architecture subgroup
DESCRIPTION
New York State Public Service Commission - Platform Technology Working Group. Architecture Subgroup. Ten Slide Outline. Initial Architecture WG Findings & Recommendations What are the gaps – if any? Do the architectural tools and technologies exist to implement the REV/DSPP? - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
NYSDPS
Architecture Subgroup
New York State Public Service Commission - Platform Technology Working Group
XX-XX-2014Page 2
Ten Slide Outline
1. Overall REV/DSPP Scope and Roles2. Framework - NIST Smartgrid Conceptual
model3. Relevance of Architecture to REV/DSPP
Scope & Goalsa. Identification of new values, gaps in
technologies, standards and protocolsb. Standardization and interoperability starts
with architecture – EDI analogy/examplec. Architecture describes the evolution of the
DSPP boundary over timed. Architecture provides a common language
and framework for all NY utilities and market players
4. IEEE 2030 base architecture1. IEEE P2030, why chosen after review of
other architecture standards2. Describe the P2030 architectural layer3. Operating at the Conceptual Architecture
level, not logical or physical
5. Initial Architecture WG Findings & Recommendations
5. What are the gaps – if any?6. Do the architectural tools and technologies
exist to implement the REV/DSPP?7. What issues/trends/technologies should we
be monitoring?8. Continue WG efforts to flesh out
architecture through use cases9. 6-18 month engagement while moving
forward with implementation10. What would a ‘phased’ implementation of
architecture look like? What are the stage-1, near term architectural things that need done?
6. Initial Architecture WG Recommendations
7. Use case (Dynamic Electricity Production Forecasting, DEPF) Power Control layer
8. Use Case - DEPF Communications Layer
9. Use Case - DEPF Information Technology Layer
XX-XX-2014Page 3
REV/DSPP Scope and Roles
• Fuel and resource diversity• System reliability• Reduced carbon emissions
Grid
Ope
ratio
nsM
arke
t Ope
ratio
ns
NY ISO DSPP Customers“Wholesale” Energy and
Capacity
“Wholesale” Market
Administration
Basic and Value Added Services
Wide Area View
Bulk Operations(115 kV and
above)
“Wholesale” Ancillary Services
“Retail to Wholesale” Aggregation
Regional/Local View
T/D/Microgrid Ops(115 kV and
below)
“Retail” Market Administration
Central Generation
ManagementDER Management
Direct Access (Individuals)
3rd PartyService Providers
“Premise” View
DER Operations
“Premise” or Microgrid
Operations
XX-XX-2014Page 44
Framework - Smart Grid Conceptual Model (NIST & SGiP)
DSPP
Domain focus on the customer and service providers’ interactions in the context of electricity markets and operations within the Smart Grid distribution system (figure below).
Major DSPP Interfaces
XX-XX-2014Page 5
Relevance of Architecture to REV/DSPP
5
XX-XX-2014Page 6
IEEE 2030 base architecture
SC
AD
A N
etw
ork
RTU
Dev
ices
VE
LCO
ICC
P
INTE
RN
ET
VPN
& Fi
rew
all
Fire
wal
l
GM
P
Em
ploy
ees
GM
P V
PN
Clie
nt
Cus
tom
ers
# Ap
ps7H
P-U
X
DB
01#
Apps1
Com
pute
r R
oom
INTR
A
# App
s
1
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
00
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
rFYR
E
# App
s
1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
rCH
EC
K
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
rBLO
CK
# App
s
7H
P-U
X
DB
02
# Ap
ps3W
indo
ws
2003
Ent
erpr
ise
Edi
tion
ME
SH
# App
s1
Virtua
l Mac
hine
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d
PR
OB
E
# App
s
1
Virt
