Upload File

appendix e2_urban community participation in nussp

  • Home
  • Documents
  • Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP
prev
next
out of 9
Download Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

Upload: cddasiapacific

Post on 06-Apr-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

Report

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    1/9

    Regional Conference on Community-DrivenDevelopment

    Sharing Knowledge on CDD: The Neighborhood Upgradingand Shelter Sector Project (NUSSP) in Indonesia

    31 January 2012

    ADB Headquarters, Manila Philippines

    1

    ADBAsian Development Bank

    Appendix E2

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    2/9

    Outline

    NUSSP Background Community Participation

    Identification of Community Needs and

    Priorities Service Delivery (Operation and Maintenance)

    Transparency and accountability

    Promoting and Sustaining CitizenParticipation

    Lessons Learn

    2

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    3/9

    Project Background The main objective of the project with CDD

    Component is to deliver infrastructure in anurban slum areas.

    NUSSP provided grant to communities to developinfrastructure, such as road conjunction,drainage, waste management system, sanitation,

    clean water, road lighting, and microcredit forbuilding/renovating modest housing.

    NUSSP encouraged community participation atplanning, executing, monitoring and maintening

    stages of the proposed project. The project had improved 6800 Hectares of urban

    slum in 800 neighborhood, in 32 cities, andbenefited 3 million people

    3

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    4/9

    Community Participation (1) Identification of Community Needs and Priorities

    Participation at this stage varied:Participation in rural villages were more intensive

    compare to that of urban villages.

    The reasons, among others were: the rural villagers

    had more time and relatively had stronger solidarityThe poor and marginal people were not systematically

    encouraged to participate

    Women participation was weak

    Despite of high quantity, the quality of participation wasremain low

    The elite still dominates decision-making processes.

    4

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    5/9

    Community Participation (2)

    Service Delivery (operation and

    maintenance) Participation in project execution depended on

    types of project implementation (SP2/SP3)

    Almost all communities were voluntarilycommitted to minor maintenance

    Some communities were committed toorganized maintenance activities.

    This maintenance variation to some extent wasrelated to the context in which constructionworks were implemented (Sp2/SP3), financialavailability, and the degree of socialcohesiveness

    5

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    6/9

    Community Participation (3)

    Transparency and Accountability The level of transparency and accountability to some

    extent is depended on the level of participation.

    Transparency and accountability under projects self-implemented by the community itself (thoseimplemented under the SP3 pattern) was greater thanthat of subprojects implemented under the less

    participatory SP2 pattern. Community perception on transparency and

    accountability was limited to the issues of corruption,channeling information

    6

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    7/9

    Major issue in Promoting and Sustainingcitizen Participations

    Deeper understanding on the communities socio -culture

    Increasing common awareness on the importanceof participatory approach through organicmechanism of facilitation.

    Mainstreaming participatory approach in all smallscale village development efforts.

    Provide more options for communityparticipation, i.e, polling (not necessarily direct

    meeting)

    Use endogenous and or trusted institution ratherthan project driven institutions.

    7

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    8/9

    Key Lessons Learn (1)

    CDD initiatives might mitigate against the negativeimpact of urbanization.

    Institutionalizing community participation is a long-term

    task in that it requires assimilation of new values andtraditions by beneficiary communities.

    Community based planning has possible lag ofintegration with that of more macro level planning.

    Encouraging large-scale involvement of heterogeneouscommunity members can in some cases complicateimplementation of the development initiative

    8

  • 8/2/2019 Appendix E2_Urban Community Participation in NUSSP

    9/9

    Key Lessons Learn (2)

    Maximizing the degree of community participation was toensure that the planning of the initiative remains in thehands of the beneficiaries themselves

    It will most likely be necessary to make adjustments toparticipatory programs implemented in urban asopposed to rural areas

    9


Appendix A: Introduction - WordPress.com · Appendix A: Introduction ... represent, and support its tenant to undertake or to resume negotiations on an participation activities. (2)

APPENDIX 3 Participation in Seminars/Workshops/Training ... · Participation in Seminars/Workshops/Training Courses ... SV University, ... Madurai Kamraj University, Madurai,

DRAFT Appendix C: Sign-In Sheets/Participation/Public Outreach › ckeditorfiles › files... · DRAFT – Appendix C: Sign-In Sheets/Participation/Public Outreach xviii Figure C.11:

APPENDIX 3 Participation in Seminars/Workshops/Training Courses

APPENDIX E - PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS Farm Piggery Aliwal... · 2017-06-13 · APPENDIX E Coastal & Environmental Services 1 Endwell Farm Piggery (Pty) Ltd APPENDIX E - PUBLIC

Appendix C: Public Participation Information€¦ · Appendix C: Public Participation Information Appendix C1 – Stakeholder Database Appendix C2 – Land Claims Letters Appendix

APPENDIX 15 Public Consultation and Participation ...APPENDIX 15 Public Consultation and Participation – Register and Supporting Documentation This appendix contains a Register of

