australian reconciliation barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · reconciliation australia and auspoll...

76
Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 COMPARING THE ATTITUDES OF INDIGENOUS PEOPLE AND AUSTRALIANS OVERALL

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010COMPARING THE ATTITUDES OF INDIGENOUS PEOPLE AND AUSTRALIANS OVERALL

Page 2: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

2010 Reconciliation Barometer

Reconciliation Australia

David Stolper

General Manager

Auspoll Campaign Intelligently

[email protected]

T/ +61 2 8213 3075

Jennifer Hammond

Researcher

Auspoll Campaign Intelligently

[email protected]

T/ +61 2 8213 3081

REPORT PREPARED BY:

REPORT PREPARED FOR:

4th June 2010

Page 3: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Contents

1. Introduction

2. Key findings

1. The situation today

2. Changes in our attitudes

3. Results

1. The quality of the relationship

2. How we see each other

3. How we interact

4. Cultural awareness and shared pride

5. Perceived reasons for Indigenous disadvantage

6. Government action

7. Personal action

8. The role of business (new for 2010)

4. Appendix

3

Page 4: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Introduction Background and methodology

4

Page 5: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Background

Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation

Barometer research project in February 2007. The objective of the research was to

develop a tool to measure the progress of reconciliation between Indigenous and

non-Indigenous Australians.

While improvements in Indigenous health, employment, housing and education are

essential for the reconciliation process, equally important, and at the core of

reconciliation, is the relationship between the first Australians and those who have

come since.

If we are to improve the relationship and create an environment which provides equal

life chances for all Australians we must first understand the underlying values and

perceptions that shape this relationship and influence our society today.

The Australian Reconciliation Barometer delves into the heart of our nation to identify

the attitudes Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians hold about each other, and

about reconciliation in this country. It also attempts to shed some light on why we

hold these attitudes.

This is the first time a study of this nature comparing Indigenous Australians‟

attitudes and values to that of other Australians has been undertaken. It is a window

into how we see ourselves today, and more importantly where we aspire to be as we

begin the 21st century.

The inspiration for the Barometer came from South Africa, where the Institute of

Justice and Reconciliation developed the „South African Reconciliation Barometer‟.

Initially it was conducted bi-annually in 2003 and 2004 and since then annually.

The 2010 edition of the Australian Reconciliation Barometer reveals where we are

today and examines how our attitudes have changed in the last two years.

5

Page 6: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Methodology – Development of the Barometer

To create the Australian Reconciliation Barometer, the first part of the research task

was to identify different factors that contribute to advancing reconciliation. Several

phases of both quantitative and qualitative research were used in the process of

identifying and defining these factors.

In May 2007 a quantitative survey among 1,024 people was conducted to determine

the underlying values of Australians towards Indigenous issues and reconciliation.

This survey was further enhanced by a series of in-depth interviews with 14 key

Indigenous and non-Indigenous stakeholders. From this, 29 hypotheses of

reconciliation were identified, forming the basis of a discussion guide for a qualitative

study.

In November-December 2007 a series of 12 forums were conducted with Indigenous

and non-Indigenous Australians in Shepparton, Rockhampton and Sydney. The

forums explored the 29 hypotheses of reconciliation and this resulted in the

development of 31 “outcomes” for reconciliation i.e. actions or conditions that will

advance reconciliation.

These outcomes were used to inform the development of the questionnaire on which

the Barometer is based. The same questionnaire was used in our surveys of

Indigenous Australians as well as the general community to allow a direct

comparison between the attitudes of the two groups.

In May, 2008, and then in May, 2010 we conducted a survey of the two groups. The

results of these surveys comprise the Barometer, and are reported, in full, in this

report.

6

Page 7: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Methodology – Survey approach

General Community Sample

The general community surveys are based upon a sample of

Australians that was selected to be representative in terms of

age, gender and location (state and urban/regional splits)

according to data from the 2006 census. Participants were

recruited from a professional market and social research panel

and they received a small incentive for their participation.

1,007 Australians aged 18+ completed the survey in May 2008

while 1,220 Australians completed the survey in April 12-29

2010. These sample sizes are associated with a margins of error

of +/- 3.1% and +/- 2.8% at the 95% confidence interval. Further

details of the composition of each sample is provided in the

appendix.

Indigenous Sample

The surveys among Indigenous respondents involved

recruitment through Indigenous networks across Australia with

an open invitation distributed by email. This targeted approach

was taken due to the relatively small proportion of Indigenous

Australians within established research panels, and the

Australian population overall. A sample of 617 Indigenous

Australians completed the survey between June 25 and July 30

2008, while 704 Indigenous Australians completed it in April

12-29 , 2010. These sample sizes are associated with margins

of error of +/- 4% and +/- 3.7% respectively.

Gaining a truly representative sample of Indigenous Australians

is difficult because of a number of geographical and

socioeconomic factors. Accounting for these factors was beyond

the scope of the research. It is acknowledged that the sample of

Indigenous people (recruited via indigenous networks) may not

be truly representative of the overall Indigenous population.

Despite this we decided to weight the data to according to

Indigenous demographic data (age/ gender and location) from

the Australian Bureau of Statistics. We also re-weighted the

2008 Indigenous data and as a result there are some small

changes in the 2008 data that is reported here, compared to our

previous reports.

Online approach

Participants from both groups completed the questionnaires

online. Previous studies have shown that online research

produces research which is at least as accurate (and sometimes

more accurate) than telephone research. Another benefit of this

approach is the removal of any interviewer bias that may come

into play when discussing sensitive issues. On-line surveys also

have the advantage of allowing people to respond at their own

pace, giving them enough time to properly consider important

and complex issues. However, it is possible that this

methodology over-samples the computer literate population

which may be more highly educated than the general population.

7

Page 8: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

The situation today

8

Page 9: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

The quality of the relationship

The relationship between Indigenous people and other

Australians is important to us

The Barometer reveals that the vast majority of Australians

believe the relationship between Indigenous people and other

Australians is important for Australia as a nation, with 87% of

general community respondents, and 99% of Indigenous

respondents believing it is “very important” or “fairly important”.

We are most likely to see the relationship as being fairly

poor or fairly good

However, there is clearly more work to be done in improving this

relationship. General community respondents were most likely to

characterise the relationship as being “fairly poor” (46%) while

another 11% believed it is “very poor”. Conversely, 38% believe

it is “fairly good” while only 5% believed it is “very good”. Results

from Indigenous respondents shows that there is broad

agreement about the quality of the relationship amongst the two

groups with 45% believing it is fairly poor and 8% believing it is

very poor.

The problematic nature of the relationship is at least partly

explained by the levels of prejudice and trust that the two groups

have for each other, and the Barometer examines these factors

in greater detail.

We acknowledge that there are high levels of prejudice

between the two groups

Around 7 in 10 general community respondents (71%)

acknowledge that that the level of prejudice Australians hold

towards Indigenous people is “very high” “or “fairly high” but they

also believe that Indigenous people are prejudiced towards other

Australians (72% believe Indigenous people hold “very high” or

“fairly high” levels of prejudice towards them).

Indigenous respondents are even more likely to believe that

Australians are prejudiced towards them (93% believe levels of

prejudice are very high or fairly high) but 74% of them also

believe that Indigenous people hold “very high” or “fairly high”

levels of prejudice towards other Australians.

Trust between us is also low

There is a low level of mutual trust between the two groups. 81%

of general community respondents believe that Indigenous

people have “fairly low” or “very low” levels of trust for other

Australians, while 81% also believe that other Australians have

the same low levels of trust towards Indigenous people.

Perceptions amongst Indigenous respondents are similar with

85% of them believing that Indigenous people have “fairly low

“or “very low” levels of trust towards other Australians, and 91%

believing that other Australians have “very low” or “fairly low”

levels of trust towards Indigenous people.

We are optimistic for the future of the relationship

Despite these difficulties, it is encouraging that respondents from

both groups are somewhat optimistic for the future of the

relationship. Both groups are most likely to agree that “the

relationship between Indigenous people and other Australians is

improving” with 49% of general community respondents, and

52% of Indigenous respondents agreeing with this statement.

Conversely, only 14% of general community respondents and

21% of Indigenous respondents disagreed with it.

9

Page 10: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How we see each other

The Barometer provides a unique insight into the characteristics

that make up our national self-image and goes further to

examine how the overall national image compares with the

image of Indigenous Australians.

Both groups see themselves positively on a number of

traits such as being good-humoured, good at sport, and

easy going

We asked respondents whether they believe that Australians,

and then Indigenous people, hold a series of positive

characteristics. Responses from general community

respondents show that their opinion of Australians is generally

high and they are particularly likely to see Australians as being

easy going, good at sport, good humoured and friendly.

However, they were less likely to see Australians as being hard

working, respectful or disciplined.

Each group has a less positive opinion of the other but

there are a number of shared positive traits

General community respondents have a less positive opinion of

Indigenous people and this is reflected in lower responses on

each positive characteristic. However, there are a number of

commonalities in how we see the two groups. General

community respondents were most likely to see Indigenous

people as being “family oriented”, “good at sport”, “proud” and

“easy going” while they are least likely to see Indigenous people

as being “co-operative”, hard working” or “disciplined”.

Indigenous respondents have a generally positive view of

Australians, although it is less positive than how Australians see

themselves. Conversely, their opinion of Indigenous people is far

more positive than the opinion of general community

respondents .

