the role of higher education in the advancement of
Post on 20-Feb-2022
4 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 1
The Role of Higher Education in the Advancement of
Veterinary Technology in Australasia
Patricia Maree Clarke
BVSc (Hons IIA)
A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at
The University of Queensland in 2018
School of Veterinary Science
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 1
Abstract
In Australasia, veterinary technology is a nascent, higher education discipline linked to an emergent
paraprofession with graduates occupying a niche positioned between the veterinary science
graduate and the vocationally qualified veterinary nurse. Because of the discipline’s fledgling status
in academia, there is currently a paucity of literature to provide a framework within which to
consider its curriculum and pedagogy.
The overarching aims of this thesis were to document the emergence of veterinary technology, and
to report on and evaluate a framework for a curriculum and pedagogy underpinning its development
as a paraprofession. A series of five studies were based on The University of Queensland’s
bachelor’s degree from 2003 to 2010. The studies centred on developing a curriculum and
pedagogical framework for ‘knowing’ (academisation), ‘doing’(vocationalism) and ways of ‘being’,
that would prepare graduates for an emergent field in a world of uncertainty. Market influences and
employability were also important considerations. All studies were enriched with the researcher’s
autoethnographic reflections. Study 1 documented the genesis of veterinary technology through a
cross-sectional survey of the demographics and employment destinations of the first three graduate
cohorts (2003-2005) (n = 69). This study gauged the success and scope of graduate employment
and placed it in a global context.
Informed by Study 1, Study 2 focused on the pivotal task of academising the curriculum of a non-
traditional higher education discipline. A pedagogical intervention was designed to engage students
in the process of academic knowledge production, a form of ‘knowing’, for an emerging profession.
Students worked in small groups to research and write scientific case reports linked to their clinical
practicum—learning how to produce legitimate disciplinary knowledge. Concomitantly, students
were professionalised through a pedagogy for ‘doing’ critical thinking, reflective practice and
teamwork, and empowering them to publish after graduation.
Study 3 involved mixed methods research exploring veterinary clients’ (n = 98) perceptions of
personal attributes and technical skills for graduates working in veterinary practices, the primary
employment sector. The study examined the importance clients placed on emotional intelligence
(personal) attributes, or graduates’ ways of ‘being’, in their clinical interactions. Findings revealed
that the graduates’ emotionality, self-control and self-motivation mattered to clients. However,
hierarchical cluster analysis revealed groups of clients who differed in the emphasis they placed on
emotional intelligence and technical skills thus having implications for developing a curriculum and
pedagogy about veterinary technologists’ ways of ‘being’ and ‘doing’ to meet client needs.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 2
In Study 4, five stakeholder groups (veterinarians, veterinary technology graduates, veterinary
nurses, clients and academics) evaluated the importance of personal attributes for graduates
working in veterinary health care teams. Although all attributes studied were viewed as important,
differences in emphasis were found between and within groups, such as veterinarians and
academics rating ’conscientiousness’ significantly higher than other groups. Thematic analysis of
veterinary health care team members’ and academics’ (n = 140) perspectives on teamwork
generated nine themes integral to veterinary interprofessional teamwork including a more ‘fine-
grained’ account of personal attributes in teamwork. Results highlighted important considerations
when designing a curriculum to enhance graduates’ ‘being’ effective in teamwork, a core skill for
graduate employability.
Study 5 provided a ‘stop, check and review’ for the veterinary technology programme and
curriculum. A timely impetus for a major curriculum review was provided by the relocation of the
School of Veterinary Science in 2010 to the rural Gatton campus, with new ‘state-of the-art’
facilities, and an opportunity to enhance the ‘doing’ dimension of curriculum via a dual
qualification with the national vocational veterinary nursing certificate. This study gathered
graduate (2003-2010) (n = 50) feedback via an online survey investigating their long-term
experiences in the workforce and reflections on their education. Graduates identified facilitators and
barriers to their success; key challenges recognised were lack of career advancement, poor
recognition by the veterinary and veterinary nursing professional bodies, and low salaries in clinical
practice. The graduate voice emphasised the pivotal roles of professional bodies, the university,
government, and graduates themselves in advancing veterinary technology through legislation,
implementation of an employment award, and national registration. Importantly, graduates also
provided insights into their ‘work-readiness’, highlighting the need for additional emphasis on
‘doing’, or vocationalism, in curriculum.
This research makes a substantial contribution to the growing body of literature on veterinary
technology in Australasia and other countries. It documents the discipline’s inception in Australian
higher education and highlights the importance of curricular and pedagogical initiatives essential to
graduates of an emerging profession in a rapidly changing veterinary landscape. Strategies to meet
stakeholder expectations in an era of marketisation, transferable to other disciplines, were also
illuminated. Associated with this, the key role of higher education in reviewing policy around dual
qualifications (vocationalism) and partnering with industry, government and professional bodies to
legitimise an emerging profession and assure graduate employability was underscored.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 3
Declaration by author
This thesis is composed of my original work, and contains no material previously published or
written by another person except where due reference has been made in the text. I have clearly
stated the contribution by others to jointly-authored works that I have included in my thesis.
I have clearly stated the contribution of others to my thesis as a whole, including statistical
assistance, survey design, data analysis, significant technical procedures, professional editorial
advice, financial support and any other original research work used or reported in my thesis. The
content of my thesis is the result of work I have carried out since the commencement of my higher
degree by research candidature and does not include a substantial part of work that has been
submitted to qualify for the award of any other degree or diploma in any university or other tertiary
institution. I have clearly stated which parts of my thesis, if any, have been submitted to qualify for
another award.
I acknowledge that an electronic copy of my thesis must be lodged with the University Library and,
subject to the policy and procedures of The University of Queensland, the thesis be made available
for research and study in accordance with the Copyright Act 1968 unless a period of embargo has
been approved by the Dean of the Graduate School.
I acknowledge that copyright of all material contained in my thesis resides with the copyright
holder(s) of that material. Where appropriate I have obtained copyright permission from the
copyright holder to reproduce material in this thesis and have sought permission from co-authors for
any jointly authored works included in the thesis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 4
Publications included in this thesis
Peer reviewed papers
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2009, ‘Demographics and employment destinations of a
new group of veterinary technologists in Australia’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education,
vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 241-5.
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT, Pitt, R & Manathunga, C 2011, ‘Enhancing professional
writing skills of veterinary technology students: linking assessment and clinical practice in a
communications course’, Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, vol. 38, no. 3, pp.
273-87.
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, RE, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives on
desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31.
Clarke, PM, Henning, J, Coleman, GT & Schull, DN 2018, ‘Recruiting the graduate voice:
informing higher education initiatives to underpin an emerging, veterinary paraprofession in
Australia’, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, vol. 71, no. 1, pp. 126-52.
Clarke, PM, Henning, J, Coleman, GT, King, E & Schull, DN, ‘What makes a great clinical team?
Stakeholder perspectives on the attributes of effective veterinary health care teams in
Australia’. Accepted by the Australian Veterinary Journal in December 2018.
Submitted manuscripts included in this thesis
No manuscripts submitted for publication.
Other publications during candidature
Peer reviewed papers
Clarke, PM 2004, ‘Veterinary technology and management—current status’, Australian Veterinary
Practitioner, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 38-9.
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2009, ‘Demographics and employment destinations of a
new group of veterinary technologists in Australia’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education,
vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 241-5.
Clarke, PM 2010, ‘Educating veterinary nurses for professional competence’, The Veterinary
Nurse, vol.1, no. 2, pp. 80-4.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 5
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT, Pitt, R, & Manathunga, C 2011, ‘Enhancing professional
writing skills of veterinary technology students: linking assessment and clinical practice in a
communications course’, Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, vol. 38, no. 3, pp.
273-87.
Clarke, PM 2012, ‘Veterinary nursing research: types, importance and dissemination’, The
Veterinary Nurse, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 142-6.
Clarke, PM 2012, ‘A time to reflect on veterinary technology/veterinary nursing beyond our own
borders’, The Veterinary Nurse, vol. 3, no. 6, p. 329.
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, RE, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives on
desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31.
Clarke, PM, Henning, J, Coleman, GT & Schull, DN 2018, ‘Recruiting the graduate voice:
informing higher education initiatives to underpin an emerging, veterinary paraprofession in
Australia’, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, vol. 71, no. 1, pp. 126-52.
Conference abstracts
Clarke, PM, Coleman, GT, Manathunga, CM & Schull, DN 2006, ‘Generating and communicating
scientific literature: an experiential learning project for final year veterinary technology
undergraduates’, abstract and oral presentation to the Effective Teaching & Learning
Conference, The University of Queensland, Australia, 3-4 November.
Clarke, PM 2007, ‘So you want to be a professional?’, abstract and oral presentation to the
American Veterinary Technician Educators’ Symposium, Waco, United States of America, 18-
21 July.
Clarke, PM 2007, ‘Veterinary Technology in Australia’, abstract and oral presentation to the
American Veterinary Technician Educators’ Symposium, Waco, United States of America, 18-
21 July.
Clarke, PM 2009, ‘Personal attributes of veterinary support staff: what clients value’, abstract and
oral presentation to the Australasian Veterinary Education Symposium, The University of
Queensland, Australia, 5-7 July.
Clarke, PM 2010, ‘What do clients and employers value in their veterinary nurses? Tips for
improving your professional competence!’, abstract and oral presentation to the National
Conference of the Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia, Gold Coast, Australia, 21-23 April.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 6
Clarke, PM 2010, ‘Veterinary technology/veterinary nurse education in Australia’, abstract and oral
presentation to the Veterinary European Transnational Network for Nursing Education and
Training (VETNETT) Conference, Groenhorst College, Barneveld, The Netherlands, 30
September-2 October.
Clarke, PM 2011, ‘Experiences in teaching the Bachelor of Applied Science (Veterinary
Technology) in combination with the Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing’, paper presented to
the National Veterinary Nursing Educators’ Forum 2011, TAFE South Australia, Adelaide,
Australia, 13-14 May.
Clarke, PM 2011, ‘Veterinary nursing at the University of Queensland: a break from tradition’,
abstract and oral presentation to the 20th National Vocational Education Training and Research
Conference, Coffs Harbour, Australia, 13-15 July.
Clarke, PM 2012, ‘Publish or perish’, abstract and oral presentation to the National Conference of
the Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia, Gold Coast, Australia, 18-20 April.
Clarke, PM 2012, ‘The veterinary healthcare team: A 360-degree perspective’, abstract and oral
presentation to the National Conference of the Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia, Gold
Coast, Australia, 18-20 April.
Clarke, PM 2013, ‘Veterinary technology/veterinary nursing in Australia: looking towards national
and international accreditations’, abstract and oral presentation to the National Conference of
the Australian Veterinary Association, Cairns, Australia, 26-31 May.
Poster presentations
Clarke, PM & Schull, DN 2007, ‘Generating and communicating scientific literature’, poster
presented to the International Conference on Communication in Veterinary Medicine,
Washington DC, United States of America, 12-15 July.
Clarke, PM, Coleman, GT & Pitt, R 2008, ‘The importance of emotional intelligence attributes in
veterinary support personnel: perspectives of Australian veterinarians’, poster presented to the
International Conference on Communication in Veterinary Medicine, Banff, Canada, 13-16
November.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 7
Contributions by others to the thesis
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2009, ‘Demographics and employment
destinations of a new group of veterinary technologists in Australia’, Journal of Veterinary
Medical Education, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 241-5, incorporated as Chapter 3.
Contributor Statement of contribution
Author Clarke (Candidate) Conception and design of project (75%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (75%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically
reviewing it so as to contribute to the interpretation (70%)
Author Schull Conception and design of project (15%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (15 %)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically
reviewing it so as to contribute to the interpretation (15%)
Author Coleman Conception and design of project (10%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (10%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically
reviewing it so as to contribute to the interpretation (15%)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 8
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT, Pitt, R & Manathunga, C 2011, ‘Enhancing
professional writing skills of veterinary technology students: linking assessment and
clinical practice in a communications course’, Assessment & Evaluation in Higher
Education, vol. 38, no. 3, pp. 273-87, incorporated as Chapter 4.
Contributor Statement of contribution
Author Clarke (Candidate) Conception and design of project (60%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (60%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically
reviewing it so as to contribute to the interpretation (65%)
Author Schull Conception and design of project (32.5 %)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (32.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically
reviewing it so as to contribute to the interpretation (10%)
Author Coleman Conception and design of project (2.5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (2.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (5%)
Author Pitt Conception and design of project (2.5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (2.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (15%)
Author Manathunga Conception and research design of project (2.5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation (2.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically
reviewing it so as to contribute to the interpretation (5%)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 9
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, RE, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives on
desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31,
incorporated as Chapter 5.
Contributor Statement of contribution
Author Clarke (Candidate) Conception and design of project (60%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and significant interpretation of research data
(32.5%)
Drafting parts of the work or critically revising it so as to
contribute to the interpretation (75%)
Author Al-Alawneh Conception and design of project (25%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (60%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising it
so as to contribute to the interpretation (12.5%)
Author Pitt Conception and design of project (5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (2.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising it
so as to contribute to the interpretation (5%)
Author Schull Conception and design of project (5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (2.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising it
so as to contribute to the interpretation (5%)
Author Coleman Conception and design of project (5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (2.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising it
so as to contribute to the interpretation (2.5%)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 10
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT & Henning, J 2018, ‘Recruiting the graduate voice:
informing higher education initiatives to underpin an emerging, veterinary paraprofession’, Journal
of Vocational Education and Training, vol. 71, no. 1, pp. 126-52, incorporated as Chapter 7.
(Appendix 13)
Contributor Statement of contribution
Author Clarke (Candidate) Conception and design of project (65%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation (55%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (70%)
Author Henning Conception and design of project (10%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (35%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (12.5%)
Author Coleman Conception and research design of project (5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (5%)
Drafting parts of the work or critically revising it so as to
contribute to the interpretation (2.5%)
Author Schull Conception and design of project (20%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation (5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (15%)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 11
Clarke, PM, Henning, J, Coleman, GT, King, E & Schull, DN, ‘What makes a great clinical team?
Stakeholder perspectives on the attributes of effective veterinary health care teams in Australia’,
incorporated as Chapter 6. Accepted by the Australian Veterinary Journal in December 2018
Contributor Statement of contribution
Author Clarke (Candidate) Conception and design of project (65%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation (50%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (70%)
Author Henning Conception and design of project (25%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation (32.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (10%)
Author King Conception and design of project (2.5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (2.5%)
Author Coleman Conception and design of project (2.5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (2.5%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (2.5%)
Author Schull Conception and design of project (5%)
Non-routine technical work (0%)
Analysis and interpretation of research data (10%)
Drafting significant parts of the work or critically revising
it so as to contribute to the interpretation (15%)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 12
Statement of parts of the thesis submitted to qualify for the
award of another degree
No works submitted towards another degree have been included in this thesis.
Research Involving Human or Animal Subjects
Please note that I have provided as much evidence as possible for Studies 1, 2, 3 and 4 which were
approved by the School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee at that time. If further evidence is
required, Professor Paul Mills has offered to write a letter of verification that ethics approval was
obtained. Copies of the first and last pages of a hardcopy of ethics applications have been included
as appendices, where applicable. I have copies of letters sent to participants and participant
information sheets and some additional related emails, if required.
Project Title
(Study 1)
‘A new group of veterinary paraprofessionals: synopsis on the first
three years of veterinary technology graduates’
Chief Investigator &
Department
Patricia Clarke
School of Veterinary Science
Project Number Not applicable as approved through the School of Veterinary Science
Ethics Committee (Appendix 7)
Date Approved 31 January 2007
Approving Committee School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee
Chair, Professor Paul Mills (current title)
Project Title
(Study 2)
‘Enhancing professional writing skills of veterinary technology
students: linking assessment in a communications course to clinical
practice’
Chief Investigator &
Department
Patricia Clarke
School of Veterinary Science
Project Number Not applicable as approved through the School of Veterinary Science
Ethics Committee (Appendix 8)
Date Approved May 2010
Approving Committee School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee
Chair, Professor Joanne Meers (current title)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 13
Project Title
(Study 3 & Study 4)
‘Veterinary technology graduate attributes questionnaire’
Chief Investigator &
Department
Patricia Clarke
School of Veterinary Science
Project Number Not applicable as approved through the School of Veterinary
Science Ethics Committee (Appendix 9)
Date Approved 14 January 2008
Approving Committee School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee
Chair, Professor Paul Mills (current title)
Project Title
(Study 3)
‘Veterinary technology graduate attributes questionnaire’
Amendment – ‘Clients of veterinary practices (Group D)’
Chief Investigator &
Department
Patricia Clarke
School of Veterinary Science
Project Number Not applicable as approved through the School of Veterinary Science
Ethics Committee (see Appendix 10)
Date Approved 10 October 2008 (approximately)
Approving Committee School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee
Chair, Professor Paul Mills (current title)
Project Title
(Study 3)
‘Veterinary technology graduate attributes questionnaire – Client
interviews’
Chief Investigator &
Department
Patricia Clarke
School of Veterinary Science
Project Number Not applicable as approved through the School of Veterinary Science
Ethics Committee (Appendix 11)
Date Approved 18 December 2008 (approximately)
Approving Committee School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee
Chair, Professor Paul Mills (current title)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 14
Project Title
(Study 5)
‘Using pedagogical strategies to foster the development of affective
graduate attributes in undergraduate veterinary technology students’
Chief Investigator &
Department
Patricia Clarke
School of Veterinary Science
Project Number 2011001125 (Appendix 12)
Date Approved 13 October 2011
Approving Committee Behavioural & Social Sciences Ethical Review Committee, The
University of Queensland, St. Lucia
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 15
Acknowledgements
Firstly, I sincerely thank the members of my advisory team who have been with me at various
stages, and for varied periods of time, over this long, personal and professional journey (in
chronological order)—Professor Richard Atwell, the late Dr Richard Sutton, Professor Glen
Coleman, Dr Catherine Manathunga, Dr Rachael Pitt, Dr Daniel Schull and Dr Joerg Henning. I am
indebted to all of my advisors for the benefit of their academic brilliance, their moral support,
patience and supervisory guidance. I am particularly grateful to Dr Daniel Schull who has been
there for the whole journey, initially as a friend and colleague, then in a supervisory capacity. His
passion for education has always been an inspiration. Importantly, though, his encouragement,
patience and guidance, through some very challenging times, were extraordinary and admirable. A
special thanks to Dr Joerg Henning, who joined the advisory team at a late stage. I not only
appreciated Joerg’s expertise in epidemiology and passion for research, but also his warmth and
encouragement. In addition, I gratefully acknowledge Dr Dianne Stephens for her mentoring and
guidance in the final stages of this thesis. I could not have completed it without her support,
generosity of spirit, wisdom, and belief in me.
There are many others whom I need to acknowledge. These include, all academic, professional and
clinical staff from The University of Queensland’s veterinary school who contributed to the success
of the programme. In particular, I would like to thank Morag Wilson, veterinary radiographer, who
showed outstanding generosity in the professional and personal support she offered in those early
years. Dr John Alawneh’s invaluable guidance and expertise in epidemiology was also greatly
appreciated. My thanks go to Eva King, fellow doctoral student, who was willing to share her
brilliant mastery of qualitative research and provided some much-appreciated encouragement along
the way. I also thank Dr Katsumi Ishioka from Nippon Veterinary and Life Science University for
sharing his passion for, and wealth of knowledge regarding, veterinary technology and veterinary
nursing in Japan.
My valued friends and current employers, Drs Christine Kidd and Pauline Gaven, have been
unwavering in their support over the past three years. They have not only provided me with the
flexibility in work hours to complete my thesis, but also encouraged my efforts in this endeavour—I
couldn’t have done it without them. I would also like to thank Professor Gary Embelton, a dear
friend, who always believed in me and inspired me to keep going. Thank you, too, to Dr Edith
Hampson, who quietly encouraged and supported me in the closing years of this thesis. My thesis
has also drawn on the wealth of experience and generosity of a number of veterinary practitioners,
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 16
their staff and clients. I thank them sincerely for their altruistic contribution to this research and the
advancement of veterinary technology in Australia.
Very importantly, I would like to acknowledge the contribution of all of the students and graduates
of the Bachelor of Applied Science (Veterinary Technology) from the University of Queensland
(2003-2012), who were the real trailblazers demonstrating the vision and tenacity required to forge
careers in a new veterinary paraprofession in Australia. They have inspired me to tell this story
which they courageously shared with me, and to keep going so that I didn’t let them down as an
academic role model.
I also acknowledge the strength and achievements of my siblings, Helen, Margaret, Joanne, Therese
and Paul who were not as fortunate to be given the opportunity of the education that I had, due to
life circumstances. They have been an inspiration to me. Similarly, I am forever indebted to my
maternal grandparents and Aunty Sheila who supported me emotionally, financially and spiritually
during my undergraduate years. Like my maternal Uncle Pat, they valued education and were
always a great source of encouragement. I also thank my late Aunty Moira for her belief in
education for women and providing me with a great role model.
Professor John Ternouth also deserves my sincere thanks. His vision, in establishing the veterinary
technology degree and elevating the status of veterinary paraprofessionals in Australia through
higher education, was pivotal. This thesis would not have existed without his foresight.
Additionally, I must acknowledge my most favourite and greatest lecturer from The University of
Queensland veterinary school, Professor John Grandage, who has always been an inspiration in my
academic journey.
Finally, to my children, Leigh and Madeleine, and my grandchildren, Caleb, Ava and Lily, who are
the most important part of my life. I am eternally grateful to them and love them dearly for
graciously accepting that my time had to be shared with this thesis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 17
Financial support
No financial support was provided to fund this research.
Keywords
veterinary technology, paraprofession, higher education, academisation, professionalisation,
vocationalism, curriculum, employability
Australian and New Zealand Standard Research Classifications
(ANZSRC)
ANZSRC code: 079999, Agriculture and Veterinary Sciences not elsewhere classified, 30%
ANZSRC code: 130299, Curriculum and Pedagogy not elsewhere classified, 70%
Fields of Research (FoR) Classification
FoR code: 0799, Other Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences, 30%
FoR code: 1302, Curriculum and Pedagogy, 70%
Dedications
I would like to dedicate this thesis to the two greatest inspirations in my life. Firstly, my late
husband, Leslie Clarke, who transformed my life and was always my greatest supporter. Secondly,
to my mother, Florence Walpole, who as a woman ‘ahead of her time’, made great personal
sacrifices to give me the gift of a good education.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 18
Table of Contents
1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 27
1.1 Overarching aims and research questions ........................................................................... 30
2 Literature Review ....................................................................................................................... 34
2.1 Veterinary paraprofessions in a global context ................................................................... 34
2.1.1 Veterinary nursing in the UK ....................................................................................... 35
2.1.2 Veterinary technology in the USA ............................................................................... 36
2.1.3 Veterinary nursing in Australia .................................................................................... 37
2.1.4 Veterinary technology in Australia .............................................................................. 38
2.1.5 Veterinary nursing and veterinary technology in NZ .................................................. 39
2.1.6 Veterinary technology in Japan.................................................................................... 39
2.1.7 Veterinary technology in Thailand and Singapore ...................................................... 40
2.1.8 Veterinary nursing in Hong Kong ................................................................................ 41
2.1.9 Summary of global education and professionalisation ................................................ 41
2.2 The socio-political context of an emerging profession ....................................................... 43
2.2.1 Setting the scene: the veterinary profession in Australia ............................................. 43
2.2.2 Setting the scene: global trends in the veterinary profession ....................................... 44
2.2.3 Setting the scene: global and national trends in higher education ............................... 46
2.3 Birth of a veterinary paraprofession in Australia ................................................................ 47
2.4 ‘Lessons to be learned’ from human nursing ...................................................................... 48
2.4.1 Changing the educational paradigm ............................................................................. 49
2.4.2 Academisation and professionalisation ........................................................................ 50
2.4.3 Educational partnerships .............................................................................................. 51
2.4.4 Consumers as partners ................................................................................................. 51
2.4.5 Clinical education and a dual curriculum .................................................................... 51
2.4.6 Interdisciplinarity ......................................................................................................... 52
2.4.7 Nurse specialisations: an emerging model of care ....................................................... 52
2.4.8 The changing role of higher education and nursing ..................................................... 53
2.4.9 Promoting the profession ............................................................................................. 53
2.4.10 International trends in nursing and nursing education ................................................. 53
2.5 Lessons to be learned from international veterinary paraprofessions ................................. 54
2.6 Shaping a paraprofession in higher education ..................................................................... 54
2.6.1 Academisation and professionalisation through curriculum ........................................ 54
2.6.2 Vocationalism in higher education .............................................................................. 55
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 19
2.6.3 Employability skills and graduate attributes ................................................................ 55
2.6.4 The stakeholder voice .................................................................................................. 56
2.6.5 Professional competence .............................................................................................. 56
2.6.6 Emotional intelligence ................................................................................................. 58
2.6.7 Emotional intelligence and the veterinary workforce .................................................. 59
2.6.8 Veterinary employers and emotional intelligence ....................................................... 60
2.7 Overview of gaps in the literature ....................................................................................... 60
2.8 Autoethnography of an inaugural VT academic and researcher ......................................... 61
3 Chapter 3 .................................................................................................................................... 64
3.1 My contribution to authorship ............................................................................................. 64
3.2 Demographics and employment destinations of a new group of veterinary technologists in
Australia ......................................................................................................................................... 66
3.2.1 Preamble: Reflecting on the birth of a new frontier in academia and a veterinary
paraprofession in Australia ........................................................................................................ 66
3.2.2 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 70
3.2.3 Methods ........................................................................................................................ 71
3.2.4 Results .......................................................................................................................... 72
3.2.5 Discussion .................................................................................................................... 74
3.2.6 Conclusion ................................................................................................................... 77
4 Chapter 4 .................................................................................................................................... 78
4.1 My contribution to authorship ............................................................................................. 78
4.2 Enhancing professional writing skills of veterinary technology students: Linking
assessment and clinical practice in a communications course ....................................................... 80
4.2.1 Preamble: A VT educator’s autoethnographic account of ‘academisation’ of a new
higher education discipline, its students and herself .................................................................. 80
4.2.2 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 81
4.2.3 Methods ........................................................................................................................ 85
4.2.4 Results .......................................................................................................................... 89
4.2.5 Discussion .................................................................................................................... 92
4.2.6 Conclusion ................................................................................................................... 95
5 Chapter 5 .................................................................................................................................... 96
5.1 My contribution to authorship ............................................................................................. 96
5.2 Client Perspectives on Desirable Attributes and Skills of Veterinary Technologists in
Australia: Considerations for Curriculum Design ......................................................................... 98
5.2.1 Preamble: A VT educator’s autoethnographic account of recruiting the client’s voice
to inform a responsive curriculum ............................................................................................. 98
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 20
5.2.2 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 99
5.2.3 Methods ...................................................................................................................... 102
5.2.4 Data collection and analysis ....................................................................................... 104
5.2.5 Results ........................................................................................................................ 109
5.2.6 Discussion .................................................................................................................. 119
5.2.7 Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 123
6 Chapter 6 .................................................................................................................................. 124
6.1 My contribution to authorship ........................................................................................... 124
6.2 What makes a great clinical team? Stakeholder perspectives on the attributes of effective
veterinary health care teams in Australia ..................................................................................... 126
6.2.1 Preamble: A VT educator’s autoethnographic account of developing a curriculum for
veterinary teamwork ................................................................................................................ 126
6.2.2 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 127
6.2.3 Methods ...................................................................................................................... 130
6.2.4 Results ........................................................................................................................ 133
6.2.5 Discussion .................................................................................................................. 144
6.2.6 Limitations ................................................................................................................. 149
6.2.7 Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 150
7 Chapter 7 .................................................................................................................................. 151
7.1 My contribution to authorship ........................................................................................... 151
7.2 Recruiting the graduate voice: Informing higher education initiatives to underpin an
emerging, veterinary paraprofession in Australia ........................................................................ 153
7.2.1 Preamble: A VT educator’s autoethnography on honouring the graduate voice in
shaping a new discipline .......................................................................................................... 153
7.2.2 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 154
7.2.3 Methods ...................................................................................................................... 157
7.2.4 Results ........................................................................................................................ 158
7.2.5 Discussion .................................................................................................................. 170
7.2.6 Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 175
8 Discussion and Conclusion ...................................................................................................... 176
8.1 Context .............................................................................................................................. 176
8.2 Summary of research questions ......................................................................................... 177
8.3 Summary of results and implications for advancement of VT .......................................... 178
8.4 Post-script .......................................................................................................................... 184
8.5 Limitations......................................................................................................................... 185
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 21
8.6 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................... 186
9 List of References .................................................................................................................... 189
10 Appendices ............................................................................................................................... 227
10.1 Appendix 1: Professional Writing Pre-Test Questionnaire ........................................... 227
10.2 Appendix 2: Professional Writing Post-Test Questionnaire .......................................... 233
10.3 Appendix 3: Veterinary Client Questionnaire ............................................................... 238
10.4 Appendix 4: Veterinary Technology Client Interview Guide ....................................... 243
10.5 Appendix 5: Veterinary Technology Stakeholder Questionnaire .................................. 244
10.6 Appendix 6: Veterinary Technology Graduate Survey 2011 ........................................ 251
10.7 Appendix 7: Copy of Ethics Approval .......................................................................... 258
10.8 Appendix 8: Copy of Ethics Approval .......................................................................... 261
10.9 Appendix 9: Copy of Ethics Approval .......................................................................... 264
10.10 Appendix 10: Copy of Ethics Approval (Amendment) ................................................. 266
10.11 Appendix 11: Copy of Ethics Approval ........................................................................ 270
10.12 Appendix 12: Copy of Ethics Approval ........................................................................ 272
10.13 Appendix 13: Acceptance for Publication (Chapter 7) .................................................. 274
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 22
List of Figures & Tables
Figure 1-1: Overview of five research studies to develop a VT curriculum and pedagogy. ............. 33
Figure 3-1: Overview of Study 1exploring the demographics and employment destinations of
graduates of a new veterinary paraprofession in Australia. ........................................................ 64
Figure 4-1: Overview of Study 2 on promoting the scholarly activities of an emerging profession
through curriculum and pedagogy. ............................................................................................. 78
Figure 5-1: Overview of Study 3 on gathering client perspectives to inform a VT curriculum for
desirable ways of ‘knowing’, ‘doing’ and ‘being’ in clinical practice. ...................................... 96
Figure 5-2: Flow diagram for client selection, exclusion, and response numbers. .......................... 103
Figure 6-1: Overview of Study 4 on gathering stakeholder perspectives to inform a VT curriculum
for desirable ‘ways of being’ effective in veterinary teamwork and notions of teamwork. ..... 124
Figure 6-2: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘agreeableness’ as
an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 = unimportant; 3 =
neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important). ............................................................................. 135
Figure 6-3: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on being ‘flexible [in
approach to work]’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant;
2 = unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important). ........................................... 136
Figure 6-4: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on
‘conscientiousness’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant;
2 = unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important). ........................................... 136
Figure 6-5: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘socially sensitive
and perceptive’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important). ................................................. 137
Figure 6-6: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘sharing
professional values’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant;
2 = unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important). ........................................... 137
Figure 6-7: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on being
‘cooperative’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important). ................................................. 138
Figure 6-8: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘accepting of
others’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important). ................................................. 138
Figure 6-9: Visual representation of veterinary teamwork with themes generated by VT graduates,
veterinarians, senior nurses, and academics in Australia. ......................................................... 141
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 23
Figure 7-1: Overview of Study 5 on recruiting the VT graduate voice on HE policy, partnerships
and curriculum to review and influence change. ...................................................................... 151
Figure 7-2: Key themes and sub-themes relevant to the professionalisation of VT in Australia. ... 162
Figure 8-1: Diagrammatic representation of the role of HE in advancing an emerging paraprofession
in the veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australia (2003-2010). ............................. 184
Table 2-1: Summary of veterinary technology and veterinary nursing education and
professionalisation in Australasia, Asia, the UK and USA. ....................................................... 42
Table 3-1: Employment of graduates at February 1, 2006. ............................................................... 73
Table 4-1: Modules developing the professional writing process. .................................................... 86
Table 4-2: Pre- & post- student responses presented as percentages. ................................................ 91
Table 5-1: EI and professional attributes from Part Two of the client questionnaire. ..................... 105
Table 5-2: Technical skills assessed in Part Three of the client questionnaire. ............................... 106
Table 5-3: Example of thematic analysis of transcribed interview data. ......................................... 108
Table 5-4: Summary statistics for demographic variables of 98 clients participating in the study. 109
Table 5-5: Client percentage ratings of EI and professional attributes of veterinary technology
graduates in order of highest ratings of importance per factor or item (adaptability, self-
motivation). ............................................................................................................................... 109
Table 5-6: Client percentage ratings of the importance of technical skills of veterinary technologists
in order of highest rating of importance per skill group. .......................................................... 112
Table 5-7: Odd ratios (and 95% confidence intervals) of significant predictors for rating a range of
EI and professional attributes of the veterinary technologist by 98 clients using a Likert scale (1
- Very Unimportant and 5 – Very Important). .......................................................................... 113
Table 5-8: Odds ratios (and 95% confidence intervals) of significant predictors for rating a range of
technical skills of the veterinary technologist by 98 clients using a Likert scale (1 - Very
Unimportant and 5 – Very Important). ..................................................................................... 115
Table 5-9: Comparison of client group (clusters) ratings of technical skills, EI and professional
attributes. ................................................................................................................................... 116
Table 5-10: Summary of themes from interviews of three veterinary clients participating in the
study. ......................................................................................................................................... 117
Table 6-1: Framework of personal attributes for veterinary teamwork. .......................................... 128
Table 6-2: Demographic characteristics of stakeholder groups associated with VT education, The
University of Queensland, Australia in 2008-2009. ................................................................. 134
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 24
Table 6-3: Association of importance placed on personal attributes and demographics of VT
stakeholder groups surveyed in Australia in 2008-2009........................................................... 139
Table 7-1: Socio-demographic characteristics of VT graduates. ..................................................... 159
Table 7-2: Current VT graduate salary ranges by employment sector (full-time permanent or full-
time contract employment). ...................................................................................................... 160
Table 7-3: VT graduates’ ratings of the importance of career challenges. ...................................... 161
Table 7-4: Themes and sub-themes elucidated from VT graduates’ perceptions of areas ‘best’ and
‘least’ prepared for employment. .............................................................................................. 166
Table 7-5: Graduate (n = 50) responses regarding ‘the five (5) most important personal attributes for
(their) current role’. ................................................................................................................... 167
Table 7-6: Graduate (n = 50) responses regarding ‘the five (5) most important technical skills for
(their) current role’. ................................................................................................................... 168
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 25
List of Abbreviations used in the thesis
AVA Australian Veterinary Association
AVMA American Veterinary Medical Association
BAppSc Bachelor of Applied Science
BVNA British Veterinary Nurses Association
BVSc Bachelor of Veterinary Science
CSU Charles Sturt University
CVTEA Committee for Veterinary Technician Education & Activities
DAFF Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (Australian Government)
DEETYA Department of Employment, Education, Science, Training and Youth Affairs
DEST Department of Education, Science and Training
HAB Human-animal bond
HE Higher education
NAVTA National Association of Veterinary Technicians in America
NCVEI National Commission on Veterinary Economic Issues
NVLU Nippon Veterinary and Life Science University
NZ New Zealand
NZVNA New Zealand Veterinary Nursing Association
PC Patricia Clarke (primary researcher)
QDPI&F Queensland Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries
RCVS Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons
RVC Royal Veterinary College, University of London
UK United Kingdom
UQ University of Queensland
USA United States of America
VNCA Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 26
VT Veterinary technology or veterinary technology graduate
WIL Work-integrated learning
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 27
1 Introduction
Learning to become a professional involves not only what we know and can do, but also who we
are (becoming). It involves integration of knowing, acting, and being in the form of professional
ways of being that unfold over time. When a professional education program focuses on the
acquisition and application of knowledge and skills, it falls short of facilitating their integration
into professional ways of being. (Dall’Alba 2009a, p. 34)
According to the World Organisation for Animal Health (Vallatt 2004), a veterinary
paraprofessional is a person who is authorised to carry out certain veterinary tasks with
authorisation from a Veterinary Statutory Body, under the responsibility and direction of a
registered or licenced veterinarian. Examples of veterinary paraprofessionals would include
veterinary nurses, veterinary technicians, community-based animal health workers, food inspectors,
and livestock inspectors. Concurring with this, the roles of veterinary paraprofessionals in Australia
align closely with veterinarians in teaching, research, industry, and most significantly, in companion
animal health and welfare (Australian Veterinary Association 2014) (AVA). Veterinarians (and
veterinary paraprofessionals) also play an integral role in rural and regional Australia ensuring food
safety, the health and welfare of livestock, biosecurity protection and disease surveillance (Frawley
2003; AVA 2014, 2017). With such diverse roles across the animal industries, it is not surprising
that veterinarians are recognised by The Australian Workforce and Productivity Agency as having a
‘specialised occupation’ because of their important contribution to the Australian economy and
community (AVA 2014, p. 9). Conversely, though, there is limited recognition of the value of
veterinary paraprofessionals to Australia’s economy, despite their vital role in supporting the work
of veterinarians. Indeed, the value of veterinary paraprofessionals is reflected in their numbers,
which are comparable to veterinarians. Currently, there are around 11,418 registered veterinarians
in Australia (Australasian Boards Council cited in AVA 2016, p. 2), with approximately 12,100
veterinary nurses (Job Outlook 2018), having grown from 3,600 in 2000 (Australian Industry and
Skills Committee 2018). These figures do not account for paraprofessionals working in other areas,
such as biosecurity inspection, veterinary nutrition and pharmaceutical companies, vocational or
higher education (HE), and in animal welfare.
Around the time of the inception of The University of Queensland’s (UQ) Bachelor of Applied
Science (BAppSc) (Veterinary Technology; VT) programme in 2001 (Clarke 2004), the Australian
veterinary landscape was changing rapidly in response to socio-political forces and global
influences. Nationally, the Australian College of Veterinary Scientists, established in 1971 to offer
higher level qualifications for veterinarians, had 1463 members of whom 147 were Fellows, or
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 28
specialists (Taylor 2002). Mirroring this trend, in 2000 the AVA (2018), the professional body for
veterinarians in Australia, had 22 special interest groups (AVA 2000). These developments
reflected the veterinary profession’s response to increasing societal demands for higher levels of
veterinary care, driven by a more educated clientele (Brown & Silverman 1999; Page-Jones 2015;
Willis et al. 2007) highly bonded to their pets (Fogle 1999; Chuer-Hansen 2010), and growing
public concerns for animal welfare (Fogle 1999; Freire et al. 2017). These developments clearly
signalled a need for university-educated paraprofessionals, following international trends in the
United Kingdom (UK) (Cooper 2002) and in the United States of America (USA) (Lukens & Walsh
2015). This premise would gain further momentum by the mid to late 2000s, due to a demand for
interprofessional teamwork created by the increasing complexity of veterinary health care
(Kinnison, May & Guile 2014)—following trends in human health care (Sargeant, Loney &
Murphy 2008; Thistlethwaite 2012).
In addition to the changes in the veterinary landscape in the early 2000s, socio-political forces
opened up the possibility of HE offering courses in VT. This began with the Australian
government’s ongoing commitment to the transformation of HE from an elite to a mass system of
education (termed ‘massification’) (Trow 2007, 2016), that commenced with the Whitlam
government’s abolition of tuition fees in 1974 (Engel & Halvorson 2016), and was fuelled by the
Dawkins’ Report of 1988 (Dobson 2001; Department of Education and Training 2015). The
expansionist policies of the latter provided greater access to segments of the population previously
excluded, creating a HE student profile more reflective of society and leading to the first period of
‘massification’ of Australian HE that lasted until the late 1990s (Dobson 2001; Department of
Education and Training 2015). Australian HE started moving towards the second dimension of
massification (Leach 2013; Southgate & Bennett 2014), Trow’s phase of universal access (Trow
2007, 2016), around the time VT commenced at UQ. Universal access aimed to widen HE access to
students from persistently under-represented equity groups (Trow 2007; Bradley et al. 2008),
including more diverse socio-economic groups (De La Harpe, Radloff & Wyber 2000; James 2000;
James, Bexley & Shearer 2009), the indigenous population, those from rural and remote areas,
mature age students and first in family to attend university (Bradley et al. 2008; Probert 2016).
Universal access aimed not only to amend persistent social inequalities (Trow 2007), but also
upskill the nation by preparing the population for social and technological change (Bradley et al
2008; Dawson, Charman & Kilpatrick 2013). Additionally, as demonstrated in the UK in the late
1990’s, the massification of the education system led to some of the more technically-oriented
occupations, such as human nursing, transitioning from vocational education into universities; a
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 29
move which facilitated their professionalisation through ‘academisation’ (Findlow 2012; Peach
2010). This phenomenon was mirrored in the birth of VT as a HE discipline in Australia.
The literature has extensively recorded the challenges of former paraprofessions, sometimes called
semi-professions (Etzioni 1969; Elzinga 1990), transitioning into HE and professionalising,
including the stories of human nursing (Shaw 1993; Forsyth 1995; Lusk et al. 2001), dental hygiene
(Hopcraft et al. 2008) and paramedicine (Williams, Brown & Onsman 2010; O’Brien et al. 2014;
Williams et al. 2015). As a fledgling HE discipline, VT could benefit from the experiences of these
historically mostly female-dominated professions, through ‘lessons learned’ in developing
curriculum (Reid 1994; Forsyth 1995), growing their research base and body of knowledge,
developing specialisations (Shaw 1993), and negotiating the ‘politics of professionalisation’
(Mahony 2003). Nonetheless, there are also contextual factors, unique to VT as an emerging
Australian veterinary paraprofession, to be considered.
The UQ VT programme, commencing in 2001 (Clarke 2004), was the vision of Professor John
Ternouth, veterinarian and Head of the School of Animal Studies, at UQ’s rural Gatton campus (J
Ternouth 2014, pers. comm., 10 January). Ternouth conceived this qualification for a mid-tier
veterinary occupation as a response to a rapidly changing veterinary landscape in Australia and
globally. A template for an ‘intended’ VT curriculum and pedagogy (Barnett & Coate 2005) was
developed by academics from the UQ Schools of Animal Studies and Veterinary Science. However,
more work was required for a ‘curriculum-in-action’ (Barnett & Coate 2005) and to enact pedagogy
that would advance VT as a veterinary paraprofession and ensure graduate employability. Such
considerations are in line with a HE agenda (Harvey 2000; Barnett & Coate 2005) and graduates’
expectations of a return on investment in their education (Barnett & Coate 2005; Findlow 2012;
Fahrnet 2015).
That said, universities educating more traditional professions are research intensive, with a mission
of knowledge production (Findlow 2012; Ek et al. 2013). This contrasts with the expectation for
paraprofessionals to be competent and ‘work ready’ at graduation, which is especially true for those
disciplines that were historically entrenched in a vocational training system, such as human nursing
(Peach 2010) and paramedicine (O’Brien et al. 2013; O’Brien et al. 2014). These considerations
therefore make ‘…vocational, professional and academic elements’ essential to HE curricula for
these disciplines (Findlow 2012, p.120). Likewise, curricula for new paraprofessions such as VT,
need to balance ‘academisation’ with ‘vocationalism’ to meet employment market and consumer
demands (Ek et al. 2013). As such, vocationalism in HE encompasses ‘the development of skills for
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 30
graduate employment and preparation for ‘work-readiness’, as well as preparing students ‘for other
aspects of their lives, after graduation’ (Rospigliosi, Bourner & Heath 2016, p. 186).
In alignment with the latter, students of new disciplines need to be prepared for their even greater
‘world of uncertainty’ in the labour market (Barnett 2000, 2004). In a world where discipline-
specific knowledge and skills are no longer enough (Barnett & Coate 2005; Dall’Alba 2009a,
2009b), students of professional and paraprofessional disciplines, in particular, also need to be
educated in professional ways of ‘being’ to negotiate their rapidly changing ‘world of ‘work’
(Dall’Alba 2009a, 2009b). Thus, it seemed essential to prepare these courageous, VT trailblazers
negotiating a new frontier in the veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australia using a
framework for curriculum and pedagogy that encompassed the philosophy of ‘knowing’, ‘doing’
and ‘being’ as espoused by Barnett & Coate (2005).
Hence, this thesis breaks new ground in the literature of paraprofessions; it explores the genesis and
development of a new paraprofession for the veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australia
and the curriculum and pedagogy that underpinned it. Currently, there is a paucity of literature
about a HE curriculum and pedagogical framework to shape a veterinary paraprofession in
Australia, and likewise about the history of veterinary paraprofessions. Therefore, this research will
contribute to the growing body of scholarly literature for VT and veterinary paraprofessions in
Australia and globally.
1.1 Overarching aims and research questions
The overarching aims of this project were to document and analyse the emergence of a new
veterinary paraprofession (VT) in Australia using the UQ BAppSc (VT) (2003-2010) as a case, and
to identify areas for improvement—in both policy and curriculum—to cement the future success of
this nascent, mid-tier paraprofession of the 21st century.
The project was designed to achieve these overarching aims by answering the following research
questions:
1. What are the demographics and employment destinations of the first three UQ VT graduate
cohorts (2003-2005) for an emerging veterinary paraprofession in the veterinary and allied
animal health fields in Australia, and how do these compare with global trends? (Chapter 3).
2. How efficacious is a pedagogical intervention about knowledge production—which links
assessment in a professional communication course to students’ clinical practicum—in
developing VT students’ professional attributes and skills, including a capacity for research
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 31
and professional writing, and inspiring them to publish in the scholarly literature after
graduation? (Chapter 4)
3. What messages for HE curriculum and pedagogy can be garnered from key stakeholders
with respect to desirable personal attributes and technical skills for VT graduates? (Chapter
5)
4. What messages for HE curriculum and pedagogy can be garnered from key stakeholders
with respect to teamwork attributes and skills for VT graduates? (Chapter 6)
5. What can the long-term VT graduate voice reveal about the facilitators and barriers to their
employability and the advancement of VT as a mid-tier, emerging veterinary profession in
Australia? (Chapter 7)
The thesis addressed these research questions through five studies utilising a combination of
quantitative and mixed methods research. Four studies contributed to VT pedagogy and curriculum
development from the philosophical perspective of ‘knowing’, ‘doing’ and ‘being’—to help better
prepare graduates for the uncertain world of a new veterinary paraprofession (Barnett & Coate
2005). The fifth study represented an evaluation of the programme’s curriculum and outcomes to
inform curriculum renewal.
The first study (Chapter 3) set the context for the thesis by documenting the genesis of VT using a
cross-sectional telephone and email survey of the first three UQ VT graduate cohorts (n = 69) to
assess their employment rate, to characterise their employment niche within the veterinary and
allied animal health fields, and to compare these findings with international trends. All data were
descriptively analysed.
The second study (Chapter 4) built on the evidence of a market for HE veterinary support personnel
in Australia established in Study 1. Based on these findings and the need to academise a new HE
discipline, the researcher implemented and evaluated a novel, pedagogical intervention to not only
‘academise’ VT education through immersion in the process of knowledge production, but also to
professionalise students. Final year VT students engaged in a series of workshops to develop their
professional writing skills, and their professional ways of ‘being’ through critical thinking,
reflection and self-assessment, teamwork and gaining an appreciation of the importance of
publishing in the literature after graduation.
Chapters 5 and 6 were based on Study 3 and Study 4 which researched the perceptions of key
stakeholders, including VT graduates, veterinarians, veterinary nurses, veterinary clients and
academics, to inform a curriculum and pedagogy for a veterinary paraprofession responsive to
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 32
employer and client needs, and graduates’ career satisfaction. Chapter 5 reported on a survey to
explore veterinary clients’ (n = 98) perceptions of the importance of a range of personal attributes
and technical skills for graduates working in veterinary practices, the primary VT employment
sector. Survey data were triangulated with semi-structured interviews (n = 3) to inform a curriculum
for paraprofessionals increasingly engaged with clients. Chapter 6 extended on Chapter 5 by
exploring the graduate attribute of teamwork from two perspectives. Key stakeholders (graduates,
veterinarians, veterinary nurses, academics and veterinary clients) rated the importance of seven
personal attributes relating to graduates’ ways of ‘being’ effective in veterinary health care teams.
The second perspective was generated by questioning members of the veterinary healthcare team
and veterinary academics on the meaning they assigned to veterinary teamwork, a core competency
for paraprofessionals engaging in interprofessional veterinary teamwork.
Study 5, reported in Chapter 7, utilised a survey of the long-term graduate voice (2003-2010) (n =
50) to investigate VT employment experiences in the veterinary and allied animal health contexts,
and to garner their views and reflections on professionalisation issues, including their university
education and ‘work-readiness’ at graduation. Data were analysed using quantitative (descriptive)
and qualitative methods (thematic analysis). This chapter explicates the barriers and facilitators to
the VT graduates’ individual career success and to the advancement of VT as an emerging, mid-tier
veterinary paraprofession in Australia. This information is vital to reviewing and informing ongoing
VT curriculum, pedagogy, policies and partnerships.
Chapter 8 discusses the main findings of the five studies and synthesises these into a montage of
‘lessons learned’ as well as providing recommendations for HE curriculum, pedagogy, policy and
partnerships in establishing and advancing a new paraprofession, including preparing its graduates
for employability in a world of uncertainty (Figure 1-1). The chapter also outlines limitations to the
research undertaken and future directions for research.
Autoethnographic accounts of the researcher’s personal experiences as an inaugural VT lecturer and
final year coordinator were written as preambles to each of the five studies (Chapters 3, 4, 5, 6 and
7) to illuminate the broader context of the VT story.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 33
Figure 1-1: Overview of five research studies to develop a VT curriculum and pedagogy.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 34
2 Literature Review
2.1 Veterinary paraprofessions in a global context
Analogous to human health care, where nursing was originally a paraprofession supporting doctors
(Zelek & Phillips 2003), the work of veterinarians has been supported by paraprofessionals with a
range of titles depending on the global context, such as veterinary nurses in Australia (Veterinary
Nurses Council of Australia 2018a) (VNCA) and the UK (Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons
2018a) (RCVS), and more recently, veterinary technologists in Australia (UQ 2018a). Veterinary
paraprofessionals or support personnel in the USA are currently called ‘veterinary technicians’ or
‘veterinary technologists’ (American Veterinary Medical Association 2018a) (AVMA). In
Australasia, VT is a relatively recent HE discipline (Clarke 2004; Clarke, Schull & Coleman 2009).
To understand where the paraprofession of VT is situated in the context of the veterinary and allied
animal health fields in Australasia and globally, the terms ‘VT/veterinary technician/technologist’
and ‘veterinary nursing/veterinary nurse’ need to be defined and international comparisons made.
Furthermore, the history of veterinary nursing in Australia is relevant to VT, a cognate field
emerging as a mid-level occupation situated between the vocational veterinary nursing and the
professional discipline of veterinary science (Moodie et al. 2013).
A comprehensive definition of ‘veterinary nursing’ and ‘veterinary nurse’ is provided by the RCVS
in the UK, where veterinary nursing was proclaimed a true profession in 2015 (RCVS 2015a):
Veterinary nursing’ is the supportive care of animals receiving treatment within a veterinary
practice. A ‘veterinary nurse’ works as a member of the veterinary team, providing expert nursing
care for sick animals. Veterinary nurses also play a significant role in educating owners on
maintaining the health of their pets. They carry out technical work and are skilled in undertaking a
range of diagnostic tests, medical treatments, and minor surgical procedures under veterinary
direction. (RCVS 2018a).
This definition and the title of ‘veterinary nurse’ are also applicable to veterinary support personnel
in Australasia who have completed a nationally recognised vocational qualification (New Zealand
Veterinary Nursing Association 2018; VNCA 2018a) (NZVNA). The VNCA ascribes the title of
‘veterinary nurse’ to those who have completed the national Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing
and are ‘trained and competent to undertake high standards of patient care and client advice’,
having knowledge and understanding of the ‘how’ and ‘why’ of the role (VNCA 2018b).
The histories of veterinary support personnel in the UK (Turner 1984; Branscombe 2010; Vivash
Jones 2011; Kinnison, May & Guile 2014; Smith & Cooper 2015; RCVS 2018b) and in the USA
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 35
(Chadderdon, Lloyd & Pazak 2014; Lukens & Walsh 2015) have been well documented. Since
these countries are leaders in the education of veterinary support personnel, they provide insights
into the global context for veterinary paraprofessions, such as VT, and models for
professionalisation.
2.1.1 Veterinary nursing in the UK
Veterinary nursing in the UK, which commenced in 1961 with the RCVS approved Animal Nursing
Auxillary Training Scheme (RCVS 2018b), celebrated its 50th anniversary in 2011 (Branscombe
2011a, 2011b). The founding of the British Veterinary Nurses Association (BVNA 2018) followed
in 1965 (Lukens & Walsh 2015). Traditionally, veterinary nursing training in the UK was based in
further education (vocational training), and more recently the academic and vocational three and
four year HE degree qualifications have been offered (RCVS 2018c). In 2010, the vocational Level
3 Diploma replaced the previous certificate level course as the national qualification, paving the
way for professional registration of veterinary nurses with the RCVS (RCVS 2010). Currently, all
19 RCVS accredited HE veterinary nursing degree qualifications are integrated with an RCVS
Certificate in Veterinary Nursing, incorporating the veterinary nursing national occupational
standards or equivalent (RCVS 2018c). As such, they entitle those qualified to a ‘licence to
practise’ veterinary nursing and listing on the RCVS Register of Veterinary Nurses (RCVS 2018d,
2018e).
The RCVS Register of Veterinary Nurses came into place with the new supplemental Royal Charter
effective from February 2015. This confirmed the RCVS as the regulator of veterinary nurses in the
UK. The RCVS controls entry to the Register of Veterinary Nurses and accredits qualifications that
provide a 'licence to practise' as a veterinary nurse, ‘through the Veterinary Surgeons Act 1966, the
Royal Charter, and the Veterinary Nurse Conduct and Discipline Rules 2014’ (RCVS 2018f). The
RCVS Register replaces the List of Veterinary Nurses that was first introduced in 1991 in
conjunction with an amendment of the Veterinary Surgeons Act 1966 to formally recognise the role
of the veterinary nurse, allowing them to perform specific procedures (schedule 3) (Branscombe
2011b). Subsequently, in 2000, the List was changed to record those attaining the National
Vocational Qualification for veterinary nursing (Branscombe 2011b), and in 2007 (RCVS 2007),
there was an addition of a non-statutory register of veterinary nurses (Smith & Cooper 2015). With
the Royal Charter, there is no longer a List and Register of veterinary nurses, just a Register (RCVS
2019).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 36
The Veterinary Nurses Council in the UK controls the standards for accrediting veterinary nursing
qualifications and awarding institutions (RCVS 2018g). HE veterinary nursing programmes based
overseas may now also apply for RCVS accreditation to facilitate international mobility of their
graduates (RCVS 2018g). Requirements for national veterinary nurse registration include minimum
standards in continuing professional development (45 hours over three years), compliance with a
Code of Professional Conduct, and disciplinary action for serious professional misconduct (RCVS
2018f). Such requirements lead the way for professionalisation of veterinary support personnel
globally.
2.1.2 Veterinary technology in the USA
VT in the USA, comparable to the UK, has a long history in the education and training of veterinary
support personnel. Although training for veterinary technologists was first proposed in the USA in
the late 1950s, the first curriculum for training animal technicians was offered at the State
University of New York Delhi in 1965 (Lukens & Walsh 2015). The word ‘veterinary’ was deemed
contentious by the AVMA at that time; hence, these paraprofessionals were given the title of
‘animal technician’ (Lukens & Walsh 2015, p. 9). In 1972, the AVMA introduced the first
accreditation procedures for animal technician programmes through the Committee on
Accreditation for Training of Animal Technicians. The committee had several name changes before
1989 when it became the Committee on Veterinary Technician Education and Activities (CVTEA),
responsible for accrediting VT programmes (Lukens & Walsh 2015, p. 12). A professional body,
the North American Veterinary Technician Association (NAVTA), was founded in 1981 (Lukens &
Walsh 2015). Its name was changed to the National Association of Veterinary Technicians in
America in 2002 (Lukens & Walsh 2015; NAVTA 2018a) and is still current in 2018.
The AVMA (2018b) recognises VT as integral to the delivery of veterinary medicine, with
veterinary technicians working under the supervision of veterinarians to provide professional health
care to animals; professional health care excludes diagnosing, prescribing or performing surgery.
Qualifications for veterinary technicians include a two-year AVMA accredited associate degree or a
four-year AVMA accredited baccalaureate degree in VT for veterinary technologists (AVMA
2018a). The latter qualification would be more comparable to the VT degree in Australia and HE
veterinary nursing degrees in the UK, which provide broader career opportunities (such as research,
teaching and the pharmaceutical industry) than vocational veterinary technician/nursing
qualifications (Purdue University 2018; RCVS 2018c).
Examination and regulation of veterinary technicians in the USA, unlike the veterinary nurses in the
UK, is fragmented due to differences between the States. Depending on the State, boards of
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 37
veterinary medicine, veterinary medical examiners, or other authorised state regulatory agencies are
responsible for these procedures (AVMA 2018b). State Veterinary Practice Acts help define what
technicians can do. However, comparable to veterinary nursing in the UK, VT in America is also
undergoing rapid change. NAVTA has recently launched a National Credential Initiative seeking
standardisation of the credential for veterinary support personnel nationally to enhance professional
recognition (Veterinary Nurse Initiative 2016; NAVTA 2017). A title change from ‘veterinary
technician’ to ‘registered veterinary nurse’ has been proposed to more clearly convey the art of
caring plus the mastery of science and technology inherent in the both the role and a HE educated
paraprofessional (Veterinary Nurse Initiative 2016). Exemplifying the growing importance and
recognition of veterinary support staff globally, NAVTA asserts that ‘pet owners are demanding
qualified veterinary nursing personnel, which leads to consumer protection and patient care’
(Veterinary Nurse Initiative 2018).
2.1.3 Veterinary nursing in Australia
Recognition of veterinary nursing as an occupation occurred much later in Australia than in the UK
or USA. The first training course for animal nursing auxiliaries in Australia, which commenced in
Western Australia in 1969, was based on the UK syllabus (Grandison et al. 1969). This is not
surprising, considering Australia’s historical ties with Britain, including the development of the
veterinary profession in Australia (Caple 2011) and the advanced state of veterinary nursing in the
UK. This influence has continued with British veterinary nurses, such as Jane Bindloss and Sue
Crampton, playing key roles in advancing veterinary nursing education and training in Australia;
Sue remains heavily involved in these activities (J. Currie 2018, pers. comm., 10 June).
In 1993-1994 some formalised vocational training for veterinary nurses occurred at state level
(Veterinary nurse training in Australia and Britain: a comparative report 2003). Prior to this some
non-accredited training for veterinary nurses was conducted at The UQ’s Veterinary School (M
McLennan 2002, pers. comm., n.d.). In 1996 the inaugural national veterinary nursing curriculum
based on national competency standards was introduced by the vocational education and training
sector (Rural Training Council of Australia 1999). This was replaced in 1998 by endorsement of the
National Veterinary Nursing Training Package, elevating the national qualification from a
certificate level III to a level IV and establishing a formal career pathway for veterinary nurses
(Australian National Training Authority 1998).
Currently, the Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing remains the national qualification
(Training.gov.au 2018a; VNCA 2018b) with four nationally-accredited, specialised diplomas
(surgical nursing, emergency and critical care, dental nursing, and general practice) available under
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 38
the umbrella of the vocational education and training sector (Training.gov.au 2018b; VNCA
2018a). The move towards higher level courses mirrors international trends, with the UK adopting
the Diploma in Veterinary Nursing as the national qualification in 2010 (RCVS 2018d), and NZ
following suit in 2015 (NZ Qualifications Authority 2015). A professional body, the VNCA, was
formed on 2 May, 1995 (H Power 2018, pers. comm. 10 July).
