board of education budget workshop 1.10.12 final 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 adopted budget *...

61
Board of Education Budget Workshop January 10, 2012

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Board of Education Budget Workshop

January 10, 2012

Page 2: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Budget Overview

2

Page 3: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Framework for Budget Development

• Align resources to support Strategic Plan 2014

• Keep strong academic focus coupled with data driven decision making

• Recognize and plan for the impact of the economic environment and employ sound fiscal management – respond to signals from state and local sources that funding may be limited

• Acknowledge uncertainty regarding expected funding levels from all sources, but use best information available to prepare plansources, but use best information available to prepare plan

• Identify savings opportunities through efficiencies and effective operations

• Request funding from County for sustaining operations, growth and new initiatives

• Establish flexibility in the budget to allow for various reduction levels

3

Page 4: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2011-12 Adopted Budget*

SOURCES

$328.3M - 28%

$18.3M - 1%

$662.3M - 57%

$160.5M - 14%

State

Federal and Other Grants

County

Other and Special Revenue

*Operating Budget only – does not include Capital or Enterprise Funds

4

Total Operating Budget $ 1.169 billion

Page 5: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2011-12 Adopted Budget*

USES

$123.6M - 11%

$69.2M - 6%

$1.7M - <1%

$16.9M - 1%

$725.8M - 62%

$232.2M - 20%

Salaries Benefits Purchased Services

Supplies and Materials Furniture and Equipment Other

* Operating Budget only – does not include Capital or Enterprise Funds

5

Total Operating Budget $ 1.169 billion

Page 6: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2011-12 Adopted Budget*

REVENUE CATEGORIES

13% 14%

8%

1%

Categorical27%

Dollar9%

6

State Position 36% County

28%

State Position Allotment State Categorical Allotment

Fed./Other Categorical Allotment State Dollar Allotment

Fed./Other Dollar Allotment County Purpose/Function

Page 7: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Average State General FundFY 2000-01 to FY 2009-10

Corporate Income, 5.8%

Franchise, 3.2%

Insurance, 2.6%

Other Taxes, 3.4%Non-Tax Transfers,

5.3%

7

Personal Income, 52.6%

Sales & Use, 27.2%

Source: Fiscal Research Division, General Fund Revenue and Budget Outlook, December 15, 2010

Page 8: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

County RevenuesFY 2011-12

Investment Interest, 0.22%

Sales Tax -Unclassified, 11.61%

Other Revenue, 0.56%

Net Property Taxes -Prior, 1.74%

8

Net Property Taxes -Current, 85.87%

Source: 2011-12 Mecklenburg County Adopted Budget Book

Page 9: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Trends

9

Page 10: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Public Schools Funding - % of State Budget

41.4%41.5%

41.2%

39.6%

39.2%

38.0%

38.9%

39.2%

37.9%38.00%

39.00%

40.00%

41.00%

42.00%

$7.5B

$7.5B

10

37.7%37.4%

37.9%

35.00%

36.00%

37.00%

38.00%

2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12

Source: North Carolina Post-Legislative Budget Summary 2011-12

Page 11: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Public Schools Funding - % of County Revenues

7.8% 8.4%9.0%

9.5% 10.0% 9.6%8.7%

10.3%11.3% 12.2% 11.8%

0.0% 0.0% 0.0%0.0% 0.0% 0.6%

0.5%0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5%

20.0%

25.0%

30.0%

35.0%

40.0%

45.0%

50.0%

11

37.2% 37.1% 35.6%33.4% 33.2% 34.1% 33.1% 33.6%

31.8% 31.4% 31.8%

0.0%

5.0%

10.0%

15.0%

20.0%

2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12

Operating Debt Services Capital Replacement

Note: Excludes fines and forfeituresSource: Mecklenburg County Adopted Budget Book

Page 12: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Sources of Revenue Trend

