asml us inc. vs xtal inc. · 2019. 4. 23. · comment for order directing xtal, inc. and its...

SAMSUNG ASML

Source: Court Superior Court of Santa Clara

ASML US Inc. vs Xtal Inc.

Case Information | 16CV295051

Court: Superior Court of Santa Clara - Civil

File Date : 05/11/2016

Case Type: Business Tort/Unfair Bus Prac Unlimited (07)

Case Status: Active

Party Plaintiff/Cross Defendant: ASML US, Inc.

Active Attorneys

Attorney : Towle, Charles Griffith – Retained

Work Phone: 4159561900

Attorney: Ryan, Patrick Martin - Retained


Lead Attorney: Ryan, Patrick Martin - Retained


Attorney: Steinberg, Stephen Cory - Retained

Work Phone: 415-956-1900

Defendant/Cross Complainant: Xtal, Inc.

Active Attorneys

Attorney: Snyder, Tobias George - Retained

Work Phone: 415-613-6905

Lead Attorney: Koppelman, Ryan W - Retained

Work Phone: 650-838-2000

Attorney: Yu, Constance J - Retained

Work Phone: 415-839-8779

Cross Defendant: ASML Holdings, N.V.

Active Attorneys

Attorney: Steinberg, Stephen Cory - Retained

Work Phone: 415-956-1900

Lead Attorney: Ryan, Patrick Martin - Retained


https://nl.letsgodigital.org/industrie-nieuws/samsung-asml/

https://cmportal.scscourt.org/Portal/Case/CaseDetail?eid=V6EMp5FWU0B35TtLF9aeWA2

Events and Hearings

05/11/2016 Civil Case Cover Sheet

05/11/2016 Complaint (Unlimited) (Fee Applies)

05/11/2016 Summons: Issued/Filed

05/17/2016 Proof of Service: Summons DLR (Civil)

06/30/2016 Answer (Unlimited) (Fee Applies)

07/11/2016 Motion: Protective Order

Comment

notice of motion and motion for protective order; 8/18/16 at 9am, dept 8; atty Putterman

07/11/2016 Declaration: In Support

Comment

of Donald J. Putterman in support of motion


Comment

of Tobias G. Snyder in support of motion

07/11/2016 Court Reporter Fee < 1 hour

08/05/2016 Memorandum: Points and Authorities

Comment

in opposition to Defendant Xtal, Inc.'s Motion for Protective Order

08/05/2016 Declaration: In Opposition

Comment

of Harry A. Mittleman in opposition to Defendant Xtal, Inc.'s Motion for Protective Order


Comment

of Wayne Hale in opposition to Defendant Xtal, Inc.'s Motion for Protective Order

08/12/2016 Supplemental

Comment

declaration of Zongchang Yu in support of Deft. XTAL inc's reply in support of mtn for protective order

08/12/2016 Application

Comment

for a nunc pro tunc order granting leave to file oversized reply brief

08/12/2016 Errata

Comment

to dft XTAL inc's reply in support of mtn for a protective order

08/12/2016 Response/Reply

Comment

in support of mtn for protective order

08/12/2016 Declaration

Comment

of Jiangwei Li in support of mtn for protective order


Comment

of Hua-Yu Liu in support of mtn for protective order


Comment

of Song Lan in support of mtn for protective order


Comment

of Zongchang Yu in support of reply in support of mtn for protective order

08/15/2016 Opposition/Objections

Comment

to application for a Nunc Pro Tunc order granting leave to file oversized reply brief

08/15/2016 Objection: Evidence

Comment

to excess pages and new arguments and evidence submitted with def Xtal, Inc.'s reply in support of its motion for protective order

08/18/2016 Minute Order

08/18/2016 Reserved: Discovery

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Motion for Protective Order by Def Xtal Inc. (Donald Putterman) Melanie 415-685-0736 rta 7-11-16

08/19/2016 Order After Hearing - POS

Comment

Def Xtal Inc's Motion for Protective Order is DENIED. Signed by Judge Folan *see file for details*

08/22/2016 Stipulation and Order

Comment

CANCELLED granting motion for protective order continued from 8/18/16 to 8/25/16 D-8 9am signed by Judge Folan

08/22/2016 Statement: Case Management Conference


08/22/2016 Proof of Service

08/22/2016 Request

Comment

for Action taking 8/25/16 motion for protective order off calendar amd stipulation and order vacated nunc pro tunc signed by Judge Folan*see file for details*


Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

Delaying the time for Xtal to Respond to Plt ASMUL US, Inc.'s First Set of Request for Production of Documents and Things to Def Xtal, Inc., ASML's Form Interrogatories, Set One and ASML's

First Set of Special Interrogs to Def Xtal, Inc. by Def Xtal Inc. (Donald Putterman) Melanie 415-685-0736 rta 7-11-16 *C/F 8/18 per S&O*

09/01/2016 Notice

Comment

of intent to appear by telephone

09/01/2016 Advance jury fee (Nonrefundable)

Comment

$150 deposited



09/06/2016 Conference: Case Management

Original Type

Conference: Case Management

Judicial Officer

Strickland, Elizabeth

Hearing Time

3:30 PM

Result

Held

Comment

COURT CALL BY: Contact: Richard W. Krebs For: Plaintiff(s), ASML US, Inc. Contact: Harry A Mittleman For: Plaintiff(s), ASML US, Inc.

09/14/2016 Ex Parte Application - Notice Required

Comment

for Order Directing XTal, Inc. and Its Counsel to Return Privileged Doc and to Withdraw or Seal Privilieged Doc from the Court Record or in the Alternative OST an Mtn (Harry Mittleman)

09/14/2016 Order

Comment

directing XTAL, Inc. & its counsel to return priviledge document & to withdraw or seal privileged doc from court record or, in the alt. shortening time re: mtn. A hearing will be held on Oct.

06, with moving papers filed by Sept. 14, opposition by Sept. 22, and reply by Sept. 28. Courtesy copies to be give to judge of all docs, signed by Judge Folan

09/14/2016 Clerk Rejection Letter

Comment

Motion for Order not served

09/15/2016 Motion: Order

Comment

atty: Mittleman, 10/06/16 @ 9am, dept. 8


Comment

Richard W. Krembs


Comment

atty: Mittleman, 10/06/16 @ 9am, dept. 8

09/15/2016 Proof of Service: Mail

Comment

supporting mtn docs

09/19/2016 Notice: Ruling


Comment

to motion for an order directing XTAL, Inc. and its counsel to return priviledged document and to withdraw or seal priviledged document from the court record

09/22/2016 Objection: Evidence

Comment

to declaration of Richard W. Krebs in support of plt's motion for an order directing XTAL, Inc. and its counsel to return priviledged document and to withdraw or seal priviledged document

from the court record


Comment

Constance J. Yu in opposition to plt's motion for an order directing XTAL, Inc. and its counsel to return priviledged document and to withdraw or seal priviledged document from the court

record



Comment

Reply in Support of Mtn for Order Directing Xtal, Inc. and Its Counsel to Return Privileged Doc and to withdraw or Seal Privi leged Doc from the Court Record (Harry A. Mittleman) 10-6-16 D8


