automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

37
1 EN 1140 ENGINEERING DESIGN ELECTRONIC AND TELECOMMUNICATION DEPARTMENT UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA BELL AND ALARM RAILWAY LEVEL CROSSING SYSTEM-PROGRESS REPORT 120063M CHANDIKA K.S.G.N. 120167K GANEWATTHE A.V. 120171R GAYAN V.G.T. 120187V GUNATHILAKE S.A. 120318C KUMARA H.P.D.P. 120613C SHANIKA L.U.K.T. 120680C WANNIGE V.M. 120708X WICKRAMASURIYA P.I.L. 120729L WIJETHILAKA M.D.S.R. TEAM 05 120740L ZOYSA H.K.G. TRACK CIRCUIT

Upload: isuru-wickramasuriya

Post on 16-Jul-2015

715 views

Category:

Engineering


4 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

1

EN 1140 ENGINEERING DESIGN

ELECTRONIC AND TELECOMMUNICATION DEPARTMENT

UNIVERSITY OF MORATUWA

BELL AND ALARM RAILWAY LEVEL CROSSING SYSTEM-PROGRESS

REPORT

120063M CHANDIKA K.S.G.N.

120167K GANEWATTHE A.V.

120171R GAYAN V.G.T.

120187V GUNATHILAKE S.A.

120318C KUMARA H.P.D.P.

120613C SHANIKA L.U.K.T.

120680C WANNIGE V.M.

120708X WICKRAMASURIYA P.I.L.

120729L WIJETHILAKA M.D.S.R. TEAM 05

120740L ZOYSA H.K.G. TRACK CIRCUIT

Page 2: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

2

CONTENTS

1. Abstract----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 05

2. Introduction------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 06

2.1. Overview in Railway level Crossing Systems in Sri Lanka--------------------07

2.2. Present Track-Relay System and track circuits in Sri Lanka-----------------08

2.2.1. Track circuit-----------------------------------------------------------------------09

2.2.2.Track Relay System---------------------------------------------------------------11

3. Literature research-----------------------------------------------------------------------12

3.1. Track circuit--------------------------------------------------------------------------13

3.1.1. Joint less track circuits-------------------------------------------------------14

3.1.2. History of track circuit-------------------------------------------------------15

3.2. Audio frequency track circuit---------------------------------------------------16

3.2.1. Dual code high frequency track circuits---------------------------------16

3.2.2. Train detection----------------------------------------------------------------17

3.2.3. Automatic speed commands----------------------------------------------17

4. Field visit

4.1. Field visit no 01--------------------------------------------------------------------20

4.2. Field visit no 02--------------------------------------------------------------------20

5. Suggested system designs-------------------------------------------------------------21

5.1. Concept no1: Usage of electromagnetic theory--------------------------22

5.1.1. Overview---------------------------------------------------------------------22

5.1.2. Circuit design----------------------------------------------------------------22

Page 3: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

3

5.1.3. Method-------------------------------------------------------------------------22

5.1.4. Components used in the circuit ------------------------------------------23

5.2. Concept no 02---------------------------------------------------------------------24

5.2.1. Circuit diagram----------------------------------------------------------------24

5.2.2. Principles and operations--------------------------------------------------25

6. Implemented concept for the project------------------------------------------------26

6.1. Overview ----------------------------------------------------------------------------26

6.2. How it works------------------------------------------------------------------------26

6.3. schematic design-------------------------------------------------------------------27

6.4. PCB design---------------------------------------------------------------------------28

6.5. Important parts in the circuit---------------------------------------------------29

6.5.1. Performed loops------------------------------------------------------------29

6.5.2. Loop extension cable------------------------------------------------------29

6.5.3. Loop train detector---------------------------------------------------------29

6.6. System implementation---------------------------------------------------------30

6.6.1. Location of the loop--------------------------------------------------------30

6.6.2. Loop installation------------------------------------------------------------31

6.6.3. Detector installation-------------------------------------------------------31

6.7. Sensitivity of the implemented system ------------------------------------32

6.7.1. Sensitivity to temperature -----------------------------------------------32

6.7.2. Trouble shooting------------------------------------------------------------32

7. Fail safe system available with the implemented system-----------------------33

Page 4: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

4

8. Identical track circuits currently existing in the world railway industry------34

10. Summary-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------35

Page 5: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

5

ABSTRACT

The objective of this project is to identify and investigate on problems related with

unprotected railway level crossings existing in Sri Lanka and provide some solution by

implementing an automated bell and alarm railway level crossing system. Having taken into

consideration the increasing number of accidents at unprotected level crossings, it essential

to have new inventions to help reduce the number of accidents at unprotected level

crossings.At the end of this project it is intended to develop a cost effective, reliable, easily

maintainable automated system for unprotected railway systems. As team 05 we are

implementing the track circuit part of that automated system. This report provides the

detailed progression of the particular section track circuit.

Page 6: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

6

1. INTRODUCTION

The place where track and highway/road intersects each other at the same level is known as

“level crossing”. There are mainly two types of level crossing they are manned level crossing

and unmanned level crossing.

Railways being the cheapest mode of transportation are preferred over all the other means

.When we go through the daily newspapers we come across many railway accidents

occurring at unmanned railway crossings. This is mainly due to the carelessness in manual

operations or lack of workers. We come up with a solution for the same. Using simple

electronic components we have tried to automate the control of railway gates.