62.4% 58.9%58.3% 59.0% 59.9% 60.2%

55.7% 55.2%56.6%

4.5% 5.0%7.9% 7.7% 8.2% 8.5%

14.6% 16.1% 13.7%

1.1% 1.1% 1.9% 2.4% 2.8% 1.9% 1.9% 2.4% 1.6%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

32.0% 35.0% 31.9% 30.9% 29.1% 29.4% 27.8% 26.3% 28.1%

0%

10%

20%

30%

99-00 01-02 03-04 05-06 07-08 08-09 09-10 10-11 11-12

Recent Trend

County State Federal and Other Grants Other and Special Revenue

History

12

Page 13: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Per Pupil Expenditure Trend

$4,207 $4,257 $4,250 $4,472 $4,500$4,835

$5,314 $5,360

$4,756 $4,680$4,793

$358 $503 $574 $651 $586$604

$726 $758

$1,241 $1,370 $1,162$80 $116 $137

$141 $186$258

$247 $173$162 $202 $132

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

10,000

$2,504 $2,418 $2,327 $2,234 $2,354 $2,451 $2,581 $2,621 $2,374 $2,228 $2,376

-

1,000

2,000

3,000

01-02 02-03 03-04 04-05 05-06 06-07 07-08 08-09 09-10 10-11 11-12

County State Federal and Other Grants Other and Special Revenue

Total Per Pupil:

13

7,149$ 7,294$ 7,288$ 7,498$ 7,626$ 8,148$ 8,868$ 8,912$ 8,533$ 8,480$ 8,463$

Note: Reflects budgeted per pupil expenditure

Page 14: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Rank State Per Pupil Rank State Per Pupil

1 New Jersey $16,967 42 California $8,743

2 New York $16,922 43 North Dakota $8,541

3 Vermont $16,308 44 North Carolina $8,529

4 Rhode Island $15,384 45 Tennessee $8,199

5 Wyoming $15,345 46 Oklahoma $7,968

6 Massachusetts $14,766 47 Idaho $7,875

2009-10 Per Pupil Expenditures

Per Pupil Expenditure Ranking

6 Massachusetts $14,766 47 Idaho $7,875

7 Connecticut $14,472 48 Nevada $7,813

8 Maine $14,247 49 Mississippi $7,752

9 Maryland $14,244 50 Utah $6,859

10 District of Columbia

$13,519 51 Arizona $6,170

National Average = $10,586

14

Source: National Education Association

Page 15: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

At $8.1K per pupil, CMS spending level is well below other districts studied

$20.0

$15.0 $14.6 $14.1 $13.6

$12.0 $11.0

$10.1 $9.3

$8.6 $8.7 $8.1

$10

$15

$20

12

$/p

up

il ($

K)

Cross District Comparison of AverageK-12 Operating $/pupil SY0910 per pupil

funding levels were 13% less than the next lowest district studied

EDUCATION RESOURCE STRATEGIES, INC.

NCES-

Comparative

Wage-Index1.20 1.43 1.55 1.30 1.31 1.33 1.55 1.39 1.19

*Dollars represent K-12 operating budget/expenditure for year studied. Dollars adjusted for geography using the National Center for Education Statistics 2005 School District Comparative Wage Index. Dollars adjusted to 2009-10 (inflation adjusted) using the Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI calculator

Source: ERS analysis of CMS SY0708, SY0809, and SY0910 Expenditures; ERS comparative database

15

$0

$5

Ro

ch

est

er

Bo

sto

n

Wa

sh. D

.C.

Atla

nta

St.

