analysis of the improvement effect of expansive soil through the soil-water characteristic curve

6
Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development Vol. 6 ,No. 4(2012)036 Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil-water Characteristic Curve * YANG Heping() * * ,LIN Liping(88�) ,XIAO Jie( �t) ,ZHAN WentaoOl�) ( Research Institute of Special Soil Engineering, Changsha University of Science and Technology, Changsha Hunan 410004, China) Abstract: This study aims to establish the relationship between the theory of unsaturated soil and the corresponding engineering problem by using the soil-water characteristic curve to determine the improvement ect of expansive soil. The contents of two improvers, i.e., lime and fiy ash, were added into Baise expansive soil for free expansion ratio testing. Based on the optimum moisture contents determined by using the modified Proctor compaction method, testing specimens of each improved soil sample were obtained. By dewetting the soil-water characteristic curve testing in the range of 5 kPa to 1 000 kPa by using a pressure plate apparatus, the expansion properties and soil-water characteristic curves of the improved expansive soils were determined. The effect of different improvers and mixing contents on the soil-water characteristic curves, which were fitted by the variance gamma model, was analyzed based on the theory of unsaturated soil and on the national determination criterion for expansive soils. Saturated gravity water content, air entry value, residual water content, and curve slope were found to have potential for use in evaluating the chemical improvement effect on expansive soils. Further analysis shows that the improvement effect can be determined if three of the four indexes of expansive soil meet the requirements. However, saturated gravity water content is in- dispensable, but any two of the remaining three indexes can be considered. Key words: road engineering; unsaturated soil; soil-water characteristic curve; expansive soil; chemical improvement; evalua- tion of effect 1 Introduction Considerable attention has been accorded to the is- sue of how expansive soil can be rationally utilized to re- duce its destructiveness to infrastructure and the environ- ment. The common method for treating expansive soil continues to be chemical improvement, with lime, fly ash, cement, etc. , used as modifiers. Improvement effects are evaluated by using the swell-shrink in- dex [I - 4] . Unsaturated soil remams a research hotspot in the field of geotechnical engineering. The soil-water charac- teristic curve ( SWCC) of unsaturated soil has signifi- cance in explaining and predicting the engineering char- acteristics of unsaturated soil, including seepage flow, strength, and volume change [5 -7]. However, most re- searchers focus on theory. Thus, only few findings have been implemented in actual projects. reference [8] out- lines the application of SWCC in determining the lower limit of suitable soil water in crop non-sufficient irriga- Manuscript received March 12, 2012 tion. SWCC was applied to landslide forecasting in refer- ence [9]. To establish the relationship between unsatu- rated soil behavior and corresponding engineering prob- lems, SWCC is used to discuss the improvement effects on expansive soil (as subgrade filler) . In this paper, va- rious modifiers at different concentrations were added to expansive soil. The optimum water contents and maxi- mum dry density of testing specimens were determined by using the modified compaction method. Dewetting SWCC tests were conducted by using a pressure plate apparatus to analyze variations in the four indexes of SWCc. Ac- cording to the free expansion ratio, the evaluation indexes and the values of improvement effects on expansive soil were established based on the unsaturated soil theory. 2 Basic experiment 2.1 Main technique theroy The SWCC has recently been thought to have poten- tial for use in analyzing the soil improvement effect. However, when the determination of whether expansive , Supported by the National Nataral Science Foundation of China e No. 50978035 ) ; and the Road and Transpont R & D Proj ect for Western Regions of China Commissioned by MOC e No.200831800089 ) E-mail address:c[email protected] J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev. (English Ed.) 2012.6:36-41. Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by UNIVERSITY OF NORTH TEXAS LIB on 11/28/14. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.

