project 3 - pune bus transit route map | 1 shweta kamble

Post on 14-Feb-2017

220 Views

Category:

Documents

0 Downloads

Preview:

Click to see full reader

TRANSCRIPT

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 1Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 2Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

ChaltaHaj

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 3Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Ab nahiChalega

पुणे बस संक्रमण मार्ग नकाशाPUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP

PU

NE BUS MAP

IDC IIT BOMBAYPROJECT

Submitted by -Shweta Kamble

Guide - Prof. Mandar Rane

Visual CommunicationIDC IIT Bombay

Project 3 | 126250006(2012 -2014)

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 5Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 6Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Cycle city (1960) to Motor Cycle city (2014)

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 7Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

TWO WHEELERS 75.3%

5.7%THREE WHEELERS

13.3%CARS

0.8%BUSES

4.9%OTHERS

According to Times of India Pune city survey report

VEHICULAR GROWTH

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 8Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

TWO WHEELERS 75.3%

5.7%THREE WHEELERS

13.3%CARS

0.8%BUSES

4.9%OTHERS

According to Times of India Pune city survey report

VEHICULAR GROWTH

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 9Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Only Public Transport

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 10Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

PUNE MAHANAGAR PARIVAHAN MAHAMANDAL LIMITED

पुणे महानरर पररवहन महामंडळ लिममटेड

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 11Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

PROBLEMSof PMPML

Bus standDesign

Frequency

RoutesInformation

Number of Buses

Behaviourof Driver

DrivingHabits

ReliabilityTimings

Maintenance

New Bus Design

DisorderedBus stopSignages

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 12Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

PROBLEMSof PMPML

Bus standDesign

Frequency

RoutesInformation

Number of Buses

Behaviourof Driver

DrivingHabits

ReliabilityTimings

Maintenance

New Bus Design

DisorderedBus stopSign ages

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 13Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

The most reliable guide is Conductor

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 14Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Whom to ask?

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 15Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

PMPML USERS- Who can not afford aTwo-wheeler & rising petrol prices- Long distance travellers who have only one means of transport- Workers who have to travel daily for long distances

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 16Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Elderly people- School & Jr. college (std. 4th to 12th)

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 17Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

What information is currently available

on the bus stops?

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 18Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Pillars used to classify the routes

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 19Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Digital Indicators- Currently not working

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 20Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Poor and insufficient information- Information is not updated

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 21Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Route, frequency and timings

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 22Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

PUNE CITY

KHADKI CANTONMENT

PIMPRI-CHINCHWAD CANTONMENT

DEHU ROAD CANTONMENT

PUNE CANTONMENT

पुणे महानगर क्ेत्र PUNE METROPOLITAN REGION

(PMR)

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 23Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY IDC IIT Bombay | Project 3 | 30

BHOSARI

PIMPRI

PUNE STATION

HADAPSAR

MARKET YARD

KATRAJ

NIGDI

SHIVAJI NAGAR

KOTHRUD

SWARGATE

NATA WADI

M.N.P

DECCAN

PULGATE

UPPER INDIRA

पुणे महानगर क्ेत्र PUNE METROPOLITAN REGION

MAJOR BUS DEPOTS

MAJOR BUS STANDS

(PMR)

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 24Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

NIGDI

BHOSARI

PIMPRI

PUNE STATION

HADAPSAR

MARKET YARD

SWARGATE

KOTHRUD

KATRAJ

SHIVAJI NAGAR

NATA WADI

UPPER INDIRA

M.N.P

PULGATE

DECCAN

MAJOR BUS DEPOTS

MAJOR BUS STANDS

ROUTES

पुणे महानगर क्ेत्र PUNE METROPOLITAN REGION

(PMR)

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 25Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

To design a system for Pune Bus Route Map which will explain you clearly about all possible information of the routes, which will work for all the bus depots

When a person goes to nearest bus stop, he should understand the route for his destination so that one can plan his journey as per the availability of buses.

