tmt investment banking - headwaters tmt blog › headwaters_ecommerce_mark… · livingsocial 5 na...
Post on 24-Jun-2020
7 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Confidential
TMT Investment Banking
eCommerce Market Update
July 2013
2Confidential
Headwaters TMT Investment Banking: Strong 2013 MomentumH
EAD
WA
TER
S TM
T O
VER
VIE
W
HAS BEEN ACQUIRED BY
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
HAS DIVESTED SPECIFIC ASSETS TO
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
HAS BEEN ACQUIRED BY
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
Avail / RichRelevance: Cross-border M&A in eCommerce Infrastructure
Cooking.com / Target Corporation: Top retailer acquiring in Specialized eCommerce focused on home and cookware vertical with hybrid content story
Payvment / Intuit: Social commerce and marketing related transaction
Headwaters’ technology, media, and telecom (“TMT”) eCommerce practice has recently completed strategic transactions across the ecosystem:
May 2013 March 2013 January 2013
Confidential 3
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
M&A Activity – M&A activity in 2Q 2013 is stronger than that of 1Q 2013, although deal volume is still below 2Q 2012 and 2Q 2011 levels. 2Q 2013 deal value was helped by SAP’s $1.1B acquisition of hybris.
Investment Activity – Investment volume increased by 35% from 1Q to 2Q 2013 after 3 straight quarters of volume decline. 2Q saw several Asian strategics (Alibaba.com, Tencent, and Itochu) making significant investments into US-based firms.
Trading Multiples – Internet Retailers (Web Only) on the whole trade at a median of 1.6x LTM revenue. Marketplaces command the greatest premium, trading at a median of 9.0x LTM revenue. Specific vertical market focus also trading at higher levels.
Capital Markets – Specialized eCommerce companies have generally outperformed the market. European Retailers with Online Presence continue to underperform on the whole.
eCommerce Market Update
Confidential 4
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
eCommerce M&A Volume Trending Slightly Down
_______Source: 451 Group; includes announced transactions with disclosed, estimated, undisclosed transaction valuesTop 3 acquisitions with disclosed transaction values greater than $50M
Top 3 Acquisitions by Quarter ($M) – Target / Acquirer
1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 1Q12 2Q12 3Q12 4Q12 1Q13 2Q13
GSI Commerce / eBay
($2,400)
Primedia / TPG
($316)
Zong / eBay
($240)
Kobo / Rakuten($315)
Bol.com / Ahold($465)
Getty Images / Carlyle Group
($3,300)
KAYAK.com / Priceline($1,800)
Channel Intel. / Google($125)
Hybris / SAP
($1,100)
AutoTrader.ca / Apax
($745)
Qunar.com /Baidu($306)
OPENLANE / KAR Auction
($210)
Wiggle / Bridgepoint
($281)
Redbaby /Suning($66)
Trivago /Expedia($632)
Market Leader / Trulia($355)
Opodo / Permira Funds
($611)
GittiGidiyor / eBay
($235)
Plimus / Great Hill
($115)
Wer Liefert / Paragon Partners
($103)
ConceptWave / Ericsson
($56)
Litle & Co. / Vantiv($361)
Society6 / Demand Media
($94)
54
47
64
34
44 47
49 51
33
39
$5.66
$1.51
$0.65 $0.77$0.48 $0.05
$3.49 $3.36
$0.13
$1.62
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
$0.00
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
1Q 2011 2Q 2011 3Q 2011 4Q 2011 1Q 2012 2Q 2012 3Q 2012 4Q 2012 1Q 2013 2Q 2013
# Deals$ in billions Deal Volume Deal Value ($B)
Confidential 5
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
Top Acquirers in eCommerce Market
Buyer # Acquisitions Total Value ($M) Targets
eBay 8 2,875 bill safe, GittiGidiyor.com, GSI Commerce, Hunch, Magento, Svpply, WHI Solutions, Zong
Rakuten 8 354 ADS eCommerce Logistics, Ikeda, Kenko.com, Kobo, Play.com, Tradoria, Webgistix, Wuaki.tv
LivingSocial 5 NA Ensogo.com, GoNabit, Lets Bonus, ONOSYS, TicketMonster
SKYE Associates 4 NA Fantasy Jewelry Box, The Hip Chick, PinkMascara.com, SimplySoles.com
Google 3 125 Android.me, Channel Intelligence, Cuil
TripAdvisor 3 NA CruiseWise (assets), Jetsetter, Niumba.com
Top Acquirers by Volume, 2011 – Present
_______Source: 451 Group through 06/30/13; includes transactions with disclosed, estimated, undisclosed values
Buyer Total Value ($M) Targets
The Carlyle Group 3,300 Getty Images
eBay 2,875 bill safe, GittiGidiyor.com, GSI Commerce, Hunch, Magento, Svpply, WHI Solutions, Zong
Priceline 1,800 KAYAK.com
SAP 1,100 hybris
Apax Partners 745 Autotrader.ca
Expedia 632 Trivago
Permira Funds 611 Opodo
Michael Rubin / Kynetic 498 Rue La La, ShopRunner
Ahold 465 Bol.com
Walgreen 429 Drugstore.com
Top Acquirers by Total Transaction Value – Greater than $400M, 2011 – Present
Confidential 6
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
eCommerce M&A Case Study
On June 5, 2013
Salesforce
ACQUIRED
Transaction Overview:• $1.1 billion acquisition of hybris by SAP• hybris had LTM revenue of $125 million with a 3-year revenue CAGR of 70%• Implied LTM revenue multiple is 8.8x• Deal comes after a $30M fundraising round in March for hybris• At 600 employees, consideration per employee is $1.8 million
Target Description• SaaS based eCommerce management software that provides product data
management, merchandising, search engine optimization, customer support management, marketing materials publishing and order management.
