annex 1 synthesis for recommendations (2014-2017) … … · annex 1 synthesis for recommendations...

Annex 1 Synthesis for recommendations (2014-2017) Color Table – rev.

1

Region Country Designation Name of the site Report Year Comments

AFRICA BENIN

2002

W Transboundary Biosphere Reserve (national report) *

No report – sent in December 2016 and withdrawn at the request of MS by the time of the AC meeting

AFRICA BENIN 1986 Pendjari* PR 2015

AFRICA BURKINA FASO 2002 W Transboundary (partie Burkina Faso)* PR 2016

AFRICA BURKINA FASO 1986 Mare aux Hippopotames* PR 2016

AFRICA CAMEROON 1981

Benoué * PR 2016 5 (zonation) ; 7 (update management plan)


Dja* PR 2017 5 (zonation); 7 (management of transition zone)


Waza* PR 2016 5 (zonation) ; 6 ( organizational arrangements multi-stakeholders)

AFRICA CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC 1977

Basse Lobaye* No report due to conflict in the area of the BR

AFRICA CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC 1979

Bamingui-Bangoran* No report due to conflict in the area of the BR

AFRICA CONGO 1988 Dimonika* PR 2017

AFRICA CONGO 1977

Odzala-Kokoua* PR 2017 5 (zonation ) ; 6 (involvement of communities)

AFRICA COTE D’IVOIRE 1983 Comoe * no response from 2010

AFRICA COTE D’IVOIRE 1977

Taï FU 2015 5 (zonation) ; 7 (updated management plan)

AFRICA DRCONGO 1976 Luki* Periodic Review never received

AFRICA DRCONGO 1982 Lufira* PR 2016 Recommended for withdrawal

AFRICA DRCONGO 1976

Yangambi* FU 2017 No FU received; Management plan received

AFRICA GABON

1983

Ipassa-Makokou*

No report; UNESCO supported the process of PR in 2013 (stakeholder meeting and draft form PR)

AFRICA GHANA 1983 Bia* PR 2017

AFRICA GUINEA 1980 Monts Nimba * No report


2

AFRICA GUINEA 1980 Ziama* No report

AFRICA GUINEA 2002 Badiar * PR 2015 ??

AFRICA GUINEA

2002

Haut Niger* PR 2015

5, 7 (updated maps in particular the zonation maps) and other, annexes and supporting documents are missing including 7 (management plan of policy)

AFRICA GUINEA BISSAU 1996 Bolama-Bijagos* PR 2015

AFRICA KENYA 1991 Amboseli* PR 2017

AFRICA KENYA

1980

Kiunga* PR 2017

5 ( current zonation); 7 (management plan); data on population and species and land use

AFRICA KENYA 1979

Malindi-Watamu* PR 2017 5 (zonation); or 5 (new zonation) + (7) management plan

AFRICA KENYA 2003 Mount Elgon* PR 2017

AFRICA KENYA 1978

Mount Kenya* PR 2016 New nomination for extension and management plan

AFRICA MALAWI 2000

Mt. Mulanje* FU 2017 5 (zonation): no population in transition area

AFRICA MAURITIUS 1977 Macchabee Bel Ombre* No report

AFRICA NIGER

2002

W (TBR) * PR 2013

1st PR in 2013; 5 (zonation: the AC particularly noted the lack of relevant information in the maps provided which do not give a proper biosphere reserve zonation)

AFRICA NIGER

1987

Aïr Teneré* FU 2015

Recommendation not conclusive : security issue, creation of aTBR with Algeria

AFRICA NIGERIA 1977 Omo* FU 2017

AFRICA RWANDA

1983

Volcans*

No report - the country communicated that they have undertaken steps toward the


3

completion of the process; they are requesting support from UNESCO (email February 2017)

AFRICA SENEGAL 1981 Niokolo koba * No report submitted

AFRICA SENEGAL 1980 Delta du Saloum * PR 2015

AFRICA SENEGAL 1979 Samba Dia* PR 2015 5 (zonation), 7 (management plan)