OBJECTIVE

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 26Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

INITIAL CONCEPTS

ONE MAPfor whole PMR

1st

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 27Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

INITIAL CONCEPTS

- Large scale- Legibility- Complexity

ONE MAPfor whole PMR

1st

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 28Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

ONE MAPfor whole PMR

INDIVIDUAL MAP for each bus

stand

1st 2nd

INITIAL CONCEPTS

- “You are here” Map- Buses which start from that Particular bus stop

- Large scale- Legibility- Complexity

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 29Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

UPPER INDIRA NAGAR DEPOT

9 ROUTES

185 BUS STOPS

10BUS DEPOTS

BUS STAND

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 30Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Bus route No. : 25From : Upper DepotTo : Pune University

Bus route No. : 12From : Upper DepotTo : Nigdi

Bus route No. : 25From : Upper DepotTo : Pune University

Bus route No. : 12From : Upper DepotTo : Nigdi

Bus route No. : 13From : Upper DepotTo : Shivaji Nagar

Bus route No. : 291From : Upper DepotTo : Hadapsar

Bus route No. : 22From : Upper DepotTo : Shanivarwada

Bus route No. : 65From : Upper DepotTo : Maharashtra Housing Board

Bus route No. : 71From : Upper DepotTo : Kothrud Depot

Bus route No. : 72From : Upper DepotTo : Kondhwa gate

DATA COLLECTION

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 31Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

MAP DESIGN PROCESS

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 33Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

VERSION 1English

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 34Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

VERSION 1Marathi

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 35Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

वण्गमािेनुसार बस स्ानके

बस मार्ग क्र. बॉक्स नं.

नकाशा मध्े ग्रीड क्र. शोधा

नकाशा मध्े बस मार्ग. क्र. शोधा

,

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 36Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 37Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

वररीि दििेल्ा मारगांशशवाय प्रवास करण्ा साठरी जवळचा

बस डेपो स्ाररेट

If your destination is not listed here, then you can got to nearest

bus depot which is Swargate

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 38Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

140

140

140

23

23

23

23

- Two routes but same destination- Same colour but different shade

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 39Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

“VERSION 1” MAP TESTING & USER FEEDBACKUpper Indira Nagar : 12th & 13th March, 2014

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 40Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- English and Marathi map on both sides.

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 41Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

OBSERVATIONS - Very few people looked at the instructions - Needed a guidance on how to read the map- Box number was confusing in first place but after guidance it was easy

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 42Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Children were very enthusiastic- They were teaching others the process of reading map

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 43Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Changes made in the

design after user testing.

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 44Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

नकाशा मध्े ग्रीड क्र. शोधा

नकाशा मध्े बस मार्ग. क्र. शोधा

वण्गमािेनुसार बस स्ानके

बस मार्ग क्र. बॉक्स नं.

,

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 45Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

नकाशा मध्े ग्रीड क्र. शोधा

बस मार्ग क्र. वण्गमािेनुसार बस स्ानके

नकाशा मधे् ग्रीड क्र. शोधा

नकाशा मधे् बस मार्ग. क्र. शोधा

नकाशा मध्े बस मार्ग. क्र. शोधा

वण्गमािेनुसार बस स्ानके

बस मार्ग क्र.

,

बॉक्स नं.

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 46Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 47Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 48Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 49Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 50Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Users were very concerned about the bus timings.

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 51Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 52Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- A lot of twists and turns in the route

- Difficult for tracing the route

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 53Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 54Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

VERSION 2

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 55Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

“VERSION 2” MAP TESTING & USER FEEDBACKLower Indira Nagar: 4th & 5th April, 2014

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 56Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Routes were looking simplified with minimum lines. - Map reading was very new for them.

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 57Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- People were clicking photographs and asking for a copy of it

- Asking questions about “How to read it”

- Some of them figured it out by themselves.