Only one State in Australia, Western Australia, approves and maintains a register of veterinary
nurses and trainee nurses. The veterinary duties performed by these groups are endorsed in the
Veterinary Surgeons Regulations 1979 (Veterinary Surgeons’ Board of Western Australia 2018). In
early 2018, the VNCA launched a national Voluntary Registration Project as a precursor to
professional registration for veterinary nurses (VNCA 2018c). This initiative followed a similar
process to that of the RCVS (2015a) veterinary nurse registration project in the UK and the
NZVNA in NZ (NZVNA 2016a).
2.1.4 Veterinary technology in Australia
VT is an emerging veterinary paraprofession in Australia and a relatively new HE discipline. The
original qualification, a Bachelor of Applied Science specialising in VT, commenced at UQ in 2001
(Clarke, Schull & Coleman 2009). The UQ VT programme subsequently had a title change in 2017
to the Bachelor of VT (UQ 2018a), reflecting a maturing HE discipline. Graduates appear to be
occupying a mid-level niche (Moodie et al. 2013) positioned between the veterinary scientist and
the vocational veterinary nurse (Clarke et al. 2015). At the time of its inception, the degree appeared
to fill a demand for a HE veterinary nursing programme, as there were none in Australia.
Subsequently, in 2015 Charles Sturt University in Wagga (CSU 2015), Australia, commenced a
dual qualification, the Bachelor of VT combined with the Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing,
similar to the NZ model for VT (Massey 2018) and the UK HE veterinary nursing programmes
(RCVS 2018c). In 2018, Latrobe University, Melbourne, in partnership with Melbourne
Polytechnic launched Australia’s first Bachelor of Veterinary Nursing (Latrobe University 2018),
adding to the growing number of HE programmes for veterinary paraprofessionals in Australasia.
Globally, employment destinations of HE VT or veterinary nursing qualifications include
veterinary nursing in general and specialist veterinary practices, veterinary nutrition and
pharmaceutical representatives, veterinary nursing and VT educators in higher and vocational
education, veterinary laboratory scientists, biosecurity inspectors, and animal health technologists
(Clarke, Schull & Coleman 2009).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 39
2.1.5 Veterinary nursing and veterinary technology in NZ
The HE discipline of VT in NZ evolved from a nationally-accredited two-year Diploma in
Veterinary Nursing delivered by Massey University (Massey University College of Sciences 2008).
The Massey VT degree, conceptualised and developed under the leadership of Hayley Squance, an
inaugural UQ VT graduate (Massey University College of Sciences 2008), was introduced in 2009.
Its inception was in response to a recognised need for enhanced support for rural veterinary
practitioners, and to elevate the standard of paraprofessional education and training in NZ to the
level of the more established HE programmes in the UK and USA (Massey University College of
Sciences 2008). The advancing use of technology in areas such as veterinary imaging, and
significant advances in the production animal industries involving technological and legislative
changes, also signalled the need for more academically prepared veterinary support personnel
(Massey University College of Sciences 2008).
Veterinary nursing education and training in NZ, comparable to Australia, is a nationally recognised
vocational qualification. This changed from the National Certificate to the NZ Diploma in
Veterinary Nursing (Level 6) in 2015 (NZ Qualifications Authority 2015). In addition, Massey
University’s Bachelor of VT provides a nationally recognised HE pathway into veterinary nursing
and broader employment opportunities, commensurate with an academic qualification (Massey
University 2018). The Massey degree has embedded veterinary nursing skills within the curriculum
(Massey University 2018).
2.1.6 Veterinary technology in Japan
Comparable to Australia, VT was emerging as a veterinary paraprofession in Asia in the 1990s and
2000s. The inaugural Bachelor of Veterinary Nursing and Technology commenced at Nippon
Veterinary and Life Science University (NVLU) in 2005 (K Ishioka 2013, pers. comm., 4 March).
Interestingly, the title of this degree reflects both nursing and VT employment destinations. Japan
has made great progress with six HE VT and veterinary nursing programmes on offer by 2015 (K
Ishioka 2015, pers. comm., 31 December) and professionalisation of the field gaining momentum
over a short period of time. While the NVLU programme places significant emphasis on veterinary
nursing, the VT stream was included to provide expanded graduate opportunities in biomedical
research and other areas (K Ishioka 2013, pers. comm., 4 March). NVLU has demonstrated a strong
commitment to VT in HE, leading the way in Asia with the development (in 2008 and 2010,
respectively) of postgraduate studies at master’s and doctoral levels (K Ishioka 2013, pers. comm.,
4 March). Such HE offerings help to ensure the emerging profession creates its own body of
knowledge to guide practice (Gruending 1985; Hunt et al. 1998; Clouston & Whitcombe 2008).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 40
Veterinary nursing is the major employment sector for NVLU graduates (K Ishioka 2015, pers.
comm., 31 December). However, congruent with HE graduates in the UK, USA and Australasia,
NVLU graduates are employed in many segments of the veterinary and allied animal health fields,
including laboratories, government agencies, wildlife management, biomedical sciences, public
health, animal welfare, education (vocational and HE), veterinary nutrition and pharmaceutical
companies, and in ecology (K Ishioka 2015, pers. comm., 31 December). A small number of
graduates enrol in research higher degrees (K Ishioka 2015, pers. comm., 31 December).
In 2012, five independent certificate agencies for veterinary nurse licensing in Japan unified to form
the Council for the Certification of Registered Veterinary Nurses—a non-government organisation
offering one certification examination under the auspices of the Japanese Veterinary Medical
Association (K Ishioka 2013, pers. comm., 4 March; Haga & Nakayama 2016). The students who
complete a VT or veterinary nursing programme with a curriculum approved by the Council for the
Certification of Registered Veterinary Nurses may sit for this new examination to be called a
‘registered veterinary nurse’. As of June 2016, there were 15,814 registered veterinary nurses in
Japan (Haga & Nakayama 2016). Although this certification is not nationally recognised currently,
the Japanese Veterinary Nurses Association is working towards making this a national licence. In
parallel, the universities and some vocational schools offering VT/veterinary nursing programmes
are working on a national curriculum for veterinary nurse education (K Ishioka 2015, pers. comm.,
31 December). Hence, Japan has made rapid progress towards professionalising these fields.
2.1.7 Veterinary technology in Thailand and Singapore
Indicative of the expansion of HE VT programmes in Asia, Kasetsart University in Bangkok,
Thailand (Kasetsart University 2018) commenced a four-year Bachelor of Science degree in VT in
1993 (W Rerkamnuaychoke, pers. comm. 2014, 17 March). The Kasetsart University degree
included veterinary nursing prior to the establishment of a four-year degree in veterinary nursing in
2013 (W Rerkamnuaychoke 2014, pers. comm., 17 March). Employment destinations for the
Kasetsart University VT graduates are comparable with those from other Australasian universities
previously described and include small and large animal veterinary practices, technicians in zoos
and research facilities, sales representatives for veterinary pharmaceutical companies, veterinary
practice managers, and faculty or personnel for teaching institutions (W Rerkamnuaychoke 2014,
pers. comm., 17 March).
The two-year Diploma in VT at Temasek Polytechnic was the first offered in Singapore.
Commencing in 2007 (Temasek Polytechnic 2014a), the diploma integrates an academic curriculum
with practical training in animal clinics and an offshore aquaculture research station (Temasek
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 41
Polytechnic 2014b). Graduate employment destinations are similar to other Australasian VT
programmes, including veterinary practices, animal welfare industries, pet industries and
biomedical research industries (Temasek Polytechnic 2014b). Additional career opportunities are
found in aquaculture and marine conservation (Temasek Polytechnic 2014b). A range of Australian
universities offer credit transfers to Temasek VT diploma graduates. This includes the VT
programme at UQ (UQ 2017).
2.1.8 Veterinary nursing in Hong Kong
Veterinary nursing is an emerging discipline in Hong Kong (Cheung 2015). Prior to the
introduction of a veterinary nursing degree programme jointly offered by The Hong Kong
Polytechnic University and the Royal Veterinary College (RVC) of the University of London in
2010 (Hong Kong Polytechnic 2009), there were no formal qualifications in veterinary nursing
offered in Hong Kong (Scofield 2012). The degree was expected to provide broad career choices
including roles in veterinary nursing, practice management, animal welfare and rehabilitation, and
veterinary nursing education (Hong Kong Polytechnic University 2009). However, the programme
closed after graduating its first cohort of 30 students in 2014 (RVC News 2014). Currently there is
no nationally accredited training for veterinary nurses in Hong Kong (K Griffin 2019, pers. comm.,
4 March). At this time, the Hong Kong Veterinary Association website lists two veterinary nursing
training providers: the Animal Industries Resource Centre, an Australian training organisation,
which offers a Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing, and Hong Kong’s City University offering an
Advanced Diploma in Veterinary Nursing (Hong Kong Veterinary Association 2019). It is reported
that the Chinese Veterinary Medical Association (2019) does engage in veterinary nursing training
(K Griffin 2019, pers. comm., 4 March), but information was difficult to source.
The Hong Kong Veterinary Nursing Association was founded in 2011 to support and promote
veterinary nursing in Hong Kong and internationally, as well as having a role in liaising with
government, the education sector and promoting continuing education (Hong Kong Veterinary
Nursing Association 2013). In 2012, Schedule 2 of the Hong Kong Veterinary Surgeons
Registration Ordinance Order was amended to ‘permit veterinary assistants, veterinary students, and
other individuals (identified as ‘persons’) to perform certain acts of veterinary surgery and provide
certain veterinary services under the direction or supervision of a registered veterinary surgeon’
(Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department 2018).
2.1.9 Summary of global education and professionalisation
A summary of the following detailed review on the education and professionalisation of VT and
veterinary nursing in Australasia, Asia, the UK and USA is provided in Table 2-1.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 42
Table 2-1: Summary of veterinary technology and veterinary nursing education and professionalisation in Australasia, Asia, the UK and USA.
Country Qualification(s) Educational sector
Professional association Registration Regulatory body
CPD*
United Kingdom
Diploma of Veterinary Nursing
Further Education British Veterinary Nursing Association
Compulsory Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons
Compulsory (45 hours over 3 years)
3-year Foundation degree (Veterinary Nursing)
Further Education & Higher Education
4-year Honours degree (Veterinary Nursing)
Higher Education
USA Associate degree in Science (VT), or equivalent
College/Polytechnic (majority)
National Association of Veterinary Technicians in America
Varies -some states have compulsory licensing (registration)
The American Association of Veterinary State Boards maintains a directory of regulatory agencies for licensing and credentialing of VTs in USA and Canada
Varies – compulsory in some states (averages 5 to 12 hours over 1 year) 4-year Bachelor of Science
in VT Higher Education
Australia Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing
Vocational Education & Training
Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia
Compulsory for veterinary nurses in Western Australia
Veterinary Surgeons Board of Western Australia
No CPD requirements
3-year Bachelor of VT Higher education AVNAT** registration scheme (voluntary) for all veterinary nurses and VTs from 1 April 2019
Precursor - AVNAT Regulatory Council
20 points over 1 year
New Zealand Diploma in Veterinary Nursing
Polytechnic
New Zealand Veterinary Nursing Association
Voluntary Register/List for veterinary nurses and VTs
Precursor - Allied Veterinary Professional Regulatory Council
20 hours CPD per year, and 40 hours in clinical or veterinary nursing related practice per year
3-year Bachelor of VT Higher Education
Japan Certificate in Veterinary Nursing
Vocational College Japanese Veterinary Nurses Association
Council for the Certification of Registered Veterinary Nurses - Licence not national
No statutory regulatory body
-
4-year Bachelor of Veterinary Nursing/VT
Higher Education
Thailand 4-year Bachelor of Science in VT
Higher Education Veterinary Technology Association of Thailand (not sure if still active)
- No statutory regulatory body
-
4-year Bachelor of Science in Veterinary Nursing
Higher Education
Singapore 2-year Diploma of Veterinary Technology
Polytechnic - - No statutory regulatory body
-
Hong Kong Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing
Vocational Education & Training (Australia)
Hong Kong Veterinary Nursing Association
- No statutory regulatory body
-
Advanced Diploma in Veterinary Nursing
Higher education (Hong Kong)
*CPD – continuing professional development; ** AVNAT – Australian Veterinary Nurse and Technicians
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 43
2.2 The socio-political context of an emerging profession
The global proliferation of HE programmes for veterinary paraprofessionals in Australasia and Asia
since the 1990s reflects the need for academically prepared veterinary paraprofessionals. To
understand the factors that influenced this phenomenon, particularly the inception of VT in
Australia, the socio-political forces operating within the veterinary and HE contexts at that time
need to be examined. As would be expected, the evolution of VT in Australia was closely aligned
with developments in the veterinary and allied animal health fields.
2.2.1 Setting the scene: the veterinary profession in Australia
In comparison to the UK and USA, veterinary science in Australia is a relatively young profession
that commenced as a four year ‘trade’ course at the Melbourne Veterinary College in 1888, just
over 100 years after Captain Cook discovered the east coast of Australia (Caple 2011, p. 282). The
first veterinary school was established at Melbourne University in 1908 (Fisher 2002; Caple 2011),
laying a foundation for the modern veterinary profession with veterinarians engaging in diverse
fields such as teaching, research, industry, and safeguarding the health and welfare of companion,
exotic, wildlife and production animals (Banyard, Farrow & Malmo 1996; AVA 2014, 2016). More
recently, the veterinarians’ role has extended to the health and wellbeing of society relating to the
importance of the human-animal bond (HAB) (Headey 1999) and issues of public health (Neumann
2007). Despite the increased significance of companion animal practice (Banyard, Farrow & Malmo
1996; AVA 2016), veterinarians in Australia continue to make a major contribution to rural and
regional areas in food safety, the health and welfare of livestock, biosecurity protection, and disease
surveillance (AVA 2014). The eradication of bovine brucellosis in 1992, and the achievement in
1997 and subsequent maintenance of Australia’s bovine tuberculosis free status (Bunn 2002)
validate this.
The veterinary profession and veterinary education have been rapidly evolving and expanding since
the late 20th century. The University of Sydney’s Post Graduate Foundation in Veterinary Science
was formed in 1968 by a group of visionary veterinarians from industry, government, practice, and
academia, who saw the need for continuing veterinary education (Bryden 2003). By 2000, the
Foundation had extended its offerings to include distance learning programmes, symposia and
workshops in 12 subjects for veterinarians throughout Australia and overseas (Bryden 2003),
opening up the practice of veterinary science in Australia to the international community. Similarly,
the Australian College of Veterinary Scientists, established in 1971 as a post-graduate accrediting
body for the Australian and NZ veterinary professions, paved the way for veterinary specialisations
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 44
(fellowships) and ‘membership level’ postgraduate qualifications, signalling a maturing profession
(Stewart cited in Woolcock & Parker 2011, p. 470).
College Membership demonstrated a high level of expertise and competence in a specific area of
veterinary science by examination (Taylor 2002; Woolcock & Parker 2011). College Chapters were
established early on in areas such as clinical medicine, preventative medicine, surgery, animal
reproduction, and obstetrics to accommodate a growing diversity of ‘disciplines and species’ in
veterinary science (Woolcock & Parker 2011, p. 471). Australia’s first veterinary specialists were
registered with the relevant State Veterinary Surgeons Board in 1988 (Woolcock & Parker 2011, p.
287). This was followed by the emergence of private specialised veterinary practices, such as the
Animal Emergency Centre in Brisbane, which was established in 1994 as the first of its kind in
Queensland (Animal Emergency Service 2018) to meet public demand for a higher level of
veterinary services.
However, despite these developments within the profession, a government review (Frawley 2003, p.
74) of rural veterinary services in Australia in the early 2000s revealed that the role of veterinary
paraprofessionals was contentious. Some veterinarians in small and large animal practices viewed
paraprofessionals as a potential jurisdictional threat impinging on the demand for veterinary
services (Frawley 2003; Ressler 2011), while others saw a need to expand the role of veterinary
nurses and technicians (Frawley 2003). Advocates envisaged veterinary nurses could be more fully
utilised and trained to perform ‘basic diagnostics, surgical and emergency medicine without direct
vet supervision’, allowing veterinarians to focus on more complex tasks (Frawley 2003, p. 76).
Subsequently, the review recommended that veterinary nurses, and a specified range of veterinary
tasks they could perform, should be formally recognised, reflecting practices in the UK, USA, and
in Western Australia, the only Australian State with veterinary nurse registration (Frawley 2003,
p.4). In the USA, other veterinary paraprofessionals such as laboratory technicians, stock inspectors
and veterinary technicians were reported to be making major contributions to animal health services
(Frawley 2003, p. 76). Australia appeared to be lagging behind global trends in the utilisation of
veterinary paraprofessionals, particularly in large animal services (Frawley 2003).
2.2.2 Setting the scene: global trends in the veterinary profession
As an example, research from the USA around that time showed that practices more effectively
utilising their technicians had better financial returns. This finding was based on examining the
financial health of the top 25% and bottom 25% of practices, with the former having higher
technician to veterinarian ratios (2.3 compared to 1.6) (Brown & Silverman 1999, p. 182). There
was also an awareness that higher quality veterinary services requiring veterinarians with more
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 45
complex skills, would, in turn, necessitate higher standards of training for veterinary
paraprofessionals (Nielsen 2003). This premise was reflected in the growth of HE programmes for
veterinary support personnel internationally. Namely, by the early 2000s, there were 13 AVMA
accredited four-year Bachelor of Science degrees in VT in the USA. In addition, some British
veterinary schools were offering ‘baccalaureate degrees in areas such as veterinary nursing…, and
other fields related to veterinary medicine’ (Nielsen 2003, p. 305).
However, despite these advances in the education and utilisation of veterinary support personnel,
the veterinary profession in the USA faced many challenges and opportunities from rapid social,
economic and technological changes at the dawn of the millennium. Its future success would
depend on its responsiveness to change, stimulating a review of veterinary work practices (Brown
& Silverman 1999). A seminal KPMG study in the USA in 1998 concurred that emerging trends
(such as the HAB, technological advances, and large corporate practices) demanded a review of the
veterinary profession’s inefficient structures, business practices, and current modes of service
delivery (Brown & Silverman 1999, p.161). As professions are committed to serving society and
their success lies with their ability to meet societal needs (Brown & Silverman 1999; Nielsen 2003),
it was imperative that the profession responded to the changing attitudes towards animals (Paul &
Podberscek 2000).
In the 1980s and 1990s, the HAB was becoming increasingly important in Australia and
internationally because of the changing role of domestic animals in society and growing public
concern about the welfare of companion, production, and research animals (Flynn 1979; Brown &
Silverman 1999; Fogle 1999). The public in Western countries, influenced by the improving
economic conditions after World War II and the rising social status of women, had accepted that
dogs and cats were sentient beings, moving them from the backyard ‘into their hearts’ (Fogle 1999,
p. 234). These changing societal values and the growing recognition of the HAB, where the pet/pet
owner relationship was more like that of parent/child (Berryman, Howells & Lloyd-Evans 1985) or
members of a family, (Fogle 1999), led to consumer expectations of constantly improving quality of
veterinary services (Brown & Silverman 1999).
In addition, consumer expectations for quality veterinary services were also motivated by a media-
driven increase in public awareness concerning science, animals, animal production and health
(Pritchard 1994). For these reasons, the veterinary profession had to be capable of delivering
increasingly higher levels of service, not only to companion animals, but to all species of animals
important to people (Pritchard 1994). As society placed higher social and economic value on
veterinary services, there was a need for more veterinary specialisations (Pritchard 1994), and
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 46
therefore more highly trained veterinary paraprofessionals. People who were highly attached to
their pets spent more on veterinary services, and veterinary practices that acknowledged the
importance of the HAB reportedly had better patient and practice outcomes (Brown & Silverman
1999). As the importance of the HAB grew, it became an emerging research field globally. In
addition to animals offering companionship, Australian research linked the psychological and
physical health benefits of pet ownership with a potential to reduce expenditure on public health
(Headey 1999). Seminal research by Friedman et al. (1980) revealed reduced mortality in pet
owners admitted to a coronary care unit and elderly pet owners were reported to experience
psychosocial benefits, including reduced visits to a doctor, due to the HAB (Siegel 1990). This
change in the social status of animals was accompanied by a change in their legal status, reflecting
changing societal values, and thus transforming the delivery of veterinary services.
Dating back to the 1960s, codes of care to ensure the welfare of livestock were developed in the UK
while similar codes for poultry and the care and use of animals in research were being drafted in
Australia. Concurrently, the AVA produced position papers on animal welfare (Flynn 1979). In
time, the humane treatment of animals in research, livestock industries, and companion animals,
provoked such public interest that it registered on the political agenda (Flynn 1979, p. 548). Over
the decades animal welfare issues had gathered such momentum that all Australian states developed
legislation to protect animals from cruelty and to regulate animal use in research and teaching.
Some Australian states also had legislation overseeing the care of companion animals (McGreevy &
Dixon 2005, p. 442), such as Queensland’s Animal Care and Protection Act 2001. At the same
time, in Queensland widespread lobbying from the community and industry resulted in the
Australian government funding a Chair of Animal Welfare at UQ (UQ News 2001). In fact, animal
welfare was viewed as one of the most prominent issues facing veterinary medicine, and therefore
veterinary education, at that time (Fogle 1999, p. 237); animal behaviour and human-animal
relations in veterinary curricula were becoming comparable in importance to psychology in human
medicine (Fogle 1999).
2.2.3 Setting the scene: global and national trends in higher education
In addition to socio-political forces impacting on veterinary education, around the time of the
inception of VT at UQ universities were increasingly viewed as a medium for creating ‘new
knowledge and preparing graduates with appropriate skills and attributes in line with the needs of
the economy and society’ (Department of Education Science and Training 2002, p. 25) (DEST).
Australian Government research on employers’ perspectives on employability skills also identified
that personal attributes, such as initiative, adaptability and managing stress were fundamentally
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 47
important to employment (DEST 2002, p. 8). Similarly, capabilities in teamwork, communication,
technology skills, problem-solving, self-management, and others—often termed graduate attributes
in HE—were also found desirable (DEST 2002). Overall, the DEST (2002) findings signalled a
holistic approach to developing a curriculum based on knowledge, skills and personal attributes that
would promote employability.
At the same time, in Australia and internationally, government policy was leading HE into its
second period of massification, that of universal access or open entry (Trow 2007, 2016), to upskill
the nation and increase productivity and equity (Bradley 2008; Probert 2016). This resulted in a
student population drawn from a broader range of socioeconomic and educational backgrounds, and
with differing expectations and aspirations (De La Harpe, Radloff & Wyber 2000; James 2000;
Kirkpatrick & Mulligan 2002; James, Bexley & Shearer 2009; Wingate 2010). The transformation
of HE from an elite to mass education system also resulted in lower entry levels (Winch & Wells
1995), and facilitated the transfer of some previously vocational occupations, such as nursing and
social work into HE (Peach 2010). Thus, the inception of VT at UQ was also influenced by a
changing HE landscape in Australia and internationally. In this milieu, disciplines such as nursing
in HE had integrated vocational competencies into the academic curricula to support graduate
employability (Reid 1994; Peach 2010). Hence, a model for vocationalism and academisation of a
new paraprofession emerged.
2.3 Birth of a veterinary paraprofession in Australia
At this time of great socio-political change for the veterinary profession and HE, UQ took up the
challenge and introduced a bachelor’s degree in VT in 2001. As previously discussed, this new HE
discipline heralded the birth of a veterinary paraprofession in Australia following global trends for
university-educated veterinary support personnel (Lukens & Walsh 2015; RCVS 2018a). The UQ
programme was the vision of Professor John Ternouth, veterinarian and Head of the School of
Animal Studies, at UQ’s rural Gatton campus. Ternouth recognised a niche for HE qualified
veterinary paraprofessionals in Australia to meet societal expectations for high quality veterinary
services and the requirements of large multi-veterinarian practices (J Ternouth 2014, pers. comm.,
28 January). Subsequently, a new mid-tier workforce model for veterinary support personnel—
positioned between the veterinary scientist and veterinary nurse—was born. According to Ternouth,
UQ veterinary technologists would meet a need for emerging roles, comparable to international
trends, working as veterinary practice managers, senior nurses, imaging technicians, laboratory
technicians and field technicians in government agencies—making an important contribution to the
veterinary and allied animal health fields (J Ternouth 2014, pers. comm., 28 January).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 48
The first UQ VT bachelor’s degree cohort graduated in 2003 (Clarke 2004), around the time of the
Frawley report (2003) which revealed disparate views in the veterinary profession’s attitude
towards veterinary paraprofessionals. In addition, transitioning what is viewed as a vocational
occupation into academia and into the milieu of a traditional profession such as veterinary science,
can be challenging, and these challenges were augmented because the new discipline was the first
of its kind in Australia. However, much can be learned about the facilitators and barriers for a new
HE paraprofession by examining the experiences of similar paraprofessions in the human health
field that have transferred from traditional vocational training (Watson 1982; Walker & Holmes
2016).
2.4 ‘Lessons to be learned’ from human nursing
Many technical occupations that have transitioned into HE support a dominant established
profession. A classic example is human nursing and its evolving role in supporting the medical
profession (Sax 1978; Shaw 1993; Eraut 1994; Forsyth 1995). In the 19th century a nurse was
described as ‘the handmaiden to the medical profession, trained to be the eyes and hands of the
physician during his absence’ (Debout et al. p. 520). This archetypical ‘subordinate-dominant’
relationship between paraprofession and profession (Eraut 1994) is changing, influenced by the
Australian government’s agenda for increasing productivity and international competitiveness
(Bradley et al. 2008; Dawson, Charman & Kilpatrick 2013), and by the resulting transformative
power of HE.
Common to other more recently professionalised health paraprofessions, such as oral health (Tsang
2010) and paramedicine (Mahony 2003), nursing in Australia began as a vocation with accredited,
apprenticeship style training. This hospital-based training for nursing students was introduced
during the 1920s and 1930s (Lusk et al. 2001). Over the next 50 years, the professionalisation of
nurse education and training was driven by a number of Australian Government inquiries and
reviews. Notably, these were the 1978 Committee of Inquiry into Nurse Education and Training to
the Tertiary Education Commission (Sax 1978), a National Review of Nurse Education in the HE
sector—1994 and Beyond (Reid 1994)—and a National Review of Nursing Education 2002 (Heath
2002). All involved strong advocacy by nurses, nurse educators, nursing professional bodies and
from within the education sector (Sax 1978; Reid 1994). These government initiatives were fuelled
by the higher expectations of informed consumers, an increasing complexity of health care delivery,
rapidly expanding knowledge in the field, and advancing technology (Sax 1978, p.4, 47; Reid 1994;
Heath 2002).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 49
2.4.1 Changing the educational paradigm
Submissions to the 1978 Nursing Inquiry argued that current hospital-based training could no
longer provide the necessary nursing body of knowledge and that it diminished the status of the
registered nurse (Sax 1978, p. 5). Poor integration of theory and practice was identified as a training
issue, and traditional hierarchical structures in hospitals were reportedly stifling learning (Sax
1978), ‘critical analysis, innovation and change’ (Sax 1978, p. 44-45). Additionally, inconsistencies
in training standards among States and hospitals created a barrier to the transferability of nurses’
employment within Australia and overseas (Sax 1978, p. 45 & 71). Hospital training was also
reported to lack educational resources, placed excessive emphasis on task-orientation, and lacked
qualified nurse educators (Sax 1978, p. 114). Some of these issues also applied to veterinary nurses
trained ‘on the job’. A survey of Australian veterinary employers/practice managers and veterinary
nurses/support personnel in 2003 revealed quite disparate views on the direction of veterinary
nursing roles in practice, with a ‘huge variation in respondents’ experiences with methods of
delivery and the subsequent competence of qualifying nurses’ (Bindloss 2003a, p. 527).
Other potential barriers to advancing the nursing paraprofession involved those who wanted to
maintain the service nurse trainees provided in hospitals and feared the risk of credentialism
adversely affecting nurses’ job satisfaction and career aspirations (Sax 1978, p. 5). There were also
reservations about opportunities for practical training in academic and professional programmes.
This is a common thread in the history of vocational occupations transitioning into HE (O’Brien et
al. 2013; O’Brien et al. 2014), but not one that should be insurmountable using a curriculum that
blends ‘academisation’ with vocationalism (Cooper 2002; Findlow 2012).
Another barrier to advancing nursing education was the reluctance of doctors to relinquish control
of nursing curricula and to change the status quo in the doctor-nurse relationship (Sax 1978).
Hospital training kept nursing engaged in a ‘medical model of practice’ (Watson 1982), where
nurses’ subordination to the dominant medical profession limited their capacity for autonomy and
developing a discipline-specific scientific base (Eraut 1994). According to Eraut (1994) from the
sociology of professions, this situation was characteristic of the struggle for professionalisation
experienced by more technically-oriented occupations under the control of a dominant profession
and is a phenomenon common to many female-dominated occupations (Eraut 1994; Kinnison, May
& Guile 2014).
Overall, there was strong advocacy for an end to service-based education and for nursing students to
‘learn the art and science of nursing’ in an educational setting (Sax 1978, p. 57). Many viewed
nurses as professionals who had to be accountable, effective members of interdisciplinary health
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 50
care teams, and able to communicate with a range of stakeholders (Sax 1978). A more scholarly
approach to their education was required to develop self-directed, reflective learners, and problem-
solvers committed to continuing education and the importance of research in their practice (Sax
1978). It was also proposed that nursing curricula incorporate scientific and behavioural studies
(Sax 1978, p. 56); these are increasingly important for nurse-patient relations, particularly in dealing
with the stressful situations found in the acute care settings (Sax 1978, p.4).
Supporters of nursing education had achieved success when, in the 1980s, nurse education and
training in Australia had progressed from certificate level to undergraduate vocational diplomas
delivered by colleges of advanced education with strong links to industry (Lusk et al. 2001, p. 198).
In 1984, the Australian government approved the transfer of all pre-registration nursing education
into HE. Although this took 10 years to achieve (1984-1993), Australia was one of the first
countries to assign all registered nursing education to HE (Reid 1994, p. xvi). A review of this
historical event revealed that it had expanded career choices and created ‘a better educated and
more flexibly trained profession’ (Blewett cited in Reid 1994, p. xvi), providing more opportunities
for women in education and employment (Reid 1994).
Additionally, in the interests of quality all HE nursing curricula had to be accredited by their State
or Territory nursing registration board as well as meet the university’s academic requirements, and
graduates had to meet the Australian Nursing Council Incorporated competencies for registration in
their State or Territory (Heath 2002, p. 56).
2.4.2 Academisation and professionalisation
For some of the more technically-oriented occupations, such as nursing, ‘academisation’ within HE
has facilitated their professionalisation (Peach 2010; Findlow 2012). The Reid Report (1994, p.9),
set up to review the transfer of nursing into HE and consider future directions for nursing education,
highlighted the role of universities in developing a full range of academic functions, including post-
graduate qualifications and research, when establishing new disciplines. Nurses undertaking study
up to doctoral level was viewed as an opportunity to develop ‘the individual nurse, the profession
and the health care system’ (Reid 1994, p. 34). A subsequent review of nursing education in 2002
identified that nursing research and nursing researchers also provided a framework for good policy
decisions, for improving clinical practice and education (Heath 2002, p. 14-15), and an evidence
base for nursing practice (Heath 2000). Similarly, the creation of clinical chairs and joint
partnerships with health agencies were all important outcomes for a professionalising occupation
(Heath 2002, p. 9).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 51
2.4.3 Educational partnerships
As nursing was transferring into HE, the importance of educational institutions building
relationships with employers and employing organisations to facilitate nursing practical training
became evident (Sax 1978; Reid 1994; Heath 2002; Grealish & Smale 2011). Partnerships
involving government, employers, and educational institutions were seen as the key to achieving
quality nursing practice and education (Sax 1978; Reid 1994; Heath 2002), and providing a positive
clinical learning environment (Hart & Rotem 1994). Stakeholder input into programme
development, training objectives, course content, assessment and programme evaluation were also
advocated to ensure relevance and ongoing improvement (Sax 1978, p.78); this is another valuable
‘lesson to be learned’ for other paraprofessions.
2.4.4 Consumers as partners
Heading into the twenty-first century, relationships with consumers of health care dramatically
grew in importance for human nursing. Advances in disease prevention, diagnosis and treatments
had broadened the scope of nursing practice, and the internet had made access to medical
information more publicly available, with the effect of increasing consumer awareness and
expectations (Heath 2002). Consumers became more involved as partners in medical decision-
making, shifting the balance of power in patient-doctor relationships (Heath 2002). This also led to
an increasingly litigious society making the contribution of nursing to the quality of health care
even more important (Heath 2002) and affirming the place of nursing in HE to meet consumer
demands for quality care.
2.4.5 Clinical education and a dual curriculum
Nursing’s transfer into HE was initially accompanied by employer disappointment. The Reid
Report (1994) revealed employers were concerned about the clinical skills of HE graduates, even
though a marked improvement was noted within 12 months of practice and the HE graduates’
capacity for lifelong learning in the workplace compensated for gaps in their clinical skills (Heath
2002). The apparent disparity between employers’ and HE’s expectations highlighted a ‘policy
dilemma’ arising when universities and employers have differing expectations for vocational
occupations transferring into HE (Reid 1994, p. xix). This not only highlighted the importance of
stakeholder involvement in curriculum design, but also the dual nature of nursing in HE having to
satisfy both vocational and academic requirements (Reid 1994), which is an issue for any
paraprofession transitioning into HE, and more so in a traditional university.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 52
To address this dilemma, the 1994 review of nursing education recommended that HE ensured
nursing competency standards met the health sectors’ needs, and employing organisations provide
additional mentoring and peer support for new HE graduates in the workplace (Reid 1994). It also
recommended longer clinical placements with more rigorous assessment by both university and
health agency and more emphasis on integrating theory and practice (Reid 1994, p. xx). Such
recommendations reiterate the importance of collaborative partnerships between employing
agencies and HE for aspiring paraprofessionals and nurse specialisations (Reid 1994; Heath 2002,
p.111). The increasing threat of litigation also supported the imperative for nursing students to
develop a level of competency prior to placement, for the provision of clinical skills training centres
in nurse education (Heath 2002), and for nurse educators to maintain clinical currency by being
engaged in clinical work as part of their workload (Heath 2002, p. 156). These are all relevant
‘lessons to be learned’ when establishing a paraprofession in HE.
The history of nursing education illustrates additional perspectives at the graduate level: initially,
some tertiary-educated graduates working with hospital trained peers experienced ‘stormy rites of
passage’ (Reid 1994, p. xix). Public relations’ strategies to manage this barrier for HE graduates
included in-service training for key stakeholders, such as medical practitioners, clinical personnel
and hospital administrators, (Sax 1978, p. 91), and familiarising registered nurses, who provide
practical training in hospitals, with the theory and practice of the new curriculum, (Sax 1978, p. 93).
2.4.6 Interdisciplinarity
Interdisciplinary education or multi-professional practice, now termed interprofessional education
and practice (Thistlethwaite 2012), was also a common theme in the earlier reviews of nursing
education (Sax 1978; Reid 1994; Heath 2002). It was recognised that nursing education needed to
prepare graduates to work collaboratively with other professions to agreed standards, while
ensuring each profession maintained its essential competencies and professional boundaries (Heath
2002, p. 175).
2.4.7 Nurse specialisations: an emerging model of care
Over time, nursing experienced expansion of roles into specialisations such as acute care,
rehabilitation, community education, preventative health care, ante-natal care, and children’s health
and welfare (Sax 1978, p. 48). Continuing growth in new technologies, scientific research, and
knowledge continued to drive new specialisations and develop the nursing role to include nurse
practitioners, nurse managers, registered nurses (general, specialist, mental health, midwives) and
nurse educators (Heath 2002): a sign of further advancement and professionalisation. New
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 53
disciplines, such as the Bachelor of Midwifery, were first introduced in 2002 (Heath 2002). These
developments forecast what lies ahead for other paraprofessions and warrant pre-emptive workforce
planning.
2.4.8 The changing role of higher education and nursing
In the 1990s and early 2000s, advances in nursing paralleled a changing agenda for HE in Australia
and internationally. Pertinent to other emerging paraprofessions, the Heath (2002, p. 77) review of
nursing education asserted that, ‘The role of education is not only a professional issue, but also one
with more encompassing returns including those of labour market supply, ethical and social
considerations and knowledge distribution’ (Heath 2002, p. 77). Modern HE now had to engage
with stakeholders regarding the potential demand for graduates, the financial cost to students, and
the need to maintain currency of the curriculum in new disciplines (Heath 2002, p. 160). Likewise,
a need for continuous improvement of nursing education and practice through ongoing research,
workforce planning, and evaluation of educational programmes was highlighted (Sax 1978, p. 120).
HE was also seen as having a role in maximising articulation pathways between different providers
and levels of nurse education (Reid 1994, xxi), to promote career transitions and continuing
professional development at all levels of nursing (Sax 1978; Heath 2002, p. 22, 136).
2.4.9 Promoting the profession
In addition, the Heath review drew attention to the importance to nursing of developing a positive
and professional public image through well-planned nationally coordinated marketing campaigns,
which promoted to potential nurses the value, contribution and benefits of a nursing career. Such
campaigns also underpin acceptance within the professional, legislative and wider communities,
which is an important part of professionalisation (Ressler 2011, p. 158; Jongbloed-Zoet et al. 2012).
2.4.10 International trends in nursing and nursing education
The struggle of Australian nursing education transitioning into HE was a common theme across
most countries (Lusk et al. p. 2001). However, nursing education in Australia and NZ evolved faster
than in the UK and America, with Australia achieving bachelor’s degree entry-level by 1994 (Reid
1994). Nurse education in the USA was still primarily at associate-degree level at this time and the
UK had university-based diplomas, but was still working towards a university bachelor’s degree as
entry-level education (Lusk et al. 2001, p. 202). As in Australia, changing societal health care
needs, including hospitals focusing on acute care patients, warranted more highly educated nurses.
By 2000, the majority of nursing students in the UK were university educated with a three-year
diploma leading to registration (Lusk et al. 2001). An important lesson to be learned from the
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 54
nursing profession is how international cooperation and mutual support between the nursing
fraternities in different countries helped advance the cause in a range of countries (Laiho 2010).
2.5 Lessons to be learned from international veterinary
paraprofessions
As well as learning from the nursing experience, the history of veterinary nursing in the UK is
pertinent to the development of VT in Australia. The achievements of veterinary nursing in the UK
involved a struggle (Smith & Cooper 2015) characterised by a dominant/subordinate relationship
between the veterinary profession and vocational veterinary nursing (Kinnison, May & Guile 2014),
In the early years, veterinarians controlled the education and training of veterinary nurses (Turner
1984): there was an imbalance in professional status between the two groups, and a lack of
protection of the title of veterinary nurse (Kinnison, May & Guile 2014). Recent developments in
the UK, where veterinary nursing has been proclaimed a profession with statutory regulation
(RCVS 2015a), provide a model for the professionalisation of veterinary paraprofessions in
Australia. In contrast to nursing, the professionalisation of veterinary paraprofessionals in
Australasia is not as advanced as the UK in terms of registration, or licensing and regulation.
However, the increasing number of HE programmes in Australia and Asia, and moves towards
veterinary nursing and VT registration in Australia (VNCA 2018c), NZ (NZVNA 2016b) and Japan
(K Ishioka 2015, pers. comm., 31 December), reflect a climate of change. A global scan also reveals
discussions of a mid-tier qualification for veterinary professional associates, analogous to physician
assistants, in the USA (Kogan & Stewart 2009; Chadderdon, Lloyd & Pazak 2014) and in Australia
(Moodie et al. 2013), signalling increasingly complex and autonomous roles emerging for
veterinary paraprofessionals globally.
2.6 Shaping a paraprofession in higher education
2.6.1 Academisation and professionalisation through curriculum
Freidson (1970), from the sociology of professions, asserted that the foundation for true professions
lies within universities. This assertion remains true in modern professions (Laiho 2010; Ek et al.
2013), as evidenced in the recommendations for the transfer of nursing into HE: to develop its body
of knowledge, for students to learn ‘the art and science of nursing’ and to develop a more scholarly
approach to nursing education (Sax 1978). This theme is re-iterated in the literature of more
recently professionalised occupations, such as physiotherapy (Hunt et al. 1998; Sparkes 2002), and
veterinary nursing in the UK (Cooper 2002).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 55
‘Academisation’ has been described as a complex process involving the scientification, or
professionalisation, of previously vocational occupations facilitated through a university education
that involves research-led teaching and academic degree qualifications, with a goal of advancing
professional practice and improving patient outcomes (Friedrichs & Schaub 2011). According to
Laiho (2010, p. 641), HE was viewed as having a critical role in the ‘academisation’ of nursing (in
Norway). The drift in vocational programmes towards an academic curriculum reflects a desire for
professionalisation (Laiho 2010), which in turn drives greater engagement in research and research-
led teaching (Ek et al. 2013).
Therefore, educators in aspiring professions have an important role in nurturing professionalisation
of both the individual student and the occupation through ‘academisation’ of curriculum and
pedagogy, as cited in physiotherapy (Sparkes 2002, p.487). To date, very little research has been
conducted in exploring the academisation of HE curriculum and pedagogy to facilitate the
professionalisation of veterinary paraprofessions at either the individual or occupational level.
2.6.2 Vocationalism in higher education
Equally important to academisation, is the role of vocationalism in the HE curricula of aspiring
practice-based professions. Vocationalism is strongly tied to ‘academisation’ in previously
vocational occupations, even after the discipline is established in HE because of the discipline’s
strong links to industry and employer expectations of ‘work-ready’ graduates (Moodie et al. 2015).
Pertinent to HE educators, Rospigliosi, Bourner & Heath (2016) also assert that being concerned
about graduate employability is also about adopting a student-centred approach to HE.
2.6.3 Employability skills and graduate attributes
As part of its brief, an Australian Government Review of HE Financing and Policy in 1998
developed a list of attributes that every graduate should attain in their primary degree, to benefit
themselves, society, and employers (Department of Employment, Education, Science, Training and
Youth Affairs 1998, p. 47) (DEETYA). These included: a capacity for critical and reflective
thinking, discipline-specific technical competence and knowledge, effective communication skills, a
capacity for teamwork, problem-solving skills, capacity for self-directed learning, high ethical
standards both personally and professionally, and an ongoing curiosity for learning (DEETYA
1998, p. 47). Many of these attributes were also featured in the DEST report of 2002.
Paraprofessions such as VT should distinguish themselves from their vocationally trained
counterparts through the attainment of these graduate attributes.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 56
As a core graduate attribute, teamwork capability has received growing attention within the
veterinary, medical and allied health education literature regarding its importance in professional
practice and, hence, in curricula (Ruby & DeBowes 2007; Sargeant, Loney & Murphy 2008;
McCallin & McCallin 2009; Thistlethwaite 2012). More recently, teamwork has been associated
with the concept of interprofessional practice in the veterinary and veterinary nursing fields
(Branscombe 2010; Kinnison, May & Guile 2014). Interprofessional practice is described as a
harmonious, multi-disciplinary, integrated approach to providing quality care (Kinnison, May &
Guile 2014). Thus, the constructs of teamwork and interprofessional practice are important
considerations in developing curriculum and pedagogy for an emerging profession, such as VT,
where graduates work in teams of professionals and other paraprofessionals in a variety of contexts.
2.6.4 The stakeholder voice
Congruent with Australian government reports (DEETYA 1998; DEST 2002) and the international
literature, a need for ‘work-ready’ graduates has been identified across the disciplines (Harris, Jones
& Coutts 2010; Moodie 2010; Peach 2010). Therefore, a focus on work-integrated learning (WIL),
involving vocational competencies integrated into the academic curriculum of a previously
vocational, practice-based discipline needs to be considered by HE curriculum designers in order to
meet stakeholder needs for ‘work-ready’ graduates. To achieve this, it is incumbent on HE to build
partnerships with employing organisations and relevant industries in order to secure opportunities
for students’ clinical or practical skills development. Advocacy for experiential learning
opportunities was evident early on in veterinary education through ‘strategic alliances with high
quality veterinary practices and registered specialists in the community’ (Banyard, Farrow &
Malmo 1996, p. 35).
However, employers aren’t the only stakeholders who can contribute to a curriculum for
employability. In the health professions, recruiting the voice of service-users for input into
curriculum planning, teaching and evaluation of professional programmes has been linked to more
patient-centred medical services (Sax 1978; Hurley 2008; Fallon et al. 2012; Rhodes 2012). Such
research has not yet been widely reported in the VT or veterinary contexts.
2.6.5 Professional competence
A common theme in the literature on professionalisation is that a profession is associated with a
lengthy period of higher level education, usually delivered within a university (Freidson 1970;
Evetts 1999). Furthermore, the discipline specific knowledge taught in HE, which defines a
profession, is generated through research by advocates of the profession (Nilsson 2007, p. 25). In
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 57
addition to education, it is HE’s function to issue the qualification and socialise professionals
(Nilsson 2007, p. 25). To achieve these goals, HE today faces many challenges as a result of the
complex, changing world in which we live, so further considerations are necessary in constructing
curriculum (Barnett 2004).
It is widely recognised in the cross-disciplinary literature that we live in a world of uncertainty, with
graduates requiring skills of increasing complexity for a future of great technological, social,
economic and environmental changes (DEETYA 1998; Holmes 2001; DEST 2002; Barnett 2004,
2009; Yorke 2006). Because of this uncertainty and complexity, universities have had to reconsider
their purpose, particularly in relation to producing ‘work-ready’ graduates (Barnett 2004, 2009;
Barrie 2006), and these considerations have significance in the development of curriculum and
pedagogy, particularly for new HE programmes where the uncertainty of employment is amplified
in the early years.
The work of Barnett (2004, 2009) in HE and Dall’Alba (2009a, 2009b) in professional education
highlight the importance of a curriculum framework that includes pedagogies for ‘being’ or
‘becoming’ in preparing graduates for a rapidly changing world, as knowledge (academisation) and
skills (vocationalism) are not enough. In developing students’ ‘being’, Barnett (2004, 2009) has
proposed that a set of personal dispositions common to all disciplines are needed to prepare students
for professional practice and lifelong learning in a world of uncertainty. Barnett identified being
open to learning, being able to engage, listen, and be curious, and to have perseverance as important
personal dispositions, with qualities such as empathy, integrity, self-discipline, and caring sitting
within these dispositions. The importance of these dispositions and qualities in VT has not been
reported, but it could be assumed that the qualities of caring and empathy would be important to all
caring occupations. Arguably, since these qualities can be further developed through reflection and
self-awareness (Novack et al. 1997), they should be integrated into pedagogy and curriculum for
‘being’ a veterinary technologist.
Resonant with Barnett’s (2004, 2009) philosophy on curriculum, professional competence involves
engaging the three dimensions of learning, i.e. the cognitive (acquiring knowledge and problem-
solving – ways of ‘knowing’) (Bloom & Krathwohl 1956), the affective (concerned with emotions
or ways of ‘being’) (Krathwohl, Bloom & Masia 1964) and the technical (‘ways of ‘doing’)
(Harrow 1972). The affective domain involves personal attributes or what can also be referred to as
emotional intelligence (EI) attributes. Concurring with Bloom’s taxonomy, Barnett (2000, 2004),
Dall’Alba (2009a, 2009b) and others from medical education (Novack et al. 1997; Wear &
Castellini 2000) have advocated for a more holistic approach to professional education where more
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 58
than just knowledge and skills are considered central to practice. The human nursing (Peplau 1988;
Benner 2000) and medical education literature have aptly described how practitioners learn the
science of their discipline, but ‘use themselves to practice its art’ (Novack et al. 1997, p. 502).
A range of pedagogical strategies for developing personal attributes important for professional
competence can be integrated into curricula. These include the use of trigger tapes to highlight
desirable attributes, such as empathy, and encouraging reflection on client interactions from the
clinical practicum (Novack et al. 1997). Although research undertaken in other practice-based
professions, such as the veterinary, health, and medical sciences, could provide useful models for
VT (Radford et al. 2003; Burns et al. 2006; Lloyd 2007; Turnwald, Sponenberg & Meldrum 2008),
there is a current paucity of research evidence that specifically identifies key personal attributes
important for VT graduates as members of veterinary healthcare teams. When establishing a new
paraprofession, research is required to inform the unique features of its practice and meet the
specific needs of employers and consumers. In discussing these graduate attributes and Barnett’s
assertion of the importance of ‘being’ to professional competence, it may be prudent to examine the
role of EI.
2.6.6 Emotional intelligence
There are numerous definitions of EI in the literature. For example, Law, Wong and Song (2004)
defined EI as a set of abilities used to understand, regulate, and use emotions. The concept of EI
dates back to the work of Thorndike in 1920 on social intelligence and includes Gardner’s (1993)
work on multiple intelligences (Petrides, Furnham & Frederickson 2004; Bar-On 2006; Timmins
2006; Nowack 2006). Several models of EI have been developed, with the three main
conceptualisations (Cherry et al. 2014) being (1) the Mayer & Salovey (2000) ability-based model,
(2) the Bar-On emotional-social intelligence trait approach/self-report model (1997), and (3) the
Goleman emotional competency/multi-rater assessment model (1995) (Petrides, Furnham &
Frederickson 2004; Bar-On 2006). Goleman is credited with raising the profile of the field in 1995
with a best-selling book titled, Emotional Intelligence (Goleman 1995), although Mayer and
Salovey’s 1990 work pre-dates it (Law, Wong & Song 2004; Petrides, Furnham & Frederickson
2004). These models share some concepts, such as self-awareness, self-management, social
awareness and relationship management (Nowack 2006), but important differences can be seen in
terms of what is measured and how it is measured. Hence, the concept of EI has been debated over
time, with some of the debate centred around whether it is intelligence and a set of abilities, or
preferred behaviours and a set of personality traits (Law, Wong & Song 2004).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 59
Petrides, Furnham and Frederickson (2004) argue that early EI models did not consider the
difference between ‘trait EI’ and ‘ability EI’; measuring EI through self-report measures the
construct as a personality trait, while measuring EI as maximum performance views it as a cognitive
ability. Consequently, they chose to focus their research on ‘trait EI’, which comprises ‘emotion-
related dispositions and self-perceived abilities… measured through self-report’ (Petrides, Furnham
& Frederickson, 2004, p. 575). These researchers justified this decision based on the subjective
nature of emotional experience. In using ‘trait EI’, they also avoided the conceptual deficits of other
EI models by developing a comprehensive inventory comprising 15 emotion-related items
(adaptability, assertiveness, emotion expression, emotion appraisal, emotion control, emotion
management, impulsiveness, relationships, self-esteem, self-motivation, self-awareness, stress
management, trait empathy, trait happiness, and trait optimism). These items were linked to
personality dispositions and self-perceived abilities (facets) with validity in laboratory and applied
settings (Austin 2004). Research by Wong and Law (2000) has produced promising relationships
between trait EI and job satisfaction and performance (Petrides 2001). Despite the ongoing debates
concerning the definition and validity of what current EI models measure, EI has been widely used
in the corporate world and increasingly in education (Mayer, Salovey & Caruso 2000; Timmins
2006). Based on the arguments of Petrides, Furnham and Frederickson (2004), it seems that the 15
items of ‘trait EI’ provide a suitable model for investigating stakeholder perceptions of the EI
attributes of VT graduates in Australia. A study of this type would be invaluable in informing a
curriculum for developing the affective domain of professional competence, an important aspect of
work for veterinary support personnel.
2.6.7 Emotional intelligence and the veterinary workforce
The importance of EI in the veterinary workforce is heightened by the fact that veterinary practice is
a ‘people-oriented’ or service industry (Willis et al. 2007) where highly developed interpersonal
skills are essential. Additionally, veterinary support personnel are playing a more significant role in
providing client services (Hancock & Schubert 2007). In many countries, veterinary support
personnel are involved in nurse consultations or clinics advising on animal nutrition, wellness and
behaviour and training (Jervring 1993; Hancock & Schubert 2007; Landsberg, Shaw & Donaldson
2008). It is suggested that this will continue to expand as veterinary practices increasingly take
advantage of their employees’ highly developed skills in response to changing societal needs, rising
expectations of veterinary services, and practice economics (Brown & Silverman 1999; Willis et al.
2007; National Research Council 2013).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 60
Consumers of professional services are now more highly educated, have access to the internet, and
a keen awareness of their rights as consumers (Dall’Alba 2009b; Hegarty et al. 2009). This had led
to reports of growing client dissatisfaction with professional education and the professions
(Dall’Alba 2009b; Hegarty et al. 2009). The effects of consumerism found in other professions
should therefore also be considered in justifying further research into EI and its integration into VT
pedagogy and curriculum.
In addition, the growing importance of the HAB evident in the veterinary education literature
(Brown & Silverman 1999; Shaw 2006) warrants a focus on the HAB in VT curricula so graduates
understand and acknowledge the bond in client interactions. Pedagogical strategies for developing
the EI attribute of empathy have been used extensively in the veterinary and medical undergraduate
fields (Shaw 2006; Schull et al. 2012a). Even though there is some literature emerging from the VT
field about this topic, further research needs to be conducted (Schull et al. 2012a).
2.6.8 Veterinary employers and emotional intelligence
The importance of personal attributes and qualities based around EI has been demonstrated in
several Australian and international studies published in the veterinary literature. A report on a
survey of Australian veterinarians by Heath and Mills (2000) identified personal attributes valued
by employers when hiring veterinarians. A more recent survey researching the perceptions of
Australian veterinarians and veterinary students on essential personal and interpersonal attributes
conducted by Schull et al. (2012b) yielded similar results with several EI attributes, such as
empathy and social awareness, being identified as important. From the USA, a review article on the
importance of teamwork in veterinary practice by Ruby and DeBowes (2007) also highlighted the
importance of EI when recruiting veterinary support personnel for a good cultural fit. All reports
provide sound justifications for further research in this area in order to develop pedagogical
strategies to nurture VT graduates’ professional competence and employability.
2.7 Overview of gaps in the literature
From the perspective of advancing VT, even though much can be learned from other
paraprofessions about developing curriculum and pedagogy, promoting professionalisation,
building partnerships and meeting stakeholder expectations, there has been limited research on VT
from sociological, historical, or educational perspectives. Because of the fledgling status of VT in
Australia, and in academia, there is currently a paucity of disciplinary literature to provide a
framework within which to consider curriculum and teaching approaches for this emerging
profession, nor a record of its history. This thesis endeavours to address these gaps and contribute to
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 61
the growing body of literature relating to VT in Australasia. It also aims to describe, record and
promote the VT discipline’s important role in the twenty-first century.
2.8 Autoethnography of an inaugural VT academic and researcher
‘Locating who we are in what we do’ (Starr 2010).
‘Autoethnographical snapshots’ of the researcher’s personal experiences have been included as
preambles to each chapter of this thesis to extend understanding of the broader socio-cultural
context of the VT story. These autoethnographic accounts provide insights into the researcher’s
experiences as the inaugural UQ VT lecturer and final year coordinator (2003-2012), and
interpretations of the HE and the veterinary contexts in which the researcher was immersed (Chang
2008; Wall 2008; Adams, Ellis & Holman Jones 2014; Wall 2016; Luvaas 2017). As such, the
preambles were also part of the researcher’s reflexivity as an author. Reflexivity, an act of self-
monitoring to reduce personal biases, is viewed as an essential element of generating knowledge in
qualitative research (Berger 2013).
Reflexivity is particularly important in autoethnography as an emerging, and somewhat contested
(Denshire 2014), qualitative approach to research (Chang 2008; Chang 2016; Wall 2016) that has
paved the way for what has been described as an ‘avant-garde’ or ‘non-traditional way of knowing’.
This genre of inquiry, recognised as both a ‘product and a process’, (Ellis, Adams & Bochner
2011), taps into the personal experiences of the researcher to understand a social phenomenon (Wall
2006, p. 1; Hamdan 2012; Chang 2016; Wall 2016, p.1)—relating ‘stories of/about the self, told
through the lens of culture’ (Chang 2008; Adams, Ellis & Holman Jones 2014, p. 1).
Thus, autoethnographies are usually written in the first person (Ellis & Bochner 2000), engaging the
researcher’s reflexivity and voice in order to share their unique, subjective experience to advance
research and knowledge. In this regard, autoethnographies are quite distinct from the silent
authorship of the positivist research paradigm, and align with the postmodern philosophy, which
questions the position of the detached, objective researcher in traditional scientific research (Wall
2006, 2008). In doing so, the genre opens up possibilities for different ways of knowing through
proximity rather than objectivity (Adams, Ellis & Holman Jones 2014), and through focusing on the
specifics of human lives, experiences and relationships rather than generalising about larger groups
(Adams, Ellis & Holman Jones 2014). As such, the use of autoethnography contributes to a fuller
representation of the VT story.
There are a range of forms of autoethnography positioned on a spectrum extending from the
evocative to the analytical (Chang 2008; Wall 2008; Chang 2016; Wall 2016). This thesis adopted
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 62
the analytical tradition of autoethnography, in contrast to the evocative narrative form espoused by
Ellis and Bochner (2011). The analytical form aligns with traditional research paradigms that
interpret the lived experience for the purpose of generating theory or knowledge (Ellis & Bochner
2011, p. 3). This contrasts with the evocative tradition that focuses on the ‘auto’ or self, and is
described as residing in the lived experience of the writer (Ellis & Bochner 2011, p. 8)—
transforming the reader from a detached observer to an intimately involved participant (Ellis &
Bochner 2011, p. 5).
The analytical approach was chosen for this thesis because, according to Chang (2016), it honours
the three components of autoethnography by using the researcher’s personal experiences (‘auto’) as
primary data, analysing and interpreting those personal experiences (‘ethno’), researching the
literature and writing (‘graphy’). This systematic approach to autoethnographic research, involving
data collection, organisation, analysis and interpretation counteracts some of the criticisms of the
method (Chang 2016). Hence, a ‘moderate’ analytic approach to autoethnography (Wall 2016, p. 5),
particularly influenced by Wall (2006; 2016) and Chang (2016), was adopted in this thesis. This
approach minimised the risk of appearing self-indulgent or self-centred (Wall 2016), and was more
compatible with the traditionally positivist norms of scholarly research in the discipline of
(veterinary) science (Wall 2006). However, the increasing use of qualitative research methods in the
veterinary education literature (Langebæk, Tanggaard & Berendt 2016; Dawson & Thompson 2017;
MacMartin et al. 2018), and the increasing legitimacy of autoethnography in scientific fields such as
the health professions over the past twenty years (Chang 2016, p. 2), paves the way for acceptance
of autoethnography within the veterinary discipline.
Using Chang’s (2016, p. 448) five standards for quality in autoethnography, multiple data sources
were utilised to ensure ‘authenticity and trustworthiness’. These included personal recollections,
reflections, emails, observations, personal communication, letters, reports for professional bodies,
student feedback, meeting agendas, industry feedback, conference presentations, and data from
curriculum reviews. Chang’s second standard, the ‘accountable research process’ was facilitated
through the researcher’s reflexivity, involving self-questioning to bring about self-understanding,
engaging with a ‘political consciousness, cultural awareness’, and owning her own perspective
(Patton 2015, p. 604). ‘Relational ethics’ concerning the researcher, as author, and the voluntary or
involuntary participants (Ellis, Adams & Bochner 2011; Chang 2016), who included students, was
also considered. To this end, the literature recommends pseudonyms and obtaining prior consent to
protect both researcher and other participants in autoethnography (Tolich 2010, p. 1601; Denshire
2014, pp. 841-842). However, in this case the latter was not possible; the researcher fulfilled
requirements of relational ethics by being sensitive to the feelings of others in the story (Ellis,
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 63
Adams and Bochner 2011, p. 7). Chang’s fourth standard of ‘socio-cultural analysis and
interpretation’ was followed by ‘an in-depth analysis and interpretation of the socio-cultural
meanings’ of the researcher’s experiences (Chang 2016, p. 449). Lastly, the requirements of
Chang’s (2016) fifth standard of making a ‘scholarly contribution’ were met by a story that was
‘relevant and transferable’ to the wider research community and those who would benefit from the
research (Chang 2016, p.449), such as broader cultural groups negotiating similar personal and
professional challenges. Connecting with the wider literature was also an important part of this
process (Chang 2016, p.449).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 64
3 Chapter 3
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2009, ‘Demographics and employment
destinations of a new group of veterinary technologists in Australia’, Journal of Veterinary
Medical Education, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 241-45, incorporated as Chapter 3.