Appendix C Samples of Assessment Tools · APPENDIX C: SAMPLES OF ASSESSMENT TOOLS 120 PHYSICAL EDUCATION CURRICULUM GUIDE - INTERMEDIATE Sample Participation Rubric Criteria Warm-up

Appendix B1: Project Description · Web viewSubstation RFO 2 Distribution Resources Plan Demo C-El Nido Substation Supplemental RFO Documents Required for Participation Contents Appendix

Appendix E - Public Participation Process (Part 2)

Milman Road Health Centre Patient Participation Group...Milman Road Health Centre - Patient Participation Group Appendix A Friends and Family Test (FFT) – Emerging results for the

Pedoman Umum NUSSP

Political Participation and the Media - BBCdownloads.bbc.co.uk/.../political-participation-technical-appendix.pdf · Political Participation and the Media Technical Appendix 9/14/2016

NEMA SECTION 24G PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS THE … Final 24G/Appendix G4...nema section 24g public participation process the unlawful construction activities on portion 1 of farm

NEIGHBOURHOOD UPGRADING AND SHELTER SECTOR PROJECT INDONESIA (NUSSP)

Appendix U SWAP Survey Participation and Acknowledgements · 2019-06-07 · Appendix U.SWAP Survey Participation and Acknowledgements Acres Land Trust Adams County Soil & Water Conservation

Appendix 1: Intergroup Agreement Template - GCIG · An appendix to the protocol which details the participation of the participating GROUP ... Reaction; “Participating Group

Public Participation Summaryrhdhv.co.za/media/Nkandla BA July 2015/Appendix E1.pdfPUBLIC PARTICIPATION SUMMARY This serves as a summary of the Public Participation Process followed

APPENDIX B Community Participation Report€¦ · 1. Introduction 1.1 Purpose The First Interim Community Participation Report for the route selection stage of the RTA’s Additional

Appendix 2 Selby District: Sports and Physical Activity ... · Selby District Indoor Sports Facilities Strategy: Appendix 2: Participation Assessment 5 population (i.e. those aged

Appendix 4.11 Public participation in 2013 Participation... · 2019-10-23 · Date Type 10-Mar Authority meeting LEDET Meeting with Competent authority 31-Mar Conservation Focus group

Appendix A. DC Bicycle Master Plan Public Participation ... · Appendix A. DC Bicycle Master Plan Public Participation Process Public participation was a critical component of the

ANNEXURE A – PUBLIC PARTICIPATIONANNEXURE INVENTORY Annexure A – Public Participation Appendix A1 – Text of Newspaper Advertisements Appendix A2 – Text of Site Notice and Flyers

Completion Report NUSSP ADB IRM

APPENDIX 6: PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS Appendix 6.1: I ... · ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT FOR A GLASS BOTTLE MANUFACTURING PLANT PROPOSED BY SAB AND PARTNERS January

PBAI Draft EIA Report 7. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION …...PBAI Draft EIA Report 353 DEIR_V2_17Jan2011 69 7. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION (See Appendix 10 for the PPP Report) 7.1. INTRODUCTION This

Appendix H Public Participation and Outreach Part 1 · PDF fileAppendix H Public Participation and Outreach Report . Appendix H ... Ashley Carrigan : U.S. Senator Dean Heller ; William

Strategy Participation Barnsley Raising - Modern Mindsetbarnsleymbc.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s27081/6 Appendix 3 Raising...In 2008, the government ... participation Create a brochure

FR Appendix 8.1: Social and environmental obligation ...€¦ · 2. This appendix explores the effect of these participation thresholds on competition. We describe the design of the

EDUCATIONAL LEADERS’ DECISION-MAKING: PRESENCE, … · Appendix A Letter Requesting Superintendent Participation in the Study ... Appendix D Survey Instrument as Administered to

APPENDIX 2 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS · APPENDIX 2 – PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS I&APs play an important role in the process, ... the farms De Paarl 246 KP, Goedgedacht 255

APNIC 2016 Survey Appendix C Survey Questionnaire...Survey Matters® APNIC 2016 Quantitative Questionnaire Reference:APNIC Appendix C - Survey Questionnaire 4 | P a g e Participation

APPENDIX H: PUBLIC PARTICIPATION SERIES OF TOWN MEETINGS ... in Richlands on Tazewell... · APPENDIX H: PUBLIC PARTICIPATION Series of Town Meetings - Tazewell County Richlands Meeting

APPENDIX G: PUBLIC PARTICIPATION SEPTEMBER 2016 Hazardous Waste Site EIA 200916B… · APPENDIX G: PUBLIC PARTICIPATION SEPTEMBER 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS ... Cllr CM Adams Nelson Mandela

Appendix D. Participation Athletics,, 1942-1943....Appendix Exhibits, Selected AT Random A. Administration Organization March 31,, 1943. B. Administrativ organization, September,1944e