appendicesfred.csir.co.za/project/smelter/report/appendices.pdfappendices, page 10 po box 27688...

EIA FOR THE PROPOSED COEGA ALUMINIUM SMELTER WITHIN THE COEGA INDUSTRIAL

DEVELOPMENT ZONE, PORT ELIZABETH, SA

FINAL TECHNOLOGY REVIEW REPORT – JULY 2005

APPENDICES

Appendix A: Letters from authorities relating to the Technology Review

Extension of duration of authorisation (letter dated 17 December 2004) Acceptance of proposed Technology Review process for potentially

amending the Record of Decision (letter dated 24 December 2005)

Appendix B: Letters, invitations and adverts issued as part of the public consultation process for the Technology Review

Invitation to attend public meeting (letter dated 30 May 2005) Newspaper advertisements Invitation to community Focus Group Meeting (letter dated 25 May 2005) Invitation to environmental Focus Group Meeting (letter dated 30 May

2005)

Appendix C: Database of interested and affected parties

Complete list of I&APs registered on the database giving their name, organisation and level of involvement

I&APs invited to the environmental sector Focus Group Meeting

Appendix D: Record of comments received during the public review period for the Draft Technology Review Report (including meeting notes and individual submissions)

Notes from Public Meeting (9 June 2005) Notes from Environmental Focus Group Meeting (8 June 2005) Notes from Community Focus Group Meeting (8 June 2005) Notes from Motherwell Tourism Forum meeting (29 June 2005) Notes from Uitenhage meeting (6 July 2005) Written comments received during the public review period




Appendices, Page 1

APPENDIX A:

Letters from authorities relating to the Technology Review

Extension of duration of authorisation (letter dated 17 December 2004) Acceptance of proposed Technology Review process for potentially amending

the Record of Decision (letter dated 24 December 2005)




Appendices, Page 2




Appendices, Page 3




Appendices, Page 4

APPENDIX B:

Letters, invitations and adverts issued as part of the public consultation process for the Technology Review

Invitation to attend public meeting (letter dated 30 May 2005) Newspaper advertisements Invitation to community Focus Group Meeting (letter dated 25 May 2005)

Invitation to environmental Focus Group Meeting (letter dated 30 May 2005)




Appendices, Page 5

PO Box 27688 Greenacres 6057 120 Diaz Road Adcockvale, PE 6001 Phone 041-3748426 Fax 041-3732002 Email [email protected] Ck 97/32984/23 VAT 44601 68273 30 May 2005 Dear RE: PUBLIC MEETING AND COMMENT PERIOD FOR THE TECHNOLOGY REVIEW OF THEENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT FOR THE COEGA ALUMINIUM SMELTER As registered interested and affected parties (I&APs) on the database for the Coega AluminiumSmelter project this letter provides you with the following:

• A summary of recent developments related to the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)conducted in 2002 for the proposed Coega Aluminium Smelter

• Notification of the public comment period for the Technology Review for the EnvironmentalImpact Assessment for the Coega Aluminium Smelter (3 June – 4 July 2005)

• Invite to a Public Meeting for the Technology Review for the Environmental ImpactAssessment for the Coega Aluminium Smelter (9 June 2005).

Background information and update on the EIA for the proposed smelter

Record of Decision The Record of Decision (ROD) was issued on 20 December 2002, authorizing the proposeddevelopment. No appeals were received within the 45 day appeal period. Confirmation hassubsequently been received from the provincial Department of Economic Affairs Environment andTourism (DEAE&T) that the ROD has been upheld. The ROD is available at the CSIR’s website for theEIA at http://smelter.csir.co.za.

Environmental Management Programme Early in 2003, CSIR prepared an Environmental Management Programme (EMP) Framework reportfor the construction phase of the smelter. This report provides the framework for ensuring that therecommendations of the Environmental Impact Report and the conditions of the Record of Decisionare implemented. The draft report was presented to representatives of local, provincial and nationalgovernment in Port Elizabeth. It has subsequently been approved by DEAE&T and the final version isavailable on the CSIR’s website for the EIA at http://smelter.csir.co.za. The implementation of theConstruction EMP Framework will be a dynamic and ongoing process. It is therefore expected thatcertain components of the report will be updated periodically. It must be noted that the EMPFramework will need to be updated with the results of recent studies. Change from Pechiney to Alcan Late in 2003 the entire Pechiney group was acquired by Alcan, which resulted in a review by Alcan ofPechiney’s existing and proposed projects, including the Coega Aluminium Smelter. Alcan has sincemade a decision to proceed with a detailed feasibility study for the proposed Coega AluminiumSmelter project, but using AP35 technology rather than AP50 technology. This feasibility study is dueto be completed by the end of the third quarter of 2005. The AP35 smelting technology is similar tothat used at the Hillside aluminium smelter at Richards Bay and the Mozal aluminium smelter atMaputo, and differs from the AP50 technology in that the smelter would operate at 350 000 amperesrather than at 500 000 amperes of electricity. Alcan is considering constructing the smelter in the




Appendices, Page 6

rather than at 500 000 amperes of electricity. Alcan is considering constructing the smelter in theCoega Industrial Development Zone using two AP35 potlines rather than the initially proposed singleAP50 potline. The output of the AP35 smelter (between 660 000 and 720 000 tonnes per annum)would exceed that of the proposed AP50 smelter (approximately 485 000 tonnes per annum). Thedecision by Alcan to change to AP35 smelting technology requires that a technology review beundertaken, that will supplement the EIA conducted in 2002. Preparation of a Technology Review Discussions between Alcan and DEAE&T have established that Alcan is not expected to go throughanother full EIA process and obtain a new Record of Decision, given that a comprehensiveEnvironmental Impact Report (EIR) and ROD have already been prepared for the AP50 smelter on thesame site. Instead, Alcan can use the condition in the current ROD, which states that the proponentmust notify DEAE&T of any changes in technology and gain approval for these. The overall approachto the Technology Review is therefore to identify the changes in technology and design from the AP50to the AP35 proposal, determine where these might alter the predicted significance of theenvironmental impacts, and review the mitigation measures accordingly. This analysis is to bepresented to DEAE&T in the form of a Technology Review report. The draft report will be provided toDEAE&T and other authorities for their comment and input; and released for a 30 day public reviewperiod, during which time a public meeting will be held. Thereafter, depending on the findings of theTechnology Review, DEAE&T may issue an amended ROD for the AP35 technology, based on thecurrent ROD. It should also be noted that the duration of authorization provided in the 2002 ROD hasbeen extended to December 2005.

Notification of Technology Review Comment Period The draft Technology Review Report is available for public comment from the 3 June – 4 July 2005. The report can be viewed at the following locations or accessed on the following website: http://smelter.csir.co.za Nelson Mandela Metropole Libraries: Govan Mbeki, New Brighton, Motherwell, Zwide, Newton Park, Walmer, Chatty, West End, Despatch, Uitenhage, KwaNobubhle, Gelvandale, KwaMagxaki, KwaZakhele, Linton Grange, Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University Summerstrand as well as Technicon Campus and Vista University Cape Town: UCT Government Publications Department Comments on the draft Technology Review can be provided via the Public Meeting (see details below)or via feedback to Sandy Wren or Wandile Junundu at the above contact details. The closing date forcomments is 4 July 2005.

Public Meeting – 9 June 2005 As part of the public review process a Public Meeting will be held to which all I&APs are invited. ThePublic Meeting will include a presentation of the findings of the Technology Review and will provideI&APs the opportunity to raise questions and make comments. Present at the Public Meeting will be arepresentative from Alcan (project proponent) as well as the CSIR who are responsible for preparingthe Technology Review. Date: 9 June 2005 Time: 17h30 – 19h00 Venue: PE City Hall, Main Reception Hall




Appendices, Page 7

Should you require any additional information on the project please don't hesitate to contact SandyWren or Wandile Junundu at the above contact details. We look forward to your attendance at theMeeting and receiving your comments on the Draft Report. Yours sincerely SANDY WREN WANDILE JUNUNDU




Appendices, Page 8

The Herald, 2 June 2005




Appendices, Page 9

Die Burger, 2 June 2005




Appendices, Page 10

PO Box 27688 Greenacres 6057 120 Diaz Road Adcockvale, PE 6001 Phone 041-3748426 Fax 041-3732002 Email [email protected] Ck 97/32984/23 VAT 44601 68273 25 May 2005 TECHNOLOGY REVIEW: COEGA ALUMINIUM SMELTER Your organisation is invited to send ………… representatives to attend a community based sector meeting for the Technology Review Report for the proposed Coega Aluminium Smelter: Date: 9 June 2005 Time: 09h00 – 15h00 Venue: Coega Construction Village, Wells Estate (Note : venue later changed to Centenary Hall) Please confirm your attendance with Wandile Junundu before the 7 June 2005 indicating the names of participations from your organisation. Contact details above or on 083 4031910. FURTHER BACKGROUND INFORMATION A Record of Decision was issued on 20 December 2002 for the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) conducted in 2002 for the proposed Coega Aluminium Smelter. Late in 2003 the entire Pechiney group was acquired by Alcan, which resulted in a review by Alcan of Pechiney’s existing and proposed projects. Alcan has since made a decision to proceed with a feasibility study for a different version of the proposed Coega Aluminium Smelter project, using two AP35 potlines rather than the initially proposed single AP50 potline. Discussions between Alcan and DEAE&T have established that Alcan is not expected to go through another full EIA process and obtain a new Record of Decision (ROD), given that a comprehensive Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and ROD have already been prepared for the AP50 smelter on the same site. Instead, Alcan can use the condition in the current ROD, which states that the proponent must notify DEAE&T of any changes in technology and gain approval for these. The Technology Review report is now available for public comment from the 2 – 30 June 2005 and copies of the report can be viewed at the following locations or accessed on the following website: http://smelter.csir.co.za Nelson Mandela Metropole Libraries: Govan Mbeki Avenue, New Brighton, Motherwell, Zwide, Newton Park, Walmer, Chatty, West End, Despatch, Uitenhage, KwaNobubhle, Gelvandale, KwaMagxaki, KwaZakhele, Linton Grange, Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University Summerstrand as well as Techicon Campus and Vista University Cape Town: UCT Government Publications Department All comments on the report are to be submitted to the public participation consultants, details indicated below.




Appendices, Page 11

Public Meeting – 9 June 2005

As part of the public review process a Public Meeting will be held to which all I&APs are invited. The Public Meeting will include a presentation of the findings of the Technology Review and will provide I&APs the opportunity to raise questions and make comments. Present at the Public Meeting will be a representative from Alcan (project proponent) as well as the CSIR who are responsible for managing the Technology Review process. Date: 9 June 2005 Time: 17h30 – 19h00 Venue: PE City Hall, Main Reception Hall For further information contact Sandy Wren or Wandile Junundu, Public Process Consultants, PO Box 27688, Greenacres, 6057 phone 041-374 8426 fax 041-373 2002 email [email protected]




Appendices, Page 12

PO Box 27688 Greenacres 6057 120 Diaz Road Adcockvale, PE 6001 Phone 041-3748426 Fax 041-3732002 Email [email protected] Ck 97/32984/23 VAT 44601 68273 30 May 2005 Dear RE: INTEREST GROUP MEETING - TECHNOLOGY REVIEW OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT

ASSESSMENT FOR THE COEGA ALUMINIUM SMELTER As registered interested and affected parties (I&APs) on the database for the Coega Aluminium Smelter project this letter extends an invitation to you to attend an interest group meeting as follows: Date: 8 June 2005 Time: 09h00 – 13h00 Venue: PE City Hall Reception Hall Kindly confirm your attendance by no later than the 7 June 2005 with Sandy Wren or Wandile Junundu at the above contact details. In addition this letter also provides you with the following information:

• A summary of recent developments related to the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) conducted in 2002 for the proposed Coega Aluminium Smelter

• Notification of the public comment period for the Technology Review for the Environmental Impact Assessment for the Coega Aluminium Smelter (3 June – 4 July 2005)

• Invite to a Public Meeting for the Technology Review for the Environmental Impact Assessment for the Coega Aluminium Smelter (9 June 2005).

• Invite to a Sector Meeting, 8 June 2005, 09h00 – 13h00, PE City Hall Reception Hall

Background information and update on the EIA for the proposed smelter Record of Decision The Record of Decision (ROD) was issued on 20 December 2002, authorizing the proposed development. No appeals were received within the 45 day appeal period. Confirmation has subsequently been received from the provincial Department of Economic Affairs Environment and Tourism (DEAE&T) that the ROD has been upheld. The ROD is available at the CSIR’s website for the EIA at http://smelter.csir.co.za.

Environmental Management Programme Early in 2003, CSIR prepared an Environmental Management Programme (EMP) Framework report for the construction phase of the smelter. This report provides the framework for ensuring that the recommendations of the Environmental Impact Report and the conditions of the Record of Decision are implemented. The draft report was presented to representatives of local, provincial and national government in Port Elizabeth. It has subsequently been approved by DEAE&T and the final version is available on the CSIR’s website for the EIA at http://smelter.csir.co.za. The implementation of the Construction EMP Framework will be a dynamic and ongoing process. It is therefore expected that certain components of the report will be updated periodically. It must be noted that the EMP Framework will need to be updated with the results of recent studies.