ual M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s X
P
Wor
ksta
tionR
ETR
IEV
ER
# App
s
1Virt
ual M
achi
ne
LIN
UX
SO
APR
OD
# App
s
3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d Ser
verG
LOB
AL
# App
s
3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
00
Adv
ance
d S
erve
rMA
TR
IX
# Ap
ps20C
ompu
ter R
oomMO
RP
HE
US
# App
s
3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d Ser
verO
HM
S
# App
s
1
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
00
Ser
ver
OP
ER
ATO
R
# App
s
1
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
00
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
rQU
EU
E
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
r
TIM
E
# App
s
3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
rTRU
MP
# App
s2
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
00
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
r
VER
DE
# Ap
ps1D
ispa
tch
behi
nd B
oard
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ser
ver S
P1
ME
SS
NE
R
# App
s7Bla
de in
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ent
erpr
ise
Edi
tion
ZEU
S
# Ap
ps1C
ompu
ter R
oom
AP
P01
# App
s4C
ompu
ter R
oom
APP
02#
App
s
1
Virt
ual M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ser
ver S
td
DV
R01
# Ap
ps3
Virt
ual M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d S
erve
r
BP
A-A
PP
01
# App
s
1
Virt
ual M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Sta
ndar
d E
ditio
nED
GE
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ent
erpr
ise
Ser
verGR
OU
ND
# App
s
1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ent
erpr
ise
Ser
ver
IMA
GE
PR
OD
# App
s
1
Virtua
l Mac
hine
Win
dow
s X
P
Wor
ksta
tionAD
IRO
ND
AC
K
High
Ava
ilabi
lity
# App
s
20Vi
rtua
l Mac
hine
Win
dow
s 20
03PA
CIN
O
# Ap
ps20Virt
ual M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03SO
PR
AN
O
GM
P - D
MZ
CO
L-E
SX
01
VM
war
e S
erve
r
High
Ava
ilabi
lity
CO
L-E
SX
02
VM
war
e S
erve
r
CO
L-E
SX
03
VM
war
e S
erve
r
CO
L-ES
X04
VM
war
e S
erve
r
# App
s1
SC
AD
A S
erve
rs
# Ap
ps4C
ompu
ter R
oom
WW
W
# App
s
1
Virt
ual M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ent
erpr
ise
Edi
tionD
AR
K
Priv
ate
Clo
ud
Cus
tom
er E
xper
ienc
e
Cor
e
Ora
cle
Peo
pleS
oft
Ente
rpris
e R
even
ue
Man
agem
ent
Cor
e
ITR
ON
MV
90
Cor
e
Sung
uard
HTE
CIS
- H
TE (S
t.
Clo
ud)
Cor
e
Elst
er
Elst
er -
MAS
Cor
e
ITR
ON
Mic
roN
et
Meter Route & Sequence
Info (MRI)/ F
TP 1xDailyC
ore
ITR
ON
Fiel
d C
olle
ctio
n
Syst
em
Surr
ound
n/aO
UC
Con
sum
ptio
n
On-
Line
Cor
e Con
verg
ys
Con
verg
ys IV
R
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
(MR
E) /
FTP
1-5
x D
aily
Man
ual
Mis
sing
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
(MR
I) / F
TP 1
x D
aily
Meter Route & Sequence Info (MRI) /
FTP 1x Daily Manual
Meter Readings (MRE) /
FTP 1-3x Daily Manual
Met
er L
ocat
ion
Info
rmat
ion
/
FTP
ad
hoc
Meter Readings (totalizer) /
FTP 1x Daily Manual
HH
F Lo
ad P
rofil
es /
FTP
1x
Dai
ly A
uto
XML
… /
FTP
Aut
o
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
HH
F Fi
le /
FTP
1x
Dai
ly A
uto
Meter Readings (MRE) /
FTP 1x Daily Manual
Met
er R
oute
& S
eque
nce
Info
(MR
I)/ F
TP 1
-2xD
aily
Man
ual
Acct
Bal
ance
& s
tatu
s --
requ
este
d by
IVR
)
/ dbl
ink/
std
proc
on
dem
and
Information
Technology
Communications
Power Control
SecurityData Integration
Covers all major areas of DSPP
NIST Compliant
National standard
Readily understood and accepted
IEEE is open to enhance as it matures
Most practical to use within the time frame.
