anthro 181: social anthropology of religion

77

Upload: mykel-pan-

Post on 12-Jan-2015

917 views

Category:

Education


4 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 2: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 3: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 4: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 5: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

All societies have spiritual beliefs and practices that anthropologists refer to as RELIGION. Yet because of great diversity of these “beliefs/ practices”, defining religion is surprisingly difficult. Most definitions focus on the supernatural , but Westerners make a clear distinction between natural and supernatural.

Page 6: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Ilagay dito yung religion vs, science

Page 7: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

The problem is that some religions explicitly DENY that supernatural beings exist, and others do not distinguish them from Westerners call the natural. Even in US, the difference may be problematic. Is God’s presence in the world supernatural to the devout, OR is it simply part of the natural order of the world?

Page 8: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Because different societies perceive reality in different ways, there is no agreed upon way to distinguish the natural from the supernatural. But our problems are even greater than this. Religions around the world show enormous variation...

Page 9: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 10: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Religion Scholars Carmody and Camody noted,

“religion ranges almost endlessly- into every geographical area, into every temporal period, into so many uses of the human body, mind, imagination, social instinct, artistic genius, and all the rest that no library could contain all the studies that the full range of religion, actual and potential, would require”.

Page 11: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

In studying religion cross-culturally, anthropologists pay attention to the social nature and roles of religion as well as to the nature, content, and meaning to people of religious doctrines, acts, events, settings, practitioners, and organizations. We also consider such verbal manifestations of religious beliefs as prayers, chants, myths, texts, and statements about ethics and morality.

Page 12: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Religion, by either definition offered here, exists in all human societies. IT IS A CULTURAL UNIVERSAL. However, we’ll see that it isn’t always easy to distinguish the supernatural from the natural and that DIFFERENT SOCIETIES conceptualize divinity, supernatural entities, and ultimate realities VERY DIFFERENTLY.

Page 13: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

What is ?

Page 14: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

anthropologist Anthony F. C. Wallace defined religion as “belief and ritual concerned with supernatural beings, powers, and forces”. The supernatural is the extraordinary realm outside the observable world. It is nonempirical and inexplicable in ordinary terms.

X Defining Religion Y

Page 15: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

focuses on bodies of people who gather together regularly for worship. These congregants or adherents subscribe to and internalize a common system of meaning. They accept (adhere to or believe in) a set of doctrines involving the relationship between the individual and divinity, the supernatural, or whatever is taken to be the ultimate nature of reality (Reese, 1999)

Page 16: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

The anthropologist Clifford Geertz defined religion as a "system of symbols which acts to establish powerful, pervasive, and long-lasting moods and motivations in men by formulating conceptions of a general order of existence and clothing these conceptions with such an aura of factuality that the moods and motivations seem uniquely realistic”.

Page 17: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Theologian Antoine Vergote also emphasized the "CULTURAL REALITY" of religion, which he defined as "the entirety of the linguistic expressions, emotions and, actions and signs that refer to a supernatural being"; he took the term "supernatural" simply to mean whatever transcends the powers of nature or human agency.

Page 18: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Anthropologist stressed:

3. Enacted nature of religion

2.shared

1.collecti

ve

5.Meanings it

embodies

4. Emotions

it generates

Page 19: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Emile Durkheim

stressed religious “effervescence”, the bubbling up of collective emotional intensity generated by worship.

updated Durkheim’s notion, using the term “communitas”, an intense community spirit, a feeling of great social solidarity, equality, and togetherness.

Y Religion is?Victor Turner

Page 20: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

The word religion derives from the Latin “religare”—

“to tie, to bind,” but it is not necessary for all members of a given religion to meet together as a common body. Subgroups meet regularly at local congregation sites.

They may attend occasional meetings with adherents representing a wider region and they may form an imagined community with people of similar faith throughout the world.

Y Etymology

Page 21: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

1) Religions are composed of sacred stories or narratives that members believed are important.

2) Religions make extensive use of symbols and symbolism.

3) All propose the existence of (supernatural) beings, powers, states, places and qualities that cannot be measured by any agreed upon scientific means.

4) All include rituals and specific means of addressing the supernatural.

5) All societies include individuals who are particularly expert in the practice of religion.

[Characteristics of Rel'gionU

Page 22: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Religion have many functions in a society. It may provide:

Meaning and order in people’s lives May reduce social anxiety Give people sense of control over their

destinies Can promote and reinforce the status quo or,

in some situations can be means of changing existing conditions.

YWhat Rel'gion Does in Society?

Page 23: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

To explain important aspects of the physical and social environment and to give meaning.

Cosmology- framework for interpreting events and experiences. This may include the creation of the universe, the origin of society, the relationship of individuals and groups to one another, relation of humankind to nature and nature of life and death.

