and in the matter of: an application from the manitoba ... · insurance corp·oration pursuant to...

12
IN THE MATTER OF: The Public Utilities Board Act, C.C.S.M. c.P280 AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba Public Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown Corporations Public Review Accountability and Consequential Amendments Act. I, Jenna Christoph, of the City of Winnipeg, in the Province of Manitoba, MAKE OATH AND SAY: 1. THAT attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "A" to this my Affidavit is the unsigned Public Utilities Board Notice of Public Hearing and Pre- Hearing Conference filed with the 2017 rates application. 2. THAT attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "B" to this my Affidavit is a list of parties that the Public Utilities Board required The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation to serve a copy of the 2017 rates application, together with the said Exhibit "A", upon. 3. THAT on June 17, 2016, I instructed First Choice Courier to deliver a copy of the 2017 rates application, together with a copy of Exhibit "A", on those parties listed on Exhibit "B" 4. That attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "C" to this my Affidavit is The Public Utilities Board Notice of Public Hearing and Pre-Hearing Conference duly signed by Jennifer Dubois, Assistant Associate Secretary of The Public Utilities Board, and dated June 17, 2016. October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13 PDF Page 1

Upload: lamkien

Post on 27-Jul-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

IN THE MATTER OF: The Public Utilities Board Act, C.C.S.M. c.P280

AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba Public Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown Corporations Public Review Accountability and Consequential Amendments Act.

I, Jenna Christoph, of the City of Winnipeg, in the Province of

Manitoba, MAKE OATH AND SAY:

1. THAT attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "A" to this my

Affidavit is the unsigned Public Utilities Board Notice of Public Hearing and Pre-

Hearing Conference filed with the 2017 rates application.

2. THAT attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "B" to this my

Affidavit is a list of parties that the Public Utilities Board required The Manitoba

Public Insurance Corporation to serve a copy of the 2017 rates application,

together with the said Exhibit "A", upon.

3. THAT on June 17, 2016, I instructed First Choice Courier to deliver

a copy of the 2017 rates application, together with a copy of Exhibit "A", on those

parties listed on Exhibit "B"

4. That attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "C" to this my Affidavit

is The Public Utilities Board Notice of Public Hearing and Pre-Hearing

Conference duly signed by Jennifer Dubois, Assistant Associate Secretary of The

Public Utilities Board, and dated June 17, 2016.

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 1

Page 2: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

- 2 -

5. THAT attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "D" to this my

Affidavit is a list of the parties that the Public Utilities Board required The

Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation to mail or email copies of Exhibit C to.

6. THAT on or about June 17, 2016, I caused to be mailed, by

ordinary mail postage prepaid, or emailed, one copy of Exhibit "C" to this my

Affidavit to each of the parties referred to in Exhibit "B" hereto.

7. THAT on or about June 17, 2016, I caused to be sent, by email,

one copy of Exhibit "C" to this my Affidavit to each of the parties referred to in

Exhibit "D" hereto.

SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City

of Winnipeg, in the Province

of Manitoba, this 4th day of

October, 2016

)

)

)

)

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 2

Page 3: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

June 17, 2016

Thi.-, Is Exhibit ".LL.11 Referred To

2017 RATE APPLICATION Media Package Notice of Hearing - MP.4

In The Affidavit of __ J.enL1,c _____ _ THE PUBLIC UTILITIES BOARD NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING AND PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE

LY/J,ishv<.l:L" ___ Sworn Before Me

At The City of Winnipeg In Manitoba . qri1 /),.;, , ·11) 'f.. Applicant: Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation

This ..... :~!.Ol-v.. .. .Ylf.f A.D.4'WL"' .. .4w1-iA)K'fi6~8''tJJ)lh? . . . · ... T 11-i !or the Province 01 Mamtob-a "

1 a "' ' HEARING:

RATE IMPACT:

The Public Utilities Board (Board) anticipates holding a public hearing of an application from Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation (MPI) for approval ·of rates and premiums for compulsory vehicle and driver insurance as of March 1, 2017. The hearing would take place at the Board's Hearing Room, 4th Floor, 330 Portage Avenue, Winnipeg, MB (commencing at 9:00 a.m.) on October 13, 2016. A Pre-Hearing Conference is to be c6nvened by the Board in its offices at 9:00 a.m. on June 30, 2016.

