water hammer in pipes - ideals

if^ # if* *»

^- -^^iN ^ ^ ^ f

4

^ f - ^ # ^^ ^ 4 ^ 4 ^# ^ -f^:^ 4 ^ 4 4

1^ ^ ^ ij.. * #

ife' Nf^-- -^^ 1^ ^ ^•

^ "Nfei > ^ 'i^:'^^-

^- ^ * 1^ ^ ^

si-

i

•f- * # ^ ^ * / * f

UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS * * #^# LIBRARY

Class Book Volume -jf^

.le 06-lliM

f f •<

r

4

- f•Ik

f 4 4

iff

If*- * 4

' f * + # <f -^^

1K- jf' -f 'J*- ^,

# "f #

* # #

f f- f

--^ ^ #f ^ -^-^ ^ ^ ^

WATER HAMMER IN PIPES

HY

MELVm LORKNIUS ENGER

THESIS

DKGRKE OF BACHELOR OF SCIENCE

IK

Civile ENGINEERING

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING

UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS

PRESENTED JUNE 1906

UNIVERSITY OF ILLIMOIS

May 29, 1906

This is to certify that the following thesis prepared

under the direction of Professor A. N. Talbot, Head of the Depart-

ment of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, by

MELVI?T LORENIUS ENGER

entitled WATER HAIOfflR IN PIPES

is hereby approved by rae as fulfilling this part of the require-

ments for the Degree of Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering.

Head of Department of Civil Engineering

Digitized by the Internet Archive

in 2013

http://archive.org/details/waterhammerinpipOOenge

e\ 1

icwe ^a(]U ^ow^cx^, ^^I^JlA, ^^^6^

U) ^(VY ^-v^ loWaC^ Aa^ A/Wi(SlvY^toc.(l,

^-6^ I^SoXUx) aa;(XV AA/wd-e^~Vcxkwv ~\c> W^GcXa^;

(2.) iS^-twwA \oai:A^>^ji^ -Sv^cdjui/iv^ '^^\^^^ WdcrvwA,

z

0^ icVvcy^ dlcwvxSCtvr

3

0^ \s \3

4

T^rv-o ^^AAo err Q^^jw-»-C^ ,

"

TVr-o ^^-^ err Q.(VvyD-Vv^^^^ •

5

A,

Air ChBrnber Water Chamber

No Chamber

Vc/oc/Ty ofM^fer/nF^zef Dr. 5e.co/7r:/ Fha/7(^s j?r. so.

2.9 / G33. 35 904-.ZO 1 13

5. 05 1^36.02 1 96y.07 23 1

8-GO

7

"T^tvjL |pnr<xi/3UrHLo CxrA ojl "WvcxMj^ ~1?vOvw ~\5voS5. \a/?vacBv

D^Vi/*^ Owid .

^>Vw. ^.^twxv^ Q^^wwcSv 'S'wvi^ jwAUjdl a ^l^^uuLvo crw

QT^iWv^|p\ -^Cxd VoJU/va AOaadjl^Ci difcjA^mwxii OvvVL^^vvvvC^

ZD'S 0^ Vto \/V\

0^^^^^ va^oWt -^o^^v^c^ V/\^ yJ^JUi

"I'VU-^ VvaC&x "^Wil ^v'jpJL. V\jL (5^>JlAA> ^045l0WWvC^^

^•'~T5^ y)rrmov\^Vi. ^yV5_afcL^ Vu^~^^^^ "^i^d^Avv^ ^O'Va/'V^

"^0.0OVA d .

^-Vtrv^ ~^^(xt \p CK/^^~t ^^(-^ Vv\A, WvA(^ 'V^Uattvv

"Taxm \_3_04.

V/vac5s "SVjljl5. y^v^JL^

^wTTv/vxc^ uv^ CX Q^^^e-W- ^Jio"?. w^*^

10

v-^^ iiiL^c^)^^ (T^ -^4^^^ ^OS'O ov^^ \Ot(3 ^xii.