AFRICA SOUTH AFRICA 2000

Cape West Coast* FU 2017 5 (zonation with regards to nuclear plant)

AFRICA TANZANIA 2000 East Usambara* FU 2017 Extension approved pending

AFRICA TANZANIA 1981 Lake Manyara* FU/EXT 2017 Extension approved

AFRICA TANZANIA 1981 Serengeti-Ngorongoro* FU/EXT 2017 Extension approved

ARAB ALGERIA 1990 El Kala* PR 2016

ARAB EGYPT

1981

Omayyed* FU 2017

5 and 6 ( Zonation map; stakeholders involvement and support to the local population)

ARAB EGYPT 1993

Wadi Allaqui* FU 2017 6 (stakeholders involvement and support to the local population)

ARAB JORDAN 1998 Dana* PR 2014

ARAB MOROCCO 2000 Oasis du Sud marocain* PR 2017

ARAB SUDAN

1979

Radom* FU 2017

3, 5, 6 and 7. to revise totally the functioning of the site in order to conform better with the criteria of a biosphere reserve. The Radom BR is located in an area of continued civil conflict in Darfur State lasting for more than 15 years. The AC concluded that the Radom BR should be provided more time to answer the recommendations once a peaceful and secure situation will be achieved.


4

ARAB SUDAN 1979 Dinder * PR 2016

ARAB TUNISIA 1977 Ichkeul* FU 2017

ARAB TUNISIA 1977 Zembra* FU 2017

ARAB TUNISIA 1977 Jebel Bou Hedma* FU 2017

ARAB TUNISIA 1977 Jebel Chaambi* FU 2017

ARAB YEMEN 2003 Socotra Island* PR 2016

ASPAC AUSTRALIA 1977

Croajingalong* 2014 Do not wish to follow the recommendation

ASPAC AUSTRALIA

1977

Kosciusko* FU 2017

No report sent (official letter justifying the request to submit by the end of September 2017)

ASPAC AUSTRALIA

1981

Hattah-Kulkyne and Murray Kulkyne* FU 2017


ASPAC AUSTRALIA 2002 Mornington Peninsula and Western Port PR 2015

ASPAC AUSTRALIA

1977

Prince Regent* FU 2017


ASPAC AUSTRALIA 1977 Riverland* FU 2017 No report sent (idem)

ASPAC AUSTRALIA 1977 Uluru * (Ayers Rock-Mount Olga) FU 2017 No report sent (idem)

ASPAC AUSTRALIA 1977 Unnamed* FU 2017 No report sent (idem)

ASPAC AUSTRALIA 1981 Wilson’s Promontory* FU 2017 No report sent (idem)

ASPAC AUSTRALIA 1977 Yathong* FU 2017 No report sent (idem)

ASPAC CAMBODIA

1997

Tonle Sap*

No report sent (official letter justifying the request to submit by mid-September 2018)

ASPAC CHINA

1979

Dinghushan*

No report sent (official letter: report will be submitted by 15 May 2017 latest due to a translation process)

ASPAC CHINA 2000 Baishuijiang* FU 2017

ASPAC CHINA 2001 Baotianman* FU 2017


5

ASPAC CHINA 1990 Bogeda* FU 2017

ASPAC CHINA 1979 Changbai Mountain* PR 2017

ASPAC CHINA 1986 Fanjingshan* PR 2017

ASPAC CHINA 2000 Gaoligong* FU 2017

ASPAC CHINA 2000 Huanglong* FU 2017

ASPAC CHINA 1997 Jiuzhaigou* FU 2017

ASPAC CHINA 2001 Saihanwula* FU 2017

ASPAC CHINA 2000 Shankou mangrove* FU 2017

ASPAC CHINA 1990 Shennongija* PR 2017

ASPAC CHINA

1987

Wuyishan*


ASPAC CHINA 1979 Wolong* PR 2017

ASPAC CHINA

1987

Xilingol*

No report sent (justifying the request to submit by the end of September 2017)

