brain activity duringtransitive and social action
TRANSCRIPT
Brain activity during transitive and social action observation in adults and
adolescents
M. Lesourd1,2, A. Afyouni1,2, F. Geringswald1,2, L. Raoul1,2, F.Cignetti3, J.
Sein4, B. Nazarian4, J.-L. Anton4, & M.-H. Grosbras1,2
1 Laboratoire de Neurosciences Cognitives (UMR 7291), Marseille, France 2 Fédération 3C, Marseille, France 3 Univ. Grenoble Alpes, TIMC-IMAG, Grenoble, France 4 INT Institut des Neurosciences de la Timone, UMR 7289, Centre IRM Fonctionnelle Cérébrale, Marseille, France
Background and rationale
� Action Observation Network (AON) = set of bilateral brain areas consistentlyengaged during observation of others’ action
Grosbras et al., Human Brain Mapping 2012
Intraparietal sulcus (IPS)
Lateral Occipitotemporal
Cortex (LOTC)
Posterior superior
temporal sulcus (pSTS)
Dorsal/Ventral Premotor
cortex (PMd/PMv)
Inferior Frontal
Gyrus (IFG)
Modulation of AON by the content of action
Iacoboni et al., 2004 Saggar et al., 2014 Centelles et al., 2011
Wurm et al., 2017
MVPA
Decoding social vs
non social action
Social vs individual interactions Social vs Non-social gestures Interacting vs isolated mvts
Development of the AON
� Core nodes of AON are present in children and adolescents (Ohnishi 2004)� Strength and extent of activity increase with age (Shaw 2011, 2012; Biagi 2016)
� From bilateral to more lateralized network (Biagi 2015)
� Occipitotemporal representation become more specific (Scherf 2007; Ross 2014; Peelen 2009; Pelphrey 2009)
� Structural changes in AON regions throughout adolescence (Gotgay 2010, Mills 2012)
� Improvement of social skills (Burnett 2011, Dumontheil 2012) � Inferring intentions of others
� adapting actions to social context, recognizing emotions…
Questions
� Does the representation of action categories in the AON change duringadolescence ?
� Differential activation for different categories of action (object-related; socially-
oriented)
� Fine-grain representation of action categories (coding of social or transitive dimensions)
� More drastic developmental changes in the representation of the « social » dimension
Material and Method
ParticipantsStimuli
Sociality
Transitivity
Tra
nsi
tive
Intr
an
siti
ve
Social Non-Social
Procedure
ST NT
SI NI
24 Adults aged 24-33 (26.6 ± 2.1), 13f
27 Adolescents aged 13-17 (15.0 ± 1.2), 13f
1 bloc = 3 videos (9 sec)
1 run = 20 blocs (6 min)
8 runs
Data analysis I: Univariate analysis
Preprocessing of fMRI data
� Realignement (6-head motion correction)
� Co-registration
� Normalization to MNI space
� Smoothing (5 FWHM)
� Physiological noise (WM & CSF)
� Removal of non-corrected volumes
exceeding FD = 2mm
Data analysis I: Univariate analysis
GLM
� Realignement (6-head motion correction)
� Co-registration
� Normalization to MNI space
� Smoothing (5 FWHM)
� Physiological noise (WM & CSF)
� Removal of non-corrected volumes
exceeding FD = 2mm4 regressors (NI, NT, SI and ST)
Design Matrix (e.g., 1 run)
Preprocessing of fMRI data
Univariate fMRI results
Data analysis II: Multi-voxel Pattern analysis (MVPA)
Preprocessing of fMRI data
� Realignement (6-head motion correction)
� Co-registration
� Normalization to MNI space
� Smoothing (5 FWHM)
� Physiological noise (WM & CSF)
� Removal of non-corrected volumes exceeding FD = 2mm
Data analysis II: Multi-voxel Pattern analysis (MVPA)
GLM
univariate
4 regressors (NI, NT, SI and ST)
Preprocessing of fMRI data
� Realignement (6-head motion correction)
� Co-registration
� Normalization to MNI space
� Smoothing (5 FWHM)
� Physiological noise (WM & CSF)
� Removal of non-corrected volumes exceeding FD = 2mm
Data analysis II: Multi-voxel Pattern analysis (MVPA)
� Realignement (6-head motion correction)
� Co-registration
� Normalization to MNI space
� Smoothing (5 FWHM)
� Physiological noise (WM & CSF)
� Removal of non-corrected volumes exceeding FD = 2mm
GLM
univariate
1 regressor for each trial (4 NI, 4 NT, 4 SI and 4 ST)
multivariate
Preprocessing of fMRI data
Data analysis II: Multi-voxel Pattern analysis (MVPA)
(1) ROI-based: Regions of the AON (Grosbras et al., 2012)
(2) Whole-brain: Searchlight = 12mm radius sphere (Kriegskorte 2006)
• Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier
IPS/SPL
Left: 213 ± 38 voxelsRight: 172 ± 28 voxels
PMv
Left: 140 ± 23 voxelsRight: 143 ± 25 voxels
pSTS
Left: 72 ± 13 voxelsRight: 75 ± 18 voxels
LOTC
Left: 236 ± 34 voxelsRight: 317 ± 52 voxels
Feature selection (F-test)
IPS/SPL: 104 voxelsPMv: 96 voxels
pSTS: 47 voxels
LOTC: 174 voxels
Data analysis II: Multi-voxel Pattern analysis (MVPA)
• Cross-validation scheme with leave-One-Run-Out