An overview of this experimental chapter is provided in Figure 3-1.
Figure 3-1: Overview of Study 1exploring the demographics and employment destinations of
graduates of a new veterinary paraprofession in Australia.
3.1 My contribution to authorship
Overall, I was responsible for at least 70% of the work in authoring this paper. My contribution to
the conception and design of the paper was 75%, working jointly with Drs Schull and Coleman on
the remainder. As a lecturer and final year coordinator for the BAppSc (VT), I was responsible for
writing the ethics application for the study. In addition, I had personal knowledge of all graduate
employment destinations during the period of the study. Furthermore, I researched and collected the
graduates’ demographic data, and, as I knew all of the students, I was aware of their years of
graduation (Section 3.2.4). I conducted the statistical analyses which were descriptive in nature.
Advice was provided by Drs Coleman and Schull on presenting the results in a more concise
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 65
manner, the presentation of the data in Table 3-1 and the standard deviation calculation for student
age (Section 3.2.4).
I was responsible for drafting the whole paper with some advice from Drs Schull and Coleman in
regards to structure and my writing style. Additionally, I was responsible for the entire literature
review, the majority of the Introduction, and interpretation of the data and relating that to the
literature (90%). Drs Coleman and Schull provided critical revision of my writing, primarily in
regards to clarifying the first three paragraphs in the Introduction (Section 3.2.2) and in parts of the
Discussion (Section 3.2.5) and Conclusion (Section 3.2.6). As this was one of my first publications,
I appreciated their advice on achieving more clarity in my writing. However, I believe I can say the
majority of the ideas (95%) in developing the Discussion and Conclusion were mine. These
included comparing UQ VT with the structure and outcomes of programmes in other countries, and
elucidating local and international trends in the veterinary field that justified a VT discipline in
Australian HE. My work also included the predictions for the future of this new veterinary
paraprofession.
I confirm that all authors of this publication are eligible to be an author as defined in section 5.1 of
the UQ policy on authorship (4.20.04) (UQ 2018b) and all have agreed to the authorship order.
Importantly, all authors have also agreed to this publication being included in this thesis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 66
3.2 Demographics and employment destinations of a new group of
veterinary technologists in Australia
‘Members of an aspiring profession should be educated in an academic setting, developing the
graduate attributes of critical thinking and ‘research-mindedness’ (Cooper 2002, p. 466).
3.2.1 Preamble: Reflecting on the birth of a new frontier in academia and a
veterinary paraprofession in Australia
To provide some insights into the researcher, which may impact on the research, I was very
fortunate in having a mother who valued education for women in an era where this was not quite the
norm. Her influence, plus, being the only one of her five daughters to have the opportunity and
benefits of a university education ignited my feminist tendencies for championing a university
education for all women. It was therefore not surprising that I ended up teaching veterinary nursing,
a female dominated occupation, after practising in the then, male-dominated veterinary field, ‘on
and off’ (because of childbearing) over a twenty-year period. Over time, the responsibilities of
being a widow and single parent made teaching a more attractive occupation for me and my
daughters. Subsequently, I found myself studying a post-graduate diploma in education at UQ in
1990. This opened up a new world for me, involving pedagogy, curriculum, and educational
sociology and psychology. Although this was a direct contrast to the scientific focus of my
profession, I loved it. Ultimately, it allowed me to combine my two loves of working in veterinary
science, and actively promoting the education of women.
During the following ten years of teaching veterinary nursing in the vocational education and
training sector, plus keeping up my veterinary practice on a very part-time basis, I observed the
rapid advances in the practice of veterinary medicine and veterinary nursing. By 2002, I had
reached a ‘fork in the road’ in my career. I observed first-hand the difficulties inherent in
apprenticeship style training for veterinary nurses, reminiscent of the human nursing story, with
inconsistency in training standards, the conflicting demands of learning ‘on the job’, and the
perception of veterinary nursing as ‘women’s work’ (Sax 1978; Reid 1994). It became evident to
me, that in some areas, the work of veterinary support personnel, also termed paraprofessionals
(Frawley 2003), had evolved beyond the ‘doing’ paradigm of vocational education and training.
Learning ‘on the job’, still had its place for some, but there were limitations educationally in the
challenges it provided for the student veterinary nurse, and their supervisors in the clinical
environment. For these reasons, and knowing how transformative a university education can be
(Barnett & Coate 2005; Barnett 2007, 2009), I believed the time had come for veterinary
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 67
paraprofessionals in Australia to follow the lead of the human health professions with HE
programmes that successfully combined ‘vocational, professional and academic elements’ (Findlow
2012, p. 120).
Fortuitously, in late 2002, I was offered a position as the inaugural final year lecturer/coordinator of
the UQ bachelor’s degree in VT, the first of its kind in Australia. I was excited to be back at my
Alma Mater, the School of Veterinary Science, and had great ambitions to make a difference to the
education of veterinary support personnel, and women, in Australia. In hindsight, my unwavering
enthusiasm and aspirations for the future of the programme and its graduates were tinged with a
degree of naivety. However, as I would often recount to my students in those early years—there are
‘those who make things happen, those who watch things happen and those who say, what
happened?’ (Ash n.d.). I was determined that as a team, we could ‘make things happen’ for VT in
Australia. Along with my students, I was embarking on another transformative journey endowed by
a university education. However, despite the ultimate benefits in transitioning from an identity of a
vocational education teacher to an enculturation in academia, or attaining a bachelor’s degree in a
new paraveterinary discipline in Australia, this was not an easy path to forge for any of us.
It was not so much a culture shock for me, initially, as I was in the ‘honeymoon’ phase of my UQ
appointment. The primary expectation was that I would get the programme up and running with
least disruption to the veterinary school, which was undergoing significant challenges. In those first
few years, the school was under considerable pressure due to declining Commonwealth
Government funding, cuts in staffing and capped veterinary student numbers (J Ternouth 2014,
pers. comm.,10 January). Concomitantly, it was under pressure through its impending and
controversial relocation to UQ’s rural Gatton campus, as a result of the Australian Government’s
Dawkins reforms in 1988 (DEETYA 1998; Beddie 2014). The Gatton campus had previously been
a college of advanced education, all of which were abolished and absorbed into HE.
Consequently, we were all working in deteriorating facilities at St. Lucia, which threatened the
school’s RCVS accreditation (RCVS 2018h). This created understandable tensions around the
arrival of the first cohort of VT students. Additionally, I was very aware of the heavy workloads of
veterinary academic and clinical staff who were ‘double-teaching’ to transition in a new veterinary
science curriculum, preparing to meet the rigorous standards of the RCVS accreditation visit, and
concurrently contemplating the re-location. My approach had to be ‘softly, softly’, and be prepared
to shoulder a heavy workload. The veterinary school staff were overwhelmingly generous in the
support they provided, considering the circumstances, but they were already stretched.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 68
However, despite this, in the establishment years I was heavily immersed developing the
curriculum, personally recruiting veterinary academics and clinical staff to teach into the
programme, timetabling, developing and securing resources, developing courses ‘on the run’,
completing course profiles, teaching across most courses, coordinating all courses, developing
assessment, attending ‘open days’ on two campuses to promote the programme to the public,
helping to generate marketing materials, attending teaching and learning committee meetings,
liaising with veterinary practices for clinical placements, mentoring students who were settling into
a busy campus and veterinary school, and trying to develop important relationships within the
veterinary profession and veterinary nursing, including the professional bodies. My vocational
educational identity knew that industry and professional partnerships were critical to the success of
the programme and the employment of graduates.
Amidst the long hours and steep learning curve, I was continually inspired and energised by the UQ
veterinary academics’ commitment to teaching, learning and knowledge creation. Slowly, I was
gaining an appreciation of what it meant to be an academic. During the first year, I was more in
‘survival’ mode and protected from the expectations of a ‘publish or perish’ culture. In subsequent
years, the cultural challenges associated with transitioning what was viewed as a vocational field
into HE became more evident. The VT students were a different type of cohort to veterinary
students, VT was not a profession, and I didn’t have a doctorate. We were all caught in the
whirlpool of the transformation of HE from an elite to a mass education system (DEETYA 1998;
Trow 2007), and my work in helping to establish a new HE discipline and veterinary paraprofession
in Australia had only just begun.
Facing the realities of life in academia and developing an academic identity, I adopted a student-
centred approach modelled on veterinary academics I admired. I also drew inspiration from the
medical (Novack et al. 1997) and nursing education literature (Johns 1995), to introduce into the
VT clinical curriculum the use of reflection to learn through practice. This was before its inception
in the UQ veterinary curriculum. There was very little VT or veterinary nursing research and
publishing in scholarly journals, at that time. The visionary Barbara Cooper (2002, p. 466), a key
figure in the development of the first HE veterinary nursing degree in the UK, was an early role
model, espousing that, ‘Members of an aspiring profession should be educated in an academic
setting, developing the graduate attributes of critical thinking and “research-mindedness” ’. Like
Cooper, I also was not prepared to let go of my vocationalism completely. With experience in that
sector, we both understood the importance of practical skills and industry partnerships in promoting
graduate employment.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 69
With this in mind, I invited representatives from government and animal welfare agencies,
veterinary pharmaceutical and nutrition companies, poultry companies, veterinary practitioners, and
others, as guest speakers to help shape a curriculum and pedagogy for a new discipline and create
graduate employment opportunities. This strategy allowed me to raise students’ awareness of the
breadth of career opportunities available, and promote VT students, and the discipline, to
prospective employers. I can distinctly recall the enthusiasm of one government agent describing
the energy palpable in the room when speaking to the inaugural cohort. I was told that this was the
type of graduate they were seeking for the previously non-graduate field of stock inspection, and
ultimately, this strategy, translated into employment for VT graduates.
Like the agent, I was continually inspired by the courage of the early VT student cohorts who had
the courage to ‘…leap into the void… where there is bound to be uncertainty’ (Barnett 2007, p. 18).
For most, it was not only the newness of the discipline that presented huge uncertainties, but also
the fact that they would be the first in their family to attain a bachelor’s degree. My maternal
instincts, and personal experience of that journey, made me very protective of the students as they
negotiated previously uncharted territory at UQ, in the veterinary school, and in the veterinary field.
The small cohorts made this easier to achieve. Although my approach may not have been viewed
positively in some academic quarters, my resolve to support these students was affirmed in later
forays into the literature on the massification of universities (De La Harpe, Radloff & Wyber 2000;
James 2001; James, Bexley & Shearer 2009), and visits to similar veterinary nursing and VT degree
programmes in the UK and USA. I also believe that creating this supportive student microculture
was a contributing factor to the UQ programme’s survival in those early years. Concurrently, I was
working hard on fitting into the academic culture in teaching and research.
Hence, this first study in the thesis that characterised the demographics and employment
destinations of the trailblazing, early graduate cohorts (2003-2005), was my first attempt at
research, and a major step in my important transition to an academic identity. I knew that this was
essential not only for my job security, but also for the credibility and sustainability of VT as a
university discipline, and as a new veterinary paraprofession that would take the veterinary
profession in Australia into the twenty-first century. Working in collaboration with a young,
enthusiastic doctoral student and colleague, I was inspired to obtain reliable data on the VT
graduates. It was imperative for me to establish whether the curricular initiatives and industry
partnerships developed in those first years where translating into employment within the veterinary
and allied animal health fields. Indirectly, I was also collecting data about essential competencies
and attributes to inform a HE curriculum and support the employability of a new group of
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 70
veterinary paraprofessionals. Looking at the bigger picture, it was necessary to compare VT
employment outcomes with international trends in an age where disciplines needed to establish their
value in global markets (Barnett 2000; Barnett & Coate 2005). It was rewarding to see the success
of the VT graduates in the labour market and know they were sought after for the graduate
attributes of critical thinking, problem-solving and ‘research-mindedness’. I felt a strong sense of
personal accomplishment through the success of these resilient and courageous trailblazers. It
wasn’t an easy road to success for the majority of graduates working as technicians in veterinary
practice, where employers were steeped in a tradition of vocationalism, and without a critical mass
of graduates preceding them to illuminate their path (Ballweg & Hooker 2017). I was also treading
a similar, untrodden path in the veterinary field—developing as an academic working at the
HE/vocational education interface, a contested and confused site in Australia (Fowler 2017).
3.2.2 Introduction
The three-year BAppSc (VT) programme was first offered at UQ in 2001 (Clarke 2004). The
programme consists of two pre-clinical years taught by the School of Animal Studies on the Gatton
campus. This campus has extensive production animal and equine facilities, and is located in a
small, rural community 85 kilometres west of the main UQ campus in suburban Brisbane. The
clinically focused third year has a quota of 30 students and is taught by the School of Veterinary
Science on the Brisbane campus.
The UQ VT curriculum is broadly similar to other VT bachelor’s degree programmes, such as that
offered at Purdue University (2007a). The Australian programme has a significant focus on
production animal science in the first two years and on veterinary clinical practice in the final year.
The first year comprises foundation science courses such as chemistry, biology, animal anatomy,
and physiology. The second year introduces applied science courses (for example, genetics and
animal breeding, animal reproduction, animal nutrition), as well as biochemistry and microbiology.
An animal health technology course in the fifth semester provides an introduction to veterinary
clinical practice. The third year is intensively clinical, primarily with a small-animal focus, but also
includes equine and large-animal health and management studies (forming approximately 12% of
each student’s workload in the final year).
In the final (third) year, clinical skills are acquired through a combination of laboratory classes and
clinical placements. Laboratory classes develop skills in clinical procedures, including blood
collection, intravenous catheterisation, fluid therapy, and patient monitoring, as well as in clinical
pathology techniques, in preparation for clinical placements. These placements include clinical
rotations in the university’s Small Animal Veterinary Teaching Hospital and the Western Animal
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 71
Emergency Centre, which share facilities on the Brisbane campus. An additional four weeks of
external placements take place in a variety of settings, including veterinary practices (both
generalist and specialist), wildlife parks, hospitals, zoos, and government agencies.
It may be appropriate at this point to review the titles adopted by different countries for veterinary
support personnel, such as veterinary nurse, veterinary technician, and veterinary technologist. The
AVMA describes the veterinary technician as an integral member of the veterinary healthcare team
who works under the supervision of a licensed veterinarian and is a graduate of an AVMA-
accredited program (AVMA 2018a, 2018b). In Canada, the titles veterinary technologist and
veterinary technician are acknowledged as a similar training designation (Registered Veterinary
Technologists and Technicians of Canada 2018), with a role analogous to that of the veterinary
technician as defined by the AVMA (2018a). In Australia and the UK, veterinary nurses work
within a veterinary practice under the supervision of veterinarians (BVNA 2006) and have
nationally recognised qualifications. It would therefore seem reasonable to say that veterinary
nurses in Australia and the UK have similar roles to veterinary technicians in the USA and Canada,
albeit with different modes of education, training, and licensing or credentialing. Career
opportunities for these qualified veterinary support personnel may also include roles outside of
veterinary practice (e.g., research laboratories, wildlife parks, or pharmaceutical companies)
(BVNA 2006; AVMA 2007) For the purposes of this study, the BAppSc (VT) graduates in
Australia may be described as veterinary technologists (that is, veterinary support personnel with a
bachelor’s degree), as distinct from veterinary nurses with a vocational qualification.
In 2004, Clarke outlined the employment destinations of the inaugural UQ VT graduates. She
postulated that veterinary technologists would assume a pivotal position in large, multi-veterinarian
practices and enhance efficiency and service levels in such environments (Stott 2004). The study
outlined in this chapter addresses the first research questions posed in this thesis, regarding what
were the demographics and employment destinations of the first three UQ VT graduate cohorts
(2003-2005) for an emerging veterinary paraprofession in Australia, and how these compared with
global trends. The study aims were designed to gain a better understanding of the career paths of a
larger group of VT graduates—the first three cohorts—and to further characterise their employment
destinations within the veterinary and allied fields, both nationally and internationally.
3.2.3 Methods
All 69 graduates from the first three cohorts of the VT programme (2003–2005) were contacted by
e-mail, telephone, or personal communication and invited to participate in this study. Employment
status at February 1, 2006, approximately two months after graduation of the 2005 cohort, was
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 72
successfully determined for 66 of the 69 graduates (96%). Data on gender, basis of admission, year
of graduation, and age at graduation for all graduates were retrieved from UQ academic records. All
data were entered onto a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet and analysed using the SigmaStat System for
Windows Version 3.0. This project has adhered to the guidelines of the ethical review process of
UQ and was cleared by the School of Veterinary Science Human Ethics Committee in accordance
with Australia’s National Health and Medical Research Council Act 1992 (National Health and
Medical Research Council 2018).
3.2.4 Results
3.2.4.1 Graduate demographics
Females comprised 93% (64/69) of the graduates. The mean age (± SD) at graduation was 23±5
years, and the range was 19–43 years. The Queensland Senior High School Certificate, or its
equivalent, had been the basis of admission for 58% (40/69); however, 35% (24/69) had previous
HE experience. Of these, 11 had completed a bachelor’s degree or diploma at a university prior to
enrolment. Seven were UQ graduates with a Bachelor or Diploma of Applied Science in a different
major (e.g., wildlife, equine studies, or animal production) and four had a bachelor’s degree from
another Australian university or overseas institution in disciplines such as business, education, and
engineering. The remaining 7% (5/69) of graduates were admitted through special entry provisions
(e.g., mature age entry), which were not based on previous educational achievements.
3.2.4.2 Employment destinations
Table 3-1 provides a brief summary of employment destinations for graduates (n = 66). Excluding
those enrolled in further education, 89% (49/55) of contacted graduates were employed in
veterinary and allied animal health fields, including university teaching and technical support, at the
time of the study. One honours student was also employed full-time in a veterinary practice, and for
the purposes of this study was considered as a veterinary practice employee.
Approximately half of the graduates were employed in either general veterinary practice (35%;
23/66) or specialist or emergency veterinary practice (17%; 11/66) as veterinary support personnel.
Five graduates were employed in specialist practices, which included the Small Animal Veterinary
Teaching Hospital (UQ), a specialist ophthalmology practice, a small-animal specialist referral
practice, and an equine veterinary hospital. A total of six graduates were employed across three
emergency centres, including UQ’s Western Animal Emergency Centre. Of the 23 graduates
employed in generalist practices, 12 were located in Brisbane, seven were living in regional and
rural areas of Queensland, and four were interstate.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 73
In all, 16% of graduates (10/66) were enrolled in another undergraduate programme—Bachelor of
Veterinary Science (BVSc) (7/66), Bachelor of Medicine (1/66), Bachelor of Education (1/66), or a
research honours year (1/66).
Table 3-1: Employment of graduates at February 1, 2006.
Type of Employment Number of Graduates (%)
Veterinary practice
- General
- Specialist
23 (35)
11 (17)
Allied animal industries 5 (7)
Government agencies 5 (7)
Wildlife parks & zoos 2 (3)
Universities
- Teaching & technical support
3 (4)
Further study
- Research honours
- Undergraduate
- Post-graduate
1 (+1*) (2)
9 (14)
1 (2)
In transition 5 (7)
Non-veterinary/non-animal industry 1 (2)
TOTAL 66 (100)
*One graduate with full-time employment in a veterinary practice was concurrently enrolled in
research honours.
One (2%) graduate had completed an honours programme and enrolled as a PhD candidate in the
field of equine parasitology.
Government agencies, including the Queensland Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries
(QDPI&F) and the Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry
(DAFF), employed 8% (5/66) of graduates. Of these, three were biosecurity inspectors with
QDPI&F, one was engaged in airport quarantine surveillance (DAFF), and one was employed in a
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 74
graduate recruitment programme (DAFF). A further 5% (3/66) were working in university teaching
and support roles. One of these graduates was the Director of a Diploma in Veterinary Nursing
programme at Massey University (NZ), one was a laboratory technician (UQ), and one was
employed in a UQ animal research facility. A relatively small group (8%; 5/66) was working in
allied animal industries, including two as sales representatives for large animal nutrition companies
and one as a greyhound trainer. Three percent (2/66) were employed as education officers/animal
attendants for wildlife parks.
Eight percent (5/66) of graduates were ‘in transition’ (that is, not employed) at the time of the study.
One had just returned from Kentucky after participating in an equine educational exchange
programme. One had previously worked in a veterinary emergency centre for approximately two
years following graduation in 2003. The remaining three had graduated in 2005, only two months
prior to the study, and were actively seeking employment within the veterinary field. One graduate
(2%) was working outside of the veterinary and allied animal health fields.
3.2.5 Discussion
This study confirms that the high level of employment (87%) achieved by the first graduating
cohort of this programme (Clarke 2004) was maintained (89% employment) over the three years of
this study period, underlining the potential for VT as an emerging profession in Australia.
On analysis, a majority of the graduates (58%) had entered the programme directly from high
school, hence the relatively young mean age of 23 years. The dominance of female graduates (93%)
mirrors the gender demographic in other ‘caring’ professions in Australia, such as human nursing
(Stott 2004), veterinary nursing, and veterinary science. For example, in 2000, 97% of veterinary
nurses (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2002a) and 91.3% of registered (human) nurses (Australian
Bureau of Statistics 2002b) in Australia were female, while 65% of veterinary science graduates
were female (Heath 2004).
The gender and age demographics reported here are also consistent with international trends in
comparable fields. A 2003 survey of AVMA-accredited VT programmes reported that 93.5% of
students (3,544/3,790) enrolled were female, with an average age of 25 years (AVMA 2003). In
2004, the Veterinary Nursing Manpower Survey revealed that most veterinary nurses in the UK
were female (98.7%) and 59.4% were between the ages of 25 and 35 years (Lantra 2004). Similarly,
98.3% of UK student veterinary nurses were female and 71.9% were between the ages of 19 and 24
years (Lantra 2004)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 75
General and specialist veterinary practices (52%) represented the largest employing sector for the
graduates. The specialist referral practices included a small animal referral centre and a veterinary
ophthalmology specialist practice, both in Brisbane, and an equine veterinary hospital in rural
Queensland. The equine hospital also had an equine teaching unit for UQ veterinary science
students. Graduates employed in veterinary practice occupied a support role analogous to that of a
veterinary nurse (Australia) or a veterinary technician in the USA and Canada. If the bachelor’s
degree programme is meeting its goal of developing the attributes of problem-solving, critical
thinking, and creativity in students, an expected outcome for graduates who had commenced their
careers in nursing positions would be a rapid advancement to senior nursing positions or practice
managers. This was beyond the scope of the current study, but it would be prudent to collect this
data in future research.
Eight percent of graduates were employed in government roles, including as biosecurity inspectors
with QDPI&F in rural Queensland, working with veterinarians in animal welfare enforcement and
animal disease surveillance (Biosecurity Queensland 2007). VT graduates were popular recruits for
these positions, which previously did not have a bachelor’s degree as a prerequisite. In this way, the
VT programme appears to be creating a more skilled workforce in an area of crucial importance to
the Australian economy.
Sixteen percent of graduates (10/66) were engaged in further undergraduate studies at the time of
this analysis, with 11% (7/66) enrolled in a BVSc programme. Entry into the UQ BVSc programme
is based solely on academic merit, and it is likely that a significant subset of students undertaking
the BAppSc (VT) programme do so because they have not achieved sufficient grades at high school
for direct entry into the BVSc programme. Having completed a very clinically focused year within
the School of Veterinary Science, they would enter a veterinary science programme having
developed technical nursing skills and an awareness of the veterinarian’s role in clinical practice,
government, and industry. However, VT graduates receive no specified credit for courses already
undertaken when they enrol in the BVSc programme at UQ.
The two graduates employed as sales representatives and nutritional advisors were primarily
involved in equine and cattle nutrition. Even though only two graduates were employed in wildlife
parks or zoos, this field has potential for growth, particularly for graduates who have the BAppSc
(Wildlife major) as well. Based on AVMA data (2003), it is expected that further employment
opportunities will develop in, for example, animal welfare organisations, veterinary pharmaceutical
companies, practice management, veterinary supply companies, diagnostic laboratories, and
research laboratories.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 76
Current developments in the veterinary profession in Australia and internationally support the need
for VT graduates who have been educated to bachelor’s degree level. In the current climate of
change, in which the future success of the veterinary profession is dependent on its responsiveness
to societal needs and expectations for high standards of service (Brown & Silverman 1999; Nielsen
2003), the profession must look at the use of its support staff. The National Commission on
Veterinary Economic Issues (NCVEI) was founded in the USA in the late 1990s to support the
profession in achieving those outcomes (Rubin 2003). The NCVEI advocates enhanced utilisation
of support staff by delegating, remunerating appropriately, and promoting an environment that
retains quality staff (Rubin 2003). In Australia, where the veterinary profession is facing similar
challenges, the development and use of an empowered and skilled additional tier of veterinary
support staff, such as these veterinary technologists, would be consistent with the NCVEI’s
philosophy.
Similarly, Nielsen (2003), in examining the veterinary profession’s ability to meet society’s
changing needs, referred to the baccalaureate veterinary nursing degrees offered by veterinary
schools in the UK as a sound model for educating support personnel. In the UK, the Bachelor of
Science (Honours in Veterinary Nursing) degree was first offered in the late 1990s (College of
Animal Welfare 2018; RCVS 2018b) and by 2014 accounted for around 28% of student veterinary
nurses (Williams & Robinson 2014). A four-year Bachelor of Science programme in VT has been
in existence at Purdue University School of Veterinary Medicine since the late 1990s (Purdue
University 2007b). This educational trend would seem to justify the development of a VT
programme in Australia, and signals that the UQ programme will not remain Australia’s sole
university degree in veterinary technology.
Veterinary technologists may also have a pivotal role in rural Australian veterinary practices and
industries. A 2003 review of rural veterinary services for the Australian government highlighted the
scope for more highly skilled veterinary support personnel to help the country address a lack of
veterinary services in rural and remote regions (Frawley 2003). These personnel were seen as a
means of freeing veterinarians to undertake more specialised tasks (Frawley 2003), thus providing a
case for highly trained veterinary technology graduates to be employed by veterinarians in rural
Australia. Globalisation of the veterinary profession and society (Lantra 2004), increasing the
possibility of national and international pandemics, also impacts on the skills and attributes required
in veterinary support staff. As well as technical skills, the attributes of critical thinking, problem
solving, flexibility, and a commitment to lifelong learning are of paramount importance in being
prepared for these potential threats. The veterinary profession needs to take these attributes into
account when considering the value of VT graduates.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 77
3.2.6 Conclusion
The veterinary profession in Australia must embrace change to continue to meet society’s needs;
VT is part of that change. This study demonstrates the diversity of occupations within the veterinary
and allied animal health fields that have opened up to the graduates of this programme in its
fledgling status. Like its international counterparts, VT in Australia is a female-dominated field
with the potential to become a profession in its own right. To enhance the development of this
emerging profession, future directions from this study would include the implementation of
graduate and employer surveys to provide more precise data on education and training
requirements, and insights into the more effective utilisation of graduates within the veterinary and
allied fields. There is also a need to further investigate international educational models to enhance
and drive curriculum development in this unique Australian programme.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 78
4 Chapter 4
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT, Pitt, R & Manathunga, C 2011, ‘Enhancing
professional writing skills of veterinary technology students: linking assessment and
clinical practice in a communications course’, Assessment & Evaluation in Higher
Education, vol. 38, no. 3, pp. 273-87, incorporated as Chapter 4.
An overview of this experimental chapter is provided in Figure 4-1.
Figure 4-1: Overview of Study 2 on promoting the scholarly activities of an emerging profession
through curriculum and pedagogy.
4.1 My contribution to authorship
My contribution to the conception and design of the paper would have been around 60%. The
majority of the remainder would be apportioned to my teaching colleague, Dr Schull. I identified the
paper by Chang (2005) on which the study was based, and conceived the idea to use a variation of
this model as a pedagogical intervention to develop professional writing skills to academise the VT
curriculum and professionalise VT students. Dr Schull and I collaborated to develop the project to its
full extent, including designing and delivering the workshop modules, and designing the format for
the ‘mock conference’. The pre- and post-intervention questionnaires were developed as a
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 79
collaboration with Dr Schull performing 80% of data analysis for Table 4-1. We also shared
assessment responsibilities and reflected on those collaboratively. I provided data from a previous
written assessment item completed by the students for comparison and developed the assessment
rubric which was used in both assessment items. I was solely responsible for organising, facilitating
and assessing the students’ presentation at the mock conference (VT Symposium), and therefore the
data derived from that component of the project.
I was responsible for drafting 75% of the paper, overall. Dr Schull and Dr Pitt were responsible for
the majority of the remainder, with some input from Drs Coleman and Manathunga. The Introduction
(Section 4.2.2) was almost solely my work having conducted an extensive literature search
encompassing the massification of universities and its implications, including increasing student
diversity and the heightened need for developing writing skills in cohorts such as the VT students. I
wrote up the Methods (Section 4.2.3) and Results (Section 4.2.4) in collaboration, with Dr Schull,
with my writing contribution being around 75%. I conducted an extensive search of the literature for
the Discussion (Section 4.2.5) and wrote the majority of it with some editing provided by other
authors. The Conclusion (Section 4.2.6) was also for the most part, my work, with some input from
Dr Schull. Authors, Coleman, Pitt and Manathunga primarily provided some critical appraisal of my
writing and added to some aspects of interpretation. After Dr Schull, Dr Pitt contributed the most
through her critical revision of the paper. I confirm that all authors of this publication are eligible to
be an author as defined in section 5.1 of the UQ policy on authorship (4.20.04) (UQ 2018b) and all
have agreed to the authorship order. Importantly, all authors have also agreed to this publication
being included in this thesis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 80
4.2 Enhancing professional writing skills of veterinary technology
students: Linking assessment and clinical practice in a
communications course
Providing what the world wants is a new and dramatic reshaping of legitimate academic knowledge.
Demands for specialist knowledge and skills emerge, and universities often respond with new course
units, new areas of specialism and even new degree programmes. (Barnett & Coate 2005, p. 83)
4.2.1 Preamble: A VT educator’s autoethnographic account of ‘academisation’ of a
new higher education discipline, its students and herself
Informed by a clearer understanding of the scope of employment destinations for VT graduates
elucidated in study one, I embarked on a project of developing a curriculum and pedagogical
framework for the final year of the VT programme. Concomitantly, my increasing academic
responsibilities for components of the ‘intended’ and ‘curriculum-in-action’ for the final year of a
new HE discipline led me to strongly identify with Barnett and Coate’s (2005) call for a broader
curricular framework based on the ‘three dimensions of human being’—epistemological
(‘knowing’), praxis (‘doing’) and ontological (‘being’) (Barnett 2009, p.258)—to prepare graduates
for a ‘world of uncertainty’ (Barnett & Coate 2005). I viewed this approach as essential to meet the
vocational, professional and academic requirements of a curriculum for an emerging profession
(Findlow 2012), and to promote graduate employability at a time when HE was under pressure from
governments to upskill the nation to increase productivity and therefore economic growth
(DEETYA 1998).
Originally, I was handed a form of template for the ‘intended’ VT curriculum (Barnett & Coate
2005) developed by a range of veterinary and animal studies’ academics, headed by Professor John
Ternouth, the UQ Head of the School of Animal Studies (J Ternouth, pers. comm., 10 January
2014). My brief was of great proportions and responsibility. Primarily, I was expected to interpret
and enact the curriculum in collaboration with veterinary school academics, clinical educators and
industry partners; the curriculum’s goal was to engage final year VT students in ‘becoming’
veterinary technologists, agents for a new veterinary paraprofession in Australia. Over time, my
convictions about the value of Barnett and Coate’s framework were strengthened by curriculum
models in the medical education literature, which promoted a widening of the curriculum beyond
knowledge and skills, encompassing elements such as fostering compassion and social
responsibility (Wear and Castellini 2000). My teaching philosophy became aligned with theirs—of
educating a holistic practitioner—developing the ‘whole’ person beyond the notion of teaching
disciplinary knowledge and skills alone (Epstein and Hundert 2002, p. 226).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 81
As a relatively new academic, the ethos of these approaches to curriculum and pedagogy resonated
with my values and conception of what was required to nurture successful VT graduates in a
changing veterinary landscape and world (Barnett & Coate 2005). Hence, this first element of my
curriculum framework centred on a pedagogical intervention for academisation of the VT
curriculum through the process of academic knowledge production—the ‘knowing’ dimension of
Barnett and Coate’s framework. My approach to this study was inspired by Chang (2005) who
created a research community of undergraduate students to develop their professional writing skills
and involve them in a process of knowledge production for their field. To this end, an academic
colleague and I engaged final year VT students in researching the literature and developing their
professional writing skills for the purpose of knowledge production, building ‘real world’
knowledge relating to their clinical practice (Barnett & Coate 2005). We were aiming for a
pedagogy that was responsive to the needs of the veterinary profession, the graduates, and a
government agenda for employability (DEETYA 1998; Barnett & Coate 2005). We appreciated that
legitimate knowledge, linked to practice, was essential for veterinary technologists to be effective in
the clinical environment (Banks 2011), and to respond to their complex and varied work
environments (Barnett & Coate 2005; Fook 2004). We also made students aware of their pivotal
role in professionalising their field through generating a body of knowledge that would define it
(Greenwood 1957; Larson 1977). For myself, I came to realise that pedagogies such as this, which
linked teaching to research, were essential to establishing a previously vocational discipline in
academia (Laiho 2010; Ek et al. 2013) and were pivotal in developing my academic identity.
4.2.2 Introduction
Since the 1990’s, there has been a significant increase in HE participation in Australia driven by a
need for a skilled labour force and economic development, as well as equity considerations (James
2000, 2001, 2009). In their recent review of Australian HE, Bradley and colleagues (2008)
advocated for an even greater widening of access to HE. Internationally, similar trends have been
observed with the British HE system expanding from 15% to 45% participation in the past two
decades resulting in greater student diversity and lower entry levels (Winch & Wells 1995;
Ganobcsik-Williams 2006; Mitchell & Ganobcsik-Williams 2008). The ‘massification’ of HE has
resulted in a student population drawn from a broader range of socioeconomic and educational
backgrounds, and with differing expectations and aspirations (De La Harpe, Radloff & Wyber
2000; James 2001; Kirkpatrick & Mulligan 2002; James, Bexley & Shearer 2009; Wingate 2010).
As a consequence of this greater student diversity, increased numbers of students are requiring the
assistance of support services (Norton 2010). It has been reported that the nature of this support
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 82
extends to academic writing, where, due to changes in HE entry criteria, students are not
sufficiently prepared for this key skill (Wingate 2010). This feeds into continuing concerns about
the quality of student writing in university, a recurring issue in the teaching literature (Lea & Street
1998; Reid & Parker 2002; Hirst et al. 2004; Hunter & Docherty 2011).
Students in the BAppSc programme at the UQ reflect these changes in Australian HE with students
from diverse backgrounds, and often including lower academic entry levels. A critical point
regarding this programme is that one of its extended majors, VT, represents a new discipline in an
emerging professional field. The developing professionalisation of the VT discipline in Australia
and internationally can be compared with the story of human nursing education. The parallel
extends to their emergence as disciplines within HE and the move away from a wholly vocational
educational model. This transition brings with it the challenge to VT graduates, similar to that
experienced earlier within human nursing, of finding a professional voice in the academic literature.
According to Lea and Street (1998) language, including writing, is a medium for the creation of
knowledge in a discipline as well as for communicating it; hence the importance of writing in the
professions and, therefore, an explicit strategy to develop writing skills in the curricula of
professional programmes such as human nursing and VT.
In pioneering the VT discipline in Australia, the UQ programme is a unique and relatively new
programme that has produced around 200 graduates over eight years, with graduates prepared for
work in a range of veterinary and allied animal health settings, including veterinary nursing,
veterinary and animal science-related private enterprises, government agencies, research, and
veterinary nursing education. The programme was developed following the introduction of similar
bachelor’s degree programmes in veterinary nursing in the UK, and VT in the USA and Canada
(Clarke, Schull, & Coleman 2009). Veterinary nurses in Australia and the UK have similar roles to
veterinary technicians in the USA and Canada, albeit with different modes of education and training
and licensing or credentialing. The veterinary nursing bachelor’s degree graduate in the UK has
experienced a similar programme of study to the VT bachelor’s degree graduates of Australia and
the USA; all would share a common goal of professionalisation of the VT/veterinary nursing
discipline.
In reviewing the nursing literature, it is noteworthy that academic staff often complains about the
writing skills of their students (Diehl 2007; Luthy et al. 2009; Bickes & Schim 2010). This is not
altogether surprising given the greater diversity of students in modern universities. It has been
suggested however that, compounding this factor, is a lack of focus on developing writing skills in
nursing education (McMillan & Raines 2010). Furthermore, this deficit in undergraduate nursing
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 83
programme curricula has also been observed in graduate nursing students entering postgraduate
studies with only basic writing and research capability (Heinrich et al. 2004). In fact, Granello
(2001) concluded that assuming graduates will have the capability of scholarly writing is a failure
of current pedagogies. Based on similarities with human nursing and the current HE context, the VT
programme could learn from the nursing experience and ensure writing skills are embedded in
curricula and included on a graduate attributes list.
It is evident from the number of studies on developing writing skills, including scholarly writing, in
a variety of fields, such as education (Hirst et al. 2004; Harris 2006), science and technology
(Chang 2005), and pharmacy (Wingate 2009), that this is likely a cross-disciplinary issue. In
developing writing skills, these studies have employed a range of different approaches. Chang
(2005, p. 388) utilised a ‘directed community’ model of teaching-research integration with
undergraduate students. This involved students undertaking individual research projects which, by a
process of inheritance from year to year, were developed into material of a publishable standard.
Hence original research which extended the current literature, group work, close supervision by
teachers, and contextualisation were key features of this model. The project described in this paper
was primarily inspired by Chang’s work in that it aimed to develop a student research community to
develop work of a publishable standard. Other aspects of Chang’s model, such as the ‘inheritance’
element whereby projects are inherited from one cohort to the next, were not replicated due to time
constraints. Similarly, the model of students working individually was not adopted by the authors as
the educational benefits of working in a group were considered valuable for the professionalisation
of the VT students.
Harris (2006) alludes to a deficit in graduate writing skills which has stemmed from a failure to
develop these skills in undergraduate education. He has described a three-stage instructional model
to improve graduate students’ writing, using abstract and critique writing as an initial foundation for
scholarly writing. A pedagogy based on well-planned teaching and evaluation strategies were also
an integral part of Harris’ approach. Our study adopted aspects of Harris’ model in implementing a
well-planned modularised project commencing with an introduction to the disciplinary literature,
and guiding students through the writing process in stages, commencing with the abstract. However,
even though our study had common aims in improving scholarly or professional writing skills,
unlike Harris’ work, our study was focused on undergraduates. Additionally, our study moved
beyond the abstract stage to students writing a complete article, the case report; a genre linked to
their disciplinary literature. Thus, our students’ learning was contextualised, based on real life
experiences. According to a number of writers (De La Harpe, Radloff & Wyber 2000; Kaldor &
Rochecouste 2002; Parker cited in Reid & Parker 2002, p. 23), writing programmes which foster the
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 84
development of writing skills within a disciplinary context are more likely to succeed; hence the
adoption of contextualisation in the study described here.
This leads into another important aspect of this study in fostering the professionalisation of students
from an emerging profession. A profession can be defined as an occupational group that has
ownership of a body of specialised knowledge, significant autonomy, and accountability to the
clients it serves and society as a whole (Hilton 2004). The role of a professional is characterised by
his/her professionalism, or demonstration of a set of professional attributes or behaviours. These
attributes or behaviours include being accountable in one’s work, being capable of reflection and
self-awareness, being committed to lifelong learning, and working cooperatively (Hilton 2004, p.
70). Effectively preparing students for professional practice should therefore include the
development of these attributes, including their assessment, as an essential feature of curricula.
These points are particularly pertinent for curriculum development in emerging professions such as
VT. This paper outlines a trial of a pedagogical approach to developing VT students’
professionalisation.
In promoting the professionalisation of VT in Australia, we agree with Cooper’s (2002, p.466) view
that aspiring members of a profession should be educated in an academic setting, developing the
graduate attributes of critical thinking and ‘research-mindedness’. This is hoped to facilitate the
emergence of a veterinary nursing profession, capable of developing its own body of knowledge
based on research from within the field (Cooper 2002). Implicit in this vision is the importance of
developing the research capability and professional writing skills of VT graduates in Australia.
Chang (2005, p. 389) found that undergraduates’ research capability could be fostered by extending
student learning ‘beyond knowledge acquisition to take the form of knowledge production’. Based
on a modification of Chang’s model, the current intervention was designed to develop VT students’
professional writing skills by writing case reports to a publishable standard through an iterative
process using peer review. Peer assessment was included to develop the professional attributes of
critical thinking and commitment to lifelong learning. It achieves this through the use of reflection
and by encouraging self-assessment (Boud 1990, 1998); ensuring students develop skills in
objectively reviewing their performance and taking responsibility for their own learning. This is
more likely to succeed when self-assessment is integrated into a learning activity, rather than
conducted as a separate exercise (Boud 1990).
Given the status of VT as an emergent profession, there is a paucity of literature, in Australia and
internationally, on developing the research capabilities and writing skills of students in the VT field.
Therefore, this study makes an original contribution in that it is based in a fledgling discipline and
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 85
contributes to the small but growing body of VT literature. This second study of the thesis
specifically addresses the following question: How efficacious is a pedagogical intervention about
knowledge production—which links assessment in a professional communication course to
students’ clinical practicum—in developing VT students’ professional attributes and skills,
including a capacity for research and professional writing, and inspiring them to publish in the
scholarly literature after graduation? In doing so, it reports on a carefully implemented,
contextualised assessment activity that serves to promote the scholarly activities of an emerging
profession, and may prove transferable to other professional programmes.
The aims of this project were thus: (1) To enhance VT student research capability and professional
writing skills, by incorporating relevant and contextualised assessment in a professional
communications course; and (2) To promote the professionalisation of VT students by motivating,
inspiring, and providing them with the skills and confidence to publish in the scholarly literature.
4.2.3 Methods
4.2.3.1 Participants and group formation
All students in the third (and final) year of the BAppSc (VT) at UQ were invited to participate in
the study during a professional communications course (n=31). Subsequently, all those approached
agreed to participate in the study. The course learning objectives addressed the development of
professional communication skills, employment preparation (résumés, interview skills, and
portfolios), professional ethics, legislation and the role of professional organisations, as well as the
fundamentals of veterinary practice management. Students self-selected into dyads, with one group
of three required.
4.2.3.2 Ethical considerations
Ethical approval for the study was provided by the School of Veterinary Science Human Ethics
Review process in accordance with the National Health and Medical Research Act 1992 (National
Health and Medical Research Council 2018). Throughout the study, procedures were enacted to
maintain the anonymity and confidentiality of participants, including coding to match pre- and post-
questionnaires and maintain response anonymity. It was clearly stated and ensured that students
were not academically disadvantaged by non-participation in the study. Student consent to
participate in the project was indicated by their completion of the pre-and post-questionnaires. All
responses were analysed at group level only and did not form any part of students’ assessment or
grades.
4.2.3.3 Details of assessment task
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 86
The contextualised assessment task was weighted at 20% of the final grade for the course. Students
worked in their small groups to co-author a case report for publication, based on an actual case they
had identified during their final year clinical practicum. To enhance the breadth of student learning
and avoid duplication, a diversity of cases was selected via consultation with the course lecturers
(the first and second authors). Nominated cases included small animal medical or surgical cases and
one equine medical case. Students were required to undertake a detailed search and critical analysis
of the scientific literature, with an emphasis on the clinical condition exhibited by their case, the
veterinary technologist’s role in patient management and the application of veterinary diagnostic
technology. Additionally, a series of five, one-hour interactive modules/workshops were delivered
to students (Table 4-1). The first four workshops were designed to build students’ skills and
confidence regarding the concept of scientific literature, its role in defining a profession, and the
process of critiquing case reports using models from peer-reviewed veterinary and VT journals. A
fifth workshop on oral presentation skills was delivered by a learning advisor from UQ Student
Services (UQ 2018c). Developing confidence and competence in professional writing skills and oral
presentations were, thus, pivotal objectives of the workshops.
Table 4-1: Modules developing the professional writing process.
Module Stage Features Assessment
Module 1
(week 1)
• Pre-test questionnaire
administered (optional)
• Evaluating the case report - its
structure, value and limitations
• Review - How to write an
‘Abstract’
• Assessment task outlined and
distributed
• Assessment criteria/Graded
assessment rubric explained
• Group selection
• Cases to be identified by end of
week 1
N/A
Module 2
(Week 2)
• Completed draft abstracts
reviewed at workshop
Blind peer review of
abstracts using a
graded assessment
rubric
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 87
• Review – How to write the ‘Case
Report’ Section
Module 3
(Week 5)
• Abstracts submitted for grading
• Draft ‘Case Report’ section due
• Review – How to write the
‘Discussion’
Graded by lecturers
Blind peer review of
‘Case Report’ section
Module 4
(Week 7)
• Graded abstracts returned to students
• Draft ‘Discussion’ section due
Lecturers’ feedback
Blind peer review of
‘Discussion’ sections
using graded
assessment rubric
Module 5
(Week 9)
• Graded ‘Discussion’ sections returned
to students
• Oral presentation skills workshop to
prepare students for ‘mock
conference’
Lecturers’ feedback
Week 11 • Final case report due Lecturers use graded
assessment rubric
Week 12 • ‘Mock’ conference
• Award for ‘Best Oral Presentation’
• Post-test questionnaire (optional)
Peer & lecturer
review using same
assessment rubric
Peers voted on Award
winner
The modular framework of the semester-long project also provided several opportunities for formal
and informal feedback on the students’ work, assisting in the developmental process. As well as the
final summative evaluation by the lecturers, blinded peer review was used to provide formative
feedback to students during the first four workshops. This blind, peer assessment involved writing
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 88
dyads appraising the de-identified work of another dyad. They were guided in the process by an
outline of the essential elements of the section they were reviewing and primed by prior activities
critiquing published articles. A graded assessment rubric used for summative assessment of the task
was also provided to students to be used as part of the peer review process. This rubric comprised a
range of criteria for assessment, including accuracy and depth of content and knowledge,
communication and clarity of expression, research evidence, adherence to referencing conventions,
and creativity. Each category was graded from a seven (highest) to three (lowest or fail), in
accordance with the UQ grading scheme. A qualitative description of each category across the
grades clarified the expectations for each of these. A dyad’s overall grade for the assessment task
was an average of the grades scored across these evaluation categories. The assessment task also
required students to comply with author guidelines for The Australian Veterinary Practitioner
journal that is appropriate to their profession. Furthermore, students were required to present their
papers at a mock ‘VT Symposium’. For this event students had to comply with a professional dress
code and demonstrate competence in using audiovisual equipment. Students were also encouraged
to engage the audience (their peers) with simulations of clinical procedures, such as coupage (use of
a ‘cupped-hand’ technique to mobilise chest secretions) and the use of technical equipment relevant
to their case. To further motivate students, an award for ‘The Best Scientific Case Report’ was
presented at the annual VT graduation dinner attended by staff, members of the veterinary and VT
professions, industry representatives, and graduates’ families. In addition, all final abstracts were
published on the UQ VT website.
4.2.3.4 Evaluation of the project
Several sources were used to evaluate the impact of the assessment task. Its success was primarily
evaluated by the use of pre- and post-test questionnaires (Appendix 1 and Appendix 2) to elucidate
student perceptions. These collected demographic data on student age, gender, previous tertiary
experience and career aspirations. A series of 10 five-point Likert-scale questions (5=Strongly
Agree to 1=Strongly Disagree) were also combined with three open-ended questions to evaluate
students’ perceptions of their confidence in their written communication skills, the purpose of
scientific journals and their relevance to their careers, the peer-review process in the publication of
scientific journals, and the students’ perceived competence and confidence in their scientific writing
ability. The post-test questionnaire included additional questions relating to students’ perceptions of
the educational value of the task and the level of enjoyment they derived from it. The distribution of
pre- and post-test responses was compared at the group level. As a benchmarking exercise, the
lecturers collaboratively reflected on the standard of the case reports compared with a previous item
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 89
of written assessment completed by the cohort. The same graded assessment rubric had been used
for evaluation of both items.
Responses to each open-ended question in both questionnaires represented a single dataset. Each
data set were transcribed verbatim by the candidate and collated. As each question was focused on a
specific topic, the authors agreed that these formed the first level of coding of the datasets, and
themes such as ‘enjoyment of the project’, ‘perceptions of the learning experience’ and ‘peer
assessment’ were generated and agreed upon. Hence, the coding was data-driven (Braun & Clarke
2013). Each dataset was then carefully read by the authors individually to develop sub-themes, such
as enjoyment derived from the ‘challenges’, or the ‘interesting topic’. Any inconsistencies were
resolved by further discussion. Quotations of responses were used to provide explanatory
information, which triangulated with the data produced from the Likert-scale questions.
4.2.4 Results
4.2.4.1 Student demographics
Thirty-one final year undergraduate BAppSc (VT) students participated, of whom 29 were female
and two were male. Data was collected from 90% (28/31) of students prior to the intervention and
100% (31/31) on completion of the intervention. Results of the pre-test survey indicated that 29%
(8/28) of students had tertiary experience prior to their enrolment in the BAppSc, and the remainder
entered the programme directly from high school.
Student perceptions of their enjoyment of the project:
The majority of students (90% or 28/31) agreed or strongly agreed in the post-test survey that they
enjoyed the project as a whole. This view was also reflected qualitatively in students’ comments:
‘When I reflect, I really enjoyed this process.’
‘As we got to choose the topic, it was interesting.’
‘Thank you so much…I really enjoyed the challenge and believe I have improved my scientific
writing skills.’
The concerns raised by the two students who did not enjoy the project included tension between
partners and inequitable efforts within their group.
4.2.4.2 Student perceptions of learning
Ninety-seven percent of respondents agreed or strongly agreed that the project was a valuable
learning experience. Furthermore, 100% of students (n=31) agreed or strongly agreed that this task
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 90
helped to develop their scientific writing skills. Open-ended responses supporting these results
included:
‘I feel that I learnt a lot while completing this task and that it [scientific writing skill] is a valuable
skill to have.’
‘I found this project a wonderful learning experience! A great learning curve!’
4.2.4.3 Peer-assessment
From the pre-test survey, it appeared that students did not have experience of peer assessment prior
to this intervention. However, the majority (61%, or 17/28) agreed or strongly agreed at pre-test that
their peers could give them valuable feedback about their learning and performance on tasks, with
the remaining students expressing uncertainty (‘were unsure’). The post-test survey closely
mirrored the perceptions of students prior to the project with 61% (19/31) agreeing or strongly
agreeing that their peers did, in fact, give them valuable feedback about their work on the task. A
small number of students (6%) disagreed with this statement citing their dissatisfaction as:
‘Depends who marks it.’
‘Very inconsistent.’
4.2.4.4 Students’ confidence and perceived competence
The students’ perceptions of their confidence and competence in scientific writing appeared to have
improved following implementation of this assessment task. For example, Table 4-2 outlines that
the proportion of students agreeing or strongly agreeing that they felt confident in their writing
skills increased from 68% at pre-test to 94% at post-test.
Student responses to open-ended questions also supported these findings:
‘I feel a lot more competent in scientific writing.’
‘This task benefited me greatly in my written communication and scientific writing skills.’
‘I had never really experienced writing a journal report and this has definitely given me some
hands-on experience.’
It was also encouraging for this emerging field to see that the 32% of students who agreed/strongly
agreed that following graduation they would consider submitting material to a scientific journal for
publication, increased to 58% at post-test.
The proportion of students agreeing with the statements: ‘I feel confident in my scientific writing
skills’ and ‘I feel competent in my scientific writing skills’ also increased from pre- to post-test.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 91
This was supported by individual comments where students acknowledged an improvement in their
writing competence such as; ‘I felt this task did further my skills in scientific writing’.
Table 4-2: Pre- & post- student responses presented as percentages.
*Respondents used the following scale to indicate their degree of agreement with each item:
SA=Strongly agree; A=Agree; U=Don’t know; D=Disagree; SD=Strongly disagree
** Indicates a statistically significant change in distribution of pre- to post-test responses at p =
<0.05.
4.2.4.5 Lecturers’ reflections on assessment
A comparative evaluation of the standard of this cohort’s writing and research skills was undertaken
by the lecturers following the assessment intervention. This was achieved by comparing the quality
of the student case reports with a written research assignment they had completed in the previous
semester. The assessment items were compared using the same assessment rubric described earlier.
In the previous written assignment item, eight students achieved an overall grade of five or less,
with two of those scoring a four. Following the intervention, only three students received a grade of
five and no student scored a grade of four. Overall seven students improved their grade by at least
one level. Of these, five students improved their grade from a five to a six or seven. One student
ITEM PRE (n=28) POST (n=31)
SA*
A
U
D
SD
SA
A
U
D
SD
p-value
I have a good
understanding of what
scientific journals are
25 68 7 0 0 62 35 0 3 0 0.017**
I feel confident in my
scientific writing skills
4 64 18 14 0 16 77 3 3 0 0.029**
I feel competent in my
scientific writing skills
4 57 29 11 0 19 74 3 3 0 0.007**
Following graduation, I
would consider submitting
material to a scientific
journal for publication
7 25 57 11 0 19 39 35 6 0 0.065
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 92
improved from a four to a six and one advanced from a six to a seven. Following the intervention,
students, as a whole, therefore appeared to demonstrate an improvement in their ability to source
research, as well as to reference and synthesise information. Additionally, students had appeared to
more effectively engage with the clinical knowledge evident through an enhanced use of scientific
language and in writing fluency.
4.2.5 Discussion
This study evaluated the impact of the introduction of a professional writing assessment task on
learning outcomes relating to the research capability and scientific writing skills of a group of final
year VT students. It also aimed to promote the cohort’s professionalisation through the use of peer
assessment and motivating students to publish in their disciplinary literature after graduation.
Students reported enjoying the task and perceived it to be a valuable learning experience which
improved their perceived competence and confidence in professional writing. These perceptions
were supported by the lecturers’ observations and discussions with students during the project. It
would appear that the students’ enjoyment and enhanced learning outcomes were driven by the
contextualised nature of the assessment, which included writing up real cases from their clinical
practicum, and practising the professional skills of reflection and self-assessment through peer-
review. Additionally, following the intervention, the number of students who reported that they
would consider submitting material to a journal for publication had almost doubled.
The format of this study, which linked theory to the students’ clinical practice, is thought to have
increased the students’ interest and their overall satisfaction with the task (Reeve 1989). This was
reflected in students’ feedback and it was also likely that the challenges created by this task, in
extending students’ writing and research skills to produce a report of publishable standard, provided
further motivation (Reeve 1989), thus adding to student enjoyment. The lecturers adopted a student-
centred approach, in allowing students to select their own clinical case and their writing dyad, in
expectation that this would also make the task more enjoyable. According to Ryan and Lynch
(2003), this strategy in meeting students’ psychological needs for autonomy enhances student
motivation and achievement. Another factor contributing to students’ enjoyment is thought to have
been the regular opportunities for both academic and social interactions facilitated by the group
work and the modular design of this project (Ciani et al. 2008). The socialisation skills fostered by
this group work are also reported to be valuable in preparing students to negotiate the ‘real world’
(Gatfield cited in Mills 2003, p. 527). However, not all students enjoy group work, as indicated by
two students in our study, who perceived that they had to carry the load of their dyad peer.
Nevertheless, teamwork is an essential professional skill that needs to be fostered, with employers
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 93
valuing this skill highly (De La Harpe, Radloff, & Wyber 2000; McNally cited in Mills 2003, p.
527). Because of the importance of team skills as an element of professionalism (Hilton 2004) and
employability this aspect of the study may benefit from an increased emphasis in future work.
In implementing the project, the lecturers attempted to engage student interest by generating
enthusiasm centred on their developing professionalisation and by using an authentic context, the
students’ clinical practice, for learning (Bain 2004). Overwhelmingly, students’ comments
suggested that the assessment task was a valuable learning experience and all agreed that it
advanced their professional writing skills. This result concurs with Boud (1990) who reported that
assessment practices that relate to the way in which knowledge is used within a profession promote
better learning outcomes. Additionally, the interest and enjoyment generated by this project would
have directly contributed to the students’ intrinsic motivation (Reeve 1989), a factor positively
linked to high-quality learning (Ryan & Deci 2000; Schmidt & Moust 2000).
Recent research into the quality of learning derived from writing at university has highlighted the
importance of students’ perceptions of the writing task. It has been established that there are close
links between students’ positive perceptions of a writing task, including a clear understanding of its
purpose, and higher standards of writing being attained (Trigwell & Prosser 1991; Ellis 2004; Ellis,
Taylor & Drury 2007). In this study, the students’ positive perceptions about their confidence and
competence in professional writing following the intervention were congruent with those findings.
The aims of the assessment task and the standards expected were made explicit by the lecturers and
reinforced by the modular design of the project where students regularly engaged with the
assessment criteria and the clinical context of their work. The task’s purpose and relevance would
also have been highlighted by the emphasis on the students’ developing professionalism; supporting
them in developing the skills and confidence necessary to contribute to the professional knowledge
of the VT discipline after graduation. This and the authentic nature of the task, using real clinical
cases, appear to have motivated students to improve on their previous performance and aspire to
produce papers of publishable quality. That said, informal discussion with students revealed that
increasing the duration of the project would have allowed more time to develop these skills, thus
adding to the quality and enjoyment of the learning experience.
Evaluation of the impact of an assessment item using students’ questionnaires and teacher
reflections, as conducted in this study, is a well-accepted technique reported in the HE literature
(Cannon & Newble 2000). The lecturers’ reflections on the quality of the final case reports
supported the value of the learning elicited from the assessment task. There were observable
changes noted in the students’ approaches to scientific writing and an improvement in their writing
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 94
and research skills. These evaluations were based on a comparison of the cohort’s skills in work
from the previous semester and also with that of prior cohorts, utilising the same graded assessment
rubric for evaluation. Previously, there had been a consistent pattern across cohorts of a limited use
of proof-reading, coupled with limitations in research capability, referencing skills and written
expression. The lecturers concluded there was improvement in all of these areas following the
intervention.
Peer assessment was integrated into this task as a pedagogical strategy to model the peer review
process utilised in professional writing and to promote the principles of lifelong learning for a
professional career. To build confidence, it was therefore used primarily as a method of providing
formative feedback to assist students in making self-assessments after comparing their work with
that of others (Boud, Cohen & Sampson 2001): an important skill for lifelong learners (Boud,
Cohen & Sampson 2001; Race 2001). The activity of students judging their own work and that of
their peers was also intended to foster their critical thinking skills through the need to justify their
decisions and to be open to feedback from others (Boud, Cohen & Sampson 2001). In combination,
the strategies of self-assessment plus encouraging students to reflect on the importance of applying
assessment criteria, as undertaken in this task, contributed to a deep rather than a surface approach
to learning. Overall, students’ perceptions regarding the value of peer assessment did not change
markedly after the completion of the task, with more than half the class agreeing that it provided
valuable feedback in both pre- and post-test surveys. However, it would appear that more time spent
on preparing students for the peer assessment process and in performing the guided peer reviews
would be advantageous in future projects.
The collaborative nature of the oral presentation task provided students with further opportunities to
actively engage in teamwork and develop their oral communication skills, both of which are very
important professional skills. The mock conference added further contextualisation and encouraged
students’ creativity by its authentic character and the scope for the use of visual media. Student
creativity was evidenced in various strategies utilised to engage the conference audience, including
the use of PowerPoint technology, oratory skills, and innovative ‘props’.