Comment

of David Kim in Suport of Mtn for Order Directing Xtal, Inc. and Its Counsel to Return Privileged Doc and to withdraw or Seal Privileged Doc from the Court Record (Harry A. Mittleman) 10-6-

16 D8


Comment

Reply in Support of Mtn for Order Directing Xtal, Inc. and Its Counsel to Return Privileged Doc and to withdraw or Seal Privileged Doc from the Court Record (Harry A. Mittleman) 10-6-16 D8



Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Directing Def Xtal Inc. & Counsel to Return an Attorney-Client Privileged Document to Counsel for ASML US, Inc. and to Withdraw or Seal Privileged Document from Court Record by Plt

ASML US, Inc. (Harry A. Mittleman)

10/07/2016 Motion: Compel

Comment

Atty Krebs, 11/8/16 @ 9;00am D-8



Comment

of Richard W. Krebs

10/07/2016 Separate Statement


10/24/2016 Order: Submitted Matter

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Comment

Hrg: 10-6-16, d-8, Mtn is Granted by Judge Folan.

10/26/2016 Other

Comment

Ntic of Undocumented Action Exhibit C to declaraton filed 8/12/16


Comment

stipulation and protective order - GRANTED by Judge Folan *see order for details*


Comment

Opp to Plt ASML US, Inc's Mtn to Compel on 11-8-16 (Donald Putterman)



Comment

Of Bill Lee


Comment

Of Tobias Snyder


Comment

To Plt's Separate Statement (Tobias Snyder)

10/31/2016 Notice: Change Address/Firm Name


Comment

Reply in Support of Mtn to Compel Discovery from Def Xtal, Inc. (Jonathan S. Kagan) 11-8-16 D8


Comment

of Wayne Hale in Support of Reply in Support of Mtn to Compel Discovery from Def Xtal, Inc. (Jonathan S. Kagan) 11-8-16 D8


Comment

Reply to Def XTal, Inc. Oppos to Separate Statement of Disputed Requests and Resonses (Jonathan Kagan) 11-8-16 D8


Comment

Decl of Richard Krebs in Support of Reply in Support of Mtn to Compel Discovery from Def Xtal, Inc. (Jonathan S. Kagan) 11-8-16 D8


Comment

Reply in Support of Mtn to Compel Discovery from Def Xtal, Inc. (Jonathan S. Kagan) 11-8-16 D8

11/02/2016 Stipulation and Order: Ex Parte

Comment

for Leave to filed Cross-Complaint (Donald Putterman) *Pending*


Comment

For leave to file a cross-complt; See file for details. Signed Judge Folan


Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

mtc by Plts (Harry Littleman) ab 09-28-16 Jim M. 310-203-7073

11/04/2016 Other

Comment

Surreply in opposition to plt Asml US, Inc. motion to compel discovery from def Xtal, Inc.


Comment

of Constance J. Yu in oppositon Surreply in opposition to plt Asml US, Inc. motion to compel discovery from def Xtal, Inc.


11/07/2016 Cross-Complaint

11/07/2016 Summons: Issued/Filed

Comment

cross-complaint



Judicial Officer

Stoelker, James L

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Def Xtal, Inc. to Provide Further Responses, Production of Documents, Information Responsive to the Document Requests and Interrogs Set Forth in the Separate Statement of Disputed

REquests and Responses Filed in this Motion by Plt Asml US, Inc. (Harry Mittleman)


Comment

attys Yu and Mittleman

12/05/2016 Motion: Strike

Comment

certain XTAL, Inc.'s prayers for relief in its xcmplt H. Mittleman 1/10/17, 9a, D8



12/05/2016 Demurrer

Comment

to XTAL, Inc.'s x-cmplt; memo of p&a H. Mittleman 1/10/17, 9a, D8




Comment

special mtn to strike x-cmplt; memo of p&a H. Mittleman 1/10/17, 9a, D8



Comment

of Gray Zhang in supp of mtn to strike x-cmplt & demurrer


Comment

of Yu Cao in supp of mtn to strike x-cmplt & demurrer


Comment

of David Kim in supp of mtn to strike x-cmplt & demurrer


Comment

of Richard Krebs in supp of mtn to strike x-cmplt & demurrer


12/06/2016 Conference: Further Case Management

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

10:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

COURT CALL BY: Contact: Richard W. Krebs For: Plaintiff(s), ASML US, Inc. Contact: Harry A Mittleman For: Plaintiff(s), ASML US, Inc

12/07/2016 Proof of Service: Summons DLR (Civil)

Comment

cross-complaint



Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

mtn for sanctions by Plt ASML US, Inc. (Harry Mittleman) 310-277-1010


Comment

for OST a Mtn for Leave to Conduct Discovery Re Special Mtn to Strike and Mtn to Compel Further Response to Special Interrogs (Tobias Snyder)


Comment

Oppos to XTal, Inc's Ex Parte Appl for OST a Mtn for Leave to Conduct Discovery Re Special Mtn to Strike and Mtn to Compel Further Response to Special Interrogs (Harry A. Mittleman)

12/09/2016 Order: Ex Parte

Comment

Stip/Order Re Oppos Deadling is 12-19-16 and Reply deadline is 1-3-17 on Special Mtn to Strike (signed by judge Folan) *See Doc for detail*


Judicial Officer

Stoelker, James L

Comment

re: Discovery matter - Monetary sanctions are DENIED to both sides. (Judge Stoelker) hrg 11/8/16 9am D-13 *see for further details


Comment

opposition to ASML's motion to strike 1-10-17 9am dept.8


Comment

opposition to ASML's demurrer to cross complaint 1-10-17 9am dept.8


Comment

Evidentiary Objections to declaration of Richard W. Krebs in support of ASML's demurrer and special motion to strike 1-10-17 9am dept.8


Comment

opposition and objections 1-10-17 9am dept.8

12/20/2016 Notice

Comment

of Lodging documents under Seal in connection with its Opposition to Plt/X-Def's Special Motion to Strike (Donald J. Putterman) 01/10/17 @9am in d-8


Comment

by Overnight delivery


Comment

Redacted-Declaration of Huyan Liu in support of Def's Opposition to Plt/X-Def's Specail Motion to Strike


Comment

Redacted- Declaration of Song Lan in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Redacted- Declaration of Zongchang Yu in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Declaration of Tobias G. Snyder in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Declaration of Xun Chen in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Declaration of Weijie Shi in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Declaration of Bill Lee in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Declaration of Fengliang Liu in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

to Plt/X-Def's Special Motionto Strike by Def (Donald J. Putterman) 01/10/17 @9am in D8


Comment

of Donald J. Putterman in suppport of Def's Opposition to Plt/X-Def's Special Motion to Strike

12/20/2016 Lodged Under Seal

Comment

Declaration of Zongchabg Yu in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Declaration of Huayu Lui in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

Declaration of Song Lan in support of Def's Oppposition to Plt/X-Def's special Motion to Strike


Comment

reply in support of its special motion to strike cross-complaint 1-10-17 9am dept.8

01/03/2017 Motion: Seal

Comment

D. Putterman 2/2/17, 9a, D8



Comment

reply in support of its demurrer to cross-compalint 1-10-17 9am dept.8


Comment

of Bill Lee


Comment

reply brief in support of its motion to strike 1-10-17 9amd ept.8


Comment

to defe Xtal's evidentiary objections to declaration of Richard W. Krebs


Comment

reply and supporting docs

01/03/2017 Joinder

Comment

to special motion to strike 1-10-17 9am dept.8 *$435.00 paid for def**


Comment

$30.00 paid

01/06/2017 Notice

Comment

Of Errata regarding it's Reply Briefs in support of it's Special Motion to Strkie and Demurrer.