Transaction Commentary:• SAP will integrate hybris’s eCommerce management software into its SAP
HANA® platform, analytical and cloud applications, and SAP Jam social platform
• According to the acquirer press release, the acquisition will allow SAP “to deliver the next-generation eCommerce platform, with the choice of on-premise or cloud deployment, as enterprises around the world seek to optimize the customer experience for businesses and consumers across an ever-growing number of delivery channels, devices and touch points”
_______Source: Acquirer Press Release, 451 Group
Confidential 7
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
eCommerce Investment Volume Remains Steady
Top 3 Investments by Quarter ($M)
1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 1Q12 2Q12 3Q12 4Q12 1Q13 2Q13
360buy.com($500)
360buy.com($1,500)
Airbnb($117)
LivingSocial($176)
Flipkart India($150)
Fanatics($150)
Flipkart India($150)
360buy.com($300)
360buy.com($700)
Fanatics($170)
Privalia($123)
LivingSocial($400)
Ozon Holdings($100)
Klarna($155)
Despegar.com($93)
Fotolia($150)
Delivery Hero($50)
Fab($120)
LivingSocial($110)
Fab($150)
Stella & Dot($37)
Wayfair($165)
Xiu.com($100)
Living Social($143)
Airbnb($70)
Lemon Tree($119)
Lazada($50)
Zulily($85)
Attivio($42)
Lamoda($130)
_______Source: PitchBook; includes announced transactions with disclosed, estimated, undisclosed transaction valuesTop 3 investments with disclosed investment values
81
98
73
83
106
134
113
90
77
104
$941
$2,869
$774
$1,235
$726
$1,301
$889$982
$1,358 $1,280
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
$0
$500
$1,000
$1,500
$2,000
$2,500
$3,000
$3,500
1Q 2011 2Q 2011 3Q 2011 4Q 2011 1Q 2012 2Q 2012 3Q 2012 4Q 2012 1Q 2013 2Q 2013
# Investments$ in millions Investment Volume Investment Value ($M)
Confidential 8
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
Top Investors In eCommerce Market
_______Source: PitchBook through 06/30/13; number of investments may include follow-on investments in same target
Investor Investments Targets
Accel Partners 36
Baby.com.br, BaubleBar, BeachMint, Bonobos, Comuto, Elo7, Endorse, eTree, Etsy, Exclusively.In,Flipkart India, HMS Infotech, Hotel Tonight, Loose Cubes, Lot18, Lyst, Modcloth, One Jackson,Ostrovok.ru, Privat Trade, Project J, Shopmium, Stylefantasia, Travelmob, UberMedia, ZopNow
First Round Capital 32
AxialMarket, BlackJet, Chloe and Isabel, CustomMade Ventures, Fab, Grand Street, Hotel Tonight,Instacanvas, Jirafe, Liftopia Holding, Modcloth, One Kings Lane, Poppin, Storenvy, TaskRabbit,Threadflip, True&Co, Wanelo, Warby Parker
Index Ventures 27
1stdibs, Brit Media, Capitaine Train, CruiseWise, Etsy, farfetch.com, HouseTrip, Nasty Gal,Notonthehighstreet.com, Ozon Holdings, People Per Hour, Privalia, Rad, Shapeways, Stylefantasia,TrialPay, UberMedia
Tiger Global Management
23
360buy.com, Baby.com.br, CatchoftheDay.com.au, Despegar.com, eTree Marketing, Exclusively.In,Flipkart India, MotorExchange, One Kings Lane, Robemall Apparels, Trendyol.com, Warby Parker,Wego, Wikimart
Battery Ventures 21 ADKU, Continuuity, Duetto Research, GoEuro, Gogobot, Hotel Tonight, JOOR, Loose Cubes, Retail Relay, Send the Trend, TrialPay, Vaunte, Wayfair, Wikets
Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers
21 Choose Energy, everlane, Lockerz, Luvocracy, One Kings Lane, Plum District, Rent The Runway,Session M, Stipple, Storenvy, Trendyol.com, Xiu.com, Zaarly
General Catalyst 19Airbnb, BigCommerce, Brit Media, Chloe and Isabel, GoodData, Optaros, Ostrovok.ru, Plum District, Room 77, Swirl Networks, TVLX Viagens e Turismo, Warby Parker, Yplan
Andreessen Horowitz 18Airbnb, Continuuity, Fab, Fanatics, GoodData, Lyft, Shapeways, ShoeDazzle.com, Shoptiques,Threadflip, Wikets, Zulily
Greylock Partners 18ADKU, Betable, Citrus Lane, hybris Software, mySupermarket, Notonthehighstreet.com, One Kings Lane, RichRelevance, Shoptiques, Threadflip, TrialPay, Wantful
Top Investors by Volume – Eighteen or More Investments, 2011 – Present
Confidential 9
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
eCommerce Investment Case Study
On June 7, 2013
INVESTED IN
Transaction Overview:• $170 million investment in Fanatics by Alibaba.com and Temasek Holdings• The investment values the company at $3.1B• CEO Michael Rubin estimates the company will reach $1B in revenue this year
Target Description:• Provider of sports merchandise. The company operates more than 250 eCommerce
websites, and more than 60 eCommerce stores for collegiate and professional sports partners and media organizations.
Transaction Commentary:• According to the CEO, the money will help fund an oversees expansion and bolster
distribution. “We think there is huge potential in sports apparel and for fanatics to grow, we’ll be looking at Western Europe and Asia as places to move into.”
_______Sources: iResearch, PitchBook, TechCrunch, VentureBeat, WSJ*Other investors include Atomico, Andreessen Horowitz, Menlo Ventures, RTP, Pinnacle, and DoCoMo
On May 21, 2013
Among Others*
INVESTED IN
Transaction Overview:• $150 million investment in Fab by Tencent and Itochu, among others• The pre-money valuation is estimated to be $1B• The Company expects $250M in 2013 revenue, and is achieving 43% gross margins
Target Description:• Provider of an online retail site specializing in designer-influenced products, including
clothing, accessories, furniture, food and pet products
Transaction Commentary:• According to CEO Jason Goldberg, Fab will use the proceeds to enhance supply chain,
logistics, customer service, technology, and merchandising• The CEO also stated that Fab will work with Tencent to expand into China
Confidential 10
1.9x
3.1x
0.5x
1.1x
0.2x
0.8x
0.0x
2.0x
4.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
0.6x
0.8x0.8x
2.2x
2.0x
0.5x
0.2x0.2x
0.6x
1.3x
0.9x
0.2x0.2x
0.5x
0.8x
0.1x
0.0x
1.0x
2.0x
3.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
U.S eCommerce Comparable Public Companies
U.S. Retailers with Online Presence*
Median:0.6x
Median:0.9x
U.S. Internet Retailers (Web Only)
_______Sources: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13, Internet Retailer 500; companies arranged by descending enterprise value*Top U.S. Retailers by websales volume, or greater than 33% of revenue in websales
Confidential 11
0.5x
0.3x
2.3x
0.4x
0.2x 0.1x
0.0x
1.0x
2.0x
3.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
5.2x
2.5x
1.6x
2.4x
0.7x
0.0x
2.0x
4.0x
6.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
European eCommerce Comparable Public Companies
Median:0.4x
Median:2.4x
_______Sources: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13, Internet Retailer 500; companies arranged by descending enterprise value*Top European Retailers by websales volume, or greater than 33% revenue in websales
European Retailers with Online Presence*European Internet Retailers (Web Only)
Confidential 12
9.0x
4.3x
3.2x
11.6x
8.8x
9.8x10.0x
0.0x
2.0x
4.0x
6.0x
8.0x
10.0x
12.0x
14.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
6.9x
1.8x
1.4x
2.0x2.3x
0.0x
2.0x
4.0x
6.0x
8.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
Specialized eCommerce Comparable Public Companies
Median:2.0x
Median:9.0x
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13; companies arranged by descending enterprise value
TravelMarketplaces
Confidential 13
4.7x
7.7x
5.0x
9.0x
1.9x
2.7x
4.6x
6.3x
0.0x
2.0x
4.0x
6.0x
8.0x
10.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
2.3x
3.5x4.2x
15.7x
0.7x0.2x
0.6x
0.0x
4.0x
8.0x
12.0x
16.0x
LTM Revenue Multiple
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
eCommerce Enablement Comparable Public Companies
Median:2.3x
Median:4.9x
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13; companies arranged by descending enterprise value
eCommerce InfrastructureeCommerce Services
Confidential 14
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13; refer to public comps for constituentsLeading Internet Companies Index includes top internet companies by revenue as per Capital IQ: Amazon, Baidu, eBay, Expedia, Facebook, Google, Priceline, Rakuten, Tencent, and Yahoo!
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
U.S, Eur. & Specialized eCommerce Capital Markets Performance
Since 2011, Travel (+72.1%) and Marketplaces (+71.4%) have outperformed European Internet Retailers (Web Only) (+64.9%), U.S. Internet Retailers (Web Only) (+50.2%), Leading Internet Companies (+40.0%), U.S. Retailers with Online Presence (+27.4%), the NASDAQ (+26.4%), the S&P 400 (+26.2%) and European Retailers with Online Presence (-17.1%)
Travel: +72.1%Marketplaces: +71.4%
U.S. Internet Retailers (Web Only): +50.2%Leading Internet Companies: +40.0%U.S. Retailers w/ Online Presence: +27.4%NASDAQ: +26.4%S&P 400: +26.2%
European Internet Retailers (Web Only): +64.9%
European Retailers w/ Online Presence: -17.1%
(60.0%)
(40.0%)
(20.0%)
0.0%
20.0%
40.0%
60.0%
80.0%
Confidential 15
ECO
MM
ERC
E M
AR
KET
eCommerce Enablement Capital Markets Performance
Since 2011, eCommerce Services (+29.5%) has underperformed compared to Leading Internet Companies (+40.0%), but outperformed the NASDAQ (+26.4%) and the S&P 400 (+26.2%). eCommerce Infrastructure (+18.7%) has underperformed Leading Internet Companies, the NASDAQ, and the S&P 400.
