an expression-induction model ten artificial people were created. they could learn colour word...

1
An Expression-Induction Model An Expression-Induction Model Ten artificial people were created. They could learn colour word denotations by observing other artificial people talking. The learning mechanism was a form of Bayesian inference, and the red, yellow, green and blue unique hues were made especially salient. Conversations consisting only of naming colours were simulated over twenty generations of speakers, in 425 separate simulations. Introduction Introduction Colour Terms vary between languages. Some languages have only 2 basic colour terms – others 11. But the variation is far from random – so what causes these patterns? Explaining Language Explaining Language Typology Typology What causes this kind of typological pattern? Individual psychology? Properties of the mind/brain constrain the range of possible human languages. Cross-Linguistic Evidence Cross-Linguistic Evidence Berlin and Kay (1969) – languages evolve from simple to complex, and gradually add colour terms over time. The best examples of each colour term fall into clusters, both for different speakers of the same language, and for speakers of different languages. The World Colour Survey looked at 110 languages – and found that most languages lie somewhere along the evolutionary trajectory shown below (Kay and Maffi, 1999). The top of the hierarchy represents a language with only two color terms such as Dani. From this starting point, colour term systems can evolve until each unique hue is represented by a separate colour term. Simulated Languages Show the Simulated Languages Show the Same Patterns seen in Real Same Patterns seen in Real Languages Languages Most of the colour terms which emerge in the simulations are of the same type as those in Kay and Maffi’s (1999) evolutionary trajectory. The correlation between the results of the World Colour Survey and the evolutionary model is 0.959 (Pearson’s product moment coefficient, P0.01). The emergent colour term systems as a whole tend to be of the same types as those found in the World Colour Survey. This research is sponsored by the This research is sponsored by the University of Sydney and the University of Sydney and the Australian Government through IPA Australian Government through IPA and IPRS scholarships. and IPRS scholarships. A Computational Evolutionary Approach to Colour A Computational Evolutionary Approach to Colour Term Typology Term Typology Mike Dowman Mike Dowman, Ph.D. Student, School of Information Technologies, Smart Internet Technology Research Group Networks and Systems Research Laboratory Supervised by Judy Kay white-red-yellow + black-green-blue white + red- yellow + black-green-blue white + red + yellow + black + green-blue white + red-yellow + black + green-blue white + red + yellow + black + green + blue white + red + yellow + black-green- blue white + red + yellow + green + black-blue white + red + yellow-green-blue + black white + red + yellow-green + blue + black Purple, pink and brown are less predictable. Purple usually but not always emerges before orange. We never see Turquoise or Lime basic terms. Language Acquisitio n Device Individual 's Knowledge of Language Primary Linguistic Data Chomsky’s Language Acquisition Device (Chomsky, 1972) Language Acquisit ion Device Arena of Language Use Primary Linguist ic Data Individu al's Knowledg e of Language Hurford’s Diachronic Spiral (Hurford, 1987) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 P ercentofterm s ofthis typ Red Yellow G reen Blue R-Y Y-G G-B B-R R -Y-G Y-G -B G -B-R Type ofcolour term W CS M odel Frequency of Types of Colour Term in the Simulations and in the World Colour Survey 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 Hue (red atleftto purple atright)+ m ark unique hues Degreeo of m em bership in color category On Example of an Emergent Colour Term System Or an interaction of psychological and social processes? Colour terms systems may have developed as the result of a process of cultural evolution. References References Berlin, B. & Kay, P. (1969). Basic Colour Terms. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Chomsky, N. (1972). Language and Mind. New York, NY: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Inc. Hurford, J. R. (1987). Language and Number The Emergence of a Cognitive System. New York, NY: Basil Blackwell. Kay, P. & Maffi, L. (1999). Colour Appearance and the Emergence and Evolution of Basic Colour Lexicons. American Anthropologist, Volume 101, pages 743-760.

Upload: laura-hudson

Post on 01-Jan-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: An Expression-Induction Model  Ten artificial people were created.  They could learn colour word denotations by observing other artificial people talking

An Expression-Induction ModelAn Expression-Induction Model Ten artificial people were created.