ASPAC CHINA

1993

Xishuangbanna*

No report sent (official letter: report will be submitted by 15 May 2017 latest due to a translation process)

ASPAC CHINA 1992 Yancheng* PR 2015

ASPAC INDONESIA 1977 Cibodas * FU 2015

ASPAC JAPAN 1980 Mount Hakusan* EXT 2016 Extension

ASPAC JAPAN 1980 Mount Odaigahara &Mont Omine and Osudigani* EXT 2016 Extension and renaming

ASPAC JAPAN 1980 Yakushima and Kuchinoerabu Jima* EXT 2016 Extension and renaming

ASPAC KYRGYZSTAN 1978

Sary-Chelek* PR 2014 6 and 7 (local communities involv.; management structure and plan)

ASPAC KYRGYZSTAN 2001 Issyk Keul * PR 2014 4 and 5 (zonation issue; functions)

ASPAC MONGOLIA 1996 Bogd Khan Uul* FU 2017

ASPAC MONGOLIA 1990 Great Gobi* PR 2017

ASPAC MONGOLIA 2002 Hustain Nuruu* FU 2016


6

ASPAC MONGOLIA 1997 Uvs Nuur Basin* FU 2017

ASPAC PHILIPPINES 1990 Palawan* FU 2017

ASPAC PHILIPPINES

1977

Puerto Galera* FU 2017

4 (zonation issue); 5 (zonation and function issues); 7 (Management Plan)

ASPAC REPUBLIC of KOREA 1982 Mount Sorak* EXT 2016 Extension

ASPAC TURKMENISTAN 1978 Repetek State* PR 2017

ASPAC UZBEKISTAN

1978

Chatkal* PR 2015

4 (zonation issue); 5 (not sufficient SD function);

EUROPE AUSTRIA 1977 Gossenköllesse W 2014 Self withdrawn

EUROPE AUSTRIA 1977 Gurgler Kamm W 2014 Self withdrawn

EUROPE AUSTRIA 1977 Lobau W 2016 Self withdrawn

EUROPE AUSTRIA 1977 Neusiedler See W 2016 Self withdrawn

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Ali Botouch* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Bistrichko Branichté* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977

Boitine* REN 2017 Included in new Central Balkan new nomination form approved


Djendema* REN 2017 Included in new Central Balkan new nomination form approved


Doupkata* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal no suport from local commuity

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Doupki-Djindjiritza* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Kamtchia* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Koupena* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Mantaritza* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal


Ouzounboudjak* EXT 2017 Approved pending (zonation to be provided)

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Parangaliztza* NOM 2017 New nomination approved

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Srébarna* NOM 2017 New nomination approved


7


Steneto* REN 2017 New nomination central Balkan approved

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Tchervenata Sténa* NOM 2017 New nomination approved

EUROPE BULGARIA 1977 Tchoupréné* PR 2017 Recommended for withdrawal


Tsaritchina* NOM 2017 New nomination approved central balkan

EUROPE CANADA 1988 Charlevoix* FU 2017

EUROPE CROATIA 1977

Velebit Mountain* PR 2017 4 ; 5 ; 6 ; 7 (size, zonation, governance, management plan)

EUROPE CZECH REPUBLIC 1977

Krivoklatsko* PR 2017 4 ; 5 ; 6 (développement function ; zonation, governance)

EUROPE CZECH REPUBLIC 1990 Sumava* PR 2017

EUROPE CZECH REPUBLIC 1977 Trebon* PR 2016

EUROPE DENMARK 1977

Northeast Greenland FU 2017 5 Country request for time extension ( law to change zonation)

EUROPE ESTONIA 1990 West-Estonian Archipelago* FU 2017

EUROPE FRANCE 1976 Camargue PR 2017

EUROPE FRANCE

1984

Cévennes PR 2015

5 and 7 (implementation of the charter and support from villages for zonation): deadline in 2018