On reflection, the lecturers agreed that this project would be enhanced by delivery over two
semesters, rather than one. This strategy would provide more time for students to select cases and to
further develop their research and writing skills via an iterative process. In addition, an area of the
project which may need addressing was students’ perceptions of the value of peer feedback, where
no change was noted. As previously stated, it would appear that more time spent in preparing
students for the peer review process would be valuable. Again, this could be addressed in future
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 95
studies. Additionally, the lecturers’ reflections could be viewed as a limitation, because the previous
assessment item used for comparison was not part of the intervention. This would impact on the
validity of this step in making decisions about improvements in students’ research and writing
abilities (Norman & Eva 2014). On the other hand, the authors were experienced in the use of
rubrics as grading tools to improve the reliability and validity of assessments (Chowdbury 2009).
As both authors delivered the majority of teaching and assessment for the small cohort studied, they
were also familiar with grading the students’ work.
4.2.6 Conclusion
Contextualisation, achieved by linking a professional communications assignment to the students’
clinical practice and to their future professionalisation, appeared to be a key element in the success
of this assessment task. Students reported that they enjoyed the learning experience and perceived
that their confidence and competence in scientific writing had improved. This was also translated
into an actual improvement in grades for several of the cohort. Developing professional writing
skills and an ethos of professionalism, based on the skills of reflection and self-assessment, are
critical factors in building a profession. Thus, it is hoped that this assessment task will motivate
these and future VT students to publish in their field as graduates. Such activity will continue to
expand and characterise their important niche in the veterinary and allied animal health fields in
Australia and internationally. The ultimate success of this aspect of the project will require
monitoring of graduates over time. Hence, a longitudinal study examining these issues is an
important direction for future research. The results of this study were encouraging and suggest
further research would be worthwhile.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 96
5 Chapter 5
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, RE, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives on
desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31.
An overview of this experimental chapter is provided in Figure 5-1.
Figure 5-1: Overview of Study 3 on gathering client perspectives to inform a VT curriculum for
desirable ways of ‘knowing’, ‘doing’ and ‘being’ in clinical practice.
5.1 My contribution to authorship
I was responsible for 65% of the conception and design of this project, with Dr Al-Alawneh the
next largest contributor through his input into the data analysis and interpretation, which enhanced
the overall depth of the quantitative results presented in the paper. I conceptualised the idea of
researching stakeholders’ views on EI attributes desirable for VT graduates working in clinical
practice, and researched the most appropriate EI model (Section 5.2.2.2 and Table 5-1) and
technical skills for the study (Table 5-2). I was responsible for 75% of the work involved in
developing the questionnaire (Section 5.2.3.2), with some input from Drs Coleman, Manathunga
and Pitt. I also researched and identified the random probability sampling method for client
selection and implemented it. In addition, I personally liaised with the four veterinary practices to
ensure correct client sampling, and developed the letters (for the practice and regarding my
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 97
research) accompanying the questionnaires, while ensuring client confidentiality (Section 5.2.4). I
also wrote the ethics application, participant information forms and accompanying letters.
Dr Al-Alawneh conducted the hierarchical cluster analysis and the proportional-odds regression
analysis and contributed to interpretation of the results. I did understand the rationale for using these
methods of analysis and had input into the decisions to use them and their interpretation. I
calculated the majority of the summary statistics involving mean, median, range, standard deviation
and quartiles (Tables 5-4, 5-5 and 5-6) and wrote up the questionnaire data analysis (Section
5.2.5.1) under Dr Al-Alawneh’s guidance. The flow diagram (Figure 5-2) for the client selection
process was my work with some refinements suggested by Dr Al-Alawneh. I also wrote up Section
5.2.5.2, designed the client interview guide based on questionnaire results, recruited the clients,
conducted the interviews and arranged the electronic transcription of interviews. In addition, I
thematically analysed and interpreted the interview data (Table 5-3, Table 5-10). The Introduction
(Section 5.2.2), Discussion (Section 5.2.5) and Conclusion (Section 5.2.6), including researching
the literature, interpreting results and writing up were 80% my work with some editorial assistance
and minor input by Drs Schull, Coleman, Pitt and Al-Alawneh. I linked the data to the VT
graduate’s role in clinical practice and elucidated its implications for VT curriculum and pedagogy.
I confirm that all authors of this publication are eligible to be an author as defined in section 5.1 of
the UQ policy on authorship (4.20.04) (UQ 2018b) and all have agreed to the authorship order.
Importantly, all authors have also agreed to this publication being included in this thesis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 98
5.2 Client Perspectives on Desirable Attributes and Skills of Veterinary
Technologists in Australia: Considerations for Curriculum Design
‘One cannot acquire the cultural competence of being a chemist or philosopher unless one is
brought to a particular form of ‘being’ as such’ (Barnett & Coate 2005, p. 118).
5.2.1 Preamble: A VT educator’s autoethnographic account of recruiting the
client’s voice to inform a responsive curriculum
During the early years of VT curriculum development, I found the veterinary school very
supportive to the extent that it could be, amidst a previously described period of great volatility in
its history. However, at this point, I was very much still leading the ‘curriculum in action’ and the
enacting of pedagogy for the VT final year. I was very cognisant that, unlike veterinary science, at
that time there was no ‘captive audience’ of employers for this new veterinary paraprofession.
Consequently, there was a heightened imperative for consulting with, and marketing the discipline
to key stakeholders to ensure graduates could fulfil a purposeful role in the veterinary and allied
animal health fields. With this in mind, my goal was to keep Barnett’s (2000, 2004) three
dimensions of ‘knowing’, ’being’ and ‘doing’ at the core of a framework for VT curriculum and
pedagogy. My teaching continued to aim to prepare professionally competent graduates who would
flourish in a world of uncertainty, while at the same time harmonising the curriculum with
government agendas for market-oriented curricula in HE (Barnett & Coate 2005; Peach 2010).
Consequently, for study 3, I gathered client perspectives on the veterinary technologist’s ways of
‘being’ (EI attributes), that they valued when interacting with these paraprofessionals in the clinical
environment, to inform VT curriculum and pedagogy. At the same time, I was expanding my
research capability by utilising a mixed methods research design. I felt the positivist paradigm of
scientific research favoured in the veterinary school was restrictive in this service-oriented
professional context, so ventured into the realm of semi-structured interviews.
I had read of educational trends in medicine and the health professions, where patients’ (service-
users) input into curriculum design and pedagogy (Morgan & Jones 2009; Fallon et al. 2012) led to
improved patient outcomes and satisfaction with the health care provider (Walkington 2002; James,
Page & Sprague 2016). It appeared to me that in an era of the emerging importance of client-centred
veterinary care, veterinary clients had an equal role to play. Likewise, I extrapolated from medical
education that veterinary clients, who valued their pets as members of the family (Fogle 1999;
Barker & Wolen 2008), would now be among the more highly-educated consumers of professional
services, with access to the internet, and a keen awareness of their rights as consumers (Dall’Alba
2009b; Hegarty et al. 2009) to have a say in their pet’s health care.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 99
In addition, I knew from my experience as a veterinary practitioner and an educator, that VT
graduates working as technicians in clinical practice frequently engaged with clients across a range
of veterinary services from providing health care advice to grief counselling. Thus, I viewed it as
vital that graduates had the personal qualities or EI attributes to effectively engage with clients in
what could be very stressful and emotive situations. Similarly, graduate roles in government
agencies, veterinary nutritional and pharmaceutical companies, and other allied fields all required a
holistic VT practitioner, who demonstrated EI when engaging with clients. Supported by the
literature, I believed this would lead to higher quality veterinary services, enhanced client
satisfaction, and ultimately enhanced job satisfaction and employability for VT graduates (Yorke &
Knight 2004; Nelis et al. 2011) equipped to flourish in a world of uncertainty (Barnett & Coate
2005).
5.2.2 Introduction
VT is an emerging profession in the veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australasia. Its
story as an emerging profession, or semi-profession, is comparable to the human health professions,
evolving as a relatively new discipline in HE with an applied or clinical science framework (Hunt et
al. 1998), and not yet having met all the criteria of a profession (Etzioni 1969). VT programmes in
Australasia currently include a three-year BAppSc (VT) offered by UQ, Australia, and a similar
Bachelor of VT degree offered by NZ’s Massey University. Japan’s NVLU delivers a four-year
Bachelor of Veterinary Nursing and Technology, while Kasetsart University, Bangkok, Thailand,
delivers a four-year Bachelor of Science (VT).
In Australia and NZ, VT has been described as a mid-tier qualification filling a niche between
veterinary science and the vocationally based veterinary nursing (Moodie et al. 2013). It provides a
HE pathway into a veterinary nursing career, with veterinary nursing in general and specialist
veterinary practices being the largest employment sector for UQ VT graduates. However, the
graduate employment destinations are broader than veterinary nursing and include veterinary
practice management, wildlife hospitals and zoos, animal behaviour management, animal welfare
agencies, veterinary diagnostic laboratories, biosecurity inspection in government agencies, large
animal health, animal health technology (research), veterinary pharmaceutical and nutrition
companies, and veterinary nurse education (vocational and HE sectors) (Clarke, Schull & Coleman
2009). Graduates from Massey University (Massey University 2018), Kasetsart University (W
Rerkamnuaychoke 2014, pers. comm., 17 March), and NVLU (K Ishioka 2014, pers. comm., 29
December) experience similar career opportunities. It should be noted that the titles adopted for
veterinary support personnel differ among countries, for example, ‘veterinary nurse’, ‘veterinary
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 100
technician’, and ‘veterinary technologist’. The AVMA (2018a) describes the ‘veterinary technician’
as ‘a graduate of a two- or three-year AVMA accredited programme in veterinary technology’ and a
veterinary technologist as ‘a graduate of a four-year AVMA accredited programme in VT’. In
Australia and the UK, ‘veterinary nurse’ is the title used for veterinary support personnel with a
nationally recognised vocational qualification in veterinary nursing (VNCA 2018b). It would
therefore seem reasonable to say that veterinary nursing in Australia and the UK is equivalent to VT
in the USA, albeit with some differences in educational and licensing requirements. The same could
be said for the HE programmes in veterinary nursing in the UK and VT in the USA and Australasia.
UQ, Massey University (NZ), and NVLU (Japan) chose to use VT for their HE programmes to
reflect the more diverse curriculum and graduate employment outcomes (K Ishioka 2014, pers.
comm., 29 December). As described by the RCVS in the UK, the HE programmes are longer in
duration, have an academic focus, and provide additional career opportunities in research and the
veterinary industries as well as clinical practice (RCVS 2018c).
5.2.2.1 User involvement in curriculum development and delivery
In training professional graduates for the twenty-first century, curriculum designers could consider
socio-politically driven, international trends in the more recently professionalised health professions
where users have been involved in curriculum planning, teaching, and evaluation of professional
programmes (Hurley 2008; Morgan & Jones 2009; Happell 2010; Fallon et al. 2012; Rhodes 2012).
These developments are also reflected in the delivery of more patient-centred medical services
where democratic professionalism, or giving a voice to consumers and service users, has been
advocated (Duyvendak, Knijn & Kremer 2006). Thus, to meet current challenges of changing
societal needs and economic sustainability (Brown & Silverman 1999; Nielsen 2003; Rubin 2003;
National Research Council 2011), VT curriculum designers could similarly consider the needs of
veterinary clients or service users (Bland et al. 2000; Walkington 2002; Gamble, Patrick & Peach
2010), as key stakeholders in VT education and practice. VT practice involves servicing clients
through the provision of high-level technical support in areas such as surgical nursing, imaging, and
clinical pathology, as well as delivering nurse consultations (Bindloss 1996; Jevring 1998; Hancock
& Schubert 2007; Landsberg, Shaw & Donaldson 2008). Research into the veterinary consultation
process shows that communication and relational skills are vital for graduates (Shaw 2006; Mossop
& Gray 2008). Hence, similar to other professional programmes, VT curricula require a holistic
approach to professional competence focusing not only on discipline-specific knowledge, problem
solving, and technical skills, but also on engaging the affective domain relating to attitudes, values,
and emotion (Krathwohl, Bloom, & Masia 1964). In this regard, VT curriculum designers can learn
from human nursing, where emotional intelligence (EI) training is advocated to develop emotional
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 101
competence (Freshwater & Stickley 2004; Hurley 2008); an imperative for producing graduates
who can relate to and communicate with clients.
5.2.2.2 Emotional intelligence
The construct of EI has generated much debate in the literature, with its use reported in educational,
organisational, and clinical settings (Petrides, Pita & Kokkinaki 2007). Several prominent models
have evolved and include (Cherry, Fletcher & O’Sullivan 2014) (1) the Mayer & Salovey ability-
based model, which views EI as a form of intelligence or cognitive ability (Mayer, Salovey &
Caruso 2000); (2) the Bar-On emotional-social intelligence model based on noncognitive,
emotional, and social competencies (Bar-On 1997); and (3) the Goleman mixed model based on a
set of emotional competencies and personality traits (Goleman 1995). A fourth, more recent model,
the Trait EI model, views EI as a personality trait rather than a cognitive ability, basing this on the
subjective nature of emotional experience (Petrides, Furnham & Frederickson 2004; Petrides, Pita
& Kokkinaki 2007). This subjectivity has been cited as a reason for questioning the use of Ability
EI models compared to Trait EI, which ‘can provide a scientifically viable context for the ever-
growing number of ... intelligences (interpersonal, intrapersonal, emotional, social, etc)’ (Petrides,
Pita & Kokkinaki 2007, p. 28). The Trait EI framework includes four broad overarching EI factors
(well-being, self-control, emotionality, and sociability) and 15 core emotion-related items or facets
linked to personality dispositions and self-perceptions of emotional abilities (Petrides, Furnham &
Frederickson 2004; Petrides, Pita & Kokkinaki 2007). Two of the 15 items, adaptability and self-
motivation, are not associated with any of the four factors (Petrides, Furnham & Frederickson 2004;
Petrides, Pita & Kokkinaki 2007). The breadth of the factors and core EI items in the Trait EI model
and their construct validity make them suitable for use in a study of veterinary client perceptions of
EI attributes in VT graduates.
Currently, there is a paucity of research into veterinary client perspectives on the desirable skills
and attributes of veterinary support personnel. Hence, this study addresses the third research
question posed in this thesis on building a framework and pedagogy for VT: What messages for HE
curriculum and pedagogy can be garnered from key stakeholders with respect to desirable personal
attributes and technical skills for VT graduates? The aims of this study were to elucidate veterinary
clients’ (service users’) views on the importance of a range of technical skills, EI, and professional
attributes of Australian VT graduates working in a clinical environment. The association between
these views and client demographics was also explored, with considerations of how to shape a
market-driven curriculum for an emerging profession.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 102
5.2.3 Methods
5.2.3.1 Study design and sample size
This study was one of a series of five studies involving key stakeholder groups of the UQ BAppSc
(VT). The study was conducted between October 2008 and February 2009, with participating
clients sourced from four urban veterinary practices in southeast Queensland. The veterinary
practices were a convenience sample of those who were accessible, willing to participate, and had
employed a minimum of two VT graduates (at least one employed for a minimum of two years) and
provided clinical placements for a minimum of two final-year VT students during the period 2003–
2007. The practices were one small animal general practice, one mixed small animal and equine
general practice, one small animal veterinary teaching and referral hospital, and one small-animal
specialist referral hospital.
The study used an explanatory, sequential mixed methods research design involving two phases
(Creswell 2014). Phase one involved collecting and analysing quantitative data (a questionnaire),
then building on these results with qualitative data (interviews) to increase the validity of findings
and provide a more comprehensive picture of client perspectives (Creswell 2014). In a second
phase, quantitative data were analysed using agglomerative hierarchical cluster analysis and
multivariable proportional-odds regression models to further examine client perceptions in light of
socio-demographic factors. A systematic random sampling method was used to select participants.
Figure 5-2 describes the process of client selection, exclusion, and responses. The client number
from each practice was proportional to the size of its client base during the study period. Sample
size calculations were conducted to estimate the number of clients to be surveyed. Considering a
total population of 13,830 clients across the 4 veterinary clinics, a 95% confidence interval and a
margin of error of 10% and an unknown proportion of clients with the factor of interest (i.e.
maximum proportion is 0.5), a total of 96 clients needed to be sampled. Assuming a response rate of
20%, the number of clients to be sampled was estimated to be at least 400. Of the 435 eligible
questionnaires submitted, 98 responses were received, resulting in a response rate of approximately
23%. Thus, our sample size of 98 was adequate for the 96 clients needed for the statistical analysis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 103
Figure 5-2: Flow diagram for client selection, exclusion, and response numbers.
All data collection for this study was approved through the ethical review process for human ethics
at the UQ, Australia. The approval process complied with guidelines made in accordance with the
National Health and Medical Research Council Act 1992 (National Health and Medical Research
Council 2015).
5.2.3.2 Questionnaire
Data collection primarily involved a purpose-designed questionnaire, the Veterinary Technologist
Questionnaire—The Clients’ Perspective (Appendix 3), comprising 60 questions to draw out the
background of clients and their expectations regarding the technical skills, EI, and professional
attributes of veterinary technologists working in a veterinary practice. Part One of the questionnaire
sought background information on the clients, including six socio-demographic items (age, gender,
number of years as a client at a primary care veterinary practice, number of visits annually, the
species of animals taken to the veterinary practice, and location of the primary care veterinary
practice [rural, urban, or regional]). In Part Two, clients responded to 42 five-point Likert-type
questions (1 = very unimportant to 5 = very important) (Table 5-1). Six questions were negatively
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 104
worded to reduce acquiescent response bias (Lodico, Spaulding & Voegtle 2010). Thirty-two
questions involved EI attributes based on 14 of the 15 EI items described in the Trait EI model
(Petrides & Furnham 2001). One of the EI items based on personal relationships was excluded as it
was not relevant to the client context. The remaining 10 questions were about professional attributes
associated with two professional factors, teamwork and reflection. Part Three comprised 10 five-
point Likert-type questions (using the same rating scale) based on technical (veterinary nursing)
skills of the veterinary technologist (Table 5-2). These technical skills were based on a review of
advanced training for veterinary technicians in the USA (de Laforcade et al. 2005). Part Four
investigated client perceptions of the importance of teamwork for veterinary technologists via a
single five-point Likert-type question and one open-ended question seeking further comments about
personal attributes and teamwork. Pilot testing of the questionnaire was conducted with veterinary
clients (n = 2), veterinarians (n = 2), a veterinary nurse (n = 1), and veterinary academics (n = 2).
Revisions were made based on feedback from this group.
5.2.3.3 Interviews
The interviews involved a convenience sample of three clients from two of the four participating
veterinary practices. The interviewees (1) were identified as key informants by the practices (based
on frequency of visits and the level of bonding with their animals), (2) provided maximum variation
in client characteristics (one client was a dog breeder, another kept dogs for recreational purposes,
and the third had a dog exclusively for companionship; all had multiple pets), and (3) represented
both genders. One week before the interviews, clients received a copy of the interview guide
(Appendix 4), comprising seven questions exploring client characteristics, the level of client
interaction with the veterinary practice and a veterinary technologist, and client views on EI
attributes based on questionnaire data. Clients chose to be interviewed either at their home or
workplace. Each interview was conducted in an informal manner over approximately 20 minutes,
audio-recorded, and electronically transcribed verbatim.
5.2.4 Data collection and analysis
5.2.4.1 Questionnaire
To maintain client confidentiality, the questionnaires were mailed directly to the clients from their
veterinary practices along with a letter outlining the objectives of the study, a reply-paid envelope to
return the questionnaire, and a letter from the practice endorsing the research study. The
questionnaires were mailed twice, approximately three weeks apart, in an attempt to capture non-
respondents from the initial mailing.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 105
Table 5-1: EI and professional attributes from Part Two of the client questionnaire.
EI Factors EI Items EI Attributes
Emotionality
Empathy
1. Understands others’ needs
2. Can put themselves in someone else's shoes
3. Fluent in communicating emotions
Emotion
expression 4. Able to express their feelings accurately to others
Emotion
perception
5. Able to interpret emotional signals from others
6. Clear about what they feel
Sociability
Social awareness 7. Socially sensitive and perceptive
8. Excellent social skills
Emotion
management
9. Able to make others feel better
10. Can positively influence others' feelings e.g.
motivate them Assertiveness
11. Able to confront others when necessary
12. Able to ask for what they want
13. Always defers to the veterinarian (negative
attribute)
14. Non-assertive (negative attribute)
Wellbeing
Happiness 15. Cheerful
Optimism 16. Optimistic
17. Expect positive things to happen in life
Self-esteem 18. Self-confident
19. Has difficulty accepting compliments (negative
attribute)
Self-control Stress
management
20. Can handle pressure calmly and effectively
21. Well-developed coping mechanisms
Emotion
regulation
22. Able to control emotions
23. Able to alter their mood through personal insight &
effort
Impulsivity (low) 24. Think before they act
25. Reflects carefully before making decisions
26. Impulsive (negative attribute)
Adaptability* 27. Flexible in approach to work
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 106
28. Adapts well to change
Self-Motivation* 29. Self-motivated
30. Determined and persevering
31. Lacks drive and persistence (negative attribute)
32. Motivated mainly by rewards (negative attribute)
Professional Factors Professional Attributes
Team work 1. Cooperative
2. Conscientious
3. Accepting of others
4. Shares professional values with colleagues
5. Agreeable
Reflection 6 Receptive to guidance
7. Learns from mistakes
8. Knows own limitations
9. Open-minded
10. Able to critically analyse situations and
experiences
* EI items not categorised under four EI factors
Table 5-2: Technical skills assessed in Part Three of the client questionnaire.
Technical Skills Items
Clinical skills
1. Prioritise patients according to illness or injury
2. Take blood samples
3. Perform preliminary examination of animal on admission
4. Assist with physical therapy techniques for the veterinary patient
5. Take x-rays
Client education
6. Provide advice on animal care e.g. worming, vaccination, desexing
7. Provide advice on dental health and hygiene for animals
8. Provide appropriate nutritional advice for animals
9. Conduct puppy pre-school classes
10. Conduct obesity clinics for cats and dogs
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 107
Questionnaire data were analysed using descriptive statistics to determine the percentage of clients
who rated an item from 1 (very unimportant) to 5 (very important) on the five-point Likert scale.
Descriptive data were then used to identify the five EI attributes considered most important by the
highest percentage of clients. These attributes formed the basis of the questions for the semi-
structured interviews conducted by the first author in January to February 2009 to validate and
expand on the questionnaire data analysis. Continuous questionnaire items such as age and number
of visits were described using mean, median, minimum and maximum values, and first and third
quartiles, while categorical variables, such as gender, were presented as percentages. Distributions
of responses by clients on the Likert scales were initially assessed using frequency plots.
Associations between responses on Likert scales and client demographics were assessed using a
univariable proportional-odds regression model. Predictor variables such as age and gender
(predicted to affect the response of dependent variables) were selected from the univariable analysis
(based on a likelihood-ratio test at p≤0.20) and then assessed using a backward stepwise model-
building procedure and a multivariable proportional-odds regression model until all remaining
predictor variables in the model were significantly associated with the attitude (p < 0.05). The odds
ratio (OR), a measure of association used in logistic regression, was calculated by exponentiating
the coefficients from the regression models. ORs increase the power to find differences in data by
comparing the relative odds of the occurrence of the outcome of interest (Grimes & Schulz 2008).
Thus, ORs were used to estimate the odds of a particular Likert-type rating or higher occurring in
one group of a predictor variable relative to a reference group. An OR value of >1 indicates the
outcome of interest is more likely to occur in the at-risk group compared to the reference group
(Enticott, Kandane-Rathnayake & Phillips 2012). The 95 percent confidence interval (CI) was used
to estimate the precision of the OR. Proportional-odds (ordinal) regression models assume that the
ORs are the same throughout the Likert-type scales categories (the proportional-odds assumption).
To test this assumption, the ordinal likelihood-ratios were compared with those from multinomial
logistic models with the same set of predictor variables. Where a significant difference was
identified between these models using likelihood-ratio tests, a comparison recommended by
Faraway (2006), the proportional-odds assumption was assumed to be violated, and the
proportional-odds model was rejected.
Results from the multinomial models are not presented here. Data manipulation and analysis were
conducted using Microsoft6 Excel 2007 and R 3.0,a,b. respectively. To capture differences and
similarities in client responses in rating the skills and attributes of the veterinary technologist, an
agglomerative hierarchical cluster analysis was performed. Cluster analysis is a data reduction tool
used to organise large quantities of data into meaningful or similar groups, and it reveals
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 108
associations not previously evident in data (Aldenderfer & Blashfield 1984). Hierarchical
agglomerative cluster analysis is a statistical method for finding relatively homogeneous clusters
and has been used by business organisations to develop a typology of clients (Aldenderfer &
Blashfield 1984) and in health professions to shape interventions to suit the profiles of the targeted
group (Doron, Trouillet & Maneveau 2015). In conducting this analysis, the survey item was
initially assigned to its own cluster (one item = one cluster). Using an iterative procedure, the
agglomerative hierarchical clustering algorithm joined at each stage the two most similar clusters
until there was a single cluster. At each stage, squared distances between clusters were recomputed
by the Lance–Williams dissimilarity update formula according to the Ward’s minimum variance
method. Ward’s method was selected because clusters were merged based on minimum increase in
total within-cluster variance after merging, resulting in compact and spherical clusters (Ward 1963;
Everitt, Landau & Leese 2001).
5.2.4.2 Interviews
Prior to transcript analysis, hardcopies of the transcripts were mailed out to clients for member
checking. Thematic analysis was then conducted to extract themes relating to EI. This process
involved analysing transcripts using a deductive approach to analysis, shaped on existing EI theory
and based on the EI items from the interview guide (Braun & Clarke 2013). The analysis comprised
two phases. Phase 1 involved immersion in the data to gain an understanding of the content by (1)
reading all three transcripts once, and then reading an individual transcript twice again before
analysing it, and (2) underlining keywords/phrases/ideas exemplifying codes and notating initial
codes in the margins. Phase 2 involved rereading and reflecting on the coded data to identify more
in-depth meanings and to make any required amendments. In transcribing keywords or phrases of
interest some of the surrounding text was kept so that the context was not lost (Braun & Clarke
2006). An example of the process is found in Table 5-3.
Table 5-3: Example of thematic analysis of transcribed interview data.
Key idea/phrase Code (EI item) Theme (EI factor)
‘You were a person. Your dogs
were known and there was real
interest in them. One of the
loveliest people I have ever
interacted with’.
Social awareness Clients appreciate support
personnel who are
sociable
(Sociability)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 109
5.2.5 Results
5.2.5.1 Questionnaire
From a total of 441 questionnaires administered, excluding six questionnaires that were returned
unopened, the response rate was 23% (98/435). A further six clients were removed from the
analysis due to multiple missing responses resulting in 98 respondents. Eighty-two percent of
clients were female and 18% were male. The primary care veterinary practice location was urban
for 87% clients, regional for 12%, and rural for 1%. Sixty-two percent of clients owned dogs, while
38% owned other species, which included cats, horses, birds, and reptiles. Statistics for continuous
demographic variables were also determined (Table 5-4).
Table 5-4: Summary statistics for demographic variables of 98 clients participating in the study.
Predictor Variable
Frequency
(%)
Mean
(SD*)
Median
(Q1†, Q3‡)
QQ3QQQ3Q3‡
) Q3‡)
QQ3)Q3‡)
Min, Max
Client age 98 (100) 49 (14) 49 (37, 62) 25, 83
Years at primary care veterinary
practice
98 (100) 7 (7) 5 (2, 9) 0, 40
Number of visits annually 98 (100) 2 (1) 2 (2, 2) 1, 4
* SD Standard deviation
† Q1 First quartile
‡ Q3 Third quartile
Overall, the majority of clients viewed 26 of the 32 EI attributes as important or very important with
four of the five highest scoring attributes being associated with two EI factors (self-control,
emotionality) and one with the EI item of self-motivation (Table 5-5). More than 83% of clients
viewed nine out of the 10 professional attributes (teamwork and reflection) as important or very
important (Table 5-5).
Table 5-5: Client percentage ratings of EI and professional attributes of veterinary technology
graduates in order of highest ratings of importance per factor or item (adaptability, self-motivation).
Factor Item Attributes (%) Client Rating
VU & U N VI & I
EI
Emotionality
1. Understands others’ needs1
2
3
95
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 110
2. Can put themselves in someone
else's shoes 1 8 91
3. Able to interpret emotional
signals from others 3 12 85
4. Able to express their feelings
accurately to others 2 18 80
5. Clear about what they feel 3 23 74
6. Fluent in communicating
emotions 7 25 68
Sociability 7. Able to make others feel better 0 12 88
8. Able to confront others when
necessary 0 12 88
9. Socially sensitive and
perceptive 1 14 85
10. Able to ask for what they want 2 14 84
11. Excellent social skills 4 15 81
12. Can positively influence
others' feelings a 4 17 79
13. Always defers to the
veterinarian (negative item) a 4 31 65
14. Non-assertive (negative item) a 18 44 38
Well-being 15. Self-confident 0 10 90
16. Cheerful 0 17 83
17. Optimistic 1 13 86
18. Expect positive things to
happen in life b 11 32 57
19. Has difficulty accepting
compliments (negative item) c 42 48 10
Self-control
20. Thinks before they act 2, d 0 0 100
21. Can handle pressure calmly
and effectively 3, d 2 0 98
22. Reflects carefully before
making decisions 4, d 0 4 96
23. Well-developed coping
mechanisms e 1 20 79
24. Able to control emotions 2 20 78
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 111
25. Able to alter mood through
personal insight & effort 3 22 75
26. Impulsive f 49 40 11
Adaptability 27. Flexible in approach to work 1 8 91
28. Adapts well to change 0 10 90
Self-
Motivation 29. Self-motivated 5, g 5 0 95
30. Determined and persevering 0 12 88
31. Lacks drive and persistence
(negative item) h 53 32 15
32. Motivated mainly by rewards
(negative item) h 54 41 5
Professional
Team work
1. Cooperative i 0 1 99
2. Conscientious i 1 4 95
3. Accepting of others 2 8 90
4. Shares professional values
with colleagues 2 14 84
5. Agreeable j 5 30 65
Reflection 6. Receptive to guidance k 0 0 100
7. Learns from mistakes k 0 3 97
8. Knows own limitations 0 5 95
9. Open-minded 0 5 95
10. Able to critically analyse
situations and experiences k 0 7 93
VU - Very Unimportant; U - Unimportant; N - Neutral; I - Important; VI - Very Important
1-5 EI attributes which highest percentage of clients viewed as important (basis for interview
questions)
a-h Clusters of EI attributes identified in client groups (see Table 5-9)
i-k Clusters of professional attributes identified in client groups (see Table 5-9)
Of the 10 technical skills surveyed, eight were rated as important or very important by at least 88%
of clients (Table 5-6). Around 30% of clients were unsure (3 = neutral) about the importance of the
remaining two items of conducting obesity clinics and puppy pre-schools. Socio-demographic
variables of age, gender, number of visits to the practice annually, number of years as a client at a
practice, and being a dog owner were a significant predictor of association with 12 (10 EI and
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 112
professional attributes and two technical skills) of the 52 attributes and skills assessed overall. Six
attributes/skills did not fit the proportional-odds assumption and were rejected. Results of the
multivariate analyses are presented in Tables 5-7 and 5-8.
Table 5-6: Client percentage ratings of the importance of technical skills of veterinary technologists
in order of highest rating of importance per skill group.
Technical
Skills
Items
(%) Client rating
VU & U N VI & I
Clinical skills 1. Prioritise patients according to illness or
injuryl 0 1 99
2. Take blood samples l 0 5 95
3. Perform preliminary examination of
animal on admission l 2 5 93
4. Assist with physical therapy techniques
for the veterinary patient l 3 6 91
5. Take x-rays l 2 9 89
Client
education
6. Provide advice on animal care e.g.
worming, vaccination, desexing 0 3 97
7. Provide advice on dental health and
hygiene for animals 0 5 95
8. Provide clients with appropriate
nutritional advice for animals 3 9 88
9. Conduct puppy pre-school classes m 9 34 62
10. Conduct obesity clinics for cats and
dogs m 7 32 61
VU - Very Unimportant; U - Unimportant; N - Neutral; I - Important; VI - Very Important
l, m Cluster of technical skills identified by client groups (see Table 5-9)
The odds of female clients rating emotionality (OR 2.97 95% CI [1.14–7.93]; p = .01) and
sociability (OR 2.99 95% CI [1.08–8.57]; p = .03) as important were approximately three times
greater than for males. Similarly, the odds of rating teamwork (OR 4.54 95% CI [1.62–13.68]; p <
.01) and reflection (OR 4.09 95% CI [1.44-12.73]; p < .01) as important were approximately four
times greater for female clients. The odds of older clients rating the flexibility and cheerfulness of
the veterinary technologist higher in importance than younger clients were approximately three
times greater (Table 5-7). Table 5-8 depicts the OR of significant predictors for clients rating the
technical skills of veterinary technologists.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 113
Table 5-7: Odd ratios (and 95% confidence intervals) of significant predictors for rating a range of
EI and professional attributes of the veterinary technologist by 98 clients using a Likert scale (1 -
very unimportant and 5 – very important).
Factor Attribute Predictorb and level OR (95% CI) p-
valuea
Flexible in approach to work
(EI)
Client’s age 0.01
≤49 years Ref *
>49 years 3.74 (1.59-
9.38)
Adapts well to change (EI) Client’s age 0.02
≤49 years Ref
>49 years 2.61 (1.16-
6.47)
Wellbeing
(EI)
Cheerful Client’s age 0.02
≤49 years Ref
>49 years 2.61 (1.16-
6.14)
Teamwork Agreeable Client’s age 0.01
≤49 years Ref
>49 years 2.58 (1.2-5.68)
Emotionality
(EI)
Fluent in communicating
emotions
Gender b
Male
Female
No. of annual visits
1
2
>2
Ref
2.97 (1.14-
7.93)
Ref
2.14 (0.79-
5.88)
4.24 (1.15-
16.14)
0.01
0.01
Reflection Able to critically evaluate
situations
Gender
Male
Female
Ref
4.09 (1.44-
12.73)
<0.01
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 114
Emotionality
(EI)
Able to express their feelings
accurately to others
No. of annual visits
1
2
>2
Gender
Ref
2.50 (0.91-
7.22)
6.52 (1.67-
28.62)
0.02
0.05
Male Ref
Female 2.68 (1.00-
7.33)
Sociability
(EI)
Able to ask for what they want Gender 0.03
Male Ref
Female 2.99 (1.08-
8.57)
Teamwork Accepting of others Gender <0.01
Male Ref
Female 4.54 (1.62-
13.68)
Pet ownership <0.01
Dogs Ref
Others 1.94 (0.86-
4.46)
Teamwork Cooperative Gender <0.01
Male Ref
Female 16.49 (3.01-
31.58)
Regular veterinary practice 0.05
≤2 years
3-7 years
Ref
2.9 (1.00-9.39)
>7 years 1.46 (0.49-
4.47)
* Reference group
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 115
a Significance of the likelihood-ratio test indicating that a model including the variables improved
the fit of the model significantly compared with a reduced or a null model, with an alpha (type I)
error equivalent to p.
b The predictor represents the effect of the predictor variable; odd ratio represents the odds of
reporting any particular rating or higher. Interpretation: the odds for rating fluent in communicating
emotions at any particular rating or higher increased by 2.97 for female clients compared with male
clients (OR 2.97) (95% CI 1.14 – 7.93).
Table 5-8: Odds ratios (and 95% confidence intervals) of significant predictors for rating a range of
technical skills of the veterinary technologist by 98 clients using a Likert scale (1 - Very
Unimportant and 5 – Very Important).
Technical Skills Predictorb and level OR (95% CI) p-valuea
Conduct puppy
pre-school
Years at regular veterinary practice 0.05
≤2 years Ref *
3-7 years 0.40 (0.15-1.06)
>7 years 0.34 (0.13-0.84)
Gender <0.01
Male Ref
Female 8.74 (2.99 - 28)
Conduct obesity clinics No. annual visits 0.04
1 Ref
2 0.29 (0.1-0.76)
>2 0.47 (0.13-1.6)
Gender 0.02
Male Ref
Female 6.62 (2.25 - 21.12)
* Reference group a and b as in Table 5-7
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 116
Table 5-9: Comparison of client group (clusters) ratings of technical skills, EI and professional
attributes.
Factors
Highly EI
focused group
(Items* = 26)
Technical
skills focused
group
(Items = 15)
Somewhat EI
focused group
(Items = 8)
Negative EI
focused
group
(Items = 4)
p-
value§
% †; median
ranking‡
(range)
%; median
ranking
(range)
%; median
ranking
(range)
%; median
ranking
(range)
Emotionality 23; 4 (4-5) <0.01
Sociability 19; 4 (4-5) 38; 4 (3-4) a 0.03
Wellbeing 12; 4 (4-4) 13; 4 (3-4) b 25; 3 (2-3) c 0.28
Self-Control 7; 4 (4-5) 20; 5 (4-5) d 13; 4 (4-4) e 25; 3 (2-3) f 0.66
Adaptability 7; 4 (4-5) 0.11
Self-Motivation 4; 4 (4-4) 7; 4 (4-5) g 50; 2 (2-3) h 0.01
Teamwork 7; 4 (4-5) 14; 4 (4-5) i 13; 4 (4-4) j 0.53
Reflection 7; 4 (4-5) 21; 4 (4-5) k 0.14
Technical Skills 12; 4 (4-5) 40; 4 (4-5) l 25; 4 (3-4) m 0.07
* Total number of EI and professional attributes or technical skills included in the client groups
† Percent of EI and professional attributes or technical skills included in the client groups
‡ Median ranking of clients’ response to factors
§ p values were derived using Chi square test.
a-h EI attributes identified by client groups (clusters) (Table 5-5)
i-k Professional attributes identified in client groups in (Table 5-5)
l, m Technical skills identified by client groups (Table 5-6)
Hierarchical cluster analysis of the questionnaire data revealed four clusters or groupings of clients
(highly EI focused; technical skills focused; somewhat EI focused; and negatively EI focused)
based on their ratings of particular attributes or skills of the veterinary technologist (Table 5-9).
Clients across these groupings differed in their rating of importance of the EI factors of
emotionality (p < 0.01), sociability (p < 0.03), and self-motivation (p = 0.01).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 117
5.2.5.2 Interviews
A summary of the interview results, which further contextualised the five EI attributes identified as
important by the highest percentage of clients in the questionnaires, is described in Table 5-10.
These results highlighted the importance of the EI factors identified by the highly EI focused group
(emotionality and sociability) and the technical skills focused group (self-control and stress
management). The interviewees’ views on the importance of support personnel demonstrating self-
motivation and commitment to professional development also aligned with perceptions of both the
technical skills focused and highly EI focused client groups. Three additional themes emerged:
‘effective communication is important to clients’, ‘clients desire knowledgeable support personnel’
and ‘clients expect support personnel to be competent’.
Table 5-10: Summary of themes from interviews of three veterinary clients participating in the
study.
Themes
(EI Factors)
Codes
(EI Items)
Condensed key
idea/phrase Quote
Clients
appreciate
support staff
demonstrating
emotionality
(Emotionality)
Empathy1 Being supportive
and
understanding of
the client’s
situation
‘The vet nurse was caring and
understanding towards us as well. That
was a pretty positive experience’.
Acknowledging
the pet as a
member of the
client’s family
‘…not respecting of the fact that this is
someone else’s family member’
Emotion
perception2
Being aware of
the clients’
distress and
anxiety
‘…you usually go because of something
you’re concerned about and there’s a
level of anxiety and if your left standing
around it just increases that anxiety
something phenomenally.’
Clients
appreciate
support
personnel who
are sociable
(Sociability)
Social
awareness3
Being
acknowledged on
arrival
Having
knowledge of the
‘Great greeting! Always came out and
gave them a pat. It was just this big
interaction. Every time we went there,
there was just this big smile and
wonderful greeting.’
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 118
client and their
pet; showing
interest in them
‘Just calling us by name. That’s
reassuring that they know us and we
know our dogs are well looked after’.
Emotion
management
Settling down
clients
experiencing
stress
‘They help to settle down everyone else
it concerns and the animal settles too.’
Clients
appreciate
support
personnel with
self-control
(Self-control)
Stress
management4
Acting calmly
and getting on
with the job
‘The staff were really great, just quietly
came out…and took me in and settled
me down and got a doctor very quickly –
a vet very quickly.’
‘You want to know they’ll act calmly
and get on with the job…it is reassuring
to me as a customer that the dog is being
looked after and he’s in safe hands’.
Clients want
support
personnel who
are self-
motivated
(Self-motivation)
Intrinsic
motivation5
Commitment to
excellence
‘Getting some indication that they like
their work and like to find out more
about their work and are keen to learn
and to progress their knowledge base.
That’s important’.
(Other)
Effective
communication
is important to
clients
(Communication)
Flow of
information
Keeping clients
informed about
their pet’s
condition
Providing
explanations
‘So I think there needs to be constant
sort of keeping you in touch, being given
information. Clear information is also
very important’.
‘I like to be informed all the time… I am
a scientist by background, so I am
naturally curious’.
Clients desire
knowledgeable
support
personnel
(Knowledge)
Source of
information
Demonstrating a
good knowledge
base reassures
clients
‘I guess to me their knowledge is
important… because they are the only
other person who can tell you what you
need to know’.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 119
Clients expect
support
personnel to be
competent
(Competence)
Knowledge
and skills
Knowledge and
skills
reflecting
quality patient
care
‘You want to know that the person
who’s helping to care for your animals
knows what they are doing, understands
what it is all about and has demonstrated
that knowledge’.
1-5 EI items ranked as important in questionnaire by the highest percentage of clients
5.2.6 Discussion
In this study, the majority of veterinary client respondents viewed EI and professional attributes to
be important in the daily clinical practice of the VT graduate. The veterinary technologist’s work in
providing specific advice and performing clinical nursing procedures was also perceived as
important by most clients. Four distinct groupings of client views—varying in the importance
placed on EI, professional attributes, and technical skills—were identified. Some of these
perceptions were affected significantly by client demographics such as age, gender, number of visits
to the practice annually, number of years as a client of a practice, and dog ownership, thus reflecting
the diversity in the veterinary client population.
The client or service user’s pivotal role in professional education has been acknowledged in many
fields. This includes the unique and important relationship clients have with professions (Forsyth &
Danisiewcz 1985; Larson 1997) and the importance of professional training and socialisation in
equipping graduates to service client needs in a rapidly changing world (Dall’Alba 2009b, p.132;
Barnett 2012) In health and medical education, client input is valued in curriculum planning,
teaching, and evaluation of professional programmes (Hurley 2008; Morgan & Jones 2009; Happell
2010; Fallon et al. 2012; Rhodes 2012). A recent study revealing differences in the views of clients
and small-animal veterinarians regarding desirable personal and professional attributes of
veterinarians draws attention to the need for further research on veterinary client perspectives to
inform veterinary curricula and teaching (Mellanby et al. 2011). These arguments and the findings
of this study highlight an important research agenda for VT: seeking client perspectives for the
design of innovative, market-driven curricula for an emerging profession.
One of the most important findings from this study was that the majority of clients valued EI in VT
graduates, and that the five EI attributes rated as important by the highest percentage of clients
related to EI factors of emotionality (empathy), self-control (stress management, low impulsivity),
and self-motivation. Emotionality, involving empathy, has been widely cited in the medical and
veterinary education literature as one of the most important skills in building client–patient
relationships (Shaw 2006; Bonvicini 2008; Batt-Rawden et al. 2013; McArthur & Fitzgerald 2013).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 120
Research in the health professions reinforces the desirability of EI attributes by service users
(Freshwater & Stickely 2004; Hurley 2008; Morgan & Jones 2009), as does the veterinary
literature, which reports that clients place more importance on a veterinarian’s communication skills
and emotion-related abilities than on technical expertise (Tinga et al. 2001). It is therefore not
surprising that healthcare educators view client input into curriculum as pivotal in producing more
empathetic and client-centred graduates (Illingworth & Chelvanayagam 2007). Thus, VT
curriculum designers need to ensure that the emphasis on emotionality valued by clients continues
to be a focus in educational interventions such as communications training and is enhanced in areas
such as clinical training.
The importance of implementing EI training for VT clinical educators is backed up by the role
model literature in the medical, dental, and veterinary fields, which demonstrates that clinical
educators are viewed as powerful role models in socialising students through modelling desirable
attributes, behaviours, and values. The literature provides recommendations for developing the non-
cognitive attributes as well as the teaching skills of educators (Sutkin 2008, p.464; Brown, Stevens
& Kermode 2012; Schull et al. 2012c). According to Barnett (2012), HE curricula need to prepare
students for a complex world requiring resilience and an ability to manage stress. In this study, the
majority of clients agreed with the importance of veterinary technologists being able to manage
stress, including the client group focused on technical skills, who placed importance on stress
management and low impulsivity. This group’s associated focus on clinical skills such as triage and
blood collection, which often occur in high stress situations, matched well with their EI
expectations.
In addition, work-related stress has been commonly cited in the veterinary literature as an issue for
practising veterinarians, with recommendations for teaching of stress management skills in
undergraduate veterinary education (Hatch et al. 2011; Epp & Waldner 2012; Skipper & Williams
2012). These findings all provide justification for the inclusion of stress management training in VT
curriculum. Strategies could include mindfulness-based stress reduction training, found to be
efficacious in a systematic review of stress management programmes for medical students
(Shiralkar et al. 2013). Mentoring, which has been used as an evidence-based intervention for
developing stress management skills in new nursing graduates (Theisen & Sandau 2013), could
similarly be emphasised in the role of clinical educators of VT students. In addition to using role
modelling and stress management training, VT curriculum designers could take note of the
significant associations found between client demographics and VT attributes and skills in this
study. These findings emphasised the diversity of veterinary clients based on demographics such as
age, gender, and their loyalty to the veterinary practice (number of visits annually and number of
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 121
years as a client). These differences have implications for interacting with clients in the clinical
environment. Compared to male clients, female clients would be more likely to respond to a
veterinary technologist who was sociable and empathetic. In addition, mature-aged clients (over 49
years) would be more likely to appreciate veterinary technologists being flexible, cheerful, and
agreeable. This view of older clients is reflected in the inclusion of flexibility and adaptability in the
list of Australian government employability skills, a set of non-technical skills and knowledge
considered essential for participation in the workforce (Ithaca Group 2012). This also aligns with
Barnett’s (2009, 2012) calling for HE curricula that develop qualities such as resilience to prepare
students for a complex, changing world. Similarly, the UQ graduate attributes, a HE response to
employability skills, state that graduates should be able to ‘adapt innovatively to changing
environments’ (UQ 2018d). It could therefore be suggested that, as well as employer input, client
input into graduate attributes would be advantageous in addressing this curricular challenge.
Another important finding about the diversity of clients was revealed in the cluster analysis, an
approach not previously attempted in VT research. Similar use of cluster analysis has been reported
in other professions such as in human nursing to identify the perception of needs of family members
visiting intensive care units (Hinkle, Fitzpatrick & Oskrochi 2009), and in business to identify client
groups for marketing purposes (Mooi & Sarstedt 2011). Thus, this type of analysis could be useful
in future studies to inform VT curricula and to determine client service needs. Overall, the
differences in clients identified in this study highlighted the need for a holistic approach to VT
curricula that emphasises the three domains of professional competence, thereby preparing
graduates to meet the needs of diverse groups of clients in a complex and changing world
(Dall’Alba 2009b, p.132; Barnett 2012).
Client service needs were further illuminated by the interview results (n = 3). Clients clearly
articulated how the EI of VT graduates positively influenced the quality of their practice visit,
commencing with an expectation of the veterinary technologist being empathetic, acting calmly,
and helping ‘to settle everyone down’. Interviews also revealed that clients wanted to interact with
veterinary technologists who could communicate effectively, providing ‘clear information’ and a
constant flow of information. Knowledgeability was also valued, as veterinary technologists were
seen as ‘the only other person who can tell you what you need to know’. It was also evident that
clients wanted to engage with support personnel who were knowledgeable, technically competent
(‘knows what they are doing’), and had a commitment to ongoing professional development (‘keen
to learn and progress their knowledge base’)—essentially a professionally competent graduate.
These findings are congruent with Dall’Alba’s (2009a, p. 34) premise in medical education of a
need to focus on the three elements of professional competence: ‘knowing’, ‘doing’, and ‘being’.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 122
This educational model is consistent with twenty-first century medical health care, which is viewed
as a collaboration between patients and medical practitioners (Dall’Alba 2009b, p.132) A similar
message is evident in the veterinary client interviews, and provides compelling evidence for client
input to shape a market-driven VT curriculum. In addition to EI and technical skills, professional
attributes essential for teamwork and reflection were explored in this study. Even though these
findings were very relevant to the design of a professionalising VT curriculum, they are beyond the
scope of this paper.
Valuable data for innovative VT curriculum design were collected from the study. There were,
however, some limitations with regard to the veterinary practice and client samples, data collection,
and participant response rate. The limitations of the client sample being drawn from a limited
number of veterinary practices were counteracted by participants being randomly selected from a
large client population, and the practices being key employers of VT graduates and clinical
placement providers for VT students. On this basis, the clients who participated may be considered
to be representative of veterinary clients who interact with VT graduates. The direction of the
gender bias on client responses to study items is difficult to predict, as the population visiting
veterinary practices may not reflect the general population. For example, one veterinary practice
client population in the study was 70% female.
If selection bias existed in this study, then the direction of the bias would be away from the null and
therefore the effect of gender may have been overestimated and vice versa. The overall client
response rate (22.3%) was low and this may have induced a non-response bias affecting the external
validity of the results (Sivo et al. 2006). As no data were collected from non-respondents, the extent
of the bias could not be determined and warrants further investigations. The low response rate
represents a limitation of this study. Strategies to encourage non-responding clients to respond, such
as follow-up calls and mailed reminders could potentially increase response rates (Sivo et al. 2006),
but were not feasible at the time.
Furthermore, a larger client sample size would have provided greater understanding of how clients’
perceptions of the importance of attributes and skills might vary with client demographics.
Consequently, caution is required in interpretation of results and the generalisability of these
findings. This flaw in the external validity was compensated by rigour in the internal validity of the
research. The majority of clients recognised the negatively worded EI items in the questionnaire,
indicating a meaningful response, and the statistically significant differences in some results also
reflected internal validity. The use of interviews for triangulation of data and methods and the
randomisation of the client sample also added to internal validity. Limitations of the interviews
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 123
included that they were short, averaging 20 minutes, and interviewees were not drawn from all four
practices. Maximum variation could also have been achieved by selecting clients from differing age
groups, and with different pets (for example, cats and dogs).
5.2.7 Conclusion
This study was driven by a gap in the literature regarding the role of veterinary clients as key
stakeholders in curriculum design for VT, an emerging profession in Australasia. Overall, client
responses indicated a desire for a professionally competent VT graduate, suggesting the need for a
curriculum focused on the three domains of learning: the affective, cognitive, and technical
domains. Another important finding was that groups of clients differed in the importance they
placed on each of these domains, with some clients being highly focused on EI and others more
focused on the technical expertise of veterinary technologists. Significant differences were also
found associated with client gender and age, and with those who visited the veterinary practice
more than twice per year or stayed with a practice for several years. These findings again
highlighted the diversity of veterinary clients and that, in meeting their service needs, ‘one size does
not fit all’. Curriculum designers therefore need to recognise this and seek diverse client input into
curricula. Additional recommendations for a market-driven VT curriculum include enhanced EI
training for students, communications training, and mindfulness techniques for stress management.
Another recommendation is to provide EI and stress management training for clinical educators,
who shape the attitudes and behaviours of VT undergraduates, to meet the needs of diverse client
groups in complex clinical environments. Furthermore, the results from this study could be valuable
in the recruitment and training of veterinary support personnel for client-centred service provision
to enhance the sustainability of veterinary practices.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 124
6 Chapter 6
Clarke, PM, Henning, J, Coleman, T, King, E & Schull, D, ‘What makes a great clinical team?
Stakeholder perspectives on the attributes of effective veterinary health care teams in Australia’.
Accepted by the Australian Veterinary Journal in December 2018.
An overview of this experimental chapter is provided in Figure 6-1.
Figure 6-1: Overview of Study 4 on gathering stakeholder perspectives to inform a VT curriculum
for desirable ‘ways of being’ effective in veterinary teamwork and notions of teamwork.
6.1 My contribution to authorship
My contribution to the conception and design of this paper was around 70% including identifying
the seven teamwork items surveyed and the question on defining teamwork for the veterinary health
care team members and academics. The majority of the remainder was attributable to Drs Schull
and Henning, I was responsible for drafting 70% of the paper, with additional input primarily from
Drs Schull and Dr Henning. The Introduction (Section 6.2.2) was almost solely my work (with a
small amount of editing and input by Drs Schull and Coleman) having conducted an extensive
literature search around the topics of employability, teamwork across disciplines, including
veterinary science, and stakeholder input into curriculum. In addition, I came up with the idea of
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 125
exploring personal attributes within the ‘Five-Factor’ Model of personality (McCrae & Costa 1987)
that are associated with teamwork effectiveness in other disciplines.
I primarily developed and wrote up the Methods (Section 6.2.3) and Results (Section 6.2.4) sections
with some input from Dr Henning into the last paragraph in Section 6.3.3.1 on sample size
calculation and with Section 6.3.3 on data analysis. I developed all results in tables (6-1, 6-2 & 6-3).
Dr Henning produced Figures 6-2 to 6-8 in their final form. However, I had previously constructed
these in Microsoft Excel 2010. Sections 6.2.3.4 and 6.2.4.26.5 on thematic analysis were almost
entirely my work. Drs King and Schull had some initial input into the method of thematic analysis
as coaches and mentors. However, I ultimately was responsible for researching the method of
analysis, conducting the final analysis, interpreting the results and writing up. I was also responsible
for developing Figure 6-9, a visual representation of veterinary teamwork themes. In addition, I
conducted an extensive search of the literature for the Discussion (Section 6.2.5) and wrote the
majority of it with some minor input and editing provided by other authors. I was also responsible
for composing and writing the Conclusion (6.2.6) and Limitations (Section 6.2.6), with minor input
from other authors. The ethics application was all my work, as well.
I confirm that all authors of this publication are eligible to be an author as defined in section 5.1 of
the UQ policy on authorship (4.20.04) (UQ 2018b) and all have agreed to the authorship order.
Importantly, all authors have also agreed to this publication being included in this thesis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 126
6.2 What makes a great clinical team? Stakeholder perspectives on the
attributes of effective veterinary health care teams in Australia
Modern day veterinary teams are complex entities. In order to offer the services required by
the public and to run a successful business, a practice will now be composed of members of
different professions and occupations providing complementary roles. (Kinnison, May &
Guile 2014)
6.2.1 Preamble: A VT educator’s autoethnographic account of developing a
curriculum for veterinary teamwork
Barnett’s (2000) call for HE to prepare students for a world of ‘supercomplexity’ and uncertainty
continued to resonate with me in developing a curriculum framework and pedagogy for VT, where
graduate employability and professionalisation of the students, and the discipline, were dominant
themes. Despite making progress in academisation, in 2008 I still felt like a lone ‘voice in the
wilderness’ in regards to strengthening the vocationalism aspect of the curriculum by integrating the
veterinary nursing competencies. In addition to this challenge, I was acutely aware that the VT
students in those early years, like other paraprofessionals before them in human health, were
negotiating new frontiers in the veterinary school, and in the veterinary workplace. Hence, I viewed
transitioning the VT students into these settings as a key responsibility. I endeavoured to provide
support by encouraging them to develop Barnett’s (2009) dispositions for a world of uncertainty—
being open to new experiences, committed to their studies, and determined to succeed (Barnett
2009). This came naturally to many, having chosen to enrol in a new HE discipline. That said, it
wasn’t always easy to negotiate the challenges: sharing resources and staff that were already
‘stretched’, a uniprofessional school culture, and a professional community coming to terms with
university educated paraprofessionals. On the other hand, the richness of the school’s professional
learning culture, the opportunity to be socialised into the veterinary profession alongside veterinary
students, and the benefits of small cohorts of 25 – 30 students, counterbalanced these challenges.
Academically, I wanted students to be prepared for a working life beyond the veterinary school,
where teamwork capability was essential (Kinnison, May & Guile 2014). Through my own personal
experience as a veterinary practitioner, a vocational teacher of veterinary nursing, and in reading the
literature of the medical and health professions, I was cognisant that VT graduates required the
knowledge, skills and attributes to work effectively in interprofessional (or interdisciplinary) teams
(Frawley 2017), following trends in human health care (Sargeant, Loney & Murphy 2008;
Thistlethwaite 2012). I also recognised that to be accepted graduates had to ‘value-add’ to the
veterinary health care team, fulfilling a role defined by the hallmarks of their university education.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 127
Hence, in researching for this study, I explored the personal attributes that VT graduates needed to
work effectively in veterinary health care teams, based on the cross-disciplinary literature (Halfhill
et al. 2003; Driskell et al. 2006; Peeters et al. 2006; Ruby & DeBowes 2007), and from the
perspectives of key stakeholders. I wanted to prepare veterinary technologists for effective ways of
‘being’ in veterinary teams, not merely to be ‘knowers’, or ‘doers’ (Barnett 2004, p. 257). I also saw
this as an opportunity to identify any differences in perspectives within or between VT stakeholder
groups that could either explicitly, or implicitly, inform a pedagogy to develop graduates’
confidence and competence in teamwork. My next challenge would be to develop learning
experiences that encouraged the formation of these personal attributes, primarily through pedagogy
based in the clinical and interprofessional contexts, and through the use of reflection (Schön 2003).
6.2.2 Introduction
As VT is a relatively new HE discipline and paraprofession in Australia (Moodie et al. 2013),
designing curricula to prepare graduates for teamwork in the veterinary practice is an emerging
research area. The UQ VT programme provides a HE pathway into a range of veterinary support
roles (Clarke, Schull & Coleman 2009; UQ 2018a) similar to the HE bachelor’s degree programmes
for veterinary nursing in the UK (RCVS 2018c, 2018e) and for veterinary technicians in the USA
(AVMA 2018d). The success of UQ VT graduates working in veterinary practice, where the
majority are employed (Clarke, Schull & Coleman 2009), hinges on their ability to ‘value-add’ to
practice services through their graduate attributes, skills, knowledge and personal attributes. Equally
important is their acceptance as valuable members of the veterinary health care team and within the
broader professional community. Based on these arguments, the graduate attribute of teamwork is
pivotal in promoting VT graduate employability (DEETYA 1998; Donleavy 2012; Matthews 2016).
More complex conceptualisations of graduate employability involving graduate identity are
emerging (Tomlinson 2012; Jackson 2016a). However, this study utilises the commonly cited
definition of employability by Knight and Yorke (2004, p. 5): ‘A set of achievements—skills,
understanding and personal attributes—that make individuals more likely to gain employment and
be successful in their chosen occupations which benefits themselves, the workforce, the community
and the economy’. With teamwork being a highly valued skill set, much can be learned from the
cross-disciplinary literature on team composition involving the individual characteristics of team
members such as age, gender, education or personality trait (Halfhill et al. 2003; Driskell et al.
2006).
Personality traits from the ‘Five-Factor’ Model of personality (‘Big-Five’), a framework for
describing key personality traits in five basic dimensions (‘conscientiousness’, ‘agreeableness’,
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 128
‘extraversion’, ‘openness’ and ‘neuroticism’) (McCrae & Costa 1987; McCrae & Costa 1991), have
been consistently linked to team effectiveness (Halfhill et al. 2003; Driskell et al. 2006; Bradley et
al. 2013). In particular, the traits of ‘conscientiousness’ and ‘agreeableness’ and some of their facets
(sub-sets of traits), such as ‘cooperation’, are widely recognised as characteristics of good team
players (Table 6-1) (Driskell et al. 2006). Conscientious individuals are reported to work well in
teams due to their dependability, achievement-orientation and individual task-proficiency (Neal et
al. 2012), whereas ‘agreeable’ individuals enable team functioning through their friendly,
accommodating behaviours (McCrae & John 1992). Understanding personal attributes, including
personality traits, and their implications for teamwork can inform the design of targeted training or
educational interventions to develop desirable team behaviours (Wille, De Fruyt & Feys 2013),
such as time management ascribed to conscientious individuals and the interpersonal skills
associated with ‘agreeableness’ (Neal et al. 2012). Likewise, personal attributes such as ‘accepting
of others’ and ‘sharing professional values’, also recognised as essential to team success in the
veterinary team’s literature (Ruby & DeBowes 2007), are worthy of consideration as outlined in
Table 6-1.