Leading Internet Companies: +40.0%
eCommerce Services: +29.5%
S&P 400: +26.2%
eCommerce Infrastructure: +18.7%
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13; refer to public comps for constituentsLeading Internet Companies Index includes top internet companies by revenue as per Capital IQ: Amazon, Baidu, eBay, Expedia, Facebook, Google, Priceline, Rakuten, Tencent, and Yahoo!
NASDAQ: +26.4%
(30.0%)
(20.0%)
(10.0%)
0.0%
10.0%
20.0%
30.0%
40.0%
50.0%
16Confidential
We are best in class bankers, technologists, and strategists
Relevant transaction expertise
- Completed transactions with many strategic acquirers, targets, and investors in eCommerce
Strong relationships with key, relevant strategic parties
- Sector focus and industry experience means we are in frequent communication with likely interested targets
Direct market coverage gives us unique insights regarding:
- Acquisition targets - IP / value chain
- Competitive and adjacent market activity - Growth markets
Highly customized process to fit specific dynamic context
- One size fits all auction processes not the best in eCommerce
- We will run a focused, intelligent process with proper target screening tailored to specific areas of interest to achieve most ideal valuation for buyer
We think “outside the box” – complex situations require creative solutions
Headwaters Is Your Premier ChoiceH
EAD
WA
TER
S TM
T O
VER
VIE
W
INVESTMENT BANK OF THE YEAR
2012 TMT DEAL OF THE YEAR <$100M
2012 INTERNATIONAL DEAL OF THE YEAR
INVESTMENT BANK OF THE YEAR
HAS BEEN ACQUIREDBY
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
HAS BEEN ACQUIREDBY
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
Tickets.com
IPO$95,500,000
Lead Manager
HAS BEEN ACQUIRED BY
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
HAS DIVESTED SPECIFIC ASSETS TO
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
HAS BEEN ACQUIRED BY
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
Solid Information Technology Ltd., Inc.
HAS BEEN ACQUIRED BY
Financial Advisor tothe Seller
HAS ACQUIRED
$120,000,000
Fairness Opinion tothe Buyer
Confidential 17
CO
NTA
CT
US
Contact
www.headwatersmb.com
Gary MoonManaging Director
Head of Technology, Media & Telecom
Investment Banking
Office: (415) 766-3862
Cell: (650) 515-8734
gmoon@headwatersmb.com
135 Main St
Suite 800
San Francisco, CA 94105
Sun Jen YungManaging Director
Head of Digital Media & Internet
Investment Banking
Office: (203) 992-1667
Cell: (917) 297-8716
sunjyung@headwatersmb.com
41 West Putnam Ave
1st Floor
Greenwich, CT 06830
Kuni TakahashiDirector
Technology, Media & Telecom
Investment Banking
Office: (415) 766-3864
Cell: (650) 465-7824
ktakahashi@headwatersmb.com
135 Main St
Suite 800
San Francisco, CA 94105
Confidential 18
Appendix:2Q 2013 eCommercePrecedent M&A Transactions
Confidential 19
2Q 2013 Precedent M&A TransactionsA
PP
END
IX
Date Target Target Description Acquirer(s)Enterprise
Value ($M)
EV /LTM
Revenue
EV /LTM
EBITDA
06/26/13 GigablastOperates an Internet search engine using results from its own index through www.gigablast.com.
Yippy, Inc. [fka Cinnabar Ventures, Inc.]
-- -- --
06/24/13 Society6 LLCProvides an online art retail marketplace where artists upload their art to be purchased by consumers.
Demand Media, Inc. [NYSE: DMD]
94.0 6.3x --
06/11/13CableOrganizer .com
Operates as an online retailer of cable, wire and related accessories for businesses and consumers in the US through www.cableorganizer.com.
CapitalSouth Partners/KT Capital Partners
-- -- --
06/05/13Webgistix Corporation
Provides e-commerce order fulfillment software as a service (SaaS) for online retailers globally.
Rakuten, Inc. -- -- --
06/05/13hybris GmbH [Huntsman Gay Global Capital]
Provides e-commerce management software and software as a service (SaaS) for businesses globally.
SAP AG 1,100.0 8.8x --
06/05/13EVS Online Auctions
Provides an online auction service for the sale of commercial trucks, construction vehicles and cars for businesses and consumers in the UK through www.evsonlineauctions.com.
Manheim -- -- --
06/03/13 OrderDynamicsProvides e-commerce management software as a service (SaaS) for online retailers.
eCommera Limited -- -- --
06/03/13Freedom Travel Group Ltd., The [dba Planet Cruise]
Provides online cruise reservations services for consumers in the UK through www.planetcruise.com. Also produces a related live TV show.
Iglu.com Ltd. -- -- --
05/31/13 Shopo.inOperates an online retailer of handmade apparel, jewelry, fashion and home accessories, beauty products and stationery for consumers in India through www.shopo.in.
Snapdeal.com -- -- --
05/30/13BigCeramicStore .com
Operates as an online retailer of ceramics crafting materials, including kilns, glazes, pottery wheels and tools, for consumers in the US through www.bigceramicstore.com.
Vertana Group LLC -- -- --
EV ($M)EV/LTM Revenue
EV/LTM EBITDA
High $1,100.0 8.8x --
Mean 200.3 5.6x --
Median 34.9 6.8x --
Low 1.2 0.1x --
_______Source: 451 Group
Confidential 20
2Q 2013 Precedent M&A TransactionsA
PP
END
IX
Date Target Target Description Acquirer(s)Enterprise
Value ($M)
EV /LTM
Revenue
EV /LTM
EBITDA
05/28/13 WebcollageProvides e-commerce catalog management software as a service (SaaS) that enables consumer goods manufacturers to publish product documents, videos and images on retailer websites.
Answers Corporation
-- -- --
05/24/13 Fab Shoes, TheOperates as a membership-based online footwear retailer for female consumers in France and Spain. Websites offer personalized recommendations based on answers given by users.
JustFabulous [dba JustFab.com]
-- -- --
05/23/13 Bluefly, Inc.Operates as an online retailer of clothing, shoes, jewelry and accessories for consumers in the US through www.bluefly.com and www.belleandclive.com.
Clearlake Capital Group
3.0 -- --
05/22/13GoLocal Inc. [dba Giftly]
Operates as an online retailer of prepaid gift cards for consumers through www.giftly.com. Gift cards can be distributed via email, social networks, text message or an iOS smart phone application.
GiftCards.com LLC -- -- --
05/22/13 Xatori, Inc.Provides a search engine that enables electric vehicle owners in the US to locate charging stations.
Recargo, Inc. -- -- --
05/13/13 OHKIOperates as an online retailer of consumers electronics and home appliances for consumers in Australia through www.ohki.com.au.
Adeffective Ltd. -- -- --
05/13/13Avail Intelligence Software
Provides product recommendation software as a service (SaaS) for online retailers in Europe.
RichRelevance, Inc. -- -- --
05/09/13Subscription Bridge
Provides customer billing software as a service (SaaS) that enables businesses to create and manage subscription packages.
Cloud Nation -- -- --
05/09/13 MileWiseProvides an online flight and hotel reservation search and comparison service that enables consumers to determine whether to use cash, points or frequent-flyer miles when traveling.
Yahoo! Inc. -- -- --
05/08/13Market Leader, Inc.
Provides lead generation software as a service (SaaS) for the real estate sector in North America.