{\] \ ^vJL ^/v^ci^c^^^c^ ^^LoC_W .-v^<y^^ O^<^o^ y^y^

.v^^ e^-tL. ^^cV Wo^ 5i;o^-v^,^

^^^^^^ ^ cxV,c>^ -^^.oc^^-\, 5v^c^

ZA^ ecx^ x.-^ ex.\oo^ ^ o^^o^^V^^

A/\_J(xtjt-r v/v^ ""^VJi- ^yJpiL CL^tx-r CX-

v^cx^^ ^^^^ V^cxeW ^a)^-£l ^x^-iy^^ v^f^^o^

crw rv^cxc5/v/-wO^ cx djia(^ -Wx(X. "T^^a^ cSlo^\o!lwx(^

rvv\

13

(7) ^.^.^^ y

14

e,\cu, - - " * 1^04

/5-

"s\atcc ^cxcX) cXaa(\ r\ V/o iSjla/v Q-^xWla^ v^ofou

-to \d ft

\1

\

w~iL K^o^iS: c^~^L

aa/xa^ (r5 (Jfji/vJow^ \s nj^JLo ^^^^^ Aaa^v^^ ~^^va.

^f^jA^cZX^^C^ "Y^OL'J, A- SLoC 1 ir\A<j 0^ X/^^'lp wL-ijjt- "^V^JU^-Ji.

3t

Cwv<^ rv^^tKClA^<>S^ ^ TVs V/CxJt^^^^ "^^vJU-yJi, fV^AiA^SLV:5

V- 0)

1^

O^/T^ ^ V^^A/O V>sJ^_^ QXjCv>^

_ (2)

\1

Vv^ ex.

CVvwvC.

zo

A

)poAA/3w^V^ OCV A Ow^A ft <V>^ l^ju^ "tSvji CWxCX/VCVw^-^A/^ P ,

A B

n

21

'~V^ uo^^A.^^ cr^ ^cxtjir^ wSi^cJ^ ^Ao-^^ ~\^uvt)^cYSv

^\KV,at ---C\)

To owxcX P V:)-Si/>^cj^ ^5vii. AjI/ta/3 rtuu? loi^^crv^ Ow^(y CX^ti^

^ z.

- ^^ e^^-K^ xdt ^ ^^tt (^^) A at i:^)

p-W-(P^)k (A--)

2Z

P-Po - -^("H-^.") (5)

\^

V k Ee

^o\Y° ^ C7)

23

\ (XQp-O-^ W<J15^ wvtj^

a

^'^^ju^ err R .^Tl.~~

Tcx5 iocA

CL

v^<v>Jl^C>|^ - 2^— — V

4«

24

crw\-

rwa o cL'^^/JLvA^ (T^ 9^C>syo"\^ClA!tA^ \aj cxtv-r = 30O OOO y>ovA/v\

\j^(r^ iL'^l^cxL <i CWJ^->rCx^^

2- •

^

^-5^ VAJ^rv^ (kcrwSL CxQ^iyo c^^cx5L~A Jl.'v^^C^

25

at

24

^-^Iva- ^.A/T^y$^ C^crwiL wn Q.cyvv^^oA/3AA/v^ A^vsl vaJCxIju^ \'

^ F

—

(rr-

1

E't

C^^v^.^w\q^ ~lSv5. Y^^>V:iov\o-J!^ ^pJW Wvvv\ CV^O. S^y^-

P- .r \/^-V

27

P - V

\

Vk

^ Y

k He

' y

Y

crv

p-.

\/l<v ir

E-'t

Joukowsky Talbot.

p\JlidL crv\ ~Voip q? l<xc^ dY^j^t . wxcfi I'JU^ wv>^

Ferp<d\j\urp\

Pet-cocks

^Quick-closit?g ValvJe

MotoKTl7i5 efpd 12 bigber Ibdi?

Rccordit?5 Apparatus

30

VAj^t^ ^"ttLz. WIdcd- Va/^^JI/o^ ^'Rjl "bwwft \MOJ^ WvaCKATVv •

31

32

\-A/^/'~v-Qw VAyO-C^j CK/^h\ VD^Q-O^AXyoJL <'^0^ oYVv VAT (X/:>

fV~W CX OL SL. ^ CTVv ^

ir -'

Ot IHt.

UNIVEKSIfy of ILLINOIS.

34

LIBRARYOf FHt

UNIVERSITY uf ILLINOIS.