Indigenous respondents are more likely than other

Australians to believe that Indigenous people are good

humoured, welcoming, hard working and respectful

Comparing the responses from both groups also allows us to

see where the biggest gaps in perception are. For example,

when looking at the attitudes towards Indigenous people, the

biggest gaps are related to being good humoured, welcoming,

respectful and hardworking: Indigenous respondents are 41-

43% more likely than general community respondents to believe

Indigenous people hold these traits.

General community respondents are more likely than

Indigenous respondents to believe Australians are

welcoming, co-operative or respectful

Comparing attitudes towards Australians in general shows that

the biggest gaps in perception are around the traits of being

welcoming, co-operative and respectful with the general

community being 20-25% more likely than Indigenous

respondents to believe that Australians hold these traits

Results from another direct question about the level of racial

prejudice showed that only 13% of general community

respondents agree that “Non-Indigenous Australians are

superior to Indigenous Australians” suggesting that the overt

level of racism is relatively low.

10

Page 11: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Attitudes to Indigenous lives and lifestyles

The general community has less appreciation of the

diverse range of Indigenous lifestyles and occupations than

Indigenous respondents

The Barometer reveals that Australians have a somewhat

misplaced level of understanding about the lifestyles and

achievements of Indigenous people, with 50% of general

community respondents agreeing that “Indigenous people have

a diverse range of lifestyles and occupations like other

Australians”, whereas 75% of Indigenous respondents agree

with this statement. Around one in five general community

respondents also believe that Indigenous people live mostly

traditional lives in tribal groups

The general community’s knowledge about the varied

achievements of Indigenous people is limited, and tends to

focus on sport and the arts

Virtually all Australians can think of an Indigenous person who

sets an example for others in sport, and half can think of an

example-setter in the arts, politics and government and

community service. However, less than 1 in 5 (17%) could think

of an Indigenous person who sets an example in business.

Virtually all Indigenous respondents can think of an Indigenous

person who sets an example for others to follow although

awareness of Indigenous business leaders is still the lowest

category (at 73%)

Both groups are aware of Indigenous disadvantage across

a wide range of Indicators

Amongst both groups there is widespread agreement that the

levels of Indigenous people are lower than other Australians on

a range of social indicators such as education, health,

employment, and housing. Self-esteem amongst Indigenous

people is also seen to be lower by 88% of Indigenous

respondents and 68% of general community respondents.

Another area where there are different views is on the issue of

access to opportunities; 83% of Indigenous respondents believe

Indigenous people have lower access to opportunities whereas

only 54% of general community respondents agree.

Indigenous respondents are more likely to believe that

Indigenous people are disadvantaged

Indigenous respondents are significantly more likely than

general community respondents to believe that Indigenous

people are marginalised by society, with 66% believing that

“Indigenous people are mostly disadvantaged and live on the

edge of mainstream society.” This compares to 48% of general

community respondents.

The general community does not see Indigenous people as

being good at working together, and co-operation amongst

Indigenous and non-Indigenous leaders is also seen to be

low

Only a minority of general community respondents(22%) agree

that Indigenous people are good at working together to address

the problems that confront them, whereas 53% of Indigenous

respondents agree with this proposition.

In contrast, only a minority of both groups agree that there is

good co-operation between Indigenous and non-Indigenous

leaders in Australia (27% and 17% of each group agree

respectively).

11

Page 12: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How we interact and our attitudes to personal involvement

The general community’s attitudes to Indigenous people

comes mostly from secondary sources like the media

The difference in responses between the two groups raises the

question of where people are getting their information from. The

Barometer shows that only 35% of general community

respondents nominate their own personal experiences as their

main source of information about Indigenous people, while 38%

nominate the media as their main source. In contrast, the main

source of information for Indigenous respondents is their own

personal experiences (57%) and their contact with parents and

family (32%).

However, we do not believe the media presents a balanced

view of Indigenous Australia

The importance of the media as a source of information on

Indigenous Australia is concerning given that only 16% of

general community respondents agree that the media presents a

balanced view of Indigenous Australia, with 45% disagreeing.

Perceptions of media bias are far stronger amongst Indigenous

respondents with 79% disagreeing that the media presents a

balanced view.

Contact with Indigenous people is limited but we want to

interact more

The Barometer also shows that Australians have limited

personal contact with Indigenous people with around two thirds

of Australians having rare contact (44%) or no contact at all

(21%). Only 9% have frequent contact and 25% have occasional

contact.

It is encouraging, however that we want more contact with

Indigenous people than we currently have, with 15% of

respondents wanting frequent contact and 46% wanting

occasional contact with Indigenous people

While this indicates an interest in personally engaging in contact

with Indigenous people, there is a somewhat different level of

desire to take steps to help overcome Indigenous disadvantage.

In fact, the Barometer shows that a third of people agree that

they “would like to do something to help disadvantaged

Indigenous people” but about half the population take a neutral

position.

There is a lack of awareness of what we can do to help

disadvantaged Indigenous people

This lack of engagement is at least partly explained by the

finding that a substantial majority of people simply do not know

what they can do to help disadvantaged Indigenous people.

Nevertheless, when asked to specify the types of things they

had done to advance reconciliation or help disadvantaged

Indigenous people in the last 12 months, around half of general

community respondents (51%) were able to nominate at least

one activity, from simply discussing Indigenous issues to

donating their time and money.

The Barometer also tested attitudes towards relations with

Indigenous people on a very personal level by showing that the

vast majority of Australians would have no problem with their

child deciding to marry an Indigenous person.

12

Page 13: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Cultural awareness and shared pride

During the development of the Barometer the notion of “shared

pride” emerged as a key theme, in that reconciliation will be

advanced when Australians feel that they can share in the

history, culture and pride that is part of Indigenous Australia.

We believe that Indigenous culture is important to Australia

The Barometer shows that more than two thirds of general

community respondents believe that Indigenous culture is

important to Australia‟s identity as a nation and that Indigenous

history should be a compulsory part of the history curriculum in

schools.

However, the general community is less likely to feel

personally proud of Indigenous culture or believe that

Indigenous people are open to sharing their culture.

Only around half of all general community respondents (44%)

believe that Indigenous people are open to sharing their culture

while 50% feel proud of Indigenous culture.

Not surprisingly, Indigenous respondents are far more likely to

believe in the importance of Indigenous culture to the identity of

Australia, and their own personal sense of pride.

The general community’s knowledge of Indigenous history

and culture is fairly low but we have a basic understanding

of key facts

Another important tenet of the Barometer is the idea that the

foundation for reconciliation is for all Australians to understand

the facts of Indigenous Australia, including the history and

culture of Indigenous people and their place in Australia today.

The Barometer measured this level of knowledge in a number of

different ways. At a base level it shows that Australians tend to

be more confident about their knowledge of history than they are

about their knowledge of Indigenous culture. However, most

people (around two-thirds) believe their knowledge is weak in

both areas.

Despite this, most have a basic level of knowledge about the

facts, with the majority aware of some important details such as

the meaning of the Dreamtime (74% are aware of its meaning)

and the landmark Mabo legislation (80% are aware of its

context) .

In contrast, there are clear knowledge gaps around some of the

more controversial or challenging aspects of modern Indigenous

life. For example, 74% of general community respondents

believe that the stolen generation policies either ended long

before they actually did, or have not idea at all.

We are open to learning more about Indigenous history and

culture

It is encouraging however that around 4 out of 5 Australians

believe it is important to know about Indigenous history and

culture and are therefore open to learning more.

13

Page 14: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Perceived reasons for Indigenous disadvantage

We agree that a wide range of factors have resulted in

Indigenous disadvantage today but the general community

is more likely to see a lack of personal responsibility

amongst Indigenous people as being a cause of their

problems

The general community is most likely to see alcohol and

substance abuse, a lack of responsibility amongst Indigenous

people, and race-based policies of the past as the most

important factors creating disadvantage suffered by some

Indigenous people today.

Most general community respondents believe a combination of

factors have contributed to the disadvantage suffered by some

Indigenous people today. Some of these factors are clearly

beyond an individual‟s control including poor access to health

and education, race-based policies, discrimination, ineffective

programs and policies and lack of respect. However, the factors

considered most influential - alcohol and substance abuse and

lack of personal responsibility - are more likely to fall on

Indigenous people themselves. This suggests many Australians

continue to see those Indigenous people living in difficult

circumstances as being largely responsible for their own

disadvantage, as does the fact that less than half of general

community respondents agree that being born Indigenous

makes it harder for an individual to achieve in Australia today.

Indigenous respondents are more likely to believe external

factors as being important causes of disadvantage

Compared to the general community, Indigenous respondents

saw all of the specific factors as being more important in

creating disadvantage today. There was general agreement

between the two groups on the importance of “personal” factors

such as alcohol and substance abuse and personal

responsibility. However Indigenous respondents were far more

likely to see external factors as being important. These factors

include poor access to health and education services,

discrimination, ineffective government programs and policies,

lack of respect for Indigenous people and inadequate living

conditions

Indigenous respondents are more likely to believe they face

barriers to personal achievement

There are differing views on the effect that “being born

Indigenous” has on the ease at which an individual can achieve.

Nearly half of all Australians (45%) agree than being born

Indigenous makes it harder for an Individual to achieve, while

around a quarter (27%) disagree with this statement. In contrast

around two thirds of Indigenous respondents (61%) agree that

being Indigenous makes it harder for them to achieve.

Both groups agree that previous race-based policies

continue to affect some Indigenous people today

Both groups agree that previous race-based policies continue to

affect some Indigenous people today although the level of

agreement amongst Indigenous respondents (91%) is

considerably higher than that of the general community (64%).