Trulia, Inc. [NYSE:TRLA]
332.8 7.4x --
EV ($M)EV/LTM Revenue
EV/LTM EBITDA
High $1,100.0 8.8x --
Mean 200.3 5.6x --
Median 34.9 6.8x --
Low 1.2 0.1x --
_______Source: 451 Group
Confidential 21
2Q 2013 Precedent M&A TransactionsA
PP
END
IX
Date Target Target Description Acquirer(s)Enterprise
Value ($M)
EV /LTM
Revenue
EV /LTM
EBITDA
05/08/13 OrderMotion, Inc.Provides e-commerce order and fulfillment management software as a service (SaaS) for online retailers.
NetSuite Inc -- -- --
05/07/13 Niumba.comProvides a searchable vacation housing rental classified ads website for consumers globally www.niumba.com.
TripAdvisor, Inc. [NASDAQ: TRIP]
-- -- --
05/03/13Sport Professional Schmid (assets)
Assets of Schmid Profi, which operates as an online retailer of sports and fitness clothing, shoes and accessories for consumers in Europe through www.sportsprofi.de.
SmartGuy Group A/S
1.4 0.1x --
05/02/13Webswappers Ltd, [dba Swapit]
Provides an online auction service that enables youths in the UK to trade in and purchase a variety of items using virtual currency through www.swapit.co.uk.
Box of Awesome -- -- --
05/02/13CruiseWise (technology and talent assets)
Technology and talent assets of CruiseWise, which provides an online travel reservations service that enables consumers in the US to book cruise trips globally.
TripAdvisor, Inc. [NASDAQ: TRIP]
-- -- --
04/24/13February Won, Inc. (assets)
The assets of Ecomom.com, which provides an online retail site focused on organic baby food and eco-friendly baby products to parents through www.ecomom.com.
etailz Inc [dba GreenCupboards]
-- -- --
04/24/13 GidsyProvides an online activity, event, workshop and tour reservations service for consumers globally. Website also provides a directory of events and enables users to rate and review events.
GetYourGuide Inc. -- -- --
04/23/13 linkchic.comOperates as an online retailer of shoes, apparel and accessories for consumers in China through linkchic.com. Also provides related fashion reference content.
Modern Media Co., Ltd. [aka Modern Media Holdings]
1.2 -- --
04/23/13 reuseit.comOperates as an online retailer of reusable bags, bottles and household products for consumers in the US through www.reuseit.com.
Plow & Hearth -- -- --
04/22/13Webhallen Svierge AB
Operates as an online retailer of computers, software, consumer electronics, video games, movies and home appliances for consumers in Sweden through www.webhallen.com.
Komplett ASA 21.5 -- --
EV ($M)EV/LTM Revenue
EV/LTM EBITDA
High $1,100.0 8.8x --
Mean 200.3 5.6x --
Median 34.9 6.8x --
Low 1.2 0.1x --
_______Source: 451 Group
Confidential 22
2Q 2013 Precedent M&A TransactionsA
PP
END
IX
Date Target Target Description Acquirer(s)Enterprise
Value ($M)
EV /LTM
Revenue
EV /LTM
EBITDA
04/18/13Innovative Automation Inc.
Provides warehouse and inventory management and product order fulfillment software for businesses.
SI Systems, Inc. -- -- --
04/17/13Tripology [Rand McNally [Patriarch Partners]]
Provides a vacation package reservations website that enables consumers to receive proposals from travel agents by answering online questions through www.tripology.com.
USA TODAY Travel Media Group
-- -- --
04/16/13Onscope Group, The (trademark business)
The trademark business of The Onscope Group, which provides online trademark search and reporting services and research content for businesses in Canada. Also provides content in printed format.
Thomson CompuMark
-- -- --
04/15/13Early Impact Inc (ProductCart assets)
Early Impact's ProductCart assets, which provide e-commerce shopping card software for online retailers.
NetSource Technologies
-- -- --
04/11/13 hoopos.comOperates as an online retailer of baby and children’s clothing, toys, books, DVDs and party favors for consumers in India through www.hoopos.com.
babyoye -- -- --
04/11/13HostelBookers .com
Provides an online service that enables consumers globally to search for and reserve budget hostel and hotel rooms, apartments, guesthouses and campsites. Website enables users to rate establishments.
Web Reservations International, Ltd.
-- -- --
04/09/13 JetsetterProvides a membership-based online service that enables users to obtain discounts on hotel and resort reservations and travel packages. Also provides related online travel reference content.
TripAdvisor, Inc. [NASDAQ: TRIP]
-- -- --
04/08/13 Werkspot.nlOperates a searchable classified ads website that enables consumers in the Netherlands to post home improvement projects and receive quotes from contractors through www.werkspot.nl.
HomeAdvisor [fka ServiceMagic Inc.] [IAC]
-- -- --
04/01/13 SGCM Pte. Ltd.Provides a searchable classified ads website that lists new and used vehicles for sale for consumers in the Singapore through www.sgcarmart.com.
Singapore Press Holdings Limited
48.3 -- --
EV ($M)EV/LTM Revenue
EV/LTM EBITDA
High $1,100.0 8.8x --
Mean 200.3 5.6x --
Median 34.9 6.8x --
Low 1.2 0.1x --
_______Source: 451 Group
Confidential 23
Appendix:2Q 2013 eCommercePrecedent Investments
Confidential 24
AP
PEN
DIX
2Q 2013 Precedent Investments, $5M+
_______Source: PitchBook
Date Target Target Description Investor(s) Deal TypeDeal Size
($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
06/26/13Revel Systems
Provider of cloud-based POS systems for the restaurant and retail industries. The company's iOS-based software includes integrated payroll, inventory tracking, CRM and more.
Individual Investor Series B 10.1 --
06/25/13 Brit MediaProvider of lifestyle services. The company provide an online platform and eCommerce that inspires and enables the digital generation.
Cowboy, Index, Individual Investor, Lerer, OIP
Series A 6.3 --
06/24/13 WegoDeveloper of global travel search engine. The company provides tools that help travellers research trips, compare prices and book travel online.
Crescent Point Group, Tiger Global, Victoria
Series C 17.0 --
06/19/13 LazadaCompany sells products such as books, electronics, phones & accessories, computers, home & living, hardware, home appliances, toys, kids & babies, travel and luggage, beauty, jewelry, fashion and sports.
Holtzbrinck, Summit, Tengelmann, Verlinvest
Early Stage VC
100.0 --
06/17/13Jumia Nigeria
Provider of online Nigerian shopping platform. The company operates an eCommerce site offering an array of products, including fashion clothing, mobile phones, computers and other electronics.
Millicom International CellularEarly Stage VC
35.0 --
06/13/13 ThumbtackProvider of a marketplace and review site for local services. The company hosts 200,000 small businesses and independent professionals skills.
Javelin Venture Partners, MHS, Sequoia
Series B 12.5 --
06/12/13 GoodDataProvider of business intelligence software and reporting tools to help companies monetize big data. The company's services includes operational dashboards, advanced reporting and data warehousing.
Andreessen Horowitz, GeneralCatalyst, NWC, Tenaya, TOTVS
Series D 22.0 --
06/11/13 LamodaOperator of an online retail store. The company provides a range of products including apparel, shoes, accessories and beauty.
Access Industries, Summit Partners, Tengelmann
Later Stage VC
130.0 --
06/11/13Custom Made Ventures
Provider of an online resource and marketplace that connects artisans with buyers of custom-built furniture and woodcrafts. The company also features commercial furnishings gallery.
Atlas, FR, Google, LaunchCapital, NextView, Schooner
Later Stage VC
18.0 --
06/07/13 FanaticsProvider of sports merchandise. The company operates more than 250 eCommerce websites, and more than 60 eCommerce stores for collegiate and professional sports partners and media organizations.