Here, in this paper we are working on the track circuit. A track circuit is a simple electrical

device used to detect the absence of a train on rail tracks, used to inform signallers and

control relevant signals.

The Purpose of Track Circuits in a railway level crossing

The track circuit is a device designed to continuously prove the absence of a train from a given section of track; it cannot absolutely prove the presence of a train, since its designed failure mode is to give the same indication as if a train is present. By proving the absence of a train, a clear track circuit can be used to confirm that it is safe to set a route and permit a train to proceed. Track circuit provides locations on the location of the trains, and this information is used to

command train speed so that trains operate safely.

Page 7: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

7

1.1 Overview in Railway level Crossing Systems in Sri Lanka

The island's first railroad line, from Colombo to Kandy, was opened in 1867, and in the

1980s Sri Lanka Railways had 1,944 kilometres of railroad track. In early 1988, service in

Northern and Eastern provinces had been irregular for several years. The network's

passenger-kilometres amounted to 1.9 billion in 1986, about 38 percent less than its total in

1982 and now the railway network of Sri Lanka consist of 1,422 kilometres.

According to the records (Nov 2013) of Sri Lankan Railway Department there are nearly 612 unprotected level crossings throughout the island.

The highest number of 225 unprotected level crossings is along the coastal rail track from Colombo Fort to Galle.

There are 121 unprotected crossings on the Ragama-Puttalamline, Polgahawela-Vavuniya line 92, Maho-Batticoloa line 81, Peradeniya-Matale line 9, Colombo-Badulla main line 59, Kelani Valley line 29 and Gal-Oya to Trincomalee16.

Sri Lanka cannot afford to spend Rs. 3 million a month for the safety of thousands of vehicular passengers who cross the railway lines daily at about 600 points throughout the country.This question is so pertinent in the light of the increasing number of fatal accidents at unprotected railway crossings since lately. The last fortnight might go down in the railway history as the fortnight with highest number of accidents or at least one of such fortnights.Accidents at railway crossings are not unavoidable phenomena as natural hazards such as tsunamies or volcanoes. It is simple logic that the only remedy for these accidents and loss of lives is to prevent the motorists from crossing the railway lines at times when trains pass through these vulnerable points or to inform them of the approaching trains. However, there is no doubt that the authorities would argue that public coffers cannot afford to protect such a large number of railway crossings by putting up gates.

" At the present rate the Railway Department would have to pay such a gateman at least Rs. 5000, a month in addition to an initial expenditure for the installation of crude wooden or iron barricades, and there is no point in requesting the authorities to install a sophisticated protective system. "

Hence there’s essential need in inventing a cost effective reliable way of protecting these unprotected railway systems.

Page 8: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

8

1.2 Present Track-Relay System and track circuits in Sri Lanka

The heart of the signaling system is the interlocking plant. This can be claimed as the decision making part of the system. The signal outputs are based on the track occupancy, motor point status, output of the remote end signal and the input from traffic controller. This plant ensures that before a signal goes in to 'clear' (green) state, it is absolutely safe for a train to enter into the track segment. The traffic controller’s commands are not executed if it is not safe to do so.

The interlockingplant is built out of electromechanical relays.

1.2.1. Track Circuit

Track circuit is one of the primary inputs for a signal interlocking plant. An 'interlocking plant' is the control logic behind the signaling system. The signal cannot be 'green' while there is another train on track segment ahead. The system should able to detect the condition of the track segment: occupied or not.

Page 9: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

9

The tracks are segmented into 'blocks'. Each block is track circuited separately. The figure below illustrates a track circuit.

Figure: Track Circuit

The track circuit consists of a power supply on one end and a directional (polarized) relay on the other end. The power supply has a 6V battery kept charged by a 6V/6A rectifier. In case of power failure the battery will supply power to the circuit.

The track relay (TR), which has a resistance of 30 ohms and a pickup voltage of 1.4 volt, is normally held in picked-up state the circuit being completed via the rails. When a train enters the segment the axels of the train short circuit the supply to the relay and the relay drops. The contacts of the track relays appear in most of the safety circuits of the interlocking plant. The interlocking logic is arranged such that only one train can be permitted to enter a section. If you carefully observe, the track circuit is fail safe; if the circuit fails it will indicate occupancy.

The variable resister is introduced into the circuit such that it can be tuned to make the system works under all weather conditions.

The rails are insulated to separate the adjacent track circuits. The polarity of the adjacent track circuit is always reversed, so that the power supply of one circuit cannot operate the relay of the other circuit should the insulate between the circuits breakdown. Within one track circuit the rails are electrically connected by two wires (for safety).

The minimum length of track circuit is depends on the degree of control necessary and the maximum length is limited by the weather conditions. On the Northern line from Loco Junction (Maradana) to Veyangoda, the segments have a maximum length of 2000 feet. On the Southern line from Loco Junction to Wadduwa, due to the saline atmosphere along the coast line, the track circuits are limited to 1500 feet max.

Page 10: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

10

1.2.2. Track Relay System

Relays are electro-mechanical devices used for switching. Relays are used to make the signaling logic circuits in the interlocking plants. They consists of one or two magnetic coils (electro magnets) and a set of contacts.

The magnetic system of the relay illustrated below (JRK 10 type) consists of a cylindrical iron

core with coil (pale blue near the bottom), two pole pieces and an armature. Larger relays

(JRK 11) have two iron cores united at the rear with a yoke and the front end being provided

with pole pieces. The armature extends across both pole pieces.