14

Page 15: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Attitudes to Government action and Indigenous policies

Effective progress towards reconciliation requires action by

government, and the Barometer examines this from a number of

perspectives.

We believe that some Indigenous people need help to

overcome disadvantage and we want the government to act.

At an overall level there is a clear recognition that some

Indigenous Australians need help to overcome disadvantage

(with 90% of Indigenous respondents and 72% of the general

community agreeing).

There is also the belief amongst most respondents that the

government should put in place measures to help Indigenous

people in specific ways (92% of Indigenous respondents and

57% of the general community agree).

Amongst both groups there is clear support for the government

to put in place a range of measures that help Indigenous people

reach equality on a wide range of measures. Health, education,

and equality in life expectancy are seen as the areas where

government should put the highest priority, although there is

also fairly strong support for measures to reach equality in

employment, housing and the development of leadership skills.

However, most of us think that government programs to

address Indigenous disadvantage have been unsuccessful

Despite the emphasis on the government as a key component of

any solution, there is dissatisfaction about the effectiveness of

government action so far. Just one in 50 people (from both

groups of respondents) believe government programs have

been „very successful‟ and only one-quarter believe they have

been “fairly successful”.

We believe the apology was important for Indigenous

people and the relationship between us

The 2008 apology to the stolen generation has been one of the

highest profile government actions in our recent history and the

Barometer examines our attitudes to this historic event.

Around 4 in 5 Australians (79%) believe that the apology was

important for Indigenous people while around two thirds (65%)

also believe it was important for the relationship between

Indigenous people and other Australians. Support for the

apology was overwhelming amongst Indigenous respondents

with virtually unanimous agreement that it was important for

Indigenous people as well as the relationship between the two

groups.

Around 3 in 5 Indigenous respondents (58%) and 2 in 5

general population respondents (42%) believe that the apology

has made the relationship between us better, while less than 1

in 10 believe it has made the relationship worse.

15

Page 16: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

The role of business (new for 2010)

In the 2010 Barometer we added additional questions which

examined the role that business should take in promoting

reconciliation and addressing Indigenous disadvantage.

Results show that there is some uncertainty about the role that

business should take, with around 2 in 5 Australians believing

that “businesses should put measures in place to help

Indigenous people in specific ways”.

There is widespread support for a range of business

initiatives that promote reconciliation and address

Indigenous disadvantage

When respondents were presented with specific actions there

was widespread support for many business initiatives. Strongest

support was for actions that were seen as being a core part of

their business activities. These included providing educational

opportunities, through scholarships, traineeships and work

placements, recruiting Indigenous staff, and partnering with

Indigenous organisations to promote reconciliation and address

disadvantage.

Respondents were less supportive of businesses promoting and

celebrating key reconciliation dates, or acknowledging the

traditional owners at official events, although around half of all

respondents do believe that businesses should take these

actions.

Indigenous respondents are particularly supportive of the

role that business can take to improve the situation

In contrast around 90% of Indigenous respondents believe that

businesses have a role to play in helping Indigenous people.

There was also virtually universal support for businesses to take

a range of initiatives, including symbolic actions, such as the

acknowledgement of traditional owners, as well as practical

steps such as partnering with Indigenous organisations and

providing education, training and work opportunities.

16

Page 17: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Changes in our attitudes

17

Page 18: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

The social context for changed attitudes

Before interpreting any changes in the survey results between

2008 and 2010 it is worthwhile to examine how the broader

social, political, and economic environment has changed in

Australia during this period. There have been some important

changes in the last two years and these may have influenced

our attitudes to reconciliation and other Indigenous issues.

The apology to the Stolen Generation

There were two “Indigenous events”, which were prominent at

the time of the first Barometer, but have since become less

visible as major issues in the media and the political debate.

The first of these was the Federal Government‟s apology to the

Stolen Generation in February 2008. This event acknowledged,

and brought attention to the impact of past government policies

on Indigenous Australians. It was generally well received by the

broader community, as well as Indigenous people, with the latter

typically seeing it as a crucial step to building better relations

between the groups. As such, the apology brought attention to

the issue of reconciliation in a positive way that set an optimistic

tone for the future.

The Northern Territory Intervention

The other major event occurring around the time of the first

Barometer was the Northern Territory Intervention which began

in late 2007. As with the apology it generated significant media

attention, but this time it was mostly focussed around negative

portrayals of Indigenous people associated with themes of

abuse, disadvantage and neglect. Although supported by both

sides of politics, the intervention was controversial, with

Indigenous people and other Australians divided on its merits. In

the time since these two events, there has been less attention

given to Indigenous issues in the media, and there has also

been a drop in the political salience of Indigenous issues

compared to other concerns.

The Global Financial Crisis

On a broader level there has also been a major change in the

global financial environment and this has affected the

importance that Australians ascribe to various issues. Concern

over the Global Financial Crisis peaked around 2009 and neatly

divided our two surveys into a “pre-GFC” and “post-GFC”

snapshot on our attitudes to reconciliation and Indigenous

issues. At a broad level the GFC has been associated with a

general shift in the public mood, from one of prosperity to one of

uncertainty and guarded optimism. Other research by Auspoll

has shown (not surprisingly) that over this period Australians

have become relatively more concerned about job security and

their financial stability and relatively less concerned with “non-

financial issues” such as the environment or Indigenous

reconciliation (as we will see).

The scale of changes

The changes we found between 2008 and 2010 are generally

small (typically less than 10%) and our overall attitudes to

reconciliation and Indigenous issues are broadly similar to what

they were two years ago. However, we have found a series of

interesting changes that reflect a subtle change in the mood of

the nation. As the Barometer continues we will get a better idea

of whether these changes resulted from the “short-term” effects

described above, or whether they represent a long-term shift in

the national psyche as we travel the long path to reconciliation.

18

Page 19: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Key changes since 2008

The relationship is less important to us

In 2010 we found a decrease in the proportion of general

community respondents who believe the relationship between

Indigenous people and other Australians is “very important” to

Australia (with a drop from 51% to 43%) and a less significant,

but similar trend amongst Indigenous respondents (a 4% drop to

90%). This is likely to have resulted from the changing social

landscape associated with a lowering of the public profile of

Indigenous issues described above.

We are more likely to believe the relationship is poor

Since 2008 the general community is less likely to believe the

relationship is good (51% to 43%) and there is a similar, but

smaller drop amongst Indigenous respondents (50% to 46%).

Indigenous respondents are also less likely to agree that the

relationship is improving than they were in 2008 (52% agree

compared to 60% in 2008). It seems reasonable that this

perceived deterioration of the quality of the relationship may be

due to a “fading” of 2008‟s post-apology “glow”.

However, we are also less likely to see ourselves in a

positive light

Interestingly, respondents were also less likely to see

Australians (in general) in a positive way with about a 5% drop in

the proportion of respondents who believe we exhibit positive

traits such as being welcoming, proud, co-operative, family

orientated or hardworking, and there are also similar drops in the

general community‟s opinion of Indigenous people. The fact that

we see ourselves in a more negative way is a consideration in

interpreting our changing attitudes towards Indigenous people

and the relationship between the two groups. On many

questions we saw a slight deterioration of attitudes towards the

relationship and Indigenous issues. However, the fact we also

found a hardening of views on a question that was not directly

about Indigenous issues suggests that the changed attitudes to

Indigenous matters may be partly explained by a general shift in

the mood of the nation from broader causes (such as the GFC)

rather than causes that are specific to Indigenous issues or

people.

The attitudes of Indigenous respondents to the two groups was

more consistent in the two surveys although we did find a 6%

drop in the proportion of Indigenous respondents who believe

that Australians are welcoming.

Indigenous respondents are less likely to believe they are

disadvantaged or affected by race-based policies of the

past

General community perceptions of Indigenous lifestyles remain

virtually unchanged ,although there are changes in how

Indigenous respondents see themselves. For example, they are

less likely to agree that Indigenous people are mostly

disadvantaged and living on the edge of mainstream society (the

proportion who strongly agrees with this is down from 35% to

25%).

There is also a reduction in the proportion of Indigenous

respondents who believe that race-based policies continue to

affect some Indigenous people today ,with the proportion of

Indigenous respondents who strongly agree dropping from 68%

to 56%. Similarly, there was a drop in the proportion of

Indigenous respondents who strongly agree that being born

Indigenous makes it harder to achieve in Australia today (down

from 35% to 21%). These results are encouraging and suggest

that Indigenous people have a greater sense of control over their

own lives.

19

Page 20: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Key changes since 2008

There is a sight reduction in the importance we place on

Indigenous culture

Agreement that Indigenous culture is important remains high (70%

of the general community agrees) , but there are small reductions

in the proportion of both groups who agree with its importance on a

range of factors. There is also a 10% reduction in the proportion of

Indigenous people who strongly agree that Indigenous people are

open to sharing their culture with other Australians (down to 37%

from 47%).

Indigenous role models have become less visible to the

general community

The profile of Indigenous people in the minds of the general

community has also reduced with a marked decrease (of around

10%) in the proportion who are aware of Indigenous role models in

a range of fields such as sports, the arts and politics.

Indigenous role models are just as visible to Indigenous

respondents as they were in 2008. However, in 2010, Indigenous

respondents were less likely to see Indigenous achievement as

being above average in areas such as sport (down to 64% from

70%), the arts (down to 46% from 57%) and service to the

community (down to 31% from 41%).

Perceived levels of contact and engagement with the issues

has dropped

Perceived levels of contact with Indigenous people has also

dropped amongst general community respondents, with 34%

having frequent or occasional contact – down from 45% in 2008.