01/10/2017 Hearing: Demurrer

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Demurrer to the Cross-Complaint by Plt/X-Def ASML US Inc. (Harry Mittleman)


Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Motion to Strike the Cross-Complaint by Plt/X-Def ASML US Inc. (Harry Mittleman)


Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Special Motion to Strike (Anti-SLAPP) the Cross-Complaint by Plt/X-Def ASML US Inc. (Harry Mittleman)

01/10/2017 Reserved

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

Motion for Sanctions Re: Protective Order by Plt/X-Def ASML US Inc. (Harry Mittleman) Jim 310-203-7073 rta 11-14-16

01/10/2017 Motion: Joinder

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Joinder in ASML US Inc.'s Special Motion to Strike Cross Complaint (CCP 425.16), Demurrer to Cross Complaint, and Motion to Strike Certain Prayers in Cross Complaint vby Cross-Defendant

ASML Holdings N.V. (Harry A. Mittleman)



Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Comment

re: demurrer and mtn to strike GRANTED in part w/out leave to amend DENIED in part by Judge Folan *see order for details**


Comment

re: mtn to file docs under seal GRANTED by Judge Folan counsel to contact clerk to facilitate sealing *see order for details*


02/02/2017 Motion: Seal Records

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Motion to File Under Seal by Def Xtal Inc. (Donald Putterman)

02/14/2017 Filed Under Seal

Comment

decl of Richard Krebs in support of Demurrer and Special Mtn to Strike

02/16/2017 Ex Parte Application

Comment

for order granting req to file docs under seal (Tobias G. Snyder)

02/16/2017 Appeal deposit for clerk's transcript

02/16/2017 Notice: Appeal

Comment

$775.00 to court of appeals

02/22/2017 Ex Parte Application

Comment

for order granting req to file docs under seal (Tobias G. Snyder)

02/22/2017 Order

Comment

DENYING order granting reequest to file docs under seal. bring ntced mtn. see file for details. signed by Judge Folan

02/22/2017 Order

Comment

re: request to file docs under seal. order need to modified to address CRC 2.250. see file for details. ordered by Judge Folan


Comment

Mtn for award of mandatory atty fees and costs - mtn is not reserved.

02/23/2017 Motion: Attorney's Fees

Comment

& costs; memo of p&a H. Mittleman 3/16/17, 9a, D8



Comment

of Harry Mittleman

02/27/2017 Designation

Comment

reporter's 8.130

02/27/2017 Designation: Rule 8.124

03/01/2017 Proof of Service: Personal

Comment

Appellants ntc designating record on appeal

03/02/2017 Notice of Appeal - Court of Appeal

Comment

D. Putterman


Comment

to mtn for atty fees and costs (atty: Tobias Snyder) 3/16/17 D-8 @9


Comment

of Tobias Snyder re: mtn for atty fees and costs 3/16/17 D-8 @9

03/02/2017 Request: Judicial Notice


Comment

atty: Putterman, 04/11/17 @ 9am, Dept. 8


Comment

Bill Lee


Comment

Tobias G. Snyder


Comment

atty: Putterman, 04/11/17 @ 9am, Dept. 8



Comment

brief in sup of mtn for award on attys fees & costs (Jonathan S. Kagan) hrg 3/16/17 9am D-8


Comment

brief in sup of mtn for award on attys fees & costs (Jonathan S. Kagan) hrg 3/16/17 9am D-8



Comment

reporter's 8.130




03/16/2017 Hearing: Other

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Motion for Award of Attorney Fees and Costs by Plt/X-Def ASML US Inc and ASML Holding NV (Harry Mittleman)


Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Comment

re: mtn for atty fees in part GRANTED by Judge Folan *see order for details*

03/23/2017 Non-Opposition

Comment

to mtn to file docs under seal

03/28/2017 Notice: Appeal (Unlimited)

Comment

$775.00 check attached for Court of Appeals atty Putterman

03/28/2017 Deposit: Clerk's Transcript

Comment

atty Putterman


Comment

stip - Please attach proposed order.

04/07/2017 Notice

Comment

Electing to use and appendix.

04/07/2017 Record on Appeal

Comment

Appellant's ntc designating record on appeal. Reporter's - 8.130.



Comment

Appellant's ntc designating record on appeal.

04/07/2017 Stipulation

Comment

regarding Filing of ASMIL US, INc's Amended Complaint Against XTAL, Inc. (H. Mittleman)

04/07/2017 Order

Comment

Granted Leave to Filing a Amended Complaint (Signed by Judge Folan)

04/07/2017 Complaint: Amended

Comment

Atty H. Mittleman



Comment

re: mtn for order to file under seal GRANTED by Judge Folan



Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Granting Request to File Documents Under Seal (Donald J. Putterman)

04/17/2017 Notice

Comment

of Undocuments Action: Filed Under Seal Pursuant to the Attached Court Order filed 4-11-17 ----Unredacted (See file for Detail)

05/10/2017 Demurrer

Comment

Ntc of hearing on Demurrer and Demurrer to plaintiff's First Amended Complaint. 07/06/17 9AM D-8.



Comment

In support of Demurrer.


Comment

Ntc of motion and motion for Protective Order Staying Discovery; Memo of P's and A;s in support thereof. 07/06/17 9AM D-8.



Comment

Decl of Tobias G. Snyder.


Comment

Of Ntc of mtn for Protective Order and Notice of Demurrer.