EUROPE FRANCE 1977 Vallée du Fango* FU 2017 5 ; 7 (zonation and governance)

EUROPE GREECE Gorges of Samaria* FU 2017

EUROPE GREECE 1981 Mount Olympus* FU 2017

EUROPE IRELAND 1982

Killarney* PR 2017 5 ; 7 (full periodic review form requested)

EUROPE IRELAND 1981 Dublin Bay (former North Bull Island) * EXT 2015 Extension and renaming

EUROPE MONTENEGRO

1976

Tara River Basin* letter 2017

No report. Letter (2016) requesting extension for submission. UNESCO Venice mission February 2017.

EUROPE POLAND 1976 Masurian lakes (former Luknajno Lake) EXT 2017 Extension and renaming approved


8

EUROPE POLAND 1992

Tatra* (TBR) FU 2017 national periodic review report by 15th May

EUROPE POLAND 1998

East Carpathians * 2017 Request for national report by 15th May

EUROPE ROMANIA 1998 Danube Delta PR National report (2003)

EUROPE ROMANIA 1979 Pietrosul Mare* No report

EUROPE ROMANIA 1979 Retezat* No report

EUROPE PORTUGAL 1981 Paul do Boquilobo* FU 2016

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1984 Astrakhan* PR 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1986 Baikalsky * FU 2016

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1986 Barguzinskiy* FU 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1985 Central Forest State* Tsentralnosnoy FU 2017

EUROPE RUSIAN FEDERATION 1993 Cherny Je Zemli No report sent

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 2002 Commander Islands * FU 2016

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1997 Daursky* FU 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 2003 Far East Marine* FU 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 2000 Katunskiy* FU 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1978

Kavkazsky* FU 2017 3,4,5,6, Recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1984 Kronoksky* FU 2017


Laplandskiy* PR 2017 3, 4, 6 recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 2002 Nizhegorodskoye Zavolje* FU 2017 5 zonation (buffer zone)


Okskiy (Oka)* FU 2017 4, 5, 6, 7 Recommendation for withdrawal

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1984 Pechoro-Ilychskiy* FU 2017 3, 4 (development function)

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1978 Priosko-Terrasnyi* FU 2017


Sayano-Shushensiy* PR 2017 3, 4, 5, 6 and no human population, recommended for withdrawal

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1978 Sikhote Aline* FU 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1984 Sokhondinsky* FU 2017


9

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1995 Taimyrskiy* FU 2017


Teberdinsky (Teberda)* FU 2017 5, 7 (zonation and management plan)

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1978 Tsentralno-Chernozemnyi* FU 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1986 Tsentralnosibirskii* FU 2017 5 (zonation)

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1997 Ubsunurskaya Kotlovina* FU 2017

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 2001 Visimskiy* FU 2017


Vodlozersky* FU 2017 4, 5, 6, (development function, zonation)

EUROPE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 1984 Voronezhsky* FU 2017

EUROPE SERBIA 2001 Golija-Studenica* FU 2017

EUROPE SLOVAKIA 1998

East Carpathians (TBR)* 2017 Request for extension of time to submit national report (sept 2017)

EUROPE SLOVAKIA 1992

Tatra (TBR)* 2017 Request for extension of time to submit national report (sept 2017

EUROPE SLOVAKIA 1990 Polana * FU 2016

EUROPE SLOVENIA 2003 Julian Alps PR 2014

EUROPE SPAIN 1992 Cuenca Alta del Rio Manzanares* FU 2017

EUROPE SPAIN 1977 Grazalema* PR 2015

EUROPE SPAIN 1995 Sierra de las Nieves y su Entorno * FU 2016

EUROPE SPAIN 1983 Sierras de Cazorla, Segura y las Villas* PR 2015

EUROPE SPAIN 1980 Mancha Humeda* PR 2014

EUROPE SPAIN 1983 Marismas del Odiel EXT 2017

EUROPE UKRAINE 1998 Danube Delta PR National report (2010)

