brands tracked - xor labs: an roi and data driven digital ... · this is our first ipl digital...
TRANSCRIPT
Brands Tracked
Pg 2
INTRODUCTION
Despite the reports in media about the declining viewership of Indian Premiere League, the 9th edition of IPL did not lose its
potential as a marketing playground. VIVO IPL 2016 on-air ad spends has garnered around Rs. 1,000 crore. IPL is still the hot-
bed for marketing.
80 sponsors, plus over 20 Hotstar advertisers, were riding on the marketing roller-coaster this season. Was simply having an
on-air ad spot, or brand presence on the jersey or ground sponsorship enough to cut above the noise?
#VIVOIPL alone had 10,297,541 tweets in total during the tournament. In fact, 70 per cent fans were using social media to share
their in stadia experiences. While companies did spend on TV ads, it was crucial to have a digital marketing strategy.
Now, when the tournament is over, it is time to reflect and find who was the brand of the tournament and who simply made a
cameo like Kevin Pietersen. This is our first IPL Digital Marketing Report to find how well the IPL sponsors and advertisers
supported their marketing campaigns on digital marketing channels.
Key Takeaways
Ÿ Creative and engaging content was rewarded with audience engagement regardless of paid promotion.
Ÿ Most brands struggled to maintain all three aspects of digital marketing.
Ÿ Display marketing was the most ignored aspect. Marketers did not even use the economical ways of display marketing like
buying ads on sports website or creating dedicated IPL website.
Pg 3
x1Social media Display marketing Content strategy
x2 x1x1
Green Cap
Brand who excelled in all 3 fields will be wearing the most enticing prize for an advertiser
Scoring & MethodologyWe tracked three aspects of digital marketing:
Ÿ Social Media
Ÿ Content Strategy
Ÿ Display Marketing
We used in-house tools to track the social media profiles—Facebook and Twitter—of brands who are either official IPL sponsor
or sponsor of IPL franchisees. On the content and display marketing side, we deployed our team to track the social media
content during the games and display ads on relevant websites and apps. We have tracked the companies in two parts
Ÿ From April 8, 2016 to April 28, 2016
Ÿ From April 29, 2016 to May 29, 2016
The results of the first part was published as a mid-IPL season report which you can download by . The final report clicking here
has the data and results compiled for throughout the season.
These three aspects of scoring have been further elaborated in each of its respective section
Pg 4
Here’s our Scoring methodolgy
x1
Some brands were so busy buying TV ad spots that they almost missed the opportunity on social media. On the other hand,
there were brands like Zeven who only used social media apart from being on Royal Challenger Bangalore’s jersey. The brands
who performed well on social media were likely to get the most of their sponsorship
Social Media
Evaluation criteria
Brand engagement Brand activity Replies to Users
x2 x1x1
Orange Cap
Brand who batted well in the social media crease
Winner
Pg 5
Ÿ Britannia5050 was the most engaging brand on social media followed by Vivo and Flipkart.
Ÿ Despite being the most active brand, Kingfisher could not top the social media chart. It shows how being active on social
media counts only if you’re getting brand engagement and social media conversations.
Ÿ Vodafone leads the chart in replies to users queries. But even then they could not make it to the top 5. It’s because
Vodafone’s social media conversations were more like customer care service while the ones in top 5 delighted users on
social media.
Orange Cap: Top 5
Social MediaPg 6
x1Brand engagementKey Brand activity Replies to customers
#1
#2#3
#4 #5
Britannia hit the accelerator on marketing campaign after the one third of the tournament was over. With a dedicated website
and campaign, they generated the highest engagement. While they stood at 10th spot in brand engagement #5050Fusion
during mid-way, at the end of IPL they stood in the 1st position.