16 betas
16 betas
112 betas
112 betas
8 iterations
8 iterations
Data analysis II: Multi-voxel Pattern analysis (MVPA)
• Cross-validation scheme with leave-One-Run-Out
56 betas
56 betas 8 betas
8 betas
Decoding Social vs Non-Social actions
*** p < .001 (FDR-corrected)
MVPA: ROI-based decoding
Chance level
Adults > Ado
(p = .0098)
Adults > Ado
(p = .006)
Adults > Ado
(p = .0039)
LOTC
left rightPMv pSTS IPS/SPL
left right left right left right
Adolescents
Adults
Decoding Social vs Non-Social actions
MVPA: ROI-based decoding
LOTC
Left Right
PMv
Left Right
pSTS
Left Right
IPS/SPL
Left Right
WithinAdults > Ado
(p = .07)
Adults > Ado
(p = .068)
Adults > Ado
(p = .018)
* p < .05, *** p < .001 (FDR-corrected)Chance level
Decoding Social dimension across transitivity
MVPA: ROI-based decoding
Adults > Ado
(p = .06)
Adults > Ado
(p = .058)
Across
LOTCleft right
PMv pSTS IPS/SPL
left right left right left rightLOTC
left rightPMv pSTS IPS/SPL
left right left right left right
Adolescents
Adults
MVPA: ROI-based decodingDecoding Transitive vs Intransitive actions
Adults > Ado
(p = .015)
LOTC
left rightPMv pSTS IPS/SPL
left right left right left right
*** p < .001 (FDR-corrected)
Chance level
Adolescents
Adults
Decoding Transitive vs Intransitive actions
MVPA: ROI-based decoding
LOTC
Left Right
PMv
Left Right
pSTS
Left Right
IPS/SPL
Left Right
* p < .05, ** p < .01, *** p < .001 (FDR-corrected)Chance level
Decoding Transitive dimension across Sociality
MVPA: ROI-based decoding
Adults > Ado
(p = .001)
Within
Adults > Ado
(p = .03)
Across
LOTC
left rightPMv pSTS IPS/SPL
left right left right left right
LOTC
left right
PMv pSTS IPS/SPL
left right left right left right
Adolescents
Adults
MVPA: Searchlight (whole-brain)
MVPA: Searchlight (whole-brain)
MVPA: Searchlight (whole-brain)
MVPA: Searchlight (whole-brain)
Left IPS/SPL
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
NI
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
NT
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
SI
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
ST
Non-Social Intransitive (NI) Non-Social Transitive (NT)
Social Intransitive (SI) Social Transitive (ST)
*
r = .47 r = .61
MVPA: Multiclass decoding and age effect
Adolescents Adults
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
ST
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
NT
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
SI
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
NI
Right IPS/SPL
Non-Social Intransitive (NI) Non-Social Transitive (NT)
Social Intransitive (SI) Social Transitive (ST)
*
r = .39
MVPA: Multiclass decoding and age effect
Adolescents Adults
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
ST
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
NT
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
SI
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
125 175 225 275 325 375 425
NI
Right pSTS
Non-Social Intransitive (NI) Non-Social Transitive (NT)
Social Intransitive (SI) Social Transitive (ST)
* *
*
MVPA: Multiclass decoding and age effect
Adolescents Adults
Adolescents > Adults
Voxel-Based Morphometry analysis
Adolescents
Adults
Discussion
�AON is already present in adolescents� Sensitivity to the nature of action (sociality and transitivity)
� Fine-grain representations of action category
Discussion
�AON is already present in adolescents� Sensitivity to the nature of action (sociality and transitivity)
� Fine-grain representations of action category
�Adolescents recruit more regions of social brain (mPFC and TPj)
Discussion
�AON is already present in adolescents� Sensitivity to the nature of action (sociality and transitivity)
� Fine-grain representations of action category
�Adolescents recruit more regions of social brain (mPFC and TPj)
�Differences within the AON� Less reliable representation of the content of the action (pSTS and IPS)
Discussion
�AON is already present in adolescents� Sensitivity to the nature of action (sociality and transitivity)
� Fine-grain representations of action category
�Adolescents recruit more regions of social brain (mPFC and TPj)
�Differences within the AON� Less reliable representation of the content of the action (pSTS and IPS)
� IPS/SPL� Age effect for social intransitive actions
� Complex goal oriented behavior and social interaction (Tunik 2007)
� « Beyond grasping »
� Structural difference not associated with age effect
« Social aspect of action representation is still
maturing in adolescents, in bilateral IPS, a core node
of the AON »
Conclusion
Thanks for your attention!