nonalcoholic steatohepatitis assessing severity and ......vitamin e may have benefit • 247 adults...

NONALCOHOLIC STEATOHEPATITISAssessing Severity and Optimizing Management

Sanjiv Chopra, M.D., MACPProfessor of Medicine

Harvard Medical SchoolEditor in Chief

Hepatology Section Up to Date

COPYRIG

HT

DefinitionofNASH

Nonalcoholicsteatohepatitis (NASH)isthetermusedtodescribethedistinctclinicalentityinwhichpatientslackahistoryofsignificantalcoholconsumptionbuthaveliverbiopsyfindingsindistinguishablefromalcoholichepatitits.

COPYRIG

HT

COPYRIG

HT

30%Can progress to cirrhosis and HCC

70% Relatively benign

COPYRIG

HT

CriteriaforDxofNASH

• Liverbx showsmacrovesicular fattychangewithinflammationandwithorwithoutMallorybodies,fibrosisorcirrhosis.

• Convincingevidenceofnegligiblealcoholconsumption(lessthan10g/dayofalcoholforwomenandlessthan20g/dayformen).

COPYRIG

HT

Ultrasoundshowing

Brightechogenicliver

COPYRIG

HT

LiverUltrasoundReport

Theliverisenlarged.Itisdiffuselyechogenicconsistentwithfatinfiltrationoftheliver.Otherformsofliverdiseaseandmoreadvancedliverdiseaseincludingearlycirrhosiscannotbeexcludedbythisstudy.

COPYRIG

HT

macrovesicularsteatosis(zoneIII)

Biopsies

COPYRIG

HT

lobular sinusoidal neutrophils

Ballooningdegeneration

COPYRIG

HT

Sinusoidal pericellular fibrosis, trichrome stain

COPYRIG

HT

NASH:LiverHistology

COPYRIG

HT

ProperInterpretationoftheHistology

...thesefeaturesareconsistentwithaToxicMetabolicetiology.

COPYRIG

HT

Cirrhosis,lowpower

COPYRIG

HT

SignsofAdvancedFibrosis

•Physicalexam• Spiderangiomata, palmar erythema

• Terry’snails

• Gynecomastia, testicular atrophyinmen

• Caputmedusa, etc.

• LaboratoryData• Thrombocytopenia

• Elevated INR

• AST/ALTratio>1

•Radiology- splenomegaly,varices,nodularliver

COPYRIG

HT

NASHisLikelyaMajorCauseofCryptogenicCirrhosis

• 74%of70consecutivepatientswithcryptogeniccirrhosishadobesityand/ordiabetes

• Thispercentageissimilartoprevalenceofobesityand/ordiabetesnotedin50consecutivepatientswithNASHCOP

YRIGHT

EpidemiologyofNAFLD

• Estimate:70million AmericanshaveNAFLDMorethan5million arecirrhotic

•MajorityofPtswithNASHhavemetabolic

syndrome

•Overage60years,40%havemetabolicsyndrome

COPYRIG

HT

NAFLDisPartoftheMetabolicSyndromeCalledSyndromeX

Obesity Hypertriglyceridemia

Hyperinsulinemia Hypertension

InsulinResistance DiabetesCOPYRIG

HT

Regularsugar-sweetenedbeverageconsumptionisassociatedwithagreaterriskoffattyliverdisease

• Examinationofcross-sectionalassociation

betweenintakeofsugar-sweetenedbeveragesand

fattyliverdiseaseinFraminghamHeartStudy

cohorts

JMaetal.,JournalofHepatology2015May29

COPYRIG

HT

PatientswithNASH

Normal ALT Increased ALT p.value

FibrosisStage22%34%NS2orgreater

FracanzaniAL,etal.Hepatology2008:48;792

COPYRIG

HT

OtherConditions AssociatedwithNASH

•DrugsorToxins •AbdominalSurgery

• MetabolicDisorders •MiscellaneousCOPYRIG

HT

Onedisorderthatiscritical toexcludeinyoungindividualsisWilson’sdisease

COPYRIG

HT

K-FRing

COPYRIG

HT

DrugsAssociatedwithNASH

•Glucocorticoids • Tamoxifen

•Syntheticestrogens • Perhexilene maleate

•Amiodarone • Isoniazid

COPYRIG

HT

ProgressiontoCirrhosis10YrSurvival

Alcoholic 38–50% 20%Hepatitis

NASH 8– 26% 60%COPYRIG

HT

ClinicalFeaturesofNASH

Symptoms

• Asymptomatic

• Fatigue

• RUQDiscomfortorPainCOPYRIG

HT

LaboratoryFeaturesofNASH

•ALTandAST2to4foldelevatedinmostpatients

•Alk phos mildlyelevatedinathirdofpatients

•Albumin,PT,bilirubinmostoftennormal

• Serumferritinelevatedinhalfthepatients

COPYRIG

HT

WeneedtoThinkDifferentlyabouttheUpperNormalLimitofALT• TruenormalhealthyALT:

19to25 IU/Linfemales

29to 33IU/Linmales

•Multiplestudies:ElevatedALTassociatedwith

increasedliver-relatedmortality.