Comment

Atty Mitlteman


Comment

cmc

06/06/2017 Referral: Mediation


06/06/2017 Conference: Further Case Management

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

10:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

*continued from 12-6-16*


Comment

to cont demurrer & mtn for protective order (Tobias G. Snyder)


Comment

app is GRANTED. Hrg on demurrer & mtn for protective order is cont. to 8/3/17 9am D-8. (Donald J. Putterman& Harry Mittleman) SIgned by Judge Folan *see for details

07/06/2017 Reserved: Demurrer

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

mtn to strike the First Amended Complaint by Def (Donald Putterman) 415-685-0761


Comment

Implementing Standstill agreement pending July 14, 2017 Mediation (Signed by Judge Folan) *see file for detail*


Comment

for order entering stip to cont hrg on xtal's demurrer & mtn for protective order to 9/7/17 (Harry A. Mittleman)


Comment

app is GRANTED. Xtal's demurrer & mtn for protective order shall be heard on 9/7/17 9am D-8. Opp due by 8/24/17. Reply due 8/630/17. (Tobias G. Snyder & Harry A. Mittleman) Signed by

Judge Folan

08/14/2017 Notice: Default (Appeal)

Comment

Default APP XTAL, Inc.-- RT Fees not timely deposited. For appeal filed 3/28/17 H044779


Comment

in opp to mtn for protective order (atty: Harry Mittleman) 9/7/17 D-8 @9


Comment

of Harry Mittleman re: opp to mtn for protective order 9/7/17 D-8 @9


Comment

in opp to demurrer (atty: Harry Mittleman) 9/7/17 D-8 @9


Comment

Appendix 8.124 & Reporter's 8.130


Comment

Appendix 8.124 & Reporter's 8.130

08/24/2017 Deposit: Reporter's Transcript

Comment

$80.00 deposit -- [half day for 1 out of 2 appeals]

08/24/2017 Deposit: Reporter's Transcript

Comment

$80.00 deposit -- [half day for 1 out of 2 appeals]



08/25/2017 Appeal: Cross-Appellant's Default Notice

Comment

Cross Appellant Xtal, Inc.--RT Deposit not timely deposited. For Cross Appeal filed 3/2/17 H044654


Comment

in support of demurrer (atty: Donald Putterman) 9/7/17 D-8 @9


Comment

in support of mtn for protective order (atty: Donald Putterman) 9/7/17 D-8 @9


Comment

of Tobias G Snyder re: mtn for protective order 9/7/17 D-8 @9


Comment

re: reply in support 9/7/17 D-8 @9


Comment

Order is needed for the 09/07/2017 date.

09/05/2017 Stipulation and Order: ADR

Comment

Appointed Hon. Wayne Brazil (Ret.) JAMS as Mediator; Session held on 7-14-17 (Signed by Judge Folan)




Comment

re: demurrer OFF CALENDAR and mtn for protective order GRANTED by Judge Folan *see order for details*


Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

to the First Amended Complaint by Def Xtal, Inc (Donald Putterman) *C/F 7/6/17 & 8/3/17 per 6/14/17 & 7/19/17 Stip*


Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

by Def Xtal, Inc (Donald Putterman) *C/F 7/6/17 & 8/3/17 per 6/14/17 & 7/19/17 Stip*


10/06/2017 Notice: Association/Co-Counsel

Comment

Associating: Atty Ryan, Atty Towel, Atty Steinberg. Firm: Bartko, Zankel, Bunzel, and MIller.

10/11/2017 Statement: Mediation Review


10/12/2017 Review: Mediation Status

Judicial Officer

Folan, Maureen A

Hearing Time

10:30 AM

Result

Held

12/11/2017 Motion: Leave

Comment

Notice of Motion and Motion for Leave to File Second Amended Complaint; Memorandum in Support; and Declaration of Stephen Steinberg 1/04/18 9 am D8 Atty Kagan



Comment

to Plt ASML US, Inc's Mtn for Leave to File SAC (Constance Yu)


Comment

of Tobias Snyder in opposition to Plt ASML US INC's Mtn for leave to file SAC (Constance Yu)

12/20/2017 Proof of Service: Electronic

Comment

cc to Patrick Ryan

12/21/2017 Motion (Amended)

Comment

Amended notice of motion and motion for leave to file second amended complaint 1/4/18 @ 9AM D19


Comment

Reply in support of motion for leave to file a 2nd amended complaint, 01-04-18 9am D-19, by atty McTigue.

01/03/2018 Notice: Association/Co-Counsel




Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

Motion to Modify Protective Order by Plt ((Harry Midlman) 310-203-7073 09/28/17 (Jim)

01/04/2018 Motion: Leave to File

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Not Held

Comment

Second Amended Complaint by Plt/X-Def ASML US, INC. and X-Def ASML Holdings, N.V. (Harry A. Mittleman)

01/05/2018 Stipulation and Appointment of Official Reporter Pro Tempore

Comment

Signed by Judge Kirwan


Comment

Responses to Requests for Special Interrogatories, and to Deem Requests for Admission Admitted 02/08/2018 9:00am, D-19. Atty. Steinberg *Cont to 032718 D19*


Comment

of Stephen C. Steinberg in Support of Motion to Compel with Exhibits A-O [Ex. N Filed Under Seal]

01/17/2018 Filed Under Seal

Comment

Exhibit N to Declaration of Stephen C. Steinberg in Support of Motion to Compel



Comment

and Appointment of Official Reporter Pro Tempore (Judge Kirwan)

01/24/2018 Order

Comment

Granting Plt's Mtn for Leave to File SAC (Judge Kirwan)


Comment

(Second)


Comment

to ASML's Mtn to Compel (Lopez)


Comment

of Nicole Lopex. hrg 02/08/18 *Cont to 032718 D19*


Comment

hrg 02/08/18 *Cont to 032718 D19*

01/29/2018 Notice: Entry of Order

01/29/2018 Clerks Certificate/Compliance


Comment

for OST on mtn for relief from protective order (Sean R. McTigue)


Comment

Application for an Order Shortening Time for hearing on protective order is GRANTED and will be heard on 3-27-18 at 9am in Dept. 19, signed Judge Kirwan.



Comment

Reply in support of motion to compel admissions, 2-08-18 9am D-19, by atty Mettleman.

02/05/2018 Demurrer

Comment

Notice of hearing on demurrer and demurrer to plaintiff's SAC 4/24/18 @ 9AM D19 Attorney Snyder


Comment

in support of demurrer to Pltf's SAC


Comment

of Attorney Snyder in support of demurrer


Comment

Overnight and personal

02/07/2018 Appeal: Notice to Court Reporter

Comment

for H044654

02/07/2018 Appeal: Clerk's Certificate of Compliance

Comment

For H044779


Comment

Amended, for H044654


Comment

For H044779


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Not Held

Comment

Responses to Requests for Production and Special Interrogatories and to Deem Requests for Admission Admitted by Plt and X-Def ASML US, Inc. and X-Def ASML Holdings, N.V. (Harry

Mittleman) *Cont to 03/27/18 per Minute Order*



Comment

and Order Granting Stipulated Order by Judge Kirwan (see order for details)

03/01/2018 Notice: Change Address/Firm Name

Comment

Notice of Change of Address??

03/06/2018 Appeal: Receipt for Record

03/06/2018 Appeal: Notice of Completion


Comment

from DCA


Comment

Confidential, Highly Confidential, Source Code Designations Signed by Judge Kirwan



Comment

K. Chok


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

Mtn for Relief from Protective Order. OST. Reserved per 01/30/18 Order by Plt ASML (Ryan)


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment


Mittleman) *Cont from 020818 and 032718 per Minute Order*

04/11/2018 Brief

Comment

Supplemental Opening Brief. 042418 D19 9AM.