The desired level of contact is also down, with 61% wanting

frequent or occasional contact (down from 71%).

Consistent with this reduced engagement is a decrease in the

proportion of general community respondents who have talked to

others about Indigenous issues in the last 12 months (down from

38% to 26%).

Amongst both groups there is also a decrease in the proportion of

people who know what they can do to help Indigenous people.

We are less supportive of Government action on Indigenous

issues

In 2010 we also saw a reduction in the proportion of Indigenous

respondents who strongly agree that the government should put

measures in place to help Indigenous people in specific ways

(down to 63% from 73%), although agreement overall remains

fairly consistent.

Amongst the general community there has been a reduction of

around 10% in the proportion who believe that the government

should make Indigenous issues, such as a health, education and

employment, a high priority (although overall levels of support

remains high).

There is also a reduction in the proportion of Indigenous

respondents who believe that some Indigenous people need

specific help to reach equality with other Australians (the

proportion who strongly agree is down to 48% from 57%). This is

consistent with the previous results that suggest Indigenous

respondents may be feeling more empowered on a personal level.

Indigenous respondents have a more positive opinion of

government programs but the general community disagrees

There are differing attitudes to government programs amongst the

two groups. General community respondents have become less

likely to believe that government programs have been successful

(down 5 percentage points to 26%). However, Indigenous

respondents are more likely to believe that the programs have

been successful (up 7 percentage points to 29%).

20

Page 21: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Key changes since 2008

There has been a drop in the perceived importance of

Indigenous culture, traditional lands and extended family

relationships amongst Indigenous respondents

Since 2008 there has been a 5% drop in the proportion of

Indigenous respondents who believes that connection to

traditional lands is an important part of their identity (the

proportion who strongly agrees is down from 75% to 70%).

There is also a 12% drop in the proportion who believe

Indigenous people tend to have close family relationships and

feel responsible for members of their extended family (strongly

agree down to 56% from 68%) .

Indigenous respondents believe they are better at working

together but they see less co-operation between Indigenous

and non-Indigenous leaders

It is also encouraging that there was an increase in the

proportion of Indigenous respondents who believe that

Indigenous people are good at working together to address the

problems that confront them (up to 53% from 47%). However,

there has also been a decrease in the proportion who believe

there is good cooperation between Indigenous and non-

Indigenous leaders (down from 22% to 17% in 2010).

21

Page 22: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

The quality of the relationship

22

Some of the most defining measures of the Barometer examine how well we regard the overall relationship between us, as

well as the fundamental levels of trust and acceptance that underpin a strong relationship.

Page 23: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How important do we believe the relationship is to Australia?

23

► The vast majority of respondents believe the relationship between Indigenous people and other Australians is important for Australia as a nation.

► However, amongst the general community respondents (in particular) there has been a decrease in the proportion of people who believe the

relationship is very important.

► Not surprisingly, Indigenous respondents are far more likely to believe the relationship is very important to Australia as a nation.

51

43

40

44

8

9

1

5

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Very important Fairly important Fairly unimportant Not important at all

94

90

6

9 1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Q13: How important is the relationship between Indigenous people and other Australians for Australia as a nation?

Page 24: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How good do we think the relationship between Indigenous

and non-Indigenous Australians is today?

24

► Indigenous and general community respondents have remarkably similar views on the quality of the relationship between the two groups, with most

people believing the relationship is either fairly good or fairly poor.

► Since 2008 there has been a perceived worsening of the relationship, characterised by an increase in the proportion of respondents who believe the

relationship is poor or very poor.

► This worsening trend is evident across both groups of respondents.

6

5

45

38

43

46

7

11

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Very good Fairly good Fairly poor Very poor

12

6

38

40

44

45

5

8

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Q12: Overall, would you say that the relationship between Indigenous people and other Australians today is.......?

Page 25: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we think the relationship is improving?

25

► Interestingly, respondents from both groups are most likely to agree that the relationship between the groups is improving.

► This contrasts with the results from the previous slide which suggest that there has been a perceived deterioration of the relationship during the last

2 years.

► Perhaps this measured short-term deterioration in the relationship since 2008 reflects a “post-apology” let-down, while the more positive results

from this question are a better reflection of respondent‟s long term attitudes.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

4

3

51

46

33

36

10

12

1

2

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

8

5

52

47

27

27

11

18

2

3

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

The

relationship

between

Indigenous

people and

other

Australians is

improving

The

relationship

between

Indigenous

people and

other

Australians is

improving

Page 26: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we see ourselves as prejudiced towards each other?

26

► Both groups agree that there are relatively high levels of prejudice between Indigenous people and other Australians.

► General community respondents see roughly equal levels of prejudice between the two groups whereas Indigenous respondents bel ieve that

prejudice towards Indigenous people from other Australians is much higher.

► Overall, there has been very little change in the levels of perceived prejudice between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians since 2008.

26

26

16

20

45

46

55

51

15

17

19

20

2

1

2

2

12

9

8

6

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Level of prejudice Indigenous people hold

towards other Australians

2008

2010

Level of prejudice Australians hold towards

Indigenous people

General community respondents

Very high Fairly high Fairly low Very low Don't know

18

19

50

53

55

55

43

40

24

21

4

5

2

3

2

2

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Level of prejudice Indigenous people hold

towards other Australians

2008

2010

Level of prejudice Australians hold towards

Indigenous people

Indigenous respondents

Q23: How would you describe the level of prejudice between the following groups of people?

Page 27: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we trust each other?

27

► Perceptions of the level of trust between non-Indigenous and Indigenous Australians remain low amongst both the general community and

Indigenous respondent groups.

► Indigenous respondents, in particular, believe that other Australians have low levels of trust towards them .

1

2

2

2

11

11

10

7

54

52

48

50

28

29

33

31

6

6

8

10

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Trust that other Australians have for Indigenous people

2008

2010

Trust that Indigenous people have for other

Australians

General community respondents

Very high Fairly high Fairly low Very low Don't know

Q14: How would you describe the level of trust between the following groups of people?

1

1

4

6

11

11

50

46

58

54

41

45

28

31

5

3

2

2

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Trust that other Australians have for Indigenous people

2008

2010

Trust that Indigenous people have for other

Australians

Indigenous respondents

Page 28: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How do we feel about having a child who decided to marry an

Indigenous person?

28

► Our willingness to bring an Indigenous person into our families, though marriage, provides a very personal indicator of the quality of the relationship.

It is therefore encouraging that respondents from both groups are most likely to agree that they would feel fine if they had a child who decided to

marry an Indigenous person.

► The attitudes of general community respondents remain largely consistent with the results from 2008.

► However, amongst Indigenous respondents, there has been a reduction in their strength of agreement, which is charactersied by a reduction in the

proportion of Indigenous people who strongly agree and an increase in the proportion who agree.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

20

17

37

38

31

32

7

8

4

5

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

79

68

14

23

6

7

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

I would feel fine

if I had a child

who decided to

marry an

Indigenous

person

I would feel fine

if I had a child

who decided to

marry an

Indigenous

person

Page 29: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How we see each other

29

The Barometer provides a unique insight into the characteristics that make up our self image and goes further to examine

how our overall image of Indigenous Australians compares our overall image of Australians.

Page 30: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How do we see “Australians” in general?

30

► There has been a slight decline in positive perceptions of Australians amongst both the general community and Indigenous respondent groups (to a

lesser degree). It is possible to see this as a change in line with the overall shift in mood among people since the global f inancial crisis (GFC) and

economic downturn of the past 2 years, which marks a significant change in the background of the two surveys.

► General community and Indigenous respondents continue to hold very similar views of “Australians” in general, and general community

respondents remain somewhat more likely to hold a positive overall view than Indigenous respondents.

42

61

74

81

84

84

87

93

93

95

93

41

59

68

76

78

79

82

89

89

89

92

0 25 50 75 100

Disciplined

Respectful

Hard working

Cooperative

Welcoming

Family-orientated

Proud

Friendly

Good humoured

Good at sport

Easy going

General community respondents

2010 2008

36

35

54

59

64

77

73

79

80

81

87

32

39

53

53

64

73

74

78

79

80

85

0 25 50 75 100

Disciplined

Respectful

Cooperative

Welcoming

Family-orientated

Friendly

Hard working

Good humoured

Easy going

Proud

Good at sport

Indigenous respondents

Q21: Thinking about your overall impression of Australians, would you say they tend to be....... (yes/no)?

Page 31: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How do we see Indigenous people?

31

► The disparity in positive perceptions of Indigenous people remains marked between the general community and Indigenous respondent groups,

and appears to have widened in the past 2 years. While Indigenous respondents show a stable widespread positive view of themselves overall,

general community respondents are still significantly less likely to attribute these positive factors to Indigenous people.

► The most notable difference between the two groups are the perceptions of Indigenous people being good humoured, welcoming, respectful and

hard-working, with Indigenous respondents being 41%-43% more likely to believe that Indigenous people hold these positive traits.

14

19

33

37

50

55

62

65

77

80

79

13

19

33

37

47

50

57

62

70

74

75

0 25 50 75 100

Disciplined

Hard working

Cooperative

Respectful

Welcoming

Good humoured

Friendly

Easy going

Proud

Good at sport

Family-orientated

General community respondents

2010 2008

40

63

67

81

90

88

84

89

94

95

97

36

60

66

78

87

87

88

89

93

96

97

0 25 50 75 100

Disciplined

Hard working

Cooperative

Respectful

Proud

Friendly

Welcoming

Easy going

Good humoured

Family-orientated

Good at sport

Indigenous respondents

Q22: Now thinking about your overall impression of Indigenous people, would you say they tend to be.....?