Table 6-1: Framework of personal attributes for veterinary teamwork.
Personal attribute Description
‘Agreeableness’ Individuals who are considerate, honest, helpful and supportive
(Driskell et al. 2006)
‘Cooperative’ Individuals who approach others cooperatively; willing to work
together (Driskell et al. 2006)
‘Socially sensitive &
perceptive’
Individuals who have social understanding, insight into the needs
of others and are empathetic (Driskell et al. 2006, p. 253-254)
‘Conscientiousness’ Individuals who are hard-working, prepared, thorough, organised,
task-oriented and reliable (Driskell et al. 2006)
‘Flexible [in approach to
work]’
Individuals who are good at handling uncertainty in task
conditions and have flexibility in problem-solving (Driskell et al.
2006)
‘Accepting of others’ Individuals who are accepting of one another’s strengths and
weaknesses; valuing differences (Ruby & DeBowes 2007)
‘Sharing professional values’ Individuals who are united in their professional values (Ruby &
DeBowes 2007, p. 26)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 129
The importance of teamwork has been highlighted in human health care where failures in teamwork
are linked to higher nursing staff turnover, higher patient mortality (Sargeant, Loney & Murphy
2008; Lin, Viscardi & McHugh 2014), and longer hospital stays (Carney et al. 2010). The
increasing complexity of veterinary health care which mirrors trends in human health care, similarly
warrants an integrated interprofessional team approach to deliver quality care (Kinnison, May &
Guile 2014). In both fields, the specialised skills of the physician or veterinarian alone are no longer
enough (Sargeant. Loney & Murphy 2008; Kinnison, May & Guile 2014). Veterinarians now work
closely in teams with highly educated VT graduates, veterinary nurses, practice managers,
veterinary specialists, and other affiliated professionals. Paraprofessionals, such as VT graduates,
‘value-add’ to veterinary practice through roles involving nutrition advising, preventative health
care education (Jevring 1993; Hancock & Schubert 2007; Mossop and Gray 2008), and practice
management. Hence teamwork research is vital for informing curriculum and pedagogy that
promote VT graduate employability and greater synergy within the veterinary health care team—
particularly important for a relatively new paraprofession.
In human nursing, stakeholders, including service providers, educational institutions, graduates and
professional organisations have helped inform curriculum to ensure programmes meet community
needs (Keogh et al. 2010). Similarly, there is evidence in the health professions that patient
outcomes and satisfaction with healthcare providers (James, Page & Sprague 2016) are improved by
engaging service-users in curriculum planning, teaching and programme evaluation (Hurley 2008;
Morgan & Jones 2009; Fallon et al. 2012). As teamwork is context-dependent (Lemieux-Charles &
McGuire 2006), it could therefore be extrapolated that perceptions of key stakeholders (Keogh et al.
2010) such as VT graduates, veterinary employers, nurses, clients and academics would be
invaluable in shaping a VT curriculum to promote teamwork capability. With graduate
employability emerging as a central function for modern universities (DEETYA 1998; Jackson
2014; McCowan 2015), VT curricula need to meet the demands of key stakeholders including
employers and graduates who, as consumers (Naidoo & Jamieson 2005), expect employability as a
return on investment in their education (DEETYA 1998; Tomlinson 2012; Jackson 2014). In
addition, because of the traditionally diverse worldviews of professional groups (Hall 2005),
comparing perceptions of teamwork between the veterinary health care groups would also be
valuable to inform curriculum.
This study on veterinary teamwork was part of a larger study exploring perceptions of UQ VT
graduates, their veterinary employers/supervisors, nurses who worked with them, veterinary clients
and academics who taught them, regarding desirable personal and professional attributes, and
technical (nursing) skills to inform V T curriculum and pedagogy on teamwork. This study
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 130
addressed the fourth research question: What messages for HE curriculum and pedagogy can be
garnered from key stakeholders with respect to teamwork attributes and skills for VT graduates?
The study aimed to explore key stakeholder perceptions of the desirability of a range of personal
attributes drawn from the ‘Big-Five’ model of personality —‘flexibility’ (in approach to work),
‘agreeableness’, being ‘cooperative’, ‘socially sensitive and perceptive’, ‘conscientiousness’—and
from the veterinary teams literature (‘accepting of others’ and ‘sharing professional values’) for VT
graduates working in veterinary health care teams. The remaining two attributes were selected from
the veterinary teams’ literature (Ruby & DeBowes 2007) because of their contextualisation to the
veterinary setting and relevance to developing a curriculum for veterinary paraprofessionals
working successfully in veterinary health care teams. The study also aimed to explore the nature of
interprofessional teamwork within our discipline. Recommendations will be made to inform a
teamwork curriculum to successfully integrate VT graduates into the veterinary health care team,
promoting their employability and the quality of veterinary care.
6.2.3 Methods
6.2.3.1 Study design and selection of study groups
This cross-sectional survey using quantitative methods was conducted between October 2008 and
February 2009 with five key stakeholder groups in VT education. These stakeholder groups
included VT graduates, veterinarians, veterinary nurses, clients and veterinary academics. All VT
graduates (n = 122) who completed a UQ BAppSc (VT) between 2003 and 2007 were invited to
participate in the study. Their contact addresses were sourced by the primary researcher (PC)
through university records or personal communication.
The veterinarians sampled (n = 44) were either employers (principal veterinarians) or supervisors of
the VT graduates. Their mailing addresses were obtained through personal communication (PC) or
via the practice website. All nurses surveyed (n = 49) held a senior nursing position, with one or
two surveyed per practice depending on its size. Senior nurses are often the university’s point of
contact for VT student placements. They also supervise VT students and contribute to feedback on
their performance. All UQ School of Veterinary Science veterinary academics (n = 15), who taught
into the third year of the VT programme, were selected to participate and mailed questionnaires
through the UQ internal mailing system. Clients were identified through a convenience sample of
four urban veterinary practices in south-east Queensland: one small animal general practice, one
mixed small animal and equine general practice, one small animal veterinary teaching and referral
hospital, and one small animal specialist referral hospital. Criteria for veterinary practice selection
included accessibility to the researchers, a willingness to participate and experience with the UQ
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 131
VT programme (that is, employing a minimum of two VT graduates and providing clinical
placements for a minimum of two final-year VT students).
Sample size calculations were conducted to estimate the number of clients to be surveyed.
Considering a total population of 13,830 clients across the 4 veterinary clinics, a 95% confidence
interval and a margin of error of 10% and an unknown proportion of clients with the factor of
interest (that is, maximum proportion is 0.5), a total of 96 clients needed to be sampled. Assuming a
response rate of 20%, the number of clients to be sampled was estimated to be at least 400. A
systematic random sampling method was used to select clients (n = 440) from a total population of
13830 clients that had visited the four veterinary practices from January 1 to August 31, 2008.
Sampling used an interval size of 30, and a randomly selected starting number between one and 20.
This resulted in sample sizes varying between 60 and 170 clients proportional to the number of
clients per practice. The targeted clients had visited the veterinary practices for more than one
consultation during the study period.
6.2.3.2 Questionnaires
Two stakeholder questionnaires were developed; one for the three veterinary health care groups and
academics (Appendix 5), and a modified version, for clients (Appendix 3). The questionnaires
surveyed respondents’ backgrounds and perceptions of the importance of a range of technical skills
and personal and professional attributes for UQ VT graduates to inform a VT curriculum responsive
to key stakeholder needs. Modifications for the client questionnaire involved the researcher
removing a small number of technical skills and personal attributes deemed less relevant to this
group, for example: ‘performs anaesthesia induction’ and ‘maintains close friendships’. Selected
results from the client questionnaire have been published previously (Clarke et al. 2015). The
questionnaire for the veterinary health care and academic groups comprised 80 questions and was
divided into three parts:
Part One comprised 12 questions seeking socio-demographic information on respondents’ age (in
years), gender (male, female) and location of the veterinary practice (rural, urban, or regional).
Regional refers to non-urban areas with populations >25,000 and good access to services versus
rural areas having smaller populations and reduced services (Roufeil & Battye 2008).
Part Two explored perceptions of the importance of technical skills, personal and professional
attributes of VT graduates working in clinical practice using five-point Likert-type questions (see
Appendix 5). Eighteen questions related to the importance of technical (veterinary nursing) skills
based on a review of advanced training for veterinary technicians in the USA (de Laforcade et al.
2005). Forty-seven questions focused on personal and professional attributes with several items
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 132
negatively worded to reduce acquiescent response style bias (Podsakoff, MacKenzie & Podsakoff
2012). Seven attributes, ‘flexible [in approach to work]’, ‘agreeableness’, ‘socially sensitive and
perceptive’, ‘sharing professional values’, ‘cooperative’, ‘accepting of others’ and
‘conscientiousness’ were selected for this study on teamwork.
Part Three of the questionnaire comprised one five-point Likert-type question rating the importance
of teamwork for VT graduates in clinical practice and two open-ended questions. One of these,
‘How would you define teamwork?’, is reported in this study.
The client questionnaire differed in having 60 questions: seven on socio-demographics (Wolfe &
Gould 1998), personal and professional attributes and 10 technical skills. Clients were not asked to
define teamwork (see Appendix 3). The questionnaires were mailed to survey participants, along
with a reply-paid envelope and a letter explaining the objectives of the research study. The client
surveys were managed by the practices to maintain confidentiality and included an additional letter
from the practice endorsing the study. A reminder was sent to all non-respondents after three
weeks.
Pilot testing of the questionnaires was conducted in Brisbane, Australia, by mailing the
questionnaire to veterinary clients (n = 2), veterinarians (n = 2), a veterinary nurse (n = 1), and
veterinary academics (n = 2). The questionnaire took approximately 15 minutes to complete.
Revisions for clarity, which included changes to the instructions, were made based on written and
verbal feedback from these groups. The study was approved through the UQ ethical review process
for human ethics (# 200700403). The approval process complied with guidelines made in
accordance with the National Health and Medical Research Council Act 1992 (National Health and
Medical Research Council 2018).
6.2.3.3 Data analysis
The demographic data for each of the five respondent groups were summarised using descriptive
statistics. The age of participants was summarised by mean, standard deviation and
minimum/maximum, while the gender and the location of veterinary practice for each group were
shown as proportions. Due to the small number of observations in rural and regional clinics, the
location of veterinary practices was dichotomised (urban and rural/regional) for further
analysis. Age was compared between the five s t a k e h o l d e r groups using the Kruskal-Wallis
test (Turner 2014), while the Fisher’s Exact test (Kraska-Miller 2013) was used to investigate
if gender and location of practice differed between the five groups.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 133
Responses to the Likert-type questions regarding the seven attributes (‘flexible [in approach to
work]’, ‘agreeableness’, ‘socially sensitive and perceptive’, ‘sharing professional values’,
‘cooperative’, ‘accepting of others’ and ‘ conscientiousness’) were summarised for each group
as proportions of responses for each Likert scale item within the study groups.
A comparison of Likert scale responses to the attributes was conducted between respondent groups
using ordinal logistic regression. The proportional odds assumption for the ordinal logistic
regression model was tested using the approximate likelihood-ratio test across response categories
(Wolfe & Gould 1998), and by using a Wald test for an overall assessment of the assumption (Brant
1990). A stratified analysis was then conducted for each stakeholder group using ordinal regression
to determine if the attributes were associated with the age, gender or location of respondents. A
multiple Wald test was computed to evaluate the statistical significance across all levels of
categorical risk factor variables (Doohoo, Martin & Stryhn 2003). Stata 12.0 was used for all
statistical analyses (Stata Corporation 2011).
6.2.3.4 Thematic analysis
The open-ended question on defining teamwork aimed to gather the perspectives of members of the
veterinary health care team and academics. Even though PC had engaged with the teamwork
literature at this stage, responses were thematically analysed via an inductive approach developed
from the data using no predetermined theory or framework (Bernard & Ryan 2010, p. 87). Guided
by Clarke and Braun’s (2013) six phases of thematic analysis, the responses were read and re-read
individually and carefully, line by line, to become familiar with the data. Phase 2 involved
generating the initial codes from the data with the coding involving systematically identifying basic
units of text (words or phrases) across the entire data set that were of interest then categorising these
by writing notes on the text. A process of constant comparison of coding across the data set was
conducted looking for recurring units, similarities and differences in the text (Clarke & Braun
2013). In Phase 3, initial codes were collated into potential themes. Phase 4 involved checking if the
themes developed were appropriate to the coded extracts across the entire data set. Phase 5 involved
generating final names and definitions for each of the nine themes. In phase 6, the themes and
explanatory exemplars were written up to tell the story of the data (Clarke & Braun 2013).
6.2.4 Results
6.2.4.1 Study population
A total of 670 questionnaires were administered across the five groups with an overall response rate
of 35.5% (238/670). The final response rates for each group were: (1) VT graduates 58.2%
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 134
(71/122), (2) veterinarians 72.7% (32/44), (3) veterinary nurses 57.1% (28/49), (4) academics
60.0% (9/15) and veterinary clients 22.3% (98/440).
The majority of all stakeholders were female (77.7%) and located in urban areas (77.4%). However,
the majority of veterinarians (71.9%) were male. Approximately 90% of VT graduates were female
and their average age was 24.5 years. Details of the demographics of the five stakeholder groups are
described (Table 6-2).
Table 6-2: Demographic characteristics of stakeholder groups associated with VT education, The
University of Queensland, Australia in 2008-2009.
Stakeholder
Group N (%)
Age Gender Location
Mean, Min,
Max, SD N (%) N (%)
Veterinarians
32
(13.5) 47 (31-61, 8.7)
Male 23 (71.9)
Female 9 (28.1)
Urban
Rural & Regional
25 (78.1)
6 (18.8)
VT graduates 71
(29.8)
24.5 (20-39,
3.5)
Male 6 (8.5)
Female 65 (91.5)
Urban
Rural & Regional
43 (60.6)
24 (33.8)
Veterinary
nurses
28
(11.8)
33.8 (21-54,
8.1)
Male 2 (7.1)
Female 26 (92.9)
Urban
Rural & Regional
22 (78.6)
6 (21.4)
Veterinary
academics 9 ( 3.8)
42.9 (32-62,
9.4)
Male 4 (44.4)
Female 5 (55.6)
Urban
Rural & Regional
9 (100.0)
0 ( 00.0)
Veterinary
clients
98
(41.2)
48.6 (25-
83,14.0)
Male 18 (18.4)
Female 80 (81.6)
Urban
Rural & Regional
85 (86.8)
13 (13.2)
Total
respondents
238
(100)
39.2 (20-83,
14.8)
Male 53 (22.3)
Female 185 (77.7)
Urban
Rural & Regional
184 (77.4)
49 (20.6)
The majority of all groups perceived that the attributes, ‘agreeableness’ (≥ 57%) (Figure 6-2),
‘socially sensitive and perceptive’ (≥ 64%) (Figure 6-5), ‘sharing professional values’ (≥ 75%)
(Figure 6-6), ‘cooperative’ (≥ 97%) (Figure 6-7) and ‘accepting of others’ (≥ 90%) (Figure 6-8),
were important or very important in teamwork. There were no significant differences in the
importance of these attributes between groups (‘agreeableness’: p = 0.1496; ‘socially sensitive and
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 135
perceptive’: p = 0.1685; ‘sharing professional values’: p = 0.4615; ‘cooperative’: p = 0.6195;
‘accepting of others’: p = 0.1206) Being ‘flexible’ (Figure 6-3) was also seen by the majority of all
groups as important or very important, but it had marginally higher importance for VT graduates
(97.2%) compared to veterinarians (90.6%) (p = 0.0013). Similarly, the majority in all groups
perceived ‘conscientiousness’ (Figure 6-4) as important or very important, but VT graduates
(95.8%), nurses (89.3%) and clients (94.9%) rated ‘conscientiousness’ significantly lower compared
to veterinarians (100%) and academics (100%) (p = 0.0016).
Figure 6-2: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘agreeableness’ as
an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 = unimportant; 3 =
neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important).
3.1 9.4 56.3 31.3
1.4 2.8 26.8 43.7 25.4
3.6 7.1 32.1 28.6 28.6
33.3 44.4 22.2
1.0 4.1 29.6 50.0 15.3Veterinary clients
Veterinary academics
Veterinary nurses
VT graduates
Veterinarians
Sta
keh
old
er
gro
up
1 2 3 4 5
Agreeableness
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 136
Figure 6-3: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on being ‘flexible [in
approach to work]’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important).
Figure 6-4: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on
‘conscientiousness’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important).
9.4 50.0 40.6
2.9 38.6 58.6
3.6 7.1 39.3 50.0
44.4 55.6
1.0 8.2 63.3 27.6Veterinary clients
Veterinary academics
Veterinary nurses
VT graduates
Veterinarians
Sta
keh
old
er
gro
ups
1 3 4 52
Flexible in the approach to work
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 137
Figure 6-5: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘socially sensitive
and perceptive’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important).
Figure 6-6: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘sharing
professional values’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important).
12.5 65.6 21.9
11.4 55.7 32.9
3.6 32.1 42.9 21.4
11.1 66.7 22.2
1.0 14.3 54.1 30.6Veterinary clients
Veterinary academics
Veterinary nurses
VT graduates
Veterinarians
Sta
keh
old
er
gro
up
2 3 4 51
Socially sensitive and perceptive
6.3 3.1 65.6 25.0
14.1 62.0 23.9
3.6 21.4 53.6 21.4
22.2 77.8
2.0 14.3 64.3 19.4Veterinary clients
Veterinary academics
Veterinary nurses
VT graduates
Veterinarians
Sta
keh
old
er
gro
up
1 3 4 5
Sharing professional values
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 138
Figure 6-7: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on being
‘cooperative’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 =
unimportant; 3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important).
Figure 6-8: Percentage ratings of the importance placed by stakeholder groups on ‘accepting of
others’ as an attribute for VT graduates in clinical practice. (1 = very unimportant; 2 = unimportant;
3 = neutral; 4 = important; 5 = very important).
3.1 6.3 50.0 40.6
2.8 42.3 54.9
7.1 39.3 53.6
55.6 44.4
1.0 1.0 8.2 52.0 37.8Veterinary clients
Veterinary academics
Veterinary nurses
VT graduates
Veterinarians
Sta
keh
old
er
gro
up
1 2 3 4 5
Accepting of others
56.3 43.8
1.4 50.7 47.9
3.6 42.9 53.6
44.4 55.6
1.0 60.2 38.8Veterinary clients
Veterinary academics
Veterinary nurses
VT graduates
Veterinarians
Sta
keh
old
er
gro
up
2 3 4 51
Cooperative
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 139
The results of the stratified analysis are shown in Table 6-3. Female clients placed significantly
more importance on VT graduates being ‘accepting of others’ (p = 0.0028), ‘cooperative’ (p =
0.001), and ‘socially sensitive and perceptive’ (p = 0.0082) compared to male clients. Significantly
more female clients considered being ‘flexible’ of higher importance than male clients (p = 0.0122)
and significantly more, older clients considered ‘flexibility’ (p = 0.0120), and ‘agreeableness’ (p =
0.0178), of higher importance than younger clients. Older veterinary nurses considered ‘sharing
professional values’ of higher importance than younger veterinary nurses (p = 0.0351). Within
groups there were no associations between location and perceptions of attributes.
Table 6-3: Association of importance placed on personal attributes and demographics of VT
stakeholder groups surveyed in Australia in 2008-2009.
Veterinary nurses Total VU
(%)
U
(%)
N
(%)
I
(%)
VI
(%)
p-value
‘Sharing professional values’ 3.6 0.0 21.4 53.6 21.4
Sex (N (%)) Female 26 (92.9) 0.0 0.0 50 50 0.0
Male 2 (7.1) 3.8 0.0 19.2 53.9 23.1 0.3642
Location (N (%)) Urban 22 (78.6) 4.5 0.0 27.3 50 18.2 0.1382
Rural/regional 6 (21.4) 0.0 0.0 0.0 67.7 33.3
Age (mean) 33.8 26 0.0 33.7 31.3 41.2 0.0351*
Veterinary Clients
‘Flexible (in approach to work)’ 1 0.0 8.2 63.3 27.6
Sex (N (%)) Female 80 (81.6) 5.6 0.0 11.1 77.7 5.6 0.0122*
Male 18 (18.4) 0.0 0.0 7.5 60 32.5
Location (N (%)) Urban 85 (86.8) 1.2 0.0 7 64.7 27.1 0.9091
Rural/regional 13 (13.2) 0.0 0.0 15.4 53.8 30.8
Age (mean) 48.6 52 0.0 37.8 48.1 53 0.0120*
‘Agreeableness’ 1 4.1 29.6 50 15.3
Sex (N (%)) Male 18 (18.4) 0.0 5.6 38.8 50 5.6 0.2174
Female 80 (81.6) 1.2 3.8 27.5 50 17.5
Location (N (%)) Urban 85 (86.8) 1.2 3.5 29.4 48.2 17.7 0.3332
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 140
Rural/regional 13 (13.2) 0.0 7.7 30.8 61.5 0.0
Age (mean) 48.6 43 46.8 43.7 50.4 48.6 0.0178*
‘Socially sensitive & perceptive’ 0.0 1 14.3 54.1 30.6
Sex (N(%)) Female 80 (81.6) 0.0 0.0 33.3 55.6 11.1 0.0082*
Male 18 (18.4) 0.0 1.2 10 53.8 35
Location (N (%)) Urban 85 (86.8) 0.0 1.2 15.3 52.9 30.6 0.6899
Rural/regional 13 (13.2) 0.0 0.0 7.7 61.5 30.8
Age (mean) 48.6 0.0 67 46.4 48.6 49.1 0.7989
‘Cooperative’ 0.0 0.0 1 60.2 38.8
Sex (N (%)) Female 80 (81.6) 0.0 0.0 0.0 100 0.0 0.0001*
Male 18 (18.4) 0.0 0.0 1.2 51.3 47.5
Location (N (%)) Urban 85 (86.8) 0.0 0.0 1.2 61.2 37.6 0.5361
Rural/regional 13 (13.2) 0.0 0.0 0.0 53.8 46.2
Age (mean) 48.6 0.0 0.0 2.6 49.4 48 0.897
‘Accepting of others’ 1 1 8.2 52 37.8
Sex (N (%)) Female 80 (81.6) 0.0 5.6 11.1 77.7 5.6 0.0028*
Male 18 (18.4) 1.2 0.0 7.5 46.3 45
Location (N (%)) Urban 85 (86.8) 1.2 1.2 9.4 51.7 36.5 0.3112
Rural/regional 13 (13.2) 0.0 0.0 0.0 53.8 46.2
Age (mean) 48.6 0.0 0.0 25 49.4 48 0.897
VU - Very Unimportant; U - Unimportant; N - Neutral; I - Important; VI - Very Important
*Indicates a statistically significant value.
6.2.4.2 Thematic analysis findings
Nine themes central to veterinary teamwork were generated: (1) team collaboration, (2) goals and
outcomes in teamwork (3) sharing values, (4) relationships in teamwork, (5) teamwork and
diversity (6) communication in teamwork, (7) task-orientation in teamwork, (8), personal attributes
for teamwork, and (9) team culture (Figure 6-9).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 141
Figure 6-9: Visual representation of veterinary teamwork with themes generated by VT graduates,
veterinarians, senior nurses, and academics in Australia.
6.2.4.3 Collaboration is the essence of teamwork
The most prevalent interpretation of veterinary teamwork across groups was of ‘collaboration by a
group of people to achieve a common goal with a positive outcome’. Team membership was most
frequently described in generic terms such as ‘a group of people working together’ [VT1]. A small
number of the veterinary health care team associated teamwork with professional identity [VT2]:
‘ability of everyone (vet + vet tech) working together’. Some veterinarians, and to a very limited
extent nurses, recognised the role of other stakeholders in teamwork, demonstrating a client- and
patient-centred perspective on teamwork [V1]: ‘Being able to work with all
stakeholders/owners/veterinarians/staff to achieve an outcome suitable for animals and owners’.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 142
6.2.4.4 Teams are committed to goals and outcomes
Although common goals and positive outcomes were widely recognised as integral to teamwork
across all groups, particularly with VT graduates and veterinarians, veterinarians’ responses again
demonstrated a client- and patient-centred focus [V2]: ‘Ability as a team to provide quality service
to patients and clients. A broader concept of team goals was also described as ‘pulling together to
achieve the goals of the day or overall practice goals’ [VN1].
6.2.4.5 Teams share values
The majority of participants incorporated shared values into their teamwork definitions. Most
commonly mentioned values were ‘working together effectively and efficiently’ [VT3] and being
responsible [V3]: ‘Everyone fulfilling their obligations. VT graduates and veterinarians [V4] also
characterised teamwork as a selfless activity: ‘… where individuals place the needs of the group
higher than their own needs and agendas’. ‘Equality’ was also an important value among the groups
[V6]: ‘A group working towards a common goal… with each member having a valued input’.
However, ‘respect’ was a value more commonly identified by the female dominated VT graduates
and nurses [VN2], ‘Everyone is equal and is to be treated with equal respect’, as was ‘harmony’ in
teamwork [VT4], ‘…work (ing) effectively, efficiently and harmoniously towards a common goal’.
‘Excellence’ appeared as another common value pertaining to individual performance, service and
outcomes [V7]: ‘Individuals performing at their best in synergy with others…motivated by a shared
vision of an exemplary outcome’. Interdependence in teamwork was also recognised [VN3]: ‘If one
person forgets something then it reflects on our team’.
6.2.4.6 Supportive relationships fuel teamwork
The relationship theme was evident across all groups but more prevalent in the female-dominated
VT and veterinary nurse groups. Terms such as, ‘helping each other’, ‘being ‘supportive/assisting’
[VT5], providing ‘encouragement’ and ‘back-up’ were frequently used. The importance of trust in
teamwork was also highlighted in one veterinarian’s definition of teamwork as simply, ‘continual
back-up from colleagues’ [V8].
6.2.4.7 Teamwork fosters diversity
The diversity theme focused primarily on differences in skills, abilities, qualifications and
experience of team members with the VT and academic groups more likely to acknowledge
diversity. However, diversity was also viewed as ‘…recognising and utilising strengths and
weaknesses of each member [VT6]’ which could refer to personal, technical or academic qualities.
Complementarity in teamwork also featured with ‘Each member having different skills and abilities
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 143
which complement each other’[VT7]. Veterinarians were the only group to refer to leadership [V9]:
‘Taking direction from a leader or lead as necessary’. Similarly, one academic referred to, ‘people
with different backgrounds’[Ac1], which in that context could refer to cultural or disciplinary
differences. The broad range of personal attributes, that are discussed below, would also contribute
to veterinary team diversity.
6.2.4.8 High-level communication skills are integral to teamwork
Several participants in each group identified the need for clear and effective communication in
teamwork in order to achieve goals and outcomes [VT8]. A few VT graduates articulated the
different forms of communication integral to teamwork which included an ‘ability to work closely
with others…negotiate/resolve conflict [VT9]’ and ‘…brainstorming to reach a collaborative
goal’[VT10]. The importance of teams communicating at an organisational level was also raised
[V9]: ‘Able to communicate at an effective level/realistic and regular feedback from
management/regular team meetings’. One veterinary nurse referred to the importance of teams
communicating to share professional knowledge [VN3]: ‘sharing/receiving ideas from others’.
6.2.4.9 Teamwork involves task-orientation
Task-orientation was not a major focus for the majority of respondents with this theme most
prevalent in the VT graduates’ definitions. Across the groups, task-orientation was expressed as
being ‘organised’, ‘completing tasks’ and in ‘timeliness’. One academic highlighted the
interdependence of task performance in teams enacted through [Ac2]: ‘…performing set tasks (that
are) integrated with tasks performed simultaneously by others’. Problem-solving associated with
task-orientation was identified by one VT graduate [VT10]: ‘A group of people…working out a
solution for a problem together’.
6.2.4.10 Personal attributes are important in teamwork
Being ‘cooperative’ was the most commonly identified attribute across groups with a broad range of
attributes, such as being ‘happy’, ‘positive’, ‘determined’, ‘flexible’ and ‘agreeable’, viewed as
integral to veterinary teamwork. Being agreeable was expressed in ‘working well with others by
being approachable’ [VT11]. Relational attributes like being ‘empathetic’, ‘caring’, ‘civil’,
‘compassionate’, ‘cooperative’ and ‘friendly’ were also viewed relevant by some. One veterinary
nurse captured the nature and value of the attribute of being ‘accepting of others’ in teamwork
[VN4]: ‘Accepting (of) everyone for their ideas and abilities’.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 144
6.2.4.11 Effective teamwork promotes a positive workplace culture
The association of workplace culture and teamwork, with ‘effective teamwork promoting a positive
workplace culture’, was acknowledged by a few, including one veterinarian who referred to
teamwork as [V11]: ‘an ability to work with others… and create a good work environment’.
However, some VT graduates and nurses were more specific and related their concept of teamwork
to the physiological and psychological characteristics of a positive work culture [VN5]: ‘When vets
and nurses work together … and maintain a happy/healthy work environment’.
6.2.5 Discussion
Personal attributes based on the ‘Factor-Five’ model of personality (McCrae & John 1992), relevant
to VT graduates working in health care teams, and key stakeholders’ understanding of veterinary
teamwork have not been previously discussed. The finding that the majority of stakeholders clearly
agreed on the importance of all seven attributes (‘flexible [in approach to work]’, ‘agreeableness’,
‘socially sensitive and perceptive’, ‘sharing professional values’, ‘cooperative’, ‘accepting of
others’ and ‘conscientiousness’) confirmed the transferability of aspects of the team composition
literature from other fields to the veterinary context. (Driskell et al. 2006; Neal et al. 2012). A key
finding was that veterinarians and academics rated ‘conscientiousness’ more highly than other
groups, whereas female clients rated relational attributes more highly than male clients.
Additionally, teamwork priorities identified in the stakeholder definitions provided unique insights
into the broad range of personal attributes, skills and values desirable for teamwork. Overall. these
findings also highlighted the importance of engaging stakeholders in VT and veterinary curriculum
planning, evaluation and assessment, as in other disciplines, to improve client and patient outcomes,
and to meet employer and graduates’ expectations of employability.
6.2.5.1 Personal attributes
Stakeholder feedback on the ‘Five-Factor’ attributes concurred with the team composition literature
from other disciplines (Driskell et. Al 2006; McAtavey & Nikolovska 2010). The importance of
‘flexibility [in approach to work]’, described as an essential attribute for teamwork in the
psychology literature (Driskell et al. 2006), is backed up by a recent study on occupational stress for
veterinary technicians in the USA. Here it was revealed how the veterinary technician needs to be
flexible to manage their ever-changing and poorly defined work mode (Foster & Maples 2014).
Similarly, support is found for stakeholder views on ‘agreeableness’ in the psychology (Peeters et
al. 2006) and management (LePine et al. 2011) literature. Findings report that professional teams
composed of a higher proportion of ‘agreeable’ members perform better at both the individual and
group level, attributable to their conflict resolution and communication skills (Neuman & Wright
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 145
1999, p. 471). Likewise, stakeholders agreed on the value of the relational attribute of being
‘socially sensitive and perceptive’ that has been linked to improved team performance (Morgeson,
Reider & Campion 2005; Driskell et al. 2006). Hence, it seems that introducing pedagogical
strategies to develop these personal attributes, either explicitly or implicitly, would enable VT
graduates to more effectively function in teamwork. Students could then be assessed on being
‘flexible’ when faced with uncertainties in the clinical environment, or on their ‘agreeableness’
when managing conflict within a simulated team environment.
Evidence from the medical and health professions reveals that personality traits are able to be
changed, particularly in regards to improving and sustaining empathy (Chen et al. 2012; Hojat,
Erdmann & Gonnella 2013; Hojat et al. 2013), a characteristic of socially sensitive and perceptive
individuals (Driskell et al. 2006). Educational interventions, such as watching and discussing videos
of patient interactions, role-playing, shadowing patients, role-modelling, small group discussions
(Hojat 2009; Hojat, Erdmann & Gonnella 2013), and mindfulness and self-awareness training
(Krasner et al. 2009), have all been shown to enhance students’ capacity for empathy. Students’
social and educational environments are also reported to influence their attitudes to caring and their
interpersonal skills (Hojat, Erdmann & Gonnella 2013). Furthermore, pedagogical strategies for
developing conflict resolution skills can enhance students’ ability to be cooperative and collaborate
more effectively (Gardner 2005). Similarly, specific pedagogical strategies as well as clinical skills
training to enhance personal attributes (such as ‘agreeableness’ and others), recognised in medical
education (Chibnall, Blaskiewicz & Detrick 2009) should be transferable to the veterinary context.
In addition, raising students’ awareness of the influence of personality on team performance (using
the ‘Big-Five’ model) has been reported to help students explain and resolve problems that arise in
teamwork (Rhee, Parent & Basu 2013).
However, to keep the importance of these attributes in perspective, although high levels of
‘agreeableness’ in teamwork are reported desirable (McCrae & Costa 1991; Bradley et al. 2013),
teams also benefit from members whose ‘agreeableness’ allows challenging of different
perspectives, more open-minded discussion and creativity in teamwork (Bradley et al. 2013; Smith
& Hou 2015). Thus, teams can benefit from heterogeneity in attributes or traits as each makes a
positive contribution (Smith & Hou 2015). On the other hand, team heterogeneity can generate
problems (Shemla et al. 2016); the relative advantage of heterogeneity versus homogeneity in team
composition is still the subject of ongoing research (LePine et al. 2011; Shemla et al. 2016).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 146
6.2.5.2 ‘Sharing professional values’
Another interesting finding was that clients placed importance on ‘sharing professional values’, and
implicitly interprofessional practice. It could be assumed that this relates to the higher expectations
of a more educated, informed veterinary clientele, and affirms the value of the client voice in
curriculum development described in other professions (Hurley 2008; Morgan & Jones 2009;
Fallon et al. 2012). The finding that VT graduates, veterinarians and academics valued this attribute
was not unexpected as shared values are internalised with professional socialisation during the
students’ clinical education and following graduation (Moyo et al. 2016). However, pertinent to VT
and veterinary curricula, the differences in professional socialisation and values supported by
uniprofessional education can create impediments to teamwork and interprofessional collaboration
(McCallin & McCallin 2009; Moyo et al. 2016). Therefore, VT and veterinary students’
competence in teamwork and interprofessional practice could be facilitated by co-learning about
‘sharing (of) professional values’ in the academic curriculum, and while working collaboratively on
clinical rotations.
6.2.5.3 Differences between groups
A key interprofessional difference highlighted in this study, which has implications for VT clinical
education, was that veterinarians and academics rated ‘conscientiousness’ as significantly more
important than the VT and nurse groups (and clients). As ‘conscientiousness’ is linked to greater
team performance and effectiveness in the organisational and psychology literature (Halfhill et al.
2003; Driskell et al. 2006; O’Neill & Allan 2011), it is clear why veterinarians, as employers and/or
supervisors, would value this attribute in support personnel. Graduates, who are organised, hard-
working, dependable, task-oriented, achievement-oriented and have initiative, would greatly
advantage the veterinary health care team (Driskell et al. 2006). On the other hand, an academic
culture may view ‘conscientiousness’ differently, through the lens of achievement-orientation,
(Grant & Elizabeth 2015) highlighting the importance of emphasis on the different facets (or sub-
units) of ‘conscientiousness’ in curriculum. Furthermore, VT graduates’ perceptions could signal
differences between employee and employer/supervisor, with veterinarians’ responses aligned with
their leadership positions as practice owners/managers (Moore et al. 2015). These findings not only
highlight the importance of ‘conscientiousness’ for graduate employability but also the relevance of
leadership and management training in VT curriculum. Graduates need to prepare for managing as
well as participating in veterinary health care teams with both requiring an awareness of desirable
attributes for teamwork. Leadership roles would represent a natural progression for conscientious
individuals. The importance of leadership training in VT curriculum is also strengthened by the fact
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 147
that in Australia graduates can own veterinary businesses and employ veterinarians to conduct their
practice. (Veterinary Surgeons Board of Queensland 2018). In summary, an ‘all of curriculum’
approach to fostering and potentially assessing the relevant sub-units of ‘conscientiousness’ is
advocated. This would include assessing students’ organisational skills, work ethic, initiative,
commitment to achieving their best and completing tasks in a timely manner (Driskell et al. 2006),
particularly on clinical rotations.
6.2.5.4 Differences within groups
Significant differences in perceptions of attributes were not found within groups relating to location,
which suggests there is nothing integral to an urban practice versus a rural/regional practice that
changes a stakeholder groups’ perceptions. The finding that significantly more female clients placed
higher importance on the relational attributes of, being ‘accepting of others’, ‘socially sensitive and
perceptive’ and ‘cooperative’, compared to males, is consistent with the literature associating
females with a more relationship-centred communication style (Christen, Alder & Bitzer 2008;
Shaw et al. 2010; Shaw et al. 2012). However, as Shaw et al. (2012) assert, other less studied
factors such as age and cultural background, may also impact on communication. Hence, the
importance of also considering these additional factors in educational interventions involving VT
and veterinary students. Pedagogical interventions such as simulations for communication training
could be utilised along with video-recording, constructive feedback and reflection to prepare
students for communicating with a diverse range of clients and personalities within the veterinary
health care team (Shaw et al. 2010; Shaw et al. 2012). This is vitally important for graduates of an
emerging profession working with clients and in the context of an interprofessional team.
6.2.5.5 A qualitative exploration of veterinary teamwork
Building on the quantitative findings, the nine themes generated from the teamwork definitions
highlighted the importance of a range of personal attributes for VT graduates working in health care
teams and placed the previous findings on attributes into context. In addition, insights were
provided into the teamwork priorities of members of veterinary health care teams, which could be
used to develop targeted interventions to better prepare VT graduates for teamwork.
In contrast to the quantitative findings, participants, overall, did not place great emphasis on
personal attributes in teamwork, apart from being ‘cooperative’ and ‘sharing professional values’.
However, those that did affirmed the importance of the seven personal attributes studied and
illuminated a more ‘fine-grained’ picture by, for example, identifying the importance of sub-units of
‘agreeableness’, in being ‘considerate’, ‘helpful’ and ‘supportive’ (Driskell et al. 2006).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 148
Almost all participants appeared to have a sound understanding of teamwork as a ‘group
collaborating effectively by working towards a common goal to achieve positive outcomes’. Even
though the theme of ‘Teams are committed to goals and outcomes’ was widely acknowledged
across groups, veterinarians were more client- and patient-centred compared to other groups. This
deficit in other groups drew attention to the need for VT curriculum and pedagogy to clearly
articulate the client’s role as a partner in team decision-making (Shaw 2006) and the relational or
affective dimension of their role—ways of ‘being’ a veterinary technologist when interacting with
clients. This dimension of their practice could be highlighted in clinical training, in real and
simulated interactions, and reinforced through individual and group reflection guided by clinical
educators.
The themes of ‘teamwork fosters diversity’ and ‘teams share values’ strengthened a case for a co-
curricular approach to VT and veterinary education to foster shared professional values (Moyo et al.
2016) and interprofessional understanding, as advocated in medical education (Thistlethwaite
2012). The interprofessional literature reports that a respect for diversity is fundamental to effective
collaborative teamwork (Sargeant, Loney & Murphy 2008), and requires understanding and respect
for each member’s role and the scope and complementarity of those roles (McCallin & McCallin
2009; Evans, Henderson & Johnson 2010). Thus, any differences in participants’ values and
emphasis on diversity noted may reflect the impact of uniprofessional education on teamwork and
interprofessional collaboration (McCallin & McCallin 2009; Moyo et al. 2016), which a co-
curricular approach to clinical education could address. Similarly, the fact that ‘equality’ (Sargeant,
Loney & Murphy 2008; Moyo et al. 2016) and ‘respect’ (Hall 2005; McCallin & McCallin 2009),
reportedly important values shared across professions, were not frequently cited infers a need for ‘a
common values framework’ (Moyo et al. 2016, p. 258) reinforced through interprofessional
teamworking opportunities during VT and veterinary student clinical rotations. However, a
potential impediment to these strategies, asserted by Witz (1992) from the sociology of professions,
is that interprofessional teamwork challenges the power and authority of the traditionally dominant
professions, such as the veterinary profession. This provides further support for a co-curricular
approach to VT and veterinary clinical education to break down hierarchical barriers that create an
impediment to veterinary teamwork (Kinnison, May & Guile 2014).
Effective communication is reportedly also vital for breaking down hierarchical barriers in teams
(Kinnison, May & Guile 2014). Some participants, VT graduates in particular, identified the
importance of ‘high-level communication skills’, within the team and with management, ‘being
integral to teamwork’. Conflict resolution skills, recognised as a core competency in human health
care (Suter, Arndt & Arthur 2009), negotiation skills and workplace meetings, mentioned by a few
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 149
graduates, are all essential for effective teamwork (Temkin-Greener et al. 2004; Sargeant, Loney &
Murphy 2008). Workplace meetings are integral to effective teamwork as they engage staff in the
work team environment and help them to feel listened to (Moore et al. 2015). Consequently,
pedagogical interventions involving simulation-based communication training that addressed
communication within the interprofessional team, conflict resolution, negotiation, and conducting
team meetings, would provide a solid framework for a VT teamwork curriculum. In addition,
making explicit the importance of the sharing of professional knowledge, a characteristic of
cohesive interprofessional teams (Walker et al. 2013), would enhance students’ preparation for
interprofessional practice.
6.2.6 Limitations
This study did have some limitations. Variation in interpretation of attributes by the individual
respondent or by a stakeholder group could have been a limitation as the attributes were not
described. The use of Likert–type questions has been reported to pose limitations associated with
the ‘capability and willingness of respondents to make the detailed distinctions requested of them’
(Willits, Theodori & Luloff 2016, p. 131). However, Likert scales are a widely used method for
survey collection (Biolcati-Rinaldi 2011), including in psychology (Ogden & Lo 2011), allowing
the respondent to respond in degrees of agreement or take a neutral stance. The neutral response
option may have reduced a response bias (Fernandez & Randell in Croasmun & Ostrom 2011), and
the anonymity of the survey may also have reduced the likelihood of social desirability bias
(Paulhus 1984). Other possible sources of bias included the purposively selected stakeholder group
samples (except client group). However, as almost all supervising veterinarians and senior
veterinary nurses from the participating veterinary practices were selected, it could be inferred that
the sample population actually represented the target population. Additionally, although the
majority of clients surveyed were female (82%), this may have reflected the characteristics of the
population that visited the participating practices.
Non-response bias may also be a limitation of this study as the client response rate was low (22.3%)
and no data were collected from non-respondents to determine the extent of the possible bias. This
may affect the external validity of the results. Consequently, caution is required in interpreting the
generalisability of these findings. The internal validity of the research was strengthened by
randomisation of the client sample.
From the perspective of the qualitative findings, the researchers, as former practitioners, were
familiar with teamwork in the veterinary clinical context as ‘insiders’ (Berger 2013). Therefore, this
background and their own personal beliefs, values, biases and experiences as veterinary academics
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 150
would have impacted on the research (Berger 2013). PC’s relationship with the VT graduates as
students may also have encouraged or impeded their ability to share their views. Although future
studies would benefit from triangulating the survey results with interview data, to date there has not
been any comparable research conducted on teamwork for veterinary support staff.
6.2.7 Conclusion
This is the first study of the perceptions of five stakeholder groups in VT education in Australia to
inform a curriculum for veterinary teamwork and with implications for interprofessional practice.
Findings demonstrated stakeholder views on the desirability of the ‘Factor-Five’ personal attributes
for VT graduates working in health care teams were similar to that of other disciplines. Differences
between groups, such as ‘conscientiousness’ being more highly rated by veterinarians and
academics, indicated a need for more emphasis on qualities associated with this attribute, such as
organisational skills, work ethic, initiative and task-completion, in curriculum and pedagogy. They
also inferred an increased emphasis on leadership and management training in VT curriculum. The
observed influence of stakeholder gender on perceptions of relational attributes highlighted the
important function of a VT communication curriculum to prepare graduates to engage with an
increasingly diverse clientele, as well as the diversity of personalities within the veterinary health
care team. The stakeholder teamwork definitions added to the research on personal attributes and
identified specific priorities for veterinary teamwork. These included being able to ‘collaborate’ and
understand that the client is ‘on the team’, achieving ‘team goals and outcomes’ which centre on the
client and patient, ‘sharing values’ with other professionals on the team, developing and
maintaining ‘team relationships’, ‘communicating effectively’ at team and management level,
‘respecting differences’ and ‘focusing on the task(s)’ - all of which need to be translated into a VT
curriculum for enhancing the performance of veterinary teams, VT graduate employability and the
overall success of this mid-tier veterinary paraprofession.
In addition to making important recommendations for VT curriculum, this study recommends future
research involving stakeholders from other Australasian programmes and triangulating the survey
data with interviews. This would provide an enriched, comparative perspective on veterinary
interprofessional teamwork to further inform VT and veterinary curricula and pedagogy.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 151
7 Chapter 7
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT & Henning, J 2018, ‘Recruiting the graduate voice:
informing higher education initiatives to underpin an emerging, veterinary paraprofession’,
accepted for publication in the Journal of Vocational Education and Training. (3 July and 24
September 2018 – see Appendix 13).
An overview of this experimental chapter is provided in Figure 7-1.
Figure 7-1: Overview of Study 5 on recruiting the VT graduate voice on HE policy, partnerships
and curriculum to review and influence change.
7.1 My contribution to authorship
This paper was substantially my work in conception and design, analysis and interpretation and in
drafting and critical revision. I would attribute 70% of the design and concept to my work, driven
by a need to ‘stop, check and review’ the VT curriculum when an opportunity arose in 2011. I
developed the questionnaire in collaboration with Dr Schull, with a small amount of input from Dr
Coleman. That said, I would have been responsible for 80% of its content, developing it within the
SurveyMonkey medium and administering it to the graduates. I was also solely responsible for
gathering contact details for the graduates, as explained in the Methods (Section 7.2.3). Similarly, I
conducted all of the analyses for the Results (Section 7.2.4) and developed all Tables (7-1, 7-2. 7-3,
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 152
7-4, 7-5, 7-6) with some guidance from Dr Henning about what data would be more useful and the
methods of presentation.
I also conducted the thematic analysis of data and interpretation, represented in Figure 7-2 being a
synthesis of graduates’ views on professionalisation. Similarly, I developed Table 7-4 providing a
synthesis of graduates’ views on curriculum and their ‘work-preparedness’. I wrote the complete
draft for all sections of the paper (7.2.2, 7.2.3, 7.2.4, 7.2.5 and 7.2.6) with some critical revision by
Drs Schull and Henning and some minor content suggestions.
I confirm that all authors of this publication are eligible to be an author as defined in section 5.1 of
the UQ policy on authorship (4.20.04) (UQ 2018b) and all have agreed to the authorship order.
Importantly, all authors have also agreed to this publication being included in this thesis.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 153
7.2 Recruiting the graduate voice: Informing higher education
initiatives to underpin an emerging, veterinary paraprofession in
Australia
Curriculum asks us … whose voice is heard and whose voice is silenced, what future is
being formed for individuals…Curriculum is concerned with effectiveness, but also
with expansiveness and voices, and who gets a say. (Yates 2005, p. 3)
7.2.1 Preamble: a VT educator’s autoethnography on honouring the graduate voice
in shaping a new discipline
By 2011, the UQ VT programme had been in place for 10 years with eight graduate cohorts
continuing to forge an expanding niche in the veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australia.
Over the period 2003-2010, I had closely monitored VT graduate employment and employability—
an important agenda for HE and graduates (Harvey 2000; Barnett & Coate 2005), and from my
perspective, a valid expectation for those who had taken a ‘leap of faith’ by enrolling in a new HE
discipline. Hence, even though I was passionate about academia and the transformative power of a
university education, my vision remained loyal to delivering a curriculum that achieved a balance of
vocationalism with academisation, following HE models in the UK (RCVS 2018c). With this in
mind, I tracked where every graduate was employed, and knew of those who had moved on to
further study and those who had changed career direction. Through these longitudinal observations,
as well as ongoing communication with graduates, student surveys, a close liaison with the
veterinary profession through students’ clinical placements, and membership of the AVA
(Queensland Division) executive committee, I had a good grasp of the barriers and facilitators to
VT graduate employability throughout the life of the programme.
On reflection, very early on I developed a keen sense of shaping and enacting a curriculum and
pedagogy that mirrored the discipline of human nursing, which transitioned from apprenticeship-
style training to a HE degree in Australia by 1994 (Reid 1994; Heath 2002; Findlow 2012). I was
also inspired by developments in medical education of preparing holistic practitioners through a
curriculum and pedagogy that nurtured ways of ‘being’, as well as the ‘knowing’ and ‘doing’
dimensions critical to their roles (Wear & Castellini 2000; Epstein & Hundert 2002). Consequently,
it was important to me that veterinary technologists could distinguish themselves as university
graduates, who were good communicators, emotionally intelligent in their interactions with clients
and within the veterinary health care team, and could demonstrate the value of their graduate
attributes such as critical thinking problem-solving, using evidence-based practice, and having a
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 154
commitment to lifelong learning. I kept reminding the students that this ‘graduateness’ (Steur,
Jansen & Hofman 2012) would be their ‘point of difference’ from vocational veterinary nurses.
Despite this ‘point of difference’, my years of teaching in VT, participating in university and
industry committees, and industry networking were not enough to achieve the level of graduate
acceptance I felt was required. I needed to summon up the time and energy amidst a busy schedule
of teaching and programme coordination to recruit the graduate voice (2003-2010) to provide
further evidence for curricular change. I viewed the VT graduates as a critical resource in
developing the discipline and their voices should be listened to and honoured in future curricula, not
only as consumers of education, but also as co-creators of an emerging profession. It was timely to
take stock of how the discipline was developing, from their perspective.
Overall, this fourth and final study of my thesis was designed to evaluate the success of
academising the VT curriculum, to professionalise VT students, and to identify other barriers and
facilitators to VT professionalisation and graduate success. The study encapsulated the ongoing
struggles to integrate vocationalism within the VT curriculum, in part due to cultural barriers
present in a traditional university adjusting to a system of mass education. Despite this barrier, I
appreciated that many veterinary employers, particularly in emergency and specialist veterinary
practices, valued the higher order attributes of HE educated support personnel. However, they also
wanted ‘work-ready’ graduates who could ‘hit the ground running’—a premise supported in the
history of other paraprofessions (Findlow 2012; O’Brien 2013). With that in mind, I sought
graduate feedback on how well the curriculum prepared them for employment—to gain support in
re-framing a three-dimensional curriculum and pedagogy for an emerging profession with graduate
employability and academisation/professionalisation as its ‘heart’.
7.2.2 Introduction
In Australia, VT bridges the gap between vocational veterinary nursing and veterinary science. Its
inception in HE in 2001 signalled the emergence of a mid-tier workforce model for veterinary
support staff (Moodie et al. 2013, p.28) in the rapidly changing landscape of the veterinary and
allied animal health fields in Australasia and Asia. Titles for veterinary support staff differ among
countries. In Australia (VNCA 2018b) and the UK (RCVS 2018a), the title of veterinary nurse is
assigned to those with a nationally-recognised vocational qualification in veterinary nursing. The
AVMA describes a veterinary technician, equivalent to the veterinary nurse in Australia and the
UK, as ‘a graduate of a two- or three-year AVMA accredited programme in VT’, whereas a
veterinary technologist is ‘a graduate of a four-year AVMA accredited programme in VT (AVMA
2018a). In Australia, VT can be differentiated from vocational veterinary nursing by a longer
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 155
duration of study, an academic focus, and by ‘graduateness’, or graduate attributes - the ‘essence of
a university education’ (Steur, Jansen & Hofman 2012, p.864). Prior to the inception of a Bachelor
of Veterinary Nursing degree at Latrobe University in 2018 and the CSU VT programme in 2015
(CSU 2015), the UQ VT degree was the only HE qualification in Australia available to those
interested in a veterinary nursing career. Hence, the VT degree could be compared to the HE
veterinary nursing programmes in the UK—providing broader employment outcomes in addition to
veterinary nursing (RCVS 2018c).
In Australia, the roles of veterinary paraprofessionals such as VT graduates (Clarke et al. 2009) are
closely affiliated with veterinarians in clinical practice, food safety, livestock and companion
animal health and welfare, biosecurity protection and disease surveillance, teaching, and research
(AVA 2014, 2016). The increase in specialisations and post-graduate qualifications for
veterinarians—in response to increasing societal expectations for high quality veterinary services
(AVA 2015), a more educated clientele (Page-Jones & Abbey 2015; Willis et al. 2007), the growing
importance of the HAB (Chuer-Hansen 2010), and public concerns for animal welfare (Freire et al.
2017)—validates the need for HE qualified veterinary paraprofessionals. This is evident in fields
such as emergency nursing, biosecurity inspection and in laboratory animal technology where the
VT graduate’s knowledge and skills have been sought after (Clarke, Schull & Coleman 2009).
Analogous to human health care, where interprofessional teamwork is essential to deliver quality
care (Sargeant, Loney & Murphy 2008; Thistlethwaite 2012), mid-tier veterinary paraprofessionals
therefore need to be prepared for evidence-based practice, multi-disciplinary teamwork, and a
mastery of technology and managing organisational information systems (Institute of Medicine
2011, p.170). Over recent years, this is reflected in the emergence of HE VT programmes in
Australasia and Asia, such as NVLU, Japan (2017), Massey University, NZ (Massey University
2018) and CSU, Australia, (CSU 2015). It also mirrors the global movement for professionalisation
of veterinary support personnel, led by veterinary nursing in the UK, which was proclaimed a ‘true’
profession in 2015 (RCVS 2015a).
The commencement of VT in HE in Australia in 2001 coincided with the global transformation of
HE from elite to mass participation (Dawson, Charman & Kilpatrick 2013). More specifically,
Australian HE was heading into a period of universal participation or open access, according to
Trow’s typology of HE development (2007, 2016). The massification of, and the ongoing widening
access to universities, has meant accommodating the educational and employability needs of a more
diverse student population (Dawson, Charman & Kilpatrick 2013; Fahrnet 2015), and accepting
responsibility for a wider range of traditionally vocational occupations (Peach 2010, p.449), such as
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 156
VT (Clarke et al. 2011)—meeting the challenge of ‘bridging the divide’ between the vocational and
HE sectors (Wheelahan 2000). Exploring the VT graduate story is therefore an important step in
documenting the emergence of this discipline and provides invaluable feedback to inform
curriculum design and HE policy that will enhance graduate employability. The latter being
essential as universities globally are pressured by governments to develop curricula that prepare
‘work-ready’ graduates (Litchfield, Frawley & Nettleton 2010; Trede, Macklin & Bridges 2012),
and, according to human capital theory (Ashton & Green cited in Tomlinson 2008), to meet student-
consumers’ expectations of employability as a return on their HE ‘investment’ (Findlow 2012;
Tomlinson 2012, p. 25). ‘Work-readiness’ here refers to graduates who are confident, proficient in
the relevant technical and non-technical skills, well-prepared for recruitment processes and the
transition to practice and enduring career success (Jackson 2016a, p. 927). Eliciting graduate
feedback about ‘work-readiness’ is therefore imperative to inform HE policy and VT curriculum
that meets stakeholder expectations.
However, based on the experiences of paramedicine in Australia, a lack of practical preparation
evident in previously vocational fields transitioning into HE, is a key concern for employers
accustomed to vocationally trained support staff (O’Brien et al. 2013; O’Brien et al. 2014), and
impedes graduate employability. According to Moodie et al. (2013), HE institutions need to engage
with key stakeholders, including employers, government (and professional bodies), to establish a
niche in the labour market for graduates in mid-tier occupations thus facilitating their employability.
By consulting with key stakeholders to promote ‘the benefits of the new role’ (Moodie et al. 2013,
p. 8), HE could reportedly reduce the potential for jurisdictional disturbances within the competing
professions, often related to perceived threats to the exclusivity of their work and expert body of
knowledge (Ressler 2011, p. 75). That said, the advent of VT was about advances in the veterinary
profession and meeting societal needs, and not about credentialism (Tomlinson 2008). To this end,
graduates, themselves, have a part to play by forging a professional identity, having a vision for the
future of their field and a commitment to developing their professional knowledge and practice
(Hagedorn 2004, p.130; Turner 2011): all of which can be nurtured through curriculum and HE
policy.
To date, there has been a paucity of literature about the development of veterinary paraprofessions
in Australasia and Asia (Clarke 2004; Clarke, Coleman & Schull 2009). Based on the experience of
other professions, the VT graduate voice would provide invaluable insights into the strengths and
weaknesses of the VT curriculum and graduate employability (Brady et al. 2012). Hence, the final
phase of this research project addressed the following research question: What can the long-term
VT graduate voice reveal about the facilitators and barriers to their employability and the
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 157
advancement of VT as a mid-tier, veterinary paraprofession in Australia? This study aimed to
recruit the VT graduate voice to inform HE initiatives in curriculum design, policy and stakeholder
engagement to underpin a mid-tier veterinary paraprofession integral to the future success of the
veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australasia. Dimensions of the graduate experience
explored included: (1) employment destinations and characteristics, (2) career development and
challenges, (3) issues relating to the professionalisation of the VT field, and, (4) ‘work-readiness’.
7.2.3 Methods
7.2.3.1 Survey
A cross-sectional online survey (Leavey 2017) using the SurveyMonkey platform
(http://www.surveymonkey.com) was conducted between November and December 2011 to explore
the demographics and experiences of all Australian VT graduates (2003-2010) (n = 165).
The questionnaire, developed for the study, was informed by a review of the literature (de
Laforcade et al. 2005; Eraut 1994; Fanning & Shepherd 2010) and unpublished data from VT final
year students’ evaluation surveys (2006, 2010), letters received from the VNCA (2007) and the
Veterinary Surgeons Board of Queensland (2006), and a study on professional writing skills of VT
undergraduates (Clarke et al. 2011). Pilot testing was performed with two veterinarians, a veterinary
academic and a veterinary nurse.
The questionnaire consisted of 37, mainly closed-ended, questions (Appendix 6) exploring graduate
socio-demographics (age, gender and year of graduation) and four dimensions of the graduate
experience (graduate employment, career development and challenges, professionalisation of VT
and feedback on curriculum). Career challenges were explored via one question with eight parts,
using a Likert-scale (1 – Very Unimportant to 5 – Very Important). Some questions employed Skip
Logic (https://www.surveymonkey.com/mp/tour/skiplogic/).
The questionnaire which took 10 to 15 minutes to complete was emailed out to all participants in
late November 2011. Student email addresses were sourced with permission from the university’s
alumni office or were personal knowledge of PC, the primary researcher. Questionnaire completion
indicated participant consent. Non-respondents were sent a reminder three weeks later. This study
was approved through the university’s human ethical review process (#2011001125) in accordance
with the National Health and Medical Research Council Act 1992, Australia (National Health and
Medical Research Council 2018).
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 158
7.2.3.2 Data analysis
The socio-demographic data for all respondents were summarised using descriptive statistics. Age
groups, gender distribution per age group and numbers of graduates by year of graduation were
summarised and expressed as a proportion. Reponses to multiple choice and dichotomous questions
were descriptively analysed and expressed as a proportion. Results for the Likert-type question
rating the importance of seven career challenges were presented as proportions of responses for
each Likert scale item.
