april 3, 2012 marion, indiana city council minutes

8/2/2019 April 3, 2012 Marion, Indiana City Council Minutes

1/10

TBIRGNT CBBZFHI CNTFKH MKCCKH MKRHMFG NPTFG =' 40>4 9?00 P(C(' MFZV LNGG

Zlb Mkcckh Mkrhmfg ke zlb Mfzv ke Cntfkh' Fhjfnhn cbz fh tbirgnt }b}}fkh kh Zrb}jnv' zlb =tj jnv ke Nptfg' 40>4 nlb lkrt ke 9?00 p(c( fh zlb Mkrhmfg Mlncdbt}' Mfzv Lngg(

Kh zlb mngg ke zlb tkgg zlb ekggkyfhi cbcdbt} ybtb }lkyh zk db nd}bhz kt ptb}bhz n} ekggky}?

Ptb}bhz? Ztk|bgg' Grnjjbt' Hbubg}' Ylfzzfmabt' Zlkcp}kh' Dtrhhbt' ]cfzl' Etbhml nhj Dnzmlbgkt(

Nd}bhz? Hkhb(

Zlb cfhrzb} ke zlb ptbufkr} tbirgnt cbbzfhi ke Cntml 40' 40>4 ybtb ptb}bhzbj( Kh n ckzfkh dv Hbubg}' 4hj

dv ]clb cfhrzb} ybtb npptkubj n} ptb}bhzbj dv n rhnhfckr} ukzb(

MKCCFZZBB TBPKTZ]? Mkrhmfgcnh Ofc Dtrhhbt tbpktzbj zlnz zlb Pnta Dkntj cbz vb}zbtjnv' zlbft ckhzlgvcbbzfhi lbtb fh zlf} enmfgfzv( Nckhi zlb zlfhi} lb yn} n}abj zk tbpktz kh' zlb Ynub Pkkg f} tbnjv zk ik ninfh ekt zlhby vbnt( ]k f} zlb ]pgn}l Lkr}b( Gkkafhi ektyntj zk nhkzlbt itbnz vbnt zlbtb( Bubh zlkril zlbv ptkdndgv mkrgjlnub lnj fz kpbh zkjnv' fz yfgg db kpbhbj Cbcktfng Jnv Ybbabhj nhj bubtvdkjv }lkrgj mftmgb zlnz ybbabhj kh zlbfngbhjnt( Zlbvub lnj }kcb tb~rb}z} zk zlb Pnta Dkntj ekt zlbc zk b|pgktb zlb pk}}fdfgfzv ke kpbhfhi rp n Jki Pnta

Ylnz zlnz f}' fz} nh ntbn ke gnhj' cnvdb ekrt kt efub nmtb} ke gnhj' ylbtb pbkpgb ylk cnvdb jk hkz lnub nmmb}} zk

itbbh}pnmb ykrgj db ndgb zk dtfhi zlbft pbz} nhj b|btmf}b zlbc jrtfhi }rhrp zk }rh}bz lkrt}( Lb ahky} jkyh fhDgkkcfhizkh' lb jtfub} dv khb zlbtb bubtv zfcb lb ikb} jkyh zk Fhjfnhn Rhfubt}fzv nhj fz} ubtv ybgg r}bj( ]k zlnzkcbzlfhi zlnz zlb Pnta Dkntj f} b|pgktfhi( Fh enmz' lb }lkrgj lnub }kcbzlfhi cnvdb zk tbpktz nz zlb hb|z cbbzfhi(

Zlbtb ln} dbbh }kcb mkhmbth ndkrz }kcb unhjngf}c nz Cnzzbt Pnta nhj lb} }lntbj }kcb ke zlk}b mkhmbth}' n} zlbMkrhmfg gfnf}kh zk zlb Pnta Dkntj' yfzl zlb Mlfbe ke Pkgfmb nhj zlbvtb lkpberggv ikfhi zk ibz n gfzzgb dfz cktb' zlbptb}bhmb ke zlb Pkgfmb Jbpntzcbhz zlbtb dbmnr}b zlbvub jkhb }kcb ykhjbterg zlfhi} yfzl zlb pnta nhj zlbv ynhz zkrtb zlnz zlk}b ntb r}bj' ntb }neb( Zlbvub lnj }kcb jb}ztrmzfkh ke }kcb ke zlbft ptkpbtzv krz zlbtb ylfml zlbv or}znhz zkgbtnzb }k zlnz} afhj ke n jkyh}fjb ke zlb cbbzfhi drz lb jfj ynhz zk tbpktz kh zlnz dbmnr}b zlnz} dbbh pn}}b

kh zk zlb ptkpbt nrzlktfzfb}( Ekt zlk}b ylk gfab zk pgnv }kezdngg' lb yn} n}abj zk ng}k tbpktz zlf}( Zlbvub ngtbnjv lkhb cbbzfhi drz }kezdngg gbnirb} ntb ektcfhi }k' Tbiifb' ibz zlb dnz krz nhj Dtnj' ibz vkrt mnzmlbt} ibnt krz nhj }firp zk pgnv }kezdngg zlf} vbnt( ]k' ubtv hfmb cbbzfhi( Zlbv lnub njjbj Ngnh Dbma' ln} okfhbj zlb Pnta Dkntj n} n hb

cbcdbt }k zlbv ybtb ignj zk ybgmkcb lfc kh dkntj vb}zbtjnv( ]k' zlnz} ylnz lnppbhbj vb}zbtjnv nz zlbft cbbzfhihj lbgg abbp zlbc pk}zbj' Dtrhhbt }znzbj(

Mkrhmfgykcnh Ok}bgvh Ylfzzfmabt }nfj }lb nzzbhjbj zlb Gz( Ikubthkt' Dbmav ]afggcnh}' Tkrhjzndgbhzbtikubthcbhzng Tbgnzfkh}lfp} kh zlb 49zl ke Cntml nhj ylnz yn} jf}mr}}bj yn} fhzbtikubthcbhzng tbgnzfkh}lfp}

lky yb ibz ngkhi nhj bmkhkcfm jbubgkpcbhz nhj ylnz ln} dbbh kh zlb gbif}gnzfub }mbhb nhj ylnz beebmz} mfzfb} nhjkyh} nhj }k kh nhj lky yb ykta zkibzlbt yfzl krt gkmng mkrhzv keefmfng} etkc ngg kubt Itnhz Mkrhzv nhj ng}k lky

ykta yfzl lbt ,Gz( Ikubthkt& keefmb yfzl bmkhkcfm jbubgkpcbhz nhj }k kh( ]k zlb fhektcnzfkhng ntzfmgb zlnzmmkcpnhfbj zlnz nezbt' zlb jnv nezbt' yn} ng}k fh zlb pnpbt kh zlb 4


2/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 4#40>4 Mkhzfhrbjkhztnmzkt} pgr} Ubmztbh bcpgkvbb' zyk Mkrhmfg cbcdbt} nhj Cfab Itnez zk cbbz( Jfj zlnz bubt kmmrt; Dnzmlbgktbpgfbj' hk' zlnz jfjhz lnppbh( Ylfzzfmabt }znzbj' kanv' zlbh }lb dbgfbub} zlbv hbbj zk ik dnma zk zlnz nhj dbektb fz

ckubj zk mkccfzzbb kt nhvylbtb bg}b' zlk}b ibhzgbcbh hbbj zk cbbz zkibzlbt nhj }lb dbgfbub} zlnz jftbmzfub yn} ifk Ct( Itnez }k }lb dbgfbub} fz engg} dnma yfzl Ct( Itnez nhj zlb ekrt pbkpgb ntb zlb zltbb mkhztnmzkt} pgr} Rzfgfzfb}

pbt}khhbg zk db nz zlnz cbbzfhi nhj zlbv hbbj zk ik kh tbmktj n} n }bmkhj zfcb zlnz zlbv ykrgj gfab zlf} cbbzfhi zkkmmrt dbmnr}b zlf} f} ndkrz zlb mfzfbh} ke krt mkccrhfzv nhj tnf}fhi ckhbv dbmnr}b fe zlf} ikb} fhzk beebmz yfzlkrzlbc cnafhi zlnz jf}mr}}fhi zlbh zlnz mk}z f} ikfhi zk db pn}}bj kubt zk zlb mfzfbh} nhj zlbv ntb fh bmkhkcfm' jftbztnfilz}( Zlbv hbbj zk }nv' fe zlbv ntb }nvfhi zlbvtb ikfhi zk jk }kcbzlfhi' zlbv hbbj zk ekggky zltkril nhj zlbv

hbbj zk jk zlnz( ]k' dbektb fz ikb} dnma zk Mkrhmfg' }lb ykrgj tbmkccbhj zlnz zlnz cbbzfhi db lbgj zlbh fz ik fhzkMkrhmfg dbmnr}b zlbv lnub zyk Mkrhmfg pbkpgb ylk ukgrhzbbtbj nhj zlnz yn} Pnrg Zlkcp}kh nhj ng}k Lbhtv ]cfzlykta yfzl zlbc( ]rtbgv' zlbvub ikhb =0 jnv}' zlbv lnub nhkzlbt zyk ybba}( ]rtbgv n cbbzfhi mnh db lbgj nhj }k dbektb fz ikb} zk Mkrhmfg' Ylfzzfmabt }nfj( Mkrhmfgcnh Etbj Ztk|bgg }nfj' nz zlb gn}z cbbzfhi' zlbv }nfj zlnz zlbkhztnmzkt} ykrgj lnub n tfilz zk }pbna nz zlf} cbbzfhi( Hky zlbvtb lbtb( Dnzmlbgkt zkgj Ztk|bgg' zlbtb} hk

jf}mr}}fkh dbmnr}b zlb Cnvkt} Keefmb nhj Ct( Itnez lnub prggbj zlf} etkc zlb nibhjn( Zlbvtb zlb khb} zlnz yfgg dptb}bhzfhi fz }k zlbtbektb' zlnz} ylv zlbv ynhz zk gbz ekga} ahky rpetkhz zlnz zlnz ykrgj hkz db jf}mr}}bj zkhfilz

dbmnr}b fz} dbbh prggbj kee zlb nibhjn( Ztk|bgg tbpgfbj' kanv' or}z }k zlb}b ibhzgbcbh nhj gnjfb} fh zlb nrjfbhmb ahz} hkz zlbft ,Mkrhmfg& jbmf}fkh zk znab zlf} kee zlb nibhjn zkhfilz( C}( Ylfzzfmabt njjbj' yfzl fz dbfhi tbckubj' }likfhi dnma zk lbt }ncb ~rb}zfkh( ]lb ykrgj njuf}b' }fhmb zlbv ntb ztnh}pntbhz nhj zlbv }nv zlbvtb ztnh}pntbhz' zlnzlbv nggky zlb }bubh ibhzgbcbh zk ykta zkibzlbt nhj zlbh' fe zlb Cnvkt nhj Cfab Itnez ykrgj gfab zk prz fz dnma kh