Pa

ul

Ph

ilad

elp

hia

Pri

nc

e

Ge

org

e's

Ch

ica

go

Du

va

l

CM

S S

Y0708

CM

S S

Y0809

CM

S S

Y0910

Av

era

ge

K-1

2 $

/pu

pil

($K

)

1.31

EDUCATION RESOURCE STRATEGIES, INC. PRESENTATION DATE FEBRUARY 23, 2011

Page 16: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Historical Budget Reductions

16

Page 17: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Budget Reductions by AreaState & Local

State & Local Budgeted Total

Budget Total Positions* Positions

Area FY2010-2011 Reductions FY2010-2011 Reduced

Central Office 85,662,147 (6,613,642) (7.7%) 893 (60) (6.7%)

Support 82,232,185 (10,161,756) (12.4%) 1,573 (235) (14.9%)

Schools 769,086,720 (31,084,995) (4.0%) 11,809 (212) (1.8%)

Total 936,981,052 (47,860,393) (5.1%) 14,275 (506) (3.5%)

State & Local

State & Local Budgeted Total

Budget Total Positions* Positions

Area FY2009-2010 Reductions FY2009-2010 Reduced

Central Office 97,464,429 (9,405,886) (9.7%) 920 (61) (6.6%)

2011-12

2010-11

% of Area

Budget

(State &

Local)

% of Area

Budget

(State &

Local)

% of Area

Budget

(State &

Local)

% of Area

Budget

(State &

Local)

Central Office 97,464,429 (9,405,886) (9.7%) 920 (61) (6.6%)

Support 99,080,367 (9,601,118) (9.7%) 1,631 (80) (4.9%)

Schools 756,478,796 (39,739,730) (5.3%) 11,957 (675) (5.6%)

Total 953,023,592 (58,746,734) (6.2%) 14,508 (816) (5.6%)

State & Local

State & Local Budgeted Total

Budget Total Positions* Positions

Area FY2008-2009 Reductions FY2008-2009 Reduced

Central Office 103,776,661 (9,380,942) (9.0%) 999 (98) (9.8%)

Support 128,229,321 (11,217,486) (8.7%) 2,206 (133) (6.0%)

Schools 837,951,318 (66,304,143) (7.9%) 13,367 (736) (5.5%)

Total 1,069,957,300 (86,902,571) (8.1%) 16,572 (967) (5.8%)

2009-10

% of Area

Budget

(State &

Local)

% of Area

Budget

(State &

Local)

17

*Totals do not include Federal, Other, Child Nutrition, or ASEP positions

Page 18: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2009-10 Budget Reductions

Reductions in Budget Request

Accountability Initiatives (341,391)$

Achievement Zone (182,544)

Bonus Programs: Departments Performance (447,904)

Building Maintenance (4,136,700)

Central Office Non-Personnel Reductions (1,398,407)

Central Office- Staffing: 58 Total Positions Eliminated (4,251,691)

CMS TV Operations (107,006)

Dental Insurance (1,917,628)

Four-Day Work Week (281,000)

Graphic Productions (94,864)

Learning Communities (613,756)

18

Learning Communities (613,756)

Legal Services (121,474)

Reduce State Central Office Funds (2,426)

Reduce State Improving Student Accountability Funds (27,349)

Storage And Distribution Personnel (144,512)

Transportation Reduction (1,348,972)

Utilities (2,209,632)

Campus Security Associates Reduction (1,920,321)

Community Partners Support: Arts & Science/Classroom Central/Jr. Achievement (453,000)

Reduce State Technology Funds (314)

Page 19: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2009-10 Budget ReductionsReductions in Budget Request (cont.)

Academy Of Reading (57,625)$

Aquatic Director Positions: 2 Positions Eliminated (131,320)

AVID Program: Eliminated Except For Licensing Fees And Support For New Sites (382,834)

Bonus Programs: Local ABC, Principal Large School, Teaching Fellows, and Signing (5,015,658)

Career And Technical Education (2,977,936)

Charter School Reduction (1,332,274)

Counselors Allotment Formula Change: 16 High And Middle School Positions Eliminated (1,121,799)

Dance Teacher Positions: 10 Positions Eliminated (523,758)

English As A Second Language; ESL Assistants, SIFE Assistant (1,426,954)

Exceptional Children: BMT And Homebound Teachers (6) (1,219,295)

Extended Day/Extended Year (1,332,619)

Extended Employment For Opening New Schools (654,927)

2009-10 Budget Reductions (cont.)