Page 32: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

What are our perceptions of Indigenous lifestyles?

32

► It is encouraging that only a small minority of respondents believe that non-Indigenous Australians are superior to Indigenous Australians.

► However, there is clearly some misunderstanding of Indigenous lifestyles amongst general community respondents, in that they are more likely than

Indigenous respondents to believe that Indigenous people live in tribal groups, and less likely to believe they have a diverse range of lifestyles and

occupations.

► Perceptions of Indigenous lifestyles amongst the general community have remained constant over the last 2 years. However, amongst Indigenous

respondents there has been a decrease in the perception of Indigenous people as being disadvantaged.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

11

9

7

8

4

3

2

3

41

41

41

40

16

18

9

10

30

29

31

33

36

33

26

27

16

18

18

15

36

36

33

30

2

4

3

3

9

11

30

30

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

48

40

35

25

5

3

7

7

28

35

39

41

10

9

7

5

11

8

13

19

18

19

6

10

11

10

11

12

41

42

12

14

2

6

3

4

27

26

68

64

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Non indigenous

Australians are superior

to Indigenous

Australians

Indigenous people

live mostly

traditional lives in

tribal groups

Indigenous people are

mostly disadvantaged

and live on the edge

of mainstream society

Indigenous people

have a diverse range

of lifestyles and

occupations like other

Australians

Non indigenous

Australians are superior

to Indigenous

Australians

Indigenous people

live mostly

traditional lives in

tribal groups

Indigenous people are

mostly disadvantaged

and live on the edge

of mainstream society

Indigenous people

have a diverse range

of lifestyles and

occupations like other

Australians

Page 33: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we believe in the special place of Indigenous people, their

connection to the land, and their family relationships?

33

► Most of the general community group agree that Indigenous people hold a special place as the first Australians, that connection to their land is

important and that they tend to have close family relationships.

► Agreement levels amongst Indigenous respondents is far stronger with most “strongly agreeing” with each statement

► Since 2008 there appears to be some decrease in the proportion of Indigenous respondents who believe connection with the land, and close family

relationships are extremely important.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

21

19

29

25

24

18

46

49

41

45

37

41

26

24

20

22

25

28

6

6

7

5

11

9

1

2

2

3

4

4

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

68

56

75

70

76

75

28

35

22

25

19

21

2

6

2

3

4

4

2

1

1

1

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Indigenous people

hold a special place

as the first Australians

Connection to their

traditional lands is an

important part of an

Indigenous persons

identity

Indigenous people

tend to have close

family relationships

and feel responsibility

for members of their

extended family

Indigenous people

tend to have close

family relationships

and feel responsibility

for members of their

extended family

Connection to their

traditional lands is an

important part of an

Indigenous persons

identity

Indigenous people

hold a special place

as the first Australians

Page 34: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we see Indigenous people as being co-operative and good

at working together?

34

► Most general community respondents do not believe that Indigenous people are good at working together, while Indigenous respondents largely

disagree with this view.

► Both groups continue to be largely sceptical about the level of cooperation between their respective leaders.

► The general community's attitudes have remained constant over the last 2 years. However, amongst Indigenous respondents there has been a slight

increase in the proportion who believe Indigenous people are good at working together, and a slight decrease in the proportion who agree there is

good co-operation between the leaders of each group.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

3

3

5

3

24

24

16

19

45

47

41

37

25

22

30

32

5

5

8

10

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

4

1

18

21

18

16

29

32

29

32

24

26

38

38

23

16

11

13

6

5

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Indigenous

people are

good at working

together to

address the

problems that

confront them

There is good

cooperation

between

Indigenous

and non-

Indigenous

leaders in

Australia

Indigenous

people are

good at working

together to

address the

problems that

confront them

There is good

cooperation

between

Indigenous

and non-

Indigenous

leaders in

Australia

Page 35: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How we think the lives of Indigenous people compare to the

lives of other Australians

35

► Most of the general population believe that Indigenous Australians are disadvantaged on most measures: particularly in terms of health, employment,

education and self esteem

► Indigenous people more likely to believe they are disadvantaged than the general population on all measures (except for personal pride).

► There is little change through time apart from a slight decrease in the proportion of Indigenous people who believe they are more proud than other

Australians

Q18: Thinking about how the lives of Indigenous Australians compare to the lives of other Australians. How do you think the levels among

Indigenous people compare to the levels among other Australians in the following areas?

1110

43

66

2

32

23

23

1114

98

119

23

35

34

46

2318

2527

1413

1919

1716

1614

1011

2124

2628

2526

3335

2729

2428

2326

2830

2827

4042

3633

4545

5149

5552

54

97

54

107

53

54

53

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Indigenous levels are much higher Indigenous levels are slightly higher Indigenous levels are the same as others

Indigenous levels are slightly lower Indigenous levels are much lower Don't know

22

1113

11

1

1

1

21

56

2012

3

2

31

32

1

89

1620

55

77

57

55

34

2727

2119

1214

3328

2020

1821

1014

5956

3034

8076

5560

7170

7371

8478

1

22

12

22

1

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Self esteem

Health

Employment

Education

Housing

Personal pride

Access to

opportunities

Access to

opportunities

Education

Health

Employment

Housing

Personal pride

Self esteem

Page 36: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Are we aware of Indigenous role models?

36

► Most people can think of an Indigenous role model, but they are most typically in the areas of sport and the arts

► There has also been a marked decline in the level of recognition of Indigenous role models among general community respondents in all areas in

the past 2 years.

► The most notable differences in perceptions between the groups relates to the awareness of example-setters in business and service to the

community.

24

59

58

76

96

17

48

48

65

85

0 25 50 75 100

Business

Politics and government

Service to the community

The Arts

Sport

General community respondents

2010 2008

77

83

95

97

99

73

84

95

95

100

0 25 50 75 100

Business

Politics and government

Service to the community

The Arts

Sport

Indigenous respondents

Q25:Can you think of Indigenous people who set an example for others in the following areas?

Page 37: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How do we characterise the level of Indigenous achievement?

37

► Once again Indigenous respondents are more likely than general community respondents to believe that Indigenous achievement is higher, with

this achievement seen as being strongest in the areas of sport and the arts.

► Perceptions of Indigenous achievement amongst the general community have changed little during the past 2 years, with business and politics still

seen as the areas of greatest underachievement by Indigenous people.

► In contrast, there has been a marked decline in the proportion of Indigenous respondents who believe that Indigenous achievement is above

average

2

3

3

3

6

6

19

17

28

32

15

13

26

21

34

32

46

45

49

46

61

64

55

60

42

43

21

25

15

13

22

20

17

16

18

19

14

13

9

8

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous achievement is above average Indigenous achievement is the same as others

Indigenous achievement is below average Don't know

8

6

14

9

41

31

57

46

70

64

20

22

14

20

33

37

29

33

23

22

67

67

69

67

24

29

13

18

7

11

5

5

3

4

3

4

2

2

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010Sport

The Arts

Service to the

community

Politics and

government

Business

Q26:How would you describe the achievements of Indigenous people compared to the rest of the Australian population in the following areas?

Sport

The Arts

Business

Politics and

government

Service to the

community

Page 38: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How we interact

38

Understanding where we get our information on Indigenous people allows us to understand the influences on the attitudes

we hold.

Page 39: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Where do we learn about Indigenous people?

39

► General community respondents continue to be far more likely to mainly learn about Indigenous people through the media or other secondary

resources (such as school or other research) and this highlights the ongoing significance the media has in shaping the views of the general

community.

► In contrast, Indigenous respondents remain most likely to learn about Indigenous people from direct cultural engagement with their communities

and families.

2

2

62

57

4

5

28

32

4

4

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Q20: Which of the following is your main source of information about Indigenous people?

37

38

35

35

15

16

3

3

9

9

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

The media Your own personal experiences with Indigenous peopleSchool education or other research Parents and familyOther people around you

Page 40: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we think the media presents a balanced view of Indigenous

Australia?

40

► Both general community respondents and Indigenous respondents continue to be sceptical about how the media portrays Indigenous Australia.

► However, while many general community respondents are still unsure whether media views are balanced or not, Indigenous respondents remain

far more likely to feel strongly that media views of Indigenous Australia are not balanced.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

2

2

12

14

39

39

36

36

12

9

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

6

5

3

4

10

12

34

33

47

46

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

The media

presents a

balanced view

of Indigenous

Australia

The media

presents a

balanced view

of Indigenous

Australia

Page 41: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How much contact do we have with Indigenous people?

41

► The perceived level of contact between general community respondents and Indigenous people has declined in the past 2 years and remains low,

with 2 out of 3 respondents feeling they have only rare or no contact with Indigenous people.

► Conversely, there continues to be regular interaction between Indigenous respondents and other Indigenous people.

12

9

33

25

39

44

15

21

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Frequent contact Occasional contact Rare contact No contact

94

91

5

8 1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Q10: How would you describe the level of contact you have with Indigenous people?

Page 42: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How much contact with Indigenous people do we want to

have?

42

► There has been a slight decline in the level of desire among general community respondents to have frequent or occasional contact with

Indigenous people during the past 2 years, and it is possible to see this as at least partially due to a subsidence in the positive effects of the formal

Apology made by the Rudd Government in 2008.

► However, nearly twice as many general community respondents would like to have frequent or occasional contact with Indigenous people than

currently do have (see preceding slide).

► Conversely, Indigenous respondents continue to desire regular contact with other Indigenous people.