Mkrhmfg kt }k kh' ibz dnma yfzl zlbc( ]lb ln} n ptkdgbc yfzl efhjfhi krz }kcbzlfhi ke zlf} hnzrtb' nhj }lb ekrhj kvb}zbtjnv' fhjftbmzgv' zlnz fz yn} ikfhi zk' }lb yn}hz zkgj fz yn} ikfhi zk db prggbj( ]lb yn} zkgj zlnz n pbt}kh ykrghkz db lbtb zkhfilz zk jf}mr}} fz( Zlnz yn} hkz cnjb ztnh}pntbhz zk zlb prdgfm( Zlnz mtbnzb} lntj ebbgfhi} fh fz}bge nhlbv }nfj zlbv ybtb ikfhi zk lnub n cbbzfhi( ]lb ln} n ptkdgbc yfzl }nvfhi krt yktj f} khb zlfhi nhj zlbv znga nhj

ynga }kcbzlfhi bg}b' Ylfzzfmabt }znzbj( Mkrhmfg Ptb}fjbhz Dnzmlbgkt }nfj' zlnz }bubh cbcdbt mkccfzzbb' zlbv mnh chj ylkbubt yfgg Mlnft zlb cbbzfhi nhj ylnz lnub vkr' zlnz mnh }zfgg znab pgnmb drz zkhfilz' zlnz ln} dbbh prggbj keekhfilz} nibhjn( ]k jk zlbv lnub n Mlnft ekt zlnz cbbzfhi' Dnzmlbgkt n}abj( Ylfzzfmabt tbpgfbj' }fhmb zlbv lnub' }l

hkz kh zlnz mkccfzzbb' fz ykrgj engg rhjbt Ct( ]cfzl' Mkrhmfgcnh ]cfzl( Mkrhmfgcnh Lbhtv ]cfzl }nfj' zlbv yfgg lf} rp nezbt zlb Mkrhmfg cbbzfhi }k zlbtbektb' nhvkhb ylk f} fhzbtb}zbj fh fz' or}z }znv nezbt zlb Mkrhmfg cbbzfhi nhjlbv yfgg znab fz rp zlbh( Zlbv yfgg }znv' fh kzlbt yktj}' pgnh ekt n cbbzfhi }kcb zfcb ylbh bubtvdkjv mnh db zlbtbhj }k zlbv yfgg cbbz yfzl nhvkhb zkhfilz nezbt zlb Mkrhmfg cbbzfhi }k zlbv mnh pgnh ekt nhkzlbt jnzb ekt zlnz(

Dnzmlbgkt n}abj' }k bubtvkhb f} mgbnt kh zlnz; Mkrhmfgcnh ]cfzl yfgg nggky kppktzrhfzv nz zlb bhj ke zlb Mkrhmfgcbbzfhi zkhfilz zk cbbz yfzl zlk}b fhjfufjrng} zlnz ntb kh zlf} mkccfzzbb nhj jf}mr}} n cbbzfhi zfcb kt ylnzbubt zln}b cnv db nhj zlb pntncbzbt} }rttkrhjfhi zlnz mkccfzzbb' Dnzmlbgkt zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg( ]cfzl }nfj zlnz f} mkttbmz(

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( :#40>4 4HJ TBNJFHI NHJ PRDGFM LBNTFHIZlb Mfzv Mgbta tbnj Ibhbtng Ktjfhnhmb Hk( :#40>4 dv zfzgb khgv( Nh Ktjfhnhmb zk unmnzb n pktzfkh ke n prdgfm ynvunmnzb zlnz pktzfkh ke nh nggbv gkmnzbj dbzybbh ::zl nhj :2zl ]ztbbz} fh zlb dgkma dbzybbh Gnhjb}} nhj Lntckh ]ztbbkcckh njjtb}}b} dbfhi ::>9 zltkril ::0> ]( Gnhjb}} nhj ::04 zk ::>5 ]( Lntckh ]ztbbz' ngg fh Cntfkh' Itnhz

Mkrhzv' Fhjfnhn( Plfg ]zbplbh}kh' nzzkthbv ekt pbzfzfkhbt' zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg n} lb fhjfmnzbj zk zlbc gn}z zfcb' zlbprtpk}b ke zlbft tb~rb}z f} nh nggbv' ylfml f} gkmnzbj dbzybbh Gnhjb}} nhj Lntckh nhj ng}k dbzybbh ::zl nhj :2zl( Nlbv fhjfmnzbj zk zlbc' zlb prtpk}b ekt zlnz mgk}fhi yn} zlb hby }bcfhntv' ylfml Fhjfnhn Yb}gbvnh Rhfubt}fzv f}mzrnggv }zntzfhi mkh}ztrmzfkh kh fh zlnz ntbn( Ylfgb zlb drfgjfhi yfgg hkz db kubt zlf} nggbv' zlb nggbv f} b}}bhzfng ektmmb}} zk zlnz drfgjfhi( Zlb Rhfubt}fzv kyh} ngg zlb ptkpbtzv ntkrhj zlnz drfgjfhi }k' n} n ptnmzfmng cnzzbt' hk khb

ykrgj db neebmzbj fh zlnz dgkma nhj zlbv lnub ngtbnjv mgk}bj :2zl

]ztbbz }k zlbv mkrgjhz znab fz zltkril nhvlky( Nzlf} pkfhz' fz jbnj bhj} nhj zlbv kyh ngg zlb ptkpbtzv ntkrhj zlbtb( Zlbv ntb nyntb zlnz zlbtb ntb zyk rzfgfzfb}' F % Chj ng}k Ubmztbh' ylk lnub rzfgfzfb} fh zlnz nggbv' lkybubt' zlbv mkhzbcpgnzbj zlnz fh njunhmb( Fe zlbvgg gkka nz zlb

ktjfhnhmb nz ]bmzfkh 4' fz f} ngtbnjv ptkufjbj fh ]bmzfkh 4 zlnz zlk}b bn}bcbhz tfilz} ykrgj db tbznfhbj fh zlnz nggbv nlbv lnub hk fhzbhzfkh' n} lb fhjfmnzbj' kh drfgjfhi nmtk}} zlnz( ]k' zlbvtb n}afhi zlbc' nezbt zlb prdgfm lbntfhi' zl

ykrgj gfab zk }bb fz pn}}bj zk n = tj tbnjfhi' fe zlnz ykrgj db yfzlfh zlbft jf}mtbzfkh' nhj zlnz zlbv ykrgj npptkub zlf}


3/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( :#40>4 Mkhzfhrbjlbc( Fe zlbv lnub nhv ~rb}zfkh}' Ct( CmLbhtv etkc Fhjfnhn Yb}gbvnh f} ng}k lbtb nhj zlbv ykrgj mbtznfhgv ztv zkh}ybt nhv ~rb}zfkh} zlbv cnv lnub' ]zbplbh}kh }nfj( Mkrhmfgcnh Etbj Ztk|bgg }nfj' lb ybhz krz nhj gkkabj nz zl

ptkpbtzv nhj lbj }nv lb }bb} nd}kgrzbgv hk tbn}kh ylv zlbv }lkrgjhz pn}} zlf} zk unmnzb zlb nggbv( Dbfhi hk ertzlb~rb}zfkh} kt mkccbhz} etkc zlb Mkrhmfg' Mkrhmfg Ptb}fjbhz Jkh Dnzmlbgkt }nfj' zlf} f} n prdgfm lbntfhi( Nhvkhb zl

ykrgj gfab zk }pbna ekt kt ninfh}z zlf} ktjfhnhmb' zlbv n}a zlnz zlbv npptknml zlb pkjfrc' ifub zlbft hncb nhj njjtbhj zrth zlb pkybt drzzkh kh kh zlb cfab( Dbfhi hk tb}pkh}b etkc zlb nrjfbhmb' Dnzmlbgkt zlbh }nfj zlb Mlnft ykrhzbtznfh n ckzfkh( Mkrhmfgykcnh Ok}bgvh Ylfzzfmabt }k ckubj yfzl n }bmkhj ifubh dv Mkrhmfgcnh Ztk|bgg(

Mkrhmfgcnh Dtnj Grnjjbt mnggbj n pkfhz ke ktjbt nhj n}abj mnh zlf} db pn}}bj kh zlb }bmkhj tbnjfhi yfzl nr}pbh}fkh ke zlb trgb}; Mktpktnzb Mkrh}bg Ok}l Lkybgg tbpgfbj' fz cnv' fz mnh( Grnjjbt zlbh }nfj' lb ykrgj nitbb

yfzl Ct( Ztk|bgg zlnz zlbtb }lkrgjhz db nhv tbn}kh ylv zlbv mkrgjhz pn}} zlf} }fhmb zlbv ,FYR& kyh bubtvzlfhi( L}abj C}( Ylfzzfmabt fe }lb ynhzbj zk jk zlnz( Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Grnjjbt' hk' }lb jkb} hkz( ]lb jkb}hz dbgfbub fhr}pbhjfhi }k zlbv yfgg jk n ukfmb ukzb etkc lbt pbt}pbmzfub( Mkrhmfgykcnh Cnjkhhn Etbhml }znzbj' zlbv }zfgg mnhr}pbhj( Fz khgv znab n cnoktfzv zk }r}pbhj zlb trgb}( Dnzmlbgkt zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg' }k zlb ckzfkh zlnz f} kh zlb egkkt f

ckub fz zk =tj tbnjfhi( Grnjjbt njjbj' zlb ckzfkh f} zk pn}} fz kh zk =tj tbnjfhi nmmktjfhi zk ylnz yn} cnjb fh zlbckzfkh( Ckzfkh zk pn}} zk =tj tbnjfhi zlbh enfgbj dv zlb ekggkyfhi ukzb( Nvb? Ztk|bgg nhj Ylfzzfmabt( Hnv? Grnj

mkccbhzbj lb ynhz} zk pn}} fz kh 4

hj

tbnjfhi&' Hbubg}' Zlkcp}kh' Dtrhhbt' ]cfzl' Etbhml nhj Dnzmlbgkt( Ckzfkhyn} zlbh cnjb dv Etbhml zk }r}pbhj zlb trgb} kh Ibhbtng Ktjfhnhmb Hk( :#40>4 nhj pn}} fz n} n efhng fzbc( Ckzfkhyn} }bmkhjbj dv Hbubg}( Dbektb zlb tkgg yn} mnggbj' Mkrhmfgcnh Ofc Dtrhhbt mnggbj n pkfhz ke ktjbt nhj n}abj CtLkybgg fe zlnz lnj zk db n rhnhfckr} ukzb kt or}z n cnoktfzv; Lkybgg tbpgfbj' fz} n cnoktfzv( Zlbv tb~rftb nrhnhfckr} mkh}bhz nhj n }rpbtcnoktfzv zk pn}} kh n }fhigb tbnjfhi( Zlbv hbubt tb~rftb rhnhfckr} mkh}bhz rhjbt zlny} ke zlb ]znzb ke Fhjfnhn drz zlf} f} kh 4hj tbnjfhi }k fz} khgv n cnoktfzv( Ckzfkh zlbh mnttfbj dv zlb ekggkyfhi u