XX-XX-2014Page 7
IEEE 2030 view of DSPP architectureSC
AD
A N
etw
ork
RTU
Dev
ices
VELC
O IC
CP
INTE
RN
ET
VPN
& F
irew
all
Fire
wall
GM
P Em
ploy
ees
GM
P V
PN C
lient
Cust
omer
s
# Ap
ps7HP
-UX
DB01
# Ap
ps1Co
mpu
ter R
oom
INTR
A
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dows
200
0
Stan
d ard
Ser
ver
FYR
E
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verCH
ECK
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dows
200
3
Stan
dard
Ser
verBL
OC
K
# Ap
ps7HP
-UX
DB02
# Ap
ps3W
indo
ws
2003
Ente
rpris
e Ed
i tion
ME
SH
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
PRO
BE
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s XP
Wor
ksta
tionRE
TRIE
VER
# Ap
ps1Vi
rtual
Mac
hine
LIN
UX
SOAP
ROD
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verG
LOB
AL
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
00
Adva
nced
Se r
verM
ATR
IX
# Ap
ps20Co
mpu
ter R
oomM
OR
PHE
US
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
ver
OH
MS
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
00
Serv
er
OPE
RAT
OR
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dows
200
0
Stan
dard
Ser
verQ
UEU
E
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
ver
TIM
E
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verTR
UM
P
# Ap
ps2
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
00
Stan
dard
Ser
ver
VERD
E
# Ap
ps1Di
spat
ch b
ehin
d B
oard
Win
dow
s 20
03
Serv
er S
P1
ME
SSNE
R
# Ap
ps7
Blad
e in
Com
pute
r Ro
om
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ente
rpr is
e Ed
ition
ZEU
S
# Ap
ps1Co
mpu
ter
Roo
m
APP0
1
# Ap
ps4Co
mpu
ter R
oom
APP
02
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Serv
er S
td
DVR
01
# Ap
ps3
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verBP
A-A
PP
01
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
ach i
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Edi
tion
EDG
E
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dows
200
3
Ente
rpris
e Se
rverGR
OU
ND
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ente
rpris
e Se
rverIMA
GEP
ROD
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s XP
Wor
ksta
tionAD
IRO
NDA
CK
High
Ava
ilabi
lity
# Ap
ps20Vi
rtual
Mac
hine
Win
dow
s 20
03
PAC
INO
# Ap
ps20Vi
rtua l
Mac
hine
Win
dow
s 20
03SOPR
ANO
GMP
- DM
Z
COL-
ESX
01
VMw
are
Serv
er
High
Ava
ilabi
lity
COL-
ESX
02
VMw
are
Serv
er
COL-
ESX
03
VMw
are
Serv
er
COL-
ESX
04
VMw
are
Serv
er
# Ap
ps1
SCAD
A Se
rver
s
# Ap
ps4Co
mpu
ter
Roo
m
WW
W
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ente
rpris
e Ed
ition
DARK
Priv
ate
Clo
ud
Cust
omer
Exp
erie
nce
Core
Ora
cle
Peop
leS
oft
Ente
rpris
e R
even
ue
Man
agem
ent
Cor
e
ITR
ON
MV
90
Cor
e
Sung
uard
HTE
CIS
- HT
E (S
t.