-55

CcQJL sSxcrv.^ ^ ^ cJLo'^>-e_ c^^Y*-^ ^-v-^v5i/vCt ^S^a ^c5-vwv^o^

P= 59.7 VActual Vrc^uYC

1 55 1 to

3 140

4 Go

4R

^> 33

7 \4

4.q 4

34,

Vo-uo-O/^d "t^VJl "^^v-^ -Wi<3v ) CX^

^cx^vJIa d cx/V'x.^ ^^.^vA-CL^ vj-CK/-v^olVi vrvv . ^(>^\\cr-o-

v^A^tK, -^-v^vyw lOOO To ?~(DO0 -^jurt SlcrvxC^, ^0-^^^^

Cw\(^ SLa>^Wv -^vJi/-vs. ~V^^vjL ^rv«L/ao vvo-«- WO</D ryv^~\ C^Q-^^/^r-'i (XAjsV

(TV ^'S.^O '"T^^ "b^/v-v^ oiLo'S.AA/^-^i- W^cJ^ C>.5^ets

Pressures 4-4 Ft. RRor^ Stand-pipe.

Ref.N9

'TV?(2oKe"tical Actual T/f?7e oF clo5in9Val\)e — Sec.

1 2 lO

Z 29 "2

3 ZGO .025

4 2GO

5 290 .022

?00

7 29X .0 1 5

37

V

to , (X ^S^^^c^i: cSacl(-

Vv\C\

CLcTv\

VD-a-S.^v- h. ~^^<_a. Q. d^~t;; (Tt^ -V

ftow^ri: Q. crv\ cLv.'Vi cm ^v^ciefijbo A -A Q^^^d^o^wvO^ A-Ato WiL

Ca/v\

ocV

Zytx

-A ZOO

OA

3^

Ct-^ /ircxfiv^ CX/^(A o\dj^ ^5^1. Ip'lp-^j ci^'tiio'

40

to it h^i

A

CO- a-.

41

d(>^.yO^ VAJCv-v(l ^-i/o-A^ ~\^\Ji -^aXTY^ '^j<riAV(xJL ^^A/^ya2. O <2l

3

43

orw)rv\c^^ (Xvxd ^^~V ^0^^^^ "^ocbco^ ^?aol o^/x/vawx CAy^cL^irf

ciyvCXCYv-CX/vi/vA) rw\ crvM_ VatTI^ .AAa/vC\ i^/J^JLo 6Ctv^ (wva/C\

XvwL ed.

4^

jpO^x^ "^2. ^ t&jZ. O-^CJ^i" IaJCXa/^ ^acJSoo

v^cx^vAii. Or-Q.cv ci^oi^ 5po-^-^^ ~~t2vs. ctwvVd oVi 0^

GOV

45"

l-^vjL "bv^^^^^Ji ^ ^t^Rjl VyO (X/\A^ ^ Cs fW/v-^ ^^^'^wo cX/voVc

iXvji nrvC^^A: Vv3(Xaa^ CrvM/^ Ctv^^ASvji ^^"^ AAJ(Xa.^

'tvoQjiA b Ov/v\ W^cLvecCVcn- \j^r\XSi ^<x^^ ^-^^ ^SvC^y-SL

a. ^

"fcwwG WxtWvJeJto . ^-iZJi. ^(XC^L, 70"^

<

(?v ex.

CM

VATV^^^^X^ ^^0\yv/^ '5-^^-o^>^Arv^

do

43

\o-ervx ^^^^

4-9

""iXui rvr oSUj^ \,A/-V-v^ ~Vr->KvjL ^ .

1

Calculated DistFEET

Acrual DislFEET

1 7Z.

z 70 V2

3 37/ 5*^1

4 3^5 3^ 1

5 375 38 1

262 2G5

7 245" 2(,5

1 IG 1/3

T'-^Ml ^Ovot i?v-v-JUl Qji-0<.Wy3 W-V>-S- N^-£C\ Q-OC.Vx),

so

CL^^^I^^^---

«i_W-cJLi;> w>.c^^ U~oJL^.^ v^yv^ |p^y^_a wvro-v^ (i

5-1

(j^ y4 W^e^ ^^\jUL^ yQ-CxXsL Vd-R/^^ oC\ O^O^i: (X^O^^&x?;

6 DKur7\

,Qu/cH Closirpg

52

h K

^ ^ ' Y

53

ZP'-P-vP.

