7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

1/43

OF Z@G WFOZGJ \ZIZG\ BIFERWTZL_ LMWRZ

CMR Z@G \MWZ@GRF JO\ZROLZ MC ZGPI\

@MW\ZMF JOSO\OMF

Of rg;

@MW\ZMF RGHOMFIA \TMRZ\FGZXMRE, A.T.

Iaaghgj Jgbtmr.

))))))))

L`iptgr 99

Lisg Fm. 9

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

2/43

o

ZIBAG MC LMFZGFZ\

Tihg

ZIBAG MC IWZ@MROZOG\ ......................................................................................................... oooOFZRMJWLZOMF .......................................................................................................................... 9

I. Z`g Istrms Cmrn Z`g Fgtwmre Zm Nmfgtozg Z`gor Ngjoi Roh`ts. ........................ :B. Lmnlist Ilquorgs I Nofmroty Oftgrgst Of Z`g Fgtwmre. ....................................... 7L. Z`g \trulturg Ifj Lmrpmritg Hmvgrfiflg Mc Z`g Fgtwmre. ................................. 7J. Z`g Aonotgj Tirtfgrs`op Ihrggngft, Z`g Hgfgria Tirtfgr Ihrggngft, Ifj

Z`g Istrms Ngjoi Roh`ts Ihrggngft Iaa Lmftiof Sotia Trmtgltomfs ZmTrmtglt Z`g Istrms Ngjoi Roh`ts. .......................................................................... 3

G. Z`g Istrms Ngjoi Roh`ts Ihrggngft Xot` Z`g Fgtwmre LmftiofsIjjotomfia Trmvosomfs Zm Trmtglt Z`g Istrms Ngjoi Roh`ts. ................................ 8

C. Lmnlists Iccoaoitomf Ihrggngft. .......................................................................... 0H. Lmnlist Ises Z`g Fgtwmre Zm Illgpt Amwgr Bisg Ritgs. .................................. ? @. Z`g Fgtwmre Cioas Zm Nieg Zwm Ngjoi Roh`ts Tiyngfts Zm Z`g Istrms,

Trmvojofh Z`g Istrms Z`g Roh`t Zm Zgrnofitg Z`g Istrms Ngjoi Roh`tsIhrggngft. .............................................................................................................. ?

O. Cmur Lmnlist Iccoaoitgs Coag Z`os Ofvmauftiry Tgtotomf Of If Ittgnpt ZmGaonofitg Z`g Istrms Roh`t Zm Zgrnofitg Z`g Ngjoi Roh`ts Ihrggngft. ......... 949. Lmnlist Ngjoi. ........................................................................................ 992. Lmnlist Liaocmrfoi. .................................................................................. 99

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

3/43

oo

I. Tgtotomfofh Lrgjotmrs Liffmt Jgnmfstritg Z`it Z`grg Irg Z`rgg @majgrsMc Fmflmftofhgft, Wfjosputgj Laions Wfjgr \gltomf

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

4/43

ooo

ZIBAG MC IWZ@MROZOG\

Tihg(s)

LisgsBrgffifs Ofl. v. Joleog Brgffif & Lm.,

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

5/43

ov

Of rg @irns,94 B.R. 098 (Bifer. J. Lmam. 9?09) ................................................................................... 23,

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

6/43

v

Of rg Ziyamr,?9< C.2j 942 (

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

7/43

OFZRMJWLZOMF

Z`g Lmurt s`muaj rgkglt Lmnlists ittgnpt tm put t`g @mustmf Rghomfia \pmrts Fgtwmre,

A.T. (t`g Fgtwmre) oftm biferuptly. Z`g Istrms ifj Lmnlist (iamfh wot` t`g Rmlegts) irg

pirtfgrs of t`g Fgtwmre ifj t`gy `ivg i josihrggngft ibmut `mw t`gor pirtfgrs`op s`muaj bg ruf.

Lmnlists Ofvmauftiry Tgtotomf sgrvgs fm aghotonitg rgmrhifozitomf mbkgltovg ufjgr l`iptgr 99,

ifj ot bgfgcots fm laiss mc ufsglurgj lrgjotmrs. Z`g Ofvmauftiry Tgtotomf coagj of t`os iltomf os i

trifspirgft ittgnpt tm ilquorg t`g Fgtwmre ifj hiof lmftrma mvgr t`g Istrms nmst viauibag issgt,

t`g ngjoi roh`ts tm tgagvosg t`gor mwf Nikmr Agihug Bisgbiaa hings. \oflg t`g Istrms prmvojgj

t`g Fgtwmre i aolgfsg tm tgagvosg Istrms hings ifj Lmnlist ihrggj tm niregt t`g Fgtwmres

prmhrinnofh tm mt`gr libag jostrobutmrs, Lmnlist `is jgaovgrgj mfay ofcmrnia prmpmsias tm gftgr

amfh-tgrn iccoaoitomf ihrggngfts wot` ufjgrviaugj ritgs t`it wmuaj kgmpirjozg t`g Istrms cuturg

sullgss of bmt` bisgbiaa ifj busofgss mpgritomfs. Kust t`rgg jiys bgcmrg t`g Istrms lmuaj

tgrnofitg t`gor ngjoi roh`ts ihrggngft wot` t`g Fgtwmre ifj cofj i strmfhgr ngjoi roh`ts

cmufjitomf cmr t`g Istrms, Lmnlist mrl`gstritgj t`g biferuptly tm hiof agvgrihg mvgr t`g Istrms

of t`gor busofgss josputg.

Z`g Ofvmauftiry Tgtotomf s`muaj bg josnossgj cmr t`g cmaamwofh t`rgg sgpiritg ifj

ofjgpgfjgft rgismfs. Corst, Lmnlist liffmt sitoscy \gltomf

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

8/43

2

ngjoi roh`ts ihrggngfts, w`ol` irg bmt` pgrsmfia sgrvolgs lmftrilts ifj liffmt bg issohfgj is i

nittgr mc aiw.

Z`grg irg fm t`orj-pirty lrgjotmrs oftgrgsts it stieg grg. Gil` mc t`g Tgtotomfofh

Lrgjotmrs os i subsojoiry mc Lmnlist ifj gil` os if iccoaoitg mc t`g Lmnlist gftoty, @mustmf

\pmrtsFgt @majofhs, AAL, t`it mwfs Lmnlists oftgrgsts of t`g Fgtwmre. Z`grg irg fm bmfi cojg

aoiboaotogs t`it irg mwgj tm t`g Tgtotomfofh Lrgjotmrsifj t`grg irg lgrtiofay fmt t`rgg jostoflt

bmfi cojg aoiboaotogs tm sitoscy \gltomf

7/22/2019 Astros Motion to Dismiss CSN Houston Bankruptcy (Redacted)

9/43