Iron core, pole pieces and armature are made out of iron with excellent magnetic

properties. The armatures are so balanced that the vibration on the unit will not affect the

relay operation

Figure: Magnetic System

Page 11: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

11

The relay contacts can be classified into four types. A relay unit will contain a combination of these types,

Front contact – NO

Back contact - NC

Front/ Back contact

Make before break contact

Figure : Contact System

The contact springs are made out of nickel and the contacts tips are silver. The front contacts are of twin contacts and the back contacts are single contact type. The rear end of the contact springs are fixed between two blocks of transfer molded carbonate plastic reinforced with glass fibre. The stationary contact springs are supported at their free ends by a strip with notches, which limits the spring movement. The lower end of this strip is attached to the magnet support.

The movable contact springs are guided by an actuating strip which at the lower end attached by bearings to the armature and at the upper end to the upper most movable contact spring. The front edge of the actuating strip provided with slots, which lock the spring and guide the movement of the contacts.

The rear end of every contact spring has eight forked terminals. This provides a very dependable connections to the plug board terminals, when the relays are plugged in.

Page 12: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

12

3. Literature research

Date:05 03 2014

Link:http://en.wikipedia.org

Source: web page

3.1 TRACKCIRCUIT

A track circuit is a simple electrical device used to detect the absence of a train on rail tracks. It was used to inform signalers and control relevant signals. The basic principle behind the track circuit lies in the connection of the two rails by the wheels and axle of locomotives and rolling stock to short out an electrical circuit. This circuit is monitored by electrical equipment to detect the absence of the trains. Since this is a safety appliance, fail-safe operation is crucial; therefore the circuit is designed to indicate the presence of a train when failures occur. On the other hand, false occupancy readings are disruptive to railway operations and are to be minimized.

Track circuits allow railway signaling systems to operate semi-automatically, by displaying signals for trains to slow down or stop in the presence of occupied track ahead of them. They help prevent dispatchers and operators from causing accidents, both by informing them of track occupancy and by preventing signals from displaying unsafe indications.

A track circuit typically has power applied to each rail and a relay coil wired across them. When no train is present, the relay is energized by the current flowing from the power source through the rails. When a train is present, its axles short (shunt) the rails together; the current to the track relay coil drops, and it is de-energized. Circuits through the relay contacts therefore report whether or not the track is occupied.

Figure 1: Schematic drawing of occupied track circuit

Page 13: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

13

Each circuit detects a defined section of track, such as a block. These sections are separated by insulated joints, usually in both rails. To prevent one circuit from falsely powering another in the event of insulation failure, the electrical polarity is usually reversed from section to section. Circuits are powered at low voltages (1.5 to 12 V DC) to protect against line power failures. The relays and the power supply are attached to opposite ends of the section to prevent broken rails from electrically isolating part of the track from the circuit. A series resistor limits the current when the track circuit is short-circuited.

In some railway electrification schemes, one or both of the running rails are used to carry the return current. This prevents use of the basic DC track circuit because the substantial traction currents overwhelm the very small track circuit currents.

Where DC traction is used on the running line or on tracks in close proximity then DC track circuits cannot be used, similarly if 50 Hz AC electrification is used then 50 Hz AC track circuits cannot be used.

To accommodate this, AC track circuits use alternating current signals instead of direct current (DC) but typically, the AC frequency is in the range of audio frequencies, from 91 Hz up to 10 kHz. The relays are arranged to detect the selected frequency and to ignore DC and AC traction frequency signals. Again, failsafe principles dictate that the relay interprets the presence of the signal as unoccupied track, whereas a lack of a signal indicates the presence of a train. The AC signal can be coded and locomotives equipped with inductive pickups to create a cab signaling system.

There are two common approaches to provide a continuous path for traction current that spans multiple track circuit blocks. The simplest method installs insulated track circuit joints on only one of the two rails with the second being a path for the return current and a ground for the track circuit rail. This has the disadvantage of only being able to detect breaks in one rail so the more popular two rail system uses impedance bonds to permit traction current to pass between isolated track circuit blocks while blocking current at track circuit frequencies.

AC circuits are sometimes used in areas where conditions introduce stray currents, which interfere with DC track circuits.

In some countries, AC-immune DC track circuits are used on AC electrified lines. This is the predominant method of track circuiting on overhead electrified parts of the UK rail network. One method provides 5 V DC to the rails, one of the rails being the traction return and the other being the signal rail. When a relay is energized and attached to the track, normal voltage is 5 V DC. When there is a break in the circuit and there is no train, the voltage rises to 9 V DC which provides a very good means for fault finding. This system filters out the voltage induced in the rails from the overhead lines. These track circuits are limited in length to about 300m.

Page 14: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

14

3.1.1. Jointless track circuits

Modern track is often continuously welded, the joints being welded during installation. This offers many benefits to all but the signaling system, which no longer has natural breaks in the rail to form the block sections. The only method to form discrete blocks in this scenario is to use different audio frequencies (AF) in each block section. To prevent the audio signal from one section passing into an adjacent section, pairs of simple tuned circuit are connected across the rails at the section boundary. The tuned circuit often incorporates the circuit to either apply the transmitted signal to the track or recover the received signal from the other end of the section.