EUROPE UKRAINE 1998 East Carpathians* (TBR) national report not received

EUROPE UK 1976 North Norfolk Coast* W 2014 Self withdrawal

EUROPE UK 1976 Wester Ross (Former Beinn Eighe *) EXT 2016 Extension and renaming

EUROPE USA 1976 Aleutian Islands No report received

EUROPE USA 1976 Big Bend* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1981 Big Thicket* PR 2017

EUROPE USA 1976 Beaver Creek No report received


10

EUROPE USA 1983 California Coast Ranges letter 2017 Self withdraw

1986 Carolinian South Atlantic letter 2017 Self withdraw

EUROPE USA 1976 Cascade head* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1976

Central Gulf Coastal Plain* Letter 2017 Request for extension of time to submit the report (legal issue)

EUROPE USA 1989 Champlain-Adirondack* PR 2017

EUROPE USA 1976 Channel Islands* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1976 Crown of the Continent (former Glacier) * FU 2017 Extension and renaming

EUROPE USA 1976 Coram No report received

EUROPE USA 1976 Denali* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1976 Desert Letter 2017 Self withdrawal

EUROPE USA 1976 Everglades and Dry Tortugas* FU 2017 5,6 (zonation and governance)

EUROPE USA 1976 Fraser No report

EUROPE USA 1976 Glacier Bay-Admiralty Island FU 2017 Request for extension of deadline

EUROPE USA 1988 Golden Gate* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1981 Guanica No report received

EUROPE USA

1976

H. J. Andrews letter 2017

Request for extension of time for submission of the report to merge with three sisters BR

EUROPE USA 1980 Hawaiian Islands* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1976

Hubbard Brook PR 2015 3, 5 request for periodic review form

EUROPE USA 1980 Isle Royale* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1976 Jornada* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1978

Konza Prairie Research Natural Area PR 2014 4, 5 request for periodic review form

EUROPE USA 1991 Land between the lake No report

EUROPE USA 1976 Luquillo* FU 2017 5 zonation map

EUROPE USA 1990 Mammoth Cave* FU 2017 5 zonation map

EUROPE USA 1984 Mojave and Colorado Deserts* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1988 New Jersey Pinelands* FU 2017 5 zonation


11

EUROPE USA

1979

Niwot Ridge* PR 2014

4, 5 (zonation and development function) new periodic review from requested

EUROPE USA

1976

Noatak* PR 2014

4, 5 (zonation and development function) new periodic review from requested

EUROPE USA 1976 Olympic National Park* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1976

Organ Pipe* FU 2017 4,5,67 submit new nomination proposal

EUROPE USA 1976 Rocky Mountain* PR 2016

EUROPE USA 1976

San Dimas Experimental Forest* letter 2017 Request for extension of time for submission of the report

EUROPE USA 1976 San Joaquin Experimental Range* FU 2017 4, 5, 6

EUROPE USA 1976 Sequoia and Kings Canyon* FU 2017 5, 6

EUROPE USA 1983 South Atlantic Coastal Plain* PR 2014

EUROPE USA 1983

Congaree (former South Atlantic Coastal Plain)* EXT REN 2017 Renaming and extension

EUROPE USA 1988 Southern Appalachian* FU 2017

EUROPE USA 1976 Stanislas-Tuolumne No report

EUROPE USA

1976

Three Sisters* letter 2017

Request for extension of time for submission of the report, merging with H.J. Andrews

EUROPE USA 1979

University of Michigan Biological Station* letter 2017 Request for extension of time for submission of the report

EUROPE USA 1976

Virgin Islands* 2017 Request for extension of time for submission of the report

EUROPE USA 1979

Virginia Coast Reserve* PR 2015 5 (zonation map) and periodic review form

EUROPE USA 1976

Yellowstone National Park* letter 2017 Request for extension of time for submission of the report