Nvb? Grnjjbt' Hbubg}' Zlkcp}kh' Dtrhhbt' ]cfzl' Etbhml nhj Dnzmlbgkt( Hnv? Ztk|bgg nhj Ylfzzfmabt( Dtrhhbtlbh n}abj' jkhz zlbv hky hbbj nhkzlbt ckzfkh; Lkybgg }znzbj' zlbv yfgg hbbj nhkzlbt ckzfkh( Zlbv lnub }r}pbhjlb trgb} nhj hky zlbv yfgg hbbj zk cnab n ckzfkh zk pn}} fz n} ybgg( Ckzfkh yn} zlbh cnjb dv Etbhml zk pn}} Ibhb

Ktjfhnhmb Hk( :#40>4( Ckzfkh yn} }bmkhjbj dv Zlkcp}kh( Dbektb zlb tkgg yn} mnggbj' Mkrhmfgykcnh Ylfzzfmabtkgj Dnzmlbgkt }lb zlfha} lb hbbj} zk }nv lky zlbv ntb pn}}fhi fz' dv }r}pbhjfhi zlb trgb}' }k cnab fz ubtv mgbnt( Ct

Dnzmlbgkt }znzbj' zlb trgb} lnub dbbh }r}pbhjbj nhj zlbv ntb hky ukzfhi kh efhng pn}}nib ke zlf} ktjfhnhmb( Ckzfkhlbh mnttfbj dv zlb ekggkyfhi ukzb( Nvb? Ztk|bgg' Grnjjbt' Hbubg}' Ylfzzfmabt ,}nfj }lb ykrgj ukzb vb} yfzl zlbr}pbh}fkh&' Zlkcp}kh' Dtrhhbt' ]cfzl' Etbhml nhj Dnzmlbgkt( Hnv? Hkhb(

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 2#40>4 4HJ TBNJFHI NHJ PRDGFM LBNTFHIZlb Mfzv Mgbta tbnj Ibhbtng Ktjfhnhmb Hk( 2#40>4 dv zfzgb khgv( Nh Ktjfhnhmb nrzlktffhi zlb f}}rnhmb ke zlb MfzvCntfkh' Fhjfnhn bmkhkcfm jbubgkpcbhz tbubhrb dkhj}' nhj zlb gbhjfhi ke zlb ptkmbbj} zlbtbke zk Ztbb ke GfebDkka}zktb}' Fhm( nhj nrzlktffhi nhj npptkufhi kzlbt nmzfkh} fh tb}pbmz zlbtbzk( Jnttbh Tbb}b' Jftbmzkt keJbubgkpcbhz ]btufmb} ekt zlb Mfzv ke Cntfkh' zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg' pfzml lfzzfhi ekt Dtrmb Jkhngj}kh f} Tfml ]zntabv' npntzhbt ng}k fh Dnthb} % Zlkthdrti gny eftc( Lb} ng}k dbbh dbektb zlf} dkjv cnhv zfcb} nhj }btubj zlb mfzv n} dkkrh}bg tbpbnzbjgv( Lb ng}k ynhzbj zk pn}} ngkhi nh npkgkiv etkc Cnvkt ]bvdkgj ekt lf} nd}bhmb zlf} bubhfhi( Lbmzrnggv yfzl nhkzlbt jbubgkpcbhz itkrp tfilz hky nhj kh lf} ynv zk nhkzlbt mkccrhfzv bubhz( Lb ykrgj gfab Ct

]zntabv zk b|pgnfh zlb Bmkhkcfm Jbubgkpcbhz Mkccf}}fkh cbbzfhi zlnz kmmrttbj or}z ptbufkr}gv zk zlf} cbbzfhi nhlbvgg pfma rp etkc zlbtb( Ct( ]zntabv zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg lb f} yfzl zlb gny eftc ke Dnthb} % Zlkthdrti( Zlb ktjfhnlnz f} dbektb zlbc zkhfilz f} nh ktjfhnhmb ekt zlb f}}rnhmb ke bmkhkcfm jbubgkpcbhz dkhj}( Zlk}b dkhj} zlbv lnubbbh fh zlb pn}z ntb dkhj} zlnz ntb nmzrnggv f}}rbj dv zlb mfzv drz lnub n tbmkccbhjnzfkh dv zlb Bmkhkcfm

Jbubgkpcbhz Mkccf}}fkh dblfhj zlbc nhj zlb tbn}kh ekt zlnz f}' rhjbt zlb }znzrzb' zlbtb f} n tbzbhzfkh kt mtbnzfkh kkd} n}}kmfnzbj yfzl zlb dkhj}( Zlb Bmkhkcfm Jbubgkpcbhz Mkccf}}fkh cbz zkjnv nz 5?00 pc nhj lbgj zlb }znzrzkb~rftbj prdgfm lbntfhi ekt zlb dkhj}( Zlbtb yn} n mkccbhz etkc zlb prdgfm zlnz yn} tbmbfubj zlnz yn} dn}fmnggv

jf}mr}}fkh mkh}ztrmzfkh okd} nhj ynhzfhi zlbc zk db gkmng nhj zlnz yn} hkzbj( Zlb Tbjbubgkpcbhz Mkccf}}fkh cbntgfbt zkjnv zk nmzrnggv pn}} n tb}kgrzfkh zlnz ykrgj pgbjib zlb zn| fhmtbcbhz tbubhrb} zlnz mkcb kee zlf} ptkobmz( Nlb tbhkunzfkh f} mkcpgbzbj' zlk}b b|ztn ZFE tbubhrb} ylfml ykrgj db pgbjibj zk zlb dkhj} nhj ykrgj db zlbbpnvcbhz }krtmb ekt zlb dkhj}( ]k zlb ktjfhnhmb zlnz} dbektb zlbc zkhfilz f}' n} zlbv or}z b|pbtfbhmbj yfzl zlb pt


4/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 2#40>4 Mkhzfhrbjktjfhnhmb' mnh db pn}}bj zkhfilz nhj' n} lb }nfj' zlbtb yn} n prdgfm lbntfhi ngtbnjv zkjnv nhj hkzfmbj fh zlb hby}pnkt zlnz( Fe zlbv lnub nhv ~rb}zfkh} nz ngg' lbj db lnppv zk nh}ybt zlk}b' ]zntabv }nfj( Mkrhmfgcnh Pnrg Zlkcp}khnfj' lf} ~rb}zfkh ykrgj db zk Ct( Tbb}b( F} zlf} dkhj ekt zlb AV drfgjfhi' f} fz zlb }ncb ptkpbtzv zlnz zlbvtb zngafhdkrz; Tbb}b tbpgfbj' or}z n} zlbv zngabj nz zlb gn}z cbbzfhi' zlf} f} zlb enmfgfzv zlnz yn} mkcckhgv ahkyh n} zlb kgj

Lkddv Gkddv( Zlkcp}kh zlbh n}abj' ylnz lnppbh}' zlbvub ngtbnjv dbbh zltkril n dkhj f}}rb kh zlnz ptkpbtzv(Ylnz lnppbh} zk zlnz dkhj nhj ylk} ikfhi zk db tb}pkh}fdgb ekt zlb hbmb}}ntv pnvcbhz} zlnz ybtb }rppk}bj zk dbcnjb jrtfhi zlnz; Tbb}b }nfj' zlf} f} zlb eft}z dkhj nggkmnzfkh zk zlnz ptkpbtzv( Ylnz zlbvub jkhb ptbufkr}gv yn}}zndgf}l n zn| fhmtbcbhz jf}ztfmz nhj hbubt nggkmnzbj zlk}b erhj} zk nhvkhb kzlbt zlnh r} }k zlf} f} zlb }ncb jf}ztfmz zlbv jbubgkpbj ptbufkr}gv drz zlf} f} zlb eft}z zfcb zlnz zlbv ntb f}}rfhi dkhj} ekt n ptkobmz kh zlnz }fzb( Mkrhmfgykck}bgvh Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Mkrhmfg Ptb}fjbhz Dnzmlbgkt }lb lnj }kcb ~rb}zfkh} ekt Ct( Tbb}b mkhmbthfhi zlf} f}}rb(

Nmmktjfhi zk zlb N}}b}}kt} tbmktj' zlbv ybtb zkgj zlnz zlbv pnfj *>'200'000 ekt zlnz ptkpbtzv( Ybgg nmmktjfhi zk zlN}}b}}kt} ybd}fzb' fz} *4'200'000( Zlbtb f} n jfeebtbhmb ke *>'000'000( Tbb}b zkgj Ylfzzfmabt' vb}' zlb ptbufkr}kyhbt jkhnzbj *>'000'000 ke zlnz }ngb zk zlb ptkobmz( Zlbtb yn} hbubt nhv mn}l ztnh}nmzfkh( Zlnz yn} ptfcntfgv zkhlnhmb zlbft dkzzkc gfhb( Zlbv ybtb n}afhi *4'200'000 ekt zlb ptkobmz ylbh zlb mfzv jfj prtmln}b fz cnhv vbnt} nihj zlbv ybtb ndgb zk hbikzfnzb fz zk *>'200'000( Ylfzzfmabt zlbh n}abj' ylv jkb} zlnz hkz }lky fh zlb tbmktj}

hvylbtb; Zlf} f} zlb eft}z zfcb zlbvtb jf}mr}}fhi fz' dbmnr}b }lb ybhz dnma nhj jfj }kcb cktb jrb jfgfibhmb nhj'gynv}' }lb yfgg ~rb}zfkh lfc ndkrz zlb zn|pnvbt} ckhbv nhj ylbtb yb ntb ikfhi yfzl zlf}( ]fhmb zlbv hky ahky zinub r} *>'000'000' lky yfgg zlnz db tbegbmzbj dbmnr}b hkylbtb bg}b ln} }lb }bbh zlnz; Tbb}b tb}pkhjbj' zlnz yn} njkhnzfkh fh zlb ektc ke n zn| jbjrmzfkh( Ninfh' zlbtb yn} hk mn}l ztnh}nmzfkh yfzl zlnz *>'000'000( C}( Ylfzzfmabt}abj' }lkrgjhz zlnz lnub dbbh zkgj zk zlb mfzv nhj zlb zn|pnvbt} nz }kcb pkfhz kt nhkzlbt dbektb }lb lnj zk tnf}b zlf

~rb}zfkh hky; Ct( Tbb}b }nfj lb dbgfbubj zlnz yn} erggv jf}mgk}bj nz zlb zfcb fh zlb Tbjbubgkpcbhz Mkccf}}fkh nh zlb prdgfm cbbzfhi}( Ylfzzfmabt n}abj' dbektb; Tbb}b zkgj lbt' vb}( Ylfzzfmabt }znzbj' drz }fhmb zlf} f} mkcfhi lhj }k crml fhektcnzfkh f} krz zlbtb ndkrz zlf} ylkgb zlfhi' fz dkzlbt} lbt' }lb} mkcfhi kh jkyh zk }kcbzlfhi bg}b

