an overview of open web steel joists - wiss, janney ... · pdf filea basic understanding of...
TRANSCRIPT
A basic understanding of open web steel joist framing systems, including their history, their unique features, and certain challenges associated with their evaluation and modification.
www.wje.com
1
Primer
Location:DENVER OFFICE 3609 South Wadsworth Boulevard Suite 400 Lakewood, CO 80235
Contact:T: 303.914.4300 E: [email protected] E: [email protected]
An Overview of Open Web Steel JoistsTheownerormanagerofabuildingthatfeaturesopenwebsteeljoistframingsystemsforthefloorsand/orroofmayoccasionallywonderiftheyarestrongenoughtosupportneworadditionalloads,and,ifnot,whethertheycanbemodifiedtodoso.ThisWJEPrimerisintendedtoprovidebuildingownersandmanagerswithabasicunderstandingofthesecommonstructuralmembers,includingtheirhistory,theiruniquefeatures,andcertainchallengesassociatedwiththeirevaluationandmodification.
A Brief History
Thenameopenwebsteeljoistsmayconcealthefactthatthese“joists”arereally“trusses.”Trussesmadeofwoodhavebeenutilizedthroughouttheworldforcenturies,buttheuseoftrussesbecamefarmoreprevalentinthelate19thandearly20thcenturiesfollowingimprovementsintheproductionofstructuralmetals,suchascastironandlatersteel.Today,openwebsteeljoistsareoneofthemostcommonlyusedframingsystemsforfloorsandroofsinbuildings.
SomeofthefirststeeljoistsusedintheUnitedStatesinthemidtolate1800sweremadeofsheetsteelwebsandflangesrivetedtogether.Useofthesememberscontinuedintotheearly1900s,whenquantityproductionofpressedsteeljoistsmadeoflightgaugesteelsheetsbegantoreplacetherivetedversions.Thesejoistsweremadebypressingthesheetsintotheformofchannelsandweldingthemback-to-back,givingtheappearanceoflightI-shapedbeams.Oneoftheprimaryobjectionstothesejoistswasthattheirsolidsteelwebsprovidednopractical
meansofinstallingconduitsandpipeswithinthedepthofthefloorandroofmembers.Thisandotherconcernsledtothedevelopmentofwhatcametobecalledopen web steel joists.
ThefirstopenwebsteeljoistsintheUnitedStatesweremanufacturedinthe1920s.Theseearlysteeljoistsfeaturedtopandbottomchordsmadeofroundbars,steelangles, orproprietaryshapes,withwebscommonlyformedfromsinglecontinuousbentbars. Asthesteeljoistindustrybegantogrow,engineersandarchitectsfoundthatthelackofuniformdesignandfabricationstandardsamongthevariousmanufacturersmadeitdifficulttoachievethemostcost-effectivestructures.Consequently,membersoftheindustrybeganworkingtostandardizethemanufactureofthesecomponents.TheseeffortsresultedintheformationoftheSteelJoistInstitute(SJI),whichpublisheditsfirst setofStandardSpecificationsforOpenWebSteelJoistsin1928,followedbythefirstloadtablesin1929.Today,theSJI,anonprofitorganizationofactivejoistmanufacturers,
By Ben COOk aND Jerry mAlyWiss, Janney, Elstner Associates, Inc.
2
Primer
andotherorganizationsandcompaniesconnectedtotheindustry,continuestodevelopandmaintainstandardsforthedesign,manufacture,anderectionofsteeljoistconstruction.
ThefirstSJISpecificationpermittedthe useofrolledshapesorstripsofsheetsteel,roundbars,anglesorspeciallyrolledbarsrivetedorweldedtogether.Modern-dayopenwebsteeljoistsaresimilartothoseproducedinthe1920sand1930s,andallfeaturetopandbottomchords,withdiagonal,andsometimesvertical,webmembersbetweenthechords.Today’ssteeljoistsareoftenfabricatedusingdoubleanglechordsandwebsmade fromanglesorroundrods.However,the SJIStandardSpecificationprovidesperformancerequirements,andeachmembercompanyispermittedtousevariousproductsandgeometriesintheirjoists,therebyprovidingproprietarydesigns,solongasthespecificationissatisfied.Thisincludestheuseofbothhot-andcold-rolledsteelshapes,bars,sheet,andstrip.Photographsofacirca1930openwebsteeljoistandamoderneraK-seriesopenwebsteeljoistareshowninFigures1and2,respectively.
Typical and Atypical Applications in new Buildings
Sincetheywerefirstpublished,eachSJIStandardSpecificationhasincludedloadtables,whichprovideallowableuniformloadsforvariousspanlengthsandjoistdepths,makingitpossibleforengineersandarchitectstospecifyratherthandesignthesetypesofstructuralcomponents.Manyjoistmanufacturersprovidecustomdesignsofopenwebsteeljoists.Thisisadvantageousforapplicationswheretheengineerofrecordspecifiesspecificloadingsonthestructuraldrawingsas
opposedtothestandardSJIjoistdesignations.Somemanufacturersalsoallowothervariablesinthedesignandfabricationoftheiropenwebsteeljoists,includingslopedorcurvedtopchords(ratherthanthetraditionalparallelchordjoists),variationsinthedepthsofjoistbearingseats,slopedbearingseats,greaterjoistdepths,andtheabilitytoincorporatesteeljoistsintothelateralforceresistingsystems.