• Likely,manyofthenewlyidentifiedpatientsusing

theseparameterswillhaveNAFLD.

COPYRIG

HT

PatientswithSuspectedNASHshouldUndergoLiverBiopsy

Pros Cons

hNASHisahistologicdx h Smallbutfiniteriskofcomplications

hPoorcorrelationbetweenlabh Biopsyresultsmaynotfindingsandhistologicseveritychangemanagement

hBiopsyresultsmaychangeh Limitedmanpowermanagement

COPYRIG

HT

SuspectedNASH:Reasonabletoperformliverbiopsy

Ifanyoffollowingpresent

• Peripheralstigmataofchronicliverdisease

• Splenomegaly

• Cytopenia

• Abnormalironstudies

• Diabetesand/orsignificantobesityinapatientover45yearsofagewithelevatedALT

COPYRIG

HT

Aretherealternativestoliverbiopsy?

COPYRIG

HT

Sampling error of liver biopsyFibrosis area: 65%

Fibrosis area: 15%Courtesy of M. Pinzani, Florence

COPYRIG

HT

Fibrotest(fibrosure)

Alpha2macroglobulin,haptoglobin,

gammaglobulin,GGT,totalbilirubin,apolipoprotein

A1

Theseverityofdiseasewascorrectlyidentifiedin

46%ofpatients.

AmJGastroenterol 2006

Fibrosure. I am not so sure!

COPYRIG

HT

Fibroscann Fasting

n Examination time < 5 minutes

n Median value of 10 successful acquisitions

n Sampling errorq Biopsy – 1/50,000q Fibroscan – 1/500

Courtesy of N. Afdhal, MD

COPYRIG

HT

Sampled volume: 1: 500

Hepatic Elastography

Courtesy N. Afdhal, MD

COPYRIG

HT

Sampling

• Liverbiopsysamplesonly1/50,000th ofwholeliver.

• Fibroscan samples1/500th ofwholeliver.

COPYRIG

HT

LikelyFutureScenario

Patients with suspected Liver Disease

Low likelihood of fibrosis

No liver biopsy

Follow or treat

Grey zone

Liver biopsy

High likelihood of fibrosis

No liver biopsy

Screen HCC, varices

Biomarkers and Fibroscan

COPYRIG

HT

Transientelastography (Fibroscan)isaccurateinmostpatientswithNAFLD.Withhighnegativepredictivevalueandmodestpositivepredictivevalue,Fibroscan isusefulasascreeningtesttoexcludeadvancedfibrosis.

WongVW-S,etal.Hepatology2010;51:454-462

COPYRIG

HT

Fibroscan- pros

• Noninvasive

• Excellent negative predictive value to exclude advanced fibrosis

• Fast- 5 minute tests

• Point of care- results immediately available

COPYRIG

HT

FibroscanResult

• LiverstiffnessinkPa

• Lowriskforadvancedfibrosis<7.9kPa

• Highriskforadvancedfibrosis>9.9kPa

• CAP- fatquantification

Tapper et al. Am J Gastroenterol 2016;111:677-684.

COPYRIG

HT

ProgressionofNAFLD

InitialBiopsyResultsMayBeUseful

• FatAlone5%

•BallooningDegenerationand

MalloryHyalineorFibrosis

Gastroenterology:1999;116:1413

Progression toCirrhosis

Progression toCirrhosis

25%

COPYRIG

HT

PathogenesisofNASH

• Perturbationoffattyacidprocessing.

• Insulinresistance

• Lipidperoxidationandoxidativestress*

*Potentialoxidativestressorsinclude:hepaticiron,intestinalbacteria,leptinandstatescharacterizedbyanti-oxidantdeficiencies

COPYRIG

HT

COPYRIG

HT

Definition

Theconceptofthehumanmicrobiomewasfirst

suggestedbyJoshuaLederberg,whocoinedthe

term“microbiome,tosignifytheecological

communityofcommensal,symbiotic,and

pathogenicmicroorganismsthatliterallyshare

ourbodyspace”.