The Corporation is requesting approval for Basic Autopac vehicle and drivers licence insurance rates and premiums effective March 1, 2017, which, if approved, will result in 2% overall change in MPI's Basic premium revenue (excluding the impact of vehicle upgrades and an increased overall driver and vehicle population) . The Corporation is also requesting an Interest Rate Forecast Risk Factor, effective March 1, 2017, to be developed collaboratively through the General Rate Application process.

Actual vehicle and driver premiums would vary depending on claim and driving experience, insurance use, territory and vehicle rate group. Full particulars, including the rate impact and application, can be found on the Manitoba Public Insurance website www.mpi.mb.ca.

PDF Page 1

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 3

Page 4: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

June 17, 2016

PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE:

GENERAL INFORMATION:

-2-

2017 RATE APPLICATION Media Package. Notice of Hearing - MP.4

Those seeking Intervener status should notify the Board of their intention by applying to the Board Secretary before the now scheduled Pre­Hearing Conference of June 30, 2016. Interveners may be entitled to financial assistance, and the Board's Rules of Practice and Procedure (Rules) provide the related guidelines, which can be seen at the Board's

·website www.pub.gov.mb.ca or obtained on request to the Board, by either emailing ([email protected]), writing or calling the Board Secretary (204-945-2638 or 1-866-854-3698, toll free). Parties wishing to submit a brief or to express comments at the hearing should also contact the Board Secretary.

Interested parties should take note that the Board does not have jurisdiction over the MPI lines of business denoted as Extension or SRE, or as to MPI's Driver and Vehicle Licensing operation.

Persons seeking further information as to MPI's application, or with respect to the Board's process, and/or wishing to addre~s the public hearing in French should notify the Board Secretary by August 26, 2016. As well, interested parties may examine MPI's application and supporting materials, either at the offices of the Corporation or on its website, or the Board's office.

The Manitoba Ombudsman has recently issued privacy guidelines for administrative tribunals. The Board is mindful of its obligations under those guidelines. Its decisions in respect of the application being considered will be sensitive to the guidelines. Personal information will not be disclosed unless it is appropriate and necessary to do so. However, the Board advises participants that these proceedings are public and that as a result, personal information protections are reduced.

PDF Page 2

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 4

Page 5: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

June 17, 2016

CONTACT INFORMATION: The Public Utilities Board 400 - 330 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C OC4 Website: www.pub.gov.mb.ca Telephone: ( 2 04) 945-2 6.38 Toll-Free: (866) 854-3698

-3-

2017 RATE APPLICATION Media Package Notice of Hearing - MP.4

Email: publicutilit:[email protected]

DATED this xxth day of June, 2016.

Wheeichair access is available

Five days notice required

'I

D. Christle Secretary and Executive Director The Public Utilities Board

PDF Page 3

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 5

Page 6: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

APPENDIX "Bn

Automo.tive Recyclers of Manitoba (ARM) Ltd. Box 43049 RPO Kildonan Place Winnipeg, Manitoba, R2C SGS

Bike Winnipeg c/o Mr. Christian Monniri Suite 2670, 360 Main Street Winnipeg, MB RJC 3Z3

... This Is Exhibit " .. B. .... " Referred To In The Affidavit oL;J.t!ona .......... . (

,,_ •--1., . h . - J.JCJ,)JJJf!.------Swom Before Me At The City of Winnipeg In Manitoba

This !1!'~'-D~ otQ:i.r CJ; ~·D;.2!/llz ' vti.~J. lt1n1,41 f-" .

A N,.,tii1Y Pub!ld m MY for the Province ct Manitoba

Consumers' Association of Canada (Manitoba) Inc. c/o Mr. Byron Williams, Director Public Interest Law Centre 200-393 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3B 3H6

CAA Manitoba Motor League Ms. Erika Milier P. o. Box 1400 870 Empress Street Winnipeg, MB R3C 2~3

Coaiition of Manitoba Motorcycle Groups Inc. Mr. Raymond P. Oakes Booth, Dennehy, Parieniuk & Ernst 387 Broadway Winnipeg, MB R3C OV5

Insurance Brokers Association of Manitoba Mr. David Schioler 600-144S Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3G 3P4

