babylon garments & dresses ltd - fair factories...

22
Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N, 90.351717E) 30 March 2014 1

Upload: vuminh

Post on 20-May-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka

(+23.783559N, 90.351717E)30 March 2014

1

Page 2: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

2

Building Observations

Page 3: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

3

Columns appear to be stressed in excess of normal design limits

Page 4: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

4Column Strength

Outline calculations indicate column working stress is in excess of normal design limits.

Building Engineer is to perform detailed calculations and concrete tests to prove column size and (if required):- Reduce loads by vacating floors- Reinforce columns

Tested Basement Floor Column – Stone Chips

Typical column layout

Page 5: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

5

Columns supported by the slab on the 8th and 9th floors

Page 6: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

6Columns supported by slab/beams

8th Floor

9th Floor

9th Floor

Columns not on Grid at 8th

and 9th floors level.

Page 7: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

7

Stability of steel roof to dining area to be reviewed by Building Engineer

Page 8: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

8Steel Roof to Dining Area

Roof structure to Dining Area not shown on the structural design drawings, no bracing visible, may be susceptible to wind uplift. Building Engineer to review.

Building Engineer to confirm support/connection detail at these locations.

Page 9: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

9

Falling hazardsStairwell canopies, Mast and Column/Beam at roof level.

Page 10: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

10

Stairwell canopy construction very light, may be susceptible to wind uplift.Building Engineer to review.

Stability of mast unknown.Building Engineer to review.

Possible falling objects

Page 11: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

11

Columns at ground floor level are susceptible to impact loading from

vehicles.

Page 12: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

12Vehicle impact loading.

Column at ground floor level are susceptible to impact loading from vehicles.

VehicleEntrance

Page 13: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

13

Cantilevered Window Cills/Brick Infill

Page 14: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

14

Building engineer to monitor/review movement of brickwork upstands on

cantilever slabs

Cracking noted on cills. Building engineer to monitor.

Page 15: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

15

Water ingress

Page 16: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

16

Tank overflow spills onto roofs.

Building engineer to monitor water ingress and take

preventative measures if necessary Water staining in a number of soffits.

Page 17: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

17

Proximity of River

Page 18: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

18

River is very close to structure though

management say the building has never flooded.

Visual evidence of damp in basement.

Building engineer to monitor building for signs of water

ingress and appropriate action to be taken if ingress

occurs.

Page 19: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

19

Priority Actions

Page 20: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

20

Problems Observed

Item 1; Columns appear to be stressed in excess of normal design limitsItem 2; Columns supported by the slab alone on the 8th and 9th floors.Item 3; Stability of unpermitted steel roof to dining area to be reviewed by

Building Engineer to confirm that it is braced and adequately designed to resist high wind loading.

Item 4; Falling hazards – stairwell canopies, mast at roof level.Item 5; Columns at ground floor level are susceptible to impact loading

from vehicles.Item 6; Cantilevered Window Cills/Brick InfillItem 7; Water ingress into building

Item 8; Proximity of River

Page 21: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

21

Item No. Observation Recommended Action Plan Recommended Timeline

1A check on column loads and

column design is required

Building Engineer to provide calculations showing the structural adequacy of all columns, taking into account the loading plans and all built structure including additions beyond the original design.

6-weeks

2A check on column loads and

column design is required

Verify insitu concrete stresses either by cores (min of 4 no. 100mm dia.) or existing cylinder strength data for ground floor columns.

6-weeks

3A check on column loads and

column design is requiredCreate controlled loading plans for all floors, designating where storage can be placed and can not be placed.

6-months

4Columns supported by the

slab alone on the 8th and 9th floors.

Building Engineer to provide calculations showing the structural adequacy of all Slab/Beams to take point loading of columns, taking into account the proposed loading and all built structure including additions beyond the original design. Verify insitu concrete stresses either by 4 cores or existing cylinder strength data for the slabs.

6-weeks

5

No bracing observed in steel roof structure. Stability of

steel roof to Dining Area to be reviewed by Building

Engineer to confirm that it is braced and adequately

designed to resist high wind loading

The steel roof over the Dining Area should be reviewed by the Building Engineer and, if required, upgraded to support code vertical and wind loads or the area should be vacated and removed.

6-weeks

Page 22: Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD - Fair Factories …accord.fairfactories.org/accord_bgd_files/1/Audit_Files/...Babylon Garments & Dresses LTD 2-B/1, Darusalam Road, Mirpur, Dhaka (+23.783559N,

22

Item No. Observation Recommended Action Plan Recommended Timeline

6Falling hazards – stairwell

canopies, mast at roof level.Lightweight canopies over stair-cores access to roofs to be strengthened or removed

6-weeks

7Falling hazards – stairwell

canopies, mast at roof level.The connection of the mast to the roof structure is to be assessed by the building engineer for stability.

6-weeks

8Falling hazards – stairwell

canopies, mast at roof level.

Building Engineer to review all of the above and provide calculations and drawings demonstrating the adequacy of the structure/connections and /or evidence of how the structures are made safe

6-weeks

9Columns at ground floor level

are susceptible to impact loading from vehicles

Column to be protected from vehicle impact. 6-weeks

10Cantilevered Window

Cills/Brick Infill

Building Engineer to monitor these elements of the structure for signs of further cracking/movement and take preventative action if necessary.

6-months

11 Water ingress into buildingBuilding Engineer to identify locations/sources of water ingress and remove/divert source to avoid contact with concrete/reinforcement of structure.

6-months

12 Proximity of RiverBuilding Engineer to monitor the structure for signs of water ingress and take preventative action if necessary.

6-months