Upload: wentao

Post on 04-Apr-2017

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil-water Characteristic Curve

Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development Vol. 6 ,No. 4(2012 )036

Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the

Soil-water Characteristic Curve *

YANG Heping(i%fIJ¥-) * * ,LIN Liping(;f;fc88�) ,XIAO Jie( �?tt) ,ZHAN WentaoOl)(�)

( Research Institute of Special Soil Engineering, Changsha University of Science and Technology, Changsha Hunan 410004, China)

Abstract: This study aims to establish the relationship between the theory of unsaturated soil and the corresponding engineering

problem by using the soil-water characteristic curve to determine the improvement effect of expansive soil. The contents of two

improvers, i. e. , lime and fiy ash, were added into Baise expansive soil for free expansion ratio testing. Based on the optimum

moisture contents determined by using the modified Proctor compaction method, testing specimens of each improved soil sample

were obtained. By dewetting the soil-water characteristic curve testing in the range of 5 kPa to 1 000 kPa by using a pressure

plate apparatus, the expansion properties and soil-water characteristic curves of the improved expansive soils were determined.

The effect of different improvers and mixing contents on the soil-water characteristic curves, which were fitted by the variance

gamma model, was analyzed based on the theory of unsaturated soil and on the national determination criterion for expansive

soils. Saturated gravity water content, air entry value, residual water content, and curve slope were found to have potential for

use in evaluating the chemical improvement effect on expansive soils. Further analysis shows that the improvement effect can be

determined if three of the four indexes of expansive soil meet the requirements. However, saturated gravity water content is in­

dispensable, but any two of the remaining three indexes can be considered.

Key words: road engineering; unsaturated soil; soil-water characteristic curve; expansive soil; chemical improvement; evalua­

tion of effect

1 Introduction

Considerable attention has been accorded to the is­

sue of how expansive soil can be rationally utilized to re­

duce its destructiveness to infrastructure and the environ­

ment. The common method for treating expansive soil

continues to be chemical improvement, with lime, fly

ash, cement, etc. , used as modifiers. Improvement

effects are evaluated by using the swell-shrink in­

dex[I-4].

Unsaturated soil remams a research hotspot in the

field of geotechnical engineering. The soil-water charac­

teristic curve ( SWCC) of unsaturated soil has signifi­

cance in explaining and predicting the engineering char­

acteristics of unsaturated soil, including seepage flow,

strength, and volume change [5 -7]. However, most re­

searchers focus on theory. Thus, only few findings have

been implemented in actual projects. reference [8] out­

lines the application of SWCC in determining the lower

limit of suitable soil water in crop non-sufficient irriga-

Manuscript received March 12, 2012

tion. SWCC was applied to landslide forecasting in refer­

ence [9]. To establish the relationship between unsatu­

rated soil behavior and corresponding engineering prob­

lems, SWCC is used to discuss the improvement effects

on expansive soil (as sub grade filler) . In this paper, va­

rious modifiers at different concentrations were added to

expansive soil. The optimum water contents and maxi­

mum dry density of testing specimens were determined by

using the modified compaction method. Dewetting SWCC

tests were conducted by using a pressure plate apparatus

to analyze variations in the four indexes of SWCc. Ac­

cording to the free expansion ratio, the evaluation indexes

and the values of improvement effects on expansive soil

were established based on the unsaturated soil theory.

2 Basic experiment

2.1 Main technique theroy

The SWCC has recently been thought to have poten­

tial for use in analyzing the soil improvement effect.

However, when the determination of whether expansive

, Supported by the National Nataral Science Foundation of China e No. 50978035 ) ; and the Road and Transpont R & D Project for

Western Regions of China Commissioned by MOC e No. 200831800089 )

• • E-mail address:[email protected]

J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev. (English Ed.) 2012.6:36-41.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

asc

elib

rary

.org

by

UN

IVE

RSI

TY

OF

NO

RT

H T

EX

AS

LIB

on

11/2

8/14

. Cop

yrig

ht A

SCE

. For

per

sona

l use

onl

y; a

ll ri

ghts

res

erve

d.