19

15

52

46

25

29

5

10

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Frequent contact Occasional contact Rare contact No contact

94

94

6

5

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Q11: How would you describe the level of contact you would like to have with Indigenous people in the future?

Page 43: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Cultural awareness and shared pride

43

During the development of the Barometer the notion of “shared pride” emerged as a key theme in that reconciliation will be

advanced when Australians can feel that they can share in the history, culture and pride that is part of Indigenous Australia.

Page 44: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

What are our attitudes to Indigenous culture?

44

► General community respondents typically agree with the importance and value of Indigenous culture and believe that it should be a compulsory part

of the school curriculum. However there is less agreement that they share a personal sense of pride or that Indigenous people are open to sharing

their culture – both are areas for improvement.

► Not surprisingly Indigenous respondents are far more likely to consider their culture as an important and valuable part of Australia than the general

community.

► Amongst both groups there has been a slight decline in the perceived importance of Indigenous culture and a decline amongst Indigenous

respondents in the belief that they are willing to share their culture with other Australians.

Q17: Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

8

8

17

13

18

15

25

20

26

21

25

21

38

36

32

37

40

41

43

42

44

45

46

49

36

34

41

37

31

29

20

23

17

20

20

20

15

17

8

8

10

11

9

10

9

9

7

7

3

5

2

5

4

4

5

4

5

2

3

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

47

37

92

86

75

69

37

33

92

90

92

87

42

43

7

11

17

22

32

34

8

10

7

11

10

15

2

6

6

22

19

1

4

2

3

7

9

2

1

6

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Indigenous culture is

important to Australia's

identity as a nation

Indigenous history should

be a compulsory part of

the history curriculum in

schools

Australia is better off

because we have many

different cultures

Australia has a richer

culture because of our

Indigenous heritage

As an Australian, I feel

proud of Indigenous

culture

Indigenous people are

open to sharing their

culture with other

Australians

Indigenous history should

be a compulsory part of

the history curriculum in

schools

Indigenous people are

open to sharing their

culture with other

Australians

As an Australian, I feel

proud of Indigenous

culture

Indigenous culture is

important to Australia's

identity as a nation

Australia has a richer

culture because of our

Indigenous heritage

Australia is better off

because we have many

different cultures

Page 45: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How much do we know about Indigenous history and culture?

45

► There is still a widespread lack of knowledge about Indigenous history and culture amongst general community respondents with more than half

claiming to have a fairly low, or very low level of knowledge.

► General community respondents are also more likely to believe they know about Indigenous history rather than culture

► Perceived knowledge amongst Indigenous respondents is far higher and this difference is likely to be at least partially responsible for the difference

in appreciation for Indigenous culture between the groups (see preceding slide).

3

3

4

4

28

25

38

35

52

48

43

41

14

19

12

16

3

5

3

5

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Knowledge about Indigenous culture

2008

2010

Knowledge about the history of Indigenous people in Australia

General community respondents

Very high Fairly high Fairly low Very low No knowledge at all

40

37

46

41

44

48

42

48

13

11

9

8

3

4

4

2

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Knowledge about Indigenous culture

2008

2010

Knowledge about the history of Indigenous people in Australia

Indigenous respondents

Q15: How would you describe your level of knowledge about the following topics?

Page 46: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How important do we think it is to know about Indigenous

history and culture?

46

► There is widespread agreement amongst both groups that it is important for all Australians to know about Indigenous history and culture.

► The fact that the importance that respondents place on history and culture is higher than their knowledge (see previous slide) is positive and

suggests that people are open to learning more.

► Indigenous respondents continue to believe that it is very important for other Australians to know about Indigenous history and culture.

28

25

34

31

57

55

53

53

13

15

11

12

2

5

2

4

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous culture

2008

2010

The history of Indigenous people in Australia

General community respondents

Very important Fairly important Fairly unimportant Not at all important

84

80

94

92

15

19

6

8

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous culture

2008

2010

The history of Indigenous people in Australia

Indigenous respondents

Q16: How important is it that all Australians know about the following topics?

Page 47: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How much do we really know? – The Dreamtime

47

► There continues to be widespread understanding of the meaning of the Dreamtime amongst both the general community and Indigenous

respondent groups, although the former are noticeably more likely to hold a misconception than the latter.

► This suggests that there is at least a basic understanding of this key part of Indigenous culture.

4

5

91

2

3

94

0 25 50 75 100

Bedtime stories told to Indigenous children

Indigenous interpretations of dreams

and natural symbols

The period of time when Indigenous people lived

in Australia before Europeans arrived

History or creation according to Indigenous

spiritual beliefs

Indigenous respondents

2008

Q36: Which statement best describes the meaning of the Dreamtime?

1

7

15

77

4

8

14

74

0 25 50 75 100

Bedtime stories told to Indigenous children

The period of time when Indigenous

people lived in Australia before Europeans

arrived

Indigenous interpretations of

dreams and natural symbols

History or creation according to Indigenous

spiritual beliefs

General community respondents

2010

Page 48: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How much do we really know? - What proportion of Australia‟s

population is Indigenous?

48

► Indigenous respondents are still more aware of the actual Indigenous percentage of Australia‟s population (around 2%), than the general

community.

► Interesting, the general community are more likely to overestimate the size of the Indigenous population.

2

7

35

30

8

4

3

3

8

2

7

33

30

13

3

3

5

5

0 25 50

Less than 1% (or less than 200,000)

1% (or about 200,000)

2% (or about 400,000)

3% (or about 600,000)

5% (or about 1,000,000)

10% (or about 2,000,000)

12% (or about 2,400,000)

15% (or about 3,000,000)

20% (or about 4,000,000)

Indigenous respondents

Q38: What proportion of Australia‟s population is Indigenous?

4

9

14

17

22

11

6

6

12

6

7

14

16

23

15

6

6

8

0 25 50

Less than 1% (or less than 200,000)

1% (or about 200,000)

2% (or about 400,000)

3% (or about 600,000)

5% (or about 1,000,000)

10% (or about 2,000,000)

12% (or about 2,400,000)

15% (or about 3,000,000)

20% (or about 4,000,000)

General community respondents

2010 2008

Page 49: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Perceived reasons for Indigenous

disadvantage

49

The Barometer examines our understanding and awareness of the facts and issues that have contributed to Indigenous

disadvantage today. A foundation for reconciliation is an understanding of the external factors that have resulted in

Indigenous disadvantage and an appreciation that they continue to affect some Indigenous people today

Page 50: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

What factors do we think are important in creating

disadvantage amongst some Indigenous people?

50

► Most respondents believe that alcohol and substance abuse, lack of personal responsibility, race-based policies of the past and poor access to health and

education services are important contributing factors in creating the disadvantage suffered by some Indigenous people.

► Indigenous respondents feel more strongly than the general community respondents about the impact that these factors have had on creating Indigenous

disadvantage, with more saying that they believe these factors are very important.

► Since 2008, there has been a slight increase in the number of general community respondents who feel that alcohol and substance abuse, lack of personal

responsibility, and race-based policies of the past are very important factors.

34

34

31

39

39

45

65

70

42

40

41

36

37

37

25

20

12

13

15

11

11

9

4

4

5

5

4

6

3

2

1

2

8

7

10

8

10

7

5

5

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Very important Fairly important Fairly unimportant Not important at all Don't know

75

81

79

77

48

48

78

79

22

14

18

17

38

35

16

16

1

3

1

3

10

12

4

3

2

1

1

2

2

3

1

1

1

1

2

3

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Alcohol and

substance

abuse

Lack of personal

responsibility

(among

Indigenous

people)

Race-based

policies of the

past

Poor access to

health and

education services

Alcohol and

substance

abuse

Lack of personal

responsibility

(among

Indigenous

people)

Race-based

policies of the

past

Poor access to

health and

education services

Q19: How important do you think the following factors have been in creating the disadvantage suffered by some Indigenous people today?

Page 51: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

What factors do we think are important in creating

disadvantage amongst some Indigenous people?

51

► Once again, Indigenous respondents are more likely to believe that a range of factors are important in creating Indigenous disadvantage.

► Since 2008, there has been minimal changes in the feelings amongst the general community or Indigenous respondents, although there is a slight

increase in the proportion of Indigenous people who believe that ineffective government programs, and inadequate living conditions, have been

important.

Q19: How important do you think the following factors have been in creating the disadvantage suffered by some Indigenous people today?

27

28

27

29

28

29

30

33

31

33

45

46

44

43

45

45

43

37

46

41

13

14

15

16

13

13

14

14

13

15

3

3

5

5

6

5

5

7

3

5

11

9

8

8

9

7

10

9

7

7

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Very important Fairly important Fairly unimportant Not important at all Don't know

60

61

71

76

77

76

72

77

80

81

34

30

25

20

20

20

25

18

18

14

5

5

3

2

1

1

2

2

1

3

2

1

2

1

1

1

2

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Discrimination

Ineffective government

programs and policies

Lack of respect (for

Indigenous people)

Inadequate

living conditions

Lack of confidence

and self esteem of

Indigenous people

Discrimination

Ineffective government

programs and policies

Lack of respect (for

Indigenous people)

Inadequate

living conditions

Lack of confidence

and self esteem of

Indigenous people

Page 52: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we believe that the policies of the past still affect

Indigenous people today?

52

► Most respondents agree that previous race based policies continue to have an impact on some Indigenous people today, with Indigenous

respondents more likely to strongly agree that this is the case.

► There has been little change in the attitudes of the general community since 2008, but amongst Indigenous respondents, there has been a drop in

the number who say that they strongly agree.

