slobodan panov-osnov za razvod duhovnog braka
Post on 26-Nov-2015
96 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
162
27-454 ; 173.1 ; 347.627.2
.
, , - . - : , . , / : ; ; - ; ; : , ; , .
: . . . . -.
1.
. , - , . ,1 : , / .
. , ,
, panov@ius.bg.ac.rs.
1 , , . , - , (. . , . ), 2007, 7; , , . , , - 1880, 188.
-
. (. 162184)
163
.2 - . , .3 , , , . , . , , , , , , , , / . . , e , - ( ). , , , -. , - - . , - . do fas , , (do ut des, facio ut facias, do ut facias, facio ut des).4 . . , - . , , , - . -/. . , ( ), . . , , .
2 , , 1999, 279. 3
, . Dragan Mitrovi, Ecclesiastical Law and State Law, Annals of the Faculty of Law in Belgrade 3/2012, 243264.
4 , . : , , . , , , (., 5,4344). : (. ), , (., 5,17). . , . , , 2011, 2629, 32, 33.
-
, LX, 2/2012
164
/ , . , - . (. 6, 1720).5
, , : ( ). . , , , .6
, , , , - , , - , (-), , ( ), .
( ), , , , : . , , .7 , , .8 , , ? () () , / .9
5 Ibid., 37, 38. 6 , Terra nostra terra incognita ,
2010, 42. 7 . , , ,
, 2006, 36. 8 . , , -
, , 1986, 8889. 9 ,
. . , (. , , 1992, 98). , (, 8). , , , () , . . (2006), 5562.
-
. (. 162184)
165
- ?10 2002. , 249.227 , 147.735 .11 2005. unreasonable behaviour.12 , , (;13 14). , - , , . / - ,15 . , , .16 , 65% (, , ) 58%
, , . : , , ... ... , , . , . : . : , . , , 2002, 73.
10 , , , 1/2012, 107136.
11 Jonathan Herring, Family Law, Oxford 2004, 79. 40% (National Office of Statistics, 2002), 25 29 -, . Mary Welstead &Suzan Edwards, Family Law, Oxford 2006, 91.
12 Brenda Hale, David Pearl, Elizabeth Cooke, Daniel Monk, The Family, Law&Society, Oxford-New York 2009, 153, 167.
13 , , Judith Masson, Rebecca Bailey-Harris, Rebecca Probert, Principles of Family Law, London 2008, 279.
14 , . - 50% . : , . . (1992), 5759.
15 3,7 , . Kate Standley, Family Law, London 1997, 2. , , , . . , . , . -, . , , , 2006, 95.
16 J. Herring (2004), 80.
-
, LX, 2/2012
166
, 52%, 44% .17 , .
/ , -/ . / 18 / ,19 - :
. - .20 . , -.21 , / , - ( ),
17 , , 2009, 190. 18 , .
, , - 4/2010.
19 , . , . , . , . , (. ), 2009, 60. , , . , , , , (. . , . ), 2007, 605.
. , 2000. , , . , , (. ), 2009, 139 140. : 2009. , , . . ?, . ,158/2011, 55.
20 , , , , / . , - , . , . ( - ), , 1898, 297299, 304.
21 : - , - . . : , , ... ... . , , .
-
. (. 162184)
167
-. : . - , .22
. - . , . - , ; , - . , . , , :,, ( 10, 5). . , - , : . -. , . , - : . .
. : , - , , . , . , . -, .
23 . -
22 . (2007), 16. 23 60 1844.
: , , . (1.. 4,8). , , .
-
, LX, 2/2012
168
.24 . 25 , . - . 6, . 2 , ... , , , . 29 , . 25
-, 26/.27
, . , , , (. ), 2007, 385. . , , .
24 , . . , , , 10/2011, 6 . . , , , , , . (), , (. . ), 2007, 549 550.
25 ( ) , , ( ), : , . -- : , , . , , 1988, 6768.
26 (indissolubile) , - . , , , : , . -, , 1902, 669.
27 . (1898), 304306. : , , -. . , , , . , , , , . . (1880), 178,180, 188. , - , , , 15 . , . , , , (. , ), -, 2006, 8, 9.
, , . , , (. ), 2010, 74. , , . , , -. -, ,
-
. (. 162184)
169
: , , , . . , . -, : , . ,28 , . , .29
, . , .
2.
. 69 , , ; ... /, - / - , , / - ( ) , , / - , .
(. . . , . ), 2010, 238,239. , , , , . , - , . , , , (. , ), , 2006, 19. , . , . -, , 2003, 105. / : , , , . , 2010, 239.
28 : . : () -, . (1. . 7, 1216), . (. ), (. ), . , , , 2000, 288, 289.
29 , . - . , , , . , . . (2011), 341. , , , ( , 87), . . , 289.
-
, LX, 2/2012
170
. , , , , , . , , , (. ).
- () .
(, ) , , . - . , (. 4,13).
, , . , .30
. - : , ; -, , ; , (. 2, 68). ,31 , .
. . - : .32
30 , , , . , . . , , , - (2007), 600.