Comment

MPA in Opposition to Xtal's Demurrer to Second Amended Complaint. 042418 D19 9am


Comment

XTAL Reply ISO Demurrer to 2nd Amended Complaint


Comment

XTAL Mot. to File Under Seal Exhibit E


Comment

Proof of Service

04/19/2018 Appeal: Notice of Completion

Comment

H044779


Comment

H044779


Comment

Supplemental Reply Brief Regarding Motions to Compel Filed on 1/17/18

04/23/2018 Errata

Comment

Re: Motion to File Doc under seal - Correct hearing date is: 06/26/2018, 9am, D19


Comment

XTAL Opposition to ASML Supplemental Brief (Redacted)


Comment

Proof of Service


Comment

G. Chikovani Declaration ISO XTAL Opposition



04/24/2018 Order

Comment

re: Demurrer (Judge Kirwan). With POS.


Comment

signed Judge Kirwan.


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

to SAC by Def/X-X-Complainant Xtal, Inc. (Tobias Snyder)


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Continued: Court's Motion

Comment


Mittleman) *Cont from 020818 and 032718 per Minute Order*


Comment

(H044779) Receipt for record from DCA

04/26/2018 Substitution: Attorney

Comment

Old: Harry Mittleman, New: Patrick Ryan


05/01/2018 Conference: Trial Setting

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

11:00 AM

Result

Continued: Court's Motion

05/03/2018 Order

Comment

Stip and Order Re: Discovery Referee (Judge Kirwan)


Comment

Third Amended Verified Complaint

05/11/2018 Order

Comment

Following 04/24/18 Hearing on MTC (Judge Kirwan)


Comment

Supplemental Opening brief


Comment

Declaration


Comment

HRG 6/12/18 Opposition to ASML's Supp Brief


Comment

HRG 6/12/18 Declaration in Opp to Supp Brief


Comment

HRG 6/12/18 Declaration in Opp to ASML's Supp Brief


Comment

Proof of Service for Opp

06/05/2018 Brief

Comment

HRG 6/12/2018 D19 9am. Reply ISO Supplemental Briefing

06/06/2018 Demurrer

Comment

Ntc of Hearing on Demurrer; 8/09/18; 9 AM; D19; Atty Yu



Comment

of Constance Yu



Comment

Granting Stip & Order for Appointment of Reporter for 06/12/18 in D19 by Judge Kirwan



06/12/2018 Hearing: Other

Original Type

Hearing: Other

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

On cal to Update the Court on the Prod of Docs. *Set per 051118 Order, No Moving Papers Needed*

06/12/2018 Hearing: Motion hearings

Original Type

Hearing: Motion hearings

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

to File Documents Under Seal by Def Xtal (Donald Puuterman) *Advanced from 062618 per 042418 Minutes*


Comment

Notice of Motion to Seal; 8/16/18; 9 AM; D19; Atty Steinberg



Comment

of Stephen C. Steinberg

06/19/2018 Motion: Other

Comment

Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Atty: Patrick Ryan. 07/12/2018, 9am, D19


Comment

HRG 7/12/18 MPA ISO Motion for Preliminary Injunction


Comment

HRG 7/12/18 Declaration of Dasso **DOCUMENT REPLACED PER EX PARTE ORDER FILED 6/29/18. SEE DECLARATION FILED 7/5/2018.


Comment

HRG 7/12/18 Declaration of Lu


Comment

HRG 7/12/18 Declaration of Hale


Comment

HRG 7/12/18 Declaration of Steinberg


Comment

Declaration of Ken Dasso ISO Plaintiff's Motion for a Preliminary Injunction


Comment

Declaration of Yen-Wen Lu ISO Plaintiff's Motion for a Preliminary Injunction


Comment

Declaration of Stephen c. Steinberg ISO Plaintiff's Motion for a Preliminary Injunction.


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

to File Documents Under Seal by Def XTAL (Donald Putterman) *Advanced to 061218 per 042418 Minutes*


Comment

HRG 7/12/18 XTAL Opposition to ASML Preliminary Injunction


Comment

of G. Chikovani ISO Opposition


Comment

of Wanyu Li ISO Opposition


Comment

of Hua Yu Lu ISO Opposition


Comment

of Jerry Bui ISO Opposition


Comment

of Jiangwei Li ISO Opposition


Comment

of Stein Hajek ISO Opposition


Comment

of Song Lan ISO Opposition


Comment

of Zongchang Yu ISO Opposition


Comment

XTAL Motion to File Under Seal; 8/23/18; 9 AM; D19; Atty Putterman


Comment

of G. Chikovani



Comment

Stipulation and Appointment of Official Reporter Pro Tempore


Comment

re: ex parte application to remove exhibit H - GRANTED by Judge Kirwan *see order for details*


Comment

HRG 7/12/18 Declaration of Ken Dasso in Support of Plaintiff's Motion for a Preliminary Injunction


Comment

HRG 8/16/18 Amended Memorandum of Points & Authorities in Support of ASML Motion to Seal


Comment

HRG 7/12/2018 Declaration of Stephen Steinberg


Comment

HRG 7/12/2018 ASML's Reply in Support of Preliminary Injunction



07/12/2018 Reserved

Judicial Officer

Pierce, Mark H

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

Motion for Preliminary Injunction (Evidentiary Hearing with Live Witness) by Plt ASML (Patrick Ryan) 415-291-4577 terri


Judicial Officer

Pierce, Mark H

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

for Preliminary Injunction by Plt/XDef ASML US, IInc. and XDef ASML Holdings, N.V. (Patrick Ryan)



Comment

Declaration of Mindy Wong in Support of Xtal's, Inc's Objections to Discovery Referee's Recommendations and Proposed Order.


Comment

objections to discovery referee's recommendations and Proposed Order


Comment

of Costance J. Yu in support of objection


Comment

of Mindy Wong in support of objections


Comment

of Jiangqei Li in support of objections


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 POS of Lodged Exs


Comment

Application to strike Xtal's objections and declarations filed on 07/17/18, by atty Steinberg.


Comment

Application to strike Xtal's objections and declarations filed on 07/17/18, by atty Steinberg.


Comment

XTAL's Opp to ASML Ex Parte App


Comment

M. Wong Decl.


Comment

HRG 7/27/18 ASML's Response to XTAL's Objections to the Recommendation and Proposed Order or Ret.Hon.James P. Kleinberg


Comment

HRG 7/27/18 Declaration of Sean R. McTigue in Support of Responses to Xtal's Objections

07/26/2018 Errata

Comment

HRG 7/27/18 ASML US, INC.'S NOTICE OF ERRATA REGARDING ITS RESPONSE TO XTAL'S OBJECTIONS TO THE RECOMMENDATION AND PROPOSED ORDER OF RET.HON. JAMES P. KLEINERG,

AND SUPPORTING DECLARATINO OF SEAN R. MCTIGUE


Comment

HRG 8/9/18 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to XTAL's Demurrer to the Third amended Complaint

07/27/2018 Order

Comment

the court declines to set a formal hearing and will rule on the objections once it has had the opportunity to fully review the arguments raised by both parties


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 D19 9am. Mtn to Seal


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 D19 9am DJP Decl

08/01/2018 Motion: Continuance (Trial)

Comment

HRG 8/23/18 D19 9am. Ntc of Motion


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 D19 9am. Memorandum


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 D19 9am. Putterman Decl.