Appendices, Page 13

Change from Pechiney to Alcan Late in 2003 the entire Pechiney group was acquired by Alcan, which resulted in a review by Alcan of Pechiney’s existing and proposed projects, including the Coega Aluminium Smelter. Alcan has since made a decision to proceed with a detailed feasibility study for the proposed Coega Aluminium Smelter project, but using AP35 technology rather than AP50 technology. This feasibility study is due to be completed by the end of the third quarter of 2005. The AP35 smelting technology is similar to that used at the Hillside aluminium smelter at Richards Bay and the Mozal aluminium smelter at Maputo, and differs from the AP50 technology in that the smelter would operate at 350 000 amperes rather than at 500 000 amperes of electricity. Alcan is considering constructing the smelter in the Coega Industrial Development Zone using two AP35 potlines rather than the initially proposed single AP50 potline. The output of the AP35 smelter (between 660 000 and 720 000 tonnes per annum) would exceed that of the proposed AP50 smelter (approximately 485 000 tonnes per annum). The decision by Alcan to change to AP35 smelting technology requires that a technology review be undertaken, that will supplement the EIA conducted in 2002. Preparation of a Technology Review Discussions between Alcan and DEAE&T have established that Alcan is not expected to go through another full EIA process and obtain a new Record of Decision, given that a comprehensive Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and ROD have already been prepared for the AP50 smelter on the same site. Instead, Alcan can use the condition in the current ROD, which states that the proponent must notify DEAE&T of any changes in technology and gain approval for these. The overall approach to the Technology Review is therefore to identify the changes in technology and design from the AP50 to the AP35 proposal, determine where these might alter the predicted significance of the environmental impacts, and review the mitigation measures accordingly. This analysis is to be presented to DEAE&T in the form of a Technology Review report. The draft report will be provided to DEAE&T and other authorities for their comment and input; and released for a 30 day public review period, during which time a public meeting will be held. Thereafter, depending on the findings of the Technology Review, DEAE&T may issue an amended ROD for the AP35 technology, based on the current ROD. It should also be noted that the duration of authorization provided in the 2002 ROD has been extended to December 2005.

Notification of Technology Review Comment Period The draft Technology Review Report is available for public comment from the 3 June – 4 July 2005. The report can be viewed at the following locations or accessed on the following website: http://smelter.csir.co.za Nelson Mandela Metropole Libraries: Govan Mbeki, New Brighton, Motherwell, Zwide, Newton Park, Walmer, Chatty, West End, Despatch, Uitenhage, KwaNobubhle, Gelvandale, KwaMagxaki, KwaZakhele, Linton Grange, Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University Summerstrand as well as Technicon Campus and Vista University Cape Town: UCT Government Publications Department Comments on the draft Technology Review can be provided via the Public Meeting (see details below) or via feedback to Sandy Wren or Wandile Junundu at the above contact details. The closing date for comments is 4 July 2005.




Appendices, Page 14

Public Meeting – 9 June 2005

As part of the public review process a Public Meeting will be held to which all I&APs are invited. The Public Meeting will include a presentation of the findings of the Technology Review and will provide I&APs the opportunity to raise questions and make comments. Present at the Public Meeting will be a representative from Alcan (project proponent) as well as the CSIR who are responsible for preparing the Technology Review. Date and Time: 9 June 2005, 17h30 – 19h00 Venue: PE City Hall, Main Reception Hall Should you require any additional information on the project please don't hesitate to contact Sandy Wren or Wandile Junundu at the above contact details. We look forward to your attendance at the Meeting and receiving your comments on the Draft Report. Yours sincerely SANDY WREN WANDILE JUNUNDU




Appendices, Page 15

APPENDIX C:

Database of interested and affected parties

Complete list of I&APs registered on the database giving their name, organisation and level of involvement

I&APs invited to the environmental sector Focus Group Meeting




Appendices, Page 16

I&AP DATABASE

TITLE INIT FIRST NAME SURNAME ORGANISATION

Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr J Johan Smith 8CR Property Trust a

Mr P Peter Zenzile ACB a

Mr JH du Plessis Action Bolt a

Cllr J Julie Jordaan Addo a

Cllr H Henry Jantjies Addo/Sundays River a

Cllr J Jeremy Lose Addo/Sundays River a

Ms J Joy Rabotapi AEL a

Mr/Ms V Vuyani Gxalela Afican National Congress a

Mr D Donald McGillivray Afri Coast Engineers Pty Ltd a

a Mr/Ms M Jacobs Africa National Congress a

Mr/Ms SG Nogumpula African National Congress a

Mr V Vuyisile Aplain African National Congress a

Mr S Sandile Dobela African National Congress a

Ms N Nomthandazo Gibe African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Adams African National Congress a

Mr MP Patrick Antoni African National Congress a

Mr MW Monde April African National Congress a

Mr T Thembile April African National Congress a

Mr S Siphokazi August African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Bambiso African National Congress a

Mr E Elvis Bana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Misumzi Banana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms NI Bangani African National Congress a

Mr L Lindile Banzi African National Congress a

Mr NG Banzi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms LP Bara African National Congress a

Mr S Sekiwe Belu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Benelwa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Beni African National Congress a

Ms P Priscilla Binqela African National Congress a

Mr M Mathews Bisitti African National Congress a

Ms C Cynthia Blaauw African National Congress a

Mr G Godfrey Blaauw African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nombuyiselo Blaauw African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Blaauw African National Congress a

Mr M Mzwanele Blou African National Congress a

Mr J John Boltina African National Congress a

Mr M Michael Bolting African National Congress a

Mr/Ms ZW Zola Bonga African National Congress a

Mr/Ms FW Booi African National Congress a

Mr A Aaron Booysen African National Congress a Ms A Annie Borens African National Congress a

Ms C Charlotte Bouah African National Congress a Mr S Samuel Bouah African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Pumla Boyce African National Congress a

Mr Y Yoliswa Breakfast African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lindile Bunu African National Congress a

Mr N Buthelezi African National Congress a

Mr R Richmond Cacela African National Congress a

Mr M Monwabisi Cekiso African National Congress a Mr/Ms F Fuleka Classen African National Congress a

Mr Conrad African National Congress a

Mr C Christopher Cuba African National Congress a

Mr M Mabhuti Dano African National Congress a

Ms M Mandisa Davids African National Congress a

Mr/Ms MP Davids African National Congress a

Mr/Ms NP Dayile African National Congress a

Mr M Mfusi Dayimani African National Congress a

Ms F Florence De Vos African National Congress a Mr Z Zama De Vos African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Zola Didiza African National Congress a




Appendices, Page 17


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr N Didiza African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mcebisi Dloto African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Zolani Dondashe African National Congress a

Ms Z Zolelwa Dumbu African National Congress a

Mr N Duvalele African National Congress a

Ms A Alice Dwakaza African National Congress a

Mr S Simphiwe Dyantyi African National Congress a

Mr M Mlungisi Dyantyisi African National Congress a

Mr A Antonnie Elias African National Congress a

Mr D Dingaan Eric African National Congress a

Mr N Nombulelo Faas African National Congress a

Ms V Vuyelwa Fadana African National Congress a

Ms J Joyce Faku African National Congress a

Mr T Thando Faku African National Congress a

Mr N Nkosinye Fani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms F Fezeka Feni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms CV Feni African National Congress a

Ms N Nomhle Fezi African National Congress a

Ms L Linda Fibi African National Congress a

Mr B Ben Fihla African National Congress a Mr M Mzwandile Funde African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nomvuzo Funde African National Congress a

Mr E Elliot Gamade African National Congress a

Mr/Ms TT Gamtolo African National Congress a

Ms P Patricia Ganga African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Gangla African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thozama Gayi African National Congress a

Mr M Moses Gazi African National Congress a

Mr M Mxolisi Gcezengana African National Congress a

Mr V Vuyani Gcezengana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nomalungisa Gedze African National Congress a

Mr S September Genu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thandolinilethu Geza African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Monwabisi Gomomo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Ncamisa Gonana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms TR Gotyana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms VN Gqabi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Ntombomzi Gqobisa African National Congress a

Ms B Belinda Gqozo African National Congress a

Mr N Gulwa African National Congress a

Ms P Phumza Gunya African National Congress a Mr/Ms P Phumelelo Gwadela African National Congress a

Mr H Howard Gweka African National Congress a

Mr/Ms CP Gwija African National Congress a

Mr M Malusi Hadi African National Congress a

Mr S Siphokazi Hanabe African National Congress a Mr N Nicholas Handile African National Congress a

Mr M Mpumelelo Hani African National Congress a

Mr B Ben Hans African National Congress a

Ms N Netley Harris African National Congress a

Mr L Lungisa Hendricks African National Congress a

Ms M Maggie Hendriks African National Congress a

a Mr M Mark Hogan African National Congress a

Mr M Melisizwe Hoyi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nosikumbuzo Hoza African National Congress a

Mr JJ Human African National Congress a

Mr S Hungana African National Congress a

Mr A Aurian Isaacs African National Congress a Mr/Ms ME Isaacs African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lulamile Jack African National Congress a

Ms NJ Noncinci Jack African National Congress a

Ms D Dina Jacobs African National Congress a

Mr R Roberto Jacobs African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Monwabisi January African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Jawila African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nelson Jelwane African National Congress a




Appendices, Page 18


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr V Vuyani Jim African National Congress a Mr L Lulama Jobela African National Congress a

Mr T Thembinkosi Johnson African National Congress a

Mr W Washington Jokani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Joni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nomasango Joxo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Busisiwe Jozela African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Sphiwo July African National Congress a

Ms T Thembelina Jwambi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Noyenayena Kanzi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms MS Kapayi African National Congress a

Mr T Temba Kate African National Congress a

Ms P Priscilla Kayser African National Congress a

Ms J Joyce Kepe African National Congress a

Mr T Thembisa Ketse African National Congress a

Mr N Nondumiso Ketye African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Noluthando Khame African National Congress a

Mr M Mboneli Khobo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mongezi Khohlakala African National Congress a

Mr/Ms EN Klaas African National Congress a

Ms M Monica Klassen African National Congress a

Mr N Koba African National Congress a

Mr B Bonani Kobo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lebisile Koliti African National Congress a

Mr/Ms H Koliti African National Congress a

Mr M Koliti African National Congress a

Mr/Ms SC Kolosa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thembisa Kom African National Congress a

Ms M Mandisa Kona African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nomasomi Koom African National Congress a

Mr T Thandoza Koya African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Krweda African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Melikhaya Kuba African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lindelwa Kula African National Congress a

Mr/Ms TM Kula African National Congress a

Mr/Ms NE Ntsikelelo Kulani African National Congress a

Mr K Kulati African National Congress a

Mr F Funzile Kume African National Congress a Mr/Ms F Kwanini African National Congress a

Mr M Mike Kwenaite African National Congress a Mr M Mazwi Lama African National Congress a

Mr A Andile Lamani African National Congress a

Mr M Mkhulti Langbooi African National Congress a Mr C Colin Lawu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms K Kholisi Letom African National Congress a

Mr M Mncedisi Leve African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Lobese African National Congress a

Mr B Bongani Lombo African National Congress a

Mr A Alfred Longo African National Congress a

Ms M Mantombi Lose African National Congress a

Mr M Mthobeli Lovis African National Congress a

Mr M Monde Lubambo African National Congress a

Mr M Mongezi Lumka African National Congress a

Mr M Monwabisi Lupondwana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mabulu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mabulu African National Congress a

Ms N Nomaxabiso Mabunzi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nokupumla Macaleni African National Congress a

Mr MJ Madakana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mboneleli Made African National Congress a

Mr/Ms W Made African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nontobeko Madika African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Noxolo Madikane African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Noxolo Madikane African National Congress a

Mr T Tembisa Madlanu African National Congress a

Mr T Thobile Madlingozi African National Congress a

a




Appendices, Page 19


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr/Ms M Mncedi Madonci African National Congress a

Mr A Apolosi Maepe African National Congress a Mr T Thobile Mafani African National Congress a

Mr K Magcotsho African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Magilane African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nondumiso Magqala African National Congress a

Ms S Sakhiwo Mahabe African National Congress a

Mr M Mzukisi Mahlaba African National Congress a

Mr GV Mahote African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Buyile Majali African National Congress a

Mr T Thembe Majika African National Congress a

Mr/Ms GN Majola African National Congress a

Mr M Mlangisi Makama African National Congress a

Mr K Kenneth Makana African National Congress a

Mr N Makeleni African National Congress a

Mr C Charles Makgatho African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Makiki African National Congress a

Mr S Silumko Makinana African National Congress a

Ms P Phumla Makoki African National Congress a

Mr C Chris Makoni African National Congress a

Ms K Kholeka Mali African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Xolelwa Mali African National Congress a

Mr A Akhono Mangali African National Congress a

Mr/Ms K Khanyiswa Mangesi African National Congress a

Ms T Thobeko Manini African National Congress a

Mr ME Mkhongozeli Mankahla African National Congress a

a Ms V Veronica Manxanga African National Congress a

Mr L Manyakanyaka African National Congress a

Mr M Mac Manzana African National Congress a

Mr G Griffiths Maqolo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nomonde Maranjosa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Sibokasi Maranjosa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms GI Innocent Marthinus African National Congress a

a Mr/Ms N Nomakathini Masala African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Masitshana African National Congress a

Ms N Nosipho Maswana African National Congress a

Mr E Elijah Matabese African National Congress a

Mr/Ms KC Mataka African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Philiswa Matanse African National Congress a

Mr V Vuyisile Matebese African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Vuyani Mateto African National Congress a

Mr B Mathenjiwa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nompumelelo Mathulu African National Congress a

Ms F Florence Matiwane African National Congress a

Mr M Mzuvukile Matomela African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Matomela African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Phumzile Matroos African National Congress a Mr M Mzolisi Matshisi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Sicelo Matshisi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Matshisi African National Congress a

Mr E Eric Mavakhala African National Congress a Ms P Phumela Mavata African National Congress a

Mr T Temba Maweni African National Congress a

Ms W Winnie Maxhela African National Congress a

Mr/Ms LF Mazantsi African National Congress a

Ms N Nombulelo Mazibuko African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Sikhumbuzo Mazondiva African National Congress a

Mr N Mbanga African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Baba Mbele African national Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nokuzola Mbengashe African National Congress a

