refusing to go quietly: gamma-ray bursts and their progenitors andy fruchter stsci hubble science...

Refusing to Go Quietly:Refusing to Go Quietly:Gamma-Ray Bursts Gamma-Ray Bursts

and Their Progenitorsand Their Progenitors

Andy FruchterAndy FruchterSTScISTScI

Hubble Science BriefingHubble Science Briefing5 Dec. 20135 Dec. 2013

What Are We Doing Here?

• An introduction to Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs)

• Massive stars and the long bursts

• Short bursts and merging neutron star binaries

• A new view on the universe

22

The Vela Satellites:Protecting the Free World from Illicit

GRBs

Designed to detect nuclear tests (in violation of the test ban treaty), the Vela satellites discovered GRBs

33

Compton Gamma-Ray Observatory

44

All Shapes and Sizes

55

BATSE Band Energies:

1: 20 - 40 keV2: 40 - 70 keV

3: 70 - 160 keV4: 160 - 430 keV

Two Classes of GRBs

Kouveliotou et al. 1993 66

BATSE Band Energies:

1: 20 - 40 keV2: 40 - 70 keV

3: 70 - 160 keV4: 160 - 430 keV

Two Classes of GRBs

Kouveliotou et al. 1993 77

88

The Milky Way According to COBE

99

So...

• GRBs must be very close -- the Solar System

• GRBs must be very far (distant galaxies)

1010

But ...

• If they are far out in the solar sytem, they must be produced by colliding balls of ice. Throwing snowballs may be more dangerous than we realized!

• If they are very far, their energies may be stupendous....something like the rest mass of the sun being turned into gamma-rays!

1111

Where Do GRBS Come From?

http://www.ibiblio.org/Dave/Dr-Fun/df9804/df980403.jpg

1212

1313

GRB 990123

• One of the brightest GRBs observed

• At its brightest, it was visible through a pair of binoculars

• But the light from the burst travelled over 12 billion light years before hitting the binoculars!

• Estimated energy in gamma rays of the burst = rest mass of the sun!

1414

GRB 990123

Fruchter et al. 1999

QuickTime™ and aGIF decompressor

are needed to see this picture. Now You See

It

The transient hasfaded by a factor

of two million sincepeak in this first

HST image

1515

GRB 990123

QuickTime™ and aGIF decompressor

are needed to see this picture. Now You

Don’t

Fruchter et al. 1999

1616

A Side View of a GRB

Doomed Star

Black Hole

Regions of γ-ray formation

GRB Hitting Interstellar Medium

300,000 light seconds

Internal Shocks?Photosphere?

1717

GRBs Go Bump in the Night

1818

Expected fromGRB Alone

Expected fromSN Alone

The Star Underneath

Interestingly, the spectra of the supernovaeunderneath Long GRBs are missing both

Hydrogen and Helium. 1919

GRBHosts

Box Width3.”75

Fruchter et al. 20062020

GOODS cc SNe Hosts

Box Width7.”5

Fruchter et al. 2006

2121

Long GRBs Are Not Just Like Other Supernovae

• They like to be on the very brightest parts of their host galaxy (much more so than regular supernovae)

• They like their hosts small -- probably to avoid “metals”

2222

Artist’s Conception Artist’s Conception of GRB Environmentof GRB Environment

2323

Long GRBs like this

Not this

You Are Here

2424

Just When You Thought You Were

Safe.....

2525

A Short-Burst Host Mosaic

Images on the left were taken in the blue,

on the right in the infrared

Short Bursts like all types of galaxies --

small to large, young to old.

2626

So What Causes Short Bursts?

• Deep searches show no sign of supernovae, and Short GRBs do not greatly favor star-forming hosts, so massive stars are probably out.

• Neutron star binaries can merge anywhere between 10 million years and a Hubble time, and are found in all types of galaxies.

• But is there an observation that would be a “smoking gun”?

2727

2828

2929

Environment of GRB 130603B

3030

SGRB 130603B in Black and White

3131

0.6 µm = visible light 1.6 µm = infrared light

What Have We Found?

http://www.sciencecartoonsplus.com/gallery/astronomy/astron51_pretty-good-nova.gif

3232

If Confirmed

• Will conclusively show that short bursts come from merging neutron stars

• Will explain much, and perhaps vast majority, of heavy elements

3333

Merging Neutron Stars Make Waves

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IZhNWh_lFuI

3434

A Future AstronomicalObservatory

Advanced LIGO will be able to detect gravitational waves thatstretch the length of the arms by a fraction of the size of a proton

3535

Listening to Neutron Star Mergers

Figure: Caltech/Cornell/Cita CollaborationAudio: Ben Farr, Northwestern U.

3636

http://hubblesource.stsci.edu/services/events/telecons/media/listening_to_neutron_star_mergers.mp3

The Nearest(?) SGRB

GRB 080905a 1.5 Billion light years away 3737

We Might Not Need a GRB

• A kilonova could act as a marker

• Large new surveys instruments, such as LSST, could locate kilonovae

• These may be our best way to find the first gravitational wave sources

3838

The Lesson

• When there are two competing theories in science, often one is right and the other is wrong.

• But in more interesting cases, they are both right.

• Welcome to the progenitors of GRBs!

3939