Alibaba Group, Temasek Holdings
Later Stage VC
170.0 3,100.0
Deal Size ($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
High $170.0 $3,100.0
Mean 32.5 885.8
Median 12.0 275.0
Low 5.0 26.3
Confidential 25
AP
PEN
DIX
2Q 2013 Precedent Investments, $5M+
_______Source: PitchBook
Date Target Target Description Investor(s) Deal TypeDeal Size
($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
06/06/13 ShopgateProvider of a mobile shopping application for mail-order and retail businesses. The company provides single-click, mobile shopping services for smartphones and tablets.
Creathor Venture, NorthCap Partners
Series B 7.0 --
06/06/13 Paddle8Provider of an online auction house, offering artworks by international artists in themed and benefit auctions. Provides online auction house that connects buyers and sellers of fine art and collectibles.
Founder Collective, Mousse, RCM
Series B 6.0 --
06/05/13 Porch.comProvider of an Internet marketplace for home design and improvement. The company’s platform connects homeowners with home-service professionals.
SV AngelSeed Round
6.3 --
06/04/13 YPlanProvider of a mobile application for event booking. The company is the developer of an application enabling users to bring up a curated list of events, select, pay and go to the event on the same evening.
A Grade, General Catalyst, Octopus, Slow, Wellington
Series A 12.0 --
06/03/13 WorldStoresProvider of online retail products. The company is an online retailer of products for the home and garden.
AVP, Balderton, Serena Series C 16.0 --
05/30/13 Surf AirlinesOperator of a membership-based private airline. The company operates short-haul flights for members who pay a fixed monthly subscription fee. Members can fly as many times as they want in a month.
AVP, Base, Individual Investor, NEA, Velos
Series B 7.0 27.4
05/29/13 BeautylishDeveloper of social commerce website for the cosmetics industry. The company provides online beauty network.
CMEA CapitalEarly Stage VC
6.5 --
05/23/13 LyftProvider of an on-demand ride-sharing service. The company provides a marketplace for drivers to sell empty seats in their car by matching them with passengers traveling along the same route.
Andreessen Horowitz Series C 60.0 275.0
05/22/13Jade eServices
Provider of an online fashion retail store. The company offers apparels, accessories, shoes, beauty, sportswear available for men, women and kids.
IABK, Rocket Internet, Summit, Tengelmann, Verlinvest
Early Stage VC
100.0 --
05/21/13 FabProvider of an online retail site specializing in designer-influenced products, including clothing, accessories, furniture, food and pet products.
Andreessen Horowitz, Atomico, DoCoMo, Itochu, Menlo, Pinnacle, RTP, Tencent
Series D 150.0 1,000.0
Deal Size ($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
High $170.0 $3,100.0
Mean 32.5 885.8
Median 12.0 275.0
Low 5.0 26.3
Confidential 26
AP
PEN
DIX
2Q 2013 Precedent Investments, $5M+
_______Source: PitchBook
Date Target Target Description Investor(s) Deal TypeDeal Size
($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
05/19/13 ReebonzProvider of an online shopping platform. The company provides online sales for short period of time that are open to members only.
GGV Capital, Infocomm, Matrix, MediaCorp, Vertex
Series A 40.0 --
05/16/13 LuvocracyCreator of an online marketplace and social platform. The company is the creator of a platform enabling users to purchase merchandise that has been recommended through social media outlets.
AngelPad, CrunchFund, Google, KPCB, RPM, XG
Early Stage VC
11.5 --
05/15/13 PrivaliaProvider of online private sales club facilities. The company organises the sale of leading name products at exceptional prices exclusively for club members.
General Atlantic, HCP, Index, IVP, La Caixa, Nauta Capital, Sofina
Later Stage VC
33.2 --
05/15/13Rock In Fashions
Provider of an online store offering international clothing. The company's retail platform provides an eCommerce site for apparel and accessories.
-- Series B 5.0 --
05/13/13Namshi General Trading
Provider of online shopping portal. The company offers a selection of apparel, footwear and accessories for men, women and children.
Summit Partners Early Stage VC
14.0 --
05/07/13CircleUp Network
Provider of an online social marketplace that supports equity investments from individual investors to small private consumer and retail companies.
Google, Maveron, Rose Park Advisors, Union Square
Series A 7.5 --
05/06/13 Project JProvider of an online shopping site that makes short videos to highlight products. The company is helping users discover goods via short-form videos.
Accel Partners, HMC, InterWest, Time Warner
Series B 11.5 --
05/06/13 MerchantryProvider of automation and integration solutions to suppliers, merchants and marketplaces. The company offers multichannel solutions that address various eCommerce scenarios.
e.ventures, Greycroft, Kite Series B 7.0 --
05/02/13 PoppinProvider of a website for buying office products. The company sells office products including paper products, pens/pencils, desktop accessories and furniture.
First Round Capital, Individual Investor, Shasta, TrilogyGrowth
Series B 11.1 --
04/30/13 Ruby RibbonProvider of a fashion commerce platform that leverages social technology and direct-sale tactics.
Mohr Davidow Ventures, Trinity Ventures
Series B 8.6 26.3
Deal Size ($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
High $170.0 $3,100.0
Mean 32.5 885.8
Median 12.0 275.0
Low 5.0 26.3
Confidential 27
AP
PEN
DIX
2Q 2013 Precedent Investments, $5M+
_______Source: PitchBook
Date Target Target Description Investor(s) Deal TypeDeal Size
($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
04/23/13 ShapewaysProvider of 3D printing services and community marketplace for 3D printed products.
Andreessen Horowitz, Index Ventures, Lux, Union Square
Series C 30.0 --
04/22/13 ATG MediaProvider of online auction information and services to the fine art and antiques industry. The company offers auction information and services through online and newspapers.
Mobeus Equity PartnersPE Growth/ Expansion
7.2 --
4/12/2013 Retail RelayProvider of online grocery shopping and delivery services. The company also provides grocery from grocery stores, eclectic restaurants and local farms through its website.
Battery Ventures, QIM, TomorrowVentures
Later Stage VC
8.3 --
4/4/2013Acumen Brands
The company maintains multiple online stores with categories that include work clothes, wedding apparel, personal protective equipment, baby gear, shoes, bedding and outdoor gear.
ARCM Fund, BLH, Dillard's, General Atlantic, Gravity, NMP
Early Stage VC
83.2 --
4/2/2013Collective Bias
Provider of a platform for social media shopping services. The company is a social media company that drives retail sales through the coordinated creation of social media stories.
Updata Partners Series A 10.5 --
4/1/2013Aquamarine HealthCare Private
Provider of an online health store. The company website hosts nutrition products, testing devices, food and footwear for diabetics, home devices for blood pressure, and other health related items.
Intel Capital, Sequoia Capital India
Series B 14.0 --
4/1/2013Trendsutra Platform Services
Provider of an online retail services. The company offers products in categories like furniture, home, lifestyle and fashion.
