moral compass harvard...a moral compass for data science in the city @re_sieber canada geothink does...

AMoralCompassforDataScienceintheCity@re_sieberCanada

www.geothink.ca

Geothinkdoessomedatascience.FromMa7hewTenney’sPhDresearch(McGill,incollaboraAonwithESRICanada)onCrowdsourcingGeotopics

Whyarewedoingcivicdatascienceandwhoarewedoingitfor?

WaterfrontToronto

DATAANDDATAGOVERNANCEWhowillown/control/haveaccesstothedatathatiscapturedbythesensorsdeployedinthisproject?Underwhattermswillthatdatabeshared?Forwhomandforwhatpurposes?WhocontrolstheSidewalkLabsplaKorm?Isittheresidents?CityHall?SidewalkLabs?DoesSidewalkLabshavetheabilitytoaccessandbuilduponpersonasfromAlphabet’sdatastores?HowverOcallyintegratedwithAlphabetproductswillthisnewsmartcitybe?WhatprivacyprotecOonprocesswillbefollowedtoensuredatacollectedisanonymous,beyondcommitmentstoPrivacybyDesign?Howarepeople’smovementstrackedinspaceOme?Especiallymarginalizedcommunitymembers,includinghomelesspeople?PassiveharvesOngofpeople’smovementinspaceOmeasanindicatorofintentdoesn’tconsOtuteengagement.WhatconsOtutesdemocraOcparOcipaOoninsmartcitydesign? Wylieetal.ndh7ps://docs.google.com/document/d/1mD-

jG5j3XWNoxiC1ZW6W7pcI5Pl71HVbqzfTg2H67eQ/edit

TheproblemwithemphasizingVolunteeredGeographicInformaAon.BoatyMcBoa`acewasactuallyReddittrolling

Whatisthisurban(gov,crowdsourced)dataofwhichwespeak?

Opaque!Transparent

Opaque!Transparent!Opaque/Proprietary

From

To

Privatization,privacy&IP

Ne`lixhosteda“Designanalgorithm.Here’s500,000records…”AwomanissuingNe`lixbecauseshewasinthecloset,andhermovie-rentaldatawaspartoftheNe`lixprizedataset.Sheclaimsthismeansthatpeoplecouldfigureouthersecret.

h7ps://www.wired.com/2009/12/ne`lix-privacy-lawsuit/

Howtoengagethepublic?

AppsInfomediariesHackathons

ACallforaMoralCompassKnowyourdata;knowyouralgorithmDeterminethesignalinthenoiseHireacriAcaldatastudies,criAcalGISresearcherAcknowledgeourownculpability

Thanks

@re_sieberCanada