19

Extended Employment For Opening New Schools (654,927)

Family School Advocates Positions: 31 Positions Eliminated (1,167,315)

Garinger Accelerated High School (138,116)

High School Challenge Funding (3,627,781)

Reduce State Textbook Funds (884,837)

Support Services Reorganization (1,855,144)

Talent Development Program (283,801)

Textbooks (2,677,587)

Teacher Asst Positions: 31 Positions Eliminated Due To Kindergarten Age Requirement (807,908)

Teacher Positions: 85 "Hold Harmless" Positions Eliminated (5,158,789)

Subtotal (52,779,168)$

Page 20: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2009-10 Budget Reductions (cont.)

Optional Reductions in Budget Request

Tier 1

Redirect Exceptional Children Teachers To IDEA ARRA Funds (1,619,411)$

Redirect Midwood Teachers To Title I ARRA Funds (1,014,152)

Reduce Furniture Cost Due To Lower Enrollment Growth (300,000)

Reduce State Staff Development Expenses (366,571)

Reduce Transportation Common Stops And Reduce Fuel Price (1,700,000)

Reduce Assistant Principals Due To Change In Formula (2,075,649)

Reduce Teacher Assistants Due To Change In 3rd Grade Formula (4,457,329) (11,533,112)

Tier 2

Reduce ADM Teachers (Elem.) - K-3 Ratio For Focus Schools From 1:16 to 1:17 (3,042,455)$

Reduce ADM Teachers (High) - Eliminate 9th Grade Academy Positions (869,273)

20

Reduce ADM Teachers (High) - Eliminate 9th Grade Academy Positions (869,273)

Reduce Teacher Assistants Due To Change In 3rd Grade Formula (4,370,497) (8,282,225)

Tier 3

Reduce ADM Teachers (High) - Increase Grade 10-12 Ratio From 1:26 to 1:27 (6,278,082)$

Reduce ADM Teachers (Middle) - Increase Grade 6-8 Ratio From 1:23.5 to 1:24 (1,303,909) (7,581,991)

Tier 4

Reduce ADM Teachers (Elem.) - Increase Grade 4-5 Ratio From 1:26.5 to 1:27.5 (1,738,546)$

Reduce ADM Teachers (High) - Increase Grade 10-12 Ratio From 1:27 to 1:28.5 (3,042,455)

Reduce ADM Teachers (Middle) - Increase Grade 6-8 Ratio From 1:24 to 1:24.5 (1,448,788)

Reduce Assistant Principals Due To Change In Formula (1,509,562) (7,739,351)

Subtotal (35,136,679)$

Page 21: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2009-10 Budget Reductions (cont.)

Additional Reductions in Adopted Budget

Eliminate All Grandfathered Transportation (377,487)$

Eliminate Billingsville Expanded Day Program (350,697)

Eliminate C & I Position And Department Expenses (249,378)

Eliminate Discovery Place Field Trips (138,000)

Eliminate Junior Achievement-Biz Town Field Trip (187,600)

Eliminate Magnet Office Positions (98,007)

Eliminate Middle School Literacy Coaches (925,710)

Eliminate Transportation For Required Field Trips (235,862)

Redirect Local Bright Beginnings Expenditures To ARRA (8,426,499)

Reduce Human Resources Staffing (225,281)

Reduce Mentor Pay (224,676)

21

Reduce Mentor Pay (224,676)

Reduce Transport. Expenses By Adj. Bell Schedule (Northwest and JT Williams) (600,000)

Reduce Communications Staffing (141,944)

Reduce CTE Equipment (600,000)

Reduce State Technology Funds (170,944)

Subtotal (12,952,085)

Added Back: (teachers allocated to zones, non-instructional staff, and staff

development) 13,965,361

Total Reductions (86,902,571)$

Page 22: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2010-11 Budget Reductions