Norwest Venture Partners Series B 8.0 --
Deal Size ($M)
Company Valuation
($M)
High $170.0 $3,100.0
Mean 32.5 885.8
Median 12.0 275.0
Low 5.0 26.3
Confidential 28
Appendix:eCommercePublic Company Comparables
Confidential 29
AP
PEN
DIX
U.S. eCommerce Comparable Public Companies
_______Sources: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13, Internet Retailer 500*Top U.S. Retailers by websales volume, or greater than 33% of revenue in websales
Trading Metrics($ in millions, except per share data) Stock
Price 52-Week Price Range Market Enterprise EV / Revenue EV / EBITDA
Company Ticker 06/28/13 Low High Cap. Value CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
U.S Internet Retailers (Web Only)
Amazon Nasdaq:AMZN $277.69 $212.61 $284.72 $126,416 $121,561 2.0x 1.6x 1.3x 48.5x 24.2x 18.1x
Shutterfly Nasdaq:SFLY 55.91 25.18 56.46 2,202 2,038 3.2x 2.6x 2.3x 24.7x 14.0x 11.5x
Overstock.com Nasdaq:OSTK 28.20 6.12 28.49 671 589 0.5x 0.5x 0.4x 20.9x 14.1x 12.2x
Blue Nile Nasdaq:NILE 37.78 22.94 43.54 478 438 1.1x 1.0x 0.9x 32.1x 18.8x 14.6x
PC Connection Nasdaq:PCCC 15.45 9.82 17.65 407 349 0.2x 0.2x 0.2x 5.6x 5.0x 4.9x
Vitacost Nasdaq:VITC 8.45 4.97 8.49 297 267 0.8x 0.7x 0.6x NM NM 67.7x
High 3.2x 2.6x 2.3x 48.5x 24.2x 67.7x
Mean 1.3x 1.1x 0.9x 26.4x 15.2x 21.5x
Median 1.0x 0.8x 0.7x 24.7x 14.1x 13.4x
Low 0.2x 0.2x 0.2x 5.6x 5.0x 4.9x
U.S. Retailers with Online Presence*
Walmart NYSE:WMT 74.49 67.37 79.96 244,080 298,556 0.6x 0.6x 0.6x 8.2x 8.0x 7.6x
Target NYSE:TGT 68.86 56.70 72.77 44,188 56,635 0.8x 0.8x 0.7x 7.5x 7.7x 6.9x
Macy’s NYSE:M 48.00 32.31 50.00 18,415 23,584 0.9x 0.8x 0.8x 6.3x 6.1x 5.9x
Liberty Interactive Nasdaq:LINT.A 23.01 17.04 24.31 12,404 23,401 2.3x 2.2x 2.1x 13.1x 12.0x 11.3x
Grainger NYSE:GWW 252.18 176.50 269.17 18,015 18,173 2.0x 1.9x 1.8x 13.9x 11.6x 10.5x
Staples Nasdaq:SPLS 15.87 10.57 16.63 10,536 11,077 0.5x 0.5x 0.5x 5.5x 5.8x 5.8x
Best Buy NYSE:BBY 27.33 11.20 28.37 9,312 10,722 0.2x 0.3x 0.2x 5.0x 5.0x 4.7x
Sears Nasdaq:SHLD 42.08 38.40 68.77 4,478 8,165 0.2x 0.2x 0.2x NM 26.1x 13.7x
CDW Nasdaq:CDW 18.62 17.38 19.17 2,704 6,491 0.6x NM NM 9.0x NM NM
Williams-Sonoma NYSE:WSM 55.89 33.56 57.36 5,511 5,263 1.3x 1.2x 1.2x 9.5x 8.7x 8.0x
HSN Nasdaq:HSNI 53.72 39.67 60.87 2,938 3,038 0.9x 0.9x 0.8x 10.7x 8.9x 8.4x
Office Depot NYSE:ODP 3.87 1.51 6.10 1,119 1,610 0.2x 0.2x 0.2x 6.6x 5.2x 5.2x
OfficeMax NYSE:OMX 10.23 4.20 14.92 904 1,373 0.2x 0.2x 0.2x 8.7x 7.0x 6.6x
1-800-Flowers Nasdaq:FLWS 6.19 2.77 6.60 409 410 0.6x 0.5x 0.5x 10.0x 8.2x 7.1x
Nutrisystem Nasdaq:NTRI 11.78 7.18 11.89 328 293 0.7x 0.8x 0.7x 24.3x 12.6x 8.2x
Systemax NYSE:SYX 9.41 8.36 12.97 345 218 0.1x 0.1x 0.1x 8.9x NM NM
High 2.3x 2.2x 2.1x 24.3x 26.1x 13.7x
Mean 0.8x 0.7x 0.7x 9.8x 9.5x 7.8x
Median 0.6x 0.6x 0.6x 8.9x 8.1x 7.3x
Low 0.1x 0.1x 0.1x 5.0x 5.0x 4.7x
Confidential 30
AP
PEN
DIX
European eCommerce Comparable Public Companies
_______Sources: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13, Internet Retailer 500*Top European Retailers by websales volume, or greater than 33% of revenue in websales
Trading Metrics($ in millions, except per share data) Stock
Price 52-Week Price Range Market Enterprise EV / Revenue EV / EBITDA
Company Ticker 06/28/13 Low High Cap. Value CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
European Internet Retailers (Web Only)
ASOS Holdings AIM:ASC 61.48 24.85 64.82 5,130 5,061 4.5x 4.1x NM 47.8x 44.8x NM
Ocado LSE:OCDO 4.53 0.86 5.34 2,655 2,744 2.5x 2.3x 2.0x NM 43.8x 27.6x
Vistaprint Nasdaq:VPRT 49.37 28.17 50.00 1,677 1,864 1.7x 1.5x 1.4x 13.9x 12.9x 10.2x
Yoox BIT:YOOX 21.46 11.75 22.72 1,230 1,212 2.4x 2.0x 1.6x 27.1x 20.7x 15.2x
Zooplus DB:ZO1 54.16 31.50 60.10 330 332 0.8x 0.6x 0.5x NM 79.3x 26.7x
High 4.5x 4.1x 2.0x 47.8x 79.3x 27.6x
Mean 2.4x 2.1x 1.4x 29.6x 40.3x 19.9x
Median 2.4x 2.0x 1.5x 27.1x 43.8x 20.9x
Low 0.8x 0.6x 0.5x 13.9x 12.9x 10.2x
European Retailers with Online Presence*
Tesco LSE:TSCO 5.04 4.65 5.90 40,486 52,419 0.5x 0.5x 0.5x 6.3x 6.7x 6.5x
Carrefour ENXTPA:CA 27.47 16.73 31.75 19,312 32,812 0.3x 0.3x 0.3x 6.7x 6.7x 6.2x
Kering / PPR ENXTPA:KER 202.99 138.25 233.73 25,635 29,844 2.3x 2.2x 2.1x 11.2x 10.3x 9.2x
Sainsburys LSE:SBRY 5.40 4.48 6.06 10,262 13,686 0.3x 0.4x 0.4x 6.2x 6.5x 6.1x
Dixon Retail LSE:DXNS 0.62 0.22 0.68 2,263 2,196 0.2x 0.2x 0.2x 5.1x 4.8x 4.3x
Home Retail Group LSE:HOME 2.04 1.05 2.51 1,671 1,076 0.1x NM NM 3.1x NM NM
High 2.3x 2.2x 2.1x 11.2x 10.3x 9.2x
Mean 0.6x 0.7x 0.7x 6.4x 7.0x 6.5x
Median 0.3x 0.4x 0.4x 6.3x 6.7x 6.2x
Low 0.1x 0.2x 0.2x 3.1x 4.8x 4.3x
Confidential 31
AP
PEN
DIX
Specialized eCommerce Comparable Public Companies
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13
Trading Metrics($ in millions, except per share data) Stock
Price 52-Week Price Range Market Enterprise EV / Revenue EV / EBITDA
Company Ticker 06/28/13 Low High Cap. Value CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
Marketplaces
Tencent SEHK:700 39.22 27.85 40.61 71,967 68,872 9.9x 7.0x 5.6x 24.5x 19.0x 15.6x
eBay Nasdaq:EBAY 51.72 38.06 58.04 67,712 62,826 4.5x 3.9x 3.3x 15.3x 11.4x 9.8x
Rakuten JASDAQ:4755 11.82 6.46 13.54 15,539 15,764 3.1x 3.1x 2.8x 13.5x 12.3x 10.8x
