7/5: *- $#>#5 0"# -/&$9 A&0 *0- >*-&(+ ,/*$0 /7 5#7#5#$=#on5/8 0"*-

    8/8#$0 /$ ;/& (5# +*-0#$*$? 0/ 0"# +($?&(?# /7 8&-*=o%/$*= #\,#5*#$=#6 ."*="

    7*$9- $/ (=J$/.+#9?#8#$0 *$ -&=" ( 8&-*=(+ /5*#$0(0*/$o-#*'#- k-*=l 0/ A# "#(59#5 -(;- *0 9*5#=0+;6 @ -&,,/-# 0"(0 *$-/7(5 (-

    /$# =($ +*-0#$ 0/ 8&-*= *$ ( G-&-,#$9#9K .(;6 +*-0#$*$? 0/ *0 (- -/&$9 0"#8-#+>#-6 0"#$ 8&-*=

    A#=/8#- -/&$9 (50< 4"# 9*77#5#$=# A#0.##$ 0"#-# 0./ 8/9#- /7 +*-0#$*$?6 A#0.##$ 8&-*=($9 -/&$9 (506 *- 9#7*$#9 *$ 0#58- /7 0"# 9*77#5#$=# A#0.##$ 0"# >*-&(+ ($9 0"# (&9*0/5;< 4"#

    (&9*0/5; *- ,5/,#5 0/ -/&$9 (506 ($9 -/&$9 (50:- ,5/,#5 /AI#=0 *- 0"# -/&$9 *0-#+7#-0*?(0#- 5#+(0*/$-"*,-6

    *$-0*0&0*/$-6 =/$0#\06 -/=*(+*0;6 ($9 "*-0/5;Y *0 #-="#.- -/&$9-H*$H0"#8-#+>#- (- ( 5#I#=0*/$ 0"#

    8#0(,";-*=- /7 ,5#-#$=##$0 /&5 "(A*0&(+

    -&A/59*$(0*/$ /7 -/&$9 0/ 0"# >*-&(+< F&-*=:- "*-0/5*=(+ *$>#-08#$0 *$ >*-&(+ 0"*$?- +*J# -=/5#-

    ($9 ,#57/58#5- ,5#>#$0- ?#$&*$# +*-0#$*$?6 05($-7/58*$? *0 *$0/ ($ (=0 /7 5#(9*$?< n/5 V*8H

    C/"#$6 -/&$9 (50 2(($ (=0 /7 5#(9*$?6 /7 8(J*$? +#?*A+# ( -#0 /7 -/=*(+6 *$-0*0&0*/$(+6 ($9

    "*-0/5*=(+ 05(=#-< %/$*= 8(0#5*(+*0; /5 ,#5=#,0&(+ #>*9#$=# *- $#>#5 0"# ,5/,#5 =/$0#$0 /7 -/&$9(50< G4"# 5#>#+(0*/$ /7 ,"#$/8#$( *- $/0 #$/&?"#5 (A/&0 0"# -/&$9 /7 0"# -*?$6

    A&0 /$+; *0- -*?$*7*=($=##+/, 0"#/5*#- /7 -/&$9 (50 0"(0 $#=#--(5*+;

    5#S&*5# F&-*= c.5*0 +(5?#d6 A&0 /$+; (- ( $#?(0*>#6 (- ($ (+0/?#0"#5Hg0"#5< B/0" 9#7*$# 0"#*5

    0"#/5*#- (- 5#-*-0*$? 0"# "#?#8/$; /7 F&-*= ($9 &$9#5-0($9 -/&$9 (50 (- *$"(A*0*$? ($

    (+0#5$(0*># 0"(0 F&-*= =($$/0 /==&,;< U#-,*0# 0"# /0"#5 9*77#5#$=#6 0"#5# *- ((*-05*0-%$ %7-,,F,&*

    A#0.##$ b/#?#+*$ ($9 V*8HC/"#$< B/0" 5#S&*5# F&-*= (- ($ g0"#56 ;#06 0"#; &00#5+; 9*-(?5##

    (A/&0 "/. 0/ ="(5(=0#5*'# F&-*=:- g0"#5$#--< n/5 V*8HC/"#$6 F&-*= *- 7*\(0#9 /$ -/&$9-H*$H

    0"#8-#+>#- 0/ -#=&5# (&0/$/8; ($9 ,5/-=5*A# #>#5;0"*$? #\05(8&-*=(+Y 7/5 b/#?#+*$6 F&-*= *-