Vivo made it to the 2nd position by performing well in the conversation chart, for they were quite behind in terms of applause
and amplification. The top two brands had one thing in common: a dedicated IPL website to engage users
Brand Engagement
Britannia5050
Vivo
Flipkart
Oppo
GoodDay Cookies
Myntra
YES Bank
Gionee
Intex
Make my Trip
RedFM
33,73,248
25,82,138
23,14,743
21,80,675
16,58,871
15,88,528
13,00,634
11,70,762
10,65,687
7,58,376
5,25,162
Top 11 Brands by Total Engagement
(likes + share + comments + favorites + retweets)
Social MediaPg 7
Engagements were also analyzed by specific engagement type. The three engagement types measured were:
Ÿ Applause, representing favorable responses and including metrics such as likes and favorites,
Ÿ Conversation, representing consumer responses and including metrics such as comments and replies,
Ÿ Amplification, representing brand advocacy and including metrics such as shares and retweets
Top brands by Engagement type
Gionee
FreeCharge
Britannia 5050
Oppo
GoodDay Cookies
Ola Cabs
Flipkart
Vivo
Kingfisher
YES Bank
RedFM
95,889
94,791
71,965
56,589
46,578
45,335
32,314
32,057
31,030
22,153
21,190
Top 11 Brands by AmplificationTop 11 Brands by Appluase
(shares + retweets)
Top 11 Brands by Conversation
Vodafone
Intex
Freecharge
Daikin
RedFM
Flipkart
Vivo
GoodDay Cookies
Britannia50550
YES Bank
Oppo
59,613
49,367
33,423
30,504
19,794
16,160
11,535
10,474
9,343
8,400
8,334
(likes + favorites)
Brand EngagementSocial MediaPg 8
(comments + replies)
Britannia 5050
Vivo
Flipkart
Oppo
GoodDay Cookies
Myntra
YES Bank
Gionee
Intex
Make my Trip
Spykar
32,91,940
25,38,546
22,66,269
21,15,752
16,01,819
15,63,312
12,70,081
10,70,092
10,07,160
7,52,072
5,04,930
Kingfisher and Britannia5050 were the most active brands. For marketers, Twitter still stands as the preferred channel for
marketing. Not only most posts are shared on the micro-blogging website, 95% of the brand activity also came from Twitter .
Brand activity
Kingfisher
Britannia5050
DTDC
FreeCharge
OLA Cabs
Gionee
Zeven
Vodafone
Astral Pipes
HE Deo
YES Bank
30,025
5,230
2,163
2,136
2,033
1,857
1,535
1,220
1,176
976
824
Top 11 Brands by Tweet Activity
(Tweets)
30,101
6,013
2,760
2,236
2,194
2,079
2,009
1,658
1,483
1,460
1,349
Kingfisher
Britannia5050
FreeCharge
DTDC
Gionee
OLA Cabs
Zeven
GoodDay Cookies
HE Deo
RedFM
YES Bank
Top 11 Brands by Total activity
(Tweets + Fb posts)
Pg 9 Social Media
Many brands are using their official Twitter handle as customer care platform. While there are brands like FreeCharge who use
personal authentic responses to serve customers, brands like Videocon are using automatic generated messages to respond to
users. But the brands who topped the overall chart were those who engaged user around personal and authentic content
59,513
4,850
1,971
1,829
1,151
1,138
742
665
550
485
375
Vodafone
Videocond2h
Daikin
DTDC
Britannia5050
FreeCharge
Myntra
DHFL
OLA Cabs
GoodDay Cookies
YES Bank
Top 11 Brands by Replies to Customers
(No. of replies)
Replies to Users
Pg 10 Social Media
Without content, there would be no conversation, no story, no message...and consequently, no brand! While there are companies
who understand this, there are many who have not caught up with the idea.
Since our mid-IPL season report, many brands have improved their content strategy. Kingfisher has ruled the content landscape
throughout the IPL. And after the success in the first half, Finolex and Zeven have also kept up their content momentum.
Read on and find out how the other brands have played on the content pitch!
Content strategy
Purple Cap
Brands who bowled out their opponents with best economy rate
Conversation with users
Personal authentic responses
On air publicity of hashtag
Actively used hashtag with the game
Consistency
Engagement authenticity
Game related content
Real time responsive Content creation
Variety in content Creation
Branded content
Synergy of content with the game
Content Development Content distribution Strategy
Pg 11
Winner
How we Scored?