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 58Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

If people apply their mind at the beginning to understand it, then it will be quite easy for them to read and follow the same

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 59Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 60Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 61Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

NEW MAP - SWARGATEVERSION 3

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 62Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

SWARGATE

62 ROUTES

NEHRUSTATDIUMABHINAV NATRAJ

HOTELBRT 1 SHAHU

DEPOT

BRT 2

18

BUS DEPOT

5 Routes 11 Routes 6 Routes 9 Routes 16 Routes

18 Routes

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 63Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

राजार्श्री शाहू महाराज डेपो

बरीआरटरी 1

बरीआरटरी 2नटराज हॉटिेनेहरू स्ेडरीअम

सारस बार

शशवा

जरी र

ोड

घोरपडरी पेठ

सात

ारा र

ोड

स्ार

रेट ए

स ट

री स्ँड

BS1

BS2BS3

BS4

BS5

BS6

SWARGATE DEPOT BUS STOPS

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 64Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

उदा. सनससटी

BS2सनलसटरी 118 अ

बस स्ानकाचे नाव वण्गमािेनुसार शोधा

नकाशा मध्े स्ानक कोड शोधा

स्ानक कोड

बस मार्गकं्र.

वणममािेनुसार बस स्ानके

स्ाररेट बस स्ानके स्ानक कोड

राजार्श्री शाहू महाराज डेपो

नटराज हॉटेि

नेहरू स्ेडरीअम

सारस बार

बरी आर टरी १

बरी आर टरी २

BS1

BS2

BS3

BS4

BS5

BS6

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 65Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

VERSION 3

This sign indicates bus stop Dotted line connecting

common bus stopsVertical Grid

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 67Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 68Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Size of the instructions was increased, people started looking at it

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 69Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- People skipped the index to look directly at the grid and started searching for the place they wished to go..

- Colour was the foremost thing that came in the sight when you look at the map

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 70Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

- Straight lines helped to show you all the available buses at one place in simplest manner- Geographically distorted view of the map compromised

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 71Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

VERSION 2 + VERSION 3 =

VERSION 4

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 72Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

VERSION 4

29122132572126514023 71वणममािेनुसार बस स्ानके ग्रीड

बस मार्ग कं्र.

बस स्ानकाचे नाव वण्गमािेनुसार शोधा

बस मार्ग क्रमांक शोधा नकाशा मध्े ग्रीड शोधा

नळ स्टॅापन

.

, ,

.

, ,

क१

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 74Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

बस मार्ग कं्र.

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 75Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

- User testing of developed version

- Install it on the bus stand permanently

- Possibilities to develop it for portable & digital media

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 76Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Happiness & Pain of map design process

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 77Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

REFERENCES

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/Pune-scores-highest-in-vehicle-percentage/articleshow/19099956.cms

Bus route and schedule planning guidelines (Central Library)

http://www.cpcb.nic.in/Pune.pdf

On the Design of Schematic Transport Maps by Silvania Avelar & Lorenz Hurni

http://sgo.pccu.edu.tw/GEOG/CHI/D/D1/D1A/24B--the%20Design%20of%20Schematic%20Transport%20Map.pdf

http://www.ted.com/talks/aris_venetikidis_making_sense_of_maps

http://cacm.acm.org/magazines/2011/4/106586-design-principles-for-visual-communication/fulltext

http://e-collection.library.ethz.ch/eserv/eth:4376/eth-4376-01.pdf?pid=eth:4376&dsID=eth-4376-01.pdf

http://andynash.com/citypages/zurich/zurich-public-transport-introduction/

http://britton.disted.camosun.bc.ca/beckmap.htm

http://punebusguide.org/

http://www.pmpml.org/

http://www.tfl.gov.uk/

http://www.tfl.gov.uk/assets/downloads/businessandpartners/accessibile_bus_stop_design_guidance.pdf

http://www.vta.org/getting-around/maps/bus-rail-map

http://braga.yapceurope.org/index.cgi?LisbonBuses

http://bitterscotch.wordpress.com/2008/12/15/kickstarting-the-chennai-bus-route-mapping-project/

http://www.vta.org/sfc/servlet.shepherd/version/download/068A0000001QIdS

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 78Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

Books Bus route and schedule planning guidelines Pune DiaryPMPML bus margPMPML Information bookImage of the city - Kevin Lynch

Typeface

Gotham Designer - Tobias Frere-Jones

Kohinoor Devnagri Designer - Satya Rajpurohit

Project 3 - PUNE BUS TRANSIT ROUTE MAP | 79Shweta Kamble | VC - 126250006 | IDC IIT BOMBAY

THANK YOU

top related