USearch for Order & Meaning

Page 24: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 25: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 26: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 27: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 28: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

By defining the place of the individual in society and thru the establishment of moral codes, religion provide us

with,

Page 29: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Sense of Personal Identity

Page 30: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Sense of Belonging

Page 31: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Standards of Behavior

Page 32: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Many religious practices are aimed at ensuring success in human activities. Prayers, sacrifice and magic are done in the hope that that they will aid a particular person or community.

Rituals are performed to call on supernatural beings and to control forces that appear to be unpredictable.

Example: You are likely to pray for passing an exam if you have not studied very well, and you may even bring your lucky charm during the examination day

RReducing Anxiety and Increasing Control

Page 33: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

The practice of “magical death” in many parts of Melanesia, a sorcerer ritually imitates throwing a magical stick in the direction of the intended victim with an expression of passionate hatred on his face, is often very effective because of its psychological effects.

Anthropologist Walter Cannon, concluded that death was usually caused by the victims extreme terror which led to despair, appetite loss, and vulnerability to heart attack.

Baseball player George Gmelch has noted to use magic for the least predictable aspects of the game like hitting, pitching, and talking to his baseball bat.

Page 34: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Shamanic healing inAmazon Jungle

Page 35: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Baseball Player George Gmelch

Page 36: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Religion is closely connected with the survival of society and generally works to preserve the social order. Through religion, beliefs about good and evil are reinforce by supernatural means of social control. Sacred stories and rituals provide a rationale for the present social order and give social values religious authority.

RReinforcing or Modifying the Social Order

Page 37: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 38: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Religious rituals also intensifies social solidarity by creating an atmosphere in which people experience their common identity in emotionally giving ways.

Page 39: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Finally, religion is an important educational institution for transmitting cultural values and knowledge.

Page 40: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Religion can also be a catalyst for social change.

Page 41: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

(Origin and Early Beginnings)

E X P R E S S I O N S O F R E L I G I O N

Page 42: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

No one knows for sure! There are suggestions of religion in Neanderthal burials and on European cave walls, where painted stick figures may represent shamans, early religious specialists. Nevertheless, any statement about when, where, why, and how religion arose, or any description of its original nature, can be only speculative. Although such speculations are inconclusive, however, many have revealed important functions and effects of religious behaviour. Several theories will be examined now.

RWhen did Religion Begin?

Page 43: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Englishman Sir Edward Burnett Tylor, the founder of the anthropology of religion

Religion was born, as people tried to understand conditions and events they could not explain by reference to daily experience.

Tylor concluded that attempts to explain dreams and trances led early humans to believe that two entities inhabit the body, one active during the day and the other—a double or soul— active during sleep and trance states.

1. Spiritual Beings

Page 44: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

“Physical Body”

“Double or

Soul”

-Balance

-

Although they never meet, they are vital to each other and keeps balance to the human. When double permanently leaves the body, the person dies. Death is departure of the soul.

Page 45: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Anima(Latin)

means “Soul”

“ANIMISM” -the earliest form of religion, was a beliefin spiritual beings.

Page 46: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Animism(spirits)Polytheism(belief in multiple gods)

Monotheism(single, all powerful deity)

Page 47: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Besides animism—and sometimes coexisting with it in the same society—is a view of the supernatural as a domain of impersonal power, or force, which people can control under certain conditions. (You’d be right to think of Star Wars:) Such a conception of the supernatural is particularly prominent in Melanesia, the area of the South Pacific that includes Papua New Guinea and adjacent islands.

Melanesians believed in mana, a sacred impersonal force existing in the universe. Mana can reside in people, animals, plants, and objects.

2. Powers and Forces

Page 48: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 49: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Melanesians attributed success to mana, which people could acquire or manipulate in different ways, such as through magic. Objects with mana could change someone’s luck.

For example, a charm or amulet belonging to a successful hunter might transmit the hunter’s mana to the next person who held or wore it. A woman might put a rock in her garden, see her yields improve dramatically, and attribute the change to the force contained in the rock.

Page 50: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 51: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

So charged with mana were the highest chiefs that contact with them was dangerous to the commoners. The mana of chiefs flowed out of their bodies wherever they went. It could infect the ground, making it dangerous for others to walk in the chief’s footsteps.

Contact between chief and commoners was dangerous because mana could have an effect like an electric shock.

Because high chiefs had so much mana, their bodies and possessions were taboo (set apart as sacred and off-limits to ordinary people).

Page 52: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Do we have “Mana” in the

Philippines?

Page 53: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Agimat

Page 54: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 55: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Magic refers to supernatural techniques intended to accomplish specific aims. These techniques include spells, formulas, and incantations used with deities or with impersonal forces.

IMITATIVE MAGIC- magicians use imitative magic to produce a desired effect by imitating it. If magicians wish to injure or kill someone, they may imitate that effect on an image of the victim. Sticking pins in “voodoo dolls” is an example.

