australian contribution to the analysis of football
DESCRIPTION
A presentation made at a World Congress of Football in Sydney, Australia. It was the start of my attempt to map a sociology of knowledge in performance analysis.TRANSCRIPT
Keith LyonsKeith LyonsCentre for Performance AnalysisCentre for Performance Analysis
University of Wales Institute University of Wales Institute CardiffCardiff
Australian Contributions Australian Contributions to the Analysis to the Analysis
ofofPerformance in FootballPerformance in Football
IntroductioIntroductionnIntroductioIntroductionn1. Aim of Paper2. A Distinctive Australian Contribution
3. Australian Rules Football4. Conceptual Issues5. Methodological Issues6. Empirical Issues7. History of Ideas8. Summary and Conclusion
1. Aim of Paper2. A Distinctive Australian Contribution
3. Australian Rules Football4. Conceptual Issues5. Methodological Issues6. Empirical Issues7. History of Ideas8. Summary and Conclusion
1. Aims of the Paper1. Aims of the Paper
To celebrate ‘early’ Australian To celebrate ‘early’ Australian research.research.
To counter ‘scholarly astigmatism’.To counter ‘scholarly astigmatism’.
To discuss performance analysis issues.To discuss performance analysis issues.
To do so in the context of a ‘history To do so in the context of a ‘history of ideas’ approach.of ideas’ approach.
2.2. A Distinctive Australian A Distinctive Australian ContributionContribution
Almost forty years of published Almost forty years of published work.work.
Practical and applied work.Practical and applied work.
All football codes All football codes
It is obvious that the content of It is obvious that the content of training will depend upon training will depend upon
intelligent analysisintelligent analysis of the of the
individual performanceindividual performance of players of players
during during a large number of gamesa large number of games..
Nettleton and Sandstrom (1963: 21)Nettleton and Sandstrom (1963: 21)
How to Chart Movement?How to Chart Movement?
Assign one observer to each player.Pen and paper notation.Pre-printed proforma.Five minute segments.Extract “general patterns of effort”
Nettleton and Sandstrom (1963)
It is suggested that the skill It is suggested that the skill performance of the player is performance of the player is charted in a similar manner to charted in a similar manner to his movements over the playing his movements over the playing area.area.
Nettleton and Sandstrom (1963: 29)Nettleton and Sandstrom (1963: 29)
Jaques & Pavia (1974)Jaques & Pavia (1974)
Distance covered by different players in different positions.
Time spent standing, walking, jogging and running.
Variation in amount, type and intensity of effort.
Each player filmed with Each player filmed with videotape camera.videotape camera.
Pen and paper notation.Pen and paper notation.
Pre-printed scale diagram.Pre-printed scale diagram.
Lapsed-time notation.Lapsed-time notation.
Three researchers.Three researchers.
How to Chart Movement?How to Chart Movement?
Reilly 1975Reilly 1975
Withers 1979Withers 1979
Charles Reep Charles Reep 1940s1940s
Winterbottom 1959Winterbottom 1959
Whitehead 1968Whitehead 1968
Brooke & Knowles Brooke & Knowles 19741974
Reilly & Thomas 1976Reilly & Thomas 1976Withers et al. 1977Withers et al. 1977
Withers et al. 1982Withers et al. 1982
Beard 1979Beard 1979
3. Australian Rules 3. Australian Rules FootballFootball
Australian Rules: The People
Australian Rules: The People
Nettleton&
Sandstrom
Nettleton&
Sandstrom
Jacques & PaviaJacques & Pavia Pyke
& Smith Pyke
& Smith
DavisDavisDavis &
Fitzclarence Davis &
Fitzclarence Hahnet al.Hahnet al.
Craig, Jacques, Pavia
& Squires
Craig, Jacques, Pavia
& Squires
Walsh, Abernethy& McArthur
Walsh, Abernethy& McArthur
SmithSmith SmithSmith
TinningTinning LockwoodLockwood DavisDavis
Smith, Nettleton& Briggs
Smith, Nettleton& Briggs
1963
1974 1975
Beard
Morton
Parkin
Pyke
1979
1979
1980
1981
1982
Withers
Australian Rules: The Places
Australian Rules: The PlacesU. M.U. M.U. M.U. M.
