strengthening child rearing in portage county: evaluation of parenting the second and third years...

Strengthening Child Rearing in Portage County: Evaluation of Parenting the Second and Third Years Instructional Newsletter Series

By Brenda Janke UW-Extension

What is Parenting the Second and Third Years?

12 Issue Set of Parenting Newsletters Continues in Footsteps of Parenting

The First Year Series Available Bi-Monthly to Parents

During Their Child’s Second and Third Year

Matched to Child’s Age

Why a 2nd & 3rd Year Parenting Newsletter Series?

Early Experience Has Big Impact on Child Development

Parents Establish Patterns of Child Rearing Early On

Lack of Knowledge About Children Can Lead to Incompetent Parenting

Impact of First Year Series May Be Maintained New Parenting Issues Emerge in Second and

Third Years

Advantages of Newsletters: Age-Paced to Reach Parents at a

“Teachable Moment” Reaches Socially Isolated Families Can Be Shared With Others Low Cost Available in Spanish Easy to Read and Understand (Written at

5th Grade Reading Level)

Developed by University of Wisconsin-Extension for Two Goals:

To Promote Competent Parenting

To Prevent Abusive Parenting

Are the Newsletters Effective? The Evaluation Study:

Sample Size: 72 Families Response Rate to Questionnaire Survey:

33% Most Respondents Were Mothers (96%) Only 3% Were Single Parents About Half (53%) Were First Time

Parents

No Teenage Respondents

35 or greater

30-34

25-29

20-24

43%

41%

12%4%

Age of Respondents

About Half Had a College Degree

39%

16%

44%

1%

4 Yr. College Degree

2 Yr. College Degree

High School Grad.

No High School Degree

0% 25% 50%

Percentage of Respondents

Parents' Formal Education

Only About 3% Had Family Incomes in the Poverty Range

52%

45%

1.5%

1.5%

$50,000 or more

$20,000 to 49,999

$14,000 to 19,999

Less than $14,000

0% 20% 40% 60%

Percentage of Respondents

Family Incomes, 2000

Did Parents Read the News-letters? They Say “Yes!”

60% Said They Read All Articles in All Issues

56% Save the Newsletters as a Reference

Readership Nearly Doubled By Sharing

29%

64%

10%

10%

7%

No

Yes, Spouse or Partner

Yes, Baby's Grandparent

Yes, Other Relative or Friend

Yes, Friend Who Has Children

0% 20% 40% 60%

Percentage of Respondents

"Does anyone else read your copy of the newsletters?"

Examples of What Parents Said:

“My husband and I have both found the information in your newsletter useful. Thank you!”

“I think the newsletter is an excellent source of information for my family to follow along with our child and how he is doing and where he should be for his age.”

Parents Rate the Newsletters “Very Useful” for Advice More Often Than Any Other Source.

61%

50%

43%

39%

36%

21%

10%

7%

Parenting the 2nd & 3rd Year

Other Parents & Friends

Physician or Nurse

Your Relatives & Inlaws

Books, Magazines & Newspapers

Child Care Provider

County Health Nurse

The Internet, World Wide Web

0% 30% 60%

Percentage of ParentsWho Answered "Very Useful"

NOTE: Other possible responses were "Somewhat Useful" and "Not Useful".

Usefulness of Each Source of Parenting Information for Parents

Parents Commented On Their Usefulness:

“These are my main source for learning. I look forward to each issue. Many ideas to promote a very smart and happy child. Thank you!”

“We have kept every newsletter from birth to 3 years and reference to them periodically…When the letter arrives, it’s the first thing I read! Excellent!”

Parents Believe That Reading the Newsletters Has Improved Their Parenting.

Examples: “Helps with discipline issues. Different

ways of interacting with a child. Different games or toys.”

“Definitely, we try a lot of things in these newsletters, anything from getting kids to eat to discipline.”

Parents Report Changing Child-Rearing Behaviors in 6 Key Areas

74%

70%

61%

57%

51%

39%

"Involve my child when we are doing household tasks."

"Explain 'why' when I tell my childto do something."

"Talk more with my child."

"Set rules and firm limits withmy child."

"Make the house safer for my child."

"Slap or spank my child less often."

0% 20% 40% 60% 80%

Percentage of Respondents

Self-Reported Behavior Change

"Reading the newsletters caused me to..."

74% Said That Reading the Newsletters Caused Them to “Involve My Child When We Are Doing Household Chores.”

Teaches Children Responsibility Fosters Sense of Pride and Self

Confidence Promotes Independence/Self Reliance Creates Sense of Family Unity

Examples of What Parents Said:

“They like to help with everything even if we’re not doing the exact same thing…I always thought kids were too young and thought they should wait. Boy was I wrong!”

“Some things done easier by myself are more fun and educational for the child when including the child.”

61% Said the Newsletters Caused Them To “Talk More With My Child.”