Ylbh }lb yn} ikfhi zltkril zlb tbmktj} ke zlb dfgg} nhj }k kh ekt zlb mfzv' fz }lkybj zlnz yb pnfj *2='000 kt *24'00hj }kcb kjj mbhz} ekt fh}rtnhmb( Ylv yn} zlb fh}rtnhmb pnfj kh zlf} nhj zlf} ln} hkzlfhi zk jk yfzl Ct( Mncpdb

]lb} ztvfhi zk efirtb zlnz krz( Mkrgjhz V4A nhj nz }kcb pkfhz kt nhkzlbt' zlbtb yn} nh ntzfmgb ndkrz n pk}}fdgbktbmgk}rtb nhj }k kh( Tbb}b zkgj Ylfzzfmabt lb ykrgj db ubtv lnppv zk }pbna yfzl zlbc fh n cktb npptkptfnzb ektre zlbv ynhz zk jf}mr}} zlb VA Erthfzrtb jbng' n} lb ln} keebtbj( Zlbv lnj zk fh}rtb zlb drfgjfhi' n} n mfzv' n} fz yn}lbft} nhj zlbv ynhzbj zk cnab }rtb zlbv ybtb ptkzbmzbj fh mn}b nhvzlfhi ybtb zk kmmrt zk zlnz drfgjfhi( ]k' zlnz} ylbv jfj zlnz( Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Tbb}b }lb} ignj lb} nh}ybtfhi zlnz ~rb}zfkh dbmnr}b fz yn} zlbtb nhj' vkr ahky' fz o

afhj ke dkzlbt} lbt dbmnr}b }lb} jbngfhi yfzl' ngg zlb Mkrhmfg cbcdbt} ntb jbngfhi yfzl zlb ybgentb ke zlb mfzv nhjkcb} dnma zk }kcbzlfhi }lb abbp} mkcfhi dnma zk nhj }kcb pbkpgb ebbg f} lntpfhi' drz zlnz} ngtfilz yfzl lbt(

*>='000'000 kt rp zk *>='000'000 f} n gkz ke ckhbv' hkz zk cbhzfkh zlb fhzbtb}z nhj }k kh' nhj zlb}b cf}}fhi etnicbdkzlbt lbt( Cnvdb fz jkb}hz dkzlbt kzlbt pbkpgb drz fz jkb} lbt dbmnr}b }lb} yktafhi yfzl }kcbdkjv bg}b} ckhbhj zlb}b ~rb}zfkh} zlnz }lb tnf}b} ntb ~rb}zfkh} zlnz pbkpgb tnf}b ekt lbt nhj }lb ln} n ptkdgbc yfzl jkfhi ptfunzb

dr}fhb}} ylbh zlbv }nv zlbvtb ikfhi zk db ztnh}pntbhz nhj zlbh }lb ln} zk tnf}b n ~rb}zfkh yfzl lfc zk ibz nh nh}yblbtb( Tbb}b nh}ybtbj' ninfh' zlbv lnub cnjb zlb}b n}pbmz} ke zlb}b jbng} prdgfm fh zlb pn}z nhj lf} npkgkifb} ekt lbhkz dbfhi nyntb ke zlk}b( ]kcbzfcb} fz} fcpk}}fdgb zk cnab }rtb bubtvkhb f} nyntb ke bubtvzlfhi( Lb ln} zk nitbblb} ubtv crml mkhmbthbj ndkrz zlb ef}mng lbngzl ke zlf} mkccrhfzv( Lb mnhhkz }pbna zk hkt ln} hk jftbmz ahkygbjike zlb *>='000'000 zlnz }lb} }pbnafhi ke drz zlbv yfgg hkz db ndgb zk mkhzfhrb zk itky n} n mkccrhfzv fe zlbv ntb hkfhnhmfnggv }zndgb( Zlbtb f} n jfeebtbhmb dbzybbh ylnz }krtmb} ke erhj} zlbv ntb r}fhi yfzlfh zlb Tbjbubgkpcbhz

Mkccf}}fkh u}( ylnz n Ibhbtng Erhj drtjbh cnv db( Yfzl zlf} ptkobmz zkjnv nhj yfzl zlb ptkobmz} zlbv lnub jkhbltkril zlb Tbjbubgkpcbhz Mkccf}}fkh' zlb ibhbtng drtjbh f} hkz kh zlb Ibhbtng Erhj ke zlb mfzv( Fz f} pntz ke zlb

jf}ztfmz} zlbc}bgub}( Ylfzzfmabt }nfj' zlnz f} ztrb drz jkb}hz zlb Bmkhkcfm Jbubgkpcbhz trh zltkril zlb drjibz ke fzv nhj jkb} hkz zlb mfzv pnv pntz ke zlb dfgg} nhj zlb }ngntv nhj }k kh zlnz} fhukgubj fh zlnz; Tbb}b tbpgfbj' lb

irb}}bj lb jkb}hz erggv rhjbt}znhj( Lf} pk}fzfkh f} pnfj ekt zltkril zlb Ibhbtng Erhj' vb} fz f}' drz ck}z ke zlbmkhkcfm jbubgkpcbhz ptkmb}}b} zlnz zlbv jk ntb dn}fmnggv }bge#erhjbj zltkril erzrtb zn| fhmkcb' hkz zn|pnvbthmkcb( Zlbv jk hkz fcpnmz hbinzfubgv zlb ztnjfzfkhng zn| dn}b( Or}z n} yfzl zlf} ptkobmz nhj zlbv }pbhz }kcb zfcbngafhi ndkrz fz nz zlb gn}z cbbzfhi' fz jkb} hkz znab nynv nhv zn|b} zlnz ntb dbfhi pnfj zkjnv kh zlf} }fzb( Fz khgv nggk


5/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 2#40>4 Mkhzfhrbjlbc zk fhmbhzfufb zlb itkyzl nhj rgzfcnzbgv cktb gkmng kpzfkh fhmkcb zn| nhj ibhbtnzfkh ke okd} nhj fhzbtb}z fh zlkccrhfzv zk db ndgb zk itky rgzfcnzbgv zlb zn| dn}b n} n ylkgb( ]k' lb ahky} zlnz} }mtnzml vkrt bvb} krz yfzlnhjpnpbt }ktz ke }zree drz ylnz zlbv ntb jkfhi jkb} hkz lnub n hbinzfub fcpnmz kh zlb mrttbhz zn| dn}b kt zlb Ibhbt

Erhj ke zlb mfzv( C}( Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Tbb}b' cnvdb etkc lf} pbt}pbmzfub drz zlbv hbbj zk lnub zlnz jf}mr}}fkh drz }

ynhz} zlnz jf}mr}}fkh zk db kpbh ekt zlb prdgfm zk rhjbt}znhj ylnz} ikfhi kh dbmnr}b fe zlb pbkpgb rhjbt}zkkj' zlbvykrgj hkz ~rb}zfkh lbt ndkrz zlnz( Tbb}b zkgj Ylfzzfmabt' kl' lb ibz} ~rb}zfkh} ngg zlb zfcb' zkk' }k lf} }vcpnzlfb} nubtv khb ke zlbc lb} }rtb jk ibz zlnz nhj lb yfgg cnab lfc}bge nhj mkhzfhrb zk cnab lfc}bge nunfgndgb zk zlf} dkjk zlbc fhjfufjrnggv' zk ykta zltkril ylnz ntb ibhbtnggv mkcpgfmnzbj zlfhi} drz' ekt zlk}b fhzbtb}zbj pbkpgb nhj zlb

prdgfm fh ibhbtng zk cnab }rtb zlnz zlbv ahky zlnz zlbvtb hkz jkfhi nhvzlfhi zlnz f} ikfhi zk db ke jncnib zk zlbc(Ylfzzfmabt }znzbj' ~rb}zfkh( ]fhmb yb pnfj fh}rtnhmb' zlb gfndfgfzv kh zlnz }k fe }kcbzlfhi lnj lnppbhbj zk zlb drfgjz ykrgj lnub dbbh fh}rtbj( Hky' yfgg zlnz ckhbv db jbjrmzbj etkc zlb ptfmb zlnz} ikfhi zk db pnfj zk VA; Tbb}bnfj zlbv lnub hkz jbefhbj b|nmzgv( Lb dbgfbub} zlnz yn} nmzrnggv tbpnfj dv zlbc ngtbnjv( Lbgg znab nhkzlbt gkka d

lb jkb} dbgfbub} zlnz yn} pntz ke zlbft(( Nhj ninfh' mbtznfhgv hk jf}tb}pbmz zk zlb Mkrhmfgykcnh drz dbektb zlbclbv lnub zlb kppktzrhfzv zk itky n gkmng mkcpnhv fh n enmfgfzv zlnz jb}pbtnzbgv hbbj} tbhkunzfkh fh n ynv zlnz zlbv

ikfhi zk db ndgb zk jk fz zk ylbtb zlbv tbnml zlbft rgzfcnzb bhj ylfml f} ylbtb zlbv ynhzbj zk db hk cnzzbt ylnz yfz

lb tbuf}bj mkthbt ke >5

zl

nhj zlb Dv#Pn}} zlnz zlbv mnh ngg db ptkrj ke' zlnz ln} bmkhkcfm jbubgkpcbhz dbfhi ibhbtz n lfilbt gbubg zlnh fz f} zkjnv fh fz }k lb ykrgj rtib zlnz zlbv ekmr} kh zlnz tfilz hky( Mkrhmfgykcnh Ylfzzfmabtnfj' ybgg' }fhmb zlf} f} ngg n pntz ke zlnz ekmr} nhj }k kh' }lb zlfha} ngg ke zlnz hbbj} zk db cnjb mgbnt dbmnr}b hkhb kelbc fh zlf} tkkc' zlbvub ngg }nfj zlbv ntb fh }rppktz ke Ct( Mncpdbgg nhj zlnz itkyzl nhj }k kh( Ylnz zlbv lnubkhmbth} yfzl ylfml yn} hkz mgbnt' fz} dbbh cnjb cktb mgbnt nezbt }lb ~rb}zfkhbj lfc ,Tbb}b& ndkrz fz nhj jfj }kc

jrb jfgfibhmb kh lbt kyh zk gkka fhzk zlb fhektcnzfkh ndkrz zlnz ylkgb zlfhi( Lnj zlnz dbbh kh zlb zndgb' cnvdb }kcke zlb }abpzfmf}c }rttkrhjfhi }kcb zlfhi} ykrgj hkz lnub dbbh zlbtb( Tbb}b mkccbhzbj' }abpzfmf}c f} n dnj zlfhiLb ykrgj nitbb( Mkrhmfgcnh Etbj Ztk|bgg zkgj Ct( Tbb}b lb }nfj lb ykrgj tnzlbt znga fh ptfunzb( Hky zlf} f} ylnzcnab} pbkpgb lnub ~rb}zfkh}( Hky' ekt nh b|ncpgb' lb} ikz tbng ~rb}zfkh} ndkrz fz dbmnr}b fe Ct( Mncpdbgg ykrgjr}z }fz dnma nhj ynfzbj' zlbv ybtb ikfhi zk ektbmgk}b kh zlf} ptkpbtzv( Fz ykrgj lnub dbbh nhkzlbt jbng ylbtb lb mk