Reductions in Budget Request

Scenario 1

Bright Beginnings – staffing and furniture costs (76,836)$

Career and Technical Ed – staffing and reduction in textbooks (228,905)

Central Office non-personnel expenses (1,249,548)

Central Office staffing – 25 positions across departments (1,736,071)

CMS TV – Staffing and operating costs (76,452)

Extended employment for opening new schools (663,103)

Learning Communities/Achievement Zone Reorganization (3,597,731)

Legal expenses (77,758)

Mileage rate reimbursement decrease (from 55 to 50 cents per mile) (110,922)

22

Mileage rate reimbursement decrease (from 55 to 50 cents per mile) (110,922)

State Textbooks (5,435,273)

Storage and Distribution – reduce deliveries for Child Nutrition and reduce postage (169,289)

Technology – deinstallation of mainframe (438,500)

Transportation expenses (742,031)

Utilities – various energy conservation measures (1,710,567)

Walton Plaza operating costs and transportation lease costs (294,486)

Subtotal (16,607,472)$

Page 23: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2010-11 Budget Reductions (cont.)

Optional Reductions in Budget Request

Scenario 2

Consolidate extended learning opportunities for HS students (343,540)$

Eliminate district's cost for employee dental insurance (1,885,241)

Expand magnet shuttle stops for four high schools (2,258,896)

Implementing Magnet Shuttle stops beyond 5 mile radius (full Magnet Middle Schools) (1,241,977)

Reduce Building Services positions (1,382,798)

Reduce bus driver positions (1,486,242)

Reduce Campus Security Associate positions (178,248)

Reduce classroom supplies and furniture (510,000)

Reduce CTE positions (non-classroom teachers) (477,436)

23

Reduce ESL supplies and materials (255,807)

Reduce extended day and summer school programs (370,583)

Reduce funds for mobile units (1,206,000)

Reduce funds for utilities (702,104)

Reduce media supplies and materials (150,000)

Reduce signing bonuses (1,898,092)

Reduce Staff Development (312,000)

Reduce Talent Development supplies and staff development (382,430)

Reduce tuition reimbursement funds (400,000)

Subtotal (15,441,394)$

Page 24: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2010-11 Budget Reductions (cont.)

Optional Reductions in Budget Request (cont.)

Scenario 3

Adjust bell schedule at Marie G. Davis (600,000)$

Adjust school secretary allotment (formula change) (1,102,148)

Eliminate CMS-TV - retain funding for Board meetings to be televised (346,122)

Eliminate Exceptional Children support positions (363,205)

Eliminate funding for AP/IB Exams- students to pay (1,279,086)

Eliminate Middle School Athletics (1,266,354)

Eliminate teacher positions (121 teacher positions added back 2009-10) (6,383,113)

Mentor Pay (1,031,945)

Modification of employment term - Technology Facilitator, IB Coordinators (38,094)

24

Modification of employment term for some central office and school based positions (1,109,592)

Modification of small high school allotment (1,446,101)

Modification of Teacher Assistant model (1,677,029)

Reduce CTE positions (1,129,803)

Reduce ESL positions (1,810,740)

Reduce School-based positions (.5AP and Media Specialist) (112,125) (19,695,457)

Scenario 4

Eliminate K-3 FOCUS school ratio of 1:17 (1,271,634)$

Eliminate teacher positions (added back 2009-10) (8,069,985) (9,341,619)

Yellow shaded items are reductions restored

Page 25: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2010-11 Budget Reductions (cont.)

Optional Reductions in Budget Request (cont.)