3. Magic & Religion

Page 56: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 57: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 58: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

CONTAGIOUS MAGIC- with contagious magic, whatever is done to an object is believed to affect a person who once had contact with it. Sometimes practitioners of contagious magic use body products from prospective victims—their nails or hair, for example. The spell performed on the body product is believed to reach the person eventually and work the desired result.

Page 59: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 60: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Religion and magic don’t just explain things. They serve emotional needs as well as cognitive (e.g., psychological) ones. For example, supernatural beliefs and practices can help reduce anxiety. Religion helps people face death and endure life crises. Magical techniques can dispel doubts that arise when outcomes are beyond human control.

4. Uncertainty, Anxiety & Solace

Page 61: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 62: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Peace of mind and heart

Page 63: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

When people face uncertainty and danger, according to Malinowski, they turn to MAGIC. Malinowski found that the Trobriand Islanders used magic when sailing, a hazardous activity. He proposed that because people can’t control matters such as wind, weather, and the fish supply, they turn to magic.

Magic is particularly evident in baseball, where George Gmelch (1978, 2001) describes a series of rituals, taboos, and sacred objects. Like Trobriand sailing magic, these behaviors serve to reduce psychological stress, creating an illusion of magical control when real control is lacking. Examples of pitchers’ magic include tugging one’s cap between pitches, touching the resin bag after each bad pitch, and talking to the ball.

Page 64: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 65: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Several features distinguish rituals from other kinds of

behaviour. Rituals are formal—stylized, repetitive, and stereotyped. People perform them in special (sacred) places and at set times. Rituals include liturgical orders—sequences of words and actions invented prior to the current performance of the ritual in which they occur.

These features link rituals to plays, but there are important differences. Plays have audiences rather than participants. Actors merely portray something, but ritual performers—who make up congregations—are in earnest. Rituals convey information about the participants and their traditions. Repeated year after year, generation after generation, rituals translate enduring messages, values, and sentiments into action.

5. Rituals

Page 66: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 67: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Magic and religion, as Malinowski noted, can reduce anxiety and allay fears. Ironically, beliefs and rituals also can create anxiety and a sense of insecurity and danger.

Anxiety may arise because a rite exists. Indeed, participation in a collective ritual may build up stress, whose common reduction, through the completion of the ritual, enhances the solidarity of the participants.

Rites of passage, such as the collective circumcision of teenagers, can be very stressful. The traditional vision quests of Native Americans, particularly the Plains Indians, illustrate rites of passage (customs associated with the transition from one place or stage of life to another), which are found throughout the world.

6. Rites of Passage

Page 68: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

The rites of passage of contemporary societies include confirmations, baptisms, bar and bat mitzvahs, and fraternity hazing. Passage rites involve changes in social status, such as from boyhood to manhood and from nonmember to sorority sister. More generally, a rite of passage may mark any change in place, condition, social position, or age.

This may also include birth, puberty, marriage and death etc.

Page 69: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

1. Separation

2. Liminality

3. Reincorporation

3 Phases of Rites of Passage:

Page 70: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

SEPARATION- the person of group is ritually detached form the former status.

LIMINAL PHASE- the person has been detached from the old status but has not yet attached to a new one, the person is in “limbo”, neither here nor there. The liminal stage mediates between separation and the third stage.

REINCORPORATION- in which the passage from one status to another is symbolically completed. The person takes on the rights and obligations of his or her new social status.

Page 71: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Oppositions between Liminality and Normal Social Life

-Liminality-TransitionHomogeneityCommunitasEqualityAnonymityAbsence of PropertyAbsence of statusTotal obedienceSacredness -Normal Social

Structure-• State• Heterogeneity• Structure• Inequality• Names• Property• Status• Obedience only to

Superior• Secularity

Page 72: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Passage rites often are collective. Several individuals—boys being circumcised, fraternity or sorority initiates, men at military boot camps, football players in summer training camps, women becoming nuns—pass through the rites together as a group.

Most notable is a social aspect of collective liminality called communitas, an intense community spirit, a feeling of great social solidarity, equality, and togetherness. People experiencing liminality together form a community of equals. The social distinctions that have existed before or will exist afterward are forgotten temporarily. Liminal people experience the same treatment and conditions and must act alike.

Page 73: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 74: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

Rites of Australian aboriginesTOTEM- an object, animal species, or feature of the natural world that is associated with a particular descent (kinship) group.

Members of each totemic group believed themselves to be descendants of their totem.

7. TOTEMISM

Page 75: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion
Page 76: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion

In contemporary nations, too, totems continue to mark groups, such as states and universities, professional teams, and political parties.

Totems are sacred emblems symbolizing common identity.

Page 77: Anthro 181: Social Anthropology of Religion