    7*\(0#9 /$ #>#5;0"*$? 0"(0 *- $/0 0"# -/&$9H0"#8-#+>#-6 0"(0 *- 0"# -=/5#6 0"# ,#57/58#56 ?#$5#6

    =(0#?/5;6 "*-0/5;6 ($9 -/ 7/50"6 ($9 0"&- -0(>#- /77 0"# ,/--*A*+*0; /7 ( 8/5# ,5/,#56 (00#$0*>#($9 7/=&-#9 8/9# /7 +*-0#$*$?*$? 0"*- 9*-(?5##8#$0 ($9 -"(,*$?6 *$ ,(50*=&+(56 0"#*5=+(*8- (A/&0 8&-*=*9&(+ A*0- /7 =/+/5

    /5*?*$(++; *8,5#--#9 /$ 0"# 5#0*$(6 ./&+9 "(># ( $/$H(5A*05(5; 5&+# 7/5 8(J*$? 9#,*=0*/$-#+(0*/$- /7 ( 05($-=#$9#$0(+

    -&AI#=0(-0(0*$? 7/5 0"# A#+*#7 *$ 0"# ,5*8(=; /7 8#9*&8 ($9

    8(0#5*(+< Z==/59*$? 0/ V5(&--6 G4"# -,(=# /7 ,/-08/9#5$*-0 ,5(=0*=# *- $/ +/$?#5 /5?($*'#9

    (5/&$9 0"# 9#7*$*0*/$ /7 ( ?*>#$ 8#9*&8 /$ 0"# ?5/&$9- /7 8(0#5*(+6 /56 7/5 0"(0 8(00#56 0"#

    ,#5=#,0*/$ /7 8(0#5*(+

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    12/20

    c1]]d E(=" 8#9*&8 *- (- ?//9 (- ($; /0"#5f#(=" *- -&A-0*0&0(A+#6 (5A*05(5;f-*$=# ."(0 .#

    (5# $/. (50*=&+(0*$? *- $/0 #--#$0*(++; 8(0#5*(+< @0 *-6 (- V5(&-- -(;-6 ( -#0 /7 =&+0&5(+ 0#58-*$? #>#$ *0-

    ,"5(-*$? ($9 =(9#$=#R GZ $/$H=/="+#(5 -/$*= (50 ,5#-#$0k-l *0-#+7 *$ -,5 &+.%8&>

    4*):)36-4*5? @))A/? 1%,+/ ), B-11/? &%66)6/? /0814:86+6 (- .#++ (- ,#57/58($=#6 -,##="6

    ="/5#/?5(,";6 -/=*(+ ,5(=0*=#6 ($9 -/ /$#$0*/$(+ ($9 -/=*(+ :%-,-7%,5/-=5*A#9 A; 0"# cL5##$A#5?*($d F/9#5$*-0

    ./5J< 4"# /$# 0"*$? $/$H=/="+#(5 -/&$9 (502( &"**- ,#5=#,0&(+< [#06 ."#$ V5(&-- .5*0#-

    (A/&0 U&="(8,:- $/$H5#0*$(+ (506 ,#5=#,0*/$ *-:-,52(,$."#5 7/=&-< @$ "#5 #--(;6 G@$ 0"# B+*$J

    /7 ($ E;#6K 0"# 0#58 $/$H5#0*$(+ *- #8,+/;#9 0/ 9#-=5*A# "/.6 *$ U&="(8,:- ./5J6 0"# >*#.#5(==#--#- G0"# -#$-(0*/$- /7 >*-*/$ 0"(0 (5# ?#$#5(0#9 #$0*5#+; A; 0"# A/9; /7 0"# >*#.#5*5?*$ ,"/0/?5(,"*= ,+(0#(0&5# /7 /$#:-

    #;#A(++-6 0"# ,5/9&=0*/$ /7 (70#5*8(?#-6 ($9 0"# 5";0"8*= 8&-=&+(5 8/0*/$ /7 0"# #;#- *$

    A*$/=&+(5 >*-*/$< 4"#-# (5# 0"# ,";-*/+/?*=(+ =/$9*0*/$- /7 -##*$? 0"(0 =($$/0 A# (==/&$0#9

    7/5 A; 0"# $/0*/$ /7 0"# #;# (- (*%G0$% -%(%6 /5 -,(0*(+ ,/*$0#"#8#$0 5#I#=0*/$ /7 0"# j5#0*$(+6: .# "(># $/$#0"#+#-- 0/ (=J$/.+#9?#