New or Additional Loads on Open Web Steel Joists in Existing Buildings
Situationsroutinelyarisewheretheownersofexistingbuildingswanttomakecertainalterations,suchasinstallingnewandheavierroofingsystems,replacingexistingrooftopmechanicalunitswithupgradedequipment,orinstallingrooftopmechanicalunitswherenonepreviouslyexisted.Proposedalterationscanalsoincludetheinstallationofheavierflooringmaterialsorhighdensityfilingsystems,whilechangesinoccupancymayresultinincreasedfloorliveloadrequirementsormodificationstotheroofframingtoaccommodatesnowdriftloadsthatwerenotnecessarywhenthebuildingwasoriginallydesignedandconstructed.Whensituationslikethesearise,thequestionisoftenasked:Can the roof or floor joists in my building support these new loads, and if not, can they be strengthened so that they can?
Similartomostexistingstructuralcomponentsorsystems,theloadcarryingcapacitiesofexistingopenwebsteeljoistscanbeestimated;however,thereliabilityofanysuchassessmentcanbeaffectedbyavarietyoffactors.Thecapacityofexistingopenwebsteeljoistscanbedeterminedwiththegreatestconfidencewhentheoriginaldesign,construction,orshopdrawingsareavailable.Whenthese
Open Web Steel Joists (COnTInUEd)
Figure 1
Photograph of an open web steel joist circa 1930
Figure 2
Photograph of a modern open web steel joist
Figure 3
Typical joist tag
documentscannotbeobtained,thenextbestoptionistoseeifjoisttagsarestill inplaceontheaffectedjoists.Ajoisttag isametallabelwiredtoeachjoistduringfabricationthatprovidesinformationsuchasthemanufacturer’sname,jobnumber,marknumber,plantlocation,anddate; anexampleisshowninFigure3.When joisttagscanberetrieved,itislikelythatthemanufacturercanbeidentifiedwho
3
Primer
maybeabletoprovideinformationonthedesignandfabricationofthejoistsinquestion.Ifthemanufacturerisnolongerinbusiness,theSJImaybeabletoprovideusefulinformation.Alternatively,whendrawingsandjoisttagsarenotavailable,oreveniftheyare,buildingowners,engineers,andcontractorstryingtoidentifyexistingjoistscanfilloutandsubmittheJoist Investi gati on Form availableontheSJIwebsite,which,weunderstand,hasproventobeaneffectiveandvaluableresource.
Finally,ifdrawingsand/orjoisttagsarenotavailable,anduseoftheSJIJoist Investi gati on Formhasbeenfruitless,thecapacityofsteeljoistscanalwaysbeestimatedbyanexperiencedstructuralengineer,usingfieldmeasurementsoftheoverallgeometryandmeasurementsofthejoistchordsandwebs,togetherwithassessmentsofthevariouschord-to-webmemberconnections.Evaluationssuchasthiswillalsorequireassumptionsregardingtheyieldstrengthofthesteel,whichcanusuallybedeterminedwithreasonableaccuracyusingtheSJIStandardSpecificationthatwasinuseatthetimethebuildingwasdesignedandconstructed.However,wheregreaterreliabilityisneeded,samplescanberetrievedfromthejoistsinquestionandthematerialpropertiesdeterminedbytests.
increasin g the load Carrying Capacity of Existi ng Open Web Steel Joist Framing Systems
Oncethecapacitiesoftheexistingjoistsareknownwithinareasonabledegreeofengineeringcertainty,theycanbecomparedtotheproposeddemandstodetermineifthenewloadscanbecarriedwithanadequatefactorofsafety.Whentheanswertothisquestionisno,thereare
Figure 4
Original top chord strengthened with new welded steel rod
Figure 5
Original top chord strengthened with a new screw-fastened steel angle
Figure 6
Original web members supplemented with new steel angles
Figure 7
Original web member strengthened with new steel rod and angles.
Open Web Steel Joists (COnTInUEd)
4
Primer
severalapproachesthatcanbetaken sothattheexistingframingcanbemadestrongand/orstiffenoughtosupport theproposedloaddemands.Theseapproachesinclude:
1.Reinforcingorstrengtheningthe existingjoists
2. Addingnewjoistsorsteelbeamsbetweentheexistingjoists
3. distributingtheloadstoseveral adjacentmembers.
Approach 1
Reinforcingorstrengtheningtheexistingjoistscanbeaccomplishedinavarietyofways,dependingtosomedegreeonthemagnitudeandextentofthenewloads. Ifthenewloadswillbeappliedatdiscretelocations(e.g.anewrooftopmechanicalunit),itispossiblethatonlyarelativelysmallnumberofthejoistcomponents willrequirereinforcement.Inthiscase, theaffectedchordsandwebsmaybereinforcedwithnewsteelrodsoranglesasshowninFigures4,5,6and7.However,ifthenewloadingisappliedoveralargearea(e.g.fromanewhighdensityfilingsystemorincreasedfloorliveload),allofthejoistchordsandwebsmayneedtobereinforcedinasimilarmanner.