#1#2
#3 #4#5
Key points
Ÿ All these brands have been consistent and authentic with their content and brand voice
Ÿ The king of good times, Kingfisher, has also been the king of great content, closely followed by Yes Bank.
Ÿ Content distribution strategy of Kingfisher, Yes Bank, and Freecharge was better than that of Vodafone
x1Engagement Authenticity Key Content Development Content Distribution Strategy
Purple Cap: Top 5
Pg 12 Content Strategy
Kingfisher
Kingfisher won the purple cap for a great content strategy. They
created almost all type of social content--videos, GIFs, and ad
banners. This is the only brand which focused well on videos and
GIFs. One of their Facebook videos received 3.5 million views.
Kingfisher used GIF in all sort of ways. They used GIF contests to
spark successful conversations. They used stand-up comedians for
reactionary GIFs. The content was witty, creative, and truly delighted
the audience. Audience response was equally creative... and it indeed
was good times for audience as well as for Kingfisher.
Pg 13 Content Strategy
Zeven
A startup with marketing budget not much as Amazon,
Flipkart, Vodafone, and VIVO. What would you do?
Develop a good content strategy and back it with social
media.
Zeven perfectly knew how to do this. They actively use
hashtag with the game, were consistent with #LivetoPlay
their content, and were able to engage audience. The only
thing they missed on was variety. Video content and real-
time responsive content for the game could have helped the
RCB sponsor to jump to the 2nd position.
Pg 14 Content Strategy
YES bank
India did say Yes! to Yes Bank’s call but it took time. In the
first half of the campaign, the clarity and consistency in Yes
Bank’s content strategy was absent. But as IPL picked up
momentum, so did Yes Bank.
They performed amazing in the second half of the campaign.
They actively used company’s hashtag with the game,
offered engaging banners, and GIFs and were among the few
companies successful in embedding brand voice with match
updates.
DHFL
The courier service company couldn’t make it to the
top 11. But they surely were creative with their
content. They were also able to engage their audience.
As Kingfisher and Amazon used stand-up comedians
for social media content, DHFL built a Facebook app
for play and win contest. They only lagged in strategic
use of hashtag, personal authentic responses, and
content type.
CEAT Tyres
The content strategy of strategic time-out partner was a big turn
off. They did create a dedicated and their cricket rating website
social media accounts were replete with followers. But they failed
to make the most of it.
There were also hardly an improvement in the second half of the
campaign when many brands shifted to top gears. They also were
silent on social conversations side and offered a very little in terms
of content.
Lava mobile
The Indian mobile manufacturer’s campaign ‘Never let
you down’ started when almost one third of the
tournament was over. Dhoni focused ad-campaign was
really creative but they were silent about IPL in their
campaign.
But it seems their content and social media team lacked
creativity when congratulating their brand ambassador
on biggest last over chase in IPL history. This didn’t use
relevant match hashtags to increase the reach of the
post.
Pg 15 Content Strategy
As we mentioned in the mid-IPL season report, display advertising is a broad arena. And if not strategically used, you might
miss many relevant corners of the display field. We covered desktop, mobile, static banners, and engagement ads to find the
top performers in display advertising. We found that the most of the e-commerce companies’ focus is on display marketing and
they really excel in this segment.
Display Marketing
Website for the game
Relevance of the website with the game
Website is hosted on the brand domain
Web traffic on the game related landing page
Purchased premium spots on sports website
Ads are related to the TV/digital campaign
On-air ad spot on TV/HOTSTAR
Official campaign website display in the commercial
Web Engagement Real time AD buys
Pg 16
Winner
Blue Cap
Brand who fielded well in Display Marketing
How we Scored?
Ÿ Freecharge outperformed all others in top 5 mainly due to its flawless game related platform and traffic they were able to
divert to their landing page.