Mr G Gege Mbikanye African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mbomba African National Congress a

Mr W Welcome Mbotyi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Noluthando Mboyi African National Congress a

Ms N Nomonde Mboyi African National Congress a

Mr S Sandile Mbunyuza African National Congress a




Appendices, Page 20


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr M Madoda Mbuqu African National Congress a

Mr M Mbuqu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lindiwe Mbusi African National Congress a

Mr Z Mbuzi African National Congress a

Mr N Non Mc Carthy African National Congress a Ms L Louisa Mckonie African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Zalisile Mdayi African National Congress a

Mr V Victor Mditshwa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Mdleleni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Xolani Mdliva African National Congress a

Mr O Orsmond Mdoda African National Congress a

Mr P Phumzile Mdunyelwa African National Congress a

Mr M Mzwandile Memani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thando Mengu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms D Dikeledi Menong African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Themisile Mens African National Congress a

Mr J Justice Mente African National Congress a

Mr C Chris Menzi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Periyane Mfengu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Y Yoleka Mfo African National Congress a

Ms M Mimmie Mfuduka African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Skhumbo Mfunda African National Congress a

Mr T Thozamile Mgimza African National Congress a

Mr S Saddam Mgoantashe African National Congress a

Mr T Mgoqi African National Congress a

Mr B Bongani Mguca African National Congress a

Mr O Oscar Mgwanza African National Congress a

Mr L Lungisa Mgwebi African National Congress a

Mr T Mhlahlo African National Congress a

Mr S Sipho Mjadu African National Congress a

Mr M Mzwandile Mjikolo African National Congress a

Ms Y Yoliswa Mjuza African National Congress a

Ms B Barbara Mkalali African National Congress a

Mr T Thembinkosi Mkalipi African National Congress a

Ms B Buyiselwa Mkavu African National Congress a

Mr T Thandisile Mkhathali African National Congress a

Mr O Owen Mkhetshana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thembisa Mkonto African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mkoto African National Congress a

Ms M Margaret Mkubuwa African National Congress a

Mr Z Zandisile Mkunyane African National Congress a

Mr M Mncedisi Mkweta African National Congress a

Mr B Bantu Mlakalaka African National Congress a

Mr W Walter Mlalandle African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Xolelwa Mlanjana African National Congress a

Mrs Mlolomba African National Congress a

Mr V Vuyo Mntushe African National Congress a

Mr Mnyamezeli African National Congress a

Ms M Mandisa Mnyani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mthetheleli Mongwele African National Congress a

Mr N Nyanisile Moni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Vayisile Mphali African National Congress a

Ms L Lindelwa Mpohla African National Congress a

Mr S Siphelo Mqoma African National Congress a

Mr/Ms SC Mqulwana African National Congress a

Mr T Temba Msayi African National Congress a

Ms S Sylvia Msila African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nkosana Msitshana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Y Yoliswa Mtabazi African National Congress a

Mr L Lizo Mtana African National Congress a Mr T Themba Mtati African National Congress a

Mr/MS M Mthetho Mtinjama African National Congress a

Ms L Linda Mtywaru African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mzingisi Musa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nzimeni Mwaculi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Zoleka Mxoli African National Congress a




Appendices, Page 21


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr/Ms MW Mxosa African National Congress a

Mr S Stanley Mzazela African National Congress a

Mr P Mzizi African National Congress a

Ms M Mary Nango African National Congress a

Mr M Macdonald Ncamiso African National Congress a

Ms E Esther Ncarashe African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Made Ncedo African national Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nqabile Ncetezo African National Congress a

Mrs KB Ncipa African National Congress a

Ms A Amanda Nciza African National Congress a

Mr S Samson Ncobo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Zomele Ndesi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thandiwe Ndevu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nompumelelo Ndinisa African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Pumla Ndinqeye African National Congress a

Mr/Ms G Giyose Ndiphiwe African National Congress a

Ms P Patricia Ndlovu African National Congress a

Mr P Phiwe Ndlumbini African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mbuzeli Ndongeni African National Congress a

Mr N Ndwayana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Ndyaneli African National Congress a

Ms X Xoliswa Ndzima African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Stalin Ngalo African National Congress a

Mr M Mzoxolo Ngapi African National Congress a Mr S Sipho Ngcaba African National Congress a

Mr/Ms JW Ngcivana African National Congress a

Ms E Evelyn Ngcobo African National Congress a

Mr T Thembani Ngcume African National Congress a

Mr B Boy Nge African National Congress a Mr/Ms GM Ngele African National Congress a

Mr V Vuyani Ngibe African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thozamile Nginza African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lulama Ngqamfana African National Congress a

Mr D Dorcas Ngqeshe African National Congress a

Mr S Sizwe Ngqezana African National Congress a

Mr MW Ngwane African National Congress a

Mr D Didima Ngxangxeni African National Congress a

Mr D Didima Ngxngxasi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mangaliso Ngxokwana African National Congress a

Mr M Monwabisi Ningi African National Congress a Mr/Ms S Nkebe African National Congress a

Mr M Mzoli Nkewu African National congress a

Mr S Simphiwe Nkohla African National Congress a

Mr P Pakamile Nkonjane African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nkosi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms NP Nkwali African National Congress a

Mr P Phathibandla Nogaya African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nika Noloyiso African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Nolutshungu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Q Quluba Nomamfene African National congress a

Mr/Ms S Sonjica Nonceba African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thembakazi Nondzube African National Congress a

Mr B Benson Nongubo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms NV Nonimba African National Congress a

Mr E Elias Noruka African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Vumile Noyila African National congress a

Mr/Ms N Ntuthuzelo Nqandu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nuyisile Nqikashe African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mbuyiselo Nqwata African National Congress a

Mr/Ms K Kholekile Ntamo African National Congress a

Ms M Maureen Ntamo African National Congress a

Mr L Lulamo Ntando African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lindiswa Ntantiso African National Congress a

Mr K Ntlonze African National Congress a

Ms X Xolisw Ntshali African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Ntutwana African National Congress a




Appendices, Page 22


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr M Mzimasi Nyamakazi African National Congress a

Mr LK Nyamakazi African National Congress a

Mr M Nyamakazi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms MA Nyati African National Congress a

Mr L Lungiswa Nyawe African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mzikayise Nyoka African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nosebenzile Nyoka African National Congress a

Mr D Deon Nzenza African National Congress a Mr N Nokanyo Odolo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms JN Odolo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Linda Pandle African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Pandle African National Congress a

Ms P Phumla Panga African National Congress a

Mr N Paul African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Pepese African National Congress a

Mr/Ms L Lungelwa Pepeto African National Congress a

Ms J Joyce Peta African National Congress a

Mr/Ms S Sandiswa Peta African National Congress a

Mr/Ms NM Peteni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms A Aaron Pieter African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nomalungelo Pieter African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nontsikelelo Plaatjie African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Phindile Qebe African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Qekema African National Congress a

Mr N Qoni African National Congress a

Ms N Nomthandazo Qoshani African National Congress a

Ms N Nomamfene Quluba African National Congress a

Mr L Lizo Qunta African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Radasi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Vukile Rala African National Congress a

Mr T Thozama Ranisi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Siyabulela Rawula African National Congress a

Ms M Maryna Rayners African National Congress a

Mr S Siphiwo Royi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Xolisile Sakube African National Congress a

Mr/Ms E Scheepers African National Congress a

Mr M Mnoneleli Scritch African National Congress a

Ms Z Zoliswa Scritch African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Seeland African National Congress a

Mr B Bongani Seti African National Congress a

Ms V Veronica Seyisi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mpumelelo Shawuza African National Congress a

Mr/Ms TC Shumpa African National Congress a

Ms M Mabel Shungu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Mxolisi Sibugashe African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Xolani Sifani African National Congress a

Mr S Simon Sihoyaya African National Congress a

Mr M Mike Sikani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thuleka Silayi African National Congress a

Mr M Marshall Silinga African National Congress a

Mr/Ms NE Sinayida African National Congress a

Mr F Fikile Siphango African National Congress a

Mr M Mncedisi Siswana African National Congress a

Mr M Mzukisi Sitoto African National Congress a Mr/Ms N Nolufete Sizani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Vuyeka Sizani African National congress a

Mr NE Eric Skepe African National Congress a

Ms E Ethel Skeyiya African National Congress a Mr/Ms S Skosana African National Congress a

Mr M Mkhuseli Skweyi African National Congress a Mr/Ms Z Zoleka Smandla African National Congress a

Mr S Sidewel Sobantu African National Congress a

Ms J Julia Sokale African National Congress a

Mr M Mkhululi Sokhiya African National Congress a

Mr/Ms DM Solomon African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Solomon African National Congress a




Appendices, Page 23


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr/Ms Z Zukiswa Somngcuka African National Congress a

Mr Z Zingisa Sonjica African National Congress a

Ms B Bukelwa Sonti African National Congress a

Mr W Wellington Sonti African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thandiwe Sota African National Congress a

Mr A Andile Sowazi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Zandisile Speelman African National Congress a

Ms E Elizabeth Stevens African National Congress a

Mr Z Zamani Stimele African National Congress a

Mr V Vuyo Tambo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms J Jacky Tana African National Congress a

Mr/Ms DN Tanda African National Congress a

Mr/Ms G Gwadela Temba African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Tempi African National Congress a

Mr/Ms B Thanduxolo African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nikelwa Tose African National Congress a

Mr/Ms ME Tose African National Congress a

Mr L Lindelwa Tshakweni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms VN Tshetsha African National Congress a

Mr M Mpumezo Tshikila African National Congress a

Mr/Ms V Velile Tshitsha African National Congress a

Mr M Mthetho Tusheni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms JV Tutu African National Congress a

Mr/Ms D Twalingca African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Xolani Vaaltyn African National Congress a

Mr D Daniel Van Roodt African National Congress a

Mr H Henry Van Wyk African National Congress a

Mr M Mlugsi Vanda African National Congress a

Mr B Buyisile Vani African National Congress a

a Mr/Ms SN Vena African National Congress a

Mr EP Vermaak African National Congress a

Mr T Themba Vizinto African National Congress a

Ms J Joyce Vukemini African National Congress a

Mr K Khaya Vusani African National Congress a

Mr T Thanduxelo Vusani African National Congress a

Mr S Soul Wanty African National Congress a

Mr M Mthobeli Watani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nolumanyano Webb African National Congress a

Mr R Richard Wellington African National Congress a

Mr H Henderson Williams African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Phindani Williams African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Malchosi Xantii African National Congress a

Ms P Pindile Xinwa African National Congress a Mr H Hatman Xola African National Congress a

Mr/Ms Z Zolole Xola African National Congress a

Mr K Klaas Xolani African National Congress a

Mr M Mdliva Xolani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms X Xolile Yako African National Congress a

Ms N Nomzamo Yatani African National Congress a

Mr M Mlungisi Yoli African National Congress a

Mr N Nombulelo Yoli African National Congress a

Mr E Elvis Zenza African National Congress a Mr S Solomzi Zibula African National Congress a

Ms NC Constance Zinto African National Congress a

Mr/Ms P Pheliswa Zinzile African National Congress a

Mr F Fezeka Zitho African National Congress a

Mr/Ms T Thoblie Zondani African National Congress a

Mr/Ms TE Zonke African National Congress a

Mr/Ms N Nqabakazi Zuma African National Congress a

Mr N Normen Zwelandile African National Congress a

Ms L Liziwe Zweni African National Congress a

Mr/Ms M Blaauw African National Congress - Despatch a

Mr/Ms N Bana African National Congress - Langa Civil Society a

Mr M Mzamo Bavuma African National Congress - New Brighton a

Mr/Ms W Welle April African National Congress - Uitenhage a

Ms X Xoliswa Nxoti African National Congress Women's League a




Appendices, Page 24


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr M Monde Duda African National Congress - Youth League a

Mr Z Zamkele Apolisi African National Congress Addo a

Cllr T Thobile Lawu African National Congress Alliance a

Mr J James Maledu African National Congress Branch Coega a

Mr/Ms M Bisu African National Congress -Despatch a

Mr J Makgato African National Congress MPL a

Ms N Nomzi Njongi African National Congress Ward Committee a

Ms Z Zoleka Mtwalo African National Congress Women a

Mrs N Nozimasile Dladla African National Congress Women's League a

a Mr/Ms B Buyiswa Dondashe African National Congress Women's League a

Mrs N Joni African National Congress Women's League a

Mrs TS Klaas African National Congress Women's League a

Ms N Kula African National Congress Women's League a

Mrs Mabele African National Congress Women's League a

Mr/Ms MS Madwara African National Congress Women's League a

Ms B Boneka Mahlahla African National Congress Women's League a

Ms N Nellie Mashicila African National Congress Women's League a

Mr/Ms N Nomhle Matiso African National Congress Women's League a

Ms N Nomzamo Mazondwa African National Congress Women's League a

Mr/Ms N Nomuyise Memani African National Congress Women's League a

Ms N Ndzenza African National Congress Women's League a

Ms Y Yoliswa Ngqiqhi African National Congress Women's League a

Ms V Vuyokazi Tshaka African National Congress Women's League a

Mr/Ms N Nomhle Vaaltein African National Congress Women's League a

Mr/Ms R Rute Xola African National Congress Women's League a

Ms N Nontobeko Zaze African National Congress Women's League a

Mr/Ms T Benelwa African National Congress Youth League a

Mr M Mandla Blaauw African National Congress Youth League a

Mr M Makhi Feni African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms S Sebenzile Fihlani African National Congress Youth League a

Mr L Gaska African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms V Vuyokazi Jacobs African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms L Lindiwe Jafta African National Congress Youth League a

a Mr/Ms S Sizakele Lolonga African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms X Xoliswa Lubengo African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms T Tonityi Madakana African National Congress Youth League a