COPYRIG

HT

WelcometoBoston WelcometoGut

Population:667,000 Population:100trillion

COPYRIG

HT

TheGutMicrobiotaandNAFLD

• Microbiotainadditiontoregulatingbodyfatgainandinsulinresistance:

• Changegeneexpression

• Increaseenergyharvestfromdiet

• Produceethanol

• Affectinflammation andimmunity

ELauetal.GutMicrobiota:AssociationwithNAFLDandMetabolicDisturbances.BiomedicalResearchInternational.2015.

COPYRIG

HT

YouMayNotDrinkAlcoholbuttheK.pneumoniabacteriainyourgut…….

• 60%ofNAFLDPatientsversus6%ofhealthycontrolshadhighandmediumalcoholproducingK.pneumoniainthegut.

• GermfreemicefedalcoholproducingK.pneumoniadevelopedfatty

liverwithinamonthandwithin2monthstherewashepaticfibrosis.

• WhenthebacteriafedmiceweregivenanantibioticagainstK.

Pneumoniathehepaticdamagewasreversed.

YuanJ.etal.FattyLiverDiseaseCausedbyHigh-AlcoholProducing

Klebsiella pneumoniae.CellMetabolism2019.

COPYRIG

HT

PreventionandTreatmentofNASH

•Preventionofobesityandmetabolicsyndrome

• Treatmentofmetabolicsyndrome

•Coffee?

•BariatricSurgeryifappropriate

COPYRIG

HT

Pioglitazone therapyovera12monthperiodinnondiabetic NASH

patientsresultedinimprovementinbiochemical,metabolicand

histologicalparameters(includingfibrosis).

Aithal GP,etal.

Gastroenterology2008:135;1176COPYRIG

HT

NASH:WeightLossisBeneficial!

1.9%orgreaterweightlossresultedin:

• Biochemicalimprovement• Histologicimprovement(steatosis,ballooning,inflammn)• ImprovementinInsulinresistance• HigherAdiponectin levels

HarrisonSA,etal.Hepatology 2009;49:80

2.Followingbariatricsurgery,HepaticFibrosisimprovedorwasreversedin66%.

Furuya CKJr.,etal.JGastroHepatol 2007;22:510

COPYRIG

HT

VitaminEMayHaveBenefit

• 247AdultswithNASH(withoutdiabetes)randomlyassignedtopioglitazone(30mg.daily)VitaminE(800IUdaily)orplacebofor96weeks*.

• VitaminEgrouphadsignificantimprovementinglobalhistologyscorescomparedwithplacebo(43%vs19%).

• ConcernsregardingVitaminEandincreasedmortalityhaveledmanyHepatologists tonotrecommendVitaminEortouse400IUdaily.

*Sanyal,A,etal.Pioglitazone, vitamine E,orplacebo for

nonalcoholic steatohepatitis. NEngl JMed2010

COPYRIG

HT

OtherPharmacologicalTreatmentModalities

• Pioglitazone• Metformin• Liraglutide• Orlistat• Probucol• Betaine

Of limited or no proven efficacy

• Ursodeoxycholic acid(UDCA)• Omega-3FattyAcids• Losartan• Atorvastatin• Pentoxifylline

COPYRIG

HT

1. Whoisthispersonandhowoldwashewhenhedied?Voltaire(1694– 1778)83years

2. Howmanycupsofcoffeedidhedrinkeveryday?50-72!

COPYRIG

HT

ANewKindofCoffeeConnection!

COPYRIG

HT

MechanismofProtectiveEffectofCoffeeUnknown•Caffeine,cafestol andkahweol protectiveinexperimentalstudies

•Antioxidanteffect

• Insulinsensitizingeffect

•Coffeedrinkershavehigherlevelsofplasmaadiponectin

COPYRIG

HT

Morethan1BillionPeopleintheWorldHaveChronicLiverDisease

Consumingtwocupsofcoffeeperdayreduceshospitalizationrateandmortalityfromchronicliverdiseasebymorethan50%

Ruhl CE,etal.Gastroenterology2005;129:1928COPYRIG

HT

References:CoffeeandLiverDisease,2012SanjivChopra,MD,MACP1.Klatsky A,ArmstrongM.Alcohol,smoking,coffeeand

cirrhosis.AmJEpidemiol.1992;136:1248.

2.Casiglia E,etal.Unexpectedeffectsofcoffeeconsumption

onliverenzymes.Eur JEpidemiol.1993;9:293.