SturtSturt SturtSturt UWA UWA
& Rusden& Rusden UWA UWA
& Rusden& Rusden
DeakinDeakin DeakinDeakin DeakinDeakinDeakinDeakin UWAUWAUWAUWA
AdelaideAdelaideAdelaideAdelaide
C.C.C.C.& U.Q.& U.Q.C.C.C.C.& U.Q.& U.Q. RusdenRusdenRusdenRusden RusdenRusden RusdenRusden
Deakin Deakin Deakin Deakin UWAUWA
UWAUWA
Deakin Deakin Deakin Deakin
Rusden & U. M.Rusden & U. M.Rusden & U. M.Rusden & U. M.
1963
1974 1975
Beard
UWAUWA
Parkin
UWAUWA
1979
1979
1980
1981
1982
FlindersFlinders
Australian Rules: The TopicsAustralian Rules: The TopicsSkill &ConditioningSkill &
Conditioning
MovementPatterns MovementPatterns Game
Analysis Game
Analysis
MovementPatternsMovementPatterns
On-FieldTraining On-FieldTraining
Training &Match Play Training &Match Play
CoachPerformance
CoachPerformance
MarkingSkill
MarkingSkill StatisticsStatistics Running
PatternsRunningPatterns
CoachingEffectivenessCoaching
EffectivenessTeam
EfficiencyTeam
Efficiency Game
Analysis Game
Analysis
Game Analysis& Design of Practice
Game Analysis& Design of Practice
1963
1974 1975
SkillAnalysis
Training
Preparation
Specificity
1979
1979
1980
1981
1982
Specificity
4. Conceptual Issues4. Conceptual Issues
5. Methodological 5. Methodological IssuesIssues
6. Empirical Issues6. Empirical Issues
7. History of Ideas7. History of Ideas
7.1 Biography
7.2 Substantive Issues
7.3 Objectification
7.4 Rectifying Scholarly Astigmatism
8. Summary and 8. Summary and ConclusionsConclusions
8.1 A celebration of Australian enthusiasm and achievement.
Even the palest ink Even the palest ink
is better than …is better than …
the most reliable memorythe most reliable memory
Chinese ProverbChinese Proverb
AppendicesAppendices
Movement Patterns TrainingMatch Play
Skills
Statistical Analysis Relational Data
Computerised Analysis
Australian Rules
J acques&
Pavia1974
Players
Craig, J acques,Pavia &Squires
1979
Field&
BoundaryUmpires
Smith1980
FieldUmpires
Umpires
Movement Patterns
Nettleton&
Sandstrom1963
Skill&
Conditioning
Davis&
Fitzclarence1979
On-FieldTraining
Hahnet al.1979
Smith,Nettleton &
Briggs1982
Training&
MatchPlay
Walsh,Abernathy
&McArthur 1980
MarkingSkill
Players
Pyne&
Ackermann1986
Training&
MatchPlay
Umpires
TrainingMatch Play
Skills
Smith 1980
StatisticalAnalysis
Smith,Nettleton& Briggs
1982
Pyke&
Smith1975
Game Analysis
Patrick1983
Relational Data
Patrick1985a
Patrick1985b
Patrick &Lowdon1986
Patrick &McKenna
1986a
Patrick &McKenna
1986b
ComputerisedAnalysis
Game AnalysisStatistical Analysis
Relational Data Computerised Analysis
C
Witherset al.1977
Workloads
Witherset al.1982
MatchAnalyses
Movement Patterns
Withers1979
Specificity
Beard1979
Skills
Spink1988
Coaching
TrainingMatch Play
Skills
Association Football
Soccer ResearchSoccer Research
Withers (1979)Withers (1979)
Maximum transfer from fitness Maximum transfer from fitness work to game?work to game?
Reported movement patterns Reported movement patterns from 1977 pilot study using from 1977 pilot study using player video tracks.player video tracks.
Soccer ResearchSoccer Research
Beard (1979)Beard (1979)
Game-skill analysisGame-skill analysis
SS(trengths) (trengths) WW(eaknesses)(eaknesses)
Coaching InterventionCoaching Intervention