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 D19 9am. Proof

08/01/2018 Order: Proposed

Comment

HRG 8/23/18 D19 9am. PO Cover Page


Comment

Declaration of Donald Putterman in Support of Def/X-Complainant Xtal's Mtn to Continue Trial (Donald Putterman)


Comment

HRG 8/9/18 XTAL, Inc. Reply


Comment

HRG 8/19/18 Stipulation and Appointment of Official Reporter Pro Tempore



Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

to the Third Amended Complaint by Def/XComplainant XTAL, Inc. (Constance Yu)


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 ASML's Opposition to Motion to Contiue Trial


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 Declaration of S. McTigue ISO Opposition to Motion to Compel



Comment

HRG 8/23/18 XTAL Reply ISO Mot. to Continue


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

filed in support of X-Def ASML Holding's Mtn for Prelim injunction by X-Def ASML Holdings (Andrew Weintraub)

08/20/2018 Answer: Amended Complaint

Comment

To third amended complaint; Atty Yu


Comment

HRG 8/23/18 Stipulation and Appointment of Offical Reporter ** Granted by Judge Kirwan**








Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

to File Docs Under Seal in Connection with Opposition to Preliminary Injunction Motion by Def/X-Complainant Xtal, Inc. (George Chikovani)

08/23/2018 Motion: Continue

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Trial by Def/X-Complainant Xtal Inc. (George Chikovani)


Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

to File Documents Under Seal by Def/X-Claimant Xtal, Inc. (Donald Putterman)


Comment

RE: Objections to Recommendations and Proposed Order of Discovery Referee


Comment

Notice: Entry of Order


Comment

Hrg: 7-12-18, d-2 for d-19, the Mtn is Granted, signed by Judge Pierce

09/14/2018 Answer: Amended

Comment

Amended Answer to 3rd Amended Complaint


Comment

to Strike Trade Secret Disclosure Under Cal Civ Proc. Code 2019.210. October 11, 2018 9:00am, D-19. Atty. Wong





Comment

10/11/18 9AM D. 19 atty Wong Motion to File Under Seal


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 Wong Declaration


Comment

HRG 10/11/18


Comment

Exhibits to be lodged under seal must be e-Filed prior.


Comment

Demurrer and motion to strike. Atty: Ryan. HRG: 10/11/2018, 9AM, D19


Comment

Declaration of Sean McTigue in support of demurrer and motion to strike

09/25/2018 Notice

Comment

Discovery Referee's Recommendations re: Fees and Costs Claimed by ASML Pertaining to the Proposed Order of August 17, 2018 and Court Order of August 24, 2018


Comment

ASML US, Inc.'s Ps&As in Opposition


Comment

Declaration of Rishi Gupta ISO Opposition


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 XTAL Opposition to ASML Demurrer


Comment

HRG 10/11/2018 Decl. of M. Wong ISO XTAL Oppo.

10/01/2018 Application: Ex Parte (Fee Applies)

Comment

to seal docs in supoprt of motion for sanctions


Comment

of Stephen C. Steinberg in support of ex parte to seal


Comment

for OSC why Xtal should not be found in contempt

10/01/2018 Affidavit

Comment

of Sean R. McTigue in support


Comment

for OST for motion for sanctions


Comment

of Stephen C. Steinberg in support of OST


Comment

Exhibit A to Request for Judicial Notice ISO Defendant's Opposition.


Comment

Motion to file under seal. Atty: Putterman. HRG: 11/20/2018, 9am, D19


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 Stipulation and Appointment of Official Reporter Pro Tempore *WFP J3CAL 10/09/18*


Comment

Exparte application [submitted on 10-01-18] for an OST re: motion for sanctions is GRANTED and shall be heard on 10-22-18 at 2:00PM, signed Judge Kirwan.


Comment

Hrg 10-22-18 - Declaration of Steven Steinberg in support of Motion for Sanctions.

10/02/2018 Motion: Sanctions

Comment

Motion for Sanctions; 10/22/18; 2:00 PM; D19; Atty Steinberg


Comment

Hrg 10/22/18 - in Support of Mtn for Sanctions


Comment

Hrg 10/22/18 - of Wayne Hale in Support of Mtn for Sanctions


Comment

Hrg 10/22/18 - of Ernesto Staroswiecki in Support of Mtn for Sanctions


Comment

Hrg 10/22/18 - of Stephen Steinberg in Support of Mtn for Sanctions


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 ASML's Reply ISO Demurrer to Amended Answer to Third Amended Complaint


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 Declaration of S. McTigue ISO ASML's Reply


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 Reply


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 Decl of C. Yu


Comment

HRG 10/11/18 Proof of Service


Comment

OF XTAL; TO DISCOVERY REFEREE'S RECOMMENDATIONS RE: FEES AND COSTS


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 Proposed Order (OSC Why XTAL & XTAL's Counsel Should Not Be Held in Contempt


Comment

D19. Proposed Order (Referee's Recommendations & Proposed Order re XTAL's Motion to Compel Depositon)


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 - of F. Liu in Support of Opposition to Mtn for Sanctions


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 - to Motion for Sanctions


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 - of C Yu in Support of Opposition to Mtn for Sanctions


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 - of J Li in Support of Opposition to Mtn for Sanctions


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 D19 2PM. Proof of Service


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 - TO PLAINTIFF AND CROSS-DEFENDANT ASML US, INC'S EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR THE COURT TO ISSUE AN ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE WHY XTAL SHOULD NOT BE FOUND IN

CONTEMPT OF COURT


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 D19 2PM. Decl Chicovani


Comment

HRG 10/22/18 D19 2PM. Decl of W. Shi

10/10/2018 Statement: Settlement Conference

Comment

HRG 10/17/18 Settlement Statement

10/11/2018 Statement: Settlement Conference

Comment

HRG 10/17/18 Settlement Conference Statement







10/11/2018 Hearing: Motion to Strike

Judicial Officer

Pierce, Mark H

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Motion to Strike Trade Secret Disclosure by Def/X-Complainant XTAL, Inc. (Mindy Wong)

10/11/2018 Motion: Demurrer and Motion to Strike

Judicial Officer

Pierce, Mark H

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

And/Or Motion to Strike Def XTAL, Inc.'s Amended Answer to the Third Amended Complaint by Plt ASML US, Inc. (Sean McTigue)

10/11/2018 Reserved: Demurrer

Judicial Officer

Pierce, Mark H

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

Motion to Strike the Answer by Plt ASML (Sean McTigue) 415-956-1900 af 8-9-18


Judicial Officer

Pierce, Mark H

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Exhibits C-E to the Declaration of Mindy M. Wong in support of Def/X-Complainant XTAL, Inc.'s Motion to Strike Trade Secret Disclosure by Def/X-Complainant XTAL, Inc. (Mindy Wong)


Comment

Reporter: Katherine Chok for hrg 10-11-18 granted.