Consider a railway with two block sections as in the diagram. Section 1 has frequency A injected at the left-hand end and received at the right-hand end. Section 2 continues from the right hand end of section 1 where frequency B is injected and then received at the right-hand end of section 2.

There is often a gap between where frequency A is received and frequency B is injected. This is referred to as a 'tuned zone' and is a section of track where the amplitude of frequency A reduces in the direction of section 2 and the amplitude of frequency B reduces in the direction of section 1. The tuned zone can be of the order of 20 m long.

Advantages of jointless track circuits:

Eliminates insulated block joints, a component liable to mechanical failure (both of insulation and by introducing stress to adjoining rails) and maintenance.

In electrified areas, jointless track circuits require fewer impedance bonds than any other double rail traction return track circuits.

Disadvantages of jointless track circuits:

Restrictions on placing impedance bonds, hence any connection for electrification purposes, in or near tuned zones as this may upset the filter properties of the tuned zone.

Electronic circuits are more vulnerable to lightning strikes.

3.1.2. History of track circuits

The first use of track circuiting was by William Robert Sykes on a short stretch of track of the London Chatham and Dover Railway at Brixton in 1864. The failsafe track circuit was invented in 1872 by William Robinson, an American electrical and mechanical engineer. His introduction of a trustworthy method of block occupancy detection was key to the development of the automatic signaling systems now in nearly universal use.

Page 15: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

15

The first railway signals were manually operated by signal tenders or station agents. When to change the signal aspect was often left to the judgment of the operator. Human error or inattentiveness occasionally resulted in improper signaling and train collisions.

The introduction of the telegraph during the mid-nineteenth century showed that information could be electrically conveyed over considerable distance, spurring the investigation into methods of electrically controlling railway signals. Although several systems were developed prior to Robinson's, none could automatically respond to train movements.

Robinson first demonstrated a fully automatic railway signaling system in model form in 1870. A full-sized version was subsequently installed on the Philadelphia and Erie Railroad at Ludlow, Pennsylvania (aka Kinzua, PA), where it proved to be practical. His design consisted of electrically operated discs located atop small trackside signal huts, and was based on an open track circuit. When no train was within the block no power was applied to the signal, indicating a clear track.

An inherent weakness of this arrangement was that it could fail in an unsafe state. For example, a broken wire in the track circuit would falsely indicate that no train was in the block, even if one was. Recognizing this, Robinson devised the closed loop track circuit described above, and in 1872, installed it in place of the previous circuit. The result was a fully automatic, failsafe signaling system that was the prototype for subsequent development.

Although a pioneer in the use of signals controlling trains, the UK was slow to adopt Robinson's design. At the time, many carriages on UK railways had wooden axles and/or wheels with wooden hubs, making them incompatible with track circuits.

Page 16: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

16

Date: 07.04.2014

Link: http://www.alstomsignalingsolutions.com/Data/Documents/Track_Circuit_09.pdf

Source: PDF document

3.2. AUDIO FREQUENCY TRACK CIRCUITS

Dual code audio frequency (AF) track circuits to mitigate electromagnetic interference (EMI) with the consequence of preventing the unsafe condition of falsely energizing track relays during track circuit occupancy. The use of dual code AF track circuits enables AF track circuits to operate under tight constraints with immunity to EMI and adjacent track circuit interference. Dual code AF track circuits were initially implemented systemwide on MARTA in 1980 with great success. 3.2.1 Dual Code High-Frequency Track Circuit reliably operates in the presence of electrical noise generated by trains. The track circuit is ideally suited for use on continuous welded rail, where insulated joints are neither desired nor required. Combining solid-state devices with proven vital circuit relays, this track circuit eliminates the need for insulated joints, protects against interference from foreign current picked up in the rails, increases track circuit versatility, and provides a simple and proven method of transmitting function commands to the train for cab signals and speed control or for complete automatic operation. Track circuit lengths of up to 1,800 feet can be obtained, with suitable ballast conditions. A unique feature of the dual code high-frequency track circuit is the flexibility afforded by the "building block" concept. This allows the basic track circuit to be upgraded with more features added to accommodate stages of expanding facilities. The Dual Code High-Frequency Track Circuit equipment consists of WEE-Z® bonds, a solid state transmitter and receiver, and a track relay. With the exception of the WEE-Z bond, this equipment can be housed in a central equipment room or in a wayside case. The WEE-Z bond couples information between the rails and the electronic wayside equipment (via a single twisted-pair line circuit), defines block limits, and confines pertinent frequencies to the applicable track circuits. The transmitter and receiver consist of printed circuit boards which plug into a rack-mounted cabinet located near the associated track relays. The transmitter supplies, and the receiver responds to, the high-frequency signals in the rails, which provide track occupancy detection and automatic train protection commands. Up to eight frequencies are available for track occupancy detection. One or two additional frequencies can be used to transmit cab signal and/or speed control information, depending on the amount of information required. The WEE-Z bond traction current return can be connected to a traction return feeder, to a substation, or to a bond on an adjacent track.

