bearing design and troubleshooting 11-7-12...bad bond – bare metal; no tin/babbitt attached loose...

26
© John Crane © 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate. Bearing Design and Troubleshooting STLE Houston Section November 7, 2012

Upload: others

Post on 14-May-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Bearing Design and Troubleshooting

STLE Houston Section

November 7, 2012

Page 2: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

2

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Primary Functions Primary Functions of of Fluid Film Bearings:Fluid Film Bearings:

� Maintain Rotor Position

� Minimize Friction

� Provide Damping

� Sacrificial Component

Page 3: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

3

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Three Requirements for FF DevelopmentThree Requirements for FF Development

� Viscous Fluid

� Relative Motion

� Converging Flow Area

Page 4: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

4

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Three Requirements for FF DevelopmentThree Requirements for FF Development

Viscosity (µ)

A materials resistance to a

change in form – a

measure of internal friction

Page 5: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

5

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Three Requirements for FF DevelopmentThree Requirements for FF Development

� Relative Motion

V1 = U

V2 = 0

U

Vavg = U/2

Page 6: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

6

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Three Requirements for FF DevelopmentThree Requirements for FF Development

� Converging Flow Area

Page 7: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

7

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

F rict io n vs. Z N / P

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

ZN/P

B oundary M ixed F ilm Full F ilm

Z = Dynamic Viscosity of Lubricant at Supply Temperature (cp); N = Rotational Speed (rpm); P = Specific Load on the

Bearing (psi)

Page 8: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

8

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Fluid Film DevelopmentFluid Film Development

+ -

Page 9: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

9

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Three Requirements for FF DevelopmentThree Requirements for FF Development

+

-

Page 10: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

10

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

�Most Common Cause of Bearing

Failure

�Easiest Problem to Identify

�Often the Hardest to Correct

Problem: MisalignmentProblem: Misalignment

Page 11: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

11

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

200 PSI

200 PSI

185 F

Peak Pressure 3 to 4 Times Peak Pressure 3 to 4 Times

Projected LoadProjected Load

Fluid Film DevelopmentFluid Film Development

Page 12: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

12

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

200 PSI

200 PSI

220 F

Peak Pressure Peak Pressure

10 to 12 Times 10 to 12 Times

Projected LoadProjected Load

MisalignementMisalignement

Page 13: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

13

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Bearing Maximum Capacity is a Function

of Temperature and Pressure

ASTM BASTM B--23 Gr2 Yield Strength vs. Temperature23 Gr2 Yield Strength vs. Temperature

Page 14: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

14

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

MisalignmentMisalignment

Page 15: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

15

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Babbitt Extrusion Due to

Edge Loading

TC on Unloaded End

MisalignmentMisalignment

Page 16: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

16

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Uneven Wear Pattern

Evidence of Misalignment

MisalignmentMisalignment

Page 17: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

17

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

MisalignmentMisalignment

Page 18: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

18

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

••Correct Unit AlignmentCorrect Unit Alignment

200 PSI

200 PSI

185 F

Install Bearing Designed to Compensate for MisalignmentInstall Bearing Designed to Compensate for Misalignment

MisalignmentMisalignment

Page 19: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

19

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad BondLoose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond

What is the Difference?

Page 20: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

20

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Base MetalBond Line/Tin

Babbitt

Babbitt FatigueBabbitt Fatigue

Page 21: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

21

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Babbitt FatigueBabbitt Fatigue

Page 22: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

22

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Page 23: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

23

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Base MetalBond Line/Tin

Babbitt

Bad BondBad Bond

Page 24: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

24

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Bad BondBad Bond

Page 25: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

25

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

Page 26: Bearing Design and Troubleshooting 11-7-12...Bad Bond – Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Bearing Design and

© John Crane

26

© 2010 John Crane Inc. Company confidential. Do not duplicate.

What is the Difference?

Fatigue Fatigue –– Bond Intact; Tin/Babbitt Still AttachedBond Intact; Tin/Babbitt Still Attached

Bad Bond Bad Bond –– Bare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt AttachedBare Metal; No Tin/Babbitt Attached

Loose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad BondLoose Babbitt: Fatigue vs. Bad Bond