Mr S Sivive Madela African National Congress Youth League a

Ms X Xola Madela African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms M Mahlakahlaka African National Congress Youth League a

Mr X Xolani Mazitshana African National Congress Youth League a

Mr M Mvuzo Mbelekane African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms A Aleka Milanzi African National Congress Youth League a

a Mr T Temba Milanzi African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms JM Mooi African National Congress Youth League a

Mr L Ndayo African National congress Youth League a

Mr V Vusumi Ndevu African National Congress Youth League a

Mr X Xola Ngcangca African National Congress Youth League a

Mr A Andile Nkatsha African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms N Nkosana Ntantiso African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms MT Semele African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms Z Zalisile September African National Congress Youth League a

a Mr/Ms B Buyelwa Skepu African National Congress Youth League a

Ms M Tsotsi African National Congress Youth League a

Mr V Vuyisile Vena African National Congress Youth League a

Mr/Ms T Tembisile Xholla African National Congress Youth League a

Mr M Marx Gerhard Albany Museum a

Dr T Tony Paterson Aluminium Federation of Southern Africa a

Mr C Clive Niven Amanzi Packhouse a

Ms N Nomajama Benya African National Congress a

a Mr/Ms ZA Blouw African National Congress a

a Mr/Ms X Dyalivane African National Congress a

a Mr M Mlungisi Dyantyisi African National Congress a

a Mr/Ms V Gogodla African National Congress a

a Mr C Claude Jantjies African National Congress a

a Ms S Sibongile Jonas African National Congress a

a Mr S Siyabulela Kolosa African National Congress a

a




Appendices, Page 25


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr M Mbuyiselo Koni African National Congress a

a Ms Z Zanele Madyosi African National Congress a

a Mr/Ms NS Magopeni African National Congress a

a Mr M Mnikeli Mapisa African National Congress a

a Ms F Fundiswa Mbane African National Congress a

a Mr K Kolisile Mde African National Congress a

a Mr/Ms N Ncedisa Menisi African National Congress a

a Ms L Lawukazi Mlambo African National Congress a

a Mr P Peace Mlindi African National Congress a

a Mr V Mongo African National Congress a

a Mr B Banzi Msutu African National Congress a

a Ms T Thandiswa NonTshinga African National Congress a

a Mr M Monde Nyushu African National Congress a

a Ms S Siphokazi Tiba African National Congress a

a Ms N Ntombekhaya Tshap African National Congress a

a Ms N Nomthandazo Vakala African National Congress a

a Ms L Linda Zondani African National Congress a

a Mr M Mzwandile Hote ANC Ward 38 a Mr M Mmeli Kondile ANC Ward 38 a Mr/Ms N Noludwe Qupe ANC ward 41 a Mr F Feziwe Sibeko ANC Ward 41 a Mr M Mtseyisi Seyisi ANC Ward 46 a Mr D Daniez Songwiqi ANC Ward 46 a Mr/Ms M Maritza Johannes ANC Ward 47 a

a Ms L Lynn Oliphant ANC Ward 47 a

a Mr L Loyiso Nduku ANC Ward 52 a Mr X Xolisa Puwana African National Congress Youth League a

a Ms P Prince Baka African National Congress Youth League a

a Ms P Portia Dladla African National Congress Youth League a

a Ms N Ntombekhaya Lungu African National Congress Youth League a

a Ms L Lindelwa Menziwa African National Congress Youth League a

a Ms N Nomthandazo Phillip African National Congress Youth League a

a Ms T Tulisa Tangweni African National Congress Youth League a

a Ms T Thembisa Williams African National Congress Youth League a

a Mr J Joel Swartz ANCYL Ward 43 a Mr A Rathbone Anti Waste a

Mr A Anton Bok Anton Bok & Associates cc. a

The Manager Apprised Agriculture (PTY) Ltd a

Mrs Davids Arcadia School a

Mr/Ms D Argyrakis Argyrakis & Associates a

Mrs P Pat Southwood Aselon a

Mr J John Balchin Atlas Plant Hire a

Mr/Ms X Xolani Gqirana Azanian People's Organisation a

Ms C Carel Swart Bateman a

Mr W Wayne Light Billiton Aluminium Projects a

Mr D David Allan Bird Life SA a

Mr/Ms W Wikkie Burger BKB a

Mr L Les Bucwa Black Management Forum a

Mr L Kilian Blue Circle/La Farge a

Mr A Alex Blacklaws Bluewater Bay Ratepayers a

Mr N Nicholas Maweni BMF - Coega a

Ms K Karen Kueck Bohlweki Environmental a

Mr G Gavin Fischer Bopite Engineering Geologists cc. a

Mr N Bakker Bosho Steel (Ballast Nedham) a

Mr/Ms J Burden Burden Consultants a

Mr P Peter Gilbert Bureau of Industrial Liaison a

Mr C Chris Albertyn C&M Consulting Engineers a

Mr/Ms F Janse van Rensburg C&M Consulting Engineers a

Mr D Darrell Baily Cacadu District Council a

Dr Chabula Cacadu District Council a

Mr S Simo Hopo Cacadu District Council a

Mr D Langman Cacadu District Council a

Ms K Kholeka Mntwapi Cacadu District Municipality a

Mr/Ms E Saunders Cacadu District Municipality a

Mr/Ms P Whitebooi Cacadu District Municipality a

Mr DM Pillay Cacadu Municipality a




Appendices, Page 26


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr C Claude Bredell Cadbuild System a

Mr B Brad Du Plessis Cape Fastner Supplies a

Mr HJ Du Toit Cape Gate a

Mr T Theo Msingizane CAWU a

Mr K Kid Lentoor CEPPWAWU a

Mr S Stanley Mabote CEPPWAWU a

Mr S Sidwell Mapela CEPPWAWU a

Ms J Judy Matsha CEPPWAWU a

Mr S Similo Mereko CEPPWAWU a

Ms C Cynthia Mkoto CEPPWAWU a

Mr MA Mnyamezeli Ndabambi CEPPWAWU a

Mr G Godfrey Nelani CEPPWAWU a

Mr D David Nzanzeka CEPPWAWU a

Mr M Mbuyiselo Rewu CEPPWAWU a

Mr/Ms M Skosana CEPPWAWU a

Mr P Patrick Hill Cerebos a

Ms M Mimi Siwa CFS a

Mr/Ms N Metiwane CHW - TLC Office a

Ms M Mia Loonat Civil Society Forum a

Mr A Allan Nyoni Civil Society Forum a

Mr B Bongani Sitembu Civil Society Forum a

Mr/Ms D Dev Varma Civil Society Forum a

Mssrs P&T Peter & Tony Mote Coastal Livestock & Farming cc. a

Mr K Kelly Byrne Coega Development Corporation a

Mr T Themba Koza Coega Development Corporation a

Mr/Ms P Leese Coega Development Corporation a

Mr K Khwezi Tiya Coega Development Corporation a

Dr M Mike Cohen Community Environment Network a

Ms L Lerato Nkone Community Environment Network a

Mr/Ms N Njengele Nkumenbe Community Environment Network a

Mr/Ms N Nohle Tebete Community Environment Network a

Ms R Ruth Mkumatela Community Environmental Network a

Mr/Ms N Nohle Tabata Community Environmental Network a

Mr E Elliot Masewu Community Police Forum Paterson a

Mr Z Zanoxolo Wayile Congress of South African Trade Union a

Mr V Vusumzi Mabho Cosatu a

a Mr/Ms T Thobile Baba CPF - Khayamnandi a

Mr/Ms T Thembisa Ntamo Creche - Khayamnandi a

Mr/Ms SC Button CSIR a

Mr R Rob Hounsome CSIR a

Mr P Paul Lochner CSIR a

a Mr D Duma Maqxwalisa CSIR a

Ms F Frauke Munster CSIR a

Mr G Gregory Scott CSIR a

a Mr S Stuart Heather-Clark CSIR Environmentek a

Mr C Clive Sharwood Deloitte & Touche a

Mr R Royden Church Demag Clanes & Components a

aa Ms M Mirriam Billet Democratic Alliance a

Mr B Stephenson Democratic Alliance a

Proff SS Long Department of Civil Engineering, PE Technicon a

Mr A Andries Struwig Department of Economic Affairs, Environment and Tourism, Eastern Cape a

Mr S Stephen Hosking Department of Economics UPE a

Mr M Lloyd Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism a

Minister M Martinus Van Schalkwyk Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism a

Mr S Mahema Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Air Quality Management a

Mr R Ravi Pillay Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Air Quality Management a

Mr W Wynand Fourie Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Environmental Impact Management

a

Mr M Mark Gordan Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Environmental Impact Management

a

Mr K Kwanele Booi Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Marine and Coastal Management

a

Mr P Buthelezi Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Marine and Coastal Management

a

Mr K Kobus de Swardt Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Marine and Coastal Management

a

DR L Lynn Jackson Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Marine and Coastal Management

a




Appendices, Page 27


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr D Dennis Mostert Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Marine and Coastal Management

a

Mr Swart Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism: Marine and Coastal Management

a

The Director Department of Mineral and Energy a

Mrs M Cox Department of Water Affairs and Forestry a

Mr P Paul Herbst Department of Water Affairs and Forestry: Water Quality Management a

Mr A Andrew Lucas Department of Water Affairs and Forestry: Water Quality Management a

Mr T Theo Geldenhuys Department of Water Affairs and Forestry: Water Quantity a

Mr S Mullineux Department of Water Affairs and Forestry: Water Quantity a

Mr/Ms S Beer Department of Welfare a

Mr L Jam-Jam Department of Welfare a

Mr/Ms M Libala Department of Welfare a

Ms S Nell Department of Welfare a

Mr/Ms C Nokwe Department of Welfare a

Ms S Stephanie Paul Department of Welfare a

Mr S Sieg Schnetter Department of Welfare a

Mr M Mervyn September Department of Welfare a

Mr TK Toyiya Department of Welfare a

Mr K Koliswa Zondani Department of Welfare a

Mr/Ms CI Ingram Dept of Housing and Local Gov. a

Mr/Ms J.P Schmidt Dept of Housing and Local Gov. a

Mr/Ms L Msi Dept of Housing,Local Government and Traditional a

Ms R Rebecca Sims-Castley Dept of Zoology UPE a

Mr L Leon Els Dept. Economic Affairs, Environment & Tourism a

Mr D Stupart Dept. Housing & Local Government a

Mr J Jannie Van As Dept. Mineral & Energy Affairs a

Mr S Sam Couldridge Dept. of Water Affairs a

Mr/Ms N Nosipho Ntantiso Despatch a

Mr/Ms Y Yoliswa November Development Forum Uitenhage a

Mr/Ms G Saki Development Forum Uitenhage a

Mr M Tabata Diya Construction a

Mr A Le Roux Dun Roven Citrus a

Mr/Ms G Hendersen Eagle Freight a

Mr/Ms H Thomas Eagle Freight a

Ms A Annetjie Liebenberg East Cape Master Builders Association a

Mr J Jan George East Cape Tourism Board a

Mr B Brian Jackson East Cape Tourism Board a

Mr W Werner Illenberger Eastern Cape Clean Air Initiative a

a Mec E Enoch Godongwana Eastern Cape Province a

Mec. M Max Mamase Eastern Cape Province a

Mec. P Phumulo Masualle Eastern Cape Province a

Mec. G Gugile Nkwinti Eastern Cape Province a

Premier A Arnold Stofile Eastern Cape Province a

Mr L Luvuyo Ngxovu Easy Sector a

Mr K Kraby Mahlulo EC African Chamber of Commerce a

Mr CJ Cornelius Pietersen EC Agricultural Union a

Mr P Brett Patrick EC Wild Bird Society a

Mr/Ms K Headbush ECACOC a

Mr P Piet Titus ECACOC a

Ms XM Xoliswa Captain ECBA a

Mr FA Gojela ECBA a

Mr P Labithi ECBA a

Mr N Mangcangaza ECBA a

Mr M Mncedisi Mkhosana ECBA a

Mr K Mkwetshana ECBA a

Mr M Mbulelo Mzwanam ECBA a

Mr Z Zongezile Ndimba ECBA a

a Ms NA Agnes Silengile ECBA a

Mr P Philip De Souza Emanti Management a

a Mr M Mzi Ramba Emanti Management a

a Mr E Ferreira Enduleni Estates a

Mr/Ms X Xolani Tiem Enviro Boosters a

Mr/Ms N Nomakhaya Dyakala Enviro Boosters - Addo Meeting a

Mr/Ms Z Zolile Bisa Envirobooster a

Mr J Joe Ntamekwana Environmental Justice Network Forum a

a Ms N Nosipho Belu Environmental Justice Network Forum a

a




Appendices, Page 28


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr R Robert Martindale Environmental Rights Association a