Manitoba Used Car Deal~rs Association Mr. Nick Roberts 110. Alburg Drive Winnipeg, MB R2N 119

Thursday, June 16, 2016

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 6

Page 7: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

Thi.s Is Exhibit " __ c_ __ " Referred To

In The Affidavit of.Ji:/11.1.(~--~---·· Ch.v1~fo v li s · ··B·. c M -----r:l-------- worn· eiore e THE PUBLIC UTILITIES BOARD

NOTICE OF HEARING At The City of Winnipeg Iri Manitoba

This fj{~·~,-~ y Of .f&,te~~r A.D.2.0lGJ~ ~~/Vi1.l,.l~

·· A l\!otary ~If¢" 7,. ·-AND PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE Applicant: Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation

in and for the Provines ot.Manltob-'J. ·

·HEARING:

RATE IMPACT:

PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE:

Room 400 - 330 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C OC4 www.pub.gov.mb.ca

·The Public Utilities Board (Board) anticipates holding a public hearing of an application from Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation (MPI) for approval of rates and premiums for c.ompulsory vehicle and driver insurance as of March 1, 2017. The hearing would take place at the Board's Hearing Room, 4th

Floor, 330 Portage Avenue, Winnipeg, MB (commencing at9:00 a.m.) on October 13, 2016. A Pre-Hearing Confererwe is to be convened by the Board in its offices at 9:00 a.m. on June 30, 2016.

The Corporation is requesting approval for Basic Autopac vehicle and drivers licence insurance rates and premiums effective March 1, 2017, which, if approved, will result in 2% overall change in MPl's Basic premium revenue (excluding the impact of vehicle upgrades and an increased overall driver and vehicle population). The Corporation is also requesting an Interest Rate Forecast Risk Factor, effective March 1, 2017, to be developed collaboratively through the General Rate Application process.

Actual vehicle and driver premiums would vary depending on claim and driving experience, insurance use, territory and vehicle rate group. Full particulars, including the rate impact and application, can be found on the Manitoba Public Insurance Website: www.mpi.mb.ca.

Those seeking Intervener status should notify the Board of their intention by applying to the Board Secretary before the now scheduled Pre-Hearing Conference of June 30, 2016. · lnterveners may be entitled to financial assistance, and the Board's Rules of Practice and Procedure (Rules) provide the

330, avenue Portage, piece 400 Winnipeg (Manitoba) Canada R3C OC4 www.pub.gov.mb.ca

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 7

Page 8: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

GENERAL INFORMATION:

related guidelines, which can be seen at the Board's website: www.pub.gov.mb.ca or obtained on request to the Board, by either emailing ([email protected]), writing or calling the Board Secretary (204-945-2638or1-866-854-3698, toll free). Parties wishing to submit a brief or to express comments at.the hearing should also contact the Board Secretary.

Interested parties should take note that the Board do.es not · have jurisdiction over the MPI lines of business denoted as Extension or SRE, or as to MPl's Driver and Vehicle Licensing operations.

Persons seeking further information as to MPl's application, or with respect to the Board's process, and/or wishing to address the public hearing in French should notify the Board Secretary by August 26, 2016. As well, interested parties may examine MPl's application and supporting materials, either at the offices of the Corporation or on its website, or the Board's office.

The Manitoba Ombudsman has recently issued privacy guidelines for administrative tribunals. The Board is mindful of its obligations under those guidelines. Its decisions in respect of the application being considered will be sensitive to the guidelines. Personal information will not be disclosed unless it is appropriate and necessary to do so. However, the Board advises participants that these proceedings are public and that as a result, personal information protections are reduced.

CONTACT INFORMATION:

The Public Utilities Board 400- 330 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C OC4 Website: www.pub.gov.mb.ca Telephone: (204) 945.;2638 Toll-Free: (866) 854-3698 Email: [email protected]

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 8

Page 9: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

-3-

DATED this 1ih day of June, 2016.