Page 2: Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil-water Characteristic Curve

YANG Heping,et al : Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil- water Characteristic Curve 37

soil doped with lime achieves modification cannot be

evaluated through the analysis of SWCC, the contents of

improved soil can be identified with the use of an existing

assessment criterion, which is the free expansion ratio,

Based on this ratio, the change in the main parameters of

the SWCC of the improved soil induced by the increased

concentrations of ameliorants can be analyzed, and the

optimal materials and conditions for the test can be indi­

rectly determined theoretically, Existing research high­

lights that initial water content, dry density, and com­

paction energy are the primary influencing factors of the

linear shape of the SWCC [!OJ, In engineering practice,

the requirements of subgrade compaction are satisfied by

controlling optimum moisture content and maximum dry

density. The modified SWCC test can be performed by

modification, but also agrees with actual working condi­

tions. In this study, relevant experiments on improved

soils involving the compactions, SWCC, and free expan­

sion ratio tests were conducted to determine the optimum

water content and maximum dry density.

2. 2 Test material, method and sample preparation

Baise expansive soil was used as test soil. Liuyang

Jiuxi quicklime and Yueyang Power Plant fly ash were

used as modifiers. The main properties of the materials

are shown in tables 1 to 3. In this paper, the modifier is

uniformly mixed with the expansive soil, and blending

dose refers to the mass ratio of former to the air-dried ex­

pansive soil. Based on previous studies [II J, considering

the decrease in the expansive characteristic of the soil

and the quantity and period of the tests, the dosage of

preparing specimens using the aforementioned compac- modifier can be determined as follows: mixing contents of

tion method, which not only guarantees the reliability of quicklime are 0% , 3 % , 5 %, and 7 %, whereas those

the test results in terms of evaluating the findings on of fly ash are 0% , 5 % , 10% , and 15 % .

Tab. 1 Physical properties of Baise expansive soil

Specific gravity

2. 75

Liquid limit ( % )

58.2

Plastic limit ( % )

24.2

Plasticity Free expansive index ( % ) ratio ( % )

34 63

Tab. 2 Chemical properties of lime (unit: %)

Name Content of CaO and MgO Content of CaO Grade

Quicklime 76 73.5 Calcium level 3

55.1

Tab. 3 Chemical properties fly -ash (unit: % )

Content of active ingredient

4.65 23.0 7

CaO

5.89

MgO

4.93

Loss on ignition

1. 02 4.84

Free expansion ratio was measured according to the

Test Methods of Soils for Highway Engineering (JTG

E40-2007) [IZJ. The compaction test index refers to the

Test Methods of Soils for Highway Engineering (JTG E

40-2007) . SWCC tests were performed by using a

pressure plate produced by the Soil Moisture Company,

United States. The gravity water content of the samples

was tested at suctions of 5, 10, 25 , 50, 100, 200, 400,

600, 800, and 1 000 kPa.

2.3 Test results

2.3. 1 Compaction and free expansion ratio tests

Table 4 shows the results of compaction test, where­

as compaction curves are shown in figure 1.

Linear Volume Particle size distribution ( mm ) ( % )

contraction ( % ) contraction ( % ) <0.002 0.002 - 0.0 75 >0.0 75

6.0 19.00 46.2 4 7.6 6.2

Tab. 4 Results of the compaction test

Content of lime ( % ) 0 3 5 7

Optimum water content ( % ) 14. 7 14.1 11. 7 11. 2

Maximum dry density ( glcm ) 1. 90 1. 88 1. 86 1. 85

Content of fly ash ( % ) 0 5 10 15

Optimum water content ( % ) 14. 7 12.2 11. 2 8.4

Maximum dry density ( glcm ) 1. 90 1. 89 1. 81 1. 80

-+- Prue soil ... 10% fly ash i::: �. 5� flyaSh

� 1.78 �\ -+- Prue soil ... 3% lime � 1.92 ___ 5% lime ___ 7% lime

�1.88 � .� 1.84 � 1.80 g 1.76

8 10 12 14 16 18 C 1.74 ��-��-��

20 Ci 5 8 11 14 1 7 20 Water content (%)

(a) Lime-improved soil

Water content (%) (b) Fly ash-improved soil

Fig. 1 Compaction curves

An increase in modifier content evidently facilitates

a decrease in the maximum dry density of improved soil.