3.Tverdal A,Skurveit S.Coffeeintakeandmortalityfrom

livercirrhosis.AnnEpidemiol.2003;13:419.

4.Shimazu T,etal.Coffeeconsumptionandtheriskof

primarylivercancer;pooledanalysisoftwoprospective

studiesinJapan.Int JCancer.2005;10:150.

COPYRIG

HT

5.Ruhl CE,EverhartJ.CoffeeandteaconsumptionareassociatedwithalowerincidenceofchronicliverdiseaseintheUnitedStates.Gastroenterology.2005;129:1928.

6.Klatsky AL,MortonC,UdaltsovaN,FriedmanG.Coffee,cirrhosis,andtransaminaseenzymes.ArchInternMed.2006;166:1190.

7.HuG,Tuomilehto J,Pukkala E,HakulinenT,Antikainen R,VartiainenE,Jousilahti P.Jointeffectsofcoffeeconsumptionandserumgamma-glutamyltransferase ontheriskoflivercancer.Hepatology.2008;48(1):129-36.

8.LarssonSC,Wolk A.Coffeeconsumptionandriskoflivercancer:ameta-analysis.Gastroenterology.2007;132(5):1740-5.COP

YRIGHT

9.Corrao G,Zambon A,Bagnardi V,D'Amicis A,Klatsky A;Collaborative

SIDECIRGroup.Coffee,caffeine,andtheriskoflivercirrhosis.AnnEpidemiol.

2001;11(7):458-65.

10.GallusS,Tavani A,Negri E,LaVecchia C.Doescoffeeprotectagainstliver

cirrhosis?AnnEpidemiol.2002;12(3):202-5.

11.Schilter B,PerrinI,Cavin C,Huggett AC.PlacentalglutathioneS-

transferase (GST-P) inductionasapotentialmechanismfortheanti-

carcinogeniceffectofthecoffee-specific componentscafestol andkahweol.

Carcinogenesis.1996;17(11):2377-84.

12.Gelatti U,Covolo L,Franceschini M,Pirali F,TaggerA,Ribero ML,Trevisi P,

Martelli C,Nardi G,Donato F;BresciaHCCStudyGroup. Coffeeconsumption

reducestheriskofhepatocellularcarcinomaindependentlyofitsaetiology:a

case-controlstudy.JHepatol.2005;42(4):528-34.

COPYRIG

HT

13.Modi AA,FeldJJ,ParkY,Kleiner DE,EverhartJE,LiangTJ,Hoofnagle JH.Increasedcaffeineconsumptionisassociatedwithreducedhepaticfibrosis.

Hepatology.2010;51(1):201-9.

14.Kalthoff S,Ehmer U,FreibergN,Manns MP,Strassburg CP.Coffeeinduces

expressionofglucuronosyltransferases bythearylhydrocarbonreceptorandNrf2inliverandstomach.Gastroenterology.2010;139(5):1699-710.

15.FreedmanNDetal.Coffeeconsumptionisassociatedwithresponsetopeginterferon andribavirintherapyinpatientswithchronichepatitisC.

Gastroenterology2011; 140:161-69.

16.MolloyJW,CalcagnoCJ,WilliamsCD,JonesFJ,TorresDM,HarrisonSA.

Associationofcoffeeandcaffeineconsumptionwithfattyliverdisease,nonalcoholicsteatohepatitis,anddegreeofhepaticfibrosis.Hepatology.2012;55(2):429-36.

COPYRIG

HT

Largeprospectivestudy;Coffeeconsumptioninverselyassociatedwithtotalandcause-specificmortality.

• Freedman,NDPh.D.,Park,YSc.D.,Abnet,CCPh.D.,etal.

AssociationofCoffeeDrinkingwithTotalandCause-SpecificMortalityNEngl JMed2012;366:1891-1904COP

YRIGHT

Twoadditonal studiespublished intheAnnalsofInternalMedicine July2017addressingcoffeedrinking andmortality.

Afourthstudypublished inJAMAInternalMedicine July2018

Naci et al. BMJ. 2013: 5577

COPYRIG

HT

CoffeeDrinkingAssociatedwithReducedRiskforDeathfromvariouscauses.Thisrelationshipwasseenin10EuropeanCountries• Largecohort- morethan520,000menandwomenfrom10European

countriesaveragefollow-up16years.

• Inverserelationshipbetweencoffeeintakeandallcausemortalityin

menandwomen.

• Notethatthepopulationsindifferentcountriesusedifferentcoffeepreparationmethodsandhaddifferentdrinkingpatterns.