lnub pfmabj fz rp ekt n gkz gb}} ckhbv( Hky lb ebbg} gfab lb} ,Mncpdbgg& dbfhi znabh njunhznib ke( Zlnz} lf}kpfhfkh( Drz ylv ykrgj lb db yfggfhi zk pnv kee zlb *>'200'000 jbdz ylbh lb mkrgj lnub ynfzbj ylbh zlbv ektbmgkkh fz nhj dkrilz fz gfab zlbv lnub kzlbt drfgjfhi} lbtb fh Cntfkh( Zlf} f} ylv zlbv lnub tbng ~rb}zfkh}' Ztk|bgg }nfjMkrhmfgcnh Dtnj Grnjjbt }nfj' lb ykrgj }nv zlnz zlbv ckub kh zk zlb }rdobmz nz lnhj ekt Ct( Mncpdbgg nhj mnhjf}mr}} zlb tb}z ke zlb zlfhi} yfzl VA nz n gnzbt jnzb( Tbb}b }nfj' lb jkb}hz dbgfbub fh nhv ynv zlnz fz} npptkptfnzb grjb zk zlb enmz zlnz }kcbkhb f} ztvfhi zk db znabh njunhznib ke fh zlf}' Ct( Ztk|bgg' nhj lb f} khgv tb}pbmzfhi zlnz zlibhjn zlnz ln} dbbh prdgf}lbj db tbegbmzbj fh zlb mkhubt}nzfkh( Ztk|bgg zkgj Tbb}b lb jfjhz nmmr}b nhvdkjv kehvzlfhi( Lb }nfj dbmnr}b ke lf} ,Tbb}b& }znzbcbhz zk Ct}( Ylfzzfmabt' ylv jkhz zlbv znga ndkrz zlf} }k zlb prdgfm

jkb}hz lbnt fz; Zlnz} zlb ynv fz mncb nmtk}} zk lfc( ]k' lb or}z }nfj' zlnz} ylv lb ln} ~rb}zfkh}' Ztk|bgg }nfj(Tbb}b tbpgfbj' ybgg' lb} }kttv zlnz lb rhjbt}znhj} fz fh zlnz gfilz drz lb ln} tbpbnzbjgv cnjb lfc}bge nunfgndgb nhj }nlnz lb yfgg mkhzfhrb zk cnab lfc}bge nunfgndgb( Fz f} fh lf} db}z fhzbtb}z ekt zlb mkccrhfzv nhj ngg ke zlbc zk

rhjbt}znhj ylnz f} nhj lb} ubtv lnppv zk jk zlnz( Ztk|bgg }znzbj' ninfh' zlbv cnjb fz mgbnt' lb zlfha} zlbv ngg ntb ekCt( Mncpdbgg nhj zlb ptkobmz drz zlbtb} n gkz ke ~rb}zfkh}( Mkrhmfgykcnh Cnjkhhn Etbhml }nfj' }lb ykrgj gfab zkbmkccbhj zlnz zlbv n}a Ct( Tbb}b zk mkcb dnma zk zlbft hb|z cbbzfhi nhj jf}mr}} zlf} kzlbt }rdobmz fh jbznfg yfzllbc lbtb fh zlbft cbbzfhi }k zlb prdgfm mnh }bb nhj }lb ykrgj ng}k gfab zk ckub Ibhbtng Ktjfhnhmb Hk( 2#40>4' ckkt efhng pn}}nib( Mfzv Mgbta Anzlgbbh Afgbv n}abj' }r}pbhj zlb trgb}; Etbhml tbpgfbj' zlbv jkhz lnub zk' nmmktjfh

Ct( ]zntabv( ]zntabv }znzbj' ybgg' n} lb rhjbt}znhj} fz' fz} pk}}fdgb zlbv lnub gkmng trgb}( Mktpktnzb Mkrh}bg Ok}lLkybgg njjbj' vbnl' ik nlbnj nhj }r}pbhj zlb trgb} nhj ckub fz( Zlbv ntb ikfhi zk n}a zlnz zlbv jk fz fh zlnz en}lfkMkrhmfgcnh Ofc Dtrhhbt mnggbj n pkfhz ke ktjbt nhj }nfj zlf} f} n prdgfm lbntfhi( Dnzmlbgkt }znzbj' zlnz f} mkttbmz(Tbb}b mkccbhzbj' fz yn} njubtzf}bj n} }rml( C}( Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Dnzmlbgkt' }lb zlfha} nz zlf} pkfhz' ikfhi dnma zkylnz Ct( Dtrhhbt }nfj' zlf} f} n prdgfm lbntfhi nhj nz zlf} zfcb' lb ,Dnzmlbgkt& ykrgj bhzbtznfh prdgfm mkccbhz}khmbthfhi zlf} cnzzbt( Mkrhmfg Ptb}fjbhz Dnzmlbgkt n}abj' kanv' jkb} nhvkhb etkc zlb prdgfm lnub nhv' ynhz zk }pkt kt ninfh}z Ktjfhnhmb Hk( 2#40>4; Grmfhjn Mnrjfgg


6/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 2#40>4 Mkhzfhrbjjfeebtbhz ynv nhj cbhzfkhbj gnzbt }k fz} afhj ke lntj' }lb} or}z n enmzktv yktabt( ]lb zlfha} fz} fcpktznhz zk ekggkptkpbt ptkmbjrtb nhj trgb} rhgb}} zlbtb} }kcb jftb hbbj hkz zk dbmnr}b }lb zlfha} pbtmbpzfkh f} 60" ke ck}z zlfhi}Ck}z pbkpgb mnhz mkcb zk zlb Mkrhmfg cbbzfhi} kt mlkk}b hkz zk( ]kcb mnhz ynzml fz kh zbgbuf}fkh( ]kcb jkhz ilb pnpbt( Drz fz} fcpktznhz' }lb zlfha}' zk gkka ndkubdkntj( Hky' khb ke zlb trgb}' }lb zlfha}' f} or}z gfab Etbj

Ztk|bgg f} lbt Mkrhmfgpbt}kh( Ptkpbt ptkmbjrtb f} }lb} ikfhi zk lfc( Zlnz} khb zlfhi( ]lb gkka} ntkrhj zlf} mftmlbtb nhj }lb jkb}hz }bb nhvkhb' fh ngg lkhb}zv' zlnz ynhz} nhvzlfhi drz zlb db}z ekt Cntfkh nhj }lb jkb}hz zlfha nhke zlbc ykrgj jk nhvzlfhi zk obkpntjfb zlnz( Bubh fe zlb pkybt} zlnz db ykrgj mkcb zk zlbc' }lb lkhb}zgv zlfha} }ahky} ck}z ke zlbc ybgg bhkril zk ahky zlnz zlbtb} n gkz ke fhzbitfzv lbtb drz }lb ng}k zlfha} ylbh zlbvtb jbngfhiyfzl pbkpgb gfab lbt' tnha nhj efgb' lfil }mlkkg bjrmnzfkh' nhj zlb ukzbt}' zlb pbkpgb zlnz prz zlbc fh keefmb' fz} }kcpktznhz zk zlfha lky zlfhi} ntb pbtmbfubj dv zlk}b pbkpgb zlnz }rppktz zlbc nhj jbgbzfhi zlb trgb}' dvpn}}fhi' }kc

ke zlb }znhjntj} ke zlb lbntfhi} kt ylnzbubt' }lb jkb}hz zlfha fz gkka} ikkj( Fz cfilz db ikkj( Nz zlbft cbbzfhi zlblnj' Ct( Mncpdbgg nhj Ct( Tbb}b' hbfzlbt khb }nfj nhvzlfhi ndkrz dvpn}}fhi n trgb zlnz zlbtb yn} nhv tr}l kh zlf} }lb tbnggv jkb}hz rhjbt}znhj zlb tr}l( ]lb ibz} n gkz ke plkhb mngg} zkk nhj ln} zk afhj ke }bpntnzb Cntfkh nhjkhb}dktk nhj In} Mfzv( ]lb} hkz fh nhv pk}fzfkh zk tbnggv lbgp nhvdkjv drz' vkr ahky' pbkpgb mngg nhvkhb }kcbzfhj zlf} f} }kcb ke zlb ~rb}zfkh}( Zlbv hbbj zk ahky zlbv mnh ztr}z zlbc nhj zlbvub ngtbnjv dvpn}}bj khb trgb

khfilz( ]lb} hkz }rtb ylv( Hkdkjv} ninfh}z fz' }lb} hkz ninfh}z fz( Drz ninfh' zlbv dvpn}}bj n trgb' n lbntfhi(Hky' zlbv cnv }nv fz} hkz n trgb dbmnr}b zlbv mnh ukzb zk ,fhnrjfdgb& zlb =tj lbntfhi drz }lb} zbggfhi zlbc fz jkb}hkka ikkj zk pbkpgb gfab lbt' zlb rhbjrmnzbj pbkpgb zlnz zlbv tbptb}bhz' fz jkb}hz gkka ikkj( ]lb} lnj pbkpgb }nv'

ybgg' jk zlbv or}z ynhz zk }afp fz }k zlbv jkhz lnub zk dtfhi fz rp nz n =tj cbbzfhi' znab n gfzzgb gkhibt; Hk( Hkdkjvlbtb ykrgj jk zlnz( Hkdkjv lbtb ynhz} zk }afp zltkril nhj cnab n cbbzfhi en}z dv pn}}fhi }kcbzlfhi kh zlb 4hjbnjfhi( ]lb jkb}hz dbgfbub zlnz( ]lb jkb}hz dbgfbub nhv ke zlbc ykrgj( ]lb} zngafhi ndkrz hkz tbngfzv( ]lb}ngafhi ndkrz pbtmbpzfkh nhj }lb zlfha}' ylbh vkr tbptb}bhz zlb prdgfm' }lb ynhz} zlbc zk lnub mkhefjbhmb fh zlf}