Mercado Libre Nasdaq:MELI 107.76 64.18 128.46 4,758 4,565 12.2x 9.7x 7.8x 32.9x 26.9x 21.3x
HomeAway Nasdaq:AWAY 32.34 19.58 34.30 2,903 2,588 10.9x 7.6x 6.3x NM 26.1x 20.9x
carsales.com ASX:CRZ 8.63 5.40 9.65 2,059 2,016 9.8x 9.4x 8.3x 18.2x 17.0x 14.8x
Shutterstock NYSE:SSTK 55.78 21.00 57.49 1,937 1,830 10.8x 8.1x 6.5x NM 38.2x 26.9x
High 12.2x 9.7x 8.3x 32.9x 38.2x 26.9x
Mean 8.7x 7.0x 5.8x 20.9x 21.6x 17.2x
Median 9.9x 7.6x 6.3x 18.2x 19.0x 15.6x
Low 3.1x 3.1x 2.8x 13.5x 11.4x 9.8x
Travel
Priceline Nasdaq:PCLN 826.67 553.43 847.33 41,441 37,912 7.2x 5.8x 4.8x 19.8x 15.3x 12.5x
Expedia Nasdaq:EXPE 60.15 43.44 68.09 7,890 7,517 1.9x 1.6x 1.4x 11.7x 8.7x 7.3x
Orbitz NYSE:OWW 8.03 2.07 8.75 855 1,085 1.4x 1.3x 1.3x 10.2x 7.8x 7.1x
MakeMyTrip Nasdaq:MMYT 14.27 10.77 18.50 546 464 2.1x 4.7x 3.9x NM NM 48.9x
Travelzoo Nasdaq:TZOO 27.26 16.56 29.80 422 357 2.4x 2.2x 2.1x 11.5x 11.5x 10.3x
High 7.2x 5.8x 4.8x 19.8x 15.3x 48.9x
Mean 3.0x 3.1x 2.7x 13.3x 10.8x 17.3x
Median 2.1x 2.2x 2.1x 11.6x 10.1x 10.3x
Low 1.4x 1.3x 1.3x 10.2x 7.8x 7.1x
Confidential 32
AP
PEN
DIX
eCommerce Enablement Comparable Public Companies
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13
Trading Metrics($ in millions, except per share data) Stock
Price 52-Week Price Range Market Enterprise EV / Revenue EV / EBITDA
Company Ticker 06/28/13 Low High Cap. Value CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
eCommerce Services
Google Nasdaq:GOOG 880.37 562.09 920.60 296,135 253,413 5.1x 4.2x 3.6x 15.6x 11.6x 9.8x
Baidu Nasdaq:BIDU 94.60 82.98 134.71 33,083 29,753 8.3x 6.1x 4.7x 14.8x 13.3x 10.7x
Yahoo! Nasdaq:YHOO 25.13 14.59 27.68 27,348 24,417 4.9x 5.4x 5.2x 18.6x 14.8x 14.4x
Yandex Nasdaq:YNDX 27.65 16.60 42.01 9,338 8,990 9.5x 7.5x 6.0x 22.1x 16.5x 13.4x
Groupon Nasdaq:GRPN 8.55 2.60 10.67 5,714 4,546 1.9x 1.8x 1.6x 29.9x 15.2x 12.6x
ValueClick Nasdaq:VCLK 24.71 15.04 32.25 1,909 1,860 2.8x 2.5x 2.2x 9.3x 7.4x 6.5x
Moneysupermarket LSE:MONY 2.91 1.89 3.38 1,563 1,533 4.6x 4.5x 4.1x 13.1x 12.5x 11.3x
ChannelAdvisor NYSE:ECOM 15.73 14.25 19.77 351 353 6.6x 5.5x 4.3x NM NM NM
High 9.5x 7.5x 6.0x 29.9x 16.5x 14.4x
Mean 5.5x 4.7x 4.0x 17.6x 13.0x 11.2x
Median 5.0x 4.9x 4.2x 15.6x 13.3x 11.3x
Low 1.9x 1.8x 1.6x 9.3x 7.4x 6.5x
eCommerce Infrastructure
IBM NYSE:IBM 191.11 181.85 215.90 213,013 234,474 2.2x 2.3x 2.2x 8.6x 8.4x 7.9x
Oracle Nasdaq:ORCL 30.71 28.61 36.43 144,534 131,309 3.5x 3.5x 3.3x 7.6x 7.1x 6.5x
SAP DB:SAP 73.04 57.96 84.44 87,099 87,669 4.1x 3.8x 3.5x 12.1x 11.1x 9.8x
Demandware NYSE:DWRE 42.41 21.35 42.49 1,415 1,313 16.5x 13.2x 9.8x NM NM NM
Digital River Nasdaq:DRIV 18.77 12.80 18.94 618 281 0.7x 0.7x 0.7x 7.5x 7.3x 4.6x
PFSweb Nasdaq:PFSW 4.00 2.14 4.65 51 57 0.2x 0.3x 0.3x 5.6x 6.4x 4.6x
Intershop XTRA:ISH2 1.99 1.86 3.25 60 44 0.6x 0.6x 0.5x NM NM NM
High 16.5x 13.2x 9.8x 12.1x 11.1x 9.8x
Mean 4.0x 3.5x 2.9x 8.3x 8.0x 6.7x
Median 2.2x 2.3x 2.2x 7.6x 7.3x 6.5x
Low 0.2x 0.3x 0.3x 5.6x 6.4x 4.6x
Confidential 33
AP
PEN
DIX
U.S. eCommerce Comparable Public Companies (Cont.)
_______Sources: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13, Internet Retailer 500*Top U.S. Retailers by websales volume, or greater than 33% of revenue in websales
Operating Metrics($ in millions, except per share data)
LTM Revenue Growth LTM Revenue EBITDA
Company Ticker As Of '12A - '13E 13E - '14E GM CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
U.S Internet Retailers (Web Only)
Amazon Nasdaq:AMZN Mar 2013 22% 22% 25% $61,093 $74,821 $91,087 $2,508 $5,023 $6,708
Shutterfly Nasdaq:SFLY Mar 2013 20% 16% 54% 641 771 894 82 145 178
Overstock.com Nasdaq:OSTK Mar 2013 13% 7% 18% 1,099 1,241 1,331 28 42 48
Blue Nile Nasdaq:NILE Mar 2013 14% 12% 19% 400 456 512 14 23 30
PC Connection Nasdaq:PCCC Mar 2013 2% 3% 13% 2,159 2,195 2,268 63 69 71
Vitacost Nasdaq:VITC Mar 2013 19% 16% 23% 331 394 458 NM NA 4
U.S. Retailers with Online Presence*
Walmart NYSE:WMT Apr 2013 3% 5% 25% 469,162 485,528 509,216 36,302 37,488 39,534
Target NYSE:TGT May 2013 4% 6% 29% 71,960 74,962 79,626 7,513 7,330 8,165
Macy’s NYSE:M May 2013 3% 3% 40% 27,686 28,380 29,238 3,715 3,840 4,028
Liberty Interactive Nasdaq:LINT.A Mar 2013 3% 5% 38% 10,054 10,404 10,951 1,789 1,955 2,070
Grainger NYSE:GWW Mar 2013 7% 8% 44% 8,950 9,585 10,361 1,304 1,562 1,738
Staples Nasdaq:SPLS May 2013 (3%) 0% 26% 24,381 23,660 23,737 2,015 1,903 1,912
Best Buy NYSE:BBY May 2013 (13%) 1% 23% 49,184 42,741 43,194 2,164 2,147 2,266
Sears Nasdaq:SHLD May 2013 (7%) (1%) 26% 39,854 37,153 36,831 NM 313 598
CDW Nasdaq:CDW Mar 2013 NM NA 17% 10,128 NA NA 721 NA NA
Williams-Sonoma NYSE:WSM May 2013 6% 6% 39% 4,043 4,279 4,556 557 602 659
HSN Nasdaq:HSNI Mar 2013 5% 5% 36% 3,267 3,442 3,619 284 342 362
Office Depot NYSE:ODP Mar 2013 (3%) (1%) 30% 10,696 10,383 10,262 244 308 309
OfficeMax NYSE:OMX Mar 2013 (3%) 0% 26% 6,920 6,724 6,738 157 196 209
1-800-Flowers Nasdaq:FLWS Mar 2013 5% 4% 41% 733 772 806 41 50 58
Nutrisystem Nasdaq:NTRI Mar 2013 (10%) 13% 48% 397 355 403 12 23 36
Systemax NYSE:SYX Mar 2013 2% 4% 14% 3,545 3,608 3,739 24 NA NA
Confidential 34
AP
PEN
DIX
European eCommerce Comparable Public Companies (Cont.)