Mr S Stuart McMullan EnviroServ Waste Management (Pty) Ltd a

Mr RP O'Moore EP Agriculture Union a

Mr G Guy Rogers EP Herald a

Mr/Ms C van Rensburg Erica House a

Mr R Radali Takalani Eskom a

Mr F Frank v d Kooy Eskom a

Mr/Ms G Galekile Frans Ethiopia Orthodox Church - Khayamnandi a

Mrs VV Dulwana Ewemasenze - TLC office a

Mr C Christopher Ntayana Ewemasenze - TLC office a

Mr N Nathaniel Tanda Ewemasenze - TLC office a

Mr L Luyanda Thabatha Ewemasenze - TLC office a

Mr/Ms K Khuselwa Yona Ewemasenze - TLC office a

Mr R Roel van Oudheusden Exporters Club of SA, Eastern Cape a

Mr E Williams Ext 28 a

Mr J Jackie Heimann Factory Perseverence a

Mr Hill Fire & Emergency Services a

Mr M Mangena Fire & Emergency Services a

Mr J John De La Harpe First National Bank a

Mr M Mike Howell First National Bank a

Mr D Douglas Breakfast Food & Allied Workers Union a

Mr/Ms V Venus Mdlela Food & Allied Workers Union a

Mr S Sipho Memani Food & Allied Workers Union a

Mr H Hamilton Mlunguzi Food & Allied Workers Union a

Mr M Myebo Mpambani Food & Allied Workers Union a

Mr C Christopher Stokwe Food & Allied Workers Union a

Mr S Solomon Tshona Food & Allied Workers Union a

Mr G Gary Francis Franco Trading a

Dr P Peter Schwartz Friends of the Beachfront a

Ms C Carol Royle Gardner Investments (PTY) Ltd a

Ms N Nolita Mazim GBA a

Mr H Hennie Meiring Global Development & Consulting cc a

Mr S Sandile Ndema Govan Mbeki Forum a

Mr S Sithembiso Peter Gqebera Development Trust a

Mr W Wally Holmes Grass Master a

Mr MR Monde Grootboom Grootboom Construction, SANCO a

a Mr/Ms M Manele Williams Health & Welfare a

Mr/Ms N Nonthando Yoyo Health & Welfare - TLC Office a

Mr M Mervin Issacs Helenvale African National Congress a

Ms D Dorothy Claasen Helenvale Resource Centre a

Mr C De Keyser Hougham Park Oysters a

Mr R Rori Riordon Human Rights Trust a

Mr M Mfundo Mhlabeni ILDP - SBU UPE a

Mr S SA Fitchet IMATU a

Mr L Van der Westhuizen IMATU a

Mr J Johann Bester Industrial Development Corporation a

Mr E Etienne Roux Industrial Development Corporation a

Mr IP du Preez IP du Preez Eng Cont/ Ibhayi Eng Cont a

Mr MB Jolingana Ithuba a

Mr M Mlindi Dingele Ithuba Lethu a

Mr P Peter Nogqala Ithuba Lethu a

Mr M Michael Ntotha Ithuba Lethu a

Mr Benjamin Ithuba Lethu a

Mr/Ms N Nompumelelo Msutwana J & S labour Brokers (Uitenhage) a

Mr/Ms Z Zithobile Tsewu J & S labour Brokers (Uitenhage) a

Mr E Eric Dubb John Price Estates a

Mr J John Price John Price Estates. a

Mr P Peter Kantor Kantor Legal Services cc a

Mr/Ms M Nyoka Khayamnandi a

Mr W Willy Matebese Khayamnandi S Centre a

Mr C Charlie Menze Khayamnandi S Centre a

Mr/Ms M Mkuseli Calata KS Centre Khayamanadi a

a Mr/Ms M Mzwandile Puwana KS Centre Khayamanadi a

Mr A Barwood Lafarge SA a

Mr K Kevin Garner Lafarge SA a

Mr P Ndlwana Lafarge SA a




Appendices, Page 29


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr RC Rod Des-Fountain Lafarge SA (PTY) Ltd a

Mr JW Ferreira Lambson's Hire a

Mr A Arnold Mona Landowner a

Mr/Ms B Ndimba Langa Civil Society a

Mr C v d Berg Lawson's Hire a

Mr A Albertyn LC Consulting a

Mr G Gordon Lake LW Lake & Sons Tankatara a

Mr P Peter Lake LW Lake & Sons Tankatara a

Mr KS Lake LW Lake & Sons Tankatara a

Mr L Lake LW Lake & Sons Tankatara a

The Managing Director Marine Growers a

Mr N Norbert Klages Marine Mammal Institute a

Mr E Mbanga Mbanga Construction a

a Mr S Siphino Beja MCDF a

Ms B Bibian Allison Metroplan a

Mr N Ndaba Ndzombane Metroplan a

Mr C Vermaak Mimosa Farms a

Mr JA Johann Jorter Mining and Beneficiation SBU a

Mr S Sidima Siganga Ministry Environmental Affairs and Tourism a

Mr/Ms MJ McQuade MJ McQuade & Associates a

Mr G Milne MMK Architects a

Mr D Duncan McLean Moeller Electric a

Mr K Kolekile Moni Moni Builders a

Ms S Sherry Moorehouse Moorehouse Consulting a

Mr/Ms Z Zukiswa Busakwe Motherwell Tourism Forum a Ms F Funeka Matole Motherwell Tourism Forum a

a Mr S Sipho Ngcaba Motherwell Tourism Forum a Ms N Nandie Ngoqo Motherwell Tourism Forum a Mr/Ms N Nona Nongalo Motherwell Tourism Forum a Ms T Treasure Ntoto Motherwell Tourism Forum a Mr/Ms NJ Odolo Motherwell Tourism Forum a

a Mr X Xola Nodwele Motherwel Youth Development Forum a

a Mr M Shoba Motherwel Youth Development Forum a

Mr N Skeates N & N Services a

Mr/Ms V Blignaut N&V a

Mr/Ms BS Blignaut N&V Jenis a

Ms N Nomhle Sididi Nationa Education Health & Allied Workers Union a

Ms S Sophia Anthony National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr PM Patrick Calata National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms L Lungiswa Dick National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr/Ms TP Dingaan National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr M Mohammed Farrat National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr S Simphiwe Gwashu National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr A Andile Jack National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr V Vukile Kosana National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms M Muriel Macauley National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr M Mthunzi Magxwalisa National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr/Ms M Mina Mpepo National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr/Ms S Sibongile Mtati National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr L Lungile Mxube National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms N Nandipha Namba National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr L Lifukazi Ngwangu National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms N Nobengazi Nobebe National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr W Wesley Nyembana National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr/Ms NJ Poyo National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms E Eva Steyn National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms R Rosie Van Rooyen National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms N Nomonde Venfol National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Ms E Eugenia Zazini National Eduation Health & Alllied Workers Union a

Mr L Len Chandler National Ingrediant Suppliers a

Ms A Angela Pienaar National Union of Metal of SA a

Mr A Arie Burggraaf National Ports Authority a

Ms L Leticia Greyling National Ports Authority - Head Office JHB a

Mr D David Brown National Ports Authority of SA a

Mr S Sidney Chait National Ports Authority of SA a

Ms V Virginia Dunjwa National Ports Authority of SA a




Appendices, Page 30


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr S Govender National Ports Authority of SA a

Mr C Chris Matchett National Ports Authority of SA a

Mr/Ms S Mhlaluka National Ports Authority of SA a

Ms M Mandisa Mondi National Ports Authority of SA a

Mr T Thabo Ndlovu National Ports Authority of SA a

Ms T Thobeka Thamange National Ports Authority of SA a

Mr N Nick Van Amstel National Ports Authority of SA a

Mr N Nkolelo Bandeza National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr/Ms SN Barendse National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr N Nyameko Belewa National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr E Eugene Browers National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr D Douglas Cawe National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr T Toyer Felix National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr S Saziso Fete National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Ms H Heidi Fillies National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr D Dennis Goliath National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr A Andile July National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr J Johnson Klaas National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr E Elroy Lloyd National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr T Thabo Lupondwana National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr S Sam Majeke National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr/Ms X Malahla National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Ms J Julian Mapela National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr/Ms M Mphumzi Maqungo National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr/Ms Z Matsolo National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr P Patrick Mfecane National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr M Mpumelelo Mngini National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Ms E Eunice Molato National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr S Simphiwe Mqayi National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr M Mzwandile Msingizana National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr E Eric Mtana National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr P Phakamisa Mtati National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr O Oscar Mtshiselwa National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr S Sipho Mtwisha National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr K Kevin Mtyeku National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr M Mbuyiselo Ncotoyi National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr B Bongani Ngqiyaza National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr N Ndumiso Njikelana National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr X Xolani Nkwenkwezi National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Ms P Phumzile Nodongwe National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

a Mr XE Xolile Eric Nyameka National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr N Nceba Nyembana National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr M Michael Pillay National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr L Lawrence Sandi National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr G Gary Seale National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr N Nicolas Sotashe National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr Z Zama Speelman National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr M Mbulelo Vece National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr P Piet Verryne National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr Z Zokufa National Union of Metal Workers of SA a

Mr P Phillip Tsoaela NEBSU a

Mr/Ms R Van der Oudeheenden Nedcor a

Mr R Rod Van Oudhensden Nedcor a

Mr RD Basson Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr MW Mahlubi Biyana Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr ML Bungane Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr/Ms M Clingham Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr JT Cronje Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr M Dastile Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr F Fikile Desi Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mayor N Nceba Faku Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr Govoni Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr/Ms S Griesel Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr S Stanley Hote Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr LP Dipho Kondile-Mlonzi Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr R Kopo Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a




Appendices, Page 31


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Cllr M Martin Kuscus Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr A Annette Lovemore Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr AM Mamcotwa Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr/ms M Matabiele Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr A Mbewu Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Ms L Liz Mc Hugh Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr J Jonathan Mercer Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr E Eric Mgwanza Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr MZ Msiwa Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr MC Mtanga Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr T Thando Mtyapa Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr G Godfrey Murrell Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr B Balu Naran Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr M Ndube Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr M Mthetheleli Ngcete Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr CM Nombiba Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr BB Ntshona Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Dr C Pailman Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr G Graham Richards Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr C Clyde Scott Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Ms N Sihlwayi Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr A Smit Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr Steyn Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr S Sisa Tabata Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr MB Tokota Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Cllr E Elizabeth Trent Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr C Calvin Van Appel Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr N Walton Nelson Mandela Metro Municipality a

Mr The Chairperson New National Party a

Mr M Major Ticket Newhope Consulting a

Mr L Luvuyo Maveca Nicro a

Mr L Lizo Mtana NMMM - Uitenhage a

Mr M Odeyan NMMM - Uitenhage a

Mr MT Seyisi NMMM - Uitenhage a

Mr A Attie Pretorius NMMM CEO Despatch a

Dr P Paul Martin NMMM Environment Busineess Unit a

Mr A Nokolo Nokolo Builders a

Ms N Nozipho Sobhekwa Nokwindla Constr a

Mr/Ms N Nkosinam Makasi Nomatamsanqa P/School a

Mr NM Norman Myers Norman Myers Attorney & Notary a

Ms J Judy Hoggons Northern Areas Development Trust a

Ms P Primrose Madikizela NPA. PE a

a Mr Z Zibu Ndikinda NPA. PLZ a

a Mr B Bob Richards Nukakamma Canoe Trail a

Mr S Shakes Kondlo Office of the Premier, Eastern Cape Province a

Mr E Jokazi Okuselwandle Fishing a

Mr B Bruce Cook Outspan a

Mr S Simphiwe Huhu Pan African Congress a

Patensie Citrus a

Mr M Green PE Civil Society Forum a

Mr B Petros PE CS Forum a

Mr D Deon Claassen PE F&S a

Mr W Wally Bulbring PE Ratepayers Association a

Mr C Colin Trader PE Ratepayers Association (PERRA) a

Ms S Samantha Barnes PE Regional Chamber of Commerce a

Mr A Alfred Da Costa PE Regional Chamber of Commerce a

Mr K Keith Wattrus PE Tourism a

Cllr T Themba Mafana PE TRC & Coega a

Mr/Ms T Thando Juku PECSF a

Mr/Ms M Mfeka Sinethemba PECSF a

Mr M Marlon Gibbs PERCCI a

Ms A Stokes PETRC a

Mr M Mpumelelo Ditala POPCRU a

Mr K Klaas Titus POPCRU a

Mr MJ Malcolm Smale Port Elizabeth Museum a

Mr K Kerneels Grundlingh PPC a




Appendices, Page 32


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr A Minnaar PPC a

Mr C Colin Mitchell PPC a

Mr D Prinsloo PPC a

Ms N Naomi Williams PPC a

Ms N Noelene Jorgensen PPC Cement a

Mr P Pieter Van Dam PPC Cement a

Mr/Ms M Mzukusi Dayile PRDP a

Mr/Ms N Medlawu PRDP a

Mr D Deon Strydom Progressive Wire a

Ms/Mr J Rossouw Protea Place of Safety a

Ms M Maria Mbengashe Provincial Dept. of Environment Affairs a

Mr C Crosby Slatsha Rape Crisis - Khayamnandi a

Mr A Alan Southwood Ratepayers Association a

Mr F Keulder Rhodes University a

Mr J Johan Luiters Riverside Construction a

Mr P Phindile Rode Rode Builders a

Mr K Kobus Smit Ruco Projects a

Ms S Saphokazi Ata SA Communist Party a

a Mr M Mthetho Feni SA Communist Party a

a Mr L Lukhanyiso Hini SA Communist Party a

a Ms R Rachel Mgedezi SA Communist Party a

a Mr L Luyanda MoHLOLI SA Communist Party a

a Mr Z Zwelandile Mpolonswana SA Communist Party a

a Ms P Phumeza Mpushe SA Communist Party a

a Ms P Phanezwa Ndlendle SA Communist Party a

a Ms N Nophelo Nzunzu SA Communist Party a

a Mr W Wandile Situtu SA Communist Party a

a Ms H Hester Bosch SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Ms N Nita Goss SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Mr E Elvis Maseti SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Mr I Israel Mayinje SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Mr R Raymond Punana SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Ms A Angeline Rolo SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Ms S Sarah Smith SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Mr B Bonisani Tikise SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

a Mr M Mlungisi Zinco SA Clothing & Textile Workers Union a

Mr H Hedaayah Abdol SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr/Ms F Cacela SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Ms N Nomonde Cenga SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr R Ray Dici SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr/Ms VA Doro SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr M Mzukisi Lamani SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr G George Lukwe SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr T Thanduxolo Mtshukwana SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Ms N Nandipa Ntshinga SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr/Ms A Rala SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Mr/Ms TM Tshoko SA Democratic Teachers Union a