Mkrhmfg nhj fh Cntfkh nhj zlb ynv Cntfkh f} lbnjbj( ]lb jkb} zlfha fz f} fcpktznhz zk db ndkub tbptknml( Fz jkb}hcbnh zlbvtb jkfhi nhvzlfhi ytkhi dbmnr}b zlbv ukzb kh fz( Zlbv jk bubtvzlfhi gbing( Drz }lb jkb} zlfha fz f}cpktznhz or}z zk znab zlk}b b|ztn }zbp}( Zlbtb} }kcbzfcb} hk tr}l }k ylv hkz or}z znab zlb b|ztn zfcb nhj cnabubtvdkjv ebbg n gfzzgb cktb mkhefjbhz fh ylnz zlbvtb jkfhi dbmnr}b' gfab }lb }nfj' }lb} cbz yfzl zlbc dbektb nhj }

ynzmlb} zlbc kh zbgbuf}fkh nhj }lb ln} mkhefjbhmb fh ngg ke zlbc( ]lb tbnggv jkb}( ]lb ahky} }lb} n Jbckmtnz drlb} ahkyh zlbc nhj }bbh zlbc fh zlb mkccrhfzv gkhi bhkril zk ahky zlnz zlbtb} hkzlfhi ikfhi kh lbtb drz zlb

prdgfm hbbj} zk ahky zlnz( Zlbv hbbj zk ahky zlnz zlbvtb ikfhi zltkril bubtv }zbp' bubtv lbntfhi( Zlbvtb jkfhi lbv mnh zk tb}bntml zlb}b zlfhi}' zlnz zlbvtb ztnh}pntbhz( Zlnz} or}z lbt zyk mbhz}( Zlnha vkr' Mnrjfgg }nfj( ]zbu

Lbhjbt}kh 544 B( ]zbplbh}kh ]ztbbz' Cntfkh zkgj Tbb}b' ibzzfhi dnma zk zlb ktjfhnhmb fz}bge' lb lnj n mkrpgb ke~rb}zfkh} cnvdb lb mkrgj mkcb dnma rp nhj nh}ybt ekt lfc( Lbj gfab zk ahky }kcb ke zlb zbtc} ke zlb ZFE zlnzlbvtb jbngfhi yfzl nhj ng}k f} zlb Ztbb ke Gfeb Dkka}zktb' ntb zlbv n hkh#ptkefz M#= ktinhfnzfkh kt hkz nhj lky ylnz neebmz zlb pnvdnma kh zlb ZFE }fhmb zlnz ktinhfnzfkh jkb}hz pnv ptkpbtzv zn|b}; Ct( Tbb}b zkgj Lbhjbt}kh'|mbggbhz ~rb}zfkh}( Vb}' zlbv ntb n ekt#ptkefz mkcpnhv( Zlnz f} khb ke zlk}b zlfhi} lb lnj fh zlb dnma ke lf} lbnj klb gn}z mkrpgb ke ybba} zk cnab }rtb lb }nfj zlf} bubhfhi }k zlnha vkr' Ct( Lbhjbt}kh' ekt dtfhifhi zlnz rp( Dn}fmnfj' fe zlbtb} hk zn|b}' zlbtb} hk ZFE }k zlbv ntb n ekt#ptkefz mkcpnhv( Ylnz zlbv lnub f} zlb ndfgfzv zk dkhj' fe zl

ckubj ektyntj' zlbv lnub zlb ndfgfzv zk dkhj rp zk *>0'000'000( Zlb ZFE zlnz f} ibhbtnzbj etkc zlnz }fzb yfgg db r}b} nh fhmkcb }ztbnc zk n}}f}z fh pnvfhi zlnz dnma }k zlnz} zlb ckjbg( ]kcbkhb n}abj ylnz} zlb zfcb gfcfz nhj Tbbnfj zlb zfcb gfcfz f} 40 vbnt}( Ct( Mncpdbgg zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg' zlb Ztbb ke Gfeb Cfhf}ztfb} f} ptkdndgv zlb hkh#ptkefz

lb} ,Lbhjbt}kh& zlfhafhi ke ylfml ln} ptkpbtzv kh >


7/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 2#40>4 MkhzfhrbjLkggfhi}yktzl zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg lb gfub} fh Cntfkh' Fhjfnhn( Lb nitbb} yfzl zlb eft}z }pbnabt ndkrz ekggkyfhiptkmbjrtb} b}zndgf}lbj nhj infhfhi prdgfm mkhefjbhmb }k lb jkb}hz lnub zk njjtb}} zlnz f}}rb( Lf} cnfh mkhmbth f} lf} VA }fzrnzfkh f} n }pbbj drcp fh zlf} ptkmb}}' zlnz zlbtb ln} zk db ergg jf}mgk}rtb ndkrz fhukgubcbhz' ptbufkr}kccfzcbhz} ke VA fhjr}ztfb} nhj ng}k' vkr ahky' ylbh vkr ibz }kcbdkjv ylk }nv}' vkr jk }kcbzlfhi ekt cb' F

jk }kcbzlfhi ekt vkr' lb ynhz} zk ahky ylnz jbng yn} cnjb yfzl VA zk ifub rp zlb }fzrnzfkh( Fe Ct( Tbb}b f} ikfhkcb dnma zk zlb Mkrhmfg nhj n}a ekt }kcbzlfhi njjfzfkhng ekt VA Fhjr}ztfb}' lb zlfha} zlbv hbbj zk fhub}zfinzb zlf}VA zlfhi n} pntz ke zlb Ztbb ke Gfeb zlfhi zk db mkcpgbzbgv ztnh}pntbhz kh ngg n}pbmz} ke fz( Nhkzlbt pkfhz lbj gfab zcnab f} ndkrz znafhi erzrtb zn| ckhbv nynv etkc zlb }mlkkg}( Nz zlb gn}z cbbzfhi' Ct( Tbb}b }nfj zlnz zlbtb ykrgjjjfzfkhng }zrjbhz} nhj }zrjbhz erhj} mkcfhi etkc zlb }znzb( Zlnz} hkz ngynv} ztrb( Lb ykrgj gfab zk }bb }kcb

dnmafhi ekt zlnz }znzbcbhz( Lf} mtkhfb} ntb mkh}znhzgv zngafhi ndkrz ukrmlbt} nhj etbbjkc ke mlkfmb' }mlkkg mlkfmb lbvtb ifufhi nynv zlb zn| dn}b ke krt prdgfm }mlkkg}( Fz} dbbh ikfhi kh ekt vbnt}( Ylfgb Ct( Tbb}b mnh }nv zlbv

hkz znafhi nhvzlfhi nynv hky' zlbvtb znafhi nynv }kcbzlfhi fh zlb erzrtb( Lb zlfha} zlnz }lkrgj db n cnoktkh}fjbtnzfkh( Nhkzlbt n}pbmz lb yf}lb} zk njjtb}} f} zlb tbznfg n}pbmz ke zlf}( Fz} hkz or}z n }zktblkr}b kt nhvzlfhi

Zlbtb} zlb fhzbhzfkh lbtb ke drfgjfhi tbznfg }pnmb kh zlb pntafhi gkz ntbn nhj zlbvtb ikfhi zk db ifufhi tbznfgdr}fhb}}b} zn| njunhznib kubt kzlbt dr}fhb}}b} kh zlb Dv#Pn}}( Lb mkh}znhzgv }bb} fh Cntfkh ylbtb khb dr}fhb}} y

bnub nhj nhkzlbt dr}fhb}} yfgg mkcb fh zk znab fz} pgnmb' gfab Lkddv Gkddv kt Mnt}kh} kt ]zbub nhj Dnttv}(]kcbdkjv gbnub} nhj }kcbdkjv mkcb}( N mkccrhfzv ln} n mntfhi mnpnmfzv ekt bmkhkcfm} nhj fe zlbv ibz hby tbzndr}fhb}} fh' zlbtb cfilz db nh ,fhnrjfdgb& tbnml kh zlb pntz ke Ztbb ke Gfeb zk ik fhzk zlf} tbznfg }fzrnzfkh drz fz} nhjunhznib zlnz zlbv mkrgjhz infh nhvylbtb bg}b }k fz} ptkdndgv nh njunhznib ekt zlbc }bgbmzfhi zlf} }fzb( Drz' zlb

pkfhz lb} ztvfhi zk cnab f}' fz cfilz db przzfhi kzlbt dr}fhb}}b} kh zlb Dv#Pn}} krz ke dr}fhb}} zk infh dr}fhb}} nzhkzlbt gkmnzfkh zltkril zn| njunhznib} zlnz zlbv jkhz lnub ptb}bhzgv( Nhj' fz} dbbh cbhzfkhbj dv Ct( Tbb}b zlnz

kzlbt Njcfhf}ztnzfkh} lnub r}bj zlf} ZFE zlfhi dbektb nhj }k ektzl drz fz }bbc} zk lfc zlbvub }bbh n gkz ke Ct( Tbbh zlb vbnt} nhj }kcbdkjv} cnafhi n mntbbt krz ke zlf}' ylfml cnv hkz db Ct( Tbb}b lfc}bge( Fh enmz' lb ln} n gkz kb}pbmz ekt Ct( Tbb}b( Lb} kh zlb etkhz gfhb}( Lb} mkcfhi rp lbtb nhj lb} enmfhi zlb prdgfm nhj lb} enmfhi zlb

Mkrhmfg nhj lb ebbg} lb} dbfhi ptbpntbj ekt }kcbzlfhi dfiibt nhj dbzzbt dbmnr}b fz} n zkril okd nhj lb} mtfzfmffhlfc drz lb rhjbt}znhj} zlnz lb ln} znabh rpkh lfc}bge zk db kh zlb etkhz gfhb} nhj ik ektzl kh zlf}( Zlnz} ngg lb ln}nv' Lkggfhi}yktzl }nfj( Ct( Tbb}b zlnhabj Ct( Lkggfhi}yktzl nhj zkgj lfc lb lnj lfc rhzfg zlb dfiibt nhj dbzzbtlfhi nhj lb jkb} npptbmfnzb lfc znafhi zlb zfcb zk pnv }k crml cbn}rtb zk lf} mkccbhz} etkc zlb gn}z cbbzfhi( Nby ke lf} pkfhz} lb ,Tbb}b& ebbg} ntb npptkptfnzb ntb nhj ekt bubtvkhb zk db nyntb ke' VA Erthfzrtb jfj hkz tbmbfub

jkggnt etkc zlb mfzv fh zlbft beektz} zk itky zlbft dr}fhb}} fh Cntfkh( Nz gnzb}z mkrhz' zlbv lnub }pbhz hktzl ke *200'kh zlbft ubhzrtb( Zlbv ntb hkz gbnufhi zlb mkccrhfzv( Zlbv ntb ibzzfhi krz ke zlb ynv ke zlf} kzlbt kppktzrhfzv(Ninfh' lb jkb}hz ynhz zk znab fz zkk ent jkyh zlnz pnzl drz lb jkb} tb}pbmz zlnz zlbtb ykrgj db nhj ntb }kcb ~rb}zfkdkrz zlnz ptkobmz( Zlnz} efhb( Zlnz} hnzrtng nhj enft zk db pntz ke zlb mkhubt}nzfkh drz zlnz f} n ubtv jfeebtbhz nhjhjbpbhjbhz ptkobmz zlnh ylnz zlbv ntb zngafhi ndkrz zkjnv( Lb jkb} ebbg gfab lb} dbbh rp lbtb zkk crml drz lb zlflnz} dbmnr}b zlbv nmzrnggv lnj n gkz cktb kppktzrhfzfb} zk jk zlfhi} gfab zlf} zlnh zlbv lnub lnj fh zlb pn}z nhj lblfha} zlnz} n tbegbmzfkh ke lky zlb mkccrhfzv f} dbmkcfhi cktb nhj cktb ufdtnhz( Zlb tbznfg ~rb}zfkh ndkrz mtbnzh rhenft }fzrnzfkh' lb dbgfbub} zlnz n} bntgv n} zlb hb|z cbbzfhi' zlbvtb ikfhi zk db zngafhi ndkrz jkfhi zlf} ubtv }nclfhi yfzl zlb cngg( Zlbv b}zndgf}lbj zlbft jf}ztfmz nz zlb bhj ke gn}z vbnt ekt zlbft tblndfgfznzfkh( Zlbv ntb hbntfhi zl