Open-ended questions asking students’ views on the most important issues in the
professionalisation of VT, including impediments to its progress, and their ‘work-readiness’ on
graduation, were thematically analysed via an inductive approach based on a six-phase procedure
described by Clarke and Braun (2013). In phase 1, PC read responses (data items) several times to
become familiar with the data, and to make any meaningful observations. In phase 2, guided by the
question, initial codes were generated by systematically identifying relevant words or phrases in
every data item and then categorising these via a process of constant comparison across the data set
seeking recurring units, similarities and differences in the text. The codes were then collated with
their associated data extracts. In phase 3, the original coded data or categories were further analysed
and constructed into key themes. These themes were reviewed in relation to the coded extracts and
data set in phase 4 to ensure they told a fluent story. The essence of the themes was defined and final
names assigned in phase 5, followed by a write up of the themes with explanatory exemplars to tell
the story of the data in phase 6 (Clarke & Braun 2013).
Data collected regarding graduate perceptions of the five most important personal attributes and
technical skills for their current roles were thematically analysed using a deductive approach for the
technical skills data, with analysis guided by the researcher’s (PC) previous knowledge (Elo &
Kyngäs 2007) of the veterinary nursing training package (curriculum). Specific areas of veterinary
nursing, such as medical nursing and surgical nursing, became themes. The personal attributes were
analysed using an inductive approach to explore a little known topic within the discipline. As the
data in both cases were quantified, this translates into a form of content analysis (Elo & Kyngäs
2007). That said, according to Braun & Clarke (2013, p. 5), small ‘Q’ qualitative research can be
found where qualitative data is quantified. Thus, it is contentious whether content analysis can be
termed qualitative or quantitative research (Braun & Clarke 2013).
7.2.4 Results
Of the 165 surveys emailed, 50 useable responses provided a final response rate of 30.3%.
Respondents represented all graduating cohorts (2003-2010) with the highest participation from
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 159
2004 and 2007 (18%; 9/50 each) and the lowest from 2009 (6%; 3/50). Socio-demographics of the
responding graduates are described in Table 7-1.
Table 7-1: Socio-demographic characteristics of VT graduates.
Age groups
(years)
Number (Percentages) N (%)
Total Male Female
20-25 17 (34.0) 1 (2.0) 16 (32.0)
26-30 26 (52.0) 2 (4.0) 24 (48.0)
31-35 4 (8.0) 0 (0.0) 4 (8.0)
36-40 2 (4.0) 1 (2.0) 1 (2.0)
41-45 1 (2.0) 0 (0.0) 1 (2.0)
Total persons 50 (100.0) 4 (8.0) 46 (92.0)
7.2.4.1 Employment destinations and characteristics
Eighty-eight percent of respondents were employed in the veterinary and allied animal health fields.
Veterinary practice, including general, specialist referral and teaching hospitals, was the largest
employment sector (48%; 24/50). The allied animal health industries (veterinary nutrition and
pharmaceutical companies, animal welfare agencies, animal research facilities, veterinary
laboratories) accounted for 18% (9/50) of employment and government agencies, such as the
Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, Queensland (2018), Department of Agriculture and Water
Resources, Australia (2017), employed 14% (7/50). Eight percent (4/50) taught in HE (VT) or
vocational education (veterinary nursing) and 12% (6/50) were in non-veterinary fields.
Almost a third (30%; 8/24) of those working in veterinary practice were in advanced roles such as
head nurse, training coordinator, practice manager/owner or nursing manager and two had
completed veterinary science degrees. Three conducted nursing clinics (dental,
puppy/kitten/vaccinations, clinical nutrition, dental and behaviour). Two thirds were in urban
veterinary practices, with the remainder almost evenly distributed between rural and regional
practices.
The majority of respondents (56%; 28/50) were in permanent, full-time work. This included all
graduates working in government agencies and HE. Of those who responded to the current salary
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 160
question, HE employees earned the highest median incomes and veterinary support staff, the lowest
(Table 7-2).
Table 7-2: Current VT graduate salary ranges by employment sector (full-time permanent or full-
time contract employment).
Employment sector Salary - Median & Range (AUD$)
All fields (n = 28)
Veterinary practice (n = 13)
Government agencies (n = 5)
Allied animal health fields (n = 5)
HE & vocational education (n = 4)
Other (non-veterinary field) (n = 1)
55,000 (30,000 - 100,000)
44,000 (30,000 - 60,000)
63,000 (50,000 - 100,000)
60,000 (55,000 - 70,000)
65,500 (60,000 - 82,000)
49,000 (49,000)
Overall, graduate salaries increased with years of experience. Graduates (2003-2006) (n = 5)
working in veterinary practice had a median salary of AUD$42,000 compared to AUD$36,000 for
graduates (2007-2010) (n = 8). In government agencies, the median graduate salary (2003-2006) (n
= 3) was AUD$9,000 more than a (2007-2010) graduate (n = 1). The median graduate salaries
overall were AUD$60,000 in 2003-2006 (n = 16) and AUD$44,500 for (2007-2010) (n = 12). The
majority of graduates (80%; 41/50) received additional employment benefits with discounted
services/products most prevalent (76%; 31/41) and often packaged with continuing professional
development. One graduate, a practice owner/manager, received business dividends.
For the twenty-six respondents who chose an employment field other than veterinary practice,
higher salary (82%; 22/26) was the most commonly cited reason, with ‘higher salary’, ‘more
benefits’ and ‘more suited to career goals’ often grouped together. Other motives included a
disinterest in clinical practice, job satisfaction, career advancement, lifestyle, and unable to gain
employment.
7.2.4.2 Career development and challenges
The majority of graduates (68%; 34/50) had completed, or were completing, further qualifications
with many (26%; 13/50) involved in multiple courses of study. HE qualifications included doctoral
studies (veterinary parasitology, emergency management) (4%; 2/50), a masters’ degree (animal
science, adult education, business, nutrition and dietetics) (8%; 4/50), a research honours year
(veterinary parasitology, human parasitology, veterinary microbiology, genetics) (8%; 4/50),
bachelor’s degrees (veterinary science and others) (22%;11/50), post-graduate certificates
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 161
(education) and diplomas (education and veterinary public health). Twenty (40%) had undertaken
vocational certificates or diplomas, and/or industry-specific training, such as AUSVETPLAN
(Animal Health Australia 2019), sales and marketing, meat inspection or dog training. Eight (16%)
had completed or were completing the Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing. Of these, four currently
worked in veterinary practice and two were in related fields (vocational education and animal
welfare). Graduates completed the certificate to improve employability and salary, gain recognition
by the VNCA, receive continuing education benefits or to satisfy an employment requirement.
Graduates working in clinical practice embraced the notion of evidence-based practice. Of these, 21
respondents (76%) reported they understood the concept and approximately 52% provided an
example. Approximately half of those demonstrated a clear understanding of the concept [VT1]:
‘Reviewing the literature about cases seen and particularly the reviews that use large collections of
published information to draw together the best practice for the cases seen’.
Although very few respondents had published in peer or non-peer-reviewed journals following
graduation, almost half had presented at a conference or seminar.
Graduates viewed all seven of the nominated challenges they could face in their VT career as
important, with lack of career advancement, recognition by the veterinary nursing profession, and
salary level rated as the greatest challenges (Table 7-3).
Table 7-3: VT graduates’ ratings of the importance of career challenges.
Career challenge Graduate rating* N (%)
Low
importance
(1-3)
High
Importance
(4 & 5)
Total (N)
Lack of career advancement 9 (18.0) 41 (82.0) 50 (100)
Recognition by veterinary nursing
profession
10 (20.0) 40 (80.0) 50 (100)
Salary level 11 (22.0) 39 (78.0) 50 (100)
Recognition by veterinary profession 12 (24.0) 38 (76.0) 50 (100)
Acceptance in veterinary workplace 17 (34.0) 33 (66.0) 50 (100)
Job burnout 18 (36.0) 32 (64.0) 50 (100)
Continuing professional development 19 38.0) 31 (62.0) 50 (100)
*1- Very Unimportant; 2 – Unimportant; 3- Neutral; 4 – Important; 5 – Very Important
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 162
7.2.4.3 Progressing professionalisation
Graduates’ viewed the professionalisation of VT through four overarching themes: the role of
professions, HE, government and graduates. Figure 7-2 provides a visual representation of the
themes and sub-themes that are discussed below using exemplars of graduate responses.
Figure 7-2: Key themes and sub-themes relevant to the professionalisation of VT in Australia.
The role of the professions
Graduates viewed the lack of recognition by the professional bodies, the AVA and the VNCA, as a
major barrier to the progression of VT [VT2]: ‘The failure of the AVA and the Vet Nurses’ Council
to recognise (VT) as part of the profession is pretty important’. It resulted in some graduates [VT3]:
‘…having to complete a lower level course to be recognised to work as a vet nurse, despite having a
degree’. In response, graduates called for ‘recognition by the AVA and VSB (Veterinary Surgeons
Board) that the vet tech degree is above the level of TAFE (Technical and Further Education) and
similarly trained nurses’ [VT4]. Many graduates felt their skills were underutilised while others
believed they were perceived as a jurisdictional threat by nurses and veterinarians [VT5]: ‘Patch
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 163
protection from veterinarians initially then from veterinary nurses. Lack of recognition that (VT) is
a veterinary paraprofession’. Many perceived educating veterinarians as a key to breaking down
these jurisdictional barriers [VT6]:
A lot of vets (are) unable to release jobs that are able to be performed by a technician. This may be a
control issue or a trust issue on behalf of the veterinarian. I feel that educating the vets on the vet
tech programme and showing them that vet techs have developed skills and knowledge to perform
these tasks will help.
Others linked the lack of recognition to the fledgling status of the discipline [VT7]:
I think that veterinary technology is not fully recognised by the veterinary industry in Australia like
it is in other countries … as it is a relatively new part of the industry being introduced in this
country.
One graduate perceived the lack of professional recognition as part of a ‘bigger picture’ where
[VT8]:
The wider public does not see the veterinary industry as being very important. I think we need some
sort of government subsidy so that the public who may have financial issues are able to treat their
pets.
Some graduates were optimistic about the future of VT with [VT9], ‘Changing trends from a one
vet practice to larger multi-vet practices (creating) greater demand for professionals with a skill
level above that of traditional vet nurses’. Likewise, the increase in job advertisements for
technicians was viewed as a sign of acceptance [VT10]:
When I graduated in 2005, the vet industry didn’t really know what vet techs were all about.
However, more and more jobs are being advertised for vet techs/nurses which is really positive.
The role of higher education
This theme depicted the multi-faceted role of HE in advancing VT through curriculum design,
stakeholder engagement and policy-making. Many graduates viewed increased practical skills
training and work placement in curriculum as a key to success [VT11]:
Lack of work experience for most but not all students… The vet tech grads who do the best seem to
be the ones who have had a greater degree of exposure to the industry.
While others suggested curricular improvements including veterinary nursing competencies and
specialisations [VT12]:
It would be great if this course not only allowed graduates to graduate with all the vet nursing
qualifications but even more than that so that they can manage veterinary clinics.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 164
Specialisations were viewed as a key to employability [VT13]:
Vet techs need to have a focus of specialisation They need to specialise in one of the areas where
they are most likely to be used such as emergency and critical care, anaesthesia or practice
management: maybe this could be offered as a coursework honours year.
One graduate envisioned the benefits of globalisation and international benchmarking of curriculum
[VT14]:
Australia is lagging behind some other countries (i.e. USA, UK) in the Veterinary Technology
profession. We need to follow in their footsteps and build up the Veterinary Technology …to a very
high standard. Graduates should be very well skilled and knowledgeable.
The role of HE in raising the public profile of VT, through promoting the degree and graduate
capabilities to key stakeholders, was also seen as a key facilitator, not only in Queensland, but
throughout Australia [15]. It still appeared that, ‘outside of teaching institutions people didn't really
understand how the role of a veterinary technologist differed from a veterinary nurse’ [VT15].
Employer awareness was also identified as pivotal to graduate employability [VT16]:
We need to create awareness of what veterinary technology' is and who we are. Many employers do
not know who we are or what we can do - and thus can be quite hesitant about employing
technicians.
The role of government
Graduates recognised the government’s role in legitimising VT by endorsing it as a distinct
workforce model in an award (outlines minimum pay rates and conditions) (Fair Work Commission
2018), in legislation and through registration of its graduates. However, limited endorsement by
governments, to date, was seen as another barrier [VT17]:
(There is) still confusion in the industry as to the difference between a veterinary technologist and a
veterinary nurse. (There is a) lack of appropriate wage award reflecting the level of education and
expertise that veterinary technologists have.
Some interpreted this as a poor return on investment in education [VT18]:
For me it is the wage. I don't feel that we get paid enough for the amount of study and effort that
goes into the job once qualified, especially after incurring several thousands of dollars in (Higher
Education Contribution Scheme) debt.
Whereas, others saw national registration as a way forward [VT19]: ‘Wide spread recognition of
veterinary technology within the veterinary Industry and across allied animal industries and
government bodies. Perhaps national registration may assist with this’.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 165
VT graduates as ‘agents’ of professionalisation
A few graduates recognised their important role in advancing VT [VT20]:
If they (graduates) desire higher pay and better job situations they need to understand how to make
themselves valuable to a clinic using their skills and attitude’ and exert influence by ‘…act(ing) in a
clinic situation, with professionalism and initiative.
Being able to confidently articulate the VT role was also seen as integral to forging a professional
identity [VT21]: ‘Teaching vet techs to define their roles accurately so they can set themselves apart
when asked “What is a vet tech?”’
7.2.4.4 Curriculum and ‘work-readiness’
Graduates’ perceptions of curriculum areas relevant to their ‘work-readiness’ were captured in
seven themes (‘practical skills’, ‘knowledge’, ‘communication’, ‘critical thinking/problem-solving’,
‘research skills’, ‘professionalism’ and ‘employability’). The graduates felt well prepared in areas
that were more aligned with the academic curriculum and deficits were more contextualised or
applied. The themes and sub-themes associated with graduate ‘work-readiness’ are outlined in
Table 7-4.
Overall, graduates identified more curricular areas as well-prepared with some graduates indicating
they felt well-prepared for all aspects of their employment. Many highlighted ‘practical skills, more
practical work should be incorporated into the degree [VT22]’. Others were satisfied with specific
areas of practical training [VT23]: ‘The extensive training that I undertook in the emergency centre
best prepared me for my job.’ Other areas identified were [VT24, 25]: ‘Knowledge of HR and
business management…I was able to move quickly in the company with these skills as opposed to
just having veterinary skills’, and ‘…I believe the vet tech programme helped me to develop my
skills … particularly with disease investigation work as well as emergency response, i.e. PPE and
taking samples safely’. Skills gaps pertained primarily to veterinary nursing competencies, large
animal health, animal handling and post-mortems, business/practice management, project
management and employment in laboratories.
Many graduates were confident in their underpinning knowledge in all areas—especially anatomy
and physiology, anaesthetics, radiology and pathology [VT26]. Clinical knowledge also met the
needs of some [VT27]: ‘… the lectures in third year provided a great introduction to the important,
common diseases and routines we would come across in the clinic’. Knowledge gaps were
primarily related to veterinary nursing and, to a lesser extent, production animals.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 166
Graduates identified a broad range of communication skills (oral, written and technology) as
relevant to employability with most gaps pertaining to contextualised applications. Critical
thinking/problem-solving, research skills and professionalism were also viewed as important.
The ‘employability’ theme overlapped with the practical skills theme. Graduates valued their
networking opportunities and industry exposure, and found [VT28] ‘Word of mouth within
Queensland about the degree, (opened) up job opportunities’. Similarly, employment preparation,
involving resume writing, interviews and addressing selection criteria, was also positively
acknowledged. One graduate felt prepared for the challenges of a new discipline [VT29] – ‘simply
having a bachelor’s degree in an area that previously didn’t have one, I was unique’.
Table 7-4: Themes and sub-themes elucidated from VT graduates’ perceptions of areas ‘best’ and
‘least’ prepared for employment.
Curriculum theme ‘Best’ prepared ‘Least’ prepared
Professionalism Attitudes
Conduct
Best practice Best practice
Communication Oral
- public speaking - oral presentation skills
- conducting interviews - client advising - grief counselling - customer service
Written
- scientific writing - report writing
- government reports
Technology
- PowerPoint presentations - Practice management software
Research skills Sourcing information
Evidence-based practice
Knowledge Applied knowledge
- first principles - theory and understanding of vet’s
decision-making
- knowledge application - premium diets - product knowledge
Underpinning knowledge
- anatomy and physiology - biosecurity - human resources and business
management - immunology - nutrition - pathology - parasitology
- animal welfare codes - biosecurity (disease investigation) - large animal health - microbiology, serology - pathophysiology - project management - sales - stocktaking
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 167
- pharmacology and therapeutics - radiography - small and large animal health
- veterinary practice management
Practical skills Program structure
- year 3 practical classes - years 1 and 2 need more practical
Veterinary nursing skills
- emergency nursing - medical nursing - surgical nursing and anaesthesia
- advanced medical and emergency skills
- basic nursing skills - clinical teaching - reception - sales
Work placements - animal research facilities - animal shelters - clinical and emergency rotations
- company representatives - laboratories - small clinics
‘day to day’ working of production animal enterprises
Employability Networking
- Industry networking and exposure - awareness of broader career options
Job preparation
- adaptability, flexibility - addressing selection criteria - interviewing skills - résumé writing - critical thinking and problem-solving
- human resource issues (e.g. sexual harassment)
- fast pace of workplace - shift work
New HE discipline
- trailblazers - unique
- employability of more educated nurses
7.2.4.5 Important personal attributes and technical skills for VT graduates
Graduate perceptions of the five most important personal attributes and technical skills for current
roles are provided in Table 7-5 and Table 7-6, respectively.
Table 7-5: Graduate (n = 50) responses regarding ‘the five (5) most important personal attributes for
(their) current role’.
Intrapersonal attributes
Professionalism n Others n n
• Work autonomously (11) • Initiative (36) • Efficient (3)
• Professionalism/professi
onal behaviour/attitude
(9) • Flexibility/adaptabil
ity
(11) • Enthusiasm (3)
• Knowledgeable (3) • Confidence (8) • Organised (3)
• Responsible/accountable (3) • Conscientious (7) • Creative (2)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 168
• Ethical (1) • Self-motivated (5) • Fast learner (2)
• Common sense (4) • Organised (3)
• Sense of humour (4) • Optimistic (2)
• Work well under
pressure
(4) • Curiosity for
learning, intuitive,
knows limitations,
multi-tasking,
observant, passion,
resilient
(1)
Interpersonal attributes
Professionalism n Others n n
• Teamwork
• Communication
• Empathy, compassionate
• Leadership
(29)
(19)
(11)
(6)
• Interpersonal skills
• Agreeable
• Cooperative
• Considerate
(8)
(3)
(3)
(2)
• Follows
instructions
• Patient, respectful,
supportive,
trustworthy
(2)
(1)
Table 7-6: Graduate (n = 50) responses regarding ‘the five (5) most important technical skills for
(their) current role’.
Category Skills
Veterinary nursing
• Emergency &
critical care
Triage, patient monitoring & monitoring equipment (n = 5)
CPR, urinary catheterisation (male and female) (n = 3)
Invasive blood pressure monitoring, arterial catheterisation, placing
nasogastric tubes (n = 1)
• Medical
Clinical pathology [sample collection (n = 30); techniques (n = 14)]
Animal handling (n = 22)
IV catheter placement (n = 21)
Patient monitoring & nursing care (n = 11)
Radiography (n = 10)
Bandaging & wound management (n = 4)
Clinical examination, fluid therapy (n = 3)
Stock control (n = 2)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 169
Patient admission & discharge (n = 1)
• Surgical
Anaesthesia & analgesia (n = 21)
Surgical aseptic techniques (n = 6)
Surgical nursing skills, surgical patient preparation (n = 2), Theatre
preparation, surgical assistance, pre- and post-operative patient care
(all n = 1),
• Wildlife Care of wildlife & euthanasia of wildlife (n = 1)
Communication Report writing (n = 7)
Communicating with clients & professional colleagues (n = 5)
Record-keeping, computer skills & software packages (n = 4)
Communicating with difficult clients, written presentation skills,
veterinary terminology, history taking (n = 2)
Negotiation skills, email etiquette (n = 1)
Government agencies Necropsy techniques & sample collection (n = 4)
Applying legislation & animal welfare codes of practice (n = 2)
Assessing animal health, animal welfare, disease investigations,
liaising with vets & farmers and biosecurity (n = 1)
Business management Management (n = 3)
Finance, veterinary practice operations, writing standard operating
procedures and writing risk assessments (n = 1)
Graduate attributes Research skills (n = 5)
Problem-solving, teamwork, working autonomously (n = 2)
Therapeutics Drug dose calculations (n = 9)
Drug preparation & administration (n = 3)
Drug dose rates, drug knowledge (n = 2)
Knowledge/Theory Anatomy& physiology, nutrition, animal health (n = 1)
Self-management Organisational skills (n = 3)
Stress management (n = 2)
Time management skills (n = 1)
Customer service Customer relations (n = 5)
Reception skills (n = 4)
Teaching skills Teaching skills (n = 1)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 170
7.2.5 Discussion
This is the first study to recruit the long-term VT graduate voice in Australia, characterising
graduates’ employment roles, career development and challenges, professionalisation, and ‘work-
readiness’. As well as being a quality assurance tool (Hobson et al. 2008), the graduate voice has
proved essential in auditing a practice-based programme to improve it, shape graduate professional
identity, and foster career satisfaction and retention (Brady et al. 2012). Graduates revealed the
relative stability of the VT graduate profile and employment destinations, with the majority being in
full-time employment within the veterinary and allied animal health fields, affirming that there was
a niche for this mid-tier discipline in Australia. Our results also revealed that a lack of career
advancement, lack of recognition by the relevant professions, and low salaries in the clinical field
were barriers to success. These findings signalled a need for curriculum renewal to introduce a dual-
sector curriculum (Moodie 2010), embedding vocational veterinary nursing competencies in the VT
degree, which would lead to the professional bodies formally recognising veterinary nursing as a
VT employment outcome.
Results of VT employment destinations concurred with earlier reports from Australia, NZ, and
Japan (Clarke, Coleman & Schull 2009), and anecdotally these appeared to have been maintained
over time (Massey University 2018; UQ 2018a). Findings that at least one-third of graduates
working in clinical practice were in leadership roles, such as practice ownership, practice
management, nursing management and training coordination, supported the importance of
leadership and management training in curriculum. The small numbers teaching vocational
veterinary nursing and VT in HE indicated expanding career pathways and a maturing discipline
with opportunities for VT dual degree programmes, or post-graduate qualifications, not only in
education, but also in areas such as business/management or project management. Many of these
offerings, including a dual degree in Agribusiness/VT, are now available (UQ 2018e) and will not
only grow student recruitment potential but also enhance graduate employability in an expanding
labour market.
Despite the uptake of VT graduates into clinical leadership roles, low salaries were a challenge for
those working as veterinary technicians, particularly in comparison to salaries in government
agencies and education. This finding was not surprising, as recent surveys of veterinary nursing in
the UK (2014) and veterinary technicians in the USA (NAVTA 2018b) reveal wages are still one of
the challenges of the job. This aligns with research in Australia and overseas linking female-
dominated fields with a wage ‘gap’ amounting to lower starting salaries and future earning potential
of graduates (Lindsay 2014). Likewise, a study of the labour market for USA credentialled VT
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 171
specialists revealed males having a higher likelihood of greater pay (Norkus, Liss & Leighton
2016): a trend reflected in salaries of the albeit, small number of males in this study. To improve
salaries overall, Australian veterinarians could delegate more effectively to utilise the enhanced
skill set of these support personnel. Research shows this would benefit not only practice income
(Fanning & Shepherd 2007, p. 846; Veterinary Business Advisors 2013), but also, support
personnel retention and career satisfaction (Hancock & Schubert 2007; Liss 2012; VN Futures
Action Group 2016).
Another interesting, salary-related finding was that graduates thought working in government
agencies warranted higher salaries than clinical practice roles. This devaluing of the work of clinical
support personnel may be linked to graduates’ perceived lack of recognition by the veterinary and
veterinary nursing professions, as well as the broader context of declining veterinary earnings in
comparison to other professions (AVA 2015, p.10). Although salary level was identified as a career
challenge that likely drove graduates to choose employment outside clinical practice—the lack of
career advancement was viewed by the majority of graduates as the most important challenge. This
echoes the views of British veterinary nurses who are leaving the profession ‘because they did not
feel their career aspirations could be met’ (Honey 2016, p.162). In response to this crisis, the BVNA
(2018) and RCVS launched a Veterinary Nursing Futures Project in 2016 (VN Futures Action
Group 2016) to increase the sustainability of their workforce via more rewarding career pathways,
with specialised roles such as a ‘nurse practitioner’ and ‘consultant nurse’ (Honey 2016, p.162).
Similar developments have been reported for VT in the USA (Chadderdon, Lloyd & Pazak 2014)
and evidenced in the Australian VT graduates’ call for specialisations to enhance the utilisation of
their skills, improve their wages and career advancement.
Arguably, the lack of career advancement could also be linked to graduates’ perceptions that the
veterinary and veterinary nursing professions did not recognise their skill set. As the development
of professional identity—or sense of belonging to a professional community (Trede, Macklin &
Bridges 2012)—hinges on new disciplines being accepted within their field (Atherton 2016;
Jackson 2016b), this lack of recognition would adversely impact graduates’ professional identity.
The lack of recognition could also reflect a response to a perceived encroachment on other’s
professional jurisdictions (Ressler 2011), as noted in graduates’ comments that veterinarians lacked
trust in their capabilities and nurses saw them as competition. According to Ressler (2011, p. 152),
jurisdictional contests are not uncommon as a profession’s tasks change, particularly with
technological advances, and over time they resolve by ‘professionalisation of a nonprofessional
occupation, by de-professionalisation of a professional group, or by internal changes within a
profession’. This resonates with the VT story in Australia and highlights that even though mid-tier
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 172
qualifications can facilitate the professionalisation and upskilling of occupations, their success is
reliant upon collaboration amongst educational institutions, employers, government (Moodie et al.
2013, p.9) and, importantly, professional bodies.
Freidson (1970), from the sociology of professions, asserted that professionalisation of an
occupation involves convincing government legislators and the public of the importance of its work.
Successfully professionalised health care occupations must therefore not only meet the criteria for
traditional professions but also engage in the politics of professionalisation (Mahoney 2003). The
success of physiotherapy, human nursing (Mahoney 2003), and now veterinary nursing in the UK
(RCVS 2015a), provides a precedent for other female dominated fields. In these professions,
registration served as a pivotal political tactic for recognition through controlling ‘qualification, pay
and conditions of work’ (Mahoney 2003, p.6). VT graduates were cognisant of the power of politics
and the pivotal role of government in advancing VT through legislation, an award for wages and
national registration. HE could play a key role in facilitating the registration of VT graduates by
working collaboratively with government and professional bodies. Furthermore, the experience of
other more recently professionalised occupations, such as dental hygiene, demonstrates that a clear
and convincing public image needs to be established to promote VT within the professional and
legislative community (Jongbloed-Zoet et al. 2012; Ressler 2011, p.158). This could be achieved
through a more entrepreneurial approach to marketing of the programme, as adopted by many HE
institutions as part of their economic activity (Grotkowska, Wincenciak & Gajderowicz 2015,
p.872).
Freidson (2001) concurs that universities are responsible for promoting a profession’s public
identity and in preparing students for the qualification, contribute to their professional identity
(Freidson cited in Ressler 2011, p.156). Based on feedback from graduates, and letters from the
veterinary nursing (VNCA 2007) and veterinary professional bodies (Veterinary Surgeons Board of
Queensland 2006), the recognition of VT graduates and, therefore their professional identity, would
be enhanced by a change in policy regarding a dual-sector curriculum, embedding vocational
veterinary nursing competencies within the academic curriculum (Moodie 2010). This would be
analogous to the UK HE veterinary nursing curricula (RVC 2017), and the more recent Bachelor of
VT from CSU in Australia (2015).
That said, the move from a more traditional, academic curriculum towards a more vocational,
functional curriculum (Peach 2010, p.450), warrants a significant change for a traditional, research-
intensive university. Considering the cultural, funding and curricular differences between the HE
and vocational education sectors in Australia, it would present challenges (Wheelahan 2000; Fowler
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 173
2017). On the other hand, a dual-sector curriculum would open up articulation pathways for
vocationally qualified veterinary nurses to transfer into the VT degree: supporting Australia’s
agenda for widening HE participation (Dawson, Charman, & Kilpatrick 2013). Rigour could be
added by establishing an external accreditation system for quality assurance of VT programmes in
Australasia, similar to the veterinary schools in the region. Ties between HE and the professions
could be strengthened by professional bodies providing input into accreditation criteria and having
representation on the committee (Australasian Veterinary Boards Council 2017). In response to the
graduate voice, an Australasian VT accreditation system could be aligned with international
accrediting bodies such as the RCVS in the UK, which has recently developed a framework for
accrediting international programmes (RCVS 2015b)—leading to international standing and
enhanced graduate mobility.
Equally as important as the role of HE, governments and professional bodies in advancing the
professionalisation of VT, were the small number of VT graduates who recognised the power
residing in their ability to promote their skills and capabilities in practice. As reported from
occupational therapy, graduates of an emergent profession must develop a confidence and positivity
about their roles and understand that ‘emerging is about becoming visible’, with each graduate
taking responsibility for the development of professional knowledge and the skills of practice
(Hagedorn 2004, p.129). This argument aligns with the claim that in the new reality of HE, with
expanding graduate numbers and rapidly evolving work environments, graduates need to be
empowered to ‘grow’ or develop their roles by taking ‘ownership of the work process’ (Harvey
2000, p.6). To this end, the graduate attributes which differentiate VT graduates from vocationally
qualified veterinary nurses are vitally important. Accordingly, in addition to the traditional
attributes of communication, teamwork and interpersonal skills, (VT) graduates need to
demonstrate initiative, self-motivation, self-confidence, self-management, lifelong learning,
research capability and the flexibility/adaptability to respond to change and lead change within the
workplace (Harvey 2000, p. 8; Osmani et al. 2015), Some of these were identified by the graduates
in this study as key attributes for their current roles. As many of these attributes are developed in
the workplace (Mason, Williams & Cranmer 2009), a VT curriculum requires extended periods of
structured WIL. WIL could also contribute to graduates’ confidence to articulate and demonstrate to
employers what they can do, and to develop their professional identity (Holmes 2001, p.117).
Many VT graduates recognised the importance of WIL in curriculum by calling for more practical
skills and work placements, predominantly in clinics, to enhance their ‘work-readiness’. This
finding mirrors the experience of other emerging professions, such as paramedicine in facing the
challenges of establishing the discipline in academia, as well as meeting the expectations of
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 174
stakeholders entrenched in a vocational, work-based training system (O’Brien 2013). However, as
Cooper (2002, p.466) from HE veterinary nursing in the UK asserted, this problem should not be
insurmountable because ‘being in possession of information, insight or understanding’ should not
‘stop good practical skills’. Subsequently, in response to the identified practical skills gap, the 2011
curriculum review extended the duration of clinical rotations in final year from three to 10 weeks
and recommended increasing the extramural placement in the first two years, from 6 weeks to 12
weeks (School of Veterinary Science Teaching & Learning Committee 2011)—aligning overall
WIL hours with the UK HE veterinary nursing curriculum models (RCVS 2018i). The former was
adopted, and as mentioned by Trish Farry, a current VT coordinator, 10 February 2018, a rural
veterinary practice rotation has recently been added, responding to an ongoing need for technicians
in Australian rural veterinary services (Frawley 2003).
In addition to changes to WIL, the paucity of graduate publications, critical to building a VT body
of knowledge, affirmed the need for a four-year VT curriculum based on the UK HE model to
enhance research-capability. This would also facilitate the development of specialisations
commensurate with mid-tier status, further differentiating VT from vocational veterinary nursing
and enhancing graduate employability. The introduction of a tailored VT research honours year in
2016 has opened a pathway to clinical specialisations through advanced professional training in
clinical and other paraprofessional areas (UQ 2018f).
Employability has always been a focus of VT curriculum with resume writing, interview skills and
industry networking (Jackson 2014) reported by graduates as well addressed. Industry networking,
provided through work placements and alumni careers sessions, and now viewed as a responsibility
of HE, increases the likelihood of a better return on investment in education for graduates
(Tomlinson 2008). The ongoing expansion of WIL will further hone this important employability
skill for graduates of an emerging paraprofession.
In addition, the observed high percentage of VT graduates’ attaining additional qualifications in
their field fits with a desire to ‘value-add’ to their credentials to gain an advantage in the labour
market (Tomlinson 2008). It also evidences their self-motivation, commitment to lifelong learning
and willingness to take ownership of their career development—resonating with Barnett’s (2007)
‘will to learn’ and strengthening the VT niche within the veterinary and allied animal health fields.
The limitations of this study should be considered. The data collection method (online survey) and
the anonymity given to participants were designed to reduce bias. However, as a teacher and
coordinator of the final year VT programme (2003-2010), PC had a student–teacher relationship
with all participants, which could have influenced both the recruitment of participants and analysis
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 175
of results. A higher percentage of respondents may have provided a more accurate picture of the
graduate experience. Nevertheless, comparing demographic data from previous studies, the survey
sample was representative of the VT graduate population.
7.2.6 Conclusion
In summary, the results of this study identified a stable VT graduate employment profile, with the
majority of graduates in full-time employment within the veterinary and allied animal health
industries, affirming a niche for a mid-tier veterinary paraprofession in Australia. The VT graduate
voice recognised the pivotal role of HE in advancing VT professionalisation through curriculum,
stakeholder engagement and policy-making. Key findings also revealed barriers to graduate success
at the time were lack of career advancement, lack of recognition by the relevant professions and
government, low salaries in the clinical field and the limitations of practical training and exposure
to the clinical field. These all indicated a need for curriculum renewal and the implementation of a
dual-sector curriculum with the veterinary nursing competencies embedded in the degree. Since a
curriculum review in 2011, advances have been made with an ongoing expansion in WIL, the
introduction of a VT research honours programme and a dual-sector curriculum under
consideration.
Future research directions could include a survey comparing Australasian VT programmes
articulated through the graduate voice.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 176
8 Discussion and Conclusion
8.1 Context
In a globalising world of increasing societal demands for quality veterinary care (Brown &
Silverman, 1999; Willis et al. 2007; National Research Council 2013) driven by a more educated
clientele (Willis et al. 2007; Page-Jones & Abbey 2015) and the power of the HAB (Fogle 1999;
Chuer-Hansen 2010), university educated veterinary support personnel, such as veterinary
technologists, are an imperative—not an option—to complement and sustain the Australian
veterinary profession, nationally and internationally. Consequently, veterinary teamwork is growing
in importance; paraprofessionals need to collaborate with veterinarians, veterinary specialists, and
affiliated professionals using advanced technology and evidence-based practice to deliver this
increasingly complex veterinary health care (Kinnison, May & Guile 2014). Global trends also
affirm the call for veterinary paraprofessionals; veterinary nursing in the UK recently achieved full
professional status, and currently there are fourteen institutions offering RCVS accredited four-year
HE veterinary nursing degrees (RCVS 2018e). The USA boasts 22 AVMA CVTEA-accredited
four-year bachelor’s degrees in VT (AVMA 2018c) and the professionalisation of VT is gaining
momentum as veterinary technicians seek national standardisation of their credentials and title
(Veterinary Nurse Initiative 2016, 2018). Likewise, voluntary registration of NZ veterinary nurses
and veterinary technologists instigated in 2014 represents a move towards professionalisation
(NZVNA 2016a, 2016b). Concomitantly, other sectors have recognised a niche for highly skilled
veterinary paraprofessionals conducting animal surveillance and disease control in the event of
national and international pandemics (Homeland Security Council 2006), and in implementing
strategies to eliminate the risk of zoonoses such as rabies in endemic areas (ASEAN 2016). If
Australia is to remain internationally competitive and at the forefront of veterinary research and
practice, it needs to embrace change and reap the benefits of HE educated veterinary support
personnel.
In turn, HE takes considerable responsibility when designing curricula and pedagogy to underpin
the success of emerging paraprofessions, such as VT, in a rapidly changing world. Accordingly,
many ‘lessons can be learned’ from former paraprofessions, such as human nursing, about
curriculum design and developing industry partnerships to support training (Sax 1978; Reid 1994);
elements that are vital to graduate employability in mid-tier occupations (Moodie et al. 2013). In
addition, an era of student consumers expecting employability from HE, employers wanting ‘work-
ready’ graduates, and clients demanding quality service in partnership with professionals, demands
a holistic approach to a curriculum for a paraprofession.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 177
This means focusing not only on disciplinary knowledge and skills, but also on professional ways
of ‘being’ in practice for both individuals and collectively for the paraprofession (Barnett 2004;
Barnett & Coate 2005; Barnett 2009; Dall’Alba 2009a, 2009b).
This thesis aimed to examine the short term and long-term outcomes of an emerging HE veterinary
paraprofessional course, to garner key stakeholder perspectives on desirable attributes for VT
graduates, to analyse the barriers and facilitators to the paraprofession’s success, and thereby inform
a framework for curriculum and pedagogy.
In achieving these aims, the thesis documents the genesis of VT in the veterinary and allied animal
health fields in Australia. Telling the VT story contributes to the literature by documenting a
vignette in the history of Australian HE and elucidates the development of curriculum and
pedagogy to frame a new, mid-tier qualification underpinning an emerging profession.
8.2 Summary of research questions
This thesis addressed 5 research questions to achieve its aims:
1. What are the demographics and employment destinations of the first three UQ VT
graduate cohorts (2003-2005) for a mid-tier, emerging veterinary profession in the
veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australia and how do these compare with
global trends? (Chapter 3).
2. How efficacious is a pedagogical intervention about knowledge production—which
links assessment in a professional communication course to students’ clinical
practicum—in developing VT students’ professional attributes and skills, including a
capacity for research and professional writing, and inspiring them to publish in the
scholarly literature after graduation? (Chapter 4)
3. What messages for HE curriculum and pedagogy can be garnered from key stakeholders
with respect to desirable personal attributes and technical skills for VT graduates?
(Chapter 5)
4. What messages for HE curriculum and pedagogy can be garnered from key stakeholders
with respect to teamwork attributes and skills for VT graduates? (Chapter 6)
5. What can the long-term VT graduate voice reveal about the facilitators and barriers to
their employability and the advancement of VT as a mid-tier, emerging veterinary
profession in Australia? (Chapter 7)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 178
8.3 Summary of results and implications for advancement of VT
Figure 8-1 provides a visual summary of the major findings of this thesis project, or ‘lessons
learned’, across the five studies. It highlights three essential, inter-related areas of responsibility for
HE in advancing the development of a paraprofession—building a curriculum, supported by
appropriate policies, and industry/professional partnerships. These findings, which would be
transferable to other paraprofessions or emerging professions, indicate the complexities of the
process of establishing a new paraprofessional discipline in HE, and, importantly, within its
professional community. Each study highlighted pivotal elements of this important triad of HE roles
and their inter-relationships.
Study 1 (Chapter 3; Clarke, Schull & Coleman 2009) addressed the first research question that
sought to determine the employment niche and demographics of the emerging VT paraprofession in
Australia and place it in a global context. Important findings were the high graduate employment
rate (89%) that assigned some legitimacy to VT as a nascent, mid-tier veterinary occupation, and to
a certain extent, the effectiveness of the VT curriculum in preparing graduates for labour market
needs. As veterinary practices (general and specialist) were found to be the largest employment
sector, and with no apparent undersupply of veterinary nurses reported at that time (Department of
Employment and Workplace Relations 2003), findings confirmed a demand for university-educated
veterinary support personnel in veterinary practices. Additionally, the observed uptake of graduates
into specialist veterinary practices affirmed that advances in veterinary medicine and increasing
societal expectations for higher quality veterinary care warranted more highly educated veterinary
paraprofessionals, as reported in the USA (Brown & Silverman 1999; Willis et al. 2007). The fact
that Australian VT graduates were also being employed in a diverse range of non-clinical roles
showed that the degree opened up broader career opportunities than those available to vocationally
qualified veterinary nurses, comparable to HE graduates in human nursing (Debout et al. 2012), and
HE educated veterinary nurses in the UK (RCVS 2018c). This finding not only provided valuable,
preliminary insights into the breadth of knowledge, skills and attributes required to better prepare
VT graduates, but it also signalled the breadth of industry and professional partnerships that would
be central to the success of the new paraprofession (see Figure 8-1).
The diversity of VT graduate employment destinations, including ‘breaking new ground’ as
government biosecurity inspectors, reflected Ternouth’s vision for this mid-tier, HE paraveterinary
discipline preparing graduates as critical thinkers, problem-solvers and lifelong learners, to work
alongside a globalising veterinary profession. These findings and the worldwide proliferation of
four year HE VT/veterinary nursing programmes (RCVS 2018e; AVMA 2018c) all justified UQ’s
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 179
decision to offer the first VT bachelor’s degree in Australia, ensuring that Australia could meet the
demands of a rapidly changing veterinary landscape and remain internationally competitive.
Overall, the findings of this study solidly encourage ongoing curricular refinement and the
development of pedagogical strategies to underpin the success of an evolving veterinary
paraprofession.
Study 2 (Chapter 4; Clarke et al. 2011) focused on a HE curriculum and pedagogy for an emerging
paraprofession, implemented and evaluated the efficacy of a pedagogical intervention to develop
students’ professional writing skills, critical thinking, and research capability. An overarching aim
was to promote professionalism and equip students with the motivation, skills, and confidence to
publish in the scholarly literature after graduation. Such ‘academising’ of the curriculum is integral
to generating a discipline-specific body of knowledge characteristic of professions (Eraut 1994;
Freidson 2001), and therefore necessary for an emerging profession (Figure 8-1). The success of the
intervention was evidenced through the students’ enjoyment of the contextualised approach to
assessment and improved confidence and competence in professional writing post-intervention.
This was reflected in improved grades, and a doubling of the number of students articulating a
desire to publish after graduation.
Pedagogies such as this also align with the HE philosophy of relating teaching to research (Chang
2005; Ek et al. 2013) and generating evidence-based research outcomes that are essential to guiding
practice (Adler & von dem Knesebeck cited in Ek et al. 2013). From an employability perspective,
it could be assumed that veterinary employers, similar to employers of allied health-care
professionals, would expect VT HE graduates to understand and apply evidence-based practice
(Atherton, Davidson & McAllister 2016, p.445), thus differentiating VT graduates from
vocationally qualified veterinary nurses. Furthermore, students would also have benefited by
learning to link theory to practice, which is reported to be one of the challenges for human nurses
transitioning into clinical practice (Newton & McKenna 2007), and therefore relevant to the ‘work-
readiness’ of VT graduates. This ‘lesson learned’ would appear to be an important goal of
curriculum design for a new veterinary paraprofession based in HE (Figure 8-1).
Indeed, to advance the professionalisation of VT and its body of knowledge, greater research
capacity could be built into a four-year VT degree, with a dissertation, similar to HE programmes in
the UK (Mansbridge & Buckley 2018) and Japan (K Ishioka 2015, pers. comm., 14 August).
Congruent with this, UQ recently opened up pathways for expanding VT research and
specialisations by offering a VT discipline-specific research honours year, whereby students
undertake research projects, including interdisciplinary research, to expand VT knowledge and
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 180
practice (UQ 2018f). Bolstered by this strategy, opportunities for post-graduate qualifications in VT
at masters and doctoral level, similar to offerings in Japan (K Ishioka 2015, pers. comm., 14
August) and the UK (University of Glasgow 2018), are evolving. This important role of HE in
developing the research capability of a new discipline to advance its professionalisation is also
identified in Figure 8-1.
Study 3 (Chapter 5; Clarke et al. 2015) aimed to attain a more refined understanding of the key
attributes required of graduates who are employed in VT’s primary employment destination,
veterinary practice. This study was driven by a gap in the literature regarding understanding the
perspectives of veterinary clients, as key stakeholders, in VT curriculum. Client expectations are
reported to be pivotal in shaping how professions practice (Faulconbridge & Muzio 2012). To
illustrate, service-user input into curriculum has been viewed as essential in producing more
empathetic and patient-centred health professionals (Illingworth & Chelvanayagam 2007), and
improving patient outcomes in human health care (Morgan & Jones 2009; Fallon et al. 2012).
Likewise, veterinary clients’ perspectives are crucial in an era of client- or relationship-centred
veterinary care, where veterinarians (and paraprofessionals) work in partnership with clients to
optimise their pet’s care (Shaw et al. 2010; Best 2013). Besides, clients now have the knowledge
(Dall’Alba 2009b), and the social and financial resources to challenge professionals (Eraut 1994).
Hence, shaping a VT curriculum that prepares graduates for a relationship-centred approach to care
is vital, not only for client satisfaction and patient outcomes, but also for graduates’ job satisfaction
(Best 2013). This, in turn, necessitates the engagement of stakeholders as a key element in
curriculum design for a paraprofession (Figure 8-1).
Overall, the study showed that clients valued interacting with a VT graduate who had capabilities
across the three domains of learning (affective, cognitive and technical) (Bloom & Krathwohl 1956;
Nilsson 2007), reinforcing the importance of more than knowledge and skills in curriculum (Barnett
& Coate 2005). Clients particularly valued EI attributes associated with emotionality, sociability,
and self-control. These findings are congruent with the expectations of a more educated veterinary
clientele (Page-Jones & Abbey 2015; Willis et al. 2007) who value university educated veterinary
support personnel. However, clients differed in the importance they placed on these domains (with
some valuing emotional intelligence (EI) more highly than technical expertise, and visa versa), and
client demographics (gender, age and interaction with the practice) also influenced the observed
differences. This result echoed findings from human nursing research (Hurley 2008) in highlighting
that a ‘one size fits all’ approach to veterinary clients is not appropriate. This client diversity also
reinforced the need for a holistic approach to a VT curriculum that would prepare a professionally
competent graduate with capabilities across all three learning domains (Krathwohl, Bloom, & Masia
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 181
1964; Nilsson 2007), involving Barnett’s (2004) dimensions of ‘knowing’, ‘doing’ and ‘being, as
reflected in Figure 8-1.
This demonstrated client diversity also had implications for a communication curriculum. Likewise,
clients’ demonstrated valuing of graduates who could manage stress in the workplace, reinforced a
place for mindfulness training in curriculum. This stress management technique, widely promoted
in veterinary curricula (Hatch et al. 2011; Epp & Waldner 2012), because of its association with job
satisfaction and staff retention (Meehan & Bradley 2007; Moore et al. 2014), could be adopted as a
‘work-readiness’ strategy in VT curriculum. Equally important, professional development on EI for
clinical educators, who model values, attitudes, and behaviours for VT students through the formal
and ‘hidden curricula’ (Goldie et al. 2007; Schull et al. 2012c), would reinforce EI pedagogies
delivered in the academic curriculum.
Study 4 (Chapter 6) interrogated five stakeholder groups to acquire a broad perspective on the key
attributes and skills required by VT graduates for effective teamwork. Teamwork capability is
arguably a pivotal graduate attribute, critical to employability in every VT employment destination
(Ruby & DeBowes 2007; Laidlaw, Guild & Struthers 2009; Kinnison, May & Guile 2014). The
stakeholder opinion affirmed the worth of seven personal attributes associated with team
effectiveness to be developed through VT curriculum and pedagogy. The finding that one of these,
‘conscientiousness’, was valued more highly by veterinarians and academics, revealed expectations
of graduates being organised, hard-working, dependable, task-oriented, achievement-oriented and
having initiative (Driskell et al. 2006). This difference in perspectives between stakeholder groups
emphasised the importance of employer consultation or partnerships in designing a curriculum for
an emerging paraprofession (Figure 8-1). It also suggested a role for leadership and management
training in the VT curriculum, because leadership roles are a natural progression for individuals
who are conscientious (Figure 8-1). Furthermore, enhancing VT graduates’ leadership and practice
management capabilities would expand their employment opportunities, as non-veterinarians in
Australia can now own veterinary practices and employ veterinarians (Veterinary Surgeons Board
of Queensland 2018).
Similarly, the data obtained through thematic analysis of teamwork definitions from veterinary
health care team members and academics provided valuable insights for building a VT curriculum
for interprofessional teamwork that would enhance VT graduate employability (Osmani et al.
2015). The themes generated, centering on ‘collaboration’, achieving ‘team goals and outcomes’,
‘sharing values’, developing and maintaining ‘team relationships’, ‘communicating effectively’ at
team and management level, ‘respecting differences’, ‘focusing on the task(s)’, and understanding
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 182
that the client is ‘on the team’, were perceived as integral to veterinary teamwork by these
stakeholders. The UQ VT programme, positioned within a veterinary school, would be well placed
to foster the required attributes and skills for interprofessional collaboration, team communication,
team goal setting, and developing ‘shared values’ through a teamwork curriculum involving
veterinary science and VT students, particularly in the clinical context—both in simulated and ‘real-
life’ clinical settings. Veterinary education needs to follow the lead of medicine and the health
professions in interprofessional and teamwork education (Thistlethwaite 2012; Kinnison, May &
Guile 2014; Moyo et al. 2016). Interprofessionalism is a vital dimension of the graduating student’s
developing professionalism (Evetts 1999; Kinnison, May & Guile 2014; Kinnison, Guile & May
2015), and, as such, needs to be an essential focus in a curriculum for a professionalising discipline
(see Figure 8-1).
Study 5 (Chapter 7; Clarke et al. 2018) represented an evaluation of the VT programme (2003-
2010) to inform a curriculum renewal commencing in 2012. The voice of VT graduates (2003-
2010) was recruited to identify facilitators and barriers to their employability and to gauge the
progress of VT as an emerging profession in Australia. The study affirmed the VT graduate
employment niche identified in Study 1. Importantly, it also identified barriers to graduate success,
including a lack of career advancement, lack of recognition by the relevant professions, limitations
of practical training and exposure to the clinical field, and low salaries in clinical employment.
Some of these barriers are directly addressable through curriculum renewal, such as more emphasis
on clinical skills training and promoting VT specialisations (for example, emergency and critical
care nursing, practice management, large animal health, a veterinary nurse/practitioner) to enhance
career pathways and remuneration (Chadderdon, Lloyd & Pazak 2014; VN Futures Action Group
2016). The latter are all pivotal to the advancement of the paraprofession, and hence included in
Figure 8-1.
The VT graduates clearly voiced a call for HE to play a more prominent role in advancing their
professionalisation through active stakeholder engagement, reviewing policy around dual
qualifications, and partnering with professional bodies and government to give their field legitimacy
through legislation, national registration, and endorsement in an employment award (Figure 8-1).
Figure 8-1 also illustrates how contemporary HE has an expanded role in responding to the
demands of market pressures and consumers, as well as offering an academic education (Ek et al.
2013, p. 1305; Fowler 2017), and this point was underscored by the VT graduate voice. Ideally, HE
should be undertaking appropriate research and consultation with industry partners, government,
and professional bodies to establish the need and the scope of employment niche prior to
introducing a new mid-tier qualification (Moodie et al. 2013) (Figure 8-1). This premise is validated
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 183
in Moodie et al.’s (2013) research on a range of mid-tier qualifications introduced into Australia in
the 2000s, which showed that those with strong links to the labour market were the most successful.
The graduate voice also demonstrated the progress of VT as an emerging profession in Australia.
Graduates articulated a preparedness to take responsibility for the development of VT professional
knowledge and to grow their VT roles through continuing education and completing additional
qualifications—evidence of their individual professionalisation facilitated through a HE curriculum,
and their role in professionalisation of their occupation (Figure 8-1). Such ownership of an
emerging profession’s direction is vitally important to its establishment and validation, and
evidence of this augers well for the future success of VT in Australia. This study also identified the
existence of other important graduate attributes, fostered through a HE curriculum, that would
differentiate VT graduates from vocationally qualified veterinary nurses; important attributes for
this distinction include initiative, self-motivation, self-confidence, self-management, lifelong
learning, research capability and the flexibility/adaptability to respond to change and lead change
within the workplace (Harvey 2000, p. 8; Osmani et al. 2015).
Key findings from this thesis, summarised in Figure 8-1, which could be translated into renewing a
VT curriculum, are also relevant to other paraprofessions embarking on a journey of
professionalisation by transitioning into HE. Important considerations for paraprofessions raised by
this research include a need for integrating academisation and vocationalism in curriculum and
pedagogy. For VT, this could be addressed through a four-year programme that incorporates a
greater research focus and potential to continue into post-graduate studies to generate a body of VT
knowledge on which to base its practice. In addition, a four-year degree could address the identified
need for enhanced practical skills training and placements; this would bestow the equivalent of a
dual qualification recommended by the VNCA in 2007 and AVA in 2006. HE could also advance
these emerging professions by creating a disciplinary Chair to establish the discipline in academia
and power its research base, as demonstrated in the UK by the appointment of Sue Gregory as
Professor of Veterinary Nursing at the Royal Veterinary College (RVC 2018). Finally, and
importantly, Ballweg & Hooker (2017, p. S75) from the physician assistant field assert that one of
the pivotal factors influencing the acceptance of emerging disciplines is having a critical mass of
students/graduates, and advocates in the associated professions. These critical factors are therefore
also incorporated into Figure 8-1 to help illuminate the path for future paraprofessions transitioning
into HE.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 184
Figure 8-1: Diagrammatic representation of the role of HE in advancing an emerging paraprofession
in the veterinary and allied animal health fields in Australia (2003-2010).
8.4 Post-script
Since 2012 and subsequent to this research, the UQ VT programme has been substantially
transformed, commencing with a faculty review of the BAppSc programmes in 2011. The
researcher (2011) led the review of the VT specialisation, obtained vital industry feedback and
augmented the VT focus in the programme via the addition of three VT-specific courses in the first
and second years. Opportunities for increased exposure to clinical training were also formulated;
these included an extended clinical placement period in final year, and plans for a four-year degree
with specialised streams, an enhanced research focus, and a clinical practicum period to meet the
international accreditation requirements of the RCVS (RCVS 2018i). These changes represented a
move away from a generic applied science model towards a ‘stand-alone’ VT programme
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 185
facilitating graduate professional identity formation and employability. In addition, following a
faculty review of the veterinary school in 2011 and new leadership in 2012, the veterinary school
committed to VT as part of its core business (G Coleman 2012, pers. comm., 11 April). This
commitment was validated in 2013 by an increase in VT academic staff numbers, with veterinary
technicians and nurses assuming programme leadership roles for the first time—a great milestone
for the VT discipline in Australia. Concurrently, increased integration of VT into the veterinary
school community at micro- (staff), meso- (school) and macro-levels (university), resulted in a
period of continuous improvement, culminating in a ‘stand-alone’ Bachelor of VT in 2017 (UQ
2018a).
The recognition of VT by the key professional bodies has also advanced. The AVA officially
opened up associate membership to all Australian VT graduates in 2016 (J McAndrew pers. comm.,
11 January), following advocacy by the researcher. The relationship with the VNCA has
strengthened due to the work and achievements of Trish Farry, a current VT lecturer/clinical
coordinator (2013 – present), who was recently appointed to the VNCA Board (T Farry 2018, pers.
comm., 29 January), and through the researcher’s position (2017-current) on the National Industry
Advisory Group for Veterinary Nursing—an industry body designed to ‘monitor and elevate the
standard and quality of veterinary nurse support staff’ (Bindloss 2003b, p. 187). Full membership of
the VNCA continues to be a ‘work in progress’. With the VNCA embarking on a process of
voluntary registration for veterinary nurses in Australia (VNCA 2018c), the possibility of including
VT graduates in that process is currently under discussion (J Feeney 2018, pers. comm., 29 July). In
addition, UQ plans for the alignment of the VT curriculum to facilitate RCVS accreditation (2018g)
and transferability of the qualification.
8.5 Limitations
In retrospect, further understanding of graduates’ employment could have been elicited in Study 1
through open-ended questions, allowing participants to more freely express their opinions and
provide insights not considered by the researcher (Albudaiwi 2017). The potential for a non-
response bias induced by the low client response rate in the stakeholder survey may have been
mitigated by offering an incentive for clients to participate, but evidence of the positive effect of
incentives on response quality is limited and mixed (Grauenhorst, Blohm & Koch 2016). A larger
client sample size would have provided greater understanding of how clients’ perceptions of the
importance of attributes and skills might vary with demographics. Consequently, caution is required
in interpretation of results and the generalisability of these findings. The aforementioned limitations
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 186
could also have applied to the graduate survey. On the other hand, triangulation of the client survey
data with interviews strengthened the rigour of those findings.
Even though Likert scales are widely used for survey research (Biolcati-Rinaldi 2011), limitations
associated with the use of Likert–type questions in the stakeholder surveys, and to a limited extent,
the graduate survey, included interpretation of the Likert items by an individual respondent or
stakeholder group which could have been reduced by providing descriptions. Additionally, the
capacity of respondents to make the fine distinction between ratings could also have varied (Willits,
Theodori & Luloff 2016).
Researching only one VT programme in Australia was not a limitation, because for the majority of
the study period, the UQ VT programme was unique in Australasia (Clarke, Schull & Coleman
2009). The VT programme at CSU, Australia, commenced in 2015 (CSU 2018) and the Massey
University VT programme (NZ) graduated its first cohort in 2011 (Massey University College of
Sciences 2008).
The researcher’s relationship with the VT graduates as students may also have encouraged or
impeded their ability to share their views in the surveys. Although future studies would benefit from
triangulating the survey results with interview data, to date there has not been any comparable
research conducted for veterinary support staff.
8.6 Conclusion
The research conducted for this thesis has answered the research questions and achieved its stated
aims: analysed the success of early VT cohorts, developed a framework for VT curriculum and
pedagogy that involved an intervention to drive ‘academisation’ through knowledge production and
professionalisation, interrogated key stakeholders to obtain a broad perspective on the personal
attributes and skills for VT graduates required to cement legitimacy for this new paraprofession,
and gathered input from the longer-term graduate voice to understand facilitators and barriers for
the new paraprofession to inform curriculum renewal. In doing so, this thesis has documented the
genesis of VT in Australia and developed recommendations for curricular advancement. This
research also fills a gap in the literature where there is limited evidence to validate the emergence of
a new veterinary paraprofession in Australia and to develop a curriculum framework that will
ensure the new profession finds its niche in the Australian and international workplace of the 21st
century.
The initial graduate survey (2003-2005) characterised the early phases of the VT para-profession in
Australia and validated a niche for VT and its graduates. The success of a novel pedagogical
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 187
intervention laid a solid foundation for both ‘academisation’ of VT education and
professionalisation of the VT student and the occupation; these elements are both integral to
building a VT profession. The surveying of key stakeholder perspectives—including employers,
health care teams, graduates, and clients—provided important insights for the development of
Australian VT curricula that will meet the workforce expectations of this new profession. The
longer-term graduate voice reiterated the importance of these findings; many of the barriers and
facilitators to VT professionalisation that emerged from the graduate voice could be rectified
through implementing curriculum changes suggested from stakeholder opinions. The graduate voice
also called for HE to take a more active role in establishing VT as a paraprofession.
From an overview perspective, the results of this thesis, which are transferable to other
paraprofessional contexts, illuminated the interprofessional context of veterinary teamwork
implying potential benefits of a co-curricular approach to VT and veterinary education as well as
the critical role that universities could—and perhaps should—play to ensure the success of their
newly created professions. As summarised in this thesis, the landscape of HE has changed
dramatically over the past 20 years. These changes bring a greater need for universities to engage
more fully in the ‘politics of professionalisation’ to secure legitimacy of a new discipline and
graduate employability. This can be achieved by forming partnerships with employers,
governments, and professional bodies, by actively consulting with industry and getting involved in
critical policy development.
Ideally, such collaborations should be instigated when the programme is in the conceptual phase to
gain the best outcomes for HE institutions, graduates, employers and the professions.
Implications for future research
This research has added to our understanding of a framework for curriculum and pedagogy to meet
the requirements for the academisation and vocationalism integral to the success of an emerging
veterinary paraprofession. It has also highlighted the nature of ‘knowing’, ‘doing’, and ways of
‘being’ to be addressed in a curriculum for paraprofessions in HE. Future research to advance VT
would focus on developing a more coordinated interprofessional approach to veterinary and VT
education, predominantly in the clinical context, where co-curricular education would develop
interprofessional competencies and understanding. In conjunction with UQ transferring to a four-
year VT programme, a joint research project with CSU, Australia, and Massey University, NZ, to
establish a VT external accreditation system that would allow transnational recognition, including
RCVS accreditation (2018g), is strongly advocated.