Ÿ However, in real-time ad buys, FreeCharge and Ola Cabs simply stole the show
Pg 17 Display Marketing
x1Web EngagementKey Real time Ad buys
Blue Cap: Top 5
#1
#2
#3 #4 #5
Freecharge
From the first day of the campaign, FreeCharge was as active
on display advertising as it was on TV ads. Since their
targeted audience are smartphone users, the display
advertising was seen regularly on mobile apps. They
purchased real-time ads on espncricinfo app and maintained
visibility throughout the campaign.
OLA Cabs
Like FreeCharge, Ola Cabs understand the importance of display ads. But the most intelligent move from the on-demand cab
service was to buy ad-spots on Hotstar.
They also bought ad-spots on Sony along with the features on their app. Had they also purchased ad spots on other #matchday
sports websites, they could have easily top the chart. Overall, Ola Cabs was really innovative with their display ad campaign.
Vivo
The title sponsor of IPL started out loud with a dedicated
website for the game It is a game website where users can
predict and win prizes. Unfortunately, the website did not
garner much traffic. It did seem that the website will be
promoted by VIVO with the progress of IPL but as it turned
out they didn’t!
Pg 18 Display Marketing
Pg 19 Display Marketing
Kingfisher
Unlike its performance in content,
Kingfisher fared poorly in display
marketing. The had no section website
for IPL 2016 despite their strong presence
on TV ads and social media. The sports
section of the website had almost
negligible mention of IPL considering
their efforts on content and social media.
Yes Bank was silent on TV. They did not
show any commercial throughout IPL. But
they did made their brand visible smartly
on-air with ads appearing on the margins
of the screen. This was indeed a smart
move if one wants to show their ad
repetitively demanding the audience
interest without creating multiple
commercials.
Yes Bank, however, lacked commitment in
web development. Instead of making a
single web page about IPL, they could
have created a dedicated website to
engage the users. They had very strong
slogans and #IndiaBoleYes
#YesBankMaximum to cash on.
YES Bank
Conclusion
Pg 20
While there are a lot of insights one can draw from the report, the two most important ones remain this:
1. Even with a great content and social media strategy, it is not possible to reap benefits without a right display marketing
strategy. The brands who topped the chart have two things in common: they were consistent and spent on display marketing.
While your audience may interact with you on social media, it is really crucial to get engagement from them on a unique
platform of your brand. The best examples came from Britannia5050 who created a dedicated . The brands who could website
not get into top 11 did not focused on display marketing.
2. Content and social media do help in entertaining, educating, or inspire your audience. But in the case of an event like IPL, it
was not enough to engage users without giving them an offering related to the game. Ola Cabs offered two free match day
tickets. Freecharge’s spin the wheel is another good example. Vodafone’s super fan and fan army are also great concepts.
The marketing messages should promote these offers rather than the message of sales.
For example, Flipkart’s and Amazon’s campaign was too focused on their own brand
and they could not make into the top 11.
It may look like FreeCharge’s Rs. 100 crore marketing budget was the reason
for their success. But it was not the top in social media. Nor top in the
content strategy. The reason for FreeCharge’s success was its ability to
understand audience and the IPL pitch better than its competitors and
create a digital marketing strategy based on it. Its digital marketing
campaign was aligned and consistent across social media, content, and
display marketing.
Content Strategy
Display Marketing
Social Media
Score by Category
Top 11 Digital Marketing kings of IPL
1
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
11
1010
Overall Ranking
Subscribe to XOR Labs Blog and get latest Digital Marketing news, trends, and insights.
Have any digital marketing questions or a problem that you want to solve through digital marketing?
XOR Labs is a digital marketing company specializing in social media, content, and display marketing. We help
businesses maximise ROI using analytics, data-driven techniques, and crafting digital marketing campaigns.
We are helping shape the digital marketing narratives in ecommerce, technology, finance, healthcare, real
estate, entertainment, and education sector.
Subscribe
Free consultancy
About Us
Pg 22
Get your FREE digital marketing consultancy
www.xorlabs.in @xor_labs [email protected]
Subscribe now