Page 17: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

17

System Operation

3.2.2. Train Detection The track is divided into blocks, with each block checked for occupancy by high-frequency track circuits. Except at interlockings, there are no insulated joints for block separation. The bonds also inject into the track speed commands that are picked up by the train. WEE-Z bonds are located at the ends of each track circuit, with one circuit usually in each block but two or more circuits in longer blocks. Except at interlockings, a particular bond serves as a track circuit boundary, the transmitter coupling for one circuit and the receiver coupling for the next downstream track circuit. An ATP transmitter at the leaving end of the track circuit feeds high-frequency energy to the track, using the WEE-Z bond as a coupling transformer. Acting as a receiver, a bond at the entering end of the circuit energizes a track relay if the signal from the transmitter is not shunted by the axles of a train. The transmitter and receiver associated with one particular track circuit are tuned to the same frequency. 3.2.3. Automatic Speed Commands The high-frequency track circuit equipment is the communication channel between the wayside and train for the ATP speed limit commands. In addition, the WEE-Z bonds and rails are the transmission mediums for the train to wayside communications (TWC) system. The ATP speed command channel has a frequency separate from the train detection and TWC frequencies. When a train is detected in a circuit, a speed command generated by the wayside track transmitter at the leaving end of the circuit is transmitted through the rails to the train to control its speed.

Page 18: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

18

WeeZ bonds

1. Filters the train detection carrier frequency unique to that track circuit by the use of a bandpass filter. 2. Amplifies the coded carrier frequency. 3. Removes the carrier frequency element of the signal and leaves only the code rate. This is called the demodulator.

Page 19: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

19

4. The code rate signal has spikes and is not a clean square wave form. The spikes are removed and a clean square wave is formed by the use of a level detector. 5. Sends square wave representing the code rate to the decoder driver board. The interface for the correct voltage and current to decoder, and eventually the track relay, is accomplished by the decoder driver board. 6. Filters the signal from the decoder driver for the correct code rate and then sends it to the track relay. The decoder contains a series tuned circuit on the primary winding of the tuned decoder transformer. The secondary winding of the transformer contains a full wave bridge rectifier and filtering capacitor to convert the code signal to DC to drive the track relay. It is the decoder that makes the dual code track immune to EMI and induced interference. 7. The track relay is a GRS vital B1 relay designed for the dual code application. This relay is a direct replacement for the original track relay.

Page 20: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

20

4. Field visit

4.1. Field visit no 1

Our group member have been visited to some rail way tracks regarding the project to get an overall

idea on the designing requirements of the track circuit we are going to implement.

Date: 08.03.2014

Place: Galle-Akurassa road, Katugoda railway crossing.

Habaraduwa railway crossing

General description of the visited area:

Katugoda railway crossing is situated in the southern coastal railway line towards Matara. Katugoda

railway station also situated near to this railway crossing and this station has double railway lines

since it is used as an exchange centre.

Description of the environment:

Climate:

Katugoda is an area within the coastal line of southern region, very close to the ocean. The region's rainfall is unimodal and obtains high rainfall from May to October. The annual rainfall is about 860 mm. The duration of the rainy season decreases from south to north. The major part of the region, about 75%, is lowlands with an altitude below 30m. It is hot for most of the year with average temperature ranging from >27.50c.The main areas affected by the project generally have a relatively high moisture deficit. The area around the site is normally hot.

4.2. Field visit no2

As our second field visit we have visited Ceylon Government Railway (CGR).

Date: 24 04 2014

Place: chief mechanical engineers office, Rathmalana.

Description: we contact the chief mechanical engineer there and he adviced us to conjtact

signalling department of the Sri Lanka railway which situated at dematagoda.

Page 21: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

21

5. Suggested track system designs

After our two field visits and investigating in to existing railway track systems our group

came up with 2 system designing concepts. Information related to these two system

designing are noted below.

5.1. Concept No 1; usage of electromagnetic theory

5.1.1. Overview

This concept consists of a method which uses electromagnetic theories. When a steady current flows in one coil a magnetic field is produced in the other coil. But if that magnetic field is not changing ,Faraday's law tells us that there will be no induced voltage in the secondary coil. But if a switch is opened to stop the current there will be a change in magnetic field in the coil and a voltage will be induced in the other coil. A coil is a reactionary device, not liking any change! The induced voltage will cause a current to flow in the secondary coil which tries to maintain the magnetic field which was there. The fact that the induced field always opposes the change is an example of Lenz' Law. Once the current is interrupted and the switch is closed to cause the current to flow again an induced current in the opposite direction will oppose that buildup of magnetic field. This persistent generation of voltages which oppose the change in magnetic field is the operating principle of a transformer. The fact that a change in the current of one coil affects the current and voltage in the second coil is quantified in the property called Mutual inductance.

In our concept we use not only the mutual inductance between two coils,but also the variation of the induced voltage.

Page 22: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

22

We use an AC power supply to give an AC current to the coil so that in other coil, a voltage is induced. This induced voltage is then going through a bridge rectifier so that the voltage signal will be DC. This DC voltage signal is then amplified and goes through a comparator. This way we give the signal to the controller.

5.1.2. Circuit Design.

5.1.3. Method

The two coils illustrated above are placed on both side of a single railway track (A single railway track is also shown above.) When a train goes through these coils, the medium between the cores are changed. Therefore the induced voltage will also change and this change is now amplified using the amplifier and then compared using the comparator. This can give us the idea whether there is a train on the particular track or not. Using the flip-flop we can give a steady signal once the train passes by the track circuit. After passing the level cross, Track circuit in the direction gives the reset signal to the flip-flop.

5.1.4. Components used in circuit

• LM324

used as the amplifier and the comparator.