Researcher reflections on working in a ‘climate of change’
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 188
Reflecting on my ten-year term as a VT lecturer and final year coordinator, culminating at the end
of 2012, my career spanned many ‘highs’ and ‘lows’. Not being able to influence change quickly
enough was the most significant challenge. However, when I compared VT to other mid-tier
qualifications in fields, such as the physician assistant in medicine, it became clear that change
takes time. This includes time to build a critical mass of students/graduates and a base of support in
the associated professions (Ballweg & Hooker 2017). These factors provide very plausible
explanations for some of the challenges I encountered in the early days of smaller VT cohorts and a
need for further advocacy amongst the professions by the university. Secondly, I found that
bridging the policy, funding and ‘cultural’ divide between vocational education and HE—described
by Fowler (2017, p. 3) as an area of significant confusion… and considerable inter-institutional
contest’ in Australia—emerged as an insurmountable challenge that is still not resolved in 2018. I
believe the issue has been compounded by a traditional university adjusting to its new role in an era
of massification. However, with some sense of satisfaction, I have noted changes that I initiated
prior to my retirement, being implemented and further extended. These include curricular changes
which have enhanced employability, the appointment of a cohesive group of enthusiastic and
inspirational VT academics generating great advocacy within the VNCA, combined with a
developing critical mass of graduates. I believe now that unconditional acceptance of VT within the
professional communities is fast approaching. However, I still reflect on the question, ‘What could
have been for previous students and graduates in terms of their professional recognition and
employability, had a dual qualification been embedded in the degree in 2009 or earlier, paralleling
HE models for VN in the UK and VT in the USA?’ Learning from the wisdom of the physician
assistant movement, I must agree that for myself and my era of VT, ‘In the end, success, adaptation,
and failures are the lessons learned’ (Ballweg & Hooker 2017, p. S75). That said, I still have great
confidence in the future of VT in Australia underpinned by a UQ HE curriculum built on strong
industry, government and professional partnerships forged in the interests of advancing VT,
graduate employability and the veterinary profession.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 189
9 List of References
Adams, TE, Holman Jones, S & Ellis, C 2014, Autoethnography: understanding qualitative
research, Oxford University Press, New York.
Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department, 2018, Amendment of Schedule 2 to the
Veterinary Surgeons Registration Ordinance (Cap. 529), viewed 18 January 2019,
<https://www.afcd.gov.hk/english/whatsnew/what_qua/public_consult_529_2.html>.
Albudaiwi, D 2017, ‘Survey: open-ended questions’, in M Allen (ed.), The Sage encyclopedia of
communication research methods, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, pp. 1716-17.
Aldenderfer, MS & Blashfield, RK 1984, Cluster analysis, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks,
viewed 9 March 2019, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781412983648, (Sage
researchmethods).
American Veterinary Medical Association 2003, Survey of accredited programs in veterinary
technology, American Veterinary Medical Association, Schaumburg, viewed 22 March 2007,
<http://www.avma.org/careforanimals/ animatedjourneys/aboutvets/survey.asp>.
American Veterinary Medical Association 2007, A career in veterinary technology, American
Veterinary Medical Association, Schaumburg, viewed 2 February 2009, <http://www.avma.
org/animal_health/brochures/careers/technology_ brochure.asp>.
American Veterinary Medical Association 2018a, AVMA policy on veterinary technology:
nomenclature, American Veterinary Medical Association, Schaumburg, viewed 8 March 2019,
<https://www.avma.org/KB/Policies/Pages/AVMA-Policy-on-Veterinary-Technology.aspx>.
American Veterinary Medical Association 2018b, AVMA policy on veterinary technology: the role
of veterinary technicians, American Veterinary Medical Association, Schaumburg, viewed 8
March 2019, <https://www.avma.org/KB/Policies/Pages/AVMA-Policy-on-Veterinary-
Technology.aspx>.
American Veterinary Medical Association 2018c, AVMA CVTEA-accredited programs that offer a
bachelor of science (4-year degree) in veterinary technology, American Veterinary Medical
Association, Schaumberg, viewed 8 March 2019,
<https://www.avma.org/ProfessionalDevelopment/Education/Accreditation/Programs/Pages/ba
chelor-of-science-programs.aspx>.
American Veterinary Medical Association 2018d, Veterinary technicians and veterinary assistants:
education, American Veterinary Medical Association, Schaumberg, viewed 8 March 2019,
<https://www.avma.org/public/YourVet/Pages/techs-and-assistants.aspx>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 190
Animal Emergency Service 2018, What is Animal Emergency Service?, Animal Emergency
Service, Brisbane, viewed 8 March 2019,
<https://www.animalemergencyservice.com.au/about-us/>.
Ash, MK 2018, ‘3 Types of People’, Power living: inspirational advice for a purposeful &
powerful life, blogpost, 5 May 2012, viewed 8 March 2019, <http://www.power-
living.com/blog/2012/05/05/3-types-of-people/>.
Association of Southeast Asian Nations 2016, ASEAN rabies elimination strategy, OIE World
Organisation for Animal Health, Bangkok, viewed 9 March 2019,
<http://asean.org/storage/2017/02/ASEAN-Rabies-Elimination-Strategy.pdf>.
Atherton, M, Davidson, B & McAllister, L 2016, ‘Exploring the emerging profession of speech-
language pathology in Vietnam through pioneering eyes’, International Journal of Speech-
Language Pathology, vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 109-20.
Auckland University 2019, Questions about thematic analysis, School of Psychology, Auckland
University, viewed 4 March 2019, <https://www.psych.auckland.ac.nz/en/about/our-
research/research-groups/thematic-analysis/frequently-asked-questions-
8.html#d0f3996cc540798d57cc51f991ce0a3b>.
Austin, EJ 2004, ‘An investigation of the relationship between trait emotional intelligence and
emotional task performance’, Personality and Individual Differences, vol. 36, no. 8, pp. 1855-
64.
Australasian Veterinary Boards Council Inc 2017, Veterinary education, Australasian Veterinary
Boards Council Inc, Melbourne, viewed 9 March 2019, <https://avbc.asn.au/veterinary-
education/>.
Australian Bureau of Statistics 2002a, Year Book Australia, 2002: Veterinary services, Australia
1999-2000, Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, viewed 9 March, 2019,
<http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/Previousproducts/1301.0Contents12002?opend
ocument&tabname=Summary&prodno=1301.0&issue=2002&num=&view= >.
Australian Bureau of Statistics 2002b, Year Book Australia, 2002 - Health: Health Workforce,
Australian Bureau of Statistics, Canberra, viewed 9 March 2019,
<http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/Previousproducts/1301.0Contents12002?opend
ocument&tabname=Summary&prodno=1301.0&issue=2002&num=&view=>.
Australian Industry and Skills Committee, Veterinary Nursing, Australian Industry and Skills
Committee, Canberra, viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://nationalindustryinsights.aisc.net.au/industries/animal-care-and-
management/veterinary-nursing>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 191
Australian National Training Authority 1998, Training Package in Veterinary Nursing RUV98:
national competency standards, assessment guidelines and qualifications, Australian Training
Products, Melbourne, viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://training.gov.au/TrainingComponentFiles/NTIS/RUV98_1.pdf>.
Australian Veterinary Association 2000, Annual Report 2000, Australian Veterinary Association,
Sydney, viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://www.ava.com.au/sites/default/files/documents/Other/Annual_Report_2000_0.pdf>.
Australian Veterinary Association 2014, AVA workforce modelling environmental scan, Australian
Veterinary Association, Sydney, viewed 9 March 2019,
<http://www.ava.com.au/sites/default/files/AVA_website/pdfs/Australian%20veterinary%20w
orkforce%20environmental%20scan.pdf>.
Australian Veterinary Association 2015, Australian veterinary workforce modelling: an Australian
Veterinary Association initiative, Australian Veterinary Association, Sydney, viewed 9 March
2019,
<http://www.ava.com.au/sites/default/files/AVA_website/pdfs/Australian%20veterinary%20w
orkforce%20modelling%20report%20foreword.pdf>.
Australian Veterinary Association 2017, Australian veterinary workforce survey 2016, Australian
Veterinary Association, Sydney, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://www.ava.com.au/sites/default/files/AVA_website/pdf/AVA-Workforce-Survey-2016-
Final.pdf>.
Australian Veterinary Association 2018, AVA, Australian Veterinary Association, Sydney, viewed
28 September 2018, <http://www.ava.com.au/>.
Animal Health Australia 2019, AUSVETPLAN, Animal Health Australia, Canberra, viewed 10
March 2019,
<https://animalhealthaustralia.com.au/our-publications/ausvetplan-manuals-and-documents/>.
Bain, K 2004, ‘How do they conduct class?’, in K Bain (ed.), What the best college teachers do,
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp. 99-134.
Ballweg, RM & Hooker, RS 2017, ‘Observations on the global spread of physician assistant
education’, Journal of Physician Assistant Education, vol. 28, no. 35, pp. s75-s80.
Banks, D 2011, ‘Evidence-based practice in veterinary nursing’, The Veterinary Nurse, vol. 1, no. 3,
pp. 136-9.
Banyard, MRC, Farrow, BRH & Malmo, J 1996, ‘Future trends for the veterinary profession in
Australia: an occasional article on the 75th anniversary of the Australian Veterinary
Association’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 74, no. 1, pp. 33-5.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 192
Barker, SB & Wolen, AR 2008, ‘The benefits of human–companion animal interaction: a review’,
Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 487-95.
Barnett, R 2000, ‘Supercomplexity and the curriculum’, Studies in Higher Education, vol. 25, no. 3,
pp. 255-65.
Barnett, R 2004, ‘Learning for an unknown future’, Higher Education Research & Development,
vol. 23, no.3, pp. 247-60.
Barnett, R & Coate, K 2005, Engaging the curriculum in higher education, SRHE/Open University
Press, Maidenhead.
Barnett, R 2007, A will to learn: being a student in an age of uncertainty, McGraw-Hill Education,
Maidenhead.
Barnett, R 2009, ‘Knowing and becoming in higher education curriculum’, Studies in Higher
Education, vol. 34, no. 4, pp. 429-40.
Barnett, R 2012, ‘Learning for an unknown future’, Higher Education Research & Development,
vol. 31, no. 1, pp. 65-77.
Bar-On, R 1997, The emotional intelligence inventory (EQ-i): technical manual, Multi-Health
Systems, Toronto.
Bar-On, R 2006, ‘The Bar-On model of emotional-social intelligence (ESI)’, Psicothena, vol. 18,
(suppl.1), pp. 13-25.
Barrie, SC 2006, ‘Understanding what we mean by generic graduate attributes’, Higher Education,
vol. 51, no. 2, pp. 215-41.
Batt-Rawden, SA, Chisolm, MS, Anton, B & Flickinger, TE 2013, ‘Teaching empathy to medical
students: an updated, systematic review’, Academic Medicine, vol. 88, no. 8, pp. 1171-7.
Beddie, F 2014, A differentiated model for tertiary education: past ideas, contemporary policy and
future possibilities, research report, National Centre for Vocational Education and Research
Adelaide, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://www.ncver.edu.au/research-and-
statistics/publications/all-publications/a-differentiated-model-for-tertiary-education-past-ideas,-
contemporary-policy-and-future-possibilities>.
Benner, P 2000, ‘The wisdom of our practice’, The American Journal of Nursing, vol. 100, no. 10,
pp. 99-105.
Berger, R 2013, ‘Now I see it, now I don’t: researcher’s position and reflexivity in qualitative
research’, Qualitative Research, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 219-34.
Bernard, HR & Ryan, GW 2010, Analysing qualitative data, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks.
Berryman, JC, Howells, K & Lloyd-Evans, M 1985, ‘Pet owner attitudes to pets and people: a
psychological study’, Veterinary Record, vol. 117, pp. 659-61.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 193
Best, C 2013, ‘Exploring and meeting client expectations of the veterinarian-client relationship
through the use of clinical communication skills’, Proceedings of the American Association of
Equine Practitioners Annual Convention 2013, American Association of Equine Practitioners,
Nashville, vol. 59, pp. 274-9.
Bickes, JT & Schim, SM 2010, ‘Righting writing: strategies for improving nursing student papers’,
International Journal of Nursing Education Scholarship, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 1-11.
Bindloss, J 1996, ‘Wise “men” embrace change’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 74, no. 1, p.
78.
Bindloss, J 2003a, ‘Report: survey on veterinary nurse training’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol.
81, no. 9, p. 527.
Bindloss, J 2003b, ‘Report: national industry advisory group for veterinary nursing’, vol. 81, no. 4,
p. 187.
Biolcati-Rinaldi, F 2011, ‘Likert scales’, in D Southerton (ed.), Encyclopedia of consumer culture,
pp. 866-7, viewed 9 March 2019, <http://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781412994248.n322>.
Biosecurity Queensland 2007, About the work of Biosecurity Queensland, Department of Primary
Industries, Brisbane, viewed 15 January 2008, <http://www.dpi.qld.gov.au/cps/rde/xchg/
dpi/hs.xsl/31_2897_ENA_HTML.htm>.
Bland, CJ, Starnaman, S, Wersal, L, Moorhead-Rosenberg, L, Zonia, S & Henry, R 2000,
‘Curricular change in medical schools: how to succeed’ Academic Medicine, vol. 75, no. 6, pp.
575-94.
Bloom, BS & Krathwohl, DR 1956, Taxonomy of educational objectives: the classification of
educational goals, by a committee of college and university examiners, Handbook I: cognitive
domain, Longmans, Green, New York.
Bochner, A & Ellis, C 2016, Evocative autoethnography: writing lives and telling stories,
Routledge, New York.
Bonvicini, KA 2008, ‘Empathy: what’s all the fuss about?’, paper presented to the International
Conference on Communication in Veterinary Medicine, Banff, Canada, 13-16 November.
Boud, D, 1990, ‘Assessment and the promotion of academic values’, Studies in Higher Education,
vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 101-12.
Boud, D 1998, ‘Assessment and learning—unlearning habits of bad assessment’, paper presented to
the Effective Assessment at University Conference, The University of Queensland, Australia,
4-5 November.
Boud, D, Cohen, R & Sampson, J 2001, ‘Peer learning and assessment’, in D Boud, R Cohen & J
Sampson (eds), Peer learning in higher education: learning from & with each other, Kogan
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 194
Page, London, pp. 67-81.
Bradley, L, Noonan, P, Nugent, H & Scales, B 2008, Review of Australian higher education: final
report [Bradley Review], Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations,
Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019, <http://hdl.voced.edu.au/10707/44384>.
Bradley, BH, Bauer, JE, Banford, CG & Postlethwaite CE 2013, ‘Team players and
collective performance: how agreeableness affects team performance over time’, Small Group
Research, vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 680-711.
Brady, J, Lordly, D, MacLellan, D & Gingras, J 2012, ‘New dietetic practitioners’ perspectives on
their education and training’, Canadian Journal of Dietetic Practice and Research, vol. 73, no.
3, pp. 117-21.
Branscombe, L 2010, ‘Evaluating the need for continuing professional development (CPD)’, The
Veterinary Nurse, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 4-11.
Branscombe, L 2011a, ‘Developing our professional role’, The Veterinary Nurse, vol. 1, no. 3,
p.135.
Branscombe, L 2011b, Looking back, stepping forward, VN Jubilee Seminar presentation, 23 June
2011, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.rcvs.org.uk/news-and-views/news/looking-back-stepping-forward-seminar-
marks-vns-50th/>.
Brant, R 1990, ‘Assessing proportionality in the proportional odds model for ordinal logistic
regression’, Biometrics, vol. 46, pp. 1171-8.
Braun, V & Clarke, V 2006, ‘Using thematic analysis in psychology’, Qualitative Research in
Psychology, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 77–101.
Braun, V & Clarke, V 2013, Successful qualitative research: a practical guide for beginners, Sage
Publications, London.
Bridgelal, M, Campling, N, Grocott, P & Weir, H 2008, ‘A methodology for a structured survey of
the healthcare literature related to medical device users’, Evaluation, vol. 14, no.1, pp. 49–73.
British Veterinary Nursing Association 2006, Careers—veterinary nursing, British Veterinary
Nursing Association, Essex, viewed 23 February 2009, <http://www.bvna.org.uk/
smartweb/vns/overview>.
British Veterinary Nursing Association 2018, BVNA: British Veterinary Nursing Association,
British Veterinary Nursing Association, Essex, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.bvna.org.uk/>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 195
Brown, JP & Silverman, JD 1999, ‘The current and future market for veterinarians and veterinary
medical services in the United States’, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical
Association, vol. 215, no. 5, pp. 161-83.
Brown, J, Stevens, J & Kermode, S 2012, ‘Supporting student nurse professionalisation: the role of
the clinical teacher’, Nurse Education Today, vol. 32, no. 5, pp. 606-10.
Bryden, D 2003, The Post Graduate Foundation in Veterinary Science of the University of Sydney,
Australian Veterinary History Society, Australian Veterinary Association, Sydney, viewed 10
March 2019, <https://www.ava.com.au/about-us/who-does-what/groups/special-interest-
groups-9 >.
Bunn, C 2002, Eradication of bovine brucellosis in Australia, Australian Veterinary History
Society, Australian Veterinary Association, Sydney, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.ava.com.au/about-us/who-does-what/groups/special-interest-groups-9>.
Burns, E 2007, ‘Positioning a post-professional approach to study professions’, New Zealand
Sociology, vol. 22, no.1, pp. 69-98.
Cannon, R & Newble, D 2000, ‘Helping students learn’, in D Black (ed.), A handbook for teachers
in universities and colleges: a guide to improving teaching methods, Kogan Page, London, pp.
1-15.
Caple, IW 2011, ‘A short history of veterinary education in Australia: the 120-year transition from
education for a trade to education for a profession’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 89, no.
8, pp. 282-8.
Carney, BT, West, P, Neily, J & Bagian, JP 2010, ‘Differences in nurse and surgeon perceptions of
teamwork: implications for use of a briefing checklist in the OR’, AORN Journal, vol. 91, no.
6, pp. 722-9.
Chadderdon, LM, Lloyd, JW & Pazak, HE 2014, ‘New directions for veterinary technology’,
Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 96-101.
Chang, H 2005, ‘Turning an undergraduate class into a professional research community’, Teaching
in Higher Education, vol. 10, no.3, pp. 387-94.
Chang, H 2008, Autoethnography as method, Left Coast Press, Walnut Creek.
Chang, H 2016, ‘Autoethnography in health research: growing pains?’, Qualitative Health
Research, vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 443-61.
Charles Sturt University 2015, News: award recognition for new vet technology degree, Charles
Sturt University, Wagga Wagga, viewed 10 March 2019, <http://news.csu.edu.au/latest-
news/agricultural-science/animal-and-veterinary-science/award-recognition-for-new-
veterinary-technology-degree>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 196
Charles Sturt University 2018, Bachelor of veterinary technology: course highlights, Charles Sturt
University, Wagga Wagga, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://futurestudents.csu.edu.au/courses/animal-vet-sciences/bachelor-veterinary-technology>.
Chen, DCR, Kirshenbaum, DS, Yan, J, Kirshenbaum, E & Aseltine, RH 2012, ‘Characterizing
changes in student empathy throughout medical school’ Medical Teacher, vol. 34, no. 4, pp.
305-11.
Cherry, MG, Fletcher, I, O’Sullivan, H & Dornan, T 2014, ‘Emotional intelligence in medical
education: a critical review’, Medical Education, vol. 48, no. 5, pp. 468-78.
Cheung, I 2015, ‘The future of veterinary nursing in Hong Kong’, British Veterinary Nursing
Journal, vol. 30, pp. 89-90.
Chibnall, JT, Blaskiewicz, RJ & Detrick, P 2009, ‘Are medical students agreeable? An exploration
of personality in relation to clinical skills training’, Medical Teacher, vol. 31, no. 7, pp. 311-15.
Chinese Veterinary Medical Association 2011, Chinese Veterinary Medical Association, People’s
Republic of China, viewed 2 March 2019, <http://www.cvma.org.cn:8899/eng/index.aspx>.
Chowdbury, F 2019, ‘Application of rubrics in the classroom: a vital tool for improvement in
assessment, feedback and learning’, International Educational Studies, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 61-8.
Christen, RN, Alder, J & Bitzer, J 2008, ‘Gender differences in physicians’ communicative skills
and their influence on patient satisfaction in gynaecological outpatient consultations’, Social
Science & Medicine, vol. 66, no. 7, pp. 1474-83.
Chuer-Hansen, A 2010, ‘Grief and bereavement issues and the loss of a companion animal: people
living with a companion animal, owners of livestock and animal support workers’, Clinical
Psychologist, vol. 14, no.1, pp. 14-21.
Ciani, KD, Summers, JJ, Easter, MA & Sheldon, KM 2008, ‘Collaborative learning and positive
experiences: does letting students choose their own groups matter?’, Educational Psychology,
vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 627-41.
Clarke, PM 2004, ‘Veterinary technology and management—current status’, Australian Veterinary
Practitioner, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 38-9.
Clarke, V & Braun, V 2013, ‘Teaching thematic analysis: overcoming challenges and developing
strategies for effective learning’, The Psychologist, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 120-3.
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2009, ‘Demographics and employment destinations of a
new group of veterinary technologists in Australia’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education,
vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 241-5.
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT, Pitt, R & Manathunga, C 2011, ‘Enhancing professional
writing skills of veterinary technology students: linking assessment and clinical practice in a
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 197
communications course’, Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education, vol. 38, no. 3, pp.
273-87.
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, R, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives on
desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31.
Clouston, TJ & Whitcombe, SW 2008, ‘The professionalisation of occupational therapy: a
continuing challenge’, British Journal of Occupational Therapy, vol. 71, no. 8, pp. 314-20.
College of Animal Welfare 2018, BSc Veterinary Nursing (Middlesex University), College of
Animal Welfare, Cambridgeshire, viewed 26 September 2018,
<https://www.caw.ac.uk/subject/veterinary-nursing/>.
Cooper, B 2002, ‘Veterinary nursing training in the 21st century: which direction should it take?’,
Veterinary Record, vol. 150, no. 3, pp. 465-6.
Creswell, JW 2014, Research design: qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods approaches, 4th
edn, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks.
Croasmun, JT & Ostrom, L 2011, ‘Using Likert-type scales in the social sciences’, Journal of Adult
Education, vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 19-22.
Dall’Alba, G 2009a, ‘Learning professional ways of being: ambiguities of becoming’, Educational
Philosophy and Theory, vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 34-45.
Dall’Alba, G 2009b, Learning to be professionals: innovation and change in professional
education, volume 4, Springer, Dordrecht.
Dawson, BFY & Thompson, NJ 2017, ‘The effect of personality on occupational stress in
veterinary surgeons’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 72-82.
Dawson, P, Charman, K & Kilpatrick, S 2013, ‘The new higher education reality: what is an
appropriate model to address the widening participation agenda?’, Higher Education Research
& Development, vol. 32, no. 5, pp. 706-21.
Debout, C, Chevallier-Darchen, F, Petit dit Dariel, O & Rothan-Tondeur, M 2012, ‘Undergraduate
nursing education reform in France: from vocational to academic programmes’, International
Nursing Review, vol. 59, no. 4, pp. 519-24.
de Laforcade, AM, Morrissey, PA, Rowell, SL & Schwartz, A 2005, ‘Market survey investigating
the feasibility of an advanced training program for veterinary technicians’, Journal of the
American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 226, no. 3, pp. 366-9.
De La Harpe, B, Radloff, A & Wyber, J 2000, ‘Quality and generic (professional) skills’, Quality in
Higher Education, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 231–43.
Denshire, S 2014, ‘On auto-ethnography’, Current Sociology Review, vol. 62, no. 6, pp. 831-50.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 198
Department of Agriculture & Fisheries 2018, Biosecurity, Queensland Government, Brisbane,
viewed 10 March 2019, <https://www.daf.qld.gov.au/business-priorities/biosecurity>.
Department of Agriculture and Water Resources 2017, Biosecurity, Australian Government,
Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019, <http://www.agriculture.gov.au/abares/research-
topics/biosecurity>.
Department of Education and Training 2015, Higher Education in Australia: a review of reviews
from Dawkins to today, Department of Education and Training, Canberra, viewed 5 April
2019, <https://docs.education.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/higher_education_in_australia_-
_a_review_of_reviews.pdf>.
Department of Employment, Education, Training and Youth Affairs (DEETYA) 1998, Learning for
life: review of higher education financing and policy, Department of Employment, Education,
Training and Youth Affairs, Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.voced.edu.au/content/ngv%3A30787>.
Department of Education, Science and Training 2002, Employability skills for the future:
Department of Education, Science and Training [West Report], Australian Government
Publishing Service, Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019, <http://hdl.voced.edu.au/10707/57886>.
Department of Employment and Workplace Relations 2003, National Skills Shortage Lists
Australia - 2003, Australian Government, Canberra, viewed 9 March 2019,
<http://hdl.voced.edu.au/10707/44384>.
Diehl, SH 2007, ‘Developing students’ writing skills: an early intervention approach’, Nurse
Educator, vol. 32, no. 5, pp. 202-6.
Dobson, IR 2001, ‘How has massification changed the shape of Australian universities? ‘, Tertiary
Education and Management, vol. 17, pp. 295-310.
Dohoo, I, Martin, W & Stryhn, H 2003, Veterinary epidemiologic research, 2nd edn, University of
Prince Edward Island, Charlottetown.
Donleavy, G 2012, ‘Proclaimed graduate attributes of Australian universities: patterns, problems
and prospects’, Quality Assurance in Education, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 341-56.
Doron J, Trouillet, R, Maneveau, A, Neveu, D & Ninot, G 2015, ‘Coping profiles, perceived stress
and health-related behaviors: a cluster analysis approach’, Health Promotion International, vol.
30, no. 1, pp. 88-100.
Driskell, JE, Goodwin, GF, Salas, E & O’Shea, PG 2006, ‘What makes a good team player?
Personality and team effectiveness’, Group Dynamics: Theory, Research & Practice, vol. 10,
no. 4. pp. 249-71.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 199
Duyvendak, JW, Knijn, T & Kremer, M (eds) 2006, Policy, people and the new professional: de-
professionalisation and re-professionalisation in care and welfare, Amsterdam University
Press, Amsterdam.
Ek, A-C, Ideland, M, Jönsson, S & Malmberg, C 2013, ‘The tension between marketisation and
academisation in higher education’, Studies in Higher Education, vol. 38, no. 9, pp. 1305-18.
Ellis, RA 2004, ‘University student approaches to learning science through writing’, International
Journal of Science Education, vol. 26, no. 15, pp. 1835-53.
Ellis, CS & Bochner, AP 2000, ‘Autoethnography, personal narrative, reflexivity: researcher as
subject’ in NK Denzin & YS Lincoln (eds), Handbook of qualitative research, Sage
Publications, Thousand Oaks, pp. 733-68.
Ellis, CS & Bochner, AP 2011, ‘Analyzing analytic autoethnography: an autopsy’, Journal of
Contemporary Ethnography, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 1-21.
Ellis, RA, Taylor, CE & Drury, H 2007, ‘Learning science through writing: associations with prior
conceptions of writing and perceptions of a writing program’, Higher Education Research &
Development, vol. 26, no. 3, pp. 297-311.
Ellis, C, Adams, TE & Bochner, AP 2011, ‘Autoethnography: an overview’, Forum Qualitative
Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 1-13.
Elo, S & Kyngäs, H 2008, ‘The qualitative content analysis approach’, Journal of Advanced
Nursing, vol. 62, no. 1, pp. 107-15.
Elzinga, A 1990, ‘The knowledge aspect of professionalisation: the case of science-based nursing
education in Sweden’, in R Torstendahl & M Burrage (eds), The formation of professions:
knowledge, state and strategy, Sage, London, pp. 151-73.
Engel, SN & Halvorson, D 2016, ‘Neoliberalism, massification and teaching transformative politics
and international relations’, Australian Journal of Political Science, vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 546-54.
Enticott, JC, Kandane-Rathnayake, RK & Phillips, LE 2012, ‘Odds ratio simplified’, Transfusion,
vol. 52, no. 3, pp. 467-9.
Epp, T & Waldner, C 2012, ‘Occupational health hazards in veterinary medicine: physical,
psychological, and chemical hazards’, Canadian Veterinary Journal, vol. 53, no. 2, pp. 151-7.
Epstein, R & Hundert, E 2002, ‘Defining and assessing professional competence’, Journal of the
American Medical Association, vol. 287, no. 2, pp. 226-34.
Eraut, M 1994, Developing professional knowledge and competence, Routledge Falmer, London.
Etzioni, A 1969, The semi-professions and their organisations: teachers, nurses, social workers,
Free Press, New York.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 200
Evans, J, Henderson, A & Johnson, N 2010, ‘The future of education and training in dental
technology: designing a dental curriculum that facilitates teamwork across the oral health
professions’, British Dental Journal, vol. 208, no. 5, pp. 227-30.
Everitt BS, Landau, S & Leese, M 2001, Cluster analysis, Oxford University Press, New York.
Evetts, J 1999, ‘Professionalisation and professionalism: issues for interprofessional care’, Journal
of Interprofessional Care, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 119-28.
Fallon, D, Warne, T, McAndrew, S & McLaughlin, H 2012, ‘An adult education: learning and
understanding what young users and carers really, really want in terms of their mental well-
being’, Nurse Education Today, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 128-32.
Fahrnet, B 2015, ‘On your marks, get set, go! —Lessons from the UK in enhancing employability
of graduates and postgraduates’, FEMS Microbiology Letters, vol. 362, no. 17, pp. 1-6.
Fair Work Commission 2018, Animal Care and Veterinary Services Award 2010, Fair Work
Commission, Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/documents/modern_awards/award/ma000118/default.htm
>.
Fanning, J & Shepherd, AJ 2010, ‘Contribution of veterinary technicians to veterinary business
revenue, 2007’, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 236, no. 8, p.
846.
Faraway JJ, 2006, Extending the linear model with R: generalized linear, mixed effects, and
nonparametric regression models, Chapman & Hall/ CRC, Boca Raton.
Faulconbridge, JR & Muzio, D 2012, ‘Professions in a globalizing world: towards a transnational
sociology of the professions’, International Sociology, vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 136-52.
Findlow, S 2012, ‘Higher education change and professional-academic identity in newly
“academic” disciplines: the case of nurse education’, Higher Education, vol. 63, pp. 117–33.
Fisher, J 2002, The early development of the Australian veterinary profession: the first half of the
twentieth century, Australian Veterinary History Society, The Australian Veterinary
Association, Sydney, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://www.ava.com.au/about-us/who-does-
what/groups/special-interest-groups-9>.
Flynn, DM 1979, ‘Animal-man relationship: occasional address at the Annual General Meeting of
the Australian College of Veterinary Scientists’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 55,
pp.547-49.
Fogle, B 1999, ‘The changing roles of animals in western society: influences upon and from the
veterinary profession’, Anthrozoös, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 234-9.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 201
Fook, J 2004,’ What professionals need from research: beyond evidence-based practice’, in D Smith
(ed.), Social work and evidence-based practice, Jessica Kingsley Publishers, London, pp. 29-
46.
Forsyth, S 1995, ‘Historical continuities and constraints in the professionalization of nursing’,
Nursing Inquiry, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 164-71.
Forsyth, PB & Danisiewcz, TJ 1985, ‘Towards a theory of professionalization’, Work and
Occupations, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 59-76.
Foster, SM & Maples, EH 2014, ‘Occupational stress in veterinary support staff’, Journal of
Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 102-10.
Fowler, C 2017, The boundaries and connections between the VET and higher education sectors:
‘confused, contested and collaborative’, occasional paper, National Centre for Vocational
Education Research, Adelaide, viewed 29 August 2018,
<https://www.ncver.edu.au/publications/publications/all-publications/the-boundaries-and-
connections-between-the-vet-and-higher-education-sectors-confused-contested-and-
collaborative>.
Frawley, PT 2003, Review of rural veterinary services report, Department of Agriculture, Fisheries
and Forestry and Department of Education, Science and Training, Canberra, viewed 10 March
2019, <https://www.ava.com.au/sites/default/files/documents/Other/Frawley%20report.pdf>.
Frawley, J 2017, Graduate qualities—what are they and why are they important?,
Teaching@Sydney homepage, The University of Sydney, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://sydney.edu.au/education-portfolio/ei/teaching@sydney/graduate-qualities-important/>.
Freidson, E 1970, Profession of medicine: a study of sociology of applied knowledge, Harper &
Row, New York.
Freidson, E 2001, Professionalism: the third logic—on the practice of knowledge, University of
Chicago Press, Chicago.
Freire, R, Phillips, CJC, Verrinder, JM, Collins, T, Degeling, C, Fawcett, A, Fisher, AD, Hazel, S,
Hood, J, Johnson, J, Lloyd, JFK, Stafford, K, Tzioumis, V & McGreevy, PD 2017, ‘The
Importance of animal welfare science and ethics to veterinary students in Australia and New
Zealand’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 44, no. 2, pp. 1-9.
Freshwater, D & Stickley, T 2004, ‘The heart of the art: emotional intelligence in nurse education’,
Nursing Inquiry, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 91-8.
Friedmann, E, Katcher, AH, Lynch, JJ & Thomas, SA 1980, ‘Animal companions and one-year
survival of patients after discharge from a coronary care unit’, Public Health Reports, vol. 95,
no. 4, pp. 307-12.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 202
Friedrichs, A & Schaub, H-A 2011, ‘Academisation of the health professions—achievements and
future prospects’, Medicine, vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 1-6.
Gamble, N, Patrick, C & Peach, D 2010, ‘Internationalizing work integrated learning: creating
global citizens to meet the economic crisis and skills shortage’, Higher Education Research &
Development, vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 535-46.
Ganobcsik-Williams, L 2006, Teaching academic writing in UK higher education: theories,
practices and models, Palgrave Macmillan, New York.
Gardner, H 1993, Multiple intelligences: the theory in practice, Basic Books, New York.
Goldie, J, Dowie, A, Cotton, P & Morrison, J 2007, ‘Teaching professionalism in the early years of
a medical curriculum: a qualitative study’, Medical Education, vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 610-17.
Goleman, G 1995, Working with emotional intelligence, Bantam Books, New York.
Grandison, MJ, Hudleston, AW, Lewis, PB & Ward, GL 1969, ‘Animal nursing auxiliaries’,
Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 45, p. 381.
Granello, DH 2001, ‘Promoting cognitive complexity in graduate written work: using Bloom’s
taxonomy as a pedagogical tool to improve literature reviews’, Counsellor Education &
Supervision, vol. 40, no. 4, pp. 292-307.
Grant, BM & Elizabeth, V 2015, ‘Unpredictable feelings: academic women under research audit’,
British Educational Research Journal, vol. 41, no. 2, pp. 287-302.
Grauenhorst, T, Blohm, M & Koch, A 2016, ‘Respondent incentives in a national face-to-face
survey: do they affect response quality?’, Field Methods, vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 266-83.
Grealish, L & Smale, LA 2011, ‘Theory before practice: implicit assumptions about clinical nursing
education in Australia as revealed through a shared critical reflection’, Contemporary Nurse,
vol. 39, no.1, pp. 51-64.
Greenwood, E 1957, ‘Attributes of a profession’, Social Work, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 44-5.
Grimes, DA & Schulz, KF 2008, ‘Making sense of odds and odds ratios’, Obstetrics & Gynecology,
vol. 111, no. 2, part 1, pp. 423-6.
Grotkowska, G, Wincenciak, L & Gajderowicz, T 2015, ‘Ivory-tower or market-oriented enterprise:
the role of higher education institutions in shaping graduate employability in the domain of
science’, Higher Education Research & Development, vol. 34, no. 5, pp. 869-82.
Gruending, DL 1985, ‘Nursing theory: a vehicle of professionalisation’, Journal of Advanced
Nursing vol. 10, no. 6, pp. 553-8.
Haga, T & Nakayama, H 2016, ‘Veterinary education in Asia, Far East and Oceania’, paper
presented to 4th OIE Global Conference on Veterinary Education, Bangkok, Thailand, 22-24
June.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 203
Hagedorn, R 2004, ‘An emergent profession—a personal perspective’, British Journal of
Occupational Therapy, vol. 67, no. 11, pp. 129-38.
Halfhill, T, Huff, JW, Sundstrom, E & Nielsen, TM 2003, ‘Group personality composition and
work team effectiveness: key factor in staffing the team-based organization?’, in M Beyerlein
(ed.), Advances in interdisciplinary studies of work teams, volume 9, Emerald Publishing
Group, Bingley, pp. 147-67.
Hall, P 2005, ‘Interprofessional team work: professional cultures as barriers’, Journal of
Interprofessional Care, vol. 19, (suppl. 1), pp. 188-96.
Hamdan, A 2012, ‘Autoethnography as genre of qualitative research: a journey inside out’,
International Institute for Qualitative Methodology, vol. 11, no. 5, pp. 585-606.
Hancock, G & Schubert, C 2007, ‘The utilisation of veterinary nurses in practice’, European
Journal of Companion Animal Practice, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 191-5.
Happell, B 2010, ‘Mental health nursing and education: walking the talk—consumer participation
in CQ University curriculum’, Australian Nursing Journal, vol. 18, no. 33, pp. 34.
Harris, MJ 2006, ‘Three steps to teaching abstract and critique writing’, International Journal of
Teaching and Learning in Higher Education, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 136-46.
Harris, L, Jones, M & Coutts, S 2010, ‘Partnerships and learning communities in work-integrated
learning: designing a community services student placement program’, Higher Education
Research & Development, vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 547-59.
Harrow, A 1972, A Taxonomy of the psychomotor domain: a guide for developing behavioral
objectives, David McKay Company, New York.
Hart, G & Rotem, A 1994, ‘The best and worst: students’ experience of clinical education’, The
Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 26–33.
Harvey, L 2000, ‘New realities: the relationship between higher education and employment’,
Tertiary Education and Management, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 3-17.
Hatch, PH, Winefield, HR, Christie, BA & Lievaart, JJ 2011, ‘Workplace stress, mental health, and
burnout of veterinarians in Australia’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 89, no. 11, pp. 460-8.
Headey, B 1999, ‘Health benefits and health cost savings due to pets: preliminary estimates from an
Australian national survey’, Social Indicators Research, vol. 47, p. 233-43.
Heaney, J, Ryan, P & Szombathelyi, MK 2012, ‘A comparison of higher education in Hungary and
Australia’, paper presented to the Academy of World Business Marketing and Management
Development (AWBMAMD) Conference, Budapest, 16-19 July.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 204
Heath, P 2002, National review of nursing education 2002: our duty of care, Department of
Education, Science and Training, Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://hdl.voced.edu.au/10707/121105>.
Heath, TJ 2004, ‘Changes in veterinarians' initial career experiences over the last five decades: an
abridged report’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 82, no. 10, pp. 602-4.
Heath, TJ & Mills, JN 2000, ‘Criteria used by employers to select new graduate employees’,
Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 78, no. 5, pp. 312-16.
Hegarty, J, Walsh E, Condon, C & Sweeney, J 2009, ‘The undergraduate education of nurses:
looking into the future’, International Journal of Nursing Education Scholarship, vol. 6, no. 1,
pp. 1-11.
Heinrich, KT, Neese, R, Rogers, D & Facente, AC 2004, ‘Turn accusations into affirmations:
transform nurses into published authors’, Nursing Education Perspectives, vol. 25, no. 3, pp.
139-45.
Hilton, S 2004, ‘Medical professionalism: how can we encourage it in our students?’, Clinical
Teacher, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 69-73.
Hinkle, JL, Fitzpatrick, E & Oskrochi, GR 2009, ‘Identifying the perception of needs of family
members visiting and nurses working in the intensive care unit’, Journal of Neuroscience
Nursing, vol. 41, no. 2, pp. 85-91.
Hirst, E, Henderson, R, Allan, M, Bode, J & Kocatepe, M 2004, ‘Repositioning academic literacy:
charting the emergence of a community of practice’, Australian Journal of Language and
Literacy, vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 66-80.
Hobson, R, Rolland, S, Rotgans, J, Schoonheim-Klein, M, Best, H, Chomyszyn-Gajewska, M,
Dymock, D & Essop, R 2008, ‘Quality assurance, benchmarking, assessment and mutual
international recognition of qualifications’, European Journal of Dental Education, vol. 12,
(suppl. 1), pp. 92-100.
Hojat, M 2009, ‘Ten approaches for enhancing empathy in health and human services cultures’,
Journal of Health and Human Services Administration, vol. 31, pp. 412-50.
Hojat, M, Erdmann, JB & Gonnella, JS 2013, ‘Personality assessment and outcomes in medical
education and the practice of medicine: AMEE Guide No. 79’, Medical Teacher, vol.35,
pp.1267-1301.
Hojat, M, Axelrod, D, Spandorfer, J & Mangione, S 2013, ‘Enhancing and sustaining empathy in
medical students’, Medical Teacher, vol. 35, no. 12. pp. 996-1001.
Holmes, L 2001, ‘Reconsidering graduate employability: the “graduate identity” approach’, Quality
in Higher Education, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 111-19.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 205
Homeland Security Council 2018, National strategy for pandemic influenza: implementation plan,
Homeland Security Council, Washington, viewed 12 August 2018,
<https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/pdf/pandemic-influenza-implementation.pdf >.
Honey, L 2016, ‘Vet Futures: taking account of the wider veterinary team’, Veterinary Record, vol.
179, no. 7, pp. 162-3.
Hong Kong Polytechnic University 2009, PolyU and RVC jointly launch HK’s first ever veterinary
nursing degree, media release, 16 September 2009, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong
Kong, viewed 20 February 2019,
<https://www.polyu.edu.hk/web/en/media/media_releases/index_id_1205.html>.
Hong Kong Veterinary Association 2019, Vet Nursing and Animal Care, Hong Kong Veterinary
Association, Hong Kong, viewed 18 January 2019,
<http://www.hkva.org/vetnurses_vnact.asp>.
Hong Kong Veterinary Nursing Association 2013, About Us: Hong Kong Veterinary Nursing
Association, Hong Kong Veterinary Nursing Association, viewed 28 February 2019,
<http://www.hkvna.org/aboutus.html>.
Hopcraft, M, McNally, C, Ng, C, Pek, L, Pham, TA, Phoon, WL, Poursoltan, P & Yu, W 2008,
‘Attitudes of the Victorian oral health workforce to the employment and scope of practice of
dental hygienists’, Australian Dental Journal, vol. 53, pp. 67-73.
Hunt, A, Adamson B, Higgs, J & Harris, L 1998, ‘University education and the physiotherapy
professional’, Physiotherapy, vol. 84, no. 6, pp. 264-73.
Hurley, J 2008, ‘The necessity, barriers and ways forward to meet user-based needs for emotionally
intelligent nurses’, Journal of Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse, vol. 15, no. 5, pp. 379-85.
Hunter, K & Docherty, P 2011, ‘Reducing variation in assessment in student writing’, Assessment
and Evaluation in Higher Education, vol. 36, no. 1, pp. 109-24.
Illingworth, P & Chelvanayagam, S 2007, ‘Benefits of interprofessional education in health care’,
British Journal of Nursing, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 121-4.
Institute of Medicine. 2011, The future of nursing: leading change, advancing health, The National
Academies Press, Washington, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.nap.edu/catalog/12956/the-future-of-nursing-leading-change-advancing-health>.
Ithaca Group 2012, Employability skills framework stage 1: final report, Department of Education,
Employment and Workplace Relations, Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://www.voced.edu.au/content/ngv%3A52686>.
Jackson, D 2014, ‘Factors influencing job attainment in recent bachelor graduates: evidence from
Australia’, Higher Education, vol. 68, pp. 135-53.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 206
Jackson, D 2016a, ‘Re-conceptualising graduate employability: the importance of pre-professional
identity’, Higher Education Research & Development, vol. 35, no. 5, pp. 925-39.
Jackson, D 2016b, ‘Skill mastery and the formation of graduate identity in bachelor graduates:
evidence from Australia’, Studies in Higher Education, vol. 41, no. 7, pp. 1313-32.
James, R, 2000, Socioeconomic background and higher education participation: an analysis of
school students’ aspirations and expectations, Department of Education, Training and Science,
Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019, <http://hdl.voced.edu.au/10707/150146>.
James, R 2001, ‘Participation disadvantage in Australian higher education: an analysis of some
effects of geographical location and socioeconomic status’, Higher Education, vol. 42, no. 4,
pp. 455-72.
James, R, Bexley, E & Shearer, M 2009, Improving selection for tertiary education places in
Victoria, commissioned report for the Department of Innovation, Industry & Regional
Development and Department of Education & Early Childhood Development, Melbourne,
viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://melbournecshe.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/1714681/Improving_Tertia
ry_Selection_in_Victoria.pdf>.
James, TA, Page, JS & Sprague, J 2016, ‘Promoting interprofessional collaboration in oncology
through a teamwork skills simulation programme’, Journal of Interprofessional Care, vol. 30,
no. 4, pp. 539-41.
Jevring, C 1993, ‘Do your support staff lay golden eggs?’, In Practice, vol. 15, no. 6, pp. 198-201.
JobOutlook 2018, Veterinary nurses: fast facts, Department of Jobs and Small Business, Australian
Government, Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://joboutlook.gov.au/occupation.aspx?code=3613>.
Johns, C 1995, ‘Framing learning through reflection with Carper’s fundamental ways of knowing in
nursing’, Journal of Advanced Nursing, vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 226-34.
Jongbloed-Zoet, C, Bol-van den Hil, EM, La Rivière-Ilsen, J & van der Sanden-Stoelinga, MSE
2012, ‘Dental hygienists in The Netherlands: the past, present and future’, International
Journal of Dental Hygiene, vol. 10, pp. 148-54.
Kaldor, S & Rochecouste, J 2002, ‘General academic writing and discipline specific academic
writing’, Australian Review of Applied Linguistics, vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 29-47.
Kasetsart University 2015, Faculty of veterinary technology, Kasetsart University, Bangkok,
viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.ku.ac.th/web2012/index.php?c=adms&m=selcon_eng&time=20120806115110>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 207
Keogh, JJ, Fourie, WJ, Watson & Gay, H 2010, ‘Involving stakeholders in the curriculum process:
a recipe for success?’, Nurse Education Today, vol. 30, pp. 37-43.
Kinnison, T, May, SA & Guile, D 2014, ‘Inter-professional practice: from veterinarian to the
veterinary team’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 41, no. 2, pp. 172-8.
Kinnison, T, May, SA & Guile, D 2015, ‘Veterinary team interactions, part one: the practice effect’,
Veterinary Record, vol. 177, no. 16, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://veterinaryrecord.bmj.com/content/177/16/419>.
Kirkpatrick, A & Mulligan, D 2002, ‘Cultures of learning: critical reading in the social and applied
sciences’, Australian Review of Applied Linguistics, vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 73-99.
Knight, P & Yorke, M, 2004, Learning, curriculum and employability in higher education,
Routledge Falmer, London.
Kogan, LR & Stewart, SM 2009, ‘Veterinary professional associates: does the profession’s
foresight include a mid-tier professional similar to physician assistants?’, Journal of Veterinary
Medical Education, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 220-5.
Kraska-Miller, M 2013, Nonparametric statistics for social and behavioral sciences [ebook],
Chapman and Hall/CRC, Boca Raton, pp. 87-93.
Krasner, MS, Epstein, RM, Beckman, H, Suchman, AL, Chapman, B, Mooney, CJ & Quill, TE
2009, ‘Association of an educational program in mindful communication with burnout,
empathy, and attitudes among primary care physicians’, Journal of the American Medical
Association, vol. 302, no. 12, pp. 1284-93.
Krathwohl, DR, Bloom, BS & Masia, BB 1964, Taxonomy of educational objectives, book II:
affective domain, David McKay Company, New York.
Laidlaw, A, Guild, S & Struthers, J 2009, ‘Graduate attributes in the disciplines of medicine,
dentistry and veterinary medicine: a survey of expert opinions’, BMC Medical Education, vol.
9, no. 28, pp. 1-6.
Laiho, A 2010, ‘Academisation of nursing education in the Nordic countries’, Higher Education,
vol. 60, pp. 641-56.
Landsberg, GM, Shaw, J & Donaldson, J 2008, ‘Handling behaviour problems in the practice
setting’, Veterinary Clinics of North America Small Animal Practice, vol. 38, no. 5, pp. 951-69.
Langebæk, R, Tanggaard, L & Berendt, M 2016, ‘Veterinary students’ recollection methods for
surgical procedures: a qualitative study’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 43, no.
1. pp. 64-70.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 208
Lantra 2004, Veterinary nursing manpower survey. Survey into recruitment, retention, education
and training issues relating to veterinary nursing, Lantra, Warwickshire, viewed 16 March
2009, <http://www.lantra. co.uk/stakeholders/research-documents/?assetdet¼6169 &p¼6>.
Larson, MS 1977, The rise of professionalism: a sociological analysis, University of California
Press, Berkeley.
Latrobe University 2018, University Handbook 2018: Bachelor of Veterinary Nursing, Latrobe
University, Melbourne, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.latrobe.edu.au/handbook/2018/undergraduate/she/science-psych/single-
degrees/sbvn.htm>.
Law, KS, Wong, LJ & Song, C 2004, ‘The construct and criterion validity of emotional intelligence
and its potential utility for management studies’ Journal of Applied Psychology, vol. 89, no. 3,
pp. 483-96.
Lea, MR & Street, BV1998, ‘Student writing in higher education: an academic literacies approach’,
Studies in Higher Education vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 57-72.
Leach, L 2013, ‘Participation and equity in higher education: are we going back to the future?’,
Oxford Review of Education, vol. 39, no. 2, pp. 267-286.
Leavey, P 2017, Research design, quantitative, qualitative, mixed methods, arts-based and
community based participatory research approaches, The Guildford Press, New York.
Lemieux-Charles, L & McGuire, WL 2006, ‘What do we know about health care team
effectiveness? A review of the literature’, Medical Care Research & Review, vol. 63, no. 3, pp.
263-300.
LePine, JA, Buckman, BR, Crawford, ER & Methot, JR 2011, ‘A review of research on personality
in teams: accounting for pathways spanning levels of theory and analysis’, Human Resource
Management Review, vol. 21, pp. 311-30.
Lin, PS, Viscardi, MK & McHugh, MD 2014, ‘Factors influencing job satisfaction of new graduate
nurses participating in nurse residency programs: a systematic review’, Journal of Continuing
Education in Nursing, vol. 45, no. 10, pp. 439-50.
Lindsay, E 2014, An analysis of the gender wage gap in the Australian graduate labour market,
2013, Graduate Careers Australia, Melbourne, viewed 3 January 2018,
<http://www.graduatecareers.com.au/research/surveys/graduateoutlooksurvey/>.
Liss, D 2012, ‘Technician utilization’, Veterinary Team Brief, viewed 4 January 2018,
<http://www.veterinaryteambrief.com/article/technician-utilization>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 209
Litchfield, A, Frawley, J & Nettleton, S 2010, ‘Contextualising and integrating into the curriculum
the learning and teaching of work‐ready professional graduate attributes’, Higher Education
Research & Development, vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 519-34.
Lloyd, JW 2007, ‘Enhancing non-technical skills, knowledge, aptitudes and attitudes in the
veterinary profession through the work of National Commission on Veterinary Economic
Issues’, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 230, no. 11, pp. 1646-52.
Lodico, MG, Spaulding, DT & Voegtle, KH 2010, Methods in educational research: from theory to
practice, 2nd edn, Jossey-Bass, San Fransisco.
Lukens, R & Walsh, D 2015, ‘The dynamic history of veterinary technology and nursing’,
Association of American Veterinary Technician Educators, Springfield, Illinois, pp. 1-47,
viewed 10 March 2019, <http://docplayer.net/10067780-The-dynamic-history-of-veterinary-
technology-and-nursing-dedication-the-beginning-1777-1960-the-first-50-years-1961-2011-
beyond.html>.
Lusk, B, Russell, R, Rodgers, J & Wilson-Barnett, J 2001, ‘Pre-registration nursing education in
Australia, New Zealand and the USA’, Journal of Nursing Education, vol. 40, no. 5, pp.197-
202.
Luthy, KE, Peterson, NE, Lassetter, JH & Callister, LC 2009, ‘Successfully incorporating writing
across the curriculum with advanced writing in nursing’, Journal of Nursing Education, vol.
48, no. 1, pp. 54-9.
Luvaas, B 2017, ‘Unbecomings: the aftereffects of autoethnography’, Ethnography,
DOI: 10.1177/1466138117742674.
MacMartin, C, Wheat, HC, Coe, JB & Adams, CL 2018, ‘Conversation analysis of veterinarians
proposals for long term dietary change in companion animal practice in Ontario, Canada’,
Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 45, no. 4, pp. 514-33.
Mahony, K 2003, ‘The politics of professionalisation: some implications for the occupation of
ambulance paramedics in Australia’, Australasian Journal of Paramedicine, vol. 1, no. 3,
viewed 10 March 2019, <https://ajp.paramedics.org/index.php/ajp/article/view/198>.
Mansbridge, SC & Buckley, LA 2018, ‘Getting started with your veterinary nursing dissertation:
what can I research?’, Veterinary Nurse Journal, vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 175-7.
Mason, G, Williams, G & Cranmer, S 2009, ‘Employability skills in higher education: what effects
do they have on graduate labour market outcomes?’, Education Economics, vol. 17, no. 1, pp.
1-30.
Massey University 2018, Programmes and courses: Bachelor of Veterinary Technology, Massey
University, Palmerston North, viewed 10 March 2019,
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 210
<http://www.massey.ac.nz/massey/learning/programme-
course/programme.cfm?prog_id=93432>.
Massey University College of Sciences 2008, The Committee on University Academic
Programmes: introduction of a new qualification - Bachelor of Veterinary Technology, Massey
University, Palmerston North.
Matthews, D 2016, Graduate outlook 2015, the report of the 2015 graduate outlook survey:
perspectives on graduate recruitment, Graduate Careers Australia, Melbourne, Australia,
viewed 3 January 2018,
<http://www.graduatecareers.com.au/research/surveys/graduateoutlooksurvey/>.
Maxwell, JA 2010, ‘Using numbers in qualitative research’, Qualitative Inquiry, vol. 16, no. 6, pp.
475-82.
Mayer, JD, Salovey, P & Caruso, D 2000, ‘Models of emotional intelligence’, in R Sternberg (ed.),
Handbook of intelligence, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 396-420.
McArthur, ML & Fitzgerald, JR 2013, ‘Companion animal veterinarians’ use of clinical
communication skills’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 91, no. 9, pp. 374-80.
McAtavey, J & Nikolovska, I 2010, ‘Team collectivist culture: a remedy for creating team
effectiveness’, Human Resource Development Quarterly, vol. 21, no. 3, pp. 307-16.
McCallin, A & McCallin, M 2009, ‘Factors influencing team working and strategies to facilitate
successful collaborative teamwork’, New Zealand Journal of Physiotherapy, vol. 37, no. 2, pp.
61-7.
McCowan, T 2015, ‘Should universities promote employability?’, Theory and Research in
Education, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 267-85.
McCrae, RR & Costa, PT, Jr 1987, ‘Validation of the Five-Factor model of personality across
instruments and observers’, Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, vol. 52, no. 1, pp. 81-
90.
McCrae, RR & Costa, PT, Jr 1991, ‘Adding Liebe und Arbeit: the full Five-Factor Model and well-
being’, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 227-32.
McCrae, RR & John, OP 1992, ‘An introduction to the Five-Factor Model and its applications’,
Journal of Personality, vol. 60, pp. 175-215.
McGreevy, PD & Dixon, RJ 2005, ‘Teaching animal welfare at the University of Sydney’s Faculty
of Veterinary Science’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 32, no. 4, pp. 442-6.
McMillan, LR & Raines, K 2010, ‘Headed in the “write direction”: nursing student publication and
health promotion in the community’, Journal of Nursing Education, vol. 49, no. 7, pp. 418-21.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 211
Meehan, M & Bradley, L 2007, ‘Identifying and evaluating job stress within the Australian small
animal veterinary profession’, Australian Veterinary Practitioner, vol. 37, no. 2, pp. 70-8.
Mellanby, RJ, Rhind, SM, Bell, C, Shaw, DJ, Gifford, J, Fennell, D, Manser, C, Spratt, DP, Wright,
MJH, Zago, S & Hudson, NPH 2011, ‘Perceptions of clients and veterinarians on what
attributes constitute “a good vet” ’, Veterinary Record, vol. 168, no. 23, pp. 616.
Mills, P 2003, ‘Group project work with undergraduate veterinary science students’, Assessment &
Evaluation in Higher Education, vol. 28, no. 5, pp. 527-38.
Mitchell, S & Ganobcsik-Williams, L 2008, ‘The role of writing development in the university:
reality and visions’, paper presented to the third international Inquiring Pedagogies (iPED)
Conference, Coventry University, UK, 8-9 September.
Moodie, G 2010, Mixed sector tertiary education: implications for self-accrediting and other
higher education institutions, issues paper, National Centre for Vocational Education Research,
Adelaide, viewed 8 March 2019, <https://www.ncver.edu.au/publications/publications/all-
publications/mixed-sector-tertiary-education-implications-for-self-accrediting-and-other-
higher-education-institutions#>.
Moodie, G, Fredman, N, Bexley, E & Wheelahan, L 2013, Vocational education’s variable links to
vocations, research report, National Centre for Vocational Education Research, Adelaide,
viewed 8 March 2019, <https://www.ncver.edu.au/publications/publications/all-
publications/vocational-educations-variable-links-to-vocations>.
Moodie, G, Wheelahan, L, Fredman, N & Bexley, E 2015, Towards a new approach to mid-level
qualifications, research report, National Centre for Vocational Education Research, Adelaide,
viewed 8 March 2019, <https://www.ncver.edu.au/publications/publications/all-
publications/towards-a-new-approach-to-mid-level-qualifications>.
Mooi, E & Sarstedt, M 2011, ‘Chapter 9: Cluster analysis’, in A concise guide to market research,
Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, viewed 8 March 2019, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-12541-6,
(SpringerLink).
Moore, IC, Coe, JB, Adams, CL, Conlon, PD & Sargeant, JM 2015, ‘Exploring the impact of toxic
attitudes and a toxic environment on the veterinary healthcare team’, Frontiers in Veterinary
Science, vol. 2, no. 78, pp. 1-9.
Morgan, A & Jones, D, 2009, ‘Perceptions of service-user and carer involvement in health care
education and impact on student’s knowledge and practice: a literature review’, Medical
Teacher, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 82-95.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 212
Morgeson, FP, Reider, MH & Campion, MA 2005, ‘Selecting individuals in team settings: the
importance of social skills, personality characteristics, and teamwork knowledge’, Personnel
Psychology, vol. 58, no. 33, pp. 583-611.
Mossop, L & Gray, C 2008, ‘Teaching communication skills’, In Practice, vol. 30, no. 6, pp. 340-
43.
Moyo, M, Goodyear-Smith, FA, Weller, J, Robb, G & Shulruf, B 2016, ‘Healthcare practitioners’
personal and professional values’, Advances in Health Science Education, vol. 21, no. 2, pp.
257-86.
Naidoo, R & Jamieson, I 2005, ‘Empowering participants or corroding learning: towards a research
agenda on the impact of student consumerism in higher education’, Journal of Education
Policy, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 267-81.
National Association of Veterinary Technicians in America 2017, ‘NAVTA moves forward with
veterinary nurse credential change: veterinary nurse initiative coalition will now pursue
legislative amendments in 50 states’, press release, 15 May 2017, National Association of
Veterinary Technicians in America, Schaumburg, viewed 8 March 2019,
<https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.navta.net/resource/resmgr/vn_initiative/NAVTA_Veterinary_
Nurse_Board.pdf>.