P > F' > T-,

CTY

FP]^-^ (P^)[ ^^^Vf" - (^T?] - ^'^^i^>-^^

CX/v\

uP\^

Z.?" = V. + ?^ ft)

2?"= ?^ + ?-,

P- el?'-?") . , . ..Q^:)

p V P T ' ?" ?"'

55"

(3) cx^<k (fV") W-^

W^Jlil 9jL(xW^ (X^d

Cry W\ c\

57

^-T-., .

v~ r" ,p"- F"; F"'-T^";

Q,.M^(^^-.F^J C5)

K

5^

^^JLxj ^^VG'"Vr'^

0>jl>-'tAj«,

A

U- .

— V

4o

Fcrv 7^7 ^ Z~vv^Q^ y^si woi^c^ Voo^l"^

UrvCtj/v ^o-M.(>w^c^ Vv\A^A/>^ecxil ^cm-^^^A^cx^ oS^

V"^ a.

G2.

"tbtoil coAii/x^ 5wC^ d/w^'cSlfi^ Vd^"^"\^ ORiLoext^ 0^

^lAA/vCK5iL . t^Wx^S 'vLo:\ ^^^IsL ^oJo/v CX^fcuv

<o3

n^oJL^-^^"tSvCVvx v^rvt^ -^J^o^ Vj-^liLoQ.Atc^

L7(XW^ 3l/vi^.^-!l^ efi^-^^. ^VA^-VA^OJ^

Wvv. V to O Cxt

300 feet oF pi pe ISO feet p\peV= 7 \/= 54 V= 22 Thco.Timc v= S.Z 1X^7.7 V = Z.2

.0457 . 4,3 .D2t^ . C>Z53 . 0\7^

(a(o

^CvAAAsiL Vyw^ou-^ VJCX.5,A^ V ^ oiLb'S ^ ^^^^

^^cxWv "^'^vji ^vx y^-Q. \^ ^Ci^jJ^-cd J VocA T\s- VjJiJlo^t;^

DIAGRAMS WITH SIX INCH PIPE \1N THE UTSei

DIAGRAMS UEAKS

Leak 72' frorzA \)a)\)e

PetcocKs ) 1 3 ^Y?d 265 Fror^A \)alve. op<z:r?

D1AQRAM3 44 FT FROM STANDPIPE.V^vS^FEET PER SETC

.3howir7^ (Z^fPect of 1ir7\e of elosure or? pKcssuv^e

.

DlAGRAh70

1 SHOWING SUCCESSION OF WAVES

1

1

5

-ji

..4 „f-

M^^.' -^-. -^:-

. ....

4 4^ ^ ^ *^ ^t^, #^ ^ #^ 4^ f

^ ^

'f' * 4^ *

'K-I,

-1^:^

4 4 44- n

f \- 4f > 4 4 ir 4

t 4^ 4 4 f-

i- f 4 4 44 4 4 4 4 4 4 -4 4

it if 4^ 4 f 4 4 4f f 4 4 4- 4 4 4 4

4 4 4 4 4- ^ 4 44 4^ 4 4

ff 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 f4- 4- 4- 4 4 4 4 4 4 4

i- 4- 4 4- 4- 4^ 4 4 4 4i- -f 4 + 4 4 i

4- 4- 4 4^ 4 4^ # 44- 4^ 4 4 4 4^ 4 4 4

4 4- 4 4 4 4 4 44> 4 4 4 4 4 4 4- 4 4 4 4

4^ ih ^ ^ ' ^ ^

-11^. ^-iF^ ^ #, t ^ ^

,# ^4

I

#

^ ^ 4 ^ 4 ^ 4 ^ ' -4 ^ ^ 4

IT

^ ^ ^ ^ ^

iJtHllf ^4 ^- ^

' ^ =^ _iJt ^ ^ ^ --It 4' ^ ^

^ ^ # ,

4 ^ "^-^ "^1^ ^"^^

-# ^ if

^ ^ ^ --^

4.

^ ^

-^-^^ ^-^^^

-^j^ ^(h- ^.if

% 4 ~n

-4

f Ik ^ ^ ^ ^

^ -f. ^ ^1^

4

' Hh^ ^ ^ ^