Wheelchair access is available

\ ~· ;· Ui1

Five days notice required

Jennifer Dubois, CPA, CMA Assistant Associate Secretary The Public Utilities Board

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 9

Page 10: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

APPENDIX "A"

Manitoba Chambers of Commerce Chuck Davidson, President & CEO 227 Portage Avenue. Winnipeg, MB R3B 2A6 [email protected]

~randon Chamber of Commerce Ms. Carolynn Cancade, General ,Manager 1043 Rosser Avenue Brandon, ~MB R7A OL5 [email protected]

Winnipeg Chamberof Commerce Dave Angus, President and· CEO 100 - 259 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3B 2A9 [email protected] .

Association of Manitoba Municipalities Joe Masii Executive Director 1910 Saskatchewan Avenue W. Portage la Prairie, MB RlN 0~1 jmasi@arnrn~mb.ca

Manitoba Association for Rights and Liberties Michelle Falk Executive Director 507 - 294 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C OB9

Manitoba Motor Dealers Association Mr. Geoff Sine Executive Director Ste. 230, 530 Century Winnipeg, MB R3H OY4 [email protected]

[email protected]

Automotive Trades Association (Man) Inc. Ms. Jean McKenzie, Administrative Assistant 112 ,- 1790 Wellington Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3H 1B2 [email protected]

This !s Exhibit 11_.J),,, .... " Referred To In The Affidavit oC;[:;,t':Jfll.:J. r..•J,.. ' . ' •a••••••

-0:1:!.n s:fonh 'Swo B ~ --~--r--,---- 7• m e~ore Me At 111e·City of Winnipeg In Manitoba Th. 'f f-'1 . . /;'} ,J. I is ---k-Da ~Of J,,~f= .. tOCY A.D. ?£!&.

, _p.-1/Vl/l.,,l(' ,'/.tJ/]~zC_ ... · '1 A Nota " blic / -

· In an~ for the Province of Manitob-a

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 10

Page 11: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

.-

Manitoba Taxicab Board Shelly,E'erens, Director & Secretary 200 - ~01 Wes~on Street · Winnipeg, MB, R3E 3~4 .

· Shelly. Ferens@gov .rnb. ca . taxl.'cabboardoffice@gov .rnb. ca

. ·.) '.• .. '

Bike Winnipeg Inc Mr.· -Jeremy Hull, Co-'Chair [email protected]

Mr. Mark Cohoe, Executive Directo~ [email protected] 3ra ·Floor, 303 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, -MB R3B 2B4

CUPW - Red River Looa·l Mr. George McCall P.O. Box 1 ~innipeg, MB R3C 2Gl

Harold Rubin 42 Daffodil Street Winnipeg, MB R2V 2Zl

Mr. Doug Houghton Box 1120 Beausejour, MB ROE OCO

Ms. Sofia Mirza President Manitoba Bar Association 1020-444 St. Mary Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C 3Tl

Ms. Janet ·Jardine Booth Dennehy LLP 387 Broadway Winnipeg, MB R3C OV5

Mr. Brent McNaught Vespa Winnipeg 634 Portage.Avenue Winnipeg, MB R3C OG6

Mr. Andrew Chirnko 302 - 119 Swindon Way Winnipeg, MB R3P OW3

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 11

Page 12: AND IN THE MATTER OF: An Application from The Manitoba ... · Insurance Corp·oration pursuant to The Crown ... SWORN BEFORE ME, at the City of Winnipeg, ... overall change in MPI's

I

Ms. Ruth Adams 3-425 Henderson Hwy Winnipeg, MB R2K 2H4

Mr. Virgilio C. Ramos 369 Banning Street Winnipeg, MB R3G 2E6

Eduard Hiebert 2186 Hwy 26

·St. Francois Xavier, M~ 'R4L 1B3

David Gurvey 35 Duncan Norrie Prive Winnipeg, MB R3P 2Kl

Mr. Jim Penziwol

1>'

Manitoba Association of Automobile Clubs [email protected]

Mr. Grant Parson [email protected]

Mr. Robyn Gray 183 Pinedale Avenue Winnipeg, MB R2H 1R7

Adrian Halpert 157 Foxmeadow Drive Winnipeg, MB R3P 1T7

Ms. Jill Ruth Headingley Sport Shop Ltd. 5160 Portage Avenue Winnipeg, MB R4H lEl [email protected]

Mr. Bruce Zeemel 59 cambie Road Winnipeg, MB R2C 4E6 [email protected]

October 7, 2016 2017 GRA - MPI Exhibit #13

PDF Page 12