Toddlers are “Ready” for Language Acquisition

Talking with Child Contributes to Vocabulary Growth

Children with Larger Vocabularies Score Higher on Language and Cognitive Tests

Language Skills Make Learning to Read Easier

Examples of What Parents Said:

“I find that talking and explaining things to them make them understand

more.” “Explain things more to him instead of

just saying no or don’t. Play more games, sing more songs.”

“We read and discuss things together.”

About Half of Readers (46%) Said the Newsletters Caused Them to Be

Firmer in Setting Limits with Their Child, and

More Likely to Explain the Reasons for Rules and Limits.

Prior Research Has Shown That Parents Who Do Both of These –Firm But Responsive— Have Children Who:

Become More Competent Are More Receptive to Parental Influence Show Higher Self-Esteem Comply With Rules Better Develop Inner Controls

Examples of What Parents Said:

“Helped guide me as to how to set rules – using terms that make my child feel good and cooperate while sticking to the rules.”

“Setting limits helps him more than myself!”

“They learn by example as I learned from a lot of examples given in the newsletters.”

Half (51%) Said the Newsletters Caused Them “To Make the House Safer for My Child.” Risk of Accidental Injury is Reduced Safe Homes Allow Children to Explore Safe Exploration Promotes Intellectual

Growth and Development of Skills

Examples of What Parents Said About Safety:

“Installed many safety locks, gate, railing guard, moved meds and

cleaners to top shelves, etc.” “Crawl around on ground for safety

check at child’s height.”

39% Said They Have Learned to “Spank or Slap My Child Less Often.”

The Newsletters Provide Many Alternative Ways to Teach and Discipline Children.

Other Research Shows, Less Physical Punishment Predicts:

Children Less Violent. Parenting Less Likely to Become

Abusive. Children More Likely to Develop

Internal Controls.

Examples of What Parents Said:

“It has reassured me my ‘no hitting’ rule is good. Many relatives/friends

spank. I thought I was wrong not to.” “I slow down and try to find alternatives,

explain, redirect.” “Timeouts for him (or me).”

Which Parents Need Child Rearing Information Most?

First-Time Parents Who Are Inexperienced With Children.

First-Time Parents Reported Greater Change in Parenting Than Experienced Parents.

In particular, first time parents were significantly more likely to involve their child when doing household tasks, as a result of reading the newsletters, compared to experienced parents (p < .05).

62%

66%

53%

56%

50%

37%

86%

75%

69%

58%

53%

"Involve my child when we aredoing household tasks."

"Explain 'why' when I tell mychild to do something."

"Talk more with my child."

"Set rules and firm limits with my child."

"Make the house safer for my child."

"Slap or spank my childless often."

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

Percentage Agreeing

43%

“Reading the newsletters caused me to...

ExperiencedFirst-time

First-Time Parents Said: “This newsletter is wonderful!! As a first time

parent I looked forward to receiving it… It has offered new ideas and tips and also reminders of things we sometimes forget in a busy family life. I hope you continue to provide it to all parents of infants and toddlers.”

“The newsletter is very informational on the first child. It is very helpful to let you know that at this stage your child should be doing this or that…”

How Reliable Are Self-Report Answers? Common Sources of Bias

Response Set Bias Social Desirability Bias

Use of Lie Scale Items to Check for BiasesParents Were Asked About Something That Might Have Been in the Newsletter But Wasn’t “Because of the parenting newsletters…

…I have changed the kind of clothing my child wears.”

…I changed how I wake my child in the morning.”

Only 2 Parents Answered “Yes” to Both Questions From the Lie Scale.

Their Data Was Removed Before Analyses.

Summary of Results: Parents Really Read the Newsletters. Parents Share the Newsletters With Others. Parents Rate the Newsletters Highly Useful. Parents Report Positive Changes in Six Key

Parenting Behaviors. Inexperienced Parents Reported Learning the

Most.

Recommendation: Continue Distribution of The Newsletter Series.

Based on Survey Results

Based on Parents’ Comments

Summary Comments From Portage County Parents:

“Great newsletter! Every parent should read this.” “Please don’t stop sending these newsletters. I

just wish more people read them and followed the advice you give. All the information I have read is great.”

“I looked forward to reading the newsletter. It had ideas that I didn’t have or a better way of doing things... I hope you continue this program for other parents and when I have my second child.”

Acknowledgment of Project Partners: St. Michael’s Hospital Mental Health Association of Portage County

(Penny Schmitt) United Way Kiwanis Clubs of Plover and Stevens Point Retired Senior Volunteer Project From Lincoln

Center CAP Fund of Milwaukee

Co-Authors of Evaluation Study:

Dr. Dave Riley,

UW-Madison/Extension Carol Ostergren,

UW-Madison

And of course,

We thank the families who thoughtfully answered our survey.

Copies of the written report are available from the Portage County Extension Office.