National Association of Veterinary Technicians in America 2018a, NAVTA, National Association of
Veterinary Technicians in America, Schaumberg, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.navta.net/>.
National Association of Veterinary Technicians in America 2018b, NAVTA 2016 survey
demographic results, National Association of Veterinary Technicians in America, Schaumburg,
viewed 8 March 2019, <http://www.navta.net/?page=demographic_survey>.
National Health and Medical Research Council 2015, National statement on ethical conduct in
human research 2007- (Updated May 2015), Australian Government, Canberra, viewed
January 2015, <https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/guidelines-publications/e72>.
National Health and Medical Research Council 2018, National statement on ethical conduct in
human research 2007- (Updated 2018), Australian Government, Canberra, viewed 8 March
2019, <https://nhmrc.gov.au/about-us/publications/national-statement-ethical-conduct-human-
research-2007-updated-2018#block-views-block-file-attachments-content-block-1>.
National Research Council 2011, Workforce needs in veterinary medicine, National Academies
Press, Washington, DC, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://dels.nas.edu/banr/Reports-Academies-Findings>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 213
National Research Council 2013, Workforce needs in veterinary medicine, The National Academies
Press, Washington DC, viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://www.nap.edu/catalog/13413/workforce-needs-in-veterinary-medicine>.
Neal, A, Yeo, G, Koy, A & Xiao, T 2012, ‘Predicting the form and direction of work role
performance from the Big 5 model of personality traits’, Journal of Organizational Behaviour,
vol. 33, pp. 175-92.
Nelis, D, Kotsou, I, Quoidbach, J, Hansenne, M, Weytens, F, Dupuis, P & Mikolajczak, M 2011,
‘Increasing emotional competence improves psychological and physical well-being, social
relationships and employability’, Emotion, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 354-66.
Neuman, GA & Wright, J 1999, ‘Team effectiveness: beyond skills and cognitive ability’, Journal
of Applied Psychology, vol. 84, no. 3, pp. 376-89.
Neumann, G 2007, Transition of veterinary students to rural practice, continuing professional
development and sustainable rural veterinary practices, phase I: identification of key issues
and proposals to mitigate their effects report, Australian Veterinary Association, Sydney,
viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://www.ava.com.au/sites/default/files/documents/Other/Neumann%20Report%20on%20
Rural%20Practice.pdf>.
Newton, J & McKenna, L 2007, ‘The transition journey through the graduate year: a focus group
study’, International Journal of Nursing Studies, vol. 44, pp. 1231-7.
New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2015, Review of animal care and veterinary nursing
qualifications, New Zealand Government, Wellington, viewed, 9 March 2019,
<http://www.nzqa.govt.nz/nqfdocs/summaries/2015/jan15/revsumjan15-13.html>.
New Zealand Veterinary Nursing Association 2016a, Regulation: Allied Veterinary Professional
Regulatory Council, New Zealand Veterinary Nursing Association, Auckland, viewed 10
March 2019, <https://www.nzvna.org.nz/regulation.html>.
New Zealand Veterinary Nursing Association 2016b, Register of veterinary nurses, New Zealand
Veterinary Nursing Association, Auckland, viewed 24 September 2018,
<https://www.nzvna.org.nz/regulation/Register+of+Veterinary+Nurses.html>.
New Zealand Veterinary Nursing Association 2018, My career, New Zealand Veterinary Nursing
Association, Auckland, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://www.nzvna.org.nz/My+Career.html>.
Nielsen, NO 2003, ‘Will the veterinary profession flourish in the future?’, Journal of Veterinary
Medical Education, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 301-7.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 214
Nilsson, S 2007, ‘From higher education to professional practice: a comparative study of
physicians’ and engineers’ learning and competence use’, PhD thesis, Linköping University,
Linköping.
Nippon and Veterinary Life Science University 2017, Undergraduate School. Faculty of Veterinary
Science: School of Veterinary Nursing and Technology, Nippon and Veterinary Life Science
University, Tokyo, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://www.nvlu.ac.jp/en/undergraduate/001.html/>.
Norkus, CL, Liss, DJ & Leighton, LS 2016, ‘Characteristics of the labor market for veterinary
technician specialists in 2013’, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, vol.
248, no. 1, pp. 105-9.
Norman, G & Eva, KW 2014, ‘Quantitative research methods in medical education: the quantitative
paradigm’, in T Swanwick (ed.), Understanding medical education: theory and practice, 2nd
edn, pp. 349-69.
Norton, J 2010, ‘Retention and personal development: assessing the role of universities in assisting
students to navigate psychological demands of higher education’, Journal of the Australian and
New Zealand Student Services Association, vol. 35, pp. 55-70.
Novack, DH, Suchman, AL, Clark, W, Epstein, RM, Najberg, E & Kaplanet, C 1997, ‘Calibrating
the physician; personal awareness and effective patient care’, Journal of the American Medical
Association, vol. 278, no. 6, pp. 502-9.
Nowack, K 2006, ‘Emotional intelligence: leaders make a difference’, HR Trends, vol. 17, pp. 40-2.
O’Brien, K, Moore, A, Hartley, P & Dawson, D 2013, ‘Lessons about work readiness from final
year paramedic students in an Australian university’, Australasian Journal of Paramedicine,
vol. 10 no. 4, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://ajp.paramedics.org/index.php/ajp/article/view/52>.
O’Brien, K, Moore, A, Dawson, D & Hartley, P 2014, ‘An Australian story: paramedic education
and practice in transition’, Australasian Journal of Paramedicine vol. 11, no. 3, viewed 10
March 2019, <https://ajp.paramedics.org/index.php/ajp/article/view/14>.
Ogden, J & Lo, J 2011, ‘How meaningful are data from Likert scales? An evaluation of how ratings
are made and the role of the response shift in the socially disadvantaged’, Journal of Health
Psychology, vol. 17, no. 3, pp. 350-61.
O’Neill, TA & Allen, NJ 2011, ‘Personality and the prediction of team performance’, European
Journal of Personality, vol. 25, pp. 31-42.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 215
Osmani, M, Weerakkody, V, Hindi, NM, Al-Esmail, R, Eldabi, T, Kapoor, K & Irani, Z 2015,
‘Identifying the trends and impact of graduate attributes on employability: a literature review’,
Tertiary Education and Management, vol. 21, no. 4, p. 367-79.
Page-Jones, S & Abbey, G 2015, ‘Career identity in the veterinary profession’, Veterinary Record,
vol. 176, no. 17, pp. 425-26.
Patton, MQ 2015, Qualitative research & evaluation methods, 4th edn, Sage Publications, Thousand
Oaks.
Paul, ES & Podberscek, AL 2000, ‘Veterinary students’ attitudes towards animal welfare’,
Veterinary Record, vol. 146, no. 10, pp. 269-72.
Paulhus, DL 1984, ‘Two-component models of socially desirable responding’, Journal of Personnel
Social Psychology, vol. 46, no. 3, p. 598.
Peach, SA 2010, ‘A curriculum philosophy for higher education: socially critical vocationalism’,
Teaching in Higher Education, vol. 15, no. 4, pp. 449-60.
Peeters, MA, Harries, FJ, Van Tuijl, JM, Rutte, CG & Reymen, IM 2006, ‘Personality and team
performance: a meta-analysis’, European Journal of Personality, vol. 20, no. 5, pp. 377-96.
Peplau, H 1988, ‘The art and science of nursing: similarities, differences, and relations’, Nursing
Quarterly, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 8-15.
Petrides, K 2001, TEIQue version 1.50, London Psychometric Laboratory, University College
London, viewed 10 March 2019, <http://psychometriclab.com/overview/>.
Petrides, KV & Furnham, A 2001, ‘Trait emotional intelligence: psychometric investigation with
reference to established trait taxonomies’, European Journal of Personality, vol. 15, no. 6, pp.
425-48.
Petrides, KV, Furnham, A & Frederickson, N 2004, ‘Emotional intelligence’, The Psychologist, vol.
17, no. 10, pp. 574-6.
Petrides, KV, Pita, R & Kokkinaki, F 2007, ‘The location of trait emotional intelligence in
personality factor space’, British Journal of Psychology, vol. 98, no. 2, pp. 273-89.
Podsakoff, PM, MacKenzie, SB & Podsakoff, NP 2012, ‘Sources of method bias in social science
research and recommendations on how to control it’, Annual Review of Psychology, vol. 63, pp.
539-69.
Pritchard, WR 1994, ‘A changing world and a changing profession challenge veterinary medical
education’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 119-23.
Probert, B 2016, ‘The era of universal participation in higher education: Australian policy problems
in relation to cost, equity and quality’, HERDSA Occasional Paper, Higher Education
Research and Development Society of Australasia Inc., Hammondville, Australia.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 216
Purdue University 2007a, Comparative pathobiology graduate admission information, Purdue
University, West Lafayette, viewed 20 January 2008,
<http://www.vet.purdue.edu/cpb/graduateprograms/admission.html>.
Purdue University 2007b, SVM veterinary technology program 2007, program curriculum: 4-year
baccalaureate curriculum (BS degree), Purdue University, West Lafayette, viewed 23 February
2009, <http://www.vet.purdue.edu/ vettech/4-year.html>.
Purdue University 2018, Purdue University College of Veterinary Medicine: veterinary nursing,
Purdue University, West Lafayette, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://vet.purdue.edu/nursing/>.
Race, P 2001, A briefing on self, peer and group assessment, Assessment series no. 9, Learning and
Teaching Support Network, York, viewed 29 September 2018,
<http://www.bioscience.heacademy.ac.uk/ftp/Resources/gc/assess09SelfPeerGroup.pdf>.
Radford AD, Stockley P, Turner IR, Gaskell, CJ, Kaney, S, Humphris, G & Magrath, C 2003, ‘Use
of simulated clients in training veterinary undergraduates in communication skills’, Veterinary
Record, vol. 152, no. 14, pp. 422-7.
Registered Veterinary Technologists and Technicians of Canada 2018, RVTTC—Who are we?,
Registered Veterinary Technologists and Technicians of Canada, Kemptville, viewed 10 March
2019, <https://rvttcanada.ca/about-us/>.
Reid, J 1994, Nursing education in Australian universities: a report of the national review of nurse
education in the higher education sector, 1994 and beyond, Australian Government Publishing
Service, Canberra.
Reid, I & Parker, L 2002, ‘Framing institutional policies on literacies’, Australian Review of
Applied Linguistics vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 19-27.
Reeve, J 1989, ‘The interest-enjoyment distinction in intrinsic motivation’, Motivation and
Enjoyment vol. 13, no. 2, p. 83-103.
Ressler, SJ 2011, ‘The sociology of professions: application to the civil engineering “raise the bar”
initiative’, Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, vol. 137, no.
3, pp. 151-61.
Rhee, J, Parent, D & Basu, A 2013, ‘The influence of personality and ability on undergraduate
teamwork and team performance’, SpringerPlus, vol. 2, no. 16, viewed 8 March 2019,
<http://www.springerplus.com/content/2/1/16>.
Rhodes, C 2012, ‘User involvement in health and social care education: a concept analysis’, Nurse
Education Today, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 185-9.
Rospigliosi, P, Bourner, T & Heath, L 2016, ‘Universities' engagement with vocationalism:
historical perspective’, International Journal for Research in Vocational Education and
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 217
Training, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 185-211.
Roufeil, L & Battye, K 2008, Effective regional, rural and remote family and relationship service
delivery, Institute of Family Services, Melbourne, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://aifs.gov.au/cfca/publications/effective-regional-rural-and-remote-family-and-
relationship#defining>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2007, RCVS List of Veterinary Nurses 2007 now available,
RCVS News, 22 June 2007, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March
2019, <https://www.rcvs.org.uk/news-and-views/news/rcvs-list-of-veterinary-nurses-2007-
now-available/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2010, ‘New qualification development on the last lap’, VN
Standard Extra, May 2010, p.1, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10
March 2019, <https://www.rcvs.org.uk/news-and-views/publications/vn-standard-extra-may-
2010/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2015a, RCVS News: New Royal Charter comes into effect,
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.rcvs.org.uk/news-and-views/news/new-royal-charter-comes-into-effect/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2015b, ‘International reach’, VN Education: The RCVS
Veterinary Nurse Training Newsletter, May 2015, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons,
London, viewed 10 March 2019, <file:///C:/Users/clark/Downloads/vneducation-
may15%20(5).pdf>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018a, I want to be a veterinary nurse, Royal College of
Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://animalowners.rcvs.org.uk/veterinary-careers/i-want-to-be-a-veterinary-nurse/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018b, RCVS Knowledge 2018: Veterinary nursing timeline,
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://knowledge.rcvs.org.uk/heritage-and-history/history-of-the-veterinary-
profession/veterinary-nursing-timeline/?action=show&module=send-to-friend>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018c, Training routes, Royal College of Veterinary
Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://animalowners.rcvs.org.uk/veterinary-careers/i-want-to-be-a-veterinary-nurse/training-
routes/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018d, Veterinary nursing careers leaflets: could you be a
veterinary nurse?, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.rcvs.org.uk/document-library/veterinary-nursing-careers-leaflet/>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 218
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018e, List of RCVS accredited higher education
qualifications in veterinary nursing, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10
March 2019, <https://animalowners.rcvs.org.uk/document-library/list-of-rcvs-accredited-
higher-education-qualifications-in/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018f, Code of professional conduct for veterinary nurses,
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.rcvs.org.uk/setting-standards/advice-and-guidance/code-of-professional-conduct-
for-veterinary-nurses/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018g, Accrediting veterinary nursing qualifications, Royal
College of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.rcvs.org.uk/setting-standards/accrediting-primary-qualifications/accrediting-
veterinary-nursing-qualifications/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018h, Accrediting veterinary qualifications, Royal College
of Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.rcvs.org.uk/setting-standards/accrediting-primary-qualifications/accrediting-
veterinary-degrees/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2018i, Enrolling as a student veterinary nurse: VN
enrolment form and guidance notes, p. 2, Veterinary Nursing Department, Royal College of
Veterinary Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://www.rcvs.org.uk/document-
library/vn-enrolment-form-and-guidance-notes/>.
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons 2019, About the VN Register, Royal College of Veterinary
Surgeons, London, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.rcvs.org.uk/registration/check-the-register/about-the-vn-register/>.
Royal Veterinary College 2017, BSc veterinary nursing: the course, University of London,
Hawkshead campus, viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://www.rvc.ac.uk/study/undergraduate/bsc-veterinary-nursing>.
Royal Veterinary College, University of London 2018, Our people: Professor Sue Gregory,
University of London, Hawkshead campus, viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://www.rvc.ac.uk/about/our-people/sue-gregory>.
Rubin, HE 2003, ‘National Commission on Veterinary Economic Issues. Reversing the downward
trend’, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 223, no. 3, pp. 306-7.
Ruby, KL & DeBowes, RM 2007, ‘The veterinary healthcare team: going from good to great’,
Veterinary Clinics of North America Small Animal Practice, vol. 37, no. 1, pp.19-35.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 219
Rural Training Council of Australia 1999, Succeeding with the veterinary nursing training package,
Rural Training Council of Australia, Canberra.
RVC News 2014, RVC veterinary nurses graduate in Hong Kong, Royal College of Veterinary
Surgeons, University of London, Hawkshead campus, viewed 9 March 2019,
<https://www.rvc.ac.uk/news-and-events/rvc-news/rvc-veterinary-nurses-graduate-in-hong-
kong>.
Ryan, RM & Deci, EL 2000, ‘Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: classic definitions and new
directions’, Contemporary Educational Psychology vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 54-67.
Ryan, R & Lynch, M 2003, ‘Motivation and classroom management’, in R Curren (ed.), A
companion to the philosophy of education, Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 260-271.
Sargeant, J, Loney, E & Murphy, G 2008, ‘Effective interprofessional teams: “contact is not
enough” to build a team’, Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, vol. 28,
no. 4, pp. 228-34.
Sax, S 1978, Nurse education and training: report of the committee of inquiry into nurse education
and training to the Tertiary Education Commission, Tertiary Education Commission, Canberra,
viewed 10 March 2019, <http://www.voced.edu.au/content/ngv%3A35641>.
Schmidt, HG & Moust, JHC 2000, ‘Factors affecting small-group tutorial learning: a review of
research’, in DH Evensen & CE Hmelo (eds), Problem-based learning: a research perspective
on learning interactions, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, New Jersey, pp. 19-51.
Schön, D 2003, The reflective practitioner: how professionals think in action, Ashgate Publishing,
Cornwall.
School of Veterinary Science Teaching & Learning Committee 2011, ‘Item 3.1: Science Faculty
review of veterinary technology’, minutes of School of Veterinary Science Teaching &
Learning Committee meeting, 12 December 2011, School of Veterinary Science, University of
Queensland.
Schull, D, Clarke, P, Meehan, M & Barnes, T 2012a, ‘Veterinary technology/nursing student
perceptions of an experiential simulated client communication workshop’, The Veterinary
Nurse, vol. 3, no. 5, pp. 314-20.
Schull, D, Morton, J, Coleman, G & Mills, P 2012b, ‘Final-year student and employer views of
essential personal, interpersonal and professional attributes for new veterinary science
graduates’, Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 90, no. 3, pp. 100-4.
Schull, DN, Kyle, GJ, Coleman, GT & Mills, PC 2012c, ‘Attributes of clinical role models as
described by senior veterinary students in Australia’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education,
vol. 39, no. 3, pp. 263-6.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 220
Scofield, J 2012, ‘Notes from a VN abroad – Hong Kong’, Veterinary Nursing Journal, vol. 27, no.
9, pp. 353-4.
Shaw, MC 1993, ‘The discipline of nursing: historical roots, current perspectives, future directions’,
Journal of Advanced Nursing, vol. 18, pp. 1651-6.
Shaw, J 2006, ‘Four core communication skills of highly effective practitioners’, Veterinary Clinics
of North America Small Animal Practice, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 385-96.
Shaw, J Barley, GE, Hill, AE, Larson, S & Roter, DL 2010, ‘Communication skills education onsite
in a veterinary practice’, Pet Education and Counselling, vol. 80, pp. 337-44.
Shaw, JR, Bonnett, BN, Roter, DL, Adams CL & Larson, S 2012, ‘Gender differences in
veterinarian-client-patient communication in companion animal practice’, Journal of the
American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 241, no. 1, pp. 81-8.
Shemla, M, Meyer, B, Greer, L & Jehn, KA 2016, ‘A review of perceived diversity in teams: does
how members perceive their team’s composition affect team processes and outcomes?’,
Journal of Organizational Behavior, vol. 37, (suppl. 1), pp. 89-106.
Siegel, JM 1990, ‘Stressful life events and use of physician services among the elderly: the
moderating role of pet ownership’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 58, no.
6, pp. 1081-6.
Shiralkar MT, Harris TB, Eddins-Folensbee, FF & Coverdale, JH 2013, ‘A systematic review of
stress-management programs for medical students’, Academic Psychiatry, vol. 37, no. 3, pp.
58-64.
Sivo, SA, Saunders, C, Chang, Q & Jian, JJ 2006, ‘How low should you go? Low response rates
and the validity of inference in IS questionnaire research’, Journal of the Associations for
Information Systems, vol. 6, no. 6, pp. 352-414.
Skipper, GE & Williams, JB 2012, ‘Failure to acknowledge high suicide risks among veterinarians’,
Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 79-82.
Smith, D & Cooper, B 2015, ‘Regulations relating to registered veterinary nurses in the United
Kingdom’, Proceedings of the Kerala Veterinary Science Congress 2015, Indian Veterinary
Association, Kerala, India, pp. 212-14, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.napier.ac.uk/~/media/worktribe/output-170066/regulations-relating-to-registered-
veterinary-nurses-in-the-united-kingdom.pdf>.
Smith, EB & Hou, Y 2015, ‘Redundant heterogeneity and group performance’, Organization
Science, vol. 26, no.1, pp. 37-51.
Southgate, E & Bennett, A 2014, ‘Excavating widening participation policy in Australian higher
education’, Creative Approaches to Research, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 21-45.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 221
Sparkes, V 2002, ‘Profession and professionalisation, part 1: role and identity of undergraduate
physiotherapy educators’, Physiotherapy, vol. 88, no. 8, pp. 481-92.
Starr, LJ 2010, ‘The use of autoethnography in educational research: locating who we are in what
we do’, Canadian Journal for New Scholars in Education, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 1-9.
Stata Corporation 2011, Stata Statistical Software: Stata 12.0, Stata Corporation, Texas.
Steur, JM, Jansen, EP & Hofman, WH 2012, ‘Graduateness: an empirical examination of the
formative function of a university education’, Higher Education, vol. 64, pp. 861-74.
Stott, A 2004, ‘Issues in the socialization process of the male student nurse: implications for
retention in undergraduate nursing courses’, Nurse Education Today, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 91-7.
Suter, E, Arndt, J & Arthur, N 2009, ‘Role understanding and effective communication as core
competencies for collaborative practice’, Journal of Interprofessional Care, vol. 23, no. 1, pp.
41-51.
Sutkin, G, Wagner, E, Harris, I & Schiffer, R 2008, ‘What makes a good clinical teacher in
medicine? A review of the literature’, Academic Medicine, vol. 83, no. 5, pp. 452-66.
Taylor, RI 2002, History of the Australian College of Veterinary Scientists, Australian Veterinary
Association, Sydney, viewed 10 March 2019, < https://www.ava.com.au/about-us/who-does-
what/groups/special-interest-groups-9>.
Temasek Polytechnic 2014a, Centre for aquaculture and veterinary science, Temasek Polytechnic,
Singapore, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.tp.edu.sg/schools/asc/about-asc/centres-of-excellence/centre-for-aquaculture-
and-veterinary-science>.
Temasek Polytechnic 2014b, Diploma in veterinary technology (T45): career prospects, Temasek
Polytechnic, Singapore, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.tp.edu.sg/schools/asc/veterinary-technology#tab3 >.
Temkin-Greener, MH, Gross, D, Kunitz, SJ & Mukamel, D 2004, ‘Measuring interdisciplinary
team performance in a long-term care setting’, Medical Care, vol. 42, no. 5, pp. 472-81.
Theisen, JL & Sandau, KE 2013, ‘Competency of new graduate nurses: a review of their
weaknesses and strategies for success’, Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, vol. 44,
no. 9, pp. 406-14.
Thistlethwaite, J 2012, ‘Interprofessional education: a review of context, learning and the research
agenda’, Medical Education, vol. 46, no. 1, pp. 58-70.
Thorndike, E 1920, ‘Intelligence and its uses’, Harper’s Magazine, vol. 140, pp. 227-35.
Timmins, R 2006, ‘How does emotional intelligence fit into the paradigm of veterinary medical
education’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 71-5.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 222
Tinga, CE, Adams CL, Bonnett, BN & Ribble, CS 2001, ‘Survey of veterinary technical and
professional skills in students and recent graduates of a veterinary college’, Journal of the
American Veterinary Medical Association, vol. 219, no. 7, pp. 924-31.
Tolich, M 2010, ‘A critique of current practice: ten foundational guidelines for autoethnographers’,
Qualitative Health Research, vol. 20, no. 12, pp. 1599-610.
Tomlinson, M 2008, ‘ “The degree is not enough”: students’ perceptions of the role of higher
education credentials for graduate work and employability’, British Journal of Sociology of
Education, vol. 29, no. 1. pp. 49-61.
Tomlinson, M 2012. ‘Graduate employability: a review of conceptual and empirical themes’,
Higher Education Policy, vol. 25, pp. 407-31.
Training.gov.au 2018a, Qualifications details: ACM40412 - Certificate IV in veterinary nursing,
Department of Education and Training, Canberra, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://training.gov.au/Training/Details/ACM40412>.
Training.gov.au 2018b, Qualifications details: ACM50412 - Diploma of veterinary nursing
(emergency and critical care), Department of Education and Training, Canberra, viewed 10
March 2019, <https://training.gov.au/Training/Details/ACM50412>.
Trede, F, Macklin, R & Bridges, D 2012, ‘Professional identity development: a review of the higher
education literature’, Studies in Higher Education, vol. 37, no. 3, pp. 365-84.
Trigwell, K & Prosser, M 1991, ‘Improving the quality of student learning: the influence of learning
context and student approaches to learning on learning outcomes’, Higher Education, vol. 22,
no.3, pp. 251-66.
Trow, M 2007, ‘Reflections on the transition from elite to mass to universal access: forms and
phases of higher education in modern societies since WWII’, in JJF Forest & PG Altbach (eds),
International Handbook of Higher Education, Springer International Handbooks Education,
vol. 18, Springer, Dordrecht.
Trow, M 2016, ‘Higher education and its growth’, in S Marginson, The dream is over: the crisis of
Clark Kerr’s California idea of higher education, University of California Press, Oakland,
California, pp. 28-35.
Tsang, AKL (ed.) 2010, Oral Health therapy programs in Australia and New Zealand: emergence
and development, The University of Queensland, Brisbane.
Turner, A 2011, ‘The Elizabeth Casson memorial lecture 2011: occupational therapy—a profession
in adolescence?’, British Journal of Occupational Therapy, vol. 74, no. 7, pp. 314-22.
Turner, JL 2014, Using statistics in small-scale language education research: focus on non-
parametric data [ebook], Routledge, New York, pp. 243-55.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 223
Turner, WT 1984, ‘The history of animal nursing: part 2’, Journal of Small Animal Practice, vol.
25, no. 6, pp. 307-11.
Turnwald, GH, Sponenberg, DP & Meldrum, JB 2008, ‘Part I: twenty-year literature overview of
veterinary and allopathic medicine’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 35, no. 1,
pp. 66-73.
University of Glasgow 2018, Postgraduate taught: advanced practice in veterinary nursing,
University of Glasgow, Glasgow, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.gla.ac.uk/postgraduate/taught/advancedpracticeinveterinarynursingonline/>.
University of Queensland 2019, Credit Transfer: international students, The University of
Queensland, Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://science.uq.edu.au/study/credit-transfer >.
University of Queensland 2018a, Study: veterinary technology, The University of Queensland,
Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://veterinary-science.uq.edu.au/study-area/veterinary-
technology>.
University of Queensland 2018b, UQ policy and procedures library: 4.20.04 authorship, The
University of Queensland, Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://ppl.app.uq.edu.au/content/4.20.04-authorship>.
University of Queensland 2018c, Student services, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, viewed
10 March 2019, <https://www.uq.edu.au/student-services/>.
University of Queensland 2018d, UQ policy and procedures library: 3.10.05 graduate attributes –
graduate attribute procedures, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, viewed 10 March
2019, <http://ppl.app.uq.edu.au/content/3.10.05-graduate-attributes#Procedures>.
University of Queensland 2018e, Future students: bachelors of agribusiness/veterinary technology,
University of Queensland, Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://future-
students.uq.edu.au/study/program/Bachelors-of-Agribusiness-Veterinary-Technology-2391>.
University of Queensland 2018f, Veterinary technology (honours) 2018, The University of
Queensland, Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://future-
students.uq.edu.au/study/program/Bachelor-of-Veterinary-Technology-Honours-2422>.
UQ News 2001, UQ welcomes federal funding for animal welfare chair, The University of
Queensland, Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.uq.edu.au/news/article/2001/10/uq-welcomes-federal-funding-animal-welfare-
chair>.
Vallat, B 2004, The role of private veterinarians and veterinary para-professionals in the provision
of animal health services, editorial, World Organisation for Animal Health, Paris, viewed 10
March 2019,
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 224
<http://www.oie.int/for-the-media/editorials/detail/article/the-role-of-private-veterinarians-and-
veterinary-para-professionals-in-the-provision-of-animal-healt/>.
Veterinary Business Advisors 2013, ‘Utilizing an underused resource: veterinary technicians’,
Veterinary Business Advisors, Flemington, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://veterinarybusinessadvisors.com/wp-
content/uploads/2016/07/Utilizing_Veterinary_Technicians_11_2013.pdf>.
Veterinary Nurse Initiative 2016, Media: the national credential initiative, online video, National
Association of Veterinary Technicians in America, Schaumburg, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://veterinarynurse.org/media/>.
Veterinary Nurse Initiative 2018, ‘The national credential initiative’, National Association of
Veterinary Technicians in America, Schaumburg, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://veterinarynurse.org/>.
Veterinary nurse training in Australia and Britain: a comparative report 2003, Travel Bursary
Report, College of Animal Welfare, Cambridgeshire.
Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia 2018a, Promoting the interests of veterinary nurses in
Australia, Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia, Melbourne, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.vnca.asn.au/>.
Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia 2018b, My career: the veterinary nurse qualification,
Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia, Melbourne, viewed 10 March 2019,
<http://www.vnca.asn.au/about-veterinary-nursing/the-veterinary-nurse-qualification/>.
Veterinary Nurses Council of Australia 2018c, What is voluntary registration?, Veterinary Nurses
Council of Australia, Melbourne, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.vnca.asn.au/index.cfm//about-veterinary-nursing/voluntary%20-registration-for-
vet-nurses/about-voluntary-registration/>.
Veterinary Surgeons Board of Queensland 2018, Veterinary premises: ownership, Queensland
Government, Brisbane, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.vsb.qld.gov.au/registrations/veterinary-premises>.
Veterinary Surgeons’ Board of Western Australia 2018, Nurses, Western Australian Government,
Perth, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://www.vsbwa.org.au/nurses/>.
Vivash Jones, B 2011, Veterinary nursing—the early years, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons,
London, viewed 10 March 2019, <http://knowledge.rcvs. org.uk/document-library/veterinary-
nursing-history-the-early-years/>.
VN Futures Action Group 2016, Taking charge of our futures together, report and action plan,
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons Veterinary Nurses Council, London, and British
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 225
Veterinary Nursing Association, Harlow, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.vetfutures.org.uk/resources/>.
Walker, A, Yong, M, Pang, L & Dunning, T 2013, ‘Work readiness of graduate health
professionals’, Nurse Education Today, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 116-22.
Walker, K & Holmes, CA 2016, ‘The “order of things”: tracing a history of the present through a
re-reading of the past in nursing education’, Contemporary Nurse, vol. 30, no. 2, pp. 106-18.
Walkington, J 2000, ‘A process for curriculum change in engineering education’, European Journal
of Engineering Education, vol. 27, no. 2, pp. 133-48.
Wall, S 2006, ‘An autoethnography on learning about autoethnography’, International Journal of
Qualitative Methods, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 1-13.
Wall, S 2008, ‘Easier said than done: writing an autoethnography’, International Journal of
Qualitative Methods, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 38-53.
Wall, S 2016, ‘Towards a moderate autoethnography’, International Journal of Qualitative
Methods, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 1-9.
Ward, DJ, Furber, C, Tierney, S & Swallow, V 2013, ‘Using framework analysis in nursing
research: a worked example, Journal of Advanced Nursing, vol. 69, no. 11, pp. 2423-31.
Ward, H, Jr 1963, ‘Hierarchical grouping to optimize an objective function’, Journal of the
American Statistical Association, vol. 58, no. 301, pp. 236-44.
Watson, J 1982, ‘Traditional vs tertiary: ideological shifts in nursing education’, Australian Nurses’
Journal, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 44-6.
Wear, D & Castellini, B 2000, ‘The development of professionalism: curriculum matters’,
Academic Medicine, vol. 75, no. 6, pp. 602-11.
Wheelahan, LM 2000, Bridging the divide: developing the institutional structures that most
effectively deliver cross-sectoral education and training, National Centre for Vocational
Education Research, Adelaide, viewed 10 March 2019, <https://research-
repository.griffith.edu.au/bitstream/handle/10072/61836/34846_1.pdf?sequence=1>.
Wille, B, De Fruyt, F & Feys, M 2013, ‘Big Five traits and intrinsic success in the new career era: a
15 year longitudinal study on employability and work-family conflict’, Applied Psychology,
vol. 62, no. 1, pp. 124-56.
Williams, M & Robinson, D 2014, The 2014 RCVS survey of the veterinary nurse profession,
Institute for Employment Studies, Brighton, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://www.employment-studies.co.uk/resource/2014-rcvs-survey-veterinary-profession>.
Williams, B, Brown, T & Onsman, A 2010, ‘Is the Australian paramedic discipline a full
profession?’, Journal of Emergency Primary Health Care, vol. 8, no.1, pp. 1-10.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 226
Williams, B, Felder, C, Strong, G, Acker, J & Thompson, S 2015, ‘Are paramedic students ready to
be professional? An international comparative study’, International Emergency Nursing, vol.
23, no. 2, 120-6.
Willis, NG, Monroe, FA, Potworowski, JA, Halbert, G, Evans, BR, Smith, JE, Andrews, KJ,
Spring, L & Bradbrook, A 2007, ‘Envisioning the future of veterinary medical education: the
Association of American Veterinary Medical Colleges Foresight Project report, final report’,
Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 1-41.
Willits, FK, Theodori, GL & Luloff, AE 2016, ‘Another look at Likert scales’, Journal of Rural
Social Sciences, vol. 31, no. 3, pp. 126-39.
Winch, C & Wells, P 1995, ‘The quality of student writing: a cause for concern’, British Journal of
Educational Studies vol. 43, no. 1, pp. 75-87.
Wingate, U 2009, ‘Developing students’ academic literacy: an online approach’, Journal of
Academic Language and Learning’, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 14-25.
Wingate, U 2010, ‘The impact of formative feedback on the development of academic writing’,
Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, vol. 35, no. 50, pp. 519-33.
Witz, A 1992, Professions and Patriarchy, Routledge, New York.
Wolfe, R & Gould, W 1998, ‘An approximate likelihood-ratio test for ordinal response models’,
Stata Technical Bulletin, vol. 42, pp. 24-7.
Wong, CS & Law, KS 2002, ‘The effects of leader and follower emotional intelligence on
performance and attitude’, Leadership Quarterly, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 243-74.
Woolcock, B & Parker, M 2011, ‘History of the Australian College of Veterinary Scientists’,
Australian Veterinary Journal, vol. 89, no. 11, pp. 469-73.
Yates, L 2005, What can schools do? Knowledge, social identities and the changing world,
Melbourne University Faculty of Education Dean’s Lecture Series 2005, Department of
Education and Training, Melbourne, viewed 9 March 2019,
<http://web.education.unimelb.edu.au/news/lectures/pdf/lynlecture.pdf>.
Yorke, M 2006, ‘Employability in higher education: what it is – what it is not?’, in M Yorke (ed.),
Learning and employability series 1, Higher Education Academy, York, pp. 1-21.
Yorke, M & Knight, PT 2004, ‘Embedding employability into the curriculum’, in M Yorke (ed.),
Learning and employability series 1, Higher Education Academy, York, pp. 1-21.
Zelek, B & Phillips, SP 2003, ‘Gender and power: nurses and doctors in Canada’, International
Journal for Equity in Health, vol. 2, no. 1, viewed 10 March 2019,
<https://doi.org/10.1186/1475-9276-2-1>.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 227
10 Appendices
10.1 Appendix 1: Professional Writing Pre-Test Questionnaire
PART A - YOUR BACKGROUND
Please tick the box or fill in the blank space where appropriate.
1. Your age in years ___ ___
2. Your gender Male Female
3. Prior to enrolment in this degree, I have had previous tertiary experience:
Yes No
4. Following graduation, I intend to seek employment in the following area/s (please circle).
Veterinary practice 1
Veterinary industry (e.g. pharmaceutical company/other) 2
Further undergraduate study e.g. (veterinary science, physiotherapy etc.) 3
Research honours year 4
Other (please describe)
5
PART B – PROFESSIONAL WRITING AND THE LITERATURE
Please indicate your level of agreement with each of the following questions (1 – Strongly Agree to
5 – Strongly Disagree), or fill in the blank space, where appropriate.
1. At this stage of my career, I feel confident in my written communication skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
2. At this stage of my career, I feel competent in my written communication skills.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 228
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
3. Based on my tertiary studies, I have a good understanding of what scientific journals are.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
4. What is the purpose of scientific journals? (Please write in your thoughts.)
5. With respect to scientific journals, what does the term, ‘peer-review’, mean? (Please write in
your thoughts.)
6. Access to, and evaluation of, scientific literature has played an important role in my tertiary
studies up until this point. (Please write in your thoughts.)
7. Access to, and evaluation of, scientific literature should play an important role in my tertiary
studies. (Please write in your thoughts.)
8. When I need further information regarding course material, I consult the following: (Please
number 1 to 6, with 6 - most important to 1- least important for you.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 229
Course notes
Internet
Textbooks
Mentor/lecturer
Veterinarian/veterinary technologist/veterinary nurse in practice
Scientific journals
9. For this stage of my career, I feel confident in my scientific writing skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
10. For this stage of my career, I feel competent in my scientific writing skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
11. Keeping up with the scientific literature is relevant to my career.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
12. Following graduation, I would consider submitting material to a scientific journal for
publication.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 230
13. Scientific writing is a skill worthy of inclusion in my résumé/portfolio.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
PART C – ORAL COMMUNICATION SKILLS
1. Good oral communication skills are very important for my career.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
2. During this degree, formal instruction in oral communication skills is as important as
instruction in technical skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
3. Over the past two and a half years, I have received adequate opportunities to practise oral
communication skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
4. I feel confident in my oral communication skills for this stage of my career.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 231
1 2 3 4 5
5. At this stage in my career, I would feel confident enough to deliver a short oral presentation
to a small audience.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
6. I would appreciate the opportunity to ‘practise’ my oral communication skills with feedback
from my peers before I graduate.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
PART D – GRADUATE ATTRIBUTES & PROFESSIONALISM
1. Can you list any of the desired graduate attributes for The University of Queensland?
2. I enjoy working in small groups (or pairs) for assessment tasks.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
3. Working in teams for assessment tasks helps me gain other life skills that will be useful
after graduation. (Please write in your thoughts.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 232
4. Working in small groups (or pairs) for assessment tasks is generally fair and equitable.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
5. Do you have any comments reading group work for assessment tasks? (Please write in
your thoughts.)
6. My peers (other classmates) can give me valuable feedback about my learning and
performance on tasks.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
7. What do you think are the attributes of a professional? (Please write in your thoughts.)
8. What do you think are the attributes of a profession? (Please write in your thoughts.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 233
10.2 Appendix 2: Professional Writing Post-Test Questionnaire
Please indicate your level of agreement with each of the following questions (1 – Strongly Agree to
5 – Strongly Disagree), or fill in the blank space, where appropriate.
1. At this stage of my career, I feel confident in my written communication skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
2. At this stage of my career, I feel competent in my written communication skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
3. Based on my tertiary studies, I have a good understanding of what scientific journals are.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
4. What is the purpose of scientific journals? (Please write in your thoughts.)
5. Access to, and evaluation of, scientific literature should play an important role in my tertiary
studies. (Please write in your thoughts.)
6. For this stage of my career, I feel confident in my scientific writing skills.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 234
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
7. For this stage of my career, I feel competent in my scientific writing skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
8. This task helped me to develop my scientific writing skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
9. Comments regarding your answer above?
10. Keeping up with the scientific literature is relevant to my career.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
11. Following graduation, I would consider submitting material to a scientific journal for
publication.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 235
1 2 3 4 5
12. The project improved my confidence in my scientific writing skills.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
13. Scientific writing is a skill worthy of inclusion in my résumé/portfolio.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
14. Good oral communication skills are very important for my career.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
15. I feel confident in my oral communication skills for this stage of my career.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
16. At this stage in my career, I would feel confident enough to deliver a short oral presentation
to a small audience.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 236
17. I appreciated the opportunity to ‘practise’ my oral communication skills with feedback from
my peers before I graduated.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
18. Can you list any of the desired graduate attributes for The University of Queensland?
19. I enjoyed working in small groups (or pairs) for this task.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
20. Marking for this assessment task was fair and equitable.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
21. I enjoyed this project as a whole.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
22. Comments regarding your answer to the question above?
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 237
23. The project was a valuable educational experience.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
24. Comments regarding your answer to the question above?
25. My peers gave me valuable feedback about my work on this task.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
26. The timeframe for the task was adequate.
Strongly Agree Agree Don’t know Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 238
10.3 Appendix 3: Veterinary Client Questionnaire
This questionnaire is intended to provide information for a doctoral study examining the clinical
education of veterinary technologists. The information you provide will help us understand the
personal attributes and skills of veterinary technologists that are valued by the persons they interact
with in the work environment. All information will be examined at the group level.
PART 1 - YOUR BACKGROUND
a. Please tick the box or fill in the blank space where appropriate.
a. Age in years:
__ __
b. Gender:
Male Female
c. For how many years have you been a client of your regular veterinary practice?
__ __
d. The location of this veterinary practice is:
Urban Regional Rural
e. On average, how many visits would you make to a veterinary practice annually?
≤1 6-10
2-5 Other (please specify) _____________________
f. Which species of animals do you take to the veterinary practice? (You may tick more than one
box)
Dog Guinea pig
Cat Reptile
Bird Equine
Rats, mice Other (please specify) _____________________
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 239
PART 2 – ATTRIBUTES & SKILLS OF THE VETERINARY TECHNOLOGIST
a. Please indicate how important you consider each of the following personal attributes to be in the
work of a veterinary technologist, by circling the most appropriate number for each attribute.
Personal Attributes/Skills Very
Unimportant Unimportant Neutral Important
Very
Important
1. Fluent in communicating their
emotions 1 2 3 4 5
2. Flexible in approach to work 1 2 3 4 5
3. Able to ask for what they want 1 2 3 4 5
4. Open-minded 1 2 3 4 5
5. Non-assertive 1 2 3 4 5
6. Excellent social skills 1 2 3 4 5
7. Accepting of others 1 2 3 4 5
8. Able to confront others when
necessary 1 2 3 4 5
9. Motivated mainly by rewards 1 2 3 4 5
10. Well-developed coping
mechanisms 1 2 3 4 5
11. Able to express their feelings
accurately to others 1 2 3 4 5
12. Agreeable 1 2 3 4 5
13. Has difficulty accepting
compliments 1 2 3 4 5
14. Can positively influence other’s
feelings e.g. motivate them 1 2 3 4 5
15. Knows own limitations 1 2 3 4 5
16. Always defers to the veterinarian 1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 240
17. Expects positive things to
happen in their life 1 2 3 4 5
18. Can handle pressure calmly and
effectively 1 2 3 4 5
19. Self-motivated 1 2 3 4 5
20. Able to control emotions 1 2 3 4 5
21. Able to make others feel better 1 2 3 4 5
22. Thinks before they act 1 2 3 4 5
23. Conscientious 1 2 3 4 5
24. Cheerful 1 2 3 4 5
25. Socially sensitive and perceptive 1 2 3 4 5
26. Adapts well to change 1 2 3 4 5
27. Understands others’ needs 1 2 3 4 5
28. Optimistic 1 2 3 4 5
29. Impulsive 1 2 3 4 5
30. Learns from mistakes 1 2 3 4 5
31. Reflects carefully before making
decisions 1 2 3 4 5
32. Able to alter their mood through
personal insight and effort 1 2 3 4 5
33. Able to interpret emotional
signals from others 1 2 3 4 5
34. Lacks drive and persistence 1 2 3 4 5
35. Shares professional values with
colleagues 1 2 3 4 5
36. Determined and persevering 1 2 3 4 5
37. Cooperative 1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 241
38. Self-confident 1 2 3 4 5
39. Able to critically analyse
situations and experiences 1 2 3 4 5
40. Clear about what they feel 1 2 3 4 5
41. Receptive to guidance 1 2 3 4 5
42. Can put themselves in someone
else’s shoes 1 2 3 4 5
b. Are there any additional personal attributes/skills that you value in a veterinary technologist on
your visits to the veterinary practice?
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
PART 3 – TECHNICAL SKILLS OF THE VETERINARY TECHNOLOGIST
a. Please indicate how important you consider each of the following skills to be in the work of a
veterinary technologist in a veterinary practice, by circling the most appropriate number for each
skill.
Technical Skills
Very
Unimporta
nt
Unimporta
nt Neutral Important
Very
Important
1. Take x-rays 1 2 3 4 5
2. Take blood samples 1 2 3 4 5
3. Prioritise patients according to
illness or injury 1 2 3 4 5
4. Perform preliminary examination
of animal on admission 1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 242
5. Conduct obesity clinics for cats
and dogs 1 2 3 4 5
6. Provide clients with appropriate
nutritional advice for animals 1 2 3 4 5
7. Conduct puppy pre-school
classes 1 2 3 4 5
8. Provide advice on dental health
and hygiene for your animal 1 2 3 4 5
9.
Provide advice on animal care
e.g. worming, vaccination,
desexing
1 2 3 4 5
10.
Assist with physical therapy
techniques for the veterinary
patient
1 2 3 4 5
PART 4 – THE VETERINARY HEALTHCARE TEAM
a. How important is it to you, that the staff (veterinarians, veterinary nurses and veterinary
technologists) in the veterinary practice you visit, work as a team?
(Please circle the most appropriate number)
Very
Unimportant Unimportant Neutral Important Very Important
1 2 3 4 5
b. Please feel free to provide any further comments on teamwork or personal attributes that you
value in a veterinary technologist.
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
Thank you for your assistance with this questionnaire.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 243
10.4 Appendix 4: Veterinary Technology Client Interview Guide
PARTICIPANT GROUP – VETERINARY CLIENT
1. What type of pets do you have, (client’s name)? Do you visit the veterinary practice often?
2. What is it actually like for you to be a veterinary client at this veterinary practice?
3. What level of interaction would you have with a veterinary technologist when you visit the
veterinary practice?
4. How do you see the role of veterinary support staff such as the veterinary technologist in a
veterinary practice? Do you see any connection between emotional intelligence (their
personal attributes or qualities) and the veterinary technologist’s role?
5. The results of the veterinary client survey that I have conducted indicate that clients perceive
having empathy and being socially sensitive are most important. Does that ring ‘true’ with
you?
6. Why do you think this may be so?
7. Is there anything else you would like to say about emotional intelligence and its importance
in the role of the clinical veterinary technologist?
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 244
10.5 Appendix 5: Veterinary Technology Stakeholder Questionnaire
This questionnaire is intended to provide information for a doctoral study examining the clinical
education of veterinary technologists. The information you provide will help us understand the
personal attributes and technical skills of veterinary technologists that are valued by the veterinary
personnel they interact with in the work environment. All information will be examined at the group
level.
PART 1 - YOUR BACKGROUND
Please tick the box or fill in the blank space where appropriate.
a. Age in years:
___ ___
b. Gender:
Male Female
c. Please indicate which stakeholder group best describes you:
Practice principal Research veterinarian
Associate veterinarian Wildlife veterinarian
Government veterinarian Veterinary nurse
Industry veterinarian Veterinary technologist
Veterinary academic Other (Please specify)
____________________
d. Do you hold any of the following awards or qualifications related to your work in the
veterinary field?
BVSc or equivalent B. Applied Science (Veterinary
Technology)
MACVSc Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing
FACVSc Diploma in Veterinary Nursing
PhD Other Veterinary Nursing qualification
MBA Other (Please specify)
____________________
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 245
e. How many years of clinical veterinary experience do you have? __________ years
f. Are you employed on a …
Permanent basis, or AND Full-time, or
Casual, or Part-time, or
Contract
Other (Please specify)
___________________
g. The location of your employment is:
Urban Regional Rural
h. How many veterinary technologists are employed for a minimum of 20 hours per week in
your workplace? __________
i. Are you currently employed in a veterinary practice?
Yes No (go to Part 2)
j. How would you describe the veterinary practice?
General practice Emergency and critical care practice
Specialist referral practice
Other (Please specify): ______________________________________
k. How many veterinarians are employed in the practice?
Full-time: __________ Part-time: __________
l. How many veterinary nurses are employed in your workplace for a minimum of 20 hours per
week? __________
PART 2 – SKILLS OF THE VETERINARY TECHNOLOGIST
Please indicate how important you consider each of the following skills to be in the clinical work of
the veterinary technologist by circling the most appropriate number for each skill.
Technical Skills Very
Unimportant Unimportant Neutral Important
Very
Important
1. Take radiographs 1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 246
2. Position patients accurately for
radiographs 1 2 3 4 5
3. Perform blood collection 1 2 3 4 5
4. Perform IV catheterisation 1 2 3 4 5
5. Triage patients 1 2 3 4 5
6. Perform an ECG 1 2 3 4 5
7. Perform anaesthesia inductions 1 2 3 4 5
8. Monitor patient anaesthesia 1 2 3 4 5
9. Perform ‘team’ consultations 1 2 3 4 5
10. Conduct obesity clinics 1 2 3 4 5
11. Provide clients with appropriate
nutritional advice for pets 1 2 3 4 5
12. Conduct puppy pre-school
classes 1 2 3 4 5
13. Develop marketing strategies for
the practice 1 2 3 4 5
14. Conduct performance appraisals
for support staff 1 2 3 4 5
15. Perform dental charting and
prophylactic procedures 1 2 3 4 5
16. Perform basic ultrasonography 1 2 3 4 5
17. Provide a high level of surgical
nursing support 1 2 3 4 5
18. Assist with animal rehabilitation
and physical therapy techniques 1 2 3 4 5
b. Please indicate how important you consider each of the following personal attributes to be in the
clinical work of the veterinary technologist by circling the most appropriate number for each
attribute.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 247
Personal Attributes/Skills Very
Unimportant Unimportant Neutral Important
Very
Important
1. Fluent in communicating their
emotions 1 2 3 4 5
2. Flexible in approach to work and
life 1 2 3 4 5
3. Able to ask for what they want 1 2 3 4 5
4. Open-minded 1 2 3 4 5
5. Non-assertive 1 2 3 4 5
6. Excellent social skills 1 2 3 4 5
7. Accepting of others 1 2 3 4 5
8. Able to confront others when
necessary 1 2 3 4 5
9. Motivated mainly by rewards
and incentives 1 2 3 4 5
10. Well-developed coping
mechanisms 1 2 3 4 5
11. Able to express their feelings
accurately to others 1 2 3 4 5
12. Agreeable 1 2 3 4 5
13.
Has a positive view of
themselves and their
achievements
1 2 3 4 5
14. Has difficulty accepting
compliments 1 2 3 4 5
15. Willing to take risks 1 2 3 4 5
16. Can positively influence other’s
feelings e.g. motivate them 1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 248
17. Knows own limitations 1 2 3 4 5
18. Always defers to veterinarian 1 2 3 4 5
19. Expects positive things to
happen in their life 1 2 3 4 5
20. Can handle pressure calmly and
effectively 1 2 3 4 5
21. Self-motivated 1 2 3 4 5
22. Able to control emotions 1 2 3 4 5
23. Able to make others feel better 1 2 3 4 5
24. Thinks before they act 1 2 3 4 5
25. Conscientious 1 2 3 4 5
26. Maintains close friendships 1 2 3 4 5
27. Cheerful 1 2 3 4 5
28. Socially sensitive and perceptive 1 2 3 4 5
29. Adapts well to change 1 2 3 4 5
30. Understands other’s needs 1 2 3 4 5
31. Optimistic 1 2 3 4 5
32. Impulsive 1 2 3 4 5
33. Learns from mistakes 1 2 3 4 5
34. Reflects carefully before making
decisions 1 2 3 4 5
35. Able to alter their mood through
personal insight and effort 1 2 3 4 5
36. Has fulfilling personal
relationships 1 2 3 4 5
37. Feels good about self 1 2 3 4 5
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 249
38. Able to interpret emotional
signals from others 1 2 3 4 5
39. Lacks drive and persistence 1 2 3 4 5
40. Shares professional values with
work colleagues 1 2 3 4 5
41. Determined and persevering 1 2 3 4 5
42 Cooperative 1 2 3 4 5
43. Self-confident 1 2 3 4 5
44. Able to critically analyse
experiences and situations 1 2 3 4 5
45 Clear about what they feel 1 2 3 4 5
46. Receptive to guidance 1 2 3 4 5
47. Can put self in someone else’s
shoes 1 2 3 4 5
c. Please list or describe any additional personal attributes/skills that you believe are important for
the veterinary technologist in the work environment.
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
PART 3 – THE VETERINARY HEALTHCARE TEAM
a. How would you define ‘teamwork’?
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 250
b. How important is it for a veterinary technologist to be a ‘team player’ in your work
environment? (Please circle the most appropriate number.)
Very Unimportant Unimportant Neutral Important Very Important
1 2 3 4 5
c. Do you have any other comments on teamwork, personal attributes or skills that you value
in a veterinary technologist?
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 251
10.6 Appendix 6: Veterinary Technology Graduate Survey 2011
1. Your age (in years):
20-25 26-30
31-35 36-40
41-45 46-50
51-55
2. Your gender:
Male Female
3. Year of graduation from Veterinary Technology programme:
2003 2004 2005 2006
2007 2008 2009 2010
4. What do you see as the most important issues in the professionalisation of veterinary technology,
that is, issues that are important to its development as a profession?
5. What do you see as the most important issues working against the professionalisation of
veterinary technology, that is, issues that are an impediment to its development as a profession?
6. Please identify the areas in your employment for which you believe you were best prepared by
the B. Applied Science (Veterinary Technology) programme.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 252
7. Please identify the areas in your employment for which you believe you were least prepared by
the B. Applied Science (Veterinary Technology) programme:
8. As a veterinary technology graduate what do you now believe are the five (5) most important
personal attributes for your current role? (Personal attributes refer to personal qualities such as
initiative, being cooperative, etc.)
1. __________________________ 2. __________________________
3. __________________________ 4. __________________________
5. __________________________
9. As a veterinary technology graduate what do you now believe are the five (5) most important
technical skills for your current role? (Technical skills relate to an ability to perform specific work
tasks such as collecting blood, writing reports, etc.)
1. _________________________ 2. _________________________
3. _________________________ 4. _________________________
5. _________________________
10. What do you perceive as the most significant challenges that you currently face in your career
as a veterinary technology graduate? (Please rate each statement on a scale from 'very important' to
'very unimportant'.)
Item Very
unimportan
t
Unimporta
nt
Neutral Important Very
important
Salary level
Lack of career advancement
Job burnout
Acceptance in the workplace
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 253
Continuing professional
development
Recognition by veterinary
profession
Recognition by veterinary
nursing profession
11. Please provide any further comments about what you believe is important in the education of
veterinary technology students.
12. Since graduation have you published in a peer-reviewed journal?
Yes No
13. Since graduation have you published in a non-peer-reviewed journal?
Yes No
14. Since graduation have you presented at a conference or seminar?
Yes No
15. Have you completed/are you completing any further qualifications since graduating from the
Veterinary Technology programme?
Yes No
16. Have you completed/are you completing the Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing since
graduation?
Yes No
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 254
17. Please identify your reason(s) for completing this qualification.
18. Please identify any other qualification that you have completed/are completing since graduation,
including the field of study.
19. Please identify which of the following most accurately describes your current employment
status.
Full-time Part-time
20. And are you…?
Permanent Casual
Locum Contract
21. Which of the following additional benefits, if any, do you receive in your employment? (Please
tick all that apply.)
Subscription to professional organisation Uniform allowance
Profit sharing Discounted services/products
Continuing professional development Other (please specify)
22. Please indicate which one (1) of the following best describes your current employment.
General practice (primarily small animals) General practice (large & small)
Equine veterinary practice Emergency and critical care
Specialist referral practice Veterinary teaching hospital
Veterinary pharmaceutical Veterinary nutrition
Quarantine Biosecurity
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 255
Animal welfare Higher education
Vocational education Veterinary laboratory
Animal research facility Other (please specify)
23. Which of the following best describes your role in the veterinary practice? (Please tick all that
apply.)
Veterinary nurse/technician Head nurse/technician
Practice owner/partner Practice manager
Veterinarian Other (please specify)
24. The location of the veterinary practice where you are employed is…
Rural Regional Urban
25. The number of full-time veterinarians working in the practice is: (Please enter a positive
number.)
26. The number of part-time veterinarians working in the practice is: (Please enter a positive
number.)
27. The number of full-time veterinary technicians/nurses working in the practice is: (Please enter a
positive number.)
28. The number of part-time veterinary technicians/nurses working in the practice is: (Please enter a
positive number.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 256
29. Are you involved in conducting nursing clinics at the veterinary practice?
Yes No
30. Please identify the types of nursing clinics that you are involved in: (Please tick all that apply.)
Clinical nutrition Obesity clinics
Dental Puppy/kitten
Vaccination Behaviour
Other (Please specify)
31. Do you understand what is meant by using ‘evidence-based practice’ in making clinical
decisions about patient care?
Yes No Not sure
32. What would be a good example of how veterinary nurses/technicians could use ‘evidence-based
practice’ in patient care?
33. Please identify which of the following best describes your reason for choosing an alternative
field of employment to veterinary practice? (Please tick all that apply.)
Higher salary level More benefits
Better working hours Skills were underutilised
Physical injury or limitation More suited to career goals
Other (please specify)
34. What is your current gross annual salary? (Before tax.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 257
35. What was your gross annual salary for your first veterinary technology related job after
graduation?
36. What do you believe is a fair gross annual starting salary for a new veterinary technology
graduate (i.e. a graduate of 6 months)?
37. Please provide any additional comments that you believe would benefit future veterinary
technology graduates or advance the professionalisation of this discipline.
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 258
10.7 Appendix 7: Copy of Ethics Approval
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2009, ‘Demographics and employment
destinations of a new group of veterinary technologists in Australia’, Journal of Veterinary
Medical Education, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 241-45, incorporated as Chapter 3.
(Approved by Chair of School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee, Dr Paul Mills, on 31
January 2007. Evidence provided includes first & last pages of application and UQ permission to
access student data. Professor Mills will provide letter to verify approval, if required.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 259
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 260
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 261
10.8 Appendix 8: Copy of Ethics Approval
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT, Pitt, R & Manathunga, C 2011, ‘Enhancing
professional writing skills of veterinary technology students: linking assessment and
clinical practice in a communications course’, Assessment & Evaluation in Higher
Education, vol. 38, no. 3, pp. 273-87. (http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02602938.2011.630975),
incorporated as Chapter 4.
(Approved by School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee Chair, Dr Joanne Meers.
Evidence provided includes first & last pages of application, and Participant Information Sheet.
Further verification can be sought from Professor Coleman or Professor Joanne Meers, if required.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 262
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 263
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 264
10.9 Appendix 9: Copy of Ethics Approval
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, RE, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives
on desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31,
incorporated as Chapter 5.
What makes a great clinical team? Stakeholder perspectives on the attributes of effective veterinary
health care teams in Australia, incorporated as Chapter 6.
(Approved by School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee, Chair, Dr Paul Mills.
Evidence provided includes first & last page of ethics application form. Can provide further
verification from Professor Coleman or Professor Joanne Meers, if required.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 265
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 266
10.10 Appendix 10: Copy of Ethics Approval (Amendment)
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, RE, Schull, DN & Coleman, GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives
on desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31,
incorporated as Chapter 5.
(Approved by School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee, Chair, Dr Paul Mills. Evidence
provided includes first & last pages of application (amendment for clients only), and template for
letter veterinary practices sent with client questionnaire. Can provide further verification from
Professor Coleman or Professor Mills, if required.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 267
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 268
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 269
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 270
10.11 Appendix 11: Copy of Ethics Approval
Clarke, PM, Al-Alawneh, J, Pitt, RE, Schull, DN & Coleman GT 2015, ‘Client perspectives
on desirable attributes and skills of veterinary technologists in Australia: considerations for
curriculum design’, Journal of Veterinary Medical Education, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 217-31,
incorporated as Chapter 5.
(Approved by School of Veterinary Science Ethics Committee, Chair, Dr Paul Mills. Evidence
provided includes first & last pages of ethics application (clients interviews). Can provide further
verification from Professor Coleman or Professor Mills, if required.)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 271
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 272
10.12 Appendix 12: Copy of Ethics Approval
Clarke, PM, Schull, DN, Coleman, GT & Henning, J 2018, ‘Recruiting the graduate voice:
informing higher education initiatives to underpin an emerging, veterinary paraprofession’, Journal
of Vocational Education and Training, in press and incorporated as Chapter 7. (Accepted for
publication 3 July 2018)
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 273
vbn
s3124323_phd_correctedthesis.pdf Page | 274
10.13 Appendix 13: Acceptance for Publication (Chapter 7)
top related