Clo
ud)
Core
Elst
er
Elst
er -
MAS
Core
ITR
ON
Micr
oNet
Meter Route & Sequence
Info (M
RI)/ FTP 1xDaily
Core
ITR
ON
Fiel
d C
olle
ctio
n
Syst
em
Surr
ound
n/aO
UC
Con
sum
ptio
n
On -
Line
Core Co
nver
gys
Conv
ergy
s IV
R
Met
er R
eadin
gs (M
RE
) /
FTP
1-5
x D
aily
Man
ual
Mis
sing
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
(MR
I) /
FTP
1x
Dai
ly
Meter Route & Sequence Info (M
RI) /
FTP 1x Daily M
anual
Meter Readings (MRE) /
FTP 1-3x Daily Manual
Met
er L
ocat
ion
Info
rmat
ion
/
FTP
ad
hoc
Meter Readings (to
talizer) /
FTP 1x Daily Manual
HH
F Lo
ad P
rofile
s / F
TP 1
x D
aily
Aut
o
XML
… /
FTP
Aut
o
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
HH
F Fi
le /
FTP
1x
Dai
ly A
uto
Meter Readings (MRE) /
FTP 1x Daily M
anual
Met
er R
oute
& S
eque
nce
Info
(MRI
)/ FT
P 1
-2xD
aily
Man
ual
Acct
Bal
ance
& s
tatu
s --
requ
este
d by
IVR
)
/ dbl
ink/
std
proc
on
dem
and
SCAD
A N
etw
ork
RTU
Dev
ices
VELC
O IC
CP
INTE
RN
ET
VPN
& Fi
rew
all
Fir
ewal
l
GM
P Em
ploy
ees
GM
P V
PN C
lient
Cust
omer
s
# Ap
ps7HP
-UX
DB01
# Ap
ps1Co
mpu
ter R
oom
INTR
A
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dows
200
0
Stan
dard
Ser
ver
FYR
E
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verCH
ECK
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verBL
OC
K
# Ap
ps7HP
-UX
DB02
# Ap
ps3W
indo
ws
2003
Ente
rpris
e Ed
ition
ME
SH
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
PRO
BE
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s XP
Wor
ksta
tionRE
TRIE
VER
# Ap
ps1Vi
rtual
Mac
hine
LINU
X
SOAP
ROD
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verGL
OB
AL
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
00
Adva
nced
Ser
verM
ATR
IX
# Ap
ps20Co
mpu
ter R
oomM
OR
PHE
US
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
ver
OH
MS
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
00
Serv
er
OPE
RAT
OR
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
00
Stan
dard
Ser
verQ
UEU
E
# Ap
ps1
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
ver
TIM
E
# Ap
ps3
Com
pute
r R
oom
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verTR
UM
P
# Ap
ps2
Com
pute
r Roo
m
Win
dow
s 20
00
Stan
dard
Ser
ver
VERD
E
# Ap
ps1Di
spat
ch b
ehin
d Bo
ard
Win
dow
s 20
03
Serv
er S
P1
ME
SSN
ER
# Ap
ps7
Blad
e in
Com
pute
r Ro
om
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ente
rpris
e Ed
ition
ZEU
S
# Ap
ps1Co
mpu
ter R
oom
APP0
1
# Ap
ps4Co
mpu
ter R
oom
APP
02
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
ach i
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Serv
er S
td
DVR
01
# Ap
ps3
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Stan
dard
Ser
verBP
A-A
PP
01
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dows
200
3
Stan
d ard
Edi
tion
EDG
E
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ente
rpris
e Se
rverG
RO
UN
D
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
a l M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ente
rpris
e Se
rverIMA
GEP
ROD
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s XP
Wor
ksta
tionAD
IRO
NDA
CK
High
Av a
ilabi
lity
# Ap
ps20Vi
rtual
Mac
h ine
Win
dow
s 20
03
PACI
NO
# Ap
ps20Vi
rtual
Mac
hine
Win
dow
s 20
03SOPR
ANO
GMP
- DM
Z
COL-
ESX
01
VMw
are
Serv
er
High
Ava
ilabi
lity
COL-
ESX
02
VMw
are
Serv
er
COL-
ESX
03
VM
war
e Se
rver
COL-
ESX
04
VMw
are
Serv
er
# Ap
ps1
SCAD
A S
erve
rs
# Ap
ps4Co
mpu
ter R
oom
WW
W
# Ap
ps1
Virtu
al M
achi
ne
Win
dow
s 20
03
Ente
rpris
e Ed
ition
DARK
Priv
ate
Clou
d
Cust
omer
Exp
erie
nce
Core
Ora
cle
Peop
leS
oft
Ente
rpris
e R
even
ue
Man
agem
ent
Core
ITR
ON
MV9
0
Core
Sung
uard
HTE
CIS
- H
TE (S
t.