    0"# ,5#-#$=# /7 ,";-*/+/?*=(+ /,0*=- (0 ./5J .*0"*$ U&="(8,:- 0"*$J*$? ($9 ,5/9&=0*/$*-&(+ /59#5 /7 -*$?+#H,/*$0 ,#5-,#=0*># .*0" *0-

    9*-#8A/9*#96 8(0"#8(0*'#9 >*#.#5< c4"# ,"5(-# G,";-*/+/?*=(+ /,0*=-K *- (+-/ ( A*0 =/$7&-*$?

    !"#$%&'(&)$*+ &- #&"./ *-0 *./ 0(1 /1!*./# &2 *-0 0(1&-3

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    13/20

    A#=(&-# V5(&-- #>#$0&(++; &-#- 0"# ./59 G/,0*=-K (- ( -"/50"($9 7/5 0"# ?#/8#05*=(+ 8/9#+6

    *$ =/$05(-0 0/ 0"# G,";-*/+/?; /7 >*-*/$K ."*=" 9#-*?$(0#- 0"# $#.+; 9*-=/>#5#96 A/9*+; 5#?*8#

    /7 >*-*/$*-*/$6 #\#8,+*7*#9 *$ 0"# #\,#5*8#$0(+ ./5J /7 L/#0"#6 i/"($$#- Fq++#5

    ($9 _#+8"/+0'< _*-0/5*=(++;6 GL/#0"# *$*0*(0#- 0"# -0&9; /7 ( ,";-*/+/?;f($9 $/ +/$?#5($9 /,0*=-f/7 >*-*/$6 ( ,";-*/+/?; 0"(0 &$9#5-0($9- 0"# A/9; /7 0"# >*#.#5 (- 0"# (=0*>#

    ,5/9&=#5 /7 /,0*=(+ #\,#5*#$=##6 *- "#$=#7/50" -#>#5#9 75/8 ( -,#=*7*=(++; -,(0*(+ 5#7#5#$0*-*/$ #\,/-#- /,0*=- (- 0"# ,5/9&=0*/$

    /7 0"# >*#.#56 $/0 0"# 5#?*-05(0*/$ /7 S&(+*0*#- /7 #\0#5*/5 A/9*#-< m$9#5 0"*- $#.6 ,";-*/+/?*=(+

    5#?*8# /7 >*-*/$6 G0"# $(0&5(+ -*?$:- $#=#--(5; =/$$#=0*/$ 0/ 0"# >*-&(+ 7*#+9 =($ $/ +/$?#5 A#

    8(*$0(*$#9*#.#5 0/ A#=/8# (.(5# /7 0"#*5 /.$

    ,5/9&=0*>*0;%( % ;2,#,-*#.#5:- /.$ A/9*+; =/$05*A&0*/$ 0/

    -##*$?< 4/ 0(J# /$+; /$# *$-0($=# 75/8 "#5 8($; 5#(9*$?- /7 U&="(8,6 G@7 0"# 8#="($*-8 /7

    0"#!%-7, V$%((/A#;- U&="(8,:- 9*=0&8 /7 j?/*$? A#;/$9: 0"# 5#0*$(6 *0 9/#- -/ $/0 0/ (="*#>#

    0"# =/$9*0*/$ /7 >*-*/$:- 05($-,(5#$=; 0/ *0-#+7f."*=" *- -&??#-0#9 A; 0"# 8/9#+ /7 =+(--*=(+

    ,#5-,#=0*># ."#$ (,,+*#9 0/ 0"# V$%((fA&0 5(0"#56 S&*0# /A>*/&-+;o0/ =/$-05&=0 >*-*/$

    *0-#+7 .*0"*$ 0"# /,(=*0; /7 0"# /5?($-oK c3]`d V5(&-- /77#5- 0"# -(8# 5#(9*$? 7/5 (50*-0-

    ."/-# ./5J-6 *$7+$=#9 A; U&="(8,6 5#7+#=0 ($ (+0#5$(0*># 0/ L5##$A#5?*($ 8/9#5$*-8*-0 -=&+,0&5#6 *- $#>#5 5#,5#-#$0#9 c*$ 0"# -=&+,0&5#d (- -0(0*/$(5;< 4"# >*#.#5