► This diminished sense of importance of past policies on Indigenous people today may reflect a reduction in the media attention given to the issue in

the two years since the apology.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

17

15

49

49

24

25

8

9

2

3

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

68

56

28

35

2

6

1

2

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Previous race

based policies

continue to

affect some

Indigenous

people today

Previous race

based policies

continue to

affect some

Indigenous

people today

Page 53: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we think that being born Indigenous makes it harder to

achieve?

53

► General community respondents are more likely to agree than disagree that being born Indigenous makes it harder for an individual to achieve in

Australia today, although views are divided.

► Indigenous respondents are far more likely to believe that being born Indigenous makes it harder to achieve with around two thirds agreeing with

this proposition.

► Attitudes amongst general community respondents show little change, however, there is a significant drop in the proportion of Indigenous people

who believe being born Indigenous makes it harder to achieve. This is a positive result which suggest a greater level of personal empowerment

amongst Indigenous respondents.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

7

8

34

37

28

28

25

18

6

9

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

35

21

32

40

17

19

12

13

5

7

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Being born

Indigenous

makes it harder

for an individual

to achieve in

Australia today

Being born

Indigenous

makes it harder

for an individual

to achieve in

Australia today

Page 54: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we know key facts about previous discriminatory policies?

– the stolen generation

54

► General community respondents are most likely to believe that the stolen generation policies ended before the 1970‟s, or have no idea at all.

► Although most of the general community is aware of discriminatory policies, they are unaware of just how recent they were, and therefore what

impact they continue to have on Indigenous people today.

► Indigenous respondents are far more likely to be aware when the stolen generation policies ended.

7

1

3

19

51

13

6

8

2

4

22

46

13

6

0 25 50 75 100

Between 1840's and 1930's

1940s

1950s

1960s

1970s

1980s

Don't know

Indigenous respondents

Q34: As mentioned, in February 2008, the Australian parliament apologised to members of the stolen generations for past policies that separated

many Indigenous people from their families and homelands. In which decade did these policies end?

10

5

16

20

18

4

25

11

4

14

18

21

4

27

0 25 50 75 100

Between 1840's and 1930's

1940s

1950s

1960s

1970s

1980s

Don't know

General community respondents

2010 2008

Page 55: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we know key facts about Indigenous life expectancy?

55

► Indigenous respondents were more likely to know that the life expectancy gap is 17 years, although fewer gave this answer than in 2008.

► Indigenous respondents were also more likely to overestimate the life expectancy gap compared to general community respondents.

► Most general community respondents are unaware of the age gap and they are more likely to underestimate the scale of the disparity.

2

8

4

12

31

27

16

1

1

7

9

16

27

24

15

0 25 50

No less

3 yrs less

5 yrs less

10 yrs less

12 yrs less

15 yrs less

17 yrs less

20 yrs less

23 yrs less

Indigenous respondents

Q37: The average life expectancy of males in Australia today is around 72 years old. How much less is the life expectancy of Indigenous males?

5

1

5

20

12

20

10

19

8

6

1

6

19

10

19

8

21

11

0 25 50

No less

3 yrs less

5 yrs less

10 yrs less

12 yrs less

15 yrs less

17 yrs less

20 yrs less

23 yrs less

General community respondents

2010 2008

Page 56: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Attitudes to government action

56

Effective progress towards reconciliation requires action by government and the Barometer examines this from a number of

perspectives.

Page 57: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we agree that some Indigenous people need help to reach

equality with other Australians?

57

► Most respondents agree that some Indigenous people need specific help to reach equality with other Australians.

► General community respondents are more likely to agree rather than strongly agree, and there is minimal change in attitudes since 2008.

► Indigenous respondents are more likely to strongly agree, although there has been a decrease since 2008. The net agree level remains consistent,

but the strength of feeling appears to be slightly diminished.

Q24:Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

18

17

55

55

21

21

6

5

1

2

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

57

48

35

42

6

7

2

21

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Some

Indigenous

people need

specific help to

reach equality

with other

Australians

Some

Indigenous

people need

specific help to

reach equality

with other

Australians

Page 58: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we think the government should provide specific help for

Indigenous people?

58

► Most believe that the government should put in place measures to help Indigenous people in specific ways, although Indigenous respondents were

more likely to strongly agree.

► General community respondents were less likely to strongly agree with this statement now than in 2008.

► Indigenous respondents were slightly less likely to strongly agree now than in 2008, but the net number who agree has largely remained constant,

(and with the majority still strongly agreeing). This suggests that a desire for government support remains strong within the community.

Q30: Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

20

13

45

44

23

27

9

11

3

6

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

73

63

20

29

6

7

1

11

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

The government

should put

measures in place

to help Indigenous

people in specific

ways

The government

should put

measures in place

to help Indigenous

people in specific

ways

Page 59: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Where do we think the government should be putting its effort?

59

► Most respondents see all the above areas as a government priority on some level. General community respondents see health as the highest

priority, followed by education. However, since 2008, there has been a consistent decline in the number of general community respondents who

see each issue as a high priority.

► Most Indigenous respondents believe all issues should be a very high priority for government, with health and education attracting the strongest

support. Once again there is a slight decrease in support – particularly for measures related to employment and leadership, although overall

support remains very high.

34

26

33

28

40

31

49

39

58

46

61

52

52

56

56

55

53

56

42

51

39

46

35

43

13

16

10

16

7

12

8

9

3

7

3

5

2

2

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

High priority Fairly high priority Fairly low priority Low priority

85

81

79

71

89

81

92

87

93

93

95

92

14

16

18

25

11

17

8

11

6

6

5

7

1

3

3

4

1

2

1

1

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Measures to

reach equality in

education

Measures to help

reach equality in

life expectancy

Measures to

reach equality

in employment

Measures to

help develop

leadership skills

Measures to

reach equality

in housing

Measures to

reach equality in

health

Q31: Thinking about ways the government can help Indigenous people, what level of priority do you believe the government should give to each of

the following specific measures?

Measures to

reach equality

in employment

Measures to

reach equality in

health

Measures to

reach equality in

education

Measures to

reach equality

in housing

Measures to

help develop

leadership skills

Measures to help

reach equality in

life expectancy

Page 60: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we think government programs have worked?

60

► Government programs designed to address Indigenous disadvantage are largely seen as having limited success.

► General community respondents are now less likely than in 2008 to think that programs designed to address Indigenous disadvantage have been

successful. However, more Indigenous respondents feel that these programs have had a measure of success compared to 2008.

► It is somewhat encouraging the respondents who are more likely to have had contact with the programs (i.e. Indigenous people) are now more

likely to believe they have been successful.

1

2

30

24

41

42

14

15

13

16

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

General community respondents

Very successful Fairly successful Fairly unsuccessful Very unsuccessful Don't know

2

2

20

27

50

43

26

24

3

4

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

Q27: Overall, would you say that programs designed to address Indigenous disadvantage have been.....?

Page 61: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

How important was the apology to us?

61

► In the 2008 survey, respondents were asked what they thought of the apology to the stolen generations – whether it was important for Indigenous

people and whether it was important for the relationship between Indigenous and other Australians.

► The majority of respondents thought the apology was important, both in terms of what it meant to Indigenous people and for the relationship,

although there was a stronger response in terms of how important it was for Indigenous people.

► Indigenous respondents were more likely than the general community respondents to agree the apology was very important, both for Indigenous

people themselves, and for the relationship.

37

54

28

24

13

6

17

10

6

6

0 25 50 75 100

It was important for the

relationship between

Indigenous people and other

Australians

It was important for Indigenous

people

General community respondents

Very important Fairly important Fairly unimportant Not important at all Don't know

78

92

13

5

6

1

2

2

0 25 50 75 100

It was important for the

relationship between

Indigenous people and other

Australians

It was important for Indigenous

people

Indigenous respondents

2008: In February 2008, the Australian Parliament apologised to members of the stolen generations for the past government policies that separated many Indigenous people

from their families and homelands. How important was this apology to indigenous people? How important was it for relations between Indigenous people and other Australians?

Page 62: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we think the apology has improved the relationship?

62

► In 2010, respondents were also asked whether they believed the apology had improved the relationship between Indigenous people and other

Australians.

► General community respondents were more likely to view the apology as having a positive impact on the relationship rather than a negative one –

although around half believed it has made no difference.

► Indigenous respondents were more likely to have a positive view, with the majority believing the apology has helped to improve the relationship.

7 35 50 5 4

0 25 50 75 100

2010

General community respondents

It has made the relationship a lot better It has made the relationship a little better It has made no difference to the relationship

It has made the relationship a little worse It has made the relationship a lot worse

11 47 37 23

0 25 50 75 100

2010

Indigenous respondents

2010 Q28: In February 2008, the Australian Parliament apologised to members of the stolen generations for past government policies that separated many Indigenous

people from their families and homelands. What effect, if any, do you think this apology has had on the relationship between Indigenous people and other Australians?

Page 63: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Are we aware of the Mabo decision?

63

► The Mabo decisions is another key institutional change to Indigenous rights in Australia and it is encouraging that most respondents are aware of

context of this decision.

► Awareness levels were higher amongst Indigenous respondents, although there was a high level of awareness amongst general community

respondents as well.

► There were minimal changes in knowledge levels between 2008 and 2010.

1

1

6

92

1

9

90

0 25 50 75 100

The forced removal of children from their parents, or the stolen

generations

Indigenous deaths in custody

Recognition of Indigenous people as the first Australians

in the Constitution

Indigenous land rights and native title

Indigenous respondents

Q35: In 1992, the High Court of Australia passed a decision known as „Mabo‟. Do you think that this decision relates to.....?