Alternatively,insomecircumstances,itmaybepossibletostrengthentheexistingjoistsbyreducingtheirspanswiththeinstallationofanewbeamorbeamsperpendiculartothespansofthejoists.Inmostcases,thiswouldrequirestrengtheningatleastsomeofthewebmembersinthevicinityofthenewbeamorbeams.However,thismaybeamorecost-effectiveapproachthan
reinforcingallormostofthejoists’chordsandwebmembersovertheentirelengthoftheaffectedjoists.
Approach 2
Theadditionofnewframing,suchassteelbeamsoradditionaljoistsbetweenandparalleltotheexistingjoists,issometimesanoptionworthyofconsideration.Ifthenewloadswillbeappliedatdiscretelocations,newjoistsorbeamsmaybedesignedandinstalledtosupportthe newloadsintheirentirety,andrelativelyindependentoftheexistingloads.However,ifthenewloadsaretobeappliedoverlargeareas(e.g.fromanewhighdensityfilingsystemorincreasedfloorliveloads),thenewframingwilllikelyhavetoworkinunisonwiththeexistingframingtosharealltheloads.Inthiscase,thestiffnessofthenewframingwillneedtoapproximatelymatchthatoftheexistingmembers.
Theadditionofnewjoistsorbeamsbetweenandparalleltotheexistingjoistsmaybemorechallengingthanitinitiallyseems.Forexample,moststeeljoistsaretopchordbearing,whichmeansthatthetopchordsextendseveralinchesoverthetopofthesupportingbeam,girder,orwallateachend;averyefficientandcosteffectivebearingdetailfornewconstruction.However,inanexistingbuilding,itcanbeverydifficult,ifnotpracticallyimpossible,toinstallanewjoistwiththissametopchordbearingdetailthatwasusedfortheoriginaljoistateachend.Onesolutionistoinstallthenewjoistswithfield-boltedsplices.Ontheotherhand,theuseofsupplementalsteeljoistsorbeamssupportedatthefaceoftheexisting
supportsatoneendmayeliminatethisproblem.Otherchallengesincludethepossibilitythataccesstotheareabetweenexistingjoists,forinstallationofnewframingmembers,maybelimitedbythepresenceofmechanicalducts,plumbingpipes,and/orelectricalconduits.Otherdifficultiesmaybeencounteredbecausetheexistingframingwillhavedeflectedbetweensupportsduetothedeadloadsalreadyonthestructure,andthiswillneedtobeconsideredinthedesignandinstallationofthenewmembers.
Approach 3
Whenthenewloadsareisolatedtoarelativelysmalllocationofafloororroof(e.g.whenamechanicalunitistobesuspendedfromtherooforceiling),itmaybepossibletodistributethenewloadsoveranumberofadjacentjoistsbytheinstallationofloaddistributionorspreaderbeams.Thissolutionisverystraightforwardwhenthenewloadsaresmallenoughthattheycanbecarriedbytwoadjacentjoists.However,thisapproachbecomesslightlymorecomplexwhenthenewloadmustbedistributedoverseveraljoistssothatnoneareloadedbeyondtheirallowablecapacitywhenthenewloadsareconsideredtogetherwiththeexistingdeadloadsandothercode-requireddesignloads.Inthiscase,thespreaderbeamsmustberelativelystiffcomparedtothestiffnessofthejoists.Asanalternativetoinstallationofastiffbeambelowthejoists,itmaybepossibletoconstructatrussperpendiculartoandwithinthedepthofthejoiststotransfertheloadappropriatelytotheexistingjoists.
Open Web Steel Joists (COnTInUEd)
www.wje.com
5
Primer
references
�� TheBergerManufacturingCo.,Handbook Describing Berloy Building Materials, First Edition,1921,Canton,OH
�� TrusconSteelCompany,Truscon Steel Joist Data Book,1924,Youngstown,OH.
�� nucorCorporation,Designing with Vulcraft Steel Joists, Joist Girders and Steel Deck,SecondEdition,2002,JamesM.Fisher,Ph.d.,P.E.,MichaelA.West,P.E.,AIA,JuliusP.VandePas,P.E.
�� SteelJoistInstitute,75 - Year Steel Joist Manual,2003,MyrtleBeach,SC.
�� SteelJoistInstitute,Technical Digest 12, Evaluation and Modification of Open-Web Steel Joists and Joist Girders, 2007, JamesM.Fisher,Ph.d.,P.E.,MyrtleBeach, SC.
�� SteelJoistInstitute,Standard Specifications,43rdEdition,Florence,SC.
Contact:T: 303.914.4300 E: [email protected] E: [email protected]: www.wje.com
Location:DENVER OFFICE 3609 South Wadsworth Boulevard Suite 400 Lakewood, CO 80235
Open Web Steel Joists (COnTInUEd)