    *- (+.(;- 9#-=5*A#9 (- *$ 8/0*/$ #>#$ *7 0"(0 8/0*/$ *- /$+; 0"# =/$-0($0 &%06)&8/081-6

    -.C8/:&+,:/0"(0 (5# 0"#0)64)6+-1%D+. 0),.%:%), )< @%

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    14/20

    Z$9 "#5#:- 0"# *5/$;< @7 .# (==#,0 V5(&--: 5#(9*$? /7 G$/$H5#0*$(+K (50 (- ( 9#7#$-# /7

    (50./5J- ."#5# 0"# >*#.#5 *- $/0 -*8,+; 0"# 5#=#*>#5 A&0 ( ,5/9&=#5f(- ( 9#7#$-# /7 (50./5J-

    ."#5# ,5/9&=0*>*0; /7 0"# >*#.#5 *- 8(9# ,#5-,*=&/&-f0"#$6 ($(+/?/&-+;6 ( Q&"&@5"5+$,%-O

    ("0&' %-* G,72&( *" $""6 F05+ F"-, $26, % ',/,&(, "/ W",7,$2&M( :-"E,5* *+%& X2F@3"+,&M(Y

    4"*- *- A#=(&-#6 &$+*J# V*8HC/"#$6 b/#?#+*$ *- #\,+*=*0+; *$0#5#-0#9 *$ 8/8#$0- ."#5#6 (-

    -"# ,&0- *06 G0"# +*-0#$#5 A#=/8#- ,5/9&=#5/5*0# 0#58-6/"-F$,((< G4"# -/$*= 0"*$? *- $/0 ,#5-,#=0*>(+6 /5?($*'#9 *$

    5#+(0*/$ 0/ /0"#5 0"*$?-6 -/=*(+ 7&$=0*/$- /5 /59#5#9 *$ 5#+(0*/$ 0/ ( ,&5,/-#o$#*0"#5 7/58#9

    $/5 9#7/58#96 A&0 7/58+#-- &$+#-- *0 8##0- 0"# "#(5*$? A/9;#5; $#\0 ,(?# -"# .5*0#-R GH& *+,

    =%5+%2-,5/9&=#- -#$-# (- ( -/$*= J$/.*$?o@ ./&+9 A# >#5; "(59 ,5#--#9 0/ 0#++ ;/& ($ #\(=0

    J$/.+#9?# ?(*$#96 A&0 @ =/&+9 9*-=&--- /+,/+ )< A,)B%,3 -@)8: &5/+1

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    15/20

    b/#?#+*$:- 0"#/5*#-< 4"# ,5/9&=0*>*0; /7 0"# >*-&(+ -;-0#8 =/&+9 /$+; =/8# *$0/ >*-*A*+*0; *$

    ./5J- 0"(0 &$9#50//J ( =5*0*S /7 0"# =/$=#,0&(+6 =/$>#$0*/$(+ ($9 *9#/+/?*=(+ 7#(0&5#- /7

    (50./5J-Y 0"# =5*0*S /7 0"# $(0&5(+ -*?$ *- $#=#--(5; 7/5 0"# 9*-=+/-&5# /7 ,";-*/+/?*=(+ >*-*/$# $/ ,5*>*+#?#9 8#9*&8 /5 7/58Y 0"&-6 0"# /$&-

    /7 0"# (50./5J6 *0- 7/58(0*/$6 *- ,+(=#9 /$0/ 0"# A#"/+9#5< GC/55#+(0#9 .*0" 0"# (9>#$0 /7

    9*?*0*'(0*/$6K _($-#$ .5*0#-6 G0"# A/9; &$9#5?/#- ( =#50(*$ #8,/.#58#$06 -*$=# *0 9#,+/;- *0-

    /.$ =/$-0*0&0*># -*$?&+(5*0; c(77#=0*/$ ($9 8#8/5;d $/0 0/ 7*+0#5 ( &$*>#5-# /7 ,5#=/$-0*0

    *8(?#-6 A&0 (=0&(++; 0/,&/-%F,-/8#0"*$? c9*?*0(+ *$7/58(0*/$d 0"(0 *- /5*?*$(++; 7/58+#--*/&-#56 *0 *- 0#++*$?< n/5 _($-#$6 $#. 8#9*( 8(J#- 0"# A#"/+9#5:- =(,(=*0; 0/ #$75(8#