31 , , . , , : . , , , , , . , ( ), . , , , , (2007), 27 .
32 , , 2000, 265 .
-
. (. 162184)
171
/ . -, .33 - . - / .34
, , /, . , .
. . : . , - , , -... , , . , , -, , . . -. 20% .35
. : - ... , (. 1, 1415). . - , . .36 : -/ , , .37
, . 38 : , -
33 , , , 2000, 211.
34 . , , 2000, 278280; . , , (2007), 432.
35 (), - , 2010, 497 .
36 . , , (2007), 472 .
37 , , , . (. . , . ), 2005, 83.
38 . . , . (2007), 90.
-
, LX, 2/2012
172
, , , .39 40 - , , - .41 / : . .
. : , . : ... : , , , ....42
/ . .43 , (Omnis festinatio ex parte diaboli est ). : , .44
.45 (. 10, 22). , . . -. , 46 , . , .47 , fast , .48
39 . . (1992), 103. 40 Una Sancta . , , -
2009, 356. 41 , , 2004, 75. 42 . (1992), 42. 43 , . .
, , 2011, 59.
44 . , , 2006, 183188. 45 , , ;
, . , . , , , (. ), 2007, 384.
46 , , , . . , , , 1987, 20.
47 . (2007), 66, 70. 48 . , , , 2008, 250.
-
. (. 162184)
173
.49 . /. . .50
, -. , : , , ... - ... . . , , . , , , , , , -....
, . -/ , .51
( ... ) ( ... , ?.52
, - . . . , , .53 .
49 Ibid., 265. 50 ,
, , (. . , . ), 2007, 506 .
51 . , . - ( ), , 1898, 297. , , . . (1992), 36.
52 (2002), 56,71. 53 . , .
(1898), 297. , , . . (1992), 36.
-
, LX, 2/2012
174
, .54 . , . - . , , . : ... ... ? - ?... .55
, . . - , : - .56 , , . - . , .57 / ( ; - , ; ...58). , , , ( ) . 59.
, , . : Video meliora proboque, deteriora sequor ( , ).60 : , . , , , . - , , .61
54 . (2006), 249. 55 (2007), 65.66. 56 , I, 2009, 138. 57 . (2011), 272, 275. 58 , 2010, 157. 59 (), -
, 2010, 17. 60 . (2006), 103. 61 , ,
20.1.2011.
-
. (. 162184)
175
, . - . ,62 , - .63 , , . - , , .
, . ,64 . - , , . : - ; , . , : , . , . : .65
. - / .66 . : , .67 : , .
: -, , , , .68
62 , . , , (2000), 376.
63 , , (2000), 418 .
64 , (), . , , - (2000), 17.
65 . (2009), 7479. 66 , ,
(2006), 12, 13. 67 , ,
, (. . -, . ), 2005, 559.
68 , , , 2011, 570 .
-
, LX, 2/2012
176
3.
(. ).69 ,70 ,71 72 .73 - /.74 .75 . - , .76
, , . 18, 22. ,
69 . (2009), 312. 70 () . ,
- , . . , . , , , (. . ), 2010, 548. , , . (2007), 67.
71 , . , - , . . (2004), 33, 34. , , , . , . : , -. , . (2007), 89.
72 ... , . ... , , . , 52, 194.
73 . . . , . : , -, . (2007), 67, 68.
74 . , (2000), 287 . 75 (1. . 4, 8).
, . . - (. 6, 1), , , , (. 5,1920), . , -, , , (. ), 2010, 589 .
76 . , , 2010, 242.
-
. (. 162184)
177
. . , (. 5, 32), 77 . , . (. 5, 25).
. () : Amor est titillatio, concomitante idea causae externae ( ). . . , , , , , , - . , () : 1977. .78
( ) (. ), .
/, , , /-,79 .80
. , , . , , , , , .81
77 -, . , . , . , . . , , , (2007), 602, 603.
78 . , , 2007, 1723, . (2010), 44.
79 : . , . , . . , (2007), 42.
80 . , . , -, (2010), 159. . , . . (2009), 312.
81 , - , , - (2007), 389391.
-
, LX, 2/2012
178
, . , , , , , , .82
.83 .84
. - , .85 . . , , . , , (-) -. . , .86 ? 1015 .87 , . , . . , .
? ( - ), , ; ,
82 . , , - 1/2010, 1112.
83 : , , , , . , - , . , . , . , - . . , - . , , , - , (. www. ).
84 , . -, , (2006), 66. , , , , . . , , , - (2007), 613. () , . . (2009), 86.
85 , . . (1902), 613. 86 , -
. : ? : , , . , - , , , , (2007), 478.
87 . . , (2007), 2436.
-
. (. 162184)
179
.88 : .89 , , , . .90
4.
91 (: , ) , // - . - , , , : (. 6, 10). : - (. 17, 21).
, , . , .92 . - , (. 10, 27).
: ?... , , - , , .
88 , . , . , , , 2004.