_______Sources: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13, Internet Retailer 500*Top European Retailers by websales volume, or greater than 33% of revenue in websales
Operating Metrics($ in millions, except per share data)
LTM Revenue Growth LTM Revenue EBITDA
Company Ticker As Of '12A - '13E 13E - '14E GM CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
European Internet Retailers (Web Only)
ASOS Holdings AIM:ASC Feb 2013 NM NA 50% 1,126 NA NA 106 113 NA
Ocado LSE:OCDO May 2013 8% 19% 31% 1,088 1,170 1,389 54 63 99
Vistaprint Nasdaq:VPRT Mar 2013 11% 9% 66% 1,108 1,228 1,338 134 144 183
Yoox BIT:YOOX Mar 2013 24% 24% 27% 496 615 765 45 56 79
Zooplus DB:ZO1 Mar 2013 26% 22% 31% 421 530 647 NM 4 12
European Retailers with Online Presence*
Tesco LSE:TSCO Feb 2013 (2%) 4% 7% 103,798 101,663 105,794 8,260 7,817 8,125
Carrefour ENXTPA:CA Dec 2012 (2%) 3% 19% 103,448 101,391 104,708 4,887 4,942 5,293
Kering / PPR ENXTPA:KER Dec 2012 4% 9% 61% 12,837 13,364 14,534 2,660 2,892 3,266
Sainsburys LSE:SBRY Mar 2013 (10%) 2% 5% 41,206 37,192 37,863 2,212 2,105 2,226
Dixon Retail LSE:DXNS Apr 2013 (3%) 2% 1% 13,278 12,895 13,102 432 455 510
Home Retail Group LSE:HOME Mar 2013 NM NA 32% 8,783 NA NA 351 NA NA
Confidential 35
AP
PEN
DIX
Specialized eCommerce Comparable Public Companies (Cont.)
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13
Operating Metrics($ in millions, except per share data)
LTM Revenue Growth LTM Revenue EBITDA
Company Ticker As Of '12A - '13E 13E - '14E GM CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
Marketplaces
Tencent SEHK:700 Mar 2013 40% 26% 57% 6,983 9,784 12,292 2,814 3,629 4,405
eBay Nasdaq:EBAY Mar 2013 16% 17% 70% 14,072 16,314 19,048 4,119 5,494 6,415
Rakuten JASDAQ:4755 Mar 2013 (1%) 11% 83% 5,127 5,095 5,668 1,172 1,281 1,460
Mercado Libre Nasdaq:MELI Mar 2013 26% 25% 79% 374 470 588 139 170 214
HomeAway Nasdaq:AWAY Mar 2013 43% 20% 84% 238 340 408 51 99 124
carsales.com ASX:CRZ Dec 2012 4% 13% 81% 207 216 244 111 119 136
Shutterstock NYSE:SSTK Mar 2013 32% 25% 62% 170 225 281 32 48 68
Travel
Priceline Nasdaq:PCLN Mar 2013 26% 20% 79% 5,248 6,592 7,923 1,915 2,479 3,032
Expedia Nasdaq:EXPE Mar 2013 19% 14% 78% 4,030 4,794 5,442 643 868 1,025
Orbitz NYSE:OWW Mar 2013 7% 4% 81% 779 830 861 106 140 151
MakeMyTrip Nasdaq:MMYT Mar 2013 (54%) 21% 23% 217 99 120 NM NA 9
Travelzoo Nasdaq:TZOO Mar 2013 6% 7% 90% 151 161 173 31 31 34
Confidential 36
AP
PEN
DIX
eCommerce Enablement Comparable Public Companies (Cont.)
_______Source: Capital IQ as of 06/28/13
Operating Metrics($ in millions, except per share data)
LTM Revenue Growth LTM Revenue EBITDA
Company Ticker As Of '12A - '13E 13E - '14E GM CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E CY 2012A CY 2013E CY 2014E
eCommerce Services
Google Nasdaq:GOOG Mar 2013 19% 17% 58% 50,175 59,816 69,854 16,278 21,816 25,847
Baidu Nasdaq:BIDU Mar 2013 36% 29% 77% 3,579 4,851 6,278 2,016 2,239 2,786
Yahoo! Nasdaq:YHOO Mar 2013 (9%) 2% 68% 4,987 4,562 4,666 1,315 1,654 1,700
Yandex Nasdaq:YNDX Mar 2013 28% 24% 75% 942 1,206 1,494 406 545 671
Groupon Nasdaq:GRPN Mar 2013 9% 11% 65% 2,334 2,550 2,831 152 299 360
ValueClick Nasdaq:VCLK Mar 2013 12% 12% 62% 661 740 830 201 251 286
Moneysupermarket LSE:MONY Dec 2012 3% 8% 74% 333 344 372 117 122 136
ChannelAdvisor NYSE:ECOM Mar 2013 21% 26% 73% 54 65 81 NM NA NA
eCommerce Infrastructure
IBM NYSE:IBM Mar 2013 (1%) 3% 48% 104,507 103,475 106,167 27,121 28,016 29,648
Oracle Nasdaq:ORCL May 2013 2% 6% 81% 37,230 37,840 39,968 17,300 18,456 20,054
SAP DB:SAP Mar 2013 8% 10% 72% 21,390 23,139 25,355 7,224 7,887 8,946
Demandware NYSE:DWRE Mar 2013 25% 35% 70% 79 99 134 NM NA 4
Digital River Nasdaq:DRIV Mar 2013 4% 2% 82% 386 400 407 37 39 61
PFSweb Nasdaq:PFSW Mar 2013 (18%) 13% 18% 240 197 223 10 9 12
Intershop XTRA:ISH2 Mar 2013 (1%) 11% 29% 75 74 82 NM NA NA
Confidential 37
DIS
CLA
IMER
Disclaimer
Disclosure: This newsletter is a periodic compilation of certain economic and corporate information, as well as completedand announced merger and acquisition activity. Information contained in this newsletter should not be construed as arecommendation to sell or buy any security. Any reference to or omission of any reference to any company in thisnewsletter should not be construed as a recommendation to buy, sell or take any other action with respect to any securityof any such company. We are not soliciting any action with respect to any security or company based on this newsletter.The newsletter is published solely for the general information of clients and friends of Headwaters MB, LLC. It does not takeinto account the particular investment objectives, financial situation, or needs of individual recipients. Certain transactions,including those involving early stage companies, give rise to substantial risk and are not suitable for all investors.
This newsletter is based upon information that we consider reliable, but we do not represent that it is accurate orcomplete, and it should not be relied upon as such. Prediction of future events is inherently subject to both known andunknown risks, and other factors that may cause actual results to vary materially. We are under no obligation to updatethe information contained in this newsletter. Opinions expressed are our present opinions only and are subject to changewithout notice. Additional information is available upon request. The companies mentioned in this newsletter may beclients of Headwaters MB, LLC. The decisions to include any company in this newsletter is unrelated in all respects to anyservice that Headwaters MB, LLC may provide to such company. This newsletter may not be copied or reproduced in anyform, or redistributed without the prior written consent of Headwaters MB, LLC. The information contained herein shouldnot be construed as legal advice.
top related