an overview of paleoethnobotany of the indus civilization 2005 · 1.wood charcoal 2.phytoliths...

37
An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005

Upload: others

Post on 20-May-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

An Overview of Paleoethnobotany

of the Indus Civilization

2005

Page 2: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

1.Wood charcoal

2.Phytoliths

3.Plant Impressions

4.Pollen

5.Inferences from Artifacts

6.Inferences from Bones

7.Ethnographic Work

8.Seeds and other identifiable plant parts

Research into Indus Civilization plantoccurrences focus on one of eight strategies

Page 3: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

1.Wood Charcoal

Charcoal analysis provides a means to the

reconstruction of vegetational histories and to the

development of models of wood exploitation patterns.

Early indications are that wood use did change during

the Indus civilization.

Images courtesy of M. Tengberg and S. Thiébault

Page 4: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

2. Phytoliths

Phytolith analysis has identified the appearance of

plants not identified through other means at sites like

Harappa.

Image: Phytolith micrograph M. Madella

Page 5: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

3. Plant Impressions

Plant impressions are a good source for identifying

the presence of particular species.

Page 6: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

4. Pollen

While pollen analysis from lake bed sequences have been

used extensively in environmental reconstruction, their

collection and analysis from archeological sites is only

beginning to be applied to South Asia.

Image: Emergence of

Agriculture B.Smith

Page 7: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

5. Inferences from Artifacts

Artifacts can indicate

the presence of certain

species of plants.

Images of a pipal tree.

Image: Ancient Cities of the Indus Civilization J.M.Kenoyer

Page 8: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

6. Inferences from Bones

The potential for stable

isotope analysis still needs

exploring.

Page 9: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

7. Ethnographic Work

Ethnographic studies can give us insight into the

significance and meaning of archeological plant remains.

Images: Forgotten Cities on the Indus Janson, Malloy, Urban eds.

Page 10: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

The basis of agricultural studies.

8. Seeds and other identifiable plant parts

Page 11: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Sites of the Indus

Civilization with

paleoethobotanical data

Page 12: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Sites with seeds

recovered

Page 13: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Sites where

impressions were found

Page 14: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Sites where charcoal

was recovered

Page 15: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Sites where

inferences have

been drawn from

artifacts

Page 16: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Sites where phytoliths

have been recovered

Page 17: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Sites where pollen

has been recovered

Page 18: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Carbonized seeds are recovered

from the archeological record in one

of three ways

•Accidental Finds

•Dry screening

•Floating

Page 19: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Sites where

flotation was

used - F

Page 20: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

The formation process and its impact on

the seed record requires us to consider

four issues:

•Pre-charring activities

•Charring and deposition

•Post depositional factors

•Methods of Collection

Page 21: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Pre-charring Activities

The location of seed processing has significance in

both preservation and in interpretation.

Page 22: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Charring and Deposition

Charring can occur both

intentionally and

accidentally.

Intentional charring may

occur through the use of

dung as fuel. Accidental

charring may occur during

food preparation.

Page 23: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Post depositional factors

Images: The National Agricultural Library Special Collections

Page 24: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Methods of Collection

Collection can occur

through accidental finds as

well as through deliberate

and systematic collection

during excavation.

Page 25: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

The temporal scheme used to discuss

archaeobotanical data:

Indus Valley Tradition

Localization Era ca. 1900 to 1300 B.C.

Late Harappan Phase

Integration Era ca. 2600 to 1900 B.C.

Harappan Phase

Regionalization Era ca. 5000 to 2600 B.C.

Early Harappan Phase

Early Food Producing Era ca. 6500 to 5000 B.C.Neolithic/Chalcolithic

Page 26: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Major Sites of

the Indus

Civilization with

archeobotanical

data

Page 27: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Early

Harappan

Sites With

Recovered

Seeds

Page 28: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Early

Harappan

Harappan

Page 29: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Early

Harappan

Harappan

Late Harappan

Page 30: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Harappan

Sites with

recovered

seeds

Page 31: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

•Late

Harappan

sites with

recovered

seeds

Page 32: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Cropping Strategies

Rabi crops or spring harvested

crops are planted in the fall and

watered by winter rains.

Kharif crops are planted in the

summer, during or after the

monsoon, and harvested in the

fall.

Page 33: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Primary crops and their rate of seed

occurrence during the Indus Civilization

Page 34: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

0: no finds

1: low ubiquity and low density

2: high ubiquity with high density

Cropping Early Late

Season Harappan Harappan Harappan________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Cereals

Wheat kharif 2 2 2

Barley kharif 2 2 2

Oat kharif ? 1 1

Rice rabi 0 ? 2

Millets rabi 1 2 2

Pulses and vegetables

Peas rabi 0 1 1

Lentil rabi 1 1 1

Cow Pea kharif 0 1 2

Gram kharif 0 2 2

Oilseed and fiber

Linseed rabi 0 1 2

Cotton perennial ? 1 1

Sesame kharif 0 1 1

Fruits

Date rabi 1 1 1

Jujube kharif 2 2 2

Grape kharif 1 1 1

Page 35: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Indications for agricultural stability

and continuity through time

•Cereals are the primary crop

•Focus is one primary season of cropping

•Rabi and Kharif patterns remain

Page 36: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

Indications for changing agricultural

practices

•New crops

•Changing proportions of some taxa

Page 37: An Overview of Paleoethnobotany of the Indus Civilization 2005 · 1.Wood charcoal 2.Phytoliths 3.Plant Impressions 4.Pollen 5.Inferences from Artifacts 6.Inferences from Bones 7.Ethnographic

• Paleoethnobotany is still in the early stages of analysis

• New crops are constantly being added but are incorporated into

the strategy at a slow rate. A gradual increasing importance in

multi-cropping can be identified

• Quantitative shifts in some cereals is identifiable

• No rapid revolution in agricultural strategies can be identified

• Shifts in crop processing imply social change was possibly

occurring

• The over riding agricultural strategy for this region is one base

on local cultivation practices that are influenced by local

hydrological conditions and local cultural traditions

Conclusions for the Indus Civilization