unicef clare, global wash cluster meeting wednesday 30 th october 2013

1

UNICEF CLARE, Global WASH Cluster MeetingWednesday 30th October 2013

2

Agenda1. CLARE Purpose and Methodology2. CLARE Findings and WASH Cluster Details3. CLARE Recommendations and Potential WASH Cluster Action Points

3UNICEF CLARE, introduction

4

Methodology

5

Methodology

6UNICEF CLARE, findings

7

Findings

• Country and Global agreement UNICEF is effective in exercising its WASH cluster responsibilities.

• WASH country partners state UNICEF is providing effective operational support.• WASH partners see positive effects on geographic and thematic coverage.• Country level WASH partners agree UNICEF adheres to partnership principles, but

global WASH partners raised concerns about Equality and Transparency.• WASH roles and responsibilities are clear at country level but only ¼ of global

respondents say they are clear.• Almost half of global WASH partners said UNICEF is not participating equally as a

member.

8

Findings

• WASH cluster RECA capacities are the only formalized regional cluster/AoR capacity.• WASH country partners mostly agree UNICEF has comparative advantages due to its

programmes and coordination capacities that support its CLA roles.• Global WASH partners questioned UNICEF’s programme and coordination comparative

advantages with only 1/3 agreeing these strengths support its CLA role.

9

Findings

• WASH cluster found to have the strongest global surge capacity systems.• 44% of all cluster positions and surge deployments filled globally by UNICEF were for

the WASH cluster.• 2/3 of WASH country partners rated cluster coordinators highly for needed technical

and coordination (soft) skills.

10

Findings

• WASH cluster participants rated deactivation mechanisms and procedures as indadequate, similar to other clusters.

11

Findings

• 85% of WASH country partners state that coordination outcomes justify their investments of time and money.

• 78% of WASH global partners state that coordination outcomes justify their investments of time and money.

12

UNICEF is increasingly implementing its CLA role well, however

the ability to carry out its CLA role well is limited and stretched due to ‘cluster scope creep’ – cluster activition beyond fit for purpose, linked to

Contextual and internal factors

13UNICEF CLARE, recommendations

14

Recommendations

Potential WASH Cluster Action Point(s)

Partnership: Develop mutual obligations of global cluster members that operationalize equality and transparency expectations. Ensure action plans clearly delineate roles and responsibilities, including those of UNICEF distinct from its cluster coordination roles.

15

Recommendations

Potential WASH Cluster Action Point(s)

Regional roles: Analyse the lessons learned from the RECA system to inform consideration of the appropriate role for UNICEF regional offices in supporting national coordination platforms.

Performance monitoring: Establish performance monitoring approach to measure support from the global WASH cluster to national coordination platforms based on agreed action plans.

Comparative advantages: Map the comparative programme and coordination advantages of global WASH cluster members and use to inform action plans.

16

Recommendations

Potential WASH Cluster Action Point(s)

Surge capacity strategy: Develop a strategy for staffing WASH cluster coordination functions that more deliberately defines when, where and for what functions different mechanisms will be used to provide coordination staff (e.g. RRT, SbPs, Country Office direct recruitment).

Capacity development: Identify the priority capacity development needs for national coordination platforms and determine the best approach to supporting them (e.g. RECA mentoring, simulations, etc.).

17

Recommendations

Potential WASH Cluster Action Point(s)

Transition: Develop WASH cluster strategies and procedures for coordinating with pre-existing sectoral coordination mechanisms, coordinating with them and supporting sectoral coordination once a full WASH cluster is no longer required.

18

Recommendations

19

UNICEF CLARE, Global WASH Cluster MeetingWednesday 30th October 2013