Comment

Response to XTAL's Objections to Recommendations re Attornyes Fees


Comment

HRG 10/23/18 Declaration of K Haworth

10/16/2018 Answer/Response (No Fee)

Comment

XTAL 2nd Amended Answer to 3rd Amended Complaint


Comment

Application for immediate status conference or, alternatively, for a pre-trial conference, by atty Putterman.


Comment

Application for immediate status conference or, alternatively, for a pre-trial conference, by atty Putterman.


Comment

Application to seal portion of the exparte application for immediate status conference or, alternatively, for a pre-trial conference, by atty Putterman., by atty Putterman.


Comment

Exhibit M to the exparte application for immediate status conference or, alternatively, for a pre-trial conference, by atty Putterman., by atty Putterman.

10/17/2018 Conference: Settlement Jury

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Judge Pro Tem John McDonnell, D-19 Jury Room

10/19/2018 Brief: Trial

Comment

Trial 10/24/18 ASML's Trial Brief

10/19/2018 Statement

Comment

Trial 10/24/18 ASML' s Statement of the Case

10/19/2018 Exhibit List (Party)

Comment

Trial 10/24/18 ASML's Trial Exhibit List

10/19/2018 Request

Comment

Trial 10/24/18 ASML's Special Instructions

10/19/2018 Request

Comment

Trial 10/24/18 ASML's Proposed Special Verdict Form

10/19/2018 Motion: In Limine

Comment

Trial 10/24/18 ASML's Motion in Limine No. 1


Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment

Trial 10/24/18 ASML's Omnibus Decl. of S. Steinberg and Exhibits


Comment

Trial 10/24/18 Proof of Service ASML's Trial Documents


Comment

Hrg: 10-11-18, on Mtn to Strike, signed by Judge Pierce [eServed 041719, env# 2772244]


Comment

XTAL MIL #1- To Exclude China Computers


Comment

XTAL MIL #2- ASML Agents' Knowledge


Comment

XTAL MIL #3- Bifurcating Damages


Comment

XTAL MIL #4- Character Evidence


Comment

XTAL MIL #5- Expert Depos Not Taken


Comment

XTAL MIL #6- Exclude Lay Witness


Comment

XTAL MIL #7- Exclude Evidence Re User Manuals


Comment

XTAL MIL #8- Exclude Penal Code


Comment

XTAL MIL #9- Exclude PI Order


Comment

XTAL MIL #10- Exclude Undisclosed Experts


Comment

XTAL MIL #11- Exclude Witness


Comment

XTAL MIL #12- Limit Expert Witness


Comment

D. Putterman Decl. Re Compendium of Evidence

10/19/2018 Notice

Comment

XTAL Compendium of Evidence (REDACTED)


Comment

XTAL Trial Exhibit List


Comment

XTAL [Proposed] Statement of the Case

10/19/2018 Jury Instructions (Proposed)

Comment

DEFENDANT AND CROSS-COMPLAINANT XTAL, INC.???S [PROPOSED] JURY INSTRUCTIONS


Comment

Proof of Service


Comment

HRG 10/24/18 ASML's Amended Trial Exhibit List


Comment

XTAL Mot. in Limine No. 14


Comment



Comment



Comment



Comment

XTAL Trial Brief


Comment

M. Wong Decl. ISO XTAL Mots. in Limine and Trial Brief

10/22/2018 Motion: Sanctions

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

2:00 PM

Comment

For Terminating and Issue Sanctions Against Def XTAL, Inc. for failure to comply with Court's Order regarding Discovery by Plt/X-Def ASML US, INC. and X-Def ASML Holdings, N.V. (Stephen

Steinberg) **Set per Ex Parte Order**


Comment

XTAL Motion in Limine no. 7 (REDACTED)


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 2


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 4


Comment

Decl of G Chikovani ISO Opposition to MIL 4


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 6


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 12


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 13


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 14


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 1 and 11


Comment

XTAL to Opp 1 and 11


Comment

XTAL to Opp MIl 3


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 3


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 10


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 5


Comment

XTAL Opp to MIL 9


Comment

XTAL MIL No 17


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML's Amended Exhibit List


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML's Depo Designations


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML's Opposition to MIL 1


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML's Response to MIL 2


Comment



Comment



Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML's Objection & Counter Motion MIL 5


Comment



Comment



Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 SEALED ASML's Objection & Counter Motion MIL 7


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 SEALED ASML's Opposition to MIL 4


Comment



Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 SEALED ASML's Opposition to MIL 8


Comment



Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 SEALED ASML's Response to MIL 9


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML'S Response to MIL 10


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML'S Opposition to MIL 11


Comment



Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML's Emergency MIL 15


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 SEALED ASML's Emergency MIL 15

10/23/2018 Notice

Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 ASML'S Notice of Conditional filing Under Seal


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Decl. of S. Steinberg ISO ASML's Emergency MIL 15


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 SEALED Decl. of S. Steinberg ISO ASML's Emergency MIL 15


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Steinberg Omnibus Decl. ISO ASML's Oppositions to MILs


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 SEALED Steinberg Omnibus Decl. ISO ASML's Oppositions to MILs


Comment

HRG 10/24/18 Supplemental Decl. of E. Staroswiecki ISO ASML Mo/Sanctions


Comment

HRG 10/24/18 Supplemental Decl. of W.Hale ISO ASML Mo/Sanctions


Comment

Pending


Comment

Proof of Service



Comment

Application to strike Xtal Inc.'s unclean hands defense, by atty McTigue.


Comment

Application to strike Xtal Inc.'s unclean hands defense, by atty McTigue.


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Opposition to MIL 13 and 14


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Opposition to MIL 15


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Opposition to MIL 16


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Decl ISO 13 14


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Confid. Decl ISO 13 14


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Decl ISO 16


Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Confid. Decl ISO 16

10/24/2018 Notice

Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Notice of Conditional Lodging 13 14

10/24/2018 Notice

Comment

TRIAL 10/24/18 Notice of Conditional Lodging 16


Comment

Motion to strike Xtal's unclean hands affirmative defense is DENIED, signed Judge Kulkarni. [eServed 102418, env# 2095565]


Comment

modifying preliminary injunction

10/24/2018 Jury Trial: Long Cause

Judicial Officer

Kulkarni, Sunil R

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Result

Held

Comment

Est. 5-7 Days


Comment

RE potential vicarious liability


Comment

Declaration of M. Rieger (REDACTED)


Comment

Declaration of J. Li ISO XTAL Oppo. (REDACTED)


Comment

Declaration


Comment

XTAL Opposition to ASML Ex Parte to Modify PI


Comment

XTAL Opposition to ASML Mot. for Sanctions


Comment

Proof of Service


Comment

Hrg: 10-11-18 Denying Mtn to Strike Trade Secret Disclosure. Mailed a copy to Atty.