This finding can be attributed to a number of reasons, in­

cluding the exchange of Caz + with Na + , the presence of

K + in soil, the clay of soil agglomerates, and the genera­

tion of hydration silicate calcium and calcium aluminate

J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev. (English Ed.) 2012.6:36-41.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

asc

elib

rary

.org

by

UN

IVE

RSI

TY

OF

NO

RT

H T

EX

AS

LIB

on

11/2

8/14

. Cop

yrig

ht A

SCE

. For

per

sona

l use

onl

y; a

ll ri

ghts

res

erve

d.

Page 3: Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil-water Characteristic Curve

38 Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development

gel. The dispersed soil particles overlap and fill in the

pores for form a space-frame structure, which the com­

paction test aims to destroy. Meanwhile, maximum dry

densities and optimum water contents are reduced with

increasing modifier content. This reduction may be at­

tributed to the short chemical reaction time ( only 24 h ) ,

which is insufficient for improved soil. This finding a­

grees with past test results [II]. The free swelling test re­

sults of the soil samples are shown in table 2.

The free expansion ratio of improved soil evidently

decreases with increasing modifier content. Therefore,

soil expansion can be partly or even completely elimina­

ted by increasing modifier content. In the national stand­

ard Construction in Expansive Soil Area Specifications

(GBJl12-87) [13]

as well as in the literature [13-14],

free expansion ( < 40%) is used as a determinant for ex­

pansive soils. Table 5 demonstrates that expansive soil

can be improved as a non-expansive soil after mixing with

a lime content of 5% or fly ash content of 15% .

Tab. 5 Test result of free expansion ratio (unit: %)

Content of lime

Free expansion ratio

Content of fly ash

Free expansion rat.io

2.3. 2 SWCC test

o 63

o 63

3

51

5

55

5

34

10

47

7

25

15

38

The results of the SWCC test for improved soil with

different contents of lime and fly ash are shown in table

6. For analysis and comparison, figures 2 and 3 show the

SWCCs of the two improved soil samples.

Tab. 6 Test result of the SWCCs of improved soil

Different matric suction ( kPa ) gravity water content ( % ) Improved soil

Improved soil with lime

Improved soil with fly ash

Pure soil

3% lime

5% lime

7% lime

Pure soil

5% fly ash

10% fly ash

15% fly ash

0 5

24.5 24.4

23.7 23.6

23.0 22.9

22.5 22.4

24.5 24.4

24.2 24.1

23.5 23.4

23.0 22.8

25� ______ �� � 24� _____ ����, �23 t==========:=;�� � 22 § 21 u � 20

� 19 " C 18

.� 17 o 16

15 0.1

-+- Pure soil --- 3% lime soil ... 5% lime soil • 7% lime soil

10 100 Malric suction (kPa)

10

24.3

23.6

22.8

22.3

24.3

23.9

23.2

22.7

1 000

Fig.2 SWCC bunch of lime-improved soil

3 Fitting and analysis of SWCC liner system

3.1 Fitting of SWCC linear system

20

23.9

23.5

22.5

22. I 23.9

23.7

23

22.6

To achieve the improvement effect through the un­

saturated soil theory, the variance gamma (VG) model

( S-shaped curve model ) is widely used for the fitting of

SWCC. The fitting formula is as follows:

50

22.8

22.7

22.0

21. 8

22.8

22.5

22.4

22.3

100 200 400 600

20.8 18.8 17.5 17

2l. 6 19.8 18.3 17.6

21. 3 20.3 18.7 17.7

21.5 20.7 19.0 17.9

20.8 18.8 17.5 17.1

20.9 19.3 17.8 17.3

20.2 20.3 18.8 18.3

20.5 20.5 19.3 18.5

� 25 � 24���������� C 23f � 22 8 21 � 20

� 19 C 18 ';; 17 � 16

-+- Pure soil ___ 5% fly ash soil ....... 10% fly ash soil -+- 15% fly ash soil

800

16.7

16.9

17.2

17.5

16.7

17.0

18.0

18.2

15 L-������������� 0.1 10 100 1000

Matric suction (kPa)

Hg. 3 SWCC bunch of fly ash-improved soil

() = (), + [1 + (0'1/1) n ] m '

1 000

16.2

16.5

16.7

16.9

16.2

16.5

17.6

18.0

where ex, n, m are fitting parameters; () is gravity water

content; ()s is the saturated water content; (), is the resid­

ual water content; I/J is the matric suction; ex is the recip­

rocal of air entry value I/J b; m, n are experIence con­

stants, which can reflect the degree of changes of water

content with varying suction and describe the shape of soil

water characteristic curve, as known as the shape factor.

J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev. (English Ed.) 2012.6:36-41.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

asc

elib

rary

.org

by

UN

IVE

RSI

TY

OF

NO

RT

H T

EX

AS

LIB

on

11/2

8/14

. Cop

yrig

ht A

SCE

. For

per

sona

l use

onl

y; a

ll ri

ghts

res

erve

d.

Page 4: Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil-water Characteristic Curve

YANG Heping,et al : Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil- water Characteristic Curve 39

Accordingly, When, m = 1 - 1/ n, the best fitting

effect is achieved based on observed values, Thus, the

method is adopted to fit the curves. Figures 4 and 5 show

the results of fitting, whereas the calculated fitting pa­

rameters are shown in table 7.

� 22 " o u t 20 � C 18 .� o 16

--+-- Pure soil --- 3% lime soil � 5% lime soil --- 7% lime soil

10 100 Matric suction (kPa)

1 000

Fig.4 Fitted SWCC bunch of lime-improved soil

� 24 c: " 22 c: 0 u --+-- Pure soil � 20 � ___ 5% fly ash soil " 18 ........ 10% fly ash soil C . ;;: --- 15% fly ash soil e 16 0

10 100 1 000 Matric suction (kPa)

Fig. 5 Fitted SWCC bunch of fly ash-improved soil

Tab.7 Parameters of SWCC of improved soil

fitted by the VG model

Fitting IJ, IJ, Correlation ifih a n m parameters (% ) (% ) coefficient ( kPa )

Pure soil 0.016 1.775 0.437 24.5 15.3 0.999 5 64.4

3%lime soil 0.010 l. 524 0.344 23.7 13.6 0.999 7 99.5

5%lime soil 0.009 1. 117 O. 105 23.0 12.6 0.999 7 116.8

7% lime soil 0.004 l. 462 0.316 22.5 11.5 0.998 4 238. I 5% Oy ash soil 0.015 1.583 0.368 24.2 14.8 0.999 73 65.0

10% Oy ash soil 0.014 l. 356 0.263 23.5 14.0 0.999 15 70.0

15% Oy ash soil 0.009 1.470 0.320 23.0 13.2 0.999 21 116. I The column on the correlation coefficient evidently

shows that the correlation coefficient of experimental data

and the model is above O. 998. The fitting curves are

consistent with the actual SWCCs, indicating that the

effect is sufficient based on the fitting of the SWCC by

the VG model.

3. 2 Analysis of SWCC linear system

Table 7 shows that the three parameters are consist­

ent. With increasing modifier content, ex becomes m­

creasingly smaller ( i. e. , air entry value becomes m­

creasingly larger ) , and saturated water content and re-

sidual water content both decrease.

Two kinds of improved SWCC linear systems are

plotted separately in figures 4 and 5. A comparison of

figures 4 and 5 reveals that the SWCCs of the improved

expansive soils' are similar despite the existence of dis­

tinct turning points. Two feature points ( i. e. , air entry

value and residual water content ) are considered to di­

vide the curve into three sections; each section corre­

sponds to different water conditions.