89 . . (2006), 240. 90 , , (2007),
18. , . . (1902), 665. 91 ,
. . -: , , ... ( ). : , . - ( - 1878. -), , , , . (), , , - 2011, 28 , 197201.
92 . . (2009), 12.
-
, LX, 2/2012
180
. . , ... , , , . , - . , - . .93
(, I), - . , , . , - . , , , , (1. . 1, 26). , - , ,94 . . ( ), . 95 . , .96 .97
.98 , ,99 : , .100
93 , . , www. . , , . , / . , , . (2009), 11, 16.
94 . , , , - . -, , , . (2007), 164.
95 : , , , . (2011), 270.
96 . , , , (2007), 10, 13.
97 . . (2009), 309314. 98 . . (2010), 4951. 99 , -
, , , , . . (1898), 352361.
100 (2007), 403. : .
-
. (. 162184)
181
, -, , . , . . , , . .101
102 () () .103
, , , , . - ( - . 3, 28), , . , . /,104 , (. 22, 30). , - - . (non posse peccare), (posse non peccare).105
, , , ( ), : .106 ( , ). (. ). , ,
101 , , (2000), 113,114.
102 , , . . (2007), 611. ... , , . . : . , . . (2007), 10.
103 , , , 2000, 1115.
104 , , . , , (2000), 122, 123.
105 y, , , 2006, 601608.
106 (2000), 27.
-
, LX, 2/2012
182
, 107.
/ . - ( ) . , , - / , , . , / , ad hoc (pl.). .108 , .
, . - , . , , - .109 .
, , , :
: (/- ); ( ); ( -, - );
; ; ; ;
;
107 . (1992), 5,23. - , . . (2009), 87.
108 . , , , 2003, 99, 100.
109 , ( ) , . , , (. . ), 2006, 146. - , , - , . , , 2009, 122123.
-
. (. 162184)
183
/ - ;
/110 ; : ; ; ; ;
, ; ( ),
; ( -
) 111 .112
Dr. Slobodan I. Panov
Associate ProfessorUniversity of Belgrade Faculty of Law
GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE IN ECCLESIASTICAL LAW
Summary
The author makes a detailed analysis of the grounds for divorce in ecclesiastical law, which perceives the idea of divorce from three angles: epektasis, love and eschatology. The author gives numerous examples and illustrations, and concludes that the difference between the secular and the ecclesiastical concepts of divorce derives from the opposite concepts of marriage. There is an antinomy or mutual incompatibility between the marriage of co-existence and the Sacraments; the marriage of equality and love; oblivion and irrelevance of guilt and permanent moral improve-ment; hedonism and sense of temptation; express sensory satisfaction and
110 , , 2/2012, 280 .
111 , ( ), . 63. , (2000), 351.
112 , . . (2007), 394.
-
, LX, 2/2012
184
neocracy a strong and permanent condition of virtue, for love as bliss-ful and wise victim; provisorium and eschatology; mans standards and Gods criteria.
Key words: Ecclesiastical marriage. Sacrament. Epektasis. Love. Eschatology.
/ColorImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorACSImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorImageDict > /AntiAliasGrayImages false /CropGrayImages true /GrayImageMinResolution 300 /GrayImageMinResolutionPolicy /OK /DownsampleGrayImages false /GrayImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /GrayImageResolution 300 /GrayImageDepth -1 /GrayImageMinDownsampleDepth 2 /GrayImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeGrayImages true /GrayImageFilter /DCTEncode /AutoFilterGrayImages true /GrayImageAutoFilterStrategy /JPEG /GrayACSImageDict > /GrayImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayACSImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayImageDict > /AntiAliasMonoImages false /CropMonoImages true /MonoImageMinResolution 1200 /MonoImageMinResolutionPolicy /OK /DownsampleMonoImages false /MonoImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /MonoImageResolution 1200 /MonoImageDepth -1 /MonoImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeMonoImages true /MonoImageFilter /CCITTFaxEncode /MonoImageDict > /AllowPSXObjects false /CheckCompliance [ /None ] /PDFX1aCheck false /PDFX3Check false /PDFXCompliantPDFOnly false /PDFXNoTrimBoxError true /PDFXTrimBoxToMediaBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXSetBleedBoxToMediaBox true /PDFXBleedBoxToTrimBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXOutputIntentProfile (None) /PDFXOutputConditionIdentifier () /PDFXOutputCondition () /PDFXRegistryName () /PDFXTrapped /False
/CreateJDFFile false /Description > /Namespace [ (Adobe) (Common) (1.0) ] /OtherNamespaces [ > /FormElements false /GenerateStructure false /IncludeBookmarks false /IncludeHyperlinks false /IncludeInteractive false /IncludeLayers false /IncludeProfiles false /MultimediaHandling /UseObjectSettings /Namespace [ (Adobe) (CreativeSuite) (2.0) ] /PDFXOutputIntentProfileSelector /DocumentCMYK /PreserveEditing true /UntaggedCMYKHandling /LeaveUntagged /UntaggedRGBHandling /UseDocumentProfile /UseDocumentBleed false >> ]>> setdistillerparams> setpagedevice
top related