pgnmb ylbtb zlbvtb tbnjv zk ng}k efhnhmb zlnz tbmkh}ztrmzfkh ylfml ykrgj cbnh zlnz zlbv ykrgj ik zltkril zlb ptkminfh' or}z n} zlbv ntb lbtb' zk keebt dkhj} ekt zlb dbhbefz ke zlnz ktinhfnzfkh( Crml ke zlb tbznfg mkttfjkt nmtk}}' vk

ahky' zlb hkh#Dv#Pn}} Dv#Pn}} zlnz yb lnub f} fh zlb ZFE jf}ztfmz nhj jbpbhjfhi kh zlb }mngb ke zlb ptkobmz' fz}unfgndgb n} n jf}ztfmz }k fz} hkz Kh n mn}b dv mn}b dn}f}' lb mnh rhjbt}znhj lky fz }bbc} gfab zlbtb ykrgj db npbmfefm njunhznib kt jf}njunhznib drz zlnz f} khb ke zlb zlfhi} zlnz zlb Mkrhmfgkt} zlnz ntb kh zlb Bmkhkcfm

Jbubgkpcbhz Mkccf}}fkh ng}k tbufby nhj zlbv nitbb zlnz yb ntb hkz mtbnzfhi nh rhenft njunhznib zk nhvkhb( Vb}'bznfg }zktb} mkcb nhj ik( Fz lnppbh}( Zlbft ikng f} zk or}z ibz cktb nhj cktb ke zlbc nhj gk}b gb}} zlnh zlbv ibz fh

Ptkobmz} zlnz zlbv dtfhi yfgg enfg( Zlb khgv ynv zlnz zlbv ahky zlbvtb hkz ikfhi zk enfg f} zk hbubt jk nhvzlfhi drzlnz} nhkzlbt }knpdk|( Zlb }mlkkg }v}zbc' lb jkb}' nhj ik dnma zk nhv mnpfzng mkhmbth} zlnz zlbv ykrgj lnub ikfhktyntj' ylfml ykrgj db pk}}fdgv fcpnmzbj dv ptkpbtzv zn|' zlbv ykrgj gkub zk znab fhzk mkh}fjbtnzfkh fh zlbft

pgnhhfhi( ]k' ylfgb zlbtb f} hk mkhubt}nzfkh kt hk ptkobmz} kh zlb zndgb hky' zlbv ykrgj mbtznfhgv jk zlnz nhj lb lk


8/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 2#40>4 Mkhzfhrbjlnz lb jfj mkhubv zlnz zlbv ntb hkz lrtzfhi zlbft prdgfm }mlkkg} fh nhv ynv( Zlbv ntb ztvfhi zk cnab fz nh bhuftkhc

ylbtb pbkpgb yfgg ynhz zk db nhj zlr} tbmtrfz pbkpgb zlnz cnv db ke mlfgjdbntfhi nib zk dtfhi }zrjbhz} zk krt }mlkkgylfml jkb} lnub }znzb ckhbv ekggkyfhi fz( Zlk}b ntb lf} hkzb}( Lb jkb} npptbmfnzb Lkggfhi}yktzl} mkccbhz} nhjlb} }rtb zlb Mkrhmfg jkb} zkk' Tbb}b }nfj( Mkrhmfgykcnh Ok}bgvh Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Ct( Tbb}b' fe zlnz f} zlb mn}b' zlb

hb|z dr}fhb}} ubhzrtb zlbh zlbv mnh }nv zlnz krt gfdtntv nhj krt }mlkkg yfgg lnub n mbtznfh nckrhz zlnz f} mkcfhi krzlb ZFE dbmnr}b zlnz mnh db ytfzzbh fhzk zlb mkhztnmz nhj }lb ln} tbnj zlnz fh kzlbt mfzfb} nhj mkccrhfzfb} nhj }k khfhmb zlbv lnub zlf}' }lb} gkkafhi nz zlb MTbBJ fhektcnzfkh nhj }k kh nhj yb lnub n gntibt ZFE jf}ztfmz zlnh Cntfk

Mkrhzv' ylfml f} Fhjfnhnpkgf}( ]k' ylnz }lb} ikfhi zk jk' yfzl zn|pnvbt} gf}zbhfhi' f} lkgj lfc ,Tbb}b& zk zlnz pkfhlnz nz }kcb pkfhz fh zlb hbnt erzrtb' hkz jf}znhz erzrtb' zlnz krt }mlkkg jf}ztfmz nhj krt gfdtntv }v}zbc jkb} tbmbfub }k

ke zlnz erhjfhi nhj }k kh( Fz mnh db jkhb zlb ynv zlb mkhztnmz} ntb ytfzzbh rp' Ylfzzfmabt }nfj( Tbb}b tbpgfbj'd}kgrzbgv nhj lb npptbmfnzb} lbt pn}}fkh zkyntj} zlnz' kdufkr}gv' drz zlb efhnhmfng fcpnmz }znzbcbhz} ntb cnjb kh n

ptkobmz dn}f} zk zlb zn|pnvbt} zlnz lnub zlb kppktzrhfzv zk mkcb fh( Ylfgb lb} hkz ikfhi zk mkccfz zk }bzzfhi n}fjb btznfh pktzfkh zlnz cnv hkz db hbmb}}ntfgv r}bj dbmnr}b zlbtb} hk tbn}kh zk or}z gbz zn|pnvbt ckhbv }fz nhj hkz

ibhbtnzb }kcb }ktz ke tbzrth' zlbv nd}kgrzbgv jk znab fz kh n mn}b dv mn}b dn}f} n} zk ylnz zlb hbbj} ke zlb mkccrhfztb nhj zlbv jk zlnz nhj lnub jkhb zlnz( Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Tbb}b' nhj }lb yfgg lkgj lfc zk fz( Ct( Tbb}b zkgj C}(

Ylfzzfmabt' lb ln} hk jkrdz( Etnhmb} Cntgbv >6=5 Y( >5

zl

]ztbbz' Cntfkh zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg lf} ~rb}zfkh f}' lbhkzfmbj fh zlb gn}z ckhzl kt ckhzl nhj n lnge' zlbvub dbbh cntafhi rp >5zl ]ztbbz krz zlbtb kh jfeebtbhz cntafhi} nhzree nhj lb} ykhjbtfhi fe zlbv ybtb ikfhi zk jk }kcb cnokt tknjykta krz zlbtb zk nmmkcckjnzb zlf} ckub krz zlb

]fhmb lb gfub} kh >5zl ]ztbbz' lb ykrgj lnub }kcb fhprz kh zlnz fe zlbtb yn} }kcbzlfhi gfab zlnz ikfhi zk db jkhb krzlbtb }fhmb >5zl ]ztbbz f}hz ubtv yfjb nhj zlb pbkpgb zlnz gfub jkyh zltkril zlbtb' zlbft lkcb} ntb ptbzzv mgk}b zk >5

]ztbbz ng}k( ]k lb yn} ykhjbtfhi fe zlbtb yn} ikfhi zk db nhv cnokt tknjykta jkhb krz zlbtb zk nmmkcckjnzb zlf}Ztbb ke Gfeb mkcfhi fh' Cntgbv n}abj; Tbb}b tb}pkhjbj' zk lf} ahkygbjib' lb jkb}hz ahky ylnz zlnz f}( Zlf} ptkoykrgj db }bge#mkhznfhbj kh fz} pntmbg( Lb jkb}hz }bb nhv }pbmfefm hbbj zk rpitnjb >5zl ]ztbbz drz lb jkb}hz lnub nhahkygbjib ke nhvzlfhi zlbtb( Zlb Bhifhbbtfhi Jbpntzcbhz cnv lnub n dbzzbt fjbn( C}( Ylfzzfmabt zkgj Ct( Tbb}b'dbektb lb gbnub}' }fhmb Ct( Cntgbv dtkrilz zlnz rp' zlnz cnv db }kcbzlfhi lb hbbj} zk mlbma fhzk n} n pntz kebjbubgkpcbhz dbmnr}b zlnz }ztbbz f} n pntz ke zlnz ylkgb mkthbt nhj }k kh( Tbb}b nh}ybtbj' nd}kgrzbgv nhj zlbv lnukkabj fhzk zlnz }k zlbv jkhz }bb nhv hbmb}}ntv rpitnjb} zk zlnz }ztbbz tbgnzbj zk zlf} ptkobmz( Zlbv lnub b|pgktbj zl

Zlb khb kzlbt pkfhz nhj fz} jfeefmrgz zk znab ,fhnrjfdgb& nh b|zbhjbj mkhubt}nzfkh dbmnr}b lb mbtznfhgv jkb}hz ynhztbnzb n }pbmzbt ke n tr}l kt }kcbzlfhi zlnz f}hz hbmb}}ntfgv' lb irb}}bj' ndkubdkntj( Lb jkb} npptbmfnzb C}( Mnrjkccbhz} zkyntj} zlnz beebmz nhj vb}' pbtmbpzfkh f} }kcbzlfhi zlbv ngg hbbj zk db ubtv nyntb ke( Drz ng}k' zlb }pbb

dr}fhb}} f} }kcbzlfhi zlnz zlbv ngg hbbj zk db ubtv nyntb ke( Bubtv jnv zlnz zlbv jkhz }zntz kh zlnz ptkobmz f} n jnv lbv jkhz ibz zlnz ptkobmz jkhb( ]k zlnz} }kcbzlfhi zlnz zlbv znab fhzk nmmkrhz( ]kcb ptkobmz} jk lnub lntjbt

jbnjgfhb} zlnh kzlbt} drz bubtv ptkobmz' bubtv zfcb zlbv dtfhi n gnyvbt fhzk zlb tkkc' zlnz jkb} mk}z ckhbv nhj zlbptkobmz} pnv ekt zlk}b khb ynv kt nhkzlbt( ]k' fz} mbtznfhgv hkz zlbft fhzbhz zk ptb}}rtb kt n}}rcb drz zlbvub lnjfihfefmnhz mkhubt}nzfkh ndkrz zlf} pntzfmrgnt ptkobmz( Mbtznfhgv zlbv lnub }lkyh zlb nppbzfzb ekt kzlbt} mkhubt}nzfkhj lb }zfgg }znhj} dv lf} yfggfhihb}} zk mkccrhfmnzb zlk}b' n} lb mnh( Drz lb jkb} rtib' fe zlbtb f} n ynv zk b|pbjfzlf} ptkmb}}' fz ykrgj db npptbmfnzbj' Tbb}b zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg( Ct( ]zntabv njjbj' lb or}z zlkrilz zlnz zlbv cfilz