Page 23: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

23

The LM324 series are low cost, quad operational amplifiers with true differential inputs. They have several distinct advantages over standard operational amplifier types in single supply applications. The quad amplifier can operate at supply voltages as low as 3.0 V or as high as 32 V with quiescent currents about one fifth of those associated with the MC1741 (on a per amplifier basis). The common mode input range includes the negative supply, thereby eliminating the necessity for external biasing components in many applications. The output voltage range also includes the negative power supply voltage

• 74LS74 flip-flop

The SN54/74LS74A dual edge-triggered flip-flop utilizes Schottky TTL circuitry to produce high speed D-type flip-flops. Each flip-flop has individual clear and set inputs, and also complementary Q and Q outputs. Information at input D is transferred to the Q output on the positive-going edge of the clock pulse. Clock triggering occurs at a voltage level of the clock pulse and is not directly related to the transition time of the positive-going pulse. When the clock input is at either the HIGH or the LOW

level, the D input signal has no effect.

• Bridge Rectifier

• AC Power supply

Page 24: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

24

5.2. Concept no2; vibration sensing 5.2.1. Circuit diagram

5.2.2. Principles and operation The basic principle of above track circuit is induction of current using vibration of railway track by piezoelectric sensor which happens on train is coming. This circuit is monitored by electrical equipment to detect the absence of the trains. Since this is a safety appliance, fail-safe operation is crucial; therefore the circuit is designed to indicate the presence of a train when failures occur. On the other hand, false occupancy readings are disruptive to railway operations and are to be minimized. Basic circuit:

A track circuit typically has power applied. Piezoelectric sensor fixed on railway track. When no train is present, no voltage generate in sensor. When a train is present and it’s coming, huge vibration generate and sensor generate voltage and detects train is coming or passing sensor position. Circuits through the relay contacts therefore report whether or not the track is occupied.

Piezoelectric sensors require some precautions when connecting to sensitive electronic components. First and foremost, the voltage levels created by hard shock can be very high, even around 100-V spikes. More than likely, an op amp will be used to interface these sensors to an A/D converter, either discrete or on a microcontroller. One tip is to choose a high-input-impedance op amp to minimize current. One possible candidate is the Linear Technology JFET input dual op amp. It has 10¹² Ω input resistance and a 1 MHz gain bandwidth product, good enough to easily handle the vibration ranges of piezoelectric sensors.

Page 25: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

25

Another suitable part is the TLV2771from Texas Instruments. This rail-to-rail low-power op-amp also has a 10¹² Ω differential input resistance and a 5 MHz unity-gain bandwidth. Signal conditioning in a single stage can prepare the input from the shock sensor directly into an A/D converter. Op-amp circuits can be designed to operate in voltage mode or charge mode. Charge mode is used when the amplifier is remote to the sensor. Voltage mode is used when the amplifier is very close to the sensor. Another tip is to attenuate the input signal and use the op amp’s gain to bring into the desired range. Be aware that you may need snubbing protection on the inputs of the op amp, especially if the design could be subjected to harsh hits. Also note that you may think that a pressure sensor would generate only a positive voltage, but, in reality, the signal from the sensor can ring and introduce negative voltage spikes. This means that you may need to squelch negative voltage levels on the op-amp inputs, especially if using only a single rail power supply on the op amp.

Page 26: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

26

6. Implemented concept for the project:

Basics of vehicle loop detectionwith electromagnetic induction

theories

6.1. Overview

There are a number of ways to detect vehicles, for traffic control or drive-thru, inductive loop technology is the most reliable. An inductive loop vehicle detector system consists of three components: a loop (preformed orsaw-cut), loop extension cable and a detector. When installing or repairing an inductive loop system the smallest detail can mean the difference between reliable detection and an intermittent detection of vehicles. Therefore, attention to detail when installing or troubleshooting an inductive loop vehicle detection system is absolutely critical.

6.2. How it Works:

Page 27: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

27

The preformed or saw-cut loop is buried in the traffic lane. The loop is a continuous run of wire that enters and exits from the same point. The two ends of the loop wire are connected tothe loop extension cable, which in turn connects to the vehicle detector. The detector powers the loop causing a magnetic field in the loop area. The loop resonates at a constant frequency that the detector monitors. A base frequency is established when there is no vehicle over the loop. When a large metal object, such as a vehicle, moves over the loop, the resonate frequency increases. This increase in frequency is sensed and, depending on the design of the detector, forces a normally open relay to close. The relay will remain closed until the vehicle leaves the loop and the frequency returns to the base level. The relay can trigger any number of devices such as an audio intercom system, a gate, a traffic light, etc. There is a misconception that inductive loop vehicle detection is based on metal mass. This is simply not true. Detection is based on metal surface area, otherwise known as skin effect. The greater the surface area of metal in the same plane as the loop, the greater the increase in frequency. For example, a one square foot piece of sheet metal positioned in the same plane of the loop has the same effect as a hunk of metal one foot square and one foot thick. Another way to illustrate the point is to take the same one square foot piece of sheet metal, which is easily detected when held in the same plane as the loop, and turn it perpendicular to the loop and it becomes impossible to detect. By looking in to overall matching of this vehicle loop detector with required track circuit

features we decided to implement the project further with this concept.

Newly implemented track circuit with induction loop concept is as follows.