Clo
ud)
Core
Elst
er
Elst
er -
MA
S
Core
ITR
ON
Mic
roN
et
Meter Route & Sequence
Info (M
RI)/ FTP 1xDaily
Cor
e
ITR
ON
Fiel
d C
olle
ctio
n
Syst
em
Surro
und
n/aO
UC
Con
sum
ptio
n
On-
Line
Core Co
nver
gys
Con
verg
ys IV
R
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
(MRE
) /
FTP
1-5x
Dai
ly M
anua
l
Miss
ing
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
(MR
I) / F
TP 1
x D
aily
Meter Route & Sequence Info (
MRI) /
FTP 1x Daily M
anual
Meter Readings (MRE) /
FTP 1-3x Daily Manual
Met
er L
ocat
ion
Info
rmat
ion
/
FTP
ad h
oc
Meter Readings (tota
lizer) /
FTP 1x Daily Manual
HHF
Load
Pro
fi les
/ FT
P 1
x D
aily
Aut
o
XML
… /
FTP
Aut
o
Met
er R
eadi
ngs
HH
F Fi
le /
FTP
1x D
aily
Aut
o
Meter Readings (MRE) /
FTP 1x Daily M
anual
Met
er R
oute
& S
eque
nce
Info
(MR
I)/ F
TP 1
-2xD
aily
Man
ual
Acct
Bal
ance
& s
tatu
s --
requ
este
d by
IVR
)
/ dbl
ink /
std
proc
on
dem
and
DSPP
3rd Party
Dist. Operator
Interf
ace/I
ntegra
tion
Interf
ace/I
ntegra
tion
Interf
ace/I
ntegra
tion
Interface/IntegrationInterface/Integration
XX-XX-2014Page 8
Architecture ‘Déjà vu’ – EDI Example
• Electronic Data Interchange was a response to the need for multiple organizations to integrate around specific functionalities
• EDI defines the data, security and integration standards within an architecture to facilitate a loosely-coupled business process
• DSPP must define the data, security and integration standards within the IEEE 2030 architecture to facilitate a TIGHTLY-coupled business process
XX-XX-2014Page 9
Architecture Subgroup – Key Findings & Recommendations
Findings:
1. The data, security and integration complexity of a DSPP requires the rigor of a structured architecture
2. The IEEE 2030 architecture is sufficient to define current DSPP functionality and adaptable to incorporate future functionality
3. DSPP Use Cases must be documented within the architecture to surface technology, process, and standards gaps
Recommendations:
1. Complete IEEE 2030 architecture framework documentation and guidelines for governance
2. Begin cross-working group activity to document DSPP use cases
3. Create high level DSPP conceptual architecture with supporting technology, process, and standards references
XX-XX-2014Page 10
Use Case - Dynamic Electricity Production forecasting
• Dynamic electricity production forecasting is the calculation and forecasting of electricity production from Distributed Energy Resources (DER).
• The forecasting is based on based on geography, forecasted fuel supply, solar isolation, wind speed and state of charge.
• The purpose of the forecasts would be to provide supply information to DSPP grid operations and planning, and to help set supply prices in the DSPP market.
• The next few slides paint a story of the DSPP in action with the use of a conceptual architecture.
• Please note this is only an example an is subject to change.
XX-XX-2014Page 11
cat
IT Layer
Distribution Management
Next Poll for Day Ahead Forecast
IT27
Distributed Energy
Resources(Local
Generation)
Command Issued to
identify DER participatio
n
Geographic Information
Management
Request for DER
Geographic Location
IT34
Availability, Geo &
Weather Combined
Energy Market
Clearing
Combined DER
Forecast Data Issued
to Operations
Retail Market
Clears DER Participatio
n
IT36
Distribution Operation
DER Dispatch
Checked for Security
Constraints
IT13
Cleared DER
Forecast Issued to
Retail Market
XX-XX-2014Page 12
Use Case - Dynamic Electricity Production forecasting
Power Layer
XX-XX-2014Page 13
Use Case - Dynamic Electricity Production forecasting
Comms Layer
XX-XX-2014Page 14
Thank you for your attention!
John Doe – Working group leader detailsJob titleGroup / Region / Department XY Street 12312345 CityPhone: +49 (123) 45 67-890Fax: +49 (123) 45 67-890Mobile: +49 (123) 45 67 89 0E-mail:[email protected]