presentation to faculty at almau - almaty management university jeffrey beall orcid number...

Presentation to Faculty at AlmaU - Almaty Management University

Jeffrey BeallORCID number 0000-0001-9012-5330

Презентация для профессорско-преподавательского состава

University of Colorado Denver = Университет Колорадо в Денвере• Two campuses, one in Denver, one

in Aurora• The Anschutz Medical Campus has

the Medical School, School of Nursing, School of Dentistry, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, etc.• The Denver Campus has The

Business School • Denver campus has 13,565 students

(9,369 U + 4,196 G)• Medical campus has 3,879 students

(all graduate students)

Школа Бизнеса

Journal finders = Поисковики научных журналов

Edanz Journal Selector = http://www.edanzediting.com/journal_selector

Elsevier Journal Finder = http://journalfinder.elsevier.com/

Journal Article Name Estimator (Jane) = http://www.biosemantics.org/jane/

Cofactor Journal selector = http://cofactorscience.com/journal-selector

ORCID = Open Researcher and Contributor ID

Distribution models for scholarly publishing = Модели распространения научных публикаций

• The traditional model•Gold open-access•Platinum open access•Green open access•Hybrid open access•Delayed open access

Predatory Publishers = "Хищные" (недобросовестные) издательства• Use the gold open-access model (author pays)• Article processing charges (APCs)

• Conflict of interest: more papers accepted = more income• Not all OA journals are bad; not all traditional ones are

good• Monetary transactions from authors to publishers cause

many problems

How predatory publishers operate = Как "хищные" (недобросовестные) издательства действуют

• Experts at manipulative spamming• Target young and

emerging researchers• They mimic legitimate

publishers in many ways

How predatory publishers operate = Как "хищные" (недобросовестные) издательства действуют• They lie; they are counterfeit publishers• They are often one-man operations• Author-oriented vs. reader oriented• Customers include unlucky honest folks and complicit folks• Chiefly in Asia and Africa, but also many in the UK, Ontario, Australia,

and the US• They also operate bogus conferences• Journals with broad coverage

My work with predatory publishers = Моя работа с "хищными" (недобросовестными) издательствами• First became interested in 2009 via spam• Coined term ‘predatory publisher’ in summer, 2010• I author a blog with regular commentary and four lists: • Predatory publishers• Predatory standalone journals• Misleading metrics• Hijacked journals

http://scholarlyoa.com

Publisher classification = Издательская классификация• Based on a published criteria• Show a lack of transparency (hiding information conventionally given

by publishers)• Use of deception• Don’t follow industry standards

Why predatory publishers are problematic = Почему "хищные" издательства являются проблематичными [1]1. They corrupt open access and give it a bad name2. They probably have increased the occurrence of research

misconduct3. They threaten demarcation and the cumulative nature of

research

Why predatory publishers are problematic [2]4. Bogus research affects societal institutions5. They sponsor many low-quality scholarly conferences6. They enable the publishing of junk science7. They don’t back up their content (digital preservation standards)8. Some authors are complicit in the process9. Predatory publishers are polluting taxonomy10. Pharmaceutical entrepreneurs are using predatory publishers

Increased Publication of Pseudo-science= Увеличение числа псевдо-научных публикаций

Fake metrics = Фальшивые критерии оценки научных публикаций

• Fake metrics (or misleading metrics) are numbers that are just “made up” and assigned to journals, etc.• Companies sell these metrics and call them “impact factors”• Publishers use fake metrics on their websites and in their spam email to

make their journals look like real ones and attract more papers• Problem: The real impact factor data is not free

Hijacked journals = “Поддельные” журналы

Hijacked journal Authentic journal

How can we stop predatory publishers? = Как остановить издательства "хищники"?

• Predatory publishers enjoy freedom of the press• Predatory publishers operate internationally• Open access advocates too often turn a blind eye to predatory

publishers• There’s much hubris and bullying in the open-access movement• We need to restore the voice of the “consumer” in scholarly

publishing

Author services companies = Компании, помогающие авторам

Changes in Peer Review = Изменения в рецензировании научных публикаций

• Cascading peer review• Outsourcing / monetization of peer review (by individual authors,

by journals)• Post-publication peer review• Will peer-review become decoupled from the journal submission

process?

Conclusion = Заключение

• There’s no end in sight to the problem of predatory publishers• Despite the OA movement, we’re seeing an increased

commercialization of various scholarly communication components• Scholarly publishing is becoming more author-focused and less-reader

focused• The validation function the subscription model offered is being lost

• jeffrey.beall@ucdenver.edu