4

8

5

83

4

7

9

80

0 25 50 75 100

Indigenous deaths in custody

Recognition of Indigenous people as the first Australians in

the Constitution

The forced removal of children from their parents, or the 'stolen

generations'

Indigenous land rights and native title

General community respondents

2010 2008

Page 64: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Attitudes to personal action

64

Our desire for personal engagement points to the potential for engagement with reconciliation on a personal level.

Page 65: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we want to be personally involved in helping Indigenous

people? Do we know what we can do?

65

► General community respondents are more likely to want to do something to help disadvantaged Indigenous people rather than not, but are less likely to

know what it is they can do to help. Since 2008, the number of respondents who want to help and who know what they can do has also dropped.

► The majority of Indigenous respondents strongly agree that they would like to help disadvantaged Indigenous people, and most either agree or strongly

agree that they know what they can do to help. Since 2008, there has been an increase in the number of Indigenous respondents who strongly agree that

they would like to help, but a decrease in the number who strongly agree that they know what they can do.

Q30: Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

5

2

8

4

14

14

29

29

51

45

48

49

25

31

11

12

5

8

4

6

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

46

39

62

65

33

36

32

28

16

17

6

6

3

6

1

2

0 25 50 75 100

2008

2010

2008

2010

Indigenous respondents

I would like to

do something

to help

disadvantaged

Indigenous

people

I know what I

can do to help

disadvantaged

Indigenous

people

I would like to

do something

to help

disadvantaged

Indigenous

people

I know what I

can do to help

disadvantaged

Indigenous

people

Page 66: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

What have we actually done to advance reconciliation or help

disadvantaged Indigenous people?

66

► In the last 12 months, Indigenous respondents are much more likely to have participated in actions to help advance reconciliation or help

disadvantaged Indigenous people, compared with general community respondents.

► General community respondents are less likely to have taken action that can help advance reconciliation or help disadvantaged Indigenous people

than they were in 2008.

► There has been a notable reduction in the number of general community respondents who have talked to others about Indigenous issues and this

reflects a general lowering of the priority of Indigenous issues in the media.

4

8

9

10

11

17

20

21

25

38

39

3

5

5

7

7

13

15

18

21

26

49

0 25 50 75 100

Implemented Indigenous employment strategies in your workplace

Donated time

Spoken out or advocated in the community or workplace

Donated money

Supported Indigenous children

Supported Indigenous arts and music

Built personal relationships with Indigenous people

Reconsidered your views about Indigenous Australia

Educated yourself about Indigenous history, culture and people

Talked to others about Indigenous issues

None of the above in the last 12 months

General community respondents

2010 2008

Q29: Below is a list of things that some people can do to advance reconciliation or help disadvantaged Indigenous people. Please indicate whether

you have done any of these things in the past 12 months.

37

38

56

70

72

82

78

75

85

94

1

35

41

55

65

65

77

77

80

86

93

0 25 50 75 100

None of the above in the last 12 months

Donated money

Reconsidered your views about Indigenous Australia

Implemented Indigenous employment strategies in your workplace

Supported Indigenous arts and music

Donated time

Supported Indigenous children

Spoken out or advocated in the community or workplace

Educated yourself about Indigenous history, culture and people

Built personal relationships with Indigenous people

Talked to others about Indigenous issues

Indigenous respondents

Page 67: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

The role of business (new for 2010)

67

In the 2010 Barometer we added additional questions which examined the role that business could take in promoting

reconciliation and addressing Indigenous disadvantage.

Page 68: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Are we aware of programs that businesses have put in place

to address Indigenous disadvantage?

68

► General community respondents are mostly unaware of programs put in place by business to address Indigenous disadvantage or promote

reconciliation although Indigenous respondents are much more familiar with them.

18 82

0 25 50 75 100

2010

General community respondents

Yes, I am aware of programs that businesses have put in place to address Indigenous disadvantage

No, I am not aware of any programs that businesses have put in place to address Indigenous disadvantage

74 26

0 25 50 75 100

2010

Indigenous respondents

Q32: Are you aware of any programs that businesses have put in place to address Indigenous disadvantage, or promote reconciliation between

Indigenous people and other Australians?

Page 69: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Do we agree that businesses should put measures in place to

help Indigenous people?

69

► Most Indigenous respondents strongly agree that businesses should put in place measures to help Indigenous people in specific ways.

► General community respondents are more likely to agree than disagree that business should do its part, but there remains a level of indifference or

uncertainty about their role. This suggests that the general community is likely to be somewhat more cautious about business programs and would

want to be aware of more specific details before giving their support .

Q30: Please indicate your level of agreement with the following statements.

8 33 37 17 6

0 25 50 75 100

2010

General community respondents

Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly disagree

57 32 9 11

0 25 50 75 100

2010

Indigenous respondents

Businesses

should put

measures in

place to help

Indigenous

people in

specific ways

Businesses

should put

measures in

place to help

Indigenous

people in

specific ways

Page 70: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

What actions do we want businesses to take?

70

► Once specific details were provided there was a far higher level of support for a variety of actions that business could take.

► Strongest support was for actions that were seen as being a core part of their business activities such as education, training and hiring, although

there was also strong support for partnerships with Indigenous organisations.

► There was less support for symbolic activities, such as the celebration of key reconciliation dates or the acknowledgement of traditional owners of

the land at official events.

► Almost all Indigenous respondents agree that businesses should be taking these specific actions.

43

50

56

60

67

67

81

57

50

44

40

33

33

19

0 25 50 75 100

Acknowledge the traditional owners of the land at the start of official company events

Promote and celebrate key reconciliation dates such as National Reconciliation Week within

the workplace

Provide opportunities for their employees to learn more about Indigenous culture

Commit to contracting Indigenous businesses, when all other tender conditions are equal, as

part of a supplier diversity strategy

Partner with Indigenous organisations to deliver programs that promote reconciliation or

address Indigenous disadvantage

Recruit more Indigenous people as staff into their businesses

Provide opportunities for Indigenous people to extend their education through scholarships,

traineeships and work placements

General community respondents

Yes, I think that businesses in Australia should take this actionNo, I do not think that businesses in Australia should take this action

92

93

96

97

97

98

98

8

7

4

3

3

2

2

0 25 50 75 100

Acknowledge the traditional owners of the land at the start of official company events

Commit to contracting Indigenous businesses, when all other tender conditions

are equal, as part of a supplier diversity …

Provide opportunities for their employees to learn more about Indigenous culture

Promote and celebrate key reconciliation dates such as National Reconciliation Week

within the workplace

Recruit more Indigenous people as staff into their businesses

Provide opportunities for Indigenous people to extend their education through scholarships,

traineeships and work placements

Partner with Indigenous organisations to deliver programs that promote reconciliation

or address Indigenous disadvantage

Indigenous respondents

Q33: Do you think that Businesses in Australia should take the following actions?

Page 71: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

AppendixRespondent profiles

71

Page 72: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Sample Characteristics (2010 survey)

72

Sample sub-segment General community

weighted %

General community

(raw numbers)

Indigenous community

weighted %

Indigenous community

(raw numbers)

Male 49 542 48 214

Female 51 678 52 490

18 to 29 years 21 212 34 126

30 to 39 years 19 186 25 169

40 to 49 years 19 195 20 224

50 to 59 years 17 213 12 140

60 to 69 years 17 288 9 44

70 plus years 7 126 0 1

Total sample = 1,220 general community, 704 Indigenous community. Please note that

percentages have been rounded, and therefore may not equal 100%

Sample sub-segment General community

weighted %

General community

(raw numbers)

Indigenous community

weighted %

Indigenous community

(raw numbers)

NSW 33 395 29 194

VIC 25 321 9 69

QLD 19 211 28 179

SA 8 115 5 42

WA 10 115 15 141

Other 5 63 14 79

Page 73: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Sample Characteristics (2010 survey)

73

Sample sub-segment General community

weighted %

General community

(raw numbers)

Indigenous community

weighted %

Indigenous community

(raw numbers)

Capital city 56 709 31 302

Major regional city 16 170 21 107

Regional town 14 153 24 137

Rural town 10 135 17 110

Remote town or community 4 53 7 48

Total sample = 1,220 general community, 704 Indigenous community. Please note that

percentages have been rounded, and therefore may not equal 100%

Sample sub-segment General community

weighted %

General community

(raw numbers)

Indigenous community

weighted %

Indigenous community

(raw numbers)

Postgraduate degree 9 98 12 87

University degree 25 281 24 195

TAFE/apprenticeship 31 381 34 198

Secondary school 25 336 22 152

Part of secondary school 10 124 9 72

Page 74: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

Sample Characteristics (2010 survey)

74

Sample sub-segmentGeneral community

weighted %

General community

(raw numbers)

Indigenous community

weighted %

Indigenous community

(raw numbers)

Less than $30,000 17 237 9 56

$30,000 - $49,999 17 210 20 114

$50,000 - $69,999 17 202 28 199

$70,000 - $89,999 13 145 18 120

$90,000 - $119,999 13 136 12 97

$120,000 - $149,999 6 66 6 56

$150,000 or more 5 59 4 44

I don't want to say 12 165 2 18

Total sample = 1,220 general community, 704 Indigenous community. Please note that

percentages have been rounded, and therefore may not equal 100%

Page 75: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007
Page 76: Australian Reconciliation Barometer 2010 · 2020-05-11 · Reconciliation Australia and Auspoll began collaboration on the Reconciliation Barometer research project in February 2007

www.reconciliation.org.au