In analyzing the two SWCC linear systems, the

curves are found to become flatter as the modifier increa­

ses, indicating that improved soil dehydration speed de­

celerates and water holding capacity is strengthened.

These observations indicate that the fine, powder-like

modifiers occupy the pore and combine with the clay at

the contact point, thus altering the particles and the pore

size distribution. Thus, gas is barred from entering the

pores, and air entry value consequently increases.

A convergence of approximately 80 kPa exists at the

suction. This finding suggests that water holding capaci­

ties of soils are altered at the convergence point, which

disagrees with traditional theoretical conclusions a higher

dry density results in higher water holding capacity. The

antinomy may be attributed to the limited number of tests

conducted in the past as well to the fact that only single­

soil sample testing had been conducted by most studies to

obtain and fit SWCC for the establishment of an appropri­

ate theoretical equation. Given the differences in the

slopes of curves ( slope of air entry value and residual

water content ) , the curves are not parallel and create an

intersection. The slopes of curves should be an evalua­

tion index in the analysis of the improvement effect.

4 Assessment of chemical modification

4. 1 Selection of evaluation index

The influence factors of SWCC have been found to

be the mineral composition in soils, pore structure, tem­

perature, confining pressure, initial water content, dry

density, compaction work, etc. [10]. The effects are

mainly reflected by the air entry values, residual water

content, and dehydration rate.

The foregoing analysis reveals that with increasing

modifier content, the SWCC of expansive soil becomes

flatter, which indicates that the dehydration rate of ex-

J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev. (English Ed.) 2012.6:36-41.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

asc

elib

rary

.org

by

UN

IVE

RSI

TY

OF

NO

RT

H T

EX

AS

LIB

on

11/2

8/14

. Cop

yrig

ht A

SCE

. For

per

sona

l use

onl

y; a

ll ri

ghts

res

erve

d.

Page 5: Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil-water Characteristic Curve

40 Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development

panslve soil decelerates after the modification, whereas

water holding capacity is strengthened. Along with in­

creasing air entry value, gas is hindered from accessing

the soil samples. As a result, residual water content con­

tinuously decreases. Therefore, the slope of the curve

can be used as an evaluation index for improvement

effects.

Soil sample saturation IS the first step in non-satu­

rated SWCC tests. Different modifier contents of compac­

ted expansive soil must correspond to different gravity

saturated water contents. Thus, the gravity saturated wa­

ter content can also be used as an evaluation index for

the modified effect of SWCC.

Based on the above findings, this paper uses the

four indexes : gravity saturated water content, aIr entry

value, residual water content, and slope of curve, to e­

valuate the improvement effects of expansive soil.

4. 2 Bases for the establishment of index systems

For the quantitative analysis of the rationality of im­

provement effects based on the evaluation of the four in­

dexes and the collection the fitting result of the SWCC

test, table 8 summarizes the gravity saturated water con­

tent, air entry value, residual water content, as well as

the slope of the curve of lime- and fly ash-improved soil.

The slope value considers not only the size but also the

direction.

Table 4 shows that changes in the index values are

regular. The saturation gravity water content and residual

water content of improved soil decreased with the increas­

ing modifier content. By contrast, the air entry value in­

creases, and the slope is flatter by comparison. These

observations show that the choice of the four indexes IS

reasonable and viable for an improvement evaluation.