    7/58+#-- 9(0( ,#5-,*=&/&-Y 0"&-6 $#. 8#9*( (50 *- ,/-0H8#9*(+ (50< Z==/59*$? 0/ _($-#$6 Gn/5

    ( 0"#/5; /7 (50 *$ 0"# -,#=*7*=(++; j,/-0H8#9*&8: =/$9*0*/$ $(8#9 A; 0"# 9*?*0(+6 0"# A/9; *0-#+7

    *- *$>#-0#9 .*0" 0"# 5#-,/$-*A*+*0; /7 ,5#-#5>*$? .*0"*$ *0-#+7 0"# -#+7H9*77#5*$? =/$9*0*/$ /7

    8#9*(

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    16/20

    @$ 0"# =(-# /7 V*8HC/"#$:- G$/$H=/="+#(5K (#-0"#0*=-6 0"# ,#5=#,0&(+ 7#(0&5#- /7 -/8#

    -,#=*7*= -/&$9 ./5J 9/ $/0 5#(++; 8(00#5 -*$=# 0"# ,&5,/-# /7 $/$H=/="+#(5 ./5J- *- 0/

    (=J$/.+#9?# 0"# #\,($9#9 -/=*(+6 *$-0*0&0*/$(+ /5 =/$0#\0&(+ -*0&(0*/$ /7 0"# ./5J< 4"#

    ,5/A+#8 .*0" 0"*- >*#. *- 0"(0 /$# =($$/0 0#++ ."; 0"# -,#=*7*= -/&$9- 8(00#5< @$ ."(0 .(;-

    9/*+, (:,52/25 ("0&'((=0 (- ( =/$-05(*$0 /$ 0"# 5#+#>($0 -/=*(+ S-0*/$-e

    4"# -05($?#-0 ,(50 *- 0"# 7(+-# 9*="/0/8; A#0.##$("0&'(($9 ("52,*.< @0 *- (- *7 (00#$0*/$ 0/

    ( -/&$9 =($ /$+; /==&5 ."#$ /$# 5#9&=#- /&0 *0- -/=*(+6 -#8*/0*=6 *$-0*0&0*/$(+ /5 "*-0/5*=(+

    (-,#=0-< @0 *- (- *7("0&'(($9("52,*..#5# 0./ *$=/8,(0*A+# (-,#=0- /7 ( ."/+#6 +*J# 0"# 9&=J

    ($9 0"# 5(AA*0 *$ i(-05/.:- 7(8/&- 7*?&5#< 4"# ="/*=# *-/"-5,'Y /$# =($ #*0"#5 "#(5 -/&$9- (-

    G-/&$9-H*$H0"#8-#+>#-K /5 (- ,(50 /7 ( -/=*(+ =/9#< B&0 /$# =($ $#>#5+,%- 2&-/&$9- 0"#*5

    -/=*(+*0;< 33

    @$ 0"# =/$=+&-*/$ 0/>& *+, 4$2&6 "/ %& ?%-6 V*8HC/"#$ 5#(--#50- 0"*- 7/5=#9 ="/*=# A; .(; /7

    ( S&/0(0*/$< ^&= n#55(5*6 -,#(J*$? /7 0"# U(58-0(90 %&88#5 C/&5-#-6 +(=/$*=(++; +(*9 /&0 0"#/,0*/$- 0"(0 =/8,/-#5- /7 0"# 3WQ2- ($9 O2- 7(=#9R G[/& "(9 0/ ="//-# A#0.##$ -#5*(+*-8

    ($9 ?*5+-< @ ="/-# ?*5+-(*+(A+# 7/5 ( -/$*= (50R *$.(596 0/.(59 ( G=/$-#5>(0*># 5#05#$="8#$0 7/=&-#9 /$ 8(0#5*(+-

    ($9 /$ =/$=#5$- =/$-*9#5#9 #--#$0*(+ 0/ 8&-*=K /5 /&0.(596 0/.(59 G0"(0 ."*=" +*#- A#;/$9

    0"# 05(9*0*/$(+ A/59#5- /7 0"# 7*#+96K 0/.(59 0"# #\,($9#9 -*0&(0*/$6 0/.(59 $/$H=/="+#(5

    -/$*= (506 0/.(59 0"# -/=*(+< c1O3d Gn#55(5* ="/-# 0/ 8/># /&0.(59 0/ ?*5+-6 75/8 8&-*= 0/ 0"#