6.3. Schematic design

Page 28: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

28

6.4. PCB design

Page 29: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

29

6.5. Important parts in the design 6.5.1. Preformed and Loops A preformed loop is typically 3 to 5 turns of loop wire encased in PVC pipe for use in new construction before the track is installed. The loop wire is 14 or 16 awg stranded machine tool wire with an insulation of XLPE (cross-linked polyethylene) encased in PVC pipe to hold the loop’s shape and to protect the loop wire from damage while the pavement is installed. A saw-cut loop is used when the pavement is already in place. The installation involves cutting the loop shape in the pavement with a concrete saw, laying the loop wire in the slot, pressing in a polyfoambacker rod to keep the wire compacted and finishing with saw-cut loop sealant or street bond to fill the slot and protect the wire. It is best to use the recommended 14 or 16-awg machine tool wire for loop installation. The insulationhas a high resistance to water, heat, abrasions, oils and gasoline. Purchase the wire from the same source you bought the saw-cut loop sealant to be sure to get the correct wire.

6.5.2. Loop Extension Cable Loop extension cable is used to extend the distance from the preformed or saw-cut loop to the vehicle detector, which is usually located indoors or in a weatherproof enclosure. The characteristics of the extension cable are just as important as the characteristics of the loop wire. Use only 14, 16, or 18 awg stranded 2 conductor twisted, shielded cable with a polyethylene insulation jacket. The extension cable connections to the loop wire and the vehicle detector wires must be soldered. Do not use any other method for connection. The distance between the loop and the detector can safely be extended to 300 feet with proper extension cable, however check with the vehicle detector manufacturer for confirmation.

6.5.3. Loop train Detector The proper installation and material is critical! In general, loop vehicle detectors from all manufacturers work under the same principle and will all work reliably if the installation is done properly and the correct materials are used. Train detector features differ between manufacturers, and most are straight forward. The following features need special consideration.

Page 30: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

30

Number of Outputs. Ourdetector provide a switch closure via a relay, which is typicallyconfigured as normally open. It is the number of outputs provided that may be importantand how they can be configured. More and more devices, particularly in the drive-thru environments, need to be triggered by vehicle detection, such as audio communication, car timing, message greeting, electronic menu boards, gates, etc. Determine the number of devices that will be used now and in the future with the train detector and can match or exceed that number with the number of available relay outputs. Signal Type. Detector provide a constant presence style of signal output. In otherwords, the relay output is closed the entire time that a vehicle is present over the loop, and does not open again until the vehicle drives away. Most devices require this style of output signal,however some devices require a pulse style, which will only momentarily close the relay at thetime when the train is detected. Check the requirements of the devices that you are connectingto the detector. If you are connecting more than one device to the detector, make sure that the detector can provide the required signal types at the same time. Some detectors can only provide one or the other style of signal output at a time. Diagnostics. This train detector provides PC diagnostics via a communication port on thedetector. Diagnostic software gives you a visual picture of what is happening at the loop, and will help you troubleshoot any problems you may experience during installation or in the future. Detectors with this feature are usually in the same cost range as other detectors and can help to save time solving a detection problem. The PC software and cable is usually additional. Diagnostics software can also help determine the depth and position of the loop.

6.6. System implementation

6.6.1. Location of Loop The position of the loop relative to the train you are trying to detect is extremely important. Vehicles entering a fast food restaurant drive-thru lane will stop at the menu board with the driver’s window positioned in line with the speaker post. The front axle is the only metal surface whose relative position to the driver is consistent from vehicle to vehicle. Because of this fact, the vehicle detector is designed to pick up the front axle, not the vehicle’s engine. Therefore, the loop should be positioned 1 ½ to 2 feet ahead of the speaker post, with the long axis of the loop running perpendicular to the traffic lane. This positions the axle of the vehicle directlyover the loop in the same direction as the loop. The proper installation and location of the loop are the most important aspects of reliable vehicle detection. In recent years, there has been an increase in the number of missed and false detectionsdue to the popularity of SUVs. The missed detections can be attributed to two factors. First, and most obvious, is that the metal surface area of the taller vehicles is farther away from the loop which makes the vehicle more difficult to detect. Second, and

Page 31: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

31

less obvious, is that larger vehicles have a greater turn- front axle. The driver finds it difficult in some drive-thru lanes to round the corner prior to theloop and as a result, the vehicle becomes positioned further away from the curb and not properly positioned over the loop. Compound the poor position of the vehicle with the height of the vehicle and you have a difficult vehicle to detect.

6.6.2. Loop Installation There are a couple of important points to make with regard to saw-cut loop and preformed loop installation. It is important that when the installation is complete the loop be no more than 2” below the surface of the asphalt or concrete. The deeper the loop the less sensitive the loop detection system becomes. It is also important that the lead-in wires from the detector to the beginning of the loop be twisted a minimum of five times per foot.

6.6.3. Detector installation The proper installation and material is critical! In general, loop vehicle detectors work under the same principle and will all work reliably if the installation is done properly and the correct materials are used.