Ms B Bulelwa Matiwane SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Ms L Lungiswa Mbambaza SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Mr/Ms NS Mjijwa SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Mr M Mineka Mkhonjeni SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Mr M Mteteleli Mkoto SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Mr A Andile Nogaga SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Mr B Bongani Plaatjie SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Mr S Simo Rayi SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Ms C Cikizwa Vambe SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Ms L Lindelwa Zonyani SA Democratic Teacher's Union a

Mr N Norton Tennille SA Environment Project a

Mr S Sabelo Ndlebe SA Institute Medical Research a

Mr/Ms M Mewabantu Ciwadela SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr M Melumzi Fedana SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr V Jim SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr/Ms N Madubedube SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr N Mafani SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr A Andile Mahala SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr K Khawulezile Malalo SA Municipal Workers Union a




Appendices, Page 33


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr L Lex Menze SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr M Mzandile Nini SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr N Nomava Skweyiya SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr V Vusumzi Twani SA Municipal Workers Union a

Mr B Bishop Koli SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Kom SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr T Temba Kondile SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms GE Kosi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms L Lindile Kota SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms E Esther Kozi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr M Mlamu Krabie SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Mlungesi Lande SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms IW Lepela SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr/Ms Madida SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms J Madlingosi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr M Mhleli Mahlulo SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms L Majikela SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms L Lindiso Makinana SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nombulelo Makinana SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms NV Makotyana SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr A Aubrey Mali SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms P Princess Manakaza SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr N Manakaza SA National Civic Organisation a

Mrs M Mandela SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms MS Manxiwa SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nompumelelo Mapuma SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms L Luvuyo Maqakaza SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr A Alfred Martin SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr L Lunga Martins SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr TN Matebese SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms PN Matenjiwa SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Matros SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms E Matsaba SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr J Matsini SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr E Mayekiso SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms KM Mbengashe SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr K Mbuthumi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr T Mdoda SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr J James Mei SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms L Lillian Memani SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr T Thozamile Metula SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr/Ms M Mfecane SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nceba Mjakuca SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Mpendulo Mnweba SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms G Molutsi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr E Ernest Moyakhe SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr S Siphiwe Mpeqeko SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms DE Mrausi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mrs LC Msutu SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms G Mtshatsheni SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms B Ndabambi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mrs NR Ndinisa SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr S Sam Ndlaleni SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nokuzola Ndlebe SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr S Samson Ndunana SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr X Nelami SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Ngalonkulu SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Ngani SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms A Anna Ngaphe SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms E Ngcezula SA National Civic Organisation a

Mrs N Ngoma SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr S Samual Ngona SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr A Andile Ngoqo SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr/Ms S Simpie Ngqond SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms V Vuyelwa Ngqondi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr N Nondyebo Ngumbela SA National Civic Organisation a




Appendices, Page 34


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr/Ms S Skulu Nkombisa SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms M Molly Nobadula SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms D Dlanga Nomawisile SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr B Boy Nteto SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr/Ms SG Ntiwanamibi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms SR Ntlaki SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms K Kindness Ntoba SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr A Peter SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr A Amos Phillip SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr K Kelvin Pieterson SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Mqondisi Pinini SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms A Punani SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Mbuyiselo Rasmeni SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms M Miranda Sam SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr G George Sampson SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr S Sithando Shongwe SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr F Siga SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms EN Ethel Sikweyiya SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms M Mirriam Silwana SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr N Sinuka SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms S Sicelo Sitonga SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms S Siwisa SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms L Linda Skosana SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms Z Zithulele Smile SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr G General Sundu SA National Civic Organisation a

a Mr S Sizwe Sweli SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms H Hope Tala SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr M Mike Tofile SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nonkululeko Tola SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms T Tasneem Tolah SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms ZT Tshice SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr A Ayanda Tshingana SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms L Lindiwe Tuswa SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr N Ntise Vena SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms T Thembisa Williams SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr J Jan Witbooi SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms Z Zoleka Xali SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms Z Zandisile Xola SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms X Xolani Yali SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms E Elma Yawa SA National civic Organisation a

Mr D Dumile Zangani SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms H Zanzeka SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Mbuyiseli Zicwele SA National Civic Organisation a

Mr D Dumile Zingani SA National Civic Organisation a

Ms I Iris Vena SA National Civic Organisational a

Mr M Mxolisi Zozi SA National Civic Organisational a

Mr M Addomsi SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr S Styles Baatjies SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms MN Bana SA National Civics Organisation a

Ms M Margaret Befile SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr/Ms XC Bele SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms P Phindile Bisa SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Mbuyiseli Bobo SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr W Wesley Bongani SA National Civics Organisation a

Ms L Lungelwa Boyce SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr JP James Bozo SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr/Ms T Thozama Budaza SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr P Patrick Cacela SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr B Bruce Calata SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr J John Dama SA National Civics Organisation a

Mrs N Nombuyiselo Dambuza SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr N Dambuza SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr H Harry Daniels SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr C Cecil De Bruin SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nokuzola Dlamini SA National Civics Organisation a

Ms N Nomawisile Dlanga SA National Civics Organisation a




Appendices, Page 35


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Ms A Agnes Dyanti SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/MS S Dzeya SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms MN Fesi SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr XW Fundam SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr B Barry Gamble SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr P Geswindt SA National Civics Organisation a

Ms N Nomachule Gexa SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr P Phillip Geza SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nomonde Gotyana SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr R Roy Gotyi SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr T Thandikhaya Gqabi SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr S Sam Gqamand SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Monde Grootboom SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms G Gladys Hliso SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr L Lulama Jamjam SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr T Thomas Jantjies SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr A Anthony Johnson SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms T Thembekile Jonga SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms L Lindiwe Jusiwa SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms E Kakana SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Mr DM KamKam SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Malakhiwe Kamteni SA National Civics Organisation a

Ms L Linda Klaas SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr M Mxolisi Klaas SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr P Patrick Kobese SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms Z Zwelitsha Maji SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr M Malawi SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms M Mjadu Mzwandile SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr M Michael Nqikela SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms S Ntshalaba SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nontombi Vena SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr S Sidwell Xola SA National Civics Organisation a

Dr G Guy Castley SA National Parks a

Mr T Tuli de Beer SA Rail Commuter Corporation a

Mr CRP Hahn SA Rail Commuter Services a

Mr T Themba Kusana SA Textile & Clothing Workers Union a

Mr/Ms W.V Bontsi SA Transport Workers Union a

Mr T Thamasanqa Kutu SA Transport Workers Union a

Mr M Majenge SA Transport Workers Union a

Mr T Mxokozeli SA Transport Workers Union a

Mr H Sinama SA Transport Workers Union a

Mr R Rodney Van Heerden SA Transport Workers Union a

Mr B Brent Newman SAB Institute for Environmental & Coastal Mang. a

Mr/Ms I Warnock SAFCEC a

Mr M Marwan Al- Sharaa SANCO a

a Mr/Ms K Kiki Dyimi SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms N Nontsikelelo Gqogqo SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr S Simon Johnson SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr T Thembikile Jonva SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms NC Joseph SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms I Iris Kula SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms Z Zukiswa Mayekiso SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr S Stembiso Mbewana SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms N Nombeko Mkonjeni SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms B Beauty Mkuhlu SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr/Ms G Mmolutsi SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr D David Mnyamza SA National Civics Organisation Mr T Thembile Mnyumane SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr/Ms N Ngqungwana SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms T Thembisa Ntantiso SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr/Ms L Lyd Ntshalaba SA National Civics Organisation Mr L Leonard Sayster SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr/Ms N Nannie Schaap SA National Civics Organisation a

a Mr/Ms SL Shongue SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms N Nontutuzelo Sineli SA National Civics Organisation a

a Ms N Ntombizodwa Tshobo SA National Civics Organisation a

a




Appendices, Page 36


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr D David Vena SA National Civics Organisation a Mr/Ms T Manzi SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms N Nomtobeko Madikane SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr/Ms L Linda Mlomo SA National Civics Organisation a

Mr R Richard Jacobsen Sani Tech a

Mr E Evan Rumbelow Sani Tech a

Mr A Ayanda Sigwela SA National Parks a

a Mr Tait SBT Konstruksie a

Dr MH Mike Knight SA National Parks a

Mr X Xolani Gqamana SDS CC a

a Mr G George Maree SEEFF Properties a

Mr C Clive Van der Riet Self a

a Mr T Tony Dold Selmar Schonland Herbarium a

Mr M Marius Olivier Setplan a

Mr JR Sharwood Sharwoods a

Ms N Nancy Rudlin Simunye Enterprise a

Ms A Anita Smith Simunye Enterprises a

Ms A Damons Simunye Environment a

Ms M Maud Thalla Simunye Environment a

Ms P Phumla Gubayo Sol Plaatjies a

a Mr J James Tenana SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms Z Zuko Adem SA Communist Party a

Mr V Vuyani Befile SA Communist Party a

Mr N Niel Bentley SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms J Calvert SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms MM Ciki SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Clay SA Communist Party a

Mr S Sindile Cona SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms JA Conway SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Mntukanti Dlabathi SA Communist Party a

Mr K Kunase Dlala SA Communist Party a

Mr M Mazotsho Dukwe SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms P Dunjana SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms L Lindelwa Dunjwa SA Communist Party a

Mr F Frieslaar Elgin SA Communist Party a

Mr A Andile Elson SA Communist Party a

Mr M Mantoor Fillis SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms T Tamsanqa France SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms O Odwa Fumba SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms N Nonkululeko Funde SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms DT Grootboom SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms ME Hermans SA Communist Party a

Mr C Chris Jamda SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms EL Jinikwe SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms N Nkotili Kalvin SA Communist Party a

Mr M Mzwandile Kinana SA Communist Party a

Mr L Lungile Kolisi SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Kutta SA Communist Party a

Mr G George Lukwe SA Communist Party a

Mr T Thami Majadu SA Communist Party a

Mr C Cheeky Makasi SA Communist Party a

Mr MK Mkauleli Maleki SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Mapu SA Communist Party a

Mr M Monwabisi Matthews Soya SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms AC Mfunda SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms T Thembile Mkosi SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms S Simphiwe Mkunqwana SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms MR Mlonzi SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms L Mokonenyane SA Communist Party a

Mr D December Moyeni SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Mpofu SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Mrara SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms A Andile Mtanga SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms V Viola Mtongana SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms Mzwandile SA Communist Party a

Mr S Sabelo Ncxiiho SA Communist Party a




Appendices, Page 37


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr/Ms N Nkosomzi Ndongeni SA Communist Party a

Mr N Ngcongcobela SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms S Sabelo Ngxito SA Communist Party a

Mr W Wonga Nkala SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Mbulelo Nkolongo SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms L Luyanda Nqai SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms T Ntola SA Communist Party a

Mr TM Ntuntwana SA Communist Party a

Mr TJ Oliphant SA Communist Party a

Mr R Ronnie Prince SA Communist Party a

Mr Z Zamuxolo Quma SA Communist Party a

Mr C Christopher Rockman SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms T Rubusana SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms ND Sandi SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms J Sigcu SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms N Nkosazana Sobantu SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms S Siyabonga Soci SA Communist Party a

Mr N Sonkwala SA Communist Party a

Mr V Vuyani Soul SA Communist Party a

Ms N Nokuzola Swepu SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms Z Zilindile Tambo SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms MO Tambo SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms S Sebenzile Tikana SA Communist Party a

Mr G Grey Tinnie SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms VG Toto SA Communist Party a

Mr M Mthuthuzeli Tshana SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms MM Yiba SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms AK Zombe SA Communist Party a

Ms L Linda Ncaphayi SA Communist Party a

Mr/Ms M Ndweyane Soweto Clinic a

Mr T Tim Fox Spoornet a

Mr G Greg Jones SRCC. a

a Mr J John Exley St Croix Development Co. a

Mr S Shaun du Toit Steeldale a

Mr/Ms LR Bester Steeledale a

Mr J Johan Stumpf Sundays River Citrus Company a

Mr W Winton Gibbs Sundays River Citrus Company a

Cllr Siyani Sunday's River Municipality a

Mr Ralo Sunday's River Valley Municipality a

Ms J Janine Briggs Sundays River Valley Tourism a

a Mr/Ms M Muffy Miller Sundays River Valley Tourism a

a Mr W Roux Swartkoppen (Farm North of Coega) a

Mr PK Mbujoza Swartkops a

Mr D Grundlingh Swartkops River Rides a

Mr A Aubrey Adshade Zwartkops Trust a

a Mr R Roald Pearson Zwartkops Trust a

a Mr A N Rump Zwartkops Trust/WESSA a

Mr S Madolo T S Builders a

Mr F Francios Talbot Talbot & Talbot a

Ms J Jean Talbot Talbot + Talbot a

Tenebrosa Lodge (PTY) Ltd a

Dr G Graham Kerley Terrestrial Ecology Research Unit a

Dr A Andre Boshoff Terrestrial Ecology Research Unit UPE a

Mr W Warren Brooks Tomago Aluminium Company a

Mr M Mabhuti Gwaqu Tomie Building Constr a

Mr G Glenton De Kock Tourism Port Elizabeth a

Mr M Moki Cekisani Ubuntu a

a Ms A Abbey Collinson UCT Library, Government Publications a

Mr R Renier Meintjes Uitehage Town Council a

Mr A Majoka Uitenhage Community Based a

Mr H Schnetler Uitenhage Health a

Mr CV Annel Uitenhage LG a

Mr P Nel Uitenhage TTD a

Mr SK Sihlahla Unemployed Workers Union a

Mr S Sisa Mafika Unemployed Workers Union of SA a

Mr/Ms M Njokweni Unemployed Workers Union of SA a




Appendices, Page 38


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr/Ms N Nkombisa Unemployed Workers Union of SA a