LAC ARGENTINA 1982 Laguna Blanca* PR 2017

LAC ARGENTINA 1984 Costero del Sur* PR 2017 5. zonation issue


12

LAC ARGENTINA 2000 Delta del Paraná* PR 2016

LAC ARGENTINA 1986 Ñacuñán* PR 2017

LAC ARGENTINA 1980 San Guillermo* FU 2016 Last PR sent 2000

LAC BOLIVIA 1977 Pilon lajas* No report - See IACBR 2013

LAC BOLIVIA 1977 Ulla Ulla * No report - See IACBR 2013

LAC BRASIL 2001 Amazônia Central* PR 2016

LAC BRASIL 2001 Caatinga* PR 2016

LAC BRASIL 1993 Cerrado* PR 2017

LAC BRAZIL 2000 Pantanal* FU 2017

LAC CHILI 1977 Archipiélago Juan Fernandez* PR 2017 5. zonation issue

LAC CHILI 1983 Araucarias* PR 2017

LAC CHILI 1984 Campana-Peñuelas* PR 2017

LAC CHILI 1979 Laguna San Rafael* PR 2017 5. zonation issue & 7.(b)

LAC CHILI 1981 Lauca* PR 2017 5. zonation issue & 7.(b)

LAC CHILI 1978 Torres del Paine* PR 2017 5. zonation issue

LAC COSTA RICA 1982 La Amistad* PR 2015

LAC COSTA RICA 1988 Cordillera Volcanica Central * EXT 2010 Extension

LAC CUBA 1984 Sierra del Rosario* No report

LAC CUBA 1987 Cuchillas del Toa* No report

LAC CUBA 1987 Peninsula de Guanahacabibes* No report

LAC CUBA 1987 Baconao* No report

LAC DOMINICAN REPUBLIC 2002 Jaragua-Bahoruco-Enriquillo* PR 2015

LAC ECUADOR 1989 Yasunì* PR 2017 5. zonation issue/ oil extraction

LAC ECUADOR 1984 Archipiélago de Colón* PR 2016

LAC ECUADOR 2000 Sumaco* PR 2016

LAC GUATEMALA 1990

Maya* FU 2017 Insufficient information; new PR requested

LAC GUATEMALA 1992 Sierra de las Minas* FU 2017

LAC HONDURAS 1980 Rio Platano* PR 2015 4 & 5 zonation issue

LAC MEXICO 1993 Alto Golfo de California y El Pinacate (renaming, former

Alto Golfo de California) * PR 2014 Renaming


13

LAC MEXICO 2003 Banco Chinchorro PR 2016

LAC MEXICO 1993 El Triunfo * PR 2016

LAC MEXICO 1995 Islas del Golfo de California* PR 2014 5. zonation issue

LAC MEXICO 1993

El Vizcaino* No report See IACBR 2013

LAC MEXICO 1977 La Michilia * No report

LAC MEXICO 1986 Sian Ka’an * PR 2016

LAC NICARAGUA 1997

Bosawas* No report - Letter sent Feb 2014 indicating that they need more time

LAC NICARAGUA 2003

Rio San Juan* No report - Letter sent Feb 2014 indicating that they need more time

LAC PANAMA 1983 Darien* PR 2017 5. zonation map

LAC PANAMA 2000 La Amistad* PR 2017 5. zonation map

LAC PERU 1977 Noroeste * EXT 2016 Extension and renaming

LAC VENEZUELA 1993 Alto Orinoco Casiquiare* PR 2017 5. zonation issue & 7.(b)

Transboundary Biosphere Reserves

AFRICA BURKINA FASO/BENIN/NIGER 2002 W Transboundary Biosphere Reserve (TBR) * FU 2017

EUROPE POLAND/SLOVAKIA 1992 Tatra * (TBR) FU 2016 7; management plan

EUROPE POLAND/SLOVAKIA/ UKRAINE 1998 East Carpathians TBR * FU 2016

EUROPE ROMANIA/UKRAINE 1998 Danube Delta* (TBR) FU 2017

annex 1 synthesis for recommendations (2014-2017) … … · annex 1 synthesis for recommendations...

Documents