Gunter,M.J.etal.CoffeeDrinkingandMortality in10European Countries: A

Multinational CohortStudy

AnnInternMed.July2017

Naci et al. BMJ. 2013: 5577

COPYRIG

HT

HigherConsumptionofCoffeeAssociatewithLowerRiskofDeathinAfrican-Americans,JapaneseAmericans,Latinos,andWhites• 185,855individualsages45-75yearsatrecruitment

• Coffeeconsumptionassociatedwithlowertotalmortalityafter

adjustmentforsmoking,otherpotentialconfounders.

• Inverseassociationsobservedfordeathsduetoheartdisease,cancer,diabetes,stroke,etc.

Park,S-Yetal.Association ofCoffeeConsumption With TotalandCause-Specific

Mortality AmongNonwhite Populations

AnnInternMed.July2017

Naci et al. BMJ. 2013: 5577

COPYRIG

HT

InverseAssociationforCoffeeDrinkingandMortality(A2018Publication)

• UKBiobankStudy.500,000Individuals

• OnecupofCoffeeaday:8%lowerriskofprematuredeath

6cupsofCoffeeaday:16%lowerriskofprematuredeath

• SpeedofCaffeineMetabolismhadnoeffectonLongevity

AssociationofCoffeeDrinkingWithMortalitybyGeneticVariationinCaffeineMetabolismFindings FromtheUKBiobankErikka Loftfield,etal.JAMAInternalMedicine2018.

Naci et al. BMJ. 2013: 5577

COPYRIG

HT

Kaldi the shepherd from Kaffa

COPYRIG

HT

“Coffeeissogood,theinfidelsshouldnothaveexclusiveuseofit.”

PopeVincentIII

COPYRIG

HT

LowVitaminDMayIncreaseRiskofNAFLD

• VitaminDDeficiencymaybemorecommoninpatientswithNAFLD

thancontrols.

• PatientswithlowVitaminDappeartohavehigherriskofmoderate-

severeNAFLDcomparedwithpatientswithnormallevels.

TrahanL.PharmacyTimesJuly2016.

COPYRIG

HT

MyDoctorSaidICouldHaveOneGlassofWineperDay

COPYRIG

HT

•HowMuchofThatBottleisintheGlass?

•A.33%

•B.50%

•C.66%

MyDoctorSaidICouldHaveOneGlassofWineperDay

COPYRIG

HT

PotentialApproachestoTreatmentintheFuture

•Willlikelyincludecombination therapyandlife-stylechanges.

• ExperimentalstudyinaratmodelofNASHcombiningangiotensin IIreceptorblockerwithanoralironchelator attenuatedprogression.

•Moderateexerciseandcoffeeconsumption likelyofbenefit.

COPYRIG

HT

PatientswithElevatedTransaminasesarenotatHigherRiskforStatinHepatotoxicity

Mild-ModerateSevereElevations Elevations

• 1439withnormaltransaminases 1.9%0.2%prescribedastatin

• 342with elevatedtransaminases 4.7%0.6%prescribedastatin

• 2245withelevatedtransaminasesnot 6.4%0.4%prescribedastatin

Chalasani etal:Gastroenterology2004;126

COPYRIG

HT

COPYRIG

HT

APotentialTreatment

• ASK1 (apoptosissignal-regulatingkinase)promoteshepatic

inflammationandfibrosis.

• Selonsertib (GS-4997)isanoralsmallmoleculeASK1inhibitorthat

hasbeenshowninmousemodelstoimprovesteatosis,inflammation

andfibrosis.

• 72patientswithbiopsyprovenNASH,stage2and3fibrosis.

• Patientsachievedsignificantreductioninfatcontentandinfibrosisscores.

Loomba Retal.

AASLDNovember 2016

COPYRIG

HT

CurrentLandscapeofClinicalTrials:2019

• AsperClinicalTrials.govover250StudiesOngoingintheUnitedStatesCOP

YRIGHT

Quiz Answer True or False

1. NAFLD is the most common hepatic disorder in the U.S.

2. Serum ferritin is elevated in 50% of pts with NASH.

3. NASH has been reported in children.

4. Progression to cirrhosis occurs in 15-20% of pts.

5. NASH is likely the leading cause of cryptogenic cirrhosis.

COPYRIG

HT

6. The histologic features of NASH maybe seen in Wilson’s disease.

7. Both Amiodarone and Tamoxifen can cause NASH.

8. Primary hepatocellular carcinoma has been reported in patients with NASH and cirrhosis.

Quiz (Continued) Answer True or False

COPYRIG

HT