Scenario 5

ADM Teachers (Elementary) - 4-5 maintain weight of 1.3: increase ratio from

1:27.5 to 1:28.5 (1,320,543)$ ADM Teachers (High) maintain weight of 1.3: increase 9th ratio from 1:25 to 1:26;

increase 10-12 ratio from 1:28.5 to 1:29.5 (2,298,723)

ADM Teachers (Middle) maintain weight of 1.3: increase ratio from 1:24.5 to 1:25.5 (2,592,177)

Change in Teacher Assistant formula- K from 1:25 to 1:31, 1-2 from 1:38 to 1:44 (4,766,660) (10,978,103)

Total Reductions (55,456,573)

Added Back: (funds to cover state shortfall in transportation and school

admin; capital replacement; non-instructional support-ARRA cliff) 13,317,311

25

admin; capital replacement; non-instructional support-ARRA cliff) 13,317,311

Total Reductions (58,746,734)$

Yellow shaded items are reductions restored

Page 26: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Reductions in Adopted Budget

Operationalized & Efficiencies

Comprehensive review - School Closures (5,210,576)$

Average salary adjustment (2,176,485)

Midwood relocation (969,617)

Redirect contracted services to state technology funds (651,321)

Eliminate annual maintenance fee for AAL NC WISE (245,000)

Utilities (reducing consumption) (1,903,552)

Eliminate prior year extended employment (79,713)

Transportation - Bell schedule and 7 hour instructional day for all students (4,009,059) (15,245,323)

Tier 1

2011-12 Budget Reductions

Tier 1

Central Office Reductions (8,785,421)$

DSSF funding for high school plans (1,229,914)

Achievement Zone - school based positions (689,290)

Media Specialists - 1 position (69,019)

Bonuses- Incentive, Critical Needs, Signing (4,293,933) (15,067,577)

26

Page 27: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Tier 2Reduce funds for equitable supplies and materials (125,000)$

CTE - 38 teachers (2,504,830)

Alternative Ed (1,146,108)

CSA's - 10 Rapid Response (362,880)

SQR training (135,000)

Building Services - trade positions (712,422)

Custodians (1,734,753)

Academic Competitions (87,559) (6,808,552)

Tier 3Extended Day allotment to schools (1,052,532)$

CTE - 10 teachers (659,170)

107 teacher-level positions for Zones and leave* (6,338,359)

2011-12 Budget Reductions (cont.)

107 teacher-level positions for Zones and leave* (6,338,359)

Talent Development - 6 teachers (412,380) CSA's - 16 positions (543,160) (9,005,601)

Tier 4Bright Beginnings Centers' administrative, clerical and custodial costs (1,733,340)$ (1,733,340)

Grand Total (47,860,393)$

27

Yellow shaded items are reductions restored

*Positions were ultimately restored for 2011-12 only

Page 28: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

2012-13 Budget Outlook

28

Page 29: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

State Budget Outlook

• General Fund revenue through October is $115 million above the revenue target

• Despite little improvement in employment, withholding income tax and sales tax collections continue to meet or surpass their targets

• Many of the volatile revenue sources do not show up until the 2nd half of the fiscal year

• Without further strengthening in the State’s economy, revenue for the second quarter could struggle to meet modest target increases relative to the first quarter’s target

29

quarter’s target

• The budget revenue forecast was built on a scenario where the State’s economic conditions would continue to improve each quarter of the fiscal year

• An improving economy will be needed to continue meeting the monthly revenue targets

• Most economists believe the economic recovery is regaining strength. Unfortunately, economic activity will be weak, which means unemployment will remain elevated

Source: Fiscal Research Division, December 2011

Page 30: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

CMS Budget Outlook

• Federal EduJobs funds of $25.5M expire September 30, 2012

• Budget plan is based upon the 2nd year of the state biennial budget which includes an increase in the LEA discretionary reduction of $7.0M

• Proactive planning during the 2011-12 budget process resulted in our being positioned to cover the expected funding reductions above

30

above

• County funding is still uncertain at this time – greatest challenge will continue to be juggling competing needs for county, debt, and education services

• Staff will continue to identify efficiencies and effectiveness savings

• Plan for increase in enrollment of approximately 2,000 students

Page 31: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Academic Achievement

31

Page 32: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Test

Change (without retest)