    ./5+9< @$ 0"# ?(++#5; (50-6 0"# 8/>#8#$0 "(- A##$ 9#=*-*>#+; /&0.(596 (.(; 75/8 0"# =#$0#5

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    17/20

    &$=#50(*$0; /7 0"# 8&-*=*($- 7/++/.*$? U;+($Y "# (+-/ 9#-=5*A#- ( -&A0+# 0(,# -,+*=# (0 0"#

    A#?*$$*$? /7 0"# 7/&50" >#5-#6 ($9 8&-#- (A/&0 "/. 0"(0 *0 =($ /77#5 #>*9#$=# 7/5 U;+($:-

    *$0#$0R G@7 ."(0 @ "#(52(( 0(,# -,+*=#6 *0 ./&+9 8#($ 0"(0 U;+($ ($9 k,5/9&=#5 4/8l !*+-/$

    7#+0 0"#;:9 0(,,#9 -/8#0"*$? >(+&(A+# *$ 0"# 7*5-0 0"5## >#5-#-f-/8#0"*$? 0"(0 *$ -,*0# /7 *0-

    >#5; (,,(5#$0 7+(.-f/5 ,#5"(,- A#=(&-# /7 0"#8f.(- (A+# 0/ =/88&$*=(0# 0"# (A-05(=06 =/8,+#\ A&-*$#-- /7 0"# -/$? ($9 0"# 8/8#$0# 0/ ="//-# A#0.##$ "#(5*$? 0"#

    -/&$9- /5 "#(5*$? 0"# -/=*(+#5+//J- *- 0"(0 F&-*= c.5*0

    +(5?#d6 #>#$ (0 *0 8/-0 -#>#5# =+(*8 0/ (&0/$/8;6 *- (+.(;- (+5#(9; -/=*(+< Z&0/$/8; *- ( -/=*(+

    7(=06 9#-,*0# 0"# =/8,/-#5-6 -/&$9 (50*-0-6 8&-*=/+/?*-0- /5 =5*0*=- ."/ 5#7&-# 0/ 5#=/?$*'# *0(+*9 .*0"/&0 ($ #-0"#0*= /AI#=0*7*=(0*/$#$ G(&0/$/8/&-K

    8&-*=6 .*0"/&0 7(++*$? ,5#; 0/ 0"# *9#/+/?; /7 -/&$9H*$H0"#8-#+>#-< 3X

    4"# .(; 0/ (5? (?(*$-0 0"# *9#/+/?; /7 0"# -/&$9H*$H*0-#+7 *-$:0 A; 0&5$*$? F&-*= c.5*0 +(5?#d*$0/ ( -05(. 8($ ($9 0"#$ 9/??#9+; =/88*00*$? /$#-#+7 0/ *0- (++#?#9 /0"#56 0"# -/=*(+< 4"#

    .(; 0/ (5? (?(*$-0 0"# *9#/+/?; /7 -/&$9H*$H*0-#+7 *- 0/ 9#8/$-05(0# 0"(0 -/&$9 *- (+.(;-

    (+5#(9; -/=*(+f."#0"#5 $/0(0#9 /5 *8,5/>*-#96 !#-0#5$ /5 $/$H!#-0#5$6 F&-*= /5 %/&$9

    Z50< F/5#/>#56 0/ -(; 0"(0 -/&$9- (5# -/=*(+ *- $/0 0/ -(; ($;0"*$? /7 *$0#5#-06 -*$=# 0"(0 *-

    -*8,+; ?*>#$Y #>#5;0"*$? "&8($- 9/ *- ,(50 /7 0"# G=&+0&5(+ +*7#./5+9*9#- &-#7&+ =/55#=0*># 0/ 0"# F&-*=/,"/A*( /7 b/#?#+*$ ($9 V*8HC/"#$< _#

    (5?-6 (?(*$ ($9 (?(*$6 7/5 0"# *$9*--/+&A*+*0; /7 0"# -/$*= ($9 -/=*(+6 0"# ,#5=#,0&(+ ($9 0"#

    =/$=#,0&(+< g$# #\(8,+# .*++ "(># 0/ -&77*=#R

    !"#$%&'(&)$*+ &- #&"./ *-0 *./ 0(1 /1!*./# &2 *-0 0(1&-3

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    18/20

    E>#$ B##0"/>#$:- 8&-*=6 A/&5?#/*- 8&-*= (0 *0- "#*?"06 5#>#5A#5(0#- .*0" 0"# 5/(5

    ($9 *9#(+ /7 0"# "#5/*= ;#(5- /7 *0- =+(-- I&-0 (- 95#(8- *$ 0"# #(5+;H8/5$*$?