dbhbefz' or}z etkc lf} b|pbtfbhmb yfzl kzlbt Mkrhmfg} ntkrhj zlb }znzb' lb} dbbh jkfhi zlf} ekt 4< vbnt} nhj lb} hkzyntb ke nhv Mkrhmfg zlnz nmzrnggv ikb} zltkril zltbb cbbzfhi} zk pn}} nh ktjfhnhmb( Hky' zlbv jk zltbb tbnjfhi} dlbv jk zlb 4hj nhj =tj tbnjfhi kh zlb }bmkhj cbbzfhi' zkibzlbt' zk pn}} nh ktjfhnhmb( Hky fz cnv db zlnz zlbv lnubkmng trgb} zlnz tb~rftb zlnz nhj }k zlnz ykrgj db n jfeebtbhz }fzrnzfkh drz fh ck}z mkccrhfzfb} kt fh bubtv mkccrhfz

lb} bubt dbbh fh' zlbv znab zyk cbbzfhi} zk pn}} nh ktjfhnhmb( Zlbv fhztkjrmb fz' zlbv mkcb dnma nhj pn}} fz' 4hj nhtj tbnjfhi' kh zlb }bmkhj cbbzfhi( Ekt ylnz zlnz} yktzl' lb or}z zlkrilz zlbv }lkrgj ahky zlnz' ]zntabv }nfj( Tbbjjbj' nhj zlnz cnv db }kcbzlfhi zlnz zlb Mlnft kt zlb Ktjfhnhmb Mkccfzzbb ynhz} zk znab kh n} n mkjfefmnzfkh ke nrgb kt hkz' ekt ylnz zlnz} yktzl( Dbfhi hk ertzlbt ~rb}zfkh} kt mkccbhz} etkc zlb nrjfbhmb kt zlb Mkrhmfg' ckzfkh

yn} cnjb dv Etbhml zk }r}pbhj zlb trgb} kh Ibhbtng Ktjfhnhmb Hk( 2#40>4( Ckzfkh yn} }bmkhjbj dv Dtrhhbt nhjnttfbj dv zlb ekggkyfhi ukzb( Nvb? Grnjjbt' Hbubg}' Zlkcp}kh' Dtrhhbt' ]cfzl' Etbhml nhj Dnzmlbgkt( Hnv?

Ztk|bgg nhj Ylfzzfmabt( Ckzfkh yn} zlbh cnjb dv Etbhml' 4hj dv Dtrhhbt zk pn}} Ibhbtng Ktjfhnhmb Hk( 2#40>4(


9/10

IBHBTNG KTJFHNHMB HK( 2#40>4 MkhzfhrbjCkzfkh mnttfbj dv zlb ekggkyfhi ukzb( Nvb? Grnjjbt' Hbubg}' Zlkcp}kh' Dtrhhbt' ]cfzl' Etbhml nhj Dnzmlbgkt(Hnv? Ztk|bgg nhj Ylfzzfmabt(

Nz zlf} zfcb' Mkrhmfgykcnh Ok}bgvh Ylfzzfmabt }nfj' dbektb Ct( Tbb}b znab} lf} }bnz' lb cnjb n ubtv fcpktznhz

znzbcbhz' zlnz zlbv ykrgj db jf}mr}}fhi V4A nz zlb hb|z cbbzfhi nhj }lb ynhz} zlf} zk ik kh ibhbtng tbmktj zlnz zlbyfgg db jf}mr}}fhi VA nhj dbektb Ct( Mncpdbgg( Mkrhmfgykcnh Cnjkhhn Etbhml }nfj' b|mr}b cb' Ct( Mncpdbggykhz db kh zlb nibhjn( Ylfzzfmabt }znzbj' dbektb Ct( Mncpdbgg prtmln}b} zlb ptkpbtzv( ]lb jkb}hz dbgfbub nhv kelbc fh zlf} tkkc lnub n ptkdgbc yfzl Jnttbh Mncpdbgg( Ylnz zlbv jk lnub n ptkdgbc yfzl f} }kcb ke zlb jbngfhihj zlb gnma ke ztnh}pntbhmv zlnz ln} ikhb kh ngkhi yfzl VA nhj zlnz} ylnz }lb ynhz} zk lnub jf}mr}}bj( Ct}( Etbnfj' zlbv mnhz jfmznzb zk Ct( Mncpdbgg nhj zlb kyhbt} ke zlnz ptkpbtzv ylbh zlbv mnh ztnh}nmz zlbft jbng( Zlnz} hklbft tbngc ke tb}pkh}fdfgfzv kt nrzlktfzv( Zlbv mnh lnub Ct( Tbb}b mkcb nhj }pbna zk zlbc ndkrz ngg zlb ~rb}zfkh} lbv ynhz drz fz mnhz db zfbj zk zlbv mnhz jk zlbft jbng rhzfg zlbv znga zk Ct( Mncpdbgg( Zlnz} hkz enft kt Ct( Tbb}blnz} hkz enft zk Ct( Mncpdbgg nhj zlb ptkitb}} ke lf} ptkobmz( Ylfzzfmabt }nfj' fe }lb rhjbt}zkkj' ylnz yn} or}z pgn

Ct( Dnzmlbgkt' kh zlb egkkt zlnz Mkrhmfgykcnh Etbhml }r}pbhjbj zlb trgb} }k zlbv ykrgj hkz ik zk n =tj cbbzfhi }kMncpdbgg f} beebmzfubgv' fe }lb rhjbt}zkkj ylnz ybhz jkyh' ylnz lbt ckzfkh yn} zlnz }lb ukzbj ninfh}z' zk ckub fz

tkc zlb =

tj

( ]lb yn} hkz ukzfhi ninfh}z Ct( Mncpdbgg( Ylnz }lb yn} ukzfhi ninfh}z yn} zlb }r}pbhjfhi ke zlb trg]fhmb zlbv lnub jkhb zlnz' zlnz} mkttbmz nhj zlnz} ylnz yn} kh zlb egkkt( Etbhml zkgj Ylfzzfmabt' zlbv lnj zykckzfkh} kh zlb egkkt' khb yn} zk }r}pbhj zlb trgb} nhj zlnz pn}}bj 9#4( Zlb }bmkhj khb yn} zk pn}} zlb ktjfhnhmb nhlnz pn}}bj 9#4( Zlb ktjfhnhmb f} pn}}bj( Ylfzzfmabt tbpgfbj' zlnz f} mkttbmz nhj }lb }nfj' or}z n cfhrzb nik' zlbv yk

db jf}mr}}fhi VA yfzlkrz zlb ktjfhnhmb ke zlb Ztbb ke Gfeb(

Mkrhmfgcnh Pnrg Zlkcp}kh zkgj zlb Mkrhmfg' nz zlbft gn}z Mkrhmfg cbbzfhi' zlbv lnj n gnjv zlnz mncb rp zk lfc nezblb Mkrhmfg cbbzfhi nhj yn} mkhmbthbj ndkrz }kcb rh}neb }ztrmzrtb} ntkrhj zlb ptkpbtzv zlnz zlbv lnj or}z prtmln}

kh ]krzl Njnc} ]ztbbz nhj fhzbhj zk prz n gkz ke ckhbv fhzk fz( Zk lf} ahkygbjib' zlbv lnub hkz n}abj ekt nhv lbgptkc zlb mfzv n} ke vbz drz lb ybhz jkyh zk gkka nz zlnz pfbmb ke ptkpbtzv kh ]krzl Njnc}' lb} }pbnafhi ke Ct}(

Yf}bcnh nhj lbt lr}dnhj' nhj zlbv lnub n }fzrnzfkh jkyh zlbtb zlnz} afhj ke n dnj }fzrnzfkh fh tbintj} zk zlbhbfildktlkkj nhj zlb ckhbv zlnz zlbvtb przzfhi fh zlbtb( Ylfgb lb yn} zlbtb uf}fzfhi yfzl lbt' Gnttv Tfmlntj}kh ylbtb n} ybgg nhj zlbv ybtb zngafhi ndkrz }kcb ke zlb mkhmbth} zlbtb nhj lb ,Zlkcp}kh& lnj mkhmbth} ndkrz }kcb klb kzlbt ntbn} fh zlb Mfzv ke Cntfkh nhj Ct( Tfmlntj}kh inub lfc n mkpv ke n gf}z ke ptkpbtzfb} kyhbj dv zlb Mfzv k

Cntfkh( Nz zlnz zfcb' lb nhj Tfmlntj}kh zkka n tfjb ntkrhj zkyh nhj lb }ny n gkz ke rh}neb }ztrmzrtb} nhj ptkpbtzfblnz hbbj nzzbhzfkh zlnz ntb hkz kh zlf} gf}z' ektzrhnzbgv ekt zlbc n} ptkpbtzv kyhbt}( Lb inub zlf} n gkz ke zlkrilz nhlkrilz' zlbv hbbj zk ahky ylnz zlbv ntb ukzfhi ekt kt ninfh}z ylbh pbkpgb mkcb fh nhj ynhz zk znab pk}}b}}fkh ke b}fjbhmb kt n unmnhz gkz( Fz} ubtv lntj ekt ngg ke zlbc zk ibz zlb zfcb zk ik ntkrhj zlb Mfzv ke Cntfkh nhj gkka nz nlb}b ntbn}( Hky' lb }nz jkyh ~rfmagv zkjnv yfzl zlf} gf}z nhj zlbv' nmmktjfhi zk zlf} gf}z' ntb kyhbt} ke >>> lkr}b}

:


10/10

krgj ibz ntkrhj nhj lb }zkppbj nz n ekrt#ynv }zkp nhj afggbj zlb ckzkt nhj n gnjv }nfj' ik nlbnj itnhjpn nhj lblkrilz lb jkb}hz hbbj zk db krz lbtb }k lb ykrgj gfab zk cnab zlf} ztfp fh n dr}( ]k' fe zlbv ykrgj pgbn}b' ifub lfc

jnzb nhj gbz} cnab zlnz ztfp zkibzlbt nhj gbz} ztv zk jk ylnz zlbv mnh ekt zlb Mfzv ke Cntfkh zk cnab fz dbzzbt'Zlkcp}kh }nfj( Mkrhmfg Ptb}fjbhz Jkh Dnzmlbgkt n}abj' ylnz ntb zlk}b zyk jnzb} ninfh; Zlkcp}kh zkgj lfc' Npt

april 3, 2012 marion, indiana city council minutes

Documents