ASBESTOS SURVEY REPORT

Location: BIN 1052160 North Clinton Avenue over Route 104

City of Rochester, New York PIN SABP.08.101

Prepared for: New York State Department of Transportation

Prepared By:

175 Sully’s Trail, Suite 202 Corporate Crossings Office Park

Pittsford, New York 14534

February 2012 Lu Project # 9920-41

ASBESTOS SURVEY REPORT

Location: BIN 1052160 North Clinton Avenue over Route 104

City of Rochester, New York PIN SABP.08.101

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

1.0 Project Summary .................................................................................................. 1 2.0 Site Description .................................................................................................... 1 3.0 Inspection Procedures ......................................................................................... 2 4.0 Results .................................................................................................................. 3 Certification .................................................................................................................. 3

Figures and Tables Figure 1 Site Location Map Figure 2 Asbestos Bulk Sample Location Plan Table 1 Bulk Sample Results Appendices Appendix A Asbestos Survey Fact Sheet Appendix B Licenses and Certifications Appendix C Laboratory Analysis Report and Chain of Custody

Clinton Avenue over Route 104 City of Rochester, New York February 2012

1

1.0 Project Summary In accordance with conditions of Term Agreement D030924, Lu Engineers conducted an asbestos sampling survey on the North Clinton Avenue Bridge over Route 104 (BIN 1052160). Based on information obtained using the procedures described in Section 3.0 Inspection Procedures, the following summarizes the results of this investigation.

BIN 1052160 – North Clinton Avenue over Route 104 Confirmed Asbestos-Containing Materials (ACMs) Based on laboratory analyses of bulk samples collected, the following materials were determined to contain asbestos: Confirmed ACMs There are no confirmed ACMs on the bridge Inaccessible/Assumed ACMs

Type of Material Typical Location Estimated Amount Friability Condition

Sheet Packing Between Bridge

Deck and Abutment

160 SF Non-Friable Fair

LF = Linear Feet SF = Square Feet

The record drawings indicate that the sheet packing is asbestos containing. No other inaccessible/assumed ACMs were identified. 2.0 Site Description The Site is located in Rochester, New York. For the purpose of this report, the Site consists of BIN 1052160 – North Clinton Avenue over Route 104. The site is indicated on the attached Figure 1 – Site Location Map.

Clinton Avenue over Route 104 City of Rochester, New York February 2012

2

3.0 Inspection Procedures The following procedures were used to obtain the data for this Report:

A. A review of record drawings supplied by Region 4 personnel and a visual inspection of the subject structure were conducted to identify potential visible/accessible sources of asbestos-containing materials. Observations and notes were made to provide a description of the structure, and an estimate of the approximate amount, length, or area of ACM present.

B. Physical or operational constraints, which might affect the removal of the ACM,

were identified and reported.

C. Bulk samples of suspected ACMs were collected during the site inspection of the subject structure. Samples were taken from each homogeneous area that may contain ACM. The investigation was limited to areas of the bridge that could be accessed from the bridge itself or reached from the ground and/or by use of a ladder from below. The approximate location of bulk samples is indicated on Figure 2, Asbestos Bulk Sample Location Plan. The paint system on the bridge had been previously tested by LaBella Associates.

D. Samples were submitted for analysis. Preliminary polarized light microscopy (PLM)

analyses of non-friable, organically bound (NOB) materials were performed by Paradigm Environmental Services, a NYSDOH approved laboratory, to determine the presence and percentage of asbestos in each sample. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analyses of NOB materials, if necessary, were performed by Paradigm Environmental Services.

E. Lab results were used to determine the approximate location, type, and amount of

the verified ACM. Only accessible areas were inspected. Inaccessible areas, such as areas within the bridge or the approaches to the bridge were not included in this inspection. No investigation was conducted by Lu Engineers to determine the presence of underground utilities on or in the immediate vicinity of the Site.

Clinton Avenue over Route 104 City of Rochester, New York February 2012

3

4.0 Results

BIN 1052160 – Clinton Avenue over Route 104 Confirmed Asbestos-Containing Materials (ACMs) There are no confirmed ACMs. Inaccessible/Assumed ACMs Sheet Packing Asbestos-containing black sheet packing is located in the horizontal joint between the abutment and the bridge deck slab at both ends of the bridge. Most of this material is presently covered by the bridge deck, although the edges of this sheet packing are exposed and visible at various locations. It is estimated that the total amount of this asbestos-containing sheet packing material on the bridge is approximately 160 square feet. The approximate locations of this asbestos-containing sheet packing are shown in Figure 2. No other inaccessible/assumed ACMs were identified.

Certification Lu Engineers certifies the accuracy of this report, to the best of our knowledge, based on the information collected as described in the Inspection Procedures Section of this report.

Figures and Table

SAMPLE RESULTS

North Clinton Avenue Bridge over Route 104 City of Rochester, New York

BIN 1052160

Sample #

Sample Location

Type of Material

Results % Asbestos

Amount of Material

Specification Item

1-A Base of Side Rails Grey Caulk No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

1-B Base of Side Rails

Grey Caulk No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

1-C Base of Side Rails

Grey Caulk No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

2-A Bridge Joint Ends Grey Caulk No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

2-B Bridge Joint Ends Grey Caulk No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

2-C Bridge Joint Ends Grey Caulk No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

3-A Middle Bridge Joint Black Rubber No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

3-B Middle Bridge Joint Black Rubber No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

3-C Middle Bridge Joint Black Rubber No Asbestos

Detected NA NA

4-A South End of Bridge on Bearing Support

Grey Masonry Coating

No Asbestos Detected

NA NA

4-B South End of Bridge on Bearing Support

Grey Masonry Coating

Trace Chrysotile

(<1%) NA NA

4-C South End of Bridge on Bearing Support

Grey Masonry Coating

No Asbestos Detected

NA NA

APPENDIX A

Asbestos Survey Fact Sheet

Asbestos Survey Fact Sheet

Name and Address of Building/Structure: North Clinton Avenue over Route 104 (BIN 1052160) City of Rochester, New York Name and Address of Building/Structure Owner: New York State Department of Transportation 50 Wolf Road Albany, New York 12232 Name and Address of Owner’s Agent: Lu Engineer’s 175 Sully’s Trail, Suite 202 Pittsford, New York Name of the Firm & Persons Conducting the Survey: Lu Engineers

Mitchell C. Smith (NYSDOL Cert. #97-15393)

Date Survey Was Conducted: January 31, 2012 List of Homogeneous Areas (Items in Bold Confirmed ACM) Grey Caulk at base of side rails Grey Caulk at bridge joints Black Joint Filler Grey Masonry Coating

APPENDIX B

License and Certifications

APPENDIX C

Laboratory Analysis Report and Chain of Custody