Page 32: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

32

6.7. Sensitivity of the implemented system

Our train detector have adjustable settings for sensitivity. If the detector is missing trains then the sensitivity is set too low. If the detector is jumpy or is creating false detections, it may be set too sensitive. However, all inductive loop detectors are dealing with the same physical characteristics of a magnetic field in a loop. The maximum height of detection is roughly 2/3 the length of the short side of the loop. For example, if you have a loop that is 18”x 60”, the maximum height of detection is 12” from the loop. The most effective way to increase sensitivity is to lengthen the short side of the loop. Most Drive-thru loops are 18 to 24 inches wide. If you take an 18” x 60” loop and increase the short Side to 24”, you have increased the height of detection by 4”. However, making the loop too Wide can cause a different problem. In the drive-thru scenario where train move slowly, and bumper to bumper, a system that is too sensitive may not be able to identify the gap between trains causing a missed detection Another misconception about loop sensitivity is that increasing the number of turns in the loop will increase sensitivity. Increasing or decreasing the number of turns does not affect sensitivity. Increasing the number of turns increases stability. Three to five turns is ideal for maintaining the proper stability and sensitivity combination. The frequency of the loop will change as the environment changes, as a result most detectors are designed to constantly adjust to this slow change in frequency over time. 6.7.1. Sensitivity to temperature The detector’s purpose is to detect rapid changes in frequency. However, inductive loops and detector is sensitive to temperature. When the temperature of the inductive loop increases, the frequency will decrease, and the opposite is true of the detector. When the temperature of the detector increases the frequency will increase. If the temperature of either the loop or the detector increases or decreases too fast, false detections will occur. The loop, buried in the track is not likely to change temperature rapidly, however mounting the detector in the wrong place can cause such a problem. For example, mounting the detector directly in line with a window where it can get a cold blast of air whenever the window is open, can result in problems.

6.7.2. Troubleshooting Most detectors provide LEDs that will indicate a problem with the loop, such as a short or an open. It is possible for a problem to occur that will cause the error indicating LED to stay on and yet the installation is ok, but simply needs a reset. Lightning can cause such a problem. Electrical storms can cause havoc with equipment, especially vehicle detectors because the loop is outside. If problems persist, check the connections to the extension cable and to the loop lead-in wires. Bad connections are a very common problem with inductive loops. If the installed detector has a communications port for diagnostics, beg, borrow or steal, a copy of the software and cabling needed to utilize this feature. Diagnostics software is an amazingly powerful tool for diagnostics, is less expensive than the test equipment needed to do the

Page 33: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

33

same job and will provide more information. Some diagnostics software will even capture the data to disk. This is especially useful if you have an intermittent problem. You can leave the computer running for days in order to capture the problem. In addition to using diagnostics software to capture or see a problem as it occurs it can often be used to help locate the loop in the pavement in order to determine if it’s been properly positioned and buried at the right depth. If a communications port is not available, the next best thing is a mega ohm meter. After disconnecting the loop from the detector, place one lead of the meter to one of the lead wires of the loop and the other to earth ground. The resistance should be greater than 100 mega ohms. If the resistance is between 50 and 100 mega ohms then it is possible that the loop wire is nicked or the extension cable has been damaged. If the resistance is less than 50 mega ohms, the loop is shorted to ground. In either case the loop or the extension cable must be replaced.

Page 34: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

34

7. Fail safe system available with the implemented system

Although our theories were well evaluated and tested, there would be some occasions where external disturbances will occur at our system. Since our circuit is placed near the railway tracks, there would definitely be heavy vibration and exposure to critical weather conditions. We consider these disturbances are the major threats that our system will go through. So for each threat, we came up with a solution.

7.1For Critical weather conditions and Vibration We planned to design the enclosure with two materials. Outer Layer would be Steel or Aluminum as they are design to withstand to vibration and critical weather. Inner layer will be design using plastic since the inner circuit will need protection from heat. Circuit is mounted on several springs/dampers to withstand the heavy vibration. A sample design of our enclosure and placement is shown below.

7.2. Circuit fail safe system

In our circuit design, there are three major functions. A Sine wave generator, tuning circuit including loop and comparators. In our fail-safe method, if there is any component failure in the sine wave generator or in loop circuit, our circuit will inform the central controller as an occupancy of a train in that particular track. So the barrier gates will be closed.

As you see in the diagram there are three comparators which compares the same signal from the loop. So if there is any trouble in one comparator, other two will work accordingly. In such situation, technicians must manually over ride this system in order to avoid road traffic.

Page 35: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

35

8. Identical track circuits currently existing in the world railway industry we found that there are many companies use track circuits identical to our implemented track circuit. The world-wide company names as follows.

Page 36: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

36

8. Summary

Inductive loop detection is relatively simple as a system, but it is important to arm yourself with the knowledge of how it works and how the pieces interrelate. There is no question that a problematic installation can be extremely frustrating, but if you break it down to basics it can be solved more efficiently.

The loop should be buried no more than 2” below the asphalt or concrete surface.

Replace any loop wire that has nicks or splices in the insulation.

Loop wire should be 14 or 16 awg machine tool wire with XLPE insulation.

Loops should be no less than three turns and no greater than five.

The number of turns increases stability of the signal over long runs between the loop and detector.

The number of turns does not affect sensitivity.

Extension cable should be 14, 16, or 18 awg twisted/shielded 2-conductor cable with polyethylene jacket.

The wires that lead into the loop must be twisted a minimum of five turns per foot.

The maximum height of detection is roughly 2/3 the length of the short side of the loop.

Connections to the detector, the loop and the extension cable should be soldered.

The frequency decreases as the temperature of the loop increases

The frequency increases as the temperature of the detector increases

Page 37: Automated railway level crossing protection system-track circuit

37

References http://en.wikipedia.org

http://www.alstomsignalingsolutions.com/Data/Documents/Track_Circuit_09.pdf

Field visits