Comment

Statement of Partial NOn-Opp to MIL # 18 (McTigue)

10/29/2018 Request

Comment

Regarding Inevitable Disclosure (McTigue)


Comment

Re preliminary injunction

10/29/2018 Amendment

Comment

to order granting mtn for preliminary injunction

10/31/2018 Notice

Comment

TRIAL: 10/24/18 XTAL Certification of Compliance


Comment

TRIAL: 10/24/18 Confidential Decl of J. Li ISO Certification

10/31/2018 Order

Comment

re: Xtal's Mtn in Limine no. 18 (Y. Cao expert deposition)


Comment

ASML's MIL 16 regarding Employee Satisfaction


Comment

ASML's Response Regarding Staroswiecki


Comment

DEFENDANT & CROSSCOMPLAINANT XTAL, INC.???S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 18 RENEWED MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE OR LIMIT THE TESTIMONY OF ASML???S PARTYEXPERT YU CAO


Comment

DECLARATION OF GEORGE CHIKOVANI IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT AND CROSSCOMPLAINANT???S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 18


Comment

DECLARATION OF GEORGE CHIKOVANI IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT AND CROSSCOMPLAINANT???S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 18 (CONFIDENTIAL)


Comment

DECLARATION OF JIANGWEI LI IN SUPPORT OF XTAL, INC.???S CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE COURT???S OCTOBER 29. 2018 ADDENDUM TO ORDER GRANTING ASML???S

MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION (CONFIDENTIAL)


Comment

DECLARATION OF JIANGWEI LI IN SUPPORT OF XTAL, INC.???S CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE COURT???S OCTOBER 29. 2018 ADDENDUM TO ORDER GRANTING ASML???S

MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION (REDACTED)

11/01/2018 Notice

Comment

DEFENDANT XTAL, INC.???S CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE COURT???S OCTOBER 29. 2018 ORDER TO MODIFY THE PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ORDER


Comment

XTAL Application to Seal- A. Winetroub Decl.


Comment

XTAL Application to Seal- G. Chikovani Decl.


Comment

XTAL Application to Seal- J. Li Decl.


Comment

XTAL Application to Seal- M. Wong Decl.


Comment

XTAL Opposition to ASML MIL #16

11/02/2018 Notice

Comment

TRIAL: Ntc of Conditional Filing Under Seal


Comment

Proposed Order Cover with Order re Chikovani


Comment

Proposed Order Cover with Order re Wong


Comment

Proposed Order Cover with Order re Li


Comment

Proposed Order Cover with Order (re Winetroub)

11/15/2018 Amended Complaint Filed - No Fee

Comment

FOURTH; Atty McTigue


Comment

ASML Sealing Brief


Comment

Opp to Yu Cao Motion


Comment

ASML Response to Jury Instructions


Comment

Motion re Rieger


Comment

Brief re Rieger Testimony


Comment

Brief to Exclude Argument


Judicial Officer

Pierce, Mark H

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Cancel Reason

Vacated

Comment

Motion for Order Sealing Exhibit A to the Request for Judicial Notice in Support of Def/X-Complainant XTAL, Inc.'s Opposition to Plt's Demurrer or in the Alternative Motion to Strike XTAL's

Amended Answer to the Third Amended Complaint by Def/X-Complainant XTAL, Inc. (Mindy Wong)

11/29/2018 Jury Fees Posted

Comment

$1,426.27 check #15745 deposited


Comment

***PENDING**HRG 12/19/18 Stipulation and Order


Comment

re: phase II hrg set for 12/19/18 ORDERED by Judge Kulkarni

12/18/2018 Brief

Comment

XTAL Additional Trial Submissions (CONFIDENTIAL)

12/18/2018 Brief

Comment

XTAL Additional Trial Submissions (REDACTED)

12/18/2018 Notice of Bankruptcy Stay - Partial

Comment

as to all parties

12/18/2018 Notice

Comment

of Party Name Change

12/19/2018 Jury Trial: Long Cause (Ongoing)

Judicial Officer

Kulkarni, Sunil R

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Comment

Phase II

01/03/2019 Order

Comment

Re: Judge Kleinberg's previous Order, by Judge Kirwan.

01/08/2019 Notice

Comment

OF REMOVAL TO UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT


Comment



Comment



Comment

for 2nd phase of trial

02/19/2019 Substitution: Attorney

Comment

Old: Putterman New: Koppelman


Comment

McTigue Decl


Comment

Proposed Injunction


Comment

Form of Judgment


Comment

ASML Brief in Support

02/21/2019 Order

Comment

Remanding case back to State Court


Comment

Objection to Proposed Judgement


Comment

Objection to Proposed Injunction

03/05/2019 Judgment

Comment

[Proposed] Judgement on Special Verdict


Comment

Memorandum of P&A in Support of Opposition to Proposed Judgement and Injunction


Comment

(Public-Redacted) Memorandum of P&A in Support of Opposition to Proposed Judgement and Injunction


Comment

(SEALED) Declaration of Ryan Koppelman in Support of Opposition to Proposed Judgement and Injunction


Comment

(Public-Redacted) Declaration of Ryan Koppelman in Support of Opposition to Proposed Judgement and Injunction

03/05/2019 Judgment

Comment

[Proposed] Injunction


Comment

Proof of Service


Comment

HRG 3/22/19 ASML's Reply Brief ISO Form of Injunction and Judgment


Comment

HRG 3/22/19 Steinberg Declaration ISO ASML's Reply


Comment

HRG 3/22/19 ASML's Responses to XTAL's Objections to Proposed Injunction


Comment

HRG 3/22/19 ASML's Objections to XTAL's Proposed Injunction


Comment

HRG 3/22/19 ASML's Responses to XTAL's Proposed Judgment


Comment

HRG 3/22/19 ASML's Objection to XTAL's [Proposed] Judgment on Special Verdict


03/15/2019 Request

Comment

HRG 3/22/19 Request for Appointment of Official Reporter Pro Tempore ***PENDING*** WFP J3LM SUB 4/15/19


Comment

to ct phase II of trial, set for 5/17/19 D8


Comment

EXHIBIT 1


Comment

EXHIBIT 2


Comment

EXHIBIT 3


Comment

EXHIBIT 4


Comment

EXHIBIT 5


Comment

EXHIBIT 6


Comment

EXHIBIT 9


Comment

EXHIBIT 10


Comment

EXHIBIT 11


Comment

#2668594 Exhibits 7 & 8- an Order is required to file documents under seal; or, label documents as "Lodged Conditionally Under Seal"


Comment

to continue reply deadline - GRANTED by Judge Kulkarni *see order for details*


Comment

to allow excess pages on reply - GRANTED by Judge Kulkarni

05/17/2019 Jury Trial: Long Cause (Ongoing)

Judicial Officer

Kulkarni, Sunil R

Hearing Time

9:00 AM

Comment

Phase II

10/03/2019 Review: Case Status

Judicial Officer

Kirwan, Peter

Hearing Time

10:00 AM

Comment

re: Order remanding case back