Mr/Ms C Cleanet Qanda Unemployed Workers Union of SA a

Mr/Ms L Lindelwa Ncamiso Uniting Reformed Church - Khayamnandi a

Ms M Finnemore University of Port Elizabeth a

Ms G Glenda Webster University of the Witwatersrand a

Mr M Martin Pram UPDEF -Langa Civil Society a

Ms H Hedwig Crooijmans Urban Services Group a

Mr C Clive Felix Urban Services Group a

Ms N Nomhle Tys V3 Consulting Engineers a

Cllr R Carolus Valencia Community Based Structure a

Mr C Clive van der Riet Van Der Riet Architects a

Ms A Antoinette Van Der Walt Van der Walt Attorneys a

Mr V Vernon Piers Vernon Piers Water a

Mr R Reginald Mlomo Vista University a

Mr GD Barnes VRN Steel a

Mr M Da Costa VRN Steel a

Mr N Nick Mynhardt VRN Steel a

Mr M Martin Schmidt VRN Steel a

Mr M Michael Gqirana w b forum a

Mr/Ms NJ Fakwa W/C Mr A Archie Ndude W/C a

a Mr/Ms KK Boqwana Ward 24 a

a Mr S Sandile Jackson Ward 38 a

Mr B Bukelwa Jama Ward 38 a

Mr M Mmeli Kondile Ward 38 a

Mr S Sydney Mabombo Ward 38 a

Mr M Mandla Mpinga Ward 38 a

Mr R Paraffin Ward 38 a

Mr M Mahlahla Boweka Ward 42 a

Mr Z Zama Pana Ward 42 a

Mr/Ms S Siyolo Stoffel Ward 5 D Forum - Uitenhage a

a Mr L Likaya Matabese Ward 54 a

Mr/Ms MW Bless Ward Committee a

Mr/Ms NP Vena Ward Committee a

Mr R Carous Ward Councillor a

Mr D Nock Warman Africa a

Mr J John West Warman Africa a

Mr B Morgan Griffiths WESSA EP a

Mr M Michael Price Wicklow Trust River Bend a

Ms V Valerie Hunt Wildlife & Environment Society a

Mr C Chris Jeffrey Wildlife & Environment Society a

Ms C Cathy Kay Wildlife & Environment Society a

Ms D Denise Davies Wildlife & Environment Society of SA, PE a

Ms J Judy Chalmers Wildlife Society Of SA a

Dr E Eckart Schumann Wildlife Society of SA a

Ms N Mbekisa Women in Construction - Uitenhage a

Ms G Gwen Mdoda Women in Construction - Uitenhage a

Ms E Elizabeth Sihlulo Women in Construction - Uitenhage a

Mr S Sivuyile Nkayi WRF a

Mr J John Exley Xmeco Pty Ltd a

a Mr S Siphiwe Mzizi Youth Project - TLC Office a

Mr/Ms R Rheat Putulu Zakhele 4 a

a Mr Y Yanda Pongolo Zamulungisa Housing Dev. a

a Mr G George Summers ZT a

a Mr R Rob Mc Williams Zwarkops Trust a

Ms J Joan Coulridge Zwartkops Trust a

Ms J Joan Finn Zwartkops Trust a

a Ms E Esme Girdlestone Zwartkops Trust a

Mr L Leon Killian Zwartkops Trust a

Mr T Lindop Zwartkops Trust a

Ms S Sue Hoffmann Zwartkops Trust/Aloes Environmental Cmt a

Mr/Ms V Vusi Misi Zwica Trust - Zwide a

Mr T Balfour Zwide Community Active Trust a

Mr G Gerald Baiwa a

Mr J Jackson Bona a

Mr MO Mnikelo Camagu a




Appendices, Page 39


Lette

r 1PM

D

TR

Pub

Mtg

9 J

un

05

Focu

s G

roup

M

tgs

Mr & Mrs D David Crews a

Mr P Patrick Cull a

Mr AJ Davies a

Mr M Marius Doubell a

Mr T Du Preez a

Mr/Ms R Rainer Engels a

Mr/Ms T Fember a

Mr C F Ferreira a

Mr S Sheldon Friel a

Ms V Vera Gomomo a

Mr Z Gxasheka a

Mr L Lulama Gxulwana a

Mr G Geoff Harrington a

Mr H Hewitt a

Ms C Carol Hiles a

Mr B Bernie Hoffman a

Mr Horsburgh a

Mr V Jacobs a

Mr L Luvuyo Johnson a

Mr S Solly Katshiwe a

Ms NM Kolisile a

Mr H Linhart a

Mr & Mrs T Tom & Kathy Long a

Mr V Victor Lukwe a

Ms Z Zingisa Mabongo a

a Mr V Vuyo Madasi a

Mr/Ms N Mafu a

Mr/Ms Z Makhaza a

Ms T Thenjiwe Maqanda a

Mr S Shaun Martin a

Mr/Ms P Puleng Mathanga a

a Mr M Monwabisi Matiwane a

Mr S Matyana a

Mr T Thembile Mbiyabo a

Mr RGM Mc Gregor a

Mr D Derek McEwan a

Ms A Ann McMaster a

Mr BE Mkavy a

Mr S Mvemve a

Mrs N Nangu a

Ms H Heather Newington a

Mr N Ngqandende a

Mrs E Esther Nomnganga a

Mr/Ms N Nopinky Noncembu a

Mr V Vuyani Nondi a

Mr B Busisiwe Nqinqi a

Mr W Z Nyaba a

Mr I O'Conner a

Ms B Busisiwe Pantshwa a

Mr MR Plaatjies a

Mr/Ms I Isaha Potgieter a

Mr D Daluxolo Pupuma a

Mr M Martin Sampies a

Mr L Leslie Scholtz a

Mr/Ms AF Sidumo a

Mr/Ms U Stander a

Mr J Turkstra a

Mr/Ms L Lindikaya Tyombo a

a Mr C v d Merwe a

Mrs RE Von Wildemann a

Mr GG Witbooi a

Mr R Rob Wylde a

Mr B Boy Mr W




Appendices, Page 40

Database of interested and affected parties invited to the environmental focus group meeting Title First Name Surname Organisation Address1 Address2 Town Code Phone Fax Mr Aubrey Adshade Zwartkops Trust 15 Ponta Del Mare De Mist Circle Bluewater Bay 6212 4661937 466 1937 Mr Marwan Al-Sharaa PE Tourism 581 7540 581 7544 Ms Samantha Barnes PERCCI P.O. Box 2221 North End Port Elizabeth 6056 4844430 4871851 Mr M.C. Botha Vista Private Bag x613 Port Elizabeth 6000 408 3111 464 2859 Mr JR Buel SRV Tourism Forum P.O. Box 67 Addo 6105 042 2330331 042 2330209 Mr PRZ Burton SRV Tourism Forum P.O.Box 21 Addo 6105 042 2330040 042 2330040 Dr Guy Castley SANParks P.O. Box 20419 Humewood Port Elizabeth 6013 5085411 5085415

Mr Moki Cekisane African Renaissance Sport Foundation P.O. Box 5612 Walmer Port Elizabeth 6065 581 0916 581 1145

Mr Len Chandler National Salt Limited P.O. Box 446 Port Elizabeth 6000 461 9462 461 9421 Mr Alfred Da Costa PERCCI P.O. Box 2221 North End Port Elizabeth 6056 4844430 4871851

The Manager

NMMM Transportation Division P.O. Box 88 Port Elizaberth 6000 506 2251 506 2231

Mr Jan Du Plessis Sundays River Irrigation Board 042 234 0038 042 234 0022

Mrs Joan Finn Zwartkops Trust 47 Riverside Drive Amsterdamhoek Port Elizabeth 6001 4662093 466 1937 Mr Morgan Griffiths WESSA 2B Lawrence Street Central Port Elizabeth 6001 5851157 5863228

Mr. Paul Hansen Sundays River Valley Community Forum P.O. Box 322 Addo 6105 083 3259398 042 2330632

Dr Kevin Hendrick Bird Life PE P.O. Box 13797 Humewood Port Elizabeth 6013 083 406 3130 4842422

Dr. Stephen Holness South African National Parks P.O. Box 20419 Humewood Port Elizabeth 6013 041 508 5414 041 508 5415

Mr Werner Illenberger East Cape Clean Air Initiative 55 Emerald Street Mt Pleasant Port Elizabeth 6001 3682771 368 2771

Mr Greg Jones Sundays River Citrus Co-operative Main St Kirkwood 6120 042 2300300 082 971 2804

Ms PPC P.O. Box 2016 North End Port Elizabeth 6056 4862272 4862145




Appendices, Page 41

Dr Graham Kerley TERU P.O. Box 4600 Port Elizabeth 6000 5042493 5042317 Mr Gordon Lake P.O. Box 150 Colchester Port Elizabeth 6175 041 468 0087 041 468 0288 Mr Stan Long PE Technicon P.O. Box X6011 Port Elizabeth 6000 5043297 5043491 Cllr Annette Lovemore DA 25 Van Wyk Street Westering Port Elizabeth 6025 041 360 9432 041 3609432

Dr Paul Martin NMMM Business Unit Manager P.O. Box 12435 Centrahilll Port Elizabeth 6006 585 9711 585 2907

Mr Rob Mc Williams Zwartkops Trust P.O. Box 27192 Greenacres Port Elizabeth 6057 3730871 3730872

Ms Ruth Mkumatela Community Environment Network P.O. Box 14636 Sidwell Port Elizabeth 6061 4668637 4671436

Mr Connie Muller Marine Growers P.O. Box 21555 Port Elizabeth 6000 461 9055 461 9010

Mr Thabo Ndlovu National Ports Authority of SA P.O. Box 162 Port Elizabeth 6000 041 507 1951 041 507 1963

Mr Cornelius Pieterse EC Agriculture Union P.O. Box 232 Uitenhage 6230 363 1890 3631896 Mr D.M. Pillay Cacadu Municipality P.O. Box 318 Port Elizabeth 6000 508 7111 508 7066

Mr Vukile Rala Community Environment Network P.O. Box 14636 Sidwell Port Elizabeth 6061 041 466 8637 041 466 8637

Mr Ayanda Sigwela SANParks P.O. Box 20419 Humewood Port Elizabeth 6013 5085411 5085415 Mr Richard Stephenson Zwartkops Trust P.O. Box 75 Swartkops Port Elizabeth 6210 Mr Warrick Stewart WESSA 2B Lawrence Street Central Port Elizabeth 6001 5851157 5863228 Mr George Summers Zwartkops Trust P.O. Box 75 Amsterdamhoek Port Elizabeth 6210 041 4670301 041 4670301 Mr Norton Tennille SAEP 10 Surbiton Road Rosebank Cape Town 7700 021-6853431 6892020/6853431

Mr Johannes Van Der Merwe Kirkwood Farmers Association P.O. Box 96 Kirkwood 6120 042 230 1305 082 474 4122

N & NP Zembe Community Environment Network P.O. Box 14636 Sidwell Port Elizabeth 6061 041 466 8637 041 466 8637

Mr Beyl Sundays River Valley Tourism 042 2330331




Appendices, Page 42

APPENDIX D:

Record of comments received during the public review period for the Draft Technology Review Report (including meeting notes and individual submissions)

Notes from Public Meeting (9 June 2005) Notes from Environmental Focus Group Meeting (8 June 2005) Notes from Community Focus Group Meeting (8 June 2005) Notes from Motherwell Tourism Forum meeting (29 June 2005) Notes from Uitenhage meeting (6 July 2005) Written comments received during the public review period




Appendices, Page 43

Technology Review for the Coega Aluminium Smelter:

Notes from Public Meeting held in the Port Elizabeth City Hall on 9 June 2005

Prepared by: Sandy Wren, Public Process Consultants

Clive Van Der Riet

What is the waste component of the project? What hazardous waste will be produced? Where does the AP50 come from, presumably it is a more advanced technology.

Eric Skepe

Initially Pechiney was using AP 50 technology now AP35 is proposed, what were the short comings in the AP50 Technology? What will be the differences between the two technologies and the impact on the environment?

Is AP35 used in other countries? What are the long term health risks, for example after 10 years?

Mr Metula

Has a conveyer belt system been considered to transport the product to the port? George Molutsi

What will be the health risks and impacts from the smelter especially on the people closest to the smelter?

Workshops need to be held closer to Coega so that the people most affected by the project understand what the impacts of the project will be.

Where will the sludge from the smelter be disposed? Elvin Mankahla

What is the scope of the public consultation process for the technology review, there do not seem to be many people at the meeting, more people need to be informed on the results of the project.

Clive Van Der Riet

How does the air pollution measurement work? What will be the cumulative impacts after more factories are built?

Where will the landfill be located? Bonisani Tikis – Cosatu

How will the tanneries in Markman be affected by this development? These factories were requested to reduce the chemical composition of their emissions, will this development impact on these factories. These factories create jobs which are needed.




Appendices, Page 44


Notes from Environmental Focus Group Meeting held in Port Elizabeth

on 8 June 2005

Prepared by: Sandy Wren, Public Process Consultants Roald Pearson – Zwartkops Trust

On what basis were distances established for the air quality and health impact assessment?

How many of the 1000 to be employed will be from PE? What will be the environmental impact of the power lines required by the development?

Joan Finn – Zwartkops Trust

Kavalelihle is a new township on the Coega Kop side of Addo Road which will be close to the factory, what will be the impact on these people.

People are not being made aware of the dangers of aluminium? What pollution will be produced by the factory? What will be done with the fluoride?

Aubrey Adshade – Zwartkops Trust

It is not a labour intensive operation and people in the area need to be employed. Moki Cekisani – Ubuntu Environmental Network

We want projects that will help and create a better society in South Africa that is owned by the people of South Africa. Black Economic Empowerment needs to be part of the development process, there needs to be a passing on of skills to local people.