    "/&5- 5#-/&$9 .*0" 0"# $/*-# /7 *0- 9(;Y ($9 0"# -/=*(+ =/$0#$0 /7 ?5#(0 8&-*= *-

    ?5(-,#9 $/0 A; -#$-&(+ +*-0#$*$? A&0 /$+; 0"# =/$=#,0&(++; 8#9*(0#9 J$/.+#9?# /7

    *0- #+#8#$0- ($9 0"#*5 =/$7*?&5(0*/$< cZ9/5$/ 122O6 322d

    N#*0"#5 V*8HC/"#$ $/5 b/#?#+*$ (5# *$ ( ,/-*0*/$ 0/ (50*=&+(0# 0"# 9*(+#=0*=(+ =/$9*0*/$ /7

    -/&$9 ($9 -/=*#0;< N/ 8(00#5 "/. 8&=" ;/& 7/5#?5/&$9 0"# ,#5=#,0*/$- ($9 -#$-(0*/$ /7

    0"# +*-0#$#56 $/ 8(00#5 "/. 8&=" ;/& 7/5#?5/&$9 0"# -/=*(+ ($9 =/$=#,0&(+ (-,#=0- /7 0"#

    -*0&(0*/$6 ;/& =($$/0 ?#0 ,(-0 0"# #+#8#$0- ($9 =/$7*?&5(0*/$ /7 0"# ./5J< @0 *- 0"# /$+; 0"*$?

    0"(0 0"# +*-0#$#5:- #(5 ($9 #\,($9#9 -*0&(0*/$ "(># *$ =/88/$*-&(+ (50- -&99#$+; +/-# 0"#*5 #S&*+*A5*&8

    (0 0"# 8#$0*/$ /7 0"# ./59 -/&$9< 4"#-# -(8# ,#/,+# ."/ ./&+9 (++ 5*9*=&+# ( $#.

    (50 7/58 =(++#96 -(;6 j%0##+ Z50: ."*=" .(- =/8,/-#9 /7 -0##+ -=&+,0&5# =/8A*$#9

    .*0" -0##+ ?&*0(5 8&-*= (+/$? .*0" ($;0"*$? #+-# .*0" -0##+ *$ *06 -/8#"/. "(># $/

    05/&A+# (0 (++ -.(++/.*$? j%/&$9 Z50:< @$ (506 0"# 8#9*&8 *- $/0 /70#$ 0"# 8#--(?#/*9(A+#6 &$5&+;6 &$7(-"*/$(A+# 0"*$? 0"(0 .# &-#9 0/ =(++ G0"# ./5J

  • 5/28/2018 Brian Kane, Musicophobia

    19/20

    . & 0 1 #

    3< "00,Rpp...(- ($9 *0- 75(8#< _# (5?- 0"(00"#:%-,-7"&7/++/.- 0"# +/?*= /7 0"# -&,,+#8#$06 0"(0 *0 /,#5(0#-6 G.*0"/&0 A#*$? ( ,(50 /7 k0"# ./5Jl ;#0 .*0"/&0 A#*$?(A-/+&0#+; #\05*$-*= 0/ *0#5 -*8,+; /&0-*9# /5 *$-*9#6 0"# U#55*9#($ :%-,-7"&6 ?*>#- *0-#+7 />#5 0/ -0(A*+*'#($9 +#?*0*8(0# 0"# *$0#?5*0; ($9 (&0/$/8; /7 0"# ./5JY ;#06 *7 0"# ./5J 5#S&*5#- -&=" +#?*0*8(0*/$ 75/8 G/&0-*9#6K *0 =($$/0A# -*8,+; (&0/$/8/&-(+ "# ,+(=#- /$ 5#9&=#9 +*-0#$*$? cR5"0*,- -R'20*,de

    4"# %="(#77#5*($ ,/-*0*/$ *- $/0 />#5=/8# A; *$>#50*$? *0- >(+-Y *0 *- />#5=/8# A; (5?&*$? (?(*$-0 *0- ,5#8*-#-< n/5 8/5#/$ %="(#77#56 -## V($# c122`d