Tab. 8 Summary of four indexes of fitted curves

Saturated Air entry Residual Slope of

Name gravity water value water curve

content ( % ) ( kPa ) content ( % ) Pure soil 24.5 64.4 15.3 6.64

3% lime soil 23.7 99.5 13.6 5.48

5% lime soil 23.0 116.8 12.6 4.70

7% lime soil 22.5 238. 1 11.5 4.55

5% fly ash soil 24.2 65.0 14.8 5.16

10% fly ash soil 23.5 70.0 14.0 4.72

15% fly ash soil 23.0 116.1 13.2 3.53

4. 3 Initial establishment of evaluation indicators

and criteria

Based on the above analysis, the modified effect of

expansive soil cannot be determines only from the shape

and four index values of the SWCC, which must be based

on the existing criterion to evaluate and establish rela­

tionships among the four indexes. Such relationships

would determine the boundary value of the evaluation in­

dexes.

In accordance with the assessment criterion of the

free expansion ratio, as given in table 5, the free expan­

sion rates of 5% lime soil, 7% lime soil, and 15% fly

ash soil are all less than 40%, which proves that the

modification of expansive soil is successful. In this re­

gard, as shown in table 8, the limiting value of the indi­

cator is preliminary proposed. Careful analysis of the da­

ta listed in the summary table reveals that saturated grav­

ity water content is an essential index; its value must be

less than or equal to 23. 0%. Considering the differences

in the effect of modification after lime and fly ash are

mixed with the expansive soil, rates of change of the cor­

responding three indexes: which are the air entry values,

residual water content, and slope of the curve, all differ.

The limiting values of the three indexes are given through

an integrated equilibrium analysis ( see table 9) .

Tab. 9 Critical values of four indexes for evaluating the

improvement effect

Saturated Air entry Residual Slope of

Name of index gravity water value water curve

content ( % ) ( kPa ) content ( % )

Expansi ve soil >23.0 < 116.0 > 13. 0 >4.0

None-expansive soil :;;:;23.0 �116.0 :;;:; 13. 0 :;;:;4.0

Tables 8 and 9 show that the saturated gravity water

content of the soils with 5% and 7% lime and 15% fly

ash satisfies the requirements. However, only two of the

remaining three indexes meet the requirements. The

slope of curve of the lime-improved soil is above the lim­

iting value, whereas the residual water content of the fly

ash-improved soil does not meet the requirements. Based

on these findings, the saturated gravity water content is

proven to be an essential indicator. Moreover, a clear con­

nection between changes in the four indexes of SWCC and

the swell-shrink characteristic of improved soil is evident.

The evaluation method employed in this study is

J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev. (English Ed.) 2012.6:36-41.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

asc

elib

rary

.org

by

UN

IVE

RSI

TY

OF

NO

RT

H T

EX

AS

LIB

on

11/2

8/14

. Cop

yrig

ht A

SCE

. For

per

sona

l use

onl

y; a

ll ri

ghts

res

erve

d.

Page 6: Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil-water Characteristic Curve

YANG Heping,et al : Analysis of the Improvement Effect of Expansive Soil through the Soil- water Characteristic Curve 41

mainly based on whether the improved soil can meet the

requirements of free expansion ratio, the significance of

which reveals the necessary connection between the

change in the four indexes of SWCC and the swell-shrink

characteristic of improved soil. An increasing number of

experts and scholars are interested in unsaturated soil re­

search, If SWCC tests are completed, the seepage,

strength, and volume change of unsaturated soil are pre­

dicted, and the effect of improved soil is evaluated,

Thus, unsaturated soil mechanics can be truly applied to

the engineering practice,

5 Conclusions

( 1) This article attempts to establish a connection

between the theory of unsaturated soil and corresponding

engineering problems, We promote the application of the

water characteristic curve of unsaturated soil to engineer­

ing projects,

(2) Through the study of the SWCC linear system

and expansion, the four-index system of evaluation is

proposed, However, given the wide distribution of ex­

pansive soil in various climates and geological condi­

tions, expansive soils of various regions often present

prominent regional distinctions, and the rationality of

each index requires further experimental verification,

(3) Only the drying curve has been studied in this

test. SWCC actually has a hysteretic nature, Thus, tests

that involve the drying and wetting of SWCC should be

performed to verify the conclusions in appropriate experi­

mental conditions,

( 4) Tests of SWCC may become conventional or ob­

ligatory, with comprehensive theoretical studies on unsat­

urated soil and the development of tests for suction, Once

this evaluation method reaches maturity and is perfected,

it will enable SWCC to evaluate the improvement of the

effectiveness of unsaturated expansive soils.