Change (with

retest)

Math 3 +3 +2

Math 4 +2 +3

Math 5 +2 +2

Math 6 +4 +3

Math 7 +3 +4

Math 8 +6 +4

Reading 3 +1 +2

Reading 4 +1 +1

Test

Change (without retest)

Change (with

retest)

Algebra I +3 +8

Algebra II +2 +9

Biology +0.2 +6

Civics +1 +6

English I +4 +9

Geometry +4 +10

Physical Science +3 +10

2009-10 Results

Reading 4 +1 +1

Reading 5 +3 +3

Reading 6 +4 +4

Reading 7 +3 +3

Reading 8 +4 +3

Science 5 +8 +9

Science 8 +6 +6

US History +5 +10

Writing +1 n/a

SAT +5 n/a

AP +2 n/a

2009-2010 Progress was made in 25 of 25 areas

32

Page 33: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Test

Change (without retest)

Change (with

retest)

Math 3 -2 -2

Math 4 +2 +1

Math 5 0 -1

Math 6 0 -1

Math 7 +2 0

Math 8 0 +1

Reading 3 0 -1

-1 0

Test

Change (without retest)

Change (with

retest)

Algebra I -8 -6

Algebra II -6 -6

Biology 0 -1

Civics -1 -2

English I -3 +4

Physical Science -1 +1

2010-11 Results

Reading 4 -1 0

Reading 5 0 0

Reading 6 +1 0

Reading 7 +1 +1

Reading 8 +1 +1

Science 5 +5 +3

Science 8 +5 +4

US History -3 +3

Writing -2 n/a

2010-11 Progress was made in 7 of 22 areas

33

Page 34: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

CMS NAEP Performance

• 4th grade

– Tops all other districts in math

– Top 3 districts in reading

– Flat in math and reading from previous test

• 8th grade

– Top 2 districts in math

– Tops all other districts in reading

– Flat in math from previous test

– Up in reading from previous test

34

Page 35: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

NAEP Results

35

Page 36: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Cost of Living Salary Increase for all CMS

EmployeesEmployees

36

Page 37: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

“It takes a village to raise a child”

37

Page 38: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Strategic Cuts through Recession

“…least impact on Student Achievement mostly protecting school

based resources

…asking our team members to provide more with and for less

…that strategy paid off…. but the trend is turning…”

38

Page 39: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

• Last salary increase in 2008

• Cost of Living up 7.58% since 2008

• CMS medical benefits more costly

Cumulative Financial Impact

Example

$40,000

-$3,000

• CMS medical benefits more costly -$500

$36,500Approximate Current Value =

39

Page 40: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Stresses on Employees and Organization

• Withdrawals against their retirement savings accounts

• Work related stress rising

• Voluntary turnover up 19.5%

• Leaving for better pay up 39%• Leaving for better pay up 39%

• More holding second jobs

• Slowing student achievement gains

40

Page 41: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Investment

3% cost of living increase for all employees and

continuation of market adjustment

$25-$30M

41

Page 42: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Attracting High Caliber New Hires

42

Page 43: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Voluntary Attrition on Rise

1688 1678

2018

1,500

2,000

2,500

Nu

mb

er

of

Lice

nse

d a

nd

No

n-L

ice

nse

d E

mp

loy

ee

s

Total Licensed Employees Total Non-Licensed Employees Total Turnover

43

948986

1165

581

740692

853

372

953

0

500

1,000

2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 YTD

Nu

mb

er

of

Lice

nse

d a

nd

No

n

School Year

Page 44: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Returning to Hiring Growth

2184

2576

4760

4081

3108

2354

3138 3177

2,500

3,000

3,500

4,000

4,500

5,000

Nu

mb

er

of

New

Em

plo

yee H

ires

Licensed Non-Licensed Total Hires for School Year

44

2184

1949

1562

1235

1514

1736

2132

1546

1119

16241441

0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 (July-Dec 2011)

Nu

mb

er

of

New

Em

plo

yee H

ires

School Year

Page 45: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Employees are Most Important!