Ayanda Sigwela - SANParks

Will there be an opportunity to explain the technical aspects of the project? Joe Ntamekwana – Environmental Justice Networking Forum

Who are the shareholders of the project and what percentage will they have? There has been a shift in the technology, what caused this shift?

Morgan Griffiths - WESSA

Concerned about pollution and the impacts on human health. Considering South Africa will accrue the environmental costs of the project what are the

actual financial benefits to SA and South Africans, salaries, what jobs will be imported, what will be the tax benefits, what downstream industries will be created?

What examples can you give of Alcans health contributions in other countries and what do you intend to do here?

What examples can you give of Alcans environmental contributions in other countries and what do you intend to do here, with regards to workers, environmental programmes, positive and negative?

Alcan should set aside a % of its turnover (not profit) for an environmental fund and health fund, which should be separate to any other emergency fund.

What is the global trend with regards to aluminium production? In terms of the new ROD that will be issued it is the expectation that it will be followed

by a 30 day appeal period.




Appendices, Page 45

How many tons of the aluminium powder makes aluminium. Alex – Wells Estate

We are staying at Wells Estate, what will be the impact of the aluminium smelter on these people?

Will people be trained to work at the Smelter? What will happen to people that are staying at the IDZ?

Ayanda Sigwela – SANParks

Lets look at the differences between the two processes. Can you not use a process that does not emit CO2?

Greg Jones - SRCC

While we are moving to AP35 we need to ensure that we are not moving backwards, what number of the AP35 smelters are 14001 compliant, and what percentage of the 80% built in the 1980’s are AP50 technology.

Aubrey Adshade – Zwartkops Trust

The Montenegro plant is a very bad example of an aluminium smelter, it has had a very negative impact on the environment. It is power hungry and uses water?

Joan Finn – Zwartkops Trust

If there is a drought will local water be compromised? Fluoride in large quantities causes brittle bones. There needs to be a pond that

captures the stormwater and the fluoride in the stormwater and the water should be treated before it is discharged to the marine environment.

How is the alumina transported? Roald Pearson – Zwartkops Trust

If something goes wrong are there guarantees that Alcan will foot the bill to correct the problem? There needs to be something in place.

The health risk assessment conducted does it apply to animals? Does aluminium impact on the immune system? Studies have revealed that aluminium

can cause Alzheimer’s. In 1968 we had 22 inches of rain in 22 hours. What will happen in such a scenario? What will happen if one of the silos are full and a ship comes in with a load?

Audrey Adshade – Zwartkops Trust

What will be the impact on the marine environment, the bay is the source of a major fishing industry in the area.

Ships come into the harbour and pump out bulge water, how will this impact on the marine environment?

Greg Jones – Sundays River Citrus Company

Why transport the heavy loads outside, why has this changed, it was part of the original record of decision?

Are there values available for the waste that will be produced? There was meant to be a study on the effect of the fluoride on the citrus trees in the

Addo Valley, what has happened to this study? Can we have an undertaking from Alcan that citrus trees can be planted at the smelter

site and fluoride emissions monitored on site, this was discussed and agreed to with Pechiney. Addo Valley creates huge employment (20 000) through the citrus industry




Appendices, Page 46

and we want to ensure that the project does not compromise the citrus industry in Addo for an aluminium smelter.

Where will the extra water that is needed be obtained from, if it comes from the Noodgedacht treatment works and it requires upgrading who will pay for this?

The recycling of water should be included in the revised ROD. Ayanda Sigwela – SANParks

It would have been nice to have had comparative models between what was modeled now and in 2002.

Was one of the modeling sites in the Sundays River Community and where was this? When you say Addo elephant park what are you referring to, the new entrance or the

old main camp? Does the assessment take into account the impact of fluoride on the proposed marine

protected area for Addo, there will be an outlet from the Port into the marine environment and has this been taken into account.

Werner Illenberger

We need to gain perspective on the amount of fluoride that it is discharged to sea water, fluoride occurs naturally in seawater and the amount proposed for discharge for this project is small?

Morgan Griffiths

What will be the impact on plants and vegetables surrounding the site, at Saldanha it has smothered plants within a km of the site?

Will it be corrosive on vehicles and buildings? Why are we not ensuring that fluoride is not released in the first place?

Surely there must be evidence from existing factories and what has been the impact on these factories.

Alex

What standards are being used to assess air quality, you mentioned New Zealand, are we using these standards?

What will be the impact on micro insects from stormwater? Roald Pearson

In the 1950’s farmers in Addo paid for water that they never got? Who would be responsible for monitoring the recommendations in the report? There

needs to be a comprehensive monitoring system for the entire area. Both our vegetable and abattoir in Markman are in close proximity to the proposed

development, how will these be affected? Joan Finn

Very skeptical of assurances that are provided due to history with a toxic waste site and the history with the Zwartkops Trust and leachate running into the Zwartkops River.

Sceptical of spillages and good housekeeping. Would like to see that the Swartkop Trust are given written assurances that Alcan will take responsibility for mistakes that are made.

Ayanda Sigwela

Don’t clearly get the understanding behind the switch from AP50 to AP35, surely it is an improvement and going back would mean short falls.

Is it not a problem when all the specialist studies come back positive?




Appendices, Page 47

Aubrey Adshade Is there cyanide generated by the plant?

Werner Illenberger

The fact that electricity production is not going to be taken into account is viewed as a major short coming in the previous EIA and should have been included in this one. The laying of power cables through the Transkei and the impact of coal emissions inland.

Could we not maximize the production process with further benefication to maximize employment opportunities?




Appendices, Page 48


Notes from the Community Focus Group Meeting held at the Centenary Hall in

New Brighton, Port Elizabeth on 9 June 2005

Prepared by: Sandy Wren, Public Process Consultants What mechanism is used for the safety of workers who operate the machinery? Mr Hini – SACP

PE is a windy city, how will the emissions from the plant be managed? If there is a negative impact on people who live close by will Alcan be prepared to take

care of them? There are people in Uitenhage who are interested in the project a presentation should

be given in Uitenhage? Mr Dyimi – SANCO

What kinds of businesses will benefit from the Aluminium smelter, can you give examples?

Phumzile Nodongwe – COSATU

What do you mean when you say a direct job? Will the new technology still create the 1000 jobs and will these be sustainable?

Leonard – SANCO Uitenhage

What criteria will be used to employ the 1000 people? Will Alcan offer shares to the community? What kinds of salaries will be paid to workers and what kind of hours will be worked? How will the working environment impact on the health of workers and their ability to

perform their work? Mr Maji – SANCO

Communities are used to endorse projects, and when it comes to jobs labour is sourced from outside of the area?

What is the impact on the health of workers at the plant? Has there ever been a problem and if so how was it dealt with?

Concerned about the levels of education of people in the Metro what will Alcan do for people to ensure that they are more employable?

Prince Baka – ANC YL

Most of the young people in the Metro do not have high levels of education? Will Alcan provide training to ensure that people are more employable?

Will Alcan communicate to people what employment process will be followed if they proceed with the project? Will the ward committees and Alliance structures be notified of the availability of jobs before they are advertised in newspapers?




Appendices, Page 49

Nanie Schaap – SANCO

Will there be age restrictions on employment and will there be gender equality? The process that has been explained for employment, will it actually be followed?

Ms Magopeni – ANC

Appreciate the opportunity provided for public participation and the receiving of information on the project.

Will it not be possible to have workshops in each of the various areas? Most of the people at the meeting are unemployed and it is far for them to travel?

Will the disabled also be considered for employment? G Martinas - ANC

Will SMME’s be supported or will Alcan go to the old long established companies. Will BEEE’s they be given opportunities to get contracts? E.g. catering, security, transport businesses. Support for BEE’s is needed to address the imbalances of the past.

Mrs Odolo – Motherwell Tourism Forum

The CDC database for employment is not working well, people have filled in the registration forms but positions are still advertised in the newspaper and people on the CDC database have not been contacted.

People have received training but they are told that their certificates are receipts and they have not been employed as a result of the training received.

Application forms for positions are not accessible for people living in the township, they are usually available in town and not in the community.

Mr Mabo - COSATU

Can the audience be provided with copies of the presentation? Can the smelter be located anywhere other than in an IDZ? The approach followed in Richards Bay to employ people has been less than favourable

than in other industries. How will the strong social infrastructure component be implemented when the team

driving the project so far does not reflect the social demographics of the area? Mr J Bozo – COSATU

Most of the big corporations look for experience before employment, how will this be addressed?

When there will be employment will Alcan meet with COSATU? Ms Skaap –

Is this the first aluminium smelter project in SA? Mr Hini – SACP

Will the waste from the smelter smell, will it affect people living near the plant and how will this be managed?

G Martinas - ANC

When is it anticipated that the actual project will commence? Leonard – SANCO Uitenhage

What kind of waste will be produced by the smelter and what will be the impact on people?




Appendices, Page 50

Mr Maji – SANCO

Animals in the Coega area have been displaced, how is the community compensated for this loss?

Will Alcan be mining at Coega? If so, will dynamite be used and how will the noise impact on local communities be managed?

Would like more explanation on the visual impacts? Dybi - SANCO

There are stock and crop farmers in the area, what will be the impact on these people and has this been assessed?

Mr Maqakaza

Has a waste landfill been identified? How will the removal of plant life around the smelter be managed? There are all these various standards and guidelines which are not being followed and

no-one is monitoring this? Waste is illegally disposed off, how will waste be disposed of from the smelter. Local

communities should be involved in the waste disposal process. Boqwana – ANC

There has been public consultation before and recommendations can we not have a summary of this as it explains how things have been done and will prevent people going back all the time?

There are recommendations to manage the Fluoride, what are they? Ms Skaap

There are other aluminium smelters in the country, will similar salaries be paid? Prince Baka - ANC

We need to keep communication open so that people are informed about the process and what is happening.

We need to be regularly updated on the project progress. This must be well managed. Alcan should work closely with communities so that the LRA is complied with. We don’t want the same problems as we have had in Richards Bay.

Pumeza – Young Communist League

There are differences between the AP35 and AP50, could you summarise what those differences are? Have you made a final decision to use AP35?

What are the experiences from other smelters in SA with regards to the impact on communities?

Mathole – Motherwell Tourism Forum

Could you give a presentation to organizations in Motherwell, we are close to the Coega IDZ and will be affected by the smelter?

Ngoqo

Can training be done before people are employed?




Appendices, Page 51


Notes from the Meeting with the Motherwell Tourism Forum held at the ANC

Constituency Office in Port Elizabeth at 6:00pm on 29 June 2005

Prepared by: Sandy Wren, Public Process Differences

What are the differences between the AP35 and AP50? Emissions

What is the level of emissions per ton of aluminium produced? Management of the Fluoride

Is there a strict measure in place to manage the fluoride on site? Impact on the community

Will the fluoride will impact on life of the community of Mothrwell? Use of powder by Algorax

Algorax uses a lot of powder near fish water flats and this powder impacts on the communities

Air quality

What would be the impact on air quality as a result of the smelter? Tourism

Would the smelter impact on the tourism potential within Motherwell community? There needs to be proper and strict measures for the management of environmental

issues. Change of technology

Is the change of technology as a result of the economic benefits of ALCAN? Disposed of chemicals and Acids

In the production of aluminium there are chemicals and acids used to convert the raw material to aluminium where would the chemicals and acids be disposed?

Marine life

Is there any impact on the marine life as a result of the smelter, this should not be negatively affected.




Appendices, Page 52

Wind direction

Has wind direction been considered with regards to the impact on the health of communities?

Use of AP35 Technology

Where in other parts of the world is the AP35 were being used. What are the advantages of the use of AP35 technology as opposed to AP50 and why is AP35 to be used in South Africa?

Environmental Management

Is there a process in place to ensure the environmental management of the project and how would communities be involved in this process?

Motherwell, as an area immediately adjacent to the project, would want to be represented in the management and monitoring of all matters relating to the development not only on the smelter.

Social reinvestment programme

What is the social responsibility of Pechiney to the community of Mothewell. Is there a plan in place to reinvest in the area?

Project Support

We are in support of the project but, we feel strongly that South Africa is used as a dumping site.

Aluminium processing

We would to see aluminium produced and processed in SA. It will be taken to other countries to be converted to different things and then be sold to South Africa at a high price.




Appendices, Page 53


Notes from the Meeting with the Uitenhage ANC Alliance held at the Uitenhage

Town Hall at 15:00 on 6 July 2005

Prepared by: Sandy Wren, Public Process Consultants Welcome the Project – Vuyo Jim - ANC

We welcome the Coega Aluminium Smelter project it has been a while not getting an update on the project.

Change of Technology

On the change of technology the ANC will wait for the final specialist reports as it is the specialists who conduct the independent assessments.

Project Support – Cllr. Hote

We support the Coega Aluminium Smelter project as this would change the economic situation of the area.

Job Creation – Cllr. Mike Kwenaite

How many jobs would the project create both permanent and temporary jobs, taking into account the change of technology, and the use of two potlines?

Update information

We would like to be updated on the developments of the project at all times.




Appendices, Page 54

WRITTEN COMMENTS RECEIVED DURING THE COMMENTS PERIOD FOR THE DRAFT TECHNOLOGY REPORT




Appendices, Page 55




Appendices, Page 56




Appendices, Page 57




Appendices, Page 58




Appendices, Page 59




Appendices, Page 60




Appendices, Page 61




Appendices, Page 62




Appendices, Page 63




Appendices, Page 64




Appendices, Page 65




Appendices, Page 66




Appendices, Page 67




Appendices, Page 68




Appendices, Page 69




Appendices, Page 70

appendicesfred.csir.co.za/project/smelter/report/appendices.pdfappendices, page 10 po box 27688...

Documents