References

[ 1 J LUTTREL B J, REEVES I N. Experience and Develop­

ments with Road Construction on Expansive Soil in North

West Queensland [C J. Proceedings of 5th International

[2J

[3J

[4J

[5J

[6J

[7J

[8 J

COTHREN S M. Roadbed Stabilization by Lime Slurry In­

jection Process [CJ //Proceedings of 5th International Ex­

pansive Soil Conference. Barton, ACT: Institution of Engi­

neers, Australia, 1984: 250 -253.

ZHA Fusheng, LIU Songyu, DU Yanjun. Experiment on

Improvement of Expansive Clays with Lime-Fly Ash [J J.

Journal of Southeast University: Natural Science Edition,

2007 (3): 339 -344. (in Chinese)

HUANG Bin, NIE Qiong, XU Yanyon. Experimental Re­

search on Cement-modification of Expansive Soil [J J.

Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute,

2009 (11): 27 -30. (in Chinese)

XU Y F, SUN D A. Determination of Expansive Soil

Strength Using a Fractal Model [J]. Fractals, 2001, 9

(1):51-60.

FREDLUND D G, XING A, FREDLUND M D. The Rela­

tionship of the Unsaturated Soil Shear Strength Function to

the Soil-water Characteristics [JJ. Canadian Geotechnical

Journal, 1996, 33 (3): 440 -448.

FREDLUND D G, RAHARDJO H. Soil Mechanics for Un­

saturated Soils [M J. New York: John Wiley&Sons, Inc. ,

1993.

LIU Chao, WANG Y ouke, ZHANG Lqiang. The Application

of Soil Water Characteristic Curve in Determination of Lower

Limit of Suitable Soil Moisture in Crop Non- sufficient Irriga­

tion [J J. Journal of Irrigation, 2007 (7): 76 -78. ( in

Chinese)

[9 J LIN Hongzhou, YU Yuzhen, LI Guangxin, et al. On Ap-

plication of Soil-water Characteristic Curves to Landslide

Forecast [J J. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and En­

gineering, 2009 (12): 2569 - 2576. (in Chinese)

[ 10 J WANG Donglin, LUAN Maotian, YANG Qing. Experi­

mental Study of Soi-water Characteristic Curve of Remolded

Unsaturated Clay [J J. Rock and Soil Mechanics, 2009

(3) : 751 -756. (in Chinese)

[ 11 J Chen Aijun. Experimental Study on the Lime Improvement

of Expansive Soil Embankment of Nan-You Highway [D J .

Changsha: Changsha University of Science and Technolo­

gy, 2004. (in Chinese)

[ 12 J lTGE40-2007 , Test Methods of Soils for Highway Engi­

neering [S J. (in Chinese)

[13 J GBll 12-987, Technical Specifications for Construction

Ground in Expanding Soil Areas [S J. (in Chinese)

[14 J LIN Liping. Analysis on Improvement Effect of Expansive

Soil by Soil-water Characteristic Curve [D J. Changsha:

Expansive Soil Conference. Barton, ACT: Institution of Changsha University of Science and Technology, 2009.

Engineers, Australia, 1984: 340 -347. (in Chinese)

(doi: 10. 3969/j. issn. 1002 - 0268. 2011. 10. O�, vol. 28, pp. 1 - 6, 2011)

J. Highway Transp. Res. Dev. (English Ed.) 2012.6:36-41.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

asc

elib

rary

.org

by

UN

IVE

RSI

TY

OF

NO

RT

H T

EX

AS

LIB

on

11/2

8/14

. Cop

yrig

ht A

SCE

. For

per

sona

l use

onl

y; a

ll ri

ghts

res

erve

d.