45

Page 46: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Building a Bench: A Process

46

Page 47: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Recruiting Strategies

• Promote opportunities

• Direct sourcing

– Hard to fill, experienced

– College

• Selection• Selection

– Prescreening

– Interview process

47

Page 48: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Increase High School Staffing

48

Page 49: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Alignment with Strategic Plan 2014 Goals

• Effective Teaching and Leadership

• Graduation Cohort

• Teaching and Learning through Technology

49

Page 50: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Impact

• Reduce class size

• Increase graduation cohort rate

• Increase personalization for students

• Reduce ninth grade retentions

50

• Provide freedom and flexibility with accountability to principals

• 28 high schools

• 38,716 high school students

– 11,834 ninth grade students

Page 51: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Results

• Graduation Cohort Coach at Mallard Creek High School

– 93.1 graduation cohort rate

• Distance Learning Teacher at Independence High School

– 688 students enrolled in North Carolina Virtual High School

51

Page 52: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Investment

Changing the 9th grade ratio from 1:25.0 to 1:22.5 yields approximately 62 additional positions

$3.1M

52

Page 53: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

H.S. Instructional Technology FacilitatorsTechnology Facilitators

53

Page 54: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Background

Critical ThinkerStrong Team Contributor

Effective Problem Solver

Capable Technology User

54

Page 55: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Build Capacity Through Professional Development

A technology integrator should be

available in each building to train and building to train and support teachers as

they learn to use technology effectively

in classrooms. (Star, 2009)

55

Page 56: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Results

Only through ongoing, consistent, leveled professional development

opportunities can users gain the technology skills and confidence

needed to teach the new literacies.

(Larson, Middle & Ribble, 2010)

Teachers cite four areas for

PD as most essential:

content knowledge, U.S. investments in teacher

learning appear to be

56

content knowledge,

classroom management,

students with special

needs, and technology.

(Adamson, Darling-Hammond & Wei, 2010)

learning appear to be

increasingly focused on the least

effective models of professional

development—short-term

workshops that research

suggests are unlikely to

influence practice and student

achievement.

(Adamson, Darling-Hammond & Wei, 2010)

Page 57: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Impact

Research indicates that computer technology can help support

learning and is especially useful in developing the higher-order

skills of critical thinking, analysis, and scientific inquiry “by

engaging students in authentic, complex tasks within

collaborative learning contexts.”

(Roschelle, Pea, Hoadley, Gordin, & Means, 2000)

32 Schools impacted2,372 Teachers impacted38,814 Students impacted

57

Page 58: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Alignment

Strategic Plan 2014Teaching Our Way to the Top

Area 4Teaching and Learning Through Technology

Key StrategyExpand student and staff access to, and use of, technology-Expand student and staff access to, and use of, technology-

based educational services.

58

CMS high school students identify “keeping up with technology” as one of the five most important issues facing CMS.

(UNC Charlotte Urban Institute, 2011)

Page 59: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Investment

23 Instructional Technology FacilitatorsX $57,500 $1,322,500

59

Page 60: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

Key Dates (tentative)

Date/Time Activity

January 24 * Board of Education budget work session

February 14 * Board of Education budget work session

February 28 * Board of Education budget work session

March 13 * Superintendent's 2012-13 Budget Recommendation presented

to Board of Education

March 27 * Public hearing on Superintendent's 2012-13 Budget

Recommendation

60

Recommendation

March 28 * Board of Education budget work session

April 10 @ 6pm * Board of Education's 2012-13 Proposed Budget including

county request approved

*Board meeting dates

Page 61: Board of Education budget workshop 1.10.12 FINAL 10... · 2012. 1. 10. · 2011-12 Adopted Budget * USES $123.6M - 11% $69.2M - 6% $1.7M -

• Closing remarks

Conclusion

61