They could learn colour word denotations by observing other artificial people talking.

The learning mechanism was a form of Bayesian inference, and the red, yellow, green and blue unique hues were made especially salient.

Conversations consisting only of naming colours were simulated over twenty generations of speakers, in 425 separate simulations.

IntroductionIntroductionColour Terms vary between languages.

Some languages have only 2 basic colour terms – others 11.

But the variation is far from random – so what causes these patterns?

Explaining Language TypologyExplaining Language TypologyWhat causes this kind of typological pattern?

Individual psychology?

Properties of the mind/brain constrain the range of possible human languages.

Cross-Linguistic EvidenceCross-Linguistic EvidenceBerlin and Kay (1969) – languages evolve from simple to complex, and gradually add colour terms over time.

The best examples of each colour term fall into clusters, both for different speakers of the same language, and for speakers of different languages.

The World Colour Survey looked at 110 languages – and found that most languages lie somewhere along the evolutionary trajectory shown below (Kay and Maffi, 1999). The top of the hierarchy represents a language with only two color terms such as Dani. From this starting point, colour term systems can evolve until each unique hue is represented by a separate colour term.

Simulated Languages Show the Same Simulated Languages Show the Same Patterns seen in Real LanguagesPatterns seen in Real LanguagesMost of the colour terms which emerge in the simulations are of the same type as those in Kay and Maffi’s (1999) evolutionary trajectory.

The correlation between the results of the World Colour Survey and the evolutionary model is 0.959 (Pearson’s product moment coefficient, P≪0.01).

The emergent colour term systems as a whole tend to be of the same types as those found in the World Colour Survey.

This research is sponsored by the University of This research is sponsored by the University of Sydney and the Australian Government through Sydney and the Australian Government through IPA and IPRS scholarships.IPA and IPRS scholarships.

A Computational Evolutionary Approach to Colour Term TypologyA Computational Evolutionary Approach to Colour Term TypologyMike DowmanMike Dowman, Ph.D. Student, School of Information Technologies,

Smart Internet Technology Research GroupNetworks and Systems Research Laboratory

Supervised by Judy Kay

white-red-yellow + black-green-blue

white + red-yellow + black-green-blue

white + red + yellow + black + green-blue

white + red-yellow + black + green-blue

white + red + yellow + black + green + blue

white + red + yellow + black-green-blue

white + red + yellow + green + black-blue

white + red + yellow-green-blue + black

white + red + yellow-green + blue + black

Purple, pink and brown are less predictable. Purple usually but not always emerges before orange.

We never see Turquoise or Lime basic terms.

Language Acquisition

Device

Individual's Knowledge of

Language

Primary Linguistic

Data

Chomsky’s Language Acquisition Device (Chomsky, 1972)

Language Acquisition

Device

Arena of Language

Use

Primary Linguistic

Data

Individual's Knowledge of Language

Hurford’s Diachronic Spiral (Hurford, 1987)

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Pe

rce

nt

of

term

s o

f th

is t

yp

e

Re

d

Ye

llo

w

Gre

en

Blu

e

R-Y

Y-G

G-B

B-R

R-Y

-G

Y-G

-B

G-B

-R

Type of colour term

WCS

Model

Frequency of Types of Colour Term in the Simulations and in the World Colour Survey

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Hue (red at left to purple at right) + mark unique hues

Deg

ree

o o

f m

em

bers

hip

in c

olo

r ca

teg

ory

On Example of an Emergent Colour Term System

Or an interaction of psychological and social processes?

Colour terms systems may have developed as the result of a process of cultural evolution.

ReferencesReferencesBerlin, B. & Kay, P. (1969). Basic Colour Terms. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Chomsky, N. (1972). Language and Mind. New York, NY: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Inc.

Hurford, J. R. (1987). Language and Number The Emergence of a Cognitive System . New York, NY: Basil Blackwell.

Kay, P. & Maffi, L. (1999). Colour Appearance and the Emergence and Evolution of Basic Colour